Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 37

02/10/2022

Universidade do Minho
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

Topic 2: Allocation of support-


department costs

Ofélia Pinto

LEARNING OBJECTIVES: Chapter 13 Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

• Distinguish the single-rate method from the dual-rate


method
• Describe the way in which the choice between budgeted
and actual cost-allocation rates affects the uncertainty
that users face
• Allocate support-department costs using the direct
method, the step-down method, and the reciprocal
method

Ofélia Pinto

1
02/10/2022

Allocating costs of a support department to Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

operating departments 3

• Operating (production) department – directly adds


value to a product or service.
• Support (service) department – provides the services
that assist other internal departments in the company.

Ofélia Pinto

Why allocate support department costs? Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

1. To provide information to support decision-making in


relation to the use of support activities

2. To provide information to help department managers


understand the economic consequences of their
decisions regarding support services

3. To provide information to motivate department


managers and other employees to manage support
department costs more effectively

4. To provide information for evaluating responsibility


centre and/or manager performance

Ofélia Pinto
4

2
02/10/2022

Allocation of support department costs Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

• Support department costs need to be allocated to the


cost objects that cause those costs
o These cost objects include -
• Other departments that use support services

• And ultimately, products or services

• Why allocate these costs?


o Remember the uses for cost allocations from earlier
lecture?

Ofélia Pinto
5

What are the issues? Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

Five (5) issues in allocating support department costs


1. Which allocation bases should be used to allocate support
department costs?
2. Should single or dual rates be used?
3. Should budgeted or actual usage of support departments be
used to allocate costs?
4. Should budgeted or actual support department costs be
allocated?
5. When there are multiple departments, which method of
allocating support department costs should be used?

Ofélia Pinto
6

3
02/10/2022

Allocating costs of a support department to Universidade do Minho

operating departments
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

Single-rate and dual-rate methods


Single-rate method – allocates costs in each cost pool (service
department) to cost objects (production departments) using the
same rate per unit of a single allocation base.
• No distinction is made between fixed and variable costs in this
method.
• Is this reasonable? – Sometimes fixed costs can be incorrectly
allocated (over or under-allocated if a single rate is used)

Ofélia Pinto

Allocating costs of a support department to Universidade do Minho

operating departments
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

Dual-rate method:
• segregates costs within each cost pool into two segments
‒ a variable-cost pool
‒ a fixed-cost pool
• each pool uses a different cost-allocation base
• treats fixed and variable costs more realistically, but is
more complex to implement.

Ofélia Pinto

4
02/10/2022

When allocating costs to departments using Universidade do Minho

dual rates
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

• Fixed Costs are incurred to provide support departments


with the ability to satisfy the demands of the operating
departments in the long-term
• In any given month operating departments may not
use all of a support department’s capacity available
– However over long period time it is assumed they
will

• Therefore long-term average usage of support


departments is likely to represent the “cause” of Fixed Costs
– “Average actual capacity” or “Practical capacity”

Ofélia Pinto

When allocating costs to departments using


dual rates
Universidade do Minho
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

10

• Using Dual Rates:


Need to determine allocation ratios (allocation bases) for
each operating department based on practical capacity
proportions (i.e. total capacity utilized by each
department out of 100% - Dept 1 = 45%; Dept 2 = 55%)

Fixed costs will not be “unitized” when allocation base


ratios are used to allocate fixed costs
– Ratios stay constant until long-term capacity changes
Ultimately dual rates provide more accurate support to
department cost allocation, as they use the “cause and
effect” rule
Ofélia Pinto

10

5
02/10/2022

Allocating costs of a support department to Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

operating departments 11

Under either method, allocation of support


costs can be based on:
– budgeted overhead rate and budgeted
hours, or
– budgeted overhead rate and actual
hours.

Ofélia Pinto

11

Allocating costs of a support department to Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

operating departments 12

Allocation based on the demand for (or usage of)


computer services
• Single-rate method ‒ a combined budgeted rate is
used for fixed and variable costs.
• Dual-rate method ‒ cost-allocation bases must be
chosen for both the variable- and fixed-cost pools.

Ofélia Pinto

12

6
02/10/2022

Allocating costs of a support department to Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

operating departments 13

If you were to use the same option throughout:


– either option 1, budgeted rates and budgeted hours of
usage, or
– option 2, budgeted rates and actual hours of usage,
then the single-rate and dual-rate methods would yield
identical results.

Ofélia Pinto

13

Allocating costs of a support department to Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

operating departments 14

Allocation based on the supply of capacity


• When practical capacity is used to allocate costs, the single-rate
and the dual-rate methods allocate, respectively, only the actual
fixed-cost resources used, or the budgeted fixed-cost resources
to be used.
• Using practical capacity to allocate costs:
‒ focuses attention on managing unused capacity
‒ avoids burdening the user divisions with the cost of unused
capacity.

Ofélia Pinto

14

7
02/10/2022

Allocating costs of a support department to Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

operating departments 15

Budgeted usage, actual usage and capacity-level


allocation bases
• Actual usage may be equal to, greater than, or less than
budgeted usage.
• Allocation may be based on:
‒ budgeted usage
‒ actual usage
‒ practical capacity.
• When budgeted usage is the allocation base, user divisions
know their allocated costs in advance. In all three cases,
regardless of actual usage, the fixed-cost allocations are
the same. Ofélia Pinto

15

Allocating costs of a support department to Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

operating departments 16

Budgeted versus actual rates


Choosing between actual and budgeted rates:
• budgeted rate is known at the beginning of the
period
• actual rate will not be known with certainty until
the end of the period.

Ofélia Pinto

16

8
02/10/2022

Example – Central Computer department Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

17

Practical Capacity: 18.750 hours


Fixed costs : $3.000.000
Budgeted long run usage in hours:
Microcomputer division 8.000 hours
Peripheral equipment division 4.000 hours
12.000 hours
Budgeted variable costs: $200
Actual usage
Microcomputer division 9.000 hours
Peripheral equipment division 3.000 hours
12.000 hours

Ofélia Pinto

17

Allocating costs of a support department to Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

operating departments 18

Budgeted usage: 8000h / (8000+4000) = 0,6667 = 2/3 => 2/3*3000000 =


2000000
3.000.000/18.750 = 160
Ofélia Pinto

18

9
02/10/2022

Allocating costs of multiple support Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

departments 19

Three methods of allocating the costs of reciprocal


support departments are:
 direct method
 step-down method
 reciprocal method.

Ofélia Pinto

19

Allocating costs of multiple support Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

departments 20

Direct method:
• allocates support costs only to operating
departments
• no interaction between support departments
prior to allocation.

Ofélia Pinto

20

10
02/10/2022

Allocating costs of multiple support Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

departments 21

•Data used in cost allocation illustrations:

Ofélia Pinto

21

Allocating costs of multiple support Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

departments 22

Ofélia Pinto

22

11
02/10/2022

Allocating costs of multiple support Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

departments 23

Ofélia Pinto

23

Allocating costs of multiple support Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

departments 24

Step-down method:
• allocates support costs to other support departments
and to operating departments that partially recognize
the mutual services provided among all support
departments
• one-way interaction between support departments prior
to allocation.

Ofélia Pinto

24

12
02/10/2022

Allocating costs of multiple support Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

departments 25

Step-down method:

Ofélia Pinto

25

Allocating costs of multiple support departments26


Universidade do Minho
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

Ofélia Pinto

26

13
02/10/2022

Allocating costs of multiple support Universidade do Minho

departments
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

27

Reciprocal method:
• allocates support department costs to operating
departments by fully recognizing the mutual services
provided among all support departments
• full two-way interaction between support departments prior
to allocation.

Ofélia Pinto

27

Allocating costs of multiple support Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

departments 28

Reciprocal method: Equations


P = 6.300.000 + 10% I
I = 1.452.150 + 20% P

I = 1.452.150 + 20% (6.300.000 + 10% I)


I = 1.452.150 + 1.260.000 + 0,02I
0,98 I = 2.712.150
I = 2.767.500

P = 6.300.000 + 276.750
Ofélia Pinto
P = 6.576.750
28

14
02/10/2022

Allocating costs of multiple support Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

departments 29

Reciprocal method:

Ofélia Pinto

29

Allocating costs of multiple support Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

departments 30

Overview of methods:
• reciprocal is the most precise
• direct and step-down are simple to compute and understand
• direct method is widely used.

Ofélia Pinto

30

15
02/10/2022

Allocating costs of multiple support Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

departments – web links 31

• YouTube lecture ‘Support Departments Cost Allocation Using


Direct Method’ can be found at:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oUk3f9SWFKU
• YouTube lecture ‘Support Departments Cost Allocation Step
Down Method’ can be found at:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oUk3f9SWFKU
• YouTube lecture ‘Support Cost Departments Allocation
Reciprocal Method’ can be found at:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NB0zsaPC4MI

Ofélia Pinto

31

Universidade do Minho
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

32

Lecture Illustration: Red


Ball Printers

Ofélia Pinto

32

16
02/10/2022

Lecture Illustration Part 1 Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

33

Red Ball Printers has 3 operating departments


• Catalogue, Magazine and Book departments;

• The Cleaning Department provides services to these


departments;

• The allocation base for Cleaning is cleaning hours to


represent usage of Cleaning Services

• Budgeted cleaning hours for November is 5.000 based on the


following budgeted usage:

Catalogue Department 1.200 hrs


Magazine Department 1.600 hrs
Book Department 2.200 hrs
Total 5.000 hrs
Ofélia Pinto

33

Lecture Illustration Part 1 Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

34

Budgeted costs of Cleaning for November are $200.000


These costs comprise the following:
– Fixed: $130.000 (fixed within relevant range of 1.000 -
10.000 cleaning hours)
– Variable: $14 per cleaning hour ($70.000)

Ofélia Pinto

34

17
02/10/2022

Determine a single budgeted application Universidade do Minho

rate for November


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

35

November’s single budgeted application rate is


$200.000/5.000 hrs = $40 /hour
• Equivalent to -
• $14 of variable costs per hour (70.000/5.000)
and;
• $26 of fixed costs per hour ($130.000/5.000)

Ofélia Pinto

35

Allocate Cleaning costs to Departments using Universidade do Minho

single rate
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

36

• Actual usage of Cleaning Department for


November is
Catalogue Department 1.200 hrs
Magazine Department 1.800 hrs (not 1.600)
Book Department 1.900 hrs (not 2.200)
Total 4.900 hrs

Ofélia Pinto

36

18
02/10/2022

Allocate Cleaning costs to Departments using Universidade do Minho

single rate
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

37

Cost allocation to Departments


Catalogue: $40 x 1.200 hours = $48.000
Magazine: $40 x 1.800 hours = $72.000
Book: $40 x 1.900 hours = $76.000
Total Allocation: $196.000

Total allocation is $196.000 not $200.000


Is this an appropriate allocation?

Ofélia Pinto

37

Allocate Cleaning costs to Departments using Universidade do Minho

single rate
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

38

Did the 3 operating departments “cause” $196.000 of


Cleaning services?
They required Variable Costs of 4.900 hrs x $14 = $68.600
○ Not $70.000 as only 4.900 hrs (not 5.000) were used
BUT still required Fixed Costs of $130.000 – no change as
they are FIXED with output (cleaning hours) in the short-term
Total “caused” = $68.600 + $130.000 = $198.600
– Therefore Cleaning costs have been underallocated by
$2.600

Ofélia Pinto

38

19
02/10/2022

Allocate Cleaning costs to Departments using Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

single rate 39

What caused Cleaning costs to be incorrectly allocated?


– The incorrect allocation of fixed costs

Remember the single allocation rate of $40/hour


Fixed costs were treated as variable with cleaning hours –
even though they are FIXED costs

As a result, when cleaning hours amounted to only 4.900 the


fixed cost allocation ended up being only
– $26 x 4.900 hours = $127.400 instead of $130.000
– i.e. $2.600 underallocated

Ofélia Pinto

39

Allocate Cleaning costs to Departments using Universidade do Minho

dual rates
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

40

The problem with fixed costs can be solved if


separate rates for Variable and Fixed support
department costs are used
Use dual rates for Red Ball Printers Cleaning
department
• Variable cost application rate will not change
– $14 per cleaning hour used

• Fixed cost allocation?


– Need to find a suitable allocation base – not cleaning
hours used
Ofélia Pinto

40

20
02/10/2022

Allocate Cleaning costs to Departments using Universidade do Minho

dual rates
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

41

Fixed Costs are incurred to provide support departments with


the ability to satisfy the demands of the operating
departments in the long-term
• In any given month operating departments may not
use all a support department’s capacity available
– However over time it is assumed they will

Therefore long-term average usage of support departments


is likely to represent the “cause” of Fixed Costs
– “Average actual capacity” or “Practical capacity”

Ofélia Pinto

41

Allocate Cleaning costs to Departments using Universidade do Minho

dual rates
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

42

Red Ball Printers’ 3 operating departments have the following practical


capacity
Catalogue Department 1.375 hrs
Magazine Department 1.925 hrs
Book Department 2.200 hrs
Total 5.500 hrs

Need to determine allocation ratios (allocation bases) for each operating


department based on practical capacity proportions
Catalogue Department 1.375/5.500 = 25%
Magazine Department 1.925/5.500 = 35%
Book Department 2.200/5.500 = 40%

Ofélia Pinto

42

21
02/10/2022

Allocate Cleaning costs to Departments using Universidade do Minho

dual rates
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

43

Budgeted Cleaning Fixed Costs =$130,000


Cleaning Fixed Cost allocation to operating departments

Department Ratios Fixed Cost Allocation


$32.500
Catalogue 25%
(25% x $130.000)

$45.500
Magazine 35%
(35% x $130.000)

$52.000
Book 40%
(40% x $130.000)

Ofélia Pinto

43

Allocate Cleaning costs to Departments using Universidade do Minho

dual rates
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

44

Total of Fixed and Variable Cost allocations

Fixed Cost Variable Cost


Department Total Allocation
Allocation allocation

$32.500 $49.300
$16.800
Catalogue
($14 x 1.200)

$45.500 $70.700
$25.200
Magazine
($14 x 1.800)

$52.000 $78.600
$26.600
Book
($14 x 1.900)

Total $130.000 $68.600 $198.600

Ofélia Pinto

44

22
02/10/2022

Allocate Cleaning costs to Departments using Universidade do Minho

dual rates
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

45

Things to note:
• Fixed costs have not been “unitized”, as allocation base
ratios were used to allocated fixed costs
• Ratios stay constant until long-term capacity changes
• Ultimately dual rates provide more accurate support
department cost allocation, as they use the “cause and
effect” rule

Ofélia Pinto

45

Comparison of single and dual rates for Universidade do Minho

support department costs


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

46

Dual
Department Single rate Allocation
rate Allocation

$48.000 $49.300
Catalogue

$72.000 $70.700
Magazine

$76.000 $78.600
Book

Total $196.000 $198.600

Ofélia Pinto

46

23
02/10/2022

Budgeted or actual usage of support Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

departments? 47

Should support department costs be allocated based on


budgeted or actual usage of allocation base?
– It depends on the purpose of the allocation
Purpose is budgeting or planning?
– Use budgeted usage, so that allocations can be done at
the beginning of the period

Purpose: evaluation of department manager performance?


– Actual usage should be used, as this most accurately
represents the outcome of managers decisions regarding
support usage

Ofélia Pinto

47

Budgeted versus actual cost allocation Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

48

The Issue
Should actual or budgeted support department costs be
allocated to operating departments?
The answer?
Budgeted costs should be allocated for two main reasons
1. It allows allocation of support department costs during
the period – more timely information
2. It provides more equitable information for the
evaluation of operating and support department
managers
Ofélia Pinto

48

24
02/10/2022

Allocation of budgeted costs – provides Universidade do Minho

more timely information


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

49

If budgeted costs are allocated -


Application rates can be determined at the start of the period
• Jobs/products can be costed during the period
• Managers can budget for the cost of using support
department resources
– i.e. They will know that every hour of cleaning time will
incur a variable cost of $14
Conversely actual costs are not known until the end of the
period, therefore actual cost allocations will not provide
timely information

Ofélia Pinto

49

Lecture Illustration Part 2 Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

50

Recall Red Ball Printers


Dual Rate variable cost allocations based on budgeted
variable costs were;

Catalogue Department $16.800


Magazine Department $25.200
Book Department $26.600
Total $68.600

Ofélia Pinto

50

25
02/10/2022

Budgeted vs actual cost allocations- lecture Universidade do Minho

illustration using variable costs


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

51

Now, assume that at the end of November actual Cleaning


variable costs amounted to $78,400

The Cleaning department did not operate as efficiently as


expected in November

In particular, three employees from the Cleaning department


have been disciplined for wasting time on jobs undertaken for
the Catalogue and Book Departments.
• This inefficiency resulted in additional costs of around
$7.000
Ofélia Pinto

51

Budgeted vs actual cost allocations- Part 2a) What Universidade do Minho

should actual variable costs have equalled?


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

52

What should actual variable costs have equalled?


Actual cleaning hours used x application rate
• 4,900 hours x $14 = $68,600 (not $78,400)
Most of the difference appears to be due to the
inefficiencies in the Cleaning Department

What happens if actual costs are allocated?

Ofélia Pinto

52

26
02/10/2022

Budgeted vs actual cost allocations- Part 2b) Universidade do Minho

Allocation of actual Cleaning variable costs


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

53

Actual Cleaning Department variable costs = $78.400


Actual Allocation rate = $78.400/4,900 = $16/hour

Department Actual Usage Actual Variable Cost


(hours) Allocation
Catalogue 1.200 $19.200
($16 x 1.200)
Magazine 1.800 $28.800
($16 x 1.800)
Book 1.900 $30.400
($16 x 1.900)
Total 4.900 $78.400
Ofélia Pinto

53

Part 2c) Comparison of the allocation of actual Universidade do Minho

and budgeted costs


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

54

Actual Variable Budgeted Variable


Cost Allocation Cost Allocation
Department Difference

Catalogue $19.200 $16.800 $2.400


Magazine $28.800 $25.200 $3.600
Book $30.400 $26.600 $3.800

Each department has higher actual cost allocations


o However the difference in allocations is caused by the
actions of the support department, not the operating
department
• The difference shouldn’t be allocated
Ofélia Pinto

54

27
02/10/2022

What if there is more than one support Universidade do Minho

department?
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

55

If multiple support departments exist, they are likely to interact


• i.e. Supply services to each other as well as to operating
departments
Allocation Methods used:
• Direct method;
• Sequential or step-down method; and
• Reciprocal method
The most accurate cost allocation takes into account these
“reciprocal” sharing of services

Ofélia Pinto

55

Lecture Illustration Part 3 Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

56

Red Ball Printers actually has two Support Departments


• Cleaning and Maintenance

Budgeted Cleaning costs (as previously)


– Fixed = $130.000
– Variable = $70.000

Budgeted Maintenance costs


– Fixed = $100.000
– Variable = $80.000

Ofélia Pinto

56

28
02/10/2022

Multiple Support Departments – An Universidade do Minho

Illustration
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

57

Budgeted usage of support departments is as follows:

Cleaning Mainten. Catalogue Magazine Book Total


Cleaning
Hours * -- 1.250 1.200 1.600 2.200 6.250

Mainten.
Hours # 80 -- 150 130 140 500

* Allocation base for Cleaning is Cleaning Hours


# Allocation base for Maintenance is Maintenance Hours
Ofélia Pinto

57

Multiple Support Departments - Universidade do Minho

Illustration
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

58

Note that Cleaning provides services to Maintenance


• Therefore some Cleaning costs should be allocated to Maintenance
• Maintenance costs of $100.000 are understated (variable costs $70,000)

Note that Maintenance provides services to Cleaning


• Therefore some Maintenance costs should be allocated to Cleaning
• Cleaning costs of $130.000 are understated (variable costs $80,000)

Ofélia Pinto

58

29
02/10/2022

1. Direct Method Allocations- Variable Costs Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

only (Figures rounded) 59

Cleaning Mainten. Catalogue Magazine Book

Initial Costs
$70,000 $80,000 $300,000 $350,000 $480,000
Cleaning 24% 32% 44%
Ratios (1200/5000) (1600/5000) (2200/5000)
Cleaning No
Alloc’n -$70,000 Allocation $16,800 $22,400 $30,800
Mainten. 35.7% 30.95% 33.34%
Ratios (150/420) (130/420) (140/420)
Mainten. No
Alloc’n Allocation -$80,000 $28,560 $24,760 $26,680
Totals $0 $0 $345,360 $397,160 $537,480

Ofélia Pinto

59

2. Sequential (step down) method Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

60

Only partially recognises interactions among support depts


– Support department cost allocation is only one way
– E.g. If Maintenance is allocated first some of its costs will be
allocated to Cleaning
Cleaning will be allocated second, but will not allocate some of its
costs back to Maintenance even though Cleaning provides services
to Maintenance
– This means the first department is allocated accurately, the
second less accurately, and so on

Allocation order (ranking) affects accuracy


of cost allocations

Ofélia Pinto

60

30
02/10/2022

Sequential method and allocation order Universidade do Minho

(ranking)
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

61

How can rankings be determined?


Several options
• Textbook ranks based on “percentage of total services
provided to other service departments”
– Cleaning provides 20% (1.250/6.250) of services to
maintenance
– Maintenance provides 16% (80/500) of its services to
Cleaning
• Therefore allocate Cleaning first – highest percentage
» However this approach may not represent the best
allocation order

Ofélia Pinto

61

Sequential method and allocation order Universidade do Minho

(ranking)
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

62

What if;
• Cleaning costs were only $10.000 and
• Maintenance costs were $800.000

If allocating Cleaning first;


• $2.000 (20% of $10.000) of Cleaning costs will be
allocated to Maintenance – which is an accurate
allocation

Ofélia Pinto

62

31
02/10/2022

Sequential method and allocation order Universidade do Minho

(ranking)
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

63

BUT
• $128.000 (16% of $800.000) of Maintenance costs will not
be allocated to Cleaning (as allocation is only one-way)
» even though Cleaning caused these costs to
be incurred through its use of Maintenance
services
» Instead, this $128.000 will be allocated
directly to the operating departments –
inaccurate allocation

Ofélia Pinto

63

Sequential method and allocation order Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

(ranking) 64

What if allocate Maintenance first;


• Cleaning costs are only $10.000
• Maintenance costs are $800.000
• $128.000 (16% of $800.000) of Maintenance costs will be
allocated to Cleaning – accurate allocation

Ofélia Pinto

64

32
02/10/2022

Sequential method and allocation order Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

(ranking) 65

BUT
• $2.000 (20% of $10.000) of Cleaning costs will not be
allocated to Maintenance (as allocation is only one-way)
– even though Cleaning caused these costs to be incurred
through its use of Maintenance services

• Allocations are still not completely accurate BUT


– At least only $2.000 is incorrectly allocated, instead of
$128.000

Ofélia Pinto

65

Preferred allocation order (ranking) in Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

this course 66

Allocation ranking is determined by the dollar value of


services provided to OTHER support departments
Red Ball Printers
• Cleaning provides services valued at 20% of $70.000 to
Maintenance = $14.000
• Maintenance provides services valued at 16% of $80.000
to Cleaning = $12.800

Allocate first the department providing the LARGEST


dollar value of services to OTHER support
departments

Ofélia Pinto

66

33
02/10/2022

Sequential (step down) method - Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

illustration 67

Allocation base ratios


‘ Cleaning Mainten. Catalogue Magazine Book

Cleaning
- 1.250 1.200 1.600 2.200
Hours
Ratios ,20 ,192 ,256 ,352
- 1.250/6.250 1.200/6.250 1.600/6.250 2.200/6.25
0

Mainten.
Hours - 150 130 140
Ratios ,357 ,31 ,333
150/420 130/420 140/420

Ofélia Pinto

67

Sequential Method – Allocations Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

(rounded) 68

Cleaning Mainten. Catalogue Magazine Book


Initial Costs
$70.000 $80.000 $300.000 $350.000 $480.000
Cleaning
,20 ,192 ,256 ,352
Ratios
Alloc’n -$70.000 $14.000 $13.440 $17.920 $24.640
Mainten.
No Allocation ,357 ,310 ,333
Ratios
Alloc’n -$94.000 $33.572 $29.095 $31.333
Totals $0 $0 $347.012 $397.015 $535.973

Ofélia Pinto

68

34
02/10/2022

3. Reciprocal Method Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

69

• Recognises ALL interactions among support departments


• Uses simultaneous equations to determine the cost
allocations required to reflect these interactions
• Start with equations that represent TOTAL support
department costs – as if support department allocations had
occurred

Maintenance cost (M) = $80.000 + 20% of C

Cleaning cost (C) = $70.000 + 16% of M

Ofélia Pinto

69

Reciprocal Method Universidade do Minho


Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

70

Solve for M and C using simultaneous equations

Maintenance costs
M = $80.000 + ,20($70.000+,16M)

M = $80.000 + $14.000 + ,032M

,968M = $94.000  M = $97.107 (rounded)

Cleaning Costs
C= $70.000 + ,16($97.107)

C = $70.000 + $15.537= $85.537 (rounded)


Ofélia Pinto

70

35
02/10/2022

Reciprocal Method
Universidade do Minho
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

71

Now allocate these “new” costs using allocation ratios

Cleaning Mainten. Catalogue Magazine Book

Initial Costs
$70.000 $80.000 $300.000 $350.000 $480.000
Cleaning
,2 ,192 ,256 ,352
Ratios
Alloc’n -$85.537 $17.107 $16.423 $21.898 $30.109
Mainten.
,16 ,30 ,26 ,28
Ratios
Alloc’n $15.537 -$97.107 $29.132 $25.248 $27.190
Totals $0 $0 $345.555 $397.146 $537.299

Ofélia Pinto

71

Comparison of Methods
Universidade do Minho
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

72

Final Allocations to Operating Departments

Direct Sequential
Reciprocal Method
Method Method
Catalogue $345.360 $347.012 $345.555
Magazine $397.160 $397.015 $397.146
Book $537.480 $535.973 $537.299
Total $1.280.000 $1.280.000 $1.280.000

Ofélia Pinto

72

36
02/10/2022

Comparison of Methods
Universidade do Minho
Esc ola de Economia e Gestão

73

Note: Allocations are quite similar


Why?
• Because there are very few support departments, and
• the interactions between the support departments are
relatively small (16% and 20%)

Choice of method should be based on cost-benefit


• Benefit to allocation accuracy vs. costs of method

Ofélia Pinto

73

37

You might also like