Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Article No 3
Article No 3
Article No 3
Amina Rizan
Zara Nisar
Hafsa Zaki
A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF MISSION STATEMENTS 2
Abstract
This article focuses on the comparative analysis of mission statements of pharmaceutical
sectors of Pakistan and Bangladesh. This article is based on the nine components of mission
statements: customers, products and services, market, technology, concern for survival,
philosophy, concern for public image, self-concept, and concern for employees. It is observed
that none of the pharmaceutical companies of Pakistan and Bangladesh have a comprehensive
mission statement inclusive of all the nine components. A qualitative content analysis
approach has been applied in this article for the analysis of mission statements. The study
also identifies that there exists a similarity between the companies of two countries as the
most least mentioned components in the statements were almost similar. Self-concept is the
Introduction
stakeholders and it addresses the stakeholders about the purpose of organization and its
direction. Organizations make objectives to achieve their mission and mission helps to
achieve the vision of the organization, which is the broad and ultimate purpose of
essential for the formation of the company’s objectives. He also states that mission statements
provide the reason for being of an organization which is communicated to all of its
stakeholders.
Many researchers have analyzed the mission statements of various industrial sectors.
In doing so, they have found a link between presence of certain components in the mission
statements with the better firms’ performances (Bartkus, Glassman, & McAfee, 2006;
Williams, 2008). The industrial analysis has also helped in the determination of focus of a
sector towards specific components in the mission statements. While these researches have
improved our knowledge and significance of mission statements, most of the research has
countries (Peyrefitte & David, 2006; Williams, 2008). With a few exceptions, a little research
has been done on the firms and industrial sectors of developing countries. Despite of its
significance on the well-being of society, little research has been done on the mission
statements of pharmaceutical sector. In order to address this significant gap, we analyze the
Bangladesh).
pharmaceutical companies of Pakistan and Bangladesh. One of the reasons of selecting these
two countries is that both of these are developing countries and have comparable
A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF MISSION STATEMENTS 4
demographic and economic status. We chose both of these countries because of the similarity
in the culture and also because Bangladesh was once a part of Pakistan. The sizes of the
pharmaceutical industries in both the countries is similar and have nine listed pharmaceutical
The objective of this article is the analysis of the nine components of mission
comparison to check how effectively these companies are communicating with their
stakeholders.
To this end this paper is organized as follows: First, we briefly review previous
research on mission statement analysis to identify the major themes and findings. Second, we
briefly discuss our data, research methods and our analytic approach which is followed by a
discussion of our detailed analysis. Finally, we discuss the main insights of our findings.
A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF MISSION STATEMENTS 5
Literature Review
The purpose of this article is to analyze that how effectively companies are
to give the competitive edge to its organization. To develop the mission statement is the first
step in strategic planning because mission statement tells about the purpose of the
organization. Mission statement addresses to stakeholders about the values and limits, and
also tells that organization cannot go out of its limits so all the actions and decision must be
relevant to the actual mission of the organization. The pharmaceutical industry is developing
day by day and it has high economic importance. Cremer (1993) defines mission as “a
collection of values, beliefs and behavioral norms which are common among the members of
a company and affect the preferences and behaviors of the employees through the strategic
target.”
communication tool. In marketing literature, mission statement still gets less importance. A
new theory and practice is suggested for mission statement to give it a new direction, that it
must be in a manner that attract and keep the customers informed (Amato & Amato, 2002).
An organization must develop and communicate a clear business mission in both strategic
planning and marketing strategy. The mission statement plays an important role in managing
stakeholders (Collins & Rukstad, 2008; Kohli & Leuthesser, 1997; Atril, Omran, & Pointon,
2005).
Some researchers have identified the relationship between the contents of mission
researchers have identified the either some contents effect the financial performances more or
500 companies with low-performing firms, found out that the higher performing companies
included corporate philosophy, self-concept and concern for public image, more often than
the others (Pearce & David, 1987). A study performed on mission statements of 83 large
Canadian and US firms found that statements which clearly specifies the contents “can affect
Some studies suggested that mission statement is not as much accurate as it should be.
Mostly organizations develop a mission statement and then they don’t pay any attention to
the exact purpose of the existence of the organization. A false and misleading mission
statement can damage the firm’s reputation. The main reason behind is that reputation built of
the creditability and if the creditability of the firm is in danger or it mislead the stakeholder so
how a firm could can seek the attention of the stakeholder. The arguments of the developing
the mission statement are based on two factors. First, the mission statement is the guideline
for the employees and managers in their behaviors and decision making process and
secondly, the mission statement is an externally directed message that is part of an auto-
which executives, top level management and employees sit together and sometimes a third
party consultant also needed. Such involvement engaged all the stakeholders in brainstorming
and discussion sessions in which each member expresses its opinion and views. After the
collection of all the opinions, firms’ chose the best views and convert them into mission
statement.
Theoretical Framework
The analysis is based on the fundamental nine components of mission statement given
by Pearce and David (1987) which should be a part of a mission statement for it to be
3. Geographic domain
4. Core technologies
6. Company philosophy
7. Company self-concept
The definitions of these components have been taken according to the explanation
Table 1
Mission statement components defined
Components Definitions
Customers Who are the firm’s customers?
Products or services What are the firm’s major products or services?
Market Geographically, where does the firm compete?
Technology Is the firm technologically current?
Concern for survival,
Is the firm committed to growth and financial soundness?
growth and profitability
What are the basic beliefs, values, aspirations, and ethical
Philosophy
priorities of the firm?
What is the firm’s distinctive competence or major competitive
Self-concept
advantage?
Concern for public Is the firm responsive to social, community, and environmental
image concerns?
Concern for employees Are employees a valuable asset of the firm?
A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF MISSION STATEMENTS 8
For the purpose of this study, all of the listed pharmaceutical companies of Pakistan
and Bangladesh were chosen. The companies were identified through the websites of national
identified and selected for this study. The mission statements of these companies were then
obtained from their respective annual reports available for download at the companies’
websites.
These statements were then compiled in a single document which was coded
independently by two researchers. While additional mission statement components have been
suggested by various researchers over the years, Bart et al. (2001) and Williams (2008) argue
that creation of new mission statement components hinders development of cohesive and
– that of Pearce and David – to facilitate comparison of our findings with prior studies.
Content analysis approach was used for the purpose of this study. Content analysis is
one of many research methods used for the analysis of data in the textual form. It is a
technique which describes the words in a systematic way. It quantifies the textual data to be
interpreted and analyzed. Graneheim and Lundman (2004) have said that “One of the most
basic decisions when using content analysis is selecting the unit of analysis. One
characteristic of qualitative content analysis is that the method, to a great extent, focuses on
the subject and context, and emphasizes differences between and similarities within codes
and categories.”
Both researchers worked independently and the mission statements were coded for the
nine components identified by Pearce and David (1987). The presence of a component within
a mission statement was coded as “1” and its absence was given the code of “0” on separate
coding sheets. The separate sheets of both the researchers were then compared and intercoder
A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF MISSION STATEMENTS 9
reliability was calculated which was 85.79%. The intercoder reliability was calculated by
adding the intercoder reliabilities of all individual components and then taking a mean of all
reliabilities. There was comparatively a larger difference between the coding of customers
and self-concept, however, the differences among the components determined by both the
The intercoder reliability can also be using Cohen’s Kappa. Cohen’s Kappa tells us
the extent to which the two researchers agree with each other in their coding, it is calculated
Observed agreement is the frequency with which the two measurements agree.
Whereas, expected agreement is calculated by calculating the expected values using marginal
frequencies and then by using these values the frequencies with which the two measurements
are expected to agree. Instead of calculating the intercoder reliability by-hand, we calculated
it by using an online software. The results of intercoder reliability and Cohen’s Kappa are
given in Table 2. A mean was taken of the values of Kappa calculated for each of the
component. The value of Kappa was 69.3%, where set of criteria is: less than 0% no
agreement, 0-20% poor, 20-40% fair, 40-60% moderate, 60-80% good, 80% or higher very
good.
Table 2
Results
Tables 3 and 4 given below show the analysis of the mission statements of
Table 3
Components covered in the mission statements of Pakistani pharmaceutical companies
Concern for
Name of the Products survival, Concern for Self- Concern for Total
Customers Market Technology Philosophy
companies and services growth and public image concept employees components
public image
Abbott Laboratories
Yes Yes - - - - - Yes - 3/9
Limited
Ferozsons
- Yes - - Yes Yes - Yes Yes 5/9
Laboratories Limited
GlaxoSmithKline
Yes - Yes Yes - Yes - Yes - 5/9
Pakistan Limited
Highnoon
Yes - - - Yes - - Yes Yes 4/9
Laboratories Limited
IBL HealthCare
Yes Yes - - Yes - Yes - Yes 5/9
Limited
Otsuka Pakistan
- Yes - - Yes - - Yes - 3/9
Limited
Sanofi-Aventis
Pakistan limited - - - - - Yes - Yes - 2/9
Wyeth Pakistan
- - - Yes - - - - - 1/9
Limited
Average score 4/9 5/9 2/9 3/9 5/9 4/9 2/9 7/9 4/9
A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF MISSION STATEMENTS 12 11
Table 4
Components covered in the mission statements of Bangladeshi pharmaceutical companies
Concern for
Name of the Products survival, Concern for Self- Concern for Total
Customers Market Technology Philosophy
companies and services growth and public image concept employees components
public image
ACME
Yes Yes Yes - Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes 8/9
Laboratories Limited
Beacon
Pharmaceuticals - Yes - Yes Yes - - Yes - 4/9
Limited
Beximco
Pharmaceuticals Yes Yes - - Yes Yes Yes Yes - 6/9
Limited
Central
Pharmaceuticals Yes - Yes - Yes - - Yes - 4/9
Limited
GlaxoSmithKline
- - - - - Yes - - - 1/9
Bangladesh Limited
Ibn Sina
Pharmaceutical Yes - Yes - Yes Yes - - - 4/9
Industry Limited
Orion Pharma Limited Yes - - Yes - Yes - Yes Yes 5/9
It can be observed in table 3 that there is only one company, The Searle Company
Limited, which has covered maximum of eight components in its mission statement. This
company has not mentioned who its customers are, thus missing one of the nine components.
Wyeth Pakistan Limited is the company which has least components covered in its mission
statement. Only one component, technology has been addressed in its mission statement.
pharmaceutical companies shows that only one company covered eight components and one
of the nine companies covered only one component. ACME Laboratories Limited covered
covered only one component. ACME Laboratories Limited did not mention anything
only communicated about its philosophy and missed all other eight components in its mission
statements.
The components of mission statements are then analyzed on average score basis in
which we have determined that on average how many times a single component have been
shows the average frequency of each component in the mission statements of pharmaceutical
companies of both the countries. It also exhibits that how much importance is given to each
component in the mission statements of the companies. The table also helps in the
identification of the component to which the most importance is given within the mission
Table 5
Products and
5/9 55% 3/9 33%
services
Market 2/9 22% 3/9 33%
Concern for
5/9 55% 7/9 78%
survival
Philosophy 4/9 44% 6/9 67%
Concern for
4/9 44% 2/9 22%
employees
Table 5 shows that 78% of the companies of Pakistan have communicated about their
self-concept i.e. their competitive advantage and the least importance has been given to the
market and concern for public image components in their mission statements.
companies are self-concept and concern for survival, growth and profitability. These two
components have been mentioned by 78% of the companies. Unlike Pakistani companies, the
least addressed components in the Bangladeshi companies are technology and concern for
employees.
In Pakistan, the second most addressed components are products & services and the
concern for survival, growth and profitability, which are communicated by 55% of the
Table 6
We also compared the pharmaceutical companies of both the countries on the basis of
their product and customer orientation. Table 6 shows that most of the Pakistani companies
are customer oriented and only two out of the nine companies are product oriented. While the
analysis of mission statement of Bangladeshi pharmaceutical companies shows that four out
of nine are customer oriented and the rest of the companies are product oriented.
A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF MISSION STATEMENTS 16
Discussion
It can be observed from Table 5 that in Pakistan majority of the companies i.e. 78%
gave the most importance to self-concept in their mission statements. In Bangladesh the
maximum frequency of occurrence was of self-concept and concern for survival, growth and
profitability in the mission statements of pharmaceutical companies. This analysis shows that
the pharmaceutical companies of both the countries give the most importance to the
Bangladeshi companies give more importance to their concern for growth, survival and
profitability which shows that Bangladeshi companies are more committed to growth and
financial soundness. This result also conforms with the studies performed by Pearce and
David (1987) on the analysis of Fortune-500 and Fortune-1000 firms, where most of the
It can also be observed that in Pakistan after self-concept the most occurring
components were products and concern for survival, whereas in Bangladesh concern for
philosophy is the second most occurring component. Philosophy conveys to the stakeholders
of the company about their basic beliefs and ethical priorities. People today pay attention to
ethical standards of a company and this factor should be at a higher place on the priority lists
of the companies.
mission to their stakeholders, and the most important stakeholders of the companies are their
shareholders and customers. It is interesting to see that customers get the third place in the
most mentioned components of the mission statements of the companies of both the
lesser importance given to the customer component in the mission statement could be that it
is generally accepted that the population as a whole can become the customers of the
A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF MISSION STATEMENTS 17
pharmaceutical companies. This could be the reason why most of the companies in both the
countries did not define who their customers were in their mission statements.
Market and concern for public image were the least addressed components in the
mission statements of the companies of Pakistan. Whereas in Bangladesh the least addressed
components were technology and concern for employees. Only 22% of the companies
mentioned their targeted market and their concern for public image in Pakistan and 22%
world, people are much concerned about the environmental issues and that is why they expect
the companies to address this issue in their mission statements. Despite of the significance of
concern for public image Pakistani companies pay least importance to this issue in their
mission statements.
It is also interesting to observe that the companies in both the countries gave very less
importance to technology in their mission statement. But in today’s age it is often said that
technology is the most important pre-requisite for becoming successful in the business world.
For example, a study done on the analysis of mission statements of pharmaceutical sector of
Iran, Turkey, USA and India also found that the companies gave the least importance to
technology in their mission statements (Azizi & Hosseinabadi, 2014). This result also
technology was among the least prioritized elements (Arefin, Rajib, & Bhuiyan, 2011). This
shows that mostly pharmaceutical companies do not give much importance to the technology
Employees are the backbone of any company and each organization needs their
employees to be working effectively and efficiently in order to thrive in the business world.
However, the pharmaceutical companies of Pakistan and Bangladesh have given very less
Pakistan have addressed their employees in their mission statement which is greater than the
Bangladeshi companies. This result shows that Bangladeshi companies are not giving the
required attention to the concern for employees’ component in their mission statements.
Whereas 44% of the Pakistani companies are addressing the employees which show that
Pakistani companies have given more value to their employees in the mission statements as
The highest importance given to self-concept and concern for survival, growth and
profitability shows that pharmaceutical companies of both the countries are giving more
importance to their profitability and competitive advantage instead of other human oriented
components such as customers, concern for employees, concern for public image, and
The analysis shows that most of the Pakistani companies are customer oriented and
only two out of the nine companies are product oriented. The analysis of mission statement of
Bangladeshi pharmaceutical companies shows that four out of nine are customer oriented and
the rest of the companies are product oriented. This also shows that in the Bangladeshi
companies there exists an approximate balance between customer and product orientation.
This shows that Pakistani companies focus more towards their customers whereas
Bangladeshi companies have a slight tilt towards their products in their mission statements.
Conclusion
In this article, after the qualitative content analysis we found that the mission
as none of the companies have covered all nine essential components of mission statement. 4
A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF MISSION STATEMENTS 19
out of 9 companies have covered more than 50% of components in Pakistan and 3 out of 9
Further, our analysis shows that most of the companies in both the countries have
given the most importance to self-concept in their mission statements. The second most
occurring component is concern for survival, growth and profitability in Pakistan, which is
the most important component, along with self-concept, in the mission statements of
The least discussed components in both the countries were different. Market and
concern for public image were the least discussed components in the companies of Pakistan.
While, in Bangladesh, technology and concern for employees gained the least importance in
Further, our analysis also shows that most Pakistani companies are customer oriented,
while, there is no set pattern in Bangladeshi companies regarding customer and product
orientation.
There is a further room for research in this field where future researchers can relate
the presence of components of mission statements with the financial performance of these
sectors of other developing countries as well to determine the similarities and differences in
References
Amato, C. H., & Amato, L. H. (2002). Corporate commitment to quality of life: Evidence
from company mission statements. Journal of Marketing theory and Practice, 10(4),
69-88.
Arefin, M. S., Rajib, M. S., & Bhuiyan, M. Y. (2011). Mission statements of pharmaceutical
firms in Bangladesh: Missing link and probable impact. Journal on Innovation and
Atril, P., Omran, M., & Pointon, J. (2005). Company mission statements and financial
Azizi, S., & Hosseinabadi, V. (2014). A content analysis of the mission statements of Iran,
Bart, C. K., Bontis, N., & Tagger, S. (2001). A model of the impact of mission statements on
Bartkus, B., Glassman, M., & McAfee, B. (2006). Mission statement quality and financial
Collins, D. J., & Rukstad, M. G. (2008). Can you say what your strategy is? Harvard
Cremer, J. (1993). Corporate mission and shared knowledge. Industrial and Corpoate
David, M. E., David, F. R., & David, F. R. (2014). Mission statement theory and practice: A
content analysis and new direction. International Journal of Business, Marketing, and
Drucker, P. F. (1974). Management: Tasks, Responsibilities, and Practices. New York, NY.
A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF MISSION STATEMENTS 21
Graneheim, U. H., & Lundman, B. (2004). Qualitative content analysis in nursing research:
Kohli, C., & Leuthesser, L. (1997). Corporate identity: The role of mission statements.
Pearce, J. A., & David, F. R. (1987). Corporate mission statements: The bottom line.
Peyrefitte, J., & David, F. R. (2006). A content analysis of mission statements of United
Williams, L. S. (2008). The mission statement: A corporte repoting tool with a past, present