Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mechanical Excavation
Mechanical Excavation
Mechanical Excavation
7.1
7.1.1
Mechanical Excavation
Mechanisms of rock cutting
The main types of tool
Indenter
Theloadappliedbyanindenterisoneofcompressionandthatappliedbyadragbitisoneof shear(HoodandRoxborough1992).However,researchhasindicatedthatbothtypesoftoolcause theformationoflargerockchipsbyinducingtensilefractures.Theimpactofanindentercrushesa smallzoneofrockbeneaththetool.Thiscrushedrockdilatesandinducestensilestressesinthe rockimmediatelysurroundingthepointofimpact.Whenadragtoolhitstherocksurfaceatan obliqueangle,thereisafreefacetowardswhichmaterialcanbedisplaced.Hence,thetoolcan moreeasilypenetratetherock,causingshearfracturesthat,inturn,causethepropagationof tensilefracturesasrockchipsarepeeledoff. Mostrocksareanorderofmagnitude(x10)strongerincompressionthanintensionandhence anyactionthatinvolvesthecrushingofrockwillconsumealargeamountofenergy.Becausethe dragtoolinitiatestensilefracturesinamoredirectmanner,withlesscrushing,itismoreefficient thananindenter.However,indentersarebyfarthemostwidelyusedtypeoftool;whyisthis?The reasonliesinthestrengthofthetoolitself.Thematerialsusedforthecuttingedgemustbehard but,becauseofthisproperty,theyarealsobrittle.Themodeofactionofadragtoolinduces bending,ortensile,stressesinthetoolcuttingedgeandmakescatastrophicfailureofthetoolmore likely.Anindenter,ontheotherhand,isloadedmainlybyacompressiveforcealongitsmainaxis andthematerialofwhichitismadeisinherentlystrongincompression.(HoodandRoxborough 1992.) 7.1.2 a) Drag picks Cuttingparameters
64357738.doc
2/8/11
Figure7.1:Cuttingactionofdrag pick(Speight1997) Figure7.2:Dragpickcuttingvariables(Speight1997) Where: F FC FN d s = = = = = = Forceappliedbytool Cuttingforcecomponent Normalforcecomponentactstoeitherpenetratetherocksurfaceof maintainitattherequiredpenetrationdepth Penetrationdepth Toolspacing Breakoutangle
b)
Tooltypes
2 b) Radial
2/8/11
Radialpickchiseltipandrectangularshank.Axisoftoolshankpassesthroughtherotational axisofthemachinecuttinghead.Inabrasiverocks,radialpicksquicklydevelopawearflatand toolperformancesuffers. Pointattackpickconicaltipandcylindricalshank.Shankaxisisinclinedrelativetotherock surface.Thetoolisdesignedtorotatebytheactionofcuttingtoproduceevenwearandis thereforefavouredinabrasiverocks.Often,however,dirtclogsthetool,sothatitcannotrotate. (Speight1997). 7.1.3 a) Indenters Generalconsiderations
b)
Disccutters
Cuttingmachinesdesignedforhardrockapplicationsuseindentersintheformofdisccutters. Thesemachinesarethetunnelboringmachine(TBM),mobileminerandraiseborer.Forefficient rockcuttingtotakeplace,thetensilefracturesproducedbytoolscuttinginadjacentgroovesjoin uptoformrockchips.Hence,acrucialaspectofcuttingmachinedesignistooptimisethespacing betweenadjacentgroovescutbytoolsmountedontheexcavationmachine. 7.1.4 Comparison of drag picks and disc cutters
DisccuttersmountedonamachinesuchasaTBMarecapableofcuttingrocksofuniaxial compressivestrength(UCS)greaterthan150MPa(Speight1997).Thisperformanceisachievedby applyingaveryhighthrustforce(equivalenttoFNforthedragpick)andalowerrollingforce (equivalenttoFCforthedragpick).Thelowerrollingforcemeansthatthetorquethathastobe appliedbythemachineisreduced.However,becausedisccuttersbreakrockbyindentationrather thanbycuttingparalleltotherocksurface,theyarelessefficientthandragpicks.Inagivenrock mass,theSErequiredforadisccuttermachinewillbehigher. 7.1.5 a) New developments Oscillatingdisccutter
AnewmethodforrockexcavationhasbeendevelopedattheCentreforMiningTechnologyand Equipment(CMTE),Brisbane,Australia.Itusesatoolcalledtheoscillatingdisccutter(ODS), whichattackstherockbyundercuttingitsoastoinducetensilefailure(CMTE2000).Becauserock ismuchweakerintensionthancompression,amachinefittedwiththeODCsystemdoesnot requirethehighaxialforcesassociatedwithindentercuttingdiscs.Aconventionaldisccutter workinginahardrocksuchasgraniterequiresaforceofabout550kNtomachineagroove25 mmwideand10mmdeep.InthesamerocktheODCcutsagroovetwiceaswideataforceof only12kN.Theeventualaimtodesignacontinuousexcavationmachinecapableofworkingin rockswithofUCS>240MPa. b) Penetratingconefracturetechnology
Penetratingconefracture(PCF)involvestheinitiationofrockfractureswithinshallowholes drilledinarockface.Thefracturesresultintheformationoflarge,roughlyconeshaped,rock chipswiththebaseoftheconeattherockface.Fracturingisproducedeitherbyanexplosive propellantsuchastheSunburstsystemorbyahighpressurewaterpulse,e.g.Hydrexsystem (Speight1997).Theboreholepressuresgeneratedaremuchlowerthanwithindustrialexplosives suchasANFO,rangingfromabout400MPato700MPa(Olson1993).Thelowintensityofthe breakingactionmeansthatthesystemcouldbeincorporatedinacontinuoushardrockexcavation machine.Typically,thetypeofconceptbeinginvestigatedinvolvesamobilevehicleequipped withadrillboom.Aseriesofshortholesaredrilledand,aseachholeiscompleted,apropellant chargeandinitiatingdeviceareinsertedintothehole,whichisthensealed.Testscarriedoutby theUSBureauofMines(Olson1993)usedagasinjectortoinitiatethechargeandastemming systemcomprisingastemmingbar,energyabsorbingdeviceandmechanicalseal.Eachholeis firedtobreakoffaseriesofrockchips,whicharethencollectedbyadebrisclearingsystemsuch asthatinstalledonaroadheader. c) Plasmablasting
4 2/8/11
64357738.doc
TheplasmablastingconceptissimilartoPCF,exceptthatanelectricaldischargeisusedto generatearapidlyexpandingplasma,whichinducesrockfractures.Anelectrodeispushedintoa shortdrillholeandthespacebetweenthisprobeandtheholewallsisthenfilledwithanelectrolyte (waterissuitable).Theconceptualplasmablastingmachineissimilartoadrilljumbo,withbooms carryingeitherrockdrillsorelectrodes.Electricalenergyisstoredinacapacitorbankandreleased whenaswitchingdeviceisactivated.Theelectricalpowerdeliveredpowertotheelectrode increasesattherateof200MWpermicroseconduntilapeakpowerof3500MWisattained,after about40microseconds.Theeffectofthisenergydischargeistoconverttheelectrolyteintoahigh temperaturehighpressureplasma,atexplosiverates.Indirectmeasurementsindicatethatthe drillholepressureexceeds2000MPa(NantelandKitzinger1990).
7.2
Table7.3:Rockstrengthclassificationsforcutting(Atkinsonetal1986)
Rockstrength assessment UCS
Toughnessindex
Ti =
Derived 45 25 15 9
2 c x 100 2E
Calculated 40.0 23.8 12.2 5.8
64357738.doc
Mechanicalminingmachinesareclassifiedby: Hardorsoftrock Cuttinggeometry Tooltype Application Themaximumstrengthofrockthatcanbecutefficiently. fullface,drum,transversehead,axialhead. Pointattackdragpicks,wedgedragpicks,buttonbits,cutting discs. Civilengineeringtunneling,Civilengineeringexcavation, undergroundminedevelopment,undergroundmineproduction, surfacemineexcavation. Horizontal,vertical,inclined.
Excavationdip
Themajorclassificationofmachineisaccordingtothestrengthofrockthatcanbecut.Section7.1 describedhowrockchipsareformedbythejoiningupoftensilefracturesproducedbytools cuttinginadjacentgrooves.Tomaintaintheoptimumspacingbetweenthesegroovesrequiresa highdegreeofmachinestiffnessandcontrol(Gertsch1994),anobjectivethatbecomesmore difficultandascuttingforcesincrease.Hence,excavationmachinesdesignedforhardrockare muchheavierandanchoredmuchmoresecurelythanmachinesusedinsofterrocks. Certaindesignsoftunnelboringmachine(TBM)andraiseborerhavebeenabletoexcavaterockof uniaxialcompressivestrengths(UCS)upto250MPabuttheiruseisrestrictedtoexcavations whichareeitherstraightlineoroflargeradiusofcurvature.Thisfeaturemakesthemidealfor largescaleoperationssuchascivilengineeringtunneling.However,drillandblasttechniquesare stillgenerallypreferredinhardrockminesbecauseoftheirflexibilityandabilitytoexcavateany rocktypetoanyshape.Insoftrockapplications,ontheotherhand,mechanicalexcavatorsare preferred(e.g.coal,salt,gypsum,tronaorpotash). Table7.4:Classificationofmechanicalexcavatorbyrocktype Hardrock Softrock Roadheader Roadheader TBM ContinuousMiner MobileMiner Shearer RaiseBorer Table7.5:Comparisonofmechanicalexcavationwithdrillandblastsystems Advantages Disadvantages Generallygivesmorerapidadvancethan Cannotexcavateveryhardrock blastinginsofttomediumhardrock. Highcapitalcost Fewerunitoperations Requirespecialistmaintenance Smootherexcavationprofiles Notasflexible Noblastingdamagetosurroundingrock Inherentlysafer
7.3
7.3.1
64357738.doc
2/8/11
BecauseofthesizeandweightofthetypicalTBM,theyaresuitableonlyfortheexcavationoflong straightdrivagessuchascivilengineeringtunnels.
Figure7.5:Tunnelboringmachine a) Rockbreakagesystem
ATBMbreaksrockwithdisccuttersmountedontherotatingcutterheadinsuchapatternthat theyrollagainsttherockofthetunnelfaceinaseriesofconcentriccirculargroovesorkerfs.The cuttingforceisproducedbypowerfulhydraulicthrustrams.Eachdisccutterisfreetorotate withinitsmounting.Figure7.4illustratesthemodeofrockchipformation,previouslydescribedin Section7.1.3.Thehighcuttingforcesrequiredtobreakstrongrocktypesproduceequallyhigh reactionforcesonthemachine.Tomaintaincontactwiththerockandtomaintaintheoptimum spacingbetweencuttinggrooves,themachineisheldstablebyacombinationofitsgreatmassand byhydraulicjacks(grippers)actingagainstthesideofthetunnel.Brokenrockisgatheredfromthe floorbyscoopsmountedaroundtheperimeterofthecuttingheadanddischargedatthecrownof thecutterheadontoabeltconveyorthatrunsthroughthecenterofthemachine(figure7.6).
64357738.doc
2/8/11
b)
Example:AtlasCopcoJarvaTBM
Main body
Invert scraper
Thrust cylinder
Main motors
Figure7.7:AtlasCopcoJarvaTBM
64357738.doc
2/8/11
Performance 80m/week
DisadvantagesofTBMs highcapitalcost(severalmilliondollars) canonlycutcircularsection largeturningradius(100m) timeconsumingtoinstall minimumtunnellengthof2kmrequiredtojustifyinstallation 7.3.2 Robbins Mobile Miner
64357738.doc
2/8/11
Figure7.9:RobbinsMobileMiner(Bullock1994) Onlyaportionofthefaceiscontactedbythecutterwheelatanypointintimesothatthereaction forcesarelowerthanforaTBM.Thisdesignfeatureallowsforasmaller,moremaneuverable machinewhichcancutacurveofminimumradius25m.ThemainbodyoftheMinerismounted oncrawlers.Tostartcutting,themachineisanchoredbymeansofhydraulicjacks.Thewheelis thenrotatedandthecutterssumpedintothefacebyhydraulicramstotherequiredepth. Hydraulicswingcylindersthentraversetheboomacrossthewidthofthedrive.Oncompletionof thefirstpasscut,thestakingjacksareretractedandtheminermovedforwardtoanewcutting position. ThefirstproductionmachinewastriedatMtIsawithadeclineinstrongabrasivequartzite. Problemswereexperiencedwithdifferentialwearofdisccutters,resultinginhighcuttercostsand insufficientstiffnessofthecuttingmechanism(Bullock1994).Animprovedversionwithan advanceratecapabilityof1m/hourisinuseatBrokenHill.Itweighs265tonnes,acutterhead powerof500kWandhasperformedsuccessfullyinrocksranginginstrengthfrom100MPato300 MPa(Forrester1996).AfurtherimproveddesignhasbeenconsideredforthenewMIMHoldings Ltd.McArthurRiverleadzincmineintheNorthernTerritory.Therockatthismineisabrittle alteredshalewithacompressivestrengthof130MPa.Theorebodywillbecutparalleltothe beddingplanes,whichwillsuitthecuttingactionoftheMobileMiner(Chadwick1995).MIMs webpagestatesthatundergroundminingisbyconventionaldrillandblasttechniques,sothe continoushardrockminerisstillexperimental.(www.mim.com.au/mcarthur.html) 7.3.3 Raise Borer
Figure7.10:Operationofraiseborer
1.8 m 0.3 m
Costs (including rig set-up and removal) 1.8 m dia. $1200/m 2.4 m dia. $1500/m
2/8/11
$2000/m
OriginallydevelopedinHungaryandBritainforuseincoalmines,roadheaderdesignsare availablefortheexcavationofeithersoftormediumrockstrengthtypes.Asmallrotatingcutter headfittedwithdragpicksismountedonaboomthatcanbeslewedbyhydraulicramsalong bothhorizontalandverticalaxes(Figure7.13).Toadvanceadrive,themachinemovesforwardto sumpthecutterheadintotheface.Theboomisthentraversedacrosstherockfacetocutoutthe desiredprofile.Virtuallyanyshapeofroadwayprofilecanbeformed,rectangularorarched.Rock debrisisloadedbymechanicalgatheringarmsorgatheringwheelsontoachainconveyorrunning throughthecentreofthemachine.Thechainconveyordischargesthematerialfromtherearofthe roadheaderontoaconveyorbeltinstalledinthetunnel.Atypicalroadheaderisequippedwith twoelectricmotorssuppliedfromatrailingcable.Onemotorpowersthecutterhead,thesecond drivesahydraulicpumpwhichsuppliesfluidpowertothevarioushydraulicramsandtothe hydraulictractionmotors.
Figure7.13:Typicalroadheadermachine Thebasicdesignconceptofaroadheadercanbeadaptedforcuttingeithersoft,mediumhardor hardrocks.Machinesdesignedforhardrockfeaturelowspeed,hightorquecuttingheads,high cutterheadpowerandlargemass,tostabilisethemachine.Moderndragpicksusedtendtobeof thepointattacktype.ExamplesofvariousmachinesaregiveninTable7.8. Table7.87:Comparisonofroadheaderdesigns Machine Weight CuttingPower Type (tonnes) (kW) DoscoMk2A 25 80 DoscoMk2B 50 90 DoscoMk3 80 AndersonRH25 25 82 AndersonRH90 90 150 TamrockT60 125
64357738.doc
12
2/8/11
7.4
7.4.1
Acontinuousminer(CM)isanexcavatingmachinecapableofcuttingsoftrockssuchascoal, potashortronaathighrateswhilstsimultaneouslygatheringthecutmineralandloadingitontoa
64357738.doc 13 2/8/11
transportsystemsuchasashuttlecarorabeltconveyor.CMsareusedinvirtuallyallmechanised coalminesinAustralia,Britain,theUSAandSouthAfricaforeitherroom&pillarminingor longwalldevelopment. Themainbodyofthecontinuousminer(CM)issimilartothatoftheroadheader,beingcompact, crawlermountedandwiththesametypeofdebrisclearancesystem.Cutting,track,conveyorand gatheringarmmotorsareelectric.Thecuttingdrumismuchwider,however,atabout3.5mand canbemovedonlyintheverticalplane(Figure7.15)sothatonlyarectangularprofilecanbe formed.Moderncontinuousminersareallelectric,multimotormachines.Electricpoweris suppliedbyareeloperatedtrailingcable.Hydraulics,poweredbyanonboardpowerpackare usedforoperationssuchasraisingandloweringthecuttingdrumandstabilisingjacks.
Figure7.15:ContinuousMiner ThenormaloperationofaCMistosumpinthecuttingdrumatthetopoftheface,thenpower thedrumdown,cuttingfromrooftofloor.TheCMisthentrammedforwardtotakeanotherslice. Thisprocessiscontinueduntilacertainspanofroofhasbeenexposed,atwhichpointtheCM mustbewithdrawninorderforroofboltstobeinstalled.Thismaximumcutdistancedependson thecompetencyorstanduptimeoftheroof.InAustralia,themaximumcutdistanceistypically 46mbutcanbeashighas15m(e.g.LalehamColliery).Wheretheroofisparticularlystrong,the maximumpermittedcutdepthwillcorrespondtothedistancebetweenthefrontofthemachine andtheoperatorposition,i.e.theoperatormustalwaysbeundersupportedroof.Useofremote controlsystemsallowsthisdistancetobefurtherextended. Atypicalheadingwidthincoalminingis6m.Therefore,theCMmustactuallymaketwopasses totakethefullwidth.Thefirstpassistakenatonesideoftheheadingtothefullwidthanddepth ofthecut.TheCMthenbacksoutandtakestheremainingfilletofcoal.Afteronecompletecuthas beentaken,theroofisbolted. CMsaresuitableonlyforcuttingsoftrockssuchascoalorpotash.Thisisbecausethenumberof picksonthelargedrumishighandhencetheindividualpickforcesarerelativelylow.For maneuverabilityinaminingsituation,themachinesizeandweighthastobelimited.CMs produceveryhighcuttingrates,upto650tonnesperhour,or10mpershift.Inroom&pillar miningoperations,asinglemachinewilloperateinaminingpaneloftwotosevenheadings,being movedbetweenheadingstoadvancethewholepanel. ProductionCMsinAustraliadischargeintoshuttlecars.Thesemachinesarehaulagevehicles, capableofholdingabout12tonnesofcoal,whichtransferloadsofcoalfromtheCMatthefaceto aconveyorloadingpointlocatedfurtherback.
64357738.doc 14 2/8/11
TypicalcontinuousminerdesigntheJoy12CM Dimensions length10m,width2.1m,height1.35m weight3641tonnes(dependingontypeofcuttingdrum) Performance maxcuttingrate12tonnespermin trammingspeed1617m/min 6electricmotors,totalpower312kW Cuttinghead. Rotatingdrumfittedwithcutterpicks.Twovariants:2.6mlengthpoweredby two60kWelectricmotorsor3.2mwithtwo90kWmotors. Cleanupsystem Twogatheringarmsmountedonamoveablefrontspadeorapron.Powered by45kWmotorthatalsodrivestheconveyor.Apronoperatedbyhydraulics. Conveyor Thisrunsthroughthecentreofthemachinefromthegatheringarmaprontoa dischargejibattherear.Itisachainconveyorandtherearendcanbeswung 45oleftorrighttospotshuttlecars. Traction Crawlermounted,poweredbyDCmotors. Incoalmining,itisimportanttoventilatethecuttingdrumandtocontroldustgeneration.Asmall electricorhydraulicdustextractionfanoracompressedairoperatedairmoverismountedatthe rearofthemachine.Thissystemdrawsdustladenairviaductingfromthecuttingzone,througha filteranddischargesbehindtheoperator.Italsodrawsfreshairintoventilatethecutarea.Dust suppressionisachievedbymeansofhighpressurespraysmountedbehindthecuttingdrum. Thesespraysalsoassistinventilationofthecutarea. 7.4.2 Bolter-miner
64357738.doc
15
2/8/11
Figure7.16:VoestAlpineABM30BolterMiner Theslideframeismountedonthemainframeandcanbemoved1.0mforwardsandbackwards, relativetothemainframe,bymeansofhydraulicrams.Inoperation,themachineisdrivenupto thecoalfaceandstabilisedwithfloorjacks.Theslideframeisthenpushedforward,thecutting drumbitingintothefacetotakeasliceofcoalinthenormalmanner.Sincethechassisremains stationary,boltingoperationscanbecarriedoutsimultaneouslywithcutting.Whenacutof1.0m hasbeentaken,theslideframeisretractedbackintothechassisandthewholemachinemoved forwardtocommencethenextcycle.TheABM20isasinglepassmachinei.e.thecuttingdrumis thefullwidthoftheheading. 7.4.3 Longwall Shearer
Figure7.17:Longwallshearer Shearersareclassedaseithersingleendedrangingdrumshearer(SERDS)ordoubleended rangingdrumshearer(DERDS)andaseitherelectrohydraulicorallelectric.Electrohydraulic shearershaveasinglelargeelectricmotorthatdrivesahydraulicpumpandthecuttingdrum throughasystemofshaftsandgears.Thehydraulicpumpprovidespowertohydraulictraction motorsandtherangingarmcylinders.Anallelectricshearercomprisesanumberofseparate modulesfittedintoarigidframe.Eachmodule:tractionunit,cuttingdrumdrive,powerpackhas itsownelectricmotor.Totalinstalledpoweristypically1000kW. ThetypicalpeakcuttingrateofasheareronanAustralianlongwallis1718tonnesperminute, withoutputsofover12,000tonnesperdaybeingcommon.Highperformancelongwallscan
64357738.doc 16 2/8/11
7.5
References
Bullock,R.L.,1994,Undergroundhardrockcontinuousmining,MiningEngineering,November 1994,pp.12541258. Chadwick,J.,1995,Mechaniseddrivage,MiningMagazine,April,1995,pp.227236. CMTE,2000,'Oscillatingdisccutter'[Online,accessed4/5/00].URL:http://www.cmte.org.au.Centre forMiningTechnologyandEquipment,Brisbane,Australia. Forrester,D.1996,Undergroundcontinuousmininganoverview,CIMBulletin,vol.89,no. 1000,pp3237,May1996. Gertsch,R.E.,1994,Mechanicalminingchallengesanddirections,MiningEngineering,November 1994,pp.12501253. Hood,M.C.andRoxborough,F.F.,Rockbreakagemechanical,SMEMiningEngineering Handbook,Chapt9.1,vol.1,pp.680721,Hartman,(Ed.),H.L.,SocietyforMining,Metallurgyand Exploration,Inc.,Littleton,Colorado. Lindqvist,P.E.andRanman,K.E.,1980,Mechanicalrockfragmentationchippingunderadisc cutter,UniversityofLulea,Lulea,Sweden,Technicalreport59T. Nantel,JHandKitzinger,F,1990,Plasmablastingtechniques,ProceedingsofThirdInternational SymposiumonRockFragmentationbyBlasting,Brisbane,August1990.AusIMM,Melbourne. Olson,J.,1993,Rapidexcavationresearcharetrospectiveview,ProceedingsofMine MechanisationandAutomationconference,EditorsAlgrenetal,Balkema,Rotterdam. Speight,H.,1997,'Observationsondragtoolexcavationandtheconsequentperformanceof roadheadersinstrongrock',TheAusIMMProceedings,No.1,1997.
64357738.doc
17
2/8/11