Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chaptek: Radoa
Chaptek: Radoa
AREA ENCLOSED BY THE GILA, Rio GRANDE DEL NORTE, AND COLO
RADOA LAND OF MYSTERY WONDERFUL REPORTS AND ADVEN
TURES OF MISSIONARIES, SOLDIERS, HUNTERS, MINERS, AND PI
ONEERS EXPLORATION RAILROAD SURVEYS CLASSIFICATION OF
REMAINS MONUMENTS OF THE GILA VALLEY BOULDER-!NSCRIP-
TIONS THE CASA GRANDE OF ARIZONA EARLY ACCOUNTS AND
MODERN EXPLORATION ADOBE BUILDINGS VIEW AND PLANS
MISCELLANEOUS REMAINS, ACEQUIAS, AND POTTERY OTHER RUINS
ON THE GILA VALLEY OF THE Rio SALADO Rio VERDE PUEBLO
CREEK UPPER GILA TRIBUTARIES OF THE COLORADO ROCK-IN
SCRIPTIONS, BILL WILLIAMS FORK RUINED CITIES OF THE COLO
RADO CHIQUITO Rio PUERCO LITHODENDRON CREEK NAVARRO
SPRING ZUNI VALLEY ARCH SPRING ZUNI OJG DEL PESCADO
INSCRIPTION ROCK Rio SAN JUAN RUINS OF THE CHELLY AND
CHACO CAXONS VALLEY OF THE Rio GRANDE PUEBLO TOWNS,
INHABITED AND IN RUIN.S THE MOQUI TOWNS THE SEVEN CITIES
OF CIBOLA RESUME, COMPARISONS, AND CONCLUSIONS.
ii., 468; Id., Cent. Amer., pp. 519-24; Emory s Recannoissance, pp. 82,,
p.
89-91, with plate.
622 ANTIQUITIES OF ARIZONA AND NEW MEXICO.
3 161-
Castaiieda, in Ternaux-Compans, Voy., serie i., torn, ix., pp. 40-1,
2. Two other accounts of the trip were written one by Juan Jarainillo,
which may be found in the same volume of Ternaux-Compans work and ;
ber, 1848; Whipple, et al., in Pac. R. R. Rcpts., vol. iii.; and ^i/np.wn, in
Smithsonian Rept., 1859, p. 309, et seq. The last is the best article on the
subject, and is accompanied by a map. All the accounts mention tl e
fact that the expedition passed through Chichilticale, but only the one
quoted describes the building.
4 Lo apunto en einbrion por no haber ido yo a este descubrimento."
Mange, in Doc. Ilixt. Jfcx., serie iv., torn, i., pp. 259, 253, 302-4.
5 In Doc. Hist.
Mcx., serie iv., torn, i., pp. 282-3. Mange s description
is as follows: One of them is a large edifice, the principal room in the
centre being four stories high, and those adjoining it on its four sides, three
stories; with walls two varas thick, of strong aryamasa y burro [that is,
the material of which adobes are made] so smooth on the inside that they
resemble planed boards, and so polished that they shine like Pnebla pot
tery. The corners of the windows, which are square, are very straight and
without supports or crosspieces of wood, as if made with a mold; the
doors are the same, though, narrow, and by this it is known to be the work
of Indians; it is 36 paces long by 21 wide, and is well built. At the dis
tance of an arquebuse-shot are seen twelve other buildings half fallen, also
with thick walls; and all the roofs burned out except one low room, which
has round beams apparently of cedar, or sabino, small and smooth, and
over them otates (reeds) of equal size, and a layer of hard mud and mortar,
forming a very curious roof or floor. In the vicinity are seen many other
CASA GRANDE OF THE GILA. 623
de la grande y altas. . .
.y en largo distrito se ve mucha losa quebraday pin
tada; tambien se ve una sequia maestra de diez varas de ancho y quatro de
alto, y un bordo muy grueso hecho de la misma tierra que va a la casa por
un llano. Bernal, in Doc. Hist. Mex., se rie iii., torn, iv., p. 804.
8 Padre Garces
says, on this river is situated the house which they
call Moctezuma s, and many other ruins of other edifices with very many
fragments of pottery both painted and plain. From what I afterwards saw
of the Moqui, I have formed a very different idea from that which I before
entertained respecting these buildings, referring to Padre Font for more
details. Doc. Hist. Mex., serie ii., torn, i., p. 242. Font s account is sub
stantially as follows: Wecarefully examined this edifice and its ruins;
624 ANTIQUITIES OF ARIZONA AND NEW MEXICO.
the echnographical plan of which I here lay down [The plan does not ac
company the translation, hut I have the same plan in another MS. which
I shall presently mention] and the better to understand it I give the follow
and round about it there are ruins indicating a fence or wall which sur
rounded the house and other buildings, particularly in the corners, where
it appears that there has been some edifice like an interior castle or watch-
tower, for in the angle which faces towards the S. W. there stands a ruin with
its divisions and an upper story. The exterior place [plaza] extends from N.
to S. 420 feet and from E. to W. 260 feet. The interior of the house con
sists of five halls, the three middle ones being of one size and the two ex
treme ones longer. The three middle ones are 26 by 10 feet, and the
others 38 by 12 feet, and all 11 feet high. The inner doors are of equal
size, two by five feet, the outer ones being of double width. The inner walls
are four feet thick and well plastered, and the outer walls six feet thick.
The house is 70 by 50 feet, the walls sloping somewhat on the outside.
Before the Eastern doorway, separate from the house there is another
building, 26 by 18 feet, without counting the thickness of the walls.
The timber, it appears, was of pine, and the nearest mountain bearing
pine is at the distance of 25 leagues; it likewise bears some mezquite. All
the building is of earth, and according to appearances the walls are built in
boxes [moldes] of different sizes. A trench leads from the river at a
great distance, by which the town was supplied with water; it is now nearly
buried up. Finally, it is perceptible that the Edifice had three stories, and
if it be true what the Indians say it had 4, the last being a kind of sub
terranean vault. For the purpose of giving light to the rooms, nothing is
seen but the doors and some round holes in the middle of the walls which
face to the East and West, and the Indians said that the Prince whom they
call the "bitter man" used to salute the sun through these holes (which are
pretty large) at its rising and setting. No signs of stairs remain, and we
therefore suppose that they must have been of wood, and that they were
destroyed when the building was burnt by the Apaches. Font s Journal,
MS., pp. 8-10; also quoted in Bartletts Pers. Nar., vol. ii., pp. 278-80;
also French translation in Ternatix-Compans, Voy., serie i., torn, ix., pp.
383-6.
9
Beaumont, Crdn. Mechoacan, MS., pp. 504-8. See an abridged ac-
AUTHORITIES ON THE CASA GRANDE. 625
iii., torn, iv., pp. 503-4; Velarde, Descrip. de la Pimeria, in Doc. llist.
Mex., serie iv., torn, i., pp. 362-3. This author speaks of ultimas paredes
de un gran estaiique, hecho a inano de cal y canto. Similar account in
Alet/rc, Hist. Co //i p. de Jesus, torn, ii., pp. 211-12.
11
Emory s Reconnaissance, pp. 81-3; Johnston s Journal, in Id., pp.
567-600; Browne s Apache Country, pp. 114-24; Bartlett" s Fers. Nar.,
vol. ii., pp. 271-84. Other authorities, containing, I believe, no original
information, are as follows: Htunboldt, Essai Pol., pp. 297-8; Baldwin s
Anc. Ainct:, p. 82; Mofras, Explor. torn, ii., p. 361; Gondra, in Prcscott,
,
Hist. Conq. Mex., torn, iii., p. 19; Mayer s Mex. Aztec, etc., vol. ii.,
p. 396,
with cut; Id., Observation*, p. 15; Itl., Mex. as it Was, p. 239; Brassenr
de Uonrbotinj, Hist.. Xat. dr., torn, ii., p. 197; Conder s Mex. Guat, vol.
ii., pp. 68-9; Btix<-luu<tnn, S/tren der Aztck. Spr., p. 297; uffx COIKJ. of
(.
6V//., pp. 186-8; Douimcch x /Msv>7.v, vol. i., pp. 381-4; Mulllvutxc,,, T<jc-
Guat., p. 12; Long s A mer. and W, /., pp. 180-1; Malte-Brun, Preri* la </r,
Wot/., torn, vi., 453; Mill s Hist. Mex., pp. 192-3; Mnmjlurc,
]>p.
tom. rxxxi., pp. 284-6, 261; Froebcl, Aus Amer., torn, ii.,
tl ^ ///.,/ .-,,.// if o/*~ r_7 4
pp. i 451-2; Gor~
don1 1
s Hist, (tit//
itjri
.S //W,- .v
Val. Scran-RooJc, p. 669; Robinson s Cal., pp. 93-4; Vein,wo, in
SV. Mex. Geog., Boletin, tom. xi., p. 96; Thunnnel, Mcxiko,
p. 347; De-
219.
VOL. IV. 40
626 ANTIQUITIES OF ARIZONA AND NEW MEXICO.
}-. 272;
60 feet square, Emonfs Reconnaissance, p. 81.
CASA GRANDE OF ARIZONA. C2D
Q=LI
Ground Plan of the Casa Grande.
>
i
Elevations of the Casa Grande.
is
eight or ten feet probably one story higher.
Mr Bartlett judged from the mass of debris within
that the main building had originally four stories;
but as the earliest visitors speak of three and four
stories some referring to the central, others appar
ently to the outer portions there would seem to be
no satisfactory evidence that the building was over
forty feet high, although it is possible that the outer
and inner walls were originally of the same height.
Respecting the arrangement of apartments in the
upper stories, there is of course no means of judging,
all the floors having fallen. There may, however,
have been additional partition walls resting on the
floors, and these may have helped to make up the
debris noticed by Mr Bartlett. The floors were evi
dently supported by round timbers four or five inches
in diameter, inserted in the walls and stretching
across the rooms at regular intervals. The holes
where the beams were placed, and in many cases the
ends of the beams themselves are still visible. At
the time of Padre Kino s visit one floor in an adjoin
ing ruin was still perfect, and was formed by cross-
sticks placed upon the round floor- timbers and cov
ered with a thick cake of mud, or adobe, 17 No marks
of any cutting instrument were noticed by any visitor
except Mr
Browne, who says "the ends show very
plainly marks of the blunt instrument with which
they were cut probably a stone hatchet." The 1
17
Mange, Itinerario, in Doc. Hist. Mex., srie iv., torn. L, pp. 282-3.
18 Browne s Apache Country, p. 118.
19
Johnston, in Emory s Reconnaissance, p. 598.
CASA GRANDE. 631
although
much smaller; the latter is of still smaller
dimensions and its remains convey no idea of its orig
inal form. "In
every direction," says Mr Bartlett,
far as the eye can reach, are seen heaps of ruined
"as
p. 297.
MISCELLANEOUS REMAINS. 633
28
Velarde, in Doc. Hist. Mex., serie iv., torn, i., pp. 348, 363. De otros
edificios de mas cxtcncion, arte y simetria, he oido referir al Padre Ygnacio
REMAINS IN THE SALADO VALLEY. C35
15.
33 Mr
Leronx also reported to Bartlett the existence in the Verde valley
of of debris like those on the Salado. IkirtlcM s Pcrs. Nrtr., vol. ii.,
heaps
p. 247. Mention of Verde remains. Warden, Rechcrches, p. 79; Mollhau-
sen, Reisenin die Felsengeb., torn, ii., pp. 140-2; Miihlenpfordt, Mejico,
PUEBLO CREEK AND THE UPPER GILA. 637
teiy."
The remains consist uniformly of lines of rough
amygdaloid stones rounded by attrition, no one of
which remains upon another, apparently the founda
tions upon which were erected adobe walls that have
altogether disappeared. The plan of the buildings as
indicated by their foundations was generally rectan
gular; many of them were very similar to the modern
Spanish dwellings, as shown in the accompanying cut;
Hist. Man, vol. ii., pp. 514-15, 538; DomenecJi s Deserts, vol. i., pp. 382-3;
Cal. Farmer, Feb.
28, 1882; CinciiinatiiJ Travels, pp. 355-7; Galiatin, in
Nouvelles Ann ales des Voy., 1851, torn, cxxxi., pp. 293-4. I find an ac
count going the rounds of the newspapers of a wonderful group of ruins
on the (lila some miles east of Florence, discovered by Lieut. Ward.
They consist of very extensive fortifications, and other structures ol l>uilt
hewn stone, the walls being yet twelve feet high, and two towers standing
20 and 31 feet respectively. Copper and stone implements, golden orna
ments and stone vases were found here. Finally, the whole account is doubt
less a hoax.
36 Awriter in the N. Y. Tribune, see Hist. May., vol. x., suppl., p. 95
describes a pyramid on the Colorado Uiver, without giving the locality.
It is 104 feet square, 20 feet high, and has at present a summit platform.
It seems, however, to have been originally pointed, judging from the de
bris. The material is hewn stone in blocks from 18 to 36 inches thick,
those of the outer facing being cut at an angle. This report is perhaps
founded on some of the ruins on the Colorado Chiquito yet to be men
tioned, or quite as probably it has no foundation whatever. Upon the
lawer part of the Rio Colorado no traces of permanent dwellings have been
discovered. Whip-pie, En-lunik, and Turner, in Pac. It. R. Itrpt., vol. iii.,
p. 15. Arizona miners occasionally refer to the ruins of old Indian build
ings on the Colorado, 40 miles above La 1 a/, on the eastern side, similar
i:\ character to those of the Gila. On Khrenl>erg s Map of A 1858,
ri;;<i<i,
they are so located, and that is all that is known of them. San Francisco
Evening Bulletin, July 14, 18G4.
3T Cal.
Fanner, March 27, 18G3.
TRIBUTARIES OF THE COLORADO. Gil
pp. 10G-7.
VOL. IV. 41
642 ANTIQUITIES OF ARIZONA AND NEW MEXICO.
At
a bend in the river, about forty miles above
the ruins last mentioned, are the remains of a
rectangular stone building, measuring one hundred
and twenty by three hundred and sixty feet, and
standing on an isolated sandstone hill. The walls
are mostly fallen, but some of the standing portions
are ten feet thick, and seem to contain small apart
ments. Many pine timbers are scattered about in
39 Si f greaves Report, Zuiii and Colorado Rivers, 1853, pp. 8-9; Whip-
pie, in Pac. R. R. R-pt., vol. iii., pp. 81, 46-50; Ives* Colorado Riv.. p.
117, no details; Mollhauscn, Tayt lmch, pp. 306-8; Id., Rciscn in Fel- <lie
scHtjrh., torn, ii., pp. 148-50, 164-5,399-401; Schooleroft s Arch., vol. iv.,
pp. 253, vol. vi., p. 68, plates of inscriptions; Hay, in Soc. Mex. Gcog.,
Boletin, 2da epoca, toni. i., p. 29; Foster s P
re- 1 list. Races, pp. 146-7.
A writer in the San Francisco Evening EnU^I m, July 3, 1868,
says
that the most extensive ruins in Arizona or New Mexico are situated
above the high falls of the Little Colorado, 20 miles north of the San
Francisco Mountains. They extend for miles along the river, and in
clude well-made walls of hewn stone now standing to the height of six or
eight feet. Both streets and irrigating canals may be traced for miles.
This writer speaks of the Jesuit inscriptions. According to an article in
t .ie San Francisco Herald of 1853,
quoted in the Cat. Farmer of June 22,
IS;!!), (/apt. Joseph Walker found some remarkable ruins on the Colorado
Zufii Vases.
torn\. ii., pp. 196, 402; Id., pp- 283-4, 278, with cut of altar; ,s / nip-
T<t</< l>u<-li,
neck s Deserts, vol. i., pp. 211-13; Barber and Howe s Western States, p. 553;
Shuck 6- Cal. Scrap-Jjuok, pp. 310-12.
OJO DEL PESCADO. 647
chocolate color. A
vast amount of labor has been
spent on decorating the unique lip. fine border A
line has been drawn along the edge and on both sides
of the deep embattled rim. Horned frogs and tad
poles alternate on the inner surface of the turrets,
while one of the latter is represented on the outside
of each. Larger frogs or toads are portrayed within
the body of the vessel/ One of these figures is pre
sented in the cut enlarged. The second vase is five
inches deep, ten inches in diameter at the widest
part, and eight inches at the lips. Both outer and
inner surface bear a white glazing, and there are four
projections of unknown use, one on each side. The
decorations are in amber color, and the horned or
tufted snakes, shown above the vase, are said to be
almost unique in America. 45
E. R. Eept., vol. iii.,p. 39. Col. Doniphan found in 184G on the head
waters of the Piscao (Pescado, Zufii?) the ruins of an ancient city, which
formed a square surrounded by double walls of stone 14 feet apart. The
space between the walls was divided into compartments 14 feet square,
opening into the interior. The houses were three stories high, the lower
story being partially subterranean. Large quantities of red cedar, appar
ently cut for firewood, were found in connection with the buildings.
Hughes Donipharfs Ex., pp. 197-8. Simpson explored the stream to its
source, and found no ruins except three at Ojo del 1
cscado, which were
probably the same on which Doniplmn s report was founded, although
there is no resemblance in the descriptions.
EL MORO, OR INSCRIPTION ROCK. C49
7
Inscriptions El Moro.
Plain of El Moro.
10!), plan of rock, w hippie, et aL, in Pac. E. E. Repts, vol. iii., pp. 22, 52,
03-4
03-4, -\vith Iliaus
plates; Mollhausen, Tagcbuch, pp. 26(5-72, pi. of plan and pot
tery; Id., Joitrnrt/, vol. ii., pp. 68-79, 52, pi.; Doinrnct-JSs J)cwrfx, vol. i.,
tery
]pp.
_ 208-9, 415-18; Dan s El Gringo, pp. 422-3; Foster s P
re- Hist. Races,
48
DoiuiHCjHez and Escalante, Diario, in Doc. Hist. lfr.i\, serie ii., torn, i.,
pp. 400-2. A correspondent of the San Fruin-iwo ErcniiKj LtttUcfin, July
8, 18(54, says that the San Juan valley is strewn with ruins for hundreds
of miles, some buildings three stories high of solid masonry still standing.
]>avis. El UriiH/o, p. 417, had heard of some ruins on the northern hank of
the San Juan, hut none further north. The valleys of the Rio las Ani-
<!e
mas and San Juan are strewn with the ruins of cities, many of them of
solid masonry. Stone buildings, three stories high, are vet standing, of
Aztec architecture. Baker, in L al. Fanner, June 19, 1863.
652 ANTIQUITIES OF ARIZONA AND NEW MEXICO.
49
Simpson s Jour. Mil. Eecon., pp. 74-5, pi. 53-4. Other slight ac
counts made up from Simpson: Dotiicncctis Deserts, vol. i., p. -IH; An-
nu id .sVv />.
Disrov., 1850, p. 362; Barber ami Howe s Western States, pp.
559-60, with cut.
RUINS OF THE CHACO. G53
50 Dr
Hammond, a companion of Simpson, describes this room as fol
lows: It was in the second of three ranges of rooms, on the north side of
the ruins. The door opened at the base of the wall, towards the interior
of the building; it had never been more than two feet and a half high, and
was tilled two-thirds with rubbish. The lintels were of natural sticks of
wood, one and a half to two and a half inches in diameter, deprived of the
bark, and placed at distances of two or three inches apart; yet their ends
were attached to each other by withes of oak with its bark well preserved.
The room was in the form of a parallelogram, about twelve feet in length,
eight feet high, and the walls, as they stood at the time of observation,
seven
feet high. The floor was of earth, and the surface irregular. The walls were
about two feet thick, and plastered within with a layer of red mud one
fourth of an inch thick. The latter, having fallen off in places, showed the
material of the wall to be sandstone. The stone was ground into pieces
the size of our ordinary bricks, the angles not as perfectly formed, though
nearly so, and put up in break-joints, having intervals between them, on
every side, of about two inches. The intervals were filled with lamina; of
a dense sandstone, about three lines in thickness, driven firmly in, and
broken off even with the general plane of the wall the whole resembling
mosaic work. Niches, varying in size from two inches to two feet and a
half square, and two inches to one and a half feet in horizontal depth,
were scattered irregularly over the walls, at various heights above the floor.
Near the place of the ceiling, the walls were penetrated, and the surfaces
of them perpendicular to the length of the beam. They had the appear
ance of having been sawed off originally, except that there were no marks
of the saw left on them; time had slightly disintegrated the surfaces,
rounding the edges somewhat here and there. Supporting the floor above
were six cylindrical beams, about seven inches in diameter, passing trans
versely of the room, and at distances of less than two feet apart the
branches of the trees having been hewn off by means of a blunt-edged in
strument. Above, and resting on these, running longitudinally with the
room, were poles of various lengths, about two inches in diameter, irregu
larly straight, placed in contact with each other, covering all the top of the
room, bound together at irregular and various distances, generally at their
ends, by slips apparently of palm-leaf or marquez, and the same material
converted into cords about one-fourth of an inch in diameter, formed of two
strands, hung from the poles at several points. Above, and resting upon
the poles, closing all above, passing transversely of the room, were planks
of about seven inches wide, and three-fourths of an inch in thickness.
The width of the plank was uniform, and so was the thickness. They
were in contact, or nearly so, admitting but little more than the passage of
a knife blade between them, by the edges, through the whole of their
lengths. They were not jointed; all their surfaces were level, and as
smooth as if planed, excepting the ends; the angles as regular and perfect
as could be retained by such vegetable matter they are probably of pine
or cedar exposed to the atmosphere for as long a time as it is probable
these have been. The ends of the plank, several of which were in viewr ,
terminated in lines perpendicular to the length of the plank, apd the plank
appears to have been severed by a blunt instrument. The planks I exam
ined them minutely by the eye and the touch, for the marks of the saw and
other instruments were smooth, and colored brown by time or by smoke.
Beyond the plank nothing was distinguishable from within. The room
\vas redolent with the perfume of cedar. Externally, upon the top, w^as
a heap of stone and mud, ruins that have fallen from above, immovable by
the instruments that we had along. The beams were probably severed by
contusions from a dull instrument, and their surfaces ground plain and
VOL. IV. 42
058 ANTIQUITIES OF ARIZONA AND NEW MEXICO.
smooth by a slab of rock; and the planks, split or hewn from the trees,
were, no doubt, rendered smooth by the same means. Hammond, in Simp-
son s Jour. Mil. Recon., pp. 131-3.
RUINS OF THE CHACO CA^ON. 659
ground plan. Pueblo Una Vida, 15J, miles from Pueblo Pintado, circum
ference 994 feet, height 15 feet, 2 stories, 4 estufas, pp. 37-8, pi. 28-9; view
and ground plan. Pueblo Hungo Pavie, 872 feet circumference, 30 feet
high, 4 stories, 72 rooms, 1 estufa, p. 38, pi. 30-2; plan, pottery, and resto
ration (all copied above). Pueblo Chettro Kettle, circumference 1300 feet, 4
stories, 124 rooms, 6 estufas, pp. 38-40, pi. 33-5; plan, interior, hieroglyph
ics. Pueblo Bonito, circumference 1300 feet, 4 stories, 139 rooms traceable,
4 estufas, pp. 40-2, 131-3, pi. 36-38, 40-41; view, plan, interior, pottery,
specimen of masonry. Pueblo Arroyo, 100 feet circumference, 2 undescribed
ruins near it, p. 42. Pueblo Penasco Blanco, on south side of river, 1700
feet circumference, 112 rooms, 3 stories, 7 estufas, pp. 42-3, pi. 41, fig. 2;
specimen of masonry. Simjison s Jour. Mil. Eccoit., pp. 34-43, 131-3.
Slight account from Simpson, in Domenech s Deserts, vol. i., pp. 199-200,
379-81, 385; Annual Scien. Discov., 1850, pp. 362-3; Baldwin s Anc.
Afuf.r., pp. 86-9, cut; Barber and House s Western States, pp. 556-9, cuts;
Thummcl, Mexiko, pp. 347-8. A
newspaper report of a ruin discovered
by one Roberts may be as well mentioned here as elsewhere, although
the locality given is 90 miles within the Arizona line, while the Charo
remains are in New Mexico. This city was built on a mesa with pre
cipitous sides, and covered an area of 3 square miles, being enclosed by
a wall of hewn sandstone, still standing in places 6 or 8 feet high. No
remains of timber were found in the city, which must have contained orig
inally 20,000 inhabitants. It was laid out in pla/as and streets, and the
walls boi e sculptured hieroglyphics. San Francisco Chronicle, Dec. Ii2,
1872. See also Alta California, June 26, 1874. I give but few of these
newspaper reports as specimens; a volume might be filled with them, with
out much profit.
PUEBLO REMAINS ON THE RIO GRANDE. 663
and there is
every reason to believe that all are so,
except a few that may have been built during the
Spanish domination. The inhabited Pueblo towns,
or those inhabited during the nineteenth century, are
about twenty in number, although authors disagree
on this point, some calling Pueblos what others say
are merely Mexican towns; but the distinction is not
52
important for my present purpose. The important
fact is, that the Spaniard found no race of people in
New Mexico which has since become extinct, nor any
class of towns or buildings that differed from the
Pueblo towns still inhabited.
Besides the towns still inhabited there are many
of precisely the same materials and architecture,
which are in ruins. Such are Pecos, Quivira, Val-
verde, San Lazaro, San Marcos, San Cristobal,
Socorro, Senacu, Abo, Quarra, Rita, Poblazon,
old San Felipe, and old Zuni. Some of these were
abandoned by the natives at a very recent date;
some have ruined Spanish buildings among the ab
original structures; some may be historically identi
fiedwith the towns conquered by the first European
visitors.These facts, together with the absence of
any mention of ruins by the first explorers, and the
well-known diminution of the Pueblos in numbers
and power, make it perfectly safe to affirm that the
ruins all belong to the same class, the same people,
and about the same epoch as the inhabited towns.
This conclusion is of some importance since it renders
it useless to examine carefully each ruin, and the
Pueblo of Taos.
Gringo, pp. 141-2. See also Gregg s Com. 7V^//vV.v, vol. i., pp. 276-7. This
author says there is a similar edifice in the pueblo of Picuris. Edwards
C dit/fftit/n, pp. 43-4; Domcncctis Deserts, vol. i., pp. 191-2. On the Arrovo
Hondo 10 miles north of Taos, Mr Peters, Life of Carson, p. 437, speaks
largest Aztec settlement in New Mexico, consisting
of the remains of the
of small cobble-stones in mud,
pottery, arrow-heads, stone pipes, and rude
tools.
55 s Jour. Mil. Eecon.,
Simpson p. 114.
6G6 ANTIQUITIES OF ARIZONA AND NEW MEXICO.
Hat roof by which admission is gained. Sitnt>$on s Jour. Mil. Hrron., p. 02.
Estufa at Jeme/, with plates of paintings. Id., pp. 21-2, pi. 7-11.
PUEBLO OF PECOS. 671
Ruins of Pecos.
came to New
Mexico but altogether probable that
;
they heard
first the name of Montezuma, of the
Aztec people, and of their former migration south
ward, from the Spaniards themselves, or their native
63
companions.
With the Quivira located by Thomas Gage and
other early writers and map-makers, on the most "
Ex., pp. 74-5; lleline s Two Thousand Miles, pp. 255-8; Gregg s Com.
Pnt tries, vol. i., pp. 270-3; Mollhausen, Rciscn in die FclscDgcb., torn, ii.,
pp. 293-8; Cutt s Conq. of CaL, p. 79; Domcnech Deserts,
s vol. i., pp. 164-5,
Baldwin s Ane. Amcr., p. 79, with cut.
64
Gage s New tim-ccy, p. 162; Gregg s Com. Prairies, vol. i., pp.
164-5; Davis El Gringo, pp. 70, 123-7; Abert s New Mcx., in Emorvs
Eeconnoissance, pp. 488-9; Domcnech s Deserts, vol. i., pp. 182-3; Wiz-
lizenus Tour p. 25; Garleton s Ruins of Abo, in Smithsonian EC/ ft.,
1854, pp. 300-15; Mollhausen, Flilchtling, torn, i., pp. 718-25, 229, 239,
267-72; Id., Rciscn, toin. ii., pp. 296, 405-6; Frocbcl s Cent. Amcr., p. 301;
Id., Aus Amcr., torn, ii., pp. 150-2; Gallatin, in Nouvcllcs Annales
<lcx
Voy., 1851, torn, cxxxi., pp. 298-9. Abert, in Emory s Reconnaissance, pp.
466-7, 484, tells us that at Teziqne the ruins of the ancient
Indian town
are partially covered with the buildings of the modern; also that at Pobla-
in a
zon, on the Puerco River, the principal ruins of stone are arranged
in the vi-
square with sides o; 200 yards, but other remains are scattered
SEVEN CITIES OF CIBOLA. 673
4th.
numerous, include no articles of any metal whatever,
and do not differ materially from articles now in use
among the Pueblo Indians. Such relics have been
found scattered among the debris of the fallen walls,
and not taken from regular excavations; consequently
no absolute proof exists that they are the work of
the builders, though there can be little room for
doubt on that point. The wandering tribes that
have occupied the country in modern times are much
more likely to have sought for and carried away
relics of the original inhabitants, than to have de
pp. 245-7; Urowue s Apache Country, p. 118; Cal. Fanner, June 22, ISCd.
GENERAL RESUME. 679
48-9; also Wlu i^ih; in Id, pp. 64-5, 69, 73, 76, 81. Of the cut given above,
iig. 2, 5, 8, 9, 11, 13-4, 17, 21, 24, 28, 31-2, are from the Colorado Chiquito;
iig. 22, 27, are from Znni, and modern; fig. 34, from the Cosnino caves, the
ornaments having been put on after the vessel had hardened; fig. 25, 29,
30, 35, are not painted, hut incrusted or indented. It is a singular fact,
that, although some of the most time-worn carvings upon rocks are of ani
mals and men, ancient pottery contains no such representations. Upon
one fragment, indeed, found upon Rio (Jila, was pictured a turtle and a
piece of pottery picked up near the same place was moulded into the form
of a monkey s head. These appeared to he ancient, and aiforded excep
tions to the rule. Id., p. 65. Cut of a fragment and comparison. with one-
found in Indiana. Fosters Prc-lliat. Races, pp. 249-50.
680 ANTIQUITIES OF ARIZONA AND NEW MEXICO.
70
Creek, in lat. 35, 30 , long.102, 30 In another
.
71
volume of this work, something has been said of
hieroglyphic development, of the different classes of
picture-records, and their respective value. The New
Mexican rock-inscriptions and paintings, such of them
as are not mere idle sketches executed without pur
pose by the natives to while away the time, belong to
the lower classes of representative and symbolic pic-
Mollhausen s Journey, vol. i. , p. 264, vol. p. 52, with pi.; Id.,
"o
ii.,
Tagebuc/i, pp. 168-70; Bartletfs Pers. Nar., vol. i., pp. 170-6; DoincnccJi s
Deserts, vol. i., pp. 161-2, 419-20.
71 See vol.
ii., p. 533, et seq.
CONCLUSIONS. C81
O
themselves than do the Pueblo tribes of the pres
ent time; the most fertile valleys of the region were
cultivated by them, and were dotted by fine town-
dwellings of stone and adobe, occupied in common
by many families, similar but superior to the pres
ent Pueblo towns. At least a century, probably
much longer, before the Spaniards made their appear
ance, the decline of this numerous and powerful peo
ple began, and it has continued uninterruptedly down
to the present time, until only a mere remnant in the
Bio Grande and Moqui towns is left. Before the
Spaniards came all the southern towns, on the Gila
and its tributaries, had been abandoned; since that
time the decline of the northern nations, which the
Spaniards found in a tolerably flourishing condition,
is a matter of
history. The reason of the decline
this is hardly the place to consider, but it is doubtless
to the inroads of outside warlike and predatory tribes
like the Apaches that we must look for the chief
cause. It is not impossible that natural changes in
the surface of the region, such as the dry ing- up of
springs, streams, or lakes, may have also contributed
to the same effect. These changes, however, if such
took place, were probably gradual in their operation ;
America.