Professional Documents
Culture Documents
G.R. No. 204766-CSC Insubordination
G.R. No. 204766-CSC Insubordination
29
A BC B5D!B235224
-0&8EF%F4G4-48E
H.:29%IJ%KLMN
OP>P%E'P%KLQNII
F0R?>SH0ES%8T%U0?<SUJ%>0R>0-0ES0F%VW%-0&>0S?>W%0E>4X@0%SP%8E?JY!
Z
O<8>4?%VP%?X@4ES0WJ%0F@?>F8%TP%H0EF8[?%?EF%?OE0-%EP%G4<<?E@0G?5
F%0%&%4%-%4%8%E
R0>?<S?J%\]^
_`!2a!`!!Zbcdefgdhdfij#!Z! #`kl0
`a!`
mnopqi !l25202 Z"r!252025!lZB5a
s
tY
073
A kl!Z! ulr!527 !l4052v
`aZt!Zla""wnxnpì #!! #B`#!r! "#
"B`wvy"5z a
!{`!
l!
A!`l !l !l `l!`8
u|r!!B295295a!}`!~kZ"}5!! rBk!
!a
D!wk!
hhfdgy5
llBu``l!ssa!#wu}ay`}lA!# # la!m
npit
|! 55` r`!k!"`~wku~y "!Zl"l!##`!
! #!r!5#!Z"l l5#!#l`B l l! lr
!`!Zl
0yl"rlB# ! 5`j #k!
D!
`B# u}a`}Aa5!#! ` !! "rB!B
Z!`r!
4
Y!!`#`rZ "!Zl"5k!
D!ZZ 5r
" l!k!
r!kwk!
cicgpqi`B# u}a`}Aa
l!l|r!!B95225ku~tl!!B5k!
kB!5# k!
k
u}a`}Aa`!` !"`B!5!|r!!B9524
}!k!
k!"
rB sB!! !D524tl!!BkB! k!"u!!
07s
07s}!Z#"` !ru}a ##k!
D!
!l"
a"###!Z rBl!l"5k!
k` `!l 1!"!!B
!!#!!mpi#A!a!mnpi`t|! 5
Ark!
D! k!
k !`l5l #!5lZB!l
a!
5D245245Aa Au 5!`!5DB005245!`!"!B
l5!l#tl!!BkB!l `!"`!l#!!!Z#k!
k`!"
u}a ##k!
D!!l"
811
1 !1!201"!201#!$29$20
" 01
012312457899
29
%&!!'('! (!
)!0 *!+,-./0-1-/23
4#!*!"!'
& 5'63
78"5!052453
&!! "&
*9.1.:92;:0<2=!!*! *8
>>>>>>>>>
?8#'"!*"5&!* ! "
9.1.:92;:02!" ! !#!'8!!3!"'
&!*">>>
>>>>>>>>>
?!!&*!"#!!&5' ) #*
" !'&@&A& !"!*59.1.:9
;:025!& ""
>>>>>>>>>
?BCCD7C5!*!!' **&!8& !!!!8!&8
!#*! #&!*!&&!8!'53!!8#!
!E& !5'?!*=!"!'F&**&8
*=*!G,-./0-1-/<
337(FHI53!!5'C%7HJC%!&! ) # 1!'!&#
!!'& *!"""#!*!!! 00)'24>
>>
C%7HJC(DK6BC5!&!8! (!
5!(H& *!"
&!## 1!!*!"#7**&!LL3!#*F&6!# # &
3!@F63A5%D! 3'5HK
C%7HJC(DF
HHI5!&5!"9.1.:92;:02!5&5&5L
& &!& !#&!8!'&!12;:0M2NOPQORPSRTOURVSSWXYTPZ[
\]RYUTPTPZ[U^R_^R̀abWV^bZRcV[VP^Zd̀
6!*!5%&!!'('! (!"7!!
240L(53!&#(!
)!!*!"*&
7F3*F63
5(!
(H!* 8&**& & !*!"*
7F3
%54&*(!"7!!
240L(5(!
)!5 8!7**&7!!5"!
! ! !'! 5*8
7**&7!!
0909 8"5!095245!&#!
4' e
!f8!'*4"5 "!5 !# " &5
" &1!#&15 !!!* !!!&')!
!!*
K !7!!5
4' e!"!!'!8 *!
"!87**&!FJ
&&FFF5!&8'
5
"! "
33 8"5!075245 !
4' e5
"! "
8"5!25245 ! J85 !&#!
! & *!"&!## 1!!*!"# !5
!!!&8
6'!5f5!! !*!*!"##**&
&"!'L '!* !8!!&! !
!&"*!!&*F63(!
)!
&
H! 8"5!25245!4!#
4' e5"!!
&""1!97!*!!*!&"'!&8 7**&7!!
0909 "! "
33
"! "
49 8"5!05245 8# e J8
!&#'" 1!&*&&fF63
"! "
8"5!235245!&#J8!8!&&5
# 7F33!5 5'! !g
*
7**&"! "
7L
(&"5!35245!!#J8&(!
)!!!#& *F63g
811
1 !1!201"!201#!$29$20
" 21
012312457899
29
#
"! "
0 %&"'!005245!&#()!)!* #
+,,&!---,-./97!,!"!&,"! ")!&"
&#,&&0'0,!1&&5 '!"!&!5!&!,&&0
&& 5'0 &!&!
2)!5! &"3& #,#,')"
"!)&#"',!%+25&&0
"!)/
3049
+5302525%+26&!!37!&&.
%8---50)!,!"6&!!3%3!5! !
%& "!)&, #!! #3,#!'!5#!)
"& &5#!#&,3 & &! &'!,!)&5 "#"
3,",!"!)&& #&&!3
6&!!3%8! ! 9!,!&#:!3,%!
5!3# +-/
,-./ !, !#!,, !'!&)! ! "'
,! "!)&
')%&/6/ 5+&'!5275/6/
70771#,8
;<=>=?@>=AB,!*
835C !7
:5
#
()
!'3DE>FGHBI>EJF=KLB
&&!#35%& 530252,6&!!3,25
%!",25, #"#3,!)& &5!#&,%35!
-'!5 / &M! &*-!,6!)& "#"
3,",!"!)&5 7'!!30452753#!
",!!&!!N@KO?O=KBP
835 : ()!
, #373,!-'! !!'3" 3,Q1R"
./6/&!,!"##,STUTVSWXVYW!! '3/
Z[\T]Y\U\]W&,
'36&!!3%3! %!
5!&5&' & &!&
!#&!)!3&!!,!",,,&'3%!
5!^&5! 9
,!&"3)!&,%!
5!"#!'!
2)!5/6/
, ! ',!#!)"& &5& &! &'!,!)& #!
#&,3
.5/6/" "3,,!"
, ",!!!&!5'/6/
1971
!&40521
_, ')5! , ,!!)/
+!&252025/
!"# %&,#)!8
;<=>=?@>=AB!"&! 5M!'3I>EJF=KB /6/
70771 +&'!527 1971 !&405215, #!!*
835C !7
:
#
()#3,!-'! "#
"3,Q1R"5!!'3C(C6C% 6C.
6-%C
.
6&!!3,2!'3 !& 3!!! !#14"
`@B@>K=>=KLa
./
! 5!8!! !, '3!!,%!
5!34# +-/,-./5&' &' !',# ,
%!
%b '#&
&5!"0',8
,P&",!" "!)'3
2!!, ",!!&!5'/
)"'!25202
2&5,!!)Z[\T]Y\U\]W' #! %&,/
&&! !! &
./!, "!!
.'&!&!!! !#3,#!'!3
&,)!!!,%!
5!&! &&3+-/,-./
811
1 !1!201"!201#!$29$20
" 41
012312457899
29
%&!0' !'&("!!5)!!'')! #* *
&(
00+!""!'! !#!'' !&!)'
"(!
%!
!,)!'-!
.!5!
/(5'!"!'#&(
!)*''!"!5*)) "'#!*") )5&'!( !'!(
0
! 5! 1*!' !!)""-!
.!2,)!
0!
!5! 3**!" "-!
.!)) '
5!/! &(!
+))!(! *!!)#1 -!
.!2
!(0%4
+!)&(#! !!'*"&!0524'4
)
!! ")'5676859:8;<9+ )'4
)!5676859:8;
!)!*!("!"# !')!"##'4
)!()! -!
.!2"''')'0%45676859:8;=9
)!58
>?0@3>-A%
@@B5!)&!"5676859:8;9!5)5)&,
) )!) !#)!*!()!79:8;=9)"&(
!-!
> !.!
02
5"54
!) +4) '!"""#0!!)
!*?)!!('C'!" ##-!
.!0%4
+)!(")')
!)*4
!)#1-!
.!2"''')'0%4'%+45 #!
')!*!(!#'( )
!*!5)!( !) -!
-@) '!" )!## 1!
!'!"#'0%4'%+4
DEFGHID
=IIJKIJLM
;A# NB"?!B
/0/N!/O
0!P5!D/Q!!
290R5
0!G9520
0E ?G
/0/S
T?P5//!!/B
/0/11
U?!R
U##
#
/5
VW
WE5XYZZY[
29R92
2
VW\WE5]^_[94R93
4D
BB@R1"5
VWSWE5XYZZY`[
R9
9D1
XYZZ[5
20
aS"
b
3
VW1WE5XYZZY`[
9
VWNWE5]^_[3R72
VWWE5]^_[74Rc
7
c
cdYZZY`[
9R90
01@D!@/1""5
@
! 5
0cc39c5
!5209520D1
c577
00>
02efgXh9
04@!"D!@/>!/DG"5
@
G!"53E
0405099R093a200b
09i^_093
03>
811
1 !1!201"!201#!$29$20
" 31
012312457899
29
%&'!()
!&*