Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Knowledge and Attitudes About Emergency Contraception Among Health Workers in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
Knowledge and Attitudes About Emergency Contraception Among Health Workers in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam
In a series of focus groups and in-depth interviews, physicians, midwives and other family plan- ticularly serious and the need for these
methods is greatest.8
ning providers in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam, were questioned about their knowledge and atti- Vietnam has a high rate of unwanted
tudes regarding use of three methods of emergency contraception—the Yuzpe regimen, a levo- fertility and, in 1992, had an estimated total
norgestrel-only regimen and postcoital insertion of a copper-bearing IUD. Most providers were abortion rate* of 2.5 abortions per woman,
the highest in Asia. Accordingly, the Viet-
familiar with the concept of emergency contraception and endorsed its practice, but lacked ac- namese government has made reducing
curate and detailed information about method use. They also overestimated contraindications the number of unwanted pregnancies a
and potential side effects. Providers advocated for additional training for themselves and for priority.9 The government is committed to
an active family planning policy and has
druggists, who provide these methods over the counter. Participants generally agreed about
taken measures to make available a broad-
the need for more empirical information about the safety and efficacy of these methods, but dis- er range of contraceptive methods.10 In-
agreed about the degree to which emergency methods should be made readily available to creasing the availability of emergency con-
traceptive methods would further the
women in Vietnam. (International Family Planning Perspectives, 23:68–72,1997)
objectives of these family planning initia-
tives. The hormonal pills required for the
E
mergency contraceptives, sometimes course, and the remainder 12 hours later.2 Yuzpe and levonorgestrel-only regimens
referred to as “morning after” meth- Efficacy studies estimate that the Yuzpe are already available in Vietnam; com-
ods, are used to prevent pregnancy regimen reduces the probability of preg- bined oral contraceptives, including sev-
after unprotected intercourse. They are tra- nancy by at least 75%.3 eral brands suitable for emergency use, can
ditionally known as a treatment for women A levonorgestrel-only regimen also has be purchased over the counter, and Posti-
who have been raped. Recently, however, been found to be highly effective for emer- nor† is sold in most pharmacies.
several international health advocacy gency contraception: Two 0.75 mg doses To determine the steps that should be
groups have called for expanded access to are taken 12 hours apart; the first dose taken to encourage the use of these meth-
these methods.1 Emergency contraceptives must be initiated within 48 hours of un- ods, we enlisted family planning providers
are typically less effective than other meth- protected intercourse.4 The most recent for participation in a series of focus groups
ods, but they are invaluable for a woman trial of this method indicated a 60% re- and in-depth interviews. Although his-
who has experienced a contraceptive fail- duction in the risk of pregnancy.5 torically used for market research, focus
ure, as well as for those occasions when she A nonhormonal emergency contracep- groups are increasingly considered a le-
has not used a method. Additionally, by tive method is also available. A copper- gitimate and critical method of research in
lowering the probability of unwanted preg- bearing IUD, when inserted no more than the health field,11 as the technique allows
nancy, emergency contraceptives can de- 5–7 days after intercourse, can be used to for exploration of a relatively unknown
crease the need for abortion. prevent pregnancy. Based on the 19 pub- topic. By fostering interaction among a
The best-studied emergency method is lished studies available, this method has group of participants, focus groups en-
the “Yuzpe” regimen, which consists of a failure rate of less than 0.1%.6 courage dialogue and an exchange of ideas
200 mcg of ethinyl estradiol and either 2.0 Regardless of the regimen selected, the and perspectives. For this reason, they are
mg of norgestrel or 1.0 mg of levo- opportunity to initiate emergency con- useful for generating public and private
norgestrel—the same active ingredients traceptive treatment is brief. Therefore, discourse on a specific topic.
found in four tablets of combined estro- women should know about these meth- The goals of our work were broader
gen-progestin oral contraceptives. In this ods and have them on hand before the than pure research; we also sought to build
regimen, a woman takes half of the dose need arises. As several of these methods research capacity and increase knowledge
within 72 hours after unprotected inter- are available through standard family of emergency contraception at the local
planning services, it may be lack of infor- level. In addition to gathering data, we
Nguyen Thi Nhu Ngoc is vice director at Hung Vuong mation that prevents women from using used the project to train researchers in
Hospital, Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam. Charlotte Ellert-
son is program associate at the Population Council, New
these regimens. Health care workers can qualitative data techniques, and we used
York, USA. Yukolsiri Surasrang is national staff associ- help remedy this situation: If providers are the focus groups to impart basic informa-
ate at the Population Council, Bangkok, Thailand. Ly Thai knowledgeable about emergency contra- tion about emergency contraception to the
Loc is a physician at Hung Vuong Hospital, Ho Chi Minh ceptives, they can routinely educate
City, Vietnam. The authors are grateful to Chris Elias, Bev- *The total abortion rate indicates the number of abortions
erly Winikoff and Batya Elul for their valuable assistance. women about their use.
a woman would be expected to have during her repro-
The authors are also grateful to the participating physi- Few studies have assessed providers’ ductive lifetime, given current age-specific abortion rates.
cians and health workers from Ho Chi Minh City, and knowledge and perceptions of emergency
the researchers who collected the data: Nguyen Thi Thu †Postinor tablets contain 0.75 mg of levonorgestrel. They
Thuy, Ton Nu Thanh Phong, Vo Thi Hong Lien, Pham
contraceptives,7 and none have done so in are manufactured in Hungary and marketed as an on-
Thi Ngoc Huong, Hoang Thi Mai, Nguyen Giang Hong, developing countries, where the conse- going postcoital method. The brand is sold in Eastern Eu-
Dang Van Qui, Nguyen Thai Binh and Vo Thi Bach Nga. quences of unwanted pregnancy are par- rope and in many developing countries.
recommended interval between doses, as clinic reporting difficulties: menstrual regulation and curettage.”—
well as the maximum length of time fol- “Many patients buy Postinor at phar- Physician's assistant, tertiary hospital.
lowing intercourse that a woman could macies, and take it by themselves. When These sentiments were linked to the be-
begin the regimen; for example, several they have side effect and complications, lief that sexual mores in Vietnam have
providers reported unnecessarily strict at that time they come to the hospital. So grown more liberal:
limits of 48 or even 24 hours. Only a few I think that we should instruct them care- “Providing emergency methods broad-
knew the correct method for postcoital fully how to use Postinor.”—Midwife, ter- ly is suitable to society now because so
IUD use, and several believed the device tiary hospital. many young people have intercourse so
should always be removed 48 hours after Many discussants insisted that patients soon, and they fear pregnancy very much.
serving its emergency function. also be educated about these methods so Now we perform menstrual regulation so
Few providers had accurate, detailed in- that women could make informed deci- broadly. Why don't we also do that with
formation about side effects and con- sions about their reproductive health care: emergency contraception to reduce the
traindications. They typically overesti- “Any method has advantages and dis- total number of menstrual regulations in
mated the incidence and severity of side advantages. Using it correctly, based on the society?”—Medical doctor, urban district
effects. Dangers including endometrial can- good knowledge, proves useful. Other- hospital.
cer and chloasma (facial skin discoloration) wise, it is harmful. Therefore, I think that A small minority of providers argued
were incorrectly cited as risks associated we should train health providers first, and that there is no real need for emergency
with emergency contraceptive use. then teach women in the society so they contraception in Vietnam, since the ma-
Similarly, providers tended toward ex- can know this method.”—Medical doctor, jority of women seeking these methods are
cessive caution regarding contraindica- urban district hospital. not likely to become pregnant even with-
tions. Virtually all participants offering Several providers, however, noted that out their use. They argued that because
opinions mentioned unnecessary con- the intervention component of the focus abortion is so easy to obtain, women might
traindications, often specifying those as- group itself provided valuable informa- as well wait to see if they did become preg-
sociated with regular oral contraceptive tion, and they intended to put the new nant and seek an abortion at that time.
use. Providers mistakenly cited hyper- knowledge to use: Support for emergency contraceptives
tension, goiters, cardiovascular disorders “Why do we prescribe only two Posti- varied somewhat by regimen. Given their
and uterine tumors as contraindications nor pills instead of four? In the past, I familiarity with the levonorgestrel-only
to the use of emergency contraception. thought that it was necessary to use four regimen, it was not surprising that
pills. From this focus-group discussion, I providers preferred it. Opposition to the
Need for Information know that two pills are enough. I will postcoital insertion of the IUD was vehe-
The discussants repeatedly expressed frus- practice this way, and after I have gained ment in some cases. Providers were con-
tration regarding the dearth of dependable some experience, I will share my com- cerned about the possibility of ectopic
information on emergency contraception ments on this practice.”—Medical doctor, pregnancy, the high risk of expulsion, ab-
in Vietnam. Some felt hesitant about pro- tertiary hospital. normal bleeding and the difficulties of in-
moting these methods in the absence of serting an IUD in the absence of menstrual
widely publicized research findings: Support for Emergency Contraception bleeding. Participants serving areas of
“I think we should have careful research While some providers were cautious in lower socioeconomic status also noted
about it first. I cannot accept it if you just their support of emergency contracep- that their patients’poor hygiene practices
introduce it, but don't have any outcomes tives—desiring more information, believ- deterred them from promoting the IUD as
of careful research.”—Midwife, urban dis- ing the side effects too severe or feeling the an emergency method.
trict hospital. efficacy of the methods to be too dubious— Despite such occasional opposition,
“All methods that don't affect a patient’s most participants endorsed the use of these most providers generally agreed that
health and can prevent pregnancy should methods. Emergency method use was de- emergency contraception was less bur-
be publicized, but I think that health fended wholeheartedly for rape victims, for densome psychologically, financially and
providers should know thoroughly the ad- sexually active unmarried adolescents, for physically than was abortion. Further-
vantages, disadvantages and effects of emer- women not in a permanent union or more, they noted that the side effects,
gency contraception before deciding women having infrequent intercourse, and while of concern, were relatively simple
whether to publicize it.”—Medical doctor, for perimenopausal women. Providers also to counteract or treat and tended to be
urban district hospital. supported the use of emergency contra- short-lived compared with those associ-
There were also forceful appeals for ac- ceptives as a back-up if a woman doubted ated with surgical abortion.
curate information about the proper use the efficacy of her regular method. Some
of emergency contraceptives and about suburban providers, however, did not sup- Attitudes Toward Distribution
the mechanisms of action of the various port the use of emergency methods; they While there was general consensus about
regimens. The participants were adamant feared that their use would hinder progress the need for emergency contraception,
in calling for training as a prerequisite to toward meeting sterilization targets. providers differed in their beliefs about
providing appropriate treatment of com- Providers who supported increased use how these methods should be distributed.
plications and side effects associated with of and access to emergency methods ar- The majority of providers believed that
the methods. These concerns were par- gued that they were invaluable to women distribution needed to be strictly con-
ticularly salient since emergency contra- because they reduced the need for surgi- trolled, and they voiced concern that phar-
ceptive supplies are already available over cal abortion: macists and other drug sellers lacked suf-
the counter, and providers feared that “If we supply information soon and ad- ficient training to provide women with
women might use these methods on their vise women to use the drug early, the ef- precise and correct instructions for use of
own and then present at the hospital or ficacy will be high, and women can avoid these methods.
7. E. Weisberg et al., “Emergency Contraception: Gen- guntó acerca de su conocimiento y actitudes cussion et d’interviews en profondeur, des
eral Practitioner Knowledge, Attitudes and Practices in con respecto a tres métodos de anticonceptivos médecins, accoucheuses et autres prestataires
New South Wales,“ Medical Journal of Australia, de emergencia—el método Yuzpe, el tratamien- de services de planification familiale de Ho Chi
162:136–138, 1995; and R. Burton and W. Savage, “Knowl-
edge and Use of Postcoital Contraception: A Survey
to de uso exclusivo de levonorgestrel y el méto- Minh-Ville, au Viet Nam, ont été interrogés
Among Health Professionals in Tower Hamlets,“ British do de la inserción postcoito de un anillo de sur leur connaissance et leurs attitudes à
Journal of General Practitioners, 40:326–330, 1990. cobre DIU. La mayoría de los proveedores del l’égard de trois méthodes contraceptives d’ur-
8. C. Ellertson et al., “Expanding Emergency Contra-
servicio estaban familiarizados con el concep- gence: le régime Yuzpe, un régime à base ex-
ception in Developing Countries,“ Studies in Family Plan- to de anticonceptivos de emergencia y apoyaron clusive de lévonorgestrel et l’insertion après
ning, 26:1–13, 1995. su práctica, aunque carecían de información rapport d’un stérilet au cuivre. La notion de
9. D. Goodkind, “Abortion in Vietnam: Measurements, exacta y detallada acerca del uso de estos méto- contraception d’urgence était connue de la plu-
Puzzles, and Concerns,“ Studies in Family Planning, dos y sobrestimaban las contraindicaciones y part des prestataires, qui en avalisaient aussi
25:342–352, 1994. los efectos secundarios potenciales de los mis- la pratique sans toutefois disposer d’informa-
10. J. Knodel et al., “Why Is Oral Contraceptive Use in mos; tenían gran interés en recibir adies- tions précises et détaillées sur l’application des
Vietnam So Low?“ International Family Planning Per- tramiento para mejorar sus habilidades y méthodes et sur les contre-indications et effets
spectives, 21:11–18, 1995. conocimientos en este campo. En general, los secondaires potentiels, qu’ils surestimaient
11. D. Morgan, Focus Groups as Qualitative Research, Sage participantes estaban de acuerdo acerca de la généralement. Ces prestataires ont également
Publications, Newbury Park, Calif., 1988; and J. Knodel, necesidad de obtener más información empírica exprimé un vif intérêt en faveur d’une forma-
N. Havanon and A. Pramualratana, “Fertility Transition acerca de la seguridad y eficacia de estos méto- tion apte à améliorer leurs connaissances et
in Thailand: A Qualitative Analysis,“ Population and De- dos, aunque indicaron su desacuerdo con res- leurs compétences en la matière. Les partici-
velopment Review, 10:297–328, 1984.
pecto al grado en que se deberían implantar y pants ont manifesté un accord général sur la
poner a disponibilidad de las mujeres de Viet- nécessité d’informations empiriques plus com-
Resumen nam este tipo de métodos anticonceptivos de plètes quant à la sécurité et à l’efficacité des
En una serie de grupos focales y entrevistas emergencia. méthodes. Les avis étaient cependant plus
detalladas con médicos, parteras y otros provee- partagés quant à la facilité avec laquelle les
dores de servicios de planificación familiar en Résumé méthodes d’urgence devraient être mises à la
la ciudad de Ho Chi Minh, Vietnam, se les pre- Dans le cadre d’une série de groupes de dis- disponibilité des femmes au Viet Nam.
Correction
In “Knowledge and Attitudes About Emergency Contraception Among Health Work-
ers in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam” [23:68–72], by Nguyen Thi Nhu Ngoc et al., the
proportions of medical doctors and nurses or midwives who participated in the focus-
group discussions (p. 69) were reversed: Approximately one-third of participants were
doctors, and slightly fewer than two-thirds were nurses or midwives.