Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Magdalaga 2019 Research
Magdalaga 2019 Research
Magdalaga 2019 Research
PROVINCE
Naval, Biliran
mclarideth@gmail.com
Abstract
This study on the management of children in conflict with the law focuses on the
police officers performance in handling and processing children who violate the law.
Based on findings, the police officers have the knowledge on the processes,
procedures and rules in dealing with children who have committed violations and
crimes. It was found out that police officers have followed the manual for handling CICL.
It was also revealed their collaboration with the agencies involved like the Department
of Social Welfare and Development and the Local Government Unit in the proper
It was then recommended that police officers assigned on the WCPD should
Children, consisting of 39% of the overall population of the Philippines can play a
significant role as agents of transformation. However, these children often live in remote
areas with limited infrastructures and access to basic services. In a typical Filipino
setting, for example in Metro Manila where 20% resides in informal housings or slum
areas (UNICEF, 2010). Children from impoverished households are often victims of
extreme forms of child labor such as prostitution or recruitment into armed forces. The
effects of poverty are also visible through that large number of children living and
working in the streets in the Philippines, even though not very visible, there are an
estimated 246,111 children living and working in the streets, between the ages of 0-17
In the 2000 Census of the Philippine population, the youth, aged 10 to 24 years
old, formed 32 percent of the 76.5 million Filipinos. With this population, a total of
5,825,425 children and youth are at risk, comprising 3,000,000 children with disabilities,
246,011 street children, 64,000 victims of armed conflict, 2,400,000 who are exposed to
hazardous working conditions, 4,097 sexually abused, 11,317 children in conflict with
the law, 3,694 abandoned and neglected, and 100,000 commercial sexually exploited
(Leones, 2006).
The increasing number of youth-in-conflict with the law in the Philippines has
been quite alarming. Among those considered “high-risk” are abandoned and neglected
children who have not been taken in by existing Department of Social Welfare and
circumstances where they come into conflict with the law (Save the Children UK, 2004).
There are three major agencies that provide custodial or confinement facilities
and services for the youth offenders. These include the DSWD, the Bureau of Jail
Management and Penology (BJMP), and the Bureau of Corrections which is under the
Department of Justice. The DSWD supervises the facilities and services for 6,991 youth
offenders nationwide. About 1,340 youth offenders are confined in various regional
rehabilitation centers for youth nationwide while 5,651 of youth offenders are under the
Because of the growing concern for delinquent youth, the Republic Act 9344,
also known as the Juvenile Justice and Welfare Act of 2006, was passed establishing a
comprehensive juvenile justice and welfare system and creating the Juvenile Justice
and Welfare Council. It covers the different stages involving children at risk and children
in conflict with the law from prevention to rehabilitation and reintegration. The increasing
number of CICL is not only true in the Philippines but in other countries as well.
procedures, authorities and institutions that respect the rights of children in conflict with
the law and are directed towards their rehabilitation and reintegration into society. The
primary instrument guiding the development of juvenile justice is the United Nations
Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC), of 1989, which has been ratified by every
country in South Asia. State parties are obliged to give effect to the Convention by
means of laws, policies and practices designed to further its goals (UNICEF, 2006).
In the Philippines over 50,000 children have been arrested and detained since
1995 (UNICEF). Roughly 28 children get arrested every day, or more than one child for
every hour. There were more than 4,000 CICL cases reported in year 2010. And there
was a move by the lawmakers such as Senator Escudero, Senator Sotto and local
executives to amend or repeal the law. But social welfare secretary Dinky Soliman and
other non-government groups stressed that these CICL are also victims of
circumstances. The authorities should not go after these youths but the adults who are
taking advantage and victimizing these young people. The legislators should instead
look at how the government can improve the lives of the Filipino people through reforms
and programs that would alleviate poverty which is the primary cause of crimes whether
Biliran province is not exempted from having problems with children in conflict
with the law, hence there are already many cases that involved them. On the premise of
these cases, the researchers conducted this study to find out how law enforcement
1.1 Background
This study is anchored on the Strain Theory of Robert Merton. Robert Merton a
sociologist who coined strain theory believed that people were placed on established
paths in order to be successful in society. Merton believed that social structure rather
than culture was the main problem for juvenile delinquents’ association with crime.
Using several adaptations of strain theory, he clarifies his argument. Merton believed
there were five adaptations in society that you could travel in order to be successful.
The five adaptations were innovation, retreatism, ritualism, conformity, and rebellion.
The three I will be explaining are innovation, conformity, and rebellion. Merton states,”
the social structure effectively limits the possibilities of individuals within these groups to
achieve this goal through the use on institutionalized mean” (Merton 1959). If a juvenile
bettering himself then he is going to adapt to the societal norms that are already in
For example, a juvenile delinquent grows up in the projects with low income
housing, his mother is a single parent who works full time but can barely afford to put
food on the table. In order for the juvenile delinquent to provide for himself he must find
other means of income. His only means of income that he has been raised to know is
selling drugs. The juvenile delinquent’s strain is that he only knows deviance and crime
in order to prevail. Although the juvenile delinquent is breaking the normative methods
of society, he is still able to survive through one of the five adaptations which is
innovation.
Robert Merton’s concept of innovation says, “people accept the cultural goals of a
society but reject the conventional methods of attaining those goals” (Merton 1976). A
prime example of an innovator would be a drug dealer. The drug dealer has fully
accepted the cultural goals that he needs to complete in order to be successful. Instead
of abiding by those cultural goals and following the process of achievement he uses
deviance to stray away from the path of success. Same prophecy goes for the juvenile
delinquent stated above he must conform to innovation in order to provide for himself
and his family. The juvenile delinquent has accepted his social status and low-income
community but has decided instead of going to school and striving for a good education
he would rather comply and sell drugs just like his peers he has looked up to his whole
life. His social constraints dictate his decisions and therefore he is placed in
environment and community lifestyle. He has learned the way of crime and deviance
through watching his elder’s and peers. The experiences that he has been a part of
make him more prone to commit deviant acts. Merton states “there are fewer legitimate
opportunities to obtain wealth for the lower socioeconomic class” (Merton, 1959). This
means he believes that the only way that you can obtain wealth is that you must be born
in the middle class or upper class of society. Merton also says it’s okay not to achieve
but everyone should give an effort and try, but those who don’t achieve still have some
sort of value. The value he is trying to portray is the value you give of yourself. Even
though you may struggle at first, it’s the greatest accomplishment to never give up. The
juvenile delinquent may never become wealthy or have the finer things in life but that
doesn’t mean he cannot make life enjoyable. If he applies himself with great values and
strives to be the best, he can overcome many obstacles that may derail his path. In
Conformity is the accusation that most people comply with society’s norms. People
are taught at a young age the rules and punishment of society. When an individual
conforms, they not only lose their individualistic ideals, but they are allowing society to
social group, such as a street gang, they are no longer looked at as an outsider but
rather embraced into likeness as an insider or brotherhood. Conformists are people who
not only believe in the assumption of cultural achievements but also believe in the
methods that allow them to reach them. The conforming processes are an easy route
into societal norms and allow an individual to hide their true agenda of individualism.
The last adaptation that comes into play is rebellion. “Rebellion occurs when an
individual reject both culturally defined goals and means and substitute’s new goals and
means” (Essays, UK 2018). This means they no longer adhere to any of societal rules
but create their own. A prime example would be a hip-hop artist. A lot of times hip hop
artists don’t adhere to any of society’s social norms but rather rebel and show the
representation of the bad boy image. The juvenile delinquent listens to hip hop music
which encourages him to party, sell drugs, and make money then more than likely he is
going to want to follow that lifestyle. Music influences everything in terms of society,
norms, and values. Without music how would becoming a deviant person be acceptable
in our world today? Most hip hop artists live a deviant crime filled lifestyle everyday of
their lives. Just like the delinquent selling drugs on the corner it’s the same self-
fulfillment they each get which make their rebellious nature. We all have rebellious
tendencies it’s in our human nature. Being the good person, all the time seems
somewhat weak and stagnant. The juvenile delinquent feels he has to prove something
to his peers but also his family. People in society always want to feel accepted no
matter what social group they come to find. The rebellious adaptation is an important
aspect of strain theory of social structure it completes the cycle of social structure.
Merton was an established thinker and a great sociologist. His development of strain
theory and the adaptations associated with it made him a well-known person of his time.
Merton coined this theory so that he could help future thinkers like us understand where
his ideals and passion steamed from especially in crime and deviance. His strain theory
led to other important theories such anomie and the self-fulfilling prophecy. Crime and
There will always be low income communities that breed out drug dealers for the
streets. The persuasion of crime is a war that has affected many generations of juvenile
delinquency. Juvenile delinquency is a privilege a young boy gets before he sees the
real institutions of punishment for crimes. The only way some delinquents learn about
punishment and the laws of society is by breaking them. Unfortunately breaking the law
has serious consequences and can affect a delinquent’s future in society. Until we learn
how to really create better opportunities for low income communities with juvenile
delinquent issues our society will be a refuge for many more to come.
This study aims to assess the management of children in conflict with the law in the
Biliran Province.
a. age
b. sex
c. civil status
e. years in service
b. Determine the crime committed by the children in conflict with the law (CICL)
in Biliran Province.
2. Methods
Research Design
This study employed the descriptive survey research design. This is a descriptive
research classified as cross-sectional survey type for it involved the collection of data
from selected respondents to attain the objectives of the study. The study covers the
Research Locale
The study was conducted in the capital town of Biliran province, the municipality
of Naval where there are reported cases of children in conflict with the law. Due to its
semi-urbanized setting, homeless children migrated to find way and means to survive.
Research Respondents
The respondents of this study are the law enforcement officers and social
workers who are in direct contact with the children in conflict with the law.
Data Collection
The researchers visited the police station and the social welfare office after letter
request of survey were approved and signed by parties concerned. A survey using a
semi-structured survey questionnaire was conducted by the researchers. The
questionnaires were distributed and retrieved after the respondents accomplished the
responses.
After data collection, responses are encoded, tallied, and analyzed. Descriptive
statistics such as frequencies, totals, mean and range were used. Data is presented in
Data Scoring
The following scoring was adopted in finding out the management of the
To determine the profile of the law enforcers and social workers in terms of age,
sex, civil status, rank and years of service, frequency and percentages were used to
give information.
To find the frequency of the management and handling of children in conflict with
Results under the variable profile of the Police Officers revealed that most of
them were male and majority of them are at their adult stage, married, with entry rank of
In the procedures in handling child at risk or children in conflict with the law,
specifically in handling violations to ordinances, it was found out most of the police
officers have conducted all the procedures by giving the child advice not to do the office
again and transfer the custody of the child to the Local Social Welfare and Development
As to the apprehending process, it was evident that the police officers have done
all the procedures and with care not to hurt or traumatize children of the process by
properly introducing themselves as kuya or ate and show their identification cards. In
processing children who committed crimes, police officers have conducted the proper
rules in the turn over of the child to the custody of the social welfare and development
office.
Lastly, in the rules and procedures of handling children in conflict with the law,
the police officers always conducted the correct processing in informing the parents,
referral of the case to the Barangay Council, conduct meeting with the LSWDO and
intervention program and the closing of the investigation of the criminal case as soon as
proper documentation and turn over are done by the police officer specifically the officer
the performance of the Philippine National Police in managing children in conflict with
the law will be presented based on its findings and implications. The data collected are
presented in tables including its analysis and interpretation written into narrative form.
Profile of Respondents
The table below presents the profile of the Police Officers which includes the
age, sex, civil status, rank and position and years in service.
Total 5 100
Sex
Male 3 60
Female 2 40
Total 5 100
Civil and
Rank Status
Position
Single
PO1 22 40
40
Married
PO2 13 60
20
Widow
PO3 1 20
PSS Total 15 100
20
Total 5 100
Years of Experience
Neophyte (1-5) 1 20
Experience (6-10) 2 40
Expert (11 & above) 2 40
Total 5 100
Age. The table above shows that 5 or 100 percent of the respondents are in the
age of 25-64. It means that most of the respondents are adults. It implies that most of
Sex. The police officers showed that 3 or 60 percent are male and 2 or 40
percent are female. This means most of the respondents are male. It implies that
percent are single, that indicates most of the respondents are married. It implies that
Rank and position. Among the 5 respondents, 2 or 40 percent are Police Officer
percent is Police Staff Sergeant. This means that most police officers are Police Officer
1. It implies that majority of the police officers are lowest in rank and position.
respondents have served for 11 years above, 2 or 40 percent have served for 6-10
years and 1 or 20 percent are in the service for 1-5 years. This means that most of the
respondents have been in service for period of years already. It implies that most of the
This part presents the data gathered that determine the crimes/violations of
Table 2 reveals the crimes and violations committed by children in conflict with
the law. It was found out that the highest case of crimes is theft that is has 20 recorded
cases. The next highest violation is the Curfew Ordinance that ranks up to 10 recorded
cases. The rest of the violations are drunkenness, harassment and a drug dealing
crime. This implies that most of the children in conflict with the law has committed a
crime of theft.
Procedures in Handling Child at Risk (CAR) of CICL (Children in Conflict with the
Law)
This part presents the results of the variables under the procedures in handling
Indicators WM Interpretatio
n
1. Give the child a friendly advice or “payo” 4.80 Always
or a simple warning not to repeat the act/s Implemented
she/he has committed;
risk of children in conflict with the law. Of all the listed procedures, the respondents
gave a highest mean of 4.80 to the procedure, give the child a friendly advice or “payo”
or a simple warning not to repeat the act/s she/he has committed, that means the police
officers always conducted giving the child a friendly advice not to repeat the offense
he/she has committed. It implies that most of the police officers has followed the
On the other hand, procedures 3, 4, and 5 got a lower mean of 4.40 that means
police officers always conduct immediate transfers the custody of the child to the
barangay of residence for proper disposition, moreover, the police officers always
implemented turnover of the child at risk to the Local Social Welfare and Development
Office of the place where the offense is committed, lastly, the WCPD officer shall submit
records of the case in sealed envelope with “CAR CASE” written on the face of the
envelope. It implies that the police officers have followed the procedures in handling
An overall total mean of 4.52 sums up all the responses of the police officers to
the procedures in handling child at risk of child in conflict with the law. This mean that all
of the procedures were always conducted by the police officers. It means that police
officers have done the right procedures in handling children who were caught violating
part presents the responses of the police officers in apprehending children in conflict
Indicators WM Interpretation
1. The apprehending officer shall identify 5.00 Always
himself/herself to the child and shall Implemented
introduce herself/himself as kuya or ate to the
child and show his/her proper identification
card as a police officer
Table 4 shows the results of the responses of the respondents in the procedures
of apprehending children in conflict with the law. The procedures 1,2,4 has gained the
highest mean of 5.00 and procedure 3 got a lower mean of 4.80. This means that police
wear vest or jacket while in uniform, show badge and nameplate, and conduct search in
a friendly non-degrading and gender sensitive manner. It implies that police officers had
followed the procedures in the apprehension process of children in conflict with the law.
The procedure that has the lower mean, implies that still police officers always
conducted the showing of their identification cards even in civilian attire during
apprehension of minors.
An overall mean of 4.95 was derived from all the procedures that means the
police officers have been following the manual that provides their process in
Table 4 shows the processing steps that police officers follow in booking children
in conflict with the law who committed a crime. All the process garnered highest mean
of 5.0 except for process no. 6 that got a lower mean of 4.20. This means that all
processes from notifying the parents, LSWDO and PAO, recording the personal
circumstances of the child and filling out entry forms, knowing the child’s age and
gathering evidence if the child is abused, neglected or abandoned has been conducted
by the police officers. It implies that they are doing what is mandated in the manual for
handling CICL. However, in taking fingerprint and photograph, the police officers often
conducted the process but there are instances where they cannot fully comply that
A total mean of 4.87 sums up all the responses of the respondents that means
they always conducted the processing steps of children who committed crimes on their
watch. It implies that police officers have been careful in processing children who
committed crimes and has followed the steps in processing them for turn over to
This part presents the results of the respondent’s response in the rules and
Indicators WM Interpretatio
n
1. The WCPD Officer shall release the child 5.00 Always
to the parents or guardians, after Implemented
consultation with the LSWDO
The table above reveals the responses of the respondents in the conduct of the
rules and procedures in handling children in conflict with the law. All of the rules and
procedures garnered the highest mean of 5.00 that means police officers had
conducted and followed the rules and procedures in handling children who are
offenders of the law. It implies that police officers have been very capacitated in
handling children as they are very familiar with the laws that protect children despite of
A 5.00 total mean came out of all the indicators given that means police officers
have always conducted the given role in handling children in conflict with the law. It
implies that police officers are well aware of the sensitivity of the matter in dealing with
children hence set of rules and procedures stipulated in the manuals are to be followed
5. Conclusions
Based on the findings of the study, the followings conclusions were drawn:
The Police Officer respondents evidently shows that most of them are at the
adult stage; male; married; in entry rank of PO1 and been in the service for 1-5 years.
The qualifications stated is enough to prove the credibility of the police officers in
All the procedures, processes, and rules in the management and handling of
children in conflict with the law has been conducted by the police officers as it was
or Manual in Handling Cases of Children at Risk and Children in Conflict with the Law.
The research study was done to assess the performance of the law enforcement
personnel in handling children who committed violations and criminal acts. Out of the
findings of the study, it was concluded that police officers have been performing well in
the implementation of the processes that are stipulated in the manual to ensure that
proper protocols are followed to avoid criminal liability on the part of the law enforcers.
Recommendations
1. Police Officers assigned in the Women Children Protection Desk must be trained
in child psychology to better respond to cases of children who committed crimes and
how to talk and process them into telling them what made them do the crime.
2. The government should provide rehabilitation programs that are sure to effect
3. Police stations should have special detentions rooms that do not resemble as
prison for children to stay while waiting for the processing the turn over of custody to the
The Local Government Unit together with the PNP and DSWD should launch extensive
campaign to orient parents of their role and responsibility in keeping children away from
the streets and introduce livelihood programs that will help families fight poverty that is
7. References
Ancheta-Templa, M. (2004) “Understanding children in conflict with the law: A study of
the situation of children in conflict with the law in Davao”, Save the Children-UK,
Quezon City.
Ateneo Law School and United Nations Children’s Fund (1998). “Situation analysis on
children in conflict with the law and juvenile justice system. Retrieved January 25,
2010 from www.childprotection.org.ph/
De La Cruz, Y. (2004) Philippines Senate action builds hope for children in jail,
UNICEF Philippines, Retrieved September 12, 2010 from www. unicef.
org/protection/Philippines
Essays, UK. (November 2018). Juvenile Delinquency: Strain Theory. Retrieved from
https://www.ukessays.com/essays/criminology/juvenile-delinquency-using-
strain-theory-criminology-essay.php?vref=1
Leones, C.V. (2006) “Effective preventive measures for youth at risk in the Philippines”,
Resource Material Series No. 68, 129th International Senior Seminar Visiting
Experts’ Papers, UNAFEI, Fuchu, Tokyo, Japan. Retrieved January 16, 2010
from www.ncjrs.gov/App/.../Abstract.aspx?id
Merton, Robert K. “Social Conformity, Deviation, and Opportunity-Structures: A
Comment on the Contributions of Dubin and Cloward.” American Sociological
Review 24 (1959): 177-189.
Myers, David G. (2002) Psychology. 2nd edition, New York: Worth Publishers, Inc..
Preda Foundation (2002) Philippine minors in jail: Report 6th September 2002.
Retrieved January 12, 2010 from www.preda.org/
Save the Children-UK Philippine Programme (2004) “Breaking rules: Children in conflict
with the law and the juvenile justice process: The experience in the Philippines”.
Quezon City, Philippines: Save the Children UK, Quezon City. Retrieved January
6, 2010 from www.eldis.org › Home › Topics
Situation of the Filipino Children, Council for the Welfare of Children (CWC), 2012
Sun Star. (2007) „Reports on Juvenile Offenders‟, A-2. Davao City: Sun Star
Publications
Umil, Anne Marxze (2011, November 4). Lowering Age of Discernment Won’t Solve
Juvenile Delinquency. Bulatlat.com. Retrieved November 5, 2011, from
http://bulatlat.com/main/2011/11/04/lowering-age-discernment-wont-solve-
juvenile-delinquencychildrens-rights-groups/