Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 20

Coping with displacement: problems and responses in camps for the internally displaced

Intervention 2009, Volume 7, Number 2, Page 110 - 129

Coping with displacement: problems


and responses in camps for the
internally displaced in Kitgum,
northern Uganda1
Rebecca Horn

Displaced communities respond to the challenges began targeting civilians. The LRA became
and losses of their changed circumstances by drawing known for using extreme violence to instil
on their remaining resources.The challenge for those terror into the general population.
working in such contexts is how to e¡ectively combine Initially, civilians tried to protect themselves
these community initiatives with their own organis- by sleeping in the bush, or by commuting
ational resources. This paper reports a study of 112 to towns or trading centres at night, whilst
residents of four camps for internally displaced maintaining contact with their homes and
Ugandans. The respondents were primarily con- land. However, as rebel activity increased,
cerned with the structural, social and economic people were forced into ‘displacement camps’
di⁄culties that a¡ected them.Those problems most for internally displaced persons (IDP) estab-
frequently identi¢ed were the fundamental issues lished by the government in 1997, in the Kit-
of food, health and poverty, which were perceived gum district. The aim of these camps was
to stem primarily from the way the camps were to cut o¡ rebel resources and allow the
structured and resourced. Respondents described Ugandan People’s Defence Forces (UPDF)
four main response strategies: assistance from others access to the LRA bases deep in the bush.
(including neighbours, relatives, agencies and By the end of 2002, almost the entire rural
community organisations); work and income gener- population of Acholiland, consisting of the
ation; personal characteristics (e.g. determination, Gulu, Kitgum and Pader districts, had
ability to work hard); and social support. moved into IDP camps. The initial intention
was for the military operation to be carried
Keywords: internally displaced persons, out quickly, and people return to their
coping strategies, Uganda, camps homes. However, the Ugandan army failed
to defeat the LRA militarily, and 10 years
after the camps ¢rst opened, people were still
Introduction living there.
The con£ict in Uganda began in 1986, when The policy of forced encampment dramatic-
President Yoweri Museveni seized power, ally increased the vulnerability of the Acholi
and a number of groups from the north of population and entrenched their feelings
Uganda fought the central government. of social and political marginalisation
Initially, these were primarily popular rebel- (Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre,
lions, but this changed when the main rebel 2007). Also, the LRA succeeded in attacking
group, the Lords Resistance Army (LRA), IDP camps, despite the deployment of the

110
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Rebecca Horn

military to provide protection, and IDPs food or cash, brewing alcohol, and petty
have also commonly reported experiencing trading. However, as time went on, ‘security
violence and abuse at the hands of the UPDF zones’ were set up around each camp. These
soldiers supposed to protect them (Paul, varied from a few hundred metres to several
2006). The vast majority of those in Acholi- kilometres, and camp inhabitants were pro-
land report that they have been victimised hibited from going outside these zones. Even
during the con£ict (Boas & Hatloy, 2005; inside the security zone, movement was
Pham,Vinck, Stover, Moss,Weirda & Bailey, restricted to between 9 am and 5 pm. Move-
2007). ment outside the security zone, or outside
The IDP camps were very densely populated of the designated hours, incurred the risk of
(Boas & Hatloy, 2005) creating poor sani- being attacked by the LRA, or being accused
tary conditions. The extreme overcrowding, of being a rebel, or a rebel collaborator, by
together with lack of access to clean water, the UPDF. This had a signi¢cant impact on
su⁄cient food, and health care services, have the lives of the IDPs, as most of their land
had a considerable impact on the health of was outside the security zone, they were no
IDPs (Checchi, 2006; Ministry of Health, longer able to cultivate it. The camps them-
2005). Healthcare facilities had severe di⁄- selves were so overcrowded, it was impossible
culties recruiting trained sta¡, with many to plant vegetable plots around the homes.
camps relying solely on unskilled volunteer It also became much more di⁄cult, as well
home visitors, and there were chronic as dangerous, for women and children to
shortages of most essential drugs (Checchi, gather ¢rewood or wild fruits to sell.
2006). In addition, insecurity and travel Residents of the Kitgum camps have com-
restrictions limited access to the main hospi- plained about the prevalence of disease,
tals for those patients requiring treatment drunkenness, violence, lack of adequate
not available in the camp clinics. sanitation, and livestock and poultry deaths
The extreme poverty of camp residents (Stites, 2006). Another large-scale survey
exacerbated their other problems. Even identi¢ed camp residents’ priorities as:
before they were forced into camps, people health (45%), peace (44%), education
in Acholiland had their crops, cattle and (31%), and livelihood concerns (including
other assets stolen (Pham, et al., 2007), and food, 43%; land, 37%; money, 35%) (Pham,
those who had assets remaining when they et al., 2007). Adults have expressed concern
entered the camps often sold them to meet about their children’s health and that they
the immediate needs of their families. They were not learning Acholi traditions in the
believed that the con£ict would soon be over camp environment. Olaa (2001) writes that
and they would be able to return to their land although many traditions have survived dis-
and generate more income. This left them placement, the basic relationships that used
with nothing to sell later on, when their situ- to hold families and villages together have
ation became even more desperate, and been damaged.
there were very limited opportunities to earn The humanitarian response in Kitgum and
cash (Boas & Hatloy, 2005). other parts of northern Uganda has been
When the camps were ¢rst established, men severely criticised (Brown, 2006). Agencies
could sometimes return home to tend to their have not coordinated their activities well,
crops, while women contributed to the resulting in some camps receiving many
family income by exchanging ¢rewood for services, and others, mainly those in less

111
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Coping with displacement: problems and responses in camps for the internally displaced
Intervention 2009, Volume 7, Number 2, Page 110 - 129

accessible areas, receiving few services, or Therefore, much of the distress experienced
nothing at all. However, it is recognised that, by displaced people is due to a mismatch
until recently, agencies’ work has been hin- between the demands of the situation in
dered by the security situation. Most were which they ¢nd themselves, and the resour-
based in Kitgum town, with only Medecin ces available to them (Miller & Rasco,
Sans Frontiers (MSF) having compounds 2004). Research conducted in a variety of
inside some of the camps as well. Due to settings has given us some understanding of
the unpredictability of the LRA attacks, the resources commonly drawn on by dis-
the UN recommended that humanitarian placed populations. These include social
agencies travel to most (with the exception support; community structures; spiritual
of four) of the camps in Kitgum district with support; material resources; and construc-
a military escort. The roads were opened tive activity.
by 9 am, and the time the escort must leave Social support Social support has been ident-
the camp was speci¢ed by the UPDF. This i¢ed across many situations as being the
could vary between 2 pm and 4 pm, depend- primary, and most e¡ective, coping strategy
ing on the security situation and the person- used by displaced populations for both
nel undertaking the escort. In the case of children (Boothby, Strang & Wessells,
the furthest camps, which can be more than 2006; Kostelny, 2006; Westerveld-Sassen,
70 km from Kitgum town, these restrictions 2005) and adults (Eyber & Ager, 2002).
meant that it was only possible to spend Social support serves a number of functions.
two or three hours in the camp. This lack of The most obvious is emotional support
presence in the camps severely limited the (Almedom, 2004; Farwell, 2001), but it can
services that agencies were able to provide. also involve economic and material assist-
When the security situation improved, ance (Birkeland & Gomes, 2001). However,
nongovernmental organisations and UN the main sources of social support, the family
personnel were able to spend the night in and community, may be severely disrupted
some camps, and could travel to many with- by displacement (Farr, 2001;Wessells & Mon-
out military escorts. teiro, 2004). Families are likely to be under
When individuals or groups become dis- severe strain as a result of their experiences
placed, they are faced with the ‘struggle to of violence, loss of resources and/or the chan-
develop new social networks, navigate unfamiliar ging roles of their members, which may limit
environments, discover new and meaningful social their ability to support each other (Sorenson
roles, ¢nd ways out of poverty and into self-su⁄- & Vincent, 2001).
ciency, and manage the day-to-day sadness of being Community structures The maintenance of
separated from loved ones unable or unwilling to traditional cultural practices is helpful for
make the journey out’ (Miller & Rasco, 2004, the whole community; providing support,
27). Coping with these challenges is not only ensuring continuity and giving meaning to
about people ¢nding new ways of providing di⁄cult events (Kostelny & Wessells, 2004).
for the basic needs of themselves and their In addition, community structures such as
families, but about ¢nding new ways of leadership systems, contribute to community
meeting their emotional, spiritual and social cohesion, and ensure that accepted ways of
needs. It has been suggested that ‘coping’ is behaving are maintained.
best seen as an attempt to adapt the resources However, these are often lost when a com-
at one’s disposal to a particular situation. munity becomes displaced, because leaders

112
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Rebecca Horn

are no longer present, or because the Some displaced people become involved in
resources required are no longer available. criminal activities, such as stealing (Olaa,
Olaa (2001, 109) describes how Ugandan 2001; Birkeland & Gomes, 2001), and there
Acholi culture and tradition is ‘rich with mech- may be an increase in sexual exchange as a
anisms for solving problems within the community, survival strategy (Boutin & Nkurunziza,
but the capacity to conduct these activities e¡ectively 2001; Olaa, 2001; Payne, 1998). However,
has been degraded by the continuing con£ict’. these strategies tend to be disapproved of
Spiritual support Faith and religion has been by other members of the community.
found to be a common bond of strength Defrauding humanitarian agencies (e.g. by
within many displaced populations (Kassam claiming multiple ration cards), on the other
& Nanji, 2006; Farr, 2001; Dzeamesi, hand, is seen as more acceptable (Kibreab,
2008). In various settings, engagement in 2004).
religious practice has been linked with Constructive activity There is considerable
positive measures of mental and physical overlap between coping strategies focusing
health (Wessells & Strang, 2006; Copeland- on obtaining material resources, and those
Linder, 2006). Resources provided by reli- involving constructive activity, since the
gious belief include constructive and mean- purpose of this activity is, in many cases, to
ingful interpretations of events (Wessells & generate income. However, the act of enga-
Strang, 2006); social support; and traditions ging in paid or unpaid work, community
and rituals which help to provide a sense activities, education, or any other form of
of meaning and continuity (Kostelny & activity which is purposeful can be an e¡ec-
Wessells, 2004). tive coping strategy in itself (Turner, 2004).
Material resources As might be expected in the Despite its usefulness, this strategy is often
desperate situations many displaced people under- utilised, especially in camps, where
¢nd themselves in, most coping strategies dependency and passivity may be encour-
described in the literature are ‘survival’ or aged (Kassam & Nanji, 2006).
‘subsistence’ strategies (Birkeland & Gomes,
2001). Even in the most unpromising settings, Context of the study
displaced people have been found to be The research described in this paper was
engaging in income-generating activities, conducted in April 2006. The situation in
such as casual labouring work, petty northern Uganda has changed considerably
trading or small business (Birkeland & since that time, and continues to be in a state
Gomes, 2001; Boutin & Nkurunziza, 2001) of £ux. In April 2006, there were around
or selling services such as tailoring or con- 300 000 people living in 21camps in Kitgum
struction. Children may be expected to district, and in the period prior to this, the
contribute to these survival strategies, some- IDP population in Kitgum had experienced
times at the expense of their education (Farr, cyclical violence followed by periods of
2001). relative calm. Attacks on the civilian popu-
Cultivation is often an important source of lation by the LRA had been steadily going
income, predisplacement (Birkeland & down from June 2005, but at the time this
Gomes, 2001), and people make great e¡orts study was conducted it was di⁄cult to pre-
to continue to cultivate their land, even dict whether this would continue. The
when this causes inconvenience or danger LRA soldiers were known to be moving
(Delgado & Laegreid, 2001; Payne, 1998). around frequently, so people did not feel

113
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Coping with displacement: problems and responses in camps for the internally displaced
Intervention 2009, Volume 7, Number 2, Page 110 - 129

secure, and it was almost impossible to pre- tions. In the current study, respondents were
dict when and where further attacks might asked:
occur.
At the time of this research, there was a plan 1. What are the main problems that a¡ect
to ‘decongest’ the Kitgum camps, and some people in your community?
people had already spontaneously relocated 2. Can you think of somebody you know
from the camps to other locations. As of who has these problems, but is coping
February 2006, ¢ve spontaneous settlements with them very well? Tell me about that
had been established in Kitgum district, person.
with another 19 planned.
The research reported here was conducted They were prompted by the interviewer to
for the Jesuit Refugee Service (JRS),2 who list as many ideas as possible, and to give a
were in the process of establishing a new brief explanation of each. They were also
psychosocial and education project in asked to identify individuals in their com-
Kitgum district in 2006. The study was munity who are commonly consulted by
carried out to assist JRS to understand the people who are struggling to cope with their
needs and priorities of the residents of the emotional or psychological problems.
camps, and to contribute to the design and
planning of the psychosocial aspect of the Key informant interviewsThese interviews were
new programme. The study aimed to conducted with the persons named in the
identify the problems experienced by IDPs free listing study as those commonly con-
in four camps in the Kitgum district, and sulted about emotional and psychological
to explore the strategies used to cope with problems. The purpose of these interviews
these challenges. was to con¢rm the descriptions of problems
and coping strategies that emerged from
the free lists, and to obtain more detailed
Methods information about the problems experienced
Research sta¡ Eight local people (four male by residents of IDP camps in Kitgum. Key
and four female) were employed to conduct informants were asked:
the research interviews, along with the JRS
Psychosocial Assistant. Two half-day train- 1. What kind of problems do people have in
ing sessions were carried out to familiarise your community?
the research sta¡ with the interview method- 2. What causes their problems?
ology and protocol. 3. How do these problems a¡ect them?
Research locations Four camps were selected for 4. What helps people to feel better?
inclusion in this study: Lokung, Nam Okora,
Lagoro, and Akwang. Translation All the questions were translated
Interview format Two qualitative interviewing into the local Luo language by the research
methods (free listing and key informant team.
interviewing) were used (Bolton, 2001). Informed consent A standardised ‘informed con-
Free listing sent’ section was developed, to ensure that
The ‘free listing’ methodology involves people potential respondents understood the pur-
from a target community generating lists in pose of the interview, and what would be
response to one or more standardised ques- involved. They were told that JRS was

114
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Rebecca Horn

conducting the research with a range of Description of participants


people selected by chance, to ¢nd out more Eighty-nine participants were interviewed
about the problems a¡ecting people in Kit- for the Free listing study, and 23 for the
gum. The information would be used to help Key Informant study.
JRS develop programmes in the camp, but Free listing: Of the 89 participants, 44 were
there would be no direct bene¢t to the inter- male (49.4% of sample) and 45 were female
viewee personally. They were told that no (50.6%). They were resident in four camps
information to identify them would be Nam Okora (n¼14); Lokung (n¼25); Lagoro
recorded, and if they chose not to take part in (n¼27) and Akwang (n¼23). Respondents
the interview it would not a¡ect any assis- reported having lived in the camp for
tance they received from JRS, nor any other between one and 16 years, although since
organisation. the camps were only established in Kitgum
Procedures The data collection exercise was district in 1997, it is unclear what was meant
carried out on Wednesday 26 ^ Friday 28 when respondents said they had stayed in
April 2006.Teams of, between three and ¢ve, the camp for more than 10 years. It is likely
researchers went to each camp. Upon arrival that they meant they had lived in the area
they ¢rst made contact with the camp com- of the camp before other IDPs came to join
mandant to obtain permission to carry out them. The mean length of time respondents
the research. In all cases, permission was had stayed in the camps was 4.62 years (stan-
given. dard deviation ¼ 3.20), although this varied
For the free listing part of the study (which between camps. The mean age of respon-
took place over two days), each interviewer dents was 35.15 years (standard deviation ¼
aimed to conduct at least four interviews 18.36).
per day, ideally including an equal number Key Informants: Only two camps (Lagoro and
of men and women, one young person (aged Akwang) were included in this part of the
14^20) and one older person (above 45 study. Of the 23 participants, 16 were male
years). (70% of sample) and 7 were female (30%).
The third day was spent interviewing key The key informants had stayed in the camps
informants in two camps. Each interviewer for a mean of 3.27 years (standard deviation
was given a list of four ‘key informants’ (ident- ¼ 0.88), and their mean age was 49.0 years
i¢ed in the free listing exercise), and aimed (standard deviation ¼ 21.57).
to interview at least two of these people.
All interviews were carried out in Luo, and Results
the interviewers were required to translate Problems The problems identi¢ed by the
the responses and record them in English largest number of respondents, and the
on the survey form. relationships between them, are sum-
Analysis During analysis, the data from the marised in Figure 1. This model illustrates
lists were combined to provide a composite the central issues identi¢ed by respondents,
list of responses in order of the frequency and the relationships between them. It is,
they were mentioned. This gave the names necessarily, an over simpli¢cation of these
and descriptions of the major problems and relationships, but it shows that respondents
coping strategies (from the community identi¢ed some issues as being fundamental.
members’ perspective) and how highly Furthermore, these issues create and
people prioritised them. maintain a further series of problems that

115
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Coping with displacement: problems and responses in camps for the internally displaced
Intervention 2009, Volume 7, Number 2, Page 110 - 129

Rebel activity
Level 1 insecurity

Restricted movement: Inadequalte facilities,


Level 2 few opportunities to equipment and staff
earn money, unable to
cultivate
Congestion

Level 3 Food shortages Poverty

Poor health

Alcohol abuse Idleness


Level 4

Neglect of
children

Level 5 Criminality; violence; sexual


promiscuity, exploitation and abuse

Figure 1: Model of problems identi¢ed by IDPs in Kitgum as a¡ecting their communities.

signi¢cantly impact on the wellbeing of their government response to it, has led to move-
communities. ment being severely restricted (Level 2 of
The model shows that participants identi¢ed the model), which hinders income gener-
the fundamental cause of their problems as ation and the cultivation of land. Other
insecurity, caused primarily by rebel activ- aspects of the situation said to impact on
ities. This insecurity, and the Ugandan wellbeing are congestion of the camps, and

116
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Rebecca Horn

inadequate services and facilities, too few Young people were said to su¡er from idle-
schools, inadequate health services, and poor ness and lack of constructive activity, related
sanitation facilities (latrines and sources of to both a lack of access to the education
clean water). system, and a lack of space for children and
This combination of factors contributes to youths to engage in leisure activities, such
the problems identi¢ed most frequently by as sports and traditional dance. Idleness
IDPs (Level 3 of the model): food shortages, was perceived to contribute to sexual prom-
poverty and poor health. Food shortages iscuity, criminal behaviour and alcohol
were the most frequently identi¢ed problem abuse. Alcohol abuse was believed to have
(109 of 112 respondents), followed by poor serious consequences, including promis-
health (98), followed by poverty (97). cuity and violence (e.g. ¢ghting, domestic
Food shortages were seen as primarily violence, sexual abuse and assault). Respon-
related to inadequate food aid, but also to dents complained that young people are
the di⁄culties of obtaining food indepen- sexually promiscuous due to factors such
dently, due to movement restrictions limiting as population congestion, poverty and
opportunities to work, cultivate the land, or parental neglect. This, in turn, has health
gather wild food. Movement restrictions consequences in terms of sexually trans-
were also said to contribute to poverty; and mitted infections, and unwanted preg-
both food shortages and poverty contribute nancies.
to poor health. Coping strategies The coping strategies ident-
The relationships between factors at Level 3 i¢ed by the general community members
and Level 4 of the model are bi-directional. and key informants were grouped into ¢ve
In addition, the Level 4 factors (alcohol main themes.These themes, and the number
abuse, neglect of children and idleness) are of times they were identi¢ed by community
closely inter-related.The two levels have been members and key informants, are listed in
separated in the model mainly to distinguish Table 1.
between those factors mentioned by the Table 1 shows that there are some di¡erences
majority of respondents (Level 3), and those in the coping strategies identi¢ed by general
referred to by fewer people (Level 4). community members and by key informants.
Neglect of children was described in It should also be noted that they were asked
material, social and emotional terms. somewhat di¡erent questions: community
Material neglect occurs due to parents’ pov- members were asked to describe a person
erty, and a number of respondents said that they knew who was coping well with their
children do not bene¢t from the parental problems, while key informants were asked
care and guidance they would have received a more abstract question; ‘what helps people to
prior to displacement. The quality of the feel better?’ It is notable, however, that almost
education children receive at school was felt all key informants referred to assistance
to be poor, and many parents were unable from others and to work as of particular
to pay the fees to send their children to sec- importance in helping IDPs cope with
ondary school. Some respondents talked their circumstances.
about a decrease in respect for traditional Respondents’ descriptions of each type of
practices and behaviour, and di⁄culty in coping strategy are outlined below. Each
¢nding ways to pass their culture onto coping strategy is illustrated by a ‘case study’,
the youth. based on an individual described as coping

117
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Coping with displacement: problems and responses in camps for the internally displaced
Intervention 2009, Volume 7, Number 2, Page 110 - 129

Table 1. Coping strategies identi¢ed


General com-
munity members Key informants
(n ¼ 89) (n ¼ 23)

n % n %

Assistance from others 51 57 22 96


Work 42 47 21 91
Personal characteristics 55 62 12 52
Social support 31 35 9 39
Other 0 0 14 61

well by a community member respondent. before. The woman is managing because of


This is somewhat arti¢cial, since in most people assisting her. (14-year-old female,
cases, individuals used more than one type Lokung camp)
of coping strategy.
Work and income generation
Assistance from others Table 3 describes the forms of work and
Assistance from others was the main coping income generation IDPs were said to engage
strategy identi¢ed by both community mem- in. The positive bene¢ts of work not only
bers and key informants. However, general include earning an income, which can
community members (who were asked to improve the life of a family, but also growing
describe a particular individual) talked crops and engaging in constructive activity,
primarily about assistance from others in instead of being idle. Both community mem-
the community, such as neighbours and bers and key informants talked about work
relatives, whereas key informants (who were as an important coping strategy.
asked to describe what helps people in Cultivation is especially important to the
general) talked primarily about assistance Acholi people; it is a crucial aspect of their
from humanitarian organisations. Table 2 culture. Access to land, and the ability to cul-
describes the ways in which IDPs receive tivate it, not only generates income, but is
assistance from others. also a constructive activity that provides
In many cases, those described as coping some continuity with the past. Where it is
well due to assistance are those who are not possible to cultivate, people ¢nd alterna-
particularly vulnerable, for example the tive ways of generating income. However,
elderly, disabled or sick. collecting items like mangoes and ¢rewood
to sell exposes the person to risk of attack
An old woman who doesn’t have anybody to by rebels or bandits, or by the UPDF who
support her in any way. She is getting WFP may take them to be a rebel collaborator.
ration and people used to give her food because It should be noted that the number of respon-
what WFP gives is not enough. In addition to dents describing ‘work’ as a coping strategy
what people give her, church has also built a is relatively low. This does not indicate that
hut for her, but recently she is not badly off as work is a poor coping strategy, but that it is

118
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Table 2. Types of assistance provided to IDPs
Community members Key informants Coping strategy Description

46 (52%) 11 (48%) Help from other IDPs The people most commonly said to assist are
relatives (25),3 but also children (19),
neighbours (19) and the church (7).
Assistance included help with household
tasks (e.g. collecting ration, fetching
water) (19); giving food (14) and other
material assistance (11). There was also help
with earning money (7), cultivation
(e.g. digging) (6); and mobility (e.g. guiding
blind person) (5).
0 11 (48%) Food aid Although theWorld Food Programme (WFP)
was said to provide too little food, it was
better than if no food was provided at all.
0 11 (48%) Humanitarian assistance Few respondents identi¢ed speci¢c ways in which
humanitarian support assists people to feel better,
but some referred to medicine (3), seeds (2) and
household utensils (2).
5 (5.8%) 0 Community organisations Including disabled associations, women’s groups,
church activities and groups which come together
to apply for loans or to implement a poultry or
livestock project.

119
Rebecca Horn

Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.


120
Table 3. Ways in which work assisted IDPs
Community members Key informants Coping strategy Description

9 (10%) 8 (35%) Cultivation For personal consumption and/or sale. Even small-scale
cultivation was said to help a person to feel better.
8 (8%) 6 (26%) Collecting items to sell Items collected and sold include ¢rewood (9),3 wild food
such as mangoes and shea nuts (6), and stones (1).
12 (13.5%) 1 (4.3%) Makes things to sell Such as charcoal (3), local brew (3), and household
utensils (6) such as hoe handles, weaving, pots, knives
and bricks.
7 (7.8%) 2 (8.7%) Employment Employment opportunities were said to be very limited,
but include being paid to dig for others, construction
work, and children working as housemaids in
Intervention 2009, Volume 7, Number 2, Page 110 - 129

Kitgum town.
4 (4.5%) 2 (8.7%) Small business Such as using a bicycle to provide transport, and
buying and selling small items (e.g. para⁄n, salt,
biscuits).
2 (2.2%) 0 Sells part of ration
0 2 (8.7%) Keeping livestock Poultry and livestock are given by humanitarian
agencies to some groups of IDPs.
Coping with displacement: problems and responses in camps for the internally displaced

Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.


Rebecca Horn

di⁄cult to engage in any of these activities or who collects ¢rewood for sale, might
due to insecurity and the resulting restric- be said to be successful at this because they
tions on movement. An example to illustrate are hardworking and don’t give up. One
the e¡ectiveness of work, when circum- community member described a man with
stances allow, is given below. 13 children who is coping well as a result of
his personal characteristics.
There is a young boy who is an orphan; the
parents died when he was still very young. He All children went to primary school (which is
had a stepmother who took care of him until free) and he really struggles to send them to
he reached 14 years. In 1999 the stepmother secondary as well . . . The man is very hard-
went to the garden and she was arrested by working; he does construction work and works
the LRA and killed.The stepmother had two in fields. Also, he’s very concerned about the
children who she left outside after she died. children’s education. He thinks about the
The young boy started digging vegetables at future rather than his current problems,
the river bank so that he could get something whereas others may be more concerned with
to eat and sell part of it for money. He dropped what is affecting them now. (47-year-old male,
schooling and became a good peasant farmer. Nam Okora camp)
That year he planted an acre of sim-sim and
got a good yield from the planting. He took Social support
part of the sim-sim to market in Kitgum main Both community members and key infor-
market and got a good money and bought with mants described social support as a factor
it a bicycle which he later used for transporting that helps people cope with their problems,
firewood for sale, crops from the field and but it seemed to be particularly important
collecting drinking water with his bicycle. Up to community members. They referred to it
to now the boy is still struggling and taking frequently when describing a speci¢c person
care of the step-brother and sister despite who copes well with their problems. Table 5
all the difficult situation he underwent. describes the forms of social support IDPs
(89-year-old man, Lokung camp) were said to draw on. Responses mentioned
by a single person are not included.
Personal characteristics Good relationships with others not only pro-
The personal strengths and internal vides social support, but also ensures that
resources of individuals were sometimes practical assistance is there when it is
described as helping them to cope with pro- needed. However, social support (including
blems. These are described in Table 4. Faith advice) was also seen as an important factor
and hope in God was particularly import- in itself.
ant, as was accepting the situation and
trying to make the best of it. A focus on some- Elderly woman with leprosy. She is a widow
thing other than one’s problems, whether with four dependents. The daughter had a
God, the future, or the family, seems to be problem with her husband and came back
important, as does a sense of personal with her children to stay with her mother.The
responsibility for dealing with the situation. mother is very poor. She brews alcohol and
Personal characteristics were often said to uses the income to provide for the needs of the
underlie the other characteristics; for children. She supports them through school.
example, a person who makes things to sell, The children she takes care of support her in

121
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
122
Table 4. Personal characteristics which help IDPs to cope
Community members Key informants Coping strategy Description

10 (11%) 5 (22%) Faith in God Faith that their situation is in the hands of God was
said to give people hope, and also help them take
risks (e.g. looking for ¢rewood in the bush)
to improve their lives.
9 (10%) 4 (17%) Accept situation Some mentioned being helped by accepting their
current situation, and not dwelling on past
experiences and losses.
4 (4.5%) 2 (8.7%) Anticipates better future People described as having hope for the future were
said to see current problems as temporary events,
Intervention 2009, Volume 7, Number 2, Page 110 - 129

and the future as more important; they place


their hope in their children and their education
9 (10%) 1 (4.3%) Determination Not giving up, and persevering even though their
problems make life hard.
7 (8%) 0 Takes responsibility for Some community members described people who
dealing with problems take responsibility for ¢nding solutions, because
they recognise that there is nobody to assist
them and/or because they have people
Coping with displacement: problems and responses in camps for the internally displaced

depending on them.
7 (7.9%) 0 Hardworking
6 (6.7%) 0 Commitment to family Commitment to the wellbeing of one’s family was
said to help one to overcome problems.
3 (3.4%) 0 Avoiding negative in£uences Avoiding alcohol or friends who take alcohol;
avoiding unsafe sex.

Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.


Table 5. Forms of social support that help IDPs to cope
Community Key
members informants Coping strategy Description

12 (13.5%) 4 (17.4%) Good relationships with others A person who has good relationships with others
is more likely to be assisted by them when in need.
12 (13.5%) 3 (13%) Social support Spending time with friends and neighbours
was said to help people to forget their
problems for a while and relax. Key
informants also described organised social
gatherings (e.g. dancing).
7 (7.8%) 0 Advice Advice from those close to the person (5)3 and
from elders (2) was believed to help someone
cope with problems, and encourage them not to give up.

123
Rebecca Horn

Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.


Coping with displacement: problems and responses in camps for the internally displaced
Intervention 2009, Volume 7, Number 2, Page 110 - 129

collecting water and doing other domestic movement outside the camp, due to the
chores. She works hard, the children support security situation. However, the other two
her and the neighbours support her with brew- fundamental causes, camp overcrowding
ing the alcohol. She is prayerful and active in and inadequate services, are not directly
the church. She is committed to the family and related to insecurity, but are consequences
endeavours to provide for them. (59-year-old of failures in planning the camps and plan-
woman, Lokung camp). ning and coordinating services. This is
perhaps what underlies Checchi’s (2006)
Other factors observation that; ‘the Acholi camps provide an
Community members referred only to the almost textbook example of how not to mitigate the
above factors in assisting people to cope with e¡ects of forced displacement’. Although life in
their problems. However, key informants a camp for displaced people is likely to
also referred to two other factors (excluding involve some level of hardship, in camps of
factors mentioned by a single person). Eight su⁄cient size for the population, and with
key informants said that security issues had adequate services, some of the problems
an impact on coping; mainly security in the identi¢ed by respondents in this study may
camp but one person also referred to the lift- have been minimised.
ing of some security restrictions, allowing The social problems a¡ecting camp resi-
more movement. Three mentioned the role dents were referred to less frequently, but
of community education, including life skills were mentioned as being closely related to
education, training opportunities and edu- basic survival issues. It was acknowledged,
cation from elders and relatives. for example, that underlying the problem
of idleness is the lack of educational, voca-
Discussion tional or employment opportunities for
The ¢ndings of this study illustrate the com- those who have completed primary school.
plex interrelationships between factors This partly comes about because of the
a¡ecting displaced individuals, families restrictions on movement, but it is also
and communities, and the ways in which partly due to inadequate services and facili-
IDPs in Kitgum respond to these challenges. ties, as well as overcrowding. Overcrowding
The respondents rarely talked about individ- is, in itself, believed to contribute to sexual
ual level problems, such as mental health, promiscuity, violence and the spread of dis-
but more about structural, social and ease. Each of the problems identi¢ed by
economic di⁄culties that a¡ect them at respondents is linked to several others, either
several levels. as a contributing factor or as a consequence.
The problems identi¢ed most often by IDPs It is striking that, despite the high levels of
as a¡ecting their communities and them- victimisation experienced by Acholi people
selves are, as would be expected, the funda- over the prolonged con£ict, the con£ict itself
mental issues of food, health and poverty. was not described as being a signi¢cant pro-
These are central to survival, and were blem. The attacks, abductions and return of
therefore, a high priority for camp residents. escaped abductees to their communities
They perceived these problems as stem- were not referred to, but the consequences,
ming, primarily, from the ways that the especially in terms of restricted movement,
camps were structured and resourced. One were described as having an extremely
of the main causes was the restriction on negative impact. This should not be seen as

124
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Rebecca Horn

an indication that the violence did not con- or ‘subsistence’strategies (Birkeland & Gomes,
cern IDPs, but rather as a re£ection of the 2001). This may be because these are the
fact that the frequency and severity of attacks main priorities of displaced populations, or
had reduced considerably over the nine (in the case of the current study) because
months prior to this study being conducted, these issues seemed particularly salient to
and there was hope that a peaceful solution respondents approached by a representative
would be found to the con£ict. of a humanitarian organisation asking about
The priorities of those who participated their problems. With hindsight, the inter-
in this study re£ect the ¢ndings of other views could have focused more speci¢cally
studies of the displaced in Kitgum. Two on social and cultural needs, and the
large scale surveys were conducted in resources people drew on to address these
Kitgum around the same time as this study in the camps.
(Pham, et al., 2007; Stites, 2006). Health However, within the narrow focus of the
was identi¢ed as a priority in both surveys responses, some useful ¢ndings emerged.
and in the current study. Poverty and Even in the extremely di⁄cult circum-
livelihood concerns were also prioritised stances in which IDPs in northern Uganda
by respondents in all three studies. The live, some found ways to work and generate
extreme overcrowding of camps, and its income. As in other settings, some found
consequence in terms of safety and health casual labour, others made and sold goods,
have been identi¢ed by a number of writers or engaged in petty trading. Children con-
as having an extremely negative impact tribute to these survival strategies and some-
on camp residents (Boas & Hatloy, 2005; times dropped out of school in order to
Checchi, 2006). The respondents in the cur- contribute to the family income. Children
rent study expressed great concern about were frequently referred to as the main
the social impact of living in displacement source of assistance for people who were
camps, especially on their children and vulnerable, such as the elderly, sick or dis-
youth. This echoes Olaa’s (2001) warning abled.
that that the forced displacement of the Nobody mentioned selling assets in order to
majority of the Acholi population ‘has shaken provide for themselves, probably because,
the foundations of Acholi society’. as Boas & Hatloy (2005) note, any assets held
Respondents described four main resources by the displaced in Kitgum were sold long
people draw on to cope with these chal- ago. Like the displaced Angolans described
lenges: assistance from others; work; by Birkeland & Gomes (2001), Kitgum’s
personal characteristics; and social support. IDPs took considerable risks in order to
It is notable that all the strategies described provide for their material needs, including
relate to coping with material and practical venturing into the bush to collect ¢rewood
needs, such as a lack of income, or di⁄culty or wild fruit to sell. In doing this, they risked
in carrying out necessary tasks such as cook- being arrested by UPDF soldiers as sus-
ing and fetching water. This re£ects the pected rebels, or being captured by the
respondents’ priorities, as discussed above, rebels themselves. That displaced persons
and has similarities with the ¢ndings of are prepared to take these risks illustrate
research conducted in other regions. Indeed, not only their desperation, but also their
most of the coping strategies described in desire to play an active part in providing
the literature, as in this study, are ‘survival’ for themselves.

125
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Coping with displacement: problems and responses in camps for the internally displaced
Intervention 2009, Volume 7, Number 2, Page 110 - 129

Cultivation was an important source of or who collects ¢rewood for sale, may be said
income, prior to displacement, for many, to be successful at this because they are hard-
and is part of the community identity working and don’t give up. Future research
of rural populations such as the Acholi could focus on whether coping well in such
(Birkeland & Gomes, 2001). Displaced circumstances is perceived to be a function
people in Kitgum continue, wherever of stable internal characteristics (which can-
possible, to cultivate whatever land they not be developed by those who do not
have access to, whether this is a small strip already have them); unstable internal
on the river bank, land given to the com- characteristics (which can be developed by
munity, or land they have been able to rent. anyone); or external factors, such as the
In this, they are similar to the displaced social resources available to a person.
Afghans and Colombians who take great As already indicated, this study was con-
risks to cultivate their land (Delgado & ducted in the initial stages of a new pro-
Laegreid, 2001; Farr, 2001). gramme being established by JRS. It would
Relatively little mention is made in the litera- be very bene¢cial to build on the ¢ndings
ture of displaced people assisting each other reported here by incorporating ongoing
(exceptions are Boutin & Nkurunziza, research activities into the JRS programme,
2001; Farr, 2001), but this was described as a using a variety of approaches. This would
central coping strategy by the IDPs inter- not only develop our understanding of the
viewed for the current study. In Kitgum, challenges a¡ecting the displaced popu-
whole communities have been displaced lation of Kitgum, and their ways of coping
into camps, and although there is a level of with these challenges, but would also assist
disintegration of social support systems, the programme to adapt to meet people’s
due to killings and abductions, and the col- needs and strengthen their resources.
lapse of traditional community structures, In addition, given the challenges facing the
people tend to be surrounded by neighbours humanitarian actors working in northern
and relatives from home. It may be, there- Uganda, and criticisms of the services pro-
fore, that there are higher levels of social vided in Kitgum IDP camps, a study of the
support available to IDPs in Kitgum than humanitarian actors themselves (managers
in some other displacement situations, in and ¢eld sta¡) could be valuable. This
which communities are scattered. The fact perspective would contribute to our under-
that assistance from others was identi¢ed standing of barriers to providing e¡ective
as a primary strategy perhaps also re£ects services in such situations, and how these
the level of dependency that has been created might be addressed.
amongst IDPs in Northern Uganda. The
examples given of those who depended on Conclusion
assistance tended to be those who are most The study reported here is limited in that it
vulnerable, including the elderly and dis- was conducted in a short space of time, in
abled. only four camps, with a relatively small
Those described as coping well in the camps number of people. In addition, the people
were often said to use a combination of strat- chosen to participate in this study are likely
egies. Personal characteristics were said to to be those who were visible and accessible,
underlie other strategies in many cases; for so the experiences of certain groups are not
example, a person who makes things to sell, represented in this study. However, even

126
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Rebecca Horn

with these limitations, the complexity of the and communities to adapt to the demands
relationships between the factors a¡ecting of the situation in which they ¢nd
the displaced communities emerged clearly. themselves.
Each problem identi¢ed by respondents is
linked to several others, either as a contri- References
buting factor or as a consequence. Writers Almedom, A. M. (2004). Factors that Mitigate
such as Williamson and Robinson (2006) War-induced Anxiety and Mental Distress.
have noted the tendency of programmes Journal of Biosocial Science, 36, 445-461.
with displaced people to consider ‘wellbeing’
in a narrow sense, focusing primarily on Birkeland, N. M. & Gomes, A. U. (2001). Angola:
the individual level and neglecting other Deslocados in the Province of Huambo. In:
contributors to wellbeing, such as economic M. Vincent & B. R. Sorenson (Eds.), Caught
factors, political, social, spiritual and cul- Between Borders: Response strategies of the internally
tural. The model presented here illustrates displaced (17^47). London: Pluto Press.
the di⁄culty of developing interventions
to address in isolation social problems Boas, M. & Hatloy, A. (2005). Northern Uganda IDP
such as idleness, exploitation and abuse. Pro¢ling Study. Kampala, Uganda: O⁄ce of
While a camp remains overcrowded, under- the Prime Minister/UNDP.
resourced, and there is a signi¢cant security
threat, the factors which contribute to these Bolton, P. (2001). Local perceptions of the mental
social problems will continue to exert an health e¡ects of the Rwandan genocide. The
in£uence, and limit the e¡ectiveness of any Journal Of Nervous And Mental Disease, 189, 243-
intervention. Those working in the psycho- 248.
social ¢eld could usefully work with decision
makers in all sectors (and at all levels) to Boothby, N., Strang, A. & Wessells, M. (2006).
highlight the psychosocial implications of Introduction. In: N. Boothby, A. Strang & M.
their plans, and to advocate for programmes Wessells (Eds.), A World Turned Upside Down:
to be implemented in a way likely to enhance Social ecological approaches to children in war zones
the psychosocial wellbeing of those a¡ected. (1^18). Bloom¢eld, CT: Kumarian Press, Inc.
Although the circumstances in Kitgum
create high levels of dependency on outside Boutin, G. & Nkurunziza, S. (2001). Burundi:
agencies, the ¢ndings of this study demon- Developing strategies for self-reliance. A study
strate that IDPs still make many attempts of displacement in four provinces. In: M.
to assist themselves and each other. Good Vincent & B. R. Sorenson (Eds.), Caught
interventions build on the resources that between borders: response strategies of the internally
already exist in a situation, and the attempts displaced (48^77). London: Pluto Press.
already being made by individuals and com-
munities to improve their lives. Even in a Brown, M. (2006). The failing humanitarian
situation as restricted as Kitgum, such response in Northern Uganda. Humanitatian
attempts can be identi¢ed. The challenge Exchange, 36, 2-4.
for agencies working in such situations is,
to paraphrase Sorenson & Vincent (2001), Checchi, F. (2006). Humanitarian interventions in
how to combine these attempts with their Northern Uganda: based on what evidence?
own resources in order to enable individuals Humanitarian Exchange,7-11.

127
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Coping with displacement: problems and responses in camps for the internally displaced
Intervention 2009, Volume 7, Number 2, Page 110 - 129

Copeland-Linder, N. (2006). Stress among Black Kibreab, G. (2004). Pulling theWool over the Eyes
women in a South African township: The of the Strangers: Refugee Deceit and Trickery
protective role of religion. Journal of Community in Institutionalized Settings. Journal of Refugee
Psychology, 34, 577-599. Studies, 17,1-26.

Delgado, E. H. & Laegreid, T. (2001). Colombia: Kostelny, K. (2006). A culture-based, integ-


Creating peace amid the violence.The church, rative approach: Helping war-a¡ected chil-
NGOs and the displaced. In: M.Vincent & B. dren. In: N. Boothby, A. Strang & M.
R. Sorenson (Eds.), Caught Between Borders: Wessells (Eds.), A World Turned Upside Down:
response strategies of the internally displaced (205^ Social ecological approaches to children in war zones
223). London: Pluto Press. (19 ^ 37). Bloomberg, CT: Kumarian Press,
Inc.
Dzeamesi, M. K. (2008). Refugees, the UNHCR
and Host Governments as Stakeholders in the Kostelny, K. & Wessells, M. (2004). Inter-
Transformation of Refugee Communities: A nally Displaced East Timorese: Challenges
study into the Buduburam Refugee Camp in and lessons of large-scale emergency
Ghana.. International Journal of Migration, assistance. In: K. E. Miller & L. M. Rasco
Health and Social Care, 4, 28-41. (Eds.), The Mental Health of Refugees: Ecolo-
gical Approaches to Healing and Adaptation
Eyber, C. & Ager, A. (2002). Conselho: Psycho- (187 ^ 225). Mahwah, New Jersey: Lawrence
logical healing in displaced communities in Erlbaum.
Angola. Lancet, 360, 871.
Miller, K. E. & Rasco, L. M. (2004). An Ecological
Farr, G. (2001). Afghanistan: Displaced in a devas- Framework for Addressing the Mental Health
tated country. In: M.Vincent & B. R. Sorenson Needs of Refugee Communities. In: K. E.
(Eds.), Caught between borders: response strategies Miller & L. M. Rasco (Eds.), The Mental
of the internally displaced (117^137). London: Health of Refugees: Ecological approaches to healing
Pluto Press. and adaptation (1^64). Mahwah, New Jersey:
Lawrence Erlbaum.
Farwell, N. (2001). ‘Onward through strength’:
Coping and psychological support among Ministry of Health, R. o. U. (2005). Health and
refugee youth returning to Eritrea from mortality survey among internally displaced persons
Sudan. Journal of refugee studies, 14, 43-69. in Gulu, Kitgum and Pader districts, northern
Uganda.
Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre (2007).
Uganda: Uncertain peace process impedes return Olaa, A. (2001). The Resilience of Tradition:
in north while protection crisis looms in Karamoja Displaced Acholi in Kitgum. In: M. Vincent
region ^ apro¢le ofthe internal displacement situation & B. R. Sorenson (Eds.), Caught between Borders:
Geneva, Switzerland: IDMC. Response strategies of the internally displaced (99^
113). London: Pluto Press.
Kassam, A. & Nanji, A. (2006). Mental Health of
Afgham refugees in Pakistan: a qualitative Paul, D. (2006). Heading home? Protection and
rapid reconnaissance ¢eld study. Intervention, return in northern Uganda. Humanitarian
4, 58-66. Exchange, 4-7.

128
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Rebecca Horn

Payne, L. (1998). Food shortages and gender Adaptation (67^94). Mahwah, New Jersey:
relations in Ikafe settlement, Uganda. Gender Lawrence Erlbaum.
And Development, 6, 30-36.
Wessells, M. & Strang, A. (2006). Religion as
Pham, P. N., Vinck, P., Stover, E., Moss, A., Resource and Risk: The double-edged sword
Weirda, M. & Bailey, R. (2007). When the for children in situations of con£ict. In: N.
War Ends: A population based survey on attitudes Boothby, A. Strang & M. Wessells (Eds.), A
about peace, justice and social reconstruction in World Turned Upside Down: Social ecological
northern Uganda Human Rights Center, Uni- approaches to children in war zones (199^222).
versity of California, Berkeley; Payson Center Bloomberg, CT: Kumarian Press, Inc.
for International Development, Tulane Uni-
versity; International Center for Transitional Westerveld-Sassen, L. (2005). The impact of the
Justice. Eritrean-Ethiopian border con£ict on the
children in Eritrea; the role of protective
Sorenson, B. R. & Vincent, M. (2001). Conclusion. factors. Intervention: International Journal of
In: M.Vincent & B. R. Sorenson (Eds.), Caught Mental Health, Psychosocial Work & Counselling
Between Borders: response strategies of the internally in Areas of Armed Con£ict, 3, 25-32.
displaced (266^281). London: Pluto Press.

Stites, E. (2006). Movement as a livelihood and


1 The development of this paper was supportedby
protective strategy in Northern Uganda.
Humanitarian Exchange,11-14. a Research Fellowship grant from the Economic
and Social Research Council.
2 The Jesuit Refugee Service is an international
Turner, S. (2004). New Opportunities: Angry you-
ng men in a Tanzanian refugee camp. In: P. Catholic organisation with a mission to accom-
Essed, G. Frerks & J. Schrivers (Eds.), Refugees pany, serve and defend the rights of refugees and
and theTransformation of Societies: Agency, Policies, forcibly displaced people.
3 The ¢gures in parentheses indicate the number
Ethics and Politics. New York and Oxford: Ber-
ghahn Books. of respondents who referred to this factor.

Wessells, M. & Monteiro, C. (2004). Internally Dr Rebecca Horn is at the Institute of Inter-
Displaced Angolans: A child-focused, com- national Health and Development, Queen
munity-based intervention. In: K. E. Miller Margaret University in Edinburgh, Scotland.
& L. M. Rasco (Eds.), The Mental Health of email: rhorn@qmu.ac.uk/Rebecca.r.horn@
Refugees: Ecological Approaches to Healing and gmail.com

129
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.

You might also like