Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Research and Academic Writing in Islamic Economics and Finance
Research and Academic Writing in Islamic Economics and Finance
1 Overview
Crucial Part of
2 Our Manuscript
Essential Questions
3 for Writing Articles
4 Tips
Tingkatan Jurnal dan Rejection Rate nya
• Q1 atau A* = 95%
• Q1/Q2 atau A = 90%
• Q2/Q3 atau B = 80%
• Q3/Q4 atau C = 60%
Crucial Part of our Manuscript
• Motivation
• Research gap
• Innovation in topic, dataset, method, etc
• Robustness test
• Implications
• Story of our manuscript
Flow
Start
•Submit to targeted journal
Read •Identify the gaps
•Review the Literature
•Cite current year and last
two years papers
Submit Circular
Write
Flow
•Present at prestigious Patience •Empirical Model
conferences •Estimations
•Revise and improve •Robustness Checks
Story of our
1
manuscript Research gap
6 2
5 3
Implications Novelty (innovation in
topic, dataset, method)
4
Robustness test
Essential Questions for Writing Articles
Originality
Relationship to
Literature
Methodology
Results and
Conclusions
Implications For
Research, Practice and/
or Society
Originality
❖ Does the paper contain new and significant
information adequate to justify publication?
Relationship to Literature
❖ Does the paper demonstrate an adequate
understanding of the relevant literature in
the field and cite an appropriate range of
literature sources?
❖ Is any significant work ignored?
Methodology
❖ Is the paper's argument built on an
appropriate base of theory, concepts or
other ideas?
❖ Has the research or equivalent intellectual
work on which the paper is based been well
designed?
❖ Are the methods employed appropriate?
This study investigates the impact of Islamic microfinance institutions on rural household welfare in Indonesia. In
particular, this study focuses on estimating the impact of financing, the level of shari’a compliance, the best
financing mechanism, and the factors that impact on rural households that become clients of Islamic microfinance
institutions. Islamic microfinance institutions play an important role in Indonesia because the country has the world’s
largest Muslim population. Hence, the availability of financial products and services that parallel Muslim beliefs is
crucial. This study estimates the impact of Islamic financing on rural household welfare using the difference-in-
difference method followed by the adjusted difference-in-difference method. Next, the study evaluates shari’a
compliance and the Islamic values of clients of Islamic microfinance institutions. The double difference-in-
0
difference and adjusted difference-in-difference methods are adopted to investigate the financing impact of two
Islamic microfinance institutions’ financing mechanisms; profit and loss sharing and non-profit and loss sharing. The
logit model is used to identify factors that influence rural households to become clients of Islamic microfinance
institutions. This study produces several important findings. The difference-in-difference method results show
Islamic microfinance institutions’ financing helps to increase the clients’ annual income. The fixed effects results
confirmed that Islamic microfinance institutions’ financing improved clients’ income compared with non-clients. The
evaluation of shari’a compliance found that Islamic microfinance institutions’ financing parallels the shari’a
standards of the National Shari’a Board of Indonesia. The results of the double difference-in-difference method
confirm that the profit and loss sharing mechanism has a greater impact on rural household welfare than the non-
profit and loss sharing mechanism. Finally, age, gender, and income are factors that significantly influence rural
households to become clients of Islamic microfinance institutions.
AB S T R A CT
Buat comments
Take your time
sanggahan jika perlu
1. Respon dengan baik
Responses to reviewer critiques and suggestions for
improvement of manuscript No. #XXX
▪ Memulai debat
▪ Menyalahkan reviewers atau
editor
▪ Dokumen response
(rejoinder) tidak profesional
▪ Tidak menanggapi semua
masukan dan saran reviewers
TIPS
✓ Sesuaikan dengan standar jurnal internasional
✓ Pastikan alur penulisan menarik dan baik
✓ Munculkan kembali motivasi, research gap, novelty
✓ Perbanyak artikel-artikel terdahulu yang terkait dengan
penelitian
✓ Pastikan data dan olah data dengan benar
✓ Memunculkan banyak implikasi dan kontribusi
✓ Mengacu ke research questions
✓ Meringkas dan memoles bagian-bagian yang sudah
dipisah
✓ Tambahkan literatur dari jurnal yang bereputasi
References
• Some parts of this presentation are adapted from Christopher Gan,
Pitching Research Clinic (2019), Lincoln University, New Zealand.
• Some parts of this presentation are adapted from Law Siong Hook,
Publishing in Citation Index Journals (2020), UPM, Malaysia.
• Robert W., Pitching Research (2018). Available at SSRN:
http://ssrn.com/abstract=2462059
• Robert W. Faff, “A Simple Template for Pitching Research,” Accounting and
Finance 55 (2015) 311–336, doi: 10.1111/acfi.12116
Thank You
Question & Answer
Live Locally
Think Globally
Act Revolutionary Bayu Arie Fianto