Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CCATMPH005
CCATMPH005
CCATMPH005
ATHIRA K
Reg: No: ---CCATMPH005-------
2019-2021
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that the project report entitled “LIGHT CURVE ANALYSIS OF
CLASSICAL CEPHEIDS” submitted to the Post Graduate and Research Department
of Physics by ATHIRA K (Reg: No: ---CCATMPH005------- ) is bona-fide work
done by her under my guidance at Post Graduate and Research Department of Physics,
Christ College (Autonomous), Irinjalakuda in partial fulfilment of the requirements for
MSc Degree in Physics.
DECLARATION
Contents
Acknowledgement
ABSTRACT
1.STARS
1.1 Introduction
1.2 History
1.3 Star naming
1.4 Star formation
1.5 Evolution of stars
1.6 Stellar structure
1.7 Stellar Classification-------------------------------------------------------------- 15
2. VARIABLE STARS
2.1 History of variable stars
2.2 Classification of variable stars
2.2.1 Intrinsic variable stars
2.2.2 Extrinsic variable stars
2.3 Variable stars: Future research----------------------------------------------- 20
3. PULSATING VARIABLE STARS
3.1Types of pulsating variable stars
3.1.1 Cepheids
3.1.2 RR Lyrae
3.1.3 RV Tauri
3.1.4 Long-periodic variables(LPVs)
3.2 Reason for stellar pulsation----------------------------------------------------
26
4.CEPHEID VARIABLE STAR AND DISTANCE DETERMINATION
4.1 Discovery of the period-luminosity relationship
4.1.2 Apparent magnitude and absolute magnitude
4.2 Calculating distance using cepheids
4.3 Standard candles
4.4 Hubble key project--------------------------------------------------------------- 33
5.1 Period04
5.1 The Time string module
5.2 The Fit module
5.3 The Fourier module
5.2 Properties calculated------------------------------------------------------------ 36
6.DATA ANALYSIS
6.1 STAR ID: OGLE-LMC-CEP-0001 This
proj
6.2 STAR ID: OGLE-LMC-CEP-0002 ect
6.3 STAR ID: OGLE-LMC-CEP-0003 repo
rt
6.4 STAR ID: OGLE-LMC-CEP-0004 deal
s
6.5 STAR ID: OGLE-LMC-CEP-0005
with
6.6 STAR ID: OGLE-LMC-CEP-0006 the
“LIG
6.7 STAR ID: OGLE-LMC-CEP-0007 HT
6.8 STAR ID: OGLE-LMC-CEP-0008 CUR
VE
6.9 STAR ID: OGLE-LMC-CEP-0009 ANA
6.10 STAR ID: OGLE-LMC-CEP-0010----------------------------------------------- LYSI
57
S OF
7. OBSERVATIONS CLA
SSIC
7.1 STAR ID: OGLE-LMC-CEP-0001 AL
7.2 STAR ID: OGLE-LMC-CEP-0002 CEP
HEI
7.3 STAR ID: OGLE-LMC-CEP-0003 DS”.
A
7.4 STAR ID: OGLE-LMC-CEP-0004
vari
7.5 STAR ID: OGLE-LMC-CEP-0005 able
star
7.6 STAR ID: OGLE-LMC-CEP-0006 is
7.7 STAR ID: OGLE-LMC-CEP-0007 simp
ly
7.8 STAR ID: OGLE-LMC-CEP-0008 one
7.9 STAR ID: OGLE-LMC-CEP-0009 who
se
7.10 STAR ID: OGLE-LMC-CEP-0010 brig
htne
7.11 Distance calculated------------------------------------------------------------- 76
ss
8. CONCLUSION cha
nges
REFERENCE over
time
. It is
divi
ded
into
two,
nam
ely
6
Acknowledgments
I am indeed happy and thankful for being able to do a project in the Post Graduate
and Research Department of Physics, Christ College (Autonomous). Irinjalakuda. I
hereby express my deep and sincere gratitude to my Guide Dr. SHAJU K.Y. who has
been very inspiring and encouraging to this project work. He helped to complete my
project work by giving valuable suggestions and information. It is with the sincere
gratitude that I acknowledge the intellectual guidance, efficient supervision and
constant encouragement I received from my guide. I would also express my thanks to
all the members of all teaching and non-teaching staff of department of physics, Christ
College for their Co-operation and giving information at various stages of my work. I
also thank all my friends and others for the help and co-operation given to me.
ATHIRA K
7
ABSTRACT
This project report deals with the “LIGHT CURVE ANALYSIS OF CLASSICAL CEPHEIDS”.
A variable star is simply one whose brightness changes over time. It is divided into two,
namely Extrinsic variables and Intrinsic Variables. Extrinsic variables and Intrinsic
variables are again classified into many categories, in which this study is focussed on
Classical cepheids; a Type 1 pulsating variable star.
Cepheid Variable is a type of star that pulsates radially, varying in both diameter and
temperature and producing changes in brightness with a well-defined stable period
and amplitude. Using the software “Period04”, I have analysed the time series of
classical Cepheid stars and parameters such as frequency, time period, epochs, signal
at different times and noise at fitted frequencies were found out. Then using the direct
relationship between a Cepheid variable’s luminosity and pulsation period; the
absolute magnitude of cepheids were found out. It is because of this strong established
relationship, cepheids serve as an important indicator of cosmic benchmarks for
scaling galactic and extragalactic distances. From the absolute magnitude found out,
the spectral class of each star were found out. Then using the distance-modulus
formulae; the distance to the cepheids were found in parsecs. Hence I tabulated the
distance of Cepheids in LMC in units of parsecs. If we infer the that the size of the LMC
relative to its distance from us is small, we have also found the distance to the LMC
within which the Cepheid is located. As the number of stars observed goes up, the
uncertainties involved in calculations for individual stars can be statistically reduced.
Hence the basic steps for distance calculation using pulsating variables are
straightforward. Here, I have also calculated the uncertainties involved in the
calculated parameters using the software in comparison to an ideal situation. This
distance to the classical cepheids played an important role in the determination of
Hubble constant, which gives a measure of the expansion of universe.
8
In this project, ten classical cepheids have been selected from the Optical Gravitational
Lensing Experiment (OGLE) Survey. The thesis is broadly divided in to 8 chapters.
Chapter 1 deals with the Introduction, History, Nomenclature of stars, Formation and
Evolution of stars, Stellar structure and Stellar Classification. Chapter 2 deals with the
History, Classification and the scope of research of Variable Stars. Chapter 3 gives brief
description about Pulsating Variable stars and its different classes. It also gives a brief
description about the Reason for stellar pulsations. Chapter 4 include the detailed view
on Classical Cepheids and the distance determination. This chapter gives light on the
Period-Luminosity relationships of Classical Cepheids and also explain in detail the
steps involved in calculating the distance to the star with an example. It also gives a
hint on how this distance calculation helped the Hubble Key project in distance
calculation and establishment of Hubble’s Law. Chapter 5 describes about the tools
used for extracting star parameters. Chapter 6 include the result of data analysis.
Chapter 7 includes the tabulated result obtained from the software alongside with the
distance calculated to the stars manually. Chapter 8 concludes this project.
9
Chapter 1
STARS
1.1 INTRODUCTION
Stars are the most widely recognized astronomical object and can be called as the
fundamental building blocks of galaxies. From the age, distribution and composition of
the stars, we can trace back the history, dynamics and the evolution of galaxy. Stars
are also responsible for the manufacture and distribution of heavy elements such as
carbon, oxygen and nitrogen. Their characteristics is also tied to the characteristics of
planetary system that may coalesce about them. This makes the study of birth, life and
death of a star; central to the field of astronomy.
1.2 HISTORY
Since the dawn of recorded civilization, stars played a pivotal role in navigation.
Astronomy, the study of heavens may be the most ancient of the sciences. The
discovery of law of motion and gravity together with the invention of telescope in the
17th century made us realise that stars too were just like sun, all obeying the same law
of physics. In the 19th century photography and spectroscopy- the study of wavelength
of light that objects emit; made it possible to investigate the compositions and motion
of star from afar, leading to the development of astrophysics.
The first radio telescope was built in 1973, enabling the astronomers to detect the
otherwise invisible radiation from stars. The first gamma-ray telescope launched in
1961, pioneered the study of star explosions(supernovae ).
10
Also in the 1960s, astronomers commenced the infrared observations using the
balloon-borne telescopes, gathering information about stars and other objects based
on their heat emissions. The first infrared telescope (the Infrared Astronomical
Satellite) was launched in 1983.
Microwave emissions were first studied from space in 1992, with NASA’s Cosmic
Microwave Background Explorer (COBE) satellite. (Even though they are used to probe
the young universe’s origin, they are occasionally used to study stars.) In 1990, the first
space-based optical telescope, the Hubble Space Telescope, was launched, providing
the deepest and detailed view of the universe.
Currently, more advanced observatories are there and even more powerful ones are
planned like the European Extremely Large Telescope (E-ELT), which is planned to start
observation in 2024. Also, there is James Webb Space Telescope-which is built as a
successor to Hubble Space Telescope as NASA’s flagship astrophysics mission.
Scheduled to launch on 2021, it will provide improved infrared resolution and
sensitivity over Hubble. The key goal of JWST is to search for light from the first stars
and galaxies that formed in the Universe after the Bib Bang and also to study the
formation of stars and planetary systems.
A number of stars have possessed names since antiquity — Betelgeuse, for instance,
means "the hand (or the armpit) of the giant" in Arabic. It is the brightest star in Orion,
and its scientific name is Alpha Orionis. Also, different astronomers over the year have
compiled star catalogues that use unique numbering systems. The Henry Draper
Catalogue, named after a pioneer in astrophotography, provides spectral classification
and rough positions for 272,150 stars and has been widely used of by the astronomical
community for over half a century. The catalogue designates Betelgeuse as HD 39801.
Since there are so many stars in the universe, the IAU uses a different system for
newfound stars. Most consist of an abbreviation that stands for either the type of star
or a catalogue that lists information about the star, followed by a group of symbols.
For instance, PSR J1302-6350 is a pulsar, thus the PSR. The J reveals that a coordinate
system known as J2000 is being used, while the 1302 and 6350 are coordinates similar
to the latitude and longitude codes used on Earth.
In recent years, the IAU formalized several names for stars amid calls from the
astronomical community to include the public in their naming process. The IAU
formalized 14 star names in the 2015 "Name ExoWorlds" contest, taking suggestions
from science and astronomy clubs around the world.
Then in 2016, the IAU approved 227 star names, mostly taking cues from antiquity in
making its decision. The goal was to reduce variations in star names and also spelling
("Formalhaut", for example, had 30 recorded variations.) However, the long-standing
name "Alpha Centauri" – referring to a famous star system with planets just four light
years from Earth – was replaced with Rigel Kentaurus.
A star develops from a giant, slowly rotating cloud that is made up entirely or almost
entirely of hydrogen and helium. Due to its own gravitational pull, the cloud behind to
collapse inward, and as it shrinks, it spins more and more quickly, with the outer parts
becoming a disk while the innermost parts become a roughly spherical clump.
12
According to NASA, this collapsing material grows hotter and denser, forming a ball-
shaped protostar. When the heat and pressure in the protostar reaches about 1.8
million degrees Fahrenheit (1 million degrees Celsius), atomic nuclei that normally
repel each other start fusing together, and the star ignites. Nuclear fusion converts a
small amount of the mass of these atoms into extraordinary amounts of energy — for
instance, 1 gram of mass converted entirely to energy would be equal to an explosion
of roughly 22,000 tons of TNT.
The life cycles of stars follow patterns based mostly on their initial mass. These include
intermediate-mass stars such as the sun, with half to eight times the mass of the sun,
high-mass stars that are more than eight solar masses, and low-mass stars a tenth to
half a solar mass in size. The greater a star's mass, the shorter its lifespan generally is.
Objects smaller than a tenth of a solar mass do not have enough gravitational pull to
ignite nuclear fusion — some might become failed stars known as brown dwarfs.
An intermediate-mass star begins with a cloud that takes about 100,000 years to
collapse into a protostar with a surface temperature of about 6,750 F (3,725 C). After
hydrogen fusion starts, the result is a T-Tauri star, a variable star that fluctuates in
brightness. This star continues to collapse for roughly 10 million years until its
expansion due to energy generated by nuclear fusion is balanced by its contraction
from gravity, after which point it becomes a main-sequence star that gets all its energy
from hydrogen fusion in its core.
The greater the mass of such a star, the more quickly it will use its hydrogen fuel and
the shorter it stays on the main sequence. After all the hydrogen in the core is fused
into helium, the star changes rapidly — without nuclear radiation to resist it, gravity
immediately crushes matter down into the star's core, quickly heating the star. This
causes the star's outer layers to expand enormously and to cool and glow red as they
13
do so, rendering the star a red giant. Helium starts fusing together in the core, and
once the helium is gone, the core contracts and becomes hotter, once more expanding
the star but making it bluer and brighter than before, blowing away its outermost
layers. After the expanding shells of gas fade, the remaining core is left, a white dwarf
that consists mostly of carbon and oxygen with an initial temperature of roughly
180,000 degrees F (100,000 degrees C). Since white dwarves have no fuel left for
fusion, they grow cooler and cooler over billions of years to become black dwarves too
faint to detect. (Our sun should leave the main sequence in about 5 billion years.)
A high-mass star forms and dies quickly. These stars form from protostars in just 10,000
to 100,000 years. While on the main sequence, they are hot and blue, some 1,000 to 1
million times as luminous as the sun and are roughly 10 times wider. When they leave
the main sequence, they become a bright red supergiant, and eventually become hot
enough to fuse carbon into heavier elements. After some 10,000 years of such fusion,
the result is an iron core roughly 3,800 miles wide (6,000 km), and since any more
fusion would consume energy instead of liberating it, the star is doomed, as its nuclear
radiation can no longer resist the force of gravity.
When a star reaches a mass of more than 1.4 solar masses, electron pressure cannot
support the core against further collapse, according to NASA. The result is a supernova.
Gravity causes the core to collapse, making the core temperature rise to nearly 18
billion degrees F (10 billion degrees C), breaking the iron down into neutrons and
neutrinos. In about one second, the core shrinks to about six miles (10 km) wide and
rebounds just like a rubber ball that has been squeezed, sending a shock wave through
the star that causes fusion to occur in the outlying layers. The star then explodes in a
so-called Type II supernova. If the remaining stellar core was less than roughly three
solar masses large, it becomes a neutron star made up nearly entirely of neutrons, and
rotating neutron stars that beam out detectable radio pulses are known as pulsars. If
the stellar core was larger than about three solar masses, no known force can support
it against its own gravitational pull, and it collapses to form a black hole.
14
A low-mass star uses hydrogen fuel so sluggishly that they can shine as main-sequence
stars for 100 billion to 1 trillion years — since the universe is only about 13.7 billion
years old, according to NASA, this means no low-mass star has ever died. Still,
astronomers calculate these stars, known as red dwarfs, will never fuse anything but
hydrogen, which means they will never become red giants. Instead, they should
eventually just cool to become white dwarfs and then black dwarves.
The structure of a star can often be thought of as a series of thin nested shells,
somewhat like an onion. A star during most of its life is a main-sequence star, which
consists of a core, radiative and convective zones, a photosphere, a chromosphere and
a corona. The core is where all the nuclear fusion takes places to power a star. In the
radiative zone, energy from these reactions is transported outward by radiation, like
heat from a light bulb, while in the convective zone, energy is transported by the roiling
hot gases, like hot air from a hairdryer. Massive stars that are more than several times
the mass of the sun are convective in their cores and radiative in their outer layers,
while stars comparable to the sun or less in mass are radiative in their cores and
convective in their outer layers. Intermediate-mass stars of spectral type A may be
radiative throughout.
After those zones comes the part of the star that radiates visible light, the
photosphere, which is often referred to as the surface of the star. After that is the
chromosphere, a layer that looks reddish because of all the hydrogen found there.
Finally, the outermost part of a star's atmosphere is the corona, which if super-hot
might be linked with convection in the outer layers.
15
For this reason, the Morgan-Keenan luminosity class (MK or MKK) was established.
Originally containing roman numerals between I (supergiant star) and V (main
sequence), these days, class I stars have been subdivided into Ia-O, Ia and Ib, and
classes VI (sub-dwarf) and D (white dwarf) have been added.
To completely describe the star, the MK luminosity class is appended to the original
Harvard classification for the star. For example, our Sun is a main sequence G2 star,
therefore its full classification is G2V.
CLASS STAR
Ia-O extremely luminous supergiant
Ia luminous supergiant
Ib less luminous supergiant
II bright giants
III normal giants
IV subgiant
V main sequence dwarf stars
VI, or sd sub dwarfs
D White dwarfs
16
Chapter 2
VARIABLE STARS
A variable star is, quite simply, a star that changes brightness. A star is considered
variable if its apparent magnitude (brightness) is altered in any way from our
perspective on Earth. These changes can occur over years or just fractions of a second,
and can range from one-thousandth of a magnitude to 20 magnitudes. More than
100,000 variable stars are known and have been catalogued, and thousands more are
suspected variables. Our own sun is a variable star; its energy output varies by
approximately 0.1 percent, or one-thousandth of its magnitude, over an 11-year solar
cycle.
The first modern identified variable star was Omicron Ceti, later renamed Mira. It had
been described as a nova in 1596 by David Fabricius. In 1638, Johannes Holwards
observed Omicron Cetipulsating in a regular 11-month cycle. This was an important
discovery, as it helped verify that the stars were not eternal and invariable as ancient
philosophers such as Aristotle had believed. The discovery of variable stars, along with
reports of supernovae, paved the way for development of the science of astronomy.
In the abstract of a talk given to celebrate the 400th anniversary of Mira’s discovery,
Dorrit Hoffleit, of Yale University, said, “Within the first century following Fabricius,
four Mira-type variables were discovered, and in all cases it has been found that the
stars were suspected of being novae long before their "official" discovery in the
Western World. Three of the four had been recorded as novae in early Chinese or
Korean records.”
17
There are a number of reasons for variability. These include changes in star luminosity
or in star mass, and obstructions in the amount of light that reaches Earth. Pulsating
variables swell and shrink. Eclipsing binaries get dimmer when a companion star moves
in front, then brighten as the occulting star moves away. Some of the identified
variable stars are actually two very close stars that exchange mass when one takes
atmosphere from the other.
There are two different categories of variable stars. Intrinsic variables are stars whose
luminosity physically changes due to pulsations, eruptions or through swelling and
shrinking. Extrinsic variables are stars that change in brightness because of being
eclipsed by stellar rotation or by another star or planet.
spherical in shape, while in the case of non-radial pulsations, the star’s shape
periodically deviates from a sphere, and even neighbouring zones of its surface may
have opposite pulsation phase.
The brightest measured nova since 1901 was Nova Aquilae, which in 1918 shone
almost as brightly as Sirius, the brightest star in the sky. Dwarf Novae are double white
stars that transfer mass and cause outbursts of regular variations. Another form of
explosive variable are Symbiotic stars, close binary systems with a red giant and a hot
blue star enmeshed in a cloud of dust or gas.
a) Eclipsing binaries
Eclipsing Binary Stars are stars that pass in front of each other, causing fluctuation and
obscuring of the light seen on Earth. Eclipsing binary stars may have their own planets,
which eclipse their light similar to a lunar eclipse on Earth. One of the best-known
eclipsing binary stars is Algol. Algol variables undergo eclipses with one or two minima
separated by periods of nearly constant light. The prototype of this class is Algol in the
constellation Perseus. Beta Lyrae (β Lyr) variables are extremely close binaries, named
after the star Sheliak. The light curves of this class of eclipsing variables are constantly
changing, making it almost impossible to determine the exact onset and end of each
eclipse.
Chapter 3
Pulsating variable stars
Pulsating variable stars are intrinsic variables as their variation in brightness is due to
a physical change within the star. In the case of pulsating variables this is due to the
periodic expansion and contraction of the surface layers of the stars. This means the
star actually increases and decreases in size periodically. The different types of
pulsating variable are distinguished by their periods of pulsation and the shapes of
their light curves. These in turn are a function of the mass and evolutionary stage of a
given star.
In October 1595 the Dutchman David Fabricus observed the star ο Ceti to disappear.
The same star was noted to vary in brightness during 1638-39 by another Dutch
observer and became known as Mira (the "Wonderful") due to its behaviour. It was
eventually found to have a period of about 334 days and was the first pulsating variable
discovered. Its light curve was different to that of Algol which was correctly inferred to
be an eclipsing binary by the brilliant young English astronomer John Goodricke in
1782.
22
3.1.1 CEPHEIDS
Cepheid are very luminous, massive variables with periods of 1 -70 days. They are
named after the first-such pulsating variable, δ Cephei discovered by John Goodricke
in 1784. Cepheid light curves are distinctive and show a rapid rise in brightness
followed by a more gradual decline, shaped like a shark fin. Their amplitude range is
typically 0.5 to 2 magnitudes. The spectral class of a Cepheid actually changes as it
pulsates, being about an F at maximum luminosity and down to a G or K at minimum.
There are in fact two types of Cepheids, the original Type I or Classical Cepheids of
which δ Cephei is an example and the slightly dimmer Type II or W Virginis Cepheids.
Both types are located in a region of the HR Diagram called the Instability Strip.
These stars take their name from δ Cephei. Most have a period of between 5 -10 days
and an amplitude range of 0.5 - 2.0 magnitudes in visible light. The variations are less
pronounced at infrared wavebands. They are 1.5 - 2 magnitudes more luminous than
Type II Cepheids. The distinctive light curve for δ Cephei is shown below.
23
The light curve for δ Cephei shows a distinctive rapid rise in brightness followed by a
more gradual decrease. δ Cephei has a period of 5.366 days and a magnitude range of
just under 1. This means that it is about twice as bright at its maximum than at its
minimum.
➢ Type II W Virginis
Type II Cepheids are named after the first star identified in this group, W Virginis. It has
a period of 17.2736 days, magnitude range of 9.46 - 10.75 and a spectral class range of
F0Ib-G0Ib.W Virginis -type Cepheids are intrinsically less luminous by 1.5 - 2
magnitudes than the Type I Classical Cepheids and have typical periods of 12 - 30 days.
As they are older stars than Type Is their spectra are characterised by having lower
metallicities. Type II light curves show a characteristic bump on the decline side and
they have an amplitude range of 0.3 - 1.2 magnitudes. As with the Type I Cepheids they
also display a similar well-defined period-luminosity relationship and can be used for
distance determination.
3.1.2 RR Lyrae
These old population II giant stars are mostly found in globular clusters. They are
characterised by their short periods, usually about 1.5 hours to a day and have a
brightness range of 0.3 to 2 magnitudes. Spectral classes range from A7 to F5. RR Lyrae
stars are less massive than Cepheids but they also follow their own period - luminosity
relationship, with a mean absolute magnitude of +0.6. They are thus useful in
determining distances to the globular clusters within which they are commonly found
to a distance of about 200 kilo parsecs. Sub-types are classified according to the shape
of their light curves. RR Lyraes fit on the Instability Strip on an HR diagram.
24
3.1.3 RV Tauri
RV Tauri variables are yellow supergiant, mostly G and K-class stars. Their distinctive
light curves show alternating deep and shallow minima with the period equal to the
time between two successive deep minima. Typical values are 20 - 100 days.
➢ Mira -Type
Mira or ο Ceti, established as a variable in 1638 gives its name to stars of this type.
Mira itself has a period of 331 days and varies its brightness by almost 6 magnitudes in
the visible waveband during a cycle. A red giant, its radius varies by 20 percent, peaking
at 330 times that of our Sun. Its effective temperature ranges from 1,900 K to 2,600 K.
It is also a visual binary and its companion is also a variable star. he Mira-type stars
have long periods, ranging from about 80 to 1,000 days, varying by 2.5 to 10
magnitudes visually. Their high luminosities mean they can, at maximum brightness,
be detected at large distances. They have tenuous outer layers in their atmospheres
which get shocked and heated from the regular pulsations. This can give rise to
emission lines in their spectra. Dust grains in their outer atmosphere get heated so
they are strong emitters in infrared wavebands. They also show evidence of molecules
in these regions
As their name implies, these stars whilst showing some periodicity and variations in
brightness also exhibit irregularities where they appear to be stable. They are giant and
supergiant stars with periods ranging from a few days to several years and the change
in brightness is typically less than two magnitudes. The light curves of semiregular have
25
a variety of shapes. Prominent examples of this type include Antares, α Scorpius, and
Betelgeuse, α Orionis.
We tend to think of stars as stable and unchanging. But in reality, stars undergo several
stages in their existence. Main sequence stars such as our Sun nonetheless are basically
stable, exhibiting no dramatic changes in size or brightness. They are in what is called
hydrostatic equilibrium, that is the gravitational force pulling the star's material
inwards is balanced by the radiation pressure and the gas pressure. The radiation
pressure acts outwards and arises from the production of photons in the core by fusion
processes. Gas pressure is much the same as any gas on Earth resisting attempts to
compress it. But still some stars pulsate.
This pulsation is not due to increased radiation pressure from higher rates of fusion in
the core. In fact, pulsations arise not from the rate of fusion which remains constant
in the core but instead from variations in the rate at which the radiation can escape
from the star.
➢ If the pressure outwards exceed the gravitational force inwards, the outer layers of
a star will expand outwards.
➢ As the star expands, its gravitational force inwards diminishes but its outwards
pressure also drops at an even greater rate (think of what happens to a gas as it
expands).
26
➢ Eventually the star would reach a position at which hydrostatic equilibrium occurs,
that is gravity = pressure. However, the outward moving layers still have
momentum so resist a change in motion. This momentum carries the layer past
the equilibrium position.
➢ As the gravitational force acts on the layer it slows down. A point is reached where
it stops but now the outward gas and radiation pressure is weaker than the inward-
acting gravitational force.
➢ The imbalance of forces now causes the star's outer layers to collapse inwards.
➢ As the layers collapse gravity increases but the pressure increases at a greater
rate.
➢ With the pressure outwards exceeding the inwards gravitational force the
collapsing layer slows down and eventually stops.
➢ Thus we came back at the start where the outwards pressure is greater than the
gravitational force so the pulsation cycle starts again.
A pulsating star is thus not in equilibrium but is always trying to regain it but shooting
past the point. It is a harmonic oscillator. Indeed, analysis of light curves comprising
many periods can often reveal more than one harmonic mode of oscillation for some
types of pulsating variable. This information in turn allows astronomers to learn more
about the interiors of those stars in much the same way as analysis of seismic waves
helps geologists probe the Earth's interior.
27
Chapter 4
CEPHEID VARIABLE STARS (Type l) AND DISTANCE
DETERMINATION
Some types of pulsating variable stars such as Cepheids exhibit a definite relationship
between their period and their intrinsic luminosity. Such period-luminosity
relationships are invaluable to astronomers as they are a vital method in calculating
distances within and beyond our galaxy.
During the first decade of the 1900s Henrietta Leavitt (1868 - 1921), working at the
Harvard College Observatory, studying photographic plates of the Large (LMC) and
Small (SMC) Magellanic Clouds, compiled a list of 1,777 periodic variables. Eventually
she classified 47 of these in the two clouds as Cepheid variables and noticed that those
with longer periods were brighter than the shorter-period ones. She correctly inferred
that as the stars were in the same distant clouds they were all at much the same
relative distance from us. Any difference in apparent magnitude was therefore related
to a difference in absolute magnitude. When she plotted her results for the two clouds
she noted that they formed distinct relationships between brightness and period. Her
plot showed what is now known as the period-luminosity relationship; Cepheids with
longer periods are intrinsically more luminous than those with shorter periods.
In 1924 Edwin Hubble detected Cepheids in the Andromeda nebula, M31 and the
Triangulum nebula M33. Using these he determined that their distances were 900,000
and 850,000 light years respectively. He thus established conclusively that these "spiral
nebulae" were in fact other galaxies and not part of our Milky Way. This was a
momentous discovery and dramatically expanded the scale of the known Universe.
Hubble later went on to observe the redshift of galaxies and propose that this was due
to their recession velocity, with more distant galaxies moving away at a higher speed
than nearby ones. This relationship is now called Hubble's Law and is interpreted to
mean that the Universe is expanding.
can say that absolute magnitude, M, of a star is the magnitude that star would have if
it were at a distance of 10 parsecs from us.
The scale of absolute magnitude is same as that for apparent magnitude, that is a
difference of 1 magnitude=2.512 times difference in the brightness. This logarithmic
scale is also open ended and unit less. Again, the lower or more negative the value of
M, brighter the star is.
From the period of a star, we can calculate the absolute magnitude, M, using the
formulae given below:
This formula is for Type l Cepheids and is established from Hubble space Telescope Trigonometric parallax for 10 nearly
Cepheids.
In order to use this relationship to determine the distance to a Cepheid, we will assume
that we are dealing with a Type I, Classical Cepheid but the same method applies for
W Virginis and RR Lyrae-type stars.
Steps:
3. From the light curve and the photometric data, two values can be determined; the
average apparent magnitude, m, of the star and its period in days. In the example
above the Cepheid has a mean apparent magnitude of 15.56 and a period of 4.76
days.
4. Knowing the period of the Cepheid we can now determine its mean absolute
magnitude, M, by interpolating on the period-luminosity plot. The one shown
below is based on Cepheids within the Milky Way. The vertical axis shows absolute
magnitude whilst period is displayed as a log value on the horizontal axes.
31
The log of 4.76 days = 0.68. When this is plotted a value of about -3.6 results for absolute magnitude.
5. Once both apparent magnitude, m, and absolute magnitude, M are known we can
simply substitute in to the distance-modulus formula and rework it to give a value
for d, the distance to the Cepheid in parsecs.
m - M = 5 log(d/10)
d = 10(𝑚−𝑀+5)/5
d = 10(15.57−(−3.6)+5)/5
d =1024.7/5
d =104.8341
d = 68,230 parsecs
This means that the Cepheid in the LMC is about 68.2 kpc (or about 222,000 light years
away). More importantly, if we infer that the size of the LMC relative to its distance
from us is small we have also found the distance to the LMC within which the Cepheid
is located.
32
The term standard candle applies to celestial objects with well-defined absolute
magnitudes which are assumed to not vary with age or distance. Type I and II Cepheids
and RR Lyraes are all examples. All Cepheids with a certain period are assumed to have
the same absolute magnitude. Measuring the apparent magnitude of a Cepheid then
allows us to determine its distance using the period-luminosity relationship. If two
Cepheids have the same period but is fainter than the other it must be further away.
RR Lyraes similarly can be used as standard candles although as their intrinsic
luminosity is lower than Classical Cepheids they cannot be detected at the great
distances of Cepheids.
The final results of the Key project, published in 2001 gave a value of H0 = 72+/-8 km
s-1 Mpc-1. This value was based on the results of the Cepheid studies which were then
combined with other techniques such as observations of Type Ia supernovae, Type II
supernovae, the Tully-Fisher relation and the surface brightness of galaxies. The
uncertainty of the value was close to the original +/- 10% target for the project.
34
Chapter 5
TOOLS FOR EXTARACTING THE STAR
PARAMETERS.
5.1 Period04
Period04 is a computer program especially dedicated to the statistical analysis of large
astronomical time series containing gaps. Fundamentally, the program is composed of
3 modules:
1. TIME STRUCTURING
Structuring of the plotted data point is done where the star tie and end time of the
plotted data points are noted and using this, the length of the observation period is
found in hours and its mean is also found.
Using the standard formula and Fourier calculation, frequency is extracted for original
data first without zero-point shift so that no additional features cantered at 0.0 will
appear. The corresponding amplitude is also noted. Then using the same original data,
frequency extraction is done including zero-point so that these features may even
dominate the frequency spectrum. After that frequency extraction is done using
Residual at original and this process is done repeatedly until the required accuracy is
required, which is done by looking Fourier spectrum. After that all the extracted
frequency is fitted and time string plot and phase plot of the plotted data is extracted.
We have a set of frequencies and a certain subdivision of time string in the attribute
"Date". By calculating a least-squares fit for each substring separately, it was found out
that the amplitude of a frequency might be variable. So this frequency is selected and
appropriately its phase and amplitude is varied and improved so that it becomes
matching with the others.
4. CALCULATE EPOCH
before the maximum light). These epochs can be used as reference along with equinox.
Because, reference to the epoch contribute to specifying the date of the values of
astronomical variables themselves; while the reference to an equinox along with
ecliptic of a certain date, addresses the identification of, or change in the coordinate
system in terms of the astronomical variable expressed. Here the program already
knows whether you are using magnitudes (maximum light at minimum value) or
intensities. Here I have evaluated the values of epoch close to the given time=0.
Chapter 6
DATA ANALYSIS
I have collected data from OGLE (The optical gravitational lensing experiment) Atlas
of Variable Star Light Curves. They present typical and not-so-typical light curves of
variable stars of various types observed in the course of the Optical Gravitational
Lensing Experiment.
The OGLE project is a large-scale sky survey conducted since 1992 by astronomers
associated with the University of Warsaw Astronomical Observatory. The PI of the
project is Prof. Andrzej Udalski. Observations are carried out with the 1.3-m Warsaw
Telescope at the Las Campanas Observatory in Chile. Currently, the OGLE survey
regularly monitors the brightness of about one billion stars in the Galactic bulge and
disk, the Magellanic Clouds, and other important regions of the sky. The primary
scientific goal of the project is the search for exoplanetary gravitational microlensing
events, but the huge amount of high quality photometric data collected by the survey
are ideal also for many other astrophysical purposes. During its long history the OGLE
project has contributed significantly to many different fields of observational
astrophysics: gravitational lensing and microlensing, extrasolar planets, cosmic
distance scale, the structure of the Galaxy and Magellanic Clouds, stellar clusters,
interstellar extinction, Kuiper Belt objects, etc. One of the most important results of
the OGLE project is huge collections of variable stars. The OGLE Collection of Variable
Stars consists of over 1,000,000 objects and is now the largest set of variable stars in
the world.
I have collected the data of 10 classical Cepheid (Type l) stars and its light curve is
plotted using Period04. A set of model data, fitted light curve, folded light curve, phase
plot and Fourier- power/amplitude spectrum are found our using the software.
Alongside with this, frequency, time period and apparent magnitude are also
calculated using the software.
38
Residual Adjusted
Phase plot
Residual Adjusted
Phase plot
Residual
Adjusted Phase
plot
Time string
plot
44
Residual
Adjusted
phase plot
Time string
plot
Residual
Adjusted phase
plot
Time string
plot
Residual
Adjusted
phase plot
Time string
plot
Residual
Adjusted
phase plot
Residual
Adjusted
phase plot
Time string
plot
Residual
Adjusted
phase plot
Residual
Adjusted phase
plot
Chapter 7
OBSERVATIONS
Given below are the properties calculated using period04:
1. Time structuring
Substring
Start time:5274.515370
End time:7401.726300
Length [hrs]:51053.062320
Mean time:5965.028639
Points unknown :28
Total observing time [hrs]:51053.1
Total mean time:5965.028639
1)Time structuring
Substring
Start time: 5275.516140
End time: 7446.614410
Length [hrs] :52106.358480
Mean time :6085.874147
Points unknown :32
Total observing time [hrs]: 52106.4
Total mean time: 6085.874147
2)Type of variation: amplitude and phase variation
F1 Fre = 0.00127202495 Amp = 0.0953531 Pha = 0.404545
F2 Fre = 0.00530357639 Amp = 0.0953186 Pha = 0.69041
F3 Fre = 0.020718757 Amp = 0.091779 Pha = 0.164154
F4 Fre = 0.0332776964 Amp = 0.0671232 Pha = 0.769678
F5 Fre = 0.0172791189 Amp = 0.0536532 Pha = 0.241169
Zero point: 16.4615581
Residuals: 0.0530353362
Iterations: 2
3)Calculation of epochs
calculate the time of minimum light
close to the time:0
Frequency Time of Epoch
F1 0.00127202495 -121.4953872122454
F2 0.00530357639 -83.04024589924342
F3 0.020718757 4.143417793481775
F4 0.0332776964 -15.6164071951915
F5 0.0172791189 0.511106603133402
calculate the time of Zero point
close to the time:0
Frequency Time of Epoch
F1 0.00127202495 -318.0324130074075
F2 0.00530357639 -130.1782489499199
F3 0.020718757 -7.922943158100719
F4 0.0332776964 -23.12894642910538
F5 0.0172791189 -13.95722375783426
61
1)Time structuring
Substring
Start time: 5275.516140
End time :7446.614410
Length [hrs]: 52106.358480
Mean time: 6085.874147
Points unknown: 32
Total observing time [hrs]: 52106.4
Total mean time: 6085.874147
2)Type of Variation: amplitude and phase variation
62
F2 0.0082963516 0.0624179318
F3 0.0255789529 0.0624875081
F4 0.0287712331 0.0624569976
F5 0.00187674524 0.0624183961
F6 0.0177561313 0.062437474
6)Analytical uncertainties
Nr. Freq. sigma Ampl. sigma Pha. sigma
F1 3.004015774e-005 0.02026254164 0.01882743110
F2 4.899323621e-005 0.02026254164 0.03070612303
F3 5.383256138e-005 0.02026254164 0.03373913178
F4 5.514834214e-005 0.02026254164 0.03456378696
F5 6.161798138e-005 0.02026254164 0.03861858214
F6 8.960565758e-005 0.02026254164 0.05615963669
1)Time structuring
Substring
Start time :5275.516140
End time: 7446.614410
Length [hrs]: 52106.358480
Mean time: 6085.874147
Points unknown :32
Total observing time [hrs]: 52106.4
Total mean time: 6085.874147
2)Type of variation: amplitude and phase variation
F1 Fre = 0.00928075126 Amp = 0.160182 Pha = 0.517656
F2 Fre = 0.0214470903 Amp = 0.0916224 Pha = 0.567242
F3 Fre = 0.0300093764 Amp = 0.108492 Pha = 0.870682
F4 Fre = 0.0177700944 Amp = 0.0895122 Pha = 0.737883
F5 Fre = 0.0164400103 Amp = 0.0671636 Pha = 0.826133
Zero point: 15.6718131
Residuals: 0.0702298847
Iterations: 2
3)Calculation of epochs
calculate the time of minimum light
close to the time:0
Frequency Time of Epoch
F1 0.00928075126 -28.83992397229716
F2 0.0214470903 -14.79183272784369
F3 0.0300093764 -20.68292757204973
64
F4 0.0177700944 -27.45529549858093
F5 0.0164400103 -35.04455138227364
calculate the time of Zero point
close to the time:0
Frequency Time of Epoch
F1 0.00928075126 -55.77739842072605
F2 0.0214470903 -26.44842559458792
F3 0.0300093764 -29.01365715415417
F4 0.0177700944 -41.523875809702
F5 0.0164400103 -50.25135450194658
calculate the time of maximum light
close to the time:0
Frequency Time of Epoch
F1 0.00928075126 -82.71487286915495
F2 0.0214470903 -38.10501846133215
F3 0.0300093764 -37.34438673625861
F4 0.0177700944 -55.59245612082307
F5 0.0164400103 -65.45815762161952
4)Signal prediction at a given time
Time The signal
5275.51614(Starting time) 15.690028
7446.614410(Ending time) 15.8416628
5)Calculation of noise at fitted frequencies
Frequency Noise-amplitude
F1 0.00928075126 0.0472360889
F2 0.0214470903 0.047250016
F3 0.0300093764 0.0472338569
F4 0.0177700944 0.0472593748
F5 0.0164400103 0.0472636302
6)Analytical uncertainties
Nr. Freq. sigma Ampl. sigma Pha. sig
F1 2.783420564e-005 0.01755747118 0.01744486809
F2 4.866219996e-005 0.01755747118 0.03049864868
F3 4.109573194e-005 0.01755747118 0.02575642473
F4 4.980934368e-005 0.01755747118 0.03121761193
F5 6.638340042e-005 0.01755747118 0.04160527081
65
1)Time structuring
Substring
Start time :5275.518200
End time :7446.616520
Length [hrs] :52106.359680
Mean time :6029.252518
Points unknown :32
Total observing time [hrs]:52106.4
Total mean time:6029.252518
2)Type of variation: amplitude and phase variation
F1 Fre = 0.0191644994 Amp = 0.0873323 Pha = 0.51991
67
1)Time structuring
Substring
Start time :5275.518200
End time :7446.616520
Length [hrs]:52106.359680
Mean time:6029.252518
Points unknown :32
Total observing time [hrs]:52106.4
Total
mean time:6029.252518
2)Type of variation: amplitude and phase variation
F1 Fre = 0.0192473755 Amp = 0.115692 Pha = 0.0164271
F2 Fre = 0.00789444243 Amp = 155.252 Pha = 0.0768963
F3 Fre = 0.00786629136 Amp = 72.7776 Pha = 0.752872
F4 Fre = 0.00796193418 Amp = 247.632 Pha = 0.656295
F5 Fre = 0.00795099857 Amp = 330.086 Pha = 0.224243
F6 Fre = 0.0252726077 Amp = 0.0694324 Pha = 0.627251
F7 Fre = 0.0038248551 Amp = 0.0517585 Pha = 0.364849
Zero point: 17.6002376
Residuals: 0.0482566576
Iterations: 8
3)Calculation of epochs
calculate the time of minimum light
close to the time:0
Frequency Time of Epoch
F1 0.0192473755 12.13531240088555
F2 0.00789444243 21.9272824251601
F3 0.00786629136 -63.92743236224452
F4 0.00796193418 -51.02965323305418
F5 0.00795099857 3.239477144579093
F6 0.0252726077 -14.92724978874734
F7 0.0038248551 -30.02696591960804
69
F4 0.0108205607 -77.05919206421397
1)Time structuring
Substring
Start time : 5275.520260
End time : 7446.618650
Length [hrs] :52106.361360
Mean time : 5945.670509
Points unknown :28
Total observing time [hrs]:52106.4
Total mean time:5945.670509
2)Type of variation: amplitude and phase variation
F1 Fre = 0.0172248116 Amp = 0.115165 Pha = 0.733518
F2 Fre = 0.0133087743 Amp = 0.097819 Pha = 0.33759
F3 Fre = 0.0219444029 Amp = 0.0507084 Pha = 0.821669
F4 Fre = 0.0212169001 Amp = 0.13767 Pha = 0.454727
Zero point: 16.1040929
Residuals: 0.0624244329
Iterations: 2
3)Calculation of epochs
72
F1 0.0699366037 -10.21159574126547
F2 0.112367257 -5.538789222397334
F3 0.157847158 -2.82329950663879
F4 0.157847671 -5.966950390555224
F5 0.15847956 -3.258475948444996
4)Signal prediction at a given time
Time The signal
5264.526440(Starting time) 15.0201366
7500.473780(Ending time) 15.091445
5)Calculation of noise fitted frequencies
Frequency Noise-amplitude
F1 0.0699366037 0.0140729405
F2 0.112367257 0.0140936634
F3 0.157847158 0.0140869644
F4 0.157847671 0.0140869655
F5 0.15847956 0.0140863252
6)Analytical uncertainties
Nr. Freq. sigma Ampl. sigma Pha. sigma
F1 6.083744738e-005 0.01108674288 0.03926828475
F2 6.347105027e-005 0.01108674288 0.04096817639
F3 3.529757854e-007 0.01108674288 0.0002278325974
F4 3.544651057e-007 0.01108674288 0.0002287938976
F5 0.0001398997119 0.01108674288 0.09030000373
75
Chapter 8
CONCLUSION
This project analysed the data of 10 classical cepheids (a class of pulsating variables)
from OGLE database, using period04 software and estimated its parameters such as
frequency, period, apparent magnitude alongside with the calculation of epochs, the
signal at different times and noise at fitted frequencies.
Using the obtained period, the absolute magnitude of each star has been found using
a formula derived from Hubble Space Telescope trigonometric parallax for 10 nearly
cephides. Then using this absolute magnitude along with the apparent magnitude and
period, we have found the distance to the stars in parsecs.
The light curves obtained for all the 10 stars were similar to those of common classical
cephides with fundamental mode of vibration and having a period between 35 and 45
days. From their absolute magnitude, it was found that 9 out of the 10 stars belong to
the spectral class supergiant (la, lb), were the 10th star under consideration belong to
the spectral class Bright giant(ll).
77
BIBLIOGRAPHY
[1] www.oxfordereference.com
[2]www.space.com
[3]www.nasa.gov