Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ASHRAE Standard 189.1-2011
ASHRAE Standard 189.1-2011
providing insights for today’s HVAC system designer Trane Engineers Newsletter volume 41–1 3
Table 1. HVAC-Related Mandatory and Prescriptive Provisions of Standard 189.1, Section 7
HVAC System Energy Use
Standard 189.1 Section Summary of Provisions
What does Standard 189.1-2011 require
Mandatory
specifically for the design of energy-efficient
HVAC systems? As stated in the Energy 7.3.1 General For HVAC systems, comply with the mandatory requirements of
Efficiency section, all HPGB projects must Standard 90.1, Section 6.4.
meet the Standard 90.1-2010 mandatory
requirements, so HVAC systems must meet 7.3.2 On-site Renewable Energy Allocate space in single-story buildings for at least 6 kBtu/ft2 (roof
the requirements of Section 6.4. Systems area) for on-site renewable energy systems. For some HVAC
systems, allowance for solar thermal heating can contribute to
Note that the requirements found in meeting this requirement.
Standard 90.1, Section 6.3—an optional
compliance path for simple systems—are 7.3.3 Energy Consumption Provide measurement devices with remote communication
not included here because Section 7.3.1 of Management capability to collect energy consumption data for each energy
Standard 189.1 already requires compliance supply source. In some buildings, the BAS coordinating HVAC
with the prescriptive path in Standard 90.1, operation can be used to collect and report this energy
Section 6.4. In other words, only one consumption data.
Standard 90.1 compliance path—namely Prescriptive (for HVAC systems)
Sections 6.1, 6.4, 6.7, and 6.8 compliance—
7.4.3 Heating, Ventilating and Air Comply with all of Section 6 of Standard 90.1, except as noted in
is available for Standard 189.1 projects.
Conditioning section 7.4.3. The prescriptive provisions of Standard 189.1 include
all provisions in Section 6.1, 6.4, 6.7, and 6.8 of Standard 90.1.
In addition to the Section 6.4 mandatory
requirements, HVAC systems complying 7.4.3.1 Minimum Equipment Use products that comply with either:
with the Standard 189.1-2011 prescriptive Efficiencies (addresses a) EPAct baseline: minimum efficiencies addressed in NAECA,
option must meet the requirements in Standard 90.1-2010, EPAct, and EISA; or
Section 7.4.3, most of which supersede Section 6.4.1 and Tables b) Higher efficiency: the greater of the ENERGY STAR
Standard 90.1 requirements. Table 1 6.8.1A through 6.8.1G) requirements in Section 7.4.7.3 or the values listed in Appendix C,
summarizes the Standard 189.1 which supersede and exceed the values in Standard 90.1, Tables
requirements. The key provisions include: 6.8.1A through 6.8.1G. Also, for systems using higher efficiency
equipment, the minimum renewable energy production
• Both single-zone and multiple-zone
requirement of Section 7.4.1.1 is reduced to 4.0 kBtu/ft2 of roof area
systems (MZS) must include demand-
annually for single-story buildings and 7.0 kBtu/ft2 of roof area
controlled ventilation (DCV) for zones
annually for other buildings, and electric peak demand requirement
with 25 or more people per 1000 ft2.
is reduced from 10% to 5%. (Note: Standard 90.1 has no
Although multiple-zone VAV systems can
renewable energy requirements or electric peak demand limits.)
be complex, ventilation reset approaches
(also required by Standard 90.1) that 7.4.3.2 Ventilation Controls for Provide DCV for any area with 25 or more people per 1000 ft2.
solve the MZS equations in real time Densely Occupied Spaces Standard 90.1 requires DCV in spaces with 40 or more people per
have been used successfully in many (addresses Standard 90.1- 1000 ft2.
VAV systems that use direct digital 2010, Section 6.4.3.9)
controls. 7.4.3.3 Economizers (addresses Provide economizer cooling in all climate zones (except 1A and 1B)
• Smaller systems (down to 2¾ tons) Standard 90.1-2010, for any system with cooling capacity of 33,000 Btu/h or greater
must include economizer cooling, which Section 6.5.1) (with exceptions). Standard 90.1-2010 requires economizer cooling
directly impacts HVAC system selection, in the same climates but only for systems with cooling capacity of
design, and control. 54,000 Btu/h or greater.
• Elimination of reheat exceptions results 7.4.3.4 Zone Controls (addresses Provide controls to limit simultaneous heating and cooling in more
in VAV system design challenges and Standard 90.1-2010, cases than required by Standard 90.1.
more sophisticated controls. Section 6.5.2.1)
7.4.3.5 Fan System Power Limit fan power to values 10% lower than those required by
• Increased requirements for exhaust-air
Limitation (addresses Standard 90.1.
energy recovery make equipment
Standard 90.1-2010, Table
selection and exhaust air capture more
6.5.3.1.1A)
important.
7.4.3.6 Exhaust Air Recovery Use energy recovery systems with at least 60% effectiveness.
Overall, HVAC systems in HPGB projects (addresses Standard 90.1- Standard 90.1-2010 requires at least 50% energy recovery
save energy compared with traditional 2010, Table 6.5.6.10) effectiveness.
systems, but not without cost.
7.4.3.7 Variable-Speed Fan Control Use commercial kitchen hoods with variable-speed exhaust-air and
for Commercial Kitchen makeup-air fans. Standard 90.1-2010 allows constant airflow
Hoods (addresses Standard exhaust hoods.
90.1-2010, Section 6.5.7.1)
7.4.3.8 Duct Insulation (addresses Use duct insulation with higher minimum R-values than required by
Standard 90.1-2010 Tables Standard 90.1.
6.8.2A and 6.8.2B)
7.4.3.9 Automatic Control of HVAC In hotels/motels with more than 50 guest rooms, provide
and Lights in Hotel/Motel automatic controls in each guest room to raise the cooling setpoint
Guest Rooms (adds a by at least 5°F in the cooling mode and lower the heating setpoint
provision not found in by at least 5°F in the heating mode, within 30 minutes of occupant
Standard 90.1-2010) departure from the room.
4 Trane Engineers Newsletter volume 41–1 providing insights for today’s HVAC system designer
Acoustics. Acoustical control is Performance-option requirements for Refrigerants. To reduce the impact of
required for both exterior and interior daylighting by sidelighting include a the building project on atmospheric
sound. Perimeter walls and roof/ceiling minimum illuminance level for ozone, HVAC equipment must not use
assemblies must achieve a minimum surfaces. Daylighting computer CFC-based refrigerants, and fire
sound transmission class. Inside the simulation models must be used to suppression systems must not use
building, interior walls must also demonstrate that the design meets the ozone-depleting substances.
achieve a minimum sound minimum specified requirements.
transmission class. Recycling or disposal. Each building
Prescriptive requirements for specific must have areas designated for the
building materials include either collection and storage of: recyclable
Daylighting. To increase the
minimum VOC emissions or minimum materials, reusable materials, and in
introduction of light from outside the
VOC content. some buildings, fluorescent and high-
building to improve visibility and visual
comfort for occupants, designs must intensity discharge (HID) lamps and
The performance-option for materials
use sufficient fenestration to ensure ballasts.
requires computer simulation to show
minimum daylighting by toplighting. In that contaminant emission rates result
a 20,000 ft2, three-story space, for in acceptable space contaminant Other requirements. In addition to
instance, overhead or high side-wall concentrations; these concentrations the mandatory requirements
fenestration must provide adequate must comply with maximum levels for discussed above, HPGB projects must
lighting for at least 50 percent of any each contaminant, as established by be designed to meet either
floor area directly beneath a roof. California Section 01350. prescriptive- or performance-option
requirements to promote the use of
Soil gas. To reduce the likelihood of reduced-impact materials.
soil gas intrusion, especially
carcinogenic radon, building projects
Building Impact on To meet prescriptive requirements,
on brownfield sites and those in high Atmosphere, Materials, the design must meet one of the
following options:
radon regions (designated “Zone 1” and Resources
areas by the EPA) must include a soil • at least 10 percent of the building’s
gas retarding system. The construction of buildings impacts
total materials must be recycled
natural resources, the atmosphere, and
materials (with a minimum
the ultimate fate of materials. HPGB
Other requirements. In addition to recycled content); or
projects address these issues.
the mandatory requirements discussed • at least 15 percent of building’s
above, HPGB projects must be total materials must be extracted,
designed to meet either prescriptive- Construction waste management.
To reduce the quantity of construction harvested, recovered, or
or performance-option requirements to manufactured within 500 miles of
ensure minimum daylighting and to materials discarded to landfills or
incinerators, HPGB projects must the building site; or
reduce indoor contaminants from
building materials. divert at least 50 percent of • at least 5 percent of the building’s
construction materials by recycling total materials must be biobased
Prescriptive requirements for and/or reuse. Total construction waste materials.
daylighting by sidelighting apply to generated must not exceed 12,000 lbs
most office spaces and classrooms. per 10,000 ft2 of building floor area. Performance-option provisions, on the
The sidelighting openings must meet other hand, require a life-cycle
minimum requirements for area and Materials. All materials, products, and assessment (LCA) to analyze at least
most offices must also meet minimum assemblies installed must comply with two alternative designs, using at least
window shading requirements. the appropriate regulations in the the materials considered for the
country of origin, and wood products prescriptive option (above). The LCA
must not include wood from must show that one approach results
endangered tree species. in at least a 5 percent improvement
providing insights for today’s HVAC system designer Trane Engineers Newsletter volume 41–1 5
over the other approach(es) in at least An erosion and sediment control plan
two of the following impact categories: ensures that soil remains in place Summary
land use, resource use, climate during construction. A plan for IAQ
change, ozone layer depletion, human management during construction and a ASHRAE Standard 189.1 defines high-
health effects, ecotoxicity, smog, moisture control plan help protect performance green buildings by
acidification, and eutrophication (i.e., workers, building materials, and future stipulating minimum building project
the depletion of oxygen in water). occupants. And a construction requirements. Similar to building rating
pollution-control plan protects workers systems, it covers many aspects of
from exhaust fumes from vehicles on high-performance projects, ranging
the construction site. from site selection to water and energy
Construction and Plans for use to material selection, without
Operation Project operation. Operation
ignoring indoor environmental quality.
When adopted into building codes,
requirements include a building
Building construction, operation, and either directly or as an IgCC
operation plan, a maintenance plan, a
maintenance has often been cited as compliance path, this standard will
service-life plan, and a transportation
the source of more problems than help project teams consistently design
management plan.
improper building design. Although this the high-performance green buildings
standard primarily addresses the A Master Building Plan for Operations of the future.
design of high-performance green covers all aspects of the design
buildings, these buildings must also be requirements in Sections 5 through 9, By Dennis Stanke, applications engineer, and
properly constructed, operated, and Jeanne Harshaw, information designer, Trane.
to ensure that the systems in each Dennis is the current committee chairman for
maintained to help them attain the category continue to operate as Standard 189.1. You can find this and previous
results envisioned by the design team. designed after building occupancy. A issues of the Engineers Newsletter at
maintenance plan requires periodic www.trane.com/engineersnewsletter. To
comment, e-mail us at comfort@trane.com.
Project construction. Construction inspection and maintenance of key
requirements include acceptance systems. A service life plan helps the
testing, project commissioning, site owner plan (and budget) for future
erosion control, IAQ management periodic repair and replacement of
during construction, moisture control materials and systems. Finally, a
and local vehicle exhaust control. transportation plan helps reduce the
energy used by building occupants to
Buildings of 5,000 ft2 or less must be travel to and from the building.
acceptance tested in accordance with
a specification, rule, guide, or All provisions in this section are
procedure generally accepted as mandatory.
authoritative. Buildings larger than
5,000 ft2 must be commissioned in
accordance with a specification, rule,
guide, or procedure generally accepted
as authoritative, or a handbook.
6 Trane Engineers Newsletter volume 41–1 providing insights for today’s HVAC system designer
References
[1] American Society of Heating, Refrigerating
and Air-Conditioning Engineers. 2011. ANSI/
ASHRAE/USGBC/IES Standard 189.1-2011.
Standard for the Design of High-Performance
Green Buildings. Atlanta, GA: ASHRAE.
providing insights for today’s HVAC system designer Trane Engineers Newsletter volume 41–1 7
New Application Manuals
Now Available Engineers
Newsletter
Water-Source and Ground-Source
Heat Pump Systems.
LIVE!
For event details and registration
(SYS-APM010-EN, November 2011) contact your local Trane office.
Trane, Trane believes the facts and suggestions presented here to be accurate. However, final design and
A business of Ingersoll Rand application decisions are your responsibility. Trane disclaims any responsibility for actions taken on
the material presented.
For more information, contact your local Trane
office or e-mail us at comfort@trane.com