Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Multiculturalism
Multiculturalism
https://www.youtube.com/watch?
v=t14kY8WLQ7g&ab_channel=CarterChell
https://www.youtube.com/watch?
v=HeDnPP6ntic&ab_channel=healthcarefuture
- For instance: a polis reserved certain rights, privileges and duties for its
citizens, that is, free individuals born into the polis
https://www.youtube.com/watch?
v=U5rKgDOs33U&ab_channel=TEDxTalks
a) Multiculturalism
Multiculturalism Theories
The melting pot model has been criticized for reducing diversity, causing people
to lose their traditions, and for having to be enforced through governmental
policy. For example, the U.S. Indian Reorganization Act of 1934 forced the
assimilation of nearly 350,000 Indians into American society without any regard
for the diversity of Native American heritage and lifestyles.
A more liberal theory of multiculturalism than the melting pot, the salad bowl
theory describes a heterogeneous society in which people coexist but retain at
least some of the unique characteristics of their traditional culture. Like a salad’s
ingredients, different cultures are brought together, but rather than coalescing
into a single homogeneous culture, retain their own distinct flavors. In the United
States, New York City, with its many unique ethnic communities like “Little
India,” “Little Odessa,” and “Chinatown” is considered an example of a salad
bowl society.
The salad bowl theory asserts that it is not necessary for people to give up their
cultural heritage in order to be considered members of the dominant society. For
example, African Americans do not need to stop observing Kwanzaa rather than
Christmas in order to be considered “Americans.”
On the negative side, the cultural differences encouraged by the salad bowl
model can divide a society resulting in prejudice and discrimination. In addition,
critics point to a 2007 study conducted by American political scientist Robert
Putnam showing that people living in salad bowl multicultural communities were
less likely to vote or volunteer for community improvement projects.
Proponents of cultural diversity argue that it makes humanity stronger and may,
in fact, be vital to its long-term survival. In 2001, the General Conference of
UNESCO took this position when it asserted in its Universal Declaration on
Cultural Diversity that “...cultural diversity is as necessary for humankind as
biodiversity is for nature.”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-
_Sqf5ZnjX4&ab_channel=LEARNVIRTUALLYWITHDRSANDHYATIWARI
- Ethnocentrism: means seeing our own culture as the central and best
one, seeing other cultures as insignificant
https://www.youtube.com/watch?
v=HlXAeOnU520&ab_channel=khanacademymedicine
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wlyS4zrklww&ab_channel=FunSimpleLIFE
c) Promoting International Business Exchange
Communicators who fail to realize that persons from different cultures may
not look, think, or act as they themselves do run the risk of having those with
whom they interact judge them to be insensitive, ignorant, or culturally
confused. The culturally confused pay a high price. Cultural misunderstandings
often lead to lost opportunities and increased levels of tension between people.
The following examples demonstrate the extent to which cultural ignorance
affects communication:
■ Showing the sole of a shoe means nothing to observers in the United States or
Europe. As a result, when visiting Saudi Arabia, the American and European
delegates to a conference thought nothing about crossing their legs and pointing
their shoes toward the speaker while listening to his presentation. The speaker,
however, was horrified. In Muslim cultures, the gesture is perceived as insulting.
Similarly, while crossing your legs in the United States indicates you are relaxed,
in Korea it is a social faux pas.
■ Eye contact preferences also differ across cultures. Americans place a high
value on eye-to-eye communication and tend to distrust those who fail to look at
them directly. The Japanese, in contrast, believe eye contact over a sustained
period of time shows disrespect. Among Asian cultures, too much eye contact is
deemed intrusive. Arabs, on the other hand, maintain direct eye contact with
those they interact with for prolonged periods.
This will sensitize you to the ways cultural values and habits influence
interaction. Learning about such differences will help you (1) appropriately
respond to varied communication styles, (2) recognize the need to expand your
choices as a communicator, and (3) increase the effectiveness of your
interactions with persons of different cultures.
Among the lessons taught by culture are how to say “hello” and “good-
bye,” when to speak or remain silent, how to act when you’re angry or upset,
where to focus your eyes when functioning as a source or receiver, how much to
gesture during speech, how close to stand to another, and how to display
happiness or rage at another’s actions. By teaching you lessons like these,
culture guides behavior and communication. It tells you who you are, how to act,
how to think, how to talk, and how to listen.
When cultures meet, when we interact with persons whose values are
different from ours or whose behavioral norms differ from our own, we must first
recognize and acknowledge our differences. We must come to accept diversity if
we are to be able to process other cultures’ influences and communicate with
each other in a meaningful way. Ethnocentrism, the tendency to see your own
culture as superior to all others, is a key characteristic of failed intercultural
communication efforts. Persons who are ethnocentric experience great anxiety
when interacting with persons from different cultures. Quick to utter statements
like “They take our jobs,” “They’re everywhere,” and “They’re just not like us,”
those who embrace ethnocentrism lack cultural flexibility and are particularly
unprepared to meet the challenges posed by our society and our world today.
The more ethnocentric you are, the greater your tendency is to view groups
other than your own as inferior. As a result, you tend to blame others for
problems and seek to maintain your distance from them.
Cultural relativism is the opposite of ethnocentrism. When you practice
cultural relativism, instead of viewing the group to which you belong as superior
to all others, you work to try to understand the behavior of other groups on the
basis of the context in which the behavior occurs rather than from your own
frame of reference.
How we define gender roles, for example, affects the way males and
females present themselves, socialize, work, perceive their futures, and
communicate. U.S. men tend to adopt a problem-solving orientation, while
women tend to be relationship-oriented. We also have ideas regarding the
meaning and significance of age, including how persons our age should look and
behave. In the United States, large numbers of people place great value on
looking youthful and appear to be younger than they are. In contrast, in Muslim,
Asian, and Latin American cultures, people respect, rather than deny, aging. Our
racial and ethnic identities are similarly socially constructed. Some racial and
ethnic groups, for example, share experiences of oppression. Their attitudes and
behaviors may reflect their struggles, influencing their attitudes toward
contemporary issues such as affirmative action. Religious identity is at the
root of countless contemporary conflicts occurring in the Middle East, India and
Pakistan, and BosniaHerzegovina. The proselytizing that occurred at the U.S. Air
Force Academy by Evangelical cadets and officers illustrates the strength and
influence of religious identity. Similarly, socioeconomic identify frames how
we respond to issues of our day. The widening gap between the ultrawealthy
and the middle and lower classes in the United States is contributing to their
developing different attitudes on a wide array of issues. National identity
refers to our legal status or citizenship. People from different countries have
been U.S. citizens for generations, yet some still perceive them as foreigners. Do
you? The reality is that approximately 32 million people (or 11.5 percent of the
total population of the United States) were born in another country.
Being able to reach so many different people who live in so many different
places so quickly gives us a new sense of communication power. Wherever we
live, the Internet may also help bring diversity and new cultures into our lives.
Over time, the Internet may help change our social and business lives. Through
it, we may meet a wider array of people. It has the capacity to introduce us to
new friends and contacts and to allow us to network with persons around the
world. The question for us to ponder, however, is the form that these new
alliances will take: Will they be shallow and short-lived or deep and enduring?
Will we commit ourselves emotionally to them or keep our online interactions
superficial? What kinds of relationships will we develop by conversing with
diverse individuals in distant lands without actually meeting them? Will all voices
really be heard? Will we be more or less tolerant of each other? Will we be aware
that words posted to global online groups have consequences, just as they do
when delivered in person?
Our Western version of the Net is loaded with Western culture and
advertising. Even most of us complain about the pop-ups and the advertising
glut. How this emphasis on consumerism is interpreted around the world is a
source of controversy.
We also need to face the fact that in some cultures and religions,
technology is considered evil. Even in our own culture, we have over 100 million
Americans who have no desire to get connected. In the past five years, over 30
million Americans chose to stop using the Internet. Why? Because they desired
to lead a more simple life, asserting that technology was making their lives too
complicated. These people are part of the digital backlash.
If the trend continues, however, the digital divide (information gap) will
widen. Those who are financially able to afford Internet service and the purchase
of new technologies will have an advantage over those who are not. (Typically,
affluent neighborhoods are the first to be wired to receive new services.) The
“information haves” will have access to social and educational services and will
be in position to acquire knowledge and skills that the “have nots” will not have
available, creating what some civil rights leaders call a “technological apartheid.”
The information gap is especially evident along racial, ethnic, age, geographic,
and income lines. What steps, if any, do you think we should take to democratize
access to new technologies?
When those you interact with have diverse communication styles, it is critical
that you acknowledge the differences and accept their validity. By not isolating
yourself within your own group or culture, you allow yourself to be more fully a
part of a multicultural society and thus a better communicator.
■ Recognize how faulty education can impede understanding.
While culture is a tie that binds, the creation of the global village makes it
essential that you leave the comfort of your cultural niche, become more
knowledgeable of other cultures, and strive to be culturally aware.
I will make a commitment to seek information from persons whose cultures are
different from my own.
I will try to understand how the experiences of persons from different cultures
leads them to develop perspectives that differ from mine.
I will pay attention to the situation and the context when I communicate with
persons from different cultures.
I will not insist that persons from other cultures communicate with me on my
terms.