Professional Documents
Culture Documents
J Ajo 2020 02 021
J Ajo 2020 02 021
PURPOSE: To evaluate the utility of repeat cultures at size at 3 months after controlling for baseline measures
days 3 and 7 after starting antifungal medications for (95% confidence interval 0.1 to 2.2 mm; P [ .03).
predicting outcomes in fungal keratitis. CONCLUSIONS: While not as predictive as day 7 cul-
DESIGN: Prespecified secondary analysis of the ran- tures, culture positivity at day 3 after starting treatment
domized clinical Mycotic Antimicrobial Localized Injec- is a significant predictor of the need for TPK in patients
tion trial. with moderate-to-severe filamentous fungal keratitis.
METHODS: Patients presenting to Aravind Eye Hospi- This has applications for risk stratification, and may facil-
tal, Pondicherry, India, with fungal keratitis and visual itate earlier consideration of TPK in high-risk
acuity worse than 20/70 received topical natamycin and patients. (Am J Ophthalmol 2020;215:1–7. Ó 2020
were randomized to either receive intrastromal injection Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.)
of voriconazole or topical therapy alone. All subjects
received corneal cultures at date of presentation, day
F
3, and day 7. Outcome measures included 3-week and UNGAL KERATITIS REPRESENTS A SIGNIFICANT PUB-
3-month visual acuity and scar size, corneal perforation, lic health challenge because, compared to bacterial
and/or the need for therapeutic penetrating keratoplasty etiologies, it is particularly difficult to treat and typi-
(TPK). Visual acuity and scar size were analyzed with cally results in worse visual outcomes.1 The Mycotic Ulcer
multiple linear regression controlling for baseline mea- Treatment Trial (MUTT) established topical natamycin as
sures. Survival analysis was used to analyze the risk the standard of care for managing filamentous fungal kera-
of corneal perforation and/or need for TPK. titis. However, many cases remain recalcitrant and continue
RESULTS: Of the 70 study subjects with fungal kera- to progress despite therapy, resulting in significant visual
titis, 25 of 69 (36%) remained culture positive at day 3, morbidity, perforation, and need for surgical intervention.2–
4
and 20 of 62 (32%) were culture positive at day 7. Cul- It has been theorized that earlier surgical intervention in
ture positivity at day 3 conferred a hazard ratio of 2.8 recalcitrant cases, before the infection has progressed to the
for requiring TPK (P [ .03) but was not a statistically point of perforation or extension to the limbus or sclera,
significant predictor of perforation, scar size, or final vi- may result in better patient outcomes and allow improved
sual acuity. Culture positivity at day 7 had a hazard ratio resource allocation in resource-poor settings.5,6 In light of
of 3.5 for requiring TPK (P [ .003). Those with positive this, novel diagnostic tools to identify recalcitrant cases as
cultures at day 7 had on average 3 logMAR lines worse vi- early as possible are of paramount importance.
sual acuity at 3 months (95% confidence interval 0.9 to Recent work has suggested repeat cultures after initia-
5.2 logMAR lines, P [ .006) and 1.1 mm larger scar tion of treatment may have excellent prognostic value.
Secondary analyses of the MUTT I and MUTT II trials
identified persistent culture positivity at day 6 after initia-
tion of appropriate medical therapy as a significant predic-
Accepted for publication Feb 24, 2020.
tor of perforation, need for therapeutic penetrating
From the Francis I. Proctor Foundation (J.P., T.C.P., T.R., T.M.L., J.R.- keratoplasty (TPK), and worse anatomic and visual out-
N.), University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, California, comes.7,8 However, given the rapid worsening in many
USA; Aravind Eye Hospital, Pondicherry, India (S.N., T.K., S.R.,
P.P.S.); UCSF Epidemiology and Biostatistics (T.C.P., T.M.L.),
cases as well as the long incubation period of filamentous
University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, California, USA; fungi in culture, even earlier identification of persistent
UCSF Department of Ophthalmology (T.R., T.M.L., J.R.-N.), culture positivity would be beneficial.
University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, California, USA;
and The Permanente Medical Group, Redwood City, California, USA
The Mycotic Antimicrobial Localized Injection Trial
(J.R.-N.). (MALIN) found no benefit to adjuvant intrastromal vori-
Inquiries to Jennifer Rose-Nussbaumer, UCSF/Proctor Foundation, conazole in addition to topical natamycin in the treatment
Division of Research, The Permanent Medical Group, 513 Parnassus
Ave, S347, San Francisco, CA 94143, USA; e-mail: jennifer.
of filamentous fungal keratitis in regard to repeat culture
rose-nussbaumer@ucsf.edu positivity, week 3 or month 3 visual acuity, rate of corneal
Baseline Characteristic Positive (n ¼ 25) Negative (n ¼ 44) Positive (n ¼ 20) Negative (n ¼ 42)
were included in the study, with a mean 6 standard de- derwent TPK during the observation period for lack of
viation (SD) age of participants of 52 6 13 years and a response to medical therapy with impending perforation
range from 19 to 80 years. Forty-four subjects (63%) or limbal involvement. Among these subjects, the median
were male. Patients with evidence of concomitant bac- time to TPK was 30 days, with a range of 3 to 141 days.
terial infection on smear were ineligible for the study. Adjusting for baseline culture positivity, subjects with
Subsequent bacterial cultures were negative for 70 of persistent culture positivity at day 3 were significantly
70 patients (100%) at baseline, 69 of 69 (100%) at day more likely to require subsequent TPK (HR 2.8, P ¼
3, and 61 of 62 (98%) at day 7. Baseline fungal cultures .026). This association remained statistically significant
were positive for 57 of the 70 participants (81%). Of when adjusting for deeper baseline infiltrate depth and
those that were culture positive at baseline, 19 grew Aspergillus ulcers, each of which were associated with
Fusarium species (33%), 17 grew Aspergillus species increased risk of TPK on univariate analysis. The Kaplan-
(30%), and 21 grew other filamentous fungal species Meier survival curves for TPK according to day 3 culture
(37%). Twenty-five of 69 subjects remained culture pos- status are depicted in Figure 1. Adjusting for baseline cul-
itive at day 3 (36%). Of these cultures, 3 grew Fusarium ture positivity, persistent culture positivity at day 7 was
(12%), 13 grew Aspergillus (52%), and 9 grew other fila- also strongly associated with subsequent TPK (HR 3.5,
mentous species (36%). Twenty of 65 subjects were P ¼ .003). The Kaplan-Meier survival curves for TPK ac-
persistently culture-positive at day 7 (30%). Of these, cording to day 7 culture status are depicted in Figure 2.
2 grew Fusarium (10%), 12 grew Aspergillus (60%), and Six of the 70 subjects (9%) developed corneal perfora-
6 grew other filamentous species (30%). Two of the 19 tion. Among these subjects, the median time to perforation
Fusarium ulcers (11%) remained culture positive at day was 85 days, with a range of 4 to 141 days. Persistent culture
7, compared to 12 of the 17 Aspergillus ulcers (71%). positivity at day 3 was not significantly associated with risk
Aspergillus ulcers were significantly more likely to of perforation (HR 1.1, P ¼ .92), nor was culture positivity
remain culture positive through day 7 compared to Fusa- at day 7 (HR 2.6, P ¼ .26). The majority of corneal ulcers
rium ulcers (P < .001). The average time to culture pos- remained smear positive at day 3 (86%; 59/69), and this was
itivity was 5.8 (3.9) days for baseline cultures, 5.0 (2.6) not predictive of need for TPK (HR 0.63, 95% CI 0.2-1.7,
days for day 3 cultures, and 4.4 (2.0) days for day 7 cul- P ¼ .36) or corneal perforation (HR 0.65, 95% CI 0.1-5.9,
tures. A comparison of baseline characteristics between P ¼ .7).
subjects based on culture status at days 3 and 7 of exam-
ination is provided in Table 1. VISUAL AND ANATOMIC OUTCOMES: Mean visual acu-
ity at baseline was 1.59 6 0.35 log MAR. At 3 months
THERAPEUTIC PENETRATING KERATOPLASTY AND follow-up, mean visual acuity was 1.28 6 0.63 log
PERFORATION: A total of 28 of the 70 subjects (40%) un- MAR. Persistent culture positivity at day 3 was not a
significant predictor of best-corrected visual acuity at ment confers a significantly increased risk of requiring
3 weeks (P ¼ .63) or 3 months (P ¼ .69) after presentation TPK; (2) persistent culture positivity at day 7 is strongly
(Table 2). However, day 7 culture positivity was associ- predictive of need for TPK, final visual acuity, and corneal
ated with significantly worse visual acuity at both week scar size; and (3) Aspergillus ulcers were more likely to
3 (P ¼ .003) and month 3 (P ¼ .006) (Table 2). After remain culture positive and were associated with worse out-
adjusting for baseline visual acuity, on average subjects comes. These findings confirm the prognostic utility of
with persistent culture positivity at day 7 had 3 logMAR repeat cultures at day 7, and are a novel demonstration of
lines worse visual acuity compared to those who were cul- the utility of day 3 cultures for predicting the need for
ture negative (95% CI 0.9 to 5.2 logMAR lines, P ¼ .006). TPK in fungal keratitis.
With respect to corneal scar size at 3 months, persistent Several clinical factors have been evaluated as
culture positivity at day 3 was not a significant predictor of possible prognosticators, including visual acuity at pre-
final scar size (multivariate linear regression adjusting for sentation, epithelial defect size, patient age, size and
baseline infiltrate size, P ¼ .55). After adjusting for base- depth of infiltrate, and the presence of ulcer pigmenta-
line infiltrate size, subjects who remained culture positive tion.11 However, clinical parameters can be problematic
at day 7 had an average final scar size 1.1 mm greater than as prognostic markers owing to inter-examiner vari-
those without (95% CI 0.1-2.2 mm; P ¼ .03). ability, even among expert cornea specialists.12,13 Previ-
ous findings indicate that patients who will eventually
need surgery may benefit from earlier intervention
before infection reaches the limbus or results in perfora-
DISCUSSION tion.5,6 However, clinicians managing fungal ulcers
THIS PRESPECIFIED SECONDARY ANALYSIS OF A CLINICAL have few clinical indicators to determine which pa-
trial evaluates the prognostic value of persistent culture tients are likely to require TPK. Thus, an objective
positivity at days 3 and 7 of treatment in patients with fila- parameter that predicts need for TPK as early as
mentous fungal keratitis. Key findings include the possible is highly beneficial. Our results indicate that
following: (1) persistent culture positivity at day 3 of treat- persistent culture positivity at day 3 after initiation of
TABLE 2. Visual Acuity 3 Weeks and 3 Months After Fungal Keratitis Infection According to Culture Status at Day 3 and Day 7
treatment was a statistically significant indicator of It is interesting that smear positivity at 3 days does not
need for subsequent TPK, with a hazard ratio of 2.8. predict the need for TPK. Previous reports have found 7-
This introduces a new and potentially valuable param- day smear results to be predictive of outcomes in fungal
eter to follow in the management of fungal keratitis. keratitis, including the need for TPK.7,8 This finding is
FUNDING/SUPPORT: NIH, NEI GRANT #EYK23025025RPB DEPARTMENT GRANT TO THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SAN
Francisco. The authors indicate no funding support. Financial Disclosures: None of the authors has a proprietary/financial interest to disclose. All authors
attest that they meet the current ICMJE criteria for authorship.