Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Rancière Aesthetics and Its Discontents (Extract)
Rancière Aesthetics and Its Discontents (Extract)
Rancière Aesthetics and Its Discontents (Extract)
S04} 01 SUIOF Umo sir sosoddo yoryas sonyod v “Wamp or seynood steep sontpod & st sonmjod stay. “13e Jo suus0y yaw uonedioueuie jeonyod yo asneo ay uoddns o1 st astutosd 30U op aouatsadxa pue uoneonps snampsar Ieyg “suru uonezionyod, 2eya puvasiepun 02 axes ayer smu oa Ing, ‘wonezionijod pur Gtmd waaaaq IoIguos ou st axy + simany amp jo sjeanisay, at Butsedaid yo ‘suomejaz uownti09 jo Xydex8odox waxaygip e Surzruesr0 jo yse2 ayp zx00d 01 pousisse ‘eauayjaax0 and rod amd ay Spunreyfepy waag “ayt] Mou axp Jo x0D3p aq orm pauoysuesa Butaq 02 ajqndaasns yjasit [ay v7] Suzary 10} 1099p mau & 10} auounnsur aanmMnstioD ay autesaq aul] ay? Jo Aud ay say pure Aarssosou sown! jo yoquixs amp aumesaq auaueWIO atp Jo Aziouoas ayy 14m ‘poSiow Sse soquiés pur we [euonsuny ‘ure paydde pu are amd arayss aovysonuyaoezms ¥ 0} amusad jerrord sau ax Jo SuVBuojaq ays “KrenUOD ay} uo ‘paxseUr af “yeriareur sat UO woREMUDDUOD aaIsn|DxXa sare [euoasid :4ruts 31 axeur 02 pasts sey au0 rey SEAN Aqudis 101 pip ~ uorsnjp: feuorsuaunp-samyp 1940 AyseUE|d jo Surures sit — seaues ayy jo Gund aanemgy-uou oy yey “eidoan sisutnxa ue 02 UoReUIpIOgns [eAUEASUMST auos Jo anazta £q 30U st 21 ‘ApH IAOG Mat ¥ Jo SuESHITe aU € sonijod se sonaipsay omy soajasuarp tuoystren 03 a[qe azom Sunured se35qe po|]eo-0s Jo surz0y and yo sioveas> ayy Ff AartMeOD amp Jo voHeIMByuoD waieyTp ¥ jo ANfeuaeM poredinue ya Jppsa Jo ayeut 03 ajqe ua9q sey re Jo AnfeLiaret ayy rE Aanmd sq jo imp Aq st a1 :Areuos ax 02 Agnsar saTRPS, wou; sn ayeredas yp solmuaa om ay “uoReZORIOd sit pur are Jo Saud axp uaoaviog ro1yuOD OU S| axoKp SMU ayy] aansaqqoo ue jenprarpur jo w0y mau e Jo “aqueuny mou e Jo WHOS aup se sreadde yorya aouotaadxa reqs st af puy “2auatedxo Arosuas Jo wo} ¥ Jo AwOUOINE ayp sf af “wHsTUsapoUT Aq pareaqa[s9 Supjeut, susie yo Awouoine 2ey3 20U St Awou ‘ome snaypsae Jog “Ize Janis pur ame umosnut ‘so; rod jo 201A98 aU UT Ie pure ayes SUE Jy Fe “Are snoMOUOI=IIY, ue ue snowouome waamiaq uontsoddo Aa9A9 soueape ‘uy afuaqyeyp o1 se em v yons uE AunEIUOD Jeonyod Jo SUNOJ tp Pue Ue Jo VORRDYTIUApT Jo suo ay WaMIDq uonejay aq samansur ae Jo sunfar snaqpsae ay], “apqistas ayy Jo uOISIMIp Jeonod axp uo saBURFUI pu suxasU0> ae yeyp aoustiadxa Jo WHOy snOWOUOME Ue Se az0;939Kp St 3] 183g JO SUIIOJ a4 JO quo 2280] ou pur sjasy souarstxe aygqisuas Jo UoRNIOAaT ¥ ‘uonnjoaas punojoud azour ¥ Jo apdioursd ayp our sny gppsi sosjeur Saratssed xaa0 Canoe Jo pure JaneU 1940 WO jo Aeuroxdns yp Jo uorsuadsns snoysoe oy, “Aanjersaret a]qisuas aarssed suyensuos Aynsey feMId—ayowUT aanoe we ‘yoiya 02 Surpsosse Japour ay o7 pazaype ]TAs H asne29q, Sata s.g9][]49g UF ‘503301 03 pam YOLNjOADY UL] “sesseur aq TAO a1eIg ay Jo SaMeUT YSIARIs FAO WO} 9x 50 uftor aqp 01 stmoure [ps Saya UT “WET ayp JO UBLay oH, “kpoquia 01 paains ,ae'] ayp JO USt94, s,uoRnjoaay yuEZy auf IMP asorp O1 eNUOD >reIS UF Poors “6 TU “YT [enuas] asuas jo dayjenba we pue wopaayy e asaytueur suonou. {hog ‘sommueuMY omy uasANIq DUDB_IP & voLLUTOP Jo Jop0 yp UI Saas EMP ajqisuas ayp Jo VONNgERSEp oyp st a8uayjey> Avjd aaxy pure aoueseadde aazy snaypsae 2eyA\ aamyeu ut saauarayyip ymin aogid pur uomouny uy saouarayp Sungnuapt yr SoMaUYsaY Jo S>!N1Od zwsefueyo pur Aujear panty ovur aouezeadde aa1y Jo apnayos ayy suuzossiren yey ssasoud ays ssoyosOy2 S| UONESNpS Dnayssoy “souHadxa jo swear sypoads o1t voweredas Jo aouariadxa ou sey yorym ayy] Jo Sem v ‘oeds wounOD Sunrqeruy Jo Avm e st sassazdxa at seyp [fe osnesaq re 20U Strat asmesoq AaunUOD Jo ostUOIT & Stat FoyLO ay uo faveds uounttos arezedas ‘oyrsads e sommnsut Aqaraq pue aouarradxa oytzads © Jo 19alqo amp st a1 asnesoq xe S141 asne39q AarunuTuO> Jo ostuOsd ¥ st anaes axp “pULY, 2u0 ay uo :paraudiarut st aouatidxa ay moy wo Smmpuadap ‘sem arsoddo ou ur poosrapun aq ue> uoRNginsIp sip. ang “o]qiSuos ax yo uoRNgLZIsIp 2ytoads € Jo uorssaxdxa ay Sf 41 astes9q astuord feorayod socie anaexs ayy ‘ouapy ‘aft Jo arayds averedas © se are sooustradxa 1280] ou ‘suoneredas asaya ssouatsadxa 198uo] Ou “oor Ay se IejosuE ao4y st ey Aan nUWOD st sastwioad snip aoueseadde aazy jo uorsuadsns ap egg “Buraq Jo Aem 19a su ges peonUpr “GrumUTEIOD 8 70 Joraq poseys ayp auors o1ur Sunejsuen ang yromure, ue Supfeus 20u sea sone sep ay Sundqnos ur ‘asnesaq, sroymne si 10} ae 10U Ses a1 asMeI0q SM TOF IE St IMTeIS p07 ayp “OxBo] stIp UY -UoIBT[ax pue sonyod Gre ‘xx Aep -4a9a0 usomaaq uonezedas Aut yo aouariadxa ou sey YSIYsN ‘ssazayds aresedas o1ur popuarp you st aouatradxa paar] asoyau Aanmuroo & sf AsTUNWUIOS snoWOUOINe ‘ox v =PorIDAUT st wopaayy snp jo Suruvau ayy “uC ~MaruMuNUOD 9915 8 Jo oIssardxa agp st asned9q 3915 st I] “SoMsst aT BOUDyAN Agrmmurazos ayp Jo auounrodwio> ayp Jo uorssardxa aq $1 [sas v 29]79 UT st {{urOWOMNe sat ‘anaes appt auf Jo apname ayy, “MH ut passosdxa st rey apy] Jo apour ay? o1 surerted Auouoine sanveis oy ‘o/fue sypoue wos 49AIMOFT sasodurt 31 1242 Aquaissed pur uorssassod-tow jo aouariadxe ay ysnomp ‘aouereadde ayy yo ssausuens ap y8nomp poarooos uoRanpa 242 st uoRNjoAas jeonod soy uoNesuaduios 242 Se ‘uoREONpa sHAyASIe PUY “PION atau e Jo OISSassOd ayp sasnttosd ‘ssassod aseay oy) ur youNes aouatsadxo aroyasae Jo rDalqns aya Yaya ‘anaes sIyL “aouassa sit Jo se sontjod se sonauisey ssouypny axp yaa aut UL ase] 18 atto “autro9 07 AaruEUINY v JO asuosd yp pue GIueuINY [Ing s,ueM yo SreuI ayP szeaq IF rip “amqepeaeun jeoxper styp £q ‘ssouaBuEs sipralqns axp Jo spuo pue saxisep SyBnomp ayp 207 a]qissa0oeu Aes O2 st eM ‘Ffasat UO paso si a] “spua Jo pue sueaLL Jo VORBUIqUIOD Az9A2 03 ‘uOR Hox [fe 01 UBIax0y StF spIOM saqO Ur “IDa!qns ~ appt - ay ausoddo yjasu spjoy “Aarmarp ayp ayy ‘ness ay, “Tuawala ajgistas snosusform19y & Jo Jamod ayp st aoueswadde 9935 Spaopur ‘puey auio ay UO “Jaua} feNTU sures ay2 WL pauTeD -uoo are sausoddo om asaqp MOY 39s 01 sh suttIA YIM. SABTEYES WL OUeUDDS ay, ‘sUONE|A Jo pue smMorArYDG 70 uv asapour ¥ pue sUIIOS Jo Ize SUTTGNS & UadMIG I8~I2U09 aya Aq. epor pakoauos $1 yryn reyp ‘sontfod sit pur ae Sur{pauapt 105 sunBo1 suua ue Jo o1Boy ay saytzep> 3x02 satus “urede 2ouo ‘Surod stip uO * uone=npa, sit pue 29u9 -tradxa Snaypsoe Jo 9109 A194 ayp ut ‘{qdaap axour paipoy st uonpipenuo> aya asnesaq sdeyzad st sr ‘are peonyod pue 2x88 §.1Fe JO} Te woasI9q UOHDIpeNUOD OU St 210 JT aoeds UoUnHOD IuarayFIp € sauIpNO {pI uoUIDAOUK qadsaUEAD ay UT PazrPEMDE st 3 TIyI0 yp UO HOAUTL ay Jo aUMJOA qeISISaX aq UY pasop>uD St ation 01 apt] 2ar199q]0> 942 “uaER puEY euO 2B UO “sseUT uensiyD auf 10 aneays quaroue Yim ayqereduros ‘Grunt -Uio9 auf Jo [eIuowa: v si ay “uOsUN, puE aoeds ,pazaiypun, s,radedsmau ayp Sunnyar 0Iq AJOSUaS snoaUAZOINAY, v jo Aouarsisuos ayy sey waod ay) ‘Pury suo IyB UO +05] sign 01 sisone SUIETPEYY “uoUNUOD ay1 Jo LOREIBguOD satpour samsyord ypryat 148 Jo Aarpersarear stip jo woRds> -uo> 242 Ut ‘jase CaLuNd UTE IIUOD e st a19yB Ng “S91. yjod sip puv Angnd sare usoav9q so1guOD Ou St axIqLL, sonmodeiaur 21942 -soe Jo wuioy sejnonzed e s} sreonpord jo wonnjoaas ay, *su1z0j a1vas Jo WOTIMOAaI v O1 pasoddo se asuaIsIxa ayq[stas sopayysay Jo sontiod ve=p uouuiss) Jo 5 “PAH, uniBoug rpewuapsks Jo ys2pI0 24.1 “wHPOPIOH pur Jey peas o1 aqueyD ayp pey Survey moyryyy “2109 anos uounjoaar jo apt ue ose Inq wonnjosar SnoNsee JO vapr te auyap auruesBord sty pip 01 sasodoxd yoy ‘son -Hodeiaur & Ajjeniuassa s1 ‘az0yazay ‘aunutesBosd Suaypsae, a4 ‘a1eys ajdoad ax pue amo axp prog Yom wr sjaqoq uoumuios put saouatradxa jo anssn Susy © ont ‘spaom ayIO Ur {XBopORpAU Iua!oUE 4OF JuaMADe|das v OIUL WOK tuna 01 ‘agisuas seapr sapuss 01 st rasuersBosduiarshg 21saiyy svg Sq paresoape ,tionesnpa snaqasae, Jo se au] e 200 “arnuHOD ,jensurstIOD, v Jo WOR -eU0} atp peais sir ur Sunes|nwOsd “arpensuassip [eoRIjod Jo aonseid ayp “at “ysruea 01 sonyod yo sonarpsoe, ay sasne9 21 ‘pury 2u0 3ip UG “woReUTUNa ployou e si>EuD spef Ur pue aqduus 003 st 9x pue Yeap Uaa4a10q UoRIsoddO SHYT, “apt sit JO uaUNPoquID ajqysuas ay Aq paystmoU Agranuraioo arp jo somod Satay aq pue avers Jo wistuey>our peop sy waamiaq apeur st isenuoa e owuesBord stm UY gq SHUUSHDAP] UaqasInaq sap uausDLBOLduarsKS a1SaI12 seq Ayaureu “UTZaplOH pue Burjayps ‘foSopy Aq roy280r wantin 1x01 snourey ay dn suns einuoy I9UIDINS sIy +[azquas] asuas jo Auunutuos & jo worreur10j pAb wonnyOxsT suasse 11 “pamauiar 0720/ ap st sanmteumy ot uoaavioq HOR -eredas ay yorya ut azkag jo uoRINjoaas on woRNyoaas [E> nyjod surede :uornjoaas jo sada oma uaoauiaq uorsoddo uv sei uonrsodord si ‘uonetMop moysra prom. ug sonijod se sonayysey v 10y ajdiourzd aanvsouaé aya out uoneuluop Jo suonejaa ayp Jo worsuadsns sonaypsae uuoysten 01 sasodosd ey 2U0 St UoHnjoaas Snaxpsae sq paroidap o1eus>s oy, “yes wo} step Jo oRDIpenuoD soUUT ay YBNosp ose ang ‘2yl| JO suHdoy JaxRo PUE WHO} ansAe WadK19q LOREL vedas axp y8nomp quo 10u ‘paazosord Ajparyeou st astunosd Jeonyod yprga uF som ay Jo aun aueasisas ays st axa Sraypo ay2 UO ‘afl| JO MITOF ¥ satODaq ‘Ize Sv aoUAZ—AP SIE Bu1seys Aq Gre Yorya ur uORNJOADT snaxpsee 40} 1DoL03d B SI uy ‘puRY uO ay1 UG TOIIND LoMIAIyXa sAepor pue ase ay Aq pasodosd diysuonvjas yo sadda aanoe “rauu! pue att 10] suontsodosd axp ur pue saydosojryd ay Aq pouordureyp yo oensqe ayp Jo axpou auigns ayy UF passant se ‘samngig ox omy suds ,vonvonpa, snoy3soe Sarojataqp. ‘snajonu feataurepuny sty Jo siseq 242 UO, “ayy Jo wry eo. uomeunoysuen su ‘areas ayezedas v sv 238 jo auf on stumoure astword rey Jo waUL|YlNy aqp ang “eoned ~rpureuta Jo astusoad ¥ satsse> apnatfos S470 aL, FIOM IE S(Burseasun pue Aseu!3130 st ey UORDTPesUOD v st 9:94], -aimdng usopounsod ous} axoq | “i7e YSnomp uouediouew Jo 10 AwouoIne sue Jo aumUaape asTuTapoU 12938 ap oF pua ue and sey Surayj & JO UORse ax Ov ssauaRpE onetASTe soneygsay Jo sontiod 9€£261 ut paonposd seas worsi9s jeusBu0 ypus.g) G66r “SOO 2H0Z SHOR MN. “ysIOG -UOs{oyPIN pleuod ‘sueN *2}2e,20ds 2g3 Jo A4706 244) ‘oz “4 “2661 * surg ‘0661-0061 ‘7Uozq1 ua LY “spe ‘poy [Nea PUE sey ur ‘and apbaseyd ase, 1 anbuseyd ae, spusg) Z00z $0812 swopuoy ‘a8ruy ag Jo aumny oq ut UO).<, a1 orm uonuaazoIut Jo wos 4a9A9 wogy sjasnr BurysMEuN -sip Aq Aarotayjod sur Strasse waoy ‘sonmod & yons uy “uw; aueisisax ay Jo sonyod ayp Ajaurem 498 ur wy Jo uoR “euruny> ue sosnyar Te suo ayp Ajasioaud st ase Jo ountBar dtasqasoe ays 01 aytoads ,sontjod, Jo unio e918 19"po ay ‘asrurosd snatpsae spunoy yore AaruaS -oxanoy ajqusuas aup Sreunma a ye Ade UF FPS aveUTUTD ay 1eyp Jpesa azqqeas yYsom ay rey spueuIap wLIOY sexy amp Jo sonyjod axp ‘saseo asaya [Te uy ,,,“aperads-Bury aqp Jo x10} a¢f1 ur pareuaye ‘9x1 191A0g 10 SHEED Jo AANA ayp isureBe avaq 01 ayBn0Ig puogaqy And reYp AeId Jo ada pue aaugp wegan arp jo yur aysrur am wrese 3G ,," Aayeax srasepd ajqearisa ayp st y>i rar Surpumoxms m0 Wo sounsip sf rey SuMpauos, se ase BuAEurUNTD step ‘pH OVUL parsalosd Aoamp nq sioalgo aresedas se asayruvar 19800] ow are aamidinos puv Suputed yorja ur saoeds paresSaruy uisop 01 snoavapua ays Jo sur 3y8tu ayy “SyYOM wMISTAT PUE UOHINASUOD 1IA0g UsdMIAG gTEL UE YoLaEYY Wey ou st axey. ‘axopT WISIpeUNIO} SneD0UIap Jo ssoueseadde oy yA posuod 6 sonyjog se sonaunsay £161 DIpnbseg ougBng seg “Joos y.T MEW 3980y, -sip Aqjeuy sey rey2 Apmurusos v Jo suzy araxU0D ax aonpord o7 ayqe st Karrensiurs sir Surssouddns Kq “preps are uv Jo vapr ays areys pungyz9g, aq Jo sxs9UIBUa ay pur puareypeyy 120d amd, au ‘s2ouaraygip stayp SupueaseptAION, ‘aqissod st se sissford Areuonnjoxss wo rey se 9q, on paindas sasnze asoquids asoxp stuney osje at ing + pnsejd pesos, snag ydasof pur sisueqan astuonens jo sioafoad uerdomn ap on Surremoy uteBe az0j0q ‘sneyneg, Dup pus pungy9A, ay Jo sisauyue pue sisourBua ayn Aq, sea If Se ,,{a7e [B1D0s, JO ssaonpoud se aun stay UE ParEK, ‘Suauanout ooaq ay aqp Jo suesnize ayp Aq ureSe dn waren sea 3] uaUIDAOUT SYED) pu SY oyp Jo sISHITE ays ‘Say. aPPIAY UeLeruNWUIOD puE [eURSHIE dyp Jo suIvaZ Jy ut ‘pandsur Apeasye ay “ire jo aunfax snaqasae amp yu per.st a] “wornjoaad 1a1A0g ax Jo SasMre IsFANANT 50 asneurardns ay pur sivouiSue asianonnsuo Aq oe sum duos parunouue “xe jo uoneuTUN, ay2 Jo auUEZBOId au OF panunty 20U st aft] au103aq a4e, Jo 15alord ayy ayd -onseie uelsei[2103, pur ,veidoin, 01 woRNjoAar snap -sae Jo any sty aonpar 02 3}duns 002 ssopay49AIU St IY “aq sau aq 103 saaytpa JO pUE ayt| Jo SuLIO} Jo UORONAISHOD ay UE ANsUEBOIIIOY onayasae pue Aajensuassip jeonyod jo uoneuruns auiol ay ssumurer8oxd aures a1p 01 paroype apis Ye aouls “SOZSL ayy UF apseB-ruexe onsmre ay pue prensuea aspcepy aq uaasiag paSraura ammoun{ v yatta uo siseq ay pausz0} uonesynuspr sty ‘paonpord are Aay yor ur sdiysuon -¥]pr [eID0s ayp pe sisa{qo axp yroq seonpord aou0 1e OYA auo ay ‘ueut aanonposd Kjaurew sweur snayasae jo uoR, -voynuap! Suzmpus pur mau e sea pasodosd xrepy Tey suayjox autres axp dg “2oueseadde ayp pey zaaa e jpey foureD xIEPY “YeIP WaN08I0y sonaupsay Jo sont od 8e(6ror eusn0 29) 9007 “sag RIOSOUUEPY Jo AysxoMUN ssyodeoUUIPY sOIU>y, np aqoy “SUE “SHY MIN, Jo Kydosopid “OWIOPY JOPO>K I... woyy sisa{qo Suniqnyxa-a3 pue Bu~mozzog Ep snorago ayp o1 dn aaey asnicr Aqpeay am ‘raaamoy ‘kep 2UQ) aye pasord st ‘uonedisueuta jo astword ay ‘ostuord onayp sae aya ‘amseafd yt wayp 01 warsty US WED ssea IMO JT gcuondssap st Sunpiroas ssajun, Sowopy pres ‘preay, aq re8u0] ou ues Kimiuas qudaioutH ay Jo suopes ax panreypua ep sproy> qpiuanas-paystuTap ayy, “AuylqEsuEs Jo SUHOJ Om uo9MI9g UORISoddo UvaATEOR sq soIIDS ~uooer fem v Ua Aqazeyp pue {asa sfzom ays Jo aumrxon TeHosuas ap ut paysyqeisa aq ‘ostuiord amp jo werprens 2ouarayyip Snoypsoe 1ey spueuIWO> y “2auINbasuo> AAKDy 2; IM sBu1zq ArNTod 520m op Jo WOIsIA sm, ‘aoua -podxaU0303 Jo wsoy As9x9 Bulsnyas sea os Surop jo 109 ay Ing Spaureias st uonredisueura jo asnuosd ay ‘orSoy step. Uy “quauadolua pue 420% jo uopresedas istpextdes ay sir spunoy yoryaa rey Surypesos Aq juamafuesre jeotayser [AFAMKAG | 410M snowoUOMeE x2 Sunqimstp snp ‘readde 01 passazdas ayy jo urers ayy sasne> Ssqowumnguy styy Susna sy uy ng -uondumsuos rsrpeardes sseur Jo sionpord ayp uem? ueumYu!, arour “fesueysour a10ur uaAa aq 02 sey >PFOM ay Kjaanoaya sampourwto> Jo swaUIYst|aquio 242 pue yom Jo uoIsIAIp IsENdeD ay sounouap 01 api Ut :XwOUOIDIaY Ployom e IEF ur st ‘owsopy Aq pazipemdasuoo se Syrom werBraqua0y95 ayp Jo Awouoie s4Z “pyom payouoas-uoU ay O2 saypsar YOM axp YTGA Aq aoueosstp aq Jo ‘uonsIpen -uo> yeusaru Jo Aatand ayp st sazizoy;ne apnitjos simp rey Agund ay “uoneunyye-yyas onsne Jo Anyesnper oyp ut Soop 3] wey azour ou SOM dtp Jo apmarjos ajduns ayp ut apisar Ir sonyjog se sanausay jou soop yenuatod stp ang “piiom pazarsturtape atp jo pue sampowmsos pazionayysae Jo sto} ay woz uoRezedas Temper sir yaIM pare1osse st jenuaod jesnyod syz0M Dy, “sonaIpsae soWOpY UF paremnsdeoua st rey pururap sign Sf af “ap pazionatpsae yo suuz0y ayy omer uonEpUNsse su Woy pur ie Jeonyodeisw e O1U! VoMeMTOJsUEN sit logy eamp pjojoau e tos} 1 aaeg “voHEduEUIA 307 [eH -uiaiod sit samnansuoo asojaiaqi pur Strouome 5,338 Jo 0103 ap suTs0} Teyp a]QISUAS a4p JO AarouaBora1ay ayp IDaI0Ad 2439 Surs}jex & ut porejnsdesua st aururesBoxd sy “aourasep 4700 aroys Aq WSIpseB-WeAE onsHsAse pue wsIprBquEAE [LD -uijod saqpo8o1 Surg 01 9a0ns uoMIpen ay, “ozI[eusaIUT OF aure> uormpen astpres-aueae jesntjod ajoysn v rey “299795 -JIpUE AraA §}70m ay 0 pan ‘AaroHOd Jo wxoy SIH st ap ‘uonusarom jesriyod Jo suu0y 1] Burproae Sound sar surerar ar yey ostaosd aya uo eontod st ze are yo adda e pure ase sv jos Sumer Aq sontjod sayeut yep wre jo ada e usamiaq pounroy Agazaya sf asenIOD Y ay] pezustysee Aepésaaa Jo rey wiogy ze Jo uMLOSUIS at jo uoneredas Jeo1pex sit jo 1p Sq ‘aA0dsip pjnom suonessuss yuanbasqns sv “oarssaaqns st ay Aypserary Te Ssouazajaid ype spuadsns 1 yore oy Aq, poaroidFI0A 2qp UF pasoppus st asnuosd ueneaTeBg ao arey JOU O21 sf, ‘ope ILM owZpy se “Ary Jo UOTIOUNY [eID0s aL. “PIPL, Sf ays asnesaq asnuosd ‘sortre> ssoppo8 weLIOTTIIS at, “waoy sty Soyer apy] TeYD are UF st ar KreUOD ay UO “ay Jo WLIO} atoDaq O1 aavy 10M SOP IZW “pHOM auepunUT d OF sonayysay Jo s>! Seanona aqp waamiaq uolstan aysisiad pue AreuS0 ue st ae peSeBua pur axes 5338 J0y 138 usas1q uoMIsoddo s1Wap -228 ofp UI pue “aqipounsod pue Aamuzapout Jo oueus9s Iwauy] a4 UF TPoq azTuBor—s a1oyas9qp ysnUt 9M BULA “sn anes ue> por v KUO YIM Woy aydonsere> peoIO] -03u0 ue Jo amieu [eqo}8 aq 01 paonpas aze ‘uonedoueuD Je 40 ‘uoreuRtOp Jo sUIIO} [Je YT ut pur uondaaxa aya jo sontodiyare ue o1ur paajossip st Aayjensuassip eourjod ‘ypIyar UF ayBnoy Areioduronuod Jo atasmMD ajoyan vy puey-ur-pury 5808 AarauaBororsy snaypsse Jo uOLMossIp Teonpe sty. “sonmjod pue ase quog “ure8e 20u0 Sno Sumo ~ueo ‘SsoUt1M SuLswaq Jo 2Jsea [EOI ayp Yara we Jo 0M. ay Surdgnuapr dq img ‘ppios dxosuas aq Jo oNNTOASL Jo sonyodeiaur yo 14ed se 198110] OW “os Soop a] “ano po||20uUR> Stay aeep amo! sexo oy? Ie Jost! soyst dors” W210} aueysiseu 9xp Jo sonmod arp ‘ureSe axa] “anne aydonseae> jo Sowur ay2 sdooy pue susno1a ayn s9a0 soyosea Ie ENNIS app soda apseF1ueAL oy Jo sxoze|g]TeA ay] N Buoy q uns APSnonunUos aydonseres yo ysis oIp pur 22429 a2 Jo somod ayy 01 AuourIsar azote auTOD9q 01 spuar aze papreng Ajsnojeaf sty ‘oun owes ayn ae Sng sur pue sudis ‘211 pue ze uaaauaq sazrepunog ay» Buuzmyq PIM pardnosoard ‘ssaussojasox ses0duiou09 uo quaWiespnt 941 -eBou 1Jes9A0 we sassed 41 puy “sanjea pur smoreyag ‘3p -|MOUY{ Jo swI0} Jo LORN]ossIp 2nes>0up a—P 3930M09 01 uonronpe apias-ueayqndas & ysyqeiso-21 01 puewop 1eyR sapnane [eantjod our parerodrosut aq 4q[sv9 ue uoReID -unuap sty "eade[nUNs isuTeBE suBKS yo pue suds surese seSewt jo ‘sofeun isurede sfunp jo ‘Sionposd eanyjno asureSe S3}J0m Jo ‘A1a190s, 1sUTeBe ,pproas, 4p Jo aDuaj—ap 3uR PurIs Y>IYM Jo apis dures ay pure suo uo auTpuoIy Sunnansut ‘ermayn> ysure¥e Tequios e dn soyyes smyp uy saamyng dos Jenxes 10 sno {eIOs snoueA ow peplaip soyzuny ‘ammo, & owt ue arerBoIur o1 siduone pur fuRrox0y st a1 woym or sdnoxi peIo0s aya 3 a9s0/9 uv Suq 01 Surure 2eya suregge AIppom ayn ype wos; rede aye jo aouaxayytp [etserwur yp aarasond on apBsiuns ayp yi aouersisar sep sareyrunsse 41 Spuey a0 ax UO “SuONIsod Om WasmI9q B1EI|!>S0 01 spt. Woy wersisar ay JO sonyodeiowr oy “22U2xy RRO avy Jo Jamod ayp Jo Auownsas aind sy sowor0q “PHO B Jo UONDIPENUOD a paquosut yoryan “euIBIUD sy:0M ay “# SurIgeT 19y1O ay o1 preHar pM Kouapuadap 2]qeipourouar s,purur ap 01 SurAynisaa Aq asruosd yons {42N9 AIwpIPAU! 02 SoU I! “KavNUOD dy3 UO “MoLedIUELHD Jo asruord xp 10y saypnoa s28Uo] OU AarauATOTAIAY ayqisuas spjsoas sup Sarsan[e apgerpattiazs we yo romod axp wo3y uo -vuoT[e s,purur axp 01 Bunsen ‘uosaqzsIY B42 Jo xOYs oy saquiosut asnire ayy “weudofua pue mogey jo uonspes -uod ay SuoRopEnuos Surd1seD-ssnu0Id ayp 19BUO] OU St soq}iosuy ashe ayp TeYA\ “pariaaut sf BuSeN seep Jo asuas S29a ay2 IN “aMYIND feDIaUNOD Jo sioMposd oy Woy urede syoauze sias rey Arepunog a[qndasiad e Suen soajoaut [jns apreS-1ueae snsture ax o1 paudisse 4S") aT, OyTSar SUNGs ayp Jo oNAYISAE UETPIIOA] 9y2 Y>IYA OF 1a [eontjod wory WauNpperap 4794 sw o1 syuEMp [ESTO ‘Sfom snowouorsysnomouome ay} Jo attT] SH St IT “mo gpasit sipoues asaford Aran sit yor 28 anny e st au043 Puy som eontjod Ayjeontode, ayp Jo ousaqeip e st azayp Ing ‘amadnr wropounsod ou st azau, -2ft] aan29I]0> jo suxI0} DIP wos; 310m ayfi Jo apruyjos arp Ize-tow jo 2ey2 WiOI} ue jo urewlop ay BunvouINs 104 eUOMID sneUIBeId Te jo uoneura ayy Aq paruedwosoe aray st “{ureas snowou some pnb wy Jo kapr at spumoy yor ‘aouarradxo nays “sav yo AWOUIOINE ULL “SotTENUOD Ud9AK19q UOISUAY ay. JO paar skeasye sey auifox siyy “Gasnus sit UY a7e jo sundex onatpsoe amp SaIeUNTUE pue sasnyUT UOIStA: asoyM SIUDULA|2 dustuoSeiue ‘uoIssz0ons feroduias fo wLOy ayp UT “IDafoxd [papingsn Aawropounsod pur 1 Od wJO ssaoxa Azan ayy Aq payqnopos st suSis om sBuryp jo uoneuZoysuresa ay YOTya UI P]iOM e Jo Aamadazod aya Ut poquasut Butaq sysiz uv eouD “smoraeyaq pure s2>9/G0 Avpizana punjaq pended Jo susis ay2 19,09sIp 01 stomata SYSe aI SE sejosuT “pHOM e Jo JoIDeIeY >]qQuI9IOIU! 30 Aavssg00U-UOU 242 01 sisone aeyp aouEsadde aueIsIsos oy jo ssauaSuens aqp ‘Butop os Aq ‘s|[Py seoueseodde sasjossip pur Surpueasiapun spying Yorya 330m op ‘puey soo ay UO “PHOM quAIsIXa aya UNpEA Woy “MOI 02 P[IOAL B JO suo] roNIStOD 01 PUE SUAAIS AIOsUIDs Jo HOREANSyUOD ap, a8ueyD 02 prq & ut ssaz0rd jeoprod e 01 pamtumwi0> pease aze pareurwiop ay rey sosoddnsard AaiSede> wv yans jo Buroay ayI ‘MON “If WHTOFSUER Or AaedeD soy UT aoUap -yuo> 358] ays asnesaq. inq sieyye Jo ayes Bunsixo oy puerszepunsqur ays osnedaq uoneupzogns ut wrewar 10 op paxeuruop ay, “uonenojdxa jo save] ay jo uoneurjdxa ue asmbar sjarex pawojdxo ayy “suonenms pur sapmue femparaiur woysten or djay Yjasu Jo pur ur Vou soop Burpuessiapun “puey suo ay uO “umouy [Jam st 1>a{o1d yp sendejd sey Arepuenb ayy. uoneussoystres p]LOs 4 aua8e sno1ostoo ¥ o1ur JoxeIDods oy2 IM} OF UONeMTUOP JO suistueypaur aya JO ssauaZEME pling O21 Ino Stes IeyI ue Jo adAi v st ure yeoqau9 ‘uorssardxa [esouaf aso sat Uy UY [POHUD Jo suoneuuojsued, pue swajqolg Sox MANY “eK SHySssANUA [>UIED “Loaqy pur sia) 40} jooqps a4p 38 TOOT aunf wt 22a{Gns auIeS aIp UO PI>y IEUAUDS v OL poigapur ose aze Aayyp “eueiodumuo wy,p nasnpy 3xp jo ssardsne ay Zo07 Sepy mt prey 521 01 sues padojasap tpog atas 9u0 Burmojos oy puP sordey> sty, aq aysrar 41 2eYPA pu st ppm ay Tey Taeaiaq TosIZEdUIOD v 40 uoneurmop jo uoneuE|dxa te sayRTE SFM ay JO WIOF ay uy ‘soueue yorya woford e fae esau, yo ‘ojduns Apuaredde os ‘oafosd ay uo ysiam avy siuressuo> |e -rxopered ayp pureisrapun o1 sn djay wes 1 ang “seidoan jo 40 A403sty{ JO ‘SouaHfod Jo pus ays 2A¥y s194I0 se sonaKpSe Jo pud 342 aounouUL o7 sn saZqqo suEaUE ou Xq “pare “Tuna 928 Woy Jo Yrog Yr Ie autod suinxe oy pur 80] pasoddo asaya Sunejosy “won uny 11 saxfeur ER Ose sta ang “We Jo suniBar nampsae ayy suawarp soayod oma soup ua9MN29q UOISKIN ay], “GORNGURSIp & Y>nS st SoHoTASOY sontjod jo wx0y wreysan e or a BULAa apqisuas ayp jo uonnqmsip oysads v mnoysim ae OW SF aay “YRS sea soyBUap! Yan AatATSMasIp PUL AaIqISEA JO WFO} 2yIoads e moqua we om st s1WP eadax OY -sonampsae, Kq Ue jo uoneides snonsesip & usaq sey ax9q) ey apnj>u0> 01 Aressanau sueaur ou Aq st mf ‘reaamoy ‘siya WOIy “2U9 aadxo aytoads e yo 1sa(qo axp se are Aprauapl amr yoryar You might also like
The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck: A Counterintuitive Approach to Living a Good LifeFrom EverandThe Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck: A Counterintuitive Approach to Living a Good LifeRating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5 (5825) The Gifts of Imperfection: Let Go of Who You Think You're Supposed to Be and Embrace Who You AreFrom EverandThe Gifts of Imperfection: Let Go of Who You Think You're Supposed to Be and Embrace Who You AreRating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5 (1093) Never Split the Difference: Negotiating As If Your Life Depended On ItFrom EverandNever Split the Difference: Negotiating As If Your Life Depended On ItRating: 4.5 out of 5 stars4.5/5 (852) Grit: The Power of Passion and PerseveranceFrom EverandGrit: The Power of Passion and PerseveranceRating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5 (590) Hidden Figures: The American Dream and the Untold Story of the Black Women Mathematicians Who Helped Win the Space RaceFrom EverandHidden Figures: The American Dream and the Untold Story of the Black Women Mathematicians Who Helped Win the Space RaceRating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5 (903) Shoe Dog: A Memoir by the Creator of NikeFrom EverandShoe Dog: A Memoir by the Creator of NikeRating: 4.5 out of 5 stars4.5/5 (541) The Hard Thing About Hard Things: Building a Business When There Are No Easy AnswersFrom EverandThe Hard Thing About Hard Things: Building a Business When There Are No Easy AnswersRating: 4.5 out of 5 stars4.5/5 (349) Elon Musk: Tesla, SpaceX, and the Quest for a Fantastic FutureFrom EverandElon Musk: Tesla, SpaceX, and the Quest for a Fantastic FutureRating: 4.5 out of 5 stars4.5/5 (474) Her Body and Other Parties: StoriesFrom EverandHer Body and Other Parties: StoriesRating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5 (823) The Sympathizer: A Novel (Pulitzer Prize for Fiction)From EverandThe Sympathizer: A Novel (Pulitzer Prize for Fiction)Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars4.5/5 (122) The Emperor of All Maladies: A Biography of CancerFrom EverandThe Emperor of All Maladies: A Biography of CancerRating: 4.5 out of 5 stars4.5/5 (271) The Little Book of Hygge: Danish Secrets to Happy LivingFrom EverandThe Little Book of Hygge: Danish Secrets to Happy LivingRating: 3.5 out of 5 stars3.5/5 (403) The World Is Flat 3.0: A Brief History of the Twenty-first CenturyFrom EverandThe World Is Flat 3.0: A Brief History of the Twenty-first CenturyRating: 3.5 out of 5 stars3.5/5 (2259) The Yellow House: A Memoir (2019 National Book Award Winner)From EverandThe Yellow House: A Memoir (2019 National Book Award Winner)Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5 (98) Devil in the Grove: Thurgood Marshall, the Groveland Boys, and the Dawn of a New AmericaFrom EverandDevil in the Grove: Thurgood Marshall, the Groveland Boys, and the Dawn of a New AmericaRating: 4.5 out of 5 stars4.5/5 (266) A Heartbreaking Work Of Staggering Genius: A Memoir Based on a True StoryFrom EverandA Heartbreaking Work Of Staggering Genius: A Memoir Based on a True StoryRating: 3.5 out of 5 stars3.5/5 (231) Team of Rivals: The Political Genius of Abraham LincolnFrom EverandTeam of Rivals: The Political Genius of Abraham LincolnRating: 4.5 out of 5 stars4.5/5 (234) On Fire: The (Burning) Case for a Green New DealFrom EverandOn Fire: The (Burning) Case for a Green New DealRating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5 (74) The Unwinding: An Inner History of the New AmericaFrom EverandThe Unwinding: An Inner History of the New AmericaRating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5 (45)