Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ETHICS - Final Paper
ETHICS - Final Paper
I. Introduction
A. Background and history of teenage plastic surgery in the Philippines
1. What causes them to perform plastic surgeries?
2. How do parents feel about it?
3. How do Filipinos view plastic surgery in the Philippines?
4. Is it common?
B. Morals and teenage plastic surgery
1. Is it morally acceptable to perform such surgery on minors?
II. Body (use theories to support answers)
A. Plastic Surgery on Self Esteem
1. Does it make you virtuous when you alter your appearance as a person?
2. Will the procedure itself, the plastic surgery, boost your confidence as an
individual?
3. If you are the person being operated upon, does it really help you to attain
happiness?
4. Does it really make you improve your moral compass?
5. Does it really make you morally upright when a person undergoes a
procedure?
B. Plastic Surgery as a Business
1. Is it ethical or morally acceptable that surgeons make business/money out
of these procedures?
2. How does the procedure go about with regards to consent with the
teenager?
3. How much do surgeons make from performing such surgeries?
4. What are the common cosmetic surgeries performed on teenagers?
C. Main Theory
III. Conclusion
1. Reconcile A, B, C
2. Overall idea
3. What is the group’s stand, is it morally accepted or not?
Abstract
This paper provides an analysis of teenage plastic surgery being morally acceptable
wherein the purpose of this essay is to explain the prevalence of plastic surgery in
teenagers by providing supporting evidence. For this procedure, the topic got divided into
four parts: (1) Background and history of teenage plastic surgery in the Philippines, (2)
Morals and teenage plastic surgery, (3) Plastic Surgery on Self Esteem, and (4) Plastic
Surgery as a Business. The first topic is about the background and history of teenage plastic
surgery in the Philippines, which determines the cause why people undergo plastic surgery
and whether it is common or not, which is prevalent and wants to increase their
confidence. Next is morals and teenage plastic surgery, which tackles whether performing
such surgery on minors is morally acceptable. Moreover, the third topic is the plastic
surgery on self confidence that uncovers how this boosts the confidence of an individual
and attains happiness. Lastly, plastic surgery as a business was considered to determine
whether the business money acquired by the surgeons is morally acceptable. In this regard,
given the stand, knowing the significance between these Ethics and plastic surgery can
“As I get older - and wiser of course - I appreciate natural beauty in a different way.”
- Kaitlyn Bristowe
Plastic surgery has equipped various individuals from different walks of life to
improve their lifestyle for distinct reasons. Medical Travel Czech (2015) explained that the
first medical literature extends back to ancient Rome, Greece, and perhaps Egypt. Plastic
Surgery can be defined as the practice of restoring or repairing body parts through tissue
transfer, either for medical or cosmetic purposes. The practice is more widely known at
present for its cosmetic and aesthetic implications over being a previous form of
the body such as physical birth defects; cleft lips and palates and ear deformities, whereas
Cosmetic Operations, on the other hand, alter a specified portion of the body with where the
contouring the nose, and removing fat pockets from specific parts of the body.
In the American Society of Plastic Surgeons’s (n.d.) article, it was stated that there is
a difference in motive when interviewing teens and adults on their desire for plastic
surgery: teens consider plastic surgery as a way to fit in and look appealing to friends and
peers. Adults, on the other hand, frequently regard plastic surgery as a method to stand out
from the crowd. Apart from plausible reasons such as for medical reasons; to repair a
physical flaw or to change an area of their body that causes them discomfort. Having said
that, common reasoning and purpose of the practice focus on the desire for a cosmetic
modification because one is unhappy with their visible appearances. Teenagers who
undergo cosmetic procedures such as otoplasty (surgical to pin back protruding ears) or
dermabrasion (a process that can help smooth or cover severe acne scars) often feel more
confident in their outward appearance afterwards. Motivations revolve around the need to
connotations about themselves. The confidence gives an individual a more positive outlook
in life that follows into their mental and social well-being. Clinical Psychological Science
(2013) stated that plastic surgery targets boosting happiness, sense of pleasure, and
self-esteem. It’s been proven that those who underwent surgery were less anxious and
In HealthyChildren’s report (2015), one’s health and well-being rest with the
parents considering that they are minors. As with any other surgery, parental authorization
is required in order to proceed. Plastic surgery has been more popular among teenage
females in recent years with most being influenced by social media. Perfect appearances
greatly impact viewers to develop bleak perceptions toward their outward looks. Some
parents, as well as doctors, also consider that teenagers may lack the maturity to recognize
the dangers and hazards of such medical therapies. Guinness (2018) expounded that
Teenagers accounted for 4% of all cosmetic surgery procedures performed that year. To
add, in a Boston University study published in JAMA Facial Plastic Surgery, social media was
noted to have the strongest influence on the growing number of people seeking plastic
surgery. People strive to obtain a filtered version of themselves due to the developed beauty
standards of society that emphasize symmetrical facial features, pointed noses, and
reasons for surgery is to secure for themselves a suitable and pleasing appearance.
Regardless, plastic surgery performed on teenagers has been on the rise in recent
years. It remains a taboo subject for some who remain to have conservative judgements
about the procedure and this is applicable to the Philippines. Given that it is a traditional
and religious country, Filipino parents feel the need to protect the child’s physical
appearance and refuse to go against nature's will despite the races’ high regard for natural
beauty. In the eyes of God, according to church teachings, the values of kindness and
reason as to why plastic surgery remains unacceptable in Philippine society is for social
reasons such as the rising case of poverty in the country; the goal of putting food on the
table outweighs the pursuit of beauty. However, it contradicts given that Filipinos adore
Main Theory
The researchers believe that happiness obtained from plastic surgery is only
temporary. As part of the principles of Stoicism, there are situations and circumstances
which one has no control over and should not attempt to force their authority over it.
Instead, one should make a distinction between one’s capabilities considering suffering
from the consequences will be part of the choice (Weaver, 2019). Knowing this, the
researchers suggest that teenagers shouldn’t feel the need to perform drastic changes on
themselves to achieve pleasure and happiness. It’s a natural reality they can control but
only to an ethical extent through how they behave and present themselves instead. At the
end of the day, what people look towards would always be one's personal values over
attained since state of mind can always be altered depending upon their way of state of
mind.
Modifications made to one's body make them feel better about themselves, but can
that change their personalities? Aguillo (2015) indicated that plastic surgery affects one's
sole personality based on the kind of bad experiences they encountered due to their
physical appearances. This leads them to the desire to undergo plastic surgery knowing it
will help them feel more confident about themselves and this interrelates to being virtuous.
The Katian’s goodwill believes that one should always be kind to fellow men as these people
come from different walks of life. lt chooses to fulfill its moral responsibility voluntarily, and
Therefore, a person behaving appropriately and properly is a result of virtue and happiness
Condron (2018) mentioned that the media is increasing the promotion of the new
standards of cosmetics, and individuals are joining the beauty industry, trusting their
psychological comfort to the surgeons. Keeping this in mind, people should be aware that
despite plastic surgery providing people a sense of fulfillment, too much of this can impair
inconsistent because some studies have linked dissatisfaction with cosmetic surgical
operations to suicide due to the unrealistic expectations from the patients (Dittman, 2005).
This is where Aristotle’s Golden Mean takes place wherein Aristotle’s Happiness and
Enjoyment welcomes actions that bring forth the individual a sense of happiness or
enjoyment once fulfilling it, and any action that brings agony is not welcome. The lack of
pleasure from the results of the procedure leads to something that is beyond our control;
therefore, these people tend to undergo plastic surgery again until they feel satisfied. In
Maslow’s (n.d.) hierarchy of needs, lower wants are more localized, tangible, and finite,
whereas higher needs' satisfaction is limitless. Higher need satisfaction makes people
happier which can accomplish higher need gratification therefore diverting it to the
to how one understands ‘social relationships’ and capabilities. It encourages one to make
an appropriate or tentative judgment that has a domino effect on how they are to respond
to their concluded perception which can also be known as ‘emotional reaction’ according to
Abdel-Khalek. Keeping this in mind, how exactly do one’s self-esteem and moral compass
interrelate? Ruyter et al. (2020) explain a young adolescent's biological being in their
research entitled What do you mean by ethical compass? Bachelor students’ ideas about
being a moral professional. Adolescents are said to derive decisions without logical
reasoning and simply base their choices according to what is appealing to them. He added
that this mindset encourages them to make unethical decisions, therefore, having poor
direction. Ciranka & van de Bos (2019) supports this in their article entitled Social Influence
his study and how these relate to adolescents' decisiveness when it comes to social
influence (Social Motivation, Reward Sensitivity, Distraction). The core prime stage of
influence in the human developmental stages is during the ‘mid-adolescent’ stage. Having
said that, adolescents simply learn from the actions of others and then systemize their
preferences. Ciranka added in his research that adolescents were more vulnerable to
familiar experiences than ones that had unfamiliar implications or ones they have not been
exposed to. How then are they able to outgrow this behavior of making impulsive decisions
without direction? It was scientifically suggested that if these young adolescents habitually
immerse themselves in engaging and productive learning environments that challenge their
Having listed down the newfound information, the researchers formulated that in
the context of one's self-esteem and better direction, having plastic surgery does not
improve their moral compass. A moral compass is intended to be the reference for decision
making and it seems that the adolescent stage is an age frame for exploration. In other
words, this is an experimental stage for them where they try and see new interests that
they might be able to develop through experience. Investing in plastic surgery at a young
age is a long-term investment and sometimes results are not always as expected.
Perception and satisfaction with oneself change depending on their current season
in life. In the expectancy that the individual’s confidence becomes weary even after having
undergone plastic surgery, it might encourage them to alter different features of themselves
considering that plastic surgery equips one with temporary satisfaction. There is also a
possibility of addiction that can negatively impact their health since they are still
biologically developing. Having said that, it is common and within human nature to
frequently want to change something about themselves when used to a routine. However,
the researchers recommend that one not base his or her happiness on the brief satisfaction
personality and actions and should be guided by moral principles that are compatible with
the kind of environment they have. A morally upright individual incorporates all qualities in
order to form a strong positive personality. This is extremely beneficial for achieving one's
objective and maintaining mental peace. Acting morally fosters a good feeling of self, which
improves the chance of future moral behavior. Self-esteem has been highlighted as a
growth should be vigorously promoted since this is what makes people great; one must
When someone discusses having plastic surgery, they are labeled as "fake" or
"plastic." Its practice is frowned upon for the following reasons: (1) “It is self-harm" people
would say that those who get plastic surgery do not appreciate how they appear therefore
wanting to change themselves to feel better. It’s often compared to situations such as when
someone who is depressed cuts themself to "feel better." (2) "It is lying and/or deceiving"
because as someone has plastic surgery, they deceive people about their appearance. (3) "It
is horrible that an entire business preys on people's fears in order to sell them unneeded
operations." With that being said, getting plastic surgery is not necessarily about how
you appear because it serves more as a rebrand, and the researchers believe that it is
not immoral. One presents themselves precisely as who they are today, including what
makes them happy and how they see themselves. Nevertheless, there are other sources to
‘rebrand’ for exploring teenagers over performing a plastic surgery with little modifications
about themselves. The prevalence of plastic surgery at this time shows how important
appearances are for these teenagers and in our society. One's appearance influences
inability to accept their physical appearance when consulting for plastic surgery. Common
physical traits that teenagers may seek to correct include nose, breast, acne, and scars.
When a physical problem is resolved, it often boosts self-esteem and confidence. Plastic
surgery for teenagers generally has different reasons and aims than for adults. They
frequently have plastic surgery to fix physical qualities they perceive to be unpleasant. If
this matter is left unaddressed, it may affect their self-worth. Plastic surgery is commonly
Based on Salary Expert’s (2022) estimated salary, the suggested net salary for a
they receive an average incentive of ₱154,082 whereas an entry-level plastic surgeon (1-3
years work experience) makes ₱1,373,865. A senior level plastic surgeon (8+ years work
for patients since it is their responsibility to help their children to make a decision
beneficial to them. In some cases, obtaining written informed consent is insufficient to offer
understanding the patient's feelings and expectations becomes a deciding element when
identifying the optimal treatment plan for the issue at hand, which may also involve
physical and mental development of the adolescent and consider particular instances that
Before receiving plastic surgery, specific development and physical maturity must be met.
Plastic surgery is appropriate for teenagers who can articulate a specific problem and set
realistic expectations for their outcome. For instance, if the structure of their nose obstructs
their breathing airway, they are recommended to undergo surgery. But, if they believe that
having a straight nose will make them more popular, then this goal is unrealistic, thus they
are not suitable for the surgery. A matured thinking teenager should also be aware of the
potential for things to go wrong and be prepared to accept the consequences. They must
demonstrate maturity and understand the process, danger, and outcomes. Further, a parent
should never recommend plastic surgery to their child. If a teen does not seek surgery,
there will be no patient consent, even if there is parental approval. As this can be
The most common plastic surgery performed on teens include (1) Breast
Administration (FDA). (2) Rhinoplasty is the most popular surgical procedure requested by
hump, and contour the tip. This can be done when they reach the age of 15 - 16 years old in
girls and a year later in boys, when the nose has finished 90% of its development. (3)
Breast Reduction is performed on women with an excessively large breast, which can cause
ongoing back and shoulder strain as well as limit daily physical activity. Breast reduction is
typically postponed until the breasts have fully developed. Further, excessive breast growth,
known as gynecomastia, can be a serious issue for certain guys. With these circumstances,
excess tissue removal can be performed. (4) Acne and Acne Scar Treatment. (5)
Liposuction.
Conclusion
The plausible risk that the teenage patient gets themselves into can still be
unpredicted with the several possible outcomes a plastic surgery can derive. Having said
that, the practice will always be shrouded by the desire to look appealing and pleasant.
Many teenagers feel self-conscious and insecure about their image, notably as their
physique changes rapidly. Apart from that, one of the most prevalent reasons people
undergo plastic surgery is to boost their self-esteem. They will benefit from the increased
self-confidence that this surgery will provide. Those who had surgery were less anxious
and had a more favorable outlook on their bodies in general. People who are pleased with
the results have a noticeable increase in how they engage with others, which boosts their
self-esteem because they are no longer insecure. Not to mention that this can often result in
an increased desire to try new things and embrace new possibilities. Allowing teenagers
to undergo surgery is morally acceptable if the motivation is sound. From here, one
must be able to fully understand why these patients are desiring these operations.
Individuals might have negative experiences that prompted them to seek plastic surgery; as
a result, a person can become more virtuous after enhancing their appearances.
Plastic surgery can change a person's personality by making them feel better about
themselves. However, it can be presumed that a person can make changes to their
personality depending on the results of the procedure. The issue at hand has both benefits
and disadvantages. Altering an existing flaw in someone's physique may enable a person in
regaining confidence and self-esteem. On the contrary, other issues to consider include
dissatisfaction, for the reason that the outcome of the procedure is not always anticipated,
and the individual may end up with such a look or body that he or she dislikes. Youth who
can express a specific concern and understand the limitations of their outcome are eligible
for cosmetic procedures. A matured thinking adolescent must also be aware of the
possibility of mishaps and be willing to accept the repercussions. They must exhibit
maturity and understand the procedure, the risks, and the outcomes.
productive learning settings that challenge their reasoning skills, as this will provide them
with better life wisdom. The study concluded that undergoing plastic surgery does not
improve one's moral compass in terms of self-esteem and better direction. A moral
compass is supposed to be a guide for making decisions, and it appears that the adolescent
stage is a suitable period of exploration. In the event that an individual's confidence wanes
even after undergoing plastic surgery, it may motivate them to change various aspects of
their appearance, as plastic surgery only provides temporary satisfaction. The personality
and actions of an individual determine their moral uprightness. A morally upright person
integrates all of the characteristics to produce a strong, positive personality. The concept
behind the perspective on self-esteem is that one's personality views ethical standards
seriously, hence one feels good or bad based on one's moral acts. Self-esteem has been
identified as an important part of good interpersonal behavior. This is highly beneficial for
reaching one's goal and preserving mental tranquility. One's sense of personal and social
identity is intricately related to one's facial appearance. That being said, having plastic
surgery does not imply that you are lying about your physical features because that is
your new appearance, and it is not immoral. Acting morally promotes a positive sense of
Plastic surgery is currently generally known for its cosmetic or aesthetic benefits
than for its earlier reconstructive use. Teenagers frequently use plastic surgery to conform
to social beauty standards. The most common plastic surgery performed on teens includes
Breast augmentation or breast implants, Rhinoplasty, Breast Reduction, Acne and Acne Scar
Treatment, and Liposuction. Plastic surgery is not prohibited in any country; however,
parental consent is required as parents must assist their children under the age of 18 in
making decisions that are in their best interests. It is the obligation of the parents to assess
the adolescent's physical and mental development and to consider certain situations that
Prior to undergoing plastic surgery, certain development and physical maturity must be
met.
There is one definition that implies that cosmetic procedures are "surgery of the
norm," with the purpose of making a person happy by changing one normality into the
other (A brief philosophy of Cosmetic Surgery, 2015). Epicurus (an ancient Greek
philosopher) taught that achieving this elusive state of happiness is an important goal in
life. These individuals are able to obtain happiness by opting to have plastic surgeries
performed on them. If the surgery will improve their overall self-worth, then it should be
appropriate for them to have the operation performed. Happiness obtained by plastic
surgery, however, is just momentary. Hence, youth must understand that they cannot
PRIMARY SOURCES
SECONDARY SOURCES
Aguillo, M. (2015, July 28). Does plastic surgery change your personality? FRANK AGUILLO,
MD.
https://www.agulloplasticsurgery.com/blog/does-plastic-surgery-change-your-pers
onality/
American Society of Plastic Surgeons. (n.d). Briefing paper: Plastic surgery for teenagers.
https://www.plasticsurgery.org/news/briefing-papers/briefing-paper-plastic-surge
ry-for-teenagers
Bessinger, C. (2016, November 28). An open letter to parents about teen plastic surgery.
Opnlttr.
https://www.opnlttr.com/letter/open-letter-parents-about-teen-plastic-surgery
Ciranka, S. & van de Bos, W. (2019, August). Social influence in adolescent decision-making: A
formal framework. ResearchGate.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/335482674_Social_Influence_in_Adolesc
ent_Decision-Making_A_Formal_Framework
Co, R. (2017, July 09). Is Plastic Surgery Really the Answer to All Our Beauty Woes?.
https://www.candymag.com/beauty/is-plastic-surgery-really-the-answer-to-all-our
-beauty-problems-a1585-20170709-lfrm
Coopersmith, S. (1990). The antecedents of self-esteem (p.1). Palo Alto, CA: Consulting
Psychologists Press, Inc.
Cosmetic Surgery Solicitors. (2017, July 19). How does cosmetic surgery affect society?
https://www.cosmeticsurgerysolicitors.co.uk/all-resources/how-cosmetic-surgery-
affects-society
Condron, E. (2018, February 14). Beauty standards: Today’s society. The Outlook.
https://outlook.monmouth.edu/2018/02/beauty-standards-today-s-society/
Devesa, B. (2017, August 16). Under the knife: Filipinos’ attitude towards plastic surgery. The
Filipino Times. Retrieved May 19, 2022, from
https://filipinotimes.net/news/2017/08/16/under-the-knife-filipinos-attitude-tow
ards-plastic-surgery/
Dunaev, I. (2015, March). Why is plastic surgery still a taboo? Medical Travel.
https://www.medicaltravelczech.com/blog/plastic-surgery/why-plastic-surgery-sti
ll-taboo
Garcia Plastic & Hand Surgery. (2016, January 14). Positive outcomes of plastic surgery.
https://www.drgarciaplasticsurgery.com/tips-for-looking-feeling-your-best/positiv
e-outcomes-of-plastic-surgery/
Guinness, R. (2018, August 28). As teens turn to cosmetic surgery, study outlines new
age-appropriate guidelines. Good Morning America.
https://www.goodmorningamerica.com/wellness/story/teens-turn-cosmetic-surge
ry-study-outlines-age-guidelines-57432332
Gupta, R. C. (2016, June). Plastic surgery. Nemours TeensHealth.
https://kidshealth.org/en/teens/plastic-surgery.html
McCrary, S.V. (n.d.). Ethical issues regarding cosmetic surgery for minors. Health Law & Policy
Institute.
https://www.law.uh.edu/healthlaw/perspectives/Bioethics/981230Cosmetic.htm
Menzel, J. E., Sperry, S. L., Small, B., Thompson, J. K., Sarwer, D. B., & Cash, T. F. (2011).
Internalization of appearance ideals and cosmetic surgery attitudes: A test of the
tripartite influence model of body image. Sex Roles: A Journal of Research, 65(7-8),
469–477. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11199-011-9983-7
Monroe, J. (2021, February 23). Is there really such a thing as snapchat dysmorphia?
Newport Academy.
https://www.newportacademy.com/resources/empowering-teens/snapchat-dysmo
rphia/
Morselli, P.G., Lippi, A., Giorgini, F.A., Fabbri, E., Pinto, V. (2019). Informed consent in plastic
surgery, evaluation of its effectiveness for mutual satisfaction of patient and doctor:
Comparison of methods.
https://www.jprasurg.com/article/S1748-6815(19)30238-4/pdf#relatedArticles
Nejadsarvari, N., Ebrahimi, A., Ebrahimi, A., & Hashem-Zade, H. (2016, July 5). NCBI -
Medical Ethics in plastic surgery: A mini review. National Library of Medicine.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5109381/
O’Neill, J. (2015, May 08). Should parents let teens get plastic surgery like Kylie Jenner?
Yahoo!News.
https://www.yahoo.com/news/should-parents-let-teens-get-plastic-surgery-like-11
8380759257.html?guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvbS8&guce_ref
errer_sig=AQAAAHsRzv3IP8FVKlRK1bjBkPBZB2-v0XYXgNu3KZMNj_AL1p7FWlNuF
LLS3wUEY4nj4V3qTk0ZJNNNeK1od-7h64Nf1iRDjMVd-ACQhFdwU4fYvGjYkgXZiwB
gCoLHwGAXNOgZcJGv7UL2AW58JhVxZ-18-klcrGcYCw8HnKIUXk0z&guccounter=2
Parsapoor, A., Parsapoor, M., Rezaei, N., & Asghari, F. (2014, June). NCBI - Autonomy of
children and adolescents in consent to treatment: Ethical, jurisprudential and legal
considerations. National Library of Medicine.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4276576/
RaisingChildren.net.au. (2021, May 13). Happiness and well-being for pre-teens and
teenagers.
https://raisingchildren.net.au/teens/mental-health-physical-health/about-mental-
health/happy-teens
Ruyter, D., Sanderse, W., Smerecnik, C., & Van Stekelenburg, L. H. (2020, December). ‘What
do you mean by ethical compass? Bachelor students’ ideas about being a moral
professional. ResearchGate.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/346247445_%27What_do_you_mean_by
_ethical_compass%27_Bachelor_students%27_ideas_about_being_a_moral_professio
nal
The Aesthetic Society. (2013, March 14). Research ties plastic surgery to higher self-esteem,
better mood.
https://www.surgery.org/consumers/plastic-surgery-news-briefs/research-ties-pla
stic-surgery-higher-self-esteem-mood-1049817
Wilks, D.J.A. (1995, May). The Relationships Between Moral Reasoning, Self-esteem, Perceived
Locus Of Control, And Perceptions Of Moral Responsibility In Community College
Students.
https://ttu-ir.tdl.org/bitstream/handle/2346/21984/31295009265959.pdf;sequen
ce=1