Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MA Topic 2 03102022
MA Topic 2 03102022
Universidade do Minho
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
Ofélia Pinto
Ofélia Pinto
1
02/10/2022
operating departments 3
Ofélia Pinto
Ofélia Pinto
4
2
02/10/2022
Ofélia Pinto
5
Ofélia Pinto
6
3
02/10/2022
operating departments
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
Ofélia Pinto
operating departments
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
Dual-rate method:
• segregates costs within each cost pool into two segments
‒ a variable-cost pool
‒ a fixed-cost pool
• each pool uses a different cost-allocation base
• treats fixed and variable costs more realistically, but is
more complex to implement.
Ofélia Pinto
4
02/10/2022
dual rates
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
Ofélia Pinto
10
10
5
02/10/2022
operating departments 11
Ofélia Pinto
11
operating departments 12
Ofélia Pinto
12
6
02/10/2022
operating departments 13
Ofélia Pinto
13
operating departments 14
Ofélia Pinto
14
7
02/10/2022
operating departments 15
15
operating departments 16
Ofélia Pinto
16
8
02/10/2022
17
Ofélia Pinto
17
operating departments 18
18
9
02/10/2022
departments 19
Ofélia Pinto
19
departments 20
Direct method:
• allocates support costs only to operating
departments
• no interaction between support departments
prior to allocation.
Ofélia Pinto
20
10
02/10/2022
departments 21
Ofélia Pinto
21
departments 22
Ofélia Pinto
22
11
02/10/2022
departments 23
Ofélia Pinto
23
departments 24
Step-down method:
• allocates support costs to other support departments
and to operating departments that partially recognize
the mutual services provided among all support
departments
• one-way interaction between support departments prior
to allocation.
Ofélia Pinto
24
12
02/10/2022
departments 25
Step-down method:
Ofélia Pinto
25
Ofélia Pinto
26
13
02/10/2022
departments
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
27
Reciprocal method:
• allocates support department costs to operating
departments by fully recognizing the mutual services
provided among all support departments
• full two-way interaction between support departments prior
to allocation.
Ofélia Pinto
27
departments 28
P = 6.300.000 + 276.750
Ofélia Pinto
P = 6.576.750
28
14
02/10/2022
departments 29
Reciprocal method:
Ofélia Pinto
29
departments 30
Overview of methods:
• reciprocal is the most precise
• direct and step-down are simple to compute and understand
• direct method is widely used.
Ofélia Pinto
30
15
02/10/2022
Ofélia Pinto
31
Universidade do Minho
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
32
Ofélia Pinto
32
16
02/10/2022
33
33
34
Ofélia Pinto
34
17
02/10/2022
35
Ofélia Pinto
35
single rate
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
36
Ofélia Pinto
36
18
02/10/2022
single rate
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
37
Ofélia Pinto
37
single rate
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
38
Ofélia Pinto
38
19
02/10/2022
single rate 39
Ofélia Pinto
39
dual rates
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
40
40
20
02/10/2022
dual rates
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
41
Ofélia Pinto
41
dual rates
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
42
Ofélia Pinto
42
21
02/10/2022
dual rates
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
43
$45.500
Magazine 35%
(35% x $130.000)
$52.000
Book 40%
(40% x $130.000)
Ofélia Pinto
43
dual rates
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
44
$32.500 $49.300
$16.800
Catalogue
($14 x 1.200)
$45.500 $70.700
$25.200
Magazine
($14 x 1.800)
$52.000 $78.600
$26.600
Book
($14 x 1.900)
Ofélia Pinto
44
22
02/10/2022
dual rates
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
45
Things to note:
• Fixed costs have not been “unitized”, as allocation base
ratios were used to allocated fixed costs
• Ratios stay constant until long-term capacity changes
• Ultimately dual rates provide more accurate support
department cost allocation, as they use the “cause and
effect” rule
Ofélia Pinto
45
46
Dual
Department Single rate Allocation
rate Allocation
$48.000 $49.300
Catalogue
$72.000 $70.700
Magazine
$76.000 $78.600
Book
Ofélia Pinto
46
23
02/10/2022
departments? 47
Ofélia Pinto
47
48
The Issue
Should actual or budgeted support department costs be
allocated to operating departments?
The answer?
Budgeted costs should be allocated for two main reasons
1. It allows allocation of support department costs during
the period – more timely information
2. It provides more equitable information for the
evaluation of operating and support department
managers
Ofélia Pinto
48
24
02/10/2022
49
Ofélia Pinto
49
50
Ofélia Pinto
50
25
02/10/2022
51
51
52
Ofélia Pinto
52
26
02/10/2022
53
53
54
54
27
02/10/2022
department?
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
55
Ofélia Pinto
55
56
Ofélia Pinto
56
28
02/10/2022
Illustration
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
57
Mainten.
Hours # 80 -- 150 130 140 500
57
Illustration
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
58
Ofélia Pinto
58
29
02/10/2022
Initial Costs
$70,000 $80,000 $300,000 $350,000 $480,000
Cleaning 24% 32% 44%
Ratios (1200/5000) (1600/5000) (2200/5000)
Cleaning No
Alloc’n -$70,000 Allocation $16,800 $22,400 $30,800
Mainten. 35.7% 30.95% 33.34%
Ratios (150/420) (130/420) (140/420)
Mainten. No
Alloc’n Allocation -$80,000 $28,560 $24,760 $26,680
Totals $0 $0 $345,360 $397,160 $537,480
Ofélia Pinto
59
60
Ofélia Pinto
60
30
02/10/2022
(ranking)
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
61
Ofélia Pinto
61
(ranking)
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
62
What if;
• Cleaning costs were only $10.000 and
• Maintenance costs were $800.000
Ofélia Pinto
62
31
02/10/2022
(ranking)
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
63
BUT
• $128.000 (16% of $800.000) of Maintenance costs will not
be allocated to Cleaning (as allocation is only one-way)
» even though Cleaning caused these costs to
be incurred through its use of Maintenance
services
» Instead, this $128.000 will be allocated
directly to the operating departments –
inaccurate allocation
Ofélia Pinto
63
(ranking) 64
Ofélia Pinto
64
32
02/10/2022
(ranking) 65
BUT
• $2.000 (20% of $10.000) of Cleaning costs will not be
allocated to Maintenance (as allocation is only one-way)
– even though Cleaning caused these costs to be incurred
through its use of Maintenance services
Ofélia Pinto
65
this course 66
Ofélia Pinto
66
33
02/10/2022
illustration 67
Cleaning
- 1.250 1.200 1.600 2.200
Hours
Ratios ,20 ,192 ,256 ,352
- 1.250/6.250 1.200/6.250 1.600/6.250 2.200/6.25
0
Mainten.
Hours - 150 130 140
Ratios ,357 ,31 ,333
150/420 130/420 140/420
Ofélia Pinto
67
(rounded) 68
Ofélia Pinto
68
34
02/10/2022
69
Ofélia Pinto
69
70
Maintenance costs
M = $80.000 + ,20($70.000+,16M)
Cleaning Costs
C= $70.000 + ,16($97.107)
70
35
02/10/2022
Reciprocal Method
Universidade do Minho
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
71
Initial Costs
$70.000 $80.000 $300.000 $350.000 $480.000
Cleaning
,2 ,192 ,256 ,352
Ratios
Alloc’n -$85.537 $17.107 $16.423 $21.898 $30.109
Mainten.
,16 ,30 ,26 ,28
Ratios
Alloc’n $15.537 -$97.107 $29.132 $25.248 $27.190
Totals $0 $0 $345.555 $397.146 $537.299
Ofélia Pinto
71
Comparison of Methods
Universidade do Minho
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
72
Direct Sequential
Reciprocal Method
Method Method
Catalogue $345.360 $347.012 $345.555
Magazine $397.160 $397.015 $397.146
Book $537.480 $535.973 $537.299
Total $1.280.000 $1.280.000 $1.280.000
Ofélia Pinto
72
36
02/10/2022
Comparison of Methods
Universidade do Minho
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão
73
Ofélia Pinto
73
37