Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 2

(CASE RECIT) 2.

Title to, or possession of and interest therein,


  exceeding 400K
DISCUSSION: It is clear that the jurisdiction is
with the CA; even the charter of PDIC says that The jurisdiction of the MTC have been expanded:
the jurisdiction will be with the CA.  it is now 400k. If more than 400k, the jurisdiction
is with the RTC.
That is the jurisdiction of the CA.
If you want to claim ownership of the property,
and the assessed value is more than 400k, that is
JURISDICTION OF THE RTC with the RTC.

1) Exclusive Original - meaning, you start with Where can you find the assessed value? In the
the RTC and that's the only court where you can Tax Declaration. If you are looking for the selling
file that case price, you look at the Deed of Sale. If the Zonal
2) Concurrent Original - you can file it in the RTC Value is what you are looking for, you look at the
but just the same as CA and SC, you can also BIR. 
file it in the CA as well as the SC
3) Appellate - RTC has this jurisdiction. Which 3. Admiralty and Maritime claims, if more than
decisions are we referring to? 2M

JURISDICTION OF THE If it's 2M or less, then that is with the MTC.


RTC (ORIGINAL) includes:
When was this law in effect(kung kailan di na
1. Incapable of pecuniary estimation  - In all civil tumatanggap ang MTC ng cases over the new
actions in which the subject of litigation is threshold)? August 20, 2021.
incapable of pecuniary estimation. What is the
meaning of this? 4. Probate proceedings, if more than 2M

EX: You have a claim of 5M pesos. Is that You look at the value of the estate. If the value of
capable of pecuniary estimation? Yes. the estate exceeds 2M, then that is with the RTC.
How about specific performance? Like perhaps
to perform an accounting. Can you estimate that? 5. All actions involving Contract of Marriage and
There is none. Marital Relations

So it is incapable of pecuniary estimation. Why is it with the RTC and not with the Family
Therefore, the jurisdiction is with the RTC. Court? Well, Family Courts are RTCs but
specialized ones. If the Court has no Family
EX: Another, recision of contracts. You are not Court, then the SC will just designate a Family
asking for money but you do not want to comply Court. Still, if there are no Family Courts in an
with the conditions anymore, because you want it area, you file it with the RTC.
rescinded. SO if you pray for recision of contract,
that is incapable of pecuniary estimation, hence 6. Special Jurisdiction
the jurisdiction is with the RTC.
6.1 What is this RA 6657? This is the
EX: Another, action for declaratory relief. You Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Law.
cannot also estimate how much, so it is
incapable of pecuniary estimation. If there's tenancy, then the jurisdiction is with the
DARAB. But the RTC has special jurisdiction.
Under RA 6657, it is an exercise of the power of
eminent domain of the state for public use upon DISCUSSION: The jurisdiction in this case is with
payment of just compensation. the RTC for Amendment of Certificates of Title,
like if you have some changes regarding the
When there is a controversy on the payment of technical description, in the name, etc. 
just compensation, the jurisdiction is not with the
DAR or DARAB but is with the RTC Q. What is the basis in this case that tells us that
the jurisdiction is with the RTC?
6.2 All criminal cases for violation of RA 6657 A: PD 1529, or the Property Registration Decree.
shall be under the jurisdiction of RA 6657.
RTC has jurisdiction on the Amendments on the
7. Personal property/damages/AF, if more than Certificate of Title.
2M

CASE DIGEST OF ORTIGAS & COMPANY,


CONCURRENT JURISDICTION - concurrent LIMITED PARTNERSHIP VS. JUDGE JOSE B.
with SC and CA: HERRERA

1) Issuance of writs of certiorari, prohibition, DISCUSSION: It is not the loan that is incapable
mandamus, quo warranto, and injunction. of pecuniary estimation in this case, but the
-concurrent with SC and CA return of money because of a certain contract. It
is incapable of pecuniary estimation and the
CONCURRENT JURISDICTION - concurrent jurisdiction is with the RTC.
with SC:

1)Actions affecting ambassadors and other public CASE DIGEST OF PIAPI VS. TALIB.
ministers and consuls
TO BE CONTINUED BY THE NEXT PERSON.

APPELATE JURISDICTIONS:

1) Decisions of the 1st level courts.

What cases are usually appealed from MTC to


RTC?
1) Land cases, particularly forcible entry and
unlawful detainers
2) Criminal cases but to a lesser extent, because
when they are acquitted, that's final and
executory. 
-What if convicted then the penalty is 6 years and
below? Not a lot of cases still because they
usually apply for probation.

CASE DIGEST FOR RUDOLF LIETZ


HOLDINGS VS. ROD OF PARANAQUE CITY

You might also like