CONTRACT NO.

: N-17759

PROJECT TITLE : Upgrading Works in Pumping Stations in Al Ain

CLIENT : Abu Dhabi Transmission & Despatch Company (TRANSCO)

CONTRACTOR : Hydropower Energy and General Construction

DOCUMENT – COMMENT SHEET – RESPONSE SHEET

Consultant Submission Ref: N1 77 59 - DCS -CM- FC- I B-0 12 7 Date Issued: 28-11-2022

Comment Sheet Ref: N1 77 59 - GE - MAT/ M00 - CN- S0 07 Date of Comment: 22-11-2022

Incoming Submittal Ref: N1 77 59 - HPE - MJ -O L-0 14 6 Date of Receipt: 22-11-2022

Document / Drawing Number Rev P Document Title QTY

Material Submittal for Pilot Operated Control

N1 77 59 - GE - MA T/ M0 0 -CN- S 00 7 0
Valve - Rev.0

P: PURPOSE CODES
0: For Distribution 1: Issued for Approval 2: Issued for Construction
3: Issued for Information 4: As Built

STATUS CODE:

Approved X Not Approved

Approved Except As Noted For Information Only/Not Subject

to Approval

Please return copy of signed CS for receipt confirmation

Ital Consult

Abu Dhabi Transmission and Despatch Company

(TRANSCO)

Consultant Submission N17 75 9 -DCS - CM- FC-I B- 01 27
Ref:
Comment Sheet Ref: N17 75 9 -G E -MAT/ M0 0 -CN- S 00 7
Incoming Submittal Ref: N17 75 9 -HP E - MJ - OL- 01 46
Sr. Cmnt TRANSCO/Engineer Comments
No. from (Rev. 00)
Please submit compliance statement
1 Ital with specification clause 5.9 & 5.9.2
paragraph by paragraph.
Contractor to clearly explain the
function of the electronic controller
and clarify/confirm the redundancy
requirement to avoid single point
failure. Similarly, communication from
RTU/PLC controller to the electronic
device within the valve need to be
clarified/confirmed.
Contractor to clarify/confirm the
power supply arrangement of this
type of valve, external or internal.
2 Ital
While no flow condition how the
power supply shall be generated in
case the valve is internally powered.
The control valve with electronic
controller shall be capable of fully
close linearly according to the
specified closing time, from the actual
initial working position to the fully
closed position, whatever the actual
initial position is. Contractor to
confirm.
Contractor to confirm that based on
the OCP (flow control / Upstream &
Down Stream pressure control &
associated override control) of the
respective branch/Tap off the
opening, closing & regulation
3 Ala
command shall be generated by the
RTU/PLC controller.
The pilot operated valve shall
open/close or maintain the opening
percentage accordingly with position
feedback and open/close status.
DOCUMENT – COMMENT SHEET – RESPONSE SHEET
Date Issued: 28-11-2022
Date of 21-11-2022
Comment:
Date of Receipt: 21-11-2022
TRANSCO/Engineer TRANSCO/Engineer TRANSCO/Engineer
Contractor Response Contractor Response Contractor Response
Comments (Rev. 01) Comments (Rev. 02) Comments (Rev. 03)
Compliance statement attached
The Electronic controller will be
used to control the opening
position of the valve. It can
receive the 4 to 20ma position
demand analogue signal from
the RTU/PLC and provide 4 to
20ma position feedback. In case
of power failure, the electronic
controller can be configured to
control the valve to fully close,
fully open, or keep the original
position as per the hydraulic
study requirements.
Redundancy requirements will
be met for PLC/RTUs as per
specification.
The Power supply is fed from
external source (From the
existing RTU/ kiosk)
Confirmed
All the process requirement is
managed by the RTU/PLC.
Pilot operated valve electronic
controller will receive the 4 to
20ma position demand analogue
signal from RTU / PLC and
provide position feedback and
open/close status to RTU/PLC

Consultant Submission N17 75 9 -DCS - CM- FC-I B- 01 27
Ref:
Comment Sheet Ref: N17 75 9 -G E -MAT/ M0 0 -CN- S 00 7
Incoming Submittal Ref: N17 75 9 -HP E - MJ - OL- 01 46
Sr. Cmnt TRANSCO/Engineer Comments
No. from (Rev. 00)
The required closing time shall be
4 Ital determined for each proposed valve
by hydraulic surge analysis
The submitted sizing calculations are
intended as examples only. Contractor
shall submit the actual sizing
5 Ital
calculations based on the outcomes of
hydraulic study (flow and pressure).
Please confirm.
Please note as per submission few
valves are open at rated flow less than
20% and few more than 80 %. This is
not acceptable. While sizing the
control valve for maximum and
minimum operating flow, the valve
opening position shall be within 20%
6 Ital and 80% with no cavitation.
Contractor to confirm.
Please confirm the leakage class of the
7 Ital valve.
The control valves are proposed to be
installed at the upstream of the flow
meters. Contractor to confirm that
there shall not be any flow turbulence
which shall hinder the flowmeter
8 Ital
operation and enough straight length
shall be provided to achieve correct
functioning of the flowmeters
including the accuracy requirements
as per MDEC.
Previous Status:
Document Number Rev.
DOCUMENT – COMMENT SHEET – RESPONSE SHEET
Date Issued: 28-11-2022
Date of 21-11-2022
Comment:
Date of Receipt: 21-11-2022
TRANSCO/Engineer TRANSCO/Engineer TRANSCO/Engineer
Contractor Response Contractor Response Contractor Response
Comments (Rev. 01) Comments (Rev. 02) Comments (Rev. 03)
Noted and confirmed
Noted and confirmed.
Due to Small tolerance of
machining of internal parts of
CLA-VAL Valves, up to 5 % of
opening at minimum flow can be
achieved with control stability,
and due to the wide range of
flow, opening in some locations
less than 20% and more than
80% , for example location CV
RP03.2 Maqam , size of valve
DN600 , minimum flow 350
m3/hr and Max flow 5210 m3/hr
We will submit revised sizing
sheets after receiving the
hydraulic study
leakage class to Rate C - Table 4 -
ISO 5208:2008 and Rate C -
Table A.5 - EN12266-1:2003.
The necessary straight length
requirement will be maintained
to avoid interference with
flowmeter accuracy during the
detailed design
P Document Title C.S. Ref. Status Date to Contractor
 DOCUMENT – COMMENT SHEET – RESPONSE SHEET

Consultant Submission N17 75 9 -DCS - CM- FC-I B- 01 27 Date Issued: 28-11-2022

Ref:

Comment Sheet Ref: N17 75 9 -G E -MAT/ M0 0 -CN- S 00 7 Date of 21-11-2022

Comment:

Incoming Submittal Ref: N17 75 9 -HP E - MJ - OL- 01 46 Date of Receipt: 21-11-2022

Note: The above comments and/or approvals do not relieve the Contractor from his obligation in the contract to ensure conformance to the specifications. Any specification deviations found subsequent to approval are to be corrected by the Contractor to the
satisfaction of the OWNER/ENGINEER.
Status Code: Not Approved
Reviewed / Approved By: Ala, KT

Signed: ________________________ Signed: ________________

For ITALCONSULT for TRANSCO