Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Severe Analysis of Cardiac Disease Detection Using The Wearable Device by Artificial Intelligence
Severe Analysis of Cardiac Disease Detection Using The Wearable Device by Artificial Intelligence
net/publication/348165151
CITATION READS
1 173
6 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Haseeb Udeen on 29 May 2021.
Abstract—In the current era of technology, Artificial minutes hearts perform normally after taking medicine or
Intelligence (AI) is playing a vital role in the health care sector relaxing techniques. But the problem is that when he visits
especially cardiac disease detection which is a major cause of his/her doctor and after monitoring the ECG, the doctor
sudden death. Both the elderly and young are at the risk of doesn’t reach the depth of the problem and he suggests that
sudden cardiac death at the ratio of 1-2% all around the world.
“the heart rate is normal”, and the problem persists.
Although AI technology with wearable technology is being used
to detect heart diseases for quite some time now, sometimes it To sort out this problem many concepts have been
fails due to multiple reasons which include algorithm failure, introduced, like the wearable device that connects with a
high cost of treatment, limited battery time wearable device, mobile application using IoT. The main advantage of this
data training issues, security and privacy issue in IoT, slow device is that a patient checks his/her heart rate itself at the
working of devices, poor internet or patients don’t reach the time when he/she feels arrhythmia (irregular heartbeat) or
hospital on time. Which gives rise to false results. Security and other disturbance felt in the heart. After that, patients can
privacy issues in the old devices are the biggest flaws due to easily show the records of heart rate at the time of the normal
which old devices work slowly and the internet issues are and abnormal stage.
common, it helps us to check their heart parameters anytime
and anywhere in the world which reduces the hospital's
workload, cost issues and to line onward. Meanwhile, these
problems can be overcome by using modern models such as
ECG assessment, AI-based guidelines, Visy’s model which can
recognize five critical diseases. A Wearable ECG patch is a very
lightweight model that provides high accuracy and efficiency.
These devices are trained by using a machine learning
algorithm, and AI plays a prime role to detect the diseases. It
helps us to check their heart parameters anytime and anywhere
in the world which reduces the hospital's workload and cost
issues, and the devices provide updated information as real-time
data is stored online and secured with firebase authentication.
It is concluded that all modern devices are more efficacious,
cost-effective, user friendly, and more secure. Figure 1
8. Deep Learning:
In this paper, Deep Learning is a sequential subgroup
of ML Methods that can be supervised or unsupervised. In
supervised deep learning trains, the system using data that is
well labeled. The author also used an error backpropagation
algorithm that is especially useful for deep neural networks
working on error-prone projects. In administered DL,
preparing information are utilized as input to build a show
over rehashing preparing cycles. To optimize demonstrate
execution, demonstrate weights are adjusted during each
preparing circular based on the differences between yield and
ground truth, each proportional to its relative commitment to
the mistake. This process is in actual called blunder
backpropagation. As before long as the ascending prescient
Figure 2: The network picture of the bracelet framework. [7] execution comes to a plateau, the calculation stops learning
from unused preparing data and the preparing prepare may be
The wearable device in Figure 2 helps the patient when stopped. In uncommon infections, pathology can indeed be
the patient is in some urgent situation with the help of a
simulated to make fake preparing information. Interests, DL
single press of a button, the signals recognize the area and
information to their relatives contacted with the help of models are some of the time considered to be ‘black boxes’
SMS. The patient’s relatives also install this app and get and, in common, give small knowledge into what they learn
information about that person.[7] and how it was learnt. For this reason, methodologies are
right now being created to envision the learning handle in DL
6. [11].
A few measurements, counting accuracy, affectability, 9.
specificity, and f-score, have been detailed within the
pertinent writing for show evaluation. Notwithstanding of The meet strategy interview method was embraced to
which metric is considered, generally the execution of the include information about the different wearable gadgets.
show depends on two key variables: (i) dataset, and (ii) ML Analysts guaranteed that important questions were tended to
pipeline. For the dataset, the investigation can be based on the interviews for the wearable gadgets, their application, and the
source of the data (nation), the test estimate, and number of level of understanding acknowledgment/dismissal towards the
highlights. The pipeline can be examined based on the ML gadgets. Restorative wearable gadgets build up a quantitative
and highlight determination strategies. The rest of Segment 2 way of assessing patient’s wellbeing by following their status
explores these components and conducts a multifaceted whereas they are absent from the healing center. Gathering
analysis of what ML-based CAD determination has such information may diminish the rate of mortality of
advertised in this way distant [8]. individuals. In addition, it may reduce the terms of the
7. treatment required within the treatment, which will result in
A. Data Collection; B. Preprocessing; C. Features based moving forward the quality of a patient’s life. The specialists
on PPG time series; D. Wavelet Analysis. All the above- uncovered their positive hone comes about upon using
discussed steps are used in this paper. All subjects are adult wearable gadgets by encouraging patients to utilize these
patients (18-89 years old) who were admitted and undergoing gadgets. In addition, utilizing wearable gadgets will move the
telemetry monitoring at the Emory University Hospital patients into a more preventative healthcare show that will
(EUH) . provide the open capability to play a more enthusiastic part in
Separated from the ghastly data of PPG, we incorporated a individual wellbeing management by moving healthcare from
few measurements based on beat-to-beat interim variations in the healing centers to the homes [12].
the picture era imitates how cardiologists study ECG
signals. In common, cardiologists will consider when
10. Firebase Authentication Console:
anomalous ECG happened and give maintenance and non-
IntelliDoctor system setup user profile by using a
sustained investigation after taking ECG. If k three unusual
firebase authentication console and contains cloud features
heartbeats are detected or the abnormal ECG flag endures
like user verification, database, storage, hosting, functions,
more than 30s cardiologists must note it as uncommon
and MI kits (based on the flow of light method). It takes
perception. Based on this concept, the preprocessed flag will
medical records of a user by generating a questionnaire;
exchange into images with a test rate of 1200 Hz (roughly
suggest medical conditions according to symptoms, and set
48s). Finally, these pictures will be the preparation,
a reminder for medicine taking.
approval, and testing information of the CNN demonstration
The learning algorithm is used to forecast the possible within another stage. This takes one-dimension CNN for
medical problem, then the data is fed into a real-time highlighting, extracting, and classifying.
database. The system also keeps records of health fitness like
heartbeat sensing, junk food records, step count, sleep To confirm this IoT framework, it is connected to the
tracking, etc. Also, check the risk factor at the last step by service of wellbeing and welfare for clinical trials, which are
alerting the user and suggesting physical check up to the carried out from patients in the clinic, services of wellbeing,
doctor [14]. and welfare. Each fragment, such as the wearable ECG
sensing device client interface on App, cloud server sensing
gadget [15].
11. Client Interface on App:
ECG signals are shown on-screen; AI algorithm divides In table 1, we have described all of the research done in the
above papers in a categorized way such that problems, their
into different cardiac arrhythmias signals at a time and local
solutions, the advantages of those solutions, and the future
mobiles save the ECG data collected. Thirdly, the plan of work in accordance with the specific solutions.
Table 1
2) There is no treatment of 2) Artificial Intelligence: AI will 2) Artificial Intelligence feed 2) Now, machine learning is
Supervised machine learning in guide better for patient’s care. Since mechanism to expand and boost worked by staff with special
the prediction task [3]. physicians will be able to explain the efficiency of cardiology. training; in the future, these
more information in vast depth than Whole-genome order and flow procedures will end up
ever before [3]. mobile sensors they authorize progressively [3].
coming times physicians to scan
interference and feedback to extra
expand biomedical information
gather fortuitously [3].
3) The previous results of model 3) The model Visy’s containing 3) Visy’s can be used for the
problems are that the models are lightweight, low power, wireless 3) detection of health disturbances
not able to monitor for a long time point-to-point conceived vital sign i)Frequent transmission like heart rate HR, respiratory rate
also the sensors don’t contain monitoring. Implementation of BLE RR, TMP, derived systolic blood
low-power and showing for connection, frequent ii) Low consumption on the pressure, and can be combined
irrelevant data on screen [4]. transmission, and low consumption biosensors [4]. with other healthcare applications
on the biosensors [4]. to alert nurses about patient's life-
threatening factors and can stop
patient's condition from
deteriorating [4].
4) No doubt Artificial Intelligence 4) General separation based on the 4) Security up-graded [5].
in the medical system has deep analysis in these types of
advantages that resolve signals confirms the correctness of 4) In 2021, improving the quality
difficulties. But still, the issues pulses in both channels and if pulses of this selection of sensors in line
occur. High voice signal don’t get equal during long-term with the required diagnostic model
interference, electronic and signals are not the correct pulses and will increase the performance of
software error, Mechanical error also the undiscovered pulses can be the system's pre-analytical
such as sensor contact failure, recorded. While increasing issues analytics. And the security method
mechanical error recognizes the have been observed during the arrest provides at the subject's pulse rate,
Problem Statement Solution Advantages Future Work
actual abnormality of the current of short-lived signals, which can be it can be increased to diagnose
cardiac signal from various reduced in design by improving the related cardiovascular disease [5].
obstructive factors such as synchronization mechanism for
cartilage breakdown [5]. receiving signals across channel [5].
5) Co2 level in our body can’t be 5) Easily discover heart blockage 5) If this technology is developed
easily determined. It becomes 5) IoT is also valuable here because [6]. then we can discover heart
harmful if it's level increases in it determines the level of co2 in the blockage through this technology
the body [6]. body by using a sensing device [6]. by doing more projects [6].
6) There are some problems the 6) Utilized the MCU of the 6) It reduces time in successful 6)In the coming years, there will
author discussed; first, there is a STM32F103 for bracelet [7]. treatment for unexpected diseases be more enhancement in this
deficiency of work shooting. And for the aged. product. Online social work will
secondly, it cannot identify the It also provides offline positioning be included so that aged with
loss of consciousness of mode [7]. comparative infections can
individuals with ordinary heart communicate with each other.
rate and temperature [7]. News and life recommendations
on aged people and common
illness will be sent to the APP. On
the equipment side, the camera
and screen can be gathered on the
bracelet so that the client can make
a video call to their crisis contact.
A lot remains to be done [7].
7) CVD is the most common 7) To resolve this problem, machine 7) Better Monitoring of the heart
disease that is the big reason of learning plays an important role by [8].
heart attack due to it many people training wearable device and due to 7) Maybe the ECG method
lost their lives. Problem is that it a native user check the replaced with AI in the future
CVD cannot be diagnosed easily. performance of the heart [8]. because machine learning play an
To find out it's routine examining important role in this field [8].
of the heart is most important and
is not possible [8].
8) Heart rates too fast and too 8) To resolve, wearable device is an 8) Reduce heart failure [9]. 8) Because of this technology, we
slow from the normal rate in excellent option to find out the will be able to overcome the
patients but when arrhythmia extreme rate of heart and then the problem of heart failure in the
arises, this time patient has no doctor may be able to treat the future [9].
resources to check the pulse rate patient in a better way [9].
or heart rate [9].
9) ECG is the computational 9) Machine learning is helpful 9) Limitation of dilated 9) Deep learning can be used in the
method to check the problem of hereby automatically checking the cardiomyopathy can be overcome. future to overcome the limitation
DCM. It is a very slow process walls of heart, by training datasets [10]. of dilated cardiomyopathy [10].
and often do not diagnose the that are given to the system [10].
actual problem [10].
10) Angiography is the only way 10) Machine learning algorithm that 10) Better Monitoring of the heart 10) Maybe the ECG method get
to detect CAD which is a very detects the Problem of CAD [11]. [11]. replaced with AI in the future
risky and invasive method [11]. because machine learning plays an
important role in this field [11].
11) There are challenges or 11) To summarize, the study finds a 11) Smart portable gadget in
problems associated with the new and effective medical prospect timely identification [12]. 11) To enhance the importance of
device, such as costs, general for appendicular cardiovascular devices adding the more trained
acceptance, effective devices for current and potential algorithms in artificial intelligence
management, privacy, and so on. patients with CVD and exciting that helps the patient to detect any
Which needs to be effectively advances in the medical field [12]. emotions that they feel [12].
countered [12].
12) Different issues related to the 12) It has been being over that 12) Real-time checking of a 12) In the future all the problems
integration of biosensors with cardiac big data store and internet of patient makes the conclusion of related to the integration of
remote capabilities through things (IoT)-based application the patient simpler and superior biosensors with wireless abilities
Bluetooth, Wi-Fi, and GPS are merged with Artificial Intelligence over time. It is learned that like Wi-Fi, Bluetooth are
significant for future biosensors, beside with biosensors for cardiac explanation of outcome through important to improve the quality
such as machine learning look after can act a logical mate machine learning and information and efficiency for future
algorithms and POCs [13]. (Assistant). Online monitoring of investigation approaches are very biosensors, like machine learning
patient particular creates the successful and help clinical algorithm [13].
identification of the patient clearly decision making [13].
and fairly in time [13].
13) IntelliDoctor App system setup
user profile by using the firebase
13) People have to visit doctor authentication console and contains 13) In the future people can get
also for minor illnesses. It cloud features like user verification, 13) It works to eliminate working medical assistance from home and
consumes time and also cost database, storage, hosting, functions, repetitively, increasing effort in also save money. In emergencies,
money. Furthermore, people have and MI kits (based on T flow light the treatment process, reducing these types of systems can help to
no idea about the medical method). It takes medical records of time and money wastage. Creating alert people and suggest nearby
condition of the patient and they the user by generating a preventive care by Artificial relevant doctors. It also saves time
also have to fetch previous health questionnaire; suggests medical Intelligence application [14]. in emergencies by keeping
records [14]. conditions according to symptoms, previous medical records [14].
and sets a reminder for medicine
Problem Statement Solution Advantages Future Work
taking. Learning Algorithm is used
to forecast the possible medical
problem then the data is fed into a
real-time database [14].
14) The aged population in the 14) This paper introduced a 14) Recognizes abnormal signals 14) In future it is possible to
USA is increasing day by day, and convolution neural network (CNN) and informs the hospital enhance the model capacity and
heart diseases cause sudden death based algorithm for cardiac disease, immediately [15]. eliminate complexity, making
[15]. also users attach a wearable easier and more efficient by using
monitoring device that recognizes AI-based algorithm on-chip [15].
abnormal signals and informs the
hospital immediately [15].
IV. RESULTS activity and only used a suitable condition to interpret the
health of the block [5].
In this paper, we evaluate some papers based on the detection
In this paper, the proposed system accurately describes the
of heart problems using wearable devices and we mention
level of CO2 in the human body, and the author describes that
these details of the results that are produced by different
carbon dioxide levels in our body increase due to exercise and
authors.
if CO2 level increase from a limited amount then due to the
In this paper authors discuss strategy for ECG Diagnosis by
shortness of breathing or nervous breakdown sudden death
an AI framework, which is created to give the similar power
occurs [6].
of human Specialists to an AI framework for performing
In this paper, author introduces the solution, switch on the
diagnosis tasks [2]. This paper presented that, cardiologists
bracelet. Specify the client’s key information and the phone
assemble choice for patient protection from information, they
number of the crisis contact person in the APP. Also, the
take care to have the approach of well-to-do quantitative
bracelet and APP are ready to recognize and pair. When the
information on patients differentiate with multiple and more
assistance button of the bracelet is pressed, the crisis contact
skills. In the face of a few possible risks, it is a good way to
individual can get the phone call and SMS. The SMS deeply
assemble choice due to information by the program of skill
explains the client data, particular area, and contact individual
sketch from AI.
within the most limited time for the user [7].
In another paper author describes the result that tells us that
This paper presented that, using ML techniques, the
AI will guide for better patient care since physicians will be
maximum accuracies are achieved by various categories of
able to explain more information in vast depth than ever
algorithms. In diagnosing CAD, author describes in this paper
before [3]. The author passed the model of Rationale of The
Emission Test that this model never shows irrelevant data by that, only a few papers achieved accurate results [8].
using biosensors. The Visy’s is also efficient in work In this paper, author firstly describes that to know the
bypassing the two clinical trials [4], the author calculated the importance of “spectral analysis in AF detection”, a model is
biological parameter of heart rate, which is correct and gives proposed. This system shows the 91.8% accuracy. The result
information about the health of the subject such as of this system is the automatic detection of cardiac disease
“bradycardia (for adults, resting heart rate <60 beats/min with the help of machine learning in the form of qualitative
treated as bradycardia) and tachycardia (for adults, graphics. The qualitative analysis includes a) Normal (b)
comfortable heart rate >100 beats/min treated as HCM (c) ASD Quantitative result is Overall Accuracy 98.30.
tachycardia)”. In Figure 3, the author investigated the normal According to the result, proposed system shows similar
and abnormal pulse and produced results in the form of results gained by electrocardiograms [9]. In this article, the
blocks. The presented fig shows the captures of PPG, ECG author looked at security work and focused on isolating signal
signal that presented the normal and abnormal pulse rate by data. He used the least number of conditions to assess the
using model that is presented by author. Blocks contain the health of patients and the ability to store huge amounts of data
details of normal and abnormal as well as not detectable pulse required to train such algorithms has boosted this progress.
etc. readings that got by the model respectively. To recognize Given the result overall match with the dataset given to the
the health quality, the paper mainly focuses on the system [11]. In this paper author discusses the results of this
segregation signal to check the ability and security of the proposed system, it is the rise of cloud platforms that gives
large processing power knowing their area by utilizing this arrhythmia classification and is more upgraded for all
innovation is an amazing feature of wearable gadgets. arrhythmia detection. AI-based model is possible on a chip.
Usually done by sending cautions in case of any unsafe The model is simpler more flexible as in the future, patients
circumstance [12]. This paper presented that Cardiac big can use it to meet the real AIOT based cardiac disease
information stores and the internet of things (IoT)-based detection more smoothly.
application coordinates with AI in conjunction with
biosensors for cardiac care can act as a virtual partner. Results REFERENCES
visualized in less time [13]. This paper shows the results of [1] (healthline, 2020)
app that is tested on the android ecosystem by registering
healthline. (2020, 4 19). Retrieved from healthline:
users, creating a profile of a user, taking fitness data, and https://www.healthline.com/health/coronary-artery-
visualizes all the data into a graphical interface. The system disease#symptoms
contains an intelligent symptom analyzer, which creates a set
of questions to predict the medical condition and generates [2] R. N. Patel and M. P. Barot, “Development Of Methodology for
health reports periodically [14]. Precise Diagnosis of ECG By Artificial Intelligent,” Proc. 2019
3rd IEEE Int. Conf. Electr. Comput. Commun. Technol. ICECCT
V. CONCLUSION 2019, pp. 1–5, 2019, doi: 10.1109/ICECCT.2019.8869413.
[3] K. W. Johnson et al., “Artificial Intelligence in Cardiology,” J. Am.
After the brief explanation, we conclude that, with the help of Coll. Cardiol., vol. 71, no. 23, pp. 2668–2679, 2018, doi:
AIOT, doctors can take decisions to take care of patients, 10.1016/j.jacc.2018.03.521.
more efficiently by the access to data. Some better decisions [4] D. L. T. Wong et al., “An Integrated Wearable Wireless Vital
can be taken by using Artificial Intelligence. Cardiologists Signs Biosensor for Continuous Inpatient Monitoring,” IEEE Sens.
J., vol. 20, no. 1, pp. 448–462, 2020, doi:
need to include Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning 10.1109/JSEN.2019.2942099.
in hospitals. As the number of patients’ data keeps on [5] P. Lakkamraju, M. Anumukonda, and S. R. Chowdhury,
expanding, to include current streams of complex biomedical “Improvements in Accurate Detection of Cardiac Abnormalities
information into the hospital, Artificial Intelligence is and Prognostic Health Diagnosis Using Artificial Intelligence in
Medical Systems,” IEEE Access, vol. 8, pp. 32776–32782, 2020,
important in clinical procedures. Radiology and pathology doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2020.2965396.
computer vision can be enhanced by the computerized [6] T. Margaret Mary, G. Ramanathan, A. Sangamithra, and K.
algorithm. Artificial Intelligence will handle patients with Soumya, “Design and Enactment of Heart Attack deduction using
better protection as physicians will be able to explain the IOT Measuring Device,” J. Phys. Conf. Ser., vol. 1427, no. 1,
2020, doi: 10.1088/1742-6596/1427/1/012014.
further information in huge depth than ever ahead. [7] Y. Gu, Y. Zhang, H. Chen, J. Dong, and Y. Ren, “Design of Health
Reinforcement Learning Algorithms will end companion Assistant Bracelet for the Elderly Based on STM32,” Proc. 2019
doctor helps, inconspicuously helping doctors, and IEEE 4th Adv. Inf. Technol. Electron. Autom. Control Conf.
streamlining clinical care. As Machine Learning is worked by IAEAC 2019, no. Itaic, pp. 2559–2562, 2019, doi:
10.1109/IAEAC47372.2019.8997765.
staff with special training, “within the Future” these [8] R. Alizadehsani et al., “Machine learning-based coronary artery
procedures will be simple and common for everyone. The disease diagnosis: A comprehensive review,” Comput. Biol. Med.,
model Visy can overcome the problems of the previous vol. 111, no. July, p. 103346, 2019, doi:
papers. This system contains wireless power wearable 10.1016/j.compbiomed.2019.103346.
[9] S. P. Shashikumar, A. J. Shah, Q. Li, G. D. Clifford, and S. Nemati,
biosensors and monitors ECG (Electro Cardiogram), RR “A deep learning approach to monitoring and detecting Atrial
(Respiratory Rate), TMP (Tran’s mural pressure), and SBP Fibrillationusing wearable technology,” 2017 IEEE EMBS Int.
(Symbolic Blood Pressure) 24 hours. This system is very Conf. Biomed. Heal. Informatics, BHI 2017, pp. 141–144, 2017,
helpful for hospital staff to work more productively. [4] doi: 10.1109/BHI.2017.7897225.
[10] S. Borkar and M. N. Annadate, “Supervised Machine Learning
Detection and display of heartbeat rate through IOT based Algorithm for Detection of Cardiac Disorders,” Proc. - 2018 4th
sensor, also for a person at home. This system can also be Int. Conf. Comput. Commun. Control Autom. ICCUBEA 2018, pp.
used in hospitals, all patients are observed by a person in a 1–4, 2018, doi: 10.1109/ICCUBEA.2018.8697795.
server room. If this technology is developed then we will be [11] J. W. Benjamins, T. Hendriks, J. Knuuti, L. E. Juarez-Orozco, and
P. van der Harst, “A primer in Artificial Intelligence in
able to discover heart blockage through this technology in the cardiovascular medicine,” Netherlands Hear. J., vol. 27, no. 9, pp.
future. [8] Presented a new deep neural network approach to 392–402, 2019, doi: 10.1007/s12471-019-1286-6.
categorize AF, continuously using a CNN. Such an algorithm [12] M. M. El Khatib and G. Ahmed, “Management of Artificial
is high, promising for deployment in a real-world setting. [9] Intelligence enabled smart wearable devices for early diagnosis
and continuous monitoring of CVDS,” Int. J. Innov. Technol.
Deep Learning is used in the future to overcome the limitation Explor. Eng., vol. 9, no. 1, pp. 1211–1215, 2019, doi:
of dilated cardiomyopathy. [10] In the future, AI will provide 10.35940/ijitee.L3108.119119.
doctors with diagnostic tools, clinical decision systems, and [13] R. Vashistha, A. K. Dangi, A. Kumar, D. Chhabra, and P. Shukla,
greatly developed workflows in electronic health records. “Futuristic biosensors for cardiac health care: an Artificial
Intelligence approach,” 3 BIOTech, vol. 8, no. 8, pp. 1–11, 2018,
Due to its cost reduction, doctors diagnosed the real problem doi: 10.1007/s13205-018-1368-y.
of patients through online monitoring; they full fill their [14] M. Gandhi, V. K. Singh, and V. Kumar, “IntelliDoctor - AI based
duties in a better way. [11] Medical Assistant,” 5th Int. Conf. Sci. Technol. Eng. Math.
The purpose of this study is to develop the cardiac vascular ICONSTEM 2019, vol. 1, pp. 162–168, 2019, doi:
10.1109/ICONSTEM.2019.8918778.
device that monitors the patients also in the medical field and [15] X. Liu, X. Su, S. Tamminen, T. Korhonen, and J. Roning,
provides efficiency and more enhancement.[12] [13] It works “Predicting the heart rate response to outdoor running exercise,”
to eliminate working repetitively, increasing effort in the Proc. - IEEE Symp. Comput. Med. Syst., vol. 2019-June, pp. 217–
treatment process, reducing time and money wastage. 220, 2019, doi: 10.1109/CBMS.2019.00052.
Creating preventive care by Artificial Intelligence application
[14] the model proposed an AI-based calculation for