BOMBAY HIGHCOURT

DAILY MAIN CAUSELIST

For Friday The 9th December 2022
COURT NO. 54
DIVISION
AT 10:30 AM
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE NITIN JAMDAR
HON'BLE JUSTICE MS. GAURI GODSE

Sr. CASE NO. PARTIES ADVOCATES

FOR CIRCULATION

1 WP/4914/2022 TATA SONS PRIVATE LIMITED Economic Laws Practice

[Original] VS
UNION OF INDIA THROUGH THE
MINISTRY OF FINANCE
REMARK : Praecipe dtd. 30.11.2022. CENTRAL GOODS AND SERVICES TAX ACT,2017.

DUE ADMISSION - 1

2 WP/782/2018 BARAMATI TALUKA SAHAKARI J SHEKHAR AND CO

[Civil] DOODH UTPADAK SANGH R.NO.1 TO 3
MARYADIT, THROUGH ITS GOVERNMENT PLEADER WRIT
AUTHORISED REPRESENTATIVE CELL
VS
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND
ORS.
REMARK : ===MATTER IS UNDER SEARCH===

3 WP/798/2018 HOTEL BANARASI INN. PRIVATE T. N. TRIPATHI and CO.

[Original] LIMITED RES. NO. 3
VS RESP NO. 1 AND 2
BANK OF BARODA AND 2 ORS. DHARMENDRA JITENDRA DAMANI
REMARK : Adj. dtd. 26.11.2022. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE OF FIROZ KHAN DT.24/04/2018 PAGE NO.1-4 FILED
ON DT.24/04/2018=== AFFIDAVIT IN REPLY OF THE RESPONDENT NO. 1 AND 2 DT. 06/08/2018 TAKEN ON
RECORD DT. 07/08/2018 (U/OBJ. NO RUNNING PAGINATION).== ADDITIONAL COMPILATION OF
DOCUMENTS (COPY) ON BEHALF OF PETITIONER DTD. 06/10/2018 FILED ON 08/10/2018 PAGES (1 TO
356). == AFFIDAVIT IN REJOINDER DT 03/10/2018 FILED ON 09/10/2018 PAGES 295-321 == AFFIDAVIT IN
REPLY OF RES NO. 3 DT. FILED ON 11/10/2018 PAGES 265-268== AFFIDAVIT IN SUR REJOINDER OF
RESPODENT DT. 22/10/2018 FILED ON 26/10/2018 PAGES 322-340==

WITH

WP/801/2018 HOTEL BANARASI INN. PRIVA T. N. TRIPATHI and CO.

[Orignal] TE LIMITED DHARMENDRA JITENDRA DAMAN
VS I

03/12/2022 01:30:52 1/4

 DAILY MAIN CAUSELIST COURT NO 54-FOR FRIDAY THE 9TH DECEMBER 2022 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 2 -

BANK OF BARODA AND 2 ORS RES. NO. 3

MR. RABINDRA HAZARI
RESP NO. 1 AND 2

WITH

WP/115/2018 HOTEL BANARASI INN. PRIVA T. N. TRIPATHI and CO.

[Orignal] TE LIMITED AND 2 ORS. MR. RABINDRA HAZARI
VS RESPONDENT
BANK OF BARODA

With

CHSW/157/2019 HOTEL BANARASI INN. PRIVA T. N. TRIPATHI AND CO.

[Orignal] TE LIMITED AND 2 ORS. T. N. TRIPATHI and CO.
VS MR. RABINDRA HAZARI
In BANK OF BARODA RESPONDENT
WP/115/2018

4 WP/2480/2018 SAMIR JAIN AND ANR. -

[Original] VS PRASAD DNYANESHWAR BORKAR
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 2 ORS.
REMARK : Adj. dtd. 26.11.2022. === LAST PAGE NO.351 ===

WITH

WP/1474/2022 PUNJAB CHEMICALS AND CROP PDS Legal

[Orignal] PROTECTION LTD. MISHRA JITENDRA BRIJBHUSH
VS AN
THE UNION OF INDIA THROUG MISHRA JITENDRA BRIJBHUSH
H THE SECRETARY AND 2 ORS AN

REMARK: ==== AS PER CIRCULATION PRAECIPE DATED 25/03/2022 ====

WITH

WP/2256/2021 PRADEEPKUMAR J. JHAVERI India Law Alliance

[Orignal] VS Maya Majumdar
UNION OF INDIA AND 2 ORS. India Law Alliance
Maya Majumdar
SANGEETA YADAV

REMARK: Praecipe Dtd. 15/02/2022

With

IA(L)/19167/2022
ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR GENER YADAV SANGEETA SABHAPATI
(ECHCBM02006782022)
[Original] AL DIRECTORATE OF REVENUE India Law Alliance
INTELLIGENCE Maya Majumdar
VS India Law Alliance
PRADEEPKUMAR J. JHAVERI A Maya Majumdar
ND ORS SANGEETA YADAV

03/12/2022 01:30:52 2/4

 DAILY MAIN CAUSELIST COURT NO 54-FOR FRIDAY THE 9TH DECEMBER 2022 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 3 -

WITH

WP/1272/2021 SATISH GANATRA AND ANR Ashok Singh

[Orignal] VS Ashok Singh
ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR, DIRE sangeeta yadav
CTORATE OF REVENUE INTELL sangeeta yadav
IGENCE MUMBAI ZONAL UNIT
AND ANR

REMARK: ==== AS PER CIRCULATION PRAECIPE DATED 26/04/2022 ====

WITH

WP/1276/2021 SATISH GANATRA AND ANR Ashok Singh

[Orignal] VS sangeeta yadav
ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR DIREC sangeeta yadav
TORATE OF REVENUE INTELLI
GENCE MUMBAI ZONAL UNIT
AND ANR

REMARK: ==== AS PER CIRCULATION PRAECIPE DATED 26/04/2022 ====

WITH

WP/1279/2021 SATISH GANATRA AND ANR Ashok Singh

[Orignal] VS sangeeta yadav
ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR, DIRE sangeeta yadav
CTORATE OF REVENUE INTELL
IGENCE MUMBAI ZONAL UNIT
AND ANR

REMARK: ==== AS PER CIRCULATION PRAECIPE DATED 26/04/2022 ====

WITH

WP/1410/2021 SATISH GANATRA AND ANR Ashok Singh

[Orignal] VS sangeeta yadav
ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR, DIRE sangeeta yadav
CTORATE OF REVENUE INTELL
IGENCE MUMBAI ZONAL UNIT
AND ANR

REMARK: ==== AS PER CIRCULATION PRAECIPE DATED 26/04/2022 ====

5 WP/3421/2018 ASSET RECONSTRUCTION M/S. APEX LAW PARTNERS
[Civil] COMPANY (INDIA) LIMITED AND FOR R.NO.1
ANR DESAI HEMA VASANTRAI
VS
ASHOK NANDKISHOR MEHRA AND
ORS.
REMARK : Note :-1) Further Affidavit in Reply of legal Heirs of Deceased Respondent No.1 is kept herewith separately as paging
not done properly. #2) Compilation of documents filed on 18/06/22 is kept herewith.#3)M/s. Apex Law Partners for Petitioner, VP
filed on 11/10/2022 #4) As per Court's order dtd. 12/10/2022 Photo copies of Record and Proceeding (i.e. Bailiff's report, Memo
Synopsis, compilation of Documents and exhibit) given to M/s. Apex Law Partners on 11/11/2022. #5)office objections are not
removed till date Court DB===for Admission.

03/12/2022 01:30:52 3/4

 DAILY MAIN CAUSELIST COURT NO 54-FOR FRIDAY THE 9TH DECEMBER 2022 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 4 -

6 WP/5073/2018 YOGESHCHANDRA SHANTARAM YOGITA DESHMUKH CHITNIS

[Civil] BHOIR AND ANR. R.NO. 1 TO 3
VS
THE UNION OF INDIA THROUGH
THE UNDER SECRETARY AND ORS.
with

CAW/800/2019 YOGESHCHANDRA SHANTARAM B YOGITA DESHMUKH CHITNIS

[Civil] HOIR AND ANR. YOGITA DESHMUKH CHITNIS
VS S V BHARUCHA
In THE UNION OF INDIA THRU T R.NO. 1 TO 3
WP/5073/2018 HE UNDER SECRETARY, MINIS
TRY OF COMMERCE AND INDUS
TRY AND ORS

7 WP/6295/2018 BHIMA SAHAKARI SAKHAR AJAY A JOSHI

[Civil] KARKHANA LTD. THROUGH MD MR. RES. 1,2,3
RAVINDRA GHULE RESP NO. 2
VS MAYA MAJUMDAR
UNION OF INDIA THROUGH
CUSTOMS, EXCISE SERVICE TAX
TRIBUNAL AND ANR
8 WP/6443/2018 VASANT NARAYAN LOTHEY (PATIL) RESPONDENT NO.2
[Civil] VS R.NO. 4
THE SECRETARY, HOUSING DEPT. Respondent
AND ORS. Res no 1
GARGE ANIRUDDHA ARUN
REMARK : Note:-Additional affidavit of petitioner filed on 21/08/2018 is kept herewith serially at page no. 59 to
73.---------------- 2) Affidavit in reply on behalf of R. No. 1 filed on 02/11/18 is kept herewith as paging not done
properly.----------------- 3)Rejoinder filed on 11/04/19 is kept herewith as paging not done properly.

BOTTOM OF THE BOARD (ADMISSION MATTER)

9 WP/210/2021 EATON INDUSTRIAL SYSTEMS Sriram Sridharan

[Original] PRIVATE LIMITED Ram Ochani
VS
THE UNION OF INDIA THROUGH
THE SECRETARY AND ANR.
REMARK : Adj. dtd. 02.12.2022. Central Excise & Salt Act.

03/12/2022 01:30:52 4/4

 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT
DAILY SUPPLEMENTARY CAUSELIST
For Friday The 9th December 2022
COURT NO. 54
DIVISION
AT 10:30 AM
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE NITIN JAMDAR
HON'BLE JUSTICE MS. GAURI GODSE

HEADER NOTE :
1) SR. NO. 901 AND SR. NO. 902 WILL BE TAKEN AFTER SR. NO. 01 OF DAILY MAIN BOARD .
2) SR. NO. 903 TO SR. NO. 932 WILL BE TAKEN AFTER SR. NO. 09 OF DAILY MAIN BOARD .

Sr. CASE NO. PARTIES ADVOCATES

FOR CIRCULATION

901 WP(L)/33250/2022 MAKE INDEX IMPEX A KHAITAN and CO.

[Original] PROPRIETORSHIP CONCERN OF Ram Ochani
PROPRIETOR RAJESH NAKHUA Ram Ochani
VS Vyas and Bhalwal
UNION OF INDIA AND 5 ORS.
REMARK : Praecipe dtd. 08.12.2022. Customs Act, 1962.

902 WP(L)/38114/2022 AMIT GALA PDS Legal

[Original] VS
THE UNION OF INDIA
REMARK : Praecipe dtd. 07.12.2022. Customs Act, 1962.

BOTTOM OF THE BOARD (ADMISSION MATTER)

903 WP/9484/2019 IMS PROSCHOOL PVT. LTD. RESP NO. 2 TO 5

[Civil] VS RESP NO. 2,5
THE UNION OF INDIA THROUGH GOVERNMENT PLEADER WRIT
THE SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF CELL
FINANCE , DEPT. OF REVENUE AND Maya Majumdar
ORS
REMARK : ADJ. FROM 07/12/2022=== Note :- 1) Affidavit in Reply on behalf of Res No.6 filed on dt.
15/02/2022 is kept herewith as paging not done properly._____ 2) Affidavit in Rejoinder filed on dated 22/04/22
is kept herewith as paging not done properly.

904 WP/9404/2019 L AND T HYDROCARBON SRIRAM SRIDHARAN

[Civil] ENGINEERING LTD. AND ANR RESP NO. 1,3,4
VS JITENDRA BRIJBHUSHAN MISHRA
THE UNION OF INDIA THROUGH
THE SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF
FINANCE, DEPT. OF REVENUE AND
ORS

08/12/2022 17:38:08 1/12

 DAILY SUPPLEMENTARY CAUSELIST COURT NO 54-FOR FRIDAY THE 9TH DECEMBER 2022 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 2 -

REMARK : AT the bottom of Admission Board 1) As per courts order dt.09/11/2022, Amendment is carried out
on dt.16/11/2022. 2) Draft Amendment tendered in court on dt. 09/11/2022 is marked "X" and is kept herewith.
Further Note: 1) Additional Affidavit on behalf of the Petitioner filed on dt. 02/12/2022 is kept herewith.

905 WP/1885/2021 SITA INFORMATION NETWORKING Economic Laws Practice

[Original] COMPUTING INDIA PVT LTD government pleader original side
VS mumbai
STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND 3 government pleader original side
ORS mumbai
-
REMARK : == Adj. dtd. 08.12.2022. == == A/W CWP 8988/2022 == Maharashtra Value Added Tax.

WITH

WP/2192/2021 G.R.INFRASTRUCTURE PVT.LT Economic Laws Practice

[Orignal] D. government pleader origin
VS al side mumbai
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA SATYAPRAKASH SHARMA (RES
AND 5 ORS. P. NO. 5 & 6)
government pleader origin
al side mumbai

REMARK: ==== AS PER CIRCULATION PRAECIPE DATED 14/02/2022 ====

WITH

WP/105/2022 HOLCIM TECHNOLOGY LTD. AN PDS Legal

[Orignal] D ANR -
VS PDS Legal
THE UNION OF INDIA THROUG government pleader origin
H THE SECRETARY AND 4 ORS al side mumbai
S

REMARK: Maharashtra Value Added Tax.

WITH

WP/3062/2022 HOLCIM TECHNOLOGY LTD. PDS Legal

[Orignal] VS
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
AND 2 ANR

REMARK: Maharashtra Value Added Tax.

WITH

WP/116/2022 HOLCIM TECHNOLOGY LTD. AN PDS Legal

[Orignal] D ANR -
VS PDS Legal
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 4 government pleader origin
ORS. al side mumbai

REMARK: Circulation Praecipe Dtd. 10.11.2021

WITH

08/12/2022 17:38:08 2/12

 DAILY SUPPLEMENTARY CAUSELIST COURT NO 54-FOR FRIDAY THE 9TH DECEMBER 2022 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 3 -

WP/3072/2022 SITA INFORMATION NETWORKI Economic Laws Practice

[Orignal] NG COMPUTING INDIA PRIVAT Government Pleader OS
E LIMITED Government Pleader OS
In VS
/0/ STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND
3 ORS.

REMARK: Maharashtra Value Added Tax.

WITH

WP/2051/2019 CASTROL LTD., UK AND 2 OT VOXLAW ADVOCATES AND SOLI

[Orignal] HERS CITORS
VS DHANESH RAMANLAL SHAH
UNION OF INDIAA AND 3 OTH THAKKER RUJU
ERS RESP. NO. 1
RESP NO. 3 AND 4

WITH

WP/3655/2019 CASTROL LTD., UK AND 2 OR VOXLAW ADVOCATES AND SOLI

[Orignal] S CITORS
VS THAKKER RUJU
UNION OF INDIA AND 3 ORS RESP. NO. 3

WITH

WP/3656/2019 CASTROL LTD. UK AND 3 ORS VOXLAW ADVOCATES AND SOLI

[Orignal] . CITORS
VS THAKKER RUJU
UNION OF INDIA AND 4 ORS. RES. NO. 3

WITH

WP/3657/2019 CASTROL LTD. UK AND 2 ORS VOXLAW ADVOCATES AND SOLI

[Orignal] . CITORS
VS THAKKER RUJU
UNION OF INDIA AND 3 ORS. RESP NO.3,4

WITH

WP/3658/2019 CASTROL LTD., UK AND 2 OR VOXLAW ADVOCATES AND SOLI

[Orignal] S CITORS
VS THAKKER RUJU
UNION OF INDIA AND 3 ORS RESP. NO 3

WITH

WP/3663/2019 CASTROL LTD. UK AND 2 ORS VOX LAW

[Orignal] . THAKKER RUJU
VS RESP. NO. 3
UNION OF INDIA AND 3 ORS.

08/12/2022 17:38:08 3/12

 DAILY SUPPLEMENTARY CAUSELIST COURT NO 54-FOR FRIDAY THE 9TH DECEMBER 2022 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 4 -

WITH

WP/788/2022 SITA INFORMATION NETWORKI Economic Laws Practice

[Orignal] NG COMPUTING INDIA PRIVAT government pleader origin
E LIMITED al side mumbai
VS government pleader origin
STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND al side mumbai
3 ORS.

REMARK: ==== AS PER CIRCULATION PRAECIPE DATED 18/02/2022 ====

WITH

WP/787/2022 SITA INFORMATION NETWORKI Economic Laws Practice

[Orignal] NG COMPUTING INDIA PRIVAT government pleader origin
E LIMITED al side mumbai
VS government pleader origin
STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND al side mumbai
3 ORS

REMARK: ==== AS PER CIRCULATION PRAECIPE DATED 18/02/2022 ====

906 WP/8988/2022 THE WHIRLPOOL CORPORATION Sharon Patole
[Civil] INC AND ORS
VS
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS
REMARK : Note : 1) As per Courts order dtd 19/09/2022, Rejoinder not filed till date. 2) Advocate for the
Petitioner has not supplied copies of the petition for issuing notice/writ to Res Nos.1a, 1b, 2 till date. 3) WP
Nos. 8988/2022 (main) 6894/19, 2595/21, 897/22, 898/22, 899/22, 900/22, 901/22 and WP(St.) No.17090/2021
are kept herewith.

WITH

WP/897/2022 THE WHIRLPOOL CORPORATION Sharon Patole

[Civil] INC AND ORS Ram Ochani
VS
In UNION OF INDIA THR. JOINT
/0/ SECRETARY DEPT. OF REVEN
UE AND ORS

WITH

WP/898/2022 THE WHIRLPOOL CORPORATION Sharon Patole

[Civil] INC AND ORS Ram Ochani
VS
In UNION OF INDIA THR. JOINT
/0/ SECRETARY DEPT. OF REVEN
UE AND ORS

WITH

WP/901/2022 THE WHIRLPOOL CORPORATION Sharon Patole

[Civil] INC AND ORS Ram Ochani

08/12/2022 17:38:08 4/12

 DAILY SUPPLEMENTARY CAUSELIST COURT NO 54-FOR FRIDAY THE 9TH DECEMBER 2022 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 5 -

VS
In UNION OF INDIA THR THE JO
/0/ INT SECRETARY AND ORS

WITH

WP/899/2022 THE WHIRLPOOL CORPORATION Sharon Patole

[Civil] INC AND ORS Ram Ochani
VS
In UNION OF INDIA THR THE JO
/0/ INT SECRETARY AND ORS

WITH

WP/900/2022 THE WHIRLPOOL CORPORATION Sharon Patole

[Civil] INC AND ORS Ram Ochani
VS
In UNION OF INDIA THR THE JO
/0/ INT SECRETARY AND ORS

WITH

WP/2595/2021 THE WHIRLPOOL CORPORATION Sharon Patole

[Civil] INC AND ORS Ram Ochani
VS
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS

REMARK: Pracepie Dt. 07.07.2021.

WITH

WP/6894/2019 WHIRLPOOL CORPORATION INC SHARON PATOLE

[Civil] . AND ORS. MITTAR SAIN MUKAT B BHARD
VS WAJ
UNION OF INDIA THROUGH TH NO. 1
E JT. SECTY. AND ORS. R.NO. 2 & 3
RESP. NO.1(a)
GOVERNMENT PLEADER WRIT C
ELL
RAM OCHANI

WITH

WP(ST)/17090/2021 LEAR AUTOMOTIVE INDIA PVT Sriram Sridharan

[Civil] LTD Sangeet Yadav
VS
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
THOU GP

FOR DIRECTION

08/12/2022 17:38:08 5/12

 DAILY SUPPLEMENTARY CAUSELIST COURT NO 54-FOR FRIDAY THE 9TH DECEMBER 2022 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 6 -

907 WP/835/2009 SUN PHARMACEUICAL INDUSTRIES M/S. SANJAY UDESHI and CO.
[Original] LIMITED AND ANR. CHANDRASHEKHAR SIDDHARTH
VS SURESH (RESP NO. 5 AND 6)
UNION OF INDIA AND 5 ORS.
REMARK : Adj. dtd. 08.12.2022. ======FOR FINAL HEARING========================
RESPONDENTS WAIVED SERVICE ========= Central Excise & Salt ActAFFIDAVIT IN REPLY FILED BY
THE RESP NO 1 2 3 4 FILED ON 20/07/2009

with

NMW/462/2011 SUN PHARMACEUICAL INDUSTR M/S. SANJAY UDESHI AND CO

[Orignal] IES LIMITED AND ANR. .
VS M/S. SANJAY UDESHI and CO
In UNION OF INDIA AND 5 ORS. .
WP/835/2009 CHANDRASHEKHAR SIDDHARTH
SURESH (RESP NO. 5 AND 6)

908 WP/2175/2010 ANUTH PHARMA LIMITED AND ANR. M.M. VAIDYA

[Original] VS GOVT. PLEADER, R.NO. 1, 2, 5 and
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA 6
REMARK : Adj. dtd. 08.12.2022. ==== TO BE HEARD ALONGWITH SR. NO. 208 (WP/199/2011) OF FINAL
HEARING BOARD ==== A/W. ASWP/322/1996, 1967/1996, 3862/2006, 3420/1996, 3466/2001 IS KEPT
HEREWITH ==

909 WP/199/2011 ANUH PHARMA LIMITED AND ANR. M.M. VAIDYA

[Original] VS GOVT. PLEADER
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
REMARK : Adj. dtd. 08.12.2022. Sales Tax Act 1979. AFFIDAVIT IN REPLY ON BEHALF OF RESPONDENT
FILED ON 03/03/2011.

FOR DISMISSAL

910 WP/1005/2011 EROS INTERNATIONAL MEDIA LTD. ADV.FOR FOR THE PETITIONER
[Original] AND ANR. ECONOMIC LAWS PRACTICE
VS fernandes Genevieve catherine
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS. (RESP NO.4 AND 5)
RESP NO, 1 AND 4
SUCHITRA KAMBLE FOR RESP.
NO. 2,3 AND 5
JITENDRA BRIJBHUSHAN MISHRA
REMARK : Adj. dtd. 08.12.2022. AFFIDAVIT IN REPLY ON BEHALF OF RES.FILED ON 09/03/2012.

FOR FINAL HEARING

911 WP/811/2007 MLC MARINE PTE LTD. AND ANR. M/S.BOSE AND MITRA AND CO.
[Civil] VS SHAM V WALVE
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS AND Maya Majumdar
ORS.
REMARK : THIS WRIT PETITION IS ADMITTED ON 29/03/2007. NOTE: 1) LD. COUNSEL WAIVES FOR RES.
NOS. 1 TO 4. ADVOCATE MAYA MUJUMDAR FOR RES, NOS. 1 TO 4 (VP FILED ON 08/04/2021) 2) WRIT
ISSUED. 3) CAW NO. 2945/2017 FOR FIXING THE DATE IS KEPT HEREWITH. 4) WPST NO. 94466/2020 IS
KEPT HEREWITH.

with

08/12/2022 17:38:08 6/12

 DAILY SUPPLEMENTARY CAUSELIST COURT NO 54-FOR FRIDAY THE 9TH DECEMBER 2022 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 7 -

CAW/2945/2017 THE COMMISSIONER OF CUSTO SHAM V WALVE

[Civil] MS, PUNE M/S.BOSE AND MITRA AND CO
VS .
In M/S. MLC MARINE PTE LTD A SHAM V WALVE
WP/811/2007 ND ANR. AMOL D JOSHI
Maya Majumdar

WITH

WP(ST)/94466/2020 AL JAZEERA SHIPPING CO. W M/S. BHATT and SALDANHA

[Civil] .L.L., BAHRAIN Mr. J. B. Mishra (Note of
VS appearance not filed)
THE COMMISSIONER OF CUSTO Maya Majumdar
MS AND ORS Maya Majumdar

912 WP/574/2010 VVF LIMITED P.K. SHETTY

[Original] VS S V BHARUCHA
UNION OF INDIA AND 7 ORS.
REMARK : Adj. dtd. 08.12.2022. Customs Act, 1962 AFFIDAVIT OF ASHUTOSH MISHRA IN REPLY FILED ON
08/06/2010 \ AFFIDAVIT OF AARTI SAEXNA ON BEHALF OF DRI FILED ON 11/06/2010 \ AFFIDAVIT TO
REJOINDER OF AARTI SAXENA FILED ON 25/06/2010 \ AFFIDAVIT TO REJOINDER OF ASHUTOSH MISHRA
FILED ON 25/06/2010

913 WP/1035/2010 M/S. ASAHI INDIA GLASS LIMITED M.M. VAIDYA

[Original] VS GOVT PLED R 1 2 3
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND
3 ORS.
REMARK : Adj. dtd. 08.12.2022. Sales Tax Act 1979.

914 WP/1429/2010 PREET INTERNATIONAL C.B. THAKAR and CO.

[Original] VS GOVT PLED R 1 TO 3
THE COMMISSIONER OF SALES TAX
AND 2 ORS.
REMARK : Adj. dtd. 08.12.2022. Sales Tax Act 1979 AFFIDAVIT OF GOVIND B. INDULKAR ON BEHALF OF
RESPONDENT FILED ON 1/09/2010.

915 WP/1593/2010 T.K. ISPAT PRIVATE LIMITED AND AMEET GEDAM

[Original] ANR. GOVT PLED R 1 TO 3
VS
STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND 2
ORS.
REMARK : Adj. dtd. 08.12.2022. Sales Tax Act 1979 AFFIDAVIT OF SERIVCE FILED ON 13/07/10 \ AFFIDAVIT
IN REPLY ON BEHALF OF RES. FILED ON 30/11/2010.

916 WP/1927/2012 JAMES MACKINTOSH AND CO. PVT. MANOJ R. KHATRI

[Original] LTD.
VS
JOINT SECRETARY, REVISIONAL
AUTHORITY AND ANR.
REMARK : Adj. dtd. 08.12.2022. Customs Act, 1962. HEARING EXPEDITED.

08/12/2022 17:38:08 7/12

 DAILY SUPPLEMENTARY CAUSELIST COURT NO 54-FOR FRIDAY THE 9TH DECEMBER 2022 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 8 -

917 WP/6130/2013 HALDEX INDIA LTD Sriram Sridharan

[Civil] VS R. NO. 5
THE UNION OF INDIA, THROUGH MRS. S.V. BHARUCHA
SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF
COMMERCE AND ORS
REMARK : BALANCE BOARD DT. 08/12/2022=== NOTE : #1) WRIT PETITION IS ADMITTED ON 22/09/2014
;#2) RESPONDENTS WAIVE SERVICE ;#3) SRIRAM SRIDHARAN FOR PETITIONER (VP FILED ON
23/06/2022 WITH NO OBJECTION) #4) NO CA.

918 WP/11037/2013 VINATI ORGANICS LIMITED Sriram Sridharan

[Civil] VS R.NO. 3
UNION OF INDIA, THROUGH NEELESH VASANT KALANTRI
SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF
FINANCE, DEPT OF REVENUE AND
ORS
REMARK : Note : 1) As per Court's Order dated 22/09/2022 passed in IA No. 18374/2022 Writ Petition No.
11037/2013 is restored. 2) This Writ Petition is admitted on 22/12/2014 and ready for final hearing. . 3)
Advocate Raju Thakkar for Res. No. 3 and 4 (VP filed on 24/02/2021 with No Objection.). 4) Respondents waives
service. (VP not filed for Res. Nos. 1 and 2. 5) No CA pending.

919 WP/598/2014 M/S. EXPRESS HANDLINGS BRIJESH PATHAK

[Civil] WORLDWIDE, THROUGH PROP. R.NO. 3
SHRI. HARBINDER SINGH P. SIDU DINKAR BHOSALE
DHANJAL
VS
UNION OF INDIA, THROUGH
SECRETARY MINISTRY OF LAW AND
JUSTICE, DEPT OF LEGAL AFFAIRS
AND ORS
REMARK : BALANCE BOARD DT. 08/12/2022=== Customs & Tariffs Act,1975=== NOTE : W.P. NO. 598/2014
IS ADMITTED ON 21/01/2014 AND READY FOR HEARING 2) NO CA PENDING 3) NO WRIT

920 WP/641/2014 KALYANI FASHIONS PRIVATE T. N. TRIPATHI and CO.

[Original] LIMITED -
VS RESPONDANT NO. 1
STRESSED ASSETS STABILISATION AKS LEGAL CONSULTANTS
FUND AND 2 ORS INTERJURIS
REMARK : == FOR HEARING == Rule on 15/04/14. FOR HRG PRAECIPE DT 25/03/2015 AFFIDAVIT OF
SERVICE DATED 10TH MARCH, 2014, FILED ON 10/03/2014.AFFIDAVIT OF REPLY DT.4/6/14. PRAECIPE DT.
04/12/2014.AFFIDAVIT IN PROOF OF SERVICE OF MR. AMOL B. SASTE DT. 06/01/2015 FILED ON
06/01/2015. COMILATION OF JUDGMENT RELIED UPON BY R.NO.3,DT.14/01/2015,FILED ON 14/01/2015.
COMPILATION OF JUDGEMENTS CORAM KANADE AND DERE JJ DATED 7/1/2015. FILED ON
14/1/2015.==== 1st amendment carried out in red ink on 11/07/2018 pursuant to Court's order
dt.05/01/2018.==== AFFIDAVIT IN REPLY OF RES.NO.1 PAGE NO.139-268 FILED ON 01/03/2018 === Adj.
dtd. 08.12.2022.

WITH

WP(L)/29046/2022 ENNENN CORP LIMITED INTERJURIS

[Original] VS
KALYANI FASHIONS PVT LTD
In AND 2 ORS
/0/

REMARK: Praecipe dtd. 13.09.2022. Constitution of India.

08/12/2022 17:38:08 8/12

 DAILY SUPPLEMENTARY CAUSELIST COURT NO 54-FOR FRIDAY THE 9TH DECEMBER 2022 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 9 -

921 WP/736/2014 EVEREST FLAVOURS LIMITED PDS LEGAL

[Civil] VS R.NO. 1 TO 4
THE UNION OF INDIA, THROUGH ANAMIKA MALHOTRA
MINISTRY OF LAW AND JUSTICE
AND ORS
REMARK : BALANCE BOARD DT. 08/12/2022=== Central Excise & Salt Act=== Note : W.P. No. 736/2014 is
Admitted n 24/08/2015 2) As per Court's order dated 24/08/2015 Res. Nos. 1 to 4 all waives service. 3) No CA
Pending 4) W.P. No. 736/2014 hearing expedited.

922 WP/2077/2014 CINEMA OWENERS AND M/S. THAKORE JARIWALA and

[Original] EXHIBITORS ASSOCIATION OF ASSOCIATES
INDIA RESPONDENT
VS GOVERNMENT PLEADER
STATE OF MAHARASHTRA ORIGINAL SIDE MUMBAI (R-
REVENUE AND FORESTS 1and3)
DEPARTMENT AND 2 ORS.
REMARK : Adj. dtd. 08.12.2022. ======= AS PER ORD. DTD. 18/10/2016 N/B. HONOURABLE SHRI JUS.B.
P. COLABAWALLA =====AS PER ORDER DATED 13/6/2016 RULE NISI ISSUED TO THE RESPONDENT
NO.3 THROUGH BAILIFF, SERVICE IS EFFECTED ON 30/11/2016 AND RESPONDENT NO. 2 THROUGH
BAILIFF SERVICE REPORT IS AWAITED AND THE RESPONDENT NO. 1 THROUGH GOVERNMENT PLEADER
SERVICE IS EFFECTED ON 01/12/2016.===

WITH

WP/1813/2016 FICCI-MULTIPLEX ASSOCIATI KHAITAN AND CO

[Orignal] ON OF INDIA GOVERNMENT PLEADER ORIGIN
VS AL SIDE MUMBAI
STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND R-1 AND 3
2 ORS.

REMARK: ==== PRAECIPE DATED 16/02/2016 ==== ==== PRAECIPE DATED 09/12/2015 = PLACE
BEFOPRE APPROPRIATE BENCH, PER SHRI V.M. KANADE AND SMT. REVATI MOHITE DERE, JJ. DT.
11/01/2016.== Pursuant to order dated 2nd September 2015 passed by the Division Bench the Registry
issued Rule Nisi to the Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 through Government Pleader vide letter No. W/Cell/Rule
Nisi/2017/2 dated 4th January 2017, service is effected on 9th January 2017====
With

NMW/6/2017 FICCI-MULTIPLEX ASSOCIATI KHAITAN and CO.

[Orignal] ON OF INDIA AND ANR KHAITAN AND CO
VS GOVERNMENT PLEADER ORIGIN
In STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND AL SIDE MUMBAI
WP/1813/2016 2 ORS. R-1 AND 3

WITH

WP/2221/2014 FICCI-MULTIPLEX ASSOCIATI KHAITAN AND CO

[Orignal] ON OF INDIA AND ANOTHER
VS
STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND
3 OTHERS

REMARK: Bombay Entertainment Duty Act 1923

WITH

08/12/2022 17:38:08 9/12

DAILY SUPPLEMENTARY CAUSELIST COURT NO 54-FOR FRIDAY THE 9TH DECEMBER 2022 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 10 -

WP/1755/2013 BIG TREE ENTERTAINMENT PV AZB AND PARTNERS

[Orignal] T. LTD. AND ANR. 0
VS GOVT. PLEADER ( R. NO.1,2
STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND & 3)
2 ORS.

REMARK: cmis Bombay Entertainment Duty Act 1923 AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE ON BEHALF OF
PETITIONERS FILED IN COURT ON 25/06/2013. AFFIDAVIT IN REPLY ON BEHALF OF RESPONDENT
FILED ON 22/7/2013 AFF.IN REJOINDER OF THE PETITIONERS TO THE AFF.IN REPLY OF RE.NO.1
DT.BY 15TH JAN,201 (CORAM: THE CHIEF JUSTICE & M.S.SANKLECHA,J. DT:11/03/2014) FILED ON
11/03/2014
WITH

WP/1689/2015 BIG TREE ENTERTAINMENT PV AZB AND PARTNERS

[Orignal] T LTD AND ANR GOVERNMENT PLEADER ORIGIN
VS AL SIDE MUMBAI
STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND RESPONDENT NO 1 & 2
ANR

REMARK: ==== PRAECIPE DATED 06/05/2015 ==== REJOINDER OF THE PETITIONER DTD
30/06/2017 AS PER COURTS ORDER DTD 01/07/2017 FILED ON 01/07/2017. =
WITH

NMW/6/2017 FICCI-MULTIPLEX ASSOCIATI KHAITAN and CO.

[Orignal] ON OF INDIA AND ANR KHAITAN AND CO
VS GOVERNMENT PLEADER ORIGIN
In STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND AL SIDE MUMBAI
WP/1813/2016 2 ORS. R-1 AND 3

923 WP/3141/2014 M/S. MEDILUX LABORATORIES PVT. Kaizeen Mistry

[Original] LTD.
VS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND ANR.
REMARK : Adj. dtd. 08.12.2022. RULE DT 17/08/2015. Customs Act, 1962

924 WP/3313/2014 WATSON PHARMA PRIVATE Sriram Sridharan

[Civil] LIMITED R. NO. 1
VS ANAMIKA MALHOTRA
THE UNION OF INDIA, THROUGH
SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF
COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY AND
ORS
REMARK : Central Excise & Salt Act=== NOTE : W.P. NO. 3313/2014 IS ADMITTED ON 28/09/2014 AND
READY FOR HEARING, 2) NO CA PENDING 3) NO WRIT 4) NO R & P.

925 WP/4756/2014 A. B. MAURI INDIA PVT. LTD. DESAI AND CHINOY

[Civil] VS RESP
UNION OF INDIA, THROUGH P S CARDOZO
SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF
FINANCE, DEPT OF REVENUE AND
ORS
REMARK : BALANCE BOARD DT. 08/12/2022=== Central Excise & Salt Act==== Note : W.P. 4756/2014 admitted on 08/05/2014 and ready for
Hearing.

08/12/2022 17:38:08 10/12

DAILY SUPPLEMENTARY CAUSELIST COURT NO 54-FOR FRIDAY THE 9TH DECEMBER 2022 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 11 -

926 WP/4990/2014 M/S. MILESTONE EXIMP PVT. LTD. SUNIL AGRAWAL

[Civil] VS
SETTLEMENT COMMISSIONE,
CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE,
ADDITIONAL BRANCH, MUMBAI
AND ORS
REMARK : NOTE :- 1) W.P. is admitted on 07/12/2015 and ready for hearing. Court (DB) for hearing II Short

927 WP/6124/2014 UNION OF INDIA, THROUGH JITENDRA BRIJBHUSHAN MISHRA

[Civil] DEDICATED LEGAL CELL AND ANR DUTTMENON DUNMORRSETT
VS
M/S. GE INDIA INDUSTRIAL
PRIVATE LIMITED
REMARK : BALANCE BOARD DT. 08/12/2022=== CUSTOMS ACT=== NOTE :- ### 1) RULE GRANTED ON
05/03/2015. #### 2) RESPONDENTS WAIVE SERVICE. #### 3) NO CIVIL APPLICATION PENDING.

928 WP/7456/2014 M/S. VIDEOCON INDUSTRIES LTD M/S. KAMAL AND CO.
[Civil] AND ORS M/S KAMAL AND CO
VS PETITIONER
UNION OF INDIA, THROUGH KAMAL and CO., SOLICITOR,
MINISTRY OF LAW, JUSTICE AND ADVOCATES and NOTARY
COMPANY AFFAIRS AND ANR MS. MAYA MUJUMDAR
MS. MAYA MUJUMDAR
REMARK : BALANCE BOARD DT. 08/12/2022=== NOTE :- 1) W.P. Admitted on 09/03/2015 and ready for
Hearing === 2) As per Court's order dated 30/08/2022, Amendment carried out, Additional reply has not filed
till date === 3) caw/61/2020 pending for fixing the date of W.P.

with

CAW/61/2020 THE COMMISSIONER OF CUSTO PRADEEP SHIVNARAIN JETLY

[Civil] MS (EXPORT ) KAMAL and CO., SOLICITOR,
VS ADVOCATES and NOTARY
In M/S. VIDEOCON INDUSTRIES M/S. KAMAL AND CO.
WP/7456/2014 LTD AND ORS M/S KAMAL AND CO
PETITIONER
MS. MAYA MUJUMDAR
MS. MAYA MUJUMDAR

929 WP/7721/2014 SHONAN ENGINEERING WORKS (P) PDS LEGAL

[Civil] LTD
VS
THE UNION OF INDIA, THROUGH
SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF
FINANCE, DEPT OF REVENUE AND
ORS
REMARK : BALANCE BOARD DT. 08/12/2022=== Central Excise & Salt Act=== Note : W.P. 7721/2014
Admitted on 14/09/2015 and ready for hearfing. 2) As per Coutrs' order dated 14/09/2015 Ad. Mr. Jetly waives
service for Respondent (V.P. not filed)

930 WP/8752/2014 WELLMAN HINDUSTAN LIMITED PDS LEGAL

[Civil] VS R.NO. 1 AND 2
THE UNION OF INDIA, THROUGH NEETA VINAY MASURKAR
SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF
COMMERCE AND ORS

08/12/2022 17:38:08 11/12

DAILY SUPPLEMENTARY CAUSELIST COURT NO 54-FOR FRIDAY THE 9TH DECEMBER 2022 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 12 -

REMARK : Note :- 1) W.P. is Admitted on 31/08/2015 and ready for Hearing. Court (DB) for Hearing A/P

931 WP/8889/2014 M/S. GRANT MEDICAL FOUNDATION Sriram Sridharan

[Civil] VS
THE UNION OF INDIA, THROUGH
SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF
FINANCE, DEPT OF REVENUE AND
ORS
REMARK : BALANCE BOARD DT. 08/12/2022=== CUSTOMS ACT ===

932 WP/11692/2014 HERBALIFE INTERNATIONAL INDIA KULDEEP U. NIKAM

[Civil] PVT. LIMITED R.NO. 2
VS JOEL CARLOS
JOINT SECRETARY, GOVERNMENT Maya Majumdar
OF INDIA AND ORS.
REMARK : BALANCE BOARD DT. 08/12/2022=== Central Excise & Salt Act=== NOTE : 1) W.P. NO.
11692/2014 IS ADMITTED ON 31/08/2015 AND HEARING EXPEDITED ====2) RULE NOTICES ISSUED TO
RES. NOS. 1 TO 4, DULY SERVED ===== 3) NO CA PENDING ====4) NO WRIT ====6) NO R & P

08/12/2022 17:38:08 12/12