Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Philo Writtenwork2
Philo Writtenwork2
- According to Russel, the value of philosophy can be found indirectly through its
effects upon the lives of those who study it. These effects make them realize that
how you value philosophy can lead you in seeing the real value of it. When you study
a certain subject or a topic you lack knowledge about, you’ll find interesting things in
it. It will also give you knowledge and of course give you the ability to see what’s the
value of studying it. This scenario is similar when we think about where the value of
philosophy can be found.
2. Why does Russel maintain that the “uncertainty of philosophy is more apparent than
real”?
- Russel claims that "uncertainty of philosophy is more apparent than real”, however
that particular statement makes you realize that all questions were previously
philosophical, but they were later moved to Science. There are no definitive solutions
to the questions that were posed. They researched it scientifically, but they came up
with their own answers without considering whether or not they were correct. The
majority of the answers were simply provided by scientists who had conducted
experiments and discovered those facts. They've simply provided the answers that
we now see as real or true.
3. What does Russel mean when he asserts that the value of philosophy is to be sought
in its “very uncertainty”?
- He claimed that a person without a philosophical education lives his life imprisoned
by prejudices derived from common sense, habitual beliefs of his age or nation, and
attitudes formed in his mind without the collaboration or approval of his conscious
reason. He argues that definitive knowledge will suffocate speculative curiosity in the
universe. He also claimed that philosophy's ambiguity can free our thoughts from the
shackles of tradition and dogmatism.
- According to Russel, the chief value of Philosophy may be through the greatness of
the objects which it contemplates, and the freedom from narrow and personal aims
resulting from this contemplation. In such a life there is something feverish and
confined, in comparison with which the philosophic life is calm and free. In such a life
there is no peace, but a constant strife between the insistence of desire and the
powerlessness of will. In one way or another, if our life is to be great and free, we
must escape this prison and this strife.
6. How does Russel sum up the value of philosophical study? Do you agree with
Russel? Why, or why not?