Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Tuck 2018
Tuck 2018
Tuck 2018
RESEARCH PAPER
Fermentable short chain carbohydrate (FODMAP) content of
common plant-based foods and processed foods suitable
for vegetarian- and vegan-based eating patterns
C. Tuck, E. Ly, A. Bogatyrev, I. Costetsou, P. Gibson, J. Barrett & J. Muir
Department of Gastroenterology, Monash University, The Alfred Hospital, Melbourne, VIC, Australia
Keywords Abstract
carbohydrates, fermentable carbohydrates,
fermentable short chain carbohydrates, irritable Background: The low FODMAP (fermentable, oligo-, di-, mono-saccharides
bowel syndrome, vegan, vegetarian. and polyols) diet is an effective strategy to improve symptoms of irritable
bowel syndrome. However, combining the low FODMAP diet with another
Correspondence dietary restriction such as vegetarianism/veganism is challenging. Greater
C. Tuck, Department of Gastroenterology Central
knowledge about the FODMAP composition of plant-based foods and food
Clinical School, Monash University, Level 6, The
processing practices common to vegetarian/vegan eating patterns would
Alfred Centre, 99 Commercial Road, Melbourne
VIC 3004, Australia. assist in the implementation of the diet in this patient population. The pre-
Tel.: +61 3 9903 0264 sent study aimed to quantify the FODMAP content of plant-based foods
Fax: +61 3 9903 0556 common in vegetarian/vegan diets and to investigate whether food process-
E-mail: caroline.tuck@monash.edu ing can impact FODMAP levels.
Methods: Total FODMAP content was quantified in 35 foods, including
How to cite this article fructose-in-excess-of-glucose, lactose, sorbitol, mannitol, galacto-oligosac-
Tuck C., Ly E., Bogatyrev A., Costetsou I.,
charide and total fructan, using high-performance-liquid-chromatography
Gibson P., Barrett J., Muir J. (2018) Fermentable
and enzymatic assays. The effects of cooking, sprouting, pickling, fermenta-
short chain carbohydrate (FODMAP) content of
common plant-based foods and processed foods tion, activation and canning on FODMAP content were assessed. The Mon-
suitable for vegetarian- and vegan-based eating ash University criteria to classify foods as low FODMAP was used.
patterns. J Hum Nutr Diet. Results: Of the 35 foods, 20 were classified as low FODMAP, including
https://doi.org/10.1111/jhn.12546 canned coconut milk (0.24 g serve–1), dulse (0.02 serve–1), nutritional yeast
(0.01 serve–1), soy cheese (0.03 serve–1), tempeh (0.26 serve–1), wheat gluten
(0.13 serve–1) and wheat grass (0.05 serve–1). No FODMAPs were detected
in agar-agar, egg replacer, vegan egg yolk, kelp noodles and spirulina. Food
processing techniques that produced the greatest reduction in FODMAP
content included pickling and canning.
Conclusions: The present study provides a greater FODMAP composition
knowledge of plant-based foods that can now be applied to the dietetic
management of vegetarians/vegans requiring a low FODMAP diet. Food
processing lowered the FODMAP content of foods, thereby increasing
options for patients following a low FODMAP diet.
The major reasons for this include religious practices, cooking may reduce the total oligosaccharide content of
ethical, environmental and social concerns, as well as legumes (16–20), the results have not been consistent (21)
putative health benefits (6). Various forms of these diets and testing for effects on total FODMAP content have
include lacto-ovo vegetarians (i.e. consumes dairy foods not been undertaken. Additionally, previous work mea-
and eggs but no meat, poultry or seafood), lacto-vegetar- suring the FODMAP content of legumes did not assess
ian (i.e. consumes dairy but no eggs, meat, poultry or the difference in FODMAP content between dried and
seafood), ovo-vegetarian (i.e. consumes eggs but no dairy, canned products of the same forms of legumes (12).
meat, poultry or seafood), pescatarian (i.e. lacto-ovo veg- Strategies such as food processing that may reduce the
etarian but also consumes seafood) and vegans (i.e. con- burden of dietary restriction in an effort to improve
sumes no animal products). Following a vegetarian diet adherence and nutritional adequacy in this patient group
in the long-term has been shown to be associated with would be welcomed (22).
the presence of IBS in a cross-sectional study (7). Com- The present study aimed first to quantify the FODMAP
bining the low FODMAP diet with other dietary restric- content of plant-based foods available to vegetarians and
tions such as vegetarian- or vegan- eating patterns can be vegans. Second, the study aimed to investigate the effect
challenging as a result of the often competing nature of of food processing and cooking on FODMAP composi-
each dietary recommendation. tion of a variety of plant-based foods.
Provided that an appropriate variety of plant-based
foods is consumed and total energy requirements are
met, a strict vegetarian or vegan diet can fulfil an indi- Materials and methods
vidual’s nutritional requirements (8). Key nutrients at risk Study 1: Analysis of key vegetarian and vegan foods and
of inadequate intake following a vegetarian and vegan food constituents
eating pattern include protein, iron, zinc, calcium and
vitamin B12. These nutrients can be sourced from Selection of key vegetarian and vegan foods and food
legumes, wholegrains, nuts and seeds, and soy-based constituents for analysis
products (8,9). Because the compositional data to date Thirty-five common vegetarian and vegan foods or food
show that many of these foods also contain significant constituents that were considered important nutrient
quantities of FODMAPs (10–12), their intake is limited on sources and had not previously been analysed for their
a low FODMAP diet. However, comprehensive analysis FODMAP content by the Department of Gastroenterol-
of the FODMAP composition of many foods frequently ogy, Monash University were chosen to be analysed as
consumed by vegetarians and vegans has not been under- shown in the Supporting information (Table S1). Foods
taken. Data for the FODMAP composition of common or food constituents were chosen by a group of eight spe-
vegetables, fruits, grains and cereals have been published cialist Dietitians based on foods most commonly con-
previously (10–13). Most varieties of legumes analysed were sumed by vegetarians and vegans that would also provide
high in galacto-oligosaccharides (GOS) and fructans (12). good nutritional value. Nutritional composition was
Other vegetarian and vegan foods analysed include nuts, based largely on the NUTTAB 2010 database (Food Stan-
with cashews and pistachios shown to contain significant dards Australia New Zealand) (23). Food samples were
amounts of FODMAPs (13). The FODMAP content of soy sourced from metropolitan Melbourne. The food collec-
products appears to be variable, with firm-tofu and soy- tion protocol requires three different brands of the same
protein based soy milk being low and silken-tofu and food to be collected and pooled, as described previously
(12)
whole soybean-based soy milk being high in FODMAP . Where three brands with similar ingredients were not
content (13). Expansion of the current FODMAP database available, one or two brands were used and, where possi-
to provide more food sources of key macro- and micro- ble, multiple packages with different expiry dates were
nutrients, especially protein, for vegetarians and vegans is used to make up a sample of three, as indicated in the
needed. Supporting information (Table S1)
Certain food processing techniques offer an opportu-
nity to reduce the FODMAP content of foods. Processes Food sampling methodology
trialled to date have aimed to reduce the GOS content of Food samples were collected and pooled using methods
legumes and soy milks via soaking, cooking, germination, described previously (10–12, 24). Briefly, three different
fermentation, enzyme treatments, ethanol extraction, brands of each food product were collected, prepared for
genetic manipulation, dry heating and dehydration (14). analysis either as purchased or cooked in accordance with
Oligosaccharides are water soluble and hence are assumed the packet instructions (see Supporting information,
to be lost when the water used for cooking is Table S1) and pooled and mixed to provide one homoge-
removed (15,16). Although it appears that soaking and nous sample.
Study 2: Analysis of processed and cooked foods subsequently strained; red kidney beans that had been
soaked and simmered for 30 min without straining; the
Selection of foods undergoing various forms of food
soaking liquid (prior to cooking the red kidney beans);
processing for analysis
and the strained liquid (after cooking the red kidney
Vegetarian and vegan food items that had undergone
beans). Two additional cooking conditions (soaked over-
additional food processing were selected including; acti-
night but uncooked and soaking liquid) were tested for
vated nuts, pickled vegetables and fermented foods (see
the red kidney beans compared to the red lentils as a
Supporting information, Table S1). To assess the effect of
result of differences in packet instructions, where red kid-
food processing on FODMAP content, a comparison was
ney beans required soaking overnight prior to cooking
made with previous results from the same foods in the
but red lentils did not.
fresh, unprocessed form. In addition, six types of grains
and legumes were chosen to be sprouted: wheat, barley,
rye, chickpeas, red kidney beans and mung beans. Three Food sampling methodology
brands of each grain or legume were sourced and 50 g of
Food sampling for the activated nuts, pickled vegetables,
each was weighed and pooled. The grains and legumes
fermented foods, sprouted products, and dried and
were first covered in water and soaked overnight for at
canned adzuki beans was undertaken in the same way as
least 12 h. They were then wrapped in muslin cloth and
Study 1, with three different samples being collected and
left damp in a cool dark place. Additional rinsing with
pooled prior to analysis. However, to assess differences
water occurred on a daily basis for 3–6 days until the
between brands of canned and dried products and differ-
grain or legume had sprouted. Once the grains or
ences in cooking conditions, samples were not pooled
legumes had sprouts of at least 1 cm, they were consid-
and, instead, they were analysed individually. As a result
ered to have adequately sprouted.
of the large availability of many different brands of dried
and canned products of red kidney beans, a larger sample
Selection of foods to compare dried and canned size was used to reflect the number of brands available;
forms hence, 6 dried and 12 canned products were chosen to be
analysed. Legumes were prepared as eaten, with dried
To compare differences between dried and canned forms legumes being cooked in accordance with the packet
of legumes, red kidney beans in dried (n = 6) and canned instructions prior to analysis (see Supporting information,
form (n = 12) were collected. Canned red kidney beans Table S1).
were strained and prepared ‘as eaten’ prior to sampling
in preparation for FODMAP analysis. Dried red kidney
beans were soaked overnight and subsequently cooked in FODMAP analysis methodology
water as directed on the packet label and then sampled in Samples from both studies were analysed using the same
preparation for analysis. Additionally, dried and canned techniques. Samples were freeze-dried (Operon Thermo-
forms (n = 3 of each) of adzuki beans were collected and line Scientific freeze-drier, TDPR-FDB-5003; Thermoline
analysed. Scientific, Wetherill Park, NSW, Australia) prior to the
extraction step. The weight of the sample before and after
freeze-drying was recorded and, following analysis, adjust-
Preparation of foods to assess the effect of
ments were made to account for the difference. Samples
cooking conditions on the FODMAP content of
that were collected in a pre-dried form (e.g., flour) or in
legumes
a liquid form (e.g. macadamia milk) did not undergo
Red lentils and red kidney beans were simmered in accor- freeze-drying. All dried samples were ground to a fine
dance with the packet instructions in water for variable particle size (approximately 0.5 mm) prior to sugar
lengths of time. Seven different cooking conditions of red extraction by use of a mortar and pestle or an electric
lentil were assessed, including raw red lentils; red lentils food processor.
that had been simmered for 5, 10, 20 and 30 min and Sugar extraction and analysis of samples were com-
subsequently strained; red lentils that had been simmered pleted in triplicate in accordance with well-defined meth-
for 30 min without straining; and the strained liquid. ods used across a wide international range of food types
Nine different cooking conditions of red kidney beans and previously described in detail (10–12,24,25). Analysis
were assessed, including raw red kidney beans; red kidney using high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC)
beans that had been soaked (overnight) but remained was completed using a Waters HPLC using evaporative
uncooked; red kidney beans that had been soaked (over- light scattering detector (ELSD) with Sugar Pak 1 column
night) and simmered for 5, 10, 20 and 30 min and (6.5 9 300 mm column; Waters, Rydalmere, NSW,
Australia) to separate carbohydrates and then compared cheese (protein), soy roll (protein), spirulina (protein),
with standards for sucrose, glucose, fructose, mannitol tempeh (protein, iron and zinc), wheat gluten (protein,
and sorbitol. Excess fructose was calculated by subtracting iron), and wheat grass (vitamin A). Foods that did not
the total glucose from the total fructose content. Analysis meet the low FODMAP criteria per serving included qui-
using ultra-performance liquid chromatography (UPLC) noa milk and wakame flakes.
was completed using a Waters Acquity UPLC with ELSD
detector (BEH Amide 1.7 lm column; Waters) to sepa-
Study 2: Analysis of processed and cooked foods
rate carbohydrates and then compared with standards for
lactose, kestose, raffinose, nystose and stachyose. At the FODMAP analysis of foods undergoing various forms of
time of testing, the most common forms of GOS in food food processing
(i.e. stachyose and raffinose) were quantified. Table 2 shows the FODMAP composition of foods that
Total fructan content of food samples was determined had undergone various types of food processing, includ-
using the enzymatic fructan assay (Megazyme Fructan ing fermentation, activation, pickling or sprouting. The
HK Assay AOAC Method 999.03, AACC Method 32.32; FODMAP contents of the activated, sprouted and pickled
Megazyme International Ireland Ltd, Wicklow, Ireland) as foods were then compared with the FODMAP contents
described previously (10). of the fresh variety of each food in accordance with the
Monash University FODMAP database (Fig. 1). The total
FODMAP content was lowered for all types of activated
Determination of the FODMAP rating
and pickled foods compared to that of the fresh versions
The results from both studies were compared with the of these foods. All types of sprouted grains and legumes
FODMAP cut-off values for each FODMAP subgroup as also had a lower FODMAP content with the exception of
used by Monash University to classify foods as low FOD- chickpeas. The most substantial changes were seen with
MAP (26), in accordance with serving size. As described pickling, where the FODMAP content was lowered by
by Varney et al. (2017), the cut-off values per serve to 87% in artichokes, 89% in onion, 95% in beetroot and
denote a food as low FODMAP were: oligosaccharides in 97% in garlic. Pickling lowered the FODMAP rating in
grains, legumes and nuts <0.30 g; oligosaccharides in veg- garlic, onion and beetroot sufficiently to be classified as
etables, fruits and other products <0.20 g; total polyols low FODMAP, although the change was not adequate to
<0.40 g; excess fructose <0.15 g; and lactose <1.00 g (26). alter the FODMAP rating of artichoke.
Serving sizes were taken from packet suggestions and
modified as necessary within typical serving size ranges to FODMAP analysis of dried and canned foods
allow for low FODMAP serving sizes where possible. Canning red kidney beans lowered the content of GOS
and fructans compared to the equivalent dried, soaked
and cooked forms (Fig. 2). On average, dried, soaked and
Results
cooked red kidney beans contained 0.60 g serve–1
Study 1: Analysis of key vegetarian and vegan foods and oligosaccharide compared to 0.21 g serve–1 in canned red
food constituents kidney beans. The same effect occurred in the adzuki
The FODMAP contents of the 35 plant-based foods or beans, which contained 0.76 g serve–1 oligosaccharide in
food constituents are shown in Table 1. The results are the dried form compared to 0.62 g serve–1 in the canned
displayed per 100 g and per serve, and include key nutri- form (Table 2).
ent sources, individual FODMAP subgroup analysis, total
FODMAP content and FODMAP rating. Eight categories Effect of cooking time on FODMAP content of legumes
of foods or food constituents were analysed, including Simmering reduced total oligosaccharide content in red
coconut products, soy products, wheat products, milk lentils from 0.89 g serve–1 in the dried form to 0.44–
alternatives, proteins, meat alternatives, sea vegetables and 0.53 g serve–1 in cooked forms (Fig. 3). Simmering red
other. Twenty foods or food constituents that were iden- lentils for 5 minutes reduced oligosaccharide content by
tified to be low in total FODMAP content with their 43% to 0.51 g serve–1. Although longer simmering times
respective nutrients for which they are major sources caused no further reduction in oligosaccharide content,
were agar-agar (gelling agent), canned coconut milk (fat), straining the lentils after 30 minutes of simmering caused
coconut yoghurt (fat), dulse (iodine), vegan egg yolk and a 12% reduction in oligosaccharide content compared to
egg replacer (protein), false chicken (protein), false pork that of unstrained lentils. Fructan content was reduced
(protein), fresh gluten (protein), kelp noodles (iodine), from 0.25 g in raw to 0.13 (0.12–0.14) g in cooked and
macadamia milk (calcium), nutritional yeast (protein, B strained lentils, whereas, in unstrained lentils, it remained
vitamins), pea and rice protein isolates (protein), soy higher (0.18 g). The total GOS (stachyose plus raffinose)
Meets low
C. Tuck et al.
Coconut Coconut flour Fat, fibre g per 50 g serve 0.34 0.11 1.04 ND ND 0.21 0.21 1.70 No
products
g per 100 g 0.68 0.22 2.08 ND ND 0.41 0.41 3.39 No
Coconut milk canned Fat g per 80 g serve ND ND 0.14 ND ND 0.10 0.10 0.24 Yes
5
6
Table 1. Continued
Meets low
Food or food Suggested Excess Total Total Total Total FODMAP
Category constituent item nutrient source Portion size fructose Lactose Sorbitol Mannitol GOS fructan Oligosaccharide FODMAP criteria (26)
Milk Macadamia milk Calcium g per 250 g serve ND ND ND ND ND 0.04 0.04 0.04 Yes
alternatives
g per 100 g 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.02 0.02 0.02 Yes
Quinoa milk (Agave Protein g per 250 g serve 0.33 ND ND ND ND 0.22 0.22 0.55 No
sweetened)†
g per 100 g 0.13 ND ND ND ND 0.09 0.09 0.22 Yes
Quinoa milk Protein g per 250 g serve ND ND ND ND ND 0.22 0.22 0.22 No
(unsweetened)*
g per 100 g ND ND ND ND ND 0.09 0.09 0.09 Yes
Proteins Egg replacer† Protein g per 6 g serve ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND Yes
FODMAP food composition for vegetarians/vegans
Suggested nutrient source largely based on NUTTAB 2010 (Food Standards Australia New Zealand). Serving sizes based on packet suggestion or standard serving size per product. UHT, ultra-high
temperature processing. Results displayed as average of triplicate samples except where marked an asterisk (*) denotes n = 1 and a dagger (†) denotes n = 2. ND, not detected; NA, not applica-
criteria (26)
FODMAP
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Simmering also reduced the total oligosaccharide con-
No
No
tent of red kidney beans, and the content continued to
ble; GOS, galacto-oligosaccharide. Excess fructose calculated via subtraction of glucose content from fructose content. Total GOS calculated from the sum of raffinose and stachyose.
FODMAP
0.02
0.19
0.21
2.12
ND
ND
ND
ND
observed when red kidney beans were cooked for 30 min
(Fig. 3). The soaking liquid (prior to cooking) did not
Oligosaccharide
0.01
0.06
0.04
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
0.01
0.06
0.04
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
Discussion
Total
GOS
0.00
0.00
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
0.13
0.21
2.08
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
assist not only patients with IBS, but also especially those
who are following vegetarian/vegan diets to adhere to the
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
7.5 g serve
g per 10 g serve
10 g serve
100 g
100 g
g per 100 g
Iodine
Iodine
Kelp noodles
(28)
. Both GOS and fructans present in legumes are
Activated Activated pistachios Fat, protein, g per 30 g serve 0.01 ND ND ND 0.57 0.20 0.77 0.78 No
nuts fibre
g per 100 g 0.03 ND ND ND 1.88 0.67 2.56 2.59 No
Activated cashews Fat, zinc, g per 30 g serve 0.01 ND ND ND 0.40 0.13 0.53 0.54 No
magnesium
g per 100 g 0.02 ND 0.01 ND 1.34 0.43 1.77 1.80 No
Fermented Kombucha Antioxidants g per 250 g serve ND ND ND ND ND 0.24 0.24 0.24 No
products (fermented tea)
g per 100 g ND ND ND ND ND 0.10 0.10 0.10 Yes
Kvass (fermented rye) B vitamins g per 250 g serve 0.05 ND ND ND ND 0.19 0.19 0.24 Yes
g per 100 g 0.02 ND ND ND ND 0.07 0.07 0.09 Yes
FODMAP food composition for vegetarians/vegans
Legumes, dried Adzuki beans Iron, fibre g per 95 g serve ND ND ND ND 0.55 0.06 0.62 0.62 No
and canned (canned)
g per 100 g ND ND ND ND 0.58 0.07 0.65 0.65 No
Adzuki beans Iron, fibre g per 95 g serve ND ND ND ND 0.61 0.15 0.76 0.76 No
(dried, cooked)
g per 100 g ND ND ND ND 0.64 0.16 0.80 0.80 No
Red kidney beans Protein, fibre g per 95 g serve 0.05 ND ND ND 0.10 0.09 0.19 0.24 Yes
(canned) [n = 12]
g per 100 g 0.05 ND ND ND 0.11 0.10 0.21 0.25 Yes
Red kidney Protein, fibre g per 95 g serve ND ND ND ND 0.49 0.10 0.59 0.59 No
beans (dried,
cooked) [n = 6]
g per 100 g ND ND ND ND 0.51 0.11 0.62 0.62 No
Red lentils Protein, fibre g per 46 g serve ND ND ND ND 0.37 0.14 0.51 0.51 No
(dried, cooked)*
g per 100 g ND ND ND ND 0.81 0.3 1.11 1.11 No
Pickled Pickled artichoke Prebiotic fibre g per 50 g serve 0.16 ND ND ND ND 0.74 0.74 0.90 No
products
g per 100 g 0.31 ND ND ND ND 1.48 1.48 1.79 No
Pickled beetroot Folate g per 60 g serve ND ND ND ND 0.02 ND ND ND Yes
g per 100 g ND ND ND ND 0.04 ND 0.04 0.04 Yes
Pickled garlic Prebiotic fibre g per 20 g serve 0.10 ND ND ND ND 0.02 0.02 0.12 Yes
g per 100 g 0.50 ND ND ND ND 0.12 0.12 0.62 No
Pickled onion Prebiotic fibre g per 45 g serve ND ND ND ND ND 0.11 0.11 0.10 Yes
g per 100 g ND ND ND ND ND 0.24 0.24 0.23 No
Sprouted Sprouted barley Fibre g per 100 g serve ND ND 0.01 ND ND 0.04 0.04 0.06 Yes
products
Sprouted chickpeas Fibre, protein g per 95 g serve ND ND ND ND 0.55 0.14 0.70 0.61 No
C. Tuck et al.
Suggested nutrient source largely based on NUTTAB 2010 (Food Standards Australia New Zealand). Serving sizes based on packet suggestion or standard serving size per product. Results dis-
played as an average of triplicate samples. ND, not detected; NA, not applicable; GOS, galacto-oligosaccharide. Excess fructose calculated via subtraction of glucose content from fructose con-
criteria (26)
FODMAP
Yes
Yes
No ven or likely nutritional and health qualities associated
No
No
No
No
with legume consumption [e.g. reduced risk of chronic
FODMAP
0.73
0.19
0.20
1.00
1.06
1.45
0.55
the importance of identifying legume varieties and pro-
(g)
0.73
0.17
0.17
1.00
1.06
1.45
0.55
0.15
0.06
0.06
0.19
0.20
1.45
0.55
0.58
0.11
0.11
0.81
0.85
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
ND
(g)
ND
ND
ND
(g)
ND
ND
ND
(g)
ND
ND
ND
ND
95 g serve
0.54 g fructan and 1.44 g GOS per 100 g and red lentils
contain 0.14 g fructan and 0.46 g GOS per 100 g, despite
100 g
100 g
g per 100 g
Portion size
Fibre
Fibre
Fibre
Sprouted rye
Food item
6.86
7
4.24
5 Processed
3.47
4
2.31
3
1.88
2
1.45
1.4
1.02
1.00
0.97
1.2
0.90
0.90
0.89
0.78
1.0
0.70
0.54
0.8
0.55
0.44
0.43
0.6
0.34
0.06
0.19
0.02
0.12
0.10
0.4
0.2
0.0
s
l ic
at
on
os
as
ye
ke
oo
an
w
le
dn ean
he
ar
R
ho
e
hi
ni
he
ar
tr
p
be
G
W
c
O
ee
ck
b
B
ic
as
ta
ey
g
rt
B
hi
s
un
A
Pi
ki
ed
R
d
6 d
n nne
= ke
12
a
C
=
Figure 2 Total FODMAP (fermentable, oligo-, di-, mono-saccharides seen with longer cooking times. By contrast to the red
and polyols) content of different samples of dried (cooked) and lentils, red kidney beans had further reduction in FOD-
canned red kidney beans. Data are expressed as grams per 95 g MAP content with longer cooking times. This may have
serve. Dried forms of red kidney beans were cooked in accordance been a result in differences in the legume size. Red lentils,
with the packet instructions prior to analysis. The FODMAP content which are small, may allow the FODMAPs to leach out
was compared with the Monash University criteria to classify foods as
quickly; hence, no further reductions occurred with
low FODMAP (26), as indicated by the dashed line.
longer cooking times. A similar effect was seen where len-
tils had a much larger reduction in oligosaccharide con-
FODMAP rating from high to low. This lower FODMAP tent with cooking compared to other legumes tested in
content following pickling is in agreement with previous one study (37). Other proposed mechanisms for the reduc-
work also showing that pickling resulted in lower abdom- tion in carbohydrate content include heat hydrolysis (17).
inal symptoms and colonic fermentation (33). We propose By contrast, some studies have shown increased oligosac-
that the water solubility of FODMAPs and the likely charide content with cooking proposed to be a result of
leaching of FODMAPs into the pickling liquid is the the comparable leaching of other soluble components, as
mechanism by which the FODMAP content is reduced; well as the release of bound oligosaccharides during
Total FODMAP content of red lentils Total FODMAP content of red kidney beans
(g per 100 g) (g per 100 g)
6 6
Total FODMAP content (g per 100 g)
4 4
3 3
2 2
1 1
0 0
d
in
in
in
d
in
u n ie d
in
in
in
ed d )
d
d
in
ed
rie
ui
ui
ke
ui
m
m
m
m
m
ne
in
liq
liq
liq
D
So coo
D
10
20
30
5
10
20
30
5
ai
ra
tr
t
ne
ns
in
ns
in
ak
i
(u
(u
ra
ra
ed
St
in
St
in
ak
m
m
So
30
30
Figure 3 Effect of cooking conditions on the FODMAP (fermentable, oligo-, di-, mono-saccharides and polyols) content of (a) red lentils and (b)
red kidney beans compared to dried forms. Data are expressed per 100 g. The FODMAP content was compared with the Monash University
criteria to classify foods as low FODMAP (26), as indicated by the dashed line.
cooking (18,21,38). These divergent results may be releated to trial such techniques to determine their individual
to the legume variety used (18), whether or not the cook- tolerance.
ing liquid has been discarded (20), and/or differences in In conclusion, the improved knowledge of FODMAP
the cooking and subsequent cooling methods prior to composition from the present study can assist in
carbohydrate analysis. improving the ability of vegetarians or vegans who
The clinical implications of these results will only be require a low FODMAP diet to better adhere to the
fully understood after conducting longitudinal studies dietary guidelines. The most common FODMAPs found
of vegetarian and/or vegan patients following the low in these plant-based foods were fructans and GOS.
FODMAP diet with a comprehensive analysis of dietary Expanding low FODMAP food choice by the strategy of
intake. Theoretically, the results provided by the present cooking and removing strained liquid from legumes is
studies will allow patients to increase their intake of likely to enhance protein intake in those who are follow-
foods containing low and moderate amounts of fruc- ing a low FODMAP diet. Other food processing tech-
tans and GOS, improving their prebiotic intake. Dieti- niques, such as pickling, provide additional ways of
tians should encourage their patients to include the improving patient tolerance of high FODMAP foods.
foods and food constituents found to be low in FOD- The variation in FODMAP content found in the present
MAP content during the initial phase of the low FOD- study, depending on product, food processing and cook-
MAP diet. Dietitians should target foods containing ing methods, highlights the importance of individual tol-
nutrients of concern, such as tempeh in an individual erance testing in patients with IBS (39). Reductions in
with low iron intake. Foods not meeting the low FOD- FODMAP content via food processing and cooking tech-
MAP cut-off criteria at a standard serving size could niques, even if only modest, may improve patient toler-
then be trialled in small quantity during the re-chal- ance. These results can be translated into practice to
lenge phase with a gradual increase in serving size to allow patients to maximise symptom relief and nutri-
assess individual patient tolerance (39). For example, tional adequacy at the same time as minimising dietary
first by commencing the patient on 100 mL of Quinoa restrictions.
milk, which did meet the low FODMAP cut-off, and
gradually increasing the serving size as tolerated toward
Transparency declaration
a standard serving size of 250 mL, which did not meet
the low FODMAP criteria. Dietitians should educate The lead author affirms that this manuscript is an honest,
their patients on the effect of food processing and accurate and transparent account of the study being
cooking on FODMAP content and encourage patients reported. The lead author affirms that no important
Table 3 Sample vegetarian and vegan low FODMAP meal plans incorporating newly analysed food items
Vegetarian
Breakfast ¼ cup of low FODMAP muesli (made with oats, rice or quinoa puffs, 10 almonds, 1 Macadamia milk: calcium
tbs of dried cranberries but without other dried fruits), served with 250 mL of lactose Wheat grass: vitamin A
free cow’s milk (vegans: use calcium fortified macadamia milk†), topped with 10 fresh
or frozen raspberriesWheat grass drink† (made with 3.5 g of wheat grass)
Snack 10 almonds
Lunch Sandwich made with two slices gluten free bread or spelt sourdough bread, 20 g of Soy cheese: protein
cheddar cheese (vegans: use soy cheese†), 60 g of pickled beetroot†, low FODMAP Pickled beetroot: folate
salad ingredients (e.g. lettuce, tomato, cucumber)
Snack One cup of fresh grapes
Dinner Stir fry made with 100 g of false chicken† (made from gluten), 113 g of kelp noodles†, False chicken: protein
95 g of sprouted mung beans†, 45 g of pickled onion†, low FODMAP vegetables Kelp noodles: iodine
(e.g. bok choy, baby corns, green beans), one egg stir-fried (vegans: use egg replacer†), Sprouted mung beans: fibre
soy sauce Pickled onion: prebiotic fibre
Egg replacer: protein
Snack 170 g of lactose free yoghurt (vegans: use coconut yoghurt†) Coconut yoghurt: fat
Vegan
Breakfast Oats (" cup) made with 250 mL of calcium fortified macadamia milk† (vegetarians: Macadamia milk: calcium rice protein:
option to use lactose free cow’s milk), topped with 10 fresh or frozen strawberriesRice protein
protein drink made with 40 g of rice protein isolate† and water
Snack Fresh orange
Lunch Homemade minestrone soup made with canned red kidney beans† (limit to 95 g of red Canned red kidney beans: prebiotic fibre,
kidney beans per serve), rice and low FODMAP vegetables (e.g. carrot, tomato, potato) protein
Add 16 g of nutritional yeast† as a topping (source of Vitamin B12 with a cheese-style Nutritional yeast: Vitamin B12
flavour) (vegetarians: option to use parmesan cheese)
Snack Rice crackers with 40 g of soy cheese† (vegetarians: option to use regular cheese) Soy cheese: protein
Dinner Peanut marinated tempeh salad, made with 100 g of tempeh† marinated in maximum Tempeh: protein, iron, zinc
of 32 peanuts, two cups of mixed low FODMAP salad vegetables (e.g. lettuce, tomato,
cucumber, roasted eggplant) and one cup of cooked rice and/or quinoa
Snack 125 g of coconut yoghurt† (vegetarians: option to use lactose free yoghurt) Coconut yoghurt: fat
†
Indicates newly tested foods.
aspects of the study have been omitted and that any dis- References
crepancies from the study as planned have been
explained. 1. Tuck CJ, Muir JG, Barrett JS et al. (2014) Fermentable
oligosaccharides, disaccharides, monosaccharides and
Conflict of interests, sources of funding and polyols: role in irritable bowel syndrome. Expert Rev
authorship Gastroenterol Hepatol 8, 819–834.
The Department of Gastroenterology financially bene- 2. Mckenzie YA, Bowyer RK, Leach H et al. (2016) British
fits from the sales of a digital application and booklets Dietetic Association systematic review and evidence-based
on the low FODMAP diet. P Gibson has published an practice guidelines for the dietary management of irritable
educational/recipe book on diet. bowel syndrome in adults (2016 update). J Hum Nutr Diet
C. Tuck was supported by an Australian Postgraduate 29, 549–575.
Award Scholarship. 3. Drossman DA (2016) Functional gastrointestinal disorders:
CT, JB and JM designed the study. CT, EL, AB and IC history, pathophysiology, clinical features, and Rome IV.
collected and analysed the samples. CT interpreted the Gastroenterology 150, 1262–1279.
data. CT, JM, JB and PG drafted the manuscript. CT 4. Sperber AD, Dumitrascu D, Fukudo S et al. (2016) The
had primary responsibility for final content. All authors global prevalence of IBS in adults remains elusive due to
have read and approved the final manuscript submitted the heterogeneity of studies: a Rome Foundation working
for publication. team literature review. Gut 66, 1075–1082.
5. Marsh A, Eslick EM & Eslick GD (2016) Does a diet low
in FODMAPs reduce symptoms associated with functional
gastrointestinal disorders? A comprehensive systematic 22. Tuck CJ, Taylor KM, Gibson PR et al. (2018) Increasing
review and meta-analysis. Eur J Nutr 55, 897–906. symptoms in irritable bowel symptoms with ingestion of
6. Leitzmann C (2014) Vegetarian nutrition: past, present, galacto-oligosaccharides are mitigated by [alpha]-
future. Am J Clin Nutr 100, 496S–502S. galactosidase treatment. Am J Gastroenterol 113, 124–134.
7. Buscail C, Sabate J-M, Bouchoucha M et al. (2017) 23. Food Standards Australia New Zealand (2010) NUTTAB
Association between self-reported vegetarian diet and the 2010. Available at: http://www.foodstandards.gov.au/scie
irritable bowel syndrome in the French NutriNet cohort. nce/monitoringnutrients/nutrientables (accessed on 20
PLoS ONE 12, e0183039. August 2017).
8. National health and medical research council (2013) 24. Yao C, Tan HL, Langenberg D et al. (2013) Dietary sorbitol
Australian dietary guidelines. National Health and Medical and mannitol: food content and distinct absorption patterns
Research Council: Canberra. between healthy individuals and patients with irritable
9. Marsh K, Zeuschner C, Saunders A et al. (2009) Meeting bowel syndrome. J Hum Nutr Diet 27, 264.
nutritional needs on a vegetarian diet. Aust Fam Physician 25. Prichard R, Rossi M, Muir J et al. (2016) Fermentable
38, 600. oligosaccharide, disaccharide, monosaccharide and polyol
10. Muir JG, Shepherd SJ, Rosella O et al. (2007) Fructan and content of foods commonly consumed by ethnic minority
free fructose content of common Australian vegetables and groups in the United Kingdom. Int J Food Sci Nutr 67,
fruit. J Agric Food Chem 55, 6619. 383–390.
11. Muir JG, Rose R, Rosella O et al. (2009) Measurement of 26. Varney J, Barrett J, Scarlata K et al. (2017) FODMAPs:
short-chain carbohydrates in common Australian food composition, defining cutoff values and international
vegetables and fruits by high-performance liquid application. J Gastroenterol Hepatol 32, 53–61.
chromatography (HPLC). J Agric Food Chem 57, 554. 27. Staudacher H, Ross F, Briscoe Z et al. (2015) PTU-183
12. Biesiekierski JR, Rosella O, Rose R et al. (2011) Advice from a dietitian regarding the low fodmap diet
Quantification of fructans, galacto-oligosacharides and broadly maintains nutrient intake and does not alter fibre
other short-chain carbohydrates in processed grains and intake. Gut 64, A143–A144.
cereals. J Hum Nutr Diet 24, 154–76. 28. Kouris-Blazos A & Belski R (2016) Health benefits of
13. Monash University (2017) The Monash University Low legumes and pulses with a focus on Australian sweet
FODMAP App. Available at: http://www.med.monash.edu/ lupins. Asia Pac J Clin Nutr 25, 1–17.
cecs/gastro/fodmap/ (accessed on 20 August 2017). 29. Matella NJ, Dolan KD, Stoeckle AW et al. (2005) Use of
14. Tosh SM & Yada S (2010) Dietary fibres in pulse seeds hydration, germination, and a-galactosidase treatments to
and fractions: characterization, functional attributes, and reduce oligosaccharides in dry beans. J Food Sci 70, C203–
applications. Food Res Int 43, 450–460. C207.
15. Ruperez P (1998) Oligosaccharides in raw and processed 30. Leblanc JG, Ledue-Clier F, Bensaada M et al. (2008)
legumes. Z Lebensm Unters F A 206, 130–133. Ability of Lactobacillus fermentum to overcome host
16. Wang N, Hatcher D, Toews R et al. (2009) Influence of alpha-galactosidase deficiency, as evidenced by reduction
cooking and dehulling on nutritional composition of of hydrogen excretion in rats consuming soya alpha-
several varieties of lentils (Lens culinaris). LWT – Food Sci galacto-oligosaccharides. BMC Microbiol 8, 22.
Technol 42, 842–848. 31. De Fatima Viana S, Guimar~aes VM, Jose IC et al. (2005)
17. Johnson CR, Thavarajah P, Payne S et al. (2015) Hydrolysis of oligosaccharides in soybean flour by soybean
Processing, cooking, and cooling affect prebiotic a-galactosidase. Food Chem 93, 665–670.
concentrations in lentil (Lens culinaris Medikus). J Food 32. Food Standards Australia New Zealand (2015) Generating
Comp Anal 38, 106–111. data for FSANZ nutrient datasets. Available at: https://
18. Han IH & Baik BK (2006) Oligosaccharide content and www.foodstandards.gov.au/science/monitoringnutrients/
composition of legumes and their reduction by soaking, nutrientables/Documents/FSANZ%20nutrient%20datasets.
cooking, ultrasound, and high hydrostatic pressure. Cereal pdf (accessed on 3 December 2017).
Chem 83, 428–433. 33. Ferris, S, Muir, J, Rosella, O etal. (2008) Minimising
19. Onigbinde A & Akinyele I (1983) Oligosaccharide content colonic fermentation of high fructan foods: using food
of 20 varieties of cowpeas in Nigeria. J Food Sci 48, 1250– processing techniques to reduce levels of fructans in onion
1251. and garlic. 32nd Nutrition Society of Australia Annual
20. Rehman Z, Salariya A & Zafar S (2001) Effect of Scientific Meeting.
processing on available carbohydrate content and starch 34. Kim S-H, Yang Y-S & Chung I-M (2016) Effect of acetic
digestibility of kidney beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). Food acid treatment on isoflavones and carbohydrates in pickled
Chem 73, 351–355. soybean. Food Res Int 81, 58–65.
21. Rao PU & Belavady B (1978) Oligosaccharides in pulses: 35. Rejano L, Sanchez A, Castro AD et al. (1997) Chemical
varietal differences and effects of cooking and germination. characteristics and storage stability of pickled garlic
J Agr Food Chem 26, 316–319. prepared using different processes. J Food Sci 62, 1120–1123.
36. Corder A & Henry R (1989) Carbohydrate-degrading 39. Tuck CJ & Barrett JS (2017) Re-challenging FODMAPs:
enzymes in germinating wheat. Cereal Chem 66, 435–439. the low FODMAP diet phase two. J Gastroenterol Hepatol
37. Baik B-K & Han IH (2012) Cooking, roasting, and 32, 11–15.
fermentation of chickpeas, lentils, peas, and soybeans for
fortification of leavened bread. Cereal Chem 89, 269–275.
38. Campos-Vega R, Reynoso-Camacho R, Pedraza-Aboytes G
Supporting information
et al. (2009) Chemical composition and in vitro Additional Supporting Information may be found online
polysaccharide fermentation of different beans (Phaseolus in the supporting information tab for this article:
vulgaris L.). J Food Sci 74, T59–T65. Table S1. Food description and sampling details