Professional Documents
Culture Documents
E18 Eia
E18 Eia
E18 Eia
Chapter One
1.0 Introduction..................................................................................................3
1.1 Brief Historical Background........................................................................4
1.2 Justification of the Report and the Project………………………………..6
1.3 Aim of the Project........................................................................................6
1.4 Objectives of the EIA Study........................................................................6
1.5 Assumptions ...............................................................................................8
1.6 Detailed Requirements of the EIA Study.....................................................9
1.7 Scope of the Report………………………………………………………..9
1.8 Terms of Reference………………………………………………………10
Chapter two
2.0 Environmental Impact Analysis and the Conception of the Environment13
2.1 The Concept of Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) ......................14
2.2 Advantage of EIA………………………………………………………..15
2.3 Environmental Impact Analysis (EIA) & Nigeria Urban Regional Planning
Degree ’92 (NURPD’ 92) ..............................................................................16
2.4 Construction & Proposed Project Execution Process................................21
Chapter Three
3.0 Environment...............................................................................................24
3.1 The Environment without the Project……………………………………25
3.2 Compliance with Planning Regulation .....................................................25
3.3 Conformity with Purpose of Allocation and Compatibility with
Surrounding Land Use .............................................................................26
3.4 Raw Material To Be Use For Construction……………………………...30
Chapter Five
5.1.1 Evaluation and Environmental Assessment Techniques......................46
5.1.2 Summary of Impact…………..………................................................47
5.1.3 Rating of Impacts ..................................................................................47
5.1.4 Parameter for Analysis………………………………………………..48
5.1.5 Environmental Management Plans (EMP)............................................55
5.1.6 What the EMP Should Address...........................................................56
5.1.7 Ambient Monitoring Through AMP ....................................................57
5.1.8 Organisation Monitor and Auditing Plan …….....................................58
5.2.1 Recommendations ……………………………………………………59
Figures & Tables
Table 1. Anticipated Noise Levels
Table 2. Weighted indices for analysis
Table 3. Scoring Scale
Table 4. Rating Scales
1.0 INTRODUCTION
The city of today is a major performer for the secondary sector of the
economy. Service oriented developments not only provide the city with
the essential inputs but also provide the means of living for the
populace. Lately, ad-hoc decisions for such developments have led to
an adverse impact on the local environment at costs which are much
higher than the benefits actually accrued.
In the Nigerian context, It has been justified given the provision of the
Decree No. 86 of 1992, and as upheld in the Decree No. 88 of 1992 of
Urban And Regional Planning Law, to act as guide towards ensuring
that the effect of developmental activities are to the barest minimum
impact negatively.
1.5 ASSUMPTIONS
In preparing this report, the following assumptions were made:
i. That the site shown to us, which this report is based on, is the site for
the proposed project i.e. proposed estate development.
ii. That in line with the Town Planning Profession, this report does not
guarantee the ownership of the land.
iv. That the Proposed Development has been designed in line with the
building regulations and other requirements for the approval and
Development permit by the authorized department of FCDA.
v. That this report is based on completion and usage of the proposed
buildings.
vi. This report shall not be responsible for any change in Government
policy that may affect the proposal.
vii. The client is to be responsible for any failure on the structural aspect of
the building.
To provide (if need be) options in design, setting and operation of the
proposed development
There are three main considerations taken into account by this law in
judging whether the impacts are likely to be significant. First the
question needs to be asked whether the project is a major one of more
than local importance, especially in terms of its size. Secondly it needs
to be established whether the project is intended for a particularly
sensitive location, such as a national park or a site of special scientific
interest. For that reason the proposed estate development may have
significant effects on the environment, even though the development is
on a smaller scale. The third consideration which needs to be taken into
Developers can decide for themselves whether projects fall within the
scope of the statutory provisions and that an environmental statement
will be needed. But there also needs to be a procedure which enables a
developer to apply to the public authority for an opinion on whether
environmental impact assessment is needed in a particular case. For this
purpose basic information about the proposal needs to be provided.
More often it will fall to the public authorities to consider whether
environmental impact assessment is required, when a particular
development project is submitted to them. A developer who is
dissatisfied with the local view that environmental assessment is
required may refer the matter to a higher authority for decision.
EIA PROCESS
An EIA process is required for a wide range of proposed activities,
including land development, use of natural resources, construction and
changes to commercial activity.
An EIA work process of this project is elaborate and consists of many
stages. They include:
• Screening: The process by which a decision is taken on whether or not
b) Preliminary Assessment
c) Full E.I.A
i) Scoping
ii) EIA study (baseline studies, impact prediction and
mitigation)
d) EIA Review
g) Decision Making
h) Implementation
i) Post Auditing
• Post audits are made to determine how close to reality the EIA
predictions were.
• Stage 4: Foundation: This is the stage for preparing the layout of the
structures to be built on site. This stage is literally set in stone. It is
devoted to the construction of the foundation of the structures.
• Stage 10: Landscaping: This stage marks the beginning of the end of
the structures are formed including any driveways or walkway. To
finish it all off, plantings such as trees, shrubs, and grass are added.
CHAPTER THREE
3.0 ENVIRONMENT
The site could be described as relatively flat and well drained, ideal for the
propose development. The vegetation on the proposed site is still full with
grass and shrubs. The vegetation type can thus be described as topical of the
Sudan Savannah characterized by few shrubs and tall grasses.
Soils of the site are also representing a miniature of the soil in the capital city
which can be described as laterite and formation of rock underneath which is
well drained and stable.
PLOT COVERAGE
It is believed that the percentage of the built up area is not specified which is
expected to adequate for this kind of land use when compared with the
minimum requirement of (Development Control manual), though it need to be
specified as appropraite.
AIR SPACE
The spatial disposition of the proposed project in relation to the surrounding
development does not pose any problem if air space both now and in the
nearby future. Enough open space to boost air circulation is to be maintained
as seen on the site plan.
PARKING PROVISION
In addition to the parking spaces 607 number parking spaces provided for the
users of the development. It is also worthy of note that there is a commercial
The site is located on a plot yet to be approved for the proposed development.
It is in conformity with the surrounding land uses i.e. religion Institute,
Commercial. These areas are well complemented with complementary uses
such as health centre, public uses within the district close to the proposed site.
The proposed project is located in the urban area of Abuja FCT at Plot N0.
7096, Cadastral Zone E18, Wasa District, FCT-Abuja surrounded by some
developments of concern to the public e.g. The only landmark one can be seen
along the arterial road leading to Wasa district is Apo mechanic village and
Waru village, present there is no much development around the vicinity where
the proposed site is located. 95% of the plots located close to the proposed site
are all vacant and presently the vicinity where the proposed site is undergoing
construction of infrastructures such as road and drainages.
• Sand;
• Laterite;
• Sandcrete blocks of various sizes;
• Cement;
• Gravel;
• Water;
• Paint;
• Wood;
• Iron rods;
• Steel frames;
• Nails;
• Roofing sheets;
• E.t.c.
CHAPTER FOUR
The surrounding developments are also serviced with electricity and roads.
Telephone and other telecommunication requirements can be met by the use
fixed wireless and other GSM networks. The site has adequate coverage of all
the networks presently available within the FCT.
has a relatively flat terrain. A further detailed engineering study of the site will
Drainage
Site investigation conducted on the drainage system within the micro-
environment of this proposal reveals that site have been serviced with sewage
points and water drainages. The proposed development should be properly
connected to the sewer line and storm water drainage to keep the site free
from water stagnation which could create breeding grounds for mosquitoes
and other harmful insects. The safety and good health of the
microenvironment is thus guaranteed.
Sewage
General degradation of environmental aesthetics, threat to hygiene, public
health as well as contamination of soil and underground water resources are
the potential effects of wastes, if not properly managed. The type of waste
envisaged for this project is amendable to easy management. The sewage to
Waste Generation
Wastes to be generated include solid and liquid wastes as well as gaseous and
noise emissions which can create strains on man and environment. The
impacts are summarized as follows.
Solid Wastes
Solid Waste during construction considers the Human population to live on
this site will be averagely 300 or above. A reasonable quantity of solid wastes
will be generated. The master plan has neither indicated nor provided a
location for its disposal. Such an omission can only produce a filthy centre
where environmental standard are grossly low. It will produce breeding spaces
for rodents and disease vectors which are detrimental to the health of
inhabitants. But reputable waste management company should assign to be
responsible for evacuating the waste that will be generated.
Storm Water will be generated through rainfall and external outdoor cleaning
and sanitation procedures. This will vary according to the seasons. They are to
be channeled into the natural streams or water courses within the vicinity
through covered concrete drains.
Effluent Disposal
In no case should effluents be allowed into public drains or stream courses in
the vicinity. They should be properly channeled and connected to the sewer
system.
Dust
Clearing the site, evacuation, casting and other general works will generate
dust in the premises and the neighborhood beyond the normal level.
This can be reduced by spraying water on the work environment before
operations.
No Toxic Wastes will be generated.
Gaseous Emissions
This will emanate from power plants operations and vehicle exhaust pipes.
Impacts of gases to be generated include greenhouse effect caused by carbon
monoxide CO2, sulphur dioxide SO, and nitrogen dioxide, methane etc.
Nitrogen oxide contributes to acid rain, soil quality depletion and respiratory
disorders that can cause damage to human. Odor can be generated from
improperly handled wastes. It can make its environment unpleasantly
habitable. The negative impact could be minimized if the machinery to be
used are regularly maintained and kept in good working condition and closely
monitored.
Noise
Thermal Pollution
No operation in the proposed station has the capacity to generate and/or
discharge temperatures that will adversely alter the ambient temperature.
Liquid effluents discharged from this building should be treated and brought
to a temperature that will not create any thermal pollution at the point of
discharge
Water supply
The requirement for water supply may not be met fully at all times from the
proposed supply system. The management of the project will therefore make
an independent arrangement for one-site water supply through boreholes and
overhead tanks; this source of water supply is not envisaged to have adverse
effect on the source of water supply to the neighboring environment. The
Electricity
The whole of the estate is to drive electricity supply mainly from the Power
Holding Company of Nigeria (PHCN), However, there will be installation of
noiseless electricity generating plant when the project starts to operate. During
any short or prolonged interruption of electricity supply to the industry, the
generating plant will be used to serve the industry and this will therefore
guarantee uninterrupted service to the industry.
Traffic
The construction activities will attract construction vehicles to the area
thereby introducing articulated trucks to the residential environment. This will
put a level of strain on the environment especially traffic movement.
Traffic during construction period can be carrying out during the day time.
This implies that those articulated vehicle will not have any adverse effect on
traffic movement during the day as one can barely find any vehicle around the
vicinity. There are 607 parking spaces; the traffic flow is two traffic way
Ecosystem
The relationship between living organisms such as: plants, animals,
communities and their environment. It also involves these organism energy
flows and the interaction with their immediate surroundings. As the survival
of these organisms' dependents mainly on their habitant for the supply of
shelter, food, air and sunshine, which they need, a proposed project of this
type may disrupt the existing ecosystem. It may therefore affect adversely the
flora and fauna lives within the study area.
An in-depth study of the site for the proposed development confirms that there
are no species of plants or animals existing on the site that will be destroyed
or adversely affected. By judgment, the proposal will neither create any
ecological problems nor destabilized existing ecosystem within the immediate
environment. Instead, it will produce a system of man-made structures that
will blend with nature through a planned landscape system as shown in the
site plan of the proposal. Visual beauty will also be produced.
Vegetation
As it was explained under site characteristics, the proposed site is still a virgin
land, by our judgment; the proposed development will not have serious
negative effect on the vegetation. The little negative effect that may be
envisaged will be neutralized through the provision of landscaped islands all
over the site area which is meant to replenish the lost vegetation and to
enhance the air flow within or around the vicinity.
Apart from the fact that the labour requirement for this type of development
which are not usually many at the operation state; it is also a fact that majority
of the prospective workers will be residents of the City. The proposal is
therefore not envisaged to exert pressure on the residence within the micro
place, and macro environment of the city.
1 Detached Duplex 5 13 65
The total number of people planning for amount to four hundred and thirty
one (431) persons.
Revenue
Government parastatals like Power Holding Company of Nigeria (PHCN) the
Nigerian Telecommunication Limited, Abuja Environmental Protection Board
(AEFB). FCT Water Board will definitely render some useful services that
Plot 7096 Wasa District Cadastral Zone E18 Page 43
will generate revenue for them. In effect, by the development of this proposal,
revenue will be accruable to the Federal Government, Federal Capital
Territory (FCT) through their agencies. Considering the volume of investment
and other economic activities that will be generated, the proposed
development will surely exert positive and desirable influence on the
microenvironment.
Employment
We strongly envisage that when the project is fully operational, job
opportunities which would be available to various cadres of workers such as
facility managers, drivers, security operators, cleaner etc among others will be
able to cater for the middle and lower income employees. Also, the coming
into operation of the project will create more jobs within the area. These may
be in the form of maintenance services of various infrastructures, equipment
etc. Categories of workers under this include drivers, cleaners, and security
services men among others.
The proposal will also create job for artisans at the construction stage of its
development. These may include carpenters, bricklayers, plumbers and others
on a short-term basis skilled and professional’s services will be required also.
The job will therefore bring positive impact on employment opportunity.
Aesthetic/Visual Impact
The vicinity of this proposed development is envisaged to create a kind of
vista made possible by the architectural design. This is obvious as the
adjoining developments are still undeveloped.
It is expected that if all these safety devices and security measures are rigidly
implemented, carefully maintained and regularly monitored along the required
standards, there is the strong belief that this proposal will not pose any
appreciable danger on its immediate (micro) environment.
Various types of techniques have been developed for the assessment and
presentation of impacts of any proposed development. Among them is the
Impact Checklist. This technique ensures that a prescribed list of impact areas
are considered in the assessment proves. The identified impacts are then given
Any score between (+5) and (-5) could be assigned to each component
assessed, this would be interpreted in line with the upper and lower limits of
(+5) and (-5) respectively. There is one major factor to be mentioned. The
impact effects are not necessarily of the same importance to the project and
the environment in which the project is located. For example; it may be wrong
to attach the same weight to an impact of a project that would have no
employment generation to that it would have on solid waste.
5.1.4 The following weights have been assigned to each parameter for
analysis.
S/N IMPACTS
Below 40 Project is not acceptable. It is environmentally unfit
51 – 60 Critical consideration should be given to the Project need to be
executed (if at all) with precautions.
61 -100 Project is acceptable, fit and poses no hazard to the
environment
From the foregoing, the rated score of this project from our analysis is 87%
positive impact. This means that the project is acceptable.
(8) Fencing. Temporary zinc fence should be put in place since the area is
going to be built-up, the site should be fenced to prevent the entry of
unauthorized persons. Security men are to be employed to check
people's entrance into the site. Visitors should not also be allowed
access to site unless accompanied by the appropriate protective
equipment.
(12) Insurance. Given the inherent economic and environmental risks which
can be occasioned by fire accidents, it is important that insurance policy
be adopted against of any loss; and / or indemnity in case of
involvement of a third party. The workmen compensation insurance
policy is necessary in this regard.
OPERATIONAL PHASE
Increase Traffic Significant There are adequate parking spaces but
there is need to ensure management
traffic control, and not to allow public
parking within the estate.
DECOMMISSIONING PHASE
The EMP should specifically address the following right from the
construction phase through to the decommissioning stage. For this
◊ Provision of appropriate First Aid on site for the initial care of the
accident victims when it occurs.
5.2.1 RECOMMENDATIONS
5.2.4 There should be no open burning of any solid waste materials on the
Site both at the construction stage and when the facility is in use.
5.2.10 The Development Control Department should also monitor the use of
the facility when it is occupied and put to use to ensure that possible
negative impacts are kept at minimum levels.
5.1.8 I (the consultant) therefore, certify that the proposed project satisfy the
requirements of land use compatibility, good air quality, aesthetic
landscape, peaceful atmosphere, non-obstructive traffic generation, and
other positive parameters for maintaining available environment. The
project will be socially, economically and environmentally friendly and
beneficial to the immediate and far residents of the environment. The
project is therefore recommended for approval and subsequent
implementation.
……………………………..
TPL Finzi A. Ghaji (Consultant) TOPREC NO: RTP/573