Professional Documents
Culture Documents
(AnnualReport-AR) - (25sep20) - 2016-2017 English
(AnnualReport-AR) - (25sep20) - 2016-2017 English
Government of India
Ministry of Water Resources,
River Development &
Ganga Rejuvenation
ANNUAL REPORT
POLAVARAM PROJECT
AUTHORITY,
HYDERABAD
1.1 Background 1
1.2 Location of the Project 1
1.3 Main Components of the Project 2
Chapter -2 Polavaram Project- Cost, Statutory Clearances & Other Aspects
Chapter-1
POLAVARAM PROJECT- An Overview
1.1 Background
The first conceptual proposal for the Polavaram Project originated from the erstwhile
Madras Presidency in July 1941. Later Diwan Bahadur L. Venkata Krishna Iyer, then Chief
Engineer in the Presidency’s Irrigation Department, conducted first survey of the project
site and made a definitive proposal for a reservoir at Polavaram. Shri Iyer not only had a
vision of cultivation of 3,50,000 acres (1,41,640 ha) over two crop seasons through this
project, but also planned for a 40 MW Hydro-Electric plant within the project. The entire
project was estimated to cost about Rs. 65 million.
This dam was initially planned at full reservoir level (FRL) 208 ft (63.4 m) with 836 TMC
gross storage capacity and 150 MW Hydro-Electric plant. By 1946-47, the estimated cost
rose to Rs.1.29 billion. It was named the “Ramapada Sagar Project” since the backwaters
of the reservoir would touch the Lord Rama temple at Bhadrachalam.
In the old finalised project design by Dr. K.L. Rao, the right bank canal of the project was
extended to south of Krishna river to serve irrigation needs in old Guntur district by
envisaging aqueduct across the Krishna river.
In 1969, after re-organization of the States, the Government of India constituted the
Godavari Water Disputes Tribunal (GWDT) for adjudication of the water disputes
regarding interstate river Godavari. GWDT gave its original report to Government of
India in 1979.
After a chain of deliberations, the States of Andhra Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh and Orissa
entered into an agreement in 1980 resolving the submergence aspects of Polavaram
Project. This agreement was filed before the Tribunal and was made part of the final
order of the Tribunal. GWDT passed final orders directing that Polavaram Project shall be
cleared by CWC as expeditiously as possible for FRL/MWL+150 ft.
The Polavaram Irrigation Project is on the river Godavari near Ramayyapeta village of
Polavaram mandal about 34 km upstream of Kovvur-Rajahmundry road-cum-rail bridge
and 42 km upstream of Sir Arthur Cotton Barrage, where river emerges out of last range
of the Eastern Ghats and enters the plains in West Godavari District of Andhra Pradesh
States. This multi-purpose major irrigation project is intended for development of all
regions of the States. It envisages construction of a dam to create ultimate irrigation
potential of 2,91,000 ha. The project also envisages generation of 960 MW of hydro
1
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
power, drinking water supply to a population of 28.50 lakh in 540 villages and diversion
of 80 TMC of water to Krishna river basin. A view of project site is shown in Fig. 1.
Dam
The project comprises an earth dam of 25.32 m high, 12.5 m wide at the crest and 564 m
long in Gap - I on the left bank of the river and an another earth dam of 15.32 m high,
9.0 m wide at the crest and 140 m long in Gap - III located on the right bank. An Earth
cum Rock fill (ECRF) dam of 45.32 m high, 15.0 m wide at the top of dam and 1750 m
long in the Gap - II is located in the main flow channel of the river Godavari. The ECRF is
provided with a cut off wall of plastic concrete diaphragm wall with guide wall to prevent
seepage and uplift pressure under the dam. The total length of the earth fill
dams/concrete dam and ECRF Dam is 2,454 m. The gross storage of the reservoir is 194
TMC at FRL El. 45.72 m and the live storage of the reservoir is 75.20 TMC.
Spillway
Ogee Spillway with crest at El. 25.72 m is located on the right bank along with
connecting approach channel of 2310 m length at the upstream of spillway. Stilling basin
is provided downstream of spillway for energy dissipation. The spill channel takes off
from the stilling basin which joins the river at the downstream.
The total width of spillway at its axis inclusive of left and right abutment piers, each of
5.5 m thick is 1,054.40 m. The crest level of spillway is at El. 25.72 m and is provided with
48 numbers of Radial Gates of size 16 m x 20 m. The Full Reservoir Level (FRL) is at
El. 45.72 m. The probable maximum flood (PMF) is 1,41,583 m3/s and the project design
flood is 1,01,943 m3/s.
2
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
The stilling basin is followed by a 2,764 m long and 1,000m wide spill channel, and a
650m long pilot channel. The length of the spill channel is 1000 m. The bed width of the
spill channel at its start is 1043.40m and gradually reduces to 1000m over a length of
215.81m.
The pilot channel joins to the deep course of the river Godavari. The bed width of the
pilot channel at its junction with the spill channel is 1,000 m. The invert level of the spill
channel at the start and end is El. 8.80 m.
Canal System
Two main canals take off on each side of the dam. The main canals are designated as
Left Main Canal and Right Main Canal. The canal systems are designed to meet the
irrigation, drinking water and industrial water requirements of East Godavari,
Vishakhapatnam, West Godavari and Krishna districts.
Left Main Canal takes off from Nelakota Ava subsidiary reservoir by means of a head
regulator. It is a contour canal. Left main canal is 181.5 km long with 31.995km long of
new water supply canal which will cater to about 1,61,855 Ha (4.0 lakh acres) of irrigation
water requirements of East Godavari and Vishakhapatnam districts besides diversion of
about 664 MCM (23.44 TMC) of water to industries in and around Vishakhapatnam. The
3
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
4
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
The salient features of both the canals are tabulated in Table 1 & 2.
Power House
5
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
The Central Electricity Authority (CEA) MOP, Government of India, New Delhi has accorded
Techno Economic Concurrence on 21.02.2012 to the ISPHEP at an estimated cost of
Rs.3013.68Cr (at 2010-11 Price level), and a levellised tariff of Rs.3.17/KWH considering
mega status to Project. Salient features of the power house is presented in Table 3.
Annexure 1 B
+31.995 km of N.W.S.C
6
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
A lay out plan of Head Works is appended at Fig. 3(a), Command area of RMC & LMC is
at Fig 3 (b).
LEADING CHANNEL
SADDLE DAM
TAIL RACE
DEVARA DONDI CHANNEL
RAMAIAH PETA
TUNNEL
PRPOSED TUNNEL 12M DIA
FREE FLOW 918 M LONG
REGULATOR
POLAVARAM
RIVER
CANALNAVIGATION
RIGHT
MAIN
CANAL
SADDLE DAM
PURUSHOTHA
EXISTING OUT FALL PATNAM REGULATOR
SLUICE OF
KADIAMMA DRAIN GOVERNMENT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
I & CAD DEPARTMENT
POLAVARAM PROJECT
INDEX MAP OF HEAD WORKS
AT RAMAIAHPETA SITE (G G’12
D)
Design by D.Raj
Kumar
7
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
Chapter-2
POLAVARAM PROJECT- Cost, Statutory Clearances & Other Aspects
The project proposal of Polavaram Irrigation Project was considered and accepted by the
Advisory Committee of MoWR in its meeting held on 20.01.2009 for Rs. 10,151.04 Cr at
price level 2005-06. The project was accorded investment clearance by the Planning
Commission for Rs. 10,151.04 Cr at 2005-06 price Level (25.02.2009).
Cost of the project was revised to Rs. 16,010.45cr at 2010-11 price level, and the same
was accepted by the Technical Advisory Committee in its 108th meeting held on
04.01.2011. The investment clearance for the revised cost estimate of Rs.16010.45 Cr
(2010-11 price level) was accorded by MOWR, RD &GR in the 5th meeting of Investment
Clearance Committee of MoWR, RD&GR held on 10.02.2017 in New Delhi and
communicated in letter No.P.20011/2/2016-SPR/947-58, dated: 08.05.2017.
The construction of the project started in the year 2004-05. It was included under AIBP
during the year 2008-09. This time beyond till March, 2014, Central Assistance of
Rs. 562.47 Cr was provided to the State under AIBP. After declaration of Polavaram
project as National Project, total amount released as central assistance are as under:
Table 4 lists the clearances issued by various agencies over the period.
8
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
9
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
a. Agreement with the States of Orissa and Madhya Pradesh was reached by the
States of Andhra Pradesh for submergence of areas in those States on 02.04.1980. The
clause-3 of the agreement indicate the operation schedules agreed upon by the party
States i.e., the pond levels to be regulated as provided in the agreement corresponding
to the inflows into the reservoir.
“ In order to protect the lands and properties above RL+150ft in the territory of the State
of Orissa likely to be affected due to construction of Polavaram Project, protective
embankments with adequate drainage sluices, shall be constructed and maintained at
the cost of Polavaram Project. However, the State of Orissa may exercise an option at
the time of construction of Polavaram Project for the compensation to land and property
likely to be affected above RL + 150 ft as agreed to in the case of the State of Madhya
Pradesh.”
The Interstate Agreement is made part of the GWDT award. The GWDT directed in
Clause – VI of their final orders that:
State of The Govt. of Supreme To declare that the clearances Further listing
Odisha Andhra Pradesh, Court obtained from various central Govt awaited.
MOEF, MOTA and agencies as illegal, null and void
others
State of The Govt. of Supreme To declare MOEF and MOTA Further listing
Chhattisgarh Andhra Pradesh, Court clearances etc as null and void awaited.
MOWR,
MOTA,CWC
10
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
11
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
Chapter-3
POLAVARAM AS A NATIONAL PROJECT
The Andhra Pradesh State Reorganisation Act, 2014 declared the Polavaram Irrigation
Project as a National Project under Section 90 and it is expedient in the public interest
that the Union should take under its control the regulation and development of the
Polavaram Irrigation Project for the purposes of irrigation.
The Act mandates that the Central Government shall execute the project and obtain all
requisite clearances including environmental, forest, and rehabilitation and resettlement
norms. In pursuance of said section and to carry out the purpose of the said provisions
of the Act, the Central Government constituted the Governing Body to Polavaram Project
Authority to carry out the task as mandated.
‘Whereas the Andhra Pradesh Reorganisation Act, 2014 (6 of 2014- hereinafter referred
to as the Act) declares Polavaram Irrigation Project to be a national project [under Sub-
section (1) of Section 90] and it is expedient in the public interest that the Union should
take under its control the regulation and development of the Polavaram Irrigation
Project for the purposes of irrigation [under Sub-section (2) of Section 90];
And whereas under Sub-section (4) of Section 90 of the Act mandates that the Central
Government shall execute the project and obtain all requisite clearances including
environmental, forests, and rehabilitation and resettlement norms’;
Now, therefore, in pursuance of said section and to carry out the purposes of the said
provisions of the Act, the Central Government hereby constitutes the Governing Body to
Polavaram Project Authority and the Polavaram Project Authority as follows;
12
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
Pradesh
3 The Chief Secretary to the Government of Telangana Member
4 The Secretaries to the Government of India, Ministries Member
of Environment and Forest, Finance (Dept. of
Expenditure), Power and Tribal Welfare (or their
nominee(S) not below the rank of Joint Secretary)
5 The Chief Executive Officer, Polavaram Project Member
Authority
6 A representative of Planning Commission (not below Member
the rank of Joint Secretary)
7 Member Secretary, Polavaram Project Authority Member
Secretary
1. The Governing Body to the Polavaram Project Authority shall be charged with
the power and shall be under a duty to do any or all things necessary, sufficient
and expedient for obtaining all requisite clearances including environmental,
forests, and rehabilitation and resettlement norms and regulation and
development of the Polavaram Project.
2. The power, functions and duties of the Governing Body may include –
The Polavaram Project Authority consists of a Chief Executive Officer (CEO) and eleven
Members, as shown in Table 7.
13
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
(1) The Chief Executive Officer and members at serial number (iv), (v) and (viii) shall
be posted to the Authority on full time basis by the Central Government or the
State Government, as the case may be.
(2) The Chief Executive Officer shall be appointed by the Central Government from
amongst Officers empanelled for the post of Additional Secretary to the
Government of India with a fixed tenure of at least three years and he shall be in-
charge of the Authority under the general supervision and control of the
Governing Body.
(3) The Chief Executive Officer shall have all the administrative, financial and work
powers as available to the Head of the Department in the Central Government.
a) The Authority may from time to time appoint or employ such officers and
employees as it think fit. All such officers and employees shall be subject to the
sole control of the Authority.
b) The Authority may, with the previous approval of the Central Government, make
regulations to regulate conditions of service of all such officers and employees in
respect of residential accommodation, house rent allowance, travelling allowance,
daily allowance, conveyance allowance and medical reimbursement.
c) The scales of pay, allowances (including project allowance) and other service
conditions shall be as applicable to Central Government employees.
d) The Authority shall arrange with the State Government to spare the services of the
persons employed in the State Governments of Andhra Pradesh and Telangana for
whole-time employment with the Authority, or for the performance of any work or
services for the Authority, and in that case, the scales of pay, allowances (including
project allowance) and other service conditions of such employees may be as
applicable to concerned State Government employees.
e) The personnel, which immediately before the notification of the Authority, was
working on the Polavaram Project on regular basis, shall continue to work on the
project after notification and would be deemed to be on deputation to the
Authority till the Authority makes alternate arrangement, if so considered
necessary.
14
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
f) All the posts of the Authority shall be exempted from the rule of immediate
absorption for appointment in the Authority.
a) The Authority shall execute the project, preferably through the concerned State
Departments and / or any other expert agency, and obtain all requisite
clearances including environmental, forests, and rehabilitation and resettlement
norms and shall be charges with the regulation and development of the
Polavaram Project.
b) The Authority shall issue appropriate directions, whenever necessary for timely
and full compliance by the concerned States in the matter of acquisition for and
making available to Authority lands and properties likely to be submerged under
the Polavaram Project and in the matter of compensation and rehabilitation of
oustees there under.
d) The Authority shall frame rules for water accounting to implement and
supplement the provisions of the Award of the Godavari Water Disputes
Tribunal.
e) The Authority shall regulate distribution of power generated from the Polavaram
project amongst the States, as notified by the Ministry of Power.
f) The Authority shall determine the volume of water stored, flowing in and out of
the Polavaram reservoir, and the volume of water utilized through each Main or
Branch head works, evaporation and seepage losses on ten daily basis in a water
year (1st June of a year to 31st May of next).
g) The Authority or any of its duly authorized representatives shall have power to
enter upon any land and property upon which any work of gauging, evaporation
or other hydrological station or measuring device has been or is being
constructed, operated or maintained by any State for the use of Polavaram water
and each State through its appropriate departments shall render all cooperation
and assistance to the Authority and its authorized representatives in this behalf.
15
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
j) The Authority shall also perform any other function as directed by the Governing
Body and the Central Government from time to time.
Ministry of Water Resources, RD & GR posted Shri Dinesh Kumar, IAS, as the first Chief
Executive Officer and the office of the Polavaram Project Authority started functioning
on his joining in January, 2015. Subsequently, Member Secretary, a Chief Engineer level
officer of the Central Water Engineering Service of Central Water Commission, was
posted and joined the office in February, 2015.
Subsequently, Chief Engineer (P&D), a Chief Engineer level officer of the Central Water
Engineering Service of Central Water Commission, joined the Authority in October, 2015
and Chief Engineer (Power), a Chief Engineer level officer of the Central Power
Engineering Service of Central Electricity Authority, joined in the month of January, 2016.
Dr. Amarjit Singh, Special Secretary (WR, RD&GR) took over the additional charge of
Chief Executive Officer of Polavaram Project Authority on 11th January, 2016.
The approved organisational structure of the office of Chief Executive Officer, Polavaram
Project Authority is as follows:
16
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report
(i) (ii) (iii) (iv) (v) (vi) (vii) (viii) (ix) (x) (xi)
17
Note: The Chief Executive Officer and Members at serial number (iii), (iv),(v),(vi),(vii) and (xi) shall be posted
to the Authority on full time basis by the Central Government or the State Government, as the case may
be.
2016-17
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
• Member Secretary
• Chief Engineer (Planning & Design)
• Chief Engineer (Power)
1. Shri R. K. Gupta
2. Shri A. Paramesham
3. Shri B. Tiwari
• Dr. Amarjit Singh, Secretary (WR, RD & GR) appointed as the Chief Executive
Officer for Polavaram Project Authority on additional charge w.e.f. 11.01.2016.
• Shri B.Tiwari, Chief Engineer (Power) retired from service on 31.12.2016.
In addition to the above, three (3) Deputy Executive Engineers and (1) Assistant
Executive Engineer from the Water Resources Department, Government of A.P. have
been diverted to work in PPA.
One Director level officer and one Executive Engineer from the office of Central Water
Commission, Hyderabad have been given additional charge to work as Director (A&C)
and Drawing & Disbursing Officer (D.D.O.) respectively for PPA to handle the day-to-day
administrative, accounts and other related matters.
18
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
Chapter-4
SUBMERGENCE, LAND ACQUISITION AND RESETTLEMENT &
REHABILITATION
An extent of about 1,83,013 acres of Forest and Non-Forest land is to be acquired for
the whole of Polavaram Project. The land acquisition for the project is being done in a
phased manner. The land acquisition for head works and canals of Polavaram Project
was being done simultaneously since 2005 and the excavation of canals has been
completed wherever land is acquired.
In-principle approval under section 2 of Forest (Conservation) Act 1980 for diversion of
3,731.07 ha. of forest land for Polavaram Project was accorded by MoEF vide its
Lr.No.F.No.8-123/2005-FC Dt. 26.12.2008 and Stage –II Forest clearance was accorded by
MoEF, New Delhi vide Lr. F.No.8-123/2005-FC Dt. 28.07.2010.
In order to completely avoid submergence of lands and properties above RL+150 ft. in
the territories of Odisha and Chhattisgarh States, and to protect the interests of Tribal
people, the Government of Andhra Pradesh proposed to provide protective
embankments with adequate drainage sluices for a length of 30 km along Sileru and
Sabari rivers in the State of Odisha and for a length of 29.12 km along the Sabari River
in Chhattisgarh State as per the directions of Ministry of Environment and Forests,
19
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
Ministry of Tribal Affairs, Central Water Commission and other statutory bodies as per
the provisions of Inter State Agreement Dated 02.04.1980 and GWDT Award. By
providing remedial measures i.e., by forming protective embankments for a length of 30
km along the Sileru and Sabari Rivers in the State of Odisha, and 29.12 km along the
Sabari River in Chhattisgarh, the submergence in the territories of Odisha and
Chhattisgarh can be avoided completely.
The Expert Appraisal Committee of Ministry of Environment and Forest (MoEF) vide their
letter dated 09.03.2009 directed the project proponent to initiate action requesting the
appropriate authorities in Odisha and Chhattisgarh States for conducting public hearings
in the States of Chhattisgarh and Odisha in respect of embankment proposal and report
back to the Committee. The conduct of public hearings is pending to be carried out by
the State Governments of Chhattisgarh and Odisha.
Details of population affected in Andhra Pradesh (as per the census-2011), in Odisha and
Chhattisgarh (as per the socio-economic survey of 2005) due to the Polavaram Irrigation
Project, village-wise and category-wise, are given in Table 09 & 10.
20
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
Table 9 District-wise Population Affected in Andhra Pradesh (as per census 2011)
Sl.N Name of No. of No. of Total Total Total Total male Total female Total Total Nature of
o. the district villag habitati geograp house populati population population schedule schedule submergence
es ons hical holds on castes tribes
area (in populati Population Full Partial
ha) on
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13)
1 East 165 234 51,427 29,303 99,463 47,703 52,051 9,405 58,825 86 148
Godavari
2 West 56 137 59,452 26,496 88,549 43,506 45,043 16,845 31,002 69 68
Godavari
Grand Total 221 371 1,10,879 55,799 1,88,012 91,209 97,094 26,250 89,827 155 216
Table 10 District-wise Population affected in Odisha and Chhattisgarh (as per the Socio-economic Survey-2005)
Sl. No. Name of the Name of No. of Total Total No. of Total Total male Total female
district the mandal villages geographical households population population population
area (ha)
Odisha State
1 Malkangiri Podia 8 587.77 1,002 6,316 3,562 2,754
Chhattisgarh State
1 Sukuma Konta 4 5,375 2,335 11,766 6,923 4,843
Note- there would be no submergence in case states of Odisha and Chhattisgarh opt for embankment along the rivers Sabari and Sileru,
which is one of the option available under GWDT award, 1980.
21
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
The details of the land acquired for the purpose of construction of the project and
rehabilitation & resettlement of the PAFs are given in Table 11.
Expendit
Probable
Requisitio ure Balance
Name of Land amount
Sl.N Name of the n filed for incurred land to
the acquired required
o District the for LA as be
Project as on date for LA of
project on date acquired
(Rupees
(Rupees
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8)
Head
256.77 256.77 3.33 0.00 0.00
Works
Left Main
6238.72 6238.72 150.68 0.00 0.00
Canal
Submerge
75074.65 41910.18 371.12 33164.47 3797.99
nce
1 East Godavari
Land to
19426.79 1674.54 55.02 17752.25 2024.43
Land
Land for
R&R 5801.70 456.48 6.09 5345.22 588.50
Colonies
Sub Total 106798.63 50536.69 586.24 56261.94 6410.92
Head
1700.28 1700.28 38.00 0.00 0.00
Works
Right Main
8930.00 8930.00 453.00 0.00 0.00
Canal
Submerge
30465.24 30465.24 1871.00 0.00 0.00
nce
2 West Godavari Land to
7829.00 7829.00 665.00 0.00 0.00
Land
Land for
R&R 2934.00 1548.00 141.00 1386.00 345.00
Colonies
Sub Total 51858.52 50472.52 3168.00 1386.00 345.00
Left Main
3 Visakhapatnam 4080.49 4080.49 80.95 0.00 0.00
Canal
Right Main
4 Krishna 3476.07 3476.07 624.71 0.00 0.00
Canal
Grand
166213.71 108565.77 4459.90 57647.94 6755.92
Total
Note: Figures are being firmed by PPA.
22
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
The Government is committed to rehabilitating the PAFs/ PDFs as per R&R package
keeping in view of the provisions of constitutional rights under schedule areas and PESA
Act, 1996. The R&R is being implemented with utmost care and human touch, so that
the project affected persons will be the first beneficiaries of the project. The R&R is
programmed in such a way that the entire R&R activities of the project will be
completed well before the actual impoundment of water in the reservoir. The status of
R&R of the Project Displaced Families as on March, 2017 is populated in Table 12.
A sum of Rs. 212.55 Cr has been incurred on the Rehabilitation of above families.
23
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
24
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
Chapter-5
PHYSICAL AND FINANCIAL PROGRESS
5.1 Brief Description about Contracts
Government of Andhra Pradesh have been executing the project since 2004. After the
constitution of Polavaram Project Authority in January, 2015 the matter was discussed in
the Ministry of Water Resources, RD & GR as regards the procedure to be adopted for
construction of project keeping in view the provisions contained in the Gazette
notification dated 28th May, 2014.
In consultation with Ministry of Law & Justice it was decided that since the contracts are
already in place and State Government has been managing the contracts, the State
Government may continue to operate the running contracts and any new contract/ work
taken up shall be with the approval of the Polavaram Project Authority. It was decided
that Polavaram Project Authority shall monitor the progress and shall provide technical
assistance with respect to designs and various other related issues.
The execution of the project is with the State Government. All the project components
are in progress, except civil and mechanical works of Power House, canal distributaries
system and construction of embankments in the territories of Chhattisgarh and Odisha.
The Head Works consisting of spillway, Earth cum Rock fill dam (in 3 gaps), approach
channel, spill channel and foundation excavation of power house have commenced with
the award of work to new agency in March,2014 and are now in progress. Total works of
the project was divided into 22 packages for which contracts were awarded and
agreements for the same were entered into by the State Government for a value of
Rs.7,916.16 Cr. This comprises 7 packages under Right Main Canal System, 8 packages
under Left Main Canal System and 7 packages under Head works.
5.2 Physical and Financial Progress before and after Declaration of National Project
Details of physical and financial progress in respect of major components of the project
namely, Head works, Right Main Canal and Left Main Canal are given in Table 13.
Progress achieved before and after declaration as National Project is also indicated.
25
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
Earthwork in
Lining in LCum Structures in LCum
LCum*10
Total Quantity 118.041 20.589 10.1041
Quantity done up to March
111.6817 12.0364 6.3102
2016
Quantity upto March 2017 117.5444 13.4302 8.7118
Balance to be Executed 0.4966 7.1588 1.3923
Earthwork in
Lining LCum Structures in LCum
LCum*10
Total Quantity 105.4488 15.65 14.12
Quantity done up to March
86.4995 9.3060 3.8259
2016
Quantity upto March 2017 89.5555 9.6334 4.4257
Balance to be Executed 15.8933 6.0166 9.6943
26
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
Table 13 Details of physical and financial progress of the project before and after
declaration of National Project in respect of works component are given in the following
tables.
27
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
28
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
A sum of Rs. 3364.16 Crs has been released to Polavaram Project Authority (PPA) by
Ministry of WR, RD & GR for releasing to State government as reimbursement of the
expenditure incurred beyond 01.04.2014 up to 31.03.2017.
After declaration of National Project, an expenditure of Rs. 439.48 Crs has been
incurred during 2014-15, Rs.1,867.94 Crs during 2015-16 and Rs.1,700.09 Crs during
2016-17.
Out of Rs. 3364.16 Crs made available to PPA during 2014-15, 2015-16 and 2016-17 a
sum of Rs. 3349.70 Crs has been released and transferred to the State Government,
keeping an amount of Rs. 14.46 Crs for meeting the expenditure towards establishment
charges of PPA and also to carry out Survey & Investigation works for the remaining
canal distributaries network yet to be taken up.
Annual expenditure of the PPA during the financial year 2016-17 was as given in
Table 14.
29
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
It was informed by Principal Director of Audit, Scientific Department, New Delhi that
the purview of Audit of accounts of State Government who is incurring the expenditure
on construction rests with Accountant General.
30
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
Chapter-6
POLAVARAM PROJECT AUTHORITY-
Vigilance/Disciplinary Cases, Meetings, etc.
(i) 69 Parliament questions were received in PPA during 2016-17. The material for
reply to these questions was prepared and sent to the Ministry of Water
Resources, River Development and Ganga Rejuvenation.
(ii) 29 VIP references on various matters were received by PPA during 2016-17. The
material for reply to these references was prepared and sent to the Ministry of
Water Resources, River Development and Ganga Rejuvenation.
The following officers were appointed as Appellate Authority and Central Public
Information Officer (CPIO) to provide information to the applicants in compliance of
RTI Act, 2005.
During the year 2016-17, eighty four requests for furnishing information under RTI Act,
2005 were received in PPA. Information as available was provided to applicants in
compliance of the Act.
The above committee shall be deemed to be the inquiring authority appointed by the
disciplinary authority for the purpose of Central Civil Services (CCA) Rules, 1965. The
committee will examine the complaints made by women employee(s) against sexual
harassment and, if necessary, conduct an enquiry and submit the findings of the
enquiry report to the Member Secretary, PPA for further necessary action.
31
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
One meeting i.e fifth meeting of Polavaram Project Authority have been convened
during the year 2016-17. Various issues pertaining to technical, administrative and
financial matters were discussed. Important outcome of the issues discussed during the
meeting are summarised as follows.
The Fifth meeting of the Polavaram Project Authority (PPA) was held on 20th April, 2016
at the office of Polavaram Project Authority in Krishna Godavari Bhawan, Hyderabad
under the Chairmanship of Dr. Amarjit Singh, Special Secretary (SS), Ministry of WR, RD
& GR and Chief Executive Officer (CEO), PPA.
• A team of experts may be constituted to visit the project and make suggestions
for further improvements
• Independent Quality Control mechanism to be in place
• Independent team for assessment of R&R status be constituted
• Construction of navigation channel
• Convening of meeting with Odisha and Chattisgarh
• Submergence of areas in Telengana.
It was proposed by Special Secretary and CEO that this is an internal matter of
Ministry, hence, it can be discussed and addressed internally. Member Secretary
expressed that for making the authority fully functional this is one of the
requirements.
2. Discussions on the draft MOU between Ministry of WR, RD & GR and PPA
and MOU between PPA and the State Government
On the aspect of MOU between State Government and PPA Principal Secretary,
Water Resources Department mentioned that some of the provisions in the draft
as enclosed with the agenda notes needs revision. Special Secretary asked the
specifics of such provisions.
32
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
Two meetings of the Monitoring Committee were held on 28.04.2016 and 16.03.2017,
where issues related to Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation aspects of Polavaram Project
were discussed. Certain specific issues with respect to rehabilitation and resettlement
were also discussed and the status was provided by PPA.
In addition to the meetings of the Authority, other meetings were convened by the
Chief Executive Officer (CEO), the Member-Secretary, PPA with other concerned Central
Organisations, with the officials of Water Resources Department of A.P., Revenue
Department of A.P., Central Water Commission, Central Soil and Material Research
Station, IIT, Delhi, executing agencies, NGOs, etc. as and when required.
• The need and requirement for preparation of Road map for Land acquisition,
R&R was expressed by Member Secretary;
• The data compilation on land acquisition, R&R and socio - economic aspects
were suggested in the prescribed format.
Member Secretary requested to prepare a road map for LA and R & R. PPA desired that
a large sized map be prepared showing clearly the lands already handed over to the
agency and the lands that are yet to be handed over to the agency and it was agreed
by the WRD to prepare and furnish such maps to PPA.
Five meetings (First, second, third , fourth and Fifth) of the Dam Design Review Panel
(DDRP) have been convened during the year 2016-17 .Various issues pertaining to
designs were discussed. Important outcome of the issues discussed during those
meetings are summarised as follows.
33
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
The First meeting of the Dam Design Review Panel (DDRP) was held on 22nd June, 2016
at the office of Central Water Commission, New Delhi under the Chairmanship of
Shri A.B.Pandya, former Chairman, Central Water Commission and Chairman, Dam
Design Review Panel.
Important issues discussed are as follows.
It was decided that extra bore holes are to be drilled in the abutment of Gap-II
which is dipping downstream. Regarding spillway, it was proposed that before
taking up the concreting works, cooling studies and alkali aggregate reaction
studies be completed and submitted to CWC, New Delhi for approval and further
suggestions.
It was suggested that PPA should have a construction Management Team for
effective control over the implementation of the project. PPA may engage an
expert agency or may hire few retired personnel experienced in project
planning, monitoring, civil construction, geology etc. In the interregnum,
PPA may engage around 4 such personnel on contract basis.
It was proposed by the Chairman, DDRP that all designs and details required
for the concurrence/ approval of the design unit of CWC, New Delhi shall be
hence forth submitted to PPA which in turn will submit to CWC.
DDRP decided that the installation of stone columns on the clay portion of the
ECRF dam may be studied by IIT, Delhi who are studying the other related
aspects.
The Second meeting of the Dam Design Review Panel (DDRP) was held on 09th
& 10th September, 2016 at the office of PPA in Krishna Godavari Bhawan,
Hyderabad under the Chairmanship of Shri A.B.Pandya, former Chairman,
Central Water Commission and Chairman, Dam Design Review Panel.
34
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
1) Various studies undertaken by IIT, Delhi, Dynamic Analysis of ECRF dam and
Vibro-compaction studies
• M/s Bauer will study the river behaviour preferably using HECRAS
model preferably recently launched HECRAS 2D version.
• The concern of pore pressure built up in the clay portion of the cut off
trench after the folding is to be addressed properly. The same may be
measured through embedded pore pressure cells in the cut off trench
at appropriate sections and results may be reported to the panel time
to time.
• The layout of panels may be taken up by site engineers and not left for
CWC designers.
• Based on the field data and mathematical model studies a proposal can
be developed for construction of cut off wall including protection
aspects to be considered by the panel.
• It was decided that a maximum aggregate size of 12.5mm will be
sufficient to meet the strength requirements with 180kg if cement per
35
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
cubic meter of concrete. This will reduce the brittleness and will
increase flexibility.
• Slump data from other projects where similar constructions has been
made needs to be collected and studied to decide on the slump value
and accordingly the provisions in the contract document will be
modified.
• FEM analysis be carried out and the results will be made available for
finalising the section of the spillway.
• Reinforcement in the upper portion can be provided for accounting the
tensile stresses. The reinforcement should fully provide for the tensile
stresses indicated under condition B and should extend below the
elevation upto which the tensile stresses are indicated in condition E for
a length not less than development length for the reinforcement bar
diameter.
• In option 2, the top of the coffer dam on the U/s is proposed to be 41.00
m assuming a maximum flood of 2 lakh cusecs in non-monsoon. This
assumption of 2 lakh cusec flood equivalent to the capacity of 15
number of spillway blocks to be constructed first on the right bank side.
• Construction of coffer dam be started from next lean season, even if the
level of concreting in spillway is less than El 25 m but is above +17 m.
• It should be ensured that the coffer dam does not get overtopped by
flood i.e., at least 31.00 m level of top of the coffer dam should be
achieved in one season.
36
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
The Third meeting of the Dam Design Review Panel (DDRP) was held on 29th
November, 2016 at the Committee room of Central Water Commission, New
Delhi under the Chairmanship of Shri A.B.Pandya, former Chairman, Central
Water Commission and Chairman, Dam Design Review Panel.
37
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
• Diaphragm wall
• Quality Control aspects
• Construction scheduling
• Survey and Investigation of Distribution system
1) Design of Spillway
38
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
• 50cm of lift in the first two layers at foundation should be used form the
deepest foundation levels, which may be revised based on the results of the
cooling studies to be done by CSMRS.
The Fourth meeting of the Dam Design Review Panel (DDRP) was held on 09th
January, 2017 at the office of PPA in Krishna Godavari Bhawan, Hyderabad
under the Chairmanship of Shri A.B.Pandya, former Chairman, Central Water
Commission and Chairman, Dam Design Review Panel.
• The top of diaphragm wall has to be kept 1500mm below the natural river bed
level.
• The maximum deviation of any panel of the diaphragm wall in both X and Y
direction should not exceed 0.3 % of the vertical height.
• The top of the diaphragm wall has to be rounded off to avoid any possible
stress concentration in accordance with IS 14344:1996.
• QAP and QAM to be submitted along with the method statement.
39
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
• The foundation needs to be modelled @ 2.5 times height of the dam at the
bottom and @ 1.5 times on the side of the block.
• The in-situ rock properties to be considered for modelling foundation.
• The uplift pressure at the foundation level needs to be considered as per
different loading conditions defined in IS:6512
• The scalar uplift pressure within dam has to be applied at each node.
• The analysis has to be done on EGA84 software instead of ABAQUS.
• 2D Dynamic model studies being carried out by IIT, Roorkee needs revision/
updation.
The Fifth meeting of the Dam Design Review Panel (DDRP) was held on
07 & 8th March, 2017 at Polavaram Dam site, Polavaram under the
Chairmanship of Shri A.B.Pandya, former Chairman, Central Water
Commission and Chairman, Dam Design Review Panel.
• The parameters namely, quality of rock pieces collected at the sanding unit,
bore hole data and penetration rate may be considered determining the start
of sound bed rock level from which the embedment of the cu-off has to be
done.
• After embedment of cut-off wall by 2.0 m into the hard rock the seepage is to
be assessed and also the adequacy of the exit gradient. Considering
deterioration over time, grouting of the sub strata is to be decided.
• Based on the bore hole data and the permeability data selective grouting can
be done instead of going in for uniform level of grouting.
40
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
41
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
• Some Electric Cone Penetration Test have to be carried out along the coffer
dam axis.
• Effect of deep soil mixing very close to the diaphragm wall need to be
examined. And thereafter a decision regarding the work of deep soil mixing
before or after the construction of the diaphragm wall can be taken. Filters in
the junction of clay core and rock fill of the ECRF dam have to be designed so
as not to be affected by settlement below the ECRF dam.
• More investigations have to be done under the cross-section are of ECRF dam
and also in the clayey region compared to the area beyond the cross-section.
• Additional CPTs and SPTs shall be conducted.
• A factor of safety of 2 for cut-off wall has to be adopted.
• Deep soil mixing is required to be carried out throughout the width of the clay
core foot print including the sand layer at the top so that diaphragm wall/ cut-
off wall is not affected and proper stiffening is achieved for safety.
• Newer technologies for stone columns may be adopted.
• Additional settlement in rock fill will not harm the rock fill but transition zones
will have to be designed so that additional settlement in the rock fill is not
transferred to clay core.
• Spacing for investigations are to be suggested by Prof. Ramana.
42
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
• ECPT can be started with 20T capacity machines which are quicker and the
results to be correlated with other boreholes at sparse intervals.
• CIFRI may be approached to study and give hydraulic particulars required for
fish management in the location and for designing the fish ladder.
• WRD shall contact the A.P State Fisheries Department and facilitate scientists of
CIFRI and officials of A.P.Fisheries Department, executing agency and PPA to
work together so as to come out with a fish management plan and evolve the
data required for design of the fish ladder.
• A comprehensive silt management plan shall be evolved for the project and for
this purpose 1D/ 2D numerical model studies be conducted by CWPRS for
identifying delta formation and exploitation through controlled sand mining.
11) Model studies for Spill Channel, protective works on both banks
• 2D modelling can be done by CWPRS for worst flow conditions, which would
guide us in deciding the energy dissipation is required and if so the measures
to be adopted. Geo technical conditions in the spill channel have to be
considered in the study.
• Some ECPT tests in the spill channel shall be done.
• Soil sample collection in the spill channel has to be done under the supervision
of CSMRS and the 2D model studies have to be done by CWPRS.
• In-house material testing facilities have to be put in place for testing the
materials used for the project.
• List of available material testing equipment shall be submitted to CSMRS, who
will suggest the additional equipment to be procured for the quality control
and quality audit.
• Quality control and Quality audit has to be computerised and maintained in
digital form.
• Concrete cube strength tests shall be conducted for 56days and 90days too in
addition to 7days and 28 days.
43
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
• Shift the main reinforcement layer from “300mm thcik layer of HPC” to “main
concrete”(below HPC) and proposed to provide 16mm diameter 300mm c/c
shear lugs between two concrete grades (between HPC and main concrete).
Additionally, DDRP proposed a provision of nominal reinforcement of 16mm
diameter bars @ 300mm c/c ( both ways) in High Performance Concrete.
Two Review meetings have been convened during the year 2016-17 .Various issues
pertaining to the status of the project were discussed. Important outcome of the issues
discussed during those meetings are summarised as follows.
The First review meeting was held on 13th May, 2016 at the office of PPA in Krishna
Godavari Bhawan, Hyderabad with the officials of Water Resources Department,
Government of Andhra Pradesh, design consultants and the executing agency under
the Chairmanship of Shri Aditya Nath Das, Principal Secretary, WRD, Government of
Andhra Pradesh.
The Second review meeting was held on 2nd August, 2016 at the office of PPA in
Krishna Godavari Bhawan, Hyderabad with the officials of Water Resources
Department, Government of Andhra Pradesh, design consultants and the executing
agency under the Chairmanship of Shri R.K.Gupta, Member Secretary, Polavaram
Project Authority.
44
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
Two Review meetings on design issues have been convened during the year 2016-17.
Various issues pertaining to the designs of the project were discussed. Important
outcome of the issues discussed during those meetings are summarised as follows.
The First review meeting on designs was held on 1st April, 2016 at the office of PPA in
Krishna Godavari Bhawan, Hyderabad with the officials of Water Resources
Department, Government of Andhra Pradesh, design consultants and the executing
agency of the Head Works under the Chairmanship of Shri R.K.Gupta, Member
Secretary, Polavaram Project Authority.
The Second review meeting on designs was held on 6th October, 2016 at the office of
PPA in Krishna Godavari Bhawan, Hyderabad with the officials of CWPRS, Water
Resources Department, Government of Andhra Pradesh, design consultants and the
executing agency under the Chairmanship of Shri R.K.Gupta, Member Secretary,
Polavaram Project Authority to discuss technical aspects related to design of dam
complex of Polavaram Project and association of Central Water and Power Research
Station (CWPRS).
45
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
With the approval of Additional Secretary, MoWR ,RD & GR and Chief Executive Officer,
Polavaram Project Authority vide email dated 05.05.2016, a team was constituted
comprising of the following three officers to visit the project as an independent expert
and to assess the requirements pertaining to their specialisation and also to interact
with the field agencies such as construction agency, State Engineers including
Polavaram Project Authority to assess the preparedness, examine the works done as
per the requirements, identify the gaps and also suggest measures to meet the
requirements.
The Committee visited the Project during 16-19th May, 2016 and submitted its report.
Main conclusions drawn in the report submitted by the Committee are as under.
1. The project is in urgent need of reviews with respect to its execution strategies,
timelines and associated costs. However, revision of costs should not be carried
out without thoroughly reviewing and modifying the execution plan.
2. The construction scheduling for the dam is found to be non-rational.
3. Design and construction of dam needs to address technical issues, like analysis
for earthquake, foundation treatment and diversion arrangements for Earth
cum Rock fill dam. Special attention is drawn to establish of a Project Design
Review Panel comprising of experts in relevant fields and headed by an
Engineer of repute. The panel may be made functional urgently under PPA.
4. A water resources project management consultancy needs to be established by
PPA for execution of the Project as per the coordinated plan of action.
5. Engineering Project Management Consultant needs to be put in place in PPA.
6. Power House works, electro mechanical as well as civil and Hydro-Mechanical
works be started simultaneously. It is suggested that the head works including
power house works be placed under single management of Polavaram Project
Authority.
7. For effective control of the execution of the project, the Committee
recommends strengthening of PPA on priority with independent organisational
support along with the field support. The existing field set up of Polavaram
Project under Water Resources Department be placed under the administrative
control of PPA.
8. A resident geologist has to be in place under PPA.
9. A Quality assurance audit is needed for setting up a proper quality
management programme for the project.
10. Planning of the distributaries network be taken up on priority.
46
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
The first meeting of the Joint Committee was held on 02.06.2016 to speed up the
process of having consensus on the planning and preparation of detailed project
report (DPR) of Mahanadi – Godavari link project and to resolve issues related to
Polavaram Project. Following main issues related to Polavaram Project were discussed:
47
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
48
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
ANNEXURE
49
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
50
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
51
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
52
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
53
Polavaram Project Authority-Annual Report 2016-17
54
Connectivity Tunnel 2 of RMC (Excavation completed, portal supports)
Completed Dyke (part of Polavaram Head works)