Daniel Yap

PHI 202

Homework 1

Exercise VII

2. The rule of relevance was violated.

4. The rule of quality was violated.

6. The rule of quantity was violated.

8. The rule of quantity and the rule of manner was violated.

10. The rule of quality and the rule of manner was violated.

Exercise IV

1. valid and sound; If the professors are paid, and they are paid too little, then the professors are
paid too little.

3. valid and sound. If the premise is that Lee cannot do anything right, running a company can be
anything therefore Lee cannot run a company right.

5. Invalid and unsound. Barack Obama can be a Republican

7. Invalid and unsound. There is no correlation between winning an election and becoming president
in the statement given. Also it could’ve been a different General Ford in a different country with
different presidential rules.

9. valid and sound

11. valid and sound/

Exercise V.

1. Valid and sound argument

3. Invalid and unsound argument