Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Carbon Quantum Dots (CQDS) As Probes of Biological Systems
Carbon Quantum Dots (CQDS) As Probes of Biological Systems
Carbon Quantum Dots (CQDS) As Probes of Biological Systems
By
Osma Gomez
May 2021
Signature Page
This thesis of Osma Gomez is approved
ii
Dedication
I would like to dedicate this thesis to my aunt, Silvia Vilma Guerra. She has had an
overwhelming influence on my life and has been a key to my research. I hope we get closer to
finding a cure to breast cancer.
iii
Acknowledgement
First and foremost, I have to thank Dr. Joseph A. Teprovich. I have spent four years in his
laboratory and been very impressed by all his knowledge, confidence and support throughout this
program. I entered the master’s program with minimum physical chemistry background.
Regardless of my academic background, Dr. Teprovich always had sufficient amounts of patience
and kindness to tolerate me and hold me accountable to different tasks. I am going to miss being
in his lab!
I would also like to show gratitude to my committee members, Dr. Jussi Eloranta, Dr.
Brenton Hammer and Dr. Daniel Tamae. Dr. Eloranta was my first advisor through my chemistry
undergraduate program. His teaching style and enthusiasm in physical chemistry made a strong
influence to pursue a chemistry master’s degree. Dr. Hammer for reinforcing my organic
chemistry skills, mentorship and encouragement. Dr. Tamae for his biochemistry collaboration in
my thesis project. Even though they all had other priorities, I feel very honored and moved to have
a great thesis committee for they have given me unfailing support, mentorship and encouragement
I would like to thank my collaborator, Dr. Paula Fischhaber for all the bioimaging help,
guidance and support in my research as well as life experience outside of research. I would also
like to thank Dr. Mike Kaiser for troubleshooting instrumentation and guidance. Michael and Dee
I also like to thank all grad students in the chemistry graduate program who had made this
journey doable. They have given me great support, laughter and encouragement. I hope it won’t
be the last and we continue our friendship beyond the master’s degree.
iv
I would like to finally thank my sister, friends and family for their unfailing and genuine
support. They helped me relieve stress and pushed me to greater scholastic achievement beyond
this program. Their motivation and attentiveness were very helpful. I wouldn’t be here if it wasn’t
for them.
v
Table of Contents
Signature Page ii
Dedication iii
Acknowledgement iv
List of Schemes x
List of Tables xi
Abstract xii
Introduction 1
Quantum Dots 15
2.1 Background 16
2.2 Fullerene based carbon dots 18
2.3 LiBH4-C60 CQDs 19
2.4 Gadolinium Doped CQDs 20
2.5 Chiral Doped CQDs 20
2.6 Lawsone CQDs 21
Biological Systems 23
3.1 Cancer 23
3.2 MRI Contrasting Agents 24
Methodology 25
vi
4.1 Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy 25
4.2 Ultraviolet-visible Spectroscopy 28
4.3 Fluorescence Spectroscopy 33
4.4 Nuclear Magnetic Resonance 34
4.5 MTT assay 37
4.6 Fluorescence Microscopy 38
4.7 X-Ray Diffraction (XRD) 42
4.8 Circular Dichroism 43
Results 47
References 69
vii
List of Figures
viii
Figure 29- 12 Hours Emission Spectra 56
Figure 30- 24 Hours Emission Spectra 56
Figure 31- 575 nm excitation spectra 56
Figure 32- Qualify effects inhibit on cell metabolism spectrum 57
Figure 33- Dialyzed CQDs comparison to control 58
Figure 34- Dialyzed CQDs comparison to the lowest concentration 50ug/mL 58
Figure 35- Undialyzed CQDs comparison to control 59
Figure 36- Undialyzed CQDs comparison to the lowest concentration 50ug/mL 59
Figure 37- Gd-CQDs comparison to control 59
Figure 38- Gd-CQDs comparison to the lowest concentration 50ug/mL 59
Figure 39- Pure Gd MTT assay comparison to control 60
Figure 40- Pure Gd MTT assay comparison to the lowest concentration 50ug/mL 60
Figure 41- Chiroptical properties of tryptophan enantiomers and their respective 63
chiral CQDs
Figure 42- FTIR of Enantiomeric CQDs 64
Figure 43- NMR Initial CQD Results 65
Figure 44- Initial Gd NMR Results 66
ix
List of Schemes
x
List of Tables
xi
Abstract
By
Osma Gomez
In order to better understand and treat disease, there is an essential need to develop a
multimodal probe that can obtain chemical information about processes that occur at both the
microscale (cellular level) and the macroscale (tissues, organs). The current focus of this project
is to determine if CQDs can be used for fluorescent microscopy imaging at the cellular level and
MRI contrast agents for tissues and organs on the macroscale. The cell line utilized for
fluorescence imaging and cytotoxicity tests are the MDA-MB-231 breast cancer cells. The
cytotoxicity of the CQDs and gadolinium doped CQDs has been evaluated through MTT assays
indicates that they do not affect cell viability up to concentration of 500𝜇g/mL. Fluorescence
microscopy studies show that the CQDs are useful as dyes and that they localize in different parts
of the cell. NMR and MRI experiments demonstrates that the CQDs shorten the T1 and T2
xii
Additional work has demonstrated that it is possible to functionalize the surface of the
CQDs with chiral amino acids. Lawsone (henna plant) has been demonstrated as an interesting
candidate for the production of CQDs which is a natural sustainable carbon source for their
production.
xiii
Introduction
Light plays a vital role in our everyday lives and has become an essential tool in meeting
the demands of our 21st century world. Light-based technologies protect health and safety,
provide sustainable energy, enable space explorations, advance lighting options in rural areas,
enable communication via the Internet, and hold the promise of limitless possibilities to improve
the human condition and protect the earth. However, in physics, light is defined as all portions of
the electromagnetic spectrum.1 Visible light is a small portion of the electromagnetic radiation
spectrum (400-700 nm) and will be primary focus of this thesis. In particular, carbon quantum
dots (CQDs), consist of fluorescent carbon nanoparticles that exhibit luminescence in distinctive
forms, that has been studied for the past decade2 because of their potential applications electronics,
fluorescence imaging, sensing, etc.3 It has been demonstrated that these novel nanomaterials have
good photostability and tunable luminescence.4 The purpose of this work is to develop a new
fluorescent CQD platform that can be used as a multi-modal probes of biological systems with a
focus on fluorescent imaging and MRI contrasting agents. A quantum dot is a quantum
mechanically confined system, which means that its optical properties are a function of its size.
For example, as the size of the quantum dot is increased, the photoluminescence shifts from the
blue portion of the visible spectrum toward the red portion of the visible spectrum. However, one
of many drawbacks of the first-generation QDs is that they are typically composed of cadmium
and other transition metals, which is toxic to biological systems. Due to this, alternative efforts
were initiated to replace cadmium and other transition metals with carbon.
Photons are electromagnetic radiation, which have both particle and wave character. For
all electromagnetic radiation, the oscillating components of the electric and magnetic fields are
1
perpendicular to each other along the direction of propagation. For simplicity, we can look at a
equation 1.1.1.
ℎ𝑐
𝐸= = ℎ𝜐 (1.1.1)
𝜆
%
where ℎ is Planck’s constant (6.626 × 10!"# 𝐽 ∙ 𝑠), 𝑐 is the speed of light 32.998 × 10$ & 6, 𝜆 is
The Poynting Theorem states that the work done electromagnetic force is equal to the
decrease in energy stored in the field when accounting for the energy which flowed out through
the surface.5 The Poynting Vector (S) is a vector defined by Equation 1.1.2.
1
𝑆⃗ = 9𝐸:⃗ × 𝐻
:⃗< (1.1.2)
𝜇(
𝜇) is known as the permeability of the vacuum, E is the electric field and H is the magnetic field
vectors.6 It represents the energy flux density, 𝑆 ∙ 𝑑𝑎, as the energy per unit time transported by
the field across a surface da. According to the Poynting Theorem, the irradiance (intensity) that is
related to an electromagnetic wave of light is proportional to the square of the amplitude of the
2
electric field.6 When light interacts with a substance, this substance will be changed, mainly
through its velocity and its intensity. Additionally, some materials are able to alter light differently
When a molecule absorbs a photon, electrons get promoted from a lower energy level
(ground state) to a higher energy level (excited state). In band theory, the ground state is described
as the conduction band and the excited state as the valence band.
When light is absorbed by a sample, the intensity of the beam of light is decreased after
spectrum of electromagnetic radiation. This light passes through a monochromator that selects a
particular wavelength of light to send to the sample. The intensity of this selected wavelength of
light (Io) is reduced as it passes through the sample. The intensity of the light that passes through
the sample (I), is then sent to a detector where it is measured. A block diagram in Figure 2 shown
intensity of the light passing through the sample to the intensity of the incident light before entering
3
T can range anywhere from 0 to 1 or 0 to 100% if measured in percent transmittance. Absorbance
*
𝐴 = log') 3* 6 = − log') 𝑇 (1.2.2)
!
If no light is absorbed, 𝐴 = 0 and 𝐼 = 𝐼( .7 If 80% of the light is absorbed, 20% is transmitted and
*
𝐼 = +)! , therefore 𝐴 = 1.30.
1.3 Luminescence
Luminescence is the emission of light due to the transition of electrons from a higher
energy state to lower energy state. Each energy level can be further divided into vibrational states,
in which the electrons can occupy in an orbital. Luminescence is categorized based on the excited
state and the source of energy that permitted the excited state. The cause of excitation, which is
the instance when electrons are promoted to an excited state, is typically achieved through the
absorption of ultraviolet radiation or visible light. If the luminescence results from a singlet excited
The term singlet state indicates that an electron pair has opposite spins. In fluorescence, there is
an emission of a photon with a lower energy and a longer wavelength in comparison to the
4
absorbed photon. This is due to vibration relaxation of the excited state and translations motion of
the atoms in the molecules or the solvent. The vibrational energy can be transferred to another
molecule by collision, to rotational motion in the same molecule or to a different vibrational mode
within the same molecule. The process of fluorescence occurs very quickly, within 10-9 s to 10-6 s.
However, if luminescence is due to the transition of an electron from a triplet excited state
this process, the electron pair will have their spins aligned in the same direction with one in the
ground state and the other in the excited state. The triplet state occurs when the spin quantum
number changes through collision. During this event, there is intersystem crossing, in which the
molecule goes from an excited singlet state to a triplet state as seen in Figure 3. The triplet state
has higher vibrational energy and a lower electronic energy in comparison to a singlet state due to
a reduced interelectronic repulsion in the triplet state. In phosphorescence, the molecule will lose
vibrational energy and it will go to the lowest excited triplet state. The process of phosphorescence
is relatively slow, 10-4 to 102 s. A molecule can undergo both phosphorescence and fluorescence
which can be difficult to distinguish each process. However, fluorescence has a higher probability
of occurrence than phosphorescence for most molecules because phosphorescence involves a spin
forbidden transition.
A fluorescence emission spectrum is obtained when the excitation wavelength is fixed, and
the wavelength of emission is scanned. On the contrary, an excitation spectrum is obtained when
the emission wavelength is fixed, and the wavelengths are scanned to determine which give rise
in terms of limits of detection compared to a UV-vis. These two spectroscopic techniques can be
used to determine the effect that different chemical and environmental conditions have on a system
5
and help to understand its electronic structure. The maximum emission or excitation wavelength
and/or intensity may change with variables such as temperature, concentration, quenchers, energy
The Jablonski diagram is an energy diagram and describes the absorption and emission
process of light from a system. It is named after Professor Alexander Jablonski, who is known as
the father of fluorescence spectroscopy. These diagrams can demonstrate the numerous molecular
processes that can happen in the excited state. An example of a Jablonski diagram is shown in
Figure 4.
The diagram’s vertical axis describes energy, meanwhile the rest of the diagram has
columns that characterizes a specific spin multiplicity. In some diagrams, the same spin
multiplicity has divided energy levels placed in different columns, and each column has horizontal
lines that symbolize eigenstates. The bold horizontal lines are limits of electronic energy states
These diagrams use curved and straight lines to show transitions between eigenstates. The
curved lines show when the molecule gives off heat to its surrounding, vibrational relaxation. The
straight lines show an energy conversion in the system. If the arrow points upward, it is gaining
Absorption, the upward red arrow in Figure 4, occurs when the molecule absorbs energy
in the form of electromagnetic radiation. The electron is excited from a ground electronic state to
a vibrational level in the excited state. For example, in Figure 4, the arrow shows that the electron
is excited to the 6th vibrational state of an excited electronic state, however, the absorption process
may result in excitation to different vibrational state depending on the excitation energy. In other
6
words, the molecule may transition to a higher energy than the bottom energy level of the singlet
excited state. In the Jablonski diagram, the arrow points to a particular energy level. The likelihood
of ending at any particular state of energy and the likelihood of a certain photon absorption follows
a rule depends on the Frank-Condon principle, which will be discussed in a later section. In the
excited singlet state, the net spin is zero, and the spin doesn’t change when the molecule undergoes
an absorption event. The electron transitions to a different eigenstate according to the amount of
energy gained. Only certain wavelengths of a photon are possible for absorption which correspond
to the wavelength of the energy difference between the two different eigenstates. After absorption,
there are several ways in which the molecule can return to ground state: non-radiative and radiative
processes. The non-radiative process are vibrational relaxation, internal conversion and
process. This is demonstrated as a curvy, downward arrow between vibrational levels, and the
electrons will not change from one electronic level to another. This can be seen in Figure 4, as a
gray arrow. During vibrational relaxation, the molecule gives some of its energy as heat to its
surrounding and is transferred through collision between the excited molecule and the surrounding
molecules or solvent. Other times, the kinetic energy can stay within the same molecule. The
electron will relax down to a lower energy level of the excited state and remains in the same
electronic state. This process occurs very quickly on the order of 10-14 to 10-12 seconds.
7
Figure 4: Jablonski diagram showing the absorption, emission and phosphorescence processes
and time scales
Under certain circumstances, vibrational energy can overlap the electronic energy levels in
which the electron transitions from a vibrational level of higher electronic state to another
vibrational level in a lower electronic state. This process is known as internal conversion. In
internal conversion, the molecules dissipate energy, and can occur simultaneous with vibrational
relaxation. It is also demonstrated as a curved arrow pointing downward from one electronic
energy state to another on the Jablonski diagram. The process is a non-radiative loss of energy
Another way for the dissipation of energy is through the emission of a photon, which is
termed as fluorescence. It is illustrated in the Jablonski diagram as a blue straight line, pointing
downward from the first electronic state to the ground electronic state. At higher electronic
energies than the first electronic state, it is more probable that the energy dissipates in the form of
vibrational relaxation and internal conversion, which is the reason most fluorescence is observed
between the first excited state and ground state. Therefore, the energy of fluorescence is always
less that the absorption of energy because a portion of the electron’s energy is dissipated through
8
vibrational relaxation and internal conversion. The emitted energy of fluorescence is the same
energy as the difference between the eigenstates. Florescence is a relatively slow process compared
to absorption and may compete with other non-radiative that can occur on the same time scale.
Another relaxation process described in the Jablonski diagram is intersystem crossing. This
transition is from an excited singlet state to an excited triplet state and the electron changes spin
multiplicity. It will have a net spin that is not zero. It is illustrated on the Jablonski diagram as a
straight, horizontal arrow from one column to another column. It isn’t changing energy, and it can
be in the excited vibrational state in the triplet state. It is just jumping from the singlet state to a
triplet state. The process is slower than fluorescence, and it is known as the forbidden transition,
which is less likely to occur. These transitions are forbidden by the electric dipole selection rules.
After the intersystem crossing to a triplet state (T1), the electron can then undergo vibrational
relaxation within that electronic state. If the electron then transitions back to the ground state
through a radiative process, then it described as phosphorescence. However, the electron can also
undergo another intersystem crossing to the ground state (S0) and then undergo vibrational
In general, emitted light is lower energy than the absorbed light. Phosphorescence has a
lower energy than fluorescence. Phosphorescence is slower than fluorescence, and vibrational
relaxation warms up the surroundings. The diagram also demonstrates which types of transitions
take place in a specific molecule, and it is dependent on the time scale of the electronic transitions.
The transitions that occur fastest have a higher probability of occurrence, based on the selection
rules.
1.5 Lifetime
Lifetime is an important parameter in fluorescence. The lifetime is the average time the
molecule remains in the excited state following excitation. Emission occurs is a random event and
9
it will emit at a photon of light after a given period of time, which will result in a decay of the
excited state. There are different decay laws, such as non-exponential decays and multi-
exponential decays.
The lifetime of the excited states becomes the average lifetime of the entire fluorescent
molecule population. When the excited state population is diminished by some process (i.e.,
average lifetime will decrease. The average lifetime (𝜏̅) measurements can provide information
about energy transfer rates, including the average time the molecule spends in the excited state
before returning to the ground state. The average lifetime is defined by equation 1.5.1 with a two-
exponential decay:
0
𝛼' 𝜏'+ + 𝛼+ 𝜏++ + ⋯ ∑0/1' 𝛼/ 𝜏/+
𝜏,-. = (𝜏̅) = = = 𝑓' 𝜏' + 𝑓+ 𝜏+ + ⋯ = N 𝑓/ 𝜏/ (1.5.1)
𝛼' 𝜏' + 𝛼+ 𝜏+ + ⋯ ∑0/1' 𝛼/ 𝜏/
/1'
In the expression above, 𝜏/ are the decay times, and 𝛼/ represent the amplitudes of each component
at 𝑡 = 0, and 𝑛 is the number of decay times. The values of 𝛼/ can depend on many factors, such
as concentration, absorption, quantum yields and intensities of each fluorescence molecule at the
observed wavelength.
Absorption is the process that generates an excited state, and all the processes occur from or
between different excited states. For each process, there is a quantum yield, which is a measure of
the amount of the excited states decaying by each method, such as florescence, internal conversion,
etc.
However, for this thesis, the topic of concern is quantum yield of fluorescence. In this case,
every photon that is absorbed will not cause a florescence event. The quantum yield for
10
fluorescence is the ratio of the number of photons emitted relative to the number of photons
absorbed. It is an essential way of measuring the efficiency of a process. The quantum yield can
range between zero and one. Zero indicates that no absorption events resulted in a fluorescence
event, while a quantum yield of one indicates that every absorbed photon resulted in a fluorescence
event. A larger quantum yield will exhibit visibly brighter emission. In terms of the kinetic model,
it is a ratio of rate constants. It is the ratio of the fluorescence rate constant divided by the sum of
all the rate constant that causes deactivation of the exited state shown in equation 1.6.1.
k 2 represent the rate constant of fluorescence, k DEF is the rate constant of intersystem crossing
Jablonski diagram, the energy of the emission of a photon is less than the energy of the absorption,
which arises due to the loss of energy through vibrational relaxation. Sir George Gabriel Stokes
noticed that fluorescence occurs at longer wavelength and lower energies than the absorption, and
the Stokes shift was named after him. The Stokes shift is the difference in the maximum
wavelength of the absorption and emission for a molecule arising from the same electronic
transition. The larger the absorption and emission peaks are, and minimal overlapping is shown in
Figure 5 is ideal. This eliminates any self-absorption interaction or interferences caused by the
sample.
11
Figure 5: Stokes Shift with minimal self-absorption
A larger stoke shift prevents spectral overlap between emission and absorption which helps
reduce interference and allows detection of fluorescence. This removes the quenching of
fluorescence and provides a better signal for certain applications such as fluorescence microscopy.
As described in the Jablonski Diagram in Figure 4, when light is absorbed, the atom or
molecule transitions to an excited state. The Frank-Condon principle allows for calculation of the
intensities of transitions between electronic energy levels and vibrational states. The atom or
molecule can only exist in discrete electronic states and absorbs energy quanta proportional to the
separation between the allowed energy states. The energy of the quanta of absorption or emission
is relative to the length of the arrow. The absorption of energy permits the rearrangement of inertia-
free electrons, and it is an instantaneous process. As the molecule or atom absorbs energy, the
nuclei remain still while the electrons move. The nuclei and solvent medium do not have time to
readjust since they are heavier, and the relative momentum does not get affected by electronic
transitions. This can be illustrated by a diagram of potential energy versus the distance between
the nuclei, as seen in Figure 6. The arrow will point to the upper curve from the lower curve. The
12
curves show the two electronic states, ground and excited states. The vertical arrow shows the
transition of the electrons from the lowest vibrational state of the ground state to a specific
vibrational state of the excited state of a molecule. For these diagrams, there aren’t any horizontal
transitions because the nuclei don’t have time to move, and only the electrons are moving. The
arrow shown represents a possible transition between the two electronic states. Each of these
arrows corresponds to different energy, which determine the peak wavelength for each transition.
In addition, each arrow will provide a relative intensity of the transitions. These are determined by
two components: the solvent environment and the molecular overlap between the vibronic
eigenfunctions.
Figure 6: Frank Condon Principle transition representation of two electronic states and an
absorption transition
The ground vibrational state will have a wavefunction for vibrational motion, which is
solved from the Schrodinger equation. The squaring of this wave function provides the probability,
and the probability is highest at the center. This illustrates that the projection of the center to the
horizontal axis is where the atom will be in position. In addition, the transition starts from the
13
center of the vibration wave function in the ground state, and it will end at the overlap of the
vibrational wave function in the excited state. The probability of the transition between the ground
and the excited state is proportional to the value of Ψ2. There needs to be a good overlap between
these states. As the vibrational states increase in each electronic state, there will be more nodes.
All vibrational excited states have large lobes at the end of the potential curve and those are
classical turning points. There are several horizontal lines, within each electronic state, which
represent specific vibrational and rotational states. There is zero-point for vibronic motion
corresponding to a nonvibrating state in liquids and solids. However, some energy diagrams omit
the rotational sub-states for each electronic state. An electronic state will remain the same for all
vibrational or rotational states that lie within the same electronic state.
After absorption, which is considered an instantaneous process, the excited state atom or
molecule will not interact with the surrounding solvent atoms or molecules. After, the atom or
molecule dissipates the energy in the form of heat due to the change in vibrational energy. The
excited atom or molecule adopts a minimum free energy, and it will transition to a lower excited
state energy, which is called the equilibrium excited state. In addition, the electron relaxes to the
lowest vibrational level of the excited state. The orientations and position of the excited state atoms
or molecules and the solvent molecules adjust to a different arrangement of solvent molecules. The
lower energy state will have a lower energy organization of the solvent and solute molecules.
After, the equilibrium configuration of the excited state molecule and solvation shell is
achieved, the electron can then undergo fluorescence then transition back to the ground state. Once
fluorescence occurs, the molecules and solvation shell will return to its equilibrium state through
14
Quantum Dots
Quantum dots (QDs) are small semiconducting particles with typical sizes that range from
one to ten nanometers. QDs are artificial clusters of semiconductive atoms that have the ability to
confine the electron’s motion due to their small size. One of the most important properties of QDs
is the ability to fine tune their bandgap which allows one to control the frequency of absorbance
and emission. In this way, it is possible for their optical and electrical properties to be adjusted
according to their applications. QDs absorb photons of light and then emit longer wavelength
photons. The frequency of absorbed and emitted from the QD can actually be controlled without
significant cost and without the use of high-end technology. There are different types of quantum
confined semiconductors which include quantum wires, quantum wells, and quantum dots.
Quantum wires are confine electrons or holes in two special dimensions and allow free propagation
in the third dimension. Quantum wells confine electrons or holes in one dimension and allow free
propagation in two dimensions. Electrons exist in discrete energy levels in the bulk semiconductor.
In these materials, there is a forbidden range of energy levels known as bandgap. The lower energy
level is called the valence band (VB) and the higher energy level above the bandgap is called a
conduction band (CB). By absorbing light, an electron can rise from the valence band to the
conduction band. This action leaves behind a hole in the valence band and the hole, and the
electron together are called an exciton. The average distance between the electron and the hole
and an exciton is called the excited Bohr radius. When the size of the semiconductor falls below
the Bohr radius, the semiconductor is called a quantum dot and its properties can differ
significantly from the bulk material. The exciton, electron hole pair, has a limited lifetime and
will eventually recombine. The recombination process is usually irradiated process which includes
15
Generally, the smaller the size of the crystal the larger the bandgap, the greater the
difference in the energy between the valence band and conduction band becomes. Therefore, more
energy is needed to excite the dot and simultaneously more energy is released when it returns to
its resting state. This equates to higher frequencies of light emitted after excitation of the dot as
the crystal size grows smaller, resulting in a color shift from red to blue in the light emitted. In
addition to such tuning, a main advantage with the quantum dot is its high level of the control
2.1 Background
Semiconducting quantum dots (QDs) were discovered in 1981 are the first generation and
most common form of fluorescent nanomaterials studies.8 They are very small semiconductor
crystals on the order of nanometers. These novel materials exhibit remarkable novel magnetic,
mechanical, physicochemical and optoelectronic properties.9 However, the first generation of QDs
typically contain heavy metal elements such as cadmium, whose potential health and
Quantum dots are made largely from the elements in the second and sixth group of the
periodic table. Cadmium chalcogenides (CdS, CdSe, CdTe), zinc (ZnSe, ZnS, ZnTe), and the third
and fifth groups, phosphides and indium arsenide.11 Quantum dots can be engineered to
fluorescence in different wavelengths based on their physical dimensions. Even though QDs have
received immense interests for their applications in medicine and biology. Studies have shown
with CdSe-core quantum dots are toxic to both cell cultures and live animals.12 Cadmium has been
reported to transport in cardiac cells and liver cells by a number of pathways.13, 14 Cadmium has
shown to transport primarily through diffusion in the renal cortical epithelial cells.15 Other
16
cadmium competes with calcium (Ca), zinc (Zn) and copper (Cu) for uptake in hepatic and renal
cells.15, 18, 19 Since these metals (Ca, Zn, Cu) are vital to cellular metabolic, homeostatic, and repair
mechanisms, the inhibition of such processes by cadmium can lead to cell death.13
There is a need to develop a more sustained and environmentally friend form of quantum
dots to replace the first generation of quantum dots based on transition metals. Carbon dots is a
general class of materials typically referring to small carbon nanoparticles with various levels of
surface passivation. They have emerged as a new class of quantum dot-like fluorescent
nanomaterials.20 Carbon dots (CQDs and CNDs) were discovered much later in 2004 followed by
graphene quantum dots (GQDs) in 2006.21 These nanomaterials are also quantum confined
systems in which their bandgap can be changed based on their size. The valence (LUMO) and a
conduction (HOMO) band are separated by some finite energy gap known as a bandgap. When
an electron from the valence band attains ample energy to overcome the bandgap, due to an
Numerous approaches with a large array of techniques and starting materials have been
utilized for the synthesis of fluorescent carbon dots. The synthesis methods can be divided into
two processes: top-down and bottom-up. Some examples of top-down approaches are laser
ablation, chemical oxidation in strong acid and electrochemical synthesis. Compared with the top-
down approach, some bottom-up strategy examples are hydrothermal and solvothermal. For the
purposes of this thesis, the method used for the synthesis of the CQDs was a bottom-up approach.
Early synthesis used top-down procedures used “brute-force” experimental schemes, using
high energy impact upon a carbon source thereby generating the fluorescent carbon
nanoparticles.22 As such, laser ablation was most often used to produce inorganic nanoparticles
17
synthesized quantum dots. For example, graphite rods were used for the electrochemical cell to
function as both anode and cathode. The electrolyte solution was sodium hydroxide and ethanol.
As the current passed through the chemical circuit, the graphite rods dissolved producing carbon
dots.23
New methods such as hydrothermal and solvothermal processes are now widely employed
to produce CQDs. Carbon quantum dots were generated by glucose and its derivatives as the
carbon source and heated in water in microwave-assisted hydrothermal method.24 Tang and his
research group took measures of 1 to 9 minutes. The only main different between hydrothermal
and solvothermal is the solvent used for the reaction. If water is used as the solvent, it is referred
as hydrothermal method while if any organic liquid is used as the solvent, it is referred as
solvothermal method.25
Alternative methods have been employed to incorporate heteroatoms into the CQD
structure. Heteroatom doping has been shown to have a significant impact of the photophysical
properties of CQDs. For example, nitrogen doped carbon dots were developed by combining citric
acid and urea through a hydrothermal process to synthesize nitrogen doped carbon dots.26 Some
specific precursors for hydrothermal conditions was heating up to 180℃ for 60 minutes followed
by cooling to room temperature. As a result, there exhibits a shift towards the red emission of the
Fullerene and its derivatives were the first class of carbon-based nanostructures to be
discovered (1985) and their chemistry and properties have remained the focus of extensive
investigations.27 Fullerene are mainly produced through the vaporization of graphite by resistive
heating under carefully defined conditions or the combustion of hydrocarbons in fuel-rich flames.28
18
Generally, they are closed hollow cages made of sp2-hybridized carbon atoms arranged into 12
pentagons and twenty hexagons carbon atoms.29 In one interesting study of fullerene-based carbon
dots, fullerene was conjugated with tetraethylene glycol (TEG), to generate TEG-fullerene
capabilities that can be employed for the next-generation biomedical applications, particularly in
scavenge free radicals, which is attributed to their strong conjugated 𝜋-system to capture
electrons.32 Low toxicity and high water solubility was discovered which open new prospects for
further clinical studies. Also, fullerene in organic solvents exhibits five stages of reversible
These characteristics were taken to account for selecting an appropriate carbon precursor to form
a fullerene, and a complex metal hydride, lithium borohydride.34 The resulting CQDs possess
good photostability and the ability to tune its photophysical properties. The solvent used to react
LiBH4 with C60 is tetrahydrofuran. Upon removal of solvent under vacuum, annealing at 300℃
under an inert atmosphere for one hour the CQD precursor is obtained. Once the black CQD
precursor is obtained, it is then exposed to air, and causes the rapid oxidation of the material. This
rapid oxidation results in a color change to red-orange and the resulting material becomes
19
2.4 Gadolinium Doped CQDs
magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). So far, there are at least nine formulations of Gd-containing
contrasting agents approved for human and they are assisting more than 10 million MRI scans per
year.35 However, MRI active Gd-chelates can be toxic to humans when Gd escapes the chelating
ligand.
The first Gd-doped C-dot that combine fluorescence with a strong MRI contrast ability was
(Tris base) and betaine hydrochloride followed by pyrolysis in air at 250℃ which led to a Gd
doped carbon dot.36 The Gd-doped C-dot showed promising results for cell cytotoxicity studies
and the dots are water soluble with strong T1 weighted MRI contrast comparable to commercial
Gadovist. It served as a dual probe for both fluorescent and MRI studies purposes. In light of this
Since we already know that fullerene has unique chemical properties, researchers began to
distinct potential for medicinal applications, since the fullerene cage guards the encapsulated metal
ion from external chemical attack and metal ion release in the body.37
One future work to consider is functionalizing CQDs with chiral groups. Chirality exists
extensively in nature and plays vitals roles in life and material sciences. Chirality has a distinct
geometry of atoms, molecules, particles, etc., defined by describing the fact that the mirror image
of an object is not superimposable with the original.38 Chiral functionalization of CQDs would
20
broaden applications to chiral recognition, chiral separation, asymmetric catalysis, chiral sensing
as well as other bio-applications.39 To this day, chirality at the nanometer scale is still being
investigated. Chiral quantum dots are a class of nanomaterials with chiral and fluorescence
properties and have shown great interest due to easy functionalization, low cost, very low toxicity
The research on chiral CQDs indicated that levorotatory CQDs (L-CQDs) and
dextrorotatory CQDs (D-CQDs) present different biological effects.40 For instance, L-CQDs
indicated chirality dependent enhancement in cellular glycolysis, while D-CQDs are selective in
energy metabolism of cells.41 D-CQDs are able to boost photosynthesis better and collect more
carbohydrate in mung bean plants, which can be possibly used as fertilizer for agricultural
application42
One approach that has been investigated was using sodium citrate and ammonium
bicarbonate to synthesize CQDs by a facile green hydrothermal process.43 Dialysis was conducted,
hydrochloride (EDC-HCL) and L-tryptophan was added to the mixture to generate L-CQDs.
Based on this and similar work, we decided to try a similar scheme using our CQD to prepare
chiral analogues.
henna leaf extract with several cytotoxic activities and used as precursor for synthesis of various
pharmaceutical compounds and is in quinones.44 Quinones contain a benzyl ring with two
21
carbonyl groups in the ortho- or para- position as seen in Scheme 1 depending on the tautomeric
form.
In Scheme 1, there are 3 possible tautomeric forms. However, the 1,4-naphthoquinone structure
is the most stable form followed by 1,2-naphthoquinone and finally 1,2,4-naphthotrione.45 This
is due to the intramolecular hydrogen bonds stability in the 1,4-naphthoquinone and the dipole
moment cancellation of the carbonyl groups. Their chemical structures enable these molecules to
interfere in several biochemical processes regarding redox homeostasis and inhibition of electron
transport.46
The benzyl group as well as the carbonyl bonds contain conjugated pi systems that can
undergo pericyclic reactions to form larger polymer macromolecules. Due to these conjugated pi
systems, lawsone exhibits very strong light absorption. The benzyl groups in lawsone are
ubiquitous precursors for producing carbon dots (CDs) with red/near-IR or multicolor emissions,
primarily those that are substituted with functional groups such as amino (-NH2), hydroxyl (-OH)
or sulfhydryl (-SH).47, 48
It has been demonstrated that certain structure presented in these
precursors would lower the energy gaps of CDs by generating large sp2 domains through
22
Biological Systems
3.1 Cancer
Tumor metastasis to distant sites is a major cause of cancer morbidity and mortality. There
is a dire need for novel imaging modalities and contrast agents in order to improve patient
outcomes.
Cancer cells are abnormal cells that divide uncontrollably, forming tumors. A tumor
consists of many cancer cells that destroy the healthy, normal cells that surrounds the tumor and
eventually damage the healthy tissue and organs. Cancer cells emerge through a series of
epigenetic and genetic changes. Some of the changes may be caused through inheritance or
carcinogens in the environment. These tumors can be benign, malignant or metastatic. Benign
tumors grow slowly and do not spread. Malignant tumors have the capability to invade nearby
tissue and organ and spread throughout the body. Metastasis is the terminal stage of the cancer.
There are various types of cancer cells, but the four main types of cancer are carcinomas, sarcomas,
leukemia and lymphomas. For the focuses of this thesis, the main focus will be on a triple negative
breast adenocarcinoma cell line, MDA-MB-231. This cell line is an epithelial, human breast cancer
cell line that was founded from a pleural effusion of a 51year old Caucasian female with a
Cancer cells differ from normal cells in several ways. Cancer cells proliferate in an
uncontrolled way. In contrast, normal cells grow as part of development or to repair injury. Normal
cells have a limited lifespan and can self-destruct when it becomes old or damaged. In contrast,
cancer cells developed a loss of tumor suppressor genes and activation of oncogenes. A way for a
cell to resist death is to restore their telomeres as it continues to divide. In addition, cancer cells
can extend to other parts of the body by not responding to any signal. On the contrary, normal cells
23
The process of a normal cells transforming into a cancer cell goes through several stages
to become more abnormal. These stages maybe hyperplasia, dysplasia and finally cancer. The
In many cases, the immune system recognizes and tries to eliminate the cancer cells.
However, during treatment, the cancer cells do not remain the same and continually mutate.
Different cancers have different mutation routes. For this reason, many times, the cancer cells are
florescent dyes labeling for specific proteins, antibodies or cell detection. Such dyes are used to
detect by attaching the target molecule or molecules and aid to the problem. As fluorescent
nanomaterials with bright fluorescence, exhibit high quantum yield, resistance to photobleaching,
biocompatibility and low biotoxicity, carbon dots have shown great potential for use in fluorescent
bioimaging.52
Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has also been extensively performed as a noninvasive
imaging technology with high spatial resolution in clinical diagnoses.53 In particular, Gadolinium
(Gd) exhibits exceptional contrasting efficiency because of its unique magnetic properties.
Gadolinium (III) is a fair large paramagnetic species with seven unpaired electrons and allows
water to enter the inner solvation sphere. In the inner solvation sphere, its able to affect the
relaxation time of water to highlight features in an MRI image. Currently there are many
multidentate ligand such as an EDTA or porphyrin derivative. However, one of the issues with
these contrasting agents is that gadolinium can actually escape and spread throughout other parts
24
Methodology
The work presented in this thesis came to fruition through several collaborations between
laboratories at The University of Texas at Austin, Savannah River National Laboratory (SRNL),
and California State University, Northridge, in California, USA. Thus, a description of each
instrumentation will be presented, which was utilized for either qualitative or quantitative or both
for analysis.
Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy, known as FTIR, is widely used in food analysis,
manufacturing, research and product development. It is used to identify and/or characterize new
materials, as well as verify known specimens. FTIR spectrometers have the following benefits: it
has high resolution of about 0.1 – 0.005 cm!' , it has a rapid scan time of all frequencies, the signal-
to-noise ratio is higher than the prior generations, the scan range is between 1000 and 10 cm!' ,
and the wavenumber has high accuracy, therefore, the error is within ±0.01cm!' .
Infrared spectroscopy examines the interaction between matter and infrared (IR) radiation.
Infrared is a region in the electromagnetic spectrum that has a longer wavelength than visible light.
It has a smaller wave number and carries less energy. The range of infrared region can be divided
into three regions: far-infrared region, mid-infrared region and near-infrared region. The IR region
is characterized by molecular vibration. There are various types of vibrations, but the main
categories are anti-symmetric, symmetric, deformation vibration, wagging, rocking and twisting
vibrations. When the sample molecules absorb infrared radiation of specific wavelengths, the
molecules have a change of dipole moment, and the vibrational energy levels transfer to the excited
state from the ground state. The vibrational energy gap governs the frequency of the absorption
peak. The intensity of the absorption peak is associated with the change of the dipole moment, and
25
the number of vibration peaks correlates to the number of vibrational degrees of freedom in the
molecule. Therefore, the infrared spectrum can provide information of the molecular structure.
The improvements of the IR spectrometers led to the invention of the Fourier Transform
Infrared (FTIR) Spectrometer. Most FTIR spectrometer comprise of a radiation source, Michelson
interferometer, sample compartment, detector, A/D converter, amplifier and a computer. Within
the interferometer, there is a beam-splitter, a fixed mirror and a movable mirror. As the source
generates the IR radiation, the beam travels from the source and enters the interferometer. Then, it
enters the beam-splitter. It has a material that reflects IR radiation and permits IR travel through
the transparent part. From the beam splitter, the beam is split and directed at equal amounts to the
moveable and fixed mirror. In other words, fifty percent of the radiation travels to the moveable
mirror and the remaining goes to the fixed mirror. Then, the beams reflect the mirrors, and
recombines, which causes interference. Finally, the light is directed at the sample. The sample
absorbs some of the light, and specific amounts of light will travel through the sample material.
The remaining light that is transmitted through the sample carries the information into the detector
to produce an electronic signal shown in Figure 7. The signal becomes amplified and converted to
a digital signal through an analog-to-digital converter. The signal transfers its information to the
26
Figure 7: FTIR schematic
FTIR displays the amount of light hitting the detector by using a broadband light detector
that observe all the wavelengths simultaneously. It doesn’t inform the user which wavelengths are
used, and it only displays the power of light reaching the detector. The power can change by
creating interference within the light through the interferometers. The interference patterns
illustrate every wavelength that exist within the light. The interference of the radiation between
the beams yields a signal that reflects the change of path length of the beams. The moveable mirror
can travel a certain distance based on the design of the spectrometer If the length between the
stationary mirror to the beam splitter and the distance between the beam splitter to the moveable
mirror are the same, the condition is known as “zero path difference.” In this situation, the light
doesn’t change, and the resulting beam matches the radiation source. Both beams are in phase, and
the maximum signal reaches the detector. The mirrors are adjusted to be the same distance apart.
The output would be a power vs distance graph. In practice, there is partial interface pattern, in-
phase pattern and out of phase pattern that occurs. The net signal reaching the detector is a cosine
wave. In nature, IR sources are polychromatic, which each wavelength generates a cosine wave.
The summation of all the cosine waves reaches the detector, and the interferogram beam is
27
generated. The interferogram holds the spectral information in the distance (m) domain. The
'
Fourier transform converts it to wavenumbers 3%6 domain.
water vapor and CO2 in the atmosphere. This process can be accomplished by measuring a
spectrum without a sample present. The raw signal undergoes a Fourier Transform into the IR plot
of light intensity vs wavenumber, and it becomes a reference spectrum. Then, a sample is inserted
into the beam path and the procedure repeats. The sample spectrum is divided into a reference
spectrum to obtain the FTIR spectrum. When adjusting the moving mirror by have of the
wavelength of the beam source, the two beams have wavelengths that are out of phase and interfere
destructively. There isn’t a signal that reaches the detector, or it has a minimal signal.
Sunlight, also known as white light, consists of a wide range of wavelengths in the
commonly treated as a wave and is characterized by its frequency or wavelength. Each segment of
the spectrum has an energy that is proportional to its frequency. Equation 4.2.1 describes the
within a substance. Specifically, a UV-Vis spectrophotometer can help determine the wavelength
or wavelengths of light that are absorbed by the compound if the molecule absorbs light in the
visible or ultraviolet region of the electromagnetic spectrum. Different molecules can absorb
28
spectroscopy. UV-Vis spectroscopy is utilized in various industries, such as production, research
The UV-Vis spectrophotometer consists of a xenon or deuterium source. The source creates
a range of wavelengths of light, which directs a beam of light into a monochromator. The
monochromator is a device that resolves a wide band of polychromatic light radiation into narrow
band of monochromatic radiation. There are three types of monochromators: prisms, gratings and
filters. In many instruments, the monochromator consists of two slits separated by a diffraction
grating or prism. As the light passes through the first slit, it ensures all the photons are traveling
along parallel pathways. The light strikes the prism, and the light refracts to different directions.
Only one wavelength of light will make it through the second slit in the monochromator.
Afterward, the beam of light passes through the beam splitter, which separates the beam of light
into two equal and parallel beams of light. Then, the beam enters the sample compartment, which
consist of the sample and reference cells. Next, the beams of light hit each detector, a device that
transforms the beam of photons into electrical current. There are a variety of detectors, such as
photo tube, photomultiplier tube, barrier layer cell, thermocouple, barometer, etc. However, the
photomultiplier is the most common detector. The following components are the amplifier and
recorder. The amplifier amplifies the incoming signal from the detector, and the recorder provides
29
The current generated by each detector is the same, and therefore, the intensity is also the
same. If the sample has zero concentration, there is 100% transmittance. This signifies the ratio of
the intensity leaving the sample cell to the reference cell must equal to one. When solute is added
into the sample, the solute can absorb some of the light. The intensity of light exiting the sample
decreases, and the current from the detector also decreases. This leads to a ratio of intensities less
than 1. As more concentration increases, the ratio of the intensities decreases further. The
relationship between the percent transmittance and the concentration of the sample is exponential
logarithm of the transmittance, which creates a linear function. The data is plotted in absorbance,
and it is easier to predict the absorbance through interpolating or extrapolating the collected data.
During the time when the sample is stored inside the cuvette, there exist a linear relationship
between the concentration and the amount of light absorbed sample, which is known as the Beer
A= 𝜀 ∙ [c] ∙ ℓ (4.2.3)
A is absorbance, and it is displayed as the y-axis on the chart. 𝜀 is the molar absorptivity,
C is the concentration of the sample, and ℓ is the path length of the specific type of
spectrophotometer. The path length and the molar absorptivity are the only constant parameters in
the Beer Lambert Law. The molar absorptivity is a specific value for each substance. The
absorbance value is inversely proportional to the light transmitted through the sample. Therefore,
a higher concentration of the solute constitutes more light absorbed. The sample absorbs particular
wavelengths. The transmitted light results from the light that isn’t absorbed and passes through the
30
cuvette. The spectrograph displays the absorbance of the sample for a range of wavelengths within
the visible and ultraviolet region. A particular absorbance value will determine the concentration
When a molecule is exposed to light that contains an energy equal to a possible electronic
transition, the electron will be promoted to a higher energy orbital as the light energy is absorbed.
Figure 9, shows the various electronic excitations that an organic molecule can undergo.
Of the six transitions, only the two with the lowest energy have energy values ranging from 200
to 800 nm. Energetic electrons will undergo a promotion and transit from the highest occupied
molecular orbit (HOMO) to the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) as depicted in figure
10.
31
Figure 10: Energetic electrons transitions
The resulting state is known as an excited state. Only molecular moieties that absorb wavelengths
in the 200 to 800 nm spectrum are pi-electron functions and hetero atoms having non-bonding
valence-shell electron pairs. These groups are known as chromophores. The presence of
chromophores can be detected with the UV-Vis spectroscopy; however, it becomes problematic
for most instruments to provide absorption data below wavelengths of 200 nm. Luckily,
The UV-Vis Spectrophotometer detects whether the sample is a conjugated system because
it can absorb light. Conjugated systems are alternating double, single, double bonds. At times, it
can be triple, single, triple bonds, or alternating bonds. If the sample doesn’t absorb light, there is
there is some absorption when UV light enters the cuvette. The conjugated system doesn’t absorb
every wavelength in the UV region of the electromagnetic spectrum. Instead, it absorbs at the
32
4.3 Fluorescence Spectroscopy
good to analyze plants, animal tissue and DNA. Fluorescence is 3 orders of magnitude better than
UV absorbance spectroscopy. Fluorescence is the process when a material emits light at one
wavelength. To understand how a molecule exchanges energy with the light, we can look at the
electromagnetic waves, and how it carries energy. Light can be understood as electromagnetic
waves with a wavelength and a speed (the speed by which the peak travels). Light can be described
as particles called photons. Each photon carries a small amount of energy that is related to the
The energy is given the Planck’s constant (ℎ), c is the speed of light, and the wavelength
is lambda. The energy of the photon is inversely proportional to the wavelength. This means, the
longer the wavelength, the less energy the photons carry. A Jablonski diagram shows the allowed
energy states that the molecule can be in. A molecule will be in the ground state can absorb a
photon with a certain wavelength and energy. The energy of the molecule gets raised to a higher
level. From this level, the molecule will relax a bit and in an excited state. Then the molecule can
source such as a Xenon lamp is used in most instruments. The light then passes through an
excitation monochromator before being directed into the sample. The light emitted from the
sample is then collected at 90° by a detector after passing through the emission monochromator.
33
The electromagnetic spectrum is then scanned with the emission monochromator to determine
The NMR is composed of radiofrequency (RF) transmitter, magnet, receiver coil, sample
holder, sweep generator, amplifier, detector and recorder. The RF transmitter generates radio
frequency to the sample, which is transferred to the coil near the sample and the electromagnetic
radiation will be perpendicular to the receiver coil as well as the magnet field. Therefore, there
will be resonance in the sample. The magnet is located near the sample holder and produce the
magnetic field. The magnet’s strength determines he accuracy and quality of the instrument. The
resolution increases with an increase of field strength. There are three types of magnets that can
(permanent). Each of the magnets have different frequencies. There is a relationship between the
magnetic field strength, 𝐵( and the frequency, v, and it can be determined using the Larmor
34
N
v = 3+O6 ∙ 𝐵( (4.4.1)
y is gyromagnetic ratio, and it is a constant, 267.53 radians/T. If the magnetic strength is known,
the frequency can be determined. The sweep generator works in conjunction with the sweep coil,
which alters the magnetic field by increasing or decreasing the magnetic field. It is a set of
The receiver coils wrap around the sample holder as seen in Figure 12. It will receive the
electromagnetic radiation and it will go into the amplifier, and it will amplify it by 10P times. Then
the signal will go to the detector to receive the signal, and it will finally reach the recorder or
oscilloscope.
RF
transmitter Radio frequency
receiver & amplifier
Sweep Coils Sweep Coils
Control Console
and
Recorder
Sample
Magnet Magnet
Receiver Coils
Sweep
Generator
There are two types of NMR instrument: one is constant magnetic field and the other is
constant radio frequency transmitter. The constant radio frequency transmitter can increase or
decrease the magnetic field. In contrast, a constant magnetic field will allow the radio frequency
transmitter to vary. Therefore, the sweep coil or sweep generator will not be required.
The physical foundation of NMR spectroscopy lies in the magnetic properties of atomic
nuclei.55 According to the rules of quantum mechanics, the interactions between the external
35
magnetic field 𝐵) and the nuclear magnetic moment 𝜇, plays a vital role in energy level diagrams.
This is due to the magnetic energy of the nucleus. These energy restrictions led to certain discrete
eigenvalues 𝐸/ associated with eigenstates that an elementary particle can exist known as stationary
states.
For the purposes of this thesis, NMR was conducted for T1 measurements. Protons without
an external magnetic field move in all types of directions shown in Figure 13(A). T1 is a
longitudinal relaxation and follows first order kinetics given by equation 4.4.2.
!RTS
𝑀Q = 𝑀) 31 − 𝑒 & 6 (4.4.2)
𝑇' is a first order time constant in this equation, 𝑀Q is the magnetization along the z-axis along the
magnetic field 𝐵) and 𝑀) is the initial magnetization. 𝑇' is defined on the return to equilibrium in
the direction of magnetization along the z-axis as seen in Figure 13(C) occurring to the equation.
𝑇' relaxation is basically an energy flow amongst spins and their external environment seen in
Figure 13(B). The measure of energy transmitted from the nuclei is extremely small relative to
normal molecular kinetic energies. All energy emission in NMR must be stimulated through
encounter of the nucleus with another magnetic field fluctuating near the Larmor frequency.56 Just
like 𝐵) (𝑀Q ) field that initially excited the nuclei into resonance, the radio frequency fields causing
𝑇' relaxation must oscillate near the Larmor frequency in the transverse plane (𝑀UN ) along 𝐵' as
36
Figure 13: NMR 𝑇' Relaxation
colorimetric assay. The MTT assay measures the reduction of the yellow MTT reagent by an
enzymatic catalyzed reaction via the NADH Oxidoreductase or NADH Dehydrogenase. This will
convert NADH to NAD+ when the cells are viable as shown by the reaction seen in Scheme 2.
The MTT reagent enters the cells and passes into the mitochondria where it is reduced to a
formazan product observed as a purple color. If you have a well with no cells. No cells mean no
mitochondria. No mitochondria mean no enzyme. Therefore, the MTT reagent will not be
converted to form formazan. But, if you have cells, the more cell you have, the more mitochondria
you have. The more mitochondria, the more NADH oxidoreductase you have and there will be a
37
quantitative relationship with the conversion to formazan. It is an output of metabolic acidity this
MTT assay. The mitochondria are the driving force of metabolism of the cell. The more
mitochondria activity there is, the faster the conversion of this MTT will be to form formazan.
With any compound, if there is a cytotoxic or cytostatic effect, there will be a diminished
understand different regions inside the cell.58 If the cell is present, the cell’s nucleus is marked
with a particular dye.59 The dye or chemical factor has a fluorescence property.60 The fluorescence
dye receives a particular wavelength, and it emits a different wavelength.60 In other words, a light
of lower wavelength is applied, and the dye responds by emitting light of a higher wavelength.61
In general, the emission light has a longer wavelength than the excitation light, and therefore the
emission light has a lower energy. The total amount of events in which light emission occurs and
some of the loss in energy can be expressed a ratio of quantum efficiency. Quantum efficiency is
an important characteristic of the dye, and the dye also depends on the environment.58 The intensity
of light emitted is another important parameter for a dye. The brightness is determined by how
well the dye absorbs the excitation light, as well as the fraction of the excited states returns to the
ground state on the emission of fluorescence. It is determined by both the quantum efficiency and
absorption coefficient. Another important factor of the dye is the time is takes between absorption
and the time it takes the dye to return to ground state from the excited state. This process is in the
order of nanoseconds, and it is a characteristic specific to the dye and the environment of the dye.
lasers, mercury or xenon arc lamps.59 The light will travel to the excitation filter to eliminate certain
38
wavelengths, and it will allow only the wavelength that will excite the dye. The light will reflect
off the dichroic mirror, enter the objective and travel to the sample.59 The specimen contains the
chemical compound which shows the fluorescence. The fluorescence molecules interact with the
excitation energy.58 Only a particular wavelength of light can excite the fluorescent molecules.
The specimen absorbs light, and the absorption is a fast process, in the time scale of femto-scale.62
The electron is excited to a higher energy state, with a higher orbital, as seen on the Jablonski
diagram, and it will come down to the ground state and emit the fluorescence.61 The fluorescence
light is of a specific wavelength, and the photon will be of a higher wavelength with a lower energy
than the absorption energy. The emitted light will pass through the same objective, and then it will
encounter the same dichroic mirror.61 The dichroic mirror not only reflects a specific wavelength
of light, but it allows another wavelength to pass the through the mirror.61 After, the emitted light
will pass through the emission filter, which will block any scattered excitation light to obtain the
fluorescence on the detector or a CCD camera.59 This entire process is shown on Figure 14.
The two important factors that determine the quality of the image are resolution and
contrast.61 High resolution and contrast are always desirable.58 The aspect that makes fluorescence
microscopy different from a normal microscope is the filters. These filters discriminate the
39
excitation light from the emitted light.61 There are filters that absorb a certain range of wavelengths
from the light. These filters, based on absorption, are not great in practice because the spectrum is
broad, and it is prone to absorb a small amount of the emission light. Typically, interference filters
are commonly utilized in most instruments.61 These are thin alternating layers that have different
refractive index, so they are interfaces that can reflect the light. The thin and transparent layers are
about a half wavelength or wavelength of light apart with semi-reflective coatings in between.
When light hits the filter, part of the light will travel through and the rest will be reflected. The
reflected light will interfere with itself. If the reflected wavelengths have a phase difference equates
interference will allow the light pass through the filter. On the other hand, when the wavelengths
are different, there is destructive interference, and the light will be reflected away.59 The
manufacturer can design which wavelengths the filter should pass, and which wavelengths should
In fluorescence microscopy, there is a filter cube shown in figure 15 which includes the
excitation filter, a dichroic mirror and an emission filter.61 It is important to know the spectrum of
these filters to know which wavelengths are being reflected and transmitted. The dichroic mirror
is made to reflect everything that has a lower wavelength than a certain cut-off band and allow the
passage of higher wavelengths. The emission filter will allow higher wavelengths to pass but reject
the excitation light.58 The task is to select the correct filter that will match well with the dye that
will be utilized. As a general rule, it is desired to get all the photons to obtain a brighter image.
40
Figure 15: Filter Cube
There are carousel or turret that contain filter cubes, and the user can select the appropriate
filter cube. The cubes are chosen to visualize the dyes that are of interest. In the computer, all the
do not last a long time, and they have a limited number of cycles. Overtime, the fluorescence can
bleach and no longer occur.58 To minimize this effect, there are dyes that are resistant against
fading and do not bleach as fast relative to others. In the market, there are other dyes that have the
same excitation and emission properties but bleach at a slower rate. Each dye has a probable chance
that it will photobleach.58 By changing the environment of the dye, you can minimize the rate of
bleaching. For example, oxygen helps speed the photobleaching process, so it is ideal to remove
oxygen as much as possible from the sample. Using glycerol or using enzymatic systems can help
remove oxygen from the system. There are a lot of compounds that can be added to reduce the
bleaching effect.
41
4.7 X-Ray Diffraction (XRD)
The XRD can analyze thin film and powder samples.63 It can identify thin film materials,
detect defects, analyze crystal structures, etc.64 The XRD consist of a source made of tungsten
filament, which emits electrons.65 The applied voltage produces an electric field, and it accelerates
the electrons.65 The electrons are directed towards the x-ray target material such as copper.66 The
electrons collide the target’s atomic structure, causing secondary electrons to be removed from the
electron shell, and leaves holes in the electron shell.65 This unstable state causes electrons from
higher energies to occupy the lower energy shells, and it leads to releasing energy in the form of
x-rays.65 After, the x-rays travel to the primary optics, which contain solar slits and divergent slits.
The slits provide better resolution.65 Next, the beam travels to the secondary optics as shown in
Figure 16, where it receives the deflected rays.65 The monochromator filters the x-rays, and the
The XRD can perform its function by using Bragg’s equation, which helps calculate the
distance, d, between the layers of atoms or the scattering angle, 𝜃, of x-rays after it hits the crystal
lattice as seen in Figure 17. Equation 4.7.1, where 𝜆 is the wavelength of the x-ray.66
42
2dsin𝜃 = n𝜆. (4.7.1)
Circular Dichroism is an absorption spectroscopy method that relies on the method of right
and left circularly polarized light absorption by the sample.67 It is used to examine biological
molecules.68 The broad majority of biological molecules are chiral.69 For instance, 19 out of 20
common amino acids that form proteins are chiral, as well as other higher structures of proteins
such as RNA and DNA.68 The Circular Dichroism spectrum of a protein, such as DNA, provides
a specific dichroic signature, and it can highlight the structural elements, as well as follow the
helix and 𝛽 sheet.69 A primary application is in the analysis of secondary structure or conformation
of macromolecules.69 Secondary structure is only a small portion of the capabilities of the circular
dichroism.71 Circular Dichroism can aid in observing the interaction between the secondary
structure and the environmental conditions or the interaction with other molecules, regardless of
if secondary structures are sensitive to temperature, pH or the environment.68 For example, it can
compare different macromolecules under different conditions, and it can provide the structure
43
analysis and can be used to verify if a protein is correctly folded.67 In addition, circular dichroism
can derive thermodynamic, kinetic and structural components of the macromolecules.68 The
benefit of using circular dichroism is that the recording time can be done in minutes.70
There are two types of polarized light: linear and circular polarized light (Figure 18).69
Linear polarized light occurs when the electric field vector oscillates in only one plane and in one
direction. It is polarized because all the other oscillations are cancelled.70 Meanwhile, circularly
polarized light occurs when the direction of the electric field vector rotates about its propagation
direction while the vector retains constant magnitude.69 Depending on the rotation, it can be
clockwise or counterclockwise, and they are referred to left-hand circular polarized or right-hand
circular polarized light.70 Circular polarized light consists of both left and right circularly polarized
light.69 When the sample absorbs both left and right circular polarized light, information about the
Figure 18: Unpolarized light with Circular and Linear Polarized Light
Circular Dichroism consist of a light source, a filter, a polarizer, a quarter phase plate, a
sample chamber and a detector.72 The light source emits electromagnetic radiation. The
44
electromagnetic radiation contains both an electric field and magnetic field, and both fields are
perpendicular to both each other and the propagation direction.69 The light will pass through a
filter wheel to form a monochromatic light of a single wavelength.67 After, it will pass through a
polarizer to obtain a linear polarized monochromatic light.73 When the light passes through the
PEM, the light becomes a circular polarized light, and it passes through the sample.67 An
appropriate plate will transform the linear polarized light into circular polarized light.67 The sample
absorbs the light and then the transmitted light passes through the detector.72 As the photon beam
passes through the sample, the sample is changing this polarization pattern and it is detected
(Figure 19).72 Circular dichroism is the difference in the spin angular momentum state of the
photon.
The sample is optically active, and it is absorbing circular polarized light.67 This can be
extended to the Beer-Lambert Law, where the differential absorbance is going to be proportional
equation 4.8.1.71 The difference in polarization status calculated the difference in absorption.69
The difference in absorbance gives insight about the secondary structure.68 The epsilon terms are
45
the molar coefficient for the left circular polarization, ∈V , and right circular polarization light, ∈W .
The molar coefficient is also known as molar circular dichroism, and it measures the dichroism of
a particular sample, which is a function of the wavelength.73 Therefore, the light that will be used
for detecting the sample is of great importance.72 Meanwhile, C is the molar concentration, and l
The limitations of using the circular dichroism spectrophotometer are determined by the
signal-to-noise ratio, which is limited by the photon shot noise.68 The contributing factors to the
Based on equation 4.8.2, there are three methods to improve the signal-to-noise. One method is to
increase the intensity of the incident linearly polarized light.68 Another method is to increase the
amount of time collecting data points. Also, a third option is to increase the quantum efficiency of
the detector.
46
Results
The CQDs in this project utilizes fullerene (C60) as the carbon source mixed with lithium
borohydride (LiBH4) dissolved in tetrahydrofuran (THF) as the solvent in a round bottom flask in
a glovebox was stirred for 3hrs. The solvent is then removed under vacuum to produce a brownish
black powder labeled as prepared material. Afterward, the sample is annealed at 300℃ for 60
minutes resulting in a carbon quantum dot precursor with a black color appearance. The CQD
precursor, with no passivation shows no florescence when exposed to a UV light source. However,
once it is passivated in air, the CQD precursor had a reddish-brown color and showed fluorescence
100
80
60
T%
40
20
Annealed sample
After air exposure
0
4000 3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500
-1
Wavenumber (cm )
The FTIR results seen in Figure 20 showed without air passivation, oxidation doesn’t
exist. A board alcohol (-OH) peak from 3200-3400cm-1. We also see a very strong board
carboxylic acid (-COOH) peak at 2700-3300 cm-1. Aromatic rings appear around 1600cm-1 and
47
1430-1500 cm-1 and can be weak to strong as in Figure 17. There is a carbonyl (C=O) group
Excite @
260
200000 280
300
320
340
150000 360
Intensity
380
400
420
440
100000 460
480
500
520
540
50000 560
0
300 400 500 600 700 800
Wavelength (nm)
map on Figure 21, the highest excitation wavelength occurred at 500 nm.
1.2
> 200 nm Stokes Shift
1.0
Intensity (a.u)
0.8
0.6
Ex. Em.
0.4
0.2
0.0
300 400 500 600 700 800
Wavelength (nm)
48
The excitation and emission spectra for the CQDs is shown in Figure 22, where the
excitation was fixed 520nm and the emission was fixed at 300nm.
35000
Fluorescence Intensity
30000
25000
20000
Excite at 400 nm
15000 Emission at 515 nm
10000
5000
0
0 100 200 300 400
Time (s)
Photostability studies were also tested on the CQDs for potential fluorescence dyes. The
emission intensity of the CQD at 151 nm remains constant for 400 s when excited at 400 nm. If
photo bleaching of the CQD is observed, a gradual decrease in the emission intensity over time
would occur. Photo bleaching is commonly observed in many fluorescence microscopy dyes.
The synthesis of doped 70:30 LiBH4-C60 CQDs was similar to the prior method with a
minor change. The fullerene was mixed with lithium borohydride and gadolinium chloride
dissolved in tetrahydrofuran in a round bottom flask inside an inert glovebox and was stirred for
3hrs. The solvent is then removed under heat and vacuum to produce a brownish black powder
labeled as prepared material. Then, the as prepared material is annealed. The temperature profile
is a ramp to 300℃ over 90 minutes followed by soak at 300℃ for 60 minutes. The resulting carbon
quantum dot precursor had a black color. A schematic of the overall synthesis is seen in Scheme
3.
49
homogenize
anneal
Gd-CQD
GdCl3 + LiBH4
The CQD precursor, with no passivation state shows no florescence when exposed to a UV
light source. However, it is passivated by air exposure, the CQD precursor had a reddish-brown
120000
Excite @ (nm)
270
100000 290
310
330
80000 350
Intensity
370
390
410
60000 430
450
470
40000 490
20000
0
300 400 500 600 700 800
Wavelength (nm)
Figure 24 shows the emission map of the Gd doped CQDs and is similar to that of the base
CQDs.
50
GdCl3
%T
Gd:CQD oxidized
-OH
C=O bend
-OH -BH
C=C
stretch stretch Ar
Figure 25 shows five different spectra. The pure GdCl3 shows no well-defined peaks. The
annealed CQD and the Gd doped CQD samples are very similar. There is a -BH bend at 1000-
1500 cm-1 and a -BH stretch 2300 cm-1. The CQD oxidized sample shows -OH stretch at 3000-
3600 cm-1, -BH stretch reduced peak at 2300 cm-1, C=O peak at 1618 cm-1, Ar C=C peak at 1427
cm-1 and an -OH bend at 975.8 cm-1. The Gd doped CQD oxidized sample shows a reduced -OH
stretch peak at 3000-3600 cm-1, -BH stretch sharp peak at 2300 cm-1, C=O peak at 1618 cm-1, Ar
C=C peak is slight shifted at 1450 cm-1 and an -OH bend is also slightly shifted and slightly
broadened at 976 cm-1 The slight differences between the CQD and the Gd doped CQD in the
oxidized state show slight differences in the –OH stretch and bending regions. However, further
studies are need to determine if the slight differences are due to the incorporation of Gd into the
CQDs.
51
Annealed GdCl3 -LiBH4 -C60
! !! ! ^ ^ As prep GdCl3-LiBH4-C60
! ! ! ^! !
!! ^
#
! !
*! ! Hand mix GdCl3-LiBH4-C60
#
# * ! *
*! !! * ! !*!
# ! !
* !# *
# * * * * ** **
*
*
* GdCl3
*
* * * * *
* * * * ** * *
10 20 30 40 50 60
Degrees (2q)
Figure 26 shows four different spectra. The GdCl3 spectra shown in black was used to
compare all Gd containing CQDs and shows all the GdCl3 peaks (*). The hand mixed shown in
red shows a mixture of all three compounds (GdCl3, LiBH4 and C60) mixed together and shows
the peaks pertaining to, LiBH4 (!) and C60 (#). The as prep GdCl3 doped CQDs is shown in blue
and clearly shows the formation of LiCl (^) and LiBH4 peaks. The annealed Gd doped CQDs
shown in purple tells us that we formed a solid solution since all the LiCl peaks disappear and only
by EDC/NHS coupling.
52
Scheme 4: Synthesis Pathway of Chiral Functional CQDs
The overall synthesis pathway summary of functionalizing our CQDs is shown in scheme
4. 10.02mg CQDs made in section 5.1 was placed in a vial to passivate for 24hrs. 9.0mg of water,
(N-hydroxysuccinimide) was added to the vial and mixed for 2 hours shown in Scheme 5.
With the addition of EDC/NHS precursor, 100mg L-Trp was slowly added to the reaction
mixture and left stirring for 24hrs as shown in scheme 6. Setup a 24-hour dialysis. We removed
53
Scheme 6: Tryptophan insertion mechanism
The 10.05mg CQDs made in section 5.1 was placed in a vial to passivate for 24hrs. 9.0mg
100mg NHS (N-hydroxysuccinimide) was added to the vial and mixed for 2 hours. Added 100mg
D-Trp slowly to the reaction mixture and left stirring for 24hrs. After a 24-hour dialysis, the
for CQDs. Lawsone was mixed with potassium periodate and ethanol to undergo a solvothermal
54
reaction at different times (1, 12 and 24 hours) to yield lawsone derived CQDs as shown in scheme
5.
30000
Excite @ Excite @
4000 350 nm 350 nm
375 nm 25000 375 nm
425 nm 425 nm
Intensity
3000 20000
Intensity
15000
2000
10000
1000
5000
0 0
300 400 500 600 700 800 300 400 500 600 700 800
Figure 27: 0 Hour Emission Spectra Figure 28: 1 Hour Emission Spectra
Figure 27 shows that pure lawsone (0 hour) has only minor, low intensity emission peaks
when compared to the hydrothermal treated samples. The sharp emission peaks in the spectrum
that change wavelength based on the excitation wavelength, are due to Raman scattering of the
solvent and not due to the emission from lawsone. The sharp Raman scattering peaks are attributed
to ethanol and possibly water and its shifts as the excitation wavelength is changed. Raman
scattering is typically observed when the sample shows weak emission. Figure 28 shows a big
significance compared to Figure 27. The emission intensity increases upon hydrothermal
treatment with the formation of a peak at 400 nm and two additional peaks at 525 nm 575 nm.
This indicates the possible formation of a larger organic polymeric structure such as a CQD.
55
35000
Excite @ Excite @
350 nm 160000 350 nm
30000
375 nm 375 nm
425 nm 425 nm
25000
Intensity
120000
Intensity
20000
15000 80000
10000
40000
5000
0 0
300 400 500 600 700 800 300 400 500 600 700 800
Figure 29: 12 Hour Emission Spectra Figure 30: 24 Hour Emission Spectra
As hydrothermal time increases to 12 hours, the overall intensity of the emission peaks increase
and the 525 and 575 nm peaks become more intense relative to the 400 nm peak. Raman scattering
is not observed due to strong emission from the sample. 24 hours of hydrothermal treatment is
shown in Figure 30. The intensity of the emission further increases, however, the well-defined
peaks at 400, 525, and 575 nm are broadened. This indicates a collapse or possible destruction of
the structure of the polymeric CQD material during the process. Further investigation is needed
100000
Lawsone
1 hr
80000 12 hr
24 hr
Intensity
60000
40000
20000
0
300 400 500 600 700 800
Wavelength (nm)
Figure 31: 375 nm excitation spectra
56
Figure 31, shows the emission spectrum at a fixed excitation wavelength of 375 nm for the
different hydrothermal treatments. There is no significant emission at the zero-hour sample (pure
Lawsone). As the hydrothermal treatment time is increased, the overall intensity of the emission
resulting from the lawsone derived CQDs increases. This clearly indicates that hydrothermal
treatment time has a major influence on the Lawsone derived CQDs. Further studies are needed
to understand the anatomy and mechanism of the CQDs formed from lawsone
Biochemical evidence indicates that MTT is mainly reduced in the cytoplasm by NADH
plasma membrane77. Measurement of the absorbance of formazan via 96-well plate assay was
proposed for assessing the effects of CQDs inhibition on the cell mechanism cytotoxicity in cancer
cells. A way to measure cell toxicity is by fluorescence plate reader using a 96 well plate reader.
Once the absorbance was collected at two distinct wavelengths shown in Figure 32, the
57
Most of the data were done on independent triplicate runs except for pure Gd. All the MTT assay
analysis were done Prism 9 software to do plots and perform statistics. Dunnett’s multiple
comparison 1-way ANOVA test was performed for all the data collections.
Dialyzed CQDs
ns ns
ns
150
ns
150
ns
100
% Viability
100
% Viability
50
50
0 0
Control 50ug/mL 200ug/mL 500ug/mL Control 50ug/mL 200ug/mL 500ug/mL
Concentration CQDs (ug/mL) Concentration CQDs (ug/mL)
Figure 33: Comparison to the Control Figure 34: Comparison to the lowest
concentration (50𝜇g/mL)
Two different comparisons for the dialyzed CQDs were performed. In Figure 33, the
control was compared to the different concentrations (50𝜇g/mL, 200𝜇g/mL, & 500𝜇g/mL). As
determined by Dunnett’s multiple comparison 1-way ANOVA test, dialyzed CQDs did not
significantly impact cell viability of the cancer cells based on the MTT assays. In Figure 34, the
cell viability is compared to the samples that contained the lowest concentration of CQDs (50
𝜇g/mL)
58
Undialyzed CQDs
ns ✱
200
✱✱ ✱✱✱✱
200
ns 150
% Viability
150
% Viability
100
100
50
50
0
0 Control 50ug/mL 200ug/mL 500ug/mL
Control 50ug/mL 200ug/mL 500ug/mL
Concentration CQDs (ug/mL)
Concentration CQDs (ug/mL)
Figure 35: Comparison to the Control Figure 36: Comparison to the lowest
concentration (50𝜇g/mL)
In Figure 35, once again, the control was compared to the different concentrations
ANOVA test, dialyzed CQDs did not affect the viability of the cancer cells. However, there was
a significant different between the control and the 200𝜇g/mL with a p-value = 0.003. We also did
a comparison based on concentrations only Figure 36 and compared it to the lowest concentration
and once again there was a large significant between the 200𝜇g/mL verses the 50𝜇g/mL with a p-
value < 0.0001 and a slight significant between 500𝜇g/mL vs the control with a p-value =0.0135.
Regardless of these results, ultimately the cancer cells did not die since it clear shows more than
150
% Viability
100
100
50 50
0 0
Control 50ug/mL 200ug/mL 500ug/mL Control 50ug/mL 200ug/mL 500ug/mL
Concentration Gd-CQDs (ug/mL) Concentration Gd-CQDs (ug/mL)
Figure 37: Comparison to the Control Figure 38: Comparison to the lowest
concentration (50𝜇g/mL)
59
In Figure 37, the control was compared to the different concentrations (50𝜇g/mL,
200𝜇g/mL, & 500𝜇g/mL). Based on the data, Gd-doped CQDs did not affect cell viability. We
also did a comparison based on concentrations only and compared it to the lowest concentration
ns 150 ns
150 ns
100
% Viability
100
% Viability
50
50
0 0
Control 50ug/mL 200ug/mL 500ug/mL Control 50ug/mL 200ug/mL 500ug/mL
Concentration Gd (ug/mL) Concentration Gd (ug/mL)
Figure 39: Pure Gd MTT assay comparison Figure 40: Pure Gd MTT assay comparison
to control to lowest concentration (50𝜇g/mL)
The Gd source (GdCl3) was also evaluated by MTT assay to make a clear indication
whether gadolinium was inside the CQD or on the surface. In Figure 39, the control was compared
to the different concentrations (50𝜇g/mL, 200𝜇g/mL, & 500𝜇g/mL). Based on the data, there is a
significant difference on the highest concentration dosage compared to the control showing cell
death with a p-value = 0.001. A comparison amongst the concentrations only and compared it to
the lowest concentration and once again, there was a huge significance different on the highest
Previous studies have done CQDs images and showed promising results. The C60 based
CQDs were then evaluated as fluorescence microscopy dyes with the MDA-MB-231 cancer cell
line.
60
5.3.1 LiBH4-C60 CQDs
Negative
Control
MDA-MB-231
Cells with
CQDs
From the results shown on Table 1, we saw promising results with our CQDs and MDA-
MB-231 cells lines when they were in the trypsinized state. The negative control looked like
photobleaching occurred or the light from the monitor was a disturbing factor since the room
wasn’t completely dark. However, the cells with CQDs, we clearly saw a sharp fluorescence where
the CQDs were localized. The big question raised if the cells were on the surface or inside the
membrane. To answer the question, a more advanced fluorescence microscope was utilized.
61
Table 2: New Fluorescence Microscope Images
Negative
Control
(10X)
MDA-MB-231
Cells with
CQDs
(10X)
MDA-MB-231
Cells with
CQDs
(100X)
From Table 2, the advanced fluorescence microscope showed very promising results for
the cancer cells in their nature (not trypsinized) state. We plated the cells in an 8 well microscope
slide. After 15 hours, we placed the slide on the microscope stage. We clearly saw the negative
control had no fluorescence. Conversely, cells with CQDs showed very sharped fluorescence with
the CQDs inside the cells. We ran Z-stack to verified if the cells were on the surface or inside the
membrane.
From Table 3, three different foci planes were selected from the z-stack and shows that the
CQDs were eventually inside the cell membrane. The first row shows the fluorescence of the cells
with CQDs blurry and out of focus with the focal plane outside of the cell. The second row shows
a focal plane that is inside the cell, but not at the exact focal plane where the CQDs are located
inside the cell. This is the cause of the increase in emission intensity in the different channels.
The last row is a focal plane that is inside the cell where the CQDs are localized with significantly
enhanced resolution. This indicates that the CQDs are localized inside the cells and not on the
surface.
62
Table 3: MDA-MB-231 Cells with three different focal planes
Chiral quantum dots are a class of nanomaterials with chiral and fluorescence properties
and have been gaining lots of interest due to its fluorescence properties and cell regulation. After
the synthesis of L/D-Trp functionalized CQDs, circular dichroism and FTIR measurements were
performed.
8
L-Trp
L-Trp:CD
6 D-Trp
D-Trp:CD
4
CD (mDeg)
-2
-4
200 210 220 230 240 250 260
Wavelength (nm)
Figure 41: Chiroptical properties of tryptophan enantiomers and their respective chiral CQDs
Based on our results seen in Figure 41, L- and D- Trp conjugated CQDs produced the
corresponding mirror image CD signature. The CD spectra of free L- and D- Trp showed, as
63
expected, near symmetrical spectra with a positive and negative effect, respectively, at 210-230
nm. The sign of CD signature from L-/D- Trp CQDs were similar to their parent L-/D- Trp,
respectively, with a slight shift of the peak maxima at 221 nm and minima at 223 nm.
L-TRP
Absorbance
L-TRP:CD
CD
The FTIR of the sample is shown in Figure 42. Based on the results, there is a sharp
primary amine peak at 3400cm-1 and a -C=O stretch at between 1500-1700 cm-1 for the pure
tryptophan sample. However, as we observe the functionalized L-Trp CQD, the primary amine is
weak and merges with a weak broad -OH hump. The carbonyl (-C=O) stretch broadens between
1500-1700cm-1 and an amide (-CN) stretch is present at 1450cm-1. When compared to the base
CQD, there is a large broad (-OH) with (-COOH) -peaks between 3300-3700cm-1. We believed
Initially, T1 were done on NMR. However, we wanted to replicate the runs to confirm if
64
5.5.1 LiBH4-C60-CQDs
Previous results showed CQDs had promising results as seen in Figure 43. The longitudinal
relaxation (r1) of the CQDs prepared under optimal conditions was measured at 3.6s to 0.047s.
1 / T1 (s-1)
0.025 5.37634409 0.186 15
0.05 8 0.125
0.075 14.5485232 0.047 10
CQD
y = 26.6x - 0.99
Table 6: Gadoderitol NMR Results
5 Gadaderitol
y = 1.5x + 0.32
concentration [mg/mL] 1/T1 (s-1 ) T1 (s)
0 0.28 3.61 0
0.11 0.61 1.65
0.22 0.66 1.51 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2
0.34 0.69 1.44 Concentration (mg / mL)
0.45 0.87 1.15
0.56 1.33 0.75 Figure 43: NMR Initial CQD Results
0.67 1.28 0.78
Commercially available MRI agent, Gadoderitol, was tested to illustrate the MRI
performance of our CQDs. The r1 relaxivity shows a superior enhancement of relaxation as the
concentration of CQD increased in Figure 43. We also ran MRI to confirm if our CQDs data was
real.
Both T1 and T2 measurements were taken on the MRI. Unfortunately, we did not see an effect
on the T1 or T2 for the base CQD (Gd free). We also didn’t see the results compatible with the
65
5.5.2 LiBH4-C60-GdCl3 CQDs
We also did a previous NMR on Gd-CQDs and showed promising results as seen in figure
34. The longitudinal (r1) of the Gd-CQDs prepared under optimal conditions was measured at
1.6
-1
concentration [mg/mL] 1/T1 (s ) T1 (s) 1.4
1.2
1/T1 (s-1)
1 y = 4.4688x + 0.1628
R² = 0.9979
0.22 0.66 1.51 0.8
0.6
0.34 0.69 1.44 0.4
0
0.56 1.33 0.75 0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3 0.35
Gd3+ [mg/mL]
0.67 1.28 0.78
Figure 44: Initial Gd NMR Results
From the data on table 8 and Figure 44, the r1 relaxivity shows a superior enhancement of
relaxation as the concentration of Gd3+ increased. We also ran MRI to confirm if the Gd3+ data
was consistent.
Both T1 and T2 measurements were taken on the MRI and showed a clear decreased in the
66
Bioimaging Implications and Conclusion
The aim of this thesis was to functionalize our CQD for bimodal purposes, particularly for
fluorescence microscopy and as MRI contrast agents. We were able to observe the
photoluminescent properties and stabilize our CQDs for potential fluorescence microscopy dyes.
We were also able to observe our CQDs are inside the MDA-MB-231 cancer cells. Fluorescence
microscopy suggest that the CQDs are localized in the nucleus of the cell, however, further studies
We performed cell viability studies using MTT assay and found that our CQDs and Gd-
CQDs did not affect cell viability. However, pure Gd showed cell death at the highest
concentration (500𝜇g/mL). This demonstrated that the Gd was encapsulated in the CQD and is
close to the surface to shorten T1 and T2. To guarantee our hypothesis, XPS would need to be
performed to conclude this thesis and determine the chemical environment around the Gd.
We were successful in doping our CQDs with Gd3+. We conducted NMR studies for MRI
CQDs compared to the commercially available MRI contrasting agent, Gadoderitol. Conversely,
we also ran trials via a benchtop MRI and found no significance in enhancement. We also
performed NMR studies for MRI purposes for the Gd-CQDs and once again found enhancements
on r1. We also ran our trials via MRI and once again found enhancements on T1 and T2.
We can also functionalization our CQDs by adding chiral groups via cross-coupling
reactions using EDC/NHS. This thesis shows one amino acid (tryptophan), but we can attach other
amino acids (e.g., proline, cysteine, histidine, etc.) to the CQD. We were successfully able to
conduct circular dichroism and confirmed they were similar to the parent signature. One other
67
Finally, we can also functionalize our CQDs using a sustainable carbon source. This thesis
shows Lawsone (henna plant), which is a natural sustainable carbon source for their production,
68
References
1. Lakowicz, J. R., Principles of Fluorescence Spectroscopy. 3 ed.; Springer: 2006.
2. Sun, Y.-P.; Zhou, B.; Lin, Y.; Wang, W.; Fernando, K. A. S.; Pathak, P.; Meziani, M. J.; Harruff, B. A.;
Wang, X.; Wang, H.; Luo, P. G.; Yang, H.; Kose, M. E.; Chen, B.; Veca, L. M.; Xie, S.-Y., Quantum-Sized
Carbon Dots for Bright and Colorful Photoluminescence. Journal of American Chemical Society: 2006;
Vol. 128, pp 7756-7757.
3. Wang, Y.; Hu, A., Carbon Quantum Dots: Synthesis, Properties and Applications. Journal of
Materials Chemistry C: 2014; Vol. 2, pp 6921-6939.
4. Wang, S.; Cole, I. S.; Zhao, D.; Li, Q., Dual Roles of Functional Groups in the Photoluminescence
of Graphene Quantum Dots. Nanoscale: 2016; Vol. 8, pp 7449-7458.
5. Arnold A Gaertner, H. W. Y. a. T. A. G., Dispersive Methods. In Spectrophotometry: Accurate
Measurement of Optical Properties of Materials, Elsevier Inc.: United Kingdom, 2014; Vol. 46, p 29.
6. Fowles, G. R., Introduction to modern optics. 2nd ed.; Dover Publications Inc.: New York, 1989.
7. Harris, D. C., Quantitative Chemical Analysis. W. H. Freeman and Co.: New York, 2015.
8. Wagner, A. M.; Knipe, J. M.; Orive, G.; Peppas, N. A., Quantum Dots in Biomedical Applications.
Acta Biomaterialia: 2019; Vol. 94, pp 44-63.
9. Bhagyaraj, S. M.; Oluwafemi, O. S.; Kalarikkal, N.; Thomas, S., Applications of
Nanomaterials: Advances and Key Technologies. Woodhead Publishing: Duxford, United Kingdom, UK,
2018.
10. Luo, P. G.; Sahu, S.; Yang, S.-T.; Sonkar, S. K.; Wang, J.; Wang, H.; Lecroy, G. E.; Cao, L.; Sun, Y.-P.,
Carbon "Quantum" Dots for Optional Bioimaging. Journal of Material Chemistry B: 2013; Vol. 1, pp 2116-
2117.
11. Zhong, X.; Han, M.; Dong, Z.; White, T. J.; Knoll, W., Composition-Tunable ZnxCd1-XSe
Nanocrystals with High Luminescence and Stability. Journal of the American Chemical Society: 2003; Vol.
125, pp 8589-8594.
12. Derfus, A. M.; Chan, W. C.; Bhatia, S. N., Probing the Cytotoxicity of Semiconductor Quantum
Dots. Nano Letters: 2004; Vol. 4, pp 11-18.
13. Limaye, D. A.; Shaikh, Z. A., Cytotoxicity of Cadmium and Characteristics of Its Transport in
Cardiomyocytes. Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology: 1999; Vol. 154, pp 59-66.
14. Rikans, L. E.; Yamono, T., Mechanisms of Cadmium-Mediated Acute Hepatotoxicity. Journal of
Biochemical and Molecular Toxicology: 2000; Vol. 14, pp 110-117.
15. Bhoite-Solomon, V.; Kessler-Icekson, G.; Shaklai, N., Myocyte Injury by Hemin. In Vitro Cellular &
Developmental Biology-Aminal: 1993; Vol. 29, pp 636-642.
16. Hinkle, P. M.; Shanshala, E. D.; Nelson, E. J., Measurement of Intracellular Cadmium with
Fluorescent Dyes. Further Evidence for the Role of Calcium Channels in Cadmium Uptake. Journal of
Biological Chemistry: 1992; Vol. 1992, pp 25553-25559.
17. Blazka, M. E.; Shaikh, Z. A., Differences in Cadmium and Mercury Uptakes by Hepatocytes: Role
of Calcium Channels. Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology: 1991; Vol. 110, pp 355-363.
18. Blazka, M. E.; Yoshida, M.; Shaikh, Z. A., A Comparison of Cadmium, Mercury and Calcium
Accumulations by Isolated Hepatocrytes of the Small Skate (Raja Erinacea) and Rat. Comparative
Biochemistry and Physiology Part C: Comparative Pharmacology: 1992; Vol. 101, pp 631-639.
19. Endo, T.; Kimura, O.; Sakata, M., Effects of Zinc and Copper on Uptake of Cadmium by LLC-PK1
Cells. Biological and Pharmaceutical Bulletin: 1996; Vol. 19, pp 944-948.
20. Luo, P. G.; Sahu, S.; Yang, S.-T.; Sonkar, S. K.; Wang, J.; Wang, H.; Lecroy, G. E.; Cao, L.; Sun, Y.-P.,
Quantum Dots for Optical Bioimaging. Journal of Materials Chemistry B: 2013; Vol. 1, pp 2116-2117.
69
21. Cayuela, A.; Soriano, M. L.; Carrillo-Carrión, C.; Valcárcel, M., Semiconductor and Carbon-Based
Fluorescent Nanodots: the Need for Consistency. Chemical Communications: 2016; Vol. 52, pp 1311-
1326.
22. Jelinek, R., Carbon Quantum Dots: Synthesis, Properties and Applications. Springer: Switzerland,
2017.
23. Li, H.; He, X.; Kang, Z.; Huang, H.; Liu, Y.; Liu, J.; Lian, S.; Tsang, C.; Yang, X. L., S, Water-Soluble
Fluorescent Carbon Quantum Dots and Photocatalyst Design. Angewandte Chemie: 2010; Vol. 122, pp
4532-4536.
24. Tang, L.; Ji, R.; Cao, X.; Lin, J.; Jiang, H.; Li, X.; Teng, K.; Luk, C.; Zeng, S.; Hao, J.; Lau, S., Deep
Ultraviolet Photoluminescence of Water-Soluble Self-Passivated Graphene Quantum Dots. ACS Nano:
2012; Vol. 6, pp 5102-5110.
25. Kurian, J.; Mathew, M. J., Structural, optical and magnetic studies of CuFe2)4, MgFe2O4 and
ZnFe2O4 nanoparticles prepared by hydrothermal/solvothermal method. Journal of Magnetism and
Magnetic Materials: 2018; Vol. 451, pp 121-130.
26. Zhu, Z.; Lin, X.; Wu, L.; Zhao, C.; Li, S.; Liu, A.; Lin, X.; Lin, L., Nitrogen-Doped Carbon Dots as a
Ratiometric Fluorescent Probe for Determination of the Activity of Acid Phosphatase, for Inhibitor
Screening, and for Intracellular Imaging. Microchimica Acta: 2019; Vol. 186, p 558.
27. Innocenzi, P.; Stagi, L., Carbon-Based Antiviral Nanomaterials: Graphene, C-Dots, and Fullerenes.
A Perspective. Chemical Science: 2020; Vol. 11, pp 6606-6622.
28. Chen, L.; Hernandez, Y.; Feng, X.; Müllen, K., Naongraphene and Graphene Nanoribbons to
Graphene Sheets: Chemical Synthesis. Angewandte Chemie International Edition: 2012; Vol. 51, pp
7640-7654.
29. Georgakilas, V.; Perman, J. A.; Tusen, J.; Zboril, R., Broad Family of Carbon Nanoallotropes:
Classification, Chemistry, and Applications of Fullerenes, Carbon Dots, Nanotubes, Graphene,
Nanodiamonds, and Combined Superstructures. Chemical Reviews: 2015; Vol. 115, pp 4744-4822.
30. Luo, P. G.; Yang, F.; Yang, S.-T.; Sonkar, S. K.; Yang, L.; Broglie, J. J.; Liu, Y.; Sun, Y.-P., Carbon-
Based Quantum Dots for Fluorescence Imaging of Cells and Tissues. RSC Advances: 2014; Vol. 4, p
10791.
31. Lalwani, G.; Sitharaman, B., Multifunctional Fullerene and Metallofullerene Based
Nanobiomaterials. Nano LIFE: 2013; Vol. 3, p 1342003.
32. Zhou, Y.; Li, J.; Ma, H.; Zhen, M.; Guo, J.; Wang, L.; Jiang, L.; Shu, C.; Wang, C., Biocompatible
[60]/[70] Fullerenols: Potent Defense against Oxidative Injury Induced by Reduplicative Chemotherapy.
ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces: 2017; Vol. 9, pp 35539-35547.
33. Afreen, S.; Muthoosamy, K.; Manickam, S.; Hashim, U., Functionalized Fullerene (C60) as a
Potential Nanomediator in the Fabrication of Highly Sensitive Biosensors. Biosensors and Bioelectronics:
2015; Vol. 63, pp 354-364.
34. Zidan, R.; Teprovich, J. A.; Washington, A. L., Carbon Quantum Dots and a Method of Making the
Same. 2017.
35. Chen, H.; Wang, G. D.; Tang, W.; Todd, T.; Zhen, Z.; Tsang, C.; Hekmatyar, K.; Cowger, T.;
Hubbard, R. B.; Zhang, W.; Stickney, J.; Shen, B.; Xie, J., Gd-Encapsulated Carbonaceous Dots with
Efficient Renal Clearance for Magnetic Resonance Imaging. Advanced Materials: 2014; Vol. 26, pp 6761-
6766.
36. Bourlinos, A. B.; Bakandritsos, A.; Kouloumpis, A.; Gournis, D.; Krysmann, M.; Giannelis, E. P.;
Polakova, K.; Safarova, K.; Hola, K.; Zboril, R., Gd(III)-doped carbon dots as a dual fluorescent-MRI probe.
Journal of Material Chemistry: 2012; Vol. 22, p 23327.
37. Tóth, É.; Bolskar, R. D.; Borel, A.; González, G.; Helm, L.; Merbach, A. E.; Sitharaman, B.; Wilson,
L. J., Water-Soluble Gadofullerenes: Toward High-Relativity, Ph-Responsive MRI Contrast Agents. Journal
of the American Chemical: 2005; Vol. 127, pp 799-805.
70
38. Ma, W.; Xu, L.; Moura, A.; Wu, X.; Kuang, H.; Xu, C.; Kotov, N., Chiral Inorganic Nanostructures.
Chemical Review: 2017; Vol. 117, pp 8041-8093.
39. Ru, Y.; Ai, L.; Jia, T.; Liu, X.; Lu, S.; Tang, Z.; Yang, B., Recent advances in chiral carbonized
polymer dots: From synthesis and properties to applications. Nano Today: 2020; Vol. 34, p 100953.
40. Wei, Y.; Chen, L.; Wang, J.; Liu, X.; Yang, Y.; Yu, S., Investigation on the Chirality Mechanism of
Chiral Carbon Quantum Dots Derived from Tryptophan. RSC Advances: 2019; Vol. 9, pp 3208-3214.
41. Li, F.; Li, Y.; Yang, X.; Han, X.; Jiao, Y.; Wei, T.; Yang, D.; Xu, H.; Nie, G., Highly Fluorescent Chiral
N-S-Doped Carbon Dots from Cysteine: Affecting Cellular Energy Metabolism. Angewandte Chemie
International Edition: 2018; Vol. 57, pp 2377-2382.
42. Kang, Z.; Lee, S.-T., Carbon Dots: Advances in Nanocarbon Applications. Nanoscale: 2019; Vol.
11, pp 19214-19224.
43. Wan, X.; Li, S.; Zhuang, L.; J., T., L-Tryptophan-capped carbon quantum dots for the sensitive and
selective fluorescence detection of mercury ion. Journal of Nanoparticle Research: 2016; Vol. 18, p 202.
44. Xavier, M.; Santos, M.; Queiroz, M.; Silva, M.; Goes, A.; De Morais, M., Lawsone, a 2-hydroxy-1,
4-naphthoquinone from Lawsonia inermis (henna), produces mitochondrial dysfunctions and triggers
mitophagy in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Molecular Biology Reports: 2019.
45. Chaudhary, A.; Khurana, J., 2-Hydroxy-1,4-naphthoquinone: A Versatile Synthon in Organic
Synthesis. Current Organic Chemistry: 2016; Vol. 20, pp 1314-1344.
46. Kurtyka, R.; Pokora, W.; Tukaj, Z.; Karcz, W., Effects of jugloneu and lawsone on oxidative stress
in maize coleoptile cells treated with IAA. AoB PLANTS 2016; Vol. 8.
47. Ding, H.; Zhou, X.; Wei, J.; Li, X.; Qin, B.; Chen, X.; Xiong, H., Carbon Dots with Red/near-Infrared
Emissions and Their Intrinsic Merits for Biomedical Applications. Carbon: 2020; Vol. 167, pp 322-344.
48. Yuan, F.; Li, S.; Fan, Z.; Meng, X.; Fan, L.; Yang, S., Shining carbon dots: synthesis and biomedical
and optoelectronic applications. Nano Today: 2016; Vol. 11, pp 565-586.
49. Arcudi, F.; Dordevic, L.; Prato, M., Design, synthesis, and functionalization strategies of tailored
carbon nanodots. Accounts of Chemical Research: 2019; Vol. 52, pp 2070-2079.
50. Lu, S.; Sui, L.; Liu, J.; Zhu, S.; Chen, A.; Jin, M., Near-infrared photoluminescent polymer-carbon
nano dots with two-photon fluorescence. Advanced Materials: 2017; Vol. 15, p 1603443.
51. Cailleau, R.; Olive, M.; Cruciger, Q., Long-term human breast carcinoma cell lines of metastatic
origin: preliminary characterization. In Vitro: 1978; Vol. 14, pp 911-915.
52. Zhou, J.; Zhou, H.; Tang, J.; Deng, S.; Yan, F.; Li, W.; Qu, M., Carbon Dots Doped with
Heteroatoms for Fluorescent Bioimaging: a Review. 2016; Vol. 184, pp 343-368.
53. Holdsworth, S. J.; and Bammer, R., Magnetic Resonance Imaging Techniques: fMRI, DWI, and
PWI. Semin Neurol: 2008; Vol. 28, pp 395-406.
54. Garcia, J.; Liu, S. Z.; and Louie, A. Y., Biological effects of MRI contrasting agents: gadolinium
retention, potential mechanisms and a role for phosphorus. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A: 2017; Vol. 375.
55. Günther, H., NMR Spectroscopy Basic Principles, Concepts, and Applications in Chemistry. 3rd
ed.; Wiley-VCH: 2013.
56. Plewes, D. B.; Kucharczyk, W., Physics of MRI: A Primer. Journal of Magnetic Resonance Imaging:
2012; Vol. 35, pp 1038-1054.
57. Markossian, S.; Sittampalam, G. S.; Grossman, A., Cell Viability Assays. Eli Lilly & Company and
the National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences, 2016.
58. Combs, C. A.; Shroff, H., Fluorescence Microscopy: A Concise Guide to Current Imaging Methods.
Current Protocols in Neuroscience: 2017; Vol. 79.
59. Zhang, J. X. J.; Hoshino, K., Optical Transducers: Optical Molecular Sensing and Spectroscopy.
Molecular Sensors and Nanodevices: 2019; pp 231-309.
60. Dey, A.; Mandal, S.; Bhandari, S.; Pal, C.; Tesur Orasugh, J.; Chattopadhyay, D., Characterization
Methods. Fiber-Reinforced Nanocomposites: Fundamentals and Applications: 2020; pp 7-67.
71
61. Sanderson, M. J.; Smith, I.; Parker, I.; Bootman, M. D., Fluorescence Microscopy. Cold Spring
Harbor Protocols: 2014; Vol. 10.
62. Kumar, P. S.; Pavithra, K. G.; Naushad, M., Characterization Techniques for Nanomaterials.
Nanomaterials for Solar Cell Applications: 2019; pp 97-124.
63. Belvansky, M., Thin Film Deposition for Front End of Line. Handbook of Thin Film Deposition:
2018; Vol. 4, pp 231-268.
64. Kohli, R.; Mittal, K. L., Methods for Assessing Surface Cleanliness. Developments in Surface
Contamination and Cleaning: 2019; Vol. 12, pp 23-105.
65. Alderton, D., X-Ray Diffraction (XRD). Encyclopedia of Geology: 2021; pp 520-531.
66. Patel, J. P.; Parsania, P. H., Characterization, Testing and Reinforcing Materials of Biodegradable
Composites. Biodegradable and Biocompatible Polymer Composites: 2018; pp 55-79.
67. Ranibar, B.; Gill, P., Circular Dichroism Techniques: Biomolecular and Nanostructural Analyses-A
Review. Chemical Biology & Drug Design: 2009; Vol. 74, pp 101-120.
68. Martin, S. R.; Schilstra, M. J., Circular Dichroism and Its Application to the Study of Biomolecules.
Biophysical Tools for Biologists, Volume One: In Vitro Techniques: 2008; pp 263-293.
69. Andrews, S. S.; Tretton, J., Physical Principles of Circular Dichroism. Journal of Chemical
Education: 2020; Vol. 97, pp 4370-4376.
70. Berova, N.; Nakanishi, K.; Woody, R. W., Circular Dichroism: Principles and Applications. Wiley:
New York, 2000.
71. Siligardi, G.; Hussain, R., Circular Dichroism, Applications. Encyclopedia of Spectroscopy and
Spectrometry: 2017.
72. Satozono, H., Measurement of Circular Dichroism Spectra without Control of a Phase Modulator
Using Retardation Domain Analysis. Molecules: 2019; Vol. 24, p 1418.
73. Rodger, A., Circular Dichroism Spectroscopy: Units. Encyclopedia of Biophysics: 2013; pp 316-
317.
74. Gulino, V.; Brighi, M.; Dematteis, E. M.; Murgia, F.; Nervi, C.; Cemy, R.; Baricco, M., Phase
Stability and Fast Ion Conductivity in the Hexagonal LiBH4-LiBr-LiCl Solid Solution. Chemistry of
Materials: 2019; Vol. 31, pp 5133-5144.
75. Berridge, M. V.; Herst, P. M.; Tan, A. S., Tetrazolium Dyes as Tools in Cell Biology: New Insights
into Their Cellular Reduction. Biotechnology Annual Review: 2005; Vol. 11, pp 127-152.
76. Bernas, T.; Dobrucki, J., Mitochondrial and Nonmitochondrial Reduction of MTT: Interaction of
MTT with TMRE, JC-1 and NAO Mitochondrial Fluorescent Probes. Cytometry: 2002; Vol. 47, pp 236-242.
77. Bernas, T.; Dobrucki, J. W., The Role of Plasma Membrane in Bioreduction of Two Tetrazolium
Salts, MTT, and CTC. Archives of Biochemistry and Biophysics: 2000; Vol. 380.
78. Stockert, J. C.; Blázquez-Castro, A.; Cañete, M.; Horobin, R. W.; A., V., MTT Assay for Cell
Viability: Intracellular Localization of the Formazan Product Is in Lipid Droplets. Acta Histochemica: 2012;
Vol. 114, pp 785-796.
72