Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 218

%..%)+1U5!-d*!

.1.2096,9 8C6C3C3 'C<C0 978&7G 7&&( 7.24:



<G1G3)& 97<&)& )4H)9 .1*7.<1* '.61.08*  2*6.0&<&
,BA *88. 4192'.& @3.:*67.8*7.3* ,.)*60*3 '&'&7G3G3
B3*6).H. 8G5 2*71*H. <*6.3* 0.2<&,*6 412&<& 0&6&6
:*6). G7& '.6 7C6* 2*6.0&3 *3.= 9::*81*6.3)* ,B6*:
<&58G08&3 7436&
 F)& 0.2<& )40846&7G3G &1&3 7.24:
47843 @3.:*67.8*7.3* '&H1G "G5 &0C18*7.3)* '.<40.2<&
)*671*6. :*62*<* '&K1&)G .6 <&3)&3 )& 3C01*.0 &7.8
&1&3G3)& &6&K8G62&1&6 <&5G<46)9 .2<& &6&K8G62&1&6G3G
<&=&61G0 2*71*H.<1* '.61.08* 7C6)C62*3.3 ,.)*6*0
=461&K2&7G 7439(9
 )* 8C2 =&2&3G3G <&=&61GH&
&)&2&0 C=*6* C3.:*67.8*)*3 &<6G1)G B<1*(* '.1.2096
,9 8C6C3C3 )C33<&<& <&<G12&7G3G 7&H1&<&3 'C<C0 '.6
<&=&6 41&6&0 *)*'.<&8 &1&3G3G3 9398912&= &)1&6G &6&7G3&
0&8G1)G
I25&6&846190 18G3 &1&07. .=1. "&36G1&6 &1&07.
>B0C<46 ?1C *=*,*3 I38.0&2 "&36GA&7G  *3 4'48
     
  
&U,d/!-d./%4+-0)

/89@@ B8IfbC8IbE;8B@ YW 9FPLKCL 9@I >XIYEKYP;Y D8 XPC<


LJK8CbBC8 FCLfKLILCDLfKL B@ FELEC8 @f P8G8E @EJ8EC8I LQLE Q8

D8E XE:< ><IW<B <E<IA@


M8ICbBC8IbEb ;YfYED<BK<E
M8Q><WD@fC<I;@ +EC8IbE ;YEP8;8E B@CFD<KI<C<I:< LQ8BK8 B8G8Cb
8C8E _><D@C<I@E;< BbQ>bE 9<P8Q bfbBK8 9<BC<;@BC<I@E@ ;YfYED<B

K<E;<
#XIB<DC@ J8Ib 9@I J8B8Cb M< BFPL B8?M<I<E>@ @I@ >XQC<I@ FC8E
YW 9FPLKCL >XIYEKY P8M8fW8 [/<I<;;YKC<I@E@Q@ M< fYG?<C<I@E@Q@
8ECbPFILD \ ;<;@ [.@Q< 8E:8B ?@W9@I Q8I8I M<ID<P<:<c@D@Q@
P<E@;<E K<BI8IC8P89@C@I@Q .@Q< +
K8P=b PbC;bQC8IbE ?8C<C<I@E;<
P8f8;bcbDbQb B8EbKC8P8E 9<C><C<I@ M<I;@B J8EbIbD '<E;@
>YE<f@E@Q@E 9@Q@D @W@E WFB JXEYB FC;LcLEL ;8 B8EbKC8;bB #<Q<

><EC<I@E@QJ< B8Kb :@J@DC<I;<E FCLfKLcLE;8E 9@Q@D @W@E WFB


P898E:bM<LP>LEJLQC8I .FEJLQ8B8;8I;8XPC<B8C8:8BC8I \
4<IPYQY K<DJ@C:@J@ 8PEb Q8D8E;8 9@C@D 98B8EbP;b M< FP
9@IC@c@PC< 4898E:b 48I8KbBC8IC8 >XIYfD<J@ @W@E J<W@CD@fK@ 8B8E
[D8 8IKbB 8E8 K@:8I<K PFCC8IbEbQbE YQ<I@E;< FC;LcLDLQL @K@I8=
<KK@E@Q \;@P<8EbDJ8KKb
[!M<K SYEBY P<E@ ;YEP8DbQ FC8E '@DDFEFJ?<B`K< GIFKFE@:
JbMb8C8EC8Ib9LCLE;L \
8B8E [ YEP8DbQ;8 \ ;<;@ [/@:8I<K PFCC8Ib YQ<I@E;<B@
P<IC<I 8JB<I@ 98BbD;8E ><IW<B ;<c<IC<I@E;<E B8K B8K =8QC8 XE<D
B8Q8EbIC8I + PYQ;<E ;< 8PEb f<P@ K<BI8IC8P8:8cbD #YM<E@D@Q@
B8Q8ED8B @W@E &YG@K<I@ E<;<E @JK<;@c@E@Q@ 9@Q< @P@:<
8WbBC8D8CbJbEbQ \
L JFIL P8 ;8 9<EQ<I@ 9@I JFIL JFILC;LcL Q8D8E ?<I J<=<I

@E;< FC;LcL >@9@ >XIYEKYEYE PYQYE;< JbBbEKbCb 9@I @=8;< 9<C@I;@


[#@QC@C@BWFBXE<DC@ !c<I(8D9<IAC<I \
8B8E [dfK< \ ;<;@ [L FEC8IC8 8I8EbQ;8 9@I J8M8f
FC;LcLE;8E BLfBLC8ED8DbQ8 E<;<E FCLPFI .@Q M< (8D9<IAC<I
;<;@c@E@QB@DJ<C<I \


#XIYEKY K<C8fC8 8KbC;b [[D8 9@Q 9L @P@C@c@E@Q< :XD<IKW<


B8IfbCbB M<I<:<c@Q .@Q J8;<:< J@JK<D@E@Q;<B@ @W ><Q<><EC<I@
JXDYI><C<fK@ID@fJ@E@Q +EC8IJ8 9@Q@ ?@W @C>@C<E;@ID@PFI @Q J@Q

@E &YG@K<I ;@P< K8EbDC8;bcbEbQ ><Q<><E@ @JK@PFILQ EC8;bcbD


B8;8IbPC8 J@Q @EJ8EC8IbE FI8;8 P8f8D8C8Ib FC8E8BJbQDbf $8KK8
&YG@K<I< @ED<E@Q 9@C< #<Q<><E@E 9YPYBCYcY \ $Ff>XIYPC<
>YC;Y [ J@Q@E@W@E=8QC8PDbf \
'8IfbJbE;8B@ P8I8KbcbE @EJ8EC8Ib 8f8cbC8I:8JbE8
BFELfD8JbE8 J@E@IC<E<E 98B8E JFcLB JFcLB [[E:8B
&YG@K<I`@E LP;LC8Ib 9@Q@D @W@E WFB LP>LE \ ;@P< :<M8G M<I;@
[[1<9@QP8BbE;8FEC8IbJXDYI><C<fK@ID<BE@P<K@E;<P@Q
[D8 9@Q LP;LC8I8 ;FBLE8:8B ;<c@C@Q +EC8I B<C@D<E@E K8D
8EC8DbPC8 ?<I Q8D8E J@Q@E FC8:8BC8I @Q J8;<:< &YG@K<I @E
B<E;@J@E@ @JK@PFILQ .@Q@E @W@E ?@W9@I P8I8Ib FCD8P8E F ><Q<><E@
LELE B8IfbCbcbEbPJ8 :XD<IKW< M<I<:<c@Q $<I?8C;< ;LILDLE
=8IBbE;8JbEbQ;bI dJK<IJ<B J@Q;<E @Q@E 8CD8;8E &YG@K<I`@ <C<
><W@I<9@C@I@Q 4@E< E< P8J8C 9@I 8EC8fD8Pb M< B8IfbCbcbEb X;<

D<P@ K<I:@? <;@PFILQ XPC<:< ><C<:<BK< K8IKbfD8C8I WbBD8Jb


XEC<ED@f FCLI #XI;YcYEYQ >@9@ J@Q@EC< ?<I f<P@ 8WbBW8
BFELfLPFILD \
8B8E@E8KC8 [[&YG@K<I@E<;<E@JK@PFIJLELQ\;<;@
[(8D9<IAC<I
[(8D9<IAC<IC<J8M8fK8DbJbEbQ
[[LG<B;< \
[SYEBY J8M8fK8PJ8EbQ P< &YG@K<I< 9@I KYI K8BM@P<C@ YJ BLI

8IJ8EbQ (8D9<IAC<I ;< ?8BCb FC8I8B 9LE8 BbQ89@C@IC<I /89@@ J@Q<


@Q@E M<I;@c@D@Q @W@E 9@Q< D@J@CC<D< P8GD8P8 B8CBbfbIC8I XPC<
9@I;LILD;8B8CD8B@JK<D<P@Q \
[<E ;< 9LEL @JK<D<D Q8K<E .@Q< JXQ M<I@PFILD
;YEP8P8 ?@W9@I Q8I8I ><CD<P<:<B $<I?8C;< &YG@K<I@E
B8IfbCbcbEb :XD<IKW< X;<P<:<c@D@Q@ 9@C@PFIJLELQ \ LID8;8E
9L EFBK8P8 ;XEYPFI;L P8I8KbB [$<I PbC J@Q< P<K<I@ B8;8I >YW

BLKLJL M<I<:<c@Q XPC<:< ;YEP8EbQbE 9@I PbCCbB >YW




><I<BJ@E@D@B8IfbC8EDbfFC8:8B \
8B8E [@C<I@;< >YW KYB<K@D@ 8IKKbcb Q8D8E 9L ;8 B8IfbC8E8

:8B \;@P<?8KbIC8KKb
[e@D;@B@I8B8DbE9<fB8KbE8B8;8I !M<K \
[,<BVCV .@Q< JXPC<;@c@D >@9@ ?YBYD<K@E PYBJ<B D<MB@;<B@
D<DLIC8IbE;8E 9@I@P@D M< J@Q@EC< 8EC8fD8DbQ @W@E 98E8 ?8KbIb
J8PbCbI P<KB@C<I M<I@C;@ D8 >Y:YD JFEJLQ ;<c@C <E f8?J<E
J@Q< >YM<E@PFILD D8 &YG@K<I@ E<;<E @JK<;@c@E@Q@ B<J@EC@BC< 8E

C8D8;bBW8 f8IKC8IbEbQb B89LC <;<D<D WbBC8D8 8BC8 P8BbE M<


@E8E;bIb:b FCLIJ8 9<CB@ ?YBYD<K@D@Q@ @BE8 <;<9@C@I@D #<C><C<C@D
9XPC< 9@I 8WbBC8D8 FCD8;8E 9@I 8EC8fD8 P8G8IJ8D 9<E@ >XI<

M@D;<E 8CbIC8I M< ;YEP8 ;8 8EC8fD8EbE f8IKC8IbEb P<I@E< ><

K@ID<P@ I<;;<;<I + Q8D8E ;<;@c@E@Q >@9@ &YG@K<I@ QFIC8 8CbIJbEbQ


8D8 8PEb Q8D8E;8 P8J8C FCD8P8E 9@I ;LILD8 ;Yf<IJ@E@Q Q
XE:<;<98E89LEL@JK<D<;@c@E@Q@JXPC<;@E@Q \
48I8KbB J89bIJbQ:8 ;@C@E@ f8BC8KKb [L XE<DJ@Q K8IKbfD8Pb
JFEJLQ8 B8;8I JYI;YI<D<D (8D9<IAC<I \ LI8BC8;b M< JFEI8
<BC<;@ [LELE (8D9<IAC<I K8I8=bE;8E 9@Q@ ><:@BK@ID<B @W@E GC8E

C8EDbf 9@I ?@C< FCD8;bcbE8 f<I<=@E@Q YQ<I@E< P<D@E <;<I


D@J@E@Q \
8B8E [4<D@E<;<I@D \;<;@

@C@D 98B8Eb J8CFE;8E WbB8IB<E 8CEbE;8B@ K<IC<I@ J@C@PFI;L


8D8 FE P8f ><EWC<fD@f >@9@P;@ 48M8fW8 [!CW@P< 98fB8EbE I<

JD@ FE8PbEb 8CbI 8CD8Q &YG@K<I`@E FEC8IbE FC8:8cbEb JXPC<;@D \ ;@

P< 8WbBC8;b [8fB8EbE @K@I8Q <;<:<c@E@ J8EDbPFILD /<DJ@C:@C<I


)<:C@J@E@E ;< XPC< /8EIbD 9@I ;YfYEYE 98PC8I $@W9@I Q8D8E
BLCC8E8D8P8:8cbDbQ 9@I ><Q<><E< B8IfbCbB 9<;8M8 >YW <C;<
<;<:<c@Q
.8MLED8 98B8Eb ;LILD;8E ?FfC8ED8;bcb @W@E X=B<PC< DFI

8ID8P8 98fC8DbfKb [D8 9@Q &YG@K<I@ @JK<D<C<I@E< 8E:8B 9@I


)@QQ8I<KK
(8D9<IA J8M8fbEbE PFC 8W89@C<:<c@E< B8I8I M<ID@fK@B
JB<I@ GFK8EJ@P<CC<I@E@ 9@Q@DB@PC< BbP8JC8;bB L ;LILD;8


KYDYPC<K8I8=JbQB8CD8DbQ><I<B@PFI \\
@C@D 98B8Eb [I b8 J8M8f PFB B <=<E;@D ;<;@ [!CW@
&YG@K<I@ E<;<E @JK<;@BC<I@E@E 98fB8 9@I 8WbBC8D8JbEb P8GKb L F
B8;8I D8EKbBCb M< @E8E;bIb:bP;b B@ E<;<E@ ?<D<E B89LC <KK@D
8fB8EbE ;8 9<E@D >@9@ ;YfYE<:<c@E@ J8EbPFILD LILDL 8E

C8;bcbEbQ Q8D8E J@QC<I ;< XPC< $8KK8 9LI8;8 P898E:bC8IbE P<E@


&YG@K<IC<@C>@C@GC8EC8IbM8I #<Q<><EP8BbE;89L?8C@8C8:8B
@c<IC<I@ 98cbI8I8B P<IC<I@E;<E =bIC8;bC8I .8MLED8 98B8Eb
[4<E@9@I&YG@K<ID@ ;@P<@EC<;@
@C@D 8B8Eb [L <JB@J@E;<E G<B =8IBCb ;<c@C 98PC8I ;<;@
[dfK< <JB@QC<I LEC8I 9@Q@D >@9@ B8Kb :@J@DC<I J8PbC8:8B P8I8KbB

C8IbE8EC8P89@C<:<BC<I@9@W@D;<?8QbIC8EDbf
8B8E GC8EC8Ib D8J8P8 P8P;b !JB@QC<I;<E 9@I@E;< F K8Eb;bB
B8CbE W@Q>@C@ ><Q<><E M8I;b .8Ib LWLB P<f@C M< 8WbB B8?M<I<E>@
eLI8;89LI8;8 BbMIbDCb 9<P8Q W@Q>@C<I IB8 GC8E;8 9<E<BC@ B8

;@=<P< 9<EQ<P<E LQ8P >XIYCYPFI;L E:8B B8CbE W@Q>@C<I@E YQ<I

@E;< =FE >@9@ B8;@=<P< 9<EQ<P<E J@P8? C<B<C<I M8I;b M< >8I@G
f<B@CC<IFCLfKLI8:8B9@W@D;<P<IC<fK@I@CD@fC<I;@
@C@D 98B8Eb [L ><Q<><E@E >YE<f< 98B8E K8I8=b ;<;@
['8I8ECbB P8Eb @J< fL <JB@Q;< >XIYCYPFI \ L I<J@D;< &YG@K<I
B8I8ECbcb J8I8E @E:< 9@I ?@C8C< 9<EQ@PFI;L + B8GB8I8 P<I;< ;<
P@E< 9<EQ<I 9@W@D;< P<IC<fK@I@CD@f @E:< W@Q>@C<I M8I;b D8 9LEC8I
KLILE:LI<EBK<P;@C<IM<=FJ=FICLPDLf>@9@bfbC;bPFIC8I;b 
@C@D 98B8Eb [eL @f8I<KC<I J8;<:< FGK@B 9@I =<EFD<E \ ;@P<
8WbBC8;b [8E8 FEC8IbE ><Q<><EC< 9@IC@BK< ;XED<P<:<BC<I@ 8K

DFJ=<I;<B@P<IC<I@E;<J89@KB8C8:8BC8IbJXPC<E;@ \
/@:8I<K98B8EbJFI;L [D8E<;@I9L\
@C@D 98B8Eb [EC8P8:8cbEbQ 9@Q@D >YE<f J@JK<D@D@Q 8IKbB
FEC8IbE <E XE<DC@ K@:8I@ PFCC8IbE;8E 9@I@E@E YQ<I@E;< @I K<B
>YE;< ><D@C<I@ J@JK<D@E 9@IB8W PYQ D@CPFE B@CFD<KI< P8BbEbE;8E
><W@PFIC8I #<D@C<I@E J8PbJb >YE;< P<;@P@ 9LCLPFI PIb:8 ?<I
><D@ FI8;8E ><W<IB<E XE<DC@ ><Q<><EC<I@ K<C<JBFGC8IC8 @E:<C@P

FI /LI@JK@B 9@I D<I8BC8 P8E@ $<I 9FP;8 B8Kb ><Q<><E FEC8I @W@E



9@I<I?8I@B8 \
[YKYE9LEC8IbEfL@f8I<KC<IC<E<@C>@J@M8I\
[L FEC8IbE 9@I KYI P8QbJb + @f8I<KC<I@ fXPC< W<M@I<9@C@I@Q
_.8cCbBM<CfbCKbCb%JbdW@E)@QQ8I<KK!I>FE$8GC8IbEb'LCC8EbE \
.8MLED8 98B8Eb G8KC8;b [48E@ &YG@K<I`@ 9@I I<BC8D K89<C8Jb
>@9@D@BLCC8E8:8BC8I\
[!M<K XPC< (8D9<IA`C<I@E ;< I8B@G 9@I <I>FE K89C<K@ YI<KK@BC<I@
8EC8fbCbPFI )@QQ8I<KK`C<I 9L PYQ;<E &YG@K<I`< KYDYPC< P8J8C
9@W@D;< J8?@G FCD8Pb WFB @JK<;@C<I (8D9<IA`C<I@E FEC8Ib ;8M8
<KD<C<I@E;<E BFIBLPFIC8I;b JCbE;8 )@QQ8I<KK`C<I@E I<BC8D @fC<I

@E;<G<BP<E@FC;LBC8Ib8EC8fbCbPFI \
dW@fC<I@98B8Eb [*<;<E9XPC<JXPCYPFIJLELQ\;@P<JFI;L
[[*<;<E FC8:8B @c<I ><Q<><EC<I BFELJLE;8 9@I ;@Q@ FG

J@PFE @JK<D<P@ LELKKLC8I &YG@K<I J8;<:< FEC8IbE YIYEYEY ;<c@C


8PEb Q8D8E;8 9@Q@D J@JK<D@D@Q@E I<BC8DbEb ;8 P8G8:8B -8B@G
(8D9<IAC<I X=B<PC< )@QQ8I<KK`C<I@E &YG@K<I YQ<I@E;< ?8BC8Ib FCLG
FCD8;bcbEb 8EC8D8P8 ><C;@BC<I@ Q8D8E 9@Q ;< FEC8I8 .8KYIE`Y
J8K8:8cbQ $<D ;< ?8CB8C8IbPC8 9@IC@BK< (8D9<IAC<I< ?8CB8C8IbE
.8KYIE`Y >XIYEKY 98BbDbE;8E WFB ;8?8 YJKYE 9@I ?8C< JFB

KLcLELBFC8PCbBC88EC8K89@C@I@Q \
)8C@P< 98B8Eb ?<D<E >YCYDJ<;@ [[1< FELE ;8?8 G8?8Cb
FC;LcLELJXPC<P<:<c@Q \
I;bE;8E98B8EC8IbE?<GJ@9@I;<E9@I<WFBB<P@=C<E;@C<I
!* d*.*
YW-F9FK48J8Jb
 @I IF9FK 9@I @EJ8E8 Q8I8I M<I<D<Q 48 ;8 ?8I<B<KJ@Q
B8C8I8B9@I@EJ8EbEQ8I8I>XID<J@E<E<;<EFC8D8Q
 @I IF9FK @EJ8EC8IbE M<I;@BC<I@ <D@IC<I< LPD8B QFILE;8;bI

E:8B 9L KYI <D@IC<I @I@E:@ 48J8PC8 W<C@fK@c@ Q8D8E ;LILD


;<c@f@I 
 @I IF9FK @I@E:@ M< dB@E:@ 48J8C8IC8 W<C@fD<;@c@ JYI<:<

M8ICbcbEbBFILD8BQFILE;8;bI


E;I<N )8IK@E [/<f<BBYI <;<I@D \ ;@P<I<B B<E;@E< >XJK<I@

C<E P<I< FKLI;L .FE W8I<P< 98fMLID8B QFILE;8 B8C8E 9@I@E< ?@W
9<EQ<D@PFI;L D8><IW<B9LP;L
JCbE;8 FEL 9@I@C<I@E< 9<EQ<KD<B P8 ;8 9<EQ<KD<D<B
DYDBYE ;<c@C;@ SYEBY ;YQ>YE PYQY @=8;<J@Q FCD8BC8 9@IC@BK<
>XQC<I@E;< B<;<I FC;LcL =8IB<;@C<9@C@PFI;L dE:< K<CC@ BLDI8C
J8WC8Ib ;YD;YQ;Y 4YQYE;<PJ< ?@W KYP PFBKL 'bCbcb K8D 8E

C8DbPC8 <JB@ K8IQ;b TE<DC@ BbJbDC8I BbIDbQbDJb


DFI B8;@=<P<
9<EQ<I9@IBLD8fK8EP8GbCDbfKb
E;I<NELE B8IfbJbE;8B@ P8Qb D8J8JbEbE 98fbE;8 9@I FG<I

8KXI FKLILPFI;L )8J8;8B@ C<M?8;8 FELE B@DC@c@E@ 8WbBC8P8E ;@Q

@PC< ?8I= M< J8Pb M8I;b D8 E;I<N FEC8IC8 @C>@C<ED<;@ 9@C<
'8IfbJbE;8B@E@ [ FBKFI \;@P<W8cbID8BP<K<IC@FC8:8BKb
E;I<N [D<C@P8K E< Q8D8E P8GbC89@C@I ;FBKFI\ ;@P<
JFI;L
+G<I8KXI LJLC:8 [L 8D<C@P8KbE B@D< P8 ;8 E8JbC
P8GbC8:8cbEb 8EC8;bcbD;8E G<B <D@E ;<c@C@D <=<E;@D \ ;<;@
.<J@E;< 9@I IF9FK 9@I @EJ8EC8 BFELfLIB<E 9<C@I<E F J8P>b M8I;b
4YQYE;<PJ< J8P>bPC8 B8IbfbB 9@I @E8K @=8;<J@ FC;LcL ;8 JXPC<E<

9@C@I;@ /89@@ FELE >@9@ G8JC8ED8Q W<C@BK<E P8GbC8I8B ?8=@=W<


9IFEQC8fKbIbCDbf 9@I IF9FKLE PYQYE;< 9XPC< 9@I @=8;<


9<C@I<9@CJ<P;@ 48;8?<I?8E>@9@I@=8;<
E;I<N )8IK@E IF9FKLE J8c <C@E@ @E:<C<;@ )8J8EbE YQ<I@E;<
JFE ;<I<:<;< ?8I<B<KJ@Q ;LI8E _B<J@:@ <C@E@ -F9FKLE D8;<E@
G8ID8BC8Ib LQLE;L <:<I@BC@P;@ M< B8M@JC<I FCLfKLI8:8B 9@W@D;<
P8GbCDbfKb SFB Q8I@= M< 8D<C@P8K8 LP>LE 9@I <C;@ 9L dEJ8E E<f

K<I@E 9L G8ID8BC8IbE 8I8JbE8 P<IC<f<I<B <CC< ><W@:@ FC8I8B 9YKYE

C<fK@c@E@ ?8P8C <;<9@C@PFI;L -F9FK W8CbfbIB<E ?@W ;LI8BJ8D8P8

:8B 9<:<I@BJ@QC<fD<P<:<B K@KI<D<P<:<B M< ?8K8 P8GD8P8:8BKb


/89@@ 9LELE E<;<E@ LQD8EC8fKbID8P;b @EJ8ECbB 9L LQD8E

C8fKbID8Pb XPC<J@E< @JK<D@fK@ B@ 8IKbB 98cbDJbQ 9<P@EC@ IF9FK G<B


8Q P8GbCbPFI;L /89@@ 9@I FG<I8KXIYE 9L KYI;<E FCD8Jb f8IKKb 1<
9L IF9FK ;8 9<PE@ FCD8JbE8 I8cD<E B8G8J@K< 98BbDbE;8E
BbJbKCbP;b + PYQ;<E E;I<NPL K8EbD8Dbf ?8KK8 9<CB@ ;< FE;8E
JXQ<;@C;@cE@?@W;LPD8DbfKb
E;I<N [$@W @EJ8E FCD8Pb K<I:@? <;<:<c@E@Q@ ;YfYE;YEYQ
DY\;@P<JFI;L
+G<I8KXI J8EB@ 9L JFIL BbJbKCb 9<PE@E;<B@ GFQ@KIFE@B PFCC8IbE
?@W9@I@E< LPDLPFIDLf >@9@ 9@I 8E ;LI8BC8;b [D8 9<E 9@I IF

9FKLD <=<E;@D \
[@I@EJ8EFCD8B;8?8@P@;<c@CD@\
[ 8?8 @P@ 9@I FG<I8KXI FCD8B ;8?8 @P@ FCLI <=<E;@D @I @EJ8E
FCJ8P;bD 9LE8 <I@f<D<Q;@D LEL 8E:8B ;8?8 ><C@fK@I@CD@f 9@I
IF9FK FCJ8P;bD 98f8IbI;bD 8?8 ><C@fK@I@CD@f 9@I IF9FK FCD8B
?FfLD8>@;<I;@ \
[.8E8 <D@IC<I M<ID<D J<E@ BbQ;bIDbPFI DL .8;<:< 9@I
JXQYDC< B8CBD8E8 FKLID8E8 J8c8 P8 ;8 JFC8 >@KD<E< E<;<E
FCD8B\
[.@Q@ D<DELE <KD<B 9<E@ ;< D<DELE <;<I <=<E;@D 1<I

;@c@E@Q <D@I J@Q P8 ;8 98fB8 9@I @EJ8EC8 @C>@C@ FC8I8B W8CbfD8Db


<E><CC<IJ< F Q8D8E J@Q< @K88K <KD<D dEJ8EC8IbE >YM<E@PC< @C>@C@
FC8E @I@E:@ 48J8 @K88K@ 9<C@IC<P<E dB@E:@ 48J8;8E ;8?8 XE<DC@
J8PbCbI 4FBJ8 @K88K <KD<B 98E8 Q<MB M<I@I D8 9L 8D<C@P8Kb
B@D<P8G8:8cbD\


E;I<N [8E8 \;<;@


[D8 9L FC8E8BJbQ D<C@P8KbE J@Q< Q8I8I M<I<:<c@ WFB
B<J@E \
E;I<NJ8B@EJ8B@E [TE<DC@;<c@C  \;@P<:<M8GM<I;@
+G<I8KXI [.@Q<Q8I8IM<ID<D<C@P@D \;<;@
E;I<N 98fbEb J8CC8;b [@I @EJ8E8 Q8I8I M<ID<D<C@J@E@Q
D89<E9@IIF9FKLD \


E;I<N @CB P8GbC;bcb JbI8;8 9@I IF9FK8 ;8?8 WFB 9<EQ@PFI;L
+ Q8D8E8 B8;8I YI<K@CD@f FC8E IF9FKC8I;8E =8IBJbQ;b dP@ GC8E

C8Dbf GI8K@B9@ID8B@E<
+ELE >XKYI;YBC<I@ <M;< ;< @P@ W8CbfDbfKb E;I<N + >YEC<I;<
<MC<I;<M<?8KK8><Q<><E;<=8QC8IF9FKPFBKL
E;I<N`ELE P8EbE;8 W8CbfKbcb 8@C< ;XIK B@f@;<E FCLfLPFI;L
<P ?8EbD BYWYB ?8EbD M< D@E@D@E@ ?8EbD -F9FK FEC8IbE 8;

C8IbEb 9@C@PFIJ8 ;8 K89@@ 9L @J@DC<I@ ?@W9@I Q8D8E BLCC8EDbPFI;L


<P #<I8C;)8IK@E`;@
-F9FKLE J<I@ ELD8I8Jb @J< * -P;@ I8;8E WFB LQLE Q8D8E
><WK@c@ @W@E J8PbC8Ib LELKDLfKL E;I<N D8 @JK<IJ< ?<D<E
?8KbIC8P89@C@I;@ SYEBY 9@I f<P@ LELKD8Jb @DBVEJbQ;b .8;<:<
?8KbIC8D8B@JK<D@PFI;L
+EL @CB B<Q E;I<N ;@P< D@E@D@E@ ?8EbD W8cbIDbfKb + ?8I

=C<I@BLCC8E8D8;bcb@W@E  @c<IC<I@;<9LBFEL;8FEL@QC<D@fC<I;@
)@E@D@E@ ?8EbD ;FBJ8EbE8 B8;8I P8f8Dbf XC<C@ 8IKbB WFB
FCDLfKL E;I<N 9@I B<I<J@E;< FEL [$8EbD<=<E;@ \ ;@P<
W8cbID8Pb ;<E<D@f 8D8 F I8Qb FCD8DbfKb .FE E<=<J@E< B8;8I
D@E@D@E@?8EbDFC8I8BB8CDbfKb
E;I<N 9@I Lf8B >@9@ W8Cbf8:8B 8PIb:8 9@I 9<P M< ?8EbD8
XQ<C ?@QD<KBVICbB P8G8:8B 9@W@D;< P8GbCDbfKb JCbE;8 FEL ;<E

@PFIC8I;b !E;YJKI@ 8C8EC8IbE;8 ;<E<D< =89I@B8C8IbE;8 M< LQ8P


@JK8JPFEC8IbE;8 BLCC8EbC8E IF9FKC8I ;bfbE;8 9YKYE D8B@E<


8;8DC8I@W@E8PEbf<PJXPC<E<9@C@I;@
)8IK@E`C<I IF9FKLE Q<MB@E@ WbB8IbPFIC8I;b E;I<N BYWYB
?8EbD M< D@E@D@E@ ?8EbD FELEC8 FPE8D8B @JK<;@BC<I@ @W@E WFcL
Q8D8E@fC<I@E@P8G8DbPFI;L
LELE E8JbC J8cC8E8:8cbEb XE:< D@E@D@E@ ?8EbD ;YfYEDYf
[.8E8 9@Q@DC< FPE8D8Eb <DI<;@PFILQ .<E ;< <D@IC<I@D@Q<
LPD8CbJbE \;<D@fK@
E;I<N [SFB YQ>YEYD D@E@D@E@ ?8EbD \ ;<D@fK@ [D8
9<P 98E8 ;8?8 XE:< 9@I <D@I M<I;@ $<I?8C;< FE8 XE:<C@B K8EbE

D8Jb><I<B@I \
D8 BYWYB BbQ 8PEb =@B@I;< ;<c@C;@ [898D J8E8 K<D@QC@B
@fC<I@PC< @C>@C<E<9@C<:<c@E@ JXPC<;@ L 9@I <D@I J8PbCD8Q D8
9<EJ8E8  \
E;I<N D@E@D@E@ ?8EbD @W@E K8?K8;8E FPD8 9@I K8Bb P8GKb
SYEBY BbQ XPC< <DI<KD@fK@ )@E@D@E@ ?8EbD8 ;FcLD>YEYE;<
=@C;@f@E< 9<EQ<P<E GC8JK@BK<E P8GbCDbf YQ<I@ JYJCY 9@I D8;8CPFE
M<I@CD@fK@ D8 BYWYB BbQ FEL 9<c<ED<D@fK@ )@E@D@E@ ?8EbD;8
BYWYB9@IK8?K8G8IW8JbM8I;bJ8;<:< +ELM<9@IDLK=8B9bW8cbEb
E;I<N`P8M<I;@
-F9FK D8;8CPFEL W89L:8B ?8QbIC8DbfKb )@E@D@E@ ?8EbD ;8
[@fK< 9L >YQ<C E;I<N \ ;<;@ [)8;8CPFEL 9898D8
>XJK<I<:<c@D \\
<P XE:< JXPC<E<EC<I< @E8ED8;b [L D8;8CPFEL E<I<;<E
9LC;LE )8E;P\ )@E@D@E@ ?8EbDb )8E;P ;@P< W8cbIbPFI;L D8
BYWYB BbQ 9898JbEb ><IW<c@ JXPC<;@c@E< @E8E;bI;bcb Q8D8E 8;8D
IF9FK8;XE;Y [LELJ<ED@P8GKbE E;I<N\
[!M<P 9<P \
[ <J<E;<J<E@ED@\
[!M<K 9<P \
[ <J<E@E<I<;<EBFGP8<KK@E\
[L><FD<KI@B9@If<B@C 9<P /8?K8EbE;8D8IbE8LPLPFI
<P <IK<J@ >YE IF9FK8 9@I K8?K8 G8IW8Jb ><K@I;@ L G8IW8
;8?8 9YPYBKY ;8D K8?K8PC8 <C<BKI@BC@ K@KI<f@D 9bW8cbEb


IF9FK8 M<I<I<B [LE;8E 9@I f<P P8G E;I<N ;<;@ [@J

K<;@c@E?<I?8E>@9@If<P@
-F9FK 9L <DI@ P<I@E< ><K@I@IB<E 9<P ;< FEL J<PI<KK@ .FEI8
E;I<N`ELE FP;LcL K8?K8 G8IW8JbE8 LQLE 9@I JYI< 98BKb
IKbB F >YE;<E JFEI8 IF9FKLE P<D<B J<IM@J@ P8GD8JbE;8E
M8Q><W@G <fP8 P8GbDbPC8 @C>@C@ B@K8GC8I FBLD8Jb <DI<;@C;@ -F

9FK;FC8GC8IM<D8J8C8IP8GD8PbXcI<E;@
<P [LEC8If8fbC8:8B<J<IC<I E;I<N \;<;@
-F9FK [+EC8Ib P8GD8BK8E Q<MB 8CbPFILD 9<P \ ;@P<
:<M8GM<I;@
[5<MBD@8CbPFIJLE\
[L @f >Y:YE 9<PE@D;<B@ ;<MI<C<I;<E ;8?8 BFC8PCbBC8 8B

D8JbEb J8cCbPFI .@Q@E _Q<MB` JXQ:YcYEY BLCC8E;bcbEbQb ;LP

;LD L 9<E@D ;LP>LC8IbD8 ;8 LPLPFI +EC8Ib P8GD8B 98E8


Q<MBM<I@PFI 9<P


#<I8C; )8IK@E E;I<N`PL @IC<f@B <MC<KC<I -F9FK M< )8B

@E< ;8DC8I e@IB<K@E@E 9XC>< DY;YICYcYE< >XKYI;Y XC><


)<:C@J@ YP<J@ FC;LcL @W@E 98fIF9F
GJ@BFCFA@ LQD8EbEb
BFC8PCbBC8 >XI<9@C;@ 58K<E XC>< )<:C@J@ YP<J@ FC;LcL @W@E IF

9FK8C89@CD@fK@ +>YEC<I;<D8B@E<8;8DC8IWFB8Q;b
E;I<N F JbI8;8 E<C<I FC;LcLEL 8EC8P8D8;b D8 ;8?8
JFEI8B@ PbCC8I;8 9@C>@J@ @P@:< 8IKDbf FC;LcL @W@E F @CB J8?E<P@
;YfYE;YcYQ8D8E;LILDL8EC8P89@C@PFI;L 
-F9F
GJ@BFCF> )<IKFE )8EJBP B<E;@J@E< 8EC8KbC8EC8Ib ;@E

C<IB<E B8fC8Ib >@K>@;< W8KbCbPFI;L @IB8W ;<=8 G8ID8BC8IbEb


D8J8P8 MLID8D8B @W@E B<E;@E@ QFI KLKKL 4YQ ?8KC8Ib ><I>@E 8CEb
W@Q>@C@ 9@I 8;8D;b #XIYE;YcYE;<E ;8?8 ><EWD@f >@9@ 9@I @QC<E

@DLP8E;bIbPFI;L@EJ8E;8
.FELE;8 [-F9FK@B B<J@E 9@I J8E8K ;<c@C 8P )8IK@E \ ;<;@
[LEL J@Q< 9YKYE 8PIbEKbC8IbPC8 8EC8K8D8D E:8B GFQ@KIFE@B


PFCC8IbE ?<J8GC8ED8JbPC8 @C>@C@ D8K<D8K@B WFB B8ID8fbB +


E<;<EC< ;< WXQYDC<I B<J@E ;<c@C @Q P8BC8fbB JFELWC8I <C;<
<;<9@C@PFILQ /89@@ ?<I f<P UW 48J8P8 >XI< YI<K@C@PFI +EC8IbE
K<IJ@E@E FCD8Jb ;8 @DB8EJbQ @Q K89@@ IF9FKLELQLE P<I@E< 9@I
P<E@J@E@M<I<:<c@Q
<P [*< DYE8J<9<K ;@P<I<B LQD8Eb JLJKLI;L [-F9FKLE
?@W9@I 8IbQ8Jb PFB B@ '<E;@E< M<I@C<E >XI<MC<I@ BLJLIJLQ:8 P<I

@E< ><K@I@PFI 58K<E XE<DC@ FC8E ;8 fL F K8?K8C8Ib FP8I8B f8?8E<


f<PC<I P8GD8Jb $@W9@I@ 9@I9@I@E< 9<EQ<D@PFI -F9FK J8E8K <J

<IC<I@P8I8KbPFI
)8EJBP f8f8C8;b [ SFB >8I@G /89@@ JFE Q8D8EC8I;8
GFQ@KIFE@B B8E8CC8Ib ><E<CC<fK@ID<P< W8CbfbPFILQ 8D8 #<IW<B

K<EP8I8Kb:bCbBC8@C>@C@f<PC<ID@FEC8I
['<E;@E@Q ;< >XIYE <P K8?K8;8E FPLCDLf L=8B BYWYB 9@I
BYI<P@ LQ8KKb LELE YQ<I@E;< G8IBK8 FPE8P8E BYWYB <IB<B M<
BbQ WF:LBC8I M8I;b 'FC8PCbBC8 >XIYC<D<P<:<B B8;8I L=8BKbC8I
8D8 FI8EC8Ib BLJLIJLQ;L M< =@>YIC<I K8?K8EbE ;8D8IbE8 B8IbfbP

FI;L 58K<E F ;8D8I ;8 J8EB@ JFEI8;8E FPLCDLf >@9@


;LILPFI;L
)8EJBP [LEL F DL P8GKb\ ;@P< 98cbI;b 8fbEb J8CC8P8I8B
BYI<P@ ><I@ M<I;@ [.@Q< G@P8E>F MLIDLf K8D 9@I f8EJ @f@
,FQ@KIFE@BB8E8CC8I;89@If<PC<IFCD8Cb ^
[PEbIF9FKK8EK<BI8IP8G89@C@ID@J@E@Q \
[,<B J8EDbPFILD e@D;@P< B8;8I 9XPC< 9@I f<P 9@Q<
9@C;@I@CD<;@ ^
[@P@.8;<:<E;I<N`ELE9XPC<FCD8Jb9<E@?@WYQDYPFI \
)8EJBP [$<I?8C;< f@IB<K IF9FKLELQL @E:<C<D<B @W@E ><I@
@JK<P<:<BK@I ^;<;@
<P 9@I;<E9@I< J<IKC<fK@ [dDBVEb PFB LEL LELKKLE \
E;I<NP8;XE;Y [IKbB<M<>@;<C@D
E;I<N [*8JbC@JK<IJ<E@Q 9<P ;<;@




'YWYB ?8EbDbE <IB<B 8IB8;8fC8Ib FC;LcL @W@E <M;< =8QC8


FKLIDLPFI 8IKbB E;I<NELE L=BLEL D@E@D@E@ ?8EbD ;FC;LILP

FI;L D8 F ;8 <JB@J@ >@9@ D@E@:@B ;<c@C;@ 'bQ E;I<NELE


B<E;@J@ @W@E @CB B<Q K8?K8;8E FP;LcL D8;8CPFEL ?@W LELK

D8DbfKb +EL?<IQ8D8E9@IQ@E:@IC<9FPELE8K8BbPFI;L
'bQ 9898JbE8 IF9FKLE <J<IC<I@E@ FE8 9LE8 ;8cbKKbcb @W@E @K@I8Q
<KK@ [$8P;@ 9898 +EC8I;8E @JK<P<E M8IJ8 G8I8JbEb X;<J@E
LE8;<c<I
<P [.<E8W>XQCY;<c@CJ@E;@I )8E;P ;<;@
[,8I8Pb 9@Q@D @W@E @JK<D@PFILD 9898 .8E8KWb @W@E
@JK@PFILD \
E;I<N 9L JXQ:YcY F Q8D8E8 B8;8I ?@W ;LPD8DbfKb 48CEbQ
B8CbE:8 ?<D<E >@;@G JXQCYc< 98BKb .FEI8 P@E< 9<PC< JFB8c8
WbBKbC8I LJ<=<IFELE8MLB8KbE8>@KK@C<I
<P 8MLB8K8 [*<;@PFIJLE &F?E\;@P<JFI;L
MLB8KbE 8;b &F?E "<@E>FC;;L <D9<P8Q J8WCb M<
>X9<BC@P;@ #XQC<I@E;<B@ C<EJC<I@E B<E8Ib G8IC8B P<f@C< 9FP8E

DbfKb MLB8K 9<P@E FE8 M<I;@c@ BYWYB C<M?8P8 98BKb [SFB


>YQ<C D8 9<E ?89<I@ ;LP;LD L FPD8Pb P8EbE;8 ><K@I;@c@E
IF9FKP8GDbf
[!M<K ?<GJ@E@E;I<NP8GbPFI TPC<;<c@CD@ E;I<N\
-F9FK [!M<K 9<P ;<;@
<PXcI<ED<B@JK<;@ [XPC<9@If<P<B8WG8I8M<I@IJ@E
[@C<D@PFILD <E 9XPC< f<PC<I@E BFC<BJ@PFELEL
P8GDbPFILD \
[.8E8 F BYWY:YB f<P @W@E @B@ PYQ <CC@ ;FC8I K<BC@= <KK@BC<I@E@
JXPC<IJ<D 98E8 @E8EbI DbJbE E;I<N`ELE P8GKbcb J8E;8CP<C<I
9<f PYQ<I ;FC8I8 J8KbC;b E;I<NELE <J<IC<I@E@E B8Q8E;bI;bcb @B@
9@E;FC8I98EB8;8 \
[/8EIbD-F9FKJ<E@Q<E>@E<;<:<B #<I8C;\
<P [48Ib Q<E>@E \ ;@P< ;YQ<CKK@ [,8I8EbE P8IbJb E;I<N
)8I K@E8;bE88WbC8E?<J898P8KbIbC;b \
[-F9FKLE8;bE8Db\


[!M<K XPC< 1< 9<E 9LELE P8J8C FCLG FCD8;bcbEb XcI<ED<B


@JK@PFILD \
[48J8C FCLG FCD8;bcbEb Db\ "<@E>FC; 8IB8JbE8 P8JC8EbIB<E
@JB<DC<J@ >b:bI;8;b [D8 9L BFEL;8 ?@W9@I <DJ8C PFB #<I8C;
-F9FK><I<BC@BVcbKC8IbE8JbC@DQ8C8;b \
[E;I<N @DQ8JbEb 8K89@C@PFI <E ;< @DQ8JbEb 98EB8P8 M<I

;@D 8D8 FEL 98EB8P8 >XKYID<;@D 48GbCD8Jb ><I<B<E 98fB8


9@If<PM8IDb\
[$bD \ "<@E>FC;` LE 98BbfC8Ib 9@I 8E J89@KC<fK@BK<E JFEI8
[!? \ ;<;@ [YKYE G8I8 @fC<I@E@ FELE 8;bE8 ?8CC<KD<B @W@E 9@I
>ILG FCLfKLI89@C@I@Q XPC<:< IF9FKC8 ;YfD8E ;YEP8 8I8JbE;8 9@I
P8CbKbD K898B8Jb FCLfLI LE;8E 98fB8 J8E8 fLEL XE<I<:<c@D
IKbB ?@W9@I f<P P8GD8 eL 8E8 B8;8I J<E@ <E><CC<P<E FCD8;b
@I@@K@I8Q<;<IJ<FE8;8M88WD8JbEbJXPC< \
[ 8M88WbCbIJ8E;I<N`PLJ8MLELIDLJLE\
[/89@@ 9@IY:I<KB8IfbCbcb \
[*<B8;8I\
"<@E>FC; [eXPC< 9@I f<P B8IfbCbcb \ ;@P<I<B K8?K8 C<M?8Pb
@f8I<K<E@
<P [LLP>LE \;<;@
MLB8K >YC<I<B IF9FK8 ;XE;Y [E;I<N G8I8E FC;LcL @W@E
D<DELEDLJLE\
[!M<K <=<E;@D \
[+G8I8PC8E<P8GD8Pb;YfYEYPFIJLE\
[8Qb f<PC<I@E D8JI8=bEb X;<D<P@ <=<E;@D 4FBJ8 F G8I8C8Ib
9<P M<ID<B QFILE;8 B8C8:8B XPC<:< FEL D8JI8=K8E
BLIK8I8:8cbD \
#<IW<BK<E ;< G8I8 ?8I:8ED8Jb ><I<B<E Q8D8EC8I FC;L +E

8IbD G8?8CbP;b -<M@QPFE ;8?8 ;8 G8?8Cb 4bCC8I ><W<IB<E P<E@


DF;<C IF9FKC8I YI<K@C;@ <P ;< E;I<N`ELE ?<I P<E@C@BK<E P8I8I

C8ED8JbEb J8cC8;b .FELE;8 IF9FK D8;<E 9@I 8;8D FC8I8B ><I

W<BK<E DYB<DD<C 9@I ?8C 8C;b YKYE D8JI8=C8Ib E;I<N


X;YPFI;L
 

LBFEL;8XQ<CC@BC<bJI8I<;@PFI;LIF9FK
.8;<:< FE8IbD P8 ;8 98BbD JbI8JbE;8 GFQ@KIFE@B PFCC8I8 ;FB

LELCDLPFI;L <P9LELbJI8IC8K<D9@?<KD@fK@
[4<E@ IF9FKC8I J<E@E B8;8I @P@ ;<c@CC<I E;I<N \ ;@PFI;L
[$8KK8 P<E@ D8B@E< 8;8DC8IbE ?@W9@I ;<c<I@ PFB e@IB<K
GFQ@KIFE@B PFCC8Ib ;8?8 B<J@EC<fK@ID<P@ 98f8I;b IKbB K8?D@E< P<I
PFB $<I f<P P<IC@ P<I@E< FKLILPFI 4<E@ IF9FKC8I ;<c@fD@PFIC8I
*< @W@E YI<K@CD@fC<IJ< FEL P8GbPFIC8I S@Q@C<E W@Q>@;<E ?@W J8G

DbPFIC8I <EJ<E;<E;8?8WFB?FfC8EbPFILD \
[.8cFCLE 9<P \
[LE8 J<E E<;<E FC;LE E;I<N LEL ?@W9@I Q8D8E LE

LKD8 )8EJBPE@E J<E@ >XI;YBK<E ?<D<E JFEI8 ><E<CC<fK@I@CD@f


GFQ@KIFE@B PFCC8I;8E M8Q><WK@c@E;<E <D@E@D @I IF9FKLE E<
P8G8:8cbEbE XE:<;<E B<JK@I@C<D<D<J@ ?@W ?FfLE8 >@KD<;@
@C@PFI DLJLE @E:<C<D<B @W@E J<E@ 9@Q;<E B8W B<Q @JK<;@ FBLQ
;<=8 D8 FELE J<E@ <C< ><W@ID<J@E< ?@W9@I Q8D8E @Q@E M<I

D<;@D ;8D<D<BC@P<8PIbC;bcbE8>XI<8IKbBI8?8K<;<9@C@I@Q \
<P@E J8WC8Ib BbIWbCC8f8I8B J<PI<C@I M< PYQY ;< J8IB8IB<E
E;I<N >@K>@;< ;8?8 @P@C<f@PFI;L @C<P< @CB B8KbC;bcb >YE;<

B@E;<E;8?8?Ff>XQYBYPFI;Lf@D;@
$8EbD<=<E;@ MILG8;8 9@I J8E8K BFCFE@J@E< B8KbCDbfKb e8@I
FC8E BYWYB ?8EbD @J< *<N 4FIB`K8P;b 8Q8E D<BKLG P8QbPFI

C8I;b 8D8 JbB JbB ;<c@C )@E@D@E@ ?8EbD <MC<ED@fK@ M< G<B ;<
LQ8B FCD8P8E 9@I P<I;< FKLILPFI;L E;I<N;8E 8PIbCD8B
@JK<D<;@c@E@ JXPCYPFI;L SF:LcL BYWYB 9<P ;YEP8P8 ><C;@c@ Q8

D8E ;8 E;I<N ELE 9@9<IFEL KLK8I8B 9<9<c< JYKY @W@ID<J@E<


@Q@EM<I;@

E;I<N 8IKbB 9<P@E KFILEL FC;LcL @W@E >@;<EC<I@E P<I@E@E ;FC

;LILC;LcLEL ;YfYEYPFI;L + PYQ;<E ;< F XQ<C @JK<c@E@ 9<P<


8WbBC8D8BC8?8BJbQCbB<KD@fJ8PbCD8P8:8cbE8B8I8IM<I;@
[,8I8Db @JK<;@c@D >@9@ ?8I:8D8D8 @Q@E M<I;@c@E@Q @W@E WFB @P

@J@E@Q 9<P \;<;@





[+G8I8J<E@E;@ E;I<N \
[ .@Q 9LE8 @JK<P<I<B I8Qb FC;LcLELQ @W@E 9<P 48J8C8IbE
9YKYEG8I8Pb8CD8EbQ8<E><CFC8D8P8:8cbEb9@C@PFI;LD \
[48J8C8I 9<E@ P8ECbf ;8MI8ED8D @W@E @BE8 <;<D<QC<I
E;I<N \
[YKYE D8JI8=C8I8 M< M<I>@C<I< I8cD<E 8IKbB P8BC8fbB 8CKb PYQ
9@E;FC8IbDM8I 9<P \
[LEL9@C@PFILD E;I<N \
[+G8I8PbJ@Q<M<ID<B@JK@PFILD 9<P \
[+EL8C8D8D E;I<N \
[,8I8Pb 98E8 M<I<9@C<:<c@E@Q 9@I f<P< B8IfbCbB FC8I8B X;<P<

:<c@D9<P \
[48*<PD@fF E;I<N\
[XQ>YICYcYD 9<P \
[TQ>YICYcYE  \
[<EXQ>YICYcYDYJ8KbE8CD8B@JK@PFILD 9<P \


L @f F B8;8I BFC8P FCD8P8:8BKb <P BbQ8I;b [/8EIb
8fBbE8\;@P<I<BKFGLBC8IbEbEYQ<I@E;<;XE;YM<?bQC8LQ8BC8fKb
;8Db D@E@D@E@ ?8EbD PFC8 ><K@I;@ .<IKW< D<P;8E FBL

P8I8B YJK<C@B E;I<N`ELE XEYE;< +KLQ PbC 9FPLE:8 B@DJ< IF

9FKLE XEYE;< BFELfD8BK8E W<B@ED<D@fK@ Q8K<E 'FEL


E;I<N`PC8@C>@C@FCJLEFCD8JbE .FELWK8FJ8;<:<9@IIF9FKKL
)@E@D@E@ ?8EbD [898 \ ;<;@ [*<;<E 9LEL J8E8 P8GbCDbf
9@I ?8B8I<K J8PbPFIJLE E;I<N P@E< 9LI8;8 B8C8:8B @Q< P@E<
J8;bB FC8:8B TPC< FCD8D8B <C@E;< ;<c@C Q8K<E E;I<N XPC<
P8GbCDbf e@D;@ 9YKYE @JK<;@c@ 9@IB8W JXQ '<E;@J@E< _TQ>YIJYE 
;<E@CD<J@E@ @JK@PFI L G<B BFIBLEW 9@I f<P D@ E;I<N 9LEL
?8B <KD<;@ D@ /8EIbD FELEC8 PbCC8I;8E 9<I@ 9LE;8E JXQ
<;@PFILQ \\
[? ;<D<BPbCC8I;8E9<I@9LE;8EJXQ<;@PFIJLELQ\
 

[!M<K E;I<N J<E@ BbID8BK8E BFIBKLcL @W@E 9L @JK<c@E@ 8WbB

C8D8Pb B8W B<Q <IK<C<;@ .FELE;8 FEL J8E8 8WbCD8P8 9<E


QFIC8;bD \
[+XQ>YICYcYEE<FC;LcLEL9@CD@PFIB@  @IIF9FKF \
[898 J<E E;I<NPL K8EbDbPFIJLE + BYKYG?8E<;<B@ ?<I
B@K89b FBL;L E;I<N ELE E<C<I ?@JJ<KK@c@E@ 9@CD@PFILD D8
 ;< E<C<I ?@JJ<KK@c@E@ 9@C;@c@D@ JXPC<P<D<D E;I<N`PC8
BFELfKLcLE Q8D8E FELE 9@IWFB JFPLK =@BI< K<GB@ >XJK<I;@c@E@
=8IB<;<:<BJ@E /bGBb J<E M< 9<E >@9@ ,<B@ 9LE;8E ;8?8 XE<DC@
E< FC89@C@I !c<I 9@I@E@E K<GB@C<I@ J<E@EB@C<I >@9@PJ< ;8?8 98fB8
E<@JK<P<9@C@IJ@E\
<P X=B<PC< [48J8C8I 9L K8MIb K8BbED8P8:8BKbI \ ;@P< :<M8G
M<I;@ [.<E LI8P8 98B\ ;8D E;I<NP8 ;XE<I<B X=B<;<E
9FcLBC8fDbf 9@I J<JC< [.<E@ 8E:8B P8J8C 9@W@D;< J<I9<JK
9bI8B89@C@I@D \ ;<;@ [LEL 98fB8 KYICY P8G8D8D !c<I @f
D8?B<D<P< ;Yf<IJ< XQ>YICYcYE< B8MLf8D8QJbE UJK<C@B G8I8E
FC;LcL ;8 I<JD<E 8EC8fbCbI .8E8 9@I IF9FKLE G8I8 B8Q8ED8P8
?8BBb FCD8;bcbEb JXPC<IC<I YKYE 9LEC8I G8I8Eb B8P9<KD<E<
;<c<ID@\
E;I<N [TQ>YICYc< G8?8 9@W@C<D<Q <=<E;@D \ ;<;@ [XQ>YI
FCD8@?K@D8C@9@C<9LG8I8PbM<ID<P<;<c<I 9<P \


)8?B<D< ;< XQ>YICYcYE G8?8 9@W@CD<Q FC;LcLEL B89LC <;<

9@C@I;@ 1< 9@I IF9FKLE E< B8;8I WFB G8I8 X;<IJ< X;<J@E
XQ>YICYcYEYJ8KbE8C8D8P8:8cbE8;8B8I8IM<I<9@C@I;@
L XQ>YICYB K8C<9@E@E I<;;<;@CD<J@ @W@E ;8M8 8W8EC8Ib K<DJ@C
<;<E 9XC>< 8MLB8Kb 98J@K 9@I 8WbBC8D8 P8GKb [_XQ>YICYB B<

C@D<J@ 9@I IF9FK8 LP>LC8E;bcb Q8D8E 8EC8DbEb B8P9<;<I .8

;<:<@EJ8EC8IX>YIFC89@C@IC<I \
;8D LP>LE 8EC8I;8 9L JXQC<I@ K<BI8IC8;b cbI 8cbI d;;@

8JbEb >YWC<E;@ID<B @W@E <CC<I@E@ XEYE;<B@ D8J8P8 I@KD@B 9@I


 

9@W@D;<MLI8I8B
)@E@D@E@ ?8EbD E;I<N 8;bE8 BFELfD8B @W@E @Q@E @JK<;@ 48I

>bW B8;bEbE K8D 8;bEb BLCC8EbIB<E E;I<N F Q8D8E8 B8;8I 9L


@J@DC<I@?@W;LPD8DbfKb
[D8E;8(8LI8)8IK@E?8IE<PBYIJYP<P8BC8f89@C@I \
'8;bE [/<f<BBYI <;<I@D J8PbE P8I>bW \ ;<;@ [<E 8MLB8K
;<c@C@D 0P>LE JXQ:YBC<I@ BLCC8ED8Pb ;8 9@CD<D D8 JXQ:YB

C<I< 8C;bID8P8I8B E< ;<D<B @JK<;@c@DC< @C>@C<E<:<c@E@Q@


LDLPFILD
[E;I<N 98BbDbE;8E XQ>YICYcYE E< 8EC8D8 ><C;@c@E@ B8M

I8D8P8 W8Cbf8CbD @IWFB 98BbD;8E XQ>YI F <E:< <E 8f8cb


P@ID@ PbC;8E 9<I@ )8IK@E 8@C<J@E@E ?@W9@I YP<J@ FE8 B<E;@ B<E;@E<
P8G8D8P8:8cbEb ;YfYE;YcY 9@I @fC< @C>@C@ FC8I8B 9@I <D@I
M<ID<;@
[D8 9@Q @JK<IJ<B FE8 ?<I f<P@ P8GD8Jb @W@E ?<I BFEL;8
<D@I M<I<9@C@I@Q dJK<;@c@D@Q B8;8I J<IK :YDC<C<I BLCC8E89@C@I@Q
SYEBY E;I<N JFELWK8 9@Q< 8IK FC8E 9@I D8B@E< D8 E<;<E 9@Q
9LEL P8G89@C<:<B ;LILD;8 FC8CbD E;I<N LQLE PbCC8I 9FPLE:8
9@Q< J8;8B8KC< ?@QD<K <KD<;@ D@ @Q@D @W@E F B8;8I WFB G8I8
B8Q8ED8;bDb
[48J8C8I E;I<N`PL 9@I <J@I >@9@ BLCC8ED8DbQb P8J8BC8J8C8I;b
9@C< F P@E< ;< B<E;@ @JK<c@PC< 9@Q< ?@QD<K <;<I;@ E;I<NELE
XQ>YICYcYE< B8MLfD8Jb 8JCbE;8 J8;<:< 9@I B<C@D< FPLEL FC8

:8B D8 9L FELE @W@E WFB XE<DC@ XPC<:< E;I<N`ELE ?<I


f<P@FC8:8cb>@9@9L9@Q<G8?8CbP8D8CFCD8P8:8B \
48I>bW J8EB@ >YCD<D<P< W8CbfbPFI;L [*< ;<D<B @JK<;@c@E@Q@
8ECbPFILD 8P ?8IE<P D8 ><IW<B fL 9L BFEL;8 E<
98cC8Pb:b 9@I P8J8 M8I E< ;< 9@I <DJ8C E:8B JXQC< JXPC<ED<P

<E 9@I ;YfYE:< FC;LcLEL ;8 LELKD8PbE     


  #   "   LI8;8 P<E@ 9@I P8J8 FCLfKLI89@

C@I@D 4YBJ<B )8?B<D<E@E ><I<BC@ 9LCLIJ8 ;<c@fK@ID<J@ f8IKbPC8


D8 ;<D@EB@ ;YfYE:<P< B8PbKJbQ:8 B8Ifb ><C<D<D e@D;@ @Q@E
M<I@E;<IF9FKC8BFELf8PbD E;I<N\


[!M<K J8PbEP8I>bW\
E;I<N D8?B<D< J8CFELE;8 @CB B<Q BFELfLPFI;L 48I>bW
IF9FKLE J<J@E@E @EJ8EC8IbEB@E< WFB 9<EQ<D<J@ PYQYE;<E 9@I 8E
f8fbI;b .FEI8 [*<;<E XQ>YI FCD8B @JK@PFIJLE E;I<N\ ;@P<
JFI;L [L ?8E>@98BbD;8EJ<E@E@W@EXE<DC@\
E;I<N [J8PbE P8I>bW \ ;<;@ [.@Q <J@I FCD8B @JK<I
D@P;@E@Q
[D8 J<E 9@I <J@I ;<c@CJ@E B@ .<E DYB<DD<C 9@I IF9FKJLE
EC8;bcbD B8;8IbPC8 ;V?@ 9@I IF9FKJLE YJK<C@B 48I8KKbcbE J8E8K
<J<IC<I@E@E ?@W9@I P<I;< <f@ PFBDLf TQ>YI FCJ8P;bE 98fB8 ;8?8
E<P8G8I;bE\
[<CB@ f@D;@B@E;<E ;8?8 =8QC8JbEb P8GD8Q;bD J8PbE P8I>bW
D8 FEC8Ib ;8?8 9YPYB 9@I DLKCLCLBC8 P8G8I;bD L D8?B<D<
J8CFELE;8 J8;<:< @EJ8EC8IbE XQ>YI FC89@C<:<BC<I@ JXPC<E;@ D8
9<E:< 8E:8B XQ>YI FCD8B @JK<P<E 9@I B@DJ< XQ>YI FC89@C@I <E
;<XQ>YIFCD8B@JK@PFILD \
.FELE;8 9L JXQC<I P8I>b:8 PFC >XJK<ID@fK@ '8I8IbEbE <E
XE<DC@ :YDC<J@ fL FC;L ['8=8Jb XQ>YICYB B8MI8DbEb 8EC8P8:8B
M< 9LEL @JK<P<:<B B8;8I ><C@fD@f FC8E 9@I@E@ 9LE;8E PFBJLE
9bI8BD8P8B@DJ<E@E?8BBbFC8D8Q \
8?8JFEI8 YEP8)8?B<D<J@;<9LB8I8Ib;<JK<BC<;@


<P ?VCV WFB ?FfELKJLQ;L .<IK J<J@ E;I<NELE B<E;@E@
BFEK8BP8GD8BYQ<I<PD@f>@9@?@JJ<KD<J@E<E<;<EFCLPFI;L
<P [+ C8E<K FC8Jb:8 G8I8Eb @JK<D@PFILD E;I<N \ ;@P<
?FDLI;8E;b [D8 FEL 8CbPFILD SYEBY 98fB8 KYICY B<E;@E@
XQ>YI ?@JJ<;<D<P<:<BJ@E LE;8E JFEI8 @fC<I@ B<E;@E J<W<I M<
FEC8Ib 9@C;@c@E >@9@ P8G8IJbE .8E8 9LELE ;bfbE;8 98fB8 ?@W9@I
<D@I M<ID<P<:<c@D @JK<;@c@E@ P8G D8 9<E P@E< ;< J<E;<E
JFILDCLPLD )8?B<D< <DI@E@E 9@I G8IW8Jb 9L LEL 8EC8;bcbEb
LD8IbD \
)@E@D@E@ ?8EbD 8KbC;b [+ B8;8I X=B<C<ED< 9898 L


JFILDCLCLB F B8;8I 8cbI 9@I f<P ;<c@C @I f<P P8GD8E8 ><I<B FC

D8;bcbEb9@C@PFIJLE YW48J8?VCV><W<IC@ \
[+?8C;<E8JbCXQ>YIFC89@C@PFI\
E;I<N [dEJ8EC8Ib;8P8J8C8IbBbJbKC8DbPFIDL 9<P\;<;@
[IKbB K8IKbf8:8B ;<c@C@D\ <P B8CBbG WbBKb E;I<N 9L FC8P

;8EJFEI8FEL;8?8<E;<I>XID<P<98fC8;b
)@E@D@E@ ?8EbD @J< E;I<N @W@E P8GbC8E M< FELE YQ<I@E< B8P

;<;@C<E BYWYB <M< JbB JbB ><C<I<B IF9FKL >XIYPFI;L /89@@ 9L


BLCY9<;< DLK=8B ;8 PFBKL 98EPF ;8 !M @B@ F;8P;b LEC8I;8E
9@I@ BYKYG?8E<P;@ ;@c<I@PJ< ;<GF M< 8KXCP< B8IbfbDb 9@I f<P
E;I<N 9@IWFB J@G8I@f@ B89LC <;@PFI M< XQ>YI 9@I IF9FK 8C8I8B
<JB@J@E;<E ;8?8 =8QC8 W8CbfbPFI;L .FELE;8 <M@E 9FI:LEL X;<;@
M<BLCY9<P8J8C8I8>XI<B<J@EC@BC<FELEFC;L
@I >YE 'YWYB 9<P ;< ><C;@ $8PbI #<FI>< 'YWYB 9<P
)8?B<D<E@E B8I8IbE;8E JFEI8 E;I<N`ELE B<E;@J@E@ 9XPC<
W8cbID8Jb @W@E bJI8I <KD@fK@ [TQ>YI 9@I IF9FK ?@W B@DJ<P< BYWYB
9<P ;@P< ?@K89 <KD<Q \ ;<D@fK@ [<E J<E@ E;I<N ;@P<
W8cbIbPFILD .<E;<9<E@#<FI><;@P<W8cbID8CbJbE \
L 9@I <D@I >@9@ JXPC<ED@fK@ E;I<N ;8 9L PYQ;<E FE8 #<

FI>< ;@P< ?@K89 <KD<P< 98fC8;b D8 D@E@D@E@ ?8EbD P@E< XPC<
B8C;b
#<FI>< BLCY9<P< ><C;@c@ >YE IF9FK8 9<P@E XCYD ;Xf<c@E;<
FC;LcLEL ?89<I M<I;@ )@E@D@E@ ?8EbD FELE 98fL:LE;8 9<BC@P

FI;L D89<PE;I<N`PL>XID<B@JK<;@
<P =8QC8 ?8I<B<K <;<D@PFI;L 8D8 J<J@ ?VCV >YWCYP;Y
'<E;@E@ QFIC8P8I8B <C@E@ B8C;bI;b M< [E;I<N \ ;<;@
[E;I<N 8E8 P8I;bD <KD< #<FI>< <E J8B8K ;<c@C@D J8

;<:< XCYPFILD E;I<N XQ>YI FC;LcLE @W@E J<M@E@PFILD


.8E89LELJXPC<D<B@JK<;@D \
E;I<N E< ;@P<:<c@E@ 9@C<D<;@ 8?8 XE:< XCD<B YQ<I< FC8E
9@I@E@E P8EbE;8 ?@W 9LCLED8DbfKb D8 9LELE @EJ8EC8IbE
W8CbfD8C8IbEbE JFE8 <ID<J@ ;<D<B FC;LcLEL 9@C@PFI;L L
@JK<D<;<E FC8E M< W8I<J@ 9LCLED8P8E 9@I _JXBYCD<` _G8IW8C8I8


8PIbCD8`P;b 1< E;I<N 9L ;LILD;8 JXPC<E<9@C<:<B LP>LE JXQ

C<I@E E<C<I FC;LcLEL ?@W XcI<ED<D@fK@ .8;<:< 8P8BK8 J<JJ@Q:<


?@WBbDbC;8D8;8EXPC<;LI;L
$<I f<P JFE8 <I;@c@E;< D@E@D@E@ ?8EbD FE8 [<CB@ 9898D
;8?8 JFEI8C8Ib J8E8 ;FJKW8 ;8MI8ED8;b E;I<N \ ;<;@ [D8
9@C;@c@E >@9@ 8IKbB P8fC8EDbfKb TQ>YI FCD8Pb @JK<D<E PYQYE;<E
J8E8BbIbCDbfKb \
E;I<N F Q8D8E JXPC<E<:<B JXQC<I@ 9LC;L [+ FCD8J8P;b
9<E ;< XQ>YICYcYD< ?@W9@I Q8D8E B8MLf8D8Q;bD D@E@D@E@
?8EbD \


E;I<N <P@E XCYDYE;<E JFEI8 <C9@J< >@PD<P< 98fC8;b
TE:< <JB@ 9@I G8EKFCFEL 8P8cbE8 ><W@I;@ LEL FE8 #<FI><
M<ID@fK@
#<FI>< )8IK@E 8IKbB <MC<ED@fK@ M< 8MLB8KCbB P8GbPFI;L "<@E

>FC; $LBLB YIFJLE8 >@ID@fK@ 48fCb "<@E>FC; XC<C@ WFB FCDLfJ8


;8 BbQb W8CbfD8C8Ib JYI;YIYPFI;L .FELE;8 9YIF "<@E>FC; M<
)8IK@E 8;bEb 8C;b $8KK8 B8;bE <D<BC@P< 8PIbC;bcb M< P<I@E@ 98fB8
9@I "<@E>FC; 8CD8;bcb Q8D8E ;8 9L @J@D ;<c@fD<;@ E;I<NELE
@CB;<=8>@P@E;@c@>YEC<I;<)8IK@E8;b;8=@ID8P8P<E@<BC<ED@fK@
#<FI>< IF9FKL G8EKFCFEC8 >XI;YcY Q8D8E >YCD<D<P<
W8CbfKb D8E;I<NP@E<;<FK<9<JJYDY>XIYI>@9@FCDLfKL
#<FI>< IF9FK8 G8EKFCFELE 8WbCD8Jb 9<C;<E 8f8cbJbE8 J8IbC

D8Jb M< B8G8ED8JbEb J8cC8P8E JK8K@B <C<BKI@c@ E8JbC BLC

C8E8:8cbEb >XJK<I;@ '<E;@ G8EKFCFEL YQ<I@E;< D8 E;I<N 9L


9@I K<B 8Bb:b ?8I<B<K@ 8E:8B 9@I JYI< JFEI8 K8BC@K <;<9@C<:<c@E@
8EC8;b
MLB8K [D8 E<;<E G8EKFCFE >@PD<B @JK@PFIJLE E;I<N\
;@P< JFI;L [1Y:L;LE GI8K@B M< 9@W@DC@ +EL XIKD<B >YE8?
9<E:< TQ<CC@BC< bJb BFEKIFCL P8 ;8 <;<G >@9@ ;<IKC<I@E FCD8;bcb
@W@E 1<G8EKFCFEDF;<C<LP>LE9@W@D;<J8IbC8DbPFI \


E;I<N [dEJ8E MY:LKC8Ib ;8 >YQ<C M< GI8K@B ;<c@C D@ #<

FI><\;<;@ [D8J@QP@E<;<MY:L;LELQLXIKYPFIJLELQ \
].b:8BCbB K<D@QC@B BFILED8 M< JYJ @W@E LEC8I;8E ?@W9@I@ ;<
J<E@E@W@E><W<IC@;<c@C \
E;I<N DbIbC;8E;b ['<E;@D@ >@PJ@J@Q WbGC8B >@9@ ?@JJ<;@PFI

LD 8fB8C8IbE;8E=8IBCbPDbf>@9@ #<FI>< \
["8IBCbPDbf>@9@D@IKbBP<IPYQYE;<D@CPFEC8I:8IF9FKM8I
E;I<N .FE J8PbD;8 9L 9XC><;< ?<D<E ?<D<E @EJ8EC8I B8;8I
IF9FKFC;LcL8EC8fbCDbf \
[@C@PFILD #<FI>< BC8 ><C<9@C<E ?<I KYICY @f@ P8G8E IF9FK

C8IM8I \
[M<FEC8I;8E?@W9@I@<C9@J<>@PD@PFI \
[D8FEC8IbE?@W9@I@XQ>YI;<c@C #<FI>< \
E;I<N P8M8f P8M8f >8I;IF9LE8 <BC<D<C<I P8GKb E:8B
#<FI><LE K<9<JJYDY M< B<E;@E< J@G8I@f M<I<E @EJ8EC8IbE
98BbfC8IbFELJbBbPFI;L
E;I<N 9<CB@ XQ>YI;Y 8D8 @EJ8EC8I8 B8Ifb ;8MI8EbfC8Ib BF

ELJLE;8 8PIbEKbCb 9@I 9@W@D;< GIF>I8DC8EDbfKb + PYQ;<E ;< 8E

:8B BbJ8:bB 8;bDC8I 8K8I8B @C<IC<D< :<J8I<K@E@ >XJK<I<9@C@PFI;L


@I@E@E ?FfELKJLQCLcLEL 8WbB 8WbB 9<C@IKD<J@ ><I@C<D<J@E<
E<;<EFCLPFI 8PC8I:8JYI<EW898C8Ib;89Ff8>@;@PFI;L
58K<E ?<IB<J E;I<N`ELE XQ>YI FC;LcLEL B89LC <KD@PFI;L
-F9FK 9LE8 K<GB@ >XJK<I<:<B 9@W@D;< P8GbCD8J8 ;8 ?8KbIC8;bcb
Q8D8E;YfYED<@fC<D@E;<9@I8BJ8D8FCLPFI;L
E;I<N XQ<CC@BC< D@E@D@E@ ?8EbDbE ><C<9@C<:<c@E@ ;YfYE;YcY
Q8D8E >@P@ED<BK<E B8WbEbPFI;L 48 ;8 =8QC8 f<P >@PD<BK<E
)@E@D@E@ ?8EbD P8fC8EDbfKb 8IKbB SFcL Q8D8E ;8?8 Jb:8B 9@I
P<I< >@;@G B8CbPFI 8D8 ;XE;YcY Q8D8E ;8 @CB @f IF9FK8
><C@PFI;L
'8;bE P@E< 9@I 8I8 B<EK< ;XE;YcY Q8D8E #<FI>< IF9FK8
YQYEKYPC< [48B8D8 P8GbfKb E;I<N \ ;@P< 8WbBC8;b [#<C<:<B
PbC XC>< )<:C@J@ J<W@DC<I@E< >@I<:<c@D EE<D _YPYB9898
E8JbCJ8 KFILE;8XPC<FCD8Cb;bI `;@PFI \


[YPYB9898E8JbCJ8 \E;I<NB8I8IJbQ:8;LI8BC8;b
[48E@ 9<E #<FI>< KFILE 9YPYB9898 9<P >@9@ FC8:8cbD +
;89@I8I8XC><)<:C@J@E@EYP<J@P;@ \
E;I<N [#<FI>< \ ;<;@ [*< ?Ff FCLI;L ;<c@C D@ 48E@ 9<P
?VCV \ LI;L [S8CbfbI ?8C;< FCJ8P;b \\ ;<D<B @JK<D@PFI;L L
JXQC<IG<BLP>LE;<c@C;@>8C@98
#<FI>< [.8c FCJ8P;b \\ ;@P< 98fbEb J8CC8;b [!M<K 9<E ;<
8I8;8JbI8;8FP8fCb:8E8M8Ib;YfYEYPFILD \\
E;I<N JFEI8;8E 9L BFELfD8Pb WFB ;YfYE;Y #<FI><`C8
BFELfLIB<E G<B ;< 98f8IbCb FC8D8;bcbEb =8IB<KD@fK@ *8JbC
FC;LPJ8 IF9FK @W@E;< JXQ ;8c8I:bcbPC8 YI<K@C;@c@ >YE;<E 9<I@ ;@C
9@I ?8PC@ ;<c@fD@fK@ PIb:8 #<FI>< 9<PC< D@E@D@E@ ?8EbDbE K<I

J@E< 98Qb ;<P@DC<I ;< BLCC8EbPFI;L *<;<E 9<P;<E _:8E8M8I ;@

P< JXQ <KD@fK@ L JXQ:YcYE ?@W LP>LE FCD8;bcb 9<CC@ ;<c@C


D@P;@
E;I<NELE W8I<P@ B<E;@ <JB@ B@K8GC8IbE;8 9LCD8Jb ;8 FC8E8

BJbQ;b SFcL K8?K8 FPD8:bCbcb J8E8K M< <fP8 P8GbDbPC8 @C>@C@P;@


@CC<@C>@C@?@WB@K8GPFBKL dEJ8EC8IbE;8MI8EbfC8IbPC8@C>@C@FC8Eb;8
E;I<N JFELE;8 LP>LE B@K8GC8I FBLD8Jb ><I<BK@c@E< B8I8I
M<I;@ TQ>YI 9@I IF9FK FC;LcL @W@E 9LEL #<FI><8 ;8 JFID8P8

:8BKb '<EK< @E<:<B M< B@K8GCbc8 >@;<:<BK@ L B8I8I FE;8 9@I Q8

=<I ;LP>LJL LP8E;bI;b !C<BKIFGFK8EJ@P<C@ 9<C@I>@E 9@I 9@W@D;<


PYBJ<C;@ .FELE;89@IXQ;@I<EW9F9@E@E@8KKbID8BQFILE;8B8C;b
E;I<N K8D K8BbD <C9@J< >@P;@ $8KK8 K8?K8 ?8CB8C8I;8E
FCLf8E 9@I FDLQ Q@E:@I@ 9@C< K8BKb JCbE;8 bfbCKbCb GC8JK@c@ K<I:@?
<;<:<BK@ D8 #<FI>< K8?K8EbE WFB ;8?8 LP>LE FC;LcLEL
JXPC<D@fM< [@C8CbJ<;@IWFB;8?8;<c<IC@ \;<D@fK@
-F9FK <M;<E FKLQ 8;bD B8;8I LQ8BC8fKbcb JbI8;8 >@K>@;<
8IK8E QFIC8D8 PYQYE;<E ;LI8BC8;b TQ;@I<EW 9F9@E@E@ ;<MI<;bfb
9bI8BKb D8 9L ;8 P<K<I@ B8;8I P8I8ICb FCD8;b -F9FK 9LELE
YQ<I@E< <M< ;XE<I<B 9@I BVcb;8 ;YQ>YE:< ['@K8GCbc8 >@;@PFI

LD \ ;@P< P8Q;b M< 9LEL W8CbfD8 D8J8JbEbE BFC8PCbBC8 >XIYC<

9@C<:<B9@IP<I@E<BFP;L
 


E;I<N ?@W9@I Q8D8E B@K8GCbc8 <I@f<D<;@ -F9FK B<EK GC8EbEb
@E:<C<D@fK@ 4FCL 9@C@PFI;L 8D8 >XIYEYfYEY ;<c@C /FGI8BC8IbE
;LILDL GC8E;8B@ J@D><C<I< ?@W 9<EQ<D@PFI;L E;I<N F
PYQ;<E JbB JbB ;LI8BC8;b .FELE;8 P8ECbf PFC8 J8GDbf FC;LcLE8
B8I8IM<I;@ $<If<P9@I8:8@GK@
E;I<N Q8D8E Q8D8E 8WbB ?8M8;8 W8Cbf8E IF9FKC8IbE
P8EbE;8E ><WD@fK@ D8 PFCL JFID8P8 B8I8I M<I;@c@ Q8D8E 9@I
K<B D8B@E< 8;8D 9@C< >XI<D<;@ 48EbE;8E 9@I K8fbK ><WK@ 8D8 F
;8 ;LID8;b E;I<N JFELE;8 B8I8IJbQ:8 ;LI8BC8;b 48E@
J8B@E:< ?8I<B<KJ@Q B8C;b .FEI8 BbI K8I8=bE;8E @B@ @EJ8EbE
><C;@c@E@>XI;Y

+EC8I8 ;FcIL ;XE;Y dB@ @EJ8E ;8 E;I<NP8 P8BC8fD8B @W@E


PXE ;<c@fK@I;@C<I @I ;8B@B8 XE:< PYBJ<B J<JC< BFELfLIC8IB<E
IF9FK FEC8IbE J<JC<I@E@ ;LPDLfKL D8 f@D;@ @P@:< J<JJ@

QC<D@fC<I;@ 4YQC<I@E;< E;I<N`ELE @EJ8EC8IbE B8I8IJbQCbBC8IbE8


98cC8;bcb F @=8;< M8I;b #<EWK@C<I E:8B WF:LB ;8 J8PbCD8QC8I;b
;8?8 WFB P@ID@J@E;< >XIYEYPFIC8I;b E;I<N @EJ8EC8IbE P8fC8IbEb
?@WK8?D@E<;<D@PFI;L
-F9FK [8E8 B<EKK<B@ B@K8GCbcbE PFCLEL K8I@= <;<I D@J@E@Q
<=<E;@C<I@D\;<;@
dB@ ><EWK<E ;8?8 LQLE 9FPCL FC8Eb E;I<N`P8 ;<c@C ;<
P8EbE;8B@E< [+ 9@I IF9FK \ ;<;@ 8fbE;8B@ PYBJ<B K<G<C@ f8GB8
PYQYE;<E9FPL;8?8;8LQLE;LILPFI;L #XIYEYfYWFB>8I@GK@
@c<I ><E:@E >XQB8G8BC8Ib f@f 9LIEL ;8 ;FD8K<J >@9@P;@ +
;8 E;I<N`P8 ;<c@C 8IB8;8fbE8 [#@PJ@C<I@ M8I \ ;@P<
DbIbC;8E;b
0QLE9FPCLP898E:bG8ID8BC8IbEbf8BC8KKb [eLXQ>YIIF9FKF
)8IK@E`C<I;< B@DJ<E@E D8Cb FCD8P8E 9@I IF9FK M8I P8 4FBJ8
E<;<E<C9@J<>@PJ@E\
dI@9LILECLP898E:b [LELFE8JFI \;@P<<DI<KK@
0QLE9FPCL><EW [.<E)8IK@EC<I@EIF9FKLDLJLE\;<;@



-F9FK8WbBC8;b [<EE;I<N)8IK@E@D <=<E;@D \


[dP@ UQ<I@E;<B@C<I@ WbB8I -F9FKC8I <C9@J< >@PD<QC<I \
IB8;8fbE8;XE;Y [dcI<EW9@If<P9L eL?8C@E<98B \
E;I<N ;LI8BC8;b SFB LQLE JYI<;<E 9<I@ FE8 9L J<J
KFELPC8 <D@I M<I@CD<D@fK@ L PYQ;<E dB@E:@ 48J8 ;<MI<J@ 9@I 8E
KbB8E;b
0QLE 9FPCL ><EW [UQ<I@E;<B@C<I@ WbB8I \ ;@P< K<BI8IC8;b
[.8E8<DI<;@PFILD \
E;I<N8cbI8cbI>@PJ@C<I@E@WbB8ID8P898fC8;b
0QLE9FPCL><EW<DI<KK@ +EC8IbP<I<8K \
e@f 9LILECL ;<C@B8ECb [)8;<D B@DJ<E@E ;<c@C \ ;<;@ [IKbB
9@Q@DFC89@C@I \
0QLE 9FPCL P898E:b [58K<E P8GKbBC8IbDbQ8 B@D @K@I8Q <;<9@

C@I\ ;@P< ?FDLI;8E;b [@I@E@E D8CbE8 Q8I8I M<ID@PFILQ B@ \


E;I<NP8;XE;Y [8fbEbEYQ<I@E;<;LI \
-F9FK [D898f9L@f@W@E \;@P<98fC8;b
[L 9@I <D@I;@I LEL E8JbC P8G8:8cbEb 9@CD@PFIJ8E ?@W FC

D8QJ89@I;<E< \
E;I<N P@E< ;LI8BC8;b .FEI8 <c@C<I<B B8=8JbEb P<I< ;8P8;b
8:8BC8IbEbB8C;bID8P8W8CbfbIB<E>YIYCKYPC<;<MI@C;@
0QLE 9FPCL ><EW [+I8;8 XPC< B8C \ ;<;@ IB8;8fbE8 98BKb
JFEI8 [+EL JXB<D<P@Q e@D;@P< B8;8I 9@I IF9FKL G8IW8C8IbE8
8PbI;bEDb?@W\
[+9LE8@Q@EM<I@ID@\
[@Q<E8JbC<E><CFC89@C@I\
E;I<NP8 P<K<I@ B8;8I >YWCY 9@I K8MbIC8 B8Ifb BFPD8D8JbEb
<DI<;<IC<IJ< IF9FK ?@W9@I f<P P8G8D8Q;b L ><EWC<I< <E><C
FC8D8Q;b dK88KC< @C>@C@ dB@E:@ 48J8 B<E;@E@ BFILD8Pb <DI<;<E
UWYE:Y 48J8;8E ;8?8 XE<DC@P;@ 58K<E IF9FK 9L @EJ8EC8I8 Q8

I8I M<ID<;<E B<E;@E@ J8MLE8D8Q;b L @I@E:@ 48J8P8 B8Ifb


><CD<B FCLI;L L ;YfYE:< PYQYE;<E IF9FKLE 9YKYE ?8I<B<K
YE@K<C<I@ ?8=@=W< 9YQYC;Y 1< E;I<N P8KKbcb P<I;< K@KI<D<P<
98fC8;b
 

0QLE 9FPCL ><EW P8BC8f8I8B 8P8cbPC8 IF9FKL @KK@ [SFB 8cbI


L@f@P8GD8B@W@E8C<KC<I><I<B<:<BJ8EbIbD \
FD8K<J 9LILECL [+E8 B<E;@ B<E;@E@ G8IW8C8D8JbEb <DI<

;<9@C@I@Q \ ;@P< >YC;Y [LEL ;<E<D<J@E@ J<PI<KD<B WFB


<cC<E:<C@FCLI \
0QLE 9FPCL ><EW ;YfYE:<C@ ;YfYE:<C@ DbIbC;8E;b [!M<K
D8FELPFC;8ELQ8BC8fKbI8CbD @I@><C<:<BFCLIJ8 \
D8 WFB ><W B8CDbfKb @I@ ><IW<BK<E ><C@PFI;L 1< ><W<E
#<FI><;L E;I<N P8KKbcb P<I;<E FELE 9@I8Q ><I@;<B@ K<G<:@c@
8fKbcbEb >XIDYfKY #<FI><`8 @f8I<K <KD<P@ WFB @JK@PFI;L 8D8 JFE
<D@I;<B<J@E;@ [+I8;8XPC<B8C \
#<FI>< 8IKbB BFfD8P8 98fC8Dbf P8EC8IbE8 <I@fK@c@ JbI8;8
JFCLB JFCLc8 B8CDbfKb dB@ ><EW 9@I8Q ><I@C<P<I<B ;YfYE:<C@ K8MbI

C8IC89<BC<;@C<I
#<FI><<E;@f<PC< [E;I<N \;<;@ [@I8IbQ8DbFC;L\
-F9FK [<E@P@P@D #<FI>< \;@P<:<M8GM<I;@
[+?8C;<8P8c8B8CB #@PJ@C<I@E<E<FC;L\
0QLE9FPKL><EW [[LIF9FKJ<E@ED@ 8?98G\;@P<JFI;L
MLB8K ?bQC8 ;XE;Y [+ B@DJ<E@E IF9FKL ;<c@C LI8;8 E<C<I
FCLPFI\
[+E;8E E8Q@BW< >@PJ@C<I@E@ WbB8ID8JbEb @JK<;@B )8;<D
J8?@9@;<c@CJ@E 9LE;8EJ8E8E<\
#<FI><IF9FK8;XE;Y [+EC8IE<P8GbPFIC8I;b E;I<N\
-F9FK [@I PFCLEL 9LC8I8B 9<E@ G8IW8C8D8Pb ;YfYEYPFI

C8I;b \ ;<;@ [<E@ J8B@E 9@I P<I< >XKYI<:<B FI8;8 98E8 B<E;@
B<E;@D@G8IW8C8D8Db<DI<;<:<BC<I;@ \
#<FI>< @B@ J<IJ<I@P< 98BKb S<E<J@ K@KI@PFI;L dB@ ><EW ;8?8
=8QC8 ><I@C<D<D@fC<I ?8KK8 JbIbKD8P8 98fC8DbfC8I;b 0QLE 9FPCL
;<C@B8ECb 8C8PC8 [e@D;@ E< P8G8:8BJbE 98B8CbD f@fBF\ ;@P<
JFI;L [@Q<J8C;bI8:8BDbJbE\
#<FI>< [$8PbI \ ;<;@ [LEL P8GD8D8 ><I<B PFB -F9FK
P<KD@f PbC;8E ;8?8 LQLE 9@I JYI<;<E 9<I@ 8@C<D@E P8EbE;8 +
9@Q@ K8EbI M< 9@Q< ;@c<I @EJ8EC8I;8E WFB ;8?8 =8QC8 ;<c<I M<I@I
 

e@D;@ FE8 @B@E@Q@E 9<E@ K<?;@K <KK@c@E@ JXPC<P<:<c@D $8P8KbDbE


K<?C@B<;< FC;LcLEL <E@ XC;YID<P@ GC8EC8;bcbEbQb + Q8D8E
J@Q@EC< 9<E@D 8I8D;8 9@I J<W@D P8GD8B QFILE;8 B8C8:8B 1<
@B@E@Q@ ;<c@C 9<E@ J<W<:<B -F9FK J@Q< J8C;bI;bcb Q8D8E E<C<I
FC8:8cbEb9@C@PFIDLJLELQ\
dB@ ><EW P8M8f P8M8f ><I@C<IB<E PYQC<I@E;< <E;@f<C@ @=8;<C<I
M8I;b
#<FI>< J<IK J<IK [E;I<N \ ;@P< 98cbI;b [$8P8KbD K<?C@B

<;< L @B@ ><EW 98E8 Q8I8I M<ID<P< ?8QbIC8EbPFIC8I +EC8I8


;FcIL>bC\
E;I<N 9L <DI@ P<I@E< ><K@I@IB<E @B@ ><EW ;8?8 =8QC8
9<BC<D<;@C<I  XE<I<B?bQC8B8WKbC8I
#<FI>< [/8D8D E;I<N \ ;<;@ [#<Mf< 8IKbB \ SFB J8I

JbCDbf FC;LcL 9<CC@P;@ IKbB ;<c@C @B@ 9@I ><EWC< 9@C< ;XMYf<:<B
P8fbWFBK8E><WD@fK@
-F9FK [<E FEC8I8 Q8I8I M<I<D<Q;@D #<FI>< \ ;<;@ [+
@B@><E:@EJ8E8J8C;bID8;bBC8IbEb>XIYPFI;LD \
[<EJ8E8FEC8I8J8C;bID8Eb<DI<KD<;@DB@ .8E8J8;<:<F
@B@ ><E:< ;FcIL >@KD<E@ JXPC<;@D #<I@J@E@ B<E;@ BFIBLC8Ib
K8D8DC8;b \
[@IIF9FKK8EE8JbCBFIB8IC8I\\
[L @EJ8EC8IbE 9@I ?8JK8Cbcb $<EYQ K<;8M@ ;< <;@CD<;@ *<P

J< 9LEL 9@I K8I8=8 9bI8B f@D;@ LI8;8 E< @f@E M8I E;I<N
.<E@ 9LC8D8QJ8D ><I@ ;XED<P@ M< 9@I ?<C@BFGK<I B@I8C8D8Pb
;YfYEYPFI;LD '@K8GCbc8 >@KD<B ;< E<I<;<E 8BCbE8 ><@;@ <E
J8E8@?K@P8:bEFC8E?<IB@K89b><K@I@I;@D \
E;I<N [<E  \;@P<98fC8;b
[TQ>YI 9@I IF9FKJLE !M<K <M<K ,<BVCV B@K8GCbBK8 E<
P8G8:8BKbE\
[<E @EJ8EC8I BFELJLE;8 ;8?8 =8QC8 9@C>@ J8?@9@ FCD8B
@JK@PFILD YEP8 BFELJLE;8 ;8 $<I f<P ?8BBbE;8 9@C>@D FC

D8Cb 1< IF9FKC8I BFELJLE;8 ;8 #<FI>< -F9FKC8IbE K8I@?W<J@E@


P8QD8Pb;YfYEYPFILD \


#<FI>< [!? \ ;<;@ [#<C <M< >@;<C@D D8 XE:<


>@PJ@C<I@E@ 8C E;I<N IF9FK@B BFELJLE;8 9@I D@CPFE B@K8G M8I M<
?<GJ@E;< ;< 9L 9@C@D@E K8I@?W<J@ 8EC8KbCbPFI YEP8 J8;<:< IF

9FKC8IC8;<c@C D8B@E<8;8DC8IC8@C>@C@8PIbEKbCb9@C>@PC<;FC;L \
E;I<N 98fbEb J8CC8;b .FE Q8D8EC8I;8 9L @EJ8E:8 ?8I<B<K@
K8BC@;< 98fC8DbfKb [<E IF9FK@B@E K8I@?W<J@E;<E JXQ <KD@PFILD
#<FI>< '8JK<KK@c@D   " K8I@?@ -F9FKC8IbE @CB D8B@E<
8;8DC8IbE P<IPYQYE;< P8f8D8C8IbE8 M< W8CbfD8C8IbE8 @Q@E M<I

@C;@c@ >YE;<E 9<I@ FC8EC8I ?8BBbE;8 E<C<I ?@JJ<KK@BC<I@E@ 8EC8KD8B


@JK@PFILD \
#<FI><B8fC8IbEbB8C;bI;b8D88WbB8WbB:<M8G;8M<ID<;@


)@E@D@E@ ?8EbDbE J<BJ<E YWYE:Y ;FcLD PbCbEb P<E@ BLK

C8DbfC8I;b D8 B8;bE ?VCV ?<D <E<IA@B ?<D ;< 8Q@DC@P;@ 8

JKFELEL;8P8ED8BK8EWFB@f8I<K<KD<B@W@EBLCC8EbPFI;L
)@E@D@E@ ?8EbD FC8EC8Ib ;@EC<IB<E =<E8 ?8C;< X=B<C<E;@
.FEI8 ['FIBLEW 9@I f<P 9L #<FI>< \ ;<;@ [+ J<IJ<I@C<I ;<
B@D;@\
[@CD@PFILD 58K<E 9LELE E< XE<D@ M8I .FELE;8
E;I<NP89@IQ8I8IM<ID<;@C<IP8 \
[1<I<9@C@IC<I;@ .<E 9@I 8MLB8KJbE #<FI>< 1< ?8C@E M8BK@E ;<
P<I@E;< YKYE 9LEC8Ib E;I<NELE P<K<E<BC<I@E< 9FIWCLJLE
.8?@G FC;LcLDLQ ?<I f<P@E K<D<C@E;< FELE B8Q8E;bcb G8I8C8I
M8I L 8@C<E@E ;<M8DbEb ;8 P@E< E;I<N J8cCbPFI +E8 BLI>LCL
9@IFPLE:8BDbf>@9@;8MI8ED8C8IbE8><C<D<D
#<FI>< [EE< E<P8GD8Db@JK@PFIJLE\;@P<JFI;L
[@I 8MLB8K FC;LcLEL JXPC<;@D .<E 9<E@ ;@EC<D@PFI DLJLE
@I ;<E<D< ;8M8Jb 8WD8P8 W8Cbf XC>< )8?B<D<C<I@E@ IF9FK

C8IbE ?8BC8Ib FC;LcLEL @C8E <KD<P< QFIC8 )<:C@J@E ><I<BC@ P8J

8C8Ib WbB8ID8JbEb J8cC8 #<I<B@PFIJ8 ;8M8Pb YEP8 )8?B<D<J

@E< B8;8I >XKYI .<E@ @QC<P<:<c@D #XFI>< #XI<M;<E B8WbC

D8JbEb?Ff>XIYPC<B8IfbC8D8D \


48fCb B8;bE WFB :@;;@P;@ L @EJ8Eb BFIBLK8E @?K@P8I ?8EbDb


P8KbfKbID8B @W@E 98fC8P8E f<P JFELE;8 B8ID8fbB 9@I FC8P8
;XEYfKY $LBLB 8WbJbE;8E ><IW<BK<E @C>@EWK@ FC8P "<@E>FC; M<
)8IK@E@E <E 9YPYB FIK8cb FC8E #<FI>< JKI8K<A@P@ J8GK8;b 8D8 8JbC
W8CbfD8Pb BYWYB FIK8C8IbE8 9bI8BKb df@E WFcL 8PEb ?LBLB
9YIFJLE;8 W8Cbf8E FcCL ,8LC8 ;YfKY #<EW 8;8D ><C@fD<C<I@
?<I >YE J8;8B8KC< 9YPYB 8EE<J@E< 9@C;@I@PFI;L 48fCb B8;bE ;8
P@E<?<I>YED<J<C<P@E;I<N`C8BFELfLPFI;L
-F9FK 9L FC8P8 @P@:< ;8CDbfKb -F9FKC8IC8 @C>@C@ B@K89bEb JYI<BC@
<IK<C<P<I<B ?LBLB@ K8IKbfD8C8Ib @E:<C@PFI M< 98Q8E ;8 J8P>bPC8
98QbXE<I@C<I;<9LCLELPFI;L
[#<FI>< F >YE 98E8 @EJ8EC8IbE ?<I Q8D8E IF9FKC8I;8E BFIB

KLBC8IbEb JXPC<;@ L 9XPC< FC;LcL JYI<:< D8?B<D<C<I M< D<

:C@JC<I D8B@E< 8;8DC8I 8;bE8 =8QC8 9@I W898 >XJK<ID<P<:<BC<I

;@I '8DLFPLBFELJLE;89@If<PC<IP8GbCD8Jb><I<BD<QD@\
dfK< 9XPC<:< ,8LC D8?B<D<;<PB<E #<FI>< ;8 B8C898CbB
>ILGC8IbE B8IfbJbE;8 BFELfD8C8I P8GD8P8 98fC8;b L J8P<;<
I<JD@ FCD8P8E 9@I K8MbI K8BbE89@C@PFI M< ?8KK8 98Q8E @f@ P<E@ 9FC
BbCbBC8Ib >@P<:<B B8;8I ;8 @C<I@ >XKYIYPFI;L + 9L DF;8;8E
_ I8G< ;@P< ;< JXQ <;@PFI;L ,8LC ;8 [.8?E<;<PB<E 8P8B

C8IbEb<K<BC<I@E<K8BD8J8E 9898 \;@PFI;L


#<FI>< JbBbEKbPC8 JXPC<E@PFI;L [LE8 <E><C FCD8P8
W8CbfbPFILD \
#<FI>< 9@I J<=<I@E;< ?FCF
?89<I <;@KXIC<I@E@E B8IfbJbE;8 9@I
BFELfD8 P8GKb .XQBFELJL BFE=<I8EJbE 9@I P<I@E;< fXPC<
JXPC<;@ [[@B@E:@ 48J8 E<;<E@PC< ?<I?8E>@ 9@I IF9FKK8E JbEbIJbQ @K

88K @JK@PFILQ /89@@ @EJ8EC8I8 Q8I8I M<I@CD<D<J@ f8IKbPC8 L 9@I


@EJ8EbE
?<I?8E>@ 9@I @EJ8EbE IF9FKC8I BFELJLE;8 DYK?@f 9@I
>Y:Y FC;LcL 8EC8DbE8 ;8 ><C@PFI TQ<CC@BC< dB@E:@ 48J8
UWYE:Y;<E ;8?8 XE<DC@ J8PbC;bcb @W@E ?<I?8E>@ 9@I @EJ8E B<E;@E@
BFILD8 P8J8JbEb BFfLCLEL @K88K f8IKbEb BLCC8E8I8B 9@I IF9FKL
<KB@J@Q ?8C< JFB89@C@PFI 48E@ 9L @EJ8E 9@I IF9FK8 JbI8;8E 9@I
E<;<EC< P8 ;8 ?@W9@I E<;<E FCD8;8E B<E;@J@E< Q8I8I M<ID<J@E@


M<?8KK8FIK8;8EB8C;bID8JbEb<DI<;<9@C@PFI
[L 8;@C:< 9@I f<P D@ @I ?8PM8E8 9XPC< ;8MI8EbPFI DLP

LQ df@D@Q< P8I8P8E :8EJbQ 9@I :@JD@ 9@C< XE<DJ<D<D@Q ><I<B@I


PIb:8 9@I IF9FK :8EJbQ 9@I :@J@D ;<c@C;@I PEb Q8D8E;8 ?8PM8E
FCD8;bcb >@9@ @I IF9FKLE B8=8Jb 9@Q@DC< BFELf8:8B D8EKbB
PYIYK<:<B M< f8B8 P8G8:8B B8;8I @P@ W8CbfbPFI +EC8I8
;FJKC8IbDbQDbf >@9@ ;8MI8EbPFILQ @IC@BK< W8Cbf89@C@PFILQ +
?8C;< E<;<E 9L ;FJKCLcLE YIYEC<I@E;<E 9L 9@IC@BK< W8CbfD8EbE
D<PM8C8IbE;8EP8I8IC8ED8JbEC8I
[@I B@DJ<E@E 9@I IF9FK8 @EJ8ECbB @W@E Q8I8ICb FCD8P8E 9@I
<D@I M<ID<P< ?8BBb M8I TPC<PJ< 9L @EJ8E 9@I IF9FK8 D8B@E<
8;8DC8I @W@E Q8I8ICb FC89@C<:<B 9@I <D@I M<ID<P<:<B B8;8I ;8
;YIYJK ;8MI8ED8Cb;bI /89@@ 9@I @EJ8EbE >YM<E@ JXQBFELJL
FC;LcL Q8D8E ;LILD ;<c@f@I F 98fB8 YPYB 9@I >YW 9@IC@BK<
9YPYB JFILDCLCLBC8Ib ;8 ><K@I@I -F9FKC8I @EJ8EC8IbE BFILED8Jb
@W@E -F9FK 48J8JbE8 LPD8B QFILE;8C8I dEJ8EC8IbE IF9FKC8IbE
BFILED8C8Ib @W@E 9@I @B@ P8J8P8 LPD8C8IbEb @JK<D<B WFB DL =8QC8
FCLI\
E;I<N ?8BCbP;b )8?B<D< M< D<:C@JC<I@E B@C@;@ B8DLFP

LP;L .FELE;8 IF9FKC8I @W@E Q8I8ICb FC89@C<:<B <D@IC<I@E M<I

@CD<J@E@E P8J8BC8E;bcb BFfLCC8I 8WbBC8E;b /89@@ G<B WFB @JK@JE8


M8I;b 9L P8J8;8 LE8 B8Ifb ><C<EC<I< M<I@C<:<B :<Q8C8I ;8
P<K<IJ@Q;@ D8 ?@W FCD8QJ8 GI<EJ@G B89LC <KK@I@CD@fK@ .FE
FC8I8B YEP8 )<:C@J@ P8J8Pb ><W@I;@c@ >YE D@E@D@E@ ?8EbD ;8
XC;Y
D8 9L 9@I I8JKC8EKb ;<c@C;@ 48fCb B8;bE JFE K8IKbfD8C8I
JbI8JbE;8 P8f8D8 W8I<J@Q:< JbDJbBb J8IbCDbf 8E:8B Q8=<I
?89<I@ ><C;@c@ Q8D8E B<E;@E@ 9bI8B89@CD@fK@ .FE FC8I8B
E;I<NP8 >YCYDJ<;@ 1< JFE JXQC<I@ ;< [.<E 9@Q< WFB @P@ ;8M

I8E;bE E;I<N \FC;L


)@E@D@E@ ?8EbD <C@ E;I<N`ELE <C@E;< JFE E<=<J@E@ M<I;@
+cCL B8IbJb M< WF:LBC8Ib @J< J8P>bPC8 FEC8I;8E 9@I8Q LQ8BK8
;LILPFIC8I;b


8EbfD8 D<DLIL @W<I@;<B@ 9YIFC8I;8E 9@I@E< >@I<I<B >XQ;<E


B8P9FCLIB<E E;I<N ;8 J89bIC8 9<BC<;@ /89@@ D<DLI ?FCF>I8=@B
;YF=FEL BLCC8E89@C@I;@ 8D8 B8IfbJbE;8B@E@E 9@I @EJ8E ;<c@C ;<
FELE9@IIF9FKFCD8JbB<E;@E@WFBJ8IJDbfKb
E;I<N 9L Q8D8Eb _J8IJD8B B<C@D<J@E@ ;YfYE<I<B ><W@I;@
-F9FKC8IC8 @C>@C@ B@K89bEbE YQ<I@E;< W8CbfbIB<E 98Qb JFILEC8IC8
B8IfbC8fbPFI;L YKYE 8PIbEKbC8Ib @=8;< <;<9@C<:<B :YDC<C<I BLI

D8P8W898C8D8EbEB<C@D<;8c8I:bcbEbQ<E>@EC<fK@I;@c@B<J@E;@
.8Q8E 9@I@ @W<I@ >@I<I<B IF9FK8 98BbPFI E;I<N 9L 98BbfC8Ib
>XID<QC@BK<E ><CD<P< W8CbfDbPFI;L $<I ><C<E D<I8BCbPb J8B@E
J8B@E JYQYPFI 9L PYQ;<E FEC8I ;8 98BbfC8IbEb IF9FKK8E
B8WbIbPFIC8I;b
.FELE;8 ,8LC )8IK@E >XQYBKY e8fbIDbf >XIYEYPFI;L 8?8
;FcILJL E;I<N FELE PYQYE;<B@ @=8;<P@ @P@:< J<W<9@CJ<P;@
9XPC< FC;LcLEL 8EC8P8:8BKb D8 ,8LC JFE Q8D8EC8I;8 WFB
=8QC8 D8BP8A P8GD8P8 98fC8DbfKb )F;8 ?<D B8;bEC8I8 ?<D ;<
<IB<BC<I< 9LEL <DI<;@PFI;L WYEBY )8BP8A ,8LCLE 9@I8Q 8E

C8DJbQ:8 FC8E PYQYEYE ?8KC8IbEb ;8?8 B<JB@EC<fK@I@PFI;L 8D8


E;I<N ?@W ?FfC8EDbPFI;L 9L PXEK<D;<E -F9FK 9L ?FfELKJL

QCLcLEL 8WbBC8D8;bcb JYI<:< @EJ8EC8IbE P8GKbBC8Ib 98Qb f<PC<I@


FE8PC8D8D8EbE B<E;@E@ I8?8KJbQ <KD<;@c@E@ 8EC8DbfKb $8KK8
E;I<N 9L ?FfELKJLQCLcLEL P8Q89@C@PFI;L ;8 D8 ;LILDLE
?<IQ8D8E9XPC<FCD8;bcbE;8E<D@E;@
,8LC [ @W<I@ ><C E;I<N \ ;<;@ [.<E@ 9<BC<KK@c@D @W@E XQYI
;@C<I@D D8 9@K@ID<B QFILE;8 FC;LcLD 9@I @f M8I;b $8P;@ ><C
<E@DC< BFELfD8B @JK<;@c@E@ JXPC<D@fK@E D8 B<EK< ><C<:<c@E@
9@CD@PFI;LD \
[df@EWFBDL ,8LC4FBJ89<BC<P<9@C@I@D
,8LC ;LM8I;8B@ J88K >XI<M@ P8G8E B8;I8E;8 K@KI<f<E
>XC><C<I< 9@I >XQ 8KKb .8E8 Q8D8E 8PbI89@C@I@D 48CEbQ Db
><C;@E
[@IFKFDF9@CKLKKLD \


,8LCFC;LBW8<E;@f<C<E;@ [@IJFILEWbBKbDb\
[XPC<9@If<P@9<BC<D@PFI;LD $8BC8IbDBFILELPFI
,8LCLE <E;@f<J@ ;8?8 ;8 8IKDbfKb [E;I<N J8E8 P8J8EbE
LP>LC8E89@C<:<B 9@I f<P FCD8;bcbEb 8EC8KKbD $@W FCD8QJ8 G<B
WFB BFfLC;8 PIb:8 <C9@J< >@PD<BK< bJI8I <;<IJ<E <E@E;<
JFELE;898fbE;<I;<>@I<:<B +@CBJ<=<IFC;LcL>@9@ \
[dCB M< JFE B<Q FC;L 9L .<E@ BbQ;bI;bPJ8D XQYI ;@C<I@D
,8LC \
[e<P 9LE8 fL 8Wb;8E 98B J<E ?<D<E ?<D<E P8f8P8E 9@I
<=J8E<J@E E;I<N UJK<C@B G<B WFB 98BbD;8E =8QC8 ;<c<IC@J@E
+ELE @W@E B<E;@E@ K<?C@B<P< 8KD8P8 ?@W ?8BBbE PFB ! B@K8G
E8JbC>@;@PFI\
[@KD<BYQ<I< ,8LC 48PbE:bWFBD<DELE \
[dP@\
['@K89b 9<c<E@G 9<c<ED<;@c@E@ 9@CD@PFILD ,8LC <E:< <J

<I@E 9@I IF9FK K8I8=bE;8E P8QbC;bcb @W@E WFB J8K8:8cbEb ;YfYEYPFI


+ELD<DELE<;<E9L \
['FIB8IbDWFB@EJ8E:89@I;YfYE:<9L \
[<E@D 9@I @K@I8QbD PFB '@K8G ?8E>@ E<;<EC< J8K8IJ8 J8KJbE
9L9<E@D@W@EG8I8;<D<B 1<G8I8;8><I<BC@ \
[YPYB8EE<DJ8E8 \
[)@E@D@E@ ?8EbD 98E8 WFB :XD<IK ;8MI8EDbfKb @C<E@E
><I<B@IJ< P8I;bD <;<:<c@E;<E <D@E@D D8 9LE;8E JFEI8
8K8:8cbD 8;bD BFELJLE;8 B@K8GK8E 8C8:8cbD K<C@= Y:I<K@E@E
P8I8IbFC8:8cbEb;YfYEYPFILD \
[$8E>@8;bDDbf9L\
[ -F9FK M< )8B@E< ;8DC8I e@IB<K@E@E PXE<K@:@J@E@
>XID<B @JK@PFILD +E;8E 9@I I8E;<ML 8CD8B @JK<;@PJ<D ;< fL
8E8 B8;8I B<E;@J@E< <I@f<D<;@D e@IB<K B@K89bE P8QbCD8Jb BF

ELJLE;8 9<E@DC< @f9@IC@c@ P8GD8;b + PYQ;<E ;< 9L KLKLDC8IbE8


f8fbID8;bD ECbPFIJLE ;<c@CD@
,8LCLE WFB <cC<E;@c@ 9<CC@P;@ [df9@IC@c@ 9<BC<D<D<C@J@E -F

9FK ?8BC8Ib BFELJLE;8 >@I@fK@c@D@Q F 9YPYB J8M8f JbI8JbE;8 ;8




9@Q< P8I;bD <KD<;@C<I $8KK8 K8D K<IJ@ 9@I K8MbI K8BbE;bC8I LELE
E<;<E@E@ 8EC8P89@C@IJ@E @I IF9FKLE 98Qb ?8BC8Ib FCLIJ8 @EJ8EC8I
FEL8CD8BK8EM8Q><W<9@C@IC<I \
E;I<N [D8 P@E< ;< \ ;<;@ [+EC8Ib 8I8J8E 9<CB@ PXE<K@

:@C<IC<BFELfD8DbJ8cC8P89@C@IJ@E \
[ e@IB<K@E 9<E;<E ;< ;8?8 =8QC8 ?FfC8E;bcbEb J8EDbPFILD
E;I<N \
[D8 9<CB@ FEC8I8 IF9FKC8IbE ?8BC8IbEb ;8?8 J8cC8DC8fKbID8B
@W@E "<@E>FC; M< )8IK@E`@E 98fC8K8:8cb 9@I B8DG8EP8Pb ;LI;LI

89@C<:<c@E@JXPC<P<9@C@IJ@E \
[LP8C8EFCD8QDb E;I<N\
[!M<K ,8LC @C@PFIJLE B@ 9<E P8C8E JXPC<P<D<D dfK< F
PYQ;<EFEC8I8J<EK<C<=FE<KD<C@J@E \
[? J<E P8C8E JXPC<P<D<QJ@E 8D8 9<E@ 9LE8 K<fM@B <;<9@

C@IJ@E XPC< D@ .<E >@K>@;< ;8?8 =8QC8 @EJ8EC8fbPFIJLE


E;I<N \


,8LCLE 8;bEbE XE<D@E< I8cD<E I8E;<ML J8cC8D8B ?@W ;<
BFC8PFCD8;b
D8 JFELE;8 98f8IbP8 <I@fK@C<I #XIYfKYBC<I@ $8IC<P .DPK?<

-F9<IKJFELE 9L ;LILD;8E ?@W ;< D<DELE FCD8;bcb 8EC8fbCbP

FI;L $8IC<P 8EE<J@ K8I8=bE;8E f@IB<K@E BLIL:LJLELE 8@C<J

@E;<E;@ M< 9LEL 9<C@IKD<B @W@E 8;bE8 9@I K@I<PC< F @JD@ <BC<D@fK@
;8DbE <D<BC@C@c@E< 8Q B8CDbf M< 98fB8E FC8I8B 9YKYE ;@BB8K@E@
IF9FK ?8BC8Ib JFILELE8 M<ID@fK@ $8IC<P J<PI<B BbI J8WC8IbEb K<

G<J@E< @P@:< P8GbfKbIDbf M< D8BP8A P8GD8DbfKb I8;8 JbI8;8


E;I<N`P8B8W8D8B98BbfC8IC8;YfD8E:898BbPFI;L
E;I<N [[!=<E;@D \ ;<;@ [$<D<E ?<D<E PYQ PbC XE:< 9L
f@IB<KK< W8Cbf8E )<IKFE )8EJBP 98E8 GFQ@KIFE@B PFCC8IbE J8GK8E

D8JbE;8 BLCC8EbC8E D8K<D8K@B ;<EBC<DC<I@E@E B<J@E WXQYD


J8cC8P8D8P8:8B B8;8I B8ID8fbB FC;LcLEL JXPC<;@ L E<;<EC<
B8G8J@K<C<I@D BFELJLE;8 ;8 ?<I Q8D8E XE:<;<E 9@I f<P
 

JXPC<E<D<P<:<c@E@8WbBC8;b \
[L PYQ PbC XE:<P;@ \ $8IC<P .DPK?<
-F9<IKJFE ;LI8BC8;b
JFEI8 ;8 9LQ >@9@ 9@I J<JC< [!=<E;@D IKbB 9L ;FcIL ;<c@C -F

9FKC8IbDbQ f@D;@ FC;LBW8 ;8B@B M< >XI<MC<I@E@ K8D K8DbE8 P8G8

:8B9@W@D;<GC8EC8EbPFIC8I \;<;@
,8LC f@IB<K@E ?8BJbQCbB P8GD8JbEb XEC<D<B @JK<;@c@E@ JXP

C<P<I<B IF9FKC8 9@IC@BK< ><CD@fK@ MLB8K [!M<K \ ;<;@ [L


PYQ;<E ;< ;8EbfD8;8B@ IF9FKLD8 FC8PC8I 9@I8Q ;<c@f@BC@B >XJ

K<I@IJ<8IB88IB8P8<D@IM<ID<B><I<B@PFI \
$8IC<P .DPK?<
-F9<IKJFE [.FILEC8I8 W8I< 9LCJ8P;b WFB
;8?8I8?8KJbQFCLI;LELQ \;@P<:<M8GM<I;@
E;I<N [IKbB 9<E@D >@9@ <JE<B FC8E M< FC8PC8I8 LPLD
J8cC8P89@C<EIF9FKC8IYI<KD@PFIJLELQJ8EbIbD \;<;@
[!M<K XPC< \
E;I<N 8WbBC8;b ['@K89bDC8 @C>@C@ 8I8fKbID8C8IbD JbI8JbE;8
;FcIL;YIYJKW8Cbf8E<E<JB@IF9FKFC;LcLDL8EC8;bD \
$8IC<P [eL 8E;8 <E <JB@ J@QJ@E@Q \ ;<;@ [ 8@D8 ;8 XPC<
B8C8:8BJbEbQ $@W9@I IF9FK P@ID@ 9<f@E:@ PbC;8E JFEI8 @f< P8I8

D8Q L JYI< JFE8 <I;@c@ Q8D8E FEC8Ib ><I@ 8CbI M< P<IC<I@E<
;8?8P<E@DF;<CC<IM<I@I@Q \
,8LC E8Q@B E8Q@B ;YQ<CKK@ [eL   IF9FKC8I;8E ?@W9@I@
P@ID@ 9<f PbC JFEI8 9@I @f< P8I8D8Q E;I<N 9L 98BbD;8E
FC8c8EYJKY9@I@ \
E;I<N J<WK@c@ PFC;8E @C<IC<D<P< W8CbfbPFI;L [ YEP8EbE <E
<JB@ IF9FKLPLD M< FC8PC8I8 BFC8PCbBC8 LP89@C@PFILD + ?8C;< f@I

B<K@E 98E8 XQ<C 9@W@D;< ;8MI8ED8JbEb 9<BC<P<:<B B8;8I


FC8c8EYJKYJ8PbCD8QDbPbD\
$8IC<P 9LQ >@9@ 9@I J<JC< [*< DYE8J<9<K \ ;<;@ [ @c<I IF

9FKC8I8 ?@W 9<EQ<D<D<E@Q f@IB<K @W@E 9@I LK8EW B8PE8cb @I


f8EJJbQCbB PYQYE;<E J@Q@ ;FcIL;8E ;FcILP8 J8KDbfC8I !c<I B@I

8C8EDbf FCJ8P;bEbQ P<I@E@Q< WFBK8E 9@I 98fB8Jb ><W@I@CD@f


FCLI;L \
E;I<N [dfK< D<J<C< ;< 9L \ ;@P< 8KbC;b [<E XQ>YI 9@I



IF9FKLD '<E;@ B<E;@D@E J8?@9@P@D L E<;<EC< J@Q< 9<E@


;<c@fK@ID<E@Q@ JXPC<D<B @W@E ><C;@D L @f@ J8?@9@E IbQ8Jb
FCD8;8E P8G8D8QJbEbQ .FE Q8D8EC8I;8 9L B@I8 8EC8fD8JbEbE
9@I f8IKb FC8I8B QFIC8 B89LC <KK@I@C@PFI D8 9<E@D Q8D8EbD;8
9XPC<f<PC<IFCD8Q;b \
$8IC<P@E f8fBbECbcbE;8E 9L JXQC<I;<E 9@I f<P 8EC8D8;bcb 8E

C8fbCbPFI;L 0QLE 9@I J<JJ@QC@B P8f8EbIB<E E;I<N ;LM8I;8B@


?FCF>I8=8 98BbPFI;L YKYE IF9FK@B LQD8EC8IbEbE 8;<K8 'FI

LPL:L )<C<c@ J8PbC8E .LJ8E 8CM@E@E XCYD D8JB<J@P;@ 9L TC<C@


@B@ PYQ PbC FCDLfKL D8 E;I<N B@K89bEb P8Q8IB<E .LJ8E
8CM@E@ WFB @P@ K8EbDbfKb *<I<;<PJ< IF9FK LQD8EbPC8 F J8cB<E
K8EbfKbcbE89@C<@E8E8:8BKb
$8IC<P [.@Q@ J@Q@EC< E8JbC ;<c@fK@I@I@D\ ;@P< DbIbC;8E;b [@I
IF9FK FC8I8B J@Q@ 8CbG P<E@ D8B@E< 8;8Db J@Q< E8JbC M<I<9@C@I@D
.FELWK8 9L ;<c@f KFBLf JbI8JbE;8 FIK8;8E B8CBDbf FCLIJLELQ \
.<IKW<>YCYDJ<;@
,8LC JXQ< B8IbfKb [L ?@W ;< QFI 9@I f<P ;<c@C E;I<N` ELE
B@f@C@c@E@E K<D<C@ GFQ@KIFE@B 9<PE@ 4<E@ 9@I IF9FK P8I8KbCD8;8E
;<c@fK@I<C<D<P<:<B K<B P<I@ FI8Jb;bI TPC<PJ< 9L GFQ@KIFE@B
9<PE@E J8?@9@ E;I<N )8B@E< 8;8DbE ;@c<I 9YKYE 8PIbEKbJb IF

9FKLE B@f@C@c@E@ 9FQD8;8E ;<c@fK@I@C<9@C@I 1< 9YKYE 9L 8PIbEKbC8I


;8 9<PE@E D8Cb;bI 48E@ E;I<N 9<PE@E< P<E@ 9@I IF9FK
>XM;<J@E@EJ8cC8ED8JbEb@JK@PFI \
E;I<N ;8 J8B@E J8B@E [!M<K XPC< \ ;@P<I<B $8IC<P<
;XE;Y [.@Q 8E;IF@; YI<K@PFIJLELQ ;<c@C D@ bf >XIYEYfC<I@ :@CK
;FBLJLE8B8;8I @EJ8E89<EQ<P<EIF9FKC8I\
$8IC<P 98fbEb J8CC8;b [!M<K 8E;IF@; YI<KK@B (@=C@ J<EK<K@B
:@CKC<I@ M< B@I@fC<I@PC< WFB ;8 @P@ W8CbfbPFIC8I;b <P@EC<I@ ;bfbE;8
?<D<E ?@W9@I P<IC<I@E;< D8;<E PFBKL UJK<C@B D8;<E IF9FKC8I
B8;8I ;8 J8cC8D M< ;8P8EbBCbP;bC8I $8KK8 8PEb B@CF;8B@ IF9FK

C8I;8E;8?8;8J8cC8DFC;LBC8IbEbJXPC<P<9@C@I@D 
,8LC @C>@C<ED@fK@ [LE;8E ?89<I@D PFBKL ,@P8J8;8 B8W 8E

;IF@;M8I\
 

$8IC<P [$@W PFB \ ;@P< 8WbBC8;b [+EC8I D8;<E DF;<CC<I;<E


WFB WFB ;8?8 G8?8CbP;bC8= @I G@P8J8 8I8fKbID8Jb 9@Q< 8E;IF@;

C<I@E B89LC <;@CD<P<:<BC<I@E@ >XJK<I;@ dEJ8EC8I8 WFB 9<EQ@PFI

C8I;bWYEBY \
E;I<N [+EC8Ib FCLfKLI8E LQD8EC8I ?VCV f@IB<KK< W8CbfbPFIC8I
J8EbIbD \ ;<;@ [dfK< 9<E ;< P<I@D< FI>8E@B 9@I IF9FKLE ><W@I

@CD<J@E@@JK@PFILD @I8E;IF@;@E \
,8LCWFBf8fbI;b [/8EIbDb
$8IC<PB8JB8KbB<J@C;@ [L@DBVEJbQ\
E;I<N [*<;<E @DBVEJbQ\ ;@P< JFI;L [0P>LE 9@I =@P8K
X;<D<P<?8QbIbDK89@@ \
$8IC<P [@Q8E;IF@;YI<KD@PFILQ8IKbB \;<;@
,8LC ?<D<E 8KbC;b [E;IF@; YI<KD<D<P< B8I8I M<ID@fJ@E@Q
D89LXPC<9@IIF9FKLP8G8D8P8:8cbEbQ8EC8DbE8><CD<Q \
$8IC<P 98fbEb J8CC8;b [*< FCLIJ8 FCJLE 8E;IF@; YI<K@D@ B8DL
J@P8J<K@E<8PBbIb
,8LC XBJYI;Y [8P .DPK?<
-F9<IKJFE E;I<N XQ>YI 9@I IF

9FK 1< IF9FK ?8BC8IbEb >8I8EK@ <;<E P8J8C8I:8 ;8 BFILELPFI


$<I?8C;<9LELE=8IBbE;8JbEbQ
["8IBbE;8FCD8QFCLIDLPLD\
[L D8B@E< 8;8D XQ>YI 9@I IF9FK FC8I8B >@P@ED<P@ K<I:@?
<;@PFI dfK< F PYQ;<E IF9FKC8IbE >LILIC8IbEbE BbIbCD8JbEb P8J8B

C8P8E P8J8C8I8 I8cD<E ;YfYE:<J@Q @EJ8EC8I K8I8=bE;8E ?8B8I<K<


LcILPFI .LW M< JLWJLQCLB BFELJLE;8 B8I8I M<ID<C<I@ ><I<B<E
B@DJ<C<I@E ><E<C ?FfELKJLQCLcLE8 E<;<E FCD8P8E 9<C@IJ@Q
J8C;bIbC8I@W@E;8M88WD8BQFI
[ -F9FK e@IB<K@ 9LEL KV 98fbE;8 8EC8Dbf E< P8QbB B@
9898EbQbE?LBLB9YIFJL9L><IW<c@>XI<D<D@fK@ \
,8LC [898D 8IKbB XC;Y \ ;<;@ [D8 9LI8;8 9@I ?<;<=<
PXE<CK@CD@f9<C@I>@E9@I?8B8I<KFC;LcLEL>XIYPFILD
$8IC<P [.@QE<;<EJXQ<;@PFIJLELQ\;<;@
[)YM<BB@C@D E;I<N )8IK@E fL 8E;8 DYM<BB@C@D FC;L
XQ>YI 9@I IF9FK  -F9FK M< )8B@E< ;8DC8I e@IB<K@E;<E 9@I
 

;<c@f KFBLf P8GbCD8JbEb @JK<D<P< ;< ?8BBb M8I e@IB<K 8@C<C<I<


P8EC8IbE;8 W8Cbf8E IF9FKC8I P@ID@ 9<f PbCC8IbEb ;FC;LI;LBC8Ib Q8

D8E P<E@ DF;<CC<I M<I@PFI $8KK8 f@IB<K 9L ;<c@f@BC@c@ P8GD8BK8


bJI8I <;@PFI ,8LC >YCYDJYPFI;L M< JFE ;<I<:<;< ;< I8?8KKb
])YM<BB@C@D@E GFQ@KIFE@B 9<PE@ P@E< DYM<BB@C@D@E >XM;<J@E@E
J8?@9@;@I 1< 9L >XM;< P@ID@ 9<f PbC;8E ;8?8 ;8 <JB@;@I
,FQ@KIFE@B 9<P@E >XM;<E@E ;<c@fK@I@CD<J@E@ K8C<G <;@PFI M< FELE
P<I@E< ><W@I@C<:<B FC8E 8E;IF@; MY:LK @W@E LP>LE 9@I Y:I<K X;<

D<P< ?8QbI L K8C<9@ I<;;<;<IJ<E@Q DYM<BB@C@D ?8B8I<K<


LcI8DbfJ8PbCbIM<9@Q;<f@IB<K@;8M8<;<I@Q
['8DL ><E<CC@BC< 9XPC< 9@I ;8M8;8 IF9FKL ;<JK<BC<D<Q 8D8
?8CBbE f@IB<K@E@Q;<E ?@W D<DELE FCD8;bcbEb J@Q< ?8KbIC8K89@C@I
D@P@D -F9FKC8Ib <E =8QC8 BLCC8E8E M< FEC8I;8E P8I8IC8E8E
B@f@C<I 9@C< f@IB<K< BLfBLPC8 98BbPFIC8I <CB@ 9L IF9FKC8I;8E P8P

>bE 9@I f<B@C;< BFIBLC;LcL F <JB@ >YEC<I;<E B8CD8 9@I f<P <CB@
;< E<;<E 9YKYE ;YEP8;8 IF9FK P8GbDb K<B<C@E@ <C@E;< KLK8E f@I

B<K@E >YW M< Q<E>@EC@c@E< B8Ifb ;LPLC8E X=B< .<9<G E< FCLIJ8
FCJLE 9L X=B< M8I <E ;< 9XPC< 9@I ;8M8P8 B8IbfD8B @JK<D<P<

:<c@E@Q;<E <D@E@D TQ<CC@BC< DYM<BB@C@D Q<E>@E FC;LcL ;8?8


PYQPbCC8I:8 P8f8P8:8cb M< J8M8fb JFEJLQ8 B8;8I JYI;YI<9@C<

:<c@@W@E \
$8IC<P`@E PYQY 8cbI 8cbI BbQ8IDbfKb [<E@ QFIC8D8P8
W8CbfbPFIJLELQ \
,8LC [<E J@Q@ ?@W9@I f<P P8GD8P8 QFIC8DbPFILD \ ;@P<
:<M8G M<I;@ [)YM<BB@C@D@E LP>LE @JK<c@E@ ><I@ W<M@ID<B E@P<K

@E;<PJ<E@Q P8G89@C@IJ@E@Q @Q ;< 98fB8 9@I f<P JXPC<D<;<E


WbB8I >@;<I 8D8 J@Q@ ;8M8 ;8 <;<I@Q SYEBY 9L 9@Q@D
?8BBbDbQ !E@E;<JFELE;89L;8M8PbB8P9<;<IJ@E@Q \
$8IC<P [e<P \;<;@ .FEI8;8JLJKL
,8LC [dJK<c@D@Q@ B89LC <;<:<c@E@Q 8EC8fbCbPFI \ ;@P<
>YCYDJ<;@ [<CB@ K<I<;;YK <;<:<B 8D8 JFELE;8 I8Qb FC8:8B

JbEbQ dQ@E M<I@E ;< 9@I EFBK8EbE YQ<I@E;< ;8?8 ;LI8PbD


)YM<BB@C@D@E GFQ@KIFE@B 9<PE@ f@D;@B@ >XM;<J@E;<E FI>8E@B 9@I


MY:L;8 ><W@I@C@IB<E 9@I Q8IVI >XIYIJ< 9L E< B8;8I XE<DJ@Q


FCLIJ8 FCJLE f@IB<K@ D8?M<;<I@D )YM<BB@C@D@E GC8K@E
@I@;PLD
XQYE;<B@ 9@I K<B 9<P@E B8E8Cb B8IbfbIJ8 B8DLFPLEL f@IB<K 8C<P

?@E< W<M@ID<B @W@E <C@D;<E ><C<E ?<I f<P@ P8G8IbD \ -F9FK8


;XE;Y [YKYE9LEC8IbFE8PCbPFIDLJLE E;I<N\
-F9FK K8D 9@I ;8B@B8 BFELfD8;b 48C8E JXPC<D<B f8EK8A
P8GD8B 9@I @EJ8EbE QFIC8ED8Jb M< BXKY ;LILD8 ;YfYIYCD<J@E@
FE8PC8D8B 8EC8DbE8 ><C@PFI;L E;I<N B<E;@ B<E;@E< 8D8 9L
=@Q@B@ 98BbD;8E Q8I8I >XID<BC< @C>@C@ ;<c@C ;<;@ "@Q@B@ 9@I Q8I8I
PFB
.FELE;8G<B?8=@=9@IJ<JC< [!M<K \;<D<P@98f8I;b


L P<E@;<E P8GbCD8P8 9<EQ@PFI;L E;I<NP8 <JB@ B<E;@J@
;<c@CD@f >@9@ ><C@PFI;L #YEC<I JFEI8 ?8=K8C8I M< JFELE;8 8PC8I
9FPLE:8 JYI;Y 9L ;LILD !E L=8B 9@I ?8I<B<K 9@C< IF9FKLE
B8I8IJbQC8fD8JbE8E<;<EFCLPFI;L
,8LC K<C8f @W@E;<P;@ [@I P<I@E@ J8B8KC8;bC8I E;I<N 8M8
8WD8DbQ><I<B<:<B
E;I<N 8cbI 8cbI [LEL P8GD8D8CbJbE \ ;<;@ [$@W9@I Q8

D8E9LEL f<P B
B
B \
['XKYE@P<KD@;<D<B@JK@PFIJLE\
[!M<K 'XKY E@P<KC< P8GKbBC8IbEb B8EbKC8P8D8QJbE PIb:8 9<E
>@K>@;<>YWC<E@PFI @P@C<f@PFILD LJ8;<:<9@IK
K
K \
[/8C@?J@QC@BD@\
[/I8MD8 @C@PFIJLE ;8?8 XE:< 9XPC< 9@I 8D<
8D<
8D<
?@WP8GbCD8Dbf \
E;I<N 9<PE@E@ @W<I@;<E ?@JJ<;<9@C@PFI;L LEL 98fB8 ?@W
B@DJ< P8G8D8Q;b -F9FK @P@ FC;LcLEL 9@C@PFI;L /8D
BFFI;@E8JPFE M< GFQ@KIFE@B <KB@C<I@ @P@:< XcI<E;@c@ F 8PC8I
JbI8JbE;88PE8EbEXEYE;<J88KC<I><W@I;@
[/8D @EJ8E >@9@ ;<c@C 4YQ @=8;<J@Q ?<D ;< WFB @=8;<J@Q
$8I<B<KC<IJ< WFB 8cbI dEJ8EC8I >@9@ B8PbKJbQ:8 BFC8PCbBC8


?8I<B<K <;<D@PFILD D8 9<CB@ Q8D8EC8 9L ;8 FCLI $@W FCD8Q

J8 8IKbB I8?8KCbBC8 <C9@J< >@P<9@C<:<c@D #@PJ@C<I@E 8I8JbE;8E F


D8;<E JLI8KbD >XQYBD<P<:<B #YCYEW M< >8I@G 9@I ;LILD;L
9L
-F9FKJFELE;8 [<EK<BI8IW8CbfD8P898fC8P8:8cbD
;<;@
,8LC >YC;Y [L ;8 @P@ FC;LcLEL >XJK<I@PFI *< P8G8:8BJbE
@IB@K8G;8?8DbP8Q8:8BJbE\
E;I<N :@;;@ :@;;@ [$8PbI ;<;@ [@I D<JC<c< B<E;@D@
@P@:< B8GKbI8D8P8:8B B8;8I LQLE P8f8P8:8cbD @I Q8D8EC8I
?<I f<P;<E XE:< 9@I J8E8KWbP;bD 4@E< F 8C8E8 ;XE<9@C@I@D @I
Q8D8EC8I K8I@?W@P;@D LE8 ;8 ;<M8D <;<9@C@I@D D8 f@D;@ 9@I
IF9F
9@PFCFA@JKFCD8B@JK@PFILD \
[-F9F
GJ@BFCFA@JK;<D<B@JK@PFIJLEJ8EbIbD
[$8PbI L GFQ@KIFE@B 9<PE@E @E:<C<ED<J@ 8EC8DbE8 ><C@I B@
9<E 9L 8I8 F BFELP8 B8Ifb 9@I @C>@ ;LPDLPFILD <E:< 9@I IF9F

9@PFCFA@JKF9<P@E<98cCbMY:L;LEW8CbfD8JbPC8@C>@C<E@I  \
[LIF9FK@BLQD8ECbcb;<D<B;<c@CD@
[ $8PbI @I IF9FK@B LQD8Eb D8;<E >XM;<C<I YQ<I@E;< W8CbfbI
<E @EJ8EC8IbEB@E< 9<EQ<P<E FI>8E@B 9@I MY:LKC8 @C>@C<E<:<c@D
1<9@C;@c@DB8;8IbPC89XPC<9@I>XM;<J8;<:<9<E;<M8I \
,8LC ;YfYE:<C@ 9@I K8MbIC8 [C8EbEb ;8I8CKbPFIJLE \ ;@P<
DbIbC;8E;b [@I J8E8KWb FC8I8B 9YKYE B8MI8DC8I J<E@E @I K8I@?W@
FC8I8B ;8?8 WFB IF9FKC8IC8 @C>@C<E;@E 1< 9@I IF9F
9@PFCFA@JK FC8I8B
J8;<:<B<E;@EC<@C>@C<E<:<BJ@E \
E;I<N98fbEbJ8CC8;b [XPC<>XQYBYPFI \
-F9FK @f< KV 98fbE;8E 98fC8D8B QFILE;8 B8C;b @PFCFA@ BF

ELJLE;8 9@C>@J@ PFBKL =<E BFELJLE;8 ;8 XPC< SFB ><WD<;<E


B@K8GCbBC8I;8 W8Cbf8EC8I FE8 8CbfKbC8I E;I<N <C<BKIFE@B >XJK<I@
D8B@E<C<I@E@E 98fbE;8 J88KC<I:< FKLILPFI >@PJ@C<I@PC< WFB EFID8C
>XQYBYPFI;L +ELE IF9FK FC;LcLEL 9@C<E 9@IB8W B@f@PJ< FE8 ?@W
B8IbfDbPFIC8I;b
-F9FK <M@E< <BC<;@c@ 9@I F;8Pb C89FI8KLM8I ?8C@E< ><K@I;@


'@K8GCbcbPJ8>@K>@;<Q<E>@EC<f@PFI;L
4bCC8I ><WK@ 1< ,8LC 9@I >YE E;I<N`P8 ><C<I<B [*< P8QbB
B@ 8IKbB IF9FKC8IbE K8I@?W<J@ YQ<I@E;< W8CbfDbPFIJLE \ ;<;@
[ -F9FK e@IB<K@E@E I8;@B8C P<E@ 9@I J@P8J<K LP>LC8D8P8
98fC8P8:8cbEb;LP;LD \
,8LC P8fC8EDbfKb FQLC8E >XQC<I@E@E P<I@E@ =FKF
FGK@B ?Y:I<C

<I8CDbfKb L98BbD;8EE;I<NP8;8?8P8BC8fDbfKb
-F9FK [e@IB<KE<P8GDbf\;@P<JFI;L
[)<IB<Q;< BLCC8EbC8:8B 9@C>@J8P8IC8I YI<K@PFIC8I JCbE;8
9LEC8I ;<M GFQ@KIFE@B 9<P@EC<I )@BIF;8C>8C8I PFCLPC8 ?<I P<I<
<I@f@PFI M< FE @B@;<E 9@E< B8;8I IF9FKC8 98cC8EKb BLI89@C@PFIC8I
-F9FKC8IbE B<E;@ 9<P@EC<I@ PFB +EC8I :?bM 9<PE@E BFCC8Ib 98:8B

C8Ib >XI<M@E@ P8GbPFIC8I 1< 9L @B@J@ =@Q@B@ FC8I8B 9@I9@IC<I@E;<E


8PIbC8I \
[XPC<:<;8?8@P@D@W8CbfbPFIC8I\
\ -F9FK XPC< FC;LcLEL @;;@8 <;@PFI L GIF>I8Db $8IC<P
.DPK?<
-F9<IKJFE XCD<;<E XE:< ?8QbIC8Dbf <E:< 9L J8E8
B8Ifb >XJK<I@C<E 9@I K<GB@ e@IB<K J<E@E >@9@ FEC8IbE 98fbE8 ;<IK
8W8:8B IF9FKC8I P8GD8D8P8 B8I8ICb dfK< 9L PYQ;<E 9<P@EC<
>XM;<P@ 9@I9@I@E;<E 8PbIDbfC8I <PE@E ;<c@fK@I@CD<J@E@ @JK<P<

9@C<:<c@ 9@I >XM;<J@ FCD8P8:8B 1Y:LK @J< 9<PE@ FCD8;bcb @W@E


?@W9@I f<P @JK<D<P<:<B \ ,8LC 9@I 8E ;LI;LBK8E JFEI8
BFELfD8JbEb JYI;YI;Y [-F9FKC8IbE K8I@?W<J@E@ WFB <KB@C<;@E
E;I<N L f8fbC8:8B 9@I f<P e@IB<K J<E@E J8E8KWb PXEYE
PYQYE;<E J8;<:< 9<C@IC@ @fC<I@ P8G89@C<:<B LQD8EC8fDbf IF9FK

C8IYI<KD<BQFILE;8B8C;b
TQ>YICYcYE IF9FK ?8BC8Ib GI<EJ@GC<I@E@E 9<C@IC<ED<J@E< PFC 8WKb
E;IF@; MY:LK YQ<I@E;< bJI8I <KK@c@E @W@E ;<  -F9FK e@IB<K@
JFELE;89<P@EC<>XM;<P@9@I9@I@E;<E8PbI;b \
E;I<N [$<I?8C;< f@IB<K JFELE;8 9@IB8W D@CP8I IF9FKL BFE

KIFC <;<:<B >YWK< ;<M 9@I 9<P@E P8G8:8B \ ;<;@ [YKYE PLDLI

K8C8Ib 9@I J<G<K< BFP8:8BC8I /<?C@B<C@ 9@I f<P 9L $@W ;< LP>LE
;<c@C \


,8LC [ $8BCbJbE J8EbIbD \\ ;@P< :<M8G M<I;@ [D8 ?<I?8C;<


9LEL 98f8ID8C8Ib PYQ PbC;8E LQLE JYI<:<B <E 9L ;<c@f@BC@c@
>XI<:<B B8;8I P8f8P8D8P8:8cbD $8KK8 9<CB@ ><C<:<B PbC8 9@C<
WbB8D8P8:8cbD \\
E;I<N<E;@f<PC< [,8LC\;@P<98cbI;b
MLB8K FDQLEL J@CBK@ [@QC<I XCYDCYPYQ E;I<N .<E@E >@9@
;<c@C@Q L F B8;8I XE<DC@ ;<c@C 48CEbQ J8E8 9@I EFBK8Pb 8WbB

C8D8D ><I<B@PFI <E )8IK@EC<I@E JFELE:LJLPLD EE<D@E


K<PQ<J@E@E KFILEC8Ib =@C8E M8I 8D8 FEC8Ib J8PDbPFILD e8?J<E
BFEKIFCLD;8 FC8E G8I8 J<E@E 8;bE8 98EB8P8 P8KbIbC8:8B 1< @C>@

C@C<I K8I8=bE;8E BFEKIFC <;@C<:<B #<C<:<c@ >XI<9@C;@c@D B8;8IbPC8


<BFEFD@B98BbD;8E>YM<E:<;<FC8:8BJbE \
E;I<N QFICLBC8 [LE8 ?@W ><I<B PFBKL \\ ;@P< DbIbC;8E;b
L B8;8I Q8D8E ><WD@f FCD8JbE8 I8cD<E )8IK@EC<I@E XCD<C<I

@E<?VCV8Cbf8D8DbfKb
,8LC [/8IKbfD8P8CbD \\ ;<;@ [L 9XPC< FC8:8B .<E f@D;@
E<P@EYQ<I@E;<W8CbfbPFIJLE\\
[E;IF@;C<I@E
P8E@ B<E;@D@E8KFD G@CC<I@E;<E ;<c@C ;<
?@;IFB8I9FEC8IbE P8ED8JbE;8E <E<IA@ 8CD8C8IbEb J8cC8P8:8B 9@I
J@JK<D><C@fK@I@PFILD \\
,8LC B8fC8IbEb B8C;bI;b [48E@ FEC8I JFCLP8:8B M< P<D<B P@P<

:<BC<I XPC<D@\
!M<K \\
[LPXE;<E<Q8D8E;8E9<I@@C<IC@PFIJLE\\
[0QLE Q8D8E FC;L #8C@98 B8K8C@Q< <;@C<E BFEKIFCCL
G8IW8C8ED8 @W@E LP>LE 9@I P8ED8 F;8:bcb ?8QbIC8D8Pb
98f8I;bD \\
[D8 E<;<E E;I<N KFD G@C@ ?<I?8b;< WFB ;8?8
YJKYE \\
[<CB@ 98Qb 98BbDC8I;8E D8 8KFD G@C@ @EJ8E:8 9@I f<P
;<c@C^


L @f Q8D8E 8C;b D8 E;I<N`ELE ;8 9FC Q8D8Eb M8I;b


58K<E IF9FK ,8LC ?LQLI @W@E;< XCD<;@BW< 9@I f<P P8GD8B E@P<K

@E;<;<c@C;@
<P@E KFILELELE FcCLELE XCYDY E;I<N`ELE ;YfD8E 9@I
;YEP8PC8 B8Ifb B8IfbP8 B8CDbf >@9@ 9@I ;YfYE:<P< J8GC8ED8JbE8
E<;<E FC;L -F9FK 9L PYQ;<E LQLE Q8D8E XE:< J<WK@c@ PFC;8
;8?89YPYB9@I8Q@DC<@C<IC<D<P@JYI;YI;Y
4@E< ;< 8JCbE;8 K8D 8EC8DbPC8 P8CEbQ ;<c@C;@ @I @EJ8E
XCDYfKY 8D8 "<@E>FC; M< )8IK@E $LBLB YIFJL ?VCV P8fbPFI;L
SYEBY f@IB<KC<I ;< IF9FKC8I >@9@ XCD<QC<I;@ $LBLB 9YIFJLELE
GIF>I8DC8Ib M8I;b M< FEL ;LP>LJLQ:8 @QC@PFI;L L 9YIF M< ,8LC
LE 98EB8:bC8IbE PXE<K@D@E< 9bI8BKbcb G8I8 J8P<J@E;<
E;I<N`ELE J<IM<K@ 8IKbPFI;L "<@E>FC; M< )8IK@E IF9FKK8E ?<I
PbC ;FC>LE 9@I Y:I<K 8C;bBC8Ib @W@E P<E@ P8BD8 F;8:bcbEbE ?LBLB@
P8EC8IbPC8P8BbE;8E@C>@C<E;@
E;I<NELE  -F9FK M< )8B@E< ;8DC8I e@IB<K@E@ Q@P8I<K
<KD< Q8D8Eb ><C;@c@ Q8D8E 9LEL P8CEbQ 98fbE8 P8GKb e@IB<K<
9@I B<I<J@E;< 9<PC< >@KD@fK@ @I B<I<J@E;< ;< ,8LCC8 D8 9L
B<QP8E@YWYE:YB<QP8CEbQ;bM<9@I@EJ8E89<EQ@PFI;L
 -F9FK e@IB<K@ ;<c@fD@f =89I@B8 9YPYB 9@I LQ8P @JK8JP

FELE8 K8fbEDbfKb !E;YJKI@ 8C8EbE;8 YI<K@D P8G8E ;@c<I =89

I@B8C8I ;8 8PEb PFC8 98fMLILPFIC8I;b +EC8IC8 9@IC@BK< G<B WFB IF

9FK ;8 >@KD@fK@ 4<IPYQY >@K>@;< ;8?8 WFB 9@I G8IB8 9<EQ<D<P<


98fCbPFI;L YEP8EbE EY=LJL 9@I D@CP8I;b M< 9L J8Pb ?@W
;<c@fD@PFI;L .8PbC8Ib 9@I ?8PC@ FC8E IF9FKC8IbE 8E:8B PYQ;<
FKLQLELE98cbDJbQ9<PE@M8I;b
e@IB<K@E I8fKbID8 XCYDYEYE )Y;YIY CM@E )8>;<J:L`P;L
.@P8? J8WCb <JD<I J@MI@ J8B8CCb 9@I 8;8D;b <C@E;<E PLB8IbJb Wb

GC8BKb M< J8;<:< DF;8P8 LP8I8B >XcJYE< 9@I f<I@K K8BDbfKb


E;I<N @J< <CC@ 8CKDbf PbC XE:<J@E@E@E DF;8JbE8 >XI< @P@:<
>@P@ED@fK@
)8>;<J:L [.@Q@ K8EbPFILD K89@@ \ ;<;@ [1< J@Q@ >XI;YcYD
@W@E J<M@E@PFILD @Q@D <E YECY YIYEYDYQJYEYQ d?K@P8I $8IC<P


.DPK?<
-F9<IKJFELE J@Q< F B8;8I ;YfD8E FCD8Jb YQYC<:<B 9@I
f<P .@Q@EC<WFBf<P98f8I89@C@I;@B \

E;I<N [LELP@E<;<P8G89@C@IJ@E@Q \;@P<:<M8GM<I;@


[$8PbI F W8cb ><WK@c@D@Q@ J8EbPFILD @I PYQPbC;8E ;8?8
LQLE 9@I JYI<;<E 9<I@ P<IPYQYE;< IF9FKC8I M8I D8 9L ;LILD
;8 ;<c@f@PFI +EC8Ib LQ8P8 PFCC8P8:8BC8I YEP8;8 B8C8EC8IbE
@J<9<P@EC<I@FCD8P8:8B \
[<EM8IbD 1<9<E;YEP8;8B8C8:8cbD \
[ FcIL D8 J@Q@E ;< IF9FK8 9<EQ<I 9@I K8I8=bEbQ G<B PFB
4<E@@JK<c@E@QE<;@I\
[-F9FKCLBK8E 9@I8Q ;8?8 BLIKLCD8B @JK@PFILD L ;<I<:<P<
B8;8I FI>8E@B FC;LcLD8 >XI< P@E< FI>8E@B 9@I <E<IA@ B8PE8cb
@JK@PFILD dfK<GC8EC8I9LI8;8 \
)8>;<J:L GC8EC8I8 ?<D<E 9@I >XQ 8K8:8BKb P8E@ 98fC8E>bWK8
E@P<K@ 9LP;L 8D8 JFEI8 B8JB8Kb B<J@C;@ M< BVcbKC8Ib @C>@PC< @E:<C<

D<P< 98fC8;b @I 8I8 [L @E8EbCD8P8:8B B8;8I Q<B@:< 9@I


f<P \\;<;@ [YKYE9LEC8IbB@D;YfYE;Y\
E;I<N98fbEbJ8CC8;b [<E \\
)8>;<J:L 98fbEb W89L:8B B8C;bI8I8B IF9FK8 98BKb [L MY:L

;LELQ;8 XE<DC@ ;<c@f@BC@BC<I P8GbCD8Jb 8EC8DbE8 ><C@PFI 1< 9L


J8;<:< ;<E<PJ<C 9@I @fC<D FCLI SYEBY 9L>YE< B8;8I 9XPC< 9@I
f<P< ?@W B8CBbfbCD8;b .@Q< 9LEL P8GD8D8EbQb XE<I@I@D +C

;LcLELQ>@9@B8CbE \
E;I<NELE PYQ @=8;<J@ =8QC8 ;<c@f<D@PFI;L D8 J<J@E;<
WFB 9<C@I>@E 9@I J89bIJbQCbB M8I;b [ I )8>;<J:L J@Q ;LILDL ?@W
8EC8P8D8;bEbQ dJK<c@D< LPD8EbQ ><I<B@PFI $@W9@I J<W<E<c@E@Q
PFB 1Y:L;LD8 9L KYI 9@I J@JK<D P8GbC89@C@IJ< @EJ8E MY:LKC8IbE8
;8 P8GbC89@C@I ;<D<BK@I dEJ8E XDIYEY GIFK<QC<IC< LQ8KD8 <c@C@D@
YQ<I@E;< Q8K<E ;LILCLPFI <E@D ><C@fK@I;@c@D M< ><C@fK@ID<BK<
FC;LcLDJ@JK<DC<I;<E;8?8YJKYEYPFBf@D;@
[LELE G8K<EK@E@ "<@E>FC; M< )8IK@E $LBLB YIFJLELE
P8I;bDbPC8 8C;bD L @f@ B<E;@ 98fbDbQ8 ;8 P8G89@C@I@Q 4<E@ P<E@
 

GIFK<QC<I ><C@fK@I<9@C@I@Q .FELE;8 IF9FKC8IbE G<B WFB XQ<CC@c@E@


K8fbP8E @EJ8EC8I FIK8P8 WbB8I + Q8D8E J@Q@E f@IB<K ;< Q8I8I
>XIYI
[[E:8B f@D;@ 9<E@ 8D<C@P8K <;<I M< @C<I@;< 8PEb f8IKC8I
8CKbE;8 9LEL K<BI8IC8D8P8 I8Qb FCLIJ8EbQ G8K<EKC<I@ BLCC8EbC

D8EbQ8 @Q@E M<I@C@I XPC<:< @EJ8EC8I8 GIFK<QC<I@E LP>LC8ED8JbEb


M< IF9FKC8IC8 @C>@C@ K<BEFCFA@P@ BFEKIFCLELQ 8CKbE8 8CDbf FCLIJLELQ
/89@@ @CB 8D<=@P8K 98f8IbPC8 JFELWC8EbE:8P8 B8;8I G8K<EK B@I

8C8ED8P8:8B +G<I8JPFELE ><IW<BK<E 98f8IbCb FC;LcL @P@:< 8E

C8fbC;bBK8E JFEI8 9L @Q@E M<I@C<:<B \ E;I<N 9@I @EJ8E8 9L J<IK


BFfLCC8Ib 8WbBC8IB<E @I@E:@ 48J8EbE E<;<E FC;LcL W<B@E><EC@c@
?@W ?@JJ<KD@PFI;L -F9FK >XIYEYfK< Q8C@DC@c< 9<EQ<P<E 9L ;LI

LDLE8JCbE;8@P@C@BFC89@C<:<c@E@8EC8D8P898fCbPFI;L
)8>;<J:L @P@:< J<IJ<DC<D@fK@ [<E 9XPC< 9@I f<P< B8I8I
M<I<D<D L B8I8Ib f@IB<K PXE<K@:@C<I@ 8C89@C@I L ;8 Q8D8E
@JK<I \
E;I<N [@I JYI< 9<BC<P<9@C@I@D \ ;<;@ [D8 J8;<:< LP

>LE 9@I JYI< \ .FEI8 ;8 D<DELE D<DELE ,8LC 9LE;8E ;8?8


@P@J@E@P8G8D8Q;b ;@P<;YfYE;Y


E;I<N ><IW<BK<E LP>LE 9@I JYI< 9<BC<D<B QFILE;8
B8C;bPJ8;88D<C@P8K98f8IbCbFC;L
)8>;<J:L [L 8D<C@P8KbE WFB 8C<P?@E;<P;@D E;I<N \
;<;@ [D8 J8E;bcbE E<;<EC<I PYQYE;<E ;<c@C L ;<E<P<
?@W9@I @K@I8QbD PFBKL /89@@ 9@I 98fB8JbEbE YQ<I@E;< P8GbCD8Jb
f8IKbPC8 WbBW8Jb GFQ@KIFE@B 9<PE@E@ K<?C@B<P< 8KD8B ?@W ?FfLD8
>@KD<D@fK@ e@D;@ GFQ@KIFE@B PFCC8IC8 LP8IbCDbf J@E@I B8E8CC8Ib
9@I9@IC<I@E@<KB@C@PFI 1Y:L;LEBXKYC<f@IJ<9<PE@E@Q8I8I>XID<;<E
BLIK8ID8DbQDYDBYEFCD8P89@C@I \
E;I<N [ -F9FK e@IB<K@E@E LQD8EC8IbEbE LJK8CbcbE8
>YM<E@PFI;LD \;@P<:<M8GM<I;@ [IKbBP<D<BP@P<9@C@I@D \
[!? 9@I8Q Q<PK@EP8cb @W<9@C@IJ@E .8E8 ;8?8 XE:<



8WbBC8;bcbDbQ >@9@ P8ED8 F;8:bcbEbE Q8D8E Q8D8E K<D@QC<E

D<J@><I<B<:<B <E:<9L9@I8QI8?8KJbQCbBM<I@:@9@I;YfYE:< \
[<CB@ 8?8 @C<I@ >@KD<P@ GC8EC8D8J8 ] D J<E@E >@9@
;YfYEYI;YD J8EbIbD +;8:bcbE B<E;@ B<E;@E@ K<D@QC<D<J@E@
J8cC8D8B FC8E8BJbQ 9@I f<P ;<c@C $8KK8 f@D;@ @WC<I@E;<
P8E8D8P8:8B D8;;<C<I 9LCLE8E B8Kb P@P<:<BC<I@ <KB@C<P<:<B 9@I
J@JK<D YQ<I@E;< W8CbfbPFILD 48E@ 9L G8IW8:bBC8I J@E;@I@C<D<Q
M<8KbCD8C8Ib;8><I<B@I \
[+Q8D8E9@ID8B8KFCLfKLID8E><I<B<:<B \
[+E89<EQ<I9@If<P \
[8fB8 E;I<N\
[8fB8?<If<P \
[@EJ<CFI>8EC8I;8Db\
[,C8EC8IbD8 LP;LBC8Ib B8;8IbPC8 1Y:L;LD 9@I KL8C 9<E@D
+ELEYQ<I@E< \
)8>;<J:L IF9FKLE :YDC<J@E@ K8D8DC8D8JbEb 9<BC<;@ D8
E;I<N J<J@E@ WbB8ID8PbE:8 9L @f@ B<E;@J@ P8GKb [ @I @EJ8E I<

JD@D@W@Q<:<BJ@E\
E;I<N [8B8CbD \;<;@ [#XI<:<c@Q \
)8>;<J:L [L ;<c<IJ@Q 9@I @JK<B E;I<N \ ;@P< =@BI@E@ 8WbB

C8;b [.<E 9@I @EJ8E;8E ;8?8 YJKYEJYE D8 FI>8E@B FCD8Pb K<I

:@?<KK@c@E8EPFBLf8f8cb>@KD<P<98fC8;bE \
[<PE@D<?@W9@If<PFCD8;b \
[!M<K FCD8;b LEL B89LC <;@PFILD D8 E;I<N J<E@E
8;bEC8 G@P8J8P8 JYIYC<E G8K<EKC<I@E J8P<J@E;< 9YKYE GIFK<Q
8C8EbE;8 P<E@ 8f8D8C8I FC;L +EC8Ib J<E@E ><C@fK@I;@c@E 9@C@E@PFI
M< ?<IB<J J8E8 J8P>b ;LPLPFI $<D ;< 9L ?8C@E;< *<;<E
MY:L;LEC898fB8FPLEC8IFPE8D8P8B8CBbPFIJLE\
-F9FK:<M8GM<ID<;@
T;YCC<I 9@I9@I@E@ @QC<;@ E;I<N 9@IB8W :@;;@ ;<IE<c@E YP<C@c@E@
B89LC <KK@ LEC8IbE 8I8JbE;8 FELE K<D<C@E@ 8KKbcb P<E@ 9@C@DC< @C>@

C<E<E 9@I :<D@P<K ;< M8I;b + 9L 9@C@D< IF9F


9@PFCFA@ 8;bEb M<I

D@fK@ D8f@D;@?<IB<JFE;8EGIFK<QFCFA@;@P<JXQ<;@PFI;L
 

E;I<N` ELE P8GbCbfbEbE PYQ <CC@E:@ PbC;XEYDYE;<  -F9FK


e@IB<K@E;< FELE FELILE8 9@I P<D<B M<I@C;@ -F9FK FC8PbE >YCYEW
9@IP8EbFC;LcLEL;YfYE;Y8D89L=@BI@E@B<E;@J@E<J8BC8;b
IKbB <D<BC@P< 8PIbCDbf FC8E CM@E )8>;<J:L P<D<BK<
BFELfD8 P8GD8B @W@E B8CBbG ><C;@ + ;8 8IKbB ;FBJ8E ;XIK
P8fbE;8P;b 48f8D8JbEb GIFK<QC<I J8cCbPFI;L LEC8IbE 8I8JbE;8
B8I8:@c<I M< 9X9I<BC<I@E >XI<MC<I@E@ P8G8E J@JK<DC<I ;< M8I;b
)8>;<J:L BbJ8 8D8 ;LP>LCL 9@I BFELfD8;8E JFEI8 [4YQ <CC@
PbCCbB IF9FKLE f<I<=@E<\ B8;<? B8C;bI;bcb Q8D8E P<D<B ;< <E
?<P<:8ECb8EbE8<I@fD@fFC;L
E;I<N ;LP>LC8IbEb 9<CC@ <;<9@CD<B @W@E PYQ B8JC8IbEb P<E

@;<E P8GKbIDbfKb D8 9YKYE KXI<E JbI8JbE;8 @=8;<J@Q 9@I PYQC<


FKLI;L [4YQ<CC@PbCCbBIF9FK\FCD8B?FfLE8>@KD@PFI;L


.FELE;8 E;I<NELE ;YEP8;8E 8PIbCD8JbE8 GIFK<QFCFA@
E<;<E FC;L 4YQ <CC@E:@ PbC;XEYDYEY BLKC8D8JbEb @QC<P<E LQLE
PbCC8I;8 P P<IW<B@D@ ;bfbE;8 ?<I 98BbD;8E ;YEP8P8 9<EQ<P<E
9@I?8C8C;b P;8B@P<I8CKbB<EKC<I@WFBB8C898CbBKb
+I8;8 GIFK<Q J@JK<DC<I@ ><C@fK@I@C@IB<E ;8?8 ?8=@= FC8E P<I

W<B@D@E@E ;@BB8K< 8CbED8Jb ><I<B@PFI;L E;I<N 9<f PbC P;8


B8C;b #<I<BC@ 8P8IC8D8C8Ib P8GD8B @W@E P<I<C GIFK<QFCFA@ LQD8E

C8IbPC8 W8CbfKb df@ FCD8;bcb Q8D8EC8I IF9FKC8IbE 8I8JbE;8 ;FC8fbP

FI D8B@E< 8;8DC8I;8 FE8 J8;<:< @EJ8EC8IbE ?8BBb FC8E F


;8CB8MLBW8J8P>bPb>XJK<I@PFIC8I;b
E;I<N JFELE;8 P8 >XI< ;8?8 JbBb:b M< J<JJ@Q FC8E
;YEP8P8 ;XEDYfKY LEL ?89<I M<ID<B @W@E "<@E>FC; M< )8IK@E
$LBLBYIFJLE8;8>@KK@
YIFELE 98fbE8 ><WD@f FC8E .@DFE <(FE> IF9FKL
B8IfbJbE;8 >XIYE:< f8fbI;b [ XE<:<c@E@Q@ ?89<I M<ID@fC<I;@
E;I<N \ Q B8CJbE 8P )8IK@E ;@P<:<BK@ [.@Q@ ><C<:<B ?8=K8
9<BC@PFI;LB \\
E;I<N J89bIJbQ:8 [ 8?8 =8QC8 9<BC<P<D<;@D \ ;<;@
 

'FELP8 >@ID<B @W@E 8:<C< <;@PFI;L [P;8 P@ID@ 9@C@D


8;8DbE;8E FCLf8E 9@I 8I8fKbID8 K@D@E@E 98fbE;8P;bD .@DFE
1<I;@c@D <D@IC<I< B@DJ< B8Ifb WbBDbPFI;L P;8B@ IF9FKC8I 98E8
@EJ8EDbfbD >@9@ J8P>b >XJK<I@PFIC8I;b TPC<PJ< 9<E E<;<E 9@I
@EJ8E;<c@C@D\
<(FE>`LE >XQC<I@E;< BLfBLCL 9@I @=8;< 9<C@I;@ [[.<M>@C@
E;I<N 9@I8Q XE:< ;< 8WbBC8;bcbEbQ >@9@ ?<D IF9FKC8I ?<D ;<
@EJ8EC8I J@Q< 9<C@IC@ 9@I K8MbI >XJK<ID@fC<I 48E@ J@Q< @EJ8E

DbfJbEbQ>@9@;8MI8EDbfC8I XPC<PJ<J@Q=@@C<E9@I@EJ8EJbEbQ \
["@@C<E @EJ8E FCD8B P<K<IC@ J8PbCD8Q 8E8 @EJ8EDbfbD >@9@
;8MI8ED8C8Ib P<K<IC@ ;<c@C <E P8J8C8I8 ;8 >XI< @EJ8E J8PbCD8B
@JK@PFILD '8ELE<E9@I@EJ8EFCD8CbPbD \
<(FE> [0 8G8PIb 9@I BFEL \ ;<;@ [XPC< 9@I ;LILD;8 @E

J8E:8 XEP8I>bC8IC8 B8IfbC8fbIbQ *< B8;8I @EJ8E8 9<EQ<IJ<E@Q


9<EQ<P@E8JCbE;8XPC<  "#"" ><IW<c@PC<;< \
E;I<N [<E ?8E>@ 98BbDC8I;8E @EJ8E ;<c@C@D\ ;@P<
JFI;L [@W@D@D 9@I @EJ8EbEB@ >@9@ dEJ8EC8I;8B@E< 9<EQ<I FI>8E

C8IbD M8I $8KK8 FI>8EC8IbD GIFK<Q J@JK<DC<I@E;<E P8I8IC8E8E @E

J8EC8IbEB@E@E 8PEb dEJ8E BYCKYIYE< J8E8K <;<9@P8K M< 9@C@D


8C8EC8IbE;8 B8KBbC8I;8 9LCLE;LD eL 8E;8 P8f8P8E @EJ8EC8I
B8;8I?<D;< 8fB8E<@JK<P<9@C@IC<I\
[<E 98fB8 9@I f<P @JK<D<Q;@D D8 @f@E BXKYJY @EJ8E
FC;LcLELQL 8E:8B YEP8 )<:C@J@ @C8E <;<9@C@I WbBW8Jb FEC8IbE
9XPC<9@If<PP8G8:8BC8IbEb?@WJ8EDbPFILD \
[)<:C@JK<B@D@EC<BFELf89@C@I@D\
[<CB@@C@DM</<BEFCFA@'FD@K<J@E@E98fB8EbPC8 \
[+ELEC8BFELfD8DbJ8cC8IDbJbEbQ\
[D89@I8I8:bP8@?K@P8:bEbQPFBB@ .@Q@E;LILDLELQ;8 \
[$8PbI LEL J@Q J8cC8PbE \ E;I<NELE 8BCbE8 9XPC<:< 9@I
@EJ8E8 B<J@E <D@I M<I;@c@ ><CD<;@ 9@C< P`;8 9LE8 8CbfDbfKb
[+ELE "<@E>FC; M< )8IK@E`@E 9L BFEL;8 9<E@ JFELE8 B8;8I
;<JK<BC<;@c@E@9@CD<J@E@@JK@PFILD \
[e<P 8D8  \


[.FELE8 B8;8I .@DFE <E PYQ P<KD@f YW PbCCbB P8f8EKbD


9FPLE:8 9L 9YIFP8 fL P8 ;8 9L 9@W@D;< XE<DC@ B8KBbC8I;8 9L

CLE;LD #<WD@fK< 9LI8;8 W8Cbf8E 98Qb B@DJ<C<I< B8Ifb B@f@J<C


D@EE<K 9FI:LD M8I;b D8 8IKbB ?<I f<P ;<c@fK@ LILD f@D;@
9LELEK<IJ@M<9<E98E8FC8E9FIWC8IbEX;<ED<J@E@@JK@PFILD \
<(FE> [!C@D;<E><C<E@P8G8IbD \;<;@


@C@D M< /<BEFCFA@ 'FD@K<J@ 98fB8Eb FcL JP8 9XC><J@E;<E
?<< (@
$J@E> 8;bE;8 9@I B8;bE;b IB8JbE;8B@ @JK<;@c@ f<PC<I@
bfbCKbJbPC8 >@QC<P<E J8P;8D >@PJ@C<IC< GC8JK@c< J8IbCDbf >@9@
>XQYBYPFI;L
'8;bE [.@Q< @EJ8EC8I8 XQ>Y KYD ?8BC8IbE M<I@CD<J@E@
@JK<D<E@Q@E E<;<EC<I@E@ 8ECbPFILD \ ;<;@ [@I Q8D8EC8I 9<C@IC@
98Qb >ILGC8I ;8 KYD @EJ8E:8 ?8BC8Ib <C;< <;<9@CD<B @W@E
J8M8fKbC8I D8J@Q;<FCD8P8E?8E>@?8BBb@JK<P<9@C@IJ@E@QB@\
[48f8D8B ?8BBb >@9@ G<B 98J@K 9@I f<P@ @I IF9FKL ?<I 8E
JXBYGG8IW8C8IbE88PbI89@C@IC<I \
[@I@EJ8EbG8?<I8E@;8D<;<9@C@IC<I \
[@I @EJ8E 8E:8B B8ELE@ @fC<DC<I;<E JFEI8 @;8D <;@C<9@C@I
<E@ G8IW8C8D8C8Ib @W@EJ< P8I>bC8D8 ><I<BD<Q .FELELE
><CD<J@ @W@E P<KB@J@ FC8E 9@I K<B @EJ8EbE JXQY P<K<IC@ FCLI
PIb:8 8PIb:8 \ E;I<N W8I<J@Q:< P8CM8I;bcbEbE 8E

C8fbCD8D8Jb @W@E S898CbPFI;L D8 ;@BB8KC< ?8QbIC8EDbf FC8E @E

J8E:8 PYQ @=8;<C<I@ M< J<J@ FEL <C< M<I@PFI;L [#<IW<B fL B@


9<E @EJ8E FCD8B @JK@PFILD LEL 8CKb @EJ8E E<JC@ 9FPLE:8 ?<G
@JK<;@D \
(@
$J@E> 98fbEb B8C;bI;b 'FPL I<EB >XQC<I@E;< 8EC8Pbf M8I;b
[)<:C@J @EJ8E FC;LcLELQL 8WbBC8P8E 9@I B8ELE WbB8I89@C@I $8KK8
K8f 9@I ?<PB<C@E @EJ8E J8PbC8:8cbEb 9<C@IK<E 9@I P8J8 9@C< ><W@I@C<

9@C@I D8 J@Q@E M< F K8f ?<PB<C@E @EJ8E FCLG FCD8;bcb ;8


K8IKbfD8 >XKYIYI /<DJ@C:@C<I )<:C@J@ YP<C<I@ ;< EY=LJLE ><I@
B8C8E 9XCYDY >@9@ @EJ8E UJK<C@B IF9FKC8I;8E ;8 ?<I Q8D8E


BLfBLC8EbC;b \
[e@D;@9@C<D@\
[e@D;@ 9@C< .@Q@E @EJ8ECbB ;<E@C<E X;YCY ?8B <KK@c@E@Q ><I

W<c@E@ B89LC <;<I@Q D8 P@E< ;< @JK<ED<P<:<B 9@I <DJ8C P8I8K

DbfFCD8BK8EBFIB8IbQ \
[$8E>@ <DJ8C /<B XQ>YI IF9FK 9<E@D L K@G DF;<CC<I@E @CB@
M< JFELE:LJL $@W9@I Q8D8E 9<E@D >@9@ 9@I IF9FK ;8?8 FCD8P8

:8B LEL -F9FKe@IB<K@E<JFI89@C@IJ@E@Q \


[_$@W9@I Q8D8E` WFB LQLE 9@I JYI< E;I<N 48 ;8 XPC<J@E@
K<I:@? <;@PFIJ8EbQ 8P )8IK@E SYEBY 9<E J@Q@E 9@I @EJ8E
FC;LcLELQL B89LC <;@PFILD D8 /<DJ@C:@C<I )<:C@J@ YP<C<I@E@E
WFcL 9XPC< 9@I <DJ8C P8I8KD8B @JK<D<P<:<B XPC< 9@I <DJ8C E<
B8;8I 8EC8DJbQ M< XE<DJ@Q FCLIJ8 FCJLE 8P )8IK@E J@Q@ 8E

CbPFILD 8D8 LDLKC8ED8EbQb JXPC<P<D<P<:<c@D $8KK8 \ ?<<


(@$J@E> B8fC8IbEb B8C;bI8I8B 8IB8JbE8 P8JC8E;b [$8KK8
K8IKbfD8C8I =8QC8 ?<P<:8ECb 9@I ?8C 8CbIJ8 ?<D D<:C@JK< ?<D ;<
;bf8Ib;8 JXQYEY <KK@c@E@Q G8IW8C8ED8EbE P8GbCD8Jb @JK<E@C<9@C@I
L BXI;YcYDY WXQD<E@E <E BFC8P PFCL J@Q@ G8IW8C8IbEbQ8 8PbI

D8B FC89@C@I L BFEL;8 bJI8I <KD<;<E XE:< 9YKYE 9LEC8Ib


;YfYED<C@J@E@Q \
E;I<N [$@W B@DJ< GIFK<QFCFA@ K<BE@c@E@ ?8KbIC8D8Q Db $<

D<E?<D<EJ8;<:<9<E@DFC8E9L9@C@D@\
[L JXQC<I@D J@Q< Q8C@D:< ><C<:<B 9<CB@ 8D8 ?8KbI

C8D8QC8I 48 ;8 ?8KbIC8IC8I 8D8 J@Q@E 8C<P?@E@Q;< FC8:8B 9@I


9@W@D;< L 9@C@D@ JbI= B<E;@E@Q @W@E ><C@fK@I;@c@E@Q@ @;;@8 <;<IC<I
LELE @EJ8EC8Ib IF9FKC8fKbID8 B8DG8EP8EbQbE 9@I G8IW8Jb
FC;LcLEL P8 ;8 IF9FKC8Ib @EJ8EC8fKbID8 B8DG8EP8EbQbE 9@I
G8IW8Jb FC;LcLEL JXPC<IC<I $<I @B@ ;LILD;8 ;8 BXKY M< 9<C8
FC;LcLELQ;8E JXQ <;<IC<I .@Q ?@W J@P8J@ 9@I E<=I<K B8DG8E

P8JbE8 B8KbCD8;bEbQ 8P )8IK@E 8E8 @E8EbE .@Q@E ;< 9<E@D


;< @E8E8D8P8:8cbEbQ KYI;< 9@I @=K@I8 M< BXKYC<D< J<C@PC<
B8IfbC8fbIJbEbQ 1< 98Qb @EJ8EC8I ;8 9YKYE JXPC<E@C<EC<I< @E8EbI

C8I 48f8DbEbQb 9<I98K 9@I ?8C< JFBD8PbE \ P8c8 B8CBKb $VCV




@JB<DC<;< FKLI8E E;I<NELE P8EbE;8 BYWY:YB 8;<K8 9@I WF:LB


>@9@;LILPFI;L
-F9FK [dEJ8ECbcbD @W@E J8M8fD8P8 B8I8I M<I@IJ<D \ ;<;@
[<E@;<JK<BC<ID@J@E@Q\
(@
$J@E> 9@I 8E ;YfYE;Y .FEI8 ;8 [!M<K \ ;@P< :<M8G
M<I;@ [)YDBYE FC;LcL B8;8I E:8B 9L KYI 9@I KLKLD J@P8J@
><C<:<c@D@ K<?C@B<P< JFB8IJ8 J@Q@ K<IB<KD<B QFILE;8 B8C89@C@I@D
SYEBY 9L BFELELE @E8E;bcbD f<PC<IC< ?@W9@I @C@fB@J@ PFB .@Q@EC<
;YIYJKW<BFELfD8P8W8CbfbPFILD 8P)8IK@E \
[/<f<BBYI <;<I@D .@Q;<E ;8?8 =8QC8JbEb @JK<D<P<:<c@D
.FELW E< FCLIJ8 FCJLE 9L BFEL;8 J8M8f8:8B J@Q;<E ;<
DYDBYEFC;LcLJYI<:<98E8P8I;bD<KD<E@Q@@JK<P<:<c@D \


L 8WbBK8E 8Wbc8 >@I@f@C<E 9@I J8M8f ;<c@C;@ "<@E>FC; M<
)8IK@E IF9FK8 J89bICb FCD8JbEb XE<I@PFIC8I;b E;I<N ;8 X=B<PC<
[.89IbD JFEJLQ \ ;@P< ?FDLI;8EbPFI;L "<@E>FC; M< )8IK@E
;8?8 JFEI8 W8IGbfD8 8C8EbEb JbEbIC8D8B M< ;8I8CKD8B @W@E 9@I
B8DG8EP898fC8KKbC8I
/8BD8 B8CGC< P8f8P8E 9@I ?8JK8P8 FC8E 9FI:L X;<D<P<I<B
FELE 8C<P?@E< ;8M8 8WKbC8I -F9FK@B 9@I FI>8Eb FC;LcL @W@E @EJ8E

CbBK8E LQ8BC8fDbf FC;LcLEL @;;@8 <KK@C<I [XPC<:< 8E8P8J8EbE


K8Eb;bcb?8BC8IFELE@W@E><W<IC@;<c@C \;<;@C<I
.8M8fb LJK8CbBC8 M< @E8KC8 JYI;YIYPFIC8I;b $<I 8;bD;8
;8M8Pb B8P9<;@PFI 8D8 9XPC<:< B8I8I B8GJ8DbEbE DYDBYE
FC;LcL B8;8I ><E@f KLKLCD8JbEb J8cCbPFIC8I;b .FEI8 YEP8
)8?B<D<J@E<98fMLI;LC8I
.8M8fPbCC8I:8JYI;YM<D@CPFEC8I:8;FC8I8D8CFC;L
.FE B8I8I 8WbBC8E;bcb Q8D8E <(FE> P8J8C B8PbG
PYQYE;<E 9@I Q8=<I KXI<E@ K<IK@GC<;@ E;I<N ;8 F JbI8;8
9YIF;8P;bK89@@
<(FE> [@Q @B@ f<P@ 98f8I;bB E;I<N \ ;@P< 8WbBC8;b
[LEC8IbE @B@J@ ;< WFB @P@ @I@E:@J@ 9@I @EJ8EbE MY:L;LE;8 E<


B8;8I WFB GIFK<Q FCLIJ8 FCJLE 9LELE F B@DJ<P@ @EJ8ECbBK8E


WbB8ID8;bcb ><IW<c@E@ B89LC <KK@I;@B dB@ B8DLELE 9L JFILEC8 @C

>@C<ED<J@E@ M< BFELELE <E ><E@f 9@W@D;< PFILDC8ED8JbEb


@JK<D<J@E@ J8cC8;bB SYEBY ?<I @EJ8E J8c B8C89@CD<B @W@E GIF

K<Q;<EP8I8IC8ED8B@JK<I \
E;I<N JFI;L [.<E:< D<:C@J @EJ8E FC;LcLDL B89LC
<;<:<BD@\
<(FE> 9@I8Q JbBbC;b [WbBW8Jb 9L 98BbD;8E @P@DJ<I FC8D8D
YEP8 )8?B<D<J@E@E @EJ8ECbB XCWYJY FC8I8B BLCC8E;bcb 9@I K<B
FI>8EM8I dEJ8EC8IbE9<P@EC<I@FI>8E@B?Y:I<C<I;<EFCLfLPFI
-F9FKC8IbEB@ @J< GC8K@E
@I@;PLD;8E P8GbCDbf 9@I GFQ@KIFE@B
9<P@E .<E@E 9<PE@E@E ;< GFQ@KIFE@B FC;LcL B<J@E ? ?8PbI
E;I<N XPC< 98BD8 $Y:I<C<I;<E FCLf8E 9<PE@E <f@E@ P8I8K8

:8B 9@C>@D@Q PFB 48E@ D8?B<D<E@E B8I8IbE8 LP8:8B B8;8I FI

>8E@B K@G< 9<EQ<P<E 9@I 9<P@E P8I8K8:8B 9@C>@D@Q L @f@ J<E 9@C<
98f8I8D8QJbE \
]+?8C;<E<P8G8:8cbQ\
[/89@@ 9@I >@I@f@D;< 9LCLE8:8cbQ UP< (@
$J@E> 9@Q;<E
P8E8 @Q@ ;<JK<BC<P<E ;@c<I D<:C@J YP<C<I@E@E J8PbC8Ib ;8 >@K

K@BW< 8IKbPFI 8fB8EbE 9L BFEL;8 WFcLECLcLE K8I8=bEb KLK8:8cb


B<J@E \
[SFcLECLB9@Q;<D@\
[$8PbI D8 B8DL @EJ8ECbB B<C@D<J@E@E <E ><E@f 9@W@D;<
PFILDC8ED8JbE;8 bJI8I <;<IB<E 9LELE J<E@ B8GJ8D8JbE8 I8Qb
FCLIJ8FQ8D8EWFcLECLB9@Q;<FCLI /89@@9LQ8Pb=9@IFC8JbCbB
LEL 9<E ;< @K@I8= <;@PFILD D8 J8M8fK8E M8Q><WD<B
@JK<D@PFIJ8EFQ8D8E9LBLD8IbFPE8D8CbPbQ \
[18Q><WD<B@JK<D@PFILD \

/<DJ@C:@C<I )<:C@J@ UP<J@ ?<< (@


$J@E> E;I<NPC8 @CB
B8IfbC8fD8C8IbE;8E 9<I@ FC;LBW8 P8fC8EDbfKb + J8P;8D


BbCbBC8Ib WFBK8E 9<I@ >@PD@PFI;L .8WC8IbEb BbJ8 B<JK@I@PFI;L


UQ<I@E;< 9FILDJL >@PJ@C<I M8I;b LE8 B8IfbCbB E;I<N 9@I
PYQPbC XE:< @CB B<Q >@P@ED<P< 98fC8;bcb Q8D8EB@ DF;8P8 LP

LPFI;L /89@@Q<MBJbEbIC8IbEb=8QC8QFIC8D8;8E
'8;bE [)YDBYE FC;LcL B8;8I @C<I@ >@KK@B E;I<N \ ;<;@
[I8;8E JFEI8 K<BI8I ;<E<P<:<c@Q D8 8WbBW8Jb P<E@C>@
B<J@E IKbB 9YKYE 9LEC8I;8E M8Q><W@CD<J@ ><I<B@PFI .FE
Q8D8EC8I;8B@ W898C8IbD PYQYE;<E P8BC8f8E J<W@D B8DG8E

P8JbE;8P<E@C>@P<LcI8P8:8cbD \
E;I<N [@C@PFILD \ ;@P< DbIbC;8E;b [dE8EbE 9L 9<E@
YQYPFI @I B<I<J@E;< @f 9L EFBK8P8 ><C@IJ< 9<E@ I<;;<

;<:<c@E@JXPC<D@fK@E LELE<;<EP8GD8;bE\
[dEJ8E =@BI@E@ ;<c@fK@I<9@C@I )<:C@JK< 9@I ;<MI< ;8?8 B8C89

@CD<E@E 9<;<C@ J<E@ K<IB<KD<BK@ 1< E<;<EJ< 9L 9<;<C 98E8


=8QC8 PYBJ<BD@f >@9@ ><C;@ 58K<E D<:C@JK< P@ID@ 9<f PbC;8E
;8?8LQLE9@IJYI<B8C;bD L;8P<K<I \
[FEC8IbE=@BI@E@;<c@fK@ID<E@E9@IPFCLPFBDL ?<<\
[)8EKbBCb JXQC<I@ ;@EC<D<P< ?8QbI FC8EC8IbE =@B@IC<I@E@
;<c@fK@ID<P@ 98f8I;bB D8 ><I@ B8C8EC8I P8E@ WFcLECLB ;LP

>LJ8CE<=I<KC<I@E;<EM8Q><WD<B@JK<D@PFIC8I \
[ LP>LJ8C E<=I<K fL P8 ;8 9L 9@W@D;< FP M<ID<B @W@E
><W<IC@9@IE<;<E;<c@C \
[LEL 9@C@PFILD E;I<N D8 FEC8I E<;<E FC8I8B ;LP

;LBC8IbE<=I<K@>XJK<ID@PFIC8IB@ \
-F9FK ;@BB8KC< [+ ?8C;< @f JFELE;8 9<P@E< ><C@G ;8P

8EbPFI \ ;@P< DbIbC;8E;b [D8 9@Q 9LEL _GFQ@KIFE8 B8Ifb


?Y:I<C<I ;YQ<P@E;< 9bI8BD8Cb DbPbQ +EC8Ib =FEBJ@PFE<C 9@I
K8I@= P8GD8P8 QFIC8D8EbE 9@I PFCL PFB DL <P@E fLE;8E P8
;8 9LE;8E FCLfDLfKLI  ;<D<B QFILE;8 DbPbQ <PE@E 9<C@IC@
9@I ;YQ<P;< ;YfYE<9@C<E 9@I f<P ?<I?8E>@ 9@I f<P FC;LcLEL
JXPC<P<D<QD@P@Q\
(@
$J@E> [0 9@I @f< P8I8D8Q \ ;<;@ [.<E@E 9<PE@E @E

J8EC8I K8I8=bE;8E FCLfKLILC;L dEJ8E 9<PE@ @J< XPC< ;<c@C




.<E@E 9<PE@E P8GbC;b FEC8IbEB@ ><C@fK@ '<E;@J@PC< 9@I IF9FK


8I8JbE;8B@ <E><C@ B8C;bID8D8B E@P<K@E;< FC8E 9@I @EJ8E @W@E
9L =8IBC8I 9@I B@CFD<KI< <E@E;< M< 9@I B@CFD<KI< 9FPLE;8 W<C@B
9@I;LM8I;<D<B \
[*<=I<KC<I@E@EB8PE8cbE8@E<9@CJ<P;@B B8PE8c8 \
[LE:8 PbC JFEI8 @EJ8EC8Ib ?VCV D8EKbBCb 9@W@D;< 8WbB

C8D8P8 Db W8CbfbPFIJLE\\ (@
$J@E>@E J<J@ B<;<IC@P;@
[58M8CCb E;I<N BbQD8  8D8 J<E@ 9L PXE< ;FcIL JYIYBC<P<E
@W@E;<B@IF9FK \\
E;I<N DbIbC;8E;b [@CD@PFILD !c<I F :<J8I<K@
9LC89@CJ<P;@D \\


 K.2). '&K1&3,GA8&0. 7&-3*<*
)B3C<469=
+:<J8I<K@9LC89@CJ<P;@
E;I<N LQLE 9@I JYI<;<E 9<I@ JFELE;8 @f@E 9L EFB

K8P8 M8I8:8cbEb 9@C@PFI;L 1< B8CBbG FG<I8KXI< >@KK@ L


@f@ P8G89@C<:<B LJK8 9@I@E@ 9LCDLfKL 48E@ 9@I IF9FK FG<I

8KXIY SYEBY 9L BFEL;8 ?@W9@I @EJ8E


FG<I8KXI<
>YM<E@C<D<Q;@ $<D P<K<E<B M< ?<D ;< >YM<E
98BbDbE;8E
+G<I8KXI 9L 8D<C@P8Kb 9@I @EJ8E8 P8G8D8Q;b
E;I<N @W@E;<B@ B8JbI>8Pb 8WbBC8P8E 8:b JFILC8I
JFI8I8BF B8WbEbC8D8Q 8Eb ><:@BK@I;@ .FEI8 @I@E:@
48J8Pb9@IK8I8=89bI8BKbM< [<E;<IF9FKLD \;<;@
4bCC8I 9FPLE:8 @EJ8EC8I;8E XcI<E;@c@ >@9@ B<J@E 9@I
K8MbI K8BbE8I8B [.8E8 9<E@ 8D<C@P8K <KD<E@ <DI<;@PFI

LD \\;<;@
@I@E:@ 48J8 ><W<IC@ FCD8;bcb M< 9@I @EJ8E8 WFB 9<E

Q<P<E 9L IF9FKLE B<J@E 9@I K8MbIC8 M<I;@c@ <D@I @B@E:@


48J8Pb>YWC<E;@I;@c@@W@EE;I<NELE @JK<;@c@FC;L
 

E;I<N B<E;@E@ WFB 9@KB@E ?@JJ<;@PFI;L 8D8 9LELE J8

;<:< BLILEKL FC;LcLE;8E <D@E;@ D<C@P8KK8E JFEI8 B<E;@E@


KFG8IC8DbfJ8 ;8 P@E< ;< =8QC8 ;@BB8K@ W<BD<;<E ;LM8I8 ;8P

8EDbfKb +KLILIJ8?<If<P8EC8fbC8:8BKb
(@
$J@E> [.FE FPC8D8 9L ?8=K8 P8GbC8:8B E;I<N \
;<;@ [L @f@ ;8?8 =8QC8 ><:@BK@I<D<;@D /89@@ J8M8fb B8P9<

;<:<c@Q +E;8E JFEI8 P8GbC8:8B 9@I f<P ;< B8CD8P8:8B


E;I<N \
E;I<N [+PC8D8Pb LJK8CbBC8 ><:@BK@I;@c@E @W@E J8E8 D@E

E<K ;LPLPFILD \ ;@P< DbIbC;8E;b [XPC<:< 9<E@D @W@E ><I<BC@


FC8EQ8D8EbB8Q8E;bD 1<><I<B<EFBLD8Ib;8FPE8;bD \
(@
$J@E>WFB<E;@f<C<E;@ [$8E>@BLD8I9L\
[LEL J8E8 ;8?8 XE:< 8WbBC8P8D8Q;bD "<@E>FC; M<
)8IK@E;<B@C<I< ;< XPC< <E@ DLKC8B8 <E><CC<I;@E@Q e@D;@
;@EC< XE<DC@ FC8E 9<P@E ;@PFILQ JCbE;8 <E XE<DC@ =8IB
XCYDJYQCYB ;<c@C D@ <P@E@E E<P< 9<EQ<;@c@E< P8 I&8 E8JbC
P8GbC;bcbE8 M<P8 ><C@fK@c@E< B@D 8C;bIbPFI TE<DC@ FC8E 9<P@E
?Y:I<C<I@E@E XCD<J@ TCD<B QFILE;8 FCD8Jb 1Y:LKK8B@ 9YKYE
;@c<I FI>8EC8I BFILEJ8 P8 ;8 ;<c@fK@I@CJ< 9@C< JFELE;8 9<P@E
?Y:I<C<I@ XCYPFI +EC8Ib B@f@C@c@ ;<c@fK@ID<;<E M< JFELE;8
XC;YID<;<EP<E@C<D<B;<@DBVEJbQ
[<E@D GFQ@KIFE@B PFCC8IbD 9<C@IC@ 9@I ;<c@f@BC@B >XJK<I

D<;<E ?<D<E ?<D<E @B@ PYQPbC ;8P8E;bC8I 1< ;8?8 PYQPbC

C8I:8 ;8 ;8P8E89@C@IC<I JbC <E><C 9L ;<c@C D@ dEJ8EC8I XCYD

JYQ 9@I IF9FK8 B8KC8E89@C@IC<I SYEBY 9@I D8B@E<E@E LQLE 9@I


JYI< W8Cbf89@CD<J@ ?@W XE<DC@ ;<c@C;@I D8 FEC8I XCYDJYQ 9@I
@EJ8Eb @JK<D<QC<I SYEBY B<E;@ XCYDCYCYBC<I@E< 9L 8E:8B
<MI<EJ<C FC;LcL JYI<:< B8KC8E89@C@IC<I dfK< 9L PYQ;<E 9<E@D
@EJ8EJ8PbCD8D8I8Qb;<c@CC<I \
(@
$J@E> [.XQY E<I<P< ><K@I<:<BJ@E E;I<N\ ;@P<
JFI;L
[<E 9L JFILEL FIK8;8E B8C;bI;bD ,FQ@KIFE@B 9<PE@D



PbCC8I PbCC8I XE:< FI>8E@B J@E@IC<I< 98cC8EDbfKb e@D;@ JFE 9@I


8D<C@P8K 9L 98cC8EKbC8Ib 9<C@IC@ 9@I 9@W@D;< ;<c@fK@I;@ IKbB
GFQ@KIFE@BPFCC8IbD;8B@GFK8EJ@P<C8cbI8cbI 8BbG>@;@PFI \
(@
$J@E>` @E @P@:< BbIbfDbf FC8E PYQYE;< 9@I 8E ?@W9@I @=8;<
9<C@ID<;@ .FEI8 B8;bEbE ;L;8BC8Ib ><I@C@M<I;@ [48E@ XC<:<B
D@J@E E;I<N LEL DL J8cC8;bE +C8D8Q L 0WY:Y
48J8P88PBbIb \
E;I<N [$8PbI \ ;<;@ [<E MY:L;LDLE XCYDYPC<
@JK<BC<I@D M< LDLKC8IbDbE XCYDY 8I8JbE;8 9@I K<I:@? P8GKbD
JbC F XE<DC@ XCYD B8IfbCbcb MY:L;LDLE P8f8D8Jb UWYE:Y
48J8P88PBbIbP;b \
(@
$J@E> J8EB@ E;I<NPL J8IJ8:8BDbf >@9@ FEL BFCLE;8E
P8B8C8;b E:8B JFEI8 B<E;@E@ KLKKL [E;I<N 9L 9@I @f<
P8I8D8P8:8B L;LILDL?<D<E;<c@fK@I !JB@?8C@E@8C \ 
[L @DBVEJbQ "8QC8 Q8I8I >XI;YD f8cb PLB8Ib J8;<:<
9@I PbCCbB 9@I XDIYD M8I 48GbCbfbDbE @B@ PYQYE:Y PbC;XEYDYEY
>XI<9@C<:<c@D LELJ8cC8P8:8BB8;8IQ8Pb=;8MI8E;bD \
[LE8;<c<ID@P;@E;I<N WFB8GK8CJbE\
[!c<I 9<E@ @EJ8E P8G8IJ8 F Q8D8E 9LE8 ;<c<I D8
P8G8D8QJ8 9YKYE W898C8IbDb JFE8 <I;@ID@f FC89@C@I 4@E< ;<
?<If<P<;<c<I9<E:< \
(@
$J@E> f8fbIKb:b 9@I f<P P8GKb M< P8M8fW8 8cC8D8P8
98fC8;b


L JFE ?8I<B<KC< ;YEP8EbE ;Yf >Y:Y <KB@C<ED@fK@ M< K89@@
9L f8fbC8:8B 9@I f<P;@ E;I<NELE F Q8D8E8 B8;8I P8GKbB

C8Ib B@DJ<P@ @C>@C<E;@ID<J< ;< JFELE;8 @EJ8E FC89@CD<B @W@E


XCYDY 9@C< B89LC <KD@fK@ L XQM<I@ I<;;<;@C<D<P<:<B B8;8I
9YPYBKY
.FE KXI<E XQ<CC@BC< @B@ PYQYE:Y PbC;XEYDYE< I8JKC8KbC;b
YEP8 8fB8Eb 9<C><P@ @DQ8C8P8I8B B8I8Ib P8J8CC8fKbI8:8BKb
 

/XI<E@ 9YKYE ;YEP8 @QC<P<:<B M< 9L P <P8C<K@E< M< ?8KK8


)8IJBFCFE@J@E<9@C<bfbEC8E8:8BKb
E;I<N K<B<IC<BC@ J8E;8CP<;<P;@ $VCV PYIYP<9@C@PFI;L
8D8J<E;<C<P<I<B
dEJ8ECbB FC8Pb J<PI<;<IB<E YEP8 8fB8Eb [!CC@ PbC
XE:< \ ;<;@ [4YQ <CC@ P8fbE;8B@ IF9FK FC;LcLE @C8E <;@C;@
E;I<N 1< 9@Q 9L>YE J@Q@E @B@ PYQ P8fbE;8 9@I @EJ8E
FC;LcLELQL8WbBCbPFILQ 8P)8IK@E \
E;I<N>YCYDJ<P<I<B98fB8EbE<C@E@JbBD8B@W@ELQ8E;b
E;I<N P8K8BK8 P8K8IB<E ;YfYE:<C<I@ 8cbI 8cbI
B8P9FCLPFI;L
;8D W8I<J@Q:< FEC8Ib P8B8C8D8P8 W8CbfKb dEJ8E + 9@I
@EJ8E;b .FE ;YfYE:<J@E@E 9L FCD8JbEb @JK@PFI;L '8=8JbE;8
9L=@B@IC<<I@D<P@ XCD<P@@JK@PFI;L
#XQC<I@E@ K<BI8I 8WKbcbE;8 JFE B<Q :@;;@ 9@I K8MbIC8
9<BC<P<E (@
$J@E>@ >XI;Y 8fB8C8Ib ;8 M8I;b 8D8 FEC8I J8

;<:< 9@I<I >XC><P;@C<I /8EbE8D8P8E >XC><C<I @I K<B (@

$J@E> >@K>@;< BFPLC8f8E >I@ J@JC<I@E 8I8JbE;8 J<W@C@PFI;L


E;I<N <C@E@ 8cbI 8cbI J8EK@D J8EK@D B8;bE8 LQ8KKb (@

$J@E>@EG8ID8BC8IbEbJbBKbcbEb?8P8CD<P8C=8IB<E@ 
E;I<NELE JFE ;YfYE:<C<I@ ;< B8P9FCLIB<E B8;bE ;8
>XQC<I@E@EXEYE;<J@C@BC<fD<P<98fC8;b
D8 (@
$J@E> KYDYPC< FIK8;8E B8P9FCD8;8E M< ?<I f<P
JFE8 <ID<;<E XE:< E;I<NELE B8=8JbE;8 JFE 9@I ;YfYE:<
9<C@ID@fK@
LPLC8D8P8:8B B8;8I 8CW8B 9@I J<JC< [)@E@D@E@
?8EbD \;@P<=bJbC;8;b
**
L FC8P 98fC8;bcb ><:< JFE8 <I;@ +IK8;8 XE<DC@ 9@I f<P FC

D8J8 ;8 BFEL J8;<:<  <E;@f<C<E;@ID@fK@ $VCV ;8


<E;@f<C<E;@I@PFI
EC8P8:8cbEbQ &F< CF:? -8P )8EE@E> M< 9<E BXf<
98fbE;8B@ 98I;8 ?<I Q8D8EB@ D8J8DbQbE 98fbE8 WXBDYfKYB
TEYDYQ;< LQLE 9@I 8Bf8D LQ8EbPFI;L @Q ;< ><M<Q<C@B <;<I<B
FJ88KC<I@><W@I<:<BK@B dfK<98fC8E>bW9XPC<P;@
$<I f<P &F< CF:? 8KFD 9FD98JbE;8E JXQ <;<IB<E 98fC8;b
L BFEL;8 E< P8GbCD8Jb ><I<BK@c@E@ 8WbBCbPFI;L [<f PbC XE:<
B@D@E8BCbE8><C@I;@ \;<;@
<E [@IWFB @EJ8E 9<f PbC XE:< 9L BFELPL ;YfYEYPFI;L \
;@P< :<M8G M<I;@D [$8KK8 9L BFEL;8 ?@BVP<C<I 9@C< P8QbPFI

C8I;b IKbB >8Q<K<C<I;<E ;8?8 XE;< FCD8B @W@E WFB


QFIC8E8:8BC8I \
+E;8E JFEI8 FC89@C<:<B >8I@G f<PC<I;<E JXQ <KD<P<
98fC8;bB .XQC<I< [TIE<c@E \;@P<98fCbPFI;L
-8P [@I@E;<E ;LP;LD \ ;<;@ 9@I 8I8 [UECY 9@I 9@C@D 8;8Db
9@I B8CbG BLIfLEL Q8D8E @W@E;< ><I@P< PFCC8Dbf @B@ J8E@P< P8 ;8
@B@ ;8B@B8 M<P8 9@I J8E@P<E@E @B@ 9@E;< 9@I@ B8;8I 9@I JYI< @W@E
IKbB FI8JbEb 9@CD@PFILD @C@D 8;8Db 9L BFEL;8 B@DJ<P< 8WbB

C8D8 P8GDbPFIDLf SYEBY B<E;@J@E< @E8ED8P8:8BC8IbEb


;YfYEYPFIDLf\
 <E F Q8D8E 8C8PC8 [TPC<PJ< J<E 9LEL E<I<;<E XcI<E;

@E\ ;@P< JFI;LD -8P@E G<B WFB 8IB8;8fb FC89@C@I D8 FEC8I
9<E@D ;< 8IB8;8fC8IbD M< @WC<I@E;< XE<DC@ 9@I 9@C@D 8;8DbEb
K8EbP8E?@WB@DJ<PFB
-8P [*8JbC ;LP;LPJ8D ;LP;LD \ ;@P< JXPC<E;@ [dJK<I @E

8E @JK<I@E8ED8 \
/89@@ FE;8E JFEI8 JXQ Q8D8E D8B@E<C<I@E< ><C;@ @C@E<E F
C8=C8Ib JXPC<;@B [#<I@ >@;@G B<E;@ 9YPYB9898Eb XC;YIYIJ<E E<


FCLI\ [*<;<E 9@I@ ><C<:<BK<E ><C@G 9LE;8E JFEI8 WbB8:8B


J8M8fb B@D@E B8Q8E8:8cbEb JXPC<D@PFI\ [:898 P<E@ 9@I J8M8f
WbB8:8B Db\ ['@D B8Q8EbIJ8 B8Q8EJbE J8M8fK8E JFEI8
P<IPYQYE;<@EJ8EC8IbEP8f8P89@C<:<c@9@IP<IB8C8:8BDb\
-8P [CKbE:b BFfL JYI<IB<E P<;@E:@P@ ?8E>@ 8KbE
B8Q8E8:8cbEb9@CD<B9<E@D@W@EP<K<IC@FCLI \;<;@
D8 &F< 98fB8 KYICY ;YfYEYPFI;L [.@Q@E ;<I;@E@Q E< 9@C@PFI
DLJLELQ BCbEbQb J8M8fC8I8 M< 8K P8IbfC8IbE8 K8BDbfJbEbQ
<EJ< D<I8BCbPbD 58D8E D8B@E<D FCJ8P;b E< P8G8I;bD 9@C@P

FIDLJLELQ
-8PC< 9<E ?<D<E XcI<ED<B @JK<;@B /89@@ E< FCLIJ8 FCJLE
FE;8EJFEI8&F<P8K8BbCbG;LI8:8BKbB
[@I Q8D8E D8B@E<D FCJ8P;b \ ;<;@ [<f P8 ;8 <CC@ D@CPFE
PbC><I@P<>@;<IM<;@EFQFIC8I8E<FC;LcLELXcI<E@I;@D \
/89@@ &F<ELE 9L 8WbBC8D8JbEb ?Ff B8IfbC8D8;bB -8P ;< 9<E
;<9LELD8EKbBJbQ9LCDLfKLB
-8P [ @EFQFIC8I8 8C;bI8E B@D\ ;@P< JXPC<E;@ <E ;<
<BC<;@D [+EC8I J8;<:< ><I@;< JYIYPC< @JB<C<K 9bI8BDbfC8I +
PYQ;<E 98Qb 8GK8CC8I ;LID8;8E DYQ<C<I;< ;FC8fbG P<IC<I@
8fbE;bIbPFIC8I JCbE;8 FIK8;8E B8CBD8C8Ib @P@ FCDLf XPC<:< @E

J8EC8I@W@EP<I8WbCDbf \
&F< -8PC< 98E8 ;@B ;@B 98BKb [/8Eb;bcbD 98Qb @EJ8EC8Ib
;YfYEYPFILD ;8 _'<fB< ;@EFQFIC8I FIK8;8E B8P9FCD8J8C8I;b 
;@PFILD \ /89@@ 9@Q 9L JXQC<I< 8C;bID8;bB 9@C< + BFELfD8JbEb
JYI;YI;Y [.@Q 8?D8BC8I B8?B8?8C8I 8KbG J8EB@ 9@I f<PC<I 9@C@PFI

DLf >@9@ ;8MI8E89@C@IJ@E@Q LELE E<;<E@ ?8P8C >Y:YEYQYE


FCD8D8Jb + ;@EFQFIC8I BFJBF:8D8E <MC<I B8;8I 9YPYB
f<PC<I;@ SFB ;8 8BbCJbQ;bC8I $<I K8I8=8 P8PbCDbfC8I M< JFEI8
9@I;<E9@I< \,8ID8BC8IbEbf8BC8KKb [ FIK8;8EB8P9FC;LC8I \
-8PC<9<E9LELEE8JbCFC;LcLELXcI<ED<B@JK<;@B
D8 F 9@I8JbEb 9@K@ID@f ?8IC@<P< 9@I K8E< ;8?8 M<ID<J@ @W@E
@e8I<K <KD<BK<P;@ '8IfbCbcbEb X;<P<:<c@E@ 9<C@IKD<B @W@E <C@E;<B@
9FQLB G8I8Pb J8CCbPFI;L .FEI8 FDQLEL J@CBK@ [@CD@PFILD


WF:LBC8I D8><WD@f<>@;@G9LELXcI<ED<B@JK<I;@D \
$<GJ@ 9L B8;8I L BFEL 9LI8;8 B8G8E89@C@I;@ <E 9@I f<P
JXPC<I;@D -8P 9@I f8B8 P8G8I;b $<G@D@Q 9@I<I 9@I8 ;8?8 @W<I
9<CB@ ;< ?8M8;8E JL;8E M< IFFBCPE F;><IJ K8BbDbE;8E JXQ
<;<I;@B .FEI8 ;8 [dP@ ><:<C<I \ ;<I M< ;@EFQFIC8Ib ;8 9@I ;8?8
;YfYED<Q;@B
D8 XPC< FCD8;b e@D;@ ;@EFQFIC8I;8E 98fB8 9@I f<P
;YfYE<D@PFILD $8JK8>@9@P@D
SYEBY K8D F JbI8;8 P8EbDbQ;8B@ D8J8;8 FKLI8E J8I?Ff
98fbEbB8C;bI8I8B [$<P\;@P<98cbI;b
+EL ;8?8 XE:< >XID<D@fK@B #<E<CC@BC< 98IC8I;8
K8EbD8;bcbDbQ J8I?FfC8IC8 @C>@C<ED<P@Q <E K8Eb;bcbD J8I

?FfC8IbE ?<J89bEb KLKD8BK8 QFICLB W<B@PFILD Q8K<E L 8;8DbE


XEYE;<P8Ib9Ff9@If@f<M8I;b !C@E;<B@98I;8B@J<P8Ib;FCLP;L
+ [$<P \;@P<98cbIbE:8;XEYG98BKbB
-8P [&F< E<@JK@PFIDLf JFI98B8CbD \;<;@
;8D8 <E P8BbE FC8EbDbQ &F<P;L dJB<DC<J@E@ 8IB8P8 ;FcIL
<c<I<B [*<@JK@PFIJLE\;@P<JFI;L
.8I?Ff [.@Q ;<D@E ;@EFQFIC8I;8E Db JXQ <;@PFI;LELQ
9<PC<I\ ;<;@ +C;LcL P<I;< 9@I8Q J8CC8EbPFI >XQC<I@ J8EB@
B8EbPFIC8IDbf >@9@ >XQYBYPFI;L #XDC<c@E@E ;< 9@I Q8D8EC8I
9<P8Q FC;LcLEL K8?D@EC< 9@C<9@C@I;@E@Q D8 BFELfD8Jb
;@BB8K@D@Q@ W<BK@ $@W ;< 9@I 8PP8f >@9@ BFELfDLPFI; @CD<D E<
;<D<B@JK<;@c@D@8ECbPFIDLJLELQ
$<I E<PJ< &F< ;8?8 J8B@E 9@I K8MbI K8BbE8I8B [!M<K \ ;<;@
[@CD<B@JK<;@c@E9@If<PD@M8I;b\
PP8f 9@Q< >YCYDJ<;@ /L?8= 9@I >YCYfKY FELEB@ cQbE;8
98fCbPFI 8D8 >XQC<I@E< <I@f<D<;<E JFE8 <I@PFI;L [@I Q8D8E
D8B@E<J@ P8GD8B M< ><I@P< >@;<I<B ;@EFQFIC8I8 E< FC;LcLEL DL
XcI<ED<B@JK@PFIJLELQ\
&F<ELE 8;8DbE 9@Q@ ;FC8E;bID8P8 ?8QbIC8E;bcbEb
;YfYE;YcY 9<CC@P;@ <E;< 8PEb =@B@I;<P;@D Q8K<E &F<
[*<;<E\ ;<;@ [<E@D @W@E 9@I Q8D8E D8B@E<J@ P8GD8Pb Db


K<BC@=<;<:<BJ@E\
PP8f ;@fC<I@E@ >XJK<I;@ [$8PbI <=<E;@D LEL 98f8I89@C@I@D
8D8 P8GD8P8:8cbD *<;<E@E@ 9@C@PFI DLJLELQ SYEBY 9@IB8W
PbC XE:< B<E;@D @W@E 9@I Q8D8E D8B@E<J@ P8GKbD .FEI8 ;8
><I@C<I< )<QFQF@B Q8D8E8 >@;@G ;@EFQFIC8I8 E< FC;LcLEL
8EC8;bD \
8?8 JFEI8 JXQCYBK< [)<QFQF@B\@E E8JbC P8QbC;bcbE8 98BKbD
+ELE @W@E 9L 8;b f@D;@ 9LI8P8 ;FcIL ;YIYJK P8Q89@C@PFILD <CB@
D<I8B <KD@fJ@E@Q;@I ;@P< JXPCYPFILD 8D8 F JbI8;8 9YKYE
9LEC8IbE J8WD8J8G8E C8=C8I FC;LcLEL ;YfYEYPFI;LD PIb:8
8;8DbE ;<C@E@E K<B@ FC;LcLE;8E ;8 <D@E;@D &F< JFEI8;8E 9L
)<QFQF@B E<JE<P@ 9@C;@c@E@ @;;@8 <KK@ D8 -8PC< 9<E FE8 @E

8EbE:8P8B8;8I;8?89@I?8PC@E<=<JKYB<KD<J@><I<B<:<B
JCbE;8 P@E< ;< 8PP8fbE F JXQC<I@E@E <KB@J@ FCDLfKL ;8Db
D8J8DbQ8 W8cbI;bB #8C@98 9<E FEL 9@I JYI< ;@EC<P<9@C<:<c@D@Q@
b< F 8I8;8 f@f<;<E 9@I8Q @WB@ @W<9@C<:<c@D@Q@ ;YfYEYPFI;LD
.8EbIbD 9@Q@DB@C<I@E B8=8JbE;8E ;8 8PEb f<PC<I ><W@PFI;L *<
M8I ; 8PP8f f@f<P@ J8c <C@PC< JbBb:8 KLK8I8B >XJK<I;@c@D@Q J8E

;8CP<:<FKLI;L .FELE8B8;8I;8<C@E;<E9bI8BD8;b
-8P \58D8ED8B@E<J@E@E<I<;<P8GKbE\;@P<JFI;L
[)@;N<JK<IE UE@M<IJ@K<J@E;< )8B@E< YQ<I@E;< BbQbDC8
9@IC@B<W8CbfDbfKbB \
#<IW<BK<E;<YE@M<IJ@K<>XIDYf9@I@>@9@BFELfLPFI;L
<E8KbC;bD \58D8ED8B@E<J@f@D;@E<I<;<<9@E;<D@\
#XQYEY 9@C< BbIGD8;b +E8 E< B8;8I K8BbCbIJ8B K8BbC8CbD
8C;bIbCbPFI;L .8EB@ M@JB@ ;@C@E@ WXQDYfKY M< FI8;8 B8CbG B8C

D8;bcbDb8 8C;bIDbPFIDLf >@9@P;@ '<E;@ B<E;@E< PYBJ<B J<JC<


BFELfLPFICL8;<K8
[)8B@E<P@ BbI;bD \ ;<;@ [+EL @JK<D@PFI;LD +C8EC8I 98E8
<KD@f;<8IKDbfKb9@C< \
/89@@ FE8 @E8ED8;bB $@W D@ ?@W @E8ED8;bB eLEL @P@:< 8E

C8D8CbJbEbQ @I@ 9@I Q8D8E D8B@E<J@ @:8K <;<IJ< D@CPFEC8Ib


>XKYIYI YEP8;8B@ 9YKYE G8I8Pb J@C@G JYGYIYI FIJ8;8


P8IbfC8I;8 M< @W@DC<I;< E<C<I FC8:8cbEb 9@CD<J@ FE8 P<K<I


)8EKbBCb FC8E ;8 CL;LI '@DJ< 9@I Q8D8E D8B@E<J@E@ ;8?8
;FcILJL 9L B8;8I G8I8@ B8C;bIbG 8KD8Q PP8fbE E<;<EC<I@E<
8C;bI8:8B ;<c@C;@D K89@@ 58K<E ?@W9@I@D@Q Q8D8E;8 PFC:LCLc8 @E

8EDbPFI;LB SYEBY @EJ8E ><I@ ;XEYG B8Q8I8 9YPYB9898JbEb


XC;YI<9@C@I;@
e<P *<PJ<
&F< [!M<K <M<K \ ;@P< ?FDLI;8E;b [)8B@E<P@ G8IW8C8;bE
/89@@P8 ;bEE<;@IJ<E@E\
.8I?Ff 9L JFILPL :<M8GC8D8;b $@W9@I Q8D8E +E8 8;bEb
9@IB8W B<I< ;8?8 JFI;LB M< JFELE;8 ;8 8PP8fb [,IF=<JXI \ ;@

P<W8cbID8P898fC8;bB
8I;8cbE;8B@ M@JB@J@E@ 9@K@I;@ M< K<BI8I ;FC;LI;L $@W9@I@D@Q<
@WB@@BI8D<KD@PFI;L @Q;<9@I8C8IbPL;LDC8PbG;LI;LB
.FELE;8 9<E [$8P;@ 8EC8K \ ;<;@D [ @EFQFIC8I8 E<
FC;L\
#<C><C<C@D 9LEL 9@Q< ?<D<E 8WbBC8D8DbfKb #XQC<I@E@ D8J

8EbE FIK8JbE8 ;@BK@ .8EB@ K8?K8C8IC8 BFELfLPFI;L [8IFC 9<E@


B8W B<Q ><WD@f< PFCC8;b 9@CD@PFILD 'V? ><WD@fK< 9@IB8W
;8B@B8 B8C;bD BV? 9@IB8W J88K .FEI8 F LQLE PFC:LCLcL P8GKbD
@EFQFIC8I 9<E@ ?@W @C>@C<E;@ID@PFI;L .8;<:< D8B@E<E@E
C89FI8KLM8I;8 <C;< <KK@c@D@Q >YWC< 9<E@ E< B8;8I ><I@C<I< >XKYI<

:<c@E@ XcI<ED<B @JK@PFI;LD $<I?8C;< K<?C@B<C@ 9@I f<P;@ 9L


JCbE;8 P8f8D ;8 F B8;8I DYK?@f 9@I f<P D@ + JbI8;8 J8M8f
JYIYPFI;L @I@E@E ;8?8 XCD<J@E@E E< XE<D@ M8I;b .8EB@ 9L
BFELPL ;YfYEYPFIDLf >@9@ 98I;8cbEb JbBb:8 B8MI8;b .FEI8 B8

=8JbE;8 9@I f<P@ 8KC8P8I8B BFELfD8JbEb JYI;YI;Y [$8M8


>YE<fC@P;@ <II8B M< >YE<fC@ 4<I J<IK M< BLILP;L !cI<CK@C<I M<
98K8BCbBC8I PFBKL @EFQFIC8I8 98cC8;bcbDbQ 'I<K8J S8cbEbE F
8PIbEKbC8Ib;8XPC< \
$<I E<PJ< PP8f 9XPC< 9@I f<PC<I JXPC<;@ @fK< + 9YPYB C8

=C8Ib ?<I J<=<I@E;< KYDYPC< 8EC8P8DbPFI;LD +ELE @W@E 9LI8P8


?8KbIC8P89@C;@BC<I@D@ P8QbPFILD YKYE 9L B<C@D<C<I@E E8JbC


P8QbC;bBC8IbE8 98BKbD !M<K fLEL ;8 JXPC<D<C@P@D 8PP8f WFB


@WD@f FCD8JbE8 I8cD<E 9YKYE F JXQ:YBC<I@ WFB ;YQ>YE JXPCYP

FI;L $@WB<B<C<D<;<E?<D;<
<CB@ 9@Q@ <E;@f<C<E;@I<E ;< 9L FC;L .8EB@ 8EC8KKbBC8IbEbE
?<GJ@ WFB K8Eb;bB f<PC<ID@f >@9@P;@ CbfKbcb f<PC<I '<C@D<C<I
8cQbE;8E;XBYCYM<I@PFIC8I;b
PP8f [#<W 9@I W8c;b \ ;@P< 8EC8KD8JbEb JYI;YI;Y [/<

9<f@I S8cb FC;LcL B<J@E @EFQFIC8I FIK8;8E B8CBD8B YQ<I<C<I;@


+ BYWYB P8I8KbBC8I ;bfbE;8 eL D8;<E B<D<IC@ M< J@C8?Cb FC8EC8Ib
B8JK<;@PFILD \
#8C@98 &F<ELE 9LIEL 9@I8JbEbE @W@E< >@I;@ ,IF=<JXI 9L JXQ

C<I@ 8;<K8 B<;<IC< JXPC<IB<E ;L9C<E@E P8EbE;8E B8=8JbEb LQ8KKb


@Q@DB@ =<E8 ?8C;< X=B<C<ED@f >@9@P;@ D&3,. BYWYB P8I8KbB

C8I'@DC<I@ED8;<EB<D<IC<I@$8E>@J@C8?C8I\
,IF=<JXI 9@I 8E FE8 98BKb .FEI8 >XQC<I@E@ @C<I@;<B@ 9@I EFB

K8P8 ;@B<I<B ['YWYB JYIYE><EC<I;@ FEC8I 4YQ P@ID@ J8EK@D 9FP

LE;8 '8CbE BLPILBC8IbEb P<I< ;8P8P8I8B 8IB8 8P8BC8IbEbE YQ<I

@E;< ;LILPFIC8I;b 'FCC8Ib BbJ8P;b M< G8ID8BC8Ib M8I;b <CC<I@E<


<EC@ D8;<E B<D<IC<I K8BDbfC8I;b M< FI8;8E J@C8?C8I J8IBbP

FI;L +K898E:8C8IBLIfLE;<c@C<E<IA@J@C8?C8IbP;bC8I \
<E [+EC8I E<P;@C<I E<P;@C<I\ ;@P< JFI;LD [.XPC<J<E<
E<Q8D8E;b9L)@CPFEC8I:8D@CPFEC8I:8PbCXE:<D@\
PP8f [!M<K XPC< \ ;<;@ [+EC8I JYIYE><E;@ M< >XM;<C<I@
GLCCLP;L #XQB8G8BC8Ib PFBKL 1< ?<I?8C;< PLDLIKCLPFIC8I;b
D8 !E<IA@ K898E:8C8Ib BLCC8EbPFIC8I;b <f B@f@P;@C<I 58D8E
D8B@E<J@E;<E @E<I @ED<Q 98E8 J8C;bI;bC8I .8EbIbD P<IPYQYE;<
D@CPFEC8I:8 XPC< JYIYE><E M8I;b )@CPFEC8I:8 YKYE ;YEP8P8
P8PbCDbfC8I;b  YEP8EbE<=<E;@C<I@P;@C<I \
#8C@98 -8P F Q8D8E 8;8Db P8B8C8;bcbE8 B8I8I M<I;@ SYEBY
>XQC<I@E;< F BLIE8Q:8 bfbCKb 9<C@ID@fK@ -8P [LI8P8 98B ,IF

=<JXI \ ;@P< 98fC8;b [)@CPFEC8I:8 JYIYE><E XPC< D@ $@W9@I @f


P8GD8PbG J8;<:< <JB@ B<D@BC<I@ 9LCD8P8 W8Cbf8E 9@IK8BbD
8;8DC8I PFB DL + B<D@BC<I@ 9LC;LBK8E JFEI8 FEC8Ib 9@IC<fK@I@PFI


M< 9@I ;@EFQFILE E<P< 9<EQ<;@c@E@ 8EC8D8P8 W8CbfDbPFIC8I Db


YKYE DYQ<C<I F B<D@BC<IC< KbB8 98J8 ;FCL ;<c@C D@ ! f@D;@
JXPC< 98B8CbD ?@W 9<C@E;< B<D<I FC8E 9@I ;@EFQFI @JB<C<K@ M8I
Db )8;<D XPC< D@CPFEC8I:8 JYIYE><E M8I;b FEC8I8 E< FC;L
'<D@BC<I@E<I<;<\
,IF=<JXI @W@E@ W<BK@ #<IW<BK<E '<;<IC< 8:b 8:b <CB@ ;< @CB
B<Q 9@I 98I;8 @f KLCLDCL YW 8;8DC8 BFELfKLcLEL =8IB<KD@fK@
$Ff 9<CB@ ;< 9XPC< f<PC<I< 8C;bIDbPFI;L [JCbE;8 =8QC8 =FJ@C
9LCLE8DbPFI B@ 4<IPYQYE;< B8W ?8PM8EbE P8f8;bcbEb ;YfYEYE
)@CP8IC8I:8 KI@CPFEC8I:8 ?8PM8E .FEI8 ;8 9LCLE8E =FJ@CC<I@E
J8PbJbEb ?8KbIC8PbE + JYIYE><EC<I 8BbCCbP;bC8I $@W9@I@E@Q dE DL
LELKD8PbE +EC8I E< W8DLI8 E< B8I PbcbEC8IbE8 J8GC8ED8P8:8B

C8I;b (8MC8IbE @W@E< ;< ;YfD<P<:<BC<I;@ /89@@ 9YPYB B8Q8C8I


;bfbE;8 '8W @EJ8E =FJ@C@E@E 9LCLE;LcLEL ;YfYEYE $8KK8 D@CP

FEC8I:8 PbC XE:bb P8f8P8E ><I@ Q<BVCb D8PDLE


8;8DC8IbE 9@C<
@JB<C<KC<I@ =8QC8 ;<c@C \ 48Ib 9Ff 98I;8cbE8 98B8I8B W<M@I;@
W<M@I;@ [58K<E =FJ@CC<I E<P@ >XJK<I@I;@ B@ )8;<E B<D<IC<I
G8JC8EbG FIK8;8E B8P9FCLI + BYWYB JYIYE><EC<I Jb:8BB8ECbP

;bC8I LEL B<J@EC@BC< '.1.<4692 D8 9LEL K8fC8fDbf B<D@B

C<IC< B8EbKC8P8D8QJbEbQ B@ '8?I<KJ@E LE;8E 9@I D@CPFE PbC


JFEI8 9@I@ @EJ8E @JB<C<K@E< 98B8I8B *<N 4FIBLE E8JbC 9@I P<I
FC;LcLEL JXPC<P<9@C@I D@ @I >FI@CC< 9@I @EJ8EbE @JB<C<KC<I@E@
9@I9@I@E;<E 8PbIK <;<9@C@I D@ $8E>@J@E@E 8KFD 9FD98JbEb
P8GKbcbEb ?8E>@J@E@E ?8PM8E8K 98?W<J@E;< DLQ P<;@c@E@ 9@C<9@C@I
D@\
&F< ?<D<E B8Ifb WbBKb [@I ;8B@B8 @I 8GK8C 9@C< 9@I >FI@C
@JB<C<K@PC<9@I@EJ8EbEB@E@8PbIK<;<9@C@I\
[.8?@ D@\ ,IF=<JXI B<E;@ B<E;@E< >YC;Y .8EB@ 9YKYE
9LEC8I WFB 9@C@E<E 98J@K f<PC<ID@f M< 9L LcLI;8 Q8D8E B8P9<K

D<P< ;<cD<QD@f >@9@ [$<I BFEL;8 @EJ8EC8IbE ><C@fK@ID<P@


98f8I;bBC8Ib 9<P@E< 98B8I8B B8I8I M<I@IJ@E@Q !MI@D@E ;<c@f@B
PXEK<DC<I@ M8I;bI 'LfC8I fXPC< LW8IC8I P8I8J8C8I 9XPC<
Fc8EbE FPLEC8IbEbE JFEL ><CD<Q <PE@E@Q@E E< B8;8IbEb


BLCC8E;bcbEbQb J8EbPFIJLELQ <fK< 9@I@E@ ,J@BFCF>C8I 9XPC<


JXPCYPFIC8I +EC8IbE 9@C;@BC<I@ B8;8IbPC8 9<PE@E@Q@E J<B@Q;< 9@I@
?@W9@I @f< P8I8DbPFI dEJ8EC8I 9@I@E:@ M@K<JK< >@;@PFIC8I /8I@?<
><WD@f 9@IB8W B@f@ ;bfbE;8 9<CB@ TIE<c@E (<FE8I;F ;8 1@E:@
If@D<K I@JKF #8LJJ #8CF@J !@EJK<@E \
<E !@EJK<@E ;bfbE;8 ;@c<IC<I@E@E 8;C8IbEb ?@W ;LPD8DbfKbD
D8 K89@@ 9LEL 9<CC@ <KD<;@D PP8f 9@IB8W 8; ;8?8 J8P;b 8E

:8B 9LI8P8 ?8KbIC8P89@C;@BC<I@D@ P8QbPFILD .FEI8 [+ BYWYB


JYIYE><EC<I@E 9<P@EC<I@ L=8:bBKb \ ;<;@ [FQLB G8I8
9YPYBCYcYE;< <CB@ ;< ;8?8 BYWYB D8 9<P@EC<I@E@ BLCC8EbPFI

C8I;b $<I K8I8=bEb ?<I D<IB<Q@E@ <CB@ B<D@BC<I@E;<E 8EC8fbCD8Q


8D8 8BbCCbP;bC8I FEC8I dEJ8EC8I B8;8I 8BbCCb 1< 9YKYE ;YEP8EbE
;8G8KIFELP;LC8I \
&F< @fK< F Q8D8E ><IW<BK<E @P@ 9@I EFBK8P8 G8ID8cbEb 98JKb
<E 9@I 8E FELE ,IF=<JXIY 8CK<KK@c@E@ ;< ;YfYE;YD &F<
BFELfD8P8 98fC8;bcb Q8D8E 98P8cb J<M@E;@D [ @EC< ,IF=<JXI
D8;<D F B<IK<EB<C<C<I 9L B8;8I YJKYE;YC<I E<;<E ><I@;< 9@I
f<PC<I9bI8BD8;bC8I'<EKC<I@ 9@E8C8IbE<I<;<.FEI8<fP8C8Ib
)8c8I8 8;8DC8IbEbE <fP8C8IbEb 9LCLPFILQ P8 /8f 9bW8BC8Ib =@C8E
'8?I<KJ@E dEJ8EC8I ;YEP8;8E 8PIbCJ8C8I;b ><I@;< E<C<I 9bI8BbI

C8I;b E<C<I @I B@CFD<KI< PYIY;YE DY DLKC8B8 9@I B<EKC<


B8IfbC8fbIJbE .FEI8PFCC8Ib;8LELKD8 \
D8 ,IF=<JXIY JLJKLID8B FC8E8BJbQ;b L JXQC<I FEL J8I

JD8;b 9@C< $<D<E [.@Q :8ECbC8Ib ?VCV @EJ8E XCWYC<I@E< >XI<


;<c<IC<E;@I@PFIJLELQ \ ;@P< B8IfbCbB M<I;@ [@Q B<EKC<I PFCC8I
?8M88C8Eb M< 9<EQ<I f<PC<I P8GbPFILQ D8 JYIYE><EC<I 9XPC<
f<PC<IC< @C>@C<ED@PFIC8I;b 1Y:LK P8GbC8Ib 9@Q@DB@C<I;<E WFB
=8IBCbP;b YKYE P8f8D K8IQC8Ib ;8 XPC< +EC8I B<EKC<I;< P8f8

D8;bBC8Ib >@9@ 9@Q@D KYI;< 9@I J8E8KC8Ib ;8 PFBKL *<C<I@


FC;LcLE;8E G<B <D@E ;<c@C@D SYEBY ?<I f<P XPC<J@E<
P898E:bP;b B@ ?@W9@I@E@ B8MI8P8DbPFI;LD /89@@ J@C8?C8Ib ;bfbE;8
+EC8I 9@Q@DB@C<I@E 8PEbP;bC8I TPC< FCD8C8Ib ><I<B@PFI;L SFB
>8I@G ;<c@C D@ <CB@ ;< FEC8IbE B8CbEKbC8IbE8 ?<I >YE I8JKCbPFILQ



8D8E<FC;LBC8IbEb9@CD@PFILQ9@C< \
IKbB 9YKYE 9LEC8I;8E JbBbCDbfKbD L 8PP8fb P<ED<B
DYDBYE ;<c@C;@ [LI8P8 98B + JYIYE><EC<I
BFELJLE;8 WFB
f<P 9@C@PFIJLE *8JbC FCLPFI 9L .<E E< P8GKbE +EC8IC8 9@IC@BK<
D@ P8f8;bE 4FBJ8 FEC8I dE>@C@Q:< D@ BFELfLPFIC8I;b 48 ;8
9<CB@ ;< J<E JYIYE><E ;@C@E@ 9@C@PFIJLE $8P;@ 9@Q< JYIYE><E:<
9@IB8W B<C@D< JXPC< \ #8C@98 9<E ;< X=B<C<ED<P< 98fCbPFI;LD
XPC< f<PC<I E8JbC FCLI 9@C@IJ@E@Q @I@ J@Q< J8WD8J8G8E f<PC<I 8E

C8KbI J@Q ;< JXQC<I@E< @E8ED8QJbEbQ D8 8;8D8 P8C8E LP

;LI;LcLEL;8@K@I8=<KK@I<D<QJ@E@Q
"8B8K ,IF=<JXI 98E8 BbQD8;b 9@C< 4@E< 8cbI 8cbI 98I;8cbEb
;FC;LILPFI;L [$8PbI <E BFELfD8;bD +EC8I ;8 XPC< 6 +
JFcLB Q8C@D :8D >@9@ >XQC<I@PC< 98E8 98BKbC8I + PbC8E >XQC<I

@PC< dfK< F Q8D8E E<C<I ;YfYE;YBC<I@E@ 8EC8;bD +EC8IbE ;8 B8

=8D
;8E ><W<EC<I@ FBL;LBC8Ib 9<CC@P;@ LELE E8JbC FC;LcLEL
98E8 JFID8PbE +C;L @fK< $<I f<P@ XcI<E;@D +EC8IbE 8M8 WbB

DbfFC;LBC8IbEb8EC8;bD #@KD<D<@Q@EM<ID<P<:<BC<I@E@;< \


,IF=<JXI< JFIL JFID8BK8E M8Q><WD@f J8;<:< FE8 XPC<:<
98BbPFI;LB .FEI8-8P [*<FC;L\;<;@ [*8JbCB8W89@C;@E\
['FC8P FC;L /<G<;<E 9@I ?8PM8E BFf8I8B ><W@PFI;L
0GLQLE 9@I f<P;@ FPL YW D<KI< B8;8I >XM;<J@PJ< @E:<P;@
4<I< JYIYEYI:<J@E< >@;@PFI;L .YIYE><EC<I F 8E;8
?<P<:8EC8ED8P8
98fC8;bC8I L ?<P<:8EC8IbEb ;8C>8 ;8C>8 8C>bCbPFI;LD .8EB@
B8E ;XBD< @JK<c@ PYQYE;<E 9<E@ LELKDLfC8I;b +I8;8E ?bQC8
LQ8BC8fKbC8I <E ;< D8B@E<P< 8KC8;bcbD >@9@ ><I@ ;XE;YD
I;bE;8E;8D8B@E<P@G8IW8C8;bD \
e@D;@P< B8;8I ;LP;LcLD ?@BVP< JFEC8IbEbE <E K8KJbQbP;b 9L
&F<ELE>bIKC8cbE;8E9@I?FDLIKLPYBJ<C;@ [! ;@EFQFIC8I8E<
FCDLf\
[? 8EC8DbPFI DLJLELQ <E ?<I f<P@E WFB 9<CC@ FC;LcLEL
J8EbPFI;LD LE8 F BYWYB 8BbCCb JYIYE><EC<I E<;<E FC;L
M:bP;bC8I FEC8I $<D >Y;YC<I@ PYQYE;<E ?<D ;< 9LEL


@JK<;@BC<I@ @W@E +EC8IbE K<B ?F9@C<I@P;@ 9L 4@P<:<B J8cC8D8B @W@E


8MC8EDbPFIC8I;b LEL<cC<ED<B@W@EP8GbPFIC8I;b \
[XPC<:< P<IPYQYE;<B@ 9YKYE ;@EFQFIC8Ib FIK8;8E B8C;bI;bC8I
XPC<D@\
[$@W FCD8QJ8 F JbI8;8 ;YEP8;8 9LCLE8E ;@EFQFIC8Ib JYIYE

><EC<IC<W8c;8f?<IKYIY .@Q:<9LDYDBYE;<c@CD@
4YQ D@CPFEC8I:8 9@QFEL FIK8;8E B8C;bID8DbQ E< B8;8I
JYI;Y
F;F BLfLE8 9@IB8W PbC @W@E;< E< FC;L '8I8I M<I@IJ<B 8JC8E

C8I B8GC8EC8I M< QYI8=8C8I E< B8;8I ;8P8EbI ? 9<E F JYIYE

><EC<I@ >XI;YcYD JbI8;8 8IKbB P<IPYQYE;< @I@ 8M ?8PM8EC8Ib


B8CD8DbfKb .YIYE><EC<I@E <E LQLEC8Ib 8E:8B ;XIK 9LWLB D<KI<
B8;8I;b $<GJ@ B8CBDbfKb FIK8;8E + BYWY:YB @9C@JC<I 8IKbB =8QC8
@I@ FCD8P8E ?8PM8EC8Ib BFM8CbPFIC8I;b 1< ?<I?8C;< F <JB@ >YQ<C
>YEC<I@;YfYE<I<B?8Pb=C8EbPFIC8I;b \
UWYDYQ ?@W9@I f<P JXPC<D<;@B Ff 9@I8 f@f<C<I@D@Q<
98B8I8B 8PP8fbE 8EC8KKbBC8IbEb ;YfYE;YB YKYE F ;@EFQFIC8I F
<M B8;8I BFJBF:8D8E ?8PM8EC8I FEC8Ib J@C8?Cb BYWYB JYIYE><E

C<IFIK8;8EB8C;bIDbfC8I;b $<D;<J8;<:<<cC<ED<B@W@E
.FEI8 &F< XE< ;FcIL <c@C<I<B <C@E@ ,IF=<JXIYE FDQLE8
BFP;L 48M8fW8 I;bE;8E 8;8Db J8IJKb [$<P ,IF=<JXI D8

;<D 9XPC< JXPCYPFIJLE F ?8C;< F J@C8?Cb BYWYB JYIYE><EC<I< E<


FC;L$8LELXcI<ED<B@W@E><I@>@KK@ED@\
,IF=<JXI 98fbEb B8C;bI;b #XQC<I@E;< >8I@G 9@I @=8;< M8I;b E

:8B B8P9FCDLf 9@I @EJ8EbE >XQC<I@E;< XPC< 9@I @=8;< FC89@C@I;@


[$VCV 8EC8P8D8;bEbQ Db .YIYE><EC<I< FCD8P8 98fCbPFI;L F
f<P
LEL >XQC<I@E;<E 8EC8;bD dI@ 8M ?8PM8EC8Ib KYB<E@PFI;L @f@E
<cC<E:<C@ P8Eb B8CD8DbfKb + ?8C;< E< P8G8:8BC8I;b 8fB8
8MbE G<f@E< ;YfKYC<I !E 9YPYB M< K<?C@B<C@ FC8E 8MbE G<f@E<
#<IW<BK<E ;< WFB <cC<E;@C<I 1< F 8M ?8PM8EbEb JFELE8 B8;8I
8MC8;bC8I \
-8P [$8E>@ 8M ?8PM8EbEb\ ;@P< JFI;L + 8PP8fbE E<


;<D<B@JK<;@c@E@B8MI8P8D8DbfKb8D8&F<PC89<E8EC8DbfKbB
,IF=<JXI PYBJ<B J<JC< ['<E;@C<I@E@ \ ;<;@ [ @c<I ?8PM8E

C8Ib FIK8;8E B8C;bI;bC8I M< JFEI8 ;8 9@I9@IC<I@E@ 8MC8D8P8


98fC8;bC8I .FELE;89@IK<B@9@C<B8CD8;b \
4@E< JLJ8I8B F ;@EFQFIC8Ib ;YfYE;YB !M B8;8I BF:8D8E
F@8E F ?8PM8EC8Ib J@C8?Cb JYIYE><EC<I FIK8;8E B8C;bIDbfC8I;b
.FEI8 BYWYB JYIYE><EC<I >XQC<I@D@Q@E XEYE;< :8EC8E;b .@C

8?C8IbEb BLCC8ED8Pb JYI;YIDYfC<I;@ IKbB B<E;@C<I@E;<E 98fB8


MLI8:8B8MB8CD8;bcbQ8D8E9@C<
&F< [58M8CCb8GK8CB<IK<EB<C<C<I \;@P<DbIbC;8E;b
-8P;<98fbEbJ8CC8;b [!M<K Q8M8CCbB8WbBB<IK<EB<C<C<I \
@fK< FE;8E JFEI8 FC8EC8I 9@Q@ ><IW<BK<E BFIBLKKL SYEBY ,IF

=<JXI 8P8c8 =bIC8;b #XQC<I@ @P@:< @I@C<fD@fK@ .8EB@ 9L >XQC<I


PLM8C8IbE;8E LcI8P8I8B YJKYDYQ< 8KbC8:8BC8I;b PP8f [.@Q@
><I@ Q<BVCbC8I\ ;@P< 98cbI;b [*<;<E PYQ D@CPFE PbC XE:< XCDYf
FC8E JYIYE><EC<I @W@E _8? M8?  <;@PFIJLELQ 4<IPYQYE;<B@ @CB
8BbCCb bIB FEC8I;b .=.2 JFELDLQLE E8JbC FC8:8cbEb J8EbPFI

JLELQ\\ @JB<DC<J@E@ @K<IB<E P<I< ;<M@I;@ $bQC8 B8GbP8 ;FcIL


>@KK@BK<E JFEI8 ;bf8Ib WbBD8;8E XE:< FI8;8 ;LI8I8B [58M8CCb
J8C8B@EJ8EC8I\;<;@ [JbCFKLILGB<E;@E@Q@W@E8cC8PbE\

+

+EC8I B8I;<fK@C<I D8 @B@J@ ;< @EJ8E FC;LBC8Ib P8 ;8 8PEb
BI<fK< 9YPY;YBC<I@ @W@E ;<c@C $8PbI +EC8I K8D 9@PFCFA@B 8EC8D;8
B8I;<fK@C<I 4YQPbCC8I XE:< 9@C< <JB@D@f 9@I JXQ:YcY BLCC8ED8B
><I<B@IJ< FEC8I _8BI898P;bC8I L JXQ _YPYB "<C8B<KK<E XE:<B@
_8@C< ;<E@C<E F B89@C<C<IC< @C>@C@ =<EFD<E@E 9@I8Q ><W<IC@ FC;LcL
W8cC8I;8EB8CD8P;b
*<B8;8ILK8EWM<I@:@9@I;LILD;L8L



EK?FEP WF:LBCLB W8cbE;8E JFEI8B@ PbCC8I;8 9L ><IW<>b ?<

D<E ?<D<E LELKDLfKL $8KK8 98Q8E 8PC8I 9FPLE:8 9L ;LILD


8BCbE8 9@C< ><CD<D@fK@ D8 f@D;@ 2@CC@8DC8 9@I8I8P8 ><C<C@
9<I@WFB8:bCb>YEC<I><W@I@PFI;L 'LIKLCLf;8PFBKLYJK<C@B
'FfLCC8I 9L ><IW<c@ KV 98fbE;8E 9<I@ 9<C@I>@E 9@I 9@W@D< JFB

J8C8I;b 9<CB@ ;LILD F B8;8I BXKY FCD8P8:8BKb TIE<c@E YPYB


"<C8B<K XE:<J@E;<B@ >YEC<I;< >XIYC;YcY >@9@ @B@E:@ 8;C8Ib 8PEb
FCJ8P;b M< 8BI898CbBC8IbEb J8;<:< 9L 9@W@D;< 9<C@IKJ<C<I;@
EK?FEP 9@I Q8D8EC8I K8I@? FBLD8P8 D<I8BCbP;b M< 9XPC< f<PC<I
FC;LcLEL9@C@PFI;L
/89@@ JFE Q8D8EC8I;8 ?<IB<J B<E;@E< LP>LE 9@I @B@E:@ 8;
J<W@PFI M< 9LEL @JK<;@c@ Q8D8E ;8 ;<c@fK@I@PFI;L .FELWK8
XE<DC@ FC8E J<D9FC Q@E:@I@P;@ L BF;C8EbPFI M< ;Fc;LcLE 8E

;8E@K@98I<EJ8E88@KFCLPFI;L
2@CC@8D EK@
LK 8;bEb 8CDbfKb @;;@ 9@I GIF=<JPFE<CC@BC< 9L
@J@D;< bJI8I <KD@fK@ /89@@ 9L FELE 9@C<:<c@ 9@I f<P;@ 8D8
9XPC<:< Q<MBJ@QC@c@E@ >XJK<ID@f FCLPFI;L EK?FEP FE YWYE<
><C;@c@ Q8D8E .D@K? 8;bEb J<WD@f M< 9@I ;8?8 9LEL ;<c@fK@ID<
@JK<c@ ;LPD8DbfKb 8J@K 9@I 8;;b 9L 'FC8PCbBC8 P8QbCbPFI;L dC

>@EWK@ EK?FEP F Q8D8E8 B8;8I 9L 8;b J<WD@f FC8E 9@I


98fB8JbPC8 ?@W B8IfbC8fD8DbfKb /89@@ 9L 8; YPYB "<C8B<KK<E
XE:< P8f8P8E @EJ8EC8I 8I8JbE;8 G<B P8P>bE;b <CB@ ;< f@D;@
<E;<I>XIYCD<BE<;<E@9LP;L
D8 EK?FEPC< 2@CC@8D 9@I8I8P8 ><C;@BC<I@ Q8D8E 8;C8IbEbE
=8IBCb FCD8JbEbE ?@W XE<D@ B8CDbPFI;L SYEBY 9@I9@IC<I@E< WFB
9<EQ@PFIC8I;b
dB@Q FCJ8C8I;b D8 K89@@ 8PEb 8E;8 ;XCC<ED@f PLDLI

K8C8I;8E 9@I@E@E ><C@fD<J@E< ?@W9@I Q8D8E @Q@E M<I@CD@PFI;L 48C

EbQ 98Q8E @B@Q FCD8P8E B8I;<fC<I 8I8JbE;8 ;8 9YPYB 9@I =@Q@B@


9<EQ<IC@B >XIYCYI;Y TQ<CC@BC< 9L @B@ B@f@ ?<D 8EE< ?<D ;<
9898C8Ib 98BbDbE;8E 8BI898 FC;LBC8Ib Q8D8E EK?FEP .D@K?
2@CC@8D;8E 9<f P8f BYWYBKY D8 @B@J@E@E ;< 9LIEL >8>8 >@9@
>XQB8G8BC8Ib f@f M< W<E<C<I@ WLBLI;L + B8?IFC8Jb:8 ><E<K@B



G@P8E>F PYQYE;<E;@ 9L /89@@ 8EE<C<I@PC< 9898C8Ib ?<I?8C;< K<B

;YQ<C@BK<E ?FfC8E;bBC8Ib @W@E 8PEb f<P@ K<BI8IC8;bBC8IbE;8E 9L


I<Q8C<K<XE8P8BFCDLfC8I;b
8fC8E>bWK8 2@CC@8DC8 EK?FEP 9<I89<IC<IB<E ;@c<IC<I@ FE

C8I8 ?8PI<KC< 98BDbfC8I M< 9LEL >8I@G 9@I J<JJ@QC@B @QC<D@fK@


EK?FEP 9L ;LILD8 8C;bID8D8P8 W8CbfbPFIJ8 ;8 2@CC@8D JbI= @E8C
FCJLE ;@P< P8 ;8 >b:bBCbcbE;8E [@Q B8I;<f@Q \ ;<D<P<
98fC8DbfKb
XPC< 9@I ;LILD;8 B8IfbJbE;8B@ [48 \ ;@P< DbIbC;8EbPFI 
J8EB@ K8D B8EB8I;<f FCLG FCD8;bBC8IbEb JFID8B @JK@PFIDLf >@9
;LI8BCbPFI;L .FEI8 ;8 K<I9@P< M< E<Q8B<K BLI8CC8Ib 98JBbE
WbBbP8 M< 9L B@DJ< J8EB@ BFEL ?@W ;< @C>@EW ;<c@CD@f >@9@ ;XEYG
>@;@PFI ;L /89@@ 9L <E;<I FCLPFI;L ,IFA<E@E YQ<I@E;< W8Cbf8E

C8IbE WFcb ><IW<c@ 9@C@PFI M< 9L BFELP8 ?@W >@ID@PFIC8I;b #<IW<c@


XcI<ED<D<C<I@ DYDBYEDYP;Y
JCbE;8 2@CC@8D BXKY 9@I @EJ8E ;<c@C;@ $@W ;<c@C;@ EK?FEP
E@E B8I;<f@ FCD8J8P;b P8 ;8 ?@W FCD8QJ8 >XIYEYfY 9L ><IW<W
D8JB<C<P<:<B B8;8I ;<c@f@B FCJ8P;b FELEC8 WFB @P@
><W@E<:<BC<I;@
D8
SF:LBB<E 9@IC@BK< FPLEC8I FPE8Dbf FCD8C8Ib ;8 ;LILD BFC8P

C8fKbIDbPFI;L UJK<C@B <c@K@DC<I@E@E @CB ;<MI<C<I@E@ ;< P@E< 8PEb


BI<fK< ><W@ID@fC<I;@ EE<C<I@ 9@IK8BbD D8E<MI8C8I JFEL:L
98f8IDbfKb 9LEL '8;bE 8PEb 9898;8E @B@ <IB<B WF:LB ;YEP8P8
><K@ID@f M< 9XPC<:< BFK8JbEb ;FC;LIDLfKL UWYE:Y WF:LB @W@E
><I<BC@ FC8E JbBb BFfLCC8Ib P<I@E< ><K@I<D<D@fK@  .FEI8 ;8 8EE<C

<I@@B@FcCLEL9@I;<EQ@P8I<K<KD<B@JK<D@fK@ /L?8=9@IB8;bE;bF
'I<fK<E XE:< 2@CC@8D 8PIbCDbfKb /89@@ E< ;< FCJ8 F ;8?8
9YPYBKY @C@D@ J<WD@fK@ P8E@ ><E<K@B DY?<E;@JC@c@E@ EK?FEP
9LEL BI<fK<PB<E 8EE<J@E@E P8Q;bV 9@I D<BKLGK8E XcI<ED@fK@
EK?FEP F JbI8;8 DY;@I<PC< B<J@E 9@I 9@W@D;< BFELf8:8B
P8fK8P;b M< 9XPC<:< D<BKLGC8IbE 8IB8Jb B<J@CD@fK@ D8 8;8D
JFED<BKL9L;8@D8?8KbICbPFI;L SYEBYXPC<J@E<LK8EDbfKbB@ 



EK?FEP ;< JFELE;8 9@C@D 8C8EbE8 >@ID@fK@ L BFEL;8


P<K<E<BC@ FC;LcL 8EC8fbCDbf M< K<fM@B ;< >XIDYfKY EK?FEP
8c89<PJ@PC< B8IfbC8f89@C<:<c@E@ ;YfYE<I<B WbC>bE:8 9@I BFIBLP8
B8GbC;bcbEb LELKDLPFI f@D;@ 9LELE 9@I B<?8E<KK<E =8IBJbQ
FC;LcLEL ;YfYEYPFI;L EK?FEP 2@CC@8DC8 B8IfbC8fD8D8B @W@E
K<C<D<KI@B BFELJLEL J<WD@fK@ L ><E<K@B DY?<E;@JC@c@PC< ?@W9@I
@C>@J@FCD8P8E9@I8C8E;b 48;8@EJ8EXPC<J8EbPFI;
.FEI8)<IBYI@,IFA<J@><C@fK@I@C@IB<EB8;<I;<9<BC<D@fK@
@I 8E ><CD@f M< GIFA< WbBD8Q8 >@ID@fK@ + Q8D8E 9@I XE<I@
;LILDL BLIK8I;b D8 EK?FEP 8PEb Q8D8E;8 8EE<J@PC< 98

98JbEbE ?8QbIC8;bBC8Ib F B8G8E8 BbJbCDbfKb df@E <E >8I@G M<


>YCYEW P8EbPJ8 XE<I@;< 9LCLE8EbE EK?FEP FCD8JbP;b .8=W8
P8GDbfKb 9LEL

2@CC@8D EK@
LKLE )<IBYI@ ,IFA<J@ BFELJLE;8 9@C>@J@ M8I;b
+ ;FcD8;8E XE:< 8KbC8E M< XC;YBK<E JFEI8 ;8 PFCLE8 ;<M8D
<;<:<B FC8E LQLE 4bC;bQ .FE;8Jb BFELJLE;8 9@C>@J@ FC;LcL >@9@
;8DbE )8IJK8B@ BFCFE@ BFELJLE;8 ;8 9@I =@BI@ M8I;b JK<IF@;

C<I;<9<EQ<IBFCFE@C<IBLILCD8JbE8W8CbfbC;bcbEbE;8=8IBbE;8P;b
D8 9YKYE 9LEC8I B8=8JbEbE ;<I@EC@BC<I@E;< B8C8E f<PC<I;@ M<
8;8D @W@E ><IW<B 9@I XE<DC<I@ PFBKL $8KbIC8P89@C;@c@ B8;8IbPC8
LQ8PC8 @C>@C@ W898C8I ?@W9@I Q8D8E @C>@J@E@ =8QC8 W<BD<D@fK@ .FEI8
9@I >YE 9@I 9IFfYI;< )<IBYI@ ,IFA<J@E@E YQ<I@E;< W8Cbf8E B@DJ<C

<I@EI<JD@E@>XIDYfKY
dWC<I@E;<E 9@I@E@E 8;bEbE EK?FEP .D@K? FCD8Jb 2@CC@8DD @C

>@J@E@ W<BD@fK@ ;8D B8I;<f@E@E J<WK@c@ F 8:8@G @B@E:@ 8;b


?8KbICbPFI;L dJD@E@E EK?FEP FC;LcLEL ;8 $<I?8C;< @B@ EK?FEP
.D@K?FC8D8Q;b
2@CC@8D JFEI8 =FKFcI8=8 98BDbfKb + PYQ BLfBL >XKYI<:<B
>@9@ ;<c@C;@ LILDL BFEKIFC @W@E ?<D<E 8C8P 8PE8P8 98BKb



$8PbI FPYQYK8EbD8D8Jb@DBVEJbQ;b
LILD 2@CC@8Db <cC<E;@ID@f FCJ8 9@C< @W@E< <E;@f< ;<
B8IbfbPFI;L L 9<EQ<P@f LK8EW M<I@:@ 9@I FC8P8 PFC 8W89@C@I;@
48E@ 9L
F @cI<EW K<I@D@ BLCC8ED8E ><I<B@PFIJ8K8D B8EB8I;<fC@B
D8 9L BFEL;8 E< P8GbC89@C@I;@ EE<C<I@E@E ;< 9898C8IbEbE ;8
?8P8C>Y:YFCD8;bcb9<CC@P;@ L><IW<BE8JbC;<c@fK@I@C<9@C@I;@
2@CC@8D @f< >@;<:<c@ JbI8;8 9IFfYIY ;8C>bECbBC8 :<9@E< JFB

DLf M< 9LEL XcC< P<D<c@ Q8D8Eb =8IB<KD@fK@ "FKFcI8=8 K<BI8I


98BKbcbE;8 EK?FEPE@E PYQYE;< Q<B@ 9@I @=8;< >XI;Y -<J@D
PYQYEY FC8E:8 :8ECbCbcbPC8 P8B8C8DbfKb D8 JFE Q8D8EC8I;8 =F

KFcI8=C8IWFB98f8IbCbFCLPFI;L
@IC@BK< P<D<B P<;@c@ )8I:F @CD<DE< + ?8=K8B@ 8;b E<PJ<
D<I8BC8 [*<P<98BbPFIJLE 2@CC@8D\;@P<JFIDLfKL
;8D @W@E;<E ><C<E J<J< LP8I8B 9IFfYIY )8I:FP8 LQ8KKb
[L 9<E@D B8I;<f@D \ L KbGBb bJbI>8EC8Ib 8MLWC8D8P8
9<EQ@PFI;L
)8I:F B8fC8IbEb W8K8I8B =FKFcI8=b @E:<C<D@fK@ ['@D -<J@D

;<P8EbE;8;LI8E8;8DDb\
[$8PbI <E J8E;bcbE F 8;8D 48E@ fL 98E8 9<EQ<P<E +
9<E@DB8I;<f@D \
L B<Q ;8?8 LQLE 9@I J<JJ@QC@B FCDLfKL .FEI8 )8I:F I<JD@
><I@ M<ID@f M< @=8;<J@Q 9@I J<JC< [PEb 8EE< M< 9898;8E Db\
;<D@fK@
[!M<K \
[$<D8EE<8PEb ?<D;<9898 XPC<D@\
[!M<K \
[#YCYEW\
[TPC< J8EbIbD \ 2@CC@8D @W@E@ W<BD@fK@ [L 9IFfYI;<E 8E

C8fbC;bcbE8 >XI< B8I;<f@D /<BJ8JK8 K<C<D<KI@B 8C8EbE;8


W8C@fbPFI
<E ;< 9LI8;8 FK@JK@QDC< @C>@C@ W8CbfD8C8I P8GbPFILD +ELE @W@E
9L98cXE<DC@D@\
2@CC@8D BFELPC8 ;8?8 =8QC8 @C>@C<ED<D@f M< F >YE ;8?8



JFEI8 9IFfYIY 8KDbfKb .FE P8K8B


8IB8;8fbEbE FEL >XID<J@E@
@JK<D<D@fK@ '8;bEbE JbI8;8E 9@I <JGI@ 8EC8PbfbEbE FCD8Jb
2@CC@8Db >@K>@;< PFILPFI;L ;8D B8;bEbE WF:LB @JK<D<D<J@E<
J<M@E@PFI;L 58K<E 2@CC@8DbE 9@IB8W PbC XE:< 9@I WF:LcL FCDLfKL
+ L=8B K<=<B <JD<IC< 9L BFEL;8 @f9@IC@c@ P8GDbfC8I;b '8;bEbE
8;b(8LI8DbP;b PFBJ8(@E;8Db @fK<9XPC<9@If<P
2@CC@8D 9IFfYIY >XI;YBK<E <E 8f8cb 9@I PbC JFEI8 -8E;8CC
FC8Pb 98fC8DbfKb L JYI< @W@E;< B8I;<f@E@ ;YfYEDYfJ< 9@C<
B@
;YfYED<D@fK@-8E;8CC;8E JFEI8 9LEL P8G8:8B Q8D8E ?@W
9LC8D8DbfKb
2@CC@8D -8E;8CCbE M8ICbcbEb XcI<E;@c@ JbI8;8 WF:LB FE 8CKb
P8fbE;8P;b '@DJ<PC< @C@fB@J@ FCD8;8E P8fbPFI;L '<EKL:BP;<
FEL P<K@fK@I;@BC<I@ BI<fK< WF:LcLE FIK8;8E B8C;bIbCD8JbE8 B8I8I
M<ID@fC<I;@ /89@@ _K<D@QC<D<P< J<B@Q FE >YE B8C8 ;LILDL *<N
4FIB dEJ8E @C@DC<I@ !EJK@KYJYE< 9@C;@ID<P@ 8BbC <;<9@CD@fC<I;@
L DY<JJ<J<;<E ;8?8 WFB _$FDFCFA@B !EJK@KY ;@P< JXQ
<;@C@PFI;L 
-8GFI 2@CC@8D8 ;@c<I 9@IB8W 9<C><PC< 9@IC@BK< M<I@CD@fK@
-8E;8EC8 @C>@C@ K8I@=K< ;< ;@BB8K@E@ W<B<:<B XQ<C 9@I f<P PFBKL
E:8B BI<fC<I< P8G8:8cb F JbBb:b PFC:LCLBC8I;8E 9@I@E@E Q8D8Eb
><CD@fK@ <CB@ 8Kb 1@I>@E@8;8 LP>LE 9@I@E@ 9LC89@C@I;@ 2@CC@8D
FI8P8 >@KK@ M< ;YfBbIbBCbcbE8 LcI8P8I8B 9<CB@ ;< <CC@E:@ B<Q
[LE;8E JFEI8 9L Q@P8I<KC<I@ K<C<M@QPFE >XIYEKYJY P8I;bDbPC8
P8G8:8cbD \ ;@P< ] P<D@E <KK@ .FEI8 ;8 B<E;@ B<E;@E< D8;<D
9LI8C8I8 B8;8I ><C;@D ;<;@ !M< ;XED<;<E fL '<EKL:BP;<B@
BI<f<;<9@I98B8PbD
JCbE;8?@W9@If<P9<BC<D@PFI;L
E:8B -8E;8CCbE ><E 9@W@D@E@ FE ;8B@B8 B8;8I @E:<C<I @E

:<C<D<Q 9@C>@J8P8I ?<J89b @W@E ?<D<E <EJK@KYPY 8I8;b .FEI8


;8 8IB8JbE8 P8JC8E8I8B JFE 8E;8 @W@D;<E ><C;@c@ @W@E
9LI8;8PbD ;@P< ;YfYE;Y 4FBJ8 9@I ?8=K8 @W<I@J@E;<
-8E;8CCb J<JJ@Q:< FIK8;8E B8C;bI8:8BC8I;b L ;YfYE:<
PYQYE;<E K<IC<D<P< 98fC8DbfKb -8E;8CC b FIK8;8E B8C;bID8B



@W@E @C8W BLCC8E8:8BC8I;b L ?@W 8:b M<ID<;<E WF:LcLE


:@C;@E;<E B8EbE8 B8Ibf8:8B M< -8E;8CC ;8 ;<I@E 9@I LPBLP8
;8C8:8BKb I;bE;8E ;8 LPBL P8M8f P8M8f XCYDC< JFELWC8E8

:8BKb dC8:bE P@ID@ YW ?<:<C@ I<JD@ 9@I 8;b M8I;b D8 2@CC@8D
;8?<IB<J>@9@9LE;8E _*@IM8E8D@E< ;@P<JXQ<;@PFI;L
@C@D 8;8Db 98f?<Df@I<P< [+ELE K8D 8;b E<;@I\ ;@P<
JFI;L
'I<f@PXE<K<EB8;bE [-8E;8CC*FN8E 9@C>@E \;<;@
2@CC@8D D4 43* Db\ ;@P< 98cbI;b \ D8 9L dE>@C@Q:<
;<?@WB@DJ<;<D<B \
8f?<Df@I< ?8I=C<I@ JbI8C8;b [*FN8E L 8;b ><W<E PbC
J<WK@ \
[1< J@Q 9LELE E< 8EC8D8 ><C;@c@E@ =8IB<KD<;@E@Q XPC<
D@ L 8; *F FE< ;@P< FBLELPFI $@W B@DJ< ;<D<B 9L L
;<C@B8ECbBFELJLE;8I8GFIM<ID<B8BCbEbQ8><CD<;@D@\
8f?<Df@I<f8f8C8DbfKb [L9@Q< \;@P<98fC8;b
2@CC@8D <C@E@ J8CC8P8I8B B8;bEb JLJKLI;L LELE E< P8I8Ib
M8I ;@P< ;YfYEYPFI;L '8;bE ;LILDL E8JbC 8EC8I;b #<E
9@W@D@E;< 9L M8B8EbE ;<IJ B@K8GC8IbE;8B@C<I< LPD8;bcbEb
>XJK<I<E 9@I f<P PFBKL L 9<CC@ 9<C@IJ@Q 9@I B8IbfbD;b 2@CC@8D
M< P8I;bD:bC8Ib P@ID@ PbC 9FPLE:8 FK@JK@B WF:LBC8I YQ<I@E;<
P8GKbBC8Ib ;<E<PC<I JFEL:L 9LCDLfC8I;b 9LEL M< 9@I <f@PC<
><IW<BP8f8D;8;8?@WB8IbfD8DbfC8I;b
<C@B8ECbPJ8FIK8;8EB8C;bIbCD8BYQ<I<P;@
#IL9LE <E J@E@IC@J@ FC8E )8I:F P8BbED8P8 98fC8;b
[ 8?8 ?8D@C<C@B K8D8DC8ED8;8E WF:LBC8Ib 8CD8P8 B8CBbPFI

C8I 8?8 JFEI8 ;8 FEC8Ib FIK8;8E B8C;bID8B @W@E 8:<C< <;@P

FIC8I YKYE ><E 9@W@DC<I@E@E @CB @E:<C<D< @W@E ><C@fD<C<I@E<


@Q@E M<I@CD<C@ @I WF:LB 9@I ?FDFCFA@JKC< >XIYfYCD<;<E FI

K8;8EB8C;bIbCD8D8Cb \
2@CC@8DJ8B@EJ8B@E [4<K<I@B8;8I?FDFCFA@JKPFB \;<;@
)8I:F [$@W FCD8QJ8 9YKYE ><E 9@W@DC<I@E@ 9@C>@J8P8IC8
@E:<C<P<9@C@I@Q \\;@P<:<M8GM<I;@



['LCC8E89@C<:<c@D@Q9@I@C<I@E@BFILD8B@W@ED@\
[LI8;8 P8 ;8 98fB8 P<I;< ?FDFCFA@ 8C8EbE;8 P8I8I

C8E89@C<:<c@D@Q B@DJ<C<I@E FIK8;8E B8C;bIbCD8C8IbEb <E><CC<

D<B @W@E '<E;@D@Q@ ;FcIL ;YIYJK 8EC8P89@CD<B @W@E ><E


9@W@DC<I@E@ FEC8I ?8I<B<K ?8C@E;<PB<E @E:<C<D<C@P@Q @C@PFI

JLE B@ 9@Q< <E =8QC8 9@C> J8cC8P8E ;8 BFIBLEW M< 8EFID8C


9@W@DC<I +K@QD 8C8EbE;8B ;<E<PC<I@D@Q 9@Q< ?FDFCFA@ BF

ELJLE;8 ><E@f 9@C>@ J8cC8;b L>YE 9@C>@D@Q @f< @CB >@I@fK@c@D

@Q>YEBYE;<EWFB;8?8=8QC8 \
$FDFCFA@ JXQ:YcYE;<E WFB dEJ8EbE #<E<K@B "@QPFCFA@J@ 
K<I@D@E@ 9<c<E<E 2@CC@8D [$8PbI \ ;<I >@9@ 98fbEb J8CC8;b [*<
FCLIJ8 FCJLE WFB ;@BB8KC@ ;8MI8ED8CbPbQ <E<PC<I@D@Q@E WFB
P8I8ICb FC;LcLEL JXPCYPFILQ 8D8 9@Q< 9L @f @W@E QFICLBC8 @Q@E
M<I@PFIC8I .FELWK8@EJ8E?8P8KbPC8FPELPFILQ9@Q \
[48I8IJbQ ?8P8KC8IC8 +IK8;8E B8C;bIbCD8P8 C8PbB
B@DJ<C<IC< \
[@I@E@ W89L:8B FE8 8:b M<ID<;<E FIK8;8E B8C;bID8B
98fB8 9@Q@D ;<E<PC<I@D@Q 98fB8 L ;<E<PC<I ><E<CC@BC< LQLE
JYIYPFIM<@JK<D<;@c@D@Q?8C;<BXKYJFELWC8E89@C@PFI \
[+EC8I898Q8EP8I;bD<;@PFILQ \
[.8Q8E;8<;<D@PFILQ \
JCbE;8 8EC8DJbQ 9@I K8IKbfD8P;b SYEBY 9LEL WXQYDC<

D<E@E PFCL PFBKL JCbE;8 ?FDFCFA@JKC<I 8E:8B 9@IB8W @C>@EW


8EFID8C B@f@ 9LC89@C@PFIC8I;b dEJ8EC8Ib 9LEC8IbE J8PbC8IbEb
8IKKbID8C8Ib @W@E K<fM@B <KD<B ;< FCD8Q;b K89@@ YPYB "<C8B<K@E
P8I8KKbcb J8IJbEKb ?@W9@I Q8D8E ><WD<P<:<B 9L P8I8 W<f@KC@ PFC

C8I;8EB<E;@E@>XJK<I<:<BK@ LM8B8C8I;8FEC8I;8E9@@P;@
0Q8P 8I8fKbID8C8IbEbE K<C8fC8 K<fM@B <;@CD<J@E@E E<;<E@ @E

J8EC8IbE YPYB "<C8B<K PYQYE;<E ;YEP8;8 P8f8DbE G8DLB


@GC@c@E< 98cCb FC;LcLEL XcI<ED<C<I@P;@ 8Qb JFJPFCF>C8I 9LEL
B8EbKC8DbfC8I;b;8
[$<IE<PJ< \
2@CC@8D F Q8D8E8 B8;8I -8E;8CC *FN8E >@9@J@PC<



B8IfbC8fD8DbfKb $@W9@I Q8D8E +K@QD@E 8cbI 8cbI >XIYCD<J@ 9L


<E;<I 9LCLE8E ><E 9@W@D@E@E <E 9<C@I>@E XQ<CC@c@P;@ L
E<;<EC< LQD8EC8IbE -8E;8CC BFELJLE;8 XE:<B@ ?8JK8C8I8 BbP

8JC8 ;8?8 =8QC8 9@C>@C<I@ M8I;b $8KK8 ;<C@B8ECb 9YKYE @C<K@f@D@


B<J<I<B :@C;@E@E @W@E< J8BC8ED8;8E @C>@J@Q <I@f@C<D<P<:<B 9@I
;LILD8 >@ID<;<E XE:< C89FI8KLM8I;8 JFE ;YfYE:<C<I@E@ 9@I8Q
P8B8C8D8Pb98f8IDbfC8I;b
+E;8E JFEI8 F 8cbI @fC<D 98fC8;b -8E;8CC8 JLE@ LP8Ib:b
LP>LCLPFI M< 9LELE JYI<J@E@ >@K>@;< LQ8KbPFIC8I;b XPC<:<
WF:LcLE 9<P@E@W@ =88C@P<KC<I@ FIK8P8 WbBbPFI;L L J8P<;< ?<D
EFID8C ?<D ;< -8E;8CC >@9@C<I@E@E 9<P@EC<I@E@E E8JbC W8CbfKbB

C8Ib8EC8fbCD8P898fC8EbPFI;L
+ B8;8I WFB 9@C>@ KFGCLPFIC8I;b B@ 2@CC@8D FK@QD@ ><I@
W<M@ID< ;YfYE:<C<I@E@E 8IKbB 9@I ?8P8C FCD8BK8E WbBKbcbE8 @E8E

D8P8 98fC8;b dB@E:@ 8; FC8I8B EK@


LKL J<WD<J@E< ;< WFB
J<M@E@PFI;L
-8E;8CC YQ<I@E;<B@ W8CbfD8C8I PYQYE;<E ;LP;LcL D<D

ELECLB <E PYBJ<B EFBK8JbE8 <I@fK@c@ JbI8;8 FEL 8CC8JK8E


8I8;bC8I !E FCD8P8:8B Q8D8E;8 FE8 W8CbfD8C8IbEb
9bI8B8I8B P<E@ 9@I JFILEC8 @C>@C<ED<J@ @W@E f@;;<KC< 98JBb P8G

D8P898fC8;bC8I
2@CC@8D ;8?8 JFEI8 ><I@P< 98BKbcbE;8 FEL JFELE;8
8CC8J8 >@KD<P< E<P@E @BE8 <KK@c@E@ 9@I KYICY 8EC8P8D8;b
/89@@ JFILC8Ib f8EJbEbE B<E;@E< WFB P8I;bD <KK@c@E@ ;YfYE<

:<BK@ D8 8CC8J8>@KD<P<E<;<EI8QbFCDLfKL


LELE E<;<E@ =8IBbE8 M8ID8;8E 9IFfYIY B8I;<f@E@E =F

KFcI8=bEb?8KbIC8D8JbDbP;bD89LFC8D8Q;bK89@@
#<C><C<C@D 2@CC@8D FI8P8 >@KD<P< JFELE;8 I8Qb FC;L E

:8B K8fbKK8 D@BIF


I<8BKXIYE ?8=@= LcLCKLJL K@QC<fK@c@ M< 8

W<B@D YE@K<J@ @E@f @W@E W8CbfD8P8 98fC8;bcb JbI8;8 2@CC@8D ;8


F =FKFcI8=b 8EbDJ8;b 8?8 ;FcILJL 9<CC<c@E@E 9@C@EWC@ P8EbE8
B8P;b
EK?FEP 8CC8JK8 W8CbfbPFI;L 2@CC@8D 8IKbB B8I;<f@E@E



)<IBYI@ ,IFA<J@ YQ<I@E;< W8Cbf8E >ILGK8E FC;LcLEL ?8KbIC8

D8BK8P;b $8=@= J8IJbEKb PFC:LCLcLE JFE8 <I;@c@E@ ?89<I M<I@

IB<EPLKBLE;L LB8IfbC8fD8@B@J@E@;<I8?8KJbQ<;<:<BK@


EK?FEP ><C<E LQD8Eb B8IfbC8D8B @W@E ;8D;8B@ B89LC
P<I@E;< 9<BC@PFI;L 48CEbQ ;<c@C;@ K89@@ +C;LBW8 B8C898CbB 9@I
>ILGK8P;b L B8C898CbB )<IBYI@ ,IFA<J@PC< @C>@C<E<E LQD8E

C8IbE E< B8;8I W8I<J@Q ;LILD;8 FC;LBC8IbEb 8WbBCbPFI;L


EK?FEP ;8?8 XE<DJ@Q B@DJ<C<I@E 8I8JbE;8P;b JCbE;8 XE

<I@ B<E;@J@E;<E ><C;@c@ @W@E B8IfbC8D8 KXI<E@E< B8KbCD8B


QFILE;8B8CDbfKb
EK?FEP 9LEL ;YfYE;YBW< ?8=@= 8D8 ;<M8DCb 9@I B8P>b
;LPLPFI;L L XE<I@ 9YPYB 9@I 9<c<E@PC< B8IfbC8EDbfKb +EL
XMDYfC<I;@ ;< D8 ?<I Q8D8E XE<I@E@E FE;8E ><C;@c@ EFB

K8Jb YQ<I@E;< ;< ?8=@=W< ;LILPFIC8I;b 48E@ 9L @f =@P8JBFPC8


JFELWC8EbIJ8 ?<GJ@ 8K<f ?8KKbE;8E LQ8BC8f8:8B M< EK?FEP@
FIK8;89bI8B8:8BC8I;b
EK?FEP JFEI8;8E JbBbEKbPC8 9<CB@ ;< 9L XE<I@D@E E<;<E@
8c89<P@D@E ?FDFCFA@ 8C8EbEb J<WD@f FC;LcLEL ?8P8C D<P8C
?8KbIC8D8D;b ;@P< ;YfYE<:<BK@ L FC89@C@I D8 f8IK ;<c@C
JCbE;8 9L XE<I@ D8EKbBCbP;b M< B8WbEbC8D8P8:8B 9@I f<P;@
c89<P@D 9@I =8EK8Q@ P8Q8Ib >@9@ Q8I8IJbQ 9@I@ FCJ8P;b P8 ;8 ?@W
8BI898DFCD8J8P;b9L=@B@IP@E<;<8BCbD8><C<:<BK@
.FILE@W><Q<><EC<IC<@C>@C@P;@
dEJ8EC8I P M< )8IJ8 P<IC<fD@fC<I;@ 8?8 9YPYB 8JK<I

F@;C<I< M< &YG@K<I@E LP;LC8IbE8 <I@f@CD@fK@ &YG@K<I@E <KI8=bE;8


?bQC8 ;XE<I<B 9L PFCC8 .8KYIEYE 9YPYB LP;LJL /@K8E8 <I@fD<
GC8EC8Ib ><C@fK@I@C@PFI;L $8KK8 @EJ8EC8IbE ;bf #YE<f .@JK<DC<I

@E< P<;@ PbC JYI<:<B 9@I PFC:LCLB P8GD8C8Ib 9@C< ;YfYEYCYPFI;L


D8 @W ><Q<><EC<I< @EJ8EC8IbE 9LCLE;LcL LQ8P ><D@C<I@ ?VCV
>XE;<I@C<D@PFI;L LELEE<;<E@#YE<fK<EBFIBLCD8JbP;b



YEP8EbE PXIYE><J@E@E @W@E;< B8C8E @B@ ><Q<><E;<E 1<EYJ


G<BW<B@:@;<c@C;@  @c<IK8I8=K8E)<IBYI@
D@KI@ (8I>< YEP8 'FD@K<J@E@E )<IBYI@ ,IFA<J@E< =FE
J8cC8ED8Jb @W@E B8I8I M<ID<J@E< PFC 8W8E BFELfD8Pb P8GKbcb
JbI8;8 EK?FEP ?<EYQ K@D< B8KbCD8DbfKb E:8B 98EKC8Ib
@QC<D@f M< D@KI@ E@E BFELfD8JbEb ;@EC<D@fK@ 0QD8EbE ?@W9@I
?8QbICbB P8GD8;8E BFELfKLcL @;;@8 <;@C@PFI;L D8 E< FCLIJ8
FCJLE WFB 98f8IbCb 9@I BFELfD8P;b UJK<C@B F >YE;<E 9<I@
)<IBYI@,IFA<J@E;<LP>LC8E8E?<IGI<EJ@9@@W<I@PFI;L
D@KI@ XQ<CC@BC< K<BEFCFA@E@E #YE<f bfbcbE;8B@ I8;P8JPFE

C8IbE @EJ8EC8I8 M<I<:<c@ Q8I8Ib <E><CC<D<P@ 98f8I8:8B B8;8I


@C<IC<D<J@E@ 9<BC<D<E@E ?8K8 FC8:8cbEb ;@BB8KC< 9<C@IKD@fK@
)<IBYI@ <fJ@Q 9@I P<I;@ M< @EJ8EC8I 9L ><Q<><E;<E WFB f<P
XcI<E<9@C@IC<I;@ )<IBYI@E@E PYQ<P@E;<E #YE<f 98fB8 P<I;<E
P8GbCD8JbDYDBYEFCD8P8E9@I9@W@D;< @P@:<@E:<C<E<9@C@I;@
/89@@ @EJ8EbE P<I@E< 98fB8 9@I f<P P8E@ 9@I IF9FK F ><Q<

><E<>XE;<I@C@IJ<
#<I<BC@ =@Q@BJ<C XQ<CC@BC<I@ FC8E 9@I IF9FK P8GbC89@C@I;@ #<Q<

><E< PLDLf8B @E@f P8GD8BJ8 BFC8P;b E:8B IF9FK )<IBYI@


><Q<><E@E<@E;@I@C;@BK<EJFEI8E<FC8:8BKb
-F9FK >XQC<D P8G89@C@I M< 9LE8 >XI< ;8MI8EbI;b D8 ,IF

A< YQ<I@E;< W8Cbf8EC8I IF9FKLE ?8I<B<KC<I@E@E B8ID8fbB M< @C

>@EW FCD8JbEb @JK@PFIC8I;b PIb:8 IF9FKLE E< KYI >XQC<DC<I


P8G8:8cbE;8E;8G<B<D@E;<c@CC<I;@
-F9FKLE ?<I KYICY D8EKbBCb @?K@D8C< B8Ifb ?8QbICbBCb FCD8Jb
M< B8ID8fbB @fC<I 98f8ID8Jb @W@E 9@I 9@C>@J8P8Ib ;8 @W<ID<J@
FE8 <fC@B <KD<J@ ><I<B@PFI;L  8CC8JK8 98QbC8Ib 9LE;8E
_9<P@E ;@P< JXQ <;@PFIC8I;b D8 EK?FEP 9LE;8E ?FfC8E

D8Q;b 8?8 JFEI8 8:898 9LELE E<;<E@ 8c89<P@D@E 9<P@E


YQ<I@E;< W8CbfD8Jb Db ;@P< B<E;@ B<E;@E< JFI8:8BKb  L BFD

GYK<I@EP<K<I@B8;8IB8ID8fbBM<WFB;8P<K<E<BC@FCD8Jbf8IKb
E:8B 9XPC< 9@I f<P@E P8GbCD8Jb M< )<IBYI@P< >XKYIYC<I<B
FI8P8 @E;@I@C<:<B B8;8I GFIK8K@= FCD8Jb FC8E8BJbQ;b PIb:8


GC8EC8;bBC8Ib KYI;< 9@I IF9FKLE @fC<I@E< P8I8D8Jb @W@E ?8I<B<K


<;<9@CD<J@ ><I<BC@P;@ <CB@ IF9FK@BW@C<I@E YQ<I@E;< FPE8;bBC8Ib
GFQ@KIFE@B PFCC8I @C<I@;< 9L 98BbD;8E @f< P8I8P8:8BC8I;b D8
F>YE?<EYQ><CD<D@fK@
@c<I 9@I PFC @J< IF9FKLE P8GKbcb ?<I >XQC<D@ 8EbE;8
;YEP8P8 PFCC8D8JbP;b XPC<:< P<IPYQYE;<B@ 9@I 9@C>@J8P8I ;8
IF9FKLE 9L >XQC<DC<I< >XI< ?8I<B<K <KD<J@E@ J8cC8P89@C@I;@
48E@D8B@E<8;8D)<IBYI@;< 9<PE@PJ<9LI8;8FC8:8BKb
LE8 B8I8I M<I@C;@c@ Q8D8E K<C<D<KI@JC<I <E XE<DC@ K<BE@JP

<EC<I J8PbCD8P8 98fC8;bC8I dfK< EK?FEP ;< F Q8D8E GIFA<P<


B8KbC;b )<JC<B;8fC8Ib >@9@  ;<E  D@CPFE D@C< B8;8I LQ8

BCbBK8E @f8I<KC<I@ 8CD8EbE M< B8IfbCbB M<ID<E@E PFCC8IbEb 8IbP

FI;L UJK<C@B 9L @f8I<KC<I@E FEC8Ib BXKY 9@I 9@W@D;< <E><CC<P<9@

C<E 9@I #YE<f ;@JB@E< ;FcIL M< 98Q8E ;8 FELE P8EbE;8E


><W<:<B9@W@D;<PXEC<E;@I@CD<C<I@;<><I<B@PFI;L
EK?FEP @f@E< ?bIJC8 J8IbCDbfKb .FELE;8 9L BFEL;8 LJK8:8
W8CbfKbcbEb M< 98f8IbCb FC;LcLEL ;YfYE<:<BK@ )<IBYI@E@E
W<MI<J@E;< PXIYE><P< FKLIKLC8E M< f8CK<I >XI<M@ P8G8E YW
D<IB<Q @f 8IB8;8fC8IbE;8E WFB FELE <J<I@P;@ )<IBYI@ LP;L

C8Ib ;<E@C<E 9L D<IB<QC<I F ><Q<><E;<E ;YEP8P8 M<


P<IPYQYE;<E ;< ><Q<><E< @f8I<K >XE;<I@G 8C8:8B >YWK<P;@C<I
UWY ;< ?<D<E ?<D<E JYI<BC@ FC8I8B #YE<f@E I8;P8JPFE

C8IbE8 ;8P8E8:8B 9@W@D;< P8GbCDbfKb !E XE<DC@J@ D<IB<QC<I


#YE<f@E@f8I<KC<I@<KB@C<D<J@E<;<<E><CFCLPFIC8I;b
L YW LP;L 8IQ;8E 9@I D@CPFE D@C B8;8I LQ8BCbc8 FKLIKLC

DLfC8I;b )<IBYI@ #YE<f@E 8IB8JbE;8 B8C;bcb M< P<IPYQYE;<B@


?<I?8E>@ 9@I @JK8JPFELE @f8I<KC<I@E@ 8C8D8;bcbE;8 9@C< 9LEL
J8cCbPFIC8I;b
XPC<:< ><I@P< IF9FK B8CbPFI;L -F9FK@B M< K<C<D<KI@BW@C<I@E
9@IC@BK< P8I8KKbBC8Ib ?8I@B8 9@I f<P;@ 9L IB8 8IB8P8 P8GbC8E FE
DF;<C@E <E 8PIbEKbCbJbP;b @I @EJ8EbE @B@ B8Kb 9YPYBCYcYE;< M<
9<f B8Kb 8cbICbcbE;8P;b @I @EJ8E;8E WFB ;8?8 =8QC8 f<P@ 8C

>bCbPFIM<P8G89@C@PFI;L D8FE8PFC>XJK<I@CD<J@f8IKbPC8


-F9FK8 I<?9<IC@B <;<:<B 9@C>@J8P8IbE WFB 8PIbEKbCb M<


B8ID8fbB FCD8Jb ><I<BK@c@ W89L:8B 8EC8fbCDbfKb PIbEKbC8I >@K

>@;< 8IKbPFI M< 9@I J8KI8EW FPLELE;8E =8IBJbQC8fbPFI;L


.FELE;8 K<C<D<KI@B LQD8EC8Ib IF9FKL BFEKIFC <;<E 9@C>@J8P8Ib
GIF>I8DC8D8B @W@E BLCC8EbC8E 9@C>@J8P8Ib GIF>I8DC8D8B @W@E 9@I
9@C>@J8P8I;8?8BLCC8ED8BQFILE;8B8C;bC8I
+IK8;88IKbBB8ID8f8;8E98fB89@If<PPFBKL
-F9FK I@QFE8 WXCC<I@E;<B@ 9@I YJK<P;@ M< @P@ ;< W8CbfbPFI;L
D8 8CC8JK8B@ 9@C>@J8P8I ;YEP8EbE F WFB @P@ 9@C@E<E BFfLC

C8IbE;8 FEL @P@ PXE<K<D@PFI;L EK?FEP F K<BC@=@ P8GKbcb K8I@?@


LELKD8DbfKb 

 LEL ?8KbIC8D8JbEbE 9@I E<;<E@ 

>YEYEYE YPYB "<C8B<KK<E XE:< 8CC8J ;FC8PC8IbE;8 98PI8D
J8PbC;bcbEb9@CD<J@P;@ 48E@PbCXE:<
4<D<B JbI8JbE;8 FCDLfKL 9L 4<D<BC<I ;< ><IW<BK<E
>YQ<C;@ XC><E@E <BFCFA@J@ 9YPYB 9@I ;@BB8KC< 8P8IC8EDbfKb
,IFA< YQ<I@E;< W8Cbf8E G<IJFE<C@E ><I<BC@ P@P<:<BC<I@ KF

GC8D8P8 ?8BC8Ib M8I;b + PYQ;<E D<EY WFB Q<E>@E;@ EK?FEP


FJbI8BbQ8IDbfXI;<c@;<E<D@fK@
TI;<B ><IW<BK<E E<=@J FC;LcL @W@E ?<I Q8D8EB@E;<E ;8?8
;FJKW8 9@I K8MbI K8BbEDbfKb $<IB<J 8WbB 8WbB BFELfLPFI;L F
>YE -@:8I;F [L @f@ 98f8I8D8P8:8cbQ \ ;<D@fK@ [LEL @K@I8=
<;<C@D8IKbB L@f@?@W9@IQ8D8EP8G8D8P8:8cbQ \
8?8 XE:< B8W B@f@E@E B8W B<Q 8PEb f<P@ ;YfYE;YcY 9<CC@
;<c@C;@ D8 F Q8D8E8 B8;8I B@DJ< 9LE;8E 8WbB 8WbB JXQ <K

D<D@fK@ 'LI8C 9LP;L 'XKYDJ<I BFELfD8C8I P8GD8B G8I8EbE


B<J@CD<J@E< PFC 8W8I M< 9@I f8EJ M8IJ8 F ;8 B8P9FCLI;L
58K<EG8I89<fPbC;8E9<I@>@K>@;<;8?8QFICLBC8M<I@C@PFI;L 
#<E<CC@BC< =8QC8 @P@DJ<I FCD8P8E 8D8 XI;<c@E Q<MB@E@
WbB8I8E EK?FEP [*<;<E P8G8D8P8:8BDbfbQ\ ;<;@
[8E89LELEE<;<E@E@JXPC<;<9<E;<@;;@8EbWYIYK<P@D \
L 8WbB 9@I D<P;8E FBLD8P;b -@:8I;FELE J@P8? >XQC<I@
?<D<EBbJbCbM<I;@ [.8E8E<;<E@JXPC<D<D@D@@JK@PFIJLE\
[!M<K \


-@:8I;F @JB<DC<J@E@ @P@:< EK?FEP< ;FcIL W<M@I;@


[$8P;@ 9@C@PFIJLE B@ 9LELE J8BC8E8:8B 9@I P8Eb PFB D@KI@
?@W9@I I8GFILE;8 JFILE;8E 8WbB 8WbB JXQ <KD<P<:<B D8
><IW<c@ J<E ;< 9@C@PFIJLE 9<E ;< -F9FK @JK<I 9LI8;8 B8CJbE
@JK<I )<IBYI@P< >XE;<I@CJ@E GIFA<E@E 98f8IbP8 <I@fD<J@ @W@E
9@I @EJ8E 9<PE@ B8;8I B8ID8fbB M< 8PIbEKbCb 9@I 9@C>@J8P8I
><I<B@PFI @Q ;< 9LEL P8G8D8PbQ + ?8C;< E< P8G8:8cbQ
YEP8 'FE>I<J@E< FPLEC8I FPE8P8I8B W8CbfD8B M< 9<CB@ ;<
P8I8ICb 9@I @B@ f<P 9LCD8B @W@E G8I8 BFG8I8:8cbQ @fK< F
B8;8I \
EK?FEP D<DELE 9@I K8MbIC8 >YCYDJ<;@ [L @;;@8Pb
WYIYKD<B BFC8P <M89b 9@Q< J<E B<E;@E M<I;@E\ @I FPLE
DL FPELPFI;L LELE E<;<E@XI;<c@E WFB E<=@J FCD8Jb DbP

;b -@:8I;FP8 K8BbCD8 8IQLJL DLP;L 4FBJ8 =8IBbE8 M8I

D8;8E 8c89<P@E@ D@ ;YfYEYPFI;L 2@CC@8DbE JFEI8;8E


9LEL8EC8D8Jb@DBVEJbQ;b
[$8E>@ :<M8G\ -@:8I;F 8P8c8 B8CBKb .FE ;<I<:< LQLE
9FPCL M< Q8Pb= 9@I 8;8D;b <P8Q >XDC<c@E@E XEYEY ?@W9@I
Q8D8E B8G8KDbPFI;L 'FCC8IbEb B8MLfKLI8I8B ?VCV P<I@E;<
FKLI8EEK?FEPE@EK<G<J@E<;@B@C;@ [$8E>@:<M8G\
[@I @EJ8E 9<PE@ B8;8I 8PIbEKbCb 9@I 9@C>@J8P8I8 ><I<B
FC;LcLELJXPC<;@E dP@P8 @Q;<9LELP8G8IbQ\
[)<J<C<;<9LP8 8GK8C LELP8G8D8PbQ \
[@QP8G8D8PbQ D898fB8C8IbM8I\
[$8E>@98fB8C8Ib\
[<P@EC<I YQ<I@E;< W8Cbf8E LQD8EC8I K89@@ @QC<I J8;<:<
B8Kb D8;;<C<I BFELJLE;8 LQD8E FC8E =@Q@BW@C<I@Q dEJ8E
9<PE@E@E ?8E>@ 98BbD;8E B8ID8fbB FC;LcLEL 9@CD@PFILQ 48
;8 E< ;<I<:<P< B8;8I B8ID8fbB J8PbC89@C<:<c@E@ *<;<E 9@I
?FDFCFA@JK W8cbIDbPFI M< 9@C>@J8P8Ib FE8 P8GKbIDbPFILQ\
EK?FEP 9L JXQC<I;<E JFEI8 XI;<B ;FCD8JbE;8E @I@ 9@I G8IW8
;8?8 8C8I8B J8B@E J8B@E 8D8 Q<MBC< P<D<P< 98fC8;b LE:8
Q8D8E JFEI8 ;FCD8EbE K8;bEb ?VCV ?8KbICbPFI;L *< M8I B@


FE;8EJFEI8FC8EC8IbE8PIbEKbC8IbEbLELKDLfKL
#8C@98 B@DJ< XE<I@J@E@ :@;;@P< 8CD8DbfKb $<GJ@ >YCDYfC<I
M< EK?FEPE@E B8W8D8c8 J8G8I8B P8B8JbEb Q<B@:< BLI

K8I;bcbEb ;YfYEDYfC<I;@ #YC;YBC<I@ -@:8I;FP;L D8 K89@@


JFEI8;8E ?<GJ@ ;< 9L =@BI@ :@;;@P< 8C;bBC8IbEb @;;@8
<;<:<BC<I;@ 
-@:8I;F X=B<PC< G8ID8cbEb EK?FEP< ;FcIL J8CC8DbfKb
[LEL P8Q .8E8 D<P;8E FBLPFILD L XE<I@E@ BVcb;8 ;XB<

D<P<:<BJ@E \  8?8 ;FcILJL EK?FEP FC8Pb 9XPC< ?8KbICbP

FI;L -@:8I;F @J< JFE Q8D8EC8I;8 ?<P<:8EC8 [L ?8I@B8 9@I


=@B@I\ ;@P< 98cbI;bcbEb @;;@8 <;@PFI;L [LEL E<;<E I<JD@ 9@I
9@W@D;<P8QDbPFIJLE EK?FEP\
$<I E<PJ< EK?FEP ;YfYE:<J@E@ BVcb;8 ;XBDYf D@KI@
(8I>< 9L =@BI@ WFB 9<c<ED@fK@ TQ<C 9@I KFGC8EKb JbI8JbE;8
EK?FEPE@E FDQLE8 MLI8I8B [<E ;< 9L PXE;< ;YfYED<P<
98fC8DbfKbD \ ;<D@fK@ [D8 K89@@ I8GFI8 9LEL B8KD8P

8:8cbD \ EK?FEP 9L @f 9@I =@P8JBFPC8 JFELWC8EbIJ8 JFILDCL

CLcL98E8PbB8:8B ;@P<;YfYEDYfKY 
0P>LE ?FDFCFA@JK@ D@KI@ (8I>< 8I8Dbf EK?FEPE@E 8BCbE8
9L BFELPC8 @C>@C<ED<J@ ><I<BK@c@ ?@W ><CD<D@fK@ *< ?FDFCFA@ BF

ELJLEL 9@C@PFI;L E< ;< ?FDFCFA@JKC<I@ /89@@ 8c89<P@ ;bfbE;8


58K<EFEL;8;YfYED<D@fK@ P8E@9@C@EWC@FC8I8B
dfK< EK?FEP f@D;@ 9LI8;8 BYWYB 9@I IFC;<P;@ 0W8cbE
B8GbJb 8WbC8I8B 9@IB8W 8;8D WbBKb !C JbBbfbCbIB<E EK?FEP ;<
B<E;@E@ 8PE8P8 98BbPFIDLf >@9@ ?@JJ<;@PFI;L 8BKbcb B<E;@
PYQYP;YJ8EB@
EK?FEPE@E P8E8BC8Ib 8C<M 8C<M P8ED8P8 98fC8;b + 8E;8
9@EC<I:<B@CFD<KI<XK<;<FCD8PbWFB@JK<;@


2@CC@8D B8I;<f@E@ ;8?8 XE:< ?8KbIC8Dbf FCD8Pb ?<I Q8D8E

B@E;<EWFB@JK@PFI;L [+EL?8KbIC8D8D><I<B@I;@ '<J@EC@BC< \




E:8B F K<BC@= >LILILEL FBf8Dbf M< LQD8E 9@I JYI< JFEI8


;8 ?<P<:8EC8ED8P8 98fC8DbfKb <CB@ ;< B8I;<f@E@ D8?JLJ
?8KbIC8D8DbfKb
@I B<I< D@KI@ (8I><bE D<;P8 PFCLPC8 BFELfD8B P<I@E<
B8CBbG B<E;@J@E@ >XID<P< ><CD<J@ FEL J<M@E;@ID@fK@ ;8D 8C

C8J K8E *<N 4FIB8 LWDLf M< 9L ;8 2@CC@8DbE ?FfLE8 >@KD@fK@


SYEBY 8;8D >@QC@:< ><I@C@D IFD8EC8Ib FBLD8P8 D<I8BCbP;b
58K<E F KYI D8:<I8C8I;8 <IB<BC<I M< B8;bEC8I >@QC@:< J<P8?8K <K

D<B @JK<;@BC<I@ Q8D8E KFGCL K8fbD8 8I8WC8IbE;8E P8I8IC8EbPFI

C8I;b .FELWK8 <C<BKIFE@B


J<P8?8K B8DLELE D8CbP;b 8?8
;FcILJL ?<I KYI I8;PF bfbEbEbE @QC<E;@c@ ><I@C@D IFD8EC8IbE;8
XPC<;<E@C@PFI;L
2@CC@8D <JGI@ P8GD8P8 W8Cbf8I8B 9LE;8E JXQ <KD@fJ< ;<
>8C@98 D@KI@ FEL G<B ;@EC<D<D@fK@ @BB8KC< 2@CC@8DbE PYQYE<
98B8IB<E J8EB@ 8BCb 98fB8 P<I;<P;@ .FELE;8 [==<;<IJ@E@Q \
;@P<DbIbC;8EDbfKb [8E89@I@E@?8KbIC8KKbEbQ;8 \
2@CC@8D F Q8D8E 9@C< ><IW<c@ 8EC8P8D8DbfKb ;8D FE;8E
JFEI8JbBJbBB<E;@B<E;@E< 9LE8JbCFC;L ;@P<JFIDLfKL 
D@KI@ (8I>< L=8B K<=<B KFD9LC 9@I 8;8D;b !E;@f<C@ P8 ;8
J@E@IC@ FC;LcLEL JXPC<;@c@ Q8D8EC8I;8 9@C< >XQC<I@ P@E< ;<
E<f<PC< G8IC8I;b LIEL PLM8IC8B ;FD8K<J >@9@ P8E8BC8Ib ;8 f@f

D8E;b $<I K8I8=b PLDLf8BKb ;8D @B@E:@ 8;b FC8E (8I><bE YQ<I

@E;< XQ<CC@BC< ;LIDLfKL F >YE $<D ;< W89L:8B 2@CC@8D ;8 F


Q8D8E D@KI@E@E 9LEL JbB JbB P8GKbcbEb ;YfYEDYfKY ;8D
[(8I>< ><E@f 8EC8DbE8 ><C@PFI K89@@ ;FJKLD \ ;<D@fK@ [D8
><E@fC@c@E9FPC89FJC8@C>@J@FCD8Jbf8IK;<c@CP8 \
+E;8E JFEI8 P8GKbBC8Ib BFELfD8 JbI8JbE;8 2@CC@8D JbB JbB
@K@I8Q <KD@fK@ [<E@D 9@C>@J8P8IC8I BFELJLE;8 ?@W9@I =@BI@D PFB
$@W9@I f<P 9@CD@PFILD +EC8IbE E8JbC W8CbfKbBC8IbEb ;8 E8JbC GIF

>I8DC8E;bBC8IbEb;88EC8P8DbPFILD \
D@KI@ 9LEL XE<DJ<D<;@c@E@ 9<C@IKD<B @W@E <C@E@ J8CC8DbfKb
[0 XE<DC@ ;<c@C ?@W ;<c@C .= 9@C>@J8P8IC8Ib 9@C@PFILQ ,IF

>I8DC8Ib ;8 '.= ?8QbIC8IbQ .@Q 9@Q< 9@I 9@C>@J8P8IbE 9@I BFDGYK<I




;<c@C ;< 9@I 9<P@E >@9@ W8CbfD8JbEb J8cC8D8B @W@E E< P8GbCD8Jb
><I<BK@c@E@JXPC<P@E \
2@CC@8D f8fbIDbfKb [<P@E BFELJLE;8 9LEL J@Q< 8WbBC8P8:8B
B8;8I9@C>@DFC;LcLELJ8EDbPFILD  D@KI@ \
,IF=<JXI [ YEP8EbE<E@C<I@><C<E?FDFCFA@JK@J@E@Q \;<D@fK@
['FELPL @P@:< @E:<C<;@D \ + Q8D8E JXPC<E<:<B ?@W9@I f<P
B8CD8DbfKb
D@KI@ BFELfD8JbEb JYI;YIYIB<E 2@CC@8D FEL >@K>@;< 8IK8E 9@I
JbBbEKbPC8 ;@EC<;@ @I @EJ8E 9@I BFELP8 LQLE JYI< ;<I@EC<D<J@E<
;8C;bcb Q8D8E ;@c<I 8C8EC8I;8 W8Cbf8E LQD8EC8IbE 9@I<I J@?@I98Q
FC;LBC8IbEb ;YfYED<P< 98fCbPFI;L +EC8IbE 9@C>@J@E@ B<E;@ 9@C>@J

@QC@c@E@E ;<I@EC@c@PC< XCWYPFI;L D@KI@ BFELfLIB<E 2@CC@8D


)<IBYI@ ,IFA<J@ BFELJLE;8 9@I ?8PC@ 9@C>@ J8?@9@ FC;L /89@@ F JbI8
9LE8?@W><I<BFCD8;bcbEb;YfYEYPFI;L
0QD8E JFELE;8 [TPC<PJ< E<;<E 9@C>@J8P8I BLCC8EbPFI

JLELQ\ ;@P< JFI;L [*@W@E 8;8DC8IbEbQ;8E 9@I@ P8 ;8 9@I K@D IF

9FKLE@f8I<KC<I@E@8CDbPFIM<FE8K8C@D8KM<ID@PFI\
D@KI@ E<I<;<PJ< ?<P<:8Eb PYQYE;<E BFCKLBK8E =bICbPFI;L
[? 8? 8? #XIYPFI DLJLELQ ;LILDLE =8IBbE;8 ;<c@CJ@E@Q dE

J8EC8IbE IF9FKLE PFCC8P8:8cb 9YKYE D8CQ<D<P@ W89L:8B @E

:<C<D<C<I@ FC8E8BJbQ bJbC8I >8Q 98JbEWC8Ib BFQD@B bfbEC8I;8


;8C>8C8ED8 M< #YE<f IYQ>VIb PFcLECLBC8Ib B@DP8J8C B8IbfbDC8I
KFGI8B ;FBLC8Ib M< 9LEC8I;8E 98fB8 ?<D<E ?<D<E FKLQ 8CKb
D8;;< @I @EJ8EbE 9LEC8Ib 8E8C@Q <KD<J@ M< FE;8E JFEI8B@ 8;bD
BFELJLE;8 B8I8I M<ID<J@ ><I<B@PFI @I @EJ8E IF9FK8 J8;<:<
6*-'*61.0 <;<9@C@I D8 9@I 9@C>@J8P8I IF9FKLE B<E;@J@PD@f >@9@
FCLI
[1< @EJ8EC8I =8QC8 ?bQCb;bIC8I $<I?8E>@ 9@I I8;P8JPFELE
)<IBYI@;<E ;YEP8P8 ><C@G ;XED<J@ FE @C8 P@ID@ @B@ ;8B@B8 JYI<I
L @B@J@E@E PXIYE><C<I@ YQ<I@E;< ?8E>@ EFBK8;8 FC;LBC8IbE8
98cCb;bI L BFEL;8 P8GbC89@C<:<B 9@I f<P PFBKLI e@D;@ 9@I >X

QC<D 8CbI M< <D@I M<I@IJ@E@Q E:8B >XQC<D@E P8GbC;bcb 8EC8 :<M

89bE 8I8JbE;8 W FB f<P FC89@C@I dEJ8E bfbB ?bQbEbE P8M8fCbcbE8




B<E;@E@ 8CbfKbI8D8Q D8 9@I 9@C>@J8P8I 9LEL ;8 ?<J898 B8K8I


$8P;@ CYK=<E9@Q<P8I;bD<;@E 2@CC@8D \
0QD8E JbBbEKbPC8 [dJK<;@c@E@Q Q8D8E 98E8 JFILC8I JFI89@

C@IJ@E@Q \ ;<;@ [/89@@ 9LELE 9@I P8I8Ib FCLIJ8 TQ<C -1 bfbEbD ?<I
Q8D8E?@QD<K@E@Q;<FC8:8B \
[D8 9<E =@B@I ;8EbfD8B @JK<D@PFILD B@ <E@DC<
><CD<C@J@E@Q \
[48E@K8fbKC8Db\2@CC@8DfFB><W@I@PFI;LJ8EB@
[!M<K K89@@ @I C8J<I bfbEbEbE @B@ L:LE;8 FKLILG 8I8;8B@
@C<K@f@D LP;LJLELE P8I;bDbPC8 9XPC< 9@I GIFA<E@E YQ<I@E;<
W8CbfbC8D8Q B@ L JFELE;8 WFB G8?8CbP8 ><C@I -8?8K 9@I PXE

K<D ;<J8PbCD8Q PIb:8?@W9@If<P>@QC@B8C8D8Q \


2@CC@8D 9L ><IW<BK<E F ><I@C@D IFD8EC8IbE8 9<EQ@PFI ;@P<
B8I8IbEbM<I;@
D@KI@ [ 8CC8J8 ><C@E \ ;<;@ [.@Q< FI8;8 E<C<I@D@Q
FC;LcLEL >XJK<ID<C@P@D FE8EbDb >XIYE @Q@D 9@C>@J8P8I

:bC8IC8 BFELfLE +EC8IbE ;YfYE:< K8IQbEbQ;8E P8I8IC8ED8C8IbE8


@Q@EM<I@E \
2@CC@8D B<J@E 9@I K8MbIC8 BFELfD8 Q8D8EbEbE ><C;@c@E@
;YfYE;Y [ D@KI@ 9LI8;8 B<E;@ @f@D M8I 48Ib;8 9bI8BD8B
@JK<D<;@c@D WFB XE<DC@ 9@I @f 9L @JK<;@c@E@Q@ P8G8IJ8D
C89FI8KLM8IbD;8E8PC8I:8LQ8BB8CbIbD \
D@KI@ f8f8C8;b [PC8I Db .<M>@C@ 2@CC@8D 9L @f PbCC:bI JYI<

9@C@I D8P8G8:8cbEbQP@E<;<J@Q@E@f@E@QJ8PbCbI \
[$8PbI ><C<D<D <E @f@D@E E< FC;LcLEL 9@C@PFILD '<J@E
FC8E 9@I f<P M8I B@ F ;8 @f@D@E 9@I IF9FKLE )<IBYI@ ><Q<><E@E;<
;FC8fD8JbEbBFEKIFC<KD<BFCD8;bcb;bI \
[*<;<E L @f@ LP>LE 9@W@D;< P8G8IJ8EbQ WFB f<P
XcI<E@IJ@E@Q @I 9@C>@J8P8IbE 9@I 9<P@E >@9@ W8CbfD8JbEb J8cC8IB<E
9L BFEL;8B@ 9@C>@E@Q WFc8CbI M< ><C@f@I + Q8D8E 9LI8P8 @f@E@Q
J8P;bcbEbQ f<P YQ<I@E;< W8CbfD8B @W@E P<E@ 9@C>@C<I <;@ED@f
FC8I8B ;XE<IJ@E@Q .@Q PFBB<E P8I;bD:bC8IbEbQ 9L W8CbfD8Pb
JYI;YI<D<QC<I D@ +EC8IC8 C8J<I bfbEb M< K<C<M@QPFEC8 98cC8EKb



BLI8D8Q DbJbEbQ I8;8 JbI8;8 *<N 4FIB8 ;XE<D<Q D@J@E@Q


'bJ8JYI<C<I@W@E \
2@CC@8D <KB@C<ED@fK@ <P@E YQ<I@E;< 98fB8 9@I PXEK<DC<
W8CbfD8 =@BI@ @C>@J@E@ W<BK@ 0QD8E FE;8E JFEI8 8CC8J8 >@KD<B
@W@E 98?8E<C<I 9LCD8P8 98fC8;b $@W FCD8QJ8 FI8Pb Q@P8I<K <;<

9@C@I@D $@W FCD8QJ8 C89FI8KLM8IC8IbE E8JbC FC;LBC8IbEb >XI<9@C@I@D


.FELWK8@JK<;@c@DQ8D8E9LI8P8;XE<9@C@I@D 
.FEI8 D@KI@ <JB@ *<N 4FIB ?8I89<C<I@E@ Q@P8I<K <KK@ M< ?<I
f<P@ J8=W8 9@I ?<P<:8EC8 @QC<;@ /89@@ P@E< ;< YPYB "<C8B<K
TE:<J@ *<N 4FIBLE 9@I @f< P8I8D8P8E ;<MC@B D<I8BbE;8E ;8?8
>YQ<C B8CbEKbC8Ib PFBKL  2@CC@8D F Q8D8E P8G8:8cb PFC:LCLB
J8P<J@E;< @C>@EW P<IC<I >XID< =bIJ8KbEb 9LCLG 9LC8D8P8:8cbEb
;YfYED<P<98fC8;b
0QD8E B<E;@ B<E;@E< 9@I JYI<;<E 9<I@ P<E@ 9@I P8K8B

8IB8;8fb 9LCD8 BFELJLEL ;YfYEYPFI;LD ;<D<P< 9@C< 98fC8;b


+EL ;<M8DCb B8CD8P8:8cbD 98fB8 9@I 9XC><;< 9LCD8B WFB
;8?8LP>LEFCLI \
4FBJ8 F JbI8;8 ><I<B<EC<I BFELJLE;8 G<B 8Q 9@C>@J@ FC

D8JbE8 I8cD<E E<C<I P8GbC89@C<:<c@E@ J<QD@f D@P;@ L LQ8B

C8I;8W8B8Ef@Df<B>@9@D@P;@
XPC<:< 2@CC@8D JFELE;8 8CC8J8 >@KK@ 0W8BK8E @E<IB<E
D@KI@ FEL J<M@EWC< B8IfbC8;b .FEI8 >XQC<I@ BbJbC;b M< ;XEYG
[@C@PFI;LD \;<;@ [*<f8fbIKb:b9@I9<EQ<IC@B9L \
2@CC@8DbE >XQC<I@ @I@C<fK@ '8IfbJbE;8 9YQYCYG ><I@C<D<P<
W8Cbf8E 9@I@ M8I;b f@D;@ 4YQY FELE PYQYE< 9<EQ@PFI;L dfK< F
Q8D8EB8IfbJbE;8B@E@EEK?FEPFC;LcLEL8EC8;b
'8I;<f@E@E PYQYE;<B@ @=8;<;<E ;< 9L 8BI898Cbcb >XDD<P@
WFB @JK<;@c@ 8EC8fbCbPFI;L 2@CC@8DbE [#<IW<BK<E @C>@EW \ ;<D<J@
M< JFEI8 98fB8 9@I BFEL;8E JXQ 8WD8Jb P<K<IC@ FC8:8BKb dEJ8E

C8IbE ><E 9@W@DC<I@ P<K<I@ B8;8I B8ID8fbBKb Q8K<E L PYQ;<E


8BI898FCD8P8EC8I8I8JbE;8;89<EQ<IC@B>XIYC<9@C@PFI;L
D8 K89@@ 2@CC@8D 9@I ?FDFCFA@JKK@ '8ID8fbB @EJ8E 9<PE@
YQ<I@E;< W8Cbf8E 9@I @EJ8E 8PIbEKbC8I8 B8Ifb FC8E ;LP8ICbCbcbEb ;8


B8P9<;@PFI;L 0QD8E 9L PYQ;<E [+ELE B8I;<f@D EK?FEP


FC;LcLE;8E<D@E@D \;@P<:<M8GM<I;@
D@KI@ ['8I;<f@E@QD@\;<;@
2@CC@8D 8WbBC8;b [898DbE 8PEb B8;bE;8E @B@ FcCL FC;L E

E<D;<EP8E@ +EC8IWFB@C>@EW@EJ8EC8I;b \
.FEI8 <C@E@ LQ8K8I8B 9@IB8W 8;bD 8KKb EK?FEP ;< 9L <C@ JbB

D8BK8E 98fB8 W8I< 9LC8D8DbfKb +E;8E JFEI8B@ 9@IB8W >YE


?<IB<JJ8;<:<9LFC8P;8EJXQ<KK@


2@CC@8DbE E< P8GKbcbEb @P@:< 8EC8;bcbE;8E G@fD8ECbB ;LPD8Jb
EK?FEP@G<B;<K<J<CC@<KD<;@
dB@ B8I;<f F ><:<P<D<BK<E JFEI8 98f98f8 FKLILIC8IB<E 2@C

C@8D [TQYI ;@C<I@D \ ;<;@ [df@E <E BXKY P8EbEb JXPC<IJ<D 9@I
;8?8 9LELE YQ<I@E;< ;LID8P8:8BC8IbEb ;YfYEDYfKYD D8
XPC< FCD8;bcb 8EC8fbCbPFI <E E< 9@I 9<C>< E< ;< 9@I 8EC8fD8
@DQ8C8;bD LI8;8E?<D<E>@;<:<c@D \
EK?FEP B898:8 [LELE E< P8I8Ib FCLI\ ;@P< ?FDLI;

8E;b [IKbB ?<IB<J ><IW<c@ 9@C@PFI dB@ MY:LK M< 9@I PYQ L @E

J8EbBLJKLID8P8P<K<I\
[#@;<IJ<D \
[#@;<D<QJ@E YKYE9LEC8I9<E@D=@BI@D;@ \
[<E@ 9LI8P8 ><K@IKD<B D@\ 2@CC@8D B8CbE f@f B8G8BCb >XQ

C<I@E@@I@@I@8W8I8BB8fC8IbEbB8C;bI;b
[$8PbI E< DYE8J<9<K LI8P8 9@I ?FDFCFA@JK ><K@IKD<
=@BI@E@ B8JK<;@PFILD .<E@ >XE;<I<:<BC<I@E@ E<I<;<E
9@C<9@C@I;@D\
[D8>@;<IJ<D \
[+CD8Q e@D;@ P8GbC8:8B K<B f<P 9L JFILEL WXQYDC<D<B
/89@@ DYDBYEJ< + Q8D8E FC8P8 XE<D M<ID<QC<I \ .FEI8
;8 B<E;@ B<E;@E< 98f8IbP8 <I@f<EC<I@E ?<I BLJLILEL 8==<;<IC<I
;@P<;YfYEYPFI;L


[LEL98f8I89@C<:<c@D;<EG<B;<<D@E;<c@C@D \
[$8PbI ;<E<D<B QFILE;8PbQ D@KI@ 9LEL 9@Q;<E 9<BC<P<

:<B \ EK?FEP GIF=<JXIYE K<EFI J<J@E@ K8BC@K <KK@ [_.L ?8I@B8 9@I
=bIJ8K dB@E@Q B8I;<fJ@E@Q M< 9@I9@I@E@Q@ 8ECbPFIJLELQ *<;<E 9<

I89<I W8CbfD8P8:8BJbEbQ\ @I 8E ;LI;LBK8E JFEI8 B<E;@


X=B<C@ J<J@PC< <BC<;@ [+ELE @W@E 9LEL P8GD8B QFILE;8PbQ
e@D;@ @f< fL JFILPC8 98fC8P8CbD .<E@E P8GKbcbE E<;@I 2@CC@

8D48E@?FDFCFA@JXQ:YcYEYEJXQCYB8EC8Db;bfbE;8\
2@CC@8D [(YK=<E 9<E@ 8==<K \ ;@P< @W@E@ W<BK@ [!M<K <E
FK@JK@BWF:LBC8IbEYQ<I@E;<W8CbfbPFILD \
['FIB8IbD9LELEE<8EC8D8><C;@c@E@9@CD@PFILD \
['bJ8:8 8EC8K8PbD 9<E ;YEP8P8 LQ8ED8P8E ;@c<I @EJ8E

C8IC8 @C<K@f@D BLID8P8E @WC<I@E< B8G8EbG ;<I@;<E FCLfDLf 9@I


;LM8I 8IB8JbE;8 P8f8P8E <I@f@CD<J@ QFI WF:LBC8IbE YQ<I@E;<
W8CbfbPFILD dC<I@;< 9@I >YE 9L ?8JK8Cbcb @P@C<fK@I<9@C<:<c@D<
@E8EbPFILD \
[LPYQ;<ED@@B@E:@8;FC8I8BEK@
LKLJ<WK@E\
[!M<K XPC< \
EK?FEP?8=@=W<>YC;Y8D88JCbE;8G<B<cC<ED@PFI;L
2@CC@8DbEK8MbIC8IbJFcLBC8fKb [ YIYJK9@I8;9L \
EK?FEP K<C8fC8 [TPC< FC;LcLE;8E <D@E@D \ ;@P<
DbIbC;8E;b 8?8 =8QC8JbEb JXPC<P<:<B M< 8c89<P@E;<E XQYI ;@

C<P<:<B ?8C;< ;<c@C;@ '<E;@E@ QFIC8P8I8B BFELP8 ;XE;Y [L


8C8E;8@C<IC<D<>XJK<I;@ED@\
[WF:LBC8Ib @P@C<fK@ID< BFELJLE;8 Db $8PbI 9L 8E8 B8;8I
98f8IbCb FC8D8;bD D8 FEC8Ib 8EC8D8B BFELJLE;8 <M<K \ 2@CC@

8D BFELfLIB<E >XQC<I@ ;8C>bEC8fbG ?<P<:8EC8ED8P8 98fC8;b


EK?FEP E< FC;LcLEL 8ECbPFI;L @EJ8E B8C9@E@ M< B8=8JbEb ;FC

;LI8E M< 98fB8 f<PC<IC< @C>@C<ED<J@E@ <E><CC<P<E 9@I BFEL;8E


JXQ<;<IB<E9XPC<FCLI;L +;88PEbf<PC<I@B8WB<Q?@JJ<KD@fK@
EK?FEP G<B 8EC8P8D8;bcb BFELPC8 @C>@C@ JXQC<I@ ;@BB8KC< ;@E

C<;@ SYEBY 9LEL P8GD8Jb ><I<BC@P;@ 2@CC@8D ;8 FEL


;@EC<P<:<BK@


EK?FEP ?<I f<P@ E< B8;8I ;8 @P@ ?8KbICbPFI;L + JbI8;8 ?8KbI

C8D8P8:8cbEb J8EDbfKb D8 F Q8D8EC8I E<C<I FC;LcLELE


=8IBbE;8 ;<c@C;@ #<I@P< 98B8I8B FC8EC8Ib ;YfYEYIB<E 98Qb :YD

C<C<I@ K8D FC8I8B 8EbDJ8;bcbEb =8IB<KK@ $<D ;< B<C@D<J@


B<C@D<J@E<
2@CC@8D [@Q:< FK@JK@B 9@I WF:LcLE ;bf @QC<E@DC<I@ 8C>bC8P8

D8;bcb M< ?8KK8 FEC8Ib LP>LE 9@I 9@W@D;< PFILDC8P8D8;bcb =@BI@


P8ECbfKb \ ;<;@ [JCbE;8 WF:LB FEC8Ib 9<c<ED@PFI M< I<;;<;@P

FI;L PIb:8 9<c<E;@c@ 9@I @QC<E@D BFELJLE;8 ;<I@EC<D<J@E<


BFELf89@CD<P<K<E<c@E@;<B8P9<KD@PFI;L \
EK?FEP8c89<P@E@;@EC<;@c@E@9<C@IKD<P<W8CbfKb [? \
[SF:LcL JbI8;8E PFCC8IC8 FK@QD;<E M8Q><WD<P< @BE8 <;

<D<QJ@E SYEBY 9YKYE ;YEP8Pb FC;LcL >@9@ J<E@ ;< 9<c<ED

<D<BK<;@I D8FEL9@C@EWC@;LI;LID8;LILDLE8><K@I@IJ<E \
[*<;LILDLE8\
[L 9@I K<BE@BK@I 48E@ 9<P@E@E MY:LKC8 FC8E 98cC8EKbJb B<J@C@I
M< F >XM;<PC< @C@fB@J@ FCD8;8E =FEBJ@PFEC8IbEb P<I@E< ><K@I@I L
9@Q@D C89FI8KLM8IC8IbDbQ;8 ><C@fK@I@CD@f B8ID8fbB 9@I K<BE@BK@I
JCbE;8 \2@CC@8D;LI8BC8;b
EK?FEPP8M8fW8JFI;L [LK<BE@c@J<ED@><C@fK@I;@E\
2@CC@8D ?8=@=W< BbQ8IbIB<E D<DELE FC;LcL 9<CC@P;@ [!M<K
8JCbE;8 XPC< _@C@EWC@ ;LI;LID8 JbI8JbE;8 MY:L;8 ?8QbIC8EDbf
?8P8CC<I@ M<I@IM< 9<P@E@ ;@=<I8EJ@P8C <C<BKIF<EJ<=8CF>I8=@
P8I;bDbPC8 @E:<C<I@Q 1< ?<D<E FK@JK@B B@f@ BFELJLE;8 WFB ;8?8
=8QC89@C>@
<;@E@I@Q +ELE E< KYI ;LPL @QC<E@DC<I@E@ @JK<;@c@E@ 8EC8I ><E<C

C@BC<;<9<P@EBFELJLE;8;8?8=8QC89@C>@KFGC8DbfFCLILQ \
[? \ EK?FEP 9L J<=<I _?`b @WK<EC@BC< JXPC<D@fK@ [<P@E
?8BBbE;8 9YKYE 9L XcI<E;@BC<I@E@ FEC8Ib 9@I BFDGYK<I@E
W8CbfD8JbE8LP>LC8P8D8QDbJbE\
2bCC@8D [$8PbI ;<;@ [L FC8E8BJbQ LEL D@KI@`P< ;<
JXPC<;@D <E@D BFDGYK<IC<I BFELJLE;8 ?@W9@I 9@C>@D PFB
<P@EBFELJLE;8B@9@C>@D@J<P<K<IC@;<c@C \


[.8E8 9@C>@J8P8IC8Ib XcI<K@I M< E<P< ><I<BJ@E@D@D@Q


FC;LcLEL<KI8=Cb:88EC8KbIJ8D FQ8D8E\
[L9@I@f<P8I8D8Q SYEBY  \
EK?FEP <KB@C<P@:@ >XIYED<P< W8Cbf8I8B [c89<P 98E8
9FI:LE M8I (YK=<E JFILEC8IbDbQbE YQ<I@E;< ;YfYED<B @W@E
;YIYJKW< 9@I W898 ?8I:8 <P@E BFELJLE;8 E<C<I 9@C@PFIJ8E
(YK=<EFEC8Ib9@Q@D9@C>@J8P8IC8I8LP>LC8 \
2@CC@8D <E;@f<PC< BbDbC;8E;b [ LILDLEL 8ECbPFILD !C@D

;<E><C<E@P8G8:8cbD !C@D;<E><C;@c@E:<W898C8P8:8cbD \


2@CC@8D W898C8;b ><IW<BK<E EK?FEP`E@E ;< K8?D@E <KK@c@
>@9@ FEC8Ib 9@IC@BK< W8CbfD8C8Ib @W@E P8CEbQ 9bI8BKbC8I 8fC8E>bWK8
8I8;8 JbI8;8 ;@c<IC<I@PC< B8IfbC8fbPFIC8I;b 2@CC@8D B8I;<f
FC;LBC8IbEb @EBVI <;<D<P<:<BC<I@ @W@E fFB K8BK@BC<I@E< 98fMLI

8I8B 9L ><IW<c@ D8?JLJ 8WbBCbPFI;L D8 JFELE;8 9LE;8E


M8Q><WK@ IKbB ;@c<IC<I@ @fC<I@E< B8IbfDbPFIC8I;b 2@CC@8D
EK?FEP`< P8BC8fKbcb P8 ;8 EK?FEP 2@CC@8D`bE P8EbE8 >@KK@c@
Q8D8E<KI8=K8B@C<ILJLC:8FIK8;8EB8P9FCLPFIC8I;b
dB@ B8I;<f >@K>@;< 9@I9@IC<I@E< 8CbfKbC8I .8Q8E J8EB@ 9@I9@IC<I

@E< ?@W 9<EQ<D@PFIC8IDbf M< WF:LBCLB 8EbC8IbEb G8PC8fDbPFI

C8IDbf>@9@BFELf89@C@PFIC8I;b;8
EK?FEP BFDGYK<IC< @C>@C@ ><I<BJ@E@DC<I@ =8QC8 K<BE@B FCD8P

8E 9@I ;@CC< 8WbBCbPFI;L 2@CC@8D ;8 LQLE LQLE ;YfYE;YBK<E


JFEI8 BFDGYK<I@E 9@I 98BbD8 @EJ8E 9<PE@E@E >XI<M@E@ P8G89@C<

:<c@E@J8E;bcbEbJXPC<;@
EK?FEP [.<E:<9LDYDBYEDY\;<;@
2@CC@8D [@CD@PFILD \ ;@P< :<M8G M<I;@ [WbBW8Jb 9LEL
;<E<D<B @W@E ?@W J89bIJbQC8EDbPFILD df< P8I8P89@C@I ;< P8I8

D8P89@C@I;< \
[ D@KI@(8I><C8BFELfD8DbQ><I<B@PFI \
[TE:< 9LEL 8I8DbQ;8 K8IKbf8CbD 8B8CbD <C@D@Q;< E<C<I
M8I D@KI@`P< DYDBYE FC;LcL B8;8I D8EKbBCb 9@I XE<I@PC<


>@KD<C@P@Q 48;8?@W>@KD<D<C@P@Q \
EK?FEP ;LI8BC8;b [ D@KI@`P< .0.2.= 9@IC@BK< D@
>@;<:<c@Q\
2@CC@8D @E:<C@BC< [.<E 9<E@D JXQ:YD FCLIJLE \ ;<;@ [@I

C@BK<>XIYCD<D@Q<?@W><I<BPFB \
[.8cFC 2@CC@8D 8f8IbCb FCLIJ8B =@BI@E J<E@E FC;LcLEL
?<IB<J<8WbBC8IbD \
2@CC@8D [L 98BbD;8E ?@W9@I <E;@f<D PFB \ ;@P< 98fbEb
J8CC8;b ["@B@I 9@I @f< P8I8IJ8 >8C@98 FEL 8E:8B 9<E
LP>LC8P89@C@I@D \
XIK 9<f KFGC8EKb P8G8I8B BFELPL K8IKbfKbC8I 2@CC@8D
EK?FEP B<E;@E< WFB P898E:b FC8E 9@I BFELPL W89L:8B B8M

I8;bcb @W@E B8I;<f@PC< >LILIC8E8:8BKb /89@@ 8BI898 FCD8J8C8I;b


I8C8IbE;8B@FJbBb:b;LP>LJ8CJFILELLELK89@CJ<P;@
dB@ B8I;<f FE;8E JFEI8 D@KI@ (8I><`C8 LQLE >XIYfD<C<I
P8GKbC8I $8KK8 ?<D<E ?<IB<JC< >XIYfKYC<I EK?FEP >YEC<I:<
FEC8IC8 BFELfKL .FEI8 ;@c<IC<I@ K<B K<B 2@CC@8D`b >XID<P<
><C;@C<I 1< J8E:bCb 9@I ?8D@C<C@B JYI<J@E;<E JFEI8 )<IBYI@ @C

>@J8P8Ib8;bM<I@C<EGIFA<FE8PC8E;b
2@CC@8D 9@I8Q I8?8KC8P8I8B *<N 4FIB`8 ;XE;Y +I8 C8 B8C

D8Pb GC8EC8DbPFI;L dB@ 8P XE:< 9LELE DYDBYE FC;LcLEL


;YfYE<9@C@I D@P;@ E:8B $FDFCFA@ !EJK@KYJYE;< P8GbCD8Jb
><I<B<EWFBf<PM8I;b
/89@@ 2@CC@8D`bE C 89FI8KLM8I;8B@ B<E;@ >IL9LE8 E<C<I
FC;LcLEL E@W@E 8PIbCD8Jb ><I<BK@c@E@ M< F PFBB<E E8JbC W8Cbf8

:8BC8IbEb 8EC8K89@CD<J@ @W@E P@E< KFGC8EKbC8I P8GbC;b .FEI8 LQD8E


P8EbE;8 ><I<BC@ 8P>bKC8I M< @B@ ><EW P8I;bD:bPC8 8CC8J`8 ;XE;Y
+I8;8E<B8;8IB8C8:8cb9<CC@;<c@C;@
2@CC@8D`bE >XQY 8IB8;8 B8CD8DbfKb '<E;@ C89FI8KLM8IbEb M<
FELE ><I<BJ@E@DC<I@E@ LELKKL '<E;@E@ K8D8D@PC< P<E@ >XI<M@E<
M<I;@
EK?FEP @W@E BXKY 9@I ;<MI< FC;L 9L 2@CC@8DD PFBCLcLELE
M<I;@c@ I8?8KCbcbE G<B Q<MB@E@ WbB8I8D8;b !E;@f< M< 8:bPC8 9<CB@
;< ;XED<Q ;@P< ;YfYEYPFI;L <CB@ ;< P8I;bD:bJbEb PFCC8I
8fB8 9@I@E@ $<I?8E>@ 9@I LQD8Eb 4YQY 9<E@DB@E< 9<EQ<D<P

<E 9@I@E@ + Q8D8E 9<E ;< B<E;@D@ @B@ JbIKCb ;XIK 98:8BCb 9@I
:8E8M8IbEP8IbJbPDbf>@9@?@JJ<KD<BK<EBLIKLCLILD
D8 2@CC@8D ><I@ ;XE;Y EK?FEP PYB LW8cbEbE ?8M8;8 J<J

J@Q:< JYQYCD<J@E@ M< PYBYEY 9Ff8CKD8JbEb LQ8BK8E J<PI<KK@


.FEI8LQ8BK8E;8FCJ8JFELE;88c89<P@E@=8IB<KK@
+C8EFCDLfKL EK?FEP?<D<EFI8;8ELQ8BC8fKb
0QD8E F >YE XcC<;<E JFEI8 D@KI@P< >@KK@ [$<I?8C;< 9<E@D
B8CD8D8 ?@W ><I<B PFB PIbEKbC8Ib J8GK8;bB IKbB GIFA<PC< 9@I
98fB8Jb@C>@C<E<9@C@I \
D@KI@ ['<J@EC@BC< FCD8Q \ ;<;@ [@I B<I< 9L J<E@E =@BI@E;@
L PYQ;<E @f@ JFELE8 B8;8I >XKYID<C@J@E L FELIL 9Ff P<I<
9XCD<E@E?@W><I<c@PFB \
EK?FEP 98fB8 ?@W B@DJ< K<?C@B<P@ >XQ< 8CD8B @JK<D@PFI ;@

P< ;YfYE;Y @f@E 98f8IbJbQCbBC8 JFELWC8ED8 FC8JbCbcbEbE ?VCV M8I


FC;LcLEL9@CD<C@P;@D JCbE;89@C@PFI;LD;8
.FEI8 @=8;<J@Q 9@I PYQC< [ECbPFIJLE ;<c@C D@\ ;<;@
[2@CC@8DC89@IC@BK<W8CbfD8D@DBVEJbQ \
D@KI@ J8EB@ f8fbIDbf >@9@ [D8 E<;<E @IC@BK< WFB 98f8IbCb
FC;LELQ \;<;@
[ @fC<I@D@ JbBKbD ;LI;LD D@KI@ D8 8IKbB ;8P8E8D8P

8:8cbD LILDLE E8JbC >XQYBKYcYEY 9@CD<;@c@D@ D@


J8EbPFIJLE\
[Q@Q ;FJKLD .<E 9L BFELPL =8QC8 898IKbPFIJLE !M<K
?<IB<J 98BbPFI FC89@C@I E< ;< FCJ8 @EJ8E FEC8I D8 JFELE;8
;LILD88Cbf8:8BC8I <E8CbfKbD9@C< \
EK?FEP J<E@ f@fBF P8C8E:b ;<;@ B<E;@ B<E;@E< $@W ;<
8Cbf8D8;bE .FEI8?FDLI;8E;b [D89<E &1GK&2&)G2\
[.<E FC8P8 LP>LE 8Wb;8E 98BDbPFIJLE EE<EC< 9898E
KL?8= @EJ8EC8IDbf D8 JFELWK8 P8GKbBC8Ib P8J8C8I8 8PBbIb 9@I f<P


;<c@C 7&)*(* >8I@G L E< J<E@E JLWLE E< ;< 2@CC@8DbE


'@DJ<@B@E@Q@;<JLWC8P8D8Q \
EK?FEP <C@PC< W89L:8B PYQYEY @f8I<K <KK@ [D8 8PEb
;8D>8PbK8fbPFILQ \
[ LILD ?@W ;< J8E;bcbE >@9@ ;<c@C <E 8I8;8B@ =8IBC8Ib >XI<

9@C@PFILD @I B<I< 2@CC@8D`;8E WFB ;8 ><EW >XQYBYPFIJLE .<E

@E J8WC8IbE ;8?8 ;8C>8Cb .8;<:< @CB 98BbfK8 8I8;8 9@I 9<EQ<IC@B


FC;LcLEL ;YfYEYPFIJLE @fK< F B8;8I $8P;@ EK?FEP J8E8 @J

K<;@c@E B8;8I Q8D8E M<I<:<c@D #<I<BK@c@ B8;8I ;8 P8I;bD:b


'LCC8E89@C<:<c@E B8;8I ;8 8I8W ><I<W $<I f<P@E ?8I@B8
FC8:8cbE;8E <D@E@D .FELE;8 ;LP8:8cbE D<DELECLcL ;YfYE
\
EK?FEP PLDLf8DbfKb K89@@ $@W FCD8QJ8 2@CC@8D8 8C<KC<I@E
P<IC<fK@I@CD<C<I@ BFELJLE;8 P8I;bD <KD<P< I8Qb FC;L 2@CC@8DbE
;8 ?<I f<P@E DYK?@f FC8:8cbE8 @E8E;bcb 8EC8fbCbPFI;L D8
D@KI@B8;8I?<P<:8ECb;<c@C J8B@E;@
2@CC@8D [YKYE D<J<C< J8;<:< LP>LE 98cC8EKbC8I;8 \ ;<;@
[D8 K89@@ 9L _J8;<:< JXQ:YcYEYE WFB XE<DC@ FC;LcLEL @K@I8=
<KD<C@P@D .<E ;LPL @QC<E@DC<I@E@ 8PIb 9@I <BI8E8 P8EJbK8:8BJbE
@Q ;< F Q8D8E ><I<B@IJ< FEC8Ib XE<DJ@QC<fK@ID<B @W@E Q@?@EJ<C
BFEKIFC LP>LC8P8:8cbQ !CC< BFEKIFC K<I@D@E@ BLCC8E8D8P8:8cbD8
>XI< \
EK?FEP [LJXPC<;@c@E@P8G89@C@I@Q \;@P<:<M8GM<I;@
[TPC<PJ< 98fC8P8CbD @EC< 98E8 98cC8EKbC8Ib P8GD8B M<
K8C@D8KbB8MI8D8B@W@E<E8f8cb9@I?8=K8><I<B@PFI \
EK?FEP;YQ<CKK@ [,IF>I8DC8D8PbB8MI8D8B@W@E \
[!? 9LI8Jb J@Q@E +ELE @W@E 9<E ;< J@Q@E K<I@DC<I@E@Q@ BLC

C8E8:8cbD 48I;bD:bC8IbD M< 9<E )<IBYI@ @C>@J8P8IbEb GIF>I8D

C8P8:8cbQ8D8J@Q@EPXEK<D@E@QC<;<c@C \
[/89@@ ;<c@C @Q 9@I ?FDFCFA@JKK<E 98J@K 9@I K<C<D<KI@J@E P8G

89@C<:<c@E;<E WFB ;8?8 DYB<DD<C 9@I GIF>I8D @JK@PFILQ \


EK?FEPE@E 8C8PCb J<J@E;< E<=I<K@E M8ICbcb ?@JJ<;@C@PFI M< 9LEL
J8BC8D8P8?@WW8CbfDbPFI;L


2@CC@8D FELE J<J KFELELE YQ<I@E;< ;LID8P8I8B JXQC<I@E@


FC;LcL >@9@ 8C;b [df< 98J@K 9@I 9@W@D;< 98fC8P8:8cbQ -F9FKL
PYIYK<:<c@Q \
@I ?8=K8 JFEI8 IF9FK 9@E 9<f PYQ B@CFD<KI< XK<;<
I@QFE8;8 PYIY;Y $8I<B<KC<I@ PLDLf8B FCD8;bcb >@9@ 98Q8E
P<I< PLM8IC8EbPFI;L 8Q8E ;8 9@C<c@E@ 9@I <E><C< W8IGbPFI Q8

D8E Q8D8E 9@I 8P8cbEbE YQ<I@E;< ;XEYPFI M< f8fbC8:8B 9@I


9@W@D;<P<E@9@IPXE<;FcIL>@;@PFI;L
2@CC@8D ]+9@I9<9<B \;<;@ [4YIYD<P@P<E@XcI<E@PFI \
D@KI@ Q8D8E Q8D8E E< @C<IC<D< FC;LcLEL 8EC8D8B @W@E
LcILPFI @fK<9LWFB@C>@EW \;@PFI;L
EK?FEP 8PEb =@B@I;< ;<c@C;@ $8=K8C8I ><WK@ .FEI8 ;8 8PC8I
)<IBYI@ @C>@J8P8Ib >@K>@;< ;8?8 B8ID8fbB 9@I 9@W@D;< GIF>I8D

C8EbIB<E IF9FK ;8 ;8?8 =8QC8 f<PC<I P8GbPFI;L 2@CC@8D )<IBYI@


@C>@J8P8IbE;8E _<P@E ;@P< JXQ <KD<P< B8CBbPFIJ8 ;8 EK?FEP
9LE8@Q@EM<ID@PFI;L E:8BFC8EC8IbE?@W9@I@P<K<IC@;<c@C;@
EK?FEP JFELE;8 ['FIB8IbD 9LEC8I P<K<IC@ J8PbCD8Q \
;<;@c@E;<F><:<?@WLPLD8DbfKb
2@CC@8D J8B@E J8B@E [*< >8I@G \ ;@P< DbIbC;8E;b [<E ;< @f@
98f8I;bcbDbQb;YfYE;YcYDYJXPC<D<BYQ<I<P;@D \
EK?FEP B<E;@E@ QFICLBC8 KLK89@C;@ 2@CC@8DC8 9@IC@BK< W8Cbf

D8EbE M< IF9FKLE 9<:<I@BJ@Q:< ?8I<B<KC<I@E@ J<PI<KD<E@E E<;<E


FC;LcL J@E@I ><I>@EC@c@ ;8P8EbC8:8B >@9@ ;<c@C;@ [<E @JK@=8
<;<:<c@D 2@CC@8D L @f@ KYDYPC< 9bI8B8:8cbD SFB YQ>YEYD
*<;<EJ<E;<c@CJ@E \
[$8PbI '*3.2 EK?FEP \
[8fB8 E<;<EC<I ;< M8I 2@CC@8D @I =@P8JBF 9L 8f8IbCb
FC8D8P8:8cbQ -F9FKLE P<IPYQYE;< FCD8JbE8 I8cD<E E<
B8;8I 9<:<I@BJ@Q:< ?8I<B<K <KK@c@E@ >XIYPFIJLE + 9LI8;8E J8

;<:< 9@E 9<f PYQ B@CFD<KI< XK<;< @C@PFIJLE B@ J@EP8CC<I 9@I J8E

@P<;<E ;8?8 BbJ8 9@I JYI<;< 8CbEbG M<I@C<9@C@PFI )<IBYI@;<PJ<


><:@BD<C<I FC8:8B 8B@B8C8I:8 JYI<:<B 9L )<IBYI@ @C>@J8

P8IbEbE ;8 9L ;8B@B8C8Ib ?<J898 B8KD8Jb ><I<B<:<B 8f8IbCb




FC8:8cbDbQb;YfYED<B;<C@C@B \
2@CC@8D [dJK@=8 <KD< EK?FEP \ ;<;@ [IKbB 9L @f@
9bI8B8D8QJbE <E IF9FKLE )<IBYI@P< >XE;<I@CD<J@E@ XE<I<

:<c@D +ELE?8QbIFC;LcLE8@E8EbPFILD \

EK?FEP PYBJ<B J<JC< M< 8c89<P@E< ?8B8I<K <;<I:<J@E<
>YC;Y [.<E;<C@ID@fJ@E 2@CC@8D \
[$8PbI ;<C@ID<;@D $<I f<P@E )<IBYI@;< ;8?8 QFI FC8:8cbEb
;YfYEYPFIJLE J8EbIbD D8 XPC< FCD8P8:8B $<I f<P ;YEP8;8
;8?8 >YW -F9FK ;YEP8 P<IW<B@D@E@E YWK< 9@I@E< >XI< ><C@fK@I@C;@
PIb:8 I@QFE8`;8 K8D P<IW<B@D@ <KB@J@E;< W8CbfbPFI -F9FK 
J8EK@>I8K ;<I<:<P< >XI< P8GbC;b D8 FI8;8 ;<I<:<;<  -F9FK
9FfCLBK8 W8Cbf8:8B 9@W@D;< GC8EC8E;b +PJ8 f@D;@ WFI98 >@9@ 9@I
8KDFJ=<I;<W898CbPFI \
[-F9FKLE8I8;8B@=8IBC8I8;8P8ED8Jb><I<B@I \
[.8EbIbD D8;<E P8Gb ;8P8E89@C@I D8 P8 9LI8;8B@ 9@C>@J8

P8I + ><C@fK@I@C;@c@ W<MI<;< FCD8P8E 9@I IF9FKC8 J@JK<DC@


W8Cbf8DbPFI LI8P8 98B EK?FEP 9<P@E B8;8I B8ID8fbB 9@I
BFDGYK<I @JK@PFIJ8E 98Qb XQ<CC@BC<I@ ;< B89LC <;<IJ@E $8P;@
><C J<E@EC< 9@I 8EC8fD8 P8G8CbD -F9FKLE )<IBYI@`P< >XE;<I

@CD<J@ @W@E 9<E@DC< 9@IC@BK< 98JBb P8G L @f 8CKb 8P 8CbI <E ;< F
JYI<@W@EK8K@C<WbB8IbD XPC<:<9<E;<EBLIKLCDLfFCLIJLE \
[)<IBYI@@C>@J8P8IbEbB@DW8CbfKbIbIFQ8D8E\
[.<E 8IKbB FELE E8JbC W8CbfKbcbEb XcI<E;@E dB@ 8;8DbDb ;8
J8E8P8I;bD<KD<C<I@@W@E9LI8;89bI8BbIbD \
EK?FEP D<P;8E FBLI:8JbE8 98fbEb J8CC8;b ['FDGYK<I@E
JFILDCLCLcLEL PYBC<E<D<D -F9FKLE )<IBYI@P< >XE;<I@CD<J@
JFILDCLCLcLEL;8XPC< L9@I@f<P8I8D8Q \
[<EP8I8P8:8cbE;8E *2.3.2E
[!D@E FC8D8QJbE .FILDCLCLB 9<E@D .LWC8P8:8BC8Ib B@f@ ;<
9<E@D YKYE9LEC8IbEJ<E@EC<9@I@C>@J@PFB \
EK?FEP JFEI8;8E 9L 8EbE WFB XE<DC@ FC;LcLEL ;YfYE<

:<BK@ 2@CC@8D @K@I8Q;8E M8Q><W<I EK?FEP ;< @JK@=8 <;<I;@ dfK< F





Q8D8E?<If<PD8?MFCLI;L
D8 2@CC@8D [<E@DC< 9@I @C>@J@ PFB DL\ ;<;@ [LI8P8
98B 898D 8EE<D BFELJLE;8 98Qb ;LP>LC8I K8fbPFIDLf
,<BVCV <E ;< YQ>YEYD @I @EJ8E E< B8;8I YQ>YE FC89@C@IJ< F
B8;8I YQ>YEYD D8 FC8E FCDLf M< FC8P >8I@G 9@I 9@W@D;<
JFELWC8EDbf 898D;8E JXQ <;<IB<E B8JK<KK@c@D J<E@E ;<
9898E 1< 9LEL JXPC<P<9@C<:<B WFB B@DJ< M8I @B@ <IB<B B8I;<f
@B@ BbQ B8I;<f 9@I <IB<B M< 9@I BbQ B8I;<f .FEI8 8EE<D;<E
JXQ <;<IB<E 7*3.3 8EE<E@ ;< B8JK<;@PFILD LEL JXPC<P<

9@C<<B WFB B@f@ M8IJ8 ;8 8PEb 8EE< M< 9898Pb G8PC8f8E 98fB8 @B@
B@f@P@ K8EbDbPFILD TPC< 9@I@C<I@E;<E JXQ <;@C;@c@E@ ;< ?@W
;LPD8;bD \
EK?FEPJ<IKW< [@C@PFILD \;@P<JXPC<E;@
2@CC@8D K<C8fC8 [!M<K 8D8 9LE8 9@I ;< 9<E@D 8WbD;8E 98B
<E 9@I ?FDFCFA@JK@D M< ><E 9@W@DC<I@ YQ<I@E;< W8CbfbPFILD .<I
?@W 9@Q@D ><E 9@W@DC<I@D@Q@ ;YfYE;YE DY .<E@EC< 8PEb 8EE< M<
9898Pb G8PC8fbPFILQ L ;8 ><E 9@W@DC<I@D@Q@E 9@I9@I@E< WFB
P8BbE FC;LcL 8EC8DbE8 ><C@PFI L P<IPYQYE;< ?@W >XIYCD<P<E
9@If<P 4YQC<I@D@Q9@C<9LP8BbECbcb>XJK<I@PFI \
[LEL9<E;<9@C@PFILD \
[e@D;@ 9L GIFA< 98f8IbCb FCLI M< J<E ;< 9L J8P<;< YE
B8Q8EbIJ8E ><E 9@W@D@E@E @EJ8ECbB @W@E WFB WFB P8I8ICb FC;LcL 8E

C8fbC8:8B /89@@ 9L 9<E@D ><E 9@W@D@D @W@E ;< ><W<IC@ FC8:8B


EC8DbPFI DLJLE EK?FEP <E 8EE<EC< 9898Eb ><E 9@W@D@E@
M< PYQYEY J<E@EC< G8PC8fbPFILD + E<;<EC< B8Q8E:bEb ;8 =8P

9bEb ;8 J<E@EC< G8PC8fbIbD L J<E@E FC;LcL B8;8I 9<E@D ;<


J8PbCbI .<E@E 98f8IbEC8 @C>@C<ED<B QFILE;8PbD <E@D ;YEP8;8
?@W B@DJ<;< FCD8P8E 9@I E<;<E@D M8I JFE ;<I<:< ;< 9<E:@C:<
9@I f<P TPC< 9<E:@C:< B@ 9LELE M8I FC;LcLE8 @E8E89@C@IJ@E <E
J<E;<E P8E8PbD EK?FEP SYEBY J<E ?<D<E ?<D<E 9<E
J8PbCbIJbE \
dB@ B8I;<f LQLE 9@I JYI< 9@I9@IC<I@E< 98BKbC8I .FELE;8
EK?FEP@CBB<QG8PC8fKbcbPYQYEYQ<I@E;<9@C<;LID8;b


2@CC@8D <BC<;@ [+ELE @W@E IF9FKLE )<IBYI@P< PFCC8ED8JbEb


@JK<P<C@D \
XPC<C@BC< EK?FEP 9FPLE <c;@ D@KI@ ;< K<BC@=@ FE8PC8;b
58K<E 9XPC< 9@I f<P@ 9<BC@PFI;L +E;8E JFEI8 EK?FEP 9YKYE
>YE;<I@E;<I@E;YfYEYG;LI;L
.FELE;82@CC@8D`b9LCLG [ @EC<\;<;@
0QLE9@IJ<JJ@QC@BFCLE:88c89<P@9LJ<JJ@QC@c@9FQD8;b
EK?FEP [ @EC< \;@P<K<BI8IC8;b
2@CC@8DJ89bIC89<BC<;@
EK?FEP [#@KD<E< ><I<B PFB \ ;<;@ [)<IBYI@ @C>@J8

P8IbPC8 J<E;<E 98fB8JbEbE @C>@C<ED<J@E;<E ?FfC8ED8P

8:8cbE;8E<D@E@DE
2@CC@8D [48E@J<ED@>@;<:<BJ@E\;@P<JFI;L
EK?FEP [$8PbI \;<;@ [<E;<B8C8:8cbD \
2@CC@8D DbIbC;8E;b [@I9@I@D@Q@ JbB JbB >XID<D@Q< ><I<B
PFB \
EK?FEP< J8EB@ 9@I W@=K <C 9Fc8QbD JbB8IB<E BFELfD8P8
W8CbfbPFIDLf >@9@ ><C@PFI;L ,8ID8BC8IbE 98JBbJb ;8?8 ;8 8IKDbf
>@9@P;@ D8 B<E;@E< <E QFI ><C<E F JXQC<I@ JXPC<D<P@ JFELE;8
98f8I;b [@I9@I@D@Q;<EB8WD8DbQ8><I<BPFB Lf8IK;<c@C \
2@CC@8D 9@I8Q f8fBbE:8 >YCYDJ<IB<E EK?FEP ?@W
>YCYDJ<D<;<EW89L:8B8c89<P@E@EP8EbE;8ELQ8BC8fKb


2@CC@8D FBL;LcL B@K8GK8E 98fbEb B8C;bI; *<I<;<PJ< 9@I 8P

;8E 9<I@ EK?FEPE@E F;8JbE8 ><CD<J@E< @W@E @W@E ?8PI<K <KD<B

K<EM8Q><WD@fK@
[@If<PD@FC;L\;@P<JFI;L
['@D 9@C<9@C@I 4LDLf8B @E@f P8GD8P8 ?8QbIC8EbPFIC8I
)<IBYI@@C>@J8P8IbW8CbfbPFIDL\
2@CC@8D B8I;<f@E@E BFDGYK<I@E ;LILDLEL WFB @P@ 9@C;@c@E@E
=8IBbE;8P;b D8P@E<;< [48IbEJ898? EK?FEP \;<;@


[$@W9@IJFILEWbBD8;bDb\
[WbBD8;b \
[TPC<PJ<PLDLf8B@E@f@9<BC<D<D@Q><I<B@PFI \
[!M<K \
EK?FEP [@IK<IJC@BFC8:8B \;<;@
[-FB<KW@C@B 9L BFELC8I;8 WFB ;<E<P@DC@ 8IKbB $@W9@I K<IJC@B
FCD8P8:8B \
`[+B8;8IW8CbfD89Ff8>@;<:<B \
[$<EYQ>@KD<;@ >@KD<P<:<B;< \
EK?FEP [<CB@ ;< J<E ?8BCbJbE \ ;<;@ !CC<I@E@ :<GC<I@E<
JFB8I8B ;XE;Y '8GbP8 M8I;bcbE;8 ;LI8BC8P8I8B <BC<;@
[.8cFC \
[*<@W@E EK?FEP\
[<E@I8?8KC8KKbcbE@W@E \
2@CC@8D 8C8PC8 >YCYDJ<;@ LP>LC8IbEb 9<CC@ <KD<;@c@ @W@E
J<M@E@PFI;L
)<IBYI@ ,IFA<J@E;< W8Cbf8EC8IbE ?<GJ@ F XE<DC@ 8E;8
FI8;8C8I;b @I >XI<M@ FCD8P8E EK?FEP <E 8IB8P8 ><WD@fK@
#XQC<I@ DFE@KXIC<I;<P;@ -F9FK ?8I<B<K <KK@I@CD@f >XQC<I@PC<
>XI;YBC<I@E@8BK8IbPFI;L
8?8 ;FcILJL 9L D<J8AC8I >XIYEKYP< ;XEYfYPFIC8I;b #<IW@
f@D;@ DFE@KXIC<I;< JXEYB 9@I bfbBK8E 98fB8 9@I f<P >XQYBDYP

FI;L $<I?8C;<)<IBYI@`E@EPYQ<P@P;@9L
!BI8E;8 >XC><C<I 9@I9@IC<I@E@ BFM8C8;bC8I <CB@ 9LEC8I ><Q<

><E@E PYQ<P@E;<B@ 9FQLBCLBC8I;b EK?FEP J8;<:< <BI8EC8I8


98BKbcb @W@E B<J@E 9@I f<P JXPC<P<D@PFI;L D8 BFEKIFCC8IbE
98fbE;8B@ LQD8EC8I 8BK8IbC8E 9@C>@P@ WbGC8B >XQYE 98f8I8D8P

8:8cb PXEK<DC<IC< @E:<C@PFIC8I;b M< >XIYEYfK< WFB ;8 J8B@E;@C<I


:@C 9@I ;LILD FC;LcLEL 8WbBC8P8E BbIDbQb bfbBC8IbE ?@W9@I@ ;<
P8EDbPFI;L
EK?FEP 2@CC@8D M< ;@c<IC<I@PC< 9@C>@J8P8IbE 98fbE;8 FCD8D
><I<B@I;@ ;@P< ;YfYE;Y 'FDGYK<I PLDLf8B @E@fK<E JFEI8
W8CbfKbIbC8:8B +I8;8FCD8CbP;bD D89LELP8G8D8P8:8cbD


!BI8E;8B@ >XC><C<I f@D;@ ;8?8 ?bQCb 9<C@I@G B8P9FCLPFIC8I;b


[-F9FK@E@PFI D8WFBDL?bQCb!M<K WFB?bQCb \
!BI8E;8B@ >XIYEKY JFE B<Q 9LC8EbBC8fKbBK8E JFEI8 ;YQ<C;@
+;8B EFBK8Jb ;<c@f@IB<E C<B< BFPLC8fKb M< JFEI8 ?8=@=C<;@ @I
J<J ;LPLCD8P8 98fC8E;b EK?FEP 8E:8B 9@IB8W J8E@P< JFEI8 9L
J<JC<I@E E< 8EC8D8 ><C;@c@E@ B8MI8P89@C;@ [4LDLf8B @E@f
98f8IbC;b4LDLf8B@E@f98f8IbC;b\
.FEI8 ;LPLC8E DbIbCKbC8I B<E;@ B<E;@C<I@E@ BLKC8P8E @EJ8EC8IbE
?<P<:8ECb J<JC<I@E< ;XEYfKY .FELE;8 <BI8E;8 9@I ;<c@f@BC@B
;8?8 FC;L YKYE DbIbCKb M< B8?B8?8C8I B<J@CD@f J8EB@ J<JJ@Q

C@BK<EFCLf8E9@I;LM8I8W8IGDbfC8I;b
#XIYEKY @P@:< ;<c@fK@ <c@fK@ b8KC8I B<JB@EC<fK@ "@CKI<C@
<BI8E;8E ;@BB8KC< JYQYC<E F G8IC8B WFB G8IC8B >YE<f bfbcbE;8
f@D;@ 9@I B8P8Pb @P@:< J<W<9@C@PFIC8I;b LELE 9@I K8I8=b >XQ
B8D8fKbIb:b 9@I 9<P8QCbBK8 ;@c<I K8I8=bPJ8 B8GB8I8P;b '8P8 9@ g
J8c8 9@I JFC8 B8P;b .8EB@ 9@I W@=K >XQ XE:< JFC8 JFEI8 ;8 J8c8
98BDbf >@9@ !BI8E;8 D8;<E 9@I <C 9<C@I@IB<E >XQC<I ;< f@D;@
B<E;@MY:L;LE898BbPFI;L
.FELE;8EK?FEP [@C>@J8P8IW8CbfKbIbCD8P898fC8E;b\;@P<
98cbI;b
L JXQC<I@ J8EB@ 98fB8 9@I@ ?8PBbIDbf >@9@ BLC8BC8IbE;8
P8EBbC8EbPFI;L .FEI8 ;bf8Ib =bIC8P8I8B D<I;@M<EC<I;<E @E;@ I

B8JbE;8J<JC<IPYBJ<C@IB<E9@IBFI@;FI;8E><WK@
@C>@J8P8I F;8JbE8 ;8CbG [2@CC@8D\ ;@P< 98cbI;b
[+C8c8EYJKY9LL \
D8 8c89<P@ <C@E@ B8C;bI;b [$@fff (YK=<E -F9FKK8E ><C<E

C<I;bfbE;8f@;;<KC@;LP>LC8IbEP8PbCD8JbEb@JK<D@PFILD \
EK?FEP [48E@9@Q@;LP89@C@ID@\;@P<=bJbC;8;b
[<CB@ ;< ;LP8D8Q 8D8 9@CD@PFILD \ +;8;8 )<IBYI@ @C

>@J8P8IbEbE P8BbEbE;8 PLB8Ib;8B@E;<E BYWYB 9@I <BI8E ;8?8


M8I;b !BI8E;8B@ J8?E< =8IBCbP;b M< ;<c@f@PFI; -F9FK ?8I<B<K
<;@PFI;L
2@CC@8D [-F9FK 8CbfD8P8 W8CbfbPFI \ ;@P< 8WbBC8;b


[;bDC8Ib ?8EK8C:8 FC8:8B K89@@ 0P8IbPC8 :<M8G 8I8JbE;8 P<;@


;8B@B8CbB9@I><:@BD<M8I LEL?<J898B8KD8B><I<B@PFI \
[D8 I@QFE8;8B@E;<E WFB ;8?8 ;YQ>YE PYIYD<P< 98fC8;b
9@C< .<E ;< 8PEb =@B@I;< ;<c@C D@J@E 2@CC@8D .<E ;< XPC<
;YfYEDYPFI DLJLE\ ;8D 8c89<P@E@E FDQLEL B8MI8Dbf FEL
J8IJbPFI;L ?C8>XQC<I@<BI8E;8P;b
2@CC@8D [<E9LE;8E<D@E@D EK?FEP \;<;@

#YE<f J@P8? M< 9<P8Q;8E FCLf8E 9L Jb:8B ><Q<><E@ B8MLI

LPFI;L .@DJ@P8? 9@I >XBPYQYE;< 9<D9<P8Q 9@I #YE<f bfbC;bPFI


9<D9<P8Q P<I< B8GB8I8 >XC><C<I ;YfYPFI;L WbBK8 B8C8E D8;

<E@E ?<I J8EK@D<KI< B8I<J@E@ bJbK8E >YE<f@E BFBLJL 9<II8B M<


K8KCbP;b L ;@c<I P8E;8E 8;<K8 JYIYEYI:<J@E< P8PbC8E XCYD BFB

LJLE8PJ8?@W9<EQ<D@PFI;L
-F9FK <C@E@ B8C;bI8I8B 98BKb ,8ID8BC8IbEb J8P;b .b:8B
Jb:8B

Jb:8B XE<I<B G8ID8BC8IbEb K<B<I K<B<I ;@c<I <C@E@E >XC><J@E<


JFBKL .b:8BCbB P8M8f P8M8f ><W<IB<E ;FBLED8 ;LPLJLE;8B@ 9L
;<c@f@BC@B 393 K<D@QM<I8?8K9FfCLcL?@JJ<KD<J@E@J8cC8;b
D8 9L K8D 9@I 9FfCLB J8PbCD8Q;b + ;FcILC;L M< @B@
<C@E@ 98fbEbE PLB8IbJbE8 ;FcIL B8C;bI;b .FEI8 XE< ;FcIL LQ8K

Kb M< 9@C<BC<I@E;<B@ ;LP8ICb EFBK8C8I J8P<J@E;< >8QC8Ib ?@JJ<KK@


cbI:bM8EbE8I8JbE;8LWLf8EK<E<B<M<BLIfLEL
P8BC8Ib ;8?8 =8QC8 9@C>@ J8cC8;b ?<I KYI;< J@C@B8K $<I
D8;<E @PFELELE 9<II8B8PIb M< 9<I89<I K8;b M< ;FBLELfL P

8cbEb KFG KFG FCDLf PLDIL PLDIL KFQC8IbE 8I8JbE;8 8cbI 8cbI
FPE8KKb M< ;<c@f@BC@BC<I@ ?@W ;< ><C@f@>YQ<C J8PbCD8P8:8B PL

DLf8B9@IJ<E=FE@>@9@;LP;L
1< #YE<f ?<I K8I8=K8P;b 8fbEb B8C;bI8I8B #YE<f< 98B

Kb dI@ f@fD8E G8IC8B M< Jb:8B 9@I f<P;@ 9L + #YE<f@E


E<f<J@E@ @f@KK@ S<G<I@E;<E 8cbI 8cbI PYBJ<C<E LQ8EKbC8I8 98BKb
M< ?<I 9@I@E@E W8KbIKbJbEb ;@EC<;@ #YE<f@E F ><G><E@f
PYQYE;<B@ ;@c<I DLKCL >YIYCKYC<I@ ;< "FE;8B@ bfbcb
JXEYBC<fK@I;@c@ Q8D8E P<I;<E PYBJ<C<E BbQbC ?@;IFA<E


9LCLK:LBC8Ib K8KCb 9@I BFEKI8CKFP8 ;XEYfKY $8I<B<K ?8C@E;<B@


J@JC<I@E ?8=@= bJCbBC8IbE8 BYWY:YB G8IC8B EFBK8C8IbE B8CbE 98J
J<JC<I@ B8IbfbPFI;L #YE<fK< G8KC8D8C8I FCLIB<E >8DD8 bfbE

C8IbEbE M< BFQD@B G8IW8:bBC8IbE G@EGFE KFGC8IbEbE K8BbIKbJbE8


9<EQ<P<E >YIYCKYC<I@ ;LPLCLPFI;L 1< ?<I PXE;< #YE<f@E
BFQD@B IYQ>8I;8 ;LID8;8E PYBJ<C@G LQ8BC8f8E PLDLf8B
98P>bE @W W<B@f@ P8EBbC8EbPFI;L 'FQD@B IYQ>8I LQ8EbPFI M<
+ELJ8EB@PbBbPFI;L
.bWI8;b + Q8D8E8 B8;8I ?@JJ<KD<;@c@ 9@I XQ>YICYBC<
?8M8;8 8cbI 8cbI PYBJ<C;@ P8BC8E P<I< ;<P@E:< K<BI8I Qb

GC8;b 1< BFfD8P8 98fC8;b IKbB JbWI8PbG QbGCbPFI M< BFfLP

FI;L 1Y:L;L 9L f8?8E< ;YEP8P8 WFB LP>LE;L '<E;@E@ 9LC

;LcL9L:<EE<K<
SFB LQLE PbCC8I 9FPLE:8 B8P9FCDLf FC8E 9L P898E:b
:<EE<K<JFELE;8<I@fD@fK@

2@CC@8D [$<If<PPFCLE;8 \;<;@


EK?FEP?8PBbI;b [D8E<P8GbPFI\
[$<If<P   ,IF>I8DC8D8<KB@C@ +;LPLC8IbEb;<E<;@
#XQC<DC<I P8GKb #YE<f`@ JXEYBC<fK@I<I<B @E:<C<;@ KDFJ=<I@ M
KFGI8cbEB@DP8J8CXQ<CC@BC<I@E@;<XPC< $<If<PW8CbfbPFI \
[D8E<;<EBFfLPFI\
[#8C@98 9L FELE B<E;@ =@BI@ EK?FEP @I 9<P@E B8;8I
B8ID8fbB 9@I 9@C>@J8P8IbE GIF>I8DC8ED8JbEb @JK<IJ<E FELE
B<E;@E:<98Qb=@B@IC<I@FCD8JbEb;89<BC<D<C@J@E \
['FfD8B .bWI8D8B\ EK?FEP <E;@f<PC< 8c89<P@E<
;XE;Y [@I P<I@E< 9@I f<P FC8:8B .<E 9@C>@J8P8Ib @;8I< <;<9@

C@IJ@E +ELBFEKIFCLE88C  LI;LI \


I;bE;8E 2@CC@8D J<IK J<IK [$8PbI \ ;<;@ [LEL P8GD8P

8:8cbD +ELE B<E;@ B<E;@E< Q8I8I M<ID< K<?C@B<J@E@ >XQ<


8C8:8cbD EC8DbPFI DLJLE + WFB  4<IPYQYE;<B@
$@W9@I Q8D8E 98f8 WbB8D8P8:8cb 9@I ;YEP8;8 e@D;@ )<IBYI@`;<
M< MY:L;L W<MI<J@E< JFE ;<I<:<;< LP>LE 4YQ LQD8Eb 98f8I;b


9LEL )<IBYI@FELE@W@E9@I:<EE<K bI8B;8Q<MB@E@WbB8IJbE \


[5<MB@E@D@WbB8IJbE-F9FKDL\
[<E IF9FKK8E JXQ <KD@PFILD .XQYEY <KK@c@D 9<P@E + 
 LI8;8P8f8P8E9<P@E \
8D 9@I D8?=8Q8P8 BFEDLf M< YQ<I@E< ;@BB8KC< LJK8CbBC8
K<CC<I 98cC8EDbf FC8E )<IBYI@ @C>@J8P8IbEbE 9YKYECYcY @E:<C@BC<
BFILEDLfKL .FCLB8CbPFIM<P8fbPFI;L
2@CC@8D <BC<;@ [<EE<KK<B@ -8E;8CC + LcILE;8 FK@QD@
J<W<I<B 9L ;YEP8;8E B8WKbcb ><Q<><E@E@ 9LC;L !JB@ MY:L;LELE
?@W9@I Q8D8E LPLD J8cC8P8D8;bcb 9@I ;YEP8P8 B8IfbCbB f@D;@
P<E@>XM;<J@E@E@P@:<LP;LcL9@I><Q<><E<<I@fK@ \
EK?FEP f8fBbECbB @W@E;< <BI8E8 98BbPFI;L [.8B@EC<fD<P<
98fC8;bJ8EbIbD \
2@CC@8D [/89@@ \ ;<;@ [)LKCLCLcL PYQYE;<E @f@E@ ;8?8 ;8
@P@P8G8:8B \
EK?FEP >YCYDJ<;@ [+ ?8C;< 9L @f@ 98f8I;bB XPC< D@ .<E
M< 9<E @c<IC<I@E< B8KbCbG FEC8IbE 9@Q< P8CK8BC8ED8C8IbE8 @Q@E
M<I<C@DD@ 2@CC@8D\
2@CC@8D [<I89<ID@\;<;@
EK?FEPFELEBFCLE8>@I;@ [<I89<I 8c89<P \

)*
I8E; #FIC8 JbBbEKbPC8 >YCYDJ<;@ [@C;@c@E >@9@ 9XPC< f<PC<I
898IKbCbI \
[$8PbI ?8PbI ?8PbI\ 0=8B K<=<B 8;8DbE 8C9@EFC8I8 XQ>Y
G<D9<DJ@ >XQC<I@E;< X=B<C@ 9@I GbIbCKb 9<C@I;@ [ FIC@J @EJ8EC8IbE
;8?8 1<>8 J@JK<D@E< >@ID<;@BC<I@ JbI8;8 WFB >YWCYP;Y @Q@D

B@E;<E;8?89YPYB9@I#8C8BJ@"<;<I8JPFELELED<IB<Q@P;@ \
[dP@ P8 FI8EbE <JB@ 9@I D<IB<Q FC;LcLEL JXPC<P<C@D LEL


B89LC<;<:<BM<><I@J@E@9@I8IB<FCFc89bI8B8:8cbD \
[IB<FCF>C8I 9L BFEL;8 ?@W9@I @f< P8I8D8Q <E@D 9LC;LB

C8IbD @W@E B<E;@ 8C8EbE;8 LQD8EC8fDbf 9@I@ ><I<BC@ !? J<E ;<


BFD@K<;<J@E \
I8E; #FIC8EbE >XQYE;< FCLDJLQ 9@I @=8;< 9<C@I;@ /?<FI
-<8CFPL JFE JbEb=K8E ?8KbICbPFI;L $@W B@DJ<PC< LPLD
J8cC8P8D8P8E L=8B K<=<B 9@I 8C9@EF $8P8C@ I8E;bE 8EbC8IbE;8
8IB8 GC8E;8 9@I P<I;< K@KI<f@PFI;L I8;8E WFB LQLE Q8D8E
><WD@f FCD8JbE8 B8IfbE 8C9@EFELE ><IW<BK<E >8I@G 9@I @EJ8E
FC;LcLEL?8KbICbPFI;L 1<FELE?VCV>8I@GFC;LcL9<CC@P;@
I8E; [.8E8 P8I;bD <KD<P< W8CbfbIbD \ ;<;@ [/89@@ 98E8
E<@JK<;@c@E@JXPC<IJ<E \
/?<FI FEL ;@BB8KC< JYQYPFI;L ['FD@K<P< 98Qb ><IW<BC<I@
8WbBC8D8Eb@JK@PFILD LELP8G8:8cbE8JXQM<I@ID@J@E\
I8E; B8W8D8c8 J8GKb [.8E8 P8I;bD <;<9@CJ<D 9@C< fLEL
?8KbIC8KD8B QFILE;8PbD /?<FI <E GJ@BFCFA@ BFD@K<J@E@E BYWYB
9@IYP<J@P@D "8QC89@IEY=LQLDPFB \
[!C@E;<E ><C<E@ P8GD8CbJbE <C><C<I ;LILDL 8WbBC8P8:8BC8I
Q8K<E \C9@EFELE<CC<I@K@KI@PFI;L
I8E; 98f<cD<BK<E 98fB8 W8I< 9LC8D8;b [,<BVCV 8EC8K
98B8CbD \ dW@E @W@E ;< <BC<;@ .FELWK8 F 9<E@D <JB@ FBLC
8IB8;8fbD L ;LILD;8 8EC8D8;8E ;@EC<D<;<E FEL >XE;<I

D<BFCD8Q
-8?8K 9@I K8MbIC8 8IB8JbE8 P8JC8E;b IBKLILJLE bfbBC8Ib
K8M8E8 B8;8I PYBJ<C<E G<E:<I<C<I;<E @W<I@P< JYQYCYPFI;L -<E

BC<E;@I@CD@f :8DC8I bfbEC8Ib P8PbG PLDLf8KbPFIC8I;b D8 >YE<f@E


9XPC< ?8=@=C<K@CD@f bfbBC8Ib 9@C< /?<FILE G<D9< >XQC<I@ @W@E
=8QC8P;b 'FELfLIB<E <C@PC< >XQC<I@E@ BFILD8P8 W8CbfKb [<E K8D
P@ID@ 9<f PbC FIC@JK< P8f8;bD I8E; L>YE ?@W B@DJ<E@E
M8ICbcbE;8E 9@C< ?89<I@ FCD8;bcb P<IC<I@ 8I8fKbI;bD M< 98Qb f<PC<I
9LC;LD FIC@J 9@Q@DB@E;<E WFB ;8?8 9YPYB 9@I LP>8ICbcbE BYCKYI
M< 9@C@D D<IB<Q@P;@ !M<K XPC< P8 TQ<CC@BC< ;< GJ@BFCFA@
8C8EbE;8 \


I8E; CYK=<E >YCYDJ<;@ [#<WD@fK<B@ f<PC<I @EJ8E8 ?<I Q8

D8E ;8?8 9YPYBDYf >@9@ >XQYBYI L BFEL;8 9@I K<FI@ M8I;bI


dJK<I<E ;<IJ B@K8GC8IbE;8 9LC89@C@IJ@E dCB JbEb= XcI<E:@C<I@ ?<I Q8

D8E FE;8E #!# /<FI<D@ ;@P< JXQ <;<IC<I 48E@ #YQ<C


!JB@
#YEC<I/<FI<D@ *<PJ< .<E;<M8D<K \
/?<FI 8PEb =@B@I;< FCD8;bcbEb 9<C@IKD<B @W@E B8fC8IbEb W8KKb
[.<E@ I8?8KJbQ <;<E 9@I ><IW<c@ XE<DJ@Q 9@I <K@B<K P8GbfKbI8I8B
?<I Q8D8E 9@I B<E8I8 8K89@C@IJ@E \ '8IfbJbE;8B@E@ 8f8cb
>XI;YcYEY 9<CC@ <KD<D<P< W8CbfbPFI;L [D8 J<E f@D;@ 98E8
fLELJXPC< GJ@BFCFA@DY?<E;@JC@c@BFELJLE;8E<9@C@PFIJLE\
I8E; FDQLEL J@CBK@ [TPC< 9@I f<P PFB B@ 48E@ ?@W FCD8QJ8
D8K<D8K@B 98BbD;8E YKYE F GIFG8>8E;8 M< I<BC8D J8;<:<
I8JK><C< LP>LC8E8E GJ@BFCFA@ DY?<E;@JC@c@E@E B898 9@I KYIY
.8Q8EWFB<KB@C@FC89@C@PFI <CB@J<E@EB8JK<KK@c@E;<9L\
[$@W ;< ;<c@C <E BFEKIFCCL BFfLCC8I 8CKbE;8 B8C898CbB @EJ8E
>ILGC8Ib YQ<I@E;< P8GbC8E ><IW<B ;<E<PC<I;<E JXQ <;@PFILD
4bCC8I:8JYI;YIYC<E;<E<PC<I;<E \
[XPC< f<PC<I K8IKbfbC;b D8 9LEC8IbE LP>LC8ED8Jb DYDBYE
;<c@C /FGCLD P8GbDbQ 9L KYI f<PC<I< =8QC8 ;8P8E8D8Q !KBAC@
BFEKIFC@W@E;<P<K<I@B8;8I9@C>@D@QPFB \
/?<FI ?<P<:8EbEb 98JBb 8CKbE;8 KLKD8P8 W8CbfbPFI;L [D8
<JB@C<I@E P<K<I@ B8;8I 9@C>@C<I@ FC;LcL @W@E BFEKIFC J8cC8D8Pb
'&K&6)G1&6
I8E; J8B@E J8B@E JFI;L [e8fbIKb:b M< @C>@EW D8 9LEL
E<I<;<E9@C@PFIJLE\
[SYEBY 9L BFELPC8 @C>@C@ 9<C><C<I 9LC;LD \ /?<FI JFCLB
JFCLc8 JLJKL [YKYE 9@I ><Q<><E I8E; 0P>LE FC;LcL @W@E
J<W@C<E BFJBF:8 9@I ;YEP8 $<I 8Wb;8E BFEKIFC <;@C<E B@DJ<C<IC<
;FCL 9@I P<I dE:<C<E<E JbEb=C8I8 8PIbC8E M< YQ<IC<I@E;< ;<E<PC<I
P8GbC8E>ILGC8I  LILDL8EC8DbPFIDLJLE\
I8E; B8=8 BFEKIFCLEL B8P9<KK@c@E@ >XJK<I<E F 8I8Q PFB ;@

P< ;YfYE;Y D8 P8BbE;8E @E:<C<E@IJ< 9<CB@ .FEI8 B<

C@D<C<I< 98J8 98J8 [$<I?8C;< P8EbC;bE \ ;<;@ [L KYDYPC<


 

FC8E8BJbQ dEJ8EC8Ib 9L f<B@C;< BFEKIFC 8CKbE8 8C8D8QJbE ,<B


WFB;<c@fB<EM8I;bIWYEBY \
[dfK< D<J<C<E@E :8E8Cb:b EFBK8Jb ;8 9L +EC8I @EJ8E
;<c@CC<I;@ \
[*<\
[-F9FKKL FEC8I ,FQ@KIFE@B IF9FKC8I YEP8 ;FCLJL D8B@E<
8;8D I8E; 48f8D8B K<GB@ >XJK<ID<B M< ><IW<B P8E@ @EJ8E
GJ@BFCF>C8I K8I8=bE;8E >XQC<ED<BK<E 98fB8 P8G8:8BC8Ib 9@I f<P
PFBKL \
[ <C@C@B9L\
['8EbKC8I 9LC;LD SYEBY F IF9FKC8IC8 ;FCL ;YEP8 ?VCV M8I
@I@E:@ 'FE=<;<I8JPFE G8IW8C8EDbf D8 F IF9FK ;YEP8Jb
P8f8DbEbJYI;YIDYf UJK<C@B9L>YE;<M8I \
[LELE<I<;<E9@C@PFIJLE\
/?<FI -<8CF 8P8c8 B8CBKb [SYEBY fL JFE P@ID@ 9<f PbCb 8J

CbE;8FI8;8><W@I;@D\

'FD@K< 98fB8Eb B<E8IC8Ib BbIDbQb JYJCY I<JD@ :YGG<J@E@ 9@I


K8I8=8 8K8I8B :<9@E;<E LQLE 9FcLDCL M< ?@W ;< I<JD@ 9@I
?8M8Jb FCD8P8E 9@I J@>8I WbB8I;b [+C8:8B >@9@ ;<c@C \ ;@P<
?FDLI;8EbPFI;L [SbC>bECbB9L \
I8E; [!M<K XPC< \ ;<;@ [<E ;< 9LEL 9@I;<E9@I< BF

D@K<P< 8WbBC8P8D8D <E@ ;@EC<D<QC<I 9@C< LILDL XE:< J@Q<


8WbBC8D8D><I<B@PFI;L +E;8EJFEI8P<KB@E@Q@BLCC8EbIJ8EbQ 
[? WFBKL?8= $@W9XPC<9@If<P;LPD8DbfKbD '@D9L
8;8D\
I8E; @W@E@ W<BK@ [+ELE 9@I B8WbB FC;LcLEL @K@I8= <KD<C@P@D
IBKLILJ UE@M<IJ@K<J@E;< 8PEb JbEb=K8P;bB L 8C9@EF F Q8D8E
9@C< B8WbcbE K<B@P;@ $@W B@DJ<PC< LPLD J8cC8P8DbPFI;L BCb
=@BI@ <JB@ W8cC8I K8I@?@E;<P;@ BCbE8 9@I f<P ><C;@ D@ 9L LcLI;8
8GK8C >@9@ ;LID8;8E W8CbfbG W898C8P8E @EJ8EC8I;8E;b
.XPC<;@c@E< >XI< FIC@J J@JK<D@E;< P@ID@ 9<f PbC FI8P8 9LI8P8
>@KD@f e@D;@ FE;8 E<I<;<PJ< 9YKYE LP>8ICbcbE K8D 9<C><C<I@



M8I \
'FD@K< 98fB8Eb J@>8IbEb X=B<C@ X=B<C@ KYKKYI;Y [!M<K
9@C@PFILD /<C<
JK8K ;@Q@C<I@E;< 9@C< 8D8KXI ?<I Q8D8E ?8I@B8
f<PC<I 9LCLI 48CEbQ 98fbE8 W8Cbf8E B8?I8D8E $@W9@I P<I< 98cCb
FCD8P8E 9@I@ $8P;@ FI8;8E IB<FCFA@ 9XCYDYE< 98fMLI;LE
DL\
[/89@@ .FELW @C>@EW FC;L '@DJ< FIC@ C< @C>@C<ED@PFI 'FEL
J8;<:< <JB@ ;<c@C FE 9<f 9@E PbC XE:<J@PC< ;< @C>@C@ FIC@J ?<

D<E ?<D<E 9@I <=J8E< J8PbC;bcb @W@E >YM<E@C@I 8IB<FCF>C8I FELEC8


@C>@C<E<I<B Q8D8E B8P9<KD@PFIC8I +I8Jb 9@I K<B BFELP8 J8GC8EbG
B8CDbf B@K8GC8I8 ;YfBYE 9@I 8D8KXIYE 9LC89@C<:<c@ 9@I P<I /89@@
9LE;8E JFEI8 FIC@J 9@I 8IB<FCF> :<EE<K@E< ;XEYf<:<B D8
/?<FILE@;;@8C8Ib;FcILWbB8IJ8 \
'FD@K< 98fB8Eb W@IB@E PYQYEY BFIBLEW 9@I 9@W@D;< 9LI

LfKLI;L [L ?@W ;< >LILI FBf8Pb:b 9@I ;LILD ;<c@C !c<I KYD
9LEC8I;8 9@I ><IW<B G8Pb M8IJ8 F Q8D8E @I@E:@ 'FE=<;<I8JP

FELE GJ@BFCFA@ 8C8EbE;8 9@Q;<E WFB @C<I@ FC;LcL 8EC8fbC8:8B @Q


;< J8WD8C8P8E 8GK8CC8I ;LILDLE8 ;Yf<:<c@Q ,FQ@KIFE@B IF9FK

C8Ib ;8 LELKD8 @Q 9L BFEL;8 ?VCV GC8EC8I YQ<I@E;< W8CbfbPFILQ


FIC@J@E 9L 8Wb;8E 9@Q;<E P<KD@f 9<f B8Kb YJKYE FC;LcL FIK8P8
WbB8:8B #8C8BJ@L@fC<@C>@C@D8K<D8K@c@;YfYE \
[<E@ ;@EC<P@E <=<E;@D $<D<E ?<IB<J@E =@BI@E@ 8CD8;8E M<
?<I FC8JbCbcb @E:<C<D<;<E BFELPL J@Q< 8W8D8Q;bD $<D<E @CB @f
C8B8 >@KK@D + ;8 @IC<f@B -F9FKC8IbE D<K8D<K@BW@J@PC< >XIYfKY
+ 9XPC< f<PC<I@E JbEbIb FCD8;bcbEb JXPCYPFI _58D8E G8I8 M< ;<

I@E 9@I GJ@BFCFA@ 9@C>@J@


9LE8 XQ<CC@BC< ;@BB8K <;@E_;<I@E 9@I GJ@BF

CFA@9@C>@J@FCLIJ8FKYIIF9FKC8If@D;@9@C<P8GbC89@C@I ;@PFI \
[!C@E;<E8JbC9@IB8EbKM8I\
['@D@EC8BbEDb\
[$8PbI ?8PbI IB8;8fbEbE C9@EFELE +E;8 9<C><C<I
FC;LcLELJXPC<;@E \
[!M<K M8I $<GJ@ 9LI8;8 /?<FI WFB <JB@ FC;LcLELE @EBV
<;@C<D<P<:<c@ 9<C><C<I 9LCDLf $<GJ@E@ W<f@KC@ f<B@CC<I;<
 

@E:<C<K K@I;@D /89@@ F 9<C><C<I@ FBLD8D @DBVEJbQ 58K<E B@D

J<E@E FBL P89@C<:<c@E@ ;< J8EDbPFILD /?<FI -<8CF ;bfbE;8


K89@@ \
[D8 9L @f8I<KC@ B8IKC8IC8 FPLE FPE8D8P8 9<EQ<D@PFI
DL 48E@ FELE @;;@8C8IbEb FC;LcL >@9@ B89LC <KD<B
QFILE;8PbQ \
[!M<K 9@I 98BbD8 D8 /?<FI ;8 9<C><C<I@E KYDYEY 8B

LP8 9@C;@c@E@ @;;@8 <KD@PFI .8;<:< 98Qb 9XCYDC<I@ WXQ<9@C;@c@E@


JXPCY PFI @C@E <JB@ .<EK8LI:8;8E KYI<;@c@E@ @;;@8 <;@PFI
<C><C<I@ ; LQD8EC8IbE8 M<I;@D FEC8IbE YQ<I@E;< W8CbfbPFIC8I
+EC8I 9L ;@ WXQ<9@C@IC<I !c<I /?<FILE W<M@I@J@ ;FcIL ;<c@CJ<
9LEL;8XcI<EI@Q \
[,<BVCV eL9<C><C<I<9@I98B8CbD \
I8E; #8IC8 YQ<IC<I@E< GC8JK@B ><W@I@CD@f FC8E 9<C><C<I@
WbB8b ;b 'FD@K< 98fB8Eb ?<GJ@E@ 9@I K8I8=8 8K8I8B fMI@P< LQ

8E;LELFBLIB<EJ@>8IbE;LD8EC8IbEbY=C<P@G;LILPFI;L
.FELE;8 [$b? \;<;@ [$<I?8C;<;@c<I8PIbEKbC8I FIC@JK<
[/?<FI J8;<:< GFQ@KIFE@B IF9FKC8IbE 9<P@EC<I@PC< @C>@C@ PYQ
P ;8 @B@ PYQ KFE GC8E FC;LcLEL @;;@8 <;@PFI +EC8I ?VCV FIC@J`
BFELC;LBC8Ib D8?Q<E;<PD@fC<I D8 9@C>@E@E <E XE<DJ@Q@ 9b
/?<FI F IF9FK ;YEP8JbE8 >@KD@f +E;8 =FKF
B8CbGC8I K<C<BJ
B8Pb C8Ib ?<I KYICY 8PIbEKb M8I /89@@ 9YKYE 9L 9@C>@ 9@I8I8P8 KF

GC8EDb Dbf LELE GJ@BFCFA@ BFELJLE;8 =8QC8 9@C>@J@ FCD8P8E


9@I@ K8I8=bb ;8E KFGC8E;bcb 9<CC@ D8 /?<FI P@E< ;< @E;@c@ ><Q<

><E@E f<P ;Fc8C FCD8;bcbEb B8EbKC8P8:8B B8;8I 9@C>@


KFGC8Dbf \
[,<B@P8EbE;8Db\
[$<GJ@ SFcL D@BIF=@CD YQ<I@E;< D8 GIFA<BJ@PFE D8B

@E8JbEb;8><K@I;@D dfK<>XQCYBC<I@E@Q \
'FD@K< 98fB8Eb 9@I J88K JFEI8 [YP<C<I@ P8IbE KFGC8EKbP8
W8KI8:8cbD \;<;@ [LBFELPL8W8:8cbD \
I8E; J@E@IC@ J@E@IC@ >YCYDJ<;@  FIC@J< 9@I BFD@JPFE DL
Pb8P8:8cbQ\
 

'FD@K< 98fB8Eb 8C8PC8 [UE@M<IJ@K<;<E 9XPC< 9@I f<P @W@E


G8I8 BFG8I89@C@IJ<B \ ;@P< DbIbC;8E;b [0 D8CQ<D<P@ 9@I JYI<
@W@E 98E8 9bI8B CYK=<E <C><C<I@ 9@I8Q ;8?8 @E:<C<D<B
@JK@PFILD \

$YBYD<K@E @C@D M< /<BEFCFA@ 8@I<J@ K<FI@B FC8I8B 9YKYE


9@C@DJ<C 8I8fKbID8C8Ib BFEKIFC <;@PFI;L D8 8JCbE;8 9YPYB
YE@M<IJ@K<C<I;< J8;<:< 8I8fKbID8 P8G8E >ILGC8I 98cbDJbQ;bC8I
$YBYD<K ><E<CC@BC< 9LELEC8 LcI8fDbPFIJ8 ;8 K89@@ 9L <MI<EJ<C
9@IBLI8C;8;<c@C;@
dfK< 9L E<;<EC< BFD@K< 98fB8Eb B8fC8IbEb W8KKb X=B<PC< BY

=I<KK@ 8D8 2PEE< )LIIPC< BFELfD8Pb I<;;<;<D<;@ LEL P8G

D8Jb @DBVEJbQ;b )LIIP 8JCbE;8 98B8E P8I;bD:bJbP;b M< GJ@BF

CFA@ GJ@BFG8K@ M< Q@?@E K<BEFCFA@J@ BFELC8IbPC8 @C>@C<E@PFI;L PIb:8


FC;LBW8@P@9@IGJ@BFCF>J8PbCbI;b
'FD@K<98fB8EbX=B<PC<98B89@C@I;@8D88E:8BFB8;8I
8B8E 48I;bD:bJb )LIIP E<f<PC< 9L 98BbfC8Ib >XID<QC@BK<E
><C;@ 0QLE W<E<J@E@ FMLfKLI8I8B [L JFELWK8 P<K<IJ@Q 9@I 9@C>@
BFELJLJ8PbCbI \;<;@ [XPC<JXPC<P<C@DD@\
'FD@K< 98fB8Eb JFcLB JFcLB [$8E>@ 9@C>@P@ @JK<;@c@E@Q@
9@CD@PFILD \ ;@P< :<M8G M<I;@ [$YBYD<K YE@M<IJ@K<PC< @C>@C@ =FE

C8I BFELJLE;8 J8;<:< 9@I ;8EbfD8E >@9@ ;8MI8E89@C@I 1< 9L J<

=<IB@FC8P;8;8?YBYD<K@E=@B@IC<I@9@Q@?@W@C>@C<E;@ID@PFI \
)LIIP FDQLEL J@CBK@ [<E G8I8P8 B8Ifb WbBDbPFILD D8
?YBYD<K@E @QE@ FCD8;8E 9L ><Q<><E;<E 8PIbC8D8QJbEbQ dfK<
P<K<IJ@Q9@C>@;<9LBFELPC8@C>@C@ \
[.@Q<M<I@C<E;<E98fB89@C>@D@QPFB \
[D8 98Qb f<PC<I ;bf8Ib JbQ;b YKYE 9L JbI >@Q WFB WF:LBW8
M<><I<BJ@Q \
48fCb GJ@BFCF> BbGBbIDbQb B<J@C;@ [.bI Db !c<I 8B8;<D@B
P8f8D K8IQbEb 9@CD@PFIJ8EbQ 9L BFEL;8 J@Q< P8I;bD <;<D<D
I8fKbID8C8I XQ<CC@BC< WFB XE<DC@ FC8EC8Ib 9<C@IC@ 9@I ><C@fD<
FCD8;8E B8DLP8 8WbBC8E8D8Q WbBC8E8D8Q #<I@ ;XE;YcYDYQ


Q8D8EJ@Q<P8PbEC8P8:8cbDbQK<QC<I@EBFGP8C8IbEb>XE;<I@I@Q \
)LIIP 98fbEb J8CC8;b [C? b? L P<K<IC@ ;<c@C .@Q FIC@J`<
>@;@PFIJLELQ ;<c@CD@\
[@C@D;8@I<J@E<9@C;@I;@BQ8K<E \
[*<;<E\
[,<B@ E<;<EXcI<ED<B@JK@PFIJLELQ\
[SYEBY 9L WFB XE<DC@ 9@I f<P 4FBJ8 BFD@K< 98fB8Eb
FI8Pb >@KD<P@ ;YfYED<Q;@ 9@C< eL ;8?8 <JB@ LP>8ICbB M< IF

9FKC8I;YEP8JbD<J<C<J@E<;@I\
[dP@P8 XcI<ED@fJ@E@Q@fK< \
[.8;<:< YJKYEBXIY 9@I =@B@I <;@E<9@C;@B <E 8PIbEKbC8Ib
@JK@PFILD \
[@C;@c@D@Q ?@W9@I 8PIbEKb PFB FIC@J`< @ED<;@BW<
XcI<E<D<P<:<c@Q \
[+?8C;<9<E;<J@Q@EC<><C<:<c@D \
[*<\
[SYEBY9<E;<8PIbEKbC8IbXcI<ED<B@JK@PFILD \
[*<;<E\
[? \ )LIIP 8P8c8 B8CBKb [e@D;@ ;< 7.= JFILC8I JFILP

FIJL ELQ IKbB 9LELE 9@I P8I8Ib PFB UE@M<IJ@K<C<I@E ?YBYD<K


BFEKI8 CLE;8E ?FfC8ED8;bBC8IbEb 9@C@PFILD $<I?8E>@ 9@I 8B8

;<D@B B8P E8cbE 98E8 @JK<P<I<B P8I;bD <KD<P<:<c@E@ 9@C;@c@D


>@9@ D8 IBKLILJ 8;bE8 L J<=<I P8I;bD 9LC8:8cbD <E

@DC< @JK<;@c@E@ B8;8I J8M8fbE MbQ><C@I .@Q< B8KbCD8QJ8D


>IL9LELQ ?@W9@I P<Ib >@;<D<Q <E ;< ?YBYD<K K<DJ@C:@J@
FC8I8BJ@Q<B8KbC8:8cbD \

FIC@J 9@I ;YEP8 FC8I8B <KB@C<P@:@ ;<c@C;@ #8C8BJ@ <BFEFD@


98BbDbE;8E ?@W XE<D@ PFBKL YPYB K@:8I<K PFCC8IbE;8E WFB
LQ8BK8P;b 4<IC@C<I@ ><I@ B8CDbf M< :8?@C;@C<I /8I@?@ B8I8ECbBKb
D8 <J@ 9@I ;YEP8Pb 9Fc8E F DFCFQ PbcbEC8IbEbE 8CKbE;8 9@I
P<I;< 9<CC@ 9<C@b J@Q B8EbKC8I M8I;b !JB@ >YEC<I@E FIC@J@E@E ;8?8
9YPYB 9@I =<;<I8JPFELE ;8?8 9YPYB 9@I D<IB<Q@ FC8E


><Q<><E@EPYBJ<C@GPFBFCLfLEL8WbBC8P8E9<C><C<I
e@D;@ ;< ;8?8 P<E@ 9@I ;YEP8;8E ><CD@f FC8E @EJ8EC8I 9L
DFCFQC8IbB8IbfKbIbPFIM<;LILDL8EC8D8P8W8CbfbPFIC8I;b
'FD@K< 98fB8Eb B8=8JbEb J8CC8;b M< JFEI8 ;8 BbI J8WC8IbEb
><I@P< ;FcIL @KK@ @I ?8=K8;8E 9<I@ KI8f FCD8DbfKb [YKYE D<

J<C8 9@I WbBbf EFBK8DbQbE FCD8D8Jb @C@ WXQD<C<I@ FC8E8BJbQ


?<I?8C;< D8P8QbC8I;8E9@I8EC8DWbBDbPFI \
[LBFEL;89@IWFBf<PP8GbC;bJ8EbIbD \
['8I8ECbBK8 <C PFI;8DbPC8 C9@EF 8IB8;8fbEbE W<M@I@C<I@E<
;8P8E8I8B PYIYKYC<E K8?D@E FPLEC8Ib 0DLKC8IbDb FEC8I8 98cC8P

8:8B;<c@C@D \
I8E; [.8WD8\ ;<;@ [*@D@8 EFID8CC@c@ YQ<I@E;< K8D @B@
PbCW8CbfKbEbQ +PJ89LI8P8><C<C@;8?8@B@8PFC;L UJK<C@B9LFC8P
;@c<I@E;<E PYQ 9@E B<Q ;8?8 XE<DC@ \ .<IKW< >YC;Y [$YBYD<K
K<DJ@C:@J@E@E :8EbEbQb JbBKbcbEb 8EC8D8B @W@E GJ@BFCF> FCD8P8
><I<BPFB \
'FD@K< 98fB8Eb J@>8IbE L:LEL bJbI;b G8IW8Pb KYBYI<I<B 9@I
D<KI< XK<P< =bIC8KKb cbI 8cbI [+ @E8KWb B8KbI8 YW f<P PYQYE;<E
J@E@IC<E@PFILD \ ;<;@ [@I ?YBYD<K@E @fC<I< 9LIELEL JFB

D8JbE;8E ?Feb8EDbPFILD dB@ GJ@BFCFA@ K8I@?@E@E <E XE<DC@


FC8PbPC8 B8Ifb B8IfbP8PB<E 9@I P898E:bEbE @f< B8IbfD8Jb K<G<D@
8KKbIbPFI UW >8C8BJ@8;bE8 E<@JK@PFIF *<.35*K.3)*\
[@CD@PFILD \
[*<P@EG<f@E;<FCD8CbLEL?@W;YfYE;YEDY\
[$8PbI WbBW8Jb 8C;bIDbPFILD .@Q@E P<I@E@Q;< FCJ8P;bD FEL
>XID<QC@BK<E><C@I;@D \
'FD@K< 98fB8Eb X=B<PC< [!M<K J<E XPC< P8G8I;bE \ ;@P<
?FDLI;8E;b [TPC< P8G8I;bE $YBYD<K@E 9L @f< B8IbfD8JbEb
>XID<QC@BK<E ><CD<E@E P<K<IC@ FC8:8cbEb J8EbPFIJLE )LIIPE@E
B<E;@E@9@IGJ@BFCF>J8P;bcbEb?<I?8C;<9@C@PFIJLE\
[!M<K 9@C@PFILD \
[1< ?<I?8C;< FELE 9YKYE P8GKbBC8IbDbQ8 B8Ifb BFIBLEW 9@I
D<I8B;LP;LcLELE;8=8IBbE;8JbE;bI \


[<E:<9L;8EFID8C \
[? PIb:8 \ 48fCb GJ@BFCF> J<J@E@ 9@I;<E9@I< f8fbC8:8B 9@I
?bQC88CW8CKKb [/8D8D )LIIPB8Gb;8 /<C8fC8ED8 \
2PEE< )LIIP >YCYDJ<P<I<B FEC8Ib J<C8DC8;b D8 BFD@K<
98fB8EbJ8;<:<J<IKW<98fbEbJ8CC8;b
)LIIP 8WbBW8 [? \ ;<;@ [@C@PFI DLJLELQ BbIB @B@ J88KK@I
8P8BK8PbD LI8;89@If<PC<IM8I TE<DC@9@IfbbPC<I \
[/<f<BBYI<;<I@D \
[$8PbI ?8PbI 9<EWFB:@;;@P@D -F9FK;YEP8Jb ><IW<BK<E
M8I\
[+CD8;bcbEbDbJ8EbPFI;LELQ\
8B8E P8I;bD:bJb ;FJKW8 9@I K8MbIC8 FDQLEL J@CBK@ [/89@@ @E

J8E;Fc8CFC8I8BBLfBLC8EbPFI e@D;@ GC8EC8IbDbQE<;@I\


[*<;<E JFI;LELQ\ 'FD@K< 98fB8Eb 9L B<C@D<C<I@ J8EB@
>bIKC8cbEbJbB8I8BBFELfKLILPFIC8IDbf>@9@K<BK<BJXPC<D@fK@
[,C8EC8IbEbQbE 9<E@DB@C<I< LPLG LPD8;bBC8IbEb 8EC8D8B
@W@E \
[+?8C;<J@Q@EGC8EC8IbEbQE<;@I\
)LIIP >YC;Y [$8PbI ?8PbI XE:< J@Q LI8;8 E< B8;8I B8C

D8Pb;YfYEYPFIJLELQ\
[dC>@C@ 9<C><C<I BFELJLE;8 @P@ 9@I 98fC8E>bW P8GbCbE:8P8
B8;8I \
[D89L9@I:<M8G;<c@CB@ dP@9@I98fC8E>bWK8EB8JKbEbQ
E<;@I\
[$@W9@I=@BI@DPFB LPbCC8I8C89@C@I \
[?'8?I<KJ@E\
'FD@K<98fB8EbB8fC8IbEbB8C;bI;b8D89@If<PJXPC<D<;@
8B8E P8I;bD:bJb KbIE8BC8IbE8 98B8I8B [L IF9FK
;YEP8JbEbEP<I@E@?<I?8C;<9@C@PFIJLELQ\;<;@
[/89@@ /?<FI -<8CF FI8P8 >@KD@f eL 8E8 B8;8I M<I;@c@
9YKYE9@C>@KLKLPFI \
[ FcIL eL8C9@EF ! F?8C;<E<;<EFI8P8>@KD@PFIJLELQ\
[+I8P8>@KD<BD@L@DBVEJbQ\


[*<;<E@E@JFI89@C@ID@P@D\
'FD@K< 98fB8Eb J89bIJbQCbcbE8 ?8B@D FCD8P8 W8Cbf8I8B
[LI8P8 98BbE \ ;<;@ [.@Q@ 9LI8P8 9@Q W8cbID8;bB .@Q;<E 9@Q<
E<C<I P8GD8DbQ ><I<BK@c@E@ JXPC<D<E@Q@ @JK<D@PFILQ D8 J@Q<
B8M>8<KD<B@W@E98?8E<8I8D8;bcbDb>XJK<ID<P<W8Cbf8:8cbD
LILDLDLQL 9@I 9<EQ<KD<PC< 8EC8K8PbD @Q< ;<M >@9@
B8ID8fbB 9@I D8B@E< M<I;@BC<I@E@ ;YfYE<C@D L ?<D<E ?@W
9@CD<;@c@D@Q GI<EJ@GC<I< >XI< P@E< G<B K8EbD8;bcbDbQ
D8CQ<D<;<E P8GbCDbf FCJLE )8B@E< F B8;8I 9YPYB B@ ;<c@C
FELE @fC<M@E@ 8EC8D8B G8IW8C8Ib 8I8JbE;8 9@C< 9@I 98cC8EKb BLI

LC8DbPFI e@D;@ 98E8 D8B@E<E@E E< FC;LcLEL 8EC8D8;8E <JI8ICb


;8B@BG8IW8C8IbE89@IbfbEC8J8C;bID8DbXE<I@ID@J@E@Q\
*<;<D<B@JK<;@c@E@Q@8ECbPFILDK89@@ D89<EQ<KD<G<B
LP>LE;<c@C\
$8PbI <E ?@W ;< XPC< ;YfYEDYPFILD ,FQ@KIFE@B IF9FKC8I
?<EYQ 9@CD<;@c@D@Q GI<EJ@GC<I< >XI< YI<K@CD@fC<I +EC8Ib P@E< ?@W
9@C>@D@Q@E FCD8;bcb 9@I 9@W@D;< W8CbfD8C8Ib @W@E P8GDbfC8I
@C;@c@D@Q K<B f<P IF9FKC8Ib B<E;@ B8;<IC<I@E@ W@QD<C<I@ @W@E
K8D8D@PC< K<:I@K <KK@BC<I@ +EC8Ib P8CEbQ 9bI8BDbfC8I e@D;@ F
><Q<><E< >@KD<B ;<E<P@E 8CKYJK FCD8JbE8 PFC 8W8I #ILG
?8C@E;< FI8P8 >@;<I XE:<;<E K8?D@E <;@CD<P<E P<E@ =8BKXIC<I
FCLfKLILI @JK<ED<P<E K<GB@C<I< PFC 8W8IJ8B ?<I f<P D8?MFCLI
!EL=8B9@I;<c@f@BC@B \
[.8WD8/?<FI-<8CFFI8P8>@KD@f9@C<\
'FD@K< 98fB8EbEbE K<G<J@ 9@I;<E9@I< 8KKb [LEL 9@CD<;@c@D@
D@ J8EbPFIJLELQ + C8E<KC@ 8C9@EF GJ@BFCFA@ BFELJLE;8 ?@W9@I 9@C

>@J@ FCD8P8E :8?@C 9@I =8E8K@B + 9L;8C8 ><Q<><E< B@D 9@C@I E< KYI
Q8I8IC8IM<I;@ 9LEL>8C8BJ@9@C@I\
@I J<JJ@QC@B FC;L 8B8E P8I;bD:bJb ;YfYE:<C@ 9@I K8MbIC8
KbIE8cbEb ;@fC<I@E< MLILPFI;L [@CD<D B@ @CD<D B@ D8
9LEL XcI<ED<B QFILE;8PbD 1< PbCC8I:8 ;8 9<BC<P<D<D \
bf8IbWbBKb
'FD@K< 98fB8Eb ;8 DYK?@f 9@I X=B<PC< I8E;8 ;XE;Y


[dJK<IJ<IF9FK;YEP8JbE8>@;<9@C@I +E8E8JbC<E><CFCLILQ\
[dQ@E M<ID<QJ<B >@;<D<Q B@ .FELWK8 9L 8I8fKbID8
>IL9LELE98fB8EbF;<c@C \
[? XPC< D@ + @W<I@ >@ID<;<E XE:< 9<E ;< J8E8 9LEL JXP

C<P<:<BK@D @Q FIC@J`<><C<C@9<I@=@CF;8EFE><D@9LI8P8@E;@ \


D*E
!M<K\
[D8E<;<E\
[dfK<9<E@D8EC8D8;bcbD;89L FcCLD \

2PEE< )LIIP E8Q@B E8Q@B [#@I<9@C@I D@P@D\ ;<;@ /?<FI


-<8CF 8E@ 9@I <E;@f<PC< D8J8JbE;8B@ B8ID8B8IbfbB BVcbK
PbcbEbE;8E98fbEbB8C;bI;b
[#CI @E .@Q< P<I 8W8PbD \ C9@EF J@E@IC@ J@E@IC@ @B@ @JB<DC<;<E
9@I@E@EYQ<I@E;<B@<fP8C8IbB8C;bI;b
)LIIP FKLI8I8B LQLE 98:8BC8IbEb YJKYJK< 8KKb [.@Q< ;<
9LI8;8>XI<MD@M<I;@C<I\8fbPC8P8QbD8J8JbEb@f8I<K<KK@
/?<FI B8=8JbEb [$8PbI \ ;<ID@f >@9@ J8CC8P8I8B >YCYDJ<

D<P< W8CbfKb .FEI8 8;<K8 ;YfYED<;<E B8cbKC8Ib KFGC8P8I8B


?<GJ@E@K<IJ@E<W<M@I;@
/?<FI K8EbEDbf P8 ;8 K8EbED8Dbf W<f@KC@ LEM8EC8Ib FC8E PYQ
GJ@BFCF>C8 FIC@J< ;XE<C@ 8PC8I FCDLfKL 1< 9L JYI<;< FEL >@K

>@;< W8CbfD8 D<IB<Q@E;<E LQ8BC8fKbIDbfC8I;b IKbB FE8 P<I


PFBKL .8;<:< B<E;@J@E@E >XI;YcY F IF9FKC8I ;YEP8JbPC8 @C>@C@
JFILC8Ib :<M8GC8D8B ;bfbE;8 FE8 9@I @f ;YfDYPFI;L XPC<
Q8D8EC8I;8 ;8 ;@c<IC<I@E@E ><Q<><E< @f@E@ 9@C<E 9@I 9@C@D
8;8DbPC8 ;<c@C ;< ><I<BJ@Q 9@I@PC< ><CD@f >@9@ ;8MI8E;bBC8IbEb
J<Q@PFI;L
!? BbIbCD8B ;8 9@I f<P J8PbCbI;b #<IW@ 9L ?<I Q8D8E 9XPC<
FCLPFI;L
/?<FI [!=<E;@D\ ;@P< DbIbC;8E;b )LIIPE@E JXQC<I@E@
;LPD8DbfKb
8B8E P8I;bD:bJb [.@Q< @f M<ID<D<C<I@E@E f8fbC8:8B 9@I f<P


FC;LcLEL JXPCYPFI;LD \ ;<;@ [*< ;< FCJ8 9LI8Pb @CB J@Q B<f=<K

K@E@Q TPC<;<c@CD@\
C9@EFB<P@=C<E;@ [!M<KD8F@f9<E;<EWbBKb8IKbB <E@
WFB8fKb 
[D8IF9FKC8I;YEP8JbE8>@KK@E@Q \
[8E8 9LELE 9@I ?8K8 FC;LcLEL JXPCYPFIC8I $<I f<P@
D8?M<KD@fFC89@C@ID@f@D \
)LIIP PYQYEY 9LILfKLI;L [<E:< FEC8Ib J@E@IC<E;@I<E J@Q@E
9@C>@ KFGC8Dbf FCD8EbQ SYEBY 9LEL B<E;@C<I@ P8G8D8;bC8I +
JYJCY LEM8EC8IbEbE J@Q@ <KB@C<D<J@E< @Q@E M<ID<P@E @I ?@W
FC;LcLELQL ;YfYED<P@E BCb 98fbE;8 9@I 8D8KXI BXI 9@I LQ

D8E;8E ;8?8 @P@;@I .@Q M< 9<E ?8BC8IbDbQb J8MLED8CbPbQ <E


;<9@I8D8KXIYD @IJ@>8I8@W@E \
[<E J@>8I8 ?@W 9@I K8E< 8C8:8cbD /<f<BBYI <;<I@D \ C

9@EF B8IfbJbE;8B@ 9L LQLE 9FPCL 8;8D8 bJbE;bcbEb ?@JJ<;@PFI;L


'8cbKC8Ib P@E< PYQC<I@ PLB8Ib ><C<:<B 9@W@D;< W<M@I;@BK<E JFEI8
J@>8I8JbEb B8?I8D8E:8 8D8 f8fBbE:8 P8BKb [4@ID@ 9<f PbC \
/?<FI9LJXQC<I@XBJYIYBC<I8I8JbE;8JXPC<D@fK@
[+;YEP8PC8@C>@C@98QbJFILC8Ib:<M8GC8IDbJbEbQ\
[$<I?8C;< 58K<E 98E8 ;8 F ><Q<><E;<E 98fB8 9@I f<P@
JFI;LBC8Ib PFB D8 9L JFILC8Ib 431&6& JFID8DbQ ><I<BD<Q
D@ $<I?8C;< 8IKbB ?<I f<P@ XcI<E;@C<I \ .@>8I8EbE ;LD8EC8IbEb
B<E;@J@E;<EDYDBYEFC;LcLB8;8ILQ8c8Y=C<D<P<W8CbfKb
)LIIP [WbBW8Jb \ ;<;@ [L @f< ;8?8 98fC8D8;bC8I 9@C< 1<
9<E F 8BbC B8IbfKbIb:b GJ@BFCFA@B W<M@I@C<I FCD8;8E 9@C>@ <;@ED<B
@JK@PFILD e@D;@ XE:< fLEL JFI8:8cbD F IF9FKC8I E8JbC @EJ8E

C8I P8;8f<PC<IdWC<I@E;<E9@I@E@E=FKF
B8Cb9bM8IDbJ@Q;<\
[e<P PFB +EC8IbE _B8CbGC8IbEb` 8CD8B @JK<D<;@D D8 FEC8I
_f<PC<I;<c@CC<I I37&3 FEC8I\
[48+EC8I @EJ8EC8I8Db9<EQ@PFIC8I\
[!M<K $<D<E ?<D<E $@W FCD8QJ8 ;bf >XIYEYfC<I@ !C@D<
?Y:I< P8GbC8IbPC8 @C>@C@ D@BIFJBFG W8CbfD8C8Ib ><WK@ $<GJ@E@ ><

K@I;@D + 9<C><C<I f@D;@ BFD@K< 98fB8EbE;8 /89@@ IF9FKC8IbE


 

@WC<I@ =8IBCb $<I f<P @P@:< 98J@KC<fK@I@CD@f D8 9LEL ?@W 8EC8DbP

FIJLELQ $<GJ@WFB@C>@EW M<@P@B@DJ<C<I \


[,<B@ ><Q<><E;<B@;@c<I:8ECbC8I;8E;8?8Db98J@KC<I\
[? ?8PbI +I8Jb WFB @CB<C 9@I ><Q<><E 1< M< \ /?<FI
XBJYID<P< 98fC8;bcb @W@E BFELfD8JbEb JYI;YI<D<;@ .@>8I8JbEb
DYDBYE FC;LcL B8;8I ;@BB8K@ W<BD<D<P< W8Cbf8I8B K89C8P8
98JKbI;b [JCbE;8 GIFKFGC8QD8 K<D<C@E< ;8P8EbPFIC8I '<E;@C<I

@E@EIF9FKFC;LBC8IbE;8EfYG?<9@C<<KD<;@BC<I@E@9@C@PFILD \
[!M<K ?<I?8C;< 489@C@DC<I@\
[@CD@PFILD LEL >XID< =bIJ8KbEb 9LC8D8;bD $<I f<P F
B8;8I ;<c@fK@ B@ $<I?8C;< ;LILDL 8E:8B 9@I LQD8E
8EC8P89@C@I;@\
[)8B@E<C<I@M8IDbP;b\
C9@EFf8fbI;b [e<P K89@@ ,<BWFBM<W<f@KC@ \
[489YPYBB<EKC<I\
[!M<K\
)LIIPE@E >XQC<I@E;< ;YfYE:<C@ 9@I @=8;< 9<C@I;@ [PIb:8 FE

C8I;8E?FfC8EbPFIJLELQ *<;<E\
/?<FI -<8CF f8fbI;b [@CD@PFILD .8;<:< ?Ff B@DJ<C<I;@
$<GJ@PC< 8EC8fbPFI;LD M< 9<E@ =8QC8 I8?8KJbQ <KD@PFIC8I;b '<J

@E 9@I f<P JXPC<D<D @DB8EJbQ <CB@ ;< E<;<E B<E;@ ;YEP8D;8


@EJ8EC8IC8 BFC8P BFC8P 8EC8f8D8D +EC8I ><IW<B @EJ8EC8I B8;8I
8BJ@;<c@CC<I;@ \
[/8MbIC8Ib;8?8Db;FJKW8P;b\
[$
$8PbI XPC< JXPC<P<D<D <E@ ?@W9@I Q8D8E 8I8C8IbE8
8CD8;bC8I <E 9@I P898E:bP;bD 8fC8E>bWKbI ;@CC<I@E@ ;< 9@CD@P

FI;LD dfK< 9XPC< f<PC<I D8 \ C9@EF 8E@ 9@I E<f<PC<


9@I;<E9@I< 98fbEb B8C;bI;b ] FEC8Ib ;8?8 @P@ 8ECbPFI;LD *<C<I
;YfYE;YBC<I@E@ ;8?8 BFC8PCbBC8 J<Q@PFI;LD <E D8 E<;<E@
9@C<D@PFILD \
[$bD f<P 9@I J@>8I8 ;8?8 @W<I D@J@E@Q $8PbI Db IKbB
P8KD8D ><I<B@PFI #<W FC;L 48IbE >FC= FPE8P8CbD Db 'YWYB
9@I J8?8 FCLfKLI;LD df< P8I8P8:8B >@9@ .@Q ;< ><C@E !BQ<IJ@Q



J@Q<P8I8I \#YCYDJ<P<I<B;bf8IbWbBKb
'<E;@ B<E;@E< 9@I K<B :YDC< DbIbC;8EbPFI;L ]L 9@I XCYD
:<Q8JbE8 9<EQ@PFI \ '<E;@ F;8JbE8 >@;<IB<E ;YfYE:<C@ 9@I
K8MbIC8bJCbBW8CD8P898fC8;b

)LIIP <IK<J@ >YE 'FD@K< 98fB8EbEbE B8IfbJbE8 ;@B@C;@c@ Q8

D8E ;8 8PEb :YDC<P@ K<BI8IC8;b <C@E< D<MB@@E@ >XJK<I<E F


BLf8cbK8BDbfKb dJB<DC<P<FKLID8;b
'FD@K<98fB8Eb9bBBbE9bBBbE ]4@E<D@\;<;@
8B8E P8I;bD:bJb [4@E< \ ;@P< 98fbEb J8CC8;b ]D8 9L B<Q
;LILD :@;;@ I8fKbID8 >IL9LELQLE 98fbE8 ><WD<D ><I<B<9@C@I
\
[*<LFC8D8Q <=<E;@DXPC<9@IXE<I@P@;@EC<D<D9@C<\
]<E@D P<KB@C<I@D M8I \ 2PEE< )LIIP D8;<EJ@ J@C@E;@I@ LQ8K

Kb L 98fG8ID8BC8 98JbC;bcb Q8D8E 8WbCbPFI;L ]/8D 9@I P<KB@D


M8I +EL ;@BB8KC< BLCC8ED8 @QE@D ;< #XI;YcYEYQ >@9@ 9L 9<C

><P@"<;<I8JPFE)<:C@J@8fB8Eb@DQ8C8;b \
]! D8 E<;<E\ 'FD@K< 98fB8Eb B<E;@E@ QFIC8P8I8B EFI

D8C 9@I 9@W@D;< JFCLB 8CD8P8 98fC8;b ]'<P=@ 9@I ;<JGFKCLB


;bfbE;8><W<IC@9@IE<;<EM8IDb\
]$<D ;< WFB @P@ 9@I E<;<E M8I <=<E;@D /V 98fbE;8E 9<I@ 9L
W8CbfD8C8I8 ;<c@f@B 8WbC8I;8E 98BbPFILQ @C@D M< /<BEFCFA@
8@I<J@ IF9FK ;YEP8JbE8 9@C@DJ<C 9@I D<I8BC8 98BDbPFI +EL 9L
><Q<><E@E =<;<I8JPFELE 98Ibf ;FCL P8f8DbEb <KB@C<P@G <KB@C<

D<P<:<c@ BFELJL @C>@C<E;@I@PFI LILG 9L IF9FKC8I ;YEP8JbEbE


8JCbE;8K<?C@B<C@FC89@C<:<c@E@;YfYE;YcYEYQYJ8EDbPFILD \
[<E 9XPC< 9@I K<?C@B< >XI<D@PFILD + ;YEP8 K<:I@K <;@CD@f
;LILD;8 1<JFE;<I<:<;<;<Q8I8IJbQ9@IP<I \
[LELE8JbC9@C<9@C@IJ@E@Q\
'FD@K< 98fB8Eb X=B<PC< [ <E<PC<I@E E@K<C@BC<I@ 9LEL >XJK<I

@PFI \ ;@P< ?8PBbI;b D ><Q<><E@ GC8EC8P8E @EJ8EC8I DYDBYE


FC;LcL B8;8I B8G8Cb 9@I J@JK<D P8I8KD8Pb @JK<D@fC<I + ;YEP8
9YKYE K@:8I<K PFCC8IbE;8E FC89@C;@c@E:< LQ8B 0Q8PbE G<B 8Q
 

PbC;bQ FC8E 9@I P<I@E;< <E<P:@C<I IF9FKC8IbE B@DJ< FEC8I8


B8IbfD8;8E><C@fD<C<I@E@@JK<D@fC<I \
)LIIP >YC;Y [L 98BbD;8E J@Q@EC< 8PEb =@B@I;< ;<c@C@D @E

C<P@E J@Q@E ;<I;@E@Q E<;@I 9@C@PFI DLJLELQ .8;<:< M8IJ8PbD

C8IC8 @C>@C<E<E 9@I @EJ8E FCD8EbQ .@Q 9@I f<P< 98BbPFI M< FEL FC

D8Jb ><I<BK@c@ >@9@ >XIYPFIJLELQ LE8 B8IfbCbB 9<E GI8K@B 9@I @E

J8EFC;LcLD@W@E?<If<P@FC;LBC8Ib>@9@>XIYPFILD $@W9@I;<E<P
B<E;@ B<E;@E< JFEJLQ8 B8;8I ;<M8D <;<D<Q )L?8BB8B
P8BbE;8 9@I P<I;< <E 8f8cb 9@I >XQC<D:@ FCLI + ;<E<P@ @QC<I M<
><I<BK@c@Q8D8E;898Qb )*H.K.01.01*6 P8G8I \
'FD@K<98fB8Eb@=8;<J@Q9@IPYQC<[!\;<;@
[L ;<E<P@E >XQC<D:@C<I@ P8E@ FIC@JC@ GJ@BFCF>C8I @I@E:@
'FE=<;<I8JPFE JFE8 <I<IB<E FIK8;8E B8CBKbC8I 1< ;<E<P FE 9<f
9@E PbC B<E;@ B<E;@E< JYIYG >@KK@ 'YWYB ?8K8C8I 9@IC<f@G 9YPYB
P8ECbfC8I8 ;XEYfKY 4898E:b =8BKXIC<I ;< 98fB8 ?8K8C8I8 E<;<E
FC;LC8I L 9@I ><FD<KI@B ;@Q@ FCLfKLI;L M< ;<E<P@ B@DJ<
;LI;LID8;b \
[.8CKM8IJ8PbD \
[<CB@ D8 J@Q@ J8;<:< IF9FKC8IbE ;YEP8Jb @C>@C<E;@I@PFI
<EJ<9YKYE=<;<I8JPFEL;YfYED<BQFILE;8PbD \
[-F9FK ;YEP8Jb =<;<I8JPFE @W@E ?8E>@ 98BbD;8E K<?C@B<C@
FC89@C@IIBKLILJ8;bE8*<;<D<B@JK<;@c@E@Q@8EC8P8DbPFILD \
)LIIP @W@E@ W<BK@ [8J@K BFELf8:8cbD D8 JXQC<I@D D<C<

;I8D8 B8W8IJ8 9<E@ JLWC8D8PbE "<;<I8JPFE;8 PYQ PbCC8I;8E


9<I@?@W@WJ8M8fWbBD8;b LIF9FKC8IC8B8IfbC8fbIJ8BE<FCLI\
[48E@J@Q9@IK<B><Q<><E;<ED@BFIBLPFIJLELQ\
[+C89@C@I +EC8IbE 9@C@D 8C8EbE;8 E< B8;8I @C<IC<;@BC<I@E@
9@CD@PFILQ -F9FKC8I98Q8EWFBKL?8=f<PC<IP8G89@C@IC<I \
[+EC8I 9@C@D;< E< B8;8I @C<IC<P<9@C@IC<I B@ + IF9FKC8I D8;<E
M< <C<BKI@BK<E FCLf8E JYG<I @EJ8EC8I ;<c@CC<I ,IFKFGC8QD8;8E
FCLf8E Q8Pb= P8I8KbBC8I #<IW<B @EJ8EC8IbE Q8M8CCb K8BC@KC<I@
,FQ@KIFE@B 9<P@EC<I@ @EJ8EC8IbE GJ@BFCFA@B B8ELEC8IbEbE 98J@KC<fK@I

@CD@f f<BC@E< >XI< 8P8IC8EDbf !c<I J@Q@ BFIBLK8E _IF9FK


 

JXQ:YcYPJ< \
[$8PbI ;<c@C D8 9<E /?<FI -<8CF`PC8BFELfKLD @C;@c@E@Q
>@9@IF9FKC8IbJ8;<:<F>XIDYf \
'FD@K< 98fB8Eb @W@E @W@E J<JJ@Q:< M< LQLE LQLE BY=I<KK@
,J@BFCFA@ 9@CD<P<E ><I@ Q<BVCb 9@I@E@E 8P8B8CKbE;8 ;FC8fD8JbE8
@Q@E M<ID@fC<I;@ + ;8 ><M<Q<C@B <;@G @fC<I@ 9FQDLfKL .FEI8
[-<8CF`ELE ?@BVP<J@E@ 98fbE;8E JFELE8 B8;8I ;@EC<;@B \ ;@P<
8WbBC8;b [+EL K8D8D@PC< LJK8CbBC8 ;<c<IC<E;@I;@B !D@E FCLE F
IF9FKC8IbE ?@W9@I K<?C@B<C@ P8EC8Ib PFB <E<P K8D 8EC8DbPC8 8B8

;<D@B !c<I ><E@f 9@I Q8D8Eb B8GJ8D8J8P;b FELEC8 @B@ >YE 9@C<
@C>@C<ED<Q;@D EC8;bcbDbQ B8;8IbPC8 FIC@J`C@C<I K<D<C 8BJ@PFD

C8I;8E 9@I P8 ;8 @B@J@E@ ;<c@fK@I<I<B GFQ@KIFE@B 9@I 9<P@E FCLfKLI

D8B @JK<D@fC<I PIbEKbC8Ib ?<EYQ J8GK8D8;bB D8 XE<DJ@Q


f<PC<I FCD8CbC8I SYEBY 9L 8C8E;8 P8GbC8E @CB ;<E<P 9L +
>YEYE <=J8E<M@ GJ@BFCF>C8Ib ;8 8;bD 8;bD @C<IC<D<B QFILE;8P

;bC8I 8E8 @E8EbE + IF9FKC8I E< 9@I<I JYG<ID<E E< ;< 9@I<I
?8PM8E .@Q@ 9@IGJ@BFCF>FC8I8BK<D@E<;@PFILD \
[SFB YQ>YEYD <E ;< 9@I GJ@BFCFcLD 'FIB8IbD 9L 98BbD

;8E B@K8GC8I8 =8QC8 98cCb ;<c@C@D D8 JXQYEY <KK@c@E@Q L=8B K<

=<B ;<c@f@BC@BC<I .8M8fD8 @JK<c@E@ <C< 8C8CbD L 9@C@DJ<C 9@I K<I

@D ;<c@C M< Q8K<E 9XPC< f<PC<I@ <Q9<IC<P<:<B B8;8I J89IbD PFB


*< ;<D<B @JK<;@c@D@ 9@C@PFIJLELQ @Q @EJ8EC8I ;8 <JB@;<E
J8M8fWbP;bB D8 f@D;@ bIBbDbQbE 9L XQ<CC@c@E@ P8M8f P8M8f JFP

LKC8D8P8 W8CbfbPFIC8I <E><C@ 9@I J@P8J@ M< <BFEFD@B J@JK<D;<


J8M8fbC8I8B <E<IA@ B8P9<;@CD<J@E< P<I PFBKLI IKbB 9L @EJ8E
bIBbEbE P8f8D8Jb @W@E ><I<BC@ FC8E 9@I E@K<C@B ;<c@C E:8B IF9FK

C8IbE J8M8fWb FC;LBC8IbEb ;YfYE<C@D <CB@ B@DJ<E@E FEC8Ib >X

QC<D<;@c@ 9@EC<I:< PbCCbB JYI<;< 9@I P8ECbfCbB FC;L M< K<IJ PXE<
J8GKbC8I 1< YI<K@:@C<I@E ;YfYE;YBC<I@E;<E WFB ;8?8 B8M>8:b
FC;LC8I + Q8D8E F IF9FKC8IC8 9@IC@BK< FCD8B @EJ8Eb WFB I8?8KJbQ
<;<I \
? 9<CB@ >8C8BJ@;<B@ 9YKYE >YE<fC<I ;< 8PEb 8E;8 *FM8 ?8

C@E@ 8CbI $8P;@ 9LEL ;YfYEYG ,*6A*08*3 <E;@f<C<ED<P<




98fC8P8CbD \
)LIIP P8fCb GJ@BFCFcLE 9L ?@W ;< @E:< FCD8P8E 8C8PbE8 8C;bI

D8;b @I f<P ;8?8 M8I /?<FI -<8CF F IF9FKC8I;8E ?FfC8EDbf


$8KK8 FEC8Ib ><IW<B @EJ8EC8I;8E ;8?8 WFB J<M@PFI -<8CF F
><Q<><E< ;8?8 WFB LP;LcLEL ;YfYEDYf !? 9@Q ;< FELE
B<E;@;YEP8JbPC8LPLDJ8cC8P8D8;bcbEb9@C@PFILQ \
'FD@K<98fB8Eb [.@Q:<9LELE8EC8DbE<;@I\;@P<JFI;L
[LEL >XI<D@PFI DLJLELQ\ 2PEE< )LIIP B8fC8IbEb
B8C;bI;b [/?<FI -<8CF F IF9FKC8Ib J<M@PFI SYEBY B<E;@J@ ;< FE

C8I8 '*3=.<46 /?<FI -<8CFELE K8D 9@I GJ@f@B 8E8C@Q@ P8GbCbIJ8


9@IB8W K<D<C 8BJ@PFD;8 ;<c@f@BC@B FC;LcL FIK8P8 WbB8I -F9FK

C8I;8B@ ;<c@f@BC@BC<I >@9@ LE;8E B<J@EC@BC< <D@E@D 1< /?<FI


-<8CF 9@I EFBK8Pb B8EbKC8D8B @W@E K8D P@ID@ 9<f PbC W8CbfDbf
@C@D ;YEP8Jb 9LEL 9@CJ<P;@ >YCD<BK<E B8KbCbI;b /?<FI -<8CF 9@I
=8E8K@B dP@ ;YIYJK ?YD8E@JK ;8P8EbCD8P8:8B 9@I 8Q@D@ M< @E8;b
M8I *6-&1)*464'481&6)&'B<1*E
[.XQC<I@E@Q WFB D8EKbBJbQ @I 8GK8C >@9@ K8IKbfbPFIJLELQ @I
><I@Q<BVCb>@9@ \
['<J@E D8K<D8K@BJ<C B8EbKC8I8 @?K@P8:bD PFB BC8 P8BbE 9@I
BLfBL P<K<IC@ <E =<;<I8JPFEL BFILD8B QFILE;8PbD @EC<P@E
8JCbE;8 9L G<BVCV 2&38G01G FIC@J`C@ GJ@BFCF>C8I YJKYE 9@I<I LQ

D8E ;<c@CC<I;@ .@Q@E ;< ;<;@c@E@Q >@9@ 8;bD 8;bD @C<IC<D<B


QFILE;8P;bC8I E;IF@;C<I@ FEC8Ib IF9FK ;@P< K8EbDC8D8BK8E
M8Q><W<C@D J8;<:< @EJ8EC8IbE BFGP8C8IbP;bC8I <CB@ @P@ BFGP

8C8I E:8B @EJ8EC8IbE WFB B8ID8fbB 9@I K<GB@ J@JK<DC<I@ M8I


KFGCLDJ8C M@:;8E 8?C8B J@JK<DC<I@ BLID8 @JK<c@ M< 8;@C FCD8B
:XD<IKC@B D<IKC@B >@9@ ;8?8 JbI8;8E f<PC<I 1< 9LEC8Ib BFGP8 <K

D<B ;< @DBVEJbQ + 8E;IF@;C<I;< 9L E@K<C@BC<I@E FC;LcLEL J8E

DbPFILD D8 ?<I?8C;< 8Q@DC@C@C<I 1< 9L ;8 @E8K M< ;XcYfB<E

C@B 8EC8DbE8 ><C@I /89@@ /?<FI -<8CF ?8BBbE;8B@ ;YfYE:<C<I@D

;< P8EbCDbPFIJ8D !? 9L 8E;IF@;C<I 9@C@D 8C8EbE;8 9@I8Q @C<I

C<D@fC<IJ< FEC8IbE >8C8BJ@;< 98fb 9Ff ;FC8fD8C8IbEb @JK<D<D


*Y=LJLDLQ FEC8IbEB@E@E 9@E P8 ;8 D@CPFE B8Kb FCJ8 9@C< +EC8IbE


I8?8KW8;FC8fD8C8IbE8@Q@EM<ID<P<:<c@D\
'FD@K< 98fB8EbEbE PYQ ?8KC8Ib ><I@CD@fK@ [eL 8I8 E< P8GD8B
E@P<K@E;<J@E@Q\
[LE8 ?<EYQ B8I8I M<ID<;@D D8 >8C@98 BYWYB 9@I >ILGC8
F><Q<><E<@ED<P@;<E<P<:<c@D \
[@I ;8B@B8\ 48fCb GJ@BFCF> P<I@E;<E =bIC8P8I8B D8J8EbE
BXf<J@E;<E ;FC8fKb 8B8E P8I;bD:bJbEb ;@IJ<c@E;<E KLKKL [*<
P8GKbcbEbQb 9@C;@c@E@Q;<E <D@E D@J@E@Q L ;<M ;<E<P@E
JFELWC8IbEb E< J@Q K8?D@E <;<9@C@IJ@E@Q E< ;< 9<E *<P@ FIK8;8E
B8C;bI;bcbEbQb;89@C<D<QJ@E@Q\
[@C@PFILD 48GD8B @JK<;@c@D f<P@E ?FfLD8 >@KK@c@E@ D@
J8EbPFIJLELQ <E ;< 9@I GJ@BFCFcLD *<C<I FC;LcLEL 8E

C8D8Pb @JK<P<:<B B8;8I 9L BFELP8 98cCbPbD D8 9<E@ 9LI8P8


=<;<I8JPFEL BFILD8D @W@E >XE;<I;@C<I <E ;< <C@D;<E
><C;@c@E:< 9LEL P8GD8P8 W8Cbf8:8cbD LELE G@J 9@I @f
FC;LcLEL9@C@PFILD D898fB8E<P8G89@C@I@D\
[L FC8Pb 9YKYE 8PIbEKbC8IbPC8 ;YfYEDYf FC8D8QJbEbQ <CB@
9L ;<E<P J8P<J@E;< GJ@BFCFA@E@E K<D<C =@B@IC<I@E@ B8MI8P89@C<:<c

@Q L @B@ >8C8BJ@E@E 9@I9@IC<I@PC< B8PE8fKbIbCD8Jb 8EC8DbE8 ><C<

:<B !C;< <;<:<c@D@Q ><E@f 9@C>@ M< >YW B8IfbJbE;8 IF9FKC8IbE


M<I<9@C<:<BC<I@ Q8I8I JFC;8 Jb=bI B8C8:8B +EC8I D8;<E M< <C<BKI@B
B8IbfbDbJYG<ID<EC<IFCJ8C8I9@C< \
8B8E P8I;bD:bJb FDQLEL J@CBK@ [e@D;@ ;< J@Q 8WbB FCD8P8E
@?K@D8CC<I@EYQ<I@E;<;LILPFIJLELQ \
[ @EC<P@E .@Q@EC< 9@I 8EC8fD8 P8G8CbD +EC8I8 8D98I>F LP

>LC8PbE #<D@C<I@E@QC< K<:I@K <;@E *X9<KW@C<I ;@B@E D8 F IF9FK

C8I8 @C@fD<P@E @Q< ;8?8 =8QC8 Q8D8E M<I@E @I =bIJ8K K8EbPbE
LELP8GD8CbJbEbQ\
[LEL 9<E ;< ;YfYE;YD D8 D<:C@JK<E @Q@E 8CD8D
><I<B@PFI L;8WFBG8?8CbP8><C@I \
'FD@K< 98fB8Eb WbC>bE:8 9@I J89bIJbQCbBC8 B<E;@E@ BFCKLcLE8
8KKb [.@Q E< KYI 9@I D8JI8=K8E JXQ <;@PFIJLELQ 8f8IbCb FCLIJ8B
<C@D@Q<E<C<I><W<:<c@E@9@CD@PFIDLJLELQ\


)LIIP ;YfYE;Y M< JFEI8 ;8 ?8=@=W< >YCYDJ<;@ [48 FEC8I


PbC;;8I8I8JbPFC:LCLc898fC8IC8IJ8\
48fCb GJ@BFCF> W89L:8B [+ Q8D8E @K@I8QbDb ><I@ 8CbIbD \
;<;@
8B8EP8I;bD:bJb8P8c8B8CBKb [)<:C@J<98fMLI8:8cbD

I8E; #FI8 BFD@K< 98fB8EbEbE B8D9LIC8fDbf JbIKbE8


98B8IB<E PYQYE;<B@ 9YKYE @=8;<P@ J@CD<P< W8CbfbPFI;L 48fCb
8;8DbE >IL9LE YP<C<I@E< P8GKbcb :<J8I<K 8fbC8Pb:b BFELfD8C8I
8IKbBG<B<KB@C@;<c@C;@ I8E;JXQC<I1J89bIJbQ:8;@EC@PFI;L
I8E; [e@D;@E<P8G8:8cbQ\;<;@
'FD@K< 98fB8EbEbE FDLQC8Ib K@KI<;@ 8D8 8;8D ;XED<;@
[/?<FI -<8CF`PL W8cbIKKbD + BYWYB 9L;8C8 ><W<E ?8=K8 ;FcL
BbK8JbE8>@KK@ \
[*<;<E\
48fCb GJ@BFCF> JXQY B<J@C;@c@ @W@E X=B<C<ED@fK@ [+ ?@CB8K
>8I@9<J@E@E P8GKbcb ?<I?8E>@ 9@I f<P@ E8JbC 8EC8P89@C@I@D )LIIP
?8BCb LEL8EC8P8DbPFIDLJLE+GJ@f@B98BbD;8E8EFID8C9@I
P8I8KbB JCbE;8 98fbE8 9@I EX9<KW@ ;@BD<D@Q ><I<B@I;@ !c<I FE8
@B@ ;<=8 98BD8Pb 8BbC <KJ<P;@D 9LEL P8G8I;bD D8 8IKbB ><I@
;XEYPFI 1< 9LI8;8 ;8 B8C8:8B \ .<J@ 9@I DbIbCKb ?8C@E@ 8C;b [dB@
J88KXE:<><CD@fFCD8CbP;b
I8E;8WbB8WbB [dfWbBD8Q8>@I;@ <=<E;@D ;<;@
[TPC<D@;YfYEYPFIJLE\
[e<P D<:C@J IF9FK ;YEP8JbEbE <KI8=bE;8 JFEJLQ8 B8;8I
;<MI@P<C<I@E ;FC8fD8JbE8 I8Qb FCLI DL ?@W L G8?8CbP8 ><C@I 1<
JbI8;8E >8C8BJ@ M8K8E;8fC8Ib ;8 9L LcLI;8 M<I>@ X;<ED<J@E<
B8Ifb ><C@IC<I ,J@BFCFA@B ;<EBC<DC<I PFQC8fbI M< 8BCb J<C@D 8B

J@PFDC8IbE8 ;XEYfYIC<I $8KK8 9<E )LIIPE@E D<:C@J< 98fMLI

D8PbE<;<EB89LC<KK@c@E@;<8EC8P8DbPFILD \
[#<IW<BK<E 8EC8DbPFI DLJLE\\ 'FD@K< 98fB8Eb JFELE;8
><EW 8;8D8 ;XE;Y [+ 9L;8C8 9@I GJ@BFCF> FC;LcLEL J8EbPFI
JCbE;8 IF9FK ;YEP8JbEb FIK8;8E B8C;bID8B @JK<D<;@c@E@


;YfYE<I<B B<E;@ B<E;@E@ XMYPFI E:8B 9LEL =<;<I8JPFELE @P

@C@c@ @W@E P8GD8B QFILE;8 FC;LcLEL JXPC<;@ M< ?<I?8E>@ 9@I


LQC8fD8 PFCLE8 P8E8fD8P8 ?8QbI )<:C@J 9L @f@E JFEJLQ8 B8;8I
JYIYG >@KD<J@E< K89@@ B@ I8Qb FCD8P8:8B LEL 98E8 JXPC<D<E<
><I<B PFB \ 48fCb GJ@BFCF> J89bIC8 J8B@E J8B@E BFELfLPFI;L
f@D;@ [D8 9<E FE PbCCbB 9@I JYI< @JK<P<:<c@D 48 ;8 @B@ PbC M<P8
8CKb 8P IKbB E< B8;8IbEb BFG8I89@C@IJ<D 58D8E 8CD8Pb
98f8I8:8cbD 1< 9@Q ;< 9L JYI<;< F ;YEP8 BFELJLE;8 P<E@
f<PC<I XcI<E<:<c@Q LILDLDLQL J8cC8DC8fKbI8:8B M< JYI<
JFE8 <I;@c@ Q8D8E 8EC8fD8Pb P<E@C<D<P@ 98f8I8:8cbQ
S8CbfD8C8IbDbQ8 ;<M8D <;<9@BK:<c@Q \ 'bJ8 9@I J<JJ@QC@B FC;L
.FEI8 BFD@K< 98fB8Eb 8cbI 8cbI <BC<;@ [1< /?<FI -<8CF ;8 9L
BFEL;8WFBXE<DC@9@IIFCFPE8P8:8B \
I8E;#FIC8FE898B8I8BJ<JJ@Q:<9<BC<;@
'FD@K< 98fB8Eb [)LIIP 9L 98BbD;8E 9@Q@D >XI<D<;@c@D@Q
9@I f<P@ =8IB<KK@ \ ;<;@ -<8CF GJ@BFCFA@B 98BbD;8E J8B8K 9@I @E

J8E 1< 9YKYE FC8PbE 8E8?K8Ib ;8 9L +EL @E:<C<IJ<B F ><Q<

><E;<B@ 9@I IF9FKLE E8JbC 9@I f<P FC;LcL BFELJLE;8 9@I =@B@I <;

@E<9@C<:<c@Q /89@@ B898 K8JC8B PIb:8 W8IGbKbCDbf FC8:8B SYEBY


-<8CF ELE 8JbC W<MI<J@ ;FJK FCD8P8E ;YfD8E:8 9@I W<MI< D8
9LEL ;8 ?<J898 B8K8I 8;8DbE B@f@C@c@E@ T= 9L BFEL;8E 9bB

KbD8IKbB\
df8I<K BLKLJLELE bfbcb P8E;b 48fCb GJ@BFCF> @W@E@ W<B<I<B
[!? ><C;@ @fK< ,<BVCV #FIC8 +KLI 98B8CbD .@E@I@D@ 9FQLPFI

JLE -<8CFPL9@I>XI<C@D \;<;@


C9@EF F;8P8 KFG >@9@ ;8C;b .FEI8 JFCLB JFCLc8 FIK8;8
;LI;L 58Pb=>XQC<I@PC<9@IBFD@K<98fB8EbE898BKb 9@II8E;<
[YKYE9LEC8IE8JbCFC;L\
'FD@K<98fB8EbJFcLBJFcLB [YKYEE<C<I\;@P<JFI;L
+KLI .8E898Qbf<PC<IJFID8B@JK@PFILD \
[$8PbITE:<J@Q98E8:<M8GM<I@E\
D896E
-<8CF 9@I @JB<DC<P< WXBKY #XQC<I@ ;FCDLfKL [-F9FKC8IbE


;YEP8JbEbD8?M<;<:<BC<I \
[+ELE@W@E<E;@f<C<ED< \
[D8 IF9FKC8I PbC;bQC8I8I8Jb PFC:LCLB P8GD8Pb 98f8IbIC8IJ8
9XPC< FC8:8cbEb JXPC<D@fK@E@Q XPC< ;<c@C D@ L;8C8 EC8DbPFI
DLJLELQ\C9@EF9FcLCLI:8JbE8JLJKL
'FD@K< 98fB8Eb <E;@f<PC< B8fC8IbEb W8KKb [.8B@EC<f@I M<
;FcIL ;YIYJKBFELfLIDLJLE\
-<8CF ;@fC<I@E@ JbB8I8B BFELf89@CD<B @W@E B<E;@E@ ] $ bb@b
[D8FEC8IWFBP8BbE;8LQ8P;8PFC:LCLBP8G89@C<:<BC<I \
dB@GJ@BFCF>L=8BK<=<B8;8D8;FcIL8KbC;bC8I [*<\
[e<P *< J8EbPFIJLELQ\ C9@EF W8I<J@QC@c@E E<;<E FC;LcL
9@I X=B<PC< P<I@E;<E =bIC8;b [.@Q 9<E@D 9@I WXC< P8 ;8 9@I FBP

8ELJLE FIK8JbE8 @E;@c@D@ M< BFJBF:8 9@I ;YEP8Pb B<E;@ 98fbD8


@E:<C<;@c@D@ D@ J8EbPFI;LELQ 48f8DbE 9@I ?@BVP< B@K89b
FC;LcLEL DL ;YfYEYPFIJLELQ <E@ ><Q<><E< @E<I @ED<Q
P8B8C8;bC8I M< F 9YPYB B<EK< >XKYI;YC<I 8?8 ;FcILJL 9<E FI

8EbE 9YPYB 9@I B<EK FC;LcLEL J8EbPFILD +I8fb 9@Q@D B<EKC<I@D

@Q;<EWFB=8IBCbP;b 1< D89LEC8IbJ@Q<8EC8K8:8B;<c@C@D \


'FD@K< 98fB8Eb ['<EK@ 9bI8B f@D;@\ ;@P< 98cbI;b [.<E@
P8B8C8;bC8I .FEI8EC8K \]
! @E:<C<;@C<I 0Q8P ><D@D@ ;< .FEI8 9@I ><:< ;LILDL
=<;<I8JPFE8 ?89<I M<ID<B @W@E FI8;8E 8PIbC;bD #@KK@c@D@ 9@CD@P

FIC8I;b +I8;8E 8PIbCD8Db @JK<D@PFIC8I;b Q8K<E C9@EFELE J<J@


K@KI<D<P< 98fC8;b [JCbE;8 9<E ;< FI8;8 B8CD8B @JK<I;@D D8
=<;<I8JPFELE;LILDLXcI<ED<J@><I<B@PFI; \
[+EC8I8LQ8P><D@E?8BBbE;89@If<PJXPC<;@ED@\
[*< JXPC<P<9@C@I;@D B@ <E D8B@E<C<I;<E 8EC8D8D 0Q8P
><D@C<I@E@E ?8E>@ K<FI@P< >XI< P8GbC;bcbEb 9@C< 9@CD@PFILD D8
FEC8I8 BFEKIFCC8IbE E8JbC BLCC8EbC;bcbEb >XJK<I;@D )FKFI@8I8 98B

D8C8IbE8;8@Q@EM<I;@D $<GJ@9LB8;8I \
I8E; #8IC8 ;8?8 WFB B<E;@ B<E;@J@E< BFELfDLf >@9@ [TP

C<PJ< ?@W9@I Q8D8E LQ8P8 8WbC8D8QC8I \ ;@P< DbIbC;8E;b [L


B8;8IbP<K<IC@;<c@C \


C9@EFELE J<J@ 9@I;<E9@I< PYBJ<C;@ M< 9@I Q8=<I WbcCbcbE8


;XEYfKY [? <M<K LQ8P8 8WbC8:8BC8I <E FEC8Ib K8EbPFILD
$<GJ@ ;< D8B@E< L LQ8P ><D@J@ GIF9C<D@ YQ<I@E;< ;< W8Cbf8

:8BC8I LID8;8E ;@EC<ED<;<E $@W9@I Q8D8E M8Q><WD<P<:<B


M< JFELE;8 @JK<;@BC<I@E@ <C;< <;<:<BC<I <E;<E P<K<I@ B8;8I
9@C>@8C;bC8I !M<K 9L9@C>@E@EP<K<IC@FC;LcLE;8E<D@E@D \
'FD@K< 98fB8Eb /?<FI8 LQLE LQLE 98BKb .FEI8 ;8 9@KB@E:<
;XE;Y [LEL9@Q<E<;<E;8?8XE:<JXPC<D<;@E\
[SYEBY J@Q 9<E@D ;YEP8Db <C@D;<E 8C;bEbQ LI8Pb 9<E
B<f=<KK@D /<B 98fbD8 48G8P8CEbQ <E :8EC8 98fC8 W8CbfKbBK8E
JFEI8 J@Q@ W8cbI;bD J@Q ;< 9<E@ B8Gb ;bf8Ib <KK@E@Q M< J8;<:<
<C<fK@I;@E@Q -F9FKC8I ;YEP8JbE8 @ED@fK@D M< 9L @f< 9LIELDL
JFBKLcLD @W@E ?<I f<P@ D8?M<KD@f FC89@C@I;@D +C8EC8Ib J@Q<
E<;<E JXPC<;@D )8;<D 9<E@ K<BD<C<P@G ;LI8:8B B8;8I 8BbCCbP

;bEbQ FQ8D8E><IW<BC<I@B<E;@E@Q;<XcI<E<9@C@I;@E@Q \
'FD@K< 98fB8Eb 8:b 8:b LPLDJLQ ;@P< ;YfYE;Y +E;8
8f8cbCbB BFDGC<BJ@ M8I $<IB<J@E B<E;@J@E< <Q@P<K <KK@c@E< @E

8EbPFI $<GJ@9@I9@I@E< LPLPFI IKbB >XQC<I@D@Q@ L=LBK8E 8PbIbG


9LIELDLQLE ;@9@E;<B@ f<P< 98BKbcbDbQ Q8D8E ><IW<c@ >XI<

9@C@PFILQ IKbB ?<I f<P D8?MFC;L .FEI8 [,<BVCV -<8CF \ ;<;@


[$<G@D@Q;<B8P9<;@PFILQ #@K8IKbB \
I8E; #FIC8 J@E@IC@ J@E@IC@ [#<IW<BK<E ?<I f<P JFE8 Db
<I;@\;@P<JFI;L [#<IW<BK<E\
48fCb GJ@BFCF> :<M8G M<I;@ [#<IW<BK<E JFE8 <I;@ + 9YPYB
;<E<P $<I f<P 9@KK@ -<8CFELE Q@P8I<K@E@E E<;<E FC;LcL
W8IGbBCbBC8I 9<CB@ ;< WFB XE<DC@P;@ <CB@ ;< 9LI8;8 @E:<C<;@c@D

@Q 9<C><C<I 8IKbB XCY 9@I ;@CC< P8QbCDbf J8PbCbPFI;L 1< Q8K<E


)LIIP ?8BCb 4bC;bQC8I8I8Jb PFC:LCLB P8G89@C@IC<IJ< 9@Q@D @W@E ;<
K<?C@B<C@FCLIC8Ig\
-<8CF 98cbI;b [D8 FEC8Ib FIK8;8E B8C;bI8D8QJbEbQ
'8C;bID8D8CbJbEbQ +EC8IB@DJ<P<Q8I8IM<ID<;@C<IB@\
+E8 :<M8G M<I<E FCD8;b C9@EF 98cbIbG W8cbID8JbEb
JYI;YI;Y [+I8P8 ;XE<:<c@D +EC8Ib LP8I8:8cbD + Q8D8E
 

?8QbICbBCbFC8:8BC8I+EC8IbLP8I8:8cbD\
#<I@ ><I@ B8GbP8 ;FcIL >@;@PFI;L !KI8=b BbQ8IDbf >XQC<I@
J8EB@PLM8C8IbE;8ELcI8Dbf @E:<K<CC@8BJ8WC8Ib;@D;@BFCDLfKL
C9@EF ;bf8Ib =bIC8IB<E BFD@K< 98fB8Eb FEL ;LI;LID8B @W@E
?@W9@I f<P P8GD8;b [bI8B >@KJ@E + 9L @f< 9YKYE XDIYEY M<I;@
IKbB9LBFELPC8@C>@C<ED<P<:<c@D \

/?<FI -<8CF IF9FKC8IbE ;YEP8JbE8 ;FcIL >@KD<BK<P;@ +


DYK?@f?bQPYQYE;<EQFICLBC8JFCLB8CbPFI;L
dC<I@;< 9@I P<I;< 9@I KFQ K8E<:@c@ >@9@ ;LI8E 9@I ;YEP8 M8I;b
$@W9@I P<IC< @C@fB@J@ FCD8P8E 9@I ><Q<><E 48G8P @EJ8EC8I 8IKbB
JFE8 <ID@f FC8E 9@I ;<E<P@E BLI8CC8IbE8 LP8I8B W898CbPFIC8I;b
+EC8I @W@E 9@I XCYD :<Q8JbE;8E =8IBJbQ FC8E P<E@ 9@I 8D8:8
;FcIL
@C<IC<D<P<W8CbfbPFIC8I;b 0Q8PPFC:LCLcLP8GD88D8:bE8;FcIL
/?<FI -<8CF F ;YEP8P8 ;FcIL >@;@PFI;L +EL P8B8C8PbG @E

:<C<;@BC<I@ F 9YPYB B<EK< C9@EF FI8Pb WFB @P@ ?8KbICbPFI;L


'<EK@E 8;bEb ;8 9@C@PFI;L + ;@C;< XcI<E;@c@ @CB B<C@D<C<I FEC8I;b
D#$ E
465-465-

#I8?8D B@D 9@C@I B8WbE:b ;<=8 9@I BbQb E< B8;8I WFB J<

M<IJ<E J<M ;@P< ;YfYE;Y +ELE @W@E ?<I f<P@ P8G89@C<:<c@E<


8C<MC<I@E P8 ;8 ;<M ;8C>8C8IbE 8I8JbE;8E D<DELECLBC8 ><W<

:<c@E< P<D@E <KD<E@E ><IW<BK<E BXKY P8EC8Ib M8I SYEBY F BbQ


98Q8EJ<E@E9L8GK8C:8JXQC<I@E@FC;LcL>@9@B89LC<;<I
48E@ E@f8ECbJb #I8?8D FIEL KLQ8c8 ;YfYIDYf P8B8C8Dbf
M< @?K@P8I 9@I BbQ FC8E K<PQ<J@E@E !;<9@P8K <IE<c@E< 9@I
BFELfD8 P8GD8Jb @W@E >XKYIDYfKY #YCD<P@E dEJ8E GF;PLD8
WbBKbcb Q8D8E 9L ;LILDL ?@W ;< BFD@B 9LCD8Q $<C< 98BD8B
QFILE;8B8C;bcb98QbW<?I<C<I@;YfYE<:<BFCLIJ8EbQ
*<PJ< PIbEKbC8Ib W89L:8B ><W<C@D *@f8ECbJb #I8?8D
FIEL 9@I GF;PLD8 WbB8I;b M< ;@D;@B ;LID8P8 QFIC8;b 48Q8I
;<?f<K ;FCL 9@I J<JC< 41.7.<* 42&3G3 2*6.0&3
)*'.<&8G3)&0. 4<I@PC< @C>@C@ P8QbPb FBL;L LEL F JFEJLQ8
B8;8I J<M<:<c@ &LE<LELE P8QDbf FCD8Jb ;LILDL ;<c@fK@ID@P

FI;L .8WD8J8G8E 9@I f<P;@ 9L &LE< FEL BFE=<I8EJ M<ID<P<


QFIC8D8B@W@EIYfM<KFC8I8B9LP8QbPb?8QbIC8D8PbXE<ID@fK@ 
1< #I8?8DbE B8C9@ B8E 8cC8IB<E :8;bC8I YQ<I@E< WLCC8E;bC8I
SYEBY JFIL :<M8G JbI8Jb ><CD@fK@ FJKW8 BFELfLC8:8B B8;bEC8I
;8P8GD8:bBCbP8GD8:bBCb>YC<:<BC<I;@
[? 8P FIE J@Q< ><C<E @C?8D8 >XI< D@ W8CbfbPFIJLELQ
48E@ D8J8EbQ8 FKLILPFIJLELQ M< F Q8D8E 8BCbEbQ8 9@I =@B@I D@
><C@PFI @I;<E9@I< 1< 9LEL P8Q89@CD<B @W@E 9YKYE ><:< FKLI

LPFI M< LPLP8B8CD8D8B @W@E 8IB8 8IB8P8 J8;< B8?M< D@


@W@PFIJLELQ\
[? <M<K K89@@ \ JCbE;8 #I8?8D >YE 8fbIb XcC<;<E JFEI8
@B@;<E;XI;<B8;8IW8CbfbPFIM<JYK@W@PFI;L
[? 8P FD 9YKYE F >8I@G :@E8P<KC<I@ P8Q89@CD<B @W@E ?<I

?8C;< WFB 8I8fKbID8 P8GbPFIJLELQ @I ?@BVP<P@ P8QD8;8E XE:<


P8GKbcbEbQ8I8fKbID8C8IE<B8;8IJYIYPFI\
 

[#<E<CC@BC< 8CKb 8P \ JCbE;8 #I8?8D J8;<:< 8CKb :@CKC@B 9@I


8EJ@BCFG<;@ M< @B@ PbC XE:<B@ YEP8 CD8E8cbE;8E
P8I8IC8EbPFI;L
[? 8P FD J@Q@E YECY -<>@E8C; ;< )<@JK<I K@G@E@ ><IW<B
P8f8D;8E Db 8C;bEbQ TPC< FCD8Cb ? F ?<I 8PIbEKbJbPC8 @E

8E;bIb:b9@IK@G \
[ < )<@JK<I8 DF;<C FC8I8B WFB J<M;@c@D 9@I FBLC
8IB8;8fbDb 8C;bD \ FD F Q8D8E8 B8;8I ;< )<@JK<I >@9@ 9@I@E@
?@W K8EbD8DbfKb UJK<C@B XPC< 9@I@PC< B8IfbC8f89@C<:<c@E@
;YfYE<I<B ;8@D@ 9@I BFIBL @W@E;< P8fbPFI;L $8KK8 9XPC< 9@I f<P
FCLIJ8 BLCC8ED8B @W@E 8EC8fbC8D8P8E 9@I ;FcL Q<?@I@PC< ;FCL
LJK8CbBC8 P8GbCDbf 9@I PYQYB 9@C< 8CDbfKb < )<@JK<I ?8BBbE;8B@
=@B@IC<I@9XPC<P;@@fK<
&LE< @CC@E>J B8;bEC8IbE ><I@J@E;< 9@I P<I;< FKLILPFI [+ELE
J8?@9@ 9<E@D \ ;<I >@9@ D@;< 9LC8E;bIb:b 9@I >LILIC8
>YCYDJYPFI;L
#I8?8D DYDBYE FC;LcL B8;8I 9<CC@ <KD<D<P< W8Cbf8I8B
G8ID8cbEb 9FPELE8 JYI;Y FcLCD8B YQ<I< FC;LcLEL @f8I<K
<;@PFI;L &LE< >YCYDJ<;@ 98fbEb J8CC8;b FE8 LJLC:8 9@I XGY:YB
PFCC8;bM<E@f8ECbJbEbBLIK8ID8B@W@E?@W9@If<PP8GD8;b
#I8?8D B8;bEJbQ P8CEbQ M< :@;;@ 9@I P8f8D JYID<P< B8I8I
M<ID@fK@ '@K8GC8IbE8 ;8 JFEJLQ8 B8;8I J8;<:< ?89@J B8;bEC8I
BFP8:8BKb
IKbB <KI8=bE;8B@ ?8PI8EC8IbE8 9@I
@B@ ?<:<C@B JXQ:YBC<IC<
:<M8GM<I@PFI 'V? [!M<K \;@PFI;L BV? [$8PbI \
[!M<K Q8D8E Q8D8E BFB8@E 8CbPFILD L P8I8KD8 >Y;YD<
P8I;bD:b FCLPFI\ [$8PbI $FCCPNFF;`LE ;< )<@JK<I8
<CBFPD8JbE8 @Q@E M<I<D<D <E:< =@CDC<I ><IW<B J8E8KbE @WK<E
9@I @=8;<J@ J8PbC8D8QC8I 58K<E =@CDC<I J8;<:< ><W@:@ 9@I DF;8 \
[!M<K )@JJ ILD <J<IC<I@E@Q@E K8JC8BC8IbEb ><K@I@IJ<E@Q FBLILD
)<DELECLBC8 D8KXIC<I@E IFD8EC8IbEb FBLD8B ><IW<BK<E WFB
Q<MBC@FCLPFI !;@KXIC<I8f8cbCbBP8I8KbBC8I \
.FEI8 9Y=<E@E 8WbC;bcb ?89<I M<I@C;@ M< P8Q8IbE <KI8=bE;8 ;8
 

9@I;<E9@I< 9@I 9FfCLB FCLfKL #I8?8D`bE B8=8Jb 9@I J8E@P<;<E WFB


;8?8 BbJ8 9@I JYI<;< 9<II8BC8fKb YKYE F B8;bE JYIYJY 9@I K<B
B@f@ ?8C@E@ 8C;b   9FPLE;8 FKLQ J<B@Q B@CF 8cbICbcbE;8 9@I
B8;bE #I8?8D`bE 9FPL @J<  ;@ M< 8cbICbcb ;8 ;FBJ8E 9<f
B@CFPL 9LCLPFI;L $<I?8C;< ><EW 8;8D 9L P898E:b B8;bEC8
BFC8PCbBC8 98f8 WbB89@C@I;@ TQ<CC@BC< @B@ <C@PC< 9YPYB 9@I W8EK8Pb
KLKKLcL @W@E D8 #I8?8D FEL 9@I MLILfK8 ;<M@ID<P@ ;< G<B
@JK<D@PFI;L
'8;bE >XQC<I@E;< @cI<EW 9@I ?8PI8ECbB M< ?<P<:8EC8 P8BC8fbP

FI;L #I8?8D <C@PC< 8IB8JbE;8B@ ;LM8Ib PFBC8;b D8 P8BbE;8


?@W9@IP8GbPFBKL
[? 8P ;< )<@JK<I (YK=<E J@Q@ 8P ;< )<@JK<I ;@P<
W8cbID8D8 @Q@E M<I@E 48I8KKbcbEbQ K@G 9<E@D @W@E F B8;8I :8ECb B@
J@Q@ #I8?8D FIE FC8I8B ;YfYE<D@PFILD .@Q:< 9@I J8BbE:8Jb
PFB
;<c@CDb\
#I8?8DbE FKLQ @B@ ;@f@ 9@I;<E B8D8fDbfKb L ;@fC<I@E
8I8JbE;8E >8I>8I8 P8G8I >@9@ [? K89@@ B@ PFB \ ;<D<P@
98f8I;b [<E ;< B<P@=C@ 8EC8IbD;8 -<>@E8C; FC;LcLDL
;YfYEYIYD \
[? WFB K<f<BBYI <;<I@D .@Q@EC< K8EbfD8B @W@E E< 0&)&6
J89bIJbQC8E;bcbDb 9@C<D<QJ@E@Q J<M>@C@ 8P ;< )<@JK<I C8C3
<J<IC<I@E@Q@FBL;LD <E:<?<GJ@;<?8I@B8 \
[gTPC< ;YfYED<E@Q< J<M@E;@D \ 48Q8I ?<D<E 8CW8B
>XEYCCY 8;8D IFCYE< >@I;@ [JCbE;8 ?@W ;< XE<DC@ ;<c@CC<I $8
?8 ?8 +BLPL:LC8Ib D<DELE <KD<B ?FfLD8 >@;@PFI D8 K89@@
<J<IC<I@DWFB;8?8@P@FC89@C@IC<I;@ $8?8?8\
[D8 J@Q ><IW<BK<E XPC<J@E@Q \ '8;bE 9L JXQC<I@ ?<P<:8ECb
9@I @WK<EC@BC< JXPC<D@fK@ [[48E@ LJK8JbEbQ *6A*08*3 LJK8
<E:< J@Q@E >@9@ 9@I P8Q8I FCD8B FC8c8EYJKY 9@I f<P ;<K8 9@I
K8EIbFCD8B>@9@9@If<P9L \
#I8?8D 9Ff >XQC<IC< 98BKb [!;@KXIC<I XPC< ;YfYEDYPFIC8I
BbQbD \


D8 B8;bE FELE =bJbCKbPC8 JXPC<;@c@ 9L JXQC<I@ ;LPD8;b


[[@I ?@WK<E P8f8P8E K@GC<I P8I8KD8B \ ;@P< BFELfD8JbEb
JYI;YI;Y [[-L?C8IbEb 9YKYE ;YEP8P8 8WbBC8D8B YfYE:<C<I@
B<C@D<C<I< ;XBD<B -<J@DC<I W@QD<B M< ;YEP8C8I P8I8KD8B
<E JbB JbB @EJ8EC8IbE <E Q8I@= M< P<K<E<BC@C<I@E@E P8Q8IC8I
FC;LcLEL;YfYEYIYD
/8?KK8 FKLI8E 9@I BI8C ;<c@C 9@I K8M8E8I8JbE;8 8W B8C8E 9@I P8Q8I
FCD8PbP<cC<I@D .@Q;<8PEb=@B@I;<;<c@CD@J@E@Q\
#I8?8D ['<J@EC@BC< \;@P<P8C8EJXPC<;@
[ YEP8EbE B898 D8;;@ Q<E>@EC@BC<I@E@E ;LP>LC8Ib M<
?8I<B<KC<I@ XI<I<B BYWYB 9@I VC<D P8I8KD8EbE P8EbE;8 E< ;<c<I@
FC89@C@I\
[#<IW<BK<E;< E<;<c<I@FC89@C@I\
[1<XCYDJYQCYBTCYDJYQCYcY9@I;YfYEYE\
[!M<K <M<K <E9LELJbBJbBP8G8IbD \
'8;bE P8Q8IbE <C@E@ P8B8C8;b [.@Q;<E 9@I K<B BYWY:YB
@JK<c@D FC8:8B 58M8CCb -<>@E8C;bE FEL 9@I ;<=8 FCJLE 9XPC<
W8cbID8D8 @Q@E M<I@E \\ $8=@=W< BbQ8I;b [ ^ Q8M8CCb -<>@E8C;bE
(<K@K@8 -<PEFC;JC8 <MC<ED<J@E< @Q@E M<I@E 'bQ FE8 B8Ifb WFB Q8

C@D:< ;8MI8EbPFI 8Q8E 9L PYQ;<E J88KC<I:< 8cC8;bcbD FCLPFI


D8 K89@@ -<>@E8C; 9<E@D @W@E ><IW<B 9@I @EJ8E >@9@ SFB ><IW<B
9@I @EJ8E \ @I P<I;<E ;8EK<CC@ 9@I D<E;@C WbB8I8I8B FEL >XQC<I@E<
>XKYI;Y .FEI8D<E;@C@@E;@I;@M<>YCYDJ<P<I<BK<C8fC8LQ8BC8fKb
#I8?8D ;<I@E 9@I JFCLB 8C;b #XQC<I@E@ PLD;L M< LJLC:8
&LE<LEBFCC8IbEbE8I8JbE8PbcbC;b
.FEI8 ?bQC8 >XQC<I@E@ 8W8I8B J<IKW< [*@f8EbDbQbE 9FQLCD8
EFBK8JbE8 ><C;@c@E@ ;YfYE<9@C@IJ@E \ ;<;@ [D8 F Q8M8CCb P8fCb
8EE<EC< 9898Eb ;YfYE;YcYD @W@E J<E;<E #I8?8D FIELE <JB@
E@f8ECbJb;@P<JXQ<;@CD<J@E@@JK<D@PFILD \
[.<M>@C@D WFB JFPCLJLE \\ &LE< P8E8cbEb 8;8DbE BFCLE8
JYI;Y [#<C J<E@ <M< >XKYI<P@D + Q8M8CCb P8I8C8IbE8 D<I?<D
FC8PbD \\
[,<BVCV D8 9<E@ K8fbD8E ><I<B<:<B + :@:@ J<M>@C@


K<PQ<E@E9@I98CK8JbM8IDb\
[D8E<;<E\
 [SYEBY 9<E@ /8EIb P8I;bD:bDbQ FCJLE YECY -<>@E8C;
;<)<@JK<IbE9<P@E
9898Jb;@P<K8EbKKb \\
[!? J<EXPC<;<c@CD@J@E\
[IKbB 9L JYIYE><EC<I PLM8JbE;8E >@;<C@D 1< fLEL ;8
B8=8E8 @P@:< JFB 9<E ;< )<@JK<I ;<E@C<E F K@G@E E< 9<P@E
98BbDbE;8E E< ;< 98fB8 K8I8=K8E 8BI898JbPbD +EL I<;;<;

@PFILD +EL B8I8ECbBC8I YCB<J@E< BFMLPFILD 4YQYE< KYBYIYPFI

LD < )<@JK<IbE PFQC8fDbf @cI<EW 9@I J<IJ<I@ M< 9@I BXG<c@E


FcCL FC;LcLEL @C8E <;@PFILD + 8J@C @=8;<C@ @cI<EW 9LIELEL 9@I
;8?8P8QbD8B@E<D<JFB8IJ8DB8?IFC8PbD\
/8BJ@P< 9@ED@fC<I;@ F JbI8;8 &LE< ><EW 8;8DbE BI8M8KbEb
;YQ<CKK@ [,<BVCV L=8BCbB fLD<BKL9L>XI<C@D98B8CbD \
[$8E>@D<BKL9L\
'bQ<C@E@LQ8KKb [48PbE:bE;8E><C<ED<BKL9LK89@@ \
#I8?8D X=B<PC< ?FDLI;8E8I8B D<BKL9L :<B<K@E@E :<9@E;<E
WbB8I;b [C8E<K FC8Jb:8 K8f B8CGC@ ?<I@= !M@E< W8P8 >@KD<P@
;YfYE;YD +ELE9@IKLK8DJKI@BE@EC<I8E;<MLJLM8I \
[ 8?8 JFEI8 98cbIbG W8cbIbIJbE 8B8CbD E< P8QDbf $bD
?b ?b <BC<E;@c@ >@9@ ;<c@C < )<@JK<I <JB@ =FIDLE;8
;<c@CD@f >@9@ ><C;@ <CB@ 9@I8Q ;<c@f@BC@B -FD8EbE ;YQ<CK@C<

9@C<:<c@E;<E <D@E@D -FD8Eb 98fB8 Q8I= @W@E;< >XE;<I@PFILQ


\ &LE< D<BKL9L 9@I B<E8I8 8KKb [.8E8 JXPC<;@D .8E:?8
-F;I@>L<Q@ XC;YID<P<:<BK@E .8E8 ><I<B<E FP;L fB @C@fB@C<I@E@
WFB8Q8CKD8P898fC8;bE \
g^+ ?8C;< B@K89b J<E P8Q <E ;< )<@JK<I;8E M8Q><W@PFILD
8IKbB df XPC< WbcIbE;8E WbBKb B@ ;<IE<B YP<J@ B8;bEC8I 9<E@ 8P
;< )<@JK<I ;@P< W8cbID8P8 98fC8;bC8I #8Q<K<C<I;< I<J@DC<I@E
WbBKbcb Q8D8E 8CKbE8 _8P ;< )<@JK<I ` ;@P< P8QbPFIC8I '@f@C@c@D
B8CD8;b '@DJ<E@E #I8?8D FIE;8E ?89<I@ 9@C< PFB <E ?<I
Q8D8E  FD FIE ?8E@ fL ;< )<@JK<I D8:<I<C8IbEb P8Q8E
8;8DbD \


&LE< [.8WD8C8D8 \ ;@P< 98cbI;b [.<E P8I8KKbcbE K@G@


BbJB8EbPFIJLE \
[<E P8I8KKbcbD K@G@ BbJB8EDbPFILD @EC< <E GFC@J@P< IF

D8EC8I;8E E<=I<K <;<I@D dB@ ?<:<C@ B<C@D<C<I@ XcI<E;@c@D


>YE;<E 9<I@ FEC8Ib ?@W FBLD8D dCB GFC@J@P< IFD8Eb Q<B@ P8Bb:b
B<JB@E 9@I J8KbI FC8I8B P8Q;bD ,FC@J@P< IFD8E P8Q8IC8IbEbE
FCLfKLI;LcL F J8?K< <BFCL PbBD8B @JK@PFI;LD + ;< )<@JK<Ib ;8
FE;8E P8I8KKbD -<Q@C ;<;<BK@=C<I@E <E I<Q@C@P;@ #I8?8D FIE
K8I8=bE;8EP8I8KbC8E #<I@5<BVCbC8IbE#<I@5<BVCbJb
[1< B8DL PbC8EC8I W@P8EC8I M< E8EBXI WF:LBC8IC8 9@IC@BK< 9L
G@J ?<I@=@ 98cIbE8 98JKb '8DLFPLEL ;<c@fK@ID<B @W@E IFD8E
YJKYE< IFD8E P8Q;bD \ #I8?8DbE FDLQC8Ib 9@I8Q ;YfKY
YKYE 9LEC8I 9FfLE8P;b [? E<PJ< \ '<;<IC< >YCYDJ<;@
[EC8P8DbPFI DLJLE 8fB8 f<PC<I P8QD8B QFILE;8PbD $8P

8KbDb Q@P8E <;<D<D D8 #I8?8D FIELE P8Q;bcb :@;;@ 9@I <J

<I@ 8IKbB B@D FBLI <E@ ?<I Q8D8E ;< )<@JK<IC8


XQ;<fC<fK@I@PFIC8I \
[/8BD89@I8;BLCC8E89@C@IJ@E \
[/8BD88;BLCC8ED8D@JD@DC<>LILIC8EbPFILD9<E \
[D8 ;< )<@JK<Ib ;<=K<I;<E J@C<D<QJ@E @I8Q D8EKbBCb FC
?8P8KbD \
#I8?8D 8:b 8:b [*FID8C 9@I E@f8ECb ><C<:<BK<B@ BF:8JbEbE
;<c<IC@ <J<IC<I P8QD8JbEb @JK<I;@ \ ;<;@ [!;<9@P8K 8C8EbE;8
B<E;@J@E<9YPYB9@I@J@DP8GD8JbEb;@C<I;@ \
[LEL 9<E ;< @JK@PFILD #I8?8D D8 8I8;8 JbI8;8 BYWYB
9@I ;< )<@JK<I IFD8Eb 9@I@B<E =8KLI8C8IbE X;<ED<J@E< P8I;bD
<;<I

[$8?\ #I8?8D >YWCY IL?LELE W<BK@c@ 8:bEbE 8EC8fbCD8D8Jb


@W@E f8GB8JbEb PYQYE< ;FcIL @E;@I;@ [ + 8cQ8 8CbED8P8:8B P8I

8KbBC8 @C>@C@ IFD8EC8I P8Q8I8B J8E8KbDb 9@I =8?@f< >@9@ J8KD8;bB:8


PYBJ<C<D<P<:<c@D@ JXPCYPFIJLE dfK< J<E@E <M $8P;@ @E <E
<M< >@;<I<B 9LE8B 8P )8: LEC8G`bDbQ8 8J9<JKFJ YQ<I@E<
P8Bb:b9@ID<BKLGP8Q8:8cbD \


&LE< FEL K<J<CC@P< W8CbfKb [dJK<;@c@E >@9@ P8G ?8P8KbD 48IbE


B<E;@E@ ;8?8 @P@ ?@JJ<KK@c@E Q8D8E 98E8 ><C@I 98fbEb FDQLD8
;8P8P8I8B 8cC8IJbE +E;8E JFEI8 ;8 @AC3(C C:*68*)* T
YDYE8JbC;<c@fK@I<:<c@D@Q@9@IC@BK<GC8EC8IbQ +CLIDL\
#I8?8D [*@f8E9FQLC;L \\;<;@
[!M<K ?8P8KbD 48IbEJ<B@Q;<<M;<FC8:8cbD \
[L9<E@?@W@C>@C<E;@ID@PFI #YC<>YC< \\

48PbE:bC8I M< <;@KXIC<I _;FBLELCD8QC8I ;@P< K8EbDC8E89@C@IC<I


!C LQ8KbG ;@fC<I@ >XJK<I< >XJK<I< >YCYDJ<D<B 98fb J8CC8P8I8B
JbIK8MLID8BFEC8I8D@I8JB8CDbfFC8E9@I><C<E<BK@I
D8 9<CB@ ><:< FC;LcL Q8D8E P8Q8IC8IbE B<E;@C<I@E@ 8KKbBC8Ib
F ;<C@BC<I;< XQ<C @EK@B8DC8I 8CbE89@C@I '@DJ<E@E ;LP8D8P8:8cb
98Qb JXQC<I JXPC<E@I ,FJK8P8 M<I@CD<J@E< ><I<B FCD8P8E D<BKL

GC8I P8QbCbI <CB@ ;< 9@I <;@KXIYE ;YfYE:<C@ ;YfYE:<C@ >YCYD

J<IB<E W<B@CD@f 9@I =FKFcI8=b P8Qb D8B@E<J@E@E YQ<I@E< P<IC<fK@I@C@I


M<9@IFB?<;<=@>@9@;<BLCC8EbCbI
8P )8: LEC8GbE ;8 9L 9@W@D;< BLCC8EbC8E 9@I I<JD@ #I8

?8D FIELE F;8JbEb 8P;bEC8KbPFI;L 1< ?<I Q8D8EB@ P8Qb


BbCbcbEb P8E@ JFB8B <C9@J<C<I@ M< 9@I ;8BK@CF D8B@E<J@ 9YIYEDYf
FC8E #I8?8D FIELE B8fC8Ib @P@:< W8KbCDbfKb )8B@E<P< K8BKbcb
9<f@E:@ J8P=8P8 98BbPFI;L @c<I ;XI;Y BVcbK J<G<K@E@E B<E8IbEb
JYJC<D<BK<P;@C<I ,<BK8KJbQKLQJLQFC;LBC8Ib@W@E8KbCDbfC8I;b
48Q8I [.8PbE 98PbD \ ;@P< 98fC8;b .FEI8 ;8 B@EC< 8cbI
8cbI <BC<;@ [48 ;8 ;LILD8 >XI< 8P8E \ dC?8D ><C@IB<E ?bQC8
P8Qb P8QD8Pb JYI;YI;Y "8QC8 bJbE8E KLfC8I;8E PYBJ<C<E ;L

D8EC8I8;88C;bID8;b
[L IFD8E;8B@ ;< )<@JK<Ib G<B 9<c<ED<;@c@E@Q@ JXPCYPFI

JLELQ <E ;< )<@JK<Ib ?@W9@I Q8D8E 9<c<ED<;@D @fK< F


B8;8I + P8cCb >XM;<E@Q@ FELEB@E< 98cC8PbG IFFBCPE BX

GIYJYE;<E 8f8cbP8 8KC8P89@C@IJ@E@Q .@Q 8KC8D8;8E ?<D<E XE:<


FcLE<?I@E@EJLC8IbEbEW<B@CD<J@E@;<;@C<I@D
[LE;8E JFEI8 B@K8GC8IbDb J@Q@E 8f8cbCbB P8PbE<M@E@Q;<E WFB


;8?8 PYBJ<BC<I@ @W@E P8Q8:8cbD 1< 9@I >YE ><I@P< ;XE<I<B


D<JC<c@D@E9L;<MI<J@E<K@BJ@EK@PC<98B8:8cbD L;<MI<E@E?8B
<KK@c@;<9L \
#I8?8D JFE BbJDb P8Q8IB<E 9@I@ FELE FDQLE8 MLID8P8
98fC8DbfKb 48Q8I 8I8;8 JbI8;8 9L <C@ X=B<PC< 8D8 P8I8IJbQ:8
@K@PFI;L
e@D;@ ;LI8I8B ;XE;Y M< F;8JbE;8B@ 9L P898E:bP8 E<Q8

B<KC< ['8?I<KJ@E\ ;<;@ [C8E<K FCJLE .<E ;< B@DJ@E .FILDL


:<M8GC8D8;8E WbBbG >@;<9@C@IJ@E '898CbB <KK@c@E@ ;<
;YfYED<D \
4898E:b E8Q@B E8Q@B >YCYDJ<;@ 8fbEb J8CC8IB<E J8WC8IbE8
?8=@=W< JYIDYf FC;LcL 9I@P8EK@E@E Q8I@= BFBLJL #I8?8DbE
9LIELE8 ><C;@ 4898E:bEbE J<IK @=8;<C@ @E:< W<E<J@ ;@BB8K@ W<B@P

FI;L #<EW 8;8D K8KCb 9@I J<JC< [;bD ;< )<@JK<I \ ;@P< :<M8G
M<I;@ [-<>@E8C;;<)<@JK<I \
#I8?8D 8BCbEbE K<D<CC<I@E< B8;8I J8IJbC;b M< FEC8IbE
>b:bI;8;bBC8IbEb;LP;L .FEI8 [$FFF? ]\;<;@
[,8I;FE\
48Q8I B<E;@E@ KFGC8;b [$9FF? ;<;@D L BYWYB 9@I f@=I<
1< _$8E>@;<)<@JK<I8EC8DbE8><C@PFI \
<)<@JK<IE<Q8B<KC<8WbBC8;b [eL;<)<@JK<I \\
[<E@DK@G@DD@<E@D;<;<BK@=@D\\
< )<@JK<I 9@I BFCKLc8 P<IC<fK@ dE:< B<JB@E ?8KCb PYQYE;<
B@98I W<MI<C<I;< WFB 9<c<E@C<E F K<I9@P<C@ 8D8 JbBbEKbCb @=8;< 9<

C@ID@fK@ @I /YIB J@>8I8Jb P8BKb #I8?8D 9LELE ;<;<BK@=@E@E <E


J<M;@c@ D8IB8 FC;LcLEL =8IB<KK@ < )<@JK<I J@>8I8EbE L:LEL
8cbI 8cbI ;@BB8KC< <C@E@E YQ<I@E< MLI;L L ;8 P@E< ?<I Q8D8E
P8GKbcb9@If<P;@
< )<@JK<I [? 8Q@Q ;FJKLD \ ;@P< DbIbC;8E;b [L ><I

W<BK<E WFB BFD@B !M<K J<E@E K@G@E J8PbC89@C@I@D 8D8 9LEL K<D<C
FC8I8B8CD8BK8EB8WbE8CbD LJ8IJbC8:8BB8;8IJbBb:bFCLI \
48Q8I :<M8G P<I@E< P@E< [$FF? \ ;@P< K<BI8IC8;b '8=8Jb K<C

8fC8 @?K@D8CC<I@ ?<J8GC8D8P8 W8CbfbPFI;L JCbE;8 @WB@ @WD<Q;@




1< E< P8QbB B@ fL 8E;8 ;8 J8I?Ff ;<c@C;@ )@;<J@ BIFD


W<C@B
8C8fbDbE;8E P8GbCDbf B8;8I J8cC8D;b L 9@I ?8CYJ@E8JPFE ;8
FC8D8Q;b #I8?8D ?@W IYP8 >XID<Q;@ $8P8C >Y:Y @J< G8I8 ><

K@I<E 9@I D8C FC8I8B ?<I Q8D8E BFEKIFCL 8CKbE;8P;b YKYE P8Q8I

C8I >@9@ FELE ;<C@E@E K<B@ FC;LcLEL ;YfYEYPFIC8I;b +ELE @W@E


WbC;bIDbf;8FC8D8Q;b
#<I@P< 9@I K<B f<P B8CbPFI;L ;< )<@JK<IbE FI8;8 FCD8Jb
@DBVEJbQ;b 1< #I8?8D I8?8KC8;b @I B@K8G P8Q8IB<E F @E:<
@DBVEJbQCbBC8I8 8C;bID8D8 J8E8KbEb XcI<E<D<P<E 9@I P8Q8I 9@I
@f<P8I8D8Q;b
48Q8I J8B@E J8B@E [dfK< JFE B@K89bD fLI8;8 \ ;<;@ ]SbBKbcbE
J8P=8EbE ELD8I8JbEb JXPC<I M< JFEI8 ;8 FI8P8 ;XE<I D@J@E
df@D 98fbD;8E 8fBbE /8EIb ;8 9@C@PFI P8 P8Q;bcbD F LP;LILB
f<PC<I;<J<E@EC<P<K<I@B8;8ILcI8fKbD
[<E 9LI8P8 @f @W@E ><C;@D 8Q@Q ;FJKLD TE:< J<E@EC< ;FJK

:89@I8EC8fD8P8GD8D><I<B@PFI  LILDJFE;<I<:<;<JbBb:b \
[LI8P8 98B :8EbDb JbBKbcbEbE =8IBbE;8 DbJbE <E ?8P8C@
K@GC<IC< BFELfD8B 8;<K@E;< ;<c@C@D #<E<CC@BC< FEC8IC8 ;FJKCLB
BLID8D 58K<E 8IKbB 8EE<E@E J8E8 8JCbE;8 M8I FCD8;bcbEb 8WbB

C8D8JbEbEQ8D8Eb;8><C;@ \\
[? 8Q@Q ;FJKLD 9<E ?<I Q8D8E M8I;bD 18I FCD8B XPC<
XQE<C 9@I f<P B@ '8=8EbE M8I FC;LcLEL ;YfYE;YcY f<P M8I
FCLI <E ;< J<E@E B8=8E;8 M8I;bD XIE<c@E <E@ @CB
;YfYE;YcYE8E;8E9<I@ \
#I8?8D YIG<I;@ [D8 f@D;@ JFIL fL B8=8DbE )GKG3)& E<
@f@E M8I +I8Jb J8E8 =8QC8 Db ;8I ><CD<P< 98fC8;b -8?8K
?8I<B<K<KD<B@W@EP<ID@@JK@PFIJLE\
[$@W ;< ;<c@C .<E@EB@ 9@I 98BbD8 FC;LBW8 @P@ 9@I B8=8 D8
9<E 9L>YE XcC<;<E JFEI8 ;8?8 JFDLK 9@I ?8C 8C;bD +ELE @W@E
;< 9L =bIJ8KK8E P8I8IC8E8I8B J<E@EC< F @f BFELJLEL PYQ PYQ<
K8IKbfD8B @W@E ><C;@D EC8P8:8cbE F ;<IE<BK<B@ Q8Pb= IFD8EK@B
?8EbD  \
#I8?8D 9FcLB 9FcLB [$8E>@ ;<IE<B\ ;@P< DbIbC;8E;b
 

IKbB;<?f<KC<E<FC;LcLEL8EC8D8P898fCbPFI;L
[eL BFE=<I8EJ M<I;@c@E ;<IE<B \ < )<@JK<I ;< YIG<I;@
[$8E@ GFC@J@P< IFD8EC8I ?8BBbE;8 9@I BFELfD8 P8GKbE P8 +
?8EbD 9<E@D M8I FC;LcLD8 @E8EbPFI;L @fK< F PYQ;<E ;< 9<E
M8IbD \.@>8I8JbEb9@K@I@G 9@C<c@E@B8PbKJbQ:89YB<I<B8KKb
#I8?8D [)8EKbB B8WbEbC8:8B >@9@ ;<c@C \ ;@P< 8WbBC8;b
[e@D;@ 9<E;<EE<@JK@PFIJLE$<If<B@C;<:<M89bD?8PbI \
[.<E ;LILDLE =8IBbE;8 DbJbE 8Q@Q ;FJKLD < )<@JK<I IF

D8EC8Ib P8QD8BK8E M8Q><W<IJ<E P8f8DbD JbBb:b 9@I ?8C 8C8:8B


+ D<;8Jb ><WD@f IFD8EC8I;8B@ ;<;<BK@=C<I@E P8f8EKbC8Ib >@9@ K8K

JbQC8f8:8B @I ?8P8C< ;XEYf<:<B + BLIfLE@ J@JC<I@E 8I8JbE;8


$FCD<J (<:F: M< LG@EC< J8WD8J8G8E BFELfD8C8IP8GD8B
QFILE;8B8C8:8cbD \
[<E:<WFBW<B@:@9@I;YfYE:<9L .8E8LP>LE9@IB8;<I \
-<>@E8C; ;< )<@JK<IbE >XQC<I@E;< 9LQ >@9@ 9@I @=8;< 9<

C@I@M<I;@ 1< #I8?8D ;8 9@I;<E9@I< 'bIbB "&'1& 1&<G IF

D8EbEbEYE:YJ8P=8JbE;8B@9@IB8W:YDC<P@?8KbIC8;b
! &3& 0&)&6 -.A'.6 K*<.3 C=*6.3)* )962&<
&3 8*2'*1 '&0GK1G ,B=1*6.3)*0. .+&)* 7*681*K8.
&:. '9=)&3 ,B1(C01*6* )B3CK8C '9 ,B=1*8
* *.78*6 '&0GK1&6G3G 9K&H& ).08. )&2
'&HG62&2&<&A&1GK&6&07*3)*1*).,*6.1.<46)9
EC8fbC8E ;< )<@JK<I JYJC<;@c@ IFD8EC8I;8E WbBKbcb Q8D8E ;8
XQ<CC@BC<I@E@E?@W9@I@E@B8P9<KD@PFI;L
#I8?8D98cbID8D8P8W8Cbf8I8BJ<E;<C<;@ #<I@C@PFI;L
< )<@JK<I K<?;@K ;FCL 9@I J<JC< [-FD8EC8IbDbE ;<M8D <K

D<J@ J<E@E @W@E ;8?8 @P@ FCLI \ ;@P< ?FDLI;8E;b [ < )<@JK<I IF

D8EC8IbEbE ECbPFIDLJLE\
#I8?8D B<E;@E@ KFGC8;b M< ?8=@= 9@I X=B< ;LPD8Pb 9@C<
98f8I;b [@I ;8B@B8 .<E ?8;;@ 8fbPFIJLE 0ELKD8 B@ 9<E 9@I
98BbD8 J<E@E 9898E J8PbCbIbD !M<K XPC< P8 )8E<M@ 9898E
8E8 YCK@D8KFDC8I M<I<D<Q K<?;@KC<I J8MLI8D8QJbE L 9@I
FcLC8 P8Bbf8:8B ;8MI8Ebf FCD8Q L 9898E8 LP>LE J8P>b M<



J<M>@EFCD8;bcb8EC8DbE8><C@I \
< )<@JK<I 8C;bID8;b 9@C< [@I f<P ;8?8 M8I eL (<K@K@8
-<PEFC;J D<J<C<J@E@ ;< ;YQ<CKD<C@J@E IKbB :8E JbBD8P8
98fC8;b \
[#YCYEW FCD8 fB J8?E<C<I@D 9@E;< 9@I GFC@J@P< IFD8E;8
9@C< >XIYCD<P<E f<=B8K M< IFD8EK@QD DL:@Q<C<I@ FC8I8B @C8E
<;@C;@ @I ;8B@B8 .8E8 9@IB8W <C<fK@I@P@ ><K@I<:<c@D 8E8 E8JbC
;8MI8ED8E ><I<BK@c@E< =8QC8 8C;bIDbPFILD D8 P8QbC8IbDb
<C<fK@ID<E<?@W><C<D<D \
[+ <C<fK@I@C<I@ LELK <E F f<=B8K@ M< ;@c<I J8WD8CbBC8Ib
@JK<D@PFILD <f IFD8E 9FPLE:8 F >YQ<C B8;bEbE G<f@E;<
;FC8fbG ;LI;LD UJK<C@B ;8P8EbC8D8P8:8B ><I@ Q<BVCb B8;8I
;8MI8E;bD IKbB9LE89@IJFEM<I@CD<C@ \
[*8JbC\
[.FE IFD8EbE;8 FELEC8 <MC<ED<C@P@D 48 9L FCLI P8 ;8 FEL
9<E@D D<KI<J@D P8G8IJbE dP@ J8P>b ;<c<I 9@I D<KI<J PIb:8
8IKbB B8;bEC8I8 B8Ifb 1@:KFI@8 ;<MI@E;<E B8CD8 9@I :<EK@CD<E >@9@
;8MI8ED8BK8E ;8 9bBKbD '8?I<KJ@E LE;8E ;8 M8Q><WD<C@J@E
<EJ8;<:<9@I@EJ8EbD ;FJKLD \
#I8?8D [dDBVEJbQ \ ;@P< 98cbI;b [L fL JFE C8=bE @W@E ;<
><W<IC@ \
< )<@JK<I X=B<PC< [? ;FJKLD 9@I P8Q8IJbE 8D8 PbCC8I
9FPLE:8 ><W@D@E@ J8cC8P8E 9@I K@G@E @P@C@c@E@ ?@W ;YfYE;YcYE
PFB \;<;@
#I8?8DE<I<;<PJ<9FcLCLPFI;L [#<W@D@D@J8cC8P8EDb
48E@ 9<E@D ><IW<B IFD8EC8I P8QbG J8K8D8P8:8cbDb JXPC<D<B
@JK@PFIJLE XPC< D@ .8E8 >XJK<I<:<c@D 8E8 9@I D@CPFE ;FC8I
;8 M<IJ<C<I 9@I ;8?8 9@I K<B ;< )<@JK<I IFD8Eb 9@C< P8QD8P

8:8cbD 4YQ;< <CC@ K<C@= Y:I<K@ M< 9YKYE K<C<M@QPFE ?8BC8IbEb 98E8
M<IJ<C<I9@C< ! f@D;@E<;@P<:<BJ@E98B8CbD\
< )<@JK<I B8fC8IbEb W8KKb M< G<B WFB JLWCLELE =<C8B<K@ ;<

D<B FC8E F JXQC<I@ K<BI8IC8;b [8B8CbD >XIYIYQ D8 J<E@EC<


@f@D@Q ?<EYQ 9@KD<;@ \ '<J@E ?8KCb W<E<J@E@ XE< ;FcIL WbB8I8I8B
 

FIK8;8EB8P9FC;L
#I8?8DbE W8IGbCDbf PYQ ?8KC8Ib ;YQ<C@PFI;L 48Q8I 8cbI 8cbI
<CC<I@E@PLB8IbB8C;bI8I8B98fbEbPFBC8;b
0QLE M< FC;LBW8 8WbB Q@?@EJ<C P8f8DbE;8 @CB ;<=8 ;YfD8E

C8IbEbE ?8BCb FC;LBC8IbEb ;YfYE;Y '8=8JbE8 BLIL K<D@QC<D<


P8GbCD8Jb?@W;<=<E8FCD8P8:8BKb
dW@E;<E<>8I@Gf<PC<IP8fbPFI;L9LB8=8EbE

#I8?8D FIE B8GbEbE Q@C@E@ @B@E:@ ;<=8 ;@IJ<c@PC< W8C;b


&LE<LE 8Bf8D J<B@Q;< <M;< FC8:8cbEb JXPC<;@c@E@ B<J@EC@BC<
?8KbICbPFI;L
'8Gb;8B@;<C@B8WbC;b [)<I?898\
[)<I?898\
@IJ<JJ@QC@BFC;L
#I8?8D [ bf8Ib;8 P8cDLI P8cbPFI \ ;@P< P8BbE;b [dW<I@
>@I@GBLILE8D8QDbPbD\
[@CD@PFILD @Q?VCVE@f8ECbDbPbQ 8P FIE\
48Q8I JFcLB JFcLB [!c<I E@f8ECb ;<c@CJ<B \ ;<;@ [+ Q8

D8E 9<E PYQC<I:< @?K@I8JCb BbQbE ?<P<:8ECb K<BC@=C<I@E@ 9Ff P<I<


I<;;<;@PFILD;<D<BK@I UJK<C@B?<GJ@;<WFB>YQ<C \
[D8;YEJ<E;<;@EB@ \
[? 8D8 9<E@D JXQC<I@D@ B@D ;@EC@PFI B@ L PXE;<E 8EK@B

8EbE 9@I@ J8PbCbIbD 8B J8E8 W@W<BC<I ><K@I;@D \ #I8?8D >YCC<I@


>XQ<KC<D<;<C@c@E<;FcILLQ8KKb
&LE< B8GbPb 8WKb [#YCC<I *< 8;@ dW<I@ >@I 8?98G M<
B8E<G<P@ B@IC<K LI ;LI ;LI @I 8;bD ;8?8 8KD8 @c<I
BFCLELE 8CKbE;8B@ E<;@I @AC3(C C:*68*)* TCYDYE DYJ

M<;;<J@FCD8JbE\
[? F@cI<EWf<P;<c@C9L SFB;<c@f@B9@I<J<I \
&LE< 9LQ >@9@ 9@I J<JC< [4FBJ8 9L J<E@E F G<B ;<c<IC@ IF

D8EbEDb ;@P<JFI;L
#I8?8D98fbEb;@BC<fK@I;@ [*8JbC9@C;@E\
[)8: LEC8GbE >YDYf PbC;XEYDYE;< BFELPL 98E8
 

J8CP8C8IbE8B8I8B8EC8KKbE \
[*< DYE8J<9<K XPC< 9@I f<P@ 8E:8B J8I?Ff FCLIJ8D
P8G8I;bD \
[.8I?FfKLE K89@@ LK >@9@P;@E ;< ;@P<9@C@I@Q UJK<C@B J8;<:<
@B@BFBK<PC@WD@fK@E \
[)8;<D J8I?FfKLD F ?8C;< J8E88JbC BFELPL 8EC8KDbf
FC8D8D \
[-FD8E BXDYI D8;<EC<I@E@E 9LCLE;LcL 9@I 9XC><;< D@
><W@PFI\

e<P <M<K\
[/@GC<I J<E M< 9<E >@9@ ;YfYEYG BFELf8E ><IW<B P8G8P FC

D8P8E I<8C@JK ;YIYJK @EJ8EC8I Db L K<D<C <BFEFD@B >YWC<IC<


@C>@C@ 9@I ?@BVP< D@ /@GC<I ?8M8P8 B8C;bIbCbG P<I< 8KbCbPFI =bIbC;8B
>@9@ ;XE;YIYCYPFIC8I Db 'XDYI D8;<E@ M< 9L>YEBY D<B8E@Q<
<E;YJKI@E@EG<EW<J@E;<C<ID@\
[e<P <M<K \
&LE< ><WD@fK< FC8EC8Ib ?8KbICbPFIDLf >@9@ 98fbEb J8CC8;b
[$<I f<P@ WFB @P@ 8EbDJbPFILD TE:< J8I?Ff FC;LE JFEI8 BLJ

KLE .FEI8 B<E;@E< ><C;@E M< 98E8 B@K89bE @CB 9@IB8W 9XCYDYEY
8EC8KKbE .FEI8 ;8 9<E BLJKLD \ #XQC<I@ X=B<J@E;<E 8K<f J8W8E
P8Q8I8 P8BC8fKb [#I8?8D \ CKbE J8WCb 98fbEb FELE FDQLE8
;8P8P8I8B K8KCb 9@I J<JC< <BC<;@ [*<;<E ;< )<@JK<I IFD8EC8IbE8
;<M8D <KD@PFIJLE +EC8IbE J8P<J@E;< J8E8 G<B >YQ<C W<BC<I
PFCCLPFIC8I \
#I8?8D WbIGbE8I8B BbQbE BFCC8IbEbE 8I8JbE;8E JbPIbC;b [.<E
WFB G8I8>XQJYE @I P8Q8IbE IL?LEL 8EC8D8EJ8 @DBVEJbQ
*@f8EbDbQbE JFE8 <I;@c@E@ ;YfYE<9@C@IJ@E \ T=B<PC< B8E<G<P<
FKLI8I8B BFCC8IbEb B8MLfKLI;L [/89@@ IFD8EbDb FBLI M< 9@I K8?

C@C@E@P8G8IJ8EFQ8D8E;LILD;<c@f@I \
[.8E8 XE:< @AC3(C C:*68*)* T YD`YE 9@I K8?C@C@E@
P8G89@C@ID@P@D\
[$8PbI \
[dP@ @I B<I< 8fB @C@fB@J@ 8IKbB D@;< 9LC8E;bI8:8B 9@I ?8C


8CD8P898fC8;b \
[*< DYE8J<9<K\ #I8?8IE X=B<PC< G8ID8cbEb J8CC8;b [+
8fB J8?E<C<I@ K8KCb 9@I IFD8EK@QD BFBLPFI .8EB@ ;8?8 <JB@ >YE

C<I;<PD@f@Q >@9@ 48EbD;8 9XPC< JXPC<P<E 9@I <C<fK@I@ M8I \


YQ;8EbEbB8IbfKbI;b
[? 9FfM<IJ<E< +BC8?FD8;8 B@DJ<E@E f@D;@P< B8;8I
8;bEb ;LPD8;bcb ,@CCJ9FIF B8J898 >8Q<K<J@E@E <C<fK@I@J@E@ D@ FB

LP8:8BJbE !D@E@D 8;8D BLQ<E@E;@I .FE @B@ IFD8EbEbE <JB@J@


B8;8I G8I8 ><K@ID<;@c@E@ J<E ;< 9@C@PFIJLE UWYE:Y #YM<IK< @J<
I<;;<;@C;@ \
[? ;8?8 @P@ P8 PPP\ #<EW 8;8D 98fbEb LcLfKLI;L
[LEL;8E<;<EP8GKbE\
[SYEBY J<E@ J8B8KC8D8;8E @JK<;@c@D B8;8I f@;;<KC< MLI

89@C<:<c@D K<B P<I B8=8E e@D;@ 9<E@ ;@EC< +BLPL:LC8I J<E@E F


DF;8Jb ><WD@f (<K@K@8 -<PEFC;JLE;8E 9bBKbC8I *<;<E FELE
_8CKbE 9@I C8W >@9@ G8IC8P8E J8Ib 9LBC<C@ 98fbEb >8Q P8cbE8 JFB

DLPFIM<9@I@9I@KBLKLJLELB8GDbPFIJLE\
[D8 &LE< 9<E F K@G@ ><IW<B 9@I @EJ8E;8E @C?8D 8C8I8B P8I

8KKbD +J<EJ@E\
[#I8?8D FD $8B8I<KC<I@E@ ;@EC<P<:<B ;<c@C@D L>YEYE
:FC@J@P< IFD8E G@P8J8Jb ?8I<B<KC@ @?K@I8JCb ;YIYJK 9@I 8fB8 ;FcIL
PXE<C@PFI 1< J<E ?VCV P<I@E;< J8PbPFIJLE <f PbC XE:<B@ F @W
98PbCKb:bK8KCbIFD8EK@QD;<E9@IKYICYM8Q><WD@PFIJLE \
[D8-<>@E8C;;<)<@JK<IbEB8I8BK<I@9XPC< \
[+ ?8C;< FELE B8I8BK<I@E@ ;<c@fK@I @EC< $@BVP<P< .8E:?8
-F;I@>L<Q@ B8KKbE dP@ <E FEL 9<c<E;@D 'bQ )<BJ@B8CbP;b
K<fC@ @?K@I8JCb M< ?<P<:8ECb M< ;< )<@JK<I8 ;8 VfbBKb .<E E<
P8GKbE < )<@JK<I XE:< WFB B@98I 9@I 9<P<=<E;@ >@9@ ;8MI8E;b
.FEI8;8J<EBbQb?@BVP<E@EFIK8JbE;8XC;YI;YE \
[$bDD ECbPFILD < )<@JK<IbE B<E;@E@ 9bI8BbM<ID<J@
J<E:<;8?8@P@D@FCLI@I@B@XGY:YB \
&LE< >YQ<C ;@fC<I@E@ M< >YQ<C PLDILBC8IbEb JbBKb [? J<M

>@C@D 8fBbE >XQY BXI FC;LcL @W@E E< B8;8I J<M@E;@c@D@




9@C<D<QJ@E !c<I >XQC<I@E@ ?8=@=W< 8I8C8J8P;b F Q8D8E ?@W9@I


f<P< ;8P8E8D8Q;bD LI8P8 98B ><I@ Q<BVCbC8I BI8Cb <
)<@JK<IC8 -F;I@>L<Q@ 9@I9@IC<I@E< 8fbB <;<:<BJ@E dB@J@ 9YKYE IF

D8E 9FPLE:8 9@I 8fB D8:<I8Jb P8f8P8:8BC8I + BFIBLEW


(<K@K@8Eb 9@I D8E8JKbI8 B8G8K89@C@IJ@E 58K<E J<E@E P8Q;bBC8IbE8
98BbCbIJ8D8E8JKbI;8;8?8I8?8K<;<I \
[.<E@E ?@W9@I f<P;<E ?89<I@E PFB K8KCbD JCbE;8 -<>@E8C;
;< )<@JK<I (<K@K@8 -<PEFC;J8 VfbB M< FEL @JK@PFI + -F;I@>L<Q
;<E<EBbQ8;<c@C \
[*<I<;<E9@C@PFIJLE\
[LELB<E;@J@JXPC<;@ \
['@DJXPC<;@\
[-<>@E8C;;<)<@JK<I \
[$8E>@-<>@E8C;;<)<@JK<I\
[<E@D-<>@E8C;;<)<@JK<IbD \g
[*<;<D<BJ<E@E-<>@E8C;;<)<@JK<IbE\
[<E@D 8.5.2 FC8E-<>@E8C;;<)<@JK<I \
&LE< 8P8c8 B8CB8I8B 9@IB8W ;<=8 ;<I@E ;<I@E JFCLB 8C;b
.FEI8 WFB J8B@E 9@I J<JC< [eLE8 98fbE;8E 98fC8P8CbD \ ;<;@
@I 8E >XQ;<E B8P9FC;L JFEI8 <C@E;< 8JG@I@EC< ;XE;Y ['@K8

GC8IbE;8B@ 9@I K@G FC8E J<E@E -<>@E8C; ;< )<@JK<I B<E;@J@ J8E8
(<K@K@8-<PEFC;J8VfbBFC;LcLELJXPC<;@ TPC<D@\
[!M<K XPC< \
&LE<8JG@I@E@PLKKL
[e<P 9LEL J8E8 8WbBC8P8:8cbD &LE< +ELE 98E8 8WbB

C8;bcb >@9@ YKYE K@GC<I 8JCbE;8 P8fbPFIC8I $@W FCD8QJ8 P8Q8I

C8IbE B8=8JbE;8 D8 @EJ8EC8I FEC8I8 ><IW<BK<E @E8ED8P8


98fC8;bBC8Ib Q8D8E 9L IFD8E B8?I8D8EC8Ib :8EC8EbM<I@PFIC8I
SYEBY @EJ8EC8IbE @E8E;bBC8Ib f<PC<I ><IW<B J8PbCbI 58K<E M8I FC

D8BE<;@IB@\
&LE<LE ;L;8BC8Ib K@KI<D<P< 98fC8;b [? #I8D@< CYK=<E
9XPC< BFELfD8 .<E@ KbD8I?8E<P< B8G8KbIC8IJ8 8EE<D J<E@EC<
<MC<ED<D<B<J@EC@BC<@Q@EM<ID<Q \


[/8EIb 8fBbE8 9<E@ #I8D@< ;@P< W8cbID8 &LE< dE8E 98E8


F FI8;8P;b 8E8 E<C<I P8QD8D ><I<BK@c@E@ JXPC<D<P< W8CbfbP

FI;L *8JbC P8QD8D ><I<BK@c@E@ ;< + ;8 ?<D<E ?<D<E J<E@E


B8;8IBXKYP;Y ? 9<9<c@D CYK=<E8cC8D8 \
[cC8D8D8B <C@D;< ;<c@C B@ <E ?<I Q8D8E J<E@E ;<C@
FC;LcLEL ;YfYE;YD D8 8JC8 J<E@E )*1. FC;LcLE8
@E8ED8;bD
[,<BVCV 9L E<P@ ;<c@fK@I@I B@ IKbB 9LE;8E JXQ <KD<P<

C@D <E 8IKbB ?@W GFC@J@P< IFD8E P8QD8P8:8cbD .FELWK8 \


48Q8I 9@I8Q X=B<C<E;@ LE8 ?8BB@ FC;LcLEL ;YfYEYPFI;L []
B<E;@ P8I8KKbcbD K@G 0*3). K@G@D 98E8 E< P8GD8D ><I<B

K@c@E@ JXPC<D<P< B8CBKbcb Q8D8E @f WbcIbE;8E WbBDbf


;<D<BK@I \\
&LE< D<E;@C@E@E YQ<I@E;<E FE8 98BKb [+ELE ><IW<BK<E ;<
)<@JK<IFC;LcLELE<I<;<E9@C@PFIJLE\
[? /8EIbD /YIB J@>8I8JbEb <C@E@E YQ<I@E< MLI;LcL M<
QYGG< 9@I dE>@C@Q >@9@ BFELfD8P8 98fC8;bcb Q8D8E =<C8B<K@E <E
9YPYcYEYEFC;LcLEL8EC8;bD \\
/<C<=FE W8CD8P8 98fC8;b &LE< P<I@E;<E =bIC8P8I8B
[.8BbE 8WD8 #I8?8D $<I?8C;< 8BbC ?8JK8E<J@E;<E 8IbPFIC8I
+EC8I8 J<E@E 9LI8;8 FCD8;bcbEb JXPC<P<:<c@D CF CF ?
8P )8: LEC8G \\ 'bQ I8?8K 9@I E<=<J 8C;b !C@PC< 8Cb:bPb B8G8

P8I8B 9FcLB 9@I J<JC< [L 9@I KLQ8B FC89@C@I \\ ;<;@ [CF
8P )8: LEC8G $8PbI 9LI8;8 ;<c@C 48IbE XcC<P@E
)8IK@E;< +E8 JXPC<I@D '@D@EC< '@D@EC< B@D@EC< \\
/<C<=FEL9@I;<E9@I<B8G8KKb
[#I8?8D P8IbE 8P )8: LEC8GC8 XcC< P<D<c@
P@P<:<BD@fJ@E
[$<J89bFX;<IJ<E:8BFQ8D8EI8QbFCLILD \
&LE<LE @I@ D8M@ >XQC<I@ ;8?8 ;8 @I@C<f@G D8M@C<fK@ [1< -<

>@E8C;;<)<@JK<I;8J@Q@EC<9@IC@BK<P<D<BP@P<:<BD@f \\
[*<-<>@E8C;;<)<@JK<Ib\
[.<E@E-<>@E8C;;<)<@JK<IbE \\


[<E@D-<> \\
[? #I8D@< P8GD8 \\ 'bQbE >XQC<I@ ;FC;L [EC8DbPFI
DLJLE e@D;@ @B@D@Q@ 9@I;<E KbD8I?8E<P< B8G8K8:8BC8I #I8D

@< 1< 8P )8: LEC8Gb ;8 $<I?8C;< ?<G@D@Q@ ;LM8IC8Ib


B8G@KFE< BLD8f B8GCb 8PEb ?Y:I<P< 8K8:8BC8I ? #I8D@< YW
B@f@ =8QC8 B8C898CbB ;<D<BK@I \ 4YQYEY 9LILfKLILIB<E P8fC8I
P8E8BC8IbE;8E8BD8P898fC8;b

#I8?8D FD CFB8EK8P8 >@I;@c@ Q8D8E #I<N .


)8: LEC8GbE D8J8;8 P8CEbQ FC;LcLEL >XI;Y L . E@E
.<IJ<D@E 98f?8I=@ FC;LcL @;;@8C8Ib @cI<EW 9@I P8C8E L @=K@I8Pb
;YfD8EC8IbP8PbPFI L;LILD#I8?8D`b9@I8EJ<M@E;@I;@
EC8P8:8cbEbQ )8: LEC8G P8CEbQ FC;LcL ;<c@C ;< )<@JK<I
FI8;89LCLED8;bcb@W@E
)8: LEC8G >XQCYcYEYE YQ<I@E;<E P8Q8I8 98BKb M< 9@I B8I8

:@c<I ?8Gb PLKKL !E J<M;@c@ f<B<I;@ 9L FELE [$8? <D<B


><C;@E 8E8 P8GKbcbE F K8KJbQ f8B8 ;8 E<;@I < )<@JK<IbE ><I

W<B FC;LcLEL JXPC<P@G 9<E@ LP8ID8;8E FEL 98fbD8 J8ID8P8

:8BKbE $@W FCD8QJ8 XEC<D 8CbI;bD @I BFILPL:L KLK8I;bD @I


K898E:8J8KbE8CbI;bD \
[+><IW<B;<c '8?I<KJ@E+ELEP8IbJbJ<E@E=@BI@E;@ \
)8: LEC8G X=B<PC< [dfK< 9L BLIL @=K@I8 \ ;@P< B8IfbCbB M<I;@
[$<D E< ;<D<B F ><IW<B ;<c@C '<E;@E@ K8EbKKbcb Q8D8E YW
B8I8:@c<I ?8Gb 9@I;<E 8C;bD 8D8 F P@E< ;< FIK8;8E B8P9FCD8;b
UW ?8GbE E< ;<D<B FC;LcLEL 9@C@PFI DLJLE J<E dWK@c@D F KYI;<
B8I8:@c<I ?8Gb 9@I =@C@E 9@C< FIK8;8E B8P9FCD8JbEb J8cC8I #<IW<B
;<c@CJ< <E 9LEL WFB @P@ 9@C@PFILD + ;FBKFILE XCD<J@E@ ;<
;@C<I@D\
#I8?8D PFI>LE PFI>LE [D8 F P@E< ;< J8;<:< 9<E@D B8

=8D;8P8fbPFI \;<;@
[+ELE B8=8E;8 M8I FC;LcLEL 9@C@PFILD 1< B8=8Eb .8= <J@E
M<dC8W'FEKIFC48J8JbE8LP8I8B@P@:<@E:<C<D<C@C<I \
#I8?8DbE 8BCbE8 8PEb 8E;8 9@IB8W E8Q@B :<M8G ><C;@ 8D8


JFEI8 9LEC8I dE>@C@Q:< <KB@C@ BY=YIC<IC< ;FCL FC;LBC8Ib @W@E ?@W9@I@E@


BLCC8ED8;b *< ;< FCJ8 9@I P8PbE:b BY=I< E< B8;8I C8PbB FCLIJ8
FCJLE P@E<;<9@IP8PbE:bP;b
#I8?8D [+ ?8C;< f@D;@ FIK8P8 fXPC< 9@I JFILE WbBbPFI ;<;@
[ <)<@JK<IbE8JbC;<=<;<:<c@Q\
[ < )<@JK<Ib ;<=<KD<B D@\ )8: LEC8G @IB@C@IB<E >XQCYcY
9LIELE;8E B8P;b M< FEL ?<D<E K<B <C@PC< P8B8C8;b LP>L

C8IbEbE <KB@J@PC< 9FcLBC8fDbf 9@I J<JC< <BC<;@ [+EL ;<=<KD<B


@JK<P<E
B@D\
[ <)<@JK<IbE<KI8=K8;FC8fD8JbEbDb@JK@PFIJLE\
)8: LEC8G K@KI<D<C<I 8I8JbE;8 [/8EIb BFILJLE \ ;@P< @E

C<;@ ['8PbE9@I8;<I@DFELEP8EbE;89@ID<C<B>@9@B8CbPFI \
[+ELEB@K8GC8IbDbE;bfbE;8?@W9@I@f@PFB \
[8E8 JFI8IJ8E FELE J<E@E B@K8GC8IbEbE @W@E;< ;< 9@I @f@ PFB
.<E@E B@K8GC8IbEb FBLD8P8 98fC8P8Cb ;FBKFILD @C8WC8IbD8 9X9I<B
?8GC8Ib M< XBJYIYB fLIL9LEL ;8 <BC<;@ \ )8: LEC8G J88K@E<
98BKb M< 9@I 9X9I<B ?8Gb 8C;b [!E 9YPYB ;YfD8EbD 9@I PbC @W@E
P8PbE:bCbBP8GD8Pb;<E<J@E >YEYEY>XIYI \
#I8?8D J89bIC8 [+ ?8C;< ;< )<@JK<Ib ;<=<KD<P@ E<;<E
@JK<D@PFIJLE\;@P<JFI;L
[SYEBY9L?8I@B89@II<BC8D\
#I8?8D8;8D89Ff>XQC<IC<98BKb
[ @EC< 8fB8 ?8E>@ P8Q8IbE ><IW<B 9@I ;<;<BK@=@ M8I #I8

?8D @c<IC<I@E@E ?<GJ@ ?8P8C YIYEY LEL ?<IB<J 9@C@PFI D8


J<E@EB@ J<E@EB@ ><IW<B +ELE :@E8P<K M8B8C8IbEb WXQD<J@E@
J8cC8IbQ #8Q<K<C<I ;< FE;8E LQLE LQLE JXQ <;<IC<I <
)<@JK<I !DE@P<K )Y;YICYcYEY >YCYEW 9@I ;LILD8 ;YfYIYI
1< \
#I8?8D )8: LEC8GbE JXQYEY B<JK@ [L f@D;@P< B8;8I BL

C8BC8IbDbB@IC<K<EK<BC@=C<I@E<EDYJK<?:<E@\
[L9@Q<G8I8B8Q8E;bIbI \
[,8I8?<If<P;<c@C \


[8E8 G8I8;8E ;8?8 XE<DC@ FC8E 9@I K<B f<P@ JXPC<


$@fff \ 48PbE:b #I8?8DbE JFC 8P8B 9@C<c@E< XPC< 9@I K<BD< 8KKb
B@ 8Q B8CJbE B<D@c@E@ BbIbPFI;L .FEI8 8:8@G 9@I 9@W@D;< >YCYD

J<P<I<B8P8c8B8CBKb [8P;<)<@JK<I\
0PLfLBW8 9@I J<J ;LPLC;L [SFB YQ>YEYD ;FJKLD /8D
Q8D8EbE;8 ><C<D<;@D .YIYPC< I8E;<MLD M8I;b $<I?8C;< WFB
JbBbC;bEbQ \
#I8?8D FIELE BLC8BC8Ib K@KI<D<P< 98fC8DbfKb 48Q8I
FDQLELE YQ<I@E;<E 98BKb M< ><I@P< ;FcIL ;<MI@C;@ dJB<DC<;<
FKLI8E 9@I @EJ8E ><I@P< ;FcIL E< B8;8I ;<MI@C<9@C@IJ< -<>@E8C;
;< )<@JK<I JFE >XIYEYfYE;<E 9<I@ DFEFBC ;8 K8BD8P8
98fC8DbfKb 1< :8DbE >XC><C<;@c@ >XQC<I@ @EJ8EbE B8EbEb ;FE;LI

8:8B>@9@P;@
< )<@JK<I P8Q8Ib B8PbKJbQ:8 J<C8DC8;b [Q@Q@D 28KJFE
.<E@EC<9LCLfKLcLD@W@EJ<M@E@PFILD .<M@ED<B;<E<B<C@D<\
#I8?8D D<I8BC8 [.<E E<;<E :<?<EE<D FCDLPFIJLE\ ;@

P<JFI;L
[Q@Q;FJKLD ? 8Q@Q;FJKLD \
)8: LEC8G P8A8E;8E >YC;Y [dfK< 9<E 9XPC< f<PC<I<
98PbCbIbD e8B8C8I /8BbCD8C8I XPC<:< ?<I f<P 98fbE;8E @K@98I

<E?Ff9@I?8M8P89YIYEDYfFCLI e@D;@@f@D@Q<98B8CbDDb\
[/89@@ 4<D<BC<I@E ><CD<B YQ<I< FC;LBC8IbEb LD8IbD +
?8C;< 9<E 9@I f@f< f8I8G JXPC<P<P@D $<I Q8D8EB@E;<E $8IIP \
#8IJFE D8J8EbE 98fbE;8E 9<BC<D<BK<E M8Q><W<I<B J8EB@ LWKL
S89L:8B ><I@ ;XE;YcYE;< <C@E;< 9@I f@f< M8I;b e@f<P@ 8W8I8B
9@IB8;<?<f8I8GBFP;L
< )<@JK<I Q8I@= 9@I K8MbIC8 f8I8GK8E 9@I PL;LD 8C;b [-F

D8EC8IbE;8 JbB JbB 9L CFB8EK8P8 ><CD<D@ P8QD8E 9YPYB @E:<C@B


8Q@Q ;FJKLD L f@D;@ 9@C< ;FcIL M< WFB ;8 LP>LE #8IJFEC8IbE
?<GJ@ 9<E@ K8EbPFIC8I 8P )8: LEC8G 8P FIELE ;< )<@JK<I
IFD8EC8IbEbEP8QbCD8Jb><I<BK@c@E<@BE8<KK@E@QJ8EbIbD \
)8: LEC8G [!M<K \;<;@
#I8?8DJ8 [$8PbI \
 

)8: LEC8G [+E8 8C;bID8PbE \ ;@P< 98cbI;b ['8GI@JC@ F


48Q8IC8Ib9@C@IJ@E@Q \
#I8?8D [+E8 8C;bID8 \ ;<;@ [+ELE B8=8Jb D@BIFJ<=8C L
P8PbE:bC8Ib9@C@IJ@E \
[LI8P8 98B ;FJKLD #8C@98 8P )8: LEC8G J8E8 @E8K
<;<IJ<BXKY9@If<PC<IFC89@C<:<c@E@JXPC<D<;@ \
#I8?8DE8Q@BE8Q@B [TIE<c@E 8Q@Q9X:<c@D\;<;@
[e<P $@W?8P8C<KC<IK8I8=bE;8E@QC<E;@c@EFC;LDL\
[48E@9@I@8IB8D;8EP8BC8f8:8BM< _X?;@P<:<B XPC<
Db\
[? 8Q@Q ;FJKLD P8GD8PbE :8EbD <E 9LE;8E ;8?8
@E:< PXEK<DC<I BLCC8EbIbD 1< 9@I@E@ WFB P<E@ M< D<;<IE PXE

K<DC<IC< @QC<I@D TIE<c@E ?@W B@f@C@c@E@E 9FcLC;LcL FC;L DL\


<)<@JK<IG@JG@J>YC;Y
L >YCYfY K8Eb;bB ><C;@ #I8?8D8 .FEI8 P8Q8I ?<I f<P@
?8KbIC8;b L >.+81.08*.3&<*8 IFD8EbEbE  J8P=8JbP;b
!"*2'*1 ,B=0&5&01&6G3G &AG5 0&5&88G &+.
+A* :* &-*301. '.6 7*71* ,C1C<46)9 .6 8*0
0*1.2* 7B<1*2*2.K8. &2& &30 &6714;*
41)9H9 <*6)* 'C=C1)C  -&+.+ ,C1CK8* ,.=1.
'.6 ,CA  8*-).8 :&6)G I6. <&6G A.+8A. )* '9
<C=)*3 7.1&-1&6G3& 9=&32&<& (*7&6*8
*)*2*).
#I8?8D8 9L ?VCV G@J 9@I >YCYfDYf >@9@ ><C@PFI;L D8
FC;LcL P<I;< 9YQYC;Y M< J@C8?C8IbE8 LQ8ED8P8 :<J8I<K
<;<D<;@
)8: LEC8G 8E@ J<JJ@QC@c@E P8I8KKbcb >XC:Yc< B<E;@J@E@ 8KKb
[#XIYPFIJLE P8 #I8?8D $8P8C<KC<IC< FPLE FPE8D8P8 E<
><I<B M8I $8P8C<KC<I D8EKbBCb P8I8KbBC8I J8PbCD8QC8I
.FELWK8 FEC8I .37&3 ;<c@CC<I !c<I ;8?8 =8QC8 K<C@= Y:I<K@
@JK@PFIJ8E \
#I8?8D G8KC8;b [IKbB G8I8;8E JXQ <KD<BK<E M8Q><W<I



D@J@E <E 9LE;8E JFEI8 J8IJb:b @EJ8E ;LP>LC8IbPC8 @C>@C@


9YPYB<J<IC<IP8Q8:8cbD \
)8: LEC8GbE BbQ8IDbf PYQYEYE @=8;<J@ 9@I;<E9@I<
;<c@f@M<I;@ [+CD8Q \
[e@D;@ BFELPL ;<c@fK@ID<B @W@E \ 48Q8IbE J<J@ G<B
K8KCbC8fKb .8EB@ ?<I B<C@D<P< 98C 9LC8fDbfKb ?<GJ@ ;< P8Gbf
P8Gbf FCDLfC8I;b [8BD8E @W@E IFD8E K8JC8cbEb ><K@I;@D \
/<I @W@E;< B8CDbf FC8E )8: LEC8GbE P8B8JbEb JbBb:8 B8MI8;b
[<E 9L IFD8Eb K8D 9<f PbC;8 P8Q;bD L <J<I ?<P<:8E
;FCL ?8M8JbPC8 J<E@ <KB@J@E< 8C8:8B .<E@ KV IL?LELE ;<I@EC@B

C<I@E< B8;8I J8IJ8:8B L IFD8E XEYE;< P<GP<E@ 9@I


;YEP8EbE8WbCD8JbE8E<;<EFC8:8B 1<9L<J<I \
)8: LEC8G [$8PbI \;<;@
[L <J<I 9L ;YEP8EbE J8?K< P8EbEb G8IW8 G8IW8 <;<:<B
LIFD8E><IW<c@;<C@G><W<:<B LIFD8E \
)8: LEC8G <CC<I@E@ ;8?8 =8QC8 ?8M8P8 B8C;bI8D8;bcb @W@E
K8JC8cb8CD8BQFILE;8B8C;b [$8PbI \
#I8?8D ['8?IFC8Jb:8 P8I8KbB FEL E<;<E FBLDLPFI

JLE\;@P<JFI;L
[e@D;@D@FBLP8:8cbD\
[$@WFCD8QJ898fC8 \
[ @EC< <E <E @P@J@ 9LEL P8IbE M< ?8KK8 X9YI >YE FBLILD
e@D;@XBJYIYBfLIL9LDL@WD<D><I<B@PFI \
[<E9LI8P8><C<C@9<I@9@I;<=8FCJLEXBJYID<;@E \
[.8E8=@BI@D@?<D<E9@C;@I@I@D  \
#I8?8D [@fK< 9L 9@I@E:@ J8P=8 \ ;<;@ [*<;<E 98fC8DbPFI

JLE.<E@?<D<E<KB@J@E<8C8:8B \
)8: LEC8G 9@IB8W :YDC<P@ FBL;L [0 BXDYI D8;<E@ FC8E
9@IB8J898;8Db><W@PFI\
[!M<K
[+?8C;<9<E9LIFD8EbFBLP8D8D 'XDYIKFQLE88C<IA@D
M8I \
[D89L><IW<BBXDYIKFQL;<c@CB@ )8:?D8B\
 

48PbE:b [ < )<@JK<I @W@E ;< 8PEb f<P@ JXPC<D@fK@E \ ;@P<


?8KbIC8KKb
-<>@E8C; ;< )<@JK<I 9@I J@>8I8Pb :@;;@ 9@I K8MbIC8 <C@E@E YQ<I

@E< MLI;L #I8?8D ?<D<E 9LELE 8E@ 9@I B8I8Ib 8WbBC8;bcbEb


?8KbIC8;b < )<@JK<I [@C@PFI DLJLELQ 9YKYE 9LEC8I WFB @W
JbBb:b \ ;@P< DbIbC;8E;b [@I KYICY BFELP8 >@ID@PFIJLELQ
$8P;@ 8P )8: LEC8G '8I8IJbQ:8 ;8MI8ED8EbE Q8D8Eb
;<c@C \
)8: LEC8G ?8QbICbB FC8I8B ?8P8C@E;< BFCC8IbEb JbM8;b
[,<BVCV 8P FD J8E8 @P@ ;8MI8ED8EbE ?@W9@I P8I8Ib PFB
8E8 ;< )<@JK<I P<I@E< BXDYI KFQL M<I@PFIJLE .FE <CC@ PbCbE <E
DYK?@f I<BC8Db P<I@E< KFGCLDJ8C XE<D@ FC8E BFELC8Ib ,<BVCV
8P 0B8C8 FD 9@I ?8=K8 @W<I@J@E;< 9<E@DC< 8EC8fD8Q LP>LE
f8IKC8IC8 8EC8fD8QJ8E J<E@ B8I8 C@JK<P< 8C;bI8:8cbD $<D
D<I@B8 @IC<f@B <MC<KC<I@ M< ?<D ;< ;bf8Ib;8 ?@W9@I J8cC8D
P8PbE<M@ B@K8GC8IbEb 98JD8P8:8B \ @I 8E ;LI;L M< G8ID8cbEb
J8CC8P8I8B?8PBbI;b [dJB8E;@E8MP8;8;8?@C \
#I8?8D FD B8PbKJbQ:8 >YC;Y [$b? $8? <E 48Q8IC8I
.<E;@B8JbEbE PXE<K@:@C<I@E;<E@D <E@ QFIC8D8P8 B8CB8IJ8E 8JbC
9<E 7*3. B8I8C@JK<P<8C;bIbIbD *8JbC 9<c<E;@ED@\
[SFB 9<c<E;@D SYEBY J<E@E IFD8EC8IbEb W8C;bcbEb
B8EbKC8IJ8D \
#I8?8D @EC<;@ [<E@D D@\ '8?B8?8Jb PYQYE;<E 9FcLC

D8BK8E QFI BLIKLC;L [<E@D fL JFE FE PbCbE <E FI@A@E8C


P8Q8IbEbE\
[TPC< D@ <CB@ J<E 9@I f<P@ LELKKLE $<I IFD8EbE;8 ;<
)<@JK<IbE ;@c<I M8B8C8IC8 @C>@C@ EFK ;<=K<IC<I@E;<E JXQ
<;@PFIJLE \
[! E<FCDLf

[*< FC8:8B + EFK ;<=K<IC<I@ FE;8 -<>@E8C; FcCLD 8P


FIE8 WXQ;YcYEYQ JFE <JI8ICb M8B8PC8 @C>@C@ EFK ;<=K<I@E@Q@
>XJK<I@E ! FEL >XIYPFI DLJLE #I8?8D .142*86* "&KG3G3
76&6G LE;8 J<E@E IFD8E;8B@ ?<I FC8P M8I YKYE
 

8PIbEKbC8IbPC8 ?<D ;< UQ<I@E;<B@ K8I@?< ;< 98B '@K89bE P8PbE

C8ED8;8E 9@I PbCXE:< P8QbCDbf 9L EFKC8I L ;<=K<I ><IW<B 9@I


9<C>< \
[4@E< < E<FCDLf\
[+ELE EFK ;<=K<I@E@ BFGP8 <KD<P< M< B@K89bEb _FI@A@E8C <JI8ICb
9@I:@E8P<K;@P<K8EbDC8D8P8?8BBbEM8IDbP;b\
[.<E@ 9<PE@ WF:LB =<C:@E< LcI8Dbf Q8M8CCb + EFK ;<=K<I@ 9<E

@DLP;LID8D;b \
['@D ;<D@f *FK ;<=K<I@E;<B@ ;< )<@JK<IbE <CP8QbJb $<I LQ

D8E 9LEL BFC8PCbBC8 B8EbKC8P89@C@I D8 9<CB@ ;< J8E8 FELE EFK
;<=K<I@E@ BLCC8ED8 ?8BBbEb M<I<E BYWYB 9@I BVcbK G8IW8Jb M8I
$8E@fXPC<BYWYB9@IBFEKI8KP8;88EC8fD8 \
[dEJ8E?8P8C@9@IK@GC<E8JbC8EC8fD8@DQ8C8I\
[$8E>@?8P8C@K@G\
[.<E;<9<E;<)<@JK<IbEM8IFCD8;bcbEb9@C@PFILQ \
[? 8D8 9@I AYI@E@E YP<C<I@ 9LEL 9@C@PFIC8I Db <E K8EbB
P<I@E< WbB8I8B YW B8I8:@c<I ?8Gb 8CD8D8 I8cD<E FELE FIK8;8E
B8P9FCD8;bcbEb 8EC8KKbcbD Q8D8E ?8E>@ FE @B@ B@f@ ;< )<@JK<IbE
M8IFCD8;bcbEbJXPC<P<9@C@I\
[e8EK8A9L \
[.8E8 9@I ?8=K8 Q8D8E M<I@PFILD 8fB8 KYICY JXPC<P<C@D
K8DP<;@>YE \
#I8?8D FIE W8I<J@Q:< ;< )<@JK<I8 ;XE;Y [L @f< J<E ;<
B8IbfKbE '@K8GC8IbD;8 J<E@ JFE ;<I<:<;< f<I<=C@ 9@I @EJ8E FC8I8B
>XJK<I;@D LP8GKbcbEf<I<=C@:<9@If<PD@\
< )<@JK<I FDQLEL J@CBK@ [Q@Q ;FJKLD ?<D 9LEC8I ?<D
;<G<f@E;<9@I?8P8C<K \
#I8?8D8P8c8B8CBKb
[*<I<P<>@;@PFIJLE\
[!M< .8E8 D<BKLG P8QD8P8 \ #I8?8D D<P;8E FBLI:

8JbE8 B8fC8IbEb W8KKb [1< D<BKL9L 9L J<=<I GFJK8P8 M<I<:<c@D


FPLE <cD<P<:<c@D .FELE8 B8;8I J8M8f8:8cbD 1< J<E ;<
)<@JK<I 9@I ?8P8C<K >@9@ G<f@D< K8BbCD8P8 B8CB F Q8D8E


>XIYIJYE '8=8Eb P<I@E;<E BFG8IbI B8EC8IbEb )8: LEC8GbE P<E@


<C9@J<J@E@E YQ<I@E< 8BbKbIbD \ T=B<PC< ;XE<I<B LQ8BC8fKb
'8Gb;8EWbB8I8B>XQ;<EB8P9FC;L
< )<@JK<I @J< ?@W9@I P<I;<E WbBD8;8E B8P9FC;L >XQ;<E
)8: LEC8G P8M8fW8 @EC<;@ .FEI8 8IB8 8IB8P8 9@I B8I8:@c<I M<
9@I9X9I<B?8Gb8C;b YQ<I@E<;<XBJYIYBfLIL9L@WK@

#I8?8D FIE &LE<LE FKLID8 F;8JbE;8P;b /bIE8BC8IbEb


WFBK8E B<D@I@G 9@K@I;@c@ @W@E f@D;@ <BC<D P<IC<I@E@ bJbID8P8 98fCbP

FI;L &LE< F JbI8;8 P8EbE;8 FCD8;bcb @W@E P8Q8I 9LE8 J<M@E@P

FI;L &LE< @P@ 9@I BbQ;b $8KK8 @P@ M< K8KCb 9@I BbQ D8 ><EW
8;8DbEFJbI8;8E@f8ECbJbEb;YfYE;YcYPFBKL
+ELE P<I@E< B8=8JbE;8E JFE 8CKb >YE @W@E;< FC8EC8I 8IB8
8IB8P8><W@PFI;L .8EB@<KI8=8D@BIFGJ8WbPFIC8I;b9LJ8?E<C<I
[$<P #I8?8D ;YE BLCYGK< J<E@E fL FIK8cbEC8 K8EbfKbD
48E@ ;< )<@JK<IC8 )YK?@f fFB ><W@I;@D <E ?<I Q8D8E FELE
.?<ICF:B $FCD<J >@9@ 9@I K@G FC;LcLEL J8EbPFI;LD 18I FCD8P8E
9@I@ FcILJL 9<E@ @P@ B8E;bI;bE FcCLD @C@PFI DLJLE $<P
E<I<P<>@;@PFIJLE\
[$<P FIE G8KIFELE ;< )<@JK<IbE B<EK< ;XE;YcYEY ;LP

;LD $<I?8C;< P8BbE;8 <C@E< P<E@ IFD8EC8I @W@E 9FC D8CQ<D<


><W<:<B FcILJL WFB f8EJCbJbE @I@ BFELC8Ib ?8QbICbPFI .<E ;<
?8QbI8BFELPFIJLE $8dP@P8 >YC<>YC<\
[? #I8?8D ?8P8KbD ;YE ><:< E<IF;<P;@E EE@E G8IK@J@
J<E FCD8;bcbE @W@E G<B JXEYB ><WK@ 8?8 ;FcILJL JXEYB ><W<

:<BK@ 8D8 E<PJ< B@ -<>>@< ;< )<@JK<I ><C;@ + ;8 J<E@ JFI;L


$<I?8C;< 28KJFEJLQ B<E;@J@E@ B8P9FCDLf >@9@ ?@JJ<;@PFI;L
FcILJL XPC< ?8I@B8 9@I@E@E 28KJFECLcLEL P8GD8B &<
FIEL?8B8I<K@E@Q@8PE<E@8;<<;@PFILD\
[ FcILJL 9<E@ B8E;bI;bE <E F WbC>bE:8 f<PC<I@ J<E@E LP

;LI;LcLEL J8EbPFI;LD ! E< ;<D@fC<I #<IW<B ?@BVP<C<I;<E


;8?8;88:8@GK@I $8??8??8\
[,FC@J P<KB@C@C<I@ YECY 8D8KXI BI@D@EFCF> -<>@E8C; ;< )<@JK<I


bE 9L M8B8PC8 @C>@C<E;@c@ JXPC<EK@C<I@E@ P8C8EC8;bC8I )L?89@I@D@Q


8P ;< )<@JK<I8 9L BFELPL JFID8B @W@E B<E;@E@ 8I8;b 8D8 FE8
<I@f<D<;@ '8DL 8P ;< )<@JK<Ib FE @B@;<E =8QC8 :@E8P<K@
;8?@:< WXQ<E B@DJ< FC8I8B K8EbPFI L D8:<I8C8Ib FELE
28KJFEL;<E@C<E8P#I8PC< FFI<IFD8E9@W@D@E;<P8QDbfKb \
#I8?8D YIG<I@PFI BFCC8Ib BFIBLEW 9@I B8E ;XBD< @JK<c@PC<
K@KI@PFI;L < )<@JK<I ><IW<BK<E ;< 9@I ?8P8C<K >@9@ G<f@E@ 9bI8B

DbPFI;L 0JK8CbBC8 P8GbPFI;L 9LEL #I8?8D B@f@C@c@E@ B8P9<K

D<P< 98fCbPFI;L < )<@JK<I ;8 FEL 9XPC< K<?;@K <KD<D@f


D@P;@
#I8?8D P8M8f P8M8f F DFEFKFE Q@C J<J@E@E B8=8JbE;8 WbEC8

D8;bcbEbB8MI8;b @I@B8GbPbW8CbPFI;L
)@JJ &LE< @CC@E>J ;< 8PEb =@B@I;<P;@ 8EC8fbC8E )<I;@M<E;<E
8f8cbP8 K@Q 9@I J<JC< 98cbI;b 48Q8IbE BLC8cbE8 9@I@ 9@I 8G8IBYK @E

;@I;@ J8EB@ [$<P 8?D8B fL B8GbP8 98BJ8E8 eL @f@ K@KI<f@DC<I


<M@PbBD8;8EP8G<EP8IbDJ88KJFEI88f8cbP8@E<I@D \
[,<B@ J<M>@C@D \
#I8?8D8P8BC8IbEbJYIYP<I<B>@KK@M<JFB8BB8GbJbEb8WKb
< )<@JK<I [? K8D8D \ ;@P<I<B FELE P8EbE;8E ><WK@
[.<C8D \
#I8?8D ;FELB >XQC<IC< FE8 98BKb '8E 98fbE8 JbWI8IB<E 9@I
?8PM8E >@9@ ?FDLI;8E;b eXPC< 9@I >FI@C >@9@ ;LI;L XPC< 8EC8I

;8 9L K8MbI B8EC8Ib B8PE8P8E D<I@B8E <IB<BC<I@E@ WFB I8?8K

C8KbI;b 48Q8I9@I8Qf8f8C8DbfFC8E;<;<BK@=@E<KI8=bE;8;XE;Y
[Q@Q ;FJKLD ?8JK8DbJbE\
#I8?8D [<E ?8JK8 ;<c@C@D \ ;@P< 8WbBC8;b [D8 J<E G<B
P8BbE;8 9XPC< f<PC<IC< @C>@C<E<D<P<:<B 9@I ?8C< >@I<:<BJ@E
SYEBY<CC<I@D@B8C9@E@E<EBbIDbQbB8EbPC8PbB8P8:8cbD \
[D8 JFEI8;8E <CC<I@E@ PbB8D8B QFILE;8 B8C8:8BJbE *< ;<
FCJ89LWFB9<C@I>@E9@I@GL:LJ8PbCbI \
[LB8;8IE<f<C@><M<Q<C@BP<K<I.XPC<P<:<BJFEJXQYEM8I
Db\
[,<BPFB \


[0 ;8?8 @P@ .FE JXQC<I@E 9<E@ ?@W @C>@C<E;@ID@PFI \ 48Q8I


>YIYCKYPC< ?8I<B<K< ><W<I<B K8C@?J@Q ;< )<@JK<IbE YQ<I@E< 9@I
<IB<B =@C >@9@ J8C;bI;b < )<@JK<I JFC8 ;FcIL B8P;b @I <C@PC< 8P

8cbEb LQ8KKb #I8?8D ?8M8;8 9@I G8I89FC W@Q;@ XMYf 9@I J@>8I8
D8J8JbEbE W@W<B ;FCL 9@I M8QFELE M< ;LM8IbE 9@I 9LWLB D<KI<C@B
9@I9XCYDYEYEG8IW8C8ED8JbPC8JFE8<I;@
#I8?8D >XQC<I@E@ BbIGKb .FC B8fbE8 K8BbCDbf FC8E D<I8BCb
BbIDbQb9@I98Cbcb8KKb
< )<@JK<I [Q@Q ;FJKLD \ ;@P< DbIbC;8E;b [? 8Q@Q
;FJKLD \
#I8?8D 8E:8B F Q8D8E !.1&-1&6 IFD8EbE;8B@ 9@IB8W :YD

C<P@?8KbIC8;b

! *.78*6G3 7G6G2 ,.'. 0411&6G '.6*6


<G1)G6G2& )B3CK2CK8C 7&30. G=1G :* ,C:*31.
:969K1&61& .0. -&<)9)9 &(.= -&1* ,*8.6).
&<:&3(& '.6 ,CA 0911&32G<46)99)4 04
39793)& 978&1G0 :* '.1,.7. 7&<*7.3)* -&<)981&6G
041&<1G01& <*3).  &6&)& 741901&6G '.1*
7G01&K2&)G&<)981&6(&3&(G7G<1&.31*).1*6E
#I8?8D:8E8:bJbPC8@EC<;@
.8c B8CW8JbEb ?8=@=W< B8C;bI;b M< =<DYIYE P<I@E< B8PD8JbEb
J8cC8;b
[4<I;<EB8CBD8E;8?8;FcILFCD8QDb <JB@;FJK\
#I8?8D >LILIC8 [<E 9LI8;8 9XPC< P8K8:8cbD \ ;<;@
[5<D@E@ GIF=@C;<E @E:<C<P<:<c@D L @f@ LP>LE 9LC;LcLD 8E8
B8;8I P8G8:8cbD 48 ;8 B8JC8IbD;8E 9@I@E@ FPE8K89@C<:<c@D@
8EC8PbE:8P8 B8;8I e@D;@ ?<J89bEb >XID<;<E 98E8 E< @J

K<;@c@E@JXPC< \
-<>@E8C; ;< )<@JK<I DFEFBCLEL ;@BB8KC< K8BKb
[)8: LEC8GbE M<I;@c@ JYI<E@E P8IbE JFE8 <I;@c@E@ ?<I?8C;<
9@C@PFIJLE\


[.<E@E;<FELE;8JFE8<I<:<c@E@LD8IbD \
[/<BI8I;YfYED<P<:<BD@J@E\
$8?\
< )<@JK<I [? E< B8;8I JbBb:b 9@I ;LILD 9L \ ;@P< @W@E@
W<BK@ [L ;YEP8;8 ?<I f<P@ 9<E@D @W@E I8?8K 9@I ?8C< JFBKLE
.FELWK8 B@K8GC8IbE;8 9YKYE BLCYGC<I;< M< CYBJ CFB8EK8C8I;8
?<IB<J@E 9<E@ K8Eb;bcbEb P8Q;bE <C<;@P< 98fB8EbPC8 !DE@P<K
)Y;YIYEYE WFB J8D@D@ ;FJKL FC;LcLDL ;8 ,8IB 8;;<J@E;<
?8I@B8 9@I ;LGC<BJ@D M< f8?8E< 9@I I<J@D BFC<BJ@PFELD
FC;LcLEL ;8 1< f@D;@ 9YKYE 9LEC8I M8I ;FJKLD FcILJL 9L
;LILD9<E@<KB@C@PFI \
#I8?8D ;YfYE:<C@ 9@I K8MbIC8 DbIbC;8E;b [SFB >8I@G .<E@
DYK?@f 9@I ?<P<:8EC8 ?@W ;@EC<D@PFILD UJK<C@B JXPC<;@BC<I@E@E
K<BB<C@D<J@E@9@C<J<W<D@PFILD \
< )<@JK<I [D8 fLEL ;8 @K@I8= <KD<C@P@D \ ;@P<
BFELfD8JbEb JYI;YI;Y ['@K8G ;YEP8D 98E8 ;8?8 LP>LE +
VC<D ;8?8 W<B@:@ dW JbBb:b D8EKbBC8 ?@W9@I @C>@J@ PFB L ;YEP8EbE
><I<BK@I;@c@ f<PC<I;<E ;< LQ8B 'bJ8:8Jb ><I@ ;XED<C@ M<
:@E8P<KC<I< 8BK@= 9@I 9@W@D;< B8IbfD8CbPbD 48IbE8 B8;8I
;YfYE \
#I8?8D bJCbBC8 E<f<C@ 9@I G8IW8 W8C;b L K8D8D@PC< 9<

DFCC<I;<EFCLfLPFI;L [L;8P<E@9@IK<?;@KD@ ;<)<@JK<I\


[!JB@ 9@I K<?;@;@E PFcLEC8fKbIbCDbf 9@W@D@ '@f@C@c@E@E ?<I
8PIbEKbJbEb <C@E;<E 8C8:8cbD .FELE;8 B8DLFPL J<E@ B<E;@ ;<P

@D@EC< ;< )<@JK<IbE BLBC8Jb FC8I8B IFD8E P8QD8P8 QFIC8P8:8B


L>YE >8Q<K<:@ WF:LBC8IbE J8E8 K8BKbBC8Ib 8;b >XI;YE DY <JB@
;FJK\
[!M<K 8P ,@J ;< )<@JK<I PEb >8Q<K<E@E FELE:L J8P

=8JbE;8B@ P8IbD JYKLE P8QbPb ;8 FBL;LE DL +EL J<E@E @W@E FB

LP8:8cbD UECY BI@D@EFCFA@ LQD8Eb J8cC8D WbBKb JB<IC@B eL9<J@


FELEP8BbE;8FI;LP88CbE8:8cbEb9@C;@I;@ \
< )<@JK<I 9@I 8E ?@W9@I f<P JXPC<P<D<;@ @I f<P ;< P8G8

D8;b .FEI8 9@K9@I@ 8I;bE8 fLEC8Ib P8GKb )FEFBCLEL 8cbI 8cbI




WbB8I;b cbI 8cbI FKLI;L 8C>bE ;8C>bE W<E<J@E@ FMLfKLI;L @I


J@>8I8Pb LQLE LQLE <C@E@E YQ<I@E< MLI;LBK8E JFEI8 P8BKb #I8

?8D FIELE P8Q8IC8I8 XQ>Y ;<E<P@DC@ >XQC<I@ 9YKYE 9L


?8I<B<KC<I@E P8I8KKbcb K@G@E J8IJbCDbf M< YQYCDYf FC;LcLEL 8WbB

C8;bBC8IbEbFE8?89<IM<I;@
#I8?8D ;< )<@JK<IbE B@K8GC8IbE ?@W9@I@E;< ;< 9L ;XIK
?8I<B<K@ 8IB8 8IB8P8 P8GD8;bcbEb 9@C@PFI;L .FELE;8 ;<;<BK@=
[@CD@PFILD JFE IFD8EbE;8 E<;<E 8JB<I< >@KD<BK<E JXQ <K

K@E \\ ;<;@ [LEL ?@W 8EC8DbPFILD L Q8D8E8 LPD8 D<I8Bb


?89<IC<I< 8P8B LP;LID8B @W@E ;LPLC8E 9L f<PK8E:8 @JK<B GFC@J@

P< IFD8EC8IbE 9<C8Jb #<IW<B <JI8ICb 9@I IFD8EbE Q8D8EC8 9@I @C

>@J@ PFBKLI .FE FC8PC8IC8 8I8JbE;8 9@I 98cC8EKb FCD8D8Cb;bI


L \\
48Q8I [JB<I;<EB8WD8EbE9@IK<BPFCLM8I \;@P<8WbBC8;b
[$@W FCD8QJ8 9@I E<;<EC< 8JB<I< 8CbE8D8P8:8cbD;8E JXQ
<;<9@C@I;@E \
#I8?8D [JB<I;<E B8WD8EbE 9@I K<B PFCL M8I \ ;@P<
K<BI8IC8;b
<)<@JK<I [LJLWJ8PbC89@C<:<B9@I@?D8C \;<;@
[ @EC<'@K8GC8I8><I@;XE<IJ<E>XM;<EBLIfLEC8;FCD8Q\
[-FD8EC8IbP8Q 9<E;<9LELP8G8PbD \
[.8M8fb;YfYE \
[!>FEL;YfYE \
dB@ >YWCY 8;8D B8Ifb BDfbP8 ;LI;LC8I  8?8 ;FcILJL #I8

?8D P8K8P ;LILD;8 FCD8J8P;b ;LI8:8BC8I;b  dB@J@ ;<


><I@C<D<;@C<I
dfWbBD8Q8>@ID@fK@
&LE< @CC@E>J@E F B8;bE:8 K8KCb J<J@ J8?E<P< 8I8 M<I;@ ><I

>@EC@c@ JFE8 <I;@I;@ [4<I;< E< P8GKbcbEb JFI89@C@I D@P@D #I8?8D


FD 4<IC<I 9L>YE J@C@E;@ L @f@ ;8?8 >YQ<C 9@I ?8C< JFB8IB<E
98E8@CK@=8K<KD@fFCDLPFIJLE \
[<E P<IC<I@ J@CD@PFILD \ #I8?8D P8M8fW8 BFELfLPFI;L
[ @BB8KC< 98B8IJ8E K8GKbcbE E@f8ECbEbE ?<I K8I8=b 9<I<C<ED@f


J8E:bM<8cIbC8I@W@E;<P8KKbcbEb8EC8IJbE \
[.@>8I8D8J8DbD8?M<KD@fJ@E \
[8:8cbDBbIbC;b \
[!EJ<M;@c@DC8D98Db;8 \
[dB@B89LI>8Db;8 \
[1<98CbBB8M8EFQLDL \
[#bIKC8BB<D@c@D@ \
[1<8IB8;8fbEb98E8K8EbKD8;bE \
[1<9FPELD;8B@FDLIC8Ib;8 ?8E>@8IB8;8fbDb\
[L8IB8;8fbEb \
[IB8;8f ?8\ #I8?8DbE >XQC<I@ 9LC8EbBC8fKb &LE< P8f8DbE
J<IK M< 8:b ><IW<BC<I@PC< B8IfbC8f8D8P8:8B B8;8I ><EW M<
E8QCbP;b 48Q8I K@KI<B 9@I J<JC< [0 \ ;@P< DbIbC;8E;b [-<>@E8C;
;<
)<@JK<I \
< )<@JK<I 8PEb 8E;8 9@I J@>8I8Pb FIK8;8E BbI;b L ?8I<B<K
<E;<I@E;LP>LC8I8><9<P;@
&LE<8cbI8cbI [ \;<;@ [.@QJ8E;bcbD;8EWFB=8IBCbJbEbQ \
< )<@JK<I ?<P<:8E LP8E;bI8E PLDLf8B 9@I J<JC< [*8JbC
FC;LcLDLJ8EbPFI;LELQ\;@P<JFI;L
[@CD@PFILD LP;LcLD ?@BVP<C<I;< 8EC8KbC8EC8I;8E WFB
;8?8=8IBCb \
[*<;<EJ< 98E8 (<K@K@K8 -<PEFC;L ?8KbIC8KbPFIJLELQ )@JJ
@CC@E>J \
[$<I?8C;< #I8?8DFK@G@98E898B8I8BP8I8KKbcbEbJXPC<;@ \
[,<B 9@W@DJ@Q 9@I BFGP8 )@JJ @CC@E>J e8fbC8:8B B8;8I
9@W@DJ@Q \
< )<@JK<IC8 &LE< f@D;@ 9@I9@IC<I@E;<E 8E:8B FE 9<f J8EK@D
LQ8BKbC8I 8BbfC8Ib J8EB@ 8PEb D8IB8 Q8DBC8 9@I9@I@E<
P8GbfKbIbCDbfKb #I8?8D K@Q 9@I J<JC< 98cbI;b <CC<c@ 8CEbEbE FI

K8JbE8BFIBLEW9@I;8I9<@E;@I@IB<E?bQC8;FcILC;L
BCbE8 >&29619 J4743 .3&<*8.3)*3 9@I 9XCYD
><CD@fK@ PEb f<P >9-& >.A*H. .3&<*81*6. &68*<
 

BK0C3)*0. *1&0*8 .6 :(G3G3 ?1C2C M< *<&=


06*58* ;< M8I;b 8?8 ;8 BbJ8:8Jb 8PEb f<P< 9YKYE IFD8E

C8I;8I8JKC8E89@C@I;@
D* *.78*6G3 A40 A*0.(. '.6 <&3 :&6)G &)G31&6
43&)&<&3&2G<461&6)GE
#I8?8DbE ;8 9Ff Q8D8EC8IbE;8 ;YfYE;YcY >@9@ &LE<
@CC@EJ;<9@IB8;bE;b
LP;LcL ?8PI8ECbB J8EB@ P8GbfB8E 9@I J<C >@9@ 8BbPFI M< Q<

D@E;<FE9<fJ8EK@DC@B9@IK898B8FCLfKLILPFI;L
48Q8I [L<;8;8E?<D<EWbB &LE< \;@P<<DI<KK@
[SbBD8P8:8cbD \
[8P;<)<@JK<IC8<IB<B<IB<c<BFELfD8D><I<B<E9@If<P
M8I \
<)<@JK<I [(YK=<E>@;@E )@JJ@CC@E>J \;<;@
&LE< ;LI8BC8;b M< JFEI8 G<B ?8=@= 9@I J<JC< [,<BVCV \ ;@P<
=bJbC;8;b
#I8?8D ?8PBbI;b [@I ;8B@B8 +ELE J8E8 <D@I M<ID<J@E<
>XQPLDD8D8CbJbE .<E;<E9LI8;8B8CD8Eb@JK@PFILD\
&LE<;bf8IbWbB8I8BB8GbPb8IB8JbE;8ELJLC:8B8G8KKb
dB@ 8;8D 9@I9@IC<I@E< ;XE;YC<I dB@J@E@E >XQC<I@E;< ;< BXf<P<
BbJKbIbCDbf >YWCY <IB<BC<I< XQ>Y F @=8;< M8I;b PIb:8 @E8KWb
XCYDJYQ 9@I ;YfD8ECbB ;8 dB@J@ ;< 9FPLE <cD<P<:<B
LQC8fD8P8:8BK8I;b #I8?8D FIELE FBLPL:LC8IbE8 ?<I Q8D8E
JLE;LcL J8?E<C<I;<E 9@I@P;@ 9L dB@ >YWCY <IB<c@E 9@I <C 9@I B8CG
9@IBbQ @W@E J8M8fD8C8Ib
dB@J@;<8PEb8E;8 [.<E@EC<8EC8f8CbD \;<;@
#I8?8D [<E@ @BE8 <KK@E -<>>@< \ ;@P< 98fbEb J8CC8;b
[+BLPL:LC8IbDbQbE 9@Q< @?K@P8:b M8I 48IbE P<E@ 9@I ;< )<@JK<I
IFD8EbE8 98fC8P8:8cbD e@D;@ <C JbBbf8CbD M< ><WD@f@
LELK8CbD \
< )<@JK<I ;LP>LC8IbPC8 J8M8fbPFI;L !C@E@ P8Q8IbE P8B8JbE8
BFP8I8B [Q@Q ;FJKLD \ ;<;@ [JbC J<E 9<E@ D8EKbcbEC8 @BE8
<KK@E '<E;@E@ 9<E@D LcILD8 =<;8 <KD<E< @Q@E M<I<D<D dW@E;<



8Wbc8 WbB8IbCD8Jb ><I<B<E ;<c<IC@ f<PC<I M8I 'XDYI D8;<EC<I

@PC< @C>@C@ IFD8EC8IbEb P8QD8CbJbE TE<DC@ FC8EC8I FEC8I 9<E


;<c@C \
[LEL P8G8D8D 8Q@Q ;FJK $<C< 9YKYE 9L P8GKbBC8IbE;8E
JFEI8 <E@D @W@E ?<I Q8D8E XE<DC@P;@E 48IbE P<E@ IFD8E8
98fCbPFILD \
[#I8?8D J<E 9<E@D 9898D J8PbCbIJbE LE8 @Q@E
M<I<D<D $@W9@I ;LP>LD FCD8;bcbEb J8ED8 @I <IB<B <MC8;8
P8Bbf8:8B;LP>LC8IbD \
[D8 J8M8fb ;YfYE .8M8fb ;YfYE ,8IW8C8EDbf BFCC8I M<
98:8BC8I '8EC8I XPC<f<PC<I \
[LI8;8B8CD8CbPbD 18K8EbDbE98E8@?K@P8:bM8I \
[D8 ;< )<@JK<I IFD8EC8Ib P8QD8BK8E M8Q><W<IJ<D J<E
;<JFELE;8FIK8;8EB8CB8IJbE dfK<9<E9LE8@Q@EM<I<D<D \
[? F DL\ < )<@JK<I B8PbKJbQ:8 Q8I@=W< >YC;Y [IKbB
WFB f<P ;<c@fK@ e@D;@ WFB B@DJ< 9<E@D M8I FC;LcLD8 @E8EbPFI
+ PYQ;<E ;< P8f8D8 JbBb:8 J8IbC;bD IKbB 9L 98cb B@DJ< BFG8

I8D8Q +IK8;8EJ@C@ED<BK<EBFIBD8D8><I<BB8CD8;b8IKbB \
[48 ]\ #I8?8D ;@fC<I@E@ JbB8I8B bJCbB W8C8I >@9@ BFELfD8P8
98fC8;b [ <D<B GC8EbE 9L PbC8E &LE<;8E ?FfC8E;bcbEbE
=8IBbE8M8ID8;bcbDbDbJ8EbPFIJLE\
< )<@JK<I 8Q8D<KC< [LI8P8 98B 8Q@Q ;FJKLD \ ;<;@
[#<IW<B M< ;YIYJK 9@I 8fBb BYWYDJ<I:<J@E< BFELfD8E8 @Q@E
M<I<D<D &LE<8 VfbcbD + ;8 9<E@ J<M@PFI LEL 9@C@PFILD
!c<I 9L PYQ;<E 1@:KFI@8 ;<MI@E;<E B8CD8 JbBb:b 9@I@ >@9@ ;8M

I8E8:8BJ8EFQ8D8EE@KIF>C@J<I@E@WM<B<E;@E<9@IW<B@WC<MLI \
[<E J<E@ E@KIF>C@J<I@EC<P<P@D ;< >XI L ><:< <M< >@;<:<B
M< P<E@ 9@I ;< )<@JK<I IFD8EbE8 98fC8P8:8cbD .<E FELE 9@I
G8IW8Jb FC8:8BJbE 1< B@K898 ;XE<:<BJ@E ! 9LE8 E<
;@PFIJLE\
[$@W9@I f<P ;<D@PFILD SYEBY P<E@ 9@I ;< )<@JK<I IFD8Eb
P8QD8P8:8BJbE <E 8IKbB ><IW<B 9@I @EJ8E >@9@P@D 1< 9<E@ @J

K<;@c@E>@9@BFEKIFC<;<D<QJ@E 48J<E9LE8E<;<IJ@E\
 

#I8?8D _9LE8 E< ;@P<:<c@E< 8E:8B 9@I ?8=K8;8 B8I8I M<I;@


IKbB ;YfYE:<C<I@ f8fbC8:8B >@9@P;@ @I B@K898 98JbCD8C8IbPJ8
@DBVEJbQ;b
WbBW8Jb@JK<;@BC<I@E@P8Q8DbPFI;L#I8?8D
48E@ 8BCbE8 9YPYB IFD8EC8I ;LP>LJ8C ;I8DC8I <G@B f@@IC<I
?8I@B8 @E:<C<D<C<I @W@E f8fbC8:8B =@B@IC<I ><C@PFI;L D8 #I8

?8D -<>@E8C;;<)<@JK<I?8BBbE;8?@W9@If<PP8Q8DbPFI;L
48QbD8B@E<J@E;<B@9YPYB-?8I=@B8P9FCDLfKL
#I8?8D 8cCbPFI BY=I<;@PFI J8WC8IbEb PFCLPFI M< G8ID8B
LWC8IbE8 D<I?<D JYIYPFI;L )8B@E< BLIfLEB8C<D DYI<BB<G
B8C<D@ 9FP8B8C<D@ =YQ<EM<B8EC8P8QbP8QD8P8W8CbfbPFI;L
D8P8Q8DbPFI;L
.FEI89@I>YEB8GbW8C;b #I8?8DB8GbPb?bQC88WbM<I;@
)8: LEC8G J<E;<C<P<I<B @W<I@P< >@I@G PbIKbCDbf BVcbKC8IbE
YQ<I@E;<EJ<E;<C<P<I<B><W<IB<EP8Q8IbEBFCC8IbE8PbcbC;b
#I8?8D FEL P<I< PLM8IC8ED8Jb @W@E 9bI8BbM<I;@ #LILIC8
[$8? \;<;@
)8: LEC8G ['8C9@D \ ;@P< @EC<P<I<B 9@I B8I8:@c<I ?8Gb
PLKKL
48Q8I E8Q@B E8Q@B FEL LP8I;b [+I8;8 XC<P@D ;<D< 4XE<K

@:@WXGK<E<B<J@E<@EJ8E<K@8KD8D8@Q@EM<ID@PFI \
)8: LEC8G ?<P<:8EC8 [#I8?8D FcCLD \ ;<;@ [IKbB YC

K@D8KFD PFB /<?;@K ;< L>YE J<E@E F @E:< ;LP>LC8IbE8 ?@K89


<KD<P< ><C;@D #I8?8D \ @I 8E 9FcLC8:8BDbf >@9@ JLJKL
[<E J<E@ FcCLDDLfJLE >@9@ J<M<I@D + ;< )<@JK<I ;<E@C<E
BFB8I:8 FIK8;8E B8P9FCD8Cb <E@D ?8KbIbD @W@E P<E@ ;< )<@JK<I
IFD8EC8Ib P8QD8CbJbE #I8?8D J8E8 D8?I<D 9@I f<P JXPC<P<

:<c@D '8IbD 9L ;<;<BK@=< VfbB FC;L 8E8 IFD8EK@B 9@I <IB<B


FCD8;bcbDb JXPCYPFI <E@ -FD8EK@B ;<c@CD@f@D LEL 8BCbE
8CbPFIDL\
48Q8I KI8A@B 9@I K8MbIC8 [CbPFI \ ;@P< :<M8G M<I;@ [+ 9YKYE
B8;bEC8Ib<KB@C@PFI \
[+PYQC<D@+DFEFBCC8Db\
 

[YKYEB@K8GC8IbD;8XPC<P8QbPFI \
)8: LEC8G ;@BC<fK@ [? P@E< J<E ?D8B @I 8E ;LILG B8

=8EbEP8QbD8B@E<E@EJXPC<;@BC<I@E@B8MI8D8JbE8@Q@EM<IJ<P;@E \
[L BFEL;8 J<E bJI8I <KK@E '8;bE FBLPL:LC8Ib W<BD<D@Q
><I<BK@c@E@ JXPC<;@E \ #I8?8D 8IKbB ?@W9@I f<P< 8C;bI8:8B ?8C;<
;<c@C;@ '8;bEC8I 48Q8I 8:b 8:b >YC;Y '8;bEC8IbE 9@I 9LC;FQ<I@E
;YQ<CKD<P<:<c@?@W9@IBLJLIC8IbPFBKL
)8: LEC8G B8W8D8c8 J8GKb [e<P B8;bE FBLPL:LC8I +EC8I
WFB ><I<BC@ D8 #I8?8D 9<E E< P8G8:8cbD )<J<C< J8;<:<
B8IbD ;<c@C )8: LEC8G e@IB<K@E@E P8IbJb FELE '8IbD 9<E@ K<IB

<;<IJ< f@IB<K@E BFEKIFCL <C@D;<E >@;<I LEL 9@I ;YfYE #I8

?8D LP8PbE;YEP8Jb@W@E9YPYB9@I=<C8B<KFCLI \
#I8?8D [#I<N <JB@ ;FJK \ ;@P< @W@E@ W<BK@ TPC< ;<I@E 9@I
JFCLB 8C;b B@ 8P8B KbIE8BC8Ib D<I?8D<KC< K@KI<;@C<I [!E @P@J@ J8E8
><IW<c@ 8WbBC8D8B FC8:8B *@f8ECbD &LE< ;8 9L JFCL:8Eb J<M@P

FI < )<@JK<I ;< FE8 VfbB SYEBY &LE< (<K@K@8 -<PEFC;JLE


GIFKFK@G@ \
)8: LEC8G >@QC@:< ?8B8I<K< LcI8;bcbE;8E BLfBLC8E;b [(<K@

K@8EbEE<J@\
[FfM<I $8P8KbD D8?MFC;L 9<E@D\ 48Q8I >YC<I<B <IB<BW<
>XQP8fC8IbEb PLKKL D8 F 9LEL P8GbE:8P8 B8;8I @B@ ;8DC8 P8f
9LIELELEL:LE;8EP<I<;8DC8;b
[58M8CCb FcCLD \ dB@8;8D ?<P<:8EC8 9@I9@IC<I@E@E <CC<I@E@
KLKKLC8I
#I8?8D [+@cI<EW:8E8M8I9@Q@:<E;<I<P<JbBbfKbI;b \;<;@
)8: LEC8G [-LJP8;8 B8G8E8 BbJbC8E CD8EC8I;8E
=8IBbDbQPFB \;@P<=@BI@E@8WbBC8;b
#I8?8D [dEJ8EFCD8P8E9@I@9C@J@EBLI98EC8IbPbQ \;<;@
[/89@@ P8 \ )8: LEC8G P8Q8IbE <C@E@ J8EB@ @E<B J8cbPFIDLf
>@9@ JbM8QC8;b [ < )<@JK<I IFD8EC8Ib P8QD8E f8IK +EL :<?<E

E<D;bfbE;88@KFC;LcL@B@E:@P<I<>XE;<ID<C@J@E TPC<;<c@C
Db\
[TPC<8D8BYWYB9@IJFILEM8I \
 

[*<\
[48Q8DbPFILD < )<@JK<I 8IKbB F B8;8I :8ECb B@ FEL B@K898
JFB8DbPFILD \
48PbE:b F Q8D8E P<I;<B@ PbIKbB BVcbK PbcbEC8IbEbE E< 8EC8D8
><C;@c@E@ B8MI8;b 8fbEb <CC<I@E@E 8I8JbE8 8C8I8B @EC<;@
[e@IB<K@D'8IbD\
#I8?8D [/89@@FEL8JB<I<PFCC8P89@C@I@Q \;<;@
)8: LEC8G 98fbEb B8C;bI;b [48 fL @AC3(C C:*68*)*
?1C2 IFD8Eb UW?8=K8XE:<I<;;<KK@c@DB@K8G\
[+ELE XE<D@ PFB + ><WD@fK< B8C;b 8IKbB + IFD8E ;<
)<@JK<Ib<KB@C<;@9@C< \
[48PbEC8ED8;8EDb\
[/89@@ dfK< 9<E F IFD8E;8 8JB<IC@BK<E JXQ <KK@D <
)<@JK<IbEJ8cC8DWbBKbcbEbP8Q;bD \
[<EFCJ8P;bD98fB8f<PC<IP8Q8I;bD \
[)8: LEC8G\ 48Q8I 9@I;<E9@I< P<I@E;<E =bIC8P8I8B
P8PbE:bEbEP8B8JbE8J8IbC;b [<CB@FIFD8Eb;YQ<CK<9@C@I@Q \
)8: LEC8G J8IJbC8 J8IJbC8 XBJYI;Y M< 9FcLB 9FcLB @EC<D

<D<P<;<W8CbfKb
['@K898@JK<;@c@D@Q?<If<P@BFP89@C@I@Q \
)8: LEC8G9FcLCLPFIDLf>@9@9@IJ<JWbB8I;b
[$<If<P@;YQ<CK<9@C@I@Q \
48PbE:bEbEJLI8KbDFJDFIB<J@C;@
#I8?8D :<B<K@E P8B8JbEb M< @W@E;<B@ 8;8Db @P@:< J8IJKb [@I
f<PJXPC<J<E<\
)8: LEC8G FELE <C@E;<E QFIC8 BLIKLC8I8B 9@I WFI98 B8fbcb
XBJYIYB fLIL9L @WK@ !C@E@ B8C9@E< >XKYI<I<B ?8=@=W< MLI;L 8fbEb
J8CC8P8I8B B8fC8IbPC8@f8I<K<KK@
#I8?8D FDQLEL J@CBK@ [!? D8;<D JFDLIKD8B @JK@PFIJLE
XPC<P8G <E;<IFD8EbJ<EJ@Q;YQ<CK@I@D \
48Q8I IFD8E DYJM<;;<J@E@ 9LC;L M< G8ID8BC8IbEb LJLC:8
KLfC8I8 MLI;L ,8ID8BC8Ib >XI<MC<I@E@ ;YQ>YE:< P8GbPFI;L
!BC<DC<I@ ;< W8KbI;8D8;b #I8?8D ?bQC8E;b .FEI8 ;8?8 ;8
 

?bQC8E;b 1< JFEI8 <JB@J@ >@9@ JYI8KC< P8QD8P8 98fC8;b ,FIK8K@=


P8QbD8B@E<J@B<P@=C<QbGC8PbG;LILPFI;L
48Q8I [+CLPFI\ ;@P< 98cbI;b [4<E@ IFD8EC8I P8Q8DbPFILD
8D8P8PbEC8ED8DbfFC8E<JB@B@K8GC8Ib;<c@fK@ID<DDYDBYE \
)8: LEC8G FELE FDQLELE YQ<I@E;<E 98BbPFI 8I8;8 JbI8;8
JFCLB8CbPFI;L

)8: LEC8G [ 8?8?bQCb \;@P<98cbI;b [ 8?8?bQCb\


#I8?8D J<IKW< [+KLQ 9<f B@CFD<KI<;<E ;8?8 ;8 ?bQCb Db >@

;<:<c@Q\;<;@ [/8EIbBFILJLE<f;8B@B8JFEI8K8D8D \
[+I8;8Db;<IJ@E\
[$<I Q8D8E FI8;8;bI L ?8=K8 ?<I 8Bf8D &LE<LE <M@E<
>@KK@ \ 48Q8I ;bf8Ib KYBYI;Y /YBIYcYE< @E:< =@C;@f@ KFQLE8 9<E

Q<I 9@I f<P B8IbfDbfKb #I8?8D XE ;@fC<I@E@E JFE B8CbEKbC8IbEb ;8


>b:bI;8K8 >b:bI;8K8 9XPC< L=8C8DbfKb [D8 J<BI<K<I@E 9L @f@
98f8I8D8QJ8/8EIbP8I;bD:bEFCJLE \
[.<BI<K<I@D<?<IQ8D8E>YM<E<9@C@IJ@E FcCLD \
[ YQ<CK@CD@fIFD8Eb;FBLQ8B8;8IFBLD8Jb><I<B@PFI \
[TCD<QJ< \
[<E;< 9L f8EJ M8IB<E ?<I?8C;< ;YfYG XCYI .<BI<K<I@E FB

L;LBC8IbE8@E8E8:8BDb;<IJ@E\
[$<I B<C@D<J@E< + ;< )<@JK<Ib >XI;Y ;8DbE M8I
FC;LcLEL9@C@PFI \
"I<EC<I >b:bI;8;b #I8?8D K<B<IC<BC<I@E JYIKYED<PC< B8P9<K

K@BC<I@?<IDFC<BYCY;YfYEYIB<EIL?L8EC8PbfC8K@KI<;@
#<EW 8;8D JFEI8 D<I;@M<E;<E BFf8I8B WbBKb )8: LEC8G
;8KFG8CC8P8I8BFEL@QC@PFI;L
#I8?8D Q@C@ W8C;b M< JFEI8 KFG >@9@ @W<I@ ;8C;b ,8ID8cbEb @C<I@
 ;FcIL LQ8KDbfKb '8GbEbE ?<D<E @W@E;< ;LI8E ;< )<@JK<IbE
JLI8KbE8 ><C;@ G8ID8cb <;<BK@= ;< 8E:8B 98fbEb ?bQC8 8IB8P8
8K8I8BK<B>XQCY?8P8C@9@IB8?I8D8EFCD8BK8EBLIKLC;L
&LE<@CC@E>J9@IB<E8I8W<B@C;@ .<JJ@QM<JbBbEKbCbP;b
#I8?8D K<?C@B<C@ 9@I K8MbIC8 [-<>@E8C; ;< )<@JK<I \ ;<;@
 

["<C8B<K@EC<B8IfbC8fD8P8?8QbIC8E \
)8: LEC8G 98cbI;b [? 8? 8? 8fbE XPC< ;<I;< >@I<:<B
B@\
< )<@JK<I [L ;I8D8K@B 8D8 8EC8fbCD8P8E 8WbBC8D8Pb
E<P< 9FIWCLPLD\ ;@P< JFI;L [WbBW8Jb @EJ8EbE 8BCbEb
B8IbfKbIbPFI9L \58I@=9@I?8I<B<KC<9@IJ@>8I8P8B8I8B>YCYDJ<;@
&LE<8cC8I:8JbE8 [)<I?898 #I8D@< \;<;@
[ <=FC @cI<EWB8;bE\
'bQ 9LIELEL W<BK@ '<E;@J@E@ 9@I IFD8E B8?I8D8Eb >@9@
?@JJ<;@PFI;L LP>LC8Ib J8EB@ G8IW8 G8IW8 <;@PFIC8I;b FEL 1<
K89@@ WFB <cC<E@PFI;L &LE< + PYQ;<E YQ>YE 9@I K8MbI K8BbE8I8B
P8fC8IbEP8E8BC8IbE;8E8BD8C8IbE8@Q@EM<I;@
< )<@JK<I PFI>LE PFI>LE ['FELP8 ;XE<C@D \ ;<;@ [*<
FCLPFI\
#I8?8D D@AC3(C C:*68*)* ?1C2 IFD8EbEb P<E@;<E
P8Q;bD \;@P<8WbBC8;b
[!\
48Q8I BFELfD8JbEb JYI;YI;Y [ <c@fK@I@CD@f IFD8E f@D;@
)8: LEC8GbE J<BI<K<I@E@E <C@E;< + <fB@ E@f8ECbD )@JJ @CC@E>J@
8EbDJ8K8E 9@I BbQ 48E@ ><I@ Q<BVCb ;<I<:<J@E< PYBJ<CD<P@ WFB
@JK@PFI 8D8 9LEL ?<EYQ 98f8I8D8;b e@D;@ FBL;LcL ?<I B<

C@D<P<@E8E8:8B \
[!\
#I8?8DbE J<J@ 9@I BXKYCYcY ?89<I M<I@PFIDLf >@9@P;@ [<CB@
.8E:?8-F;I@>L<Q@?8KbICbPFIJLE\
-<>@E8C; ;< )<@JK<I @CB ;<=8 F Q8D8E K@KI<;@ .@>8I8JbEb
;Yf<IB<E QFI P8B8C8;b [+EL 8CKbE:b 9XCYD;< .8D C8B<
XC;YI;Y 'bQ 98E8 VfbBKb Q@Q ;FJKLD ><IW<BK<E ;< 98fbD8
KYICY9<C8J8I;bE \
[? FEC8I f@D;@B@ 9<C8EbE P8EbE;8 ?8=@= B8CbI 8Q@Q ;FJKLD
-FD8Eb;<c@fK@I;@D 1<.8E:?8-F;I@>L<QXCDYPFI \
.<IK 9@I B8;bE J<J@ ;LPLC;L [TCD<B D@ +E8 XCYG
XCD<;@c@D@>XJK<I<:<c@DeLJFE8PE<I<;<P;@E 8CW8B\]
 

< )<@JK<I 9L J<=<I ;Yf<E J@>8I8JbEb P8B8C8P8D8;b $8KK8


9LE8 B8CBbfD8;b 9@C< +IK8P8 WbB8E BbQb K8EbDbfKb ,<f@E P8I>bC8Ib
FCD8P8E 9@I@ @W@E J8;<:< @E:< P8GbCb )<BJ@B8Cb 9@I BbQ;b F ,8IC8B
J@P8? >XQC<I@ LGLQLE bfbCKbCb KbIE8BC8Ib M8I;b D8 ;< )<@JK<I @W@E
F.8E:?8-F;I@>L<Q;@ 1< B12*2.K8.
)8: LEC8GbE J<BI<K<I@ IFD8Eb FBLDLf M< ?<I f<P< ;<
@E8EDbfKb
< )<@JK<I ?<P<:8ECb 9@I J<J M< J<M@DC@ 9@I K8MbIC8 [)@JJ
-F;I@>L<Q \;<;@ [.@Q@>XID<BE<@C>@EW \
[8P8E ;< )<@JK<I ;<D<E ><I<B@PFI 8CW8B !MC<E;@c@D@Q@
LELKKLE DL PbC8E f8cbCbB BXG<B dcI<EW 8BI<G 1< B@D 9L
B8;bE\
&LE<<EP8BbE;8B@BFCKLcLE8IB8JbE8JYQYC;Y
-<>@E8C; P8CM8IbI:8JbE8 [8P8E ;< )<@JK<I \ ;@P<
DbIbC;8E8I8B8:@Q9@IK8MbIC8#I8?8D FIE8;XE;Y
[? ;<D<B 9LEL LELKKLE ?8@E .<E@ K8KCb ;@CC@ 8CW8B .8E8
Q8Pb= 9@I B8;bEb 8C;8KD8EbE E< ;<D<B FC;LcLEL XcI<K<:<c@D
.<E@fLKbIE8BC8IbDC8BbPD8P8G8:8cbD \
<)<@JK<IK<C8fC8><I@C<;@ [D8 J<M>@C@D \
[/8KCbJXQC<I@9@IK8I8=89bI8Bf@D;@LB8;bEC8E<@C>@EM8I\
[D8 J<M>@C@D \
[0P;LID88WbBC8D8C8I@JK<D@PFILD LB8;bEC8E<@C>@E
M8I\
[D8 J<M>@C@D \
['<JJ<J@E@LB8;bEC8E<P8GbPFI;LE\
-<>@E8C; ;< )<@JK<I BXf<P< JbBbfDbfKb )<BJ@B8Cb B8IbJb
PLDILcLELFE8;FcILJ8CC8;b [<M8GM<I\
1<;<)<@JK<IFIK8;8EB8P9FC;L
8P8E;<)<@JK<I;<XPC< $<D<E;<;<BK@=@E8IB8JbE;8E
&LE<@CC@E>J9LB<Q><IW<BK<E8cC8D8P898fC8;b
#I8?8D FIEBFCC8IbEbB8MLfKLI8I8BFE8J<IKJ<IK98BKb
)8: LEC8G<CC<I@E@FMLfKLI;LBK8EJFEI89@I9X9I<B?8Gb
8C;b
 

&LE< [.LW 9<E;< ;<c@C;@ #I8D@< \ ;<;@ [.<E B@K8GC8IbE;8


FELE 9YKYE B8;bEC8Ib W<BK@c@E@ P8QDbfKbE +E;8E ?FfC8ED8D8B
<C@D;< ;<c@C;@ JCbE;8 KV 98fbE;8E 9<I@ FE;8E @W@E @W@E E<=I<K
<;@PFI;LD 8E8@E8EbPFIJLE;<c@CD@\
48Q8I 9@I B8E<G<P< WXBDYf FC8E BbQbE P8EbE8 FKLI;L [?
E< ;< @E8EbC8:8B 9@I ?@BVP< #YQ<C 9@I D8J8C D8 9<CB@ J<E@
8==<;<I@D \
)8: LEC8G K@KI<B 9@I J<JC< [e@IB<K@D@ BLIK8I;bE FcCLD \
;<;@ [/89@@ B8IbDb ;8 1< LELKD8 98E8 ?<I PbC 9@I ;< )<@JK<I
IFD8EbP8Q8:8cbE8JXQM<I;@E \
#I8?8D ;@fC<I@E@ JbBKb [@I K<B 1< FEL @P@:< BbCb9bB

C8fKbI8:8cbD PIb:8 <C@D@E 8CKbE;8 JFEJLQ8 B8;8I P8PbEC8E

D8Dbf 9@I IFD8E FC8:8B *< FCLI E< FCD8Q ;@P< #I<N ;FJKLD
9<E@D:@;;@IFD8EbDb;8P8PbEC8P8:8BJbE;<c@CD@\
)8: LEC8G [#L??? \;<;@
[TPC<;<c@CD\
[!M<K #I8?8D /89@@ #I8?8D '<J@EC@BC< #I8?8D
)L?8BB8B #I8?8D \
[+ ?8C;< 8IKbB 9@Q@ P8CEbQ 9bI8B *@f8ECbDC8 BFELeD8D
><I<B<EXE<DC@BFELC8IM8I \
)8: LEC8G >YCYDJ<;@ M< 8P8BC8IbEbE L:LE8 98J8I8B ;bf8Ib
WbBKb ? 8fB 8fB ;@P< ;YfYE<I<B 9@I B8I8:@c<I ?8Gb ;8?8 8C;b
+ELEYJKYE<;<XBJYIYBfLIL9L@WK@
d-d(de'd+()5

-8G? K@G@B 9@I D<I@B8CbP;b 58D8EbE8 LP>LE 9@I K@G @Q@D


W8cbDbQbE XCWYC<I@E< >XI<PJ< JFE ;<I<:<;< W@IB@E;@ S<E<
B<D@BC<I@ WFB @I@ 9LIEL B8M@JC@ M< ><E@f J@P8? >XQC<I@ ;<
BYWY:YBKY L >XQC<I 9LIELELE ><E@fC@c@ PYQYE;<E 9@I9@IC<I

@E;<E @P@:< LQ8BKb -8G?bE 9FPEL B8CbE >XM;<J@ <EC@P;@ ,8I

D8BC8IbBYK B8M@JC@KbIE8BC8IbPJ8>YWCYP;Y
'8CbE 98:8BC8IbEbE M< K898EC8Ib <KC@ @I@ 8P8BC8IbEbE YQ<I@E;<
;@D;@B ;LI;LcLE;8 9FPL E<I<;<PJ< @B@ PYQ P@ID@ 9<f J8EK@D@
><W<:<BK@ P8BK8 P8 ;8 FKLILIB<E 8cbICbcb 9@I KFELE ;XIK< 9@I@
B8;8I;b
D8 8CEb ><E@f 9@I B8M@J W@Q@PFI;L M< B8=8K8Jb ><E@fK@ e@D;@
P8Qb D8J8JbEbE YQ<I@E< <c@CD@f ;<M <C@PC< B8C<D@ @E:<C@BC< BLC

C8EbPFIM<I8?8KW8W8CbfbPFI;L
JCbE;8 B8IbJb M< ;@c<I D<I@B8CbC8IbE WFcL FELE P8BbfbBCb 9@I
GIB<BFC;LcLEL;YfYEYPFIC8I;b
L Q8D8E <BJ<E@ YQ<I@E;<B@ LQLE 9@I J8GD8EbE B@DP8JbEb
>XJK<I@PFI;L

-8G? &LE@FI 9@Q@D K@G@B D<I@B8CbEbE ;8?8 BYWYB 9@I BFGP

8JbP;b 4<E@ P<K@fD< W8cbE;8P;b M< WF:LBCLB ;<MI<J@E< XQ>Y F


BbCC8I ?VCV M8I;b L BFPL I<EB BbMbI:bB JbB 9@I BYIB >@9@ >XcJYEY
M< JbIKbEb B8GCbPFI;L D8 8IKbB J<PI<CD<P< 98fC8DbfKb 9@C<
-8G? &LE@FI 9<CB@ WC< 9@I PbC @W<I@J@E;< <IB<BC@c@E@E >LILICL Wb

GC8BCbcbEbXIK<:<BFC8EFC>LECLB>XDC<c@E@>@P<:<BK@
D8 F 8I8;8 G8EKFCFELPC8 FKLILPFI M< ;@8=I8DbEbE ?<D<E
YQ<I@E;<B@ 9@I EFBK8Pb K<D9<C K<D9<C B8fbPFI;L dEJ8EC8I
DYQ<;<PB<E 9898JbPC8 FI8P8 ><CD<J@ ?@W ;< =<E8 FCDLPFI;L
*< M8I B@ 9L>YE DYQ< B8G8CbP;b e@D;@ -8G? &LE@FI 9Ff BFI

@;FIC8I;8E><W<IB<E8P8BJ<JC<I@FIK8CbBK8P8EBbC8EbPFI;L
58K<E FI8;8B@ ?<I f<P@ 9@C@I;@ )YQ<;< ;8?8 WFB B<D@BC<I M<
K8fC8IM8I;b
 

&LE@FI [fLE<;@I\;@P<JFI;L
[$8E>@J@\ -8G? 98fbEb B8C;bI8I8B FDQLELE YQ<I@E;<E 98B

Kb .FEI8 ;8 PYQYE;< D<DELE 9@I @=8;< 9<C@I;@ [? F P<E@ 9@I


f<P dCB<C GI@D8K XIE<c@ ,8IW8C8Ib 9@IC<fK@I@G ?<I f<P@E@ FCLfKLI

DLfC8I TIE<c@ 98E8 'LQ<P *<?I@ #IL9LE;8E PFCC8;bC8I *< ?Ff


;<c@C D@\ ECbB 9@I D<DELECLBC8 K<BI8I @f@E< ;XE;Y dCB<C GI@D8K
<E 8f8cb 9@I ?8=K8 ;8?8 >XJK<I@CD<P<:<BK@ -8G?bE FELE P<I

C<fK@I<:<c@ f<I<= BXf<J@E@ ?8QbIC8D8Jb ><I<B@PFI;L S<MI< LP>LE


FCD8CbP;b eL 8E;8 D<;<C -8G?bE J<M;@c@ XQ<C 9@I <fP8 >@9@
9YIFJLE;8P;b 
-8G? &LE@FI @J< 9L _?Ff f<P< 98fB8 ;LP>LC8IC8 98BbPFI;L
#XI;YcY 8f8cbC8E8:8B B8;8I BbJ8 9FPCL JbJB8 @E:< BFC M< 98

:8BCb YQ<I@ BbCC8IC8 B8GCb BYWYB JLI8KCb @I@ G8KC8B >XQCY 9@I
P8I8KbBKb
SF:LB [D8FE<;@I 9898\;@P<bJI8I<KK@
-8G? J89bIJbQ:8 BbDbC;8E;b [+ELE D@CPFEC8I:8 PbC XE:<
P8f8P8E 9@I P8I8KbB FC;LcLEL ;YfYEYPFILQ @Q:< >XIYEYfY
XPC< \
SF:LBbJI8I<KK@ [*<;<E\
-8G? B8Ifb BFPD8BK8E M8Q><WK@ 'FELPL 8PIbEKbC8IbPC8 @P@:<
8WbBC8D8Jb ><I<BK@c@E@ 8ECbPFI;L [e<P @I B<I< B<D@BC<I@E 9@W@

D@E;<E B8JC8IbE E8JbC FC;LBC8IbEb 8ECbPFILQ '@I@fC<I@E E<I<C<I<


LP8:8BC8Ib M< J@E@IC<I@E ?8E>@ EFBK8C8I8 98cC8E8:8BC8IbEb ;8
@fC<I;<E ?8PM8EbE E< KYI 9@I J@E;@I@D J@JK<D@ FCD8Jb ><I<BK@c@E@
XcI<E@PFILQ P8B B<D@BC<I@E;<E ;< ;LILfLEL #<I@ B8C8EbEb
<EQ<IC@B GI<EJ@9@E< >XI< WXQYDCYPFILQ 48E@ 9L>YE P8f8P8E
M< 8PEb KYI @JB<C<KC<I@ FC8E P8I8KbBC8IbE ;bf >XIYEYfC<I@E<
98BbPFILQ L P8I8KbcbE YQ<I@ ;< BbIDbQb BbCC8IC8 B8GCb FC;LcL >@9@
>YEYDYQ;<B@ GI@D8KC8IbE ;8 WFcL BbQbC KYPCY SbGC8B 9LKC8Ib
E8JbICb 58K<E >YEYDYQ;<B@ GI@D8KC8I BYWYB XE<DJ@Q P8I8KbBC8I
.FPC8Ib;8KYB<ED<BYQ<I< \
&LE@FI DF;<C@E 8IB8JbE8 BFf8I8B 9LKC8IbEbE WbGC8B FCLG FC

D8;bBC8IbE898BKb



[ 'LC8BC8Ib BYWYB M< 9LILfLB .LI8KC8Ib XE< ;FcIL LQLE M<


<KC@ TQ<C P@P<:<BC<IC< 9<JC<ED@PFIC8I +ELE @W@E ;< ;@fC<I@ ?<I
9<J@E< LP>LE #<:<C<I@ ;FC8fbPFIC8I L PYQ;<E >XQC<I@ @I@
JCbE;89YKYE9LEC8IWFB98J@Kf<PC<I ! FC;LDL ;<C@B8ECb\
&LE@FI 9L BFELPL ;YfYE;Y ;YfYE;Y M< JFELE;8 DF;<C@
8f8cbC8I:8JbE8 [<E:< F 9@I !<B8?`8 9<EQ@PFI \ ;@P< =@BI@E@
8WbBC8;b [S@IB@EM<P8fCb9@I!<B8?`8 \
-8G? ?8PI<KC< FcCLE8 98BKb @I EFBK8Pb B8WbIDbf FC;LcL 9<C

C@P;@ [!<8B? ;8 E<;@I '@K8GC8I;8 FBL;LcLE ?8P8C@ 9@I P8I8KbB


Db\
[$8P8C@ D@ D8E 9898 J<E -.A '8PbKWbP8 LcI8DbPFI
DLJLE\
L LK8E;bIb:b 9@I JFILP;L SYEBY _898` 9LEL ?@W9@I Q8D8E
P8G8DbPFI;L 48E@ ?@W FCD8QJ8 <I>@EC@c< <I@f<C@ 9<I@ /89@@
WF:LBB<E ;YEP8EbE BFELfLC8E P8QbC8E M< B8P;<;@C<E ?@BVP<C<I

@E@E BFILPL:LJL FC8E '8PbKWb ?<I Q8D8E @C>@J@E@ W<BD@fK@ D8


JFEI8FC>LEC8fDbf
-8G? ?Ff>XIYPC< [!<B8?`C8I BFELJLE;8 P<E@ ?@BVP<C<I D@
M8I\;<;@ [SF:LBB<EXPC<f<PC<IPFBKLJ8EbIbD \
[*< ;<D<B @JK<;@c@D@ 8EC8DbPFIJLE 9898 \ #<EW -8G?`bE
X=B<C<ED<B YQ<I< FC;LcL ;YfYEYC<9@C@I;@ D8 9LEL 9<CC@ <K

D<P<:<B B8;8I ;@BB8KC@P;@ SF:LB BbIbCDbf:8JbE8 [!<B8?`C8I


><IW<B :8ECbC8I \ ;@P< 8WbBC8;b [+EC8I @c<I YEP8;8E
><CD@fC<I .<E 9LEL ;LPD8;bE Db LE;8E FBLC;8 9@C< JXQ
<;@C@PFI #ILG ;<I>@J@E;< ;< '<E;@ YCB<C<I@E;< K<G<YJKY ;LILP

FIC8I 8D8 9LELE =8IBbE;8 ;<c@CC<I PIb:8 fLI8;8B@ @?K@P8I @CB<C


P8I8Kbc8;8WFB9<EQ@PFIC8I \
dP@:< f8f8C8P8E -8G? B8=8JbEb KFGC8;b 4<E@ P<K@f<E FcCLEL
8IB<FCFA@ BFELJLE;8 9@C>@ <;@ED<B @W@E JFI>LP8 W<BD<B WFB
KL?8= B8W8:8BKb ;8D 9@I 8E ;LI8BC8;b .FELWK8 F ;8 98Qb
f<PC<I ;LPDLfKL YEP8EbE ;@c<I P8IbD BYI<J@E;< ><E@f BbK8C8I
FC;LcL JXPC<E@PFI;L #8C@98 FEC8IbE YQ<I@E;< :8ECbC8IbE P8f8;bcb
;8 9@C;@I@CD@fK@ D8 -8G?bE B8=8JbE;8 WFB 8Q 9@C>@ B8CDbfKb
 

$<I?8C;< @EJ8EbE B<E;@J@E@ @C>@C<E;@I<E 8C8E8 98cC8EbG B8CD8Jb


?<IQ8D8E8BbCCb:89@If<P;<c@C;@
+cCLE8 [#ILGC8I;8!<B8?C8IM8IDb\;@P<JFI;L
SF:LB W89L:8B 98fbEb J8CC8;b ['8PbKWb B8=8C8IbEbE 9@Q@

DB@C<I B8;8I @P@ W8CbfKbcbEb JXPCYPFI $8M8;8 >@;<E D8B@E<C<I@


M8IDbf LI8P8;8XPC<><CD@fC<I \
-8G?J<IKJ<IK [&LE@FI\;<;@
SF:LB ?8BJbQ:8 JLWC8E;bcb @W@E [48C8E JXPC<D@PFILD \ ;@P<
98cbI;b ['8PbKWbP8JFI8B98B8CbDJ8E8E<;@P<:<B\
-8G? BVcbKC8IbEb 8cbI 8cbI KFGC8;b L $<I e<P@E '8G8Cb +C

;LcL#YE;Y D8?<I?8C;<'8PbKWbPb<M@E;<9LC89@C@I;@

'8PbKWb 'bQbC *<?@I #LIIFN #IL9LELE P8fCb 9@I YP<J@P;@


48f8P8EC8I;8E G<B 8Qb FELE ><EWC@c@E@ ?8KbICbPFI;L L >XI<M<
?<IB<J@E IbQ8JbPC8 ><K@I@CD@f M< 98f8IbCb FCDLfKL SYEBY F ;8
-8G? >@9@P;@ -8G? E<;<E )YQ<:@ FCDLfJ8 P8fCb 8;8D ;8 8PEb
E<;<EC< '8PbKWbCbcb J<WD@fK@ SYEBY 9LEL @JK@PFI 9L ?FfLE8
>@;@PFI;LM<98fB8KYI9@IP8f8Db8BCb8CDbPFI;L
#LIIFN #IL9LE;8 ;FcD8Dbf FC8EC8IbE 9L KFGCLDLE JFJP8C
P8GbJbEb B8MI8D8C8Ib QFI;L JCbE;8 WFB ><Mf<B FCLfDLf 9@I
9@W@D FC;LcL @W@E ;< _P8Gb JXQ:YcY LP>LE ;<c@C;@ #LIIFNCL 9@I
B@DJ< P<K<E<c@E< @E8E;bcb 9@I @f< >@I<I;@ 48IbD B8C8E P8 ;8
P8GbCD8Jb ><I<B<E @fC<IC< 9YKYE YP<C<I @C>@C<E@PFIC8I;b 48 ;8 9L
@fC<I@ BLI8 JbI8JbPC8 >XIYPFIC8I;b L 9@W@D;< 8WbBC8E;bcbE;8 9L
J@JK<D W8Cbf8D8P8:8B B8;8I 98J@KD@f >@9@ >XQYBYPFI;L D8
><IW<B 9XPC< ;<c@C;@ dCB #XEYCCY #LIIFN #IL9L BLILC;LcLE;8E
9<I@ ><W<E 9@E PbCCbB JYI<;< KFGC8E8E KXI<C<I J@JK<D@ B8ID8fbB
<JE<BM<W8Cbf89@C@I9@I?8C<JFBLPFIC8I;b
-8G?bE ;8 K8?D@E <KK@c@ >@9@ '8PbKWb <M@E;<P;@ )YQ<:@ <JB@
M< ?8BJbQ:8 @?D8C <;@CD@f 9@I ;FJKCLcL K8Q<C<IB<E LK8E;b /89@@
'8PbKWbEbE I<=<I8EJ B@K8GC8IbE;8E P8I8IC8EbPFI;L 8D8 ?<I Q8D8E
;FC8PCb 9@I 9@W@D;< "8B8K 9@I Q8D8EC8I F ;8 WF:LBKL M< 9L 8BCb
J<C@D 8;8DbE ;@Q@E@E ;@9@E;< WFB f<P XcI<ED@f 8E:8B JFEI8;8E
 

9L;FJKCLcLJYI;YID<D@fK@
-8G?bE f@D;@ >@I;@c@ F;8 KbB8 98J8 B8PbKC8IC8 ;FCLP;L
8JbCDbf D8CQ<D< ;< M8I;b 9LI8;8 '8PbKWb )YQ<:@P@ J<M@EWC<
B8IfbC8IB<E9@IP8E;8E;8XQYI;@C<P@G;LI;L
[ @c<I >ILGC8I;8E D8CQ<D< ><C;@ +EC8IbE B8K8CFcLEL P8G

D8B Q8D8E 8CbPFI <E ;< >8C@98 <JB@J@ B8;8I M8B@K 9LC8DbPFI

LD \ ,@GFJLEL P8B8I8B ;LD8EC8IbEb >YWC< J8MLID8P8 98fC8;b


[#8C@98 ?<I Q8D8E P8EbD;8 W8Cbf8:8B 9@I P8I;bD:b 9LCD8D
><I<B<:<B +cCLE8 E< ;<IJ@E -8G? + ;8 J<E@E P@ID@ PbC XE:<
P8GKbcbE>@9@JbBJbB9LI8P8><C@PFI \
[+>YEC<I@?8KbICbPFIDLJLE\
[#8C@98 J<E;<E ;8?8 @P@ ?8KbICbPFILD +cCLE 9L >XI<M;<E
?FfC8EbIDb;<IJ@E\
[dJK<IJ<E FELEC8 9@I BFELf <CB@ J8E8 P8I;bD <KD<B
?FfLE8 >@;<I +cCLDLE 8IB<FCFA@P< 98PbC;bcbEb JXPC<P<D<P<

:<c@D \ -8G? ><C@f@>YQ<C 9@I B8P;b 8C8I8B YQ<I@E;<B@ <K@B<K<


98BKb [$bD &FHL@E 18;@J@ #IL9LE;8E +I8Jb 9LI8;8E WFB
LQ8B \
[!M<K WFB LQ8B \ '8PbKWb 98fbEb J8CC8;b [/89@@ 9<E ;< FE

C8I8 9@Q@D '8PbKWbC8I;8E 98QbC8IbEb PFCC8;bD @Q@D >IL9LE


W8CbfD8C8Ib 9YKYE BbK8;8 ?8PI8ECbBC8 B8IfbC8EbPFI \ .<J@E;<
>LILI M8I;b [$8KK8 \ ,@GFJLELE J8GbPC8 )YQ<:@P@ @f8I<K <KK@
[ J<E@E JFPC8Ib KYB<ED@f GI@D8KC8IC8 @C>@C@ K<Q@E ?<I K8I8=8
;8cbKbC;b dB@ 9@E BFGP8 PFCC8;bD 8?8 ;8 @JK@PFIC8I L
8IB<FCFA@@W@E WFB@P@9@If<PJ8PbCbI \
[<E ;< 9LI8P8 8IB<FCFA@ PYQYE;<E ><C;@D L M< 9@I ;<
FcCLD8 8EC8KKbBC8IbE PYQYE;<E \ -8G? BFELP8 >@ID<BK< QFICLB
W<B@PFI;L [48EbCDbPFIJ8D FcCLD8 ;@c<I P8IbD BYI<;< P8f8P8E
!<B8? 8;Cb P8I8KbBC8I;8E JXQ <KD@fJ@E +EC8I ?8BBbE;8 E< 9@C@P

FIJ8E?<GJ@E@XcI<ED<B@JK<I@D \
'8PbKWbEbE PYQYE;< ;YfYE:<C@ 9@I @=8;< 9<C@I;@ e<P .8E8
9YKYE9@C;@BC<I@D@fLI8:bBK88EC8K89@C@I@D 48;8@JK<IJ<EB@K8GCbc8
>@;@GFI8;8B@<J<IC<I<98B89@C@I@Q \



['@K8GCbcb 9<E@D @W@E 8WD8B Q8?D<K@E< >@ID< '8G8Cb #YEY


9L>YE .<E98E89@I8Q=@B@IM<I  8?8JFEI8B@K8GC8I89:@B8IbD \
'8PbKWb G@GFJLELE L:LEL bJbI8I8B @JB<DC<J@E@ @PBK< ;LM8I8
B8;8I ><I@P< @KK@ #XQC<I@E@ ;YfYE:<C@ 9@I K8MbIC8 @R<I@;<B@ 9@I EZBK8P8
;@B<I<B [e<P #8C@98 FC8P 9<f PbC XE:< ;@c<I P8IbD BYI<;<B@
BbK8C8IbE9LCLED8JbPC898fC8;b <CB@9LFC8Pb9@C@PFIJLE\;<;@
[.8;<:< ;LP;LD 48E@ ?<IB<J >@9@ 9<E ;< F BbK8C8IbE M8I
FC;LcLEL 9@C@PFILD @I 8I8 8IB<FCFA@ 8I8fKbID8C8Ib @W@E P<GP<E@
GbIbC GbIbC 9@I 8C8E ;@P< ;YfYE;YcYDY ;< ?8KbICbPFILD 8D8 ?<GJ@
FB8;8I \
[? XPC<PJ< J8E8 8EC8KbC8:8B WFB f<P M8I @C;@c@E >@9@ F
BbK8C8Ib ;FcIL;8E ;FcILP8 9@Q 9LC;LB <f PbC XE:< 9@IB8W
P898E:b P8I8KbB LW8E 9@I D8B@E<PC< !8JK $8I9FI #IL9LE8 <I@fK@
+EC8I #LIIFN ;<c@CC<I;@ )8B@E< B<J@E 9@C@DJ<C GI<EJ@GC<I< >XI<
LWLPFI;L LEL ;8?8 JFEI8 XcI<E;@B ,I<EJ@9@E K<D<C@E;<
?8M8EbE 98Qb E@K<C@BC<I@ M8I;b L P898E:bC8I 8I8C8IbE;8 P898E:b
9@I ;@C;< BFELfLPFIC8I;b 5<B@ FC;LBC8Ib 9<CC@P;@ '<E;@C<I@E@
!<B8? ;@P< K8EbDCbPFIC8I;b !8JK $8I9FI #IL9LE;8B@ #LIIFNC8I
FEC8IbE ;@C@E@ XcI<E;@C<I L ;@C 98J@KK@ 8D8 JXPC<E@C<D<P<:<B
98Qb J<JC<IC< ;FCLP;L <E;< F ;@C@E >I8D<I@ ;< M8I .<E@
@C>@C<E;@I@PFIJ8 \
-8G?@C>@C<E;@ID<;@c@E@9<C@IKD<B@W@E<C@E@J8CC8;b
'8PbKWb [#ILGK8B@ #LIIFNC8I \ ;@P< BFELfD8JbEb JYI;YI;Y
[ <D@I 8cb #IL9LELE P8I;bDbPC8 LW8E D8B@E<E@E <f@E@
P8GKbC8I @C;@c@E >@9@ <D@I 8cCbC8I W<C@B @fC<I@E;< LQD8E;bI L
LW8E D8B@E<C<IC< FBP8ELJ 8fbC;b LELEC8 @C>@C@ FC8I8B 9@IB8W
;YQ@E< <J<I P8QbC;bcbEb JXPC<P<9@C@I@Q 48E@ LW8E D8B@E< 8<IF;@

E8D@B ;<E@C<E P<E@ 9@I 9@C@D M< ?8KK8 Q<B@ 9@I K<B P8I8KbB FC

D8;bcbPC8 @C>@C@ ;<c@f@B 9@I =<CJ<=< J@JK<D@ ?8BBbE;8 B@K8GC8I


P8QbC;b YKYE 9LEC8I !8JK $8I9FI M< <D@I 8cb #ILGC8IbE:8
?8QbIC8E;b <f PbCCbB 9@I JYI<;< f8fbC8:8B B8;8I WFB <J<I M<I

;@C<I $<GJ@;<9@Q;<M8I \
[D8 F !<B8?C8I FEC8I ?VCV !8JK $8I9FI #IL9LELE



P8EbE;8C8IDb\
[$bDD TPC< FC;LcLE;8E ?<D<E ?<D<E <D@E@D '<E;@
BbK8C8IbE8 ;XED<P< P8E8fDbPFIC8I '<E;@C<I@E;<E J@P8J@ DYCK<:@
;@P<JXQ<;@PFIC8I\
[.@P8 E<\
'8PbKWb [+EC8I@E B<E;@ ;@CC<I@E;< JXPC<;@BC<I@ 9@I C8= 9L \
;<;@ [1<9@Q@D;@C@D@Q<8E:8B9XPC<W<MI@C<9@C@PFI \
[D8 E<;<E 7.<&7. DYCK<:@ *@W@E A<FCFA@B DYCK<:@ ;<c@C
48 ;8 =<fD<BVE DYCK<:@ <E:< 9@I W<M@I@;<E 8EC8D
WbBD8Cb;bI \
'8PbKWb FDQLEL J@CBK@ ['@K8GC8I8 98fMLID8Eb XE<I<:<c@D
!<B8?C8I 9@IK8BbD JLWCLC8I FCD8;bBC8IbEb @;;@8 <;@PFIC8I <E
J8E8J8;<:<9@C;@BC<I@D@8EC8KbPFILD \
[,<BVCV >XIYEYfC<I@ E8JbC FEC8IbE .<E;< I<J@DC<I@ M8I
Db\['@K8GCbBK8M8I \
[<E@D 60*414/. 6*37.51*6. 8;Cb B@K89bDb FBL;LE DL\
[eXPC<9@I98BKbD \
[dCB<C GI@D8KbE <CC< W@Q@CD@f I<JD@E@ ?8KbICbPFI DLJLE\
['FIB8IbD?8KbIC8DbPFILD \
[TPC<PJ<B@K8GCbc8>@;<C@D 
[/8D8D \ '8PbKWb QFICLBC8 8P8c8 B8CB8IB<E 9@I f<PC<I
DbIbC;8EbPFI;L

'bQbC *<?@I #LIIFN #IL9L PXE<K@:@J@E@E ;LILDL )YQ<:@ P8


;8 '8PbKWbEbEB@E;<E G<B =8IBCb ;<c@C;@ 48 ;8 >XEYCCY FC8I8B 9@I
@f@ P8G8E 9@I@E@EB@E;<E I8;8 9@I =8IB FCD8JbEb @JK<D<B KFGCLD

;8PXE<K@:@C@BP<K<E<c@E@E<E;<I9LCLE;LcLELJ8ED8B8EC8DbE8
><C@I
#LIIFN #IL9LE;8 @f D<PM8C8IbE;8E J8;<:< W8Cbf8E B@D

J<E@E ;<c@C ;@c<IC<I@E@E ;< P8I8IC8E;bBC8Ib 9@I W898 8EC8DbE8


><C@I;@ dfC<I @B@ JbEb=8 8PIbCbPFI;L @I #XEYCCY dfC<I dB@ 5FILECL
P8 ;8 /FGCLDJ8C dfC<I dCB JbEb=K8E FC8E 9YKYE @fC<I 9@I9@I@E< <f@KK@
@I #LIIFN @f< P8I8P8E ?<E;<BC<I B8QD8BK8E ?FfC8E89@C@I;@ +



Q8D8E FELE 9L <c@C@D@E< M< @f@E< J8P>b >XJK<ID<B ><I<B@I;@


D8 B@DJ< 9L KYI ?<E;<B B8QD8 @fC<I@E;<E ?FfC8ED8;bcb 8E

:8B 9LELE >IL9LELE I8?8Kb @W@E ><I<BC@ FC;LcL 8EC8fbC;bcb Q8

D8E 9L KFGCLDJ8C 9@I >XI<M< ;XEYfYPFI;L /FGCLDJ8C 9@I @f< +


Q8D8E 9L >XI<M P8 JbI8PC8 P8GbCbPFI;L P8 ;8 BLI8PK8 .bBb:b
8D8B8WbEbC8D8P8:8B9@If<P;@9L
dfK< 9L E<;<EC< 4XE<K@:@E@E FKLI;LcL <M ;@c<IC<I@E@EB@E;<E
E< ;8?8 ><E@fK@ E< ;< ;8?8 CYBJ ;8D ?@W9@I D8J8EbE 98fbE8
><W@G FKLIDLPFI;L df@E@E 8;bE;8E 98fB8 9@I LEM8Eb PFBKL
'@DJ< 4XE<K@:@P< B8Ifb ?8J<K P8 ;8 E<=I<K ;LPDLPFI P8 ;8 FE8
K8GDbPFI;L
;8D >ILGC8I8I8Jb K@:8I<K@ ;YQ<EC<D<B KFGCLDLE D8C@ @fC<I

@E@ BFEKIFC <KD<B M< 9@E;< 9@I WbB8E 8EC8fD8QCbBC8I;8 B8I8I M<I

D<BK<E ?FfC8EbPFI;L /89@@ ?FfLE8 >@;<E 9@I f<P@ P8GKbcb @W@E


FE8 <B P@P<:<B M<I@CD@PFI P8 ;8 <E<IA@PC< @C>@C@ 8PIb:8CbBC8I
K8EbEDbPFI;L
dfK< -8G? ;8 F PYQ;<E @Q@E 8CD8B ;<c@C ?<J8GC8IbEb ;YQ>YE
9@I 9@W@D;< JLED8B @W@E 4XE<K@:@P< LcI8;b '8G8Cb #YEY ?<EYQ
JFE8 <ID<D@fK@ 4XE<K@:@ 8Bf8D P<D<c@E;<E JFEI8 BFCKLcLE8
P<IC<fD@f 8Bf8D P<D<c@E;<E JFEI8 @WK@c@ J@>8IbEb KYKKYIYPFI;L
!C@E;< ;< 8Bf8D P<D<c@E;<E JFEI8 FBL;LcL B@K8G M8I;b CKb
WF:LcL M< B8IbJbEbE Q8D8EC8 G<B @C>@C<I@ PFBKL 8D8 FEC8I;8 ;8
8Bf8DP<D<c@JFEI8JbE8XQ>Y9@I?8M8M8I;b;<E@C<9@C@I
-8G? @W<I@ >@I;@c@ Q8D8E 9YKYE 8@C<E@E J<JC@ J<C8DC8IbPC8
B8IfbC8E;b )YQ<:@ @B@ <C@PC< BLC8BC8IbEb B8G8KKb )@E@B 4XE<K@:@C<I

@E /<B LEM8EC8Ib 9LP;L 48Q8I  9@I @fC<I@ M8IJ8 F ;8 >YIYCKY <K

D<BK@ #<IW<BK<E ;< 9LE;8E ?FfC8EbPFIC8I M< ;@c<IC<I@ ;< 9L


W898C8IbE D<PM8C8IbEb G8PC8fbPFIC8I;b SF:LBC8IbE BLC8B Q8I

C8IbEbE9L>YIYCKYC<I;<E?@W<KB@C<ED<;@c@9<CC@P;@
4XE<K@:@FEC8Ib<;8;8EWbB8I;b
-8G? FELE LQ8KKbcb J@>8Ib 8CbIB<E [@I JYI< @W@E >ILGK8E
8PIbCD8Pb;YfYEYPFILD (8?I \;<;@ [df@D9LEL><I<BK@I@PFI \
[#@;@f@E ?FfLDLQ8 >@KD<P<:<B -8G? @Q;<E =8QC8 8PIb



B8CD8P8:8cbEbLD8IbD \
[<E;<XPC< +IK8BYE@K<C<I@E;LILDLE8JbC\
[? J8E8 9FC 9FC P<K<I J8EbIbD *<I<P< >@KD<P@
;YfYEYPFIJLE\
[!8JK$8I9FI#IL9LE8 \
4XE<K@:@ 98fbEb J8CC8;b M< ;YfYE:<C@ 9@I K8MbIC8 J@>8IbEbE ;L

D8EC8IbEb Y=C<;@ [*< P8QbB B@ ;<=K<IC<I< >XI< !8JK $8I9FILE


9@Q;<E 9@I8Q 8C8:8cb M8I dJK<IJ<E 9LEL K<BI8I BFEKIFC <;<I@D
D8 <C@D@Q;<B@ +IK8B /I8DG8 UE@K<C<I@ ?<D PFC D8JI8=C8IbEb
?<D;<;@c<I?8I:8D8C8IbEbB8IfbC8I \
[L WFB @P@ D8 f@D;@ JXPC< /FGCLD df@ (@JK<J@E;<B@ ;LIL

DLDE8JbC\
[$bD '8PbKC8Ib 8CD8D ><I<B<:<B 8E8 9@I ;8B@B8 @Q@E
M<I \ 4XE<K@:@ 8cbI M< @I@ >XM;<J@PC< @C<IC<P<I<B F;8;8E ?FC< WbB

Kb -8G? ;LI;L 48C8E:b 9@I M8?f@C@BC< ?FDLI;8E8I8B FE8 ;@fC<I@E@


>XJK<I<E M< PLM8IC8E8I8B P8BC8f8E 9@I BYWYcY LJLC:8 @KK@
SF:LBC8IbE <E BYWYcYP;Y F .bB J@P8? BYIBK<E FCLf8E 9@I PL

D8B LIEL WF:LBJL M< LQLE;L ?<EYQ ><E@fC<D<D@f M< P8IbD


D@CPFE PbC XE:< P8f8P8E ?8PM8E 8K8C8IbEbEB@E< 9<EQ<I 9@I ?8C
8CD8DbfKb
4XE<K@:@ <C@E;< B8CbE 9@I ;<=K<IC< ;XE;Y dI@ :8DCb 9@I >XQCYB
K8BDbfKb <=K<I@ ;@BB8KC< 8W8I8B J8P=8C8Ib B8IbfKbI;b M< 8I8;bcb
P<I@ 9LC;L .FEI8 ;8 G8ID8cbEb LJLC:8 JYKLEC8IbE YQ<I@E;<
;FC8fKbI;b [.8;<:< JL J@JK<D@PC< @C>@C@ @f M8I #<C<:<B ?8=K8
98BbD K@D@E;< W8Cbf8:8BJbE +E;8E JFEI8 <E 8f8cb @B@ 8P ?@W9@I
>XI<M@EPFB \
[+ Q8D8E8 B8;8I Q8K<E ;XE<I@D @I@E@E 98BbD @f@E;< P<I@D@
8CD8JbDYDBYEDY8:898\
[$bD <E 9@I@E@ 9LCLILD L @f@ ?<I Q8D8E <E 9YPYB
FcCLD8 P8GKbI89@C@I@D + W8CbfD8 P8fbE8 >@ID<B YQ<I< $<I f<P@E
K8;bE8 98BD8Jb @P@ FCLI <CB@ ;< 98I8A;8 W8CbfD8B ?FfLE8
>@;<I \
[TPC< D@ + 9<E@D >XI<M@D@ YQ<I@E< 8CbIJ8 98E8 ?89<I M<I



.bBJbBP<I@D<><W<9@C@I \
4XE<K@:@ LJLC:8 [+E8 ?@W >YM<ED< -8G? \ ;@P< >YC;Y
[+cCLD LPLD8Pb ?<G@D@Q @W@E P8I8ICb 9@I ?8C< JFB89@CJ<P;@ ?<

D<E 9L >XI<M@ YJKC<E@I;@ .8?@ 8BCbD8 ><CD@fB<E !8JK $8I9FI


#IL9LE8 E<;<E >@;@PFIJLE 'FELfD8B @JK<D@PFIJ8E
B8G8K89@C@I@D \
[<CB@ 98E8 >YC<:<BJ@E 8D8 9<E !<B8? ;<E@C<E P8I8KbBC8IbE
><IW<BK<EM8IFC;LBC8IbEbP<E@XcI<E;@D \
[!<B8?C8I Db !M<K 9@C@PFILD \ 4XE<K@:@ G8ID8cbEb LQ8KKb
[eL;<E@Q@EXK<J@E;<E><C<EP8I8KbBC8I TPC<;<c@CD@\
[!M<K XPC< D8 ?<GJ@ 9L B8;8I ;<c@C <E B@K8GCbBK8E
><C@PFILD +EC8IbE YW 9FPLKCL I<J@DC<I@E@ >XI;YD (8?I L
!<B8? C8I @CB<C GI@D8K 48 ;8 ?<D<E ?<D<E XPC<C<I $@W FCD8Q

J8 GI@D8K FEC8I %*0. GI@D8KC8I #XQC<I@ BYWY:YB 9LILEC8Ib ;8


P8JJb S<E< B<D@BC<I@ ;< K8D8D@PC< =8IBCb 8D8 ?@W FCD8QJ8
@CB<CGI@D8KC8IbEP8BbE8BI898C8Ib +EC8Ib>XID<Df8IK (8?I \
4XE<K@:@ FDQLEL J@CBK@ L BFEL FEL f8?J<E @C>@C<E;@ID@P

FI;L [*<;<E LEL 9@C>@J@QC@c@D PYQYE;<E JFILPFILD -8G?


+EC8Ib>XID<E9LB8;8IXE<DC@D@\
[TE<DC@ D@\ L JFILELE -8G?b WFB f8fbIKKbcb 9<CC@P;@ [eL
JFE PbCC8I;8 E<C<I FC;LcLEL 9@C@PFI DLJLE IB<FCFA@PC< @C>@C@ B@K

89bDbFBL;LEDL\
4XE<K@:@ B<J@E 9@I K8MbIC8 [$8PbI \ ;<;@ [SXG ;XBD< @f@E;<E
BLIKLC8:8cbDb9@C<9@CJ<DFB@K89bP@E<;<FBLD8D \
[LE;8E ;8 J<E@E WXG @f@E< 8IB<FCFA@;<E ;8?8 P8KBbE
FC;LcLE 8EC8fbCbPFI \ ;<;@ [D8 E<PJ< <E ?<D<E ?<D<E
FE PbC;bI K<B 98fbD8 FIK8P8 8KKbcbD M8IJ8PbD LcILE8 J8M8fbPFI

LD <E @CB<C GI@D8KbE ><C@fD@f 9@I LP>8ICbcb P8I8K8E Q<B@ 9@I P8I

8KbB FC;LcLE8 @E8EbPFI;LD L 8E8 B8;8I D8EKbBK8E 98fB8


?@W9@I ;<JK<c@D ;< PFBKL IB<FCF>C8IbE WFcL ;8 FEL Q8K<E G<B
B89LC <KD<QC<I '<J@E 9@I f<P @JK<IC<I @I >IL9LE B8CbEKbC8Ib <J

<IC<I@ P8GbC8Ib P8 ;8 B@K8GC8Ib >@9@ f<PC<I@ ECbPFI DLJLE <E@D


<C@D;< @J< J8;<:< B8=8K8Jb G<B ><E@f 9@I @JB<C<K M8I 4bC;bQC8I



8;bE8 (8?I FEC8I FE D@CPFE PbC JFEI8 ><I@P< E< B8C8:8cbEb


J8EbPFIC8I)8;<EB8P9FCLI 'VcbK;8XPC< "@CD;<
[.8;<:< K8f ;8P8EbI (8?I M< K8fC8f8E B<D@BC<I <E;< 9L
M8I dW@E< 9<PE@E Jbc89@C<:<c@ 9@I B8=8K8Jb 1< K8f @C<ED@f
9bW8BC8I 4FEKLCDLfW8BD8BK8fC8Ib \
(8?I [dP@P8 \;<;@ [dfK<J8E8<J<IC<I \
[+EC8I8 _<FC@K ;<E@C@PFI e8=8B K8fb @c<I 8IB<FCF>C8I FEC8Ib
B89LC <KD@PFIC8I +EC8IbE 8fbED8 PYQYE;<E F 9@W@DC<I@ 8CDbf
;Fc8C f<PC<I FC;LBC8IbEb JXPCYPFIC8I ?D8BC8I\ -8G? JFEI8
X=B<PC<>YC;Y
[D8 <c<I !<B8?C8I Q<B@ GI@D8KC8IJ8 F Q8D8E 9<E ;< @;

;@8DbB8EbKC8DbfFCLILD \

-8G? ;8?8 XE:< ;< PFC:LCLB P8GDbfKb 8D8 ;FcLP8 ;FcIL


;<c@C 4FC:LCLB JbI8JbE;8 K8IbDbE 8Q8CD8Jb FEL <KB@C<;@ /8I@?@E
98fC8IbE;8 #LIIFN #ILGC8Ib LQD8EC8fD8P8 >@KD<D@fC<I;@ $<I
9@I >ILG B<E;@ B<E;@E< P<K@PFI;L /@:8I<K @J< 9@I ><I<BJ@E@D;<E
WFB;FJKW89@I;8MI8EbfKb
#ILGC8IbE WFcLE;8 ;LILD ?VCV 9XPC<P;@ <CB@ ;< -8G?bE
'bQbC *<?@I #IL9L 9LELE K@G@B 9@I XIE<c@P;@ <E@Q;<E P<;@ PYQ
<CC@ D<KI< B8;8I @W<I@;< M<I@DC@ W@=KC@B 8I8Q@J@E@E FIK8JbE;8 P8fbP

FIC8I;b +ELE @W@E K8IbDbE ?VCV XE<D@ M8I;b *<?@I;<E 98CbB WbBbP

FI;L 9@I8Q .YKWYCYB <E;YJKI@J@ ;< @P@ ><C@fD@fK@ $8KK8 FIK8B YE

@K< ;LILDLELE J8cCbBCb FCD8JbEbE E<;<E@ ;< P@P<:<B @?I8W


<;@CD<J@P;@
E:8B ;FcLP8 ;FcIL >@;<IC<IB<E ><WK@BC<I@ >ILGC8I KFGI8BC8
>@K>@;< ;8?8 8Q @C>@C<ED<P< 98fC8;bC8I 8:8C8Ib KYK<E =89I@B8
J8PbJb;8?88IKKb
-8G? !8JK $8I9FI #IL9LE;8 9@I K@:8I<K D<IB<Q@ 9LC;L L
>IL9LE Q<E>@EC@c@ ;8?8 WFB ><D@C<I< 98cCbP;b 18J8KK8E ;8?8
B8C898CbBKb 9L >ILG !MC<I =8QC8P;b $8KK8 98QbC8Ib 9@I9@IC<I@E@E PYQ
D<KI<P8BbEbE8P8GbCDbfC8I;b
-8G? 9XPC< 9@I9@I@E< >@ID@f ;LILD;8 P8f8D8Pb ;YfYE;YcY



Q8D8E KYPC<I@ JbBbEKbPC8 ;@B<E ;@B<E FC;L FBC8IbE ;LILDL ;8?8


;8 BXKYP;Y #LIIFN`C8I KFGCLDJ8C @f< ;8CDbfC8I; #<D@C<I< PYB
;FC;LID8M<9Ff8CKD8@fC<I@E<
!8JK $8I9FI #IL9LELE 4XE<K@:@J@ ><EW 9@I 8;8D;b L
>XI<M< P<E@ 98fC8DbfKb df@ FE8 DYK?@f 9@I Q<MB M<I@PFI;L UECY
9@I P898E:bPb BFELB <KD<E@E E<;<E FC;LcL J<M@EWK<E E<I<;<PJ<
98PbC8:8BKb
-8G?`8 f8?8E< 9@I Q@P8=<K W<BK@C<I 1< FE8 ?<I P<D<c@E
E<I<;<E ><C;@c@E@ 8WbBC8;bC8I +M8 #IL9LE;8E JbcbI <K@ 'LQ<P
FcL +ID8EC8Ib #IL9LE;8E G8K8K<J 48IbD ;8 #IL9LE;8E
B8?M< ,8J@=@B #IL9LE;8E f8I8G M< )<IB<Q #XCC<I@E;<E D<PM8
YKYE9LEC8I9@IK8fI8CbFC8E-8G?`8f8?8E<M<P898E:b><C;@
.FLK? CJC8E; #IL9LE;8E ><C<E J@>8IC8IbEb @W<IC<IB<E )YQ<:@
!<B8?`C8I BFELJLEL 8WKb !8JK $8I9FI 4XE<K@:@J@ :@;;@C<fK@ F Q8

D8E @I8Q;8<E;@f<C<E;@
[#XID<E@Q ><I<B<E B@DJ< (<D@E + J@Q< D<DELECLBC8
<C@E;<E ><C;@c@ B8;8I P8I;bD <;<I L !<B8?`C8I BFELJLE;8 9@I
f<PC<I9@C;@c@E@Q@D@JXPC<;@E@Q\
[@I f<PC<I XcI<ED<B .78*).H.2. JXPC<;@D +EC8I 9@C;@c@D
JFPLKYB<ED@f9@I?8PM8E:@EJ@E<9<EQ@PFIC8I \
[ <D<B@C>@8C8EbEbQ9L ECbPFILD \
-8G? E8Q@B E8Q@B [<CB@ 98E8 FEC8IbE 9LI8P8 E8JbC ><C;@B

C<I@E@8PIbEKbC8IbPC88EC8K89@C@IJ@E@Q 4XE<K@:@ \;<;@


[<E F JbI8;8 4XE<K@:@ ;<c@C;@D ;FJKLD +ELE @W@E 9L BF

EL;8 B<E;@D ;FcIL;8E ;FcILP8 9@C>@ <;@E<D<;@D D8 B8PbK8I


8WbB 0W8E D8B@E<C<I@PC< 9LI8P8 ><C<E F !<B8? #IL9L
$8M8;8LW8EF8C<KC<I;<EJXQ<;@C;@c@E@?<I?8C;<;LP;LELQ \
[!M<K <M<K \
[!M<K e<P  +EC8IbEB8W8BFC;LBC8Ib8EC8fbCbPFI;L \
[LEL ;LP;LD D8 JLWCL FCD8;bBC8IbEb ;8 @;;@8 <;@PFI

C8IDbf TPC<;<c@CD@\
[!M<K SFB >8I@G ;<c@C D@ $YBYD >@P;@BC<I@E@ @K@I8= <KK@C<I
/89@@ 9LEL LQLE M< LJK8:8 9@I JFI>LC8D8EbE JFELE;8




8WbBC8;bC8I L @f@ ;< 8E:8B FEC8IbE ;@C@E@ XcI<E;@BK<E JFEI8 P8G

89@C;@B D8 BXKYCYB <KD<;@BC<I@E@ bJI8IC8 JXPC<;@C<I EC8fbC8E


J@P8J<K GI<EJ@GC<I@ BFELJLE;8 4XE<K@:@C<I@PC< 8PEb =@B@I;<
;<c@CC<ID@f \
-8G? @I@ 98fbEb 9@C>@W 9@I K8MbIC8 J8CC8;b [? 1< K89@@ KFGCLD

LEM<I;@c@B8I8I8LPD8Pb;8I<;;<KD@fC<I TPC<;<c@CD@\
[+C8P 9LE;8E ;8?8 B8IbfbB +EC8I KFGCLDLE FIK8B 9@I B8I8I
M<ID<;@c@E;< bJI8I <;@PFIC8I 4XE<K@:@E@E J@P8J<K BFELJLE;8
B<E;@98fbE8B8I8IM<I;@c@E@JXPCYPFIC8I d;;@8C8Ib9L \
[! 4XE<K@:@;<c@fK@I@CD<D@fD@\
[EC8fbC8E FELE ;<c@fK@I@CD<J@ ><I<BK@c@E@ ;YfYE<EC<I JLWCL
J8PbCbPFIC8IDbf L!<B8?C8I>@9@ \
-8G? 9L JXQC<I< @E8E8D8DbfKb @I J<JJ@QC@B FC;L .FEI8
)YQ<:@ [LJ@Q<D8EKbBCb><C@PFIDL\;@P<JFI;L
 [$8PbI <E J8;<:< J@Q< FEC8IbE JXQC<I@E@ K<BI8ICbPFILD /89@@
!<B8? ;@C@ 9YPYB 9@I <E><C 8Qb J<JC<I@ WbB8ID8B @DBVEJbQ '<

C@D<C<I@E 8EC8DC8Ib :YDC<;<B@ P<IC<I@E< >XI< ;<c@f@PFI .XPC<P

@fK<B@ =8IB8 >XI< ;< SFcL Q8D8E !<B8? JXQ:YBC<I@ ;FcIL


;YIYJKW<MI@C;@BC<I@Q8D8E9@C<9@CD<:<;<E=8IBJbQFCLPFI \
-8G? =@BI@E@ 8WbBC8;b [$<I?8C;< 9LI8;8 #LIIFNC8IbE
P8f8;bBC8IbEb>XI;YBC<I@Q8D8EWFBf8fbI;bC8I \
[e8fbID8B Db\ 4XE<K@:@E@E J<J@ ?8=@=C<;@ [$<D ;< E<
f8fbID8B e@D;@ J@Q< 9@I f<P@ 8WbBC8P8:8cbD L FC8P 9<CC@
E<;<EC<IC< 8WbBC8ED8;b +ELE @W@E 9LELE D8?I<D 9@I f<P
FC;LcLEL LELKD8P8:8cbEbQb LD8IbD L !<B8?C8I J@C8?C8Ib
<CC<I@E;<E 8CbEbE:8P8 B8;8I 9<f #LIIFNL XC;YI;YC<I !CC<I@E;<
B@DP8J8C I<8BJ@PFE PFCLPC8 D8;<E G8IW8:bBC8IbEb 9YPYB 9@I ?bQC8
=bIC8K8E 9@I 8I8W M8I;b @Q ;< ;8?8 JFEI8 FELE K8BC@;@E@ P8GKbB
/89@@ 9L BFfLCC8I 8CKbE;8 FEC8IbE JLWCL FC;LBC8IbEb @C8E <KD<;@B
SYEBY 9@Q@D Q<B@ P8I8KbBC8I FC;LcLDLQL 8EC8D8DbfC8I;b E

C8fbC8E \ 4XE<K@:@ YQYEKYPC< >YC;Y [9@Q FEC8IbE ;YEP8JbE;8B@


98Qb ?8PM8EC8I8 9<EQ@PFILQ 8?8 ;FcILJL !<B8?C8I XPC<
JXPCYPFIC8I \



-8G? 9@I;<E9@I< ?<P<:8EC8E;b [#XBK<B@ PbC;bQC8I TPC<


JXPC<;@C<I ;<D<B PIbEKbC8Ib 8WbBC8;bC8I Db *< KYI ?8PM8E

C8IDbf9LEC8I\
4XE<K@:@ f8f8C8;b [e<P 9@CD@PFILD + ?8PM8EC8IbE B<E;@
;@CC<I@E;<B@ 8;C8IbEb JXPC<;@C<I LELE E< 8EC8Db M8I @Q;<E
;<M8PbC8I`;@P<JXQ<KK@C<I \
[ <ME<C<I\
[PbC8I + ?8PM8EC8IbE E8JbC f<PC<I FC;LBC8Ib BFELJLE;8 <E
L=8B 9@I =@BI@D PFB @Q< 9<EQ<;@BC<I@ ;bfbE;8 K89@@ D<I@B8;8
XPC<9@I?8PM8EFC;LcLELJ8EDbPFILD \
[PbC8I PbC8I \ -8G? 9L JXQ:YcY B<B<C<P<I<B K<BI8IC8;b
[SFB @C>@EW dC>@EWK<E ;< XK< )YK?@f 9@I f<P 9L @C@PFI DLJLELQ
9@Q #LIIFNC8IbE 8K8C8Ib BFELJLE;8 K8IKbfbG ;LILPFILQ 4XE<K@:@
BbCCb #LIIFNC8IbE 8BI898C8Ib FC8E M< P8f8P8E ?8PM8EC8I 9@Q@D
@W@EWFBXE<DC@ \-8G?@I@<CC<I@E@D<DELED<DELEFMLfKLI;L
4XE<K@:@ ?<P<:8E LP8E;bI;bcb @W@E D<DELE FCDLfKL [dEJ8Eb
f8fbIK8E 9@If<P ;8?8 M8I !<B8?C8I B<E;@C<I@E@ 8PIb @B@ 8;C8
W8cbIbPFIC8I \
[dB@8;C8Db\
[!M<K '@DJ< 8I8;8 E< =8IB FC;LcLEL ?<EYQ 9@CD@PFI
!<B8?C8I E< B8;8I 8EC8KbIC8IJ8 8EC8KJbEC8I 9L EFBK8Pb B8M

I8P8DbPFILQ .8;<:< 9@I@E@E ><E<C 9@I@E@E ;< ;8?8 XQ<C 9@I @J@D
FC;LcLEL9@C@PFILQ D8K<D<C=8IBbP8B8C8P8DbPFILQ \
[ECbPFILD !<B8??8E>@J@\
[+ XQ<C 8; #<E<C FC8E @J< \ 4XE<K@:@ BLC8B KbID8C8P8E
?<:<C<I@ 9<:<I@BJ@Q:< K<BI8IC8;b [e<D
G8E
Q< $8? @fK< 9XPC<
!<B8? ;<E@C<E 9@I >ILG M8IDbf 8fB8 8;C8Ib FC8E 9@IK8BbD
>ILGC8I ;8 D8 ><E<CC@BC< FEC8I;8E 9XPC< JXQ <;@C@PFIDLf
e<D <D@E JXPC<;@c@D >@9@ \ 4XE<K@:@ 98fB8 @C>@EW f<PC<I 9L

CLGJXPC<D<B@W@E9<CC<c@E@8I8fKbI;b
D8 -8G? FE;8E XE:< ;8MI8E;b [(<IE@E@ P8IbE >XI<9@C@I
D@P@D\
[/89@@ \



 ?8C;< XPC< P8G8:8cbD *<Q8B<K@E@Q @W@E K<f<BBYI <;<I@D


4XE<K@:@ \

(<D@E L=8B K<=<B 9@I 8;8D;b '@CFJL ?<I?8C;< PYQ FE;8E


=8QC8 FC8D8Q;b 4YIYD<J@ ;< ;YQ>YE ;<c@C;@ $8=@=W< KFG8CCbP

FI;L D8 BFELfD8 98fC8I 98fC8D8Q -8G? 9YKYE 9LEC8Ib LE

LKKL SYEBY(<D@E98fB8C8IbE8<E<IA@8fbC8P8E9@I;YfYEYI;Y
'FELfD8EbE @CB P8IbJbE;8 -8G?bE ?<P<:8Eb ;LILD8 ?8B@D
FC;L (<D@E@E JXQC<I@ @J< f@Df<BC<I@E bfbcb >@9@ BbJ8 M< GbIbCKbCbP;b
.FEI8W<B@DD<IB<Q@;<c@fK@M<@;8I<P@(<D@E<C<8C;b
(<D@E@E XQ<CC@c@ FC8E M< ?@W9@I Q8D8E ;FJKW8 9@I ?8M8
M<I<D<;@c@ F JFcLB K8MbIC8IbPC8 [.FILELELQL XE<DJ@Q 9LC;LcL

DL JXPC<IJ<D ?<I?8C;< BLJLILD8 98BD8QJbEbQ 9@C>@C@ ;FJKLD \


;<;@ [$8PbI ?8PbI \ 0QLE G8ID8BCb <C@E@ B8C;bI;b
[58D8EbDbQ;8 P8GbC8E M< B8ID8fbB FCD8P8E BFELfD8C8I
98BbDbE;8E ;<c@C .8;<:< 9<E@D @W@E XE<DJ@Q SYEBY 9<E@
98fB8 9@I BFEL @C>@C<E;@I@PFI E:8B 9LELE 9YKYE >ILGC8I M<
;YEP8;8B@ ?<I #LIIFN @W@E ;< XE<DC@ FCD8;bcbEb ;8
JXPC<D<C@P@D \
L @EJ8Eb J8IJ8E 9@I B8MI8D;b -8G? 9@I 8E 8CbE;bcb >@9@
B@f@J<CFC8I8BWFB;8BbIbC;b 4YQYE;<E;<8EC8fbCbPFI;L9L
(<D@E W89L:8B <BC<;@ [L JXQC<I@D J@Q< B898 M< K<I9@P<J

@Q:< f<PC<ID@f >@9@ ><C<9@C@I 0P>8I:8 FCD8P8E C8=C8I >@9@ D8


;LILDL J@Q< 8WbBC8D8CbPbD WbBC8D8CbPbD WYEBY J@Q 8JCbE;8
KFGCLDJ8C 9@I 9@C@DC< @C>@C<E<E 9@I@J@E@Q M< FC8Pb 8EC8P8:8BJbEbQ
$8KK89<CB@9LEL9@Q;<E;8?8@P@B8MI8P8:8BJbEbQ \
-8G? X=B<PC< [48f8DbD 9FPLE:8 9<E@ @C>@C<E;@I<E BFEL
9<E@D @W@E WFB XE<DC@ \ ;<;@ [<E@ 98fB8 f<PC<I @C>@C<E;@I@PFI

DLf>@9@;8MI8E8D8D \
[.XQYEY <KK@c@D f<P ?<IB<J@ @C>@C<E;@ID<C@ SYEBY ?@W FCD8Q

J89XPC<:<?<G@D@Q@E?8P8KbBLIKLCDLfFCLI \
-8G? KYICY f<PC<I;<E BLfBLC8ED8P8 98fC8;b L KL?8= 9@I
f8B8P;b 48 ;8 8;8D P8fC8E;bcb @W@E B8=8 ;<E><J@ 9FQLCDLfKL
 

D8(<D@E8JCbE;8XPC<P8fCb;8;<c@C;@
;8D B8IfbJbE;8B@E@ <KB@C<P<E 9@I ?<P<:8EC8 8WbBC8;b
[ @c<I
;YEP8;8 P8f8P8E !<B8?C8I 9@Q@D @W@E K<?C@B<C@C<I SYEBY 9@Q<
B8Ifb;FJKCLB;LPDLPFIC8I \
1< K89@@ -8G? 9<BC<E@C<E :<M89b M<I;@ [*<I<;<E
9@C@PFIJLELQ\
[$@W B@DJ< 9<E@D >@9@ 9LI8P8 ><C<E F !<B8?C8IC8 9@IC@BK<
P8f8D8;b ;FJKLD +EC8IC8 JbBb=bBb FCD8;b +EC8IbE B8=8C8IbEbE
@W<I;@c@ ;LP>LC8I 9@Q< WFB P898E:b #8I@G ><IW<BC<I@ XcI<E;@D
8D8 FEC8Ib PFILDC8D8BK8 QFICLB W<B@PFILD D8 FEC8I P@E< ;<
9@Q@J8IJ8E9@IPXEY@f8I<K<;@PFIC8I
[@IB8WbEb J8P8:8cbD !<B8?C8I 9<C@IC@ Q8D8EC8I;8 FI>8E@Q<
<;@CD@f >ILGC8I ?8C@E;< 9@I9@IC<I@E@ XC;YIYPFIC8I !<B8?C8I B8IbE

:8C8I >@9@ P8f8D8P8 8CbfbBC8I 48E@ ;<M BYD<C<I ?8C@E;< 8fB8


9@I K8IQ P8f8Db 8BbCC8Ib 8CDbPFI E:8B PbcbEC8I ?8C@E;<
P8f8D8C8IbE8 I8cD<E 9@I9@IC<I@E@E M8ICbcbEb ;8 ?Ff B8IfbC8P8DbP

FIC8I 48 ;8 JFJP8C 9@C@DC<IC< @C>@C<E<E LQD8EC8IbE ;<;@BC<I@ >@9@


KFGCLD;8E ?FfC8EDbPFIC8I 8D8 8E:8B KFGCL ?8C;< P8f8P89@C@P

FIC8I LE8 B8IfbCbB 9@Q #LIIFNC8I KFGCLD;8 P8fbPFILQ 8D8


KFGCLCLBC8I;8E ?FfC8EDbPFILQ !<B8?C8IbE ;8MI8EbfC8IC8 @C>@C@ WFB
B8ID8fbB M< 8PIbEKbCb BLI8CC8Ib M8I +EC8Ib WF:LBC8I8 XcI<K@PFIC8I
D8 8EC8P8D8;bcbDbQ 9@I E<;<EC< ?@W B@DJ< 9L BLI8CC8I8
LPDLPFI19 19 19 \
-8G? JFcLB JFcLB [<E 9@I 8IB<FCFcLD \ ;@P< ?8KbIC8KKb
[0 !<B8?C8I 9<E@ J8;<:< 9@PFCFA@B 98BbD;8E @C>@C<E;@I@PFI
'8CW8 B<D@c@E@E B8M@J@E@ 9@CD<D 98E8 P<K<I 'YCKYI<C @fC<DC<I@E@E
W@Q;@c@ B8M@JC<I 9<E@ ?@W @C>@C<E;@ID<Q '8=8K8JbEbE 9@W@D@E@ @E:<

C<P<9@C@I@D D8 8?C8B BLI8CC8IbEbE <JI8ICb f<PC<I FCD8JbEbE 9<E

@D@W@E?@W9@IXE<D@PFBKLI \
[+EC8IbE ;<C@C@BC<I@E@E 9@Q@ <KB@C<D<P<:<c@E@ D@
;YfYEYPFIJLELQ\
-8G? [I8DbQ;8 ;FBLQ 9@E B@CFD<KI<C@B P8 ;8 ;8?8 ><E@f
 

9@I ;<E@Q M8I \ ;<;@ [ LILD 9L FBP8ELJK8 ;8 9XPC< ;@c<I@E;<


;< @Q@DB<E;@;YEP8DbQM8I FEC8IbE;8 I8DbQ;8?@W9@I@C@fB@
PFB\
(<D@E ;YfYE:<C@ ;YfYE:<C@ DbIbC;8E;b [$@W9@I @C@fB@ PFB
@c<IC<I@ ;< XPC< JXPC<;@C<I $@W9@ @C@fB@ FC8D8Q D8 !<B8?C8I
P@E< ;< 9@Q< <I@fK@C<I +EC8Ib 98fB8C8Ib ;8 @QC<P<9@C@I @Q< ;@c<I
;YEP8EbE J8;<:< 9@IB8W B@f@E@E PXE<K@D@E;< FC;LcLEL 8WbB

C8;bC8I +EC8Ib @J< >YM<E;< FCD8P8 B8Ifb ;LP;LBC8Ib 8:8@G @JK<B


PXE<K@PFIDLf L @JK<c@ !<B8?C8I;8 >YW 8EC8DbE8 ><C<E 9@I
JXQ:YBC< B8IbfKbIbPFI@8IDbf EC8fbC8E 9L 9@I B@DJ<E@E @I8;<J@E@
KFGCLDLE KYD @I8;<J@E;<E YJKYE J8PD8Jb 8EC8DbE8 ><C@PFI 48
9L>YW9@Q<;<LQ8EbIJ8\
-8G? B8=8JbEb 9L BFELP8 M<ID<P< W8CbfKb L C8=C8I JFE
;<I<:< >YCYEWKY L P898E:b B8MI8DC8Ib ?8P8C <KD<B
@DBVEJbQ;b
(<D@E [L !<B8?C8I ;YEP8C8IbDbQbE PYQPbCC8I XE:< 9@I9@IC<I

@E< ;8?8 P8BbE FC;LBC8IbEb JXPCYPFIC8I +EC8IbE ;YEP8JbE;8 WFB


@P@ 9@C@E<E 9@C@DJ<C 9@I M8IJ8PbD FC;LcLEL ;8 L BbK8C8IbE
JYIYBC<ED<C<I@PC< @C>@C@PD@f <CB@ 9L J@Q@ @C>@C<E;@I@I 4FBJ8 ;FB

LQ 9@E B@CFD<KI< LQ8BK8 P8f8P8E !<B8?C8I8 WFB 9<EQ<P<E @CB<C


GI@D8KC8IbE =FJ@CC<I@E@E 9LCLED8Jb FC8PbEb D8EKbBCb 9@I 9@W@D;<
@Q8?<;<D<QJ@E@Q\
1< 8IB<FCF>LE 9<PE@E;<B@ J@JC<I ;8cbC;b -8G? 98fbEb
B8C;bI8I8B <E;@f<C<I;<E LQ8B 9@I @C>@PC< B8IfbJbE;8B@E< 98BKb
[? 9LEL;8?8XE:<JXPC<D<C@P;@E@Q \
[LEL J@Q< f@D;@ JXPCYPFILD @Q< B8KbCbI M< P8I;bD <;<I

J<E@Q B<E;@ 98BbDbEbQ;8E E<C<I 98f8I89@C<:<c@E@Q@ >XJK<I<9@

C@IJ@E@Q @I f<P ;8?8 M8I L !<B8?C8I =@Q@BW@ @Q !8JK


$8I9FI;8B@C<I >@9@ D8 K89@@ 8I8;8 BYCKYIC<I@E@E XE>XI;YcY 9@I
=8IB M8I +EC8I BFM8E;8 P8f8;bBC8Ib @W@E 9L ;LILD8 LP>LE 9@I
9@W@D;< ;< ;YfYEYPFIC8I 48 ;8 9@I B8IbE:8 PLM8JbE;8 P8f8;bB

C8Ib @W@E @C@DC<I@ B8IbE:8


KFGCLDLELE 9@I JFEL:L /<B 98fC8IbE8
B8C;bBC8Ib Q8D8E B8=8C8Ib WFB 8cbI W8CbfbPFI 1< ?8P8C >YWC<I@ ;<
 

PFB D8 9@I8I8;8PB<E ?<GJ@ ;< ;@c<IC<I@E;<E =8IBCb 9@I<I


G8IW8:bB J8cCbPFIC8I XPC<:< W89L:8B G<B BF:8D8E 9@I P8Gb @E

f8 <;<9@C@PFIC8I LI8;8 @J< B@f@C<I FEC8I;8E WFB WFB Q<B@C<I


D8 FEC8I P8CEbQ 98fC8IbE8 W8CbfbPFIC8I TIE<c@E J@Q ?<I?8C;<
B@DP8BFELJLE;8?@W9@C>@E@QPFB \
-8G? [.8;<:< 9@IB8W K<D<C BLI8Cb 9@C@PFILD \ ;@P< @K@I8= <KK@
[$<GJ@FB8;8I /89@@9LBFELPL9@IB@DP8><I<9bI8BbPFILD \
[!M<K K89@@ D8 '*3 9@I B@DP8><I@D 1< 9L !<B8?C8I B8

=8:8 9<E;<E ;8?8 8f8cb FCD8C8IbE8 M< ;YEP8C8IbE;8 B@DP8><I


;@P< 9@I f<P 9LCLED8D8JbE8 I8cD<E 9L BFEL;8 9<E;<E 9@C>@

C@C<I SFB ;8?8 9@C>@C@ TIE<c@E J@Q ;LILG ;LILIB<E G8IW8C8E8E


<C<D<EKC<IFC;LcLEL9@C@PFIDLP;LELQ\
-8G? [dDBVEJbQ\ ;@P< G8KC8;b [!C<D<EKC<I XCYDJYQ;YI
?@W;<c@fD<QC<I \
(<D@E >YC;Y [!M<K J@Q< XPC< XcI<K@C;@ 8E8 ;8 XPC< <E
;< ;@c<IC<I@E< 9XPC< XcI<KK@D D8 P@E< ;< !<B8?`C8I ?8BCb (89

FI8KLM8IC8IbD;8 FEC8IbE JXPC<;@BC<I@ ?<I f<P@ @E:<C<;@D M< ?<I


8Wb;8E ?8BCb FC;LBC8IbEb >XI;YD 0I8EPLD;8E 9@I;<E9@I< I8;P

8JPFE P8PbC89@C@PFI /89@@ LI8EPLD;8E JXQ <;@C;@c@E@ ;LP;LELQ


LE;8E 98fB8 LI8EPLDLE YI<KK@c@ <E<IA@ I8;P8JPFEC8Ib ;bfbE;8
98fB8 B8PE8BC8Ib FC;LcLEL ;8 =8IB<KK@D *<;<E@PJ< 9@CD<;@c@D

@Q 8D8 !<B8?`C8IbE K8I@= <KK@BC<I@ <C<D<EKC<I;@ 1< 9L 9@C@ED<P<E


<C<D<EKC<I ;< 98Qb B@DP8:bC8IbE 9@C@D ;YEP8JbE8 QFIC8 B89LC <K

K@ID<P< W8CbfKbBC8Ib ,<I@PF;@B <KM<CC<I< ;< @P@:< LPLPFI /89@@


8IKbBFEC8Ib8f8cbC8I:8JbE8BFELfD8D;FcIL;<c@C \
-8G? [,<B@ 8D8 \ ;<;@ [YKYE 9LEC8Ib YKYE 9LEC8Ib
98E8 E<;<E 8EC8KbPFIJLELQ LELE ;8 JFILELDLE WXQYDYE<
P8I;bDbFC8:8BDb\
(<D@E 8C8PC8 [<CB@ \ ;@P< :<M8G M<I;@ [<CB@ ;8?8 JFEI8
9LELE JFPCL:8 9@I IYfM<K FC;LcLEL 8EC8P8:8BJbEbQ EC8P

8:8cbEbQ LI8EPLDLE <E<IA@ YI<K@D@ J89@KK@I /8D8D@P< S<MI<

;<B@ 9@C@E<E ?@W9@I ;bf ;<c@f@BC@B 9LEL <KB@C<D<Q 0I8EPLD <E<IA@


B8P9b PYQYE;<E 8cbI 8cbI BLIfLE8 ;XEYfYI '<J@E M< J89@K 9@I
 

?bQC8 ;8DC8IbDbQ f@D;@ 9@C< 9L K<D<C< ;8P8E8E 9@I PXEK<DC<


;YEP8EbE P8fbEb XCWD<P< W8CbfbPFIC8I EC8P8:8cbEbQ KFGI8BK8B@
9@I B8P8 K898B8JbEbE P8fbEb 8EC8D8B @W@E LI8EPLD @QC<I@ FC8E 9@I
9XCYDY 9LCD8B ><I<B@PFI JCbE;8 LI8EPLD WFB ><E@f 9@I 8C8E8
P8PbCDbf FC8E 9@I <C<D<EKK@I 0QD8EC8I 9L 9XC><;<B@ BLIfLE
D@BK8IbE8 98B8IC8I LI8;8 fLEL ;8 JXPC<D<C@P@D 0I8EPLD;8E
FCLf8E BLIfLEC8 ;@c<I BLIfLE 8I8JbE;8 =8IB M8I;bI L BFC8PCbBC8
8EC8fbCbI /89@@ 9XPC<:< F B8P8 K898B8JbEbE E< B8;8I Q8D8E;8E
9<I@ B8Kb FC;LcL FIK8P8 WbB8I PIb:8 F K898B8;8 9@I =FJ@C 9L

CLELIJ8FELE;88PEbP8fK8FC;LcL;YfYEYCYI TPC<;<c@CD@\
[4LB8Ib;8B@ PbC;bQC8I\ -8G? K@KI<P<I<B 8P8H& 0&108G <E@
B8E;bIDbPFIJLELQ;<c@CD@LELP8GD8B><IW<BK<EDYDBYE
DL^
]/89@@ 1< ?8KK8 BFC8P .@Q< <E 9YPYB J8MLED8 J@C8?bDbQbE
9@C@D 8C8EbE;8 @f9@IC@c@ P8GD8B FC;LcLEL JXPC<P<:<c@D SFB ><W
B8CDbf FCD8DbQ8 I8cD<E 9L 9XPC< LI8P8 G<B WFB >ILGK8E
9@C@D 8;8Db ><C;@ ;FJKLD @Q 9@I >ILG FCLfKLI;LB M< J@Q@E ;<
9@Q< B8KbCD8EbQb @JK@PFILQ @Q< B8KbCbIJ8EbQ >XJK<I<:<c@E@Q
9XC><C<I@ ;< GIF>I8DbDbQ8 8C8:8cbQ "FJ@C 98BbDbE;8E Q<E>@E
FC8E9XC><C<I@ *<;@PFIJLELQ\
].@Q<P8I;bD8?8QbIbD \

#LIIFN #ILGC8IbE;8 ;8?8 XE:< 9L ><E@fC@BK< KFGCLDJ8C 9@I


GIF>I8D LP>LC8E;bcb G<B >XIYCD<D@fK@ 8?8 XE:< ;< 8WbB

C8E;bcb >@9@ !8JK $8I9FI #IL9L 9@I E8BC@P8K D<IB<Q@P;@ D<I@B8


BbK8C8IbEbE @B@ BbPbJbE;8 ;8 PLB8Ib;8E 8f8cbP8 B8;8I K@:8I<K
P8G8E 9@I >ILG KC8EK@c@ 8f8:8B 9@I ><D@P@ ;< @Ef8 <;<9@C@I;@
+C8c8EYJKY FC8E @J< G<B WFB >ILGK8E ><C<E #LIIFNLE @f9@IC@c@
P8GD8Jb UJK<C@B@C>@8C8EC8Ib=8IBCbPB<E
/89@@?<GJ@E@EDLKCLFC;LBC8IbJXPC<E<D<Q;@ F;898fB8
TIE<c@E 9@Q@ @C>@C<E;@I<E 9L J898? -8G? <E;@f<PC< (<IE@E@
8IbPFI;L +!8JK$8I9FI8><C<C@8IKbB8CKb8PFCDLfKL
(<D@E@J<J8;<:<?<If<P@E;8?8?bQCbP8GbCD8JbEb@JK@PFI;L
 

dB@ 8;8D ;FBC8I;8 B8IfbC8fKbC8I (<D@E 9@I J@>8IbE L:LEL


bJbI8I8B -8G?b KYKYE @W@CD<J@E< @Q@E M<I@C<E 9@I P<I< >XKYI;Y
[!E;@f<C@ >@9@ 9@I ?8C@E M8I ;FJKLD $<I?8C;< 9L 9@Q@D KI8EJ8K

C8EK@BC<@C>@C@W8CbfD8C8IPYQYE;<E;<c@C \
-8G? :@;;@ 9@I K8MbIC8 ['8P8C8IbE P8fC8IbEb XcI<ED<P<
W8Cbf8E K@DC<I;<E ><C<E I8GFIC8I PYQYE;<E <E;@f<C@P@D \ ;@P<
8WbBC8;b
[? FEC8IPYQYE;<ED@YQYCYPFIJLE\
-8G?G8KC8;b [UQYCD<BD@.<EFI8GFIC8Ib>XI;YEDY\
[8E8 ;8 9@I BFGP8 ><C;@ M< 98BKbD ;8 $8KK8 98Qb 9XCYDC<I

@E@ FBL;LD D8 =8QC8 Q8D8EbD PFBKL SFcLEL B8MI8P8D8;bD


9@C< (YK=<E9<E@8P;bEC8KbIDbJbE\
[/89@@ .FE9@IB8W8P@W<I@J@E;<=FJ@CC@FC;LcLEL9<C@IKK@c@D
9XC><C<I;<E YWY @E:<C<E;@ dCB 9XC>< !8JK $8I9FI #IL9L P8BbE

C8IbE;8P;b dB@E:@J@ ,8J@=@B 8P #IL9LE;8 YWYE:YJY ;< )<IB<Q


#XCC<I #IL9LE;8 TE:< FEC8IC8 @C>@C<E@CD<J@E@ XQ<CC@BC< @JK<;@D
SYEBY =FJ@C 98BbDbE;8E <E Q<E>@E P<IC<I 8I8C8I;b M< 9@I9@IC<I

@E;<E @P@:< ;< LQ8BKbC8I e@D;@ XIE<c@E 98E8 fL YQ<I@E;<


;LI;LcLDLQB8P8EbEB8WP8fbE;8FC;LcLELJXPC<;@C<I;<IJ@E\
["8IB<KK@c@D<E9YPYBJ8Pb@B@D@CP8IPbC;bIJ8EbIbD \
[L <E <JB@ B8P8C8IbE P8fb /<D<C MFCB8E@B 98Q8CK
K898B8JbEbE E:8B
YJK K898B8C8IbE P8fb E< B8;8I ;<IJ@E dCB<C
GI@D8KC8IbE JYIYPC< =FJ@C@ 9LCLE8E KFIKL K898B8JbEbE <f
PYQ

KI@CPFEPbCLE8E<;@PFIJLEECbPFIDLJLE\
[/I@CPFE DL\ (<D@E >XQC<I@E@ BbJ8I8B PLB8IbP8 ;FcIL 98BKb
M< 98fbEb [EC8P8DbPFILD \ ;<D@f >@9@ J8CC8;b [L WFB
>8I@G \
[ 8?8Jb ;8 M8I ,8J@=@B 'bPbJb #IL9LELE PYQ KI@CPFE P8fbE;8
FC;LcLEL JXPC<;@C<I 98E8 )<IB<Q #XCC<I @J< ?<D<E ?<D<E J<B

J<EKI@CPFEP8fbE;8 \
(<D@E [48 ;@c<I XCWYDC<I\ ;@P< JFI;L [.<E@E K898B8C8IC8
@C>@J@FCD8P8EC8I\
[df@E <E >8I@9@ ;< 9L dE:<C<D<C<I@E WFcL XQ<CC@BC< =FJ@C:<
 

Q<E>@E FCD8P8E K898B8C8I;8 P8GbC;b 0QD8EC8I FEC8Ib A<FCFA@B


E<;<EC<IC< J<WK@C<I 1< ?<G 9@I9@I@E< LP8E JFELWC8I 8C;bC8I
dE:<C<E<E 9XC><E@E ;<I@EC@c@E< M< A<FCFA@B K8I@?@E< >XI< 9@I D@CP

FE;8E @B@ D@CPFE PbC8 B8;8I .8;<:< '*3.2 9XC><C<I@D;< FC

D8P8:8B>8I@GC@BC<I>XIYCYPFI \
(<D@E [&<FCF>C8I 9L BFEL;8 E< JXPCYPFIC8I\ ;@P< JFI;L
[@IP8ECbfCbBFC89@C@ID@\
[L B<J@E D8 8BC8 P8BbE ;FcIL ;YIYJK <CC@ XCWYD P8G

DbfC8I '<E;@8WbC8IbE;8EPXEK<D@E><W<IC@C@c@E@B8EbKC8;bBC8Ib@W@E
WFB DLKCLC8I /89@@ 9L YW 9XC><PC< @C>@C@ 8EFID8CC@BC<I M8I D8
J8B@E J8B@E @f< 9@C@ED<P<E 98Qb =8BKXIC<I@E B8IbfDbf FC;LcLEL
;YfYEYPFIC8I +PJ8 9<E 9XPC< ;YfYEDYPFILD + YW XCWYD ?<I
f<P;<E XE<DC@\ -8G? X=B<PC< ;LI8BC8;b [-8;PF8BK@M@K<E@E
;8@D8J89@KFC;LcLE;8E@P@:<<D@ED@J@E\
[!D@E FCD8B Db dEJ8E ?@W <D@E FC89@C@I D@ eL 8E8 B8;8I
9@C;@c@D@Q ?@W9@I f<P FEL <KB@C<P<D@PF @Q@D !<B8?C8I ;8
B<J@EC@BC< 8PEb f<P@ JXPCYPFIC8I PIb:8 fLEL ;8 JXPC<P<:<c@D
;FJKLD <c<I I8;PF8BK@M@K<E@E ><WD@fK< f@D;@P< >XI< ;8?8
=8QC8 FC;LcLEL @D8 <;@PFIJ8E F Q8D8E E<;<E J8;<:< J<E@E
9XC><C<I@E;<>XIYCYPFI9L*<;<E?<IK8I8=8P8PbCD8Dbf\
[!M<K E<;<E L ;8 ?<I >YE ;8?8 XE<D B8Q8E8E 9@I GIF9

C<D@E ;@c<I 9@I P8Eb YfYE 8Qb 9XC><C<I@E ><WD@fK< 8EFID8C


;<E@C<:<B B8;8I I8;PF8BK@= FC;LcL 8EC8fbCbPFI 8Qb 9XC><C<I;<
;< 8EFID8C J8PbC8:8B B8;8I WFB =FJ@C M8I *<;<E 9L 9XC><C<I
8PEb (<D@E\
[dEJ8EbE 8BCbE8 WFB 9<C@I>@E 9@I :<M8G ><C@PFI ;FJKLD .<E@E
@CB<C GI@D8KC8I 9<CB@ ;< 98Qb 9XC><C<I@E PYBJ<B ;<I<:<;<
I8;PF8BK@= FC;LcL 9@I W8c;8 P8f8;bC8I 1< @WC<I@E;<E 98QbC8Ib
P8ECbfCbBC8 F 9XC><C<I< >@I<I<B XC;YC<I /89@@ PYBJ<B ;<I<:<;<
I8;PF8BK@= I8;P8JPFE XC;YIY:Y;YI -8;P8JPFE M< =FJ@CC<I dfK<
9XPC< \
-8G? JFI;L [+ ?8C;< E<;<E 98fB8 P8I8KbBC8I ;8 XCD<;@
.8;<:< @CB<C GI@D8KC8IbE WFB J8Pb;8 =FJ@C@ 9LCLE;L 1< @CB<C
 

GI@D8K8BbCCbP;b /<?C@B<C@I8;P8JPFE8P8B8C8ED8Q;b \
[<CB@ ;< Q<B@ ;<c@C;@ .FELWK8 9L J<E@E M8IJ8PbDbE '8EbK

C8EDbf9@If<P;<c@C \
[D8 @CB<C GI@D8K L=8B 9<P@EC@ W8c;8fC8IbE;8E WFB ;8?8
Q<B@P;@ \
[<CB@ ;< ;<c@C;@ .<E 9L BFELP8 ;LP>LJ8C 9@I W<IW<M<;<E
98BbPFIJLE \
[<CB@ \ -8G? P8Ib =bJbC;8I >@9@ BFELfLPFI;L [@I D@CPFE PbC
P8 ;8 ;8?8 XE:< P8I8KbCDbf FC8E 9YPYB 9@I LP>8ICbcb ?8P8C <;<

9@C@PFILD +IK8;8E B8CB8E 9YPYB 9@I >YW YPYB 9@I B8=8 1<
><I@;< B8C8E K8fC8fDbf B<D@BC<I @I Q8D8EC8I @W@E;< 9<PE@E
P8f8;bcb BFJBF:8D8E 9@I B8=8K8Jb '<D@BC@ 9<f G8ID8BCb
BbMIbCDbf 9@I <C @BC<D<J@E< ><C<E 9@I 98fG8ID8B 48E@ 9L P8I

8KbcbE <CC<I@E@ LJK8CbBC8 BLCC8E;bcbEb >XJK<I<E @f8I<KC<I !M<K FE

C8I 2981&0& 8BbCCbP;bC8I TPC<FCD8CbC8I \


[+ ?8C;< FEC8Ib E< XC;YI;Y\ (<D@E FDQLEL J@CBK@ [+PJ8
9@IB8WD@CPFE:8ECbKYIYP8f8D8Pb98f8I;b \

-8G? 9@I8Q ;8 X=B<PC< 98fbEb B8C;bI;b [#XEYCCY FC8I8B J<E@E


>IL9LEC8 ><C<D<D (<D@E !M<K ;@c<I ;YEP8P8 >@KD<B P8I8ICb
FCLI /89@@ FI8;8 B<E;@ W8CbfD8C8IbDb JYI;YI<9@C@IJ<D D8 J<E

@E GC8EC8IbE 98BbDbE;8E 9L 9<E@D @W@E J8;<:< 9@I /FGCLD df@


FCLI \
D8 (<IE@E@E W<E< B8JC8Ib B898IDbfKb [dJK<;@c@E@ P8G8IJ8B
?8BJbQCbB <KD@f FCLILQ SFcLDLQ =<;8BVICbB <;@PFI M< 9@Q@ @C>@C<E

;@I<E BFELC8Ib 9@I K8I8=8 9bI8BbPFILQ ;FJKLD !c<I ?<G@D@Q


B<E;@ @C>@ 8C8EC8IbDbQ8 XE<D M<I@I ;@c<I ;YEP8Pb B<E;@ XQ<C
K8fI8Cb E@K<C@BC<I@D@Q< >XI< @E:<C<IJ<B F Q8D8E F 9YPYB
8D8:bDbQ8 <I@f<D<P@Q $<I f<P D8?MFCLI FJKLD 9@I K<B
B@f@;<E 9@C< M8Q><WD<C@P@Q $<G@D@Q ;< ?8P8KbDbQbE !<B8?
JFILELE W89L:8B WXQYDC<ED<J@E< 98cCbPDbf >@9@ W8CbfD8B
QFILE;8PbQ 1<98E8@E8E ><IW<BK<E;<XPC< \
-8G? K@BJ@EK@PC< W<E<J@E@ W8IGbKKb [.<E@EB@ J8;<:< ><I<BJ@Q



_9@I <E;@f< L Q8Pb= M< B8=8JbQ BYWYB P8I8KbBC8I;8E BFIBLPFI

JLE <EJ< B8=8 98BbDbE;8E WFB W<B@:@ FC8E B<J@E 9@I GIF9C<DC<
B8Ifb B8IfbP8PbD 1< 9<E 9L @B@J@ 8I8JbE;8 9@I @C@fB@ >XI<D@PFI

LD I8C8IbE;8?@W9@I@C@fB@FC8D8Q \
[<E ;< 8PD =@B@I;<P@D D8 9@I ;8B@B8 ;@EC< #YM<E;@c@D

@Q B@DJ<C<I;<E FCLf8E 9@I >ILG ><W<E ?8=K8 ;@c<I ;YEP8P8


P8GKbcb Q@P8I<KK<E ;XE;Y L 9@Q@DB@E@E K<IJ@E< I<JD@ 9@I Q@P8I<K
;<c@C;@ #ILGK8B@C<I B@DJ<PC< 8WbB 8WbB >XIYfD<;@C<I 8?8 WFB
:8JLJCLB P8GKbC8I LEL J8E8 f@D;@ 8WbBCbPFILD L BFEL;8
BFELfD8D8CbJbE \
[/89@@BFELfD8D \
[@Q@DB@C<I!<B8?C8IbEFC8P
BVcbKC8IbEb<C<><W@I;@C<I\
[!=<E;@D\
[+ f<P@ 8WbBC8D8B @W@E 9L 8;b LP;LI;LB !<B8?C8IbE P<I

C<f@D D<IB<QC<I@E;< ?<I >YE 98JbCDbf B8PbKC8I P8PbEC8EbPFI +E

C8I;8 >YECYB FC8PC8I 8EC8KbCbPFI !;<9@ <J<I J8PbC8:8B 98Qb f<PC<I


;<P8PbEC8EbPFI \
-8G?8ECbB9@I@C>@;LP;L [<E:<9LFC8c8EYJKY9@I=@B@I \
[!M<K 8JCbE;8 XPC< E:8B !<B8?C8IbE @C>@EW FC8PC8I BF

ELJLE;8B@ =@B@IC<I@ 9@I8Q =8IBCb +EC8I KFGCLDLE 8C<P?@E< FC8E


FC8PC8IC8 @C>@C<E@PFIC8I *<PJ< LEL f@D;@ 9@I P8E8 9bI8B8CbD
eLEL JXPC<D<B @JK@PFILD 8IKbB D<I@B8 BbK8C8IbEbE M8ICbcb 9@C@E@P

FI M< 9LI8;8E ?<I Q8D8E _P<E@ =bIJ8KC8I YCB<J@ ;@P< JXQ <;@C@PFI
S<f@KC@ !<B8? KFGCLDC8Ib ;8 9LI8P8 <MI<EJ<C 9@I ?bIJC8 98BbPFIC8I
!<B8?C8IbE J8PbJb WFB 4<IC<f@D D<IB<QC<I@ =8QC8 B8C898CbB !BF

EFD@C<I@ D8EKbBJbQ +EC8I P<E@ KFGI8BC8I @JK@PFIC8I 1< 9LI8Jb FE

C8I@W@EK8D@JK<;@BC<I@>@9@9@IP<I 4<E@M<9FD9FfKFGI8BC8I \
-8G?LPJ8C:8 [LI8Jb9Ff;<c@CB@ \;@P<?8KbIC8KKb
(<D@E BFIBLEW 9@I K8MbIC8 bJI8I <;@PFI;L [+EC8I @W@E 9FD9Ff
@fK< K<?C@B<E@E <E 9YPYcY ;< 9L +EC8I #LIIFNC8IbE P8f8;bBC8Ib
KFGI8BC8Ib 9Ff J8PbPFIC8I M< 9LI8C8Ib <C< ><W@ID<B E@P<K@E;<C<I
58K<E9@I9@IC<I@E@E<CC<I@E;<EYCB<C<I@E@8CD8P88CbfDbfC8I \
-8G?FDQLELJ@CBK@ [TPC<;<FCJ8 \
 

[!M<K Q8Pb=M<8GK8CC8I  <D@E9XPC<JXPC<;@E D8K<BK<B


E:8B 9@I 8D8W LcILE8 9@IC<f<:<BC<I /89@@ @JK<;@BC<I@E@ <C;< <K

K@BC<I@ Q8D8E P@E< 9@I9@IC<I@E< ;Yf<:<BC<I "8B8K BbJ8 9@I JYI< @W@E
9@IC<f<:<B M< >YWCY 9@I ?8C 8C8:8BC8I <CB@ 9@Q 9LEL 98f8I8D8P

8:8cbQ eL 8E;8 E8JbC ;8MI8E;bcbEb ;YfYE -8G? !<B8?C8IbE


J8M8f J@C8?C8Ib ] W8IGbfD8C8IbE 8K<f@E;< B<JB@EC<fD@f TIE<c@E
LW8ED8B@E<C<I@YJKYE9@I<IJ8M8fJ@C8?b \
[D89@QFELE<f@E@P8GKbB \
[SFB J8Pb;8 Db +EC8IbE B@DP8J8C G8KC8Pb:bC8IbEb ;8 K8BC@K <K

K@B D8 J8;<:< C89FI8KLM8I;8 K<fC<D< 9FILC8Ib M< QbI?Cb K8fbK

C8IbEbE <f@E@ ;< P8GKbB D8 J8;<:< ;<E<P 8KXCP<C<I@E;< PIb:8


!<B8?C8IbE 98fB8 J@C8?C8Ib ;8 M8I eL JFE 9<f PbC @W<I@J@E;<
><C@fK@I@CD@f FC8E 9@I f<P SYEBY 9@Q@D !<B8?C8IbE FE;8E
?89<IC<I@PFB \
[*<PD@fF\
[LEL 9@CD@PFILQ +C8P
BVcbKC8IbE;8 9LE;8E JXQ <;@C@PFI
+EC8I8 M<I@C<E 8;C8IbE 9@QC<I @W@E ?@W9@I 8EC8DC8Ib PFB D8
P8QbC8I;8E J@C8?C8IbE XC;YID< ;<C@J@ !<B8?C8Ib 9@C< ;<?f<K<
;YfYI;YcY 8EC8fbCbPFI +EC8IbE BLCC8EbC;bBC8IbEb >XJK<I<E 9@I
B8EbK PFB >@9@ YKYE !<B8? >ILGC8IbE;8 8PEb J@C8?K8E FC;LcLEL
>XJK<I<E 9@I f<P ;< D8 FEL YJKYE 9@I K<?;@K 8I8:b FC8I8B BLC

C8EbPFIC8I 4FC8 WbBKbBK8E JFEI8 9YKYE B8EbKC8Ib >XI;YcYE Q8D8E


9<CB@;LILDL;8?8@P@8EC8IJbE \
[D8 E<;@I 9L J@C8? +E;8E J8EB@ 9@I LD8:bPDbf >@9@ JXQ
<;@PFIJLE
[? 8JbC FEC8I 9LE;8E 9@I LD8:bPDbf >@9@ JXQ <;@PFIC8I 1<
9@I !<B8? @W@E 9@I LD8:b E< FC89@C@I dfK< @f@E <E BFIBLKL:L P8Eb
;8 9L @Q fL 8E8 B8;8I J8;<:< 9L @f@E GCYKFEPLD ;<E@C<E 9@I
<C<D<EK@E 9FD98I;bD8EbPC8 @C>@C@ FC;LcLEL XcI<E<9@C;@B L
D8;<E;<E JXQ <;@C;@c@E@ ?@W ;LPD8DbfKbB @Q@D !<B8?C8I ;8
XPC< FD98I;bD8E EXKIFE ;<E@C<E 9@I f<PC<IC< P8GbC8:8BDbf
@Q@D !<B8?C8I FEC8IbE 8KFD;8E ;8?8 BYWYB G8IW8:bBC8I FC;LB

C8IbEbJXPC<;@C<I L9@Q<WFB>YCYEW><C@PFI \
 

[$<GJ@9LB8;8IDb\
[!M<K 9L B8;8I @Q J8E8 F BVcbKC8Ib >XJK<I@E:<P< B8;8I
9<BC<ID@J@E'8I8IbEbFE;8EJFEI8M<I@IJ@E \
-8G?@JK<D<P<@JK<D<P<98fbEbJ8CC8;b [,<BVCV \

-8G? FI8;8 P8CEbQ 98fbE8 ;LILIB<E B8=8JbE;8 ?<G 8PEb


;YfYE:<C<I ;FC8fbG ;LILPFI;L .8EB@ BLIfLE B8;8I 8cbI

C8fDbfC8I;b9LEC8I
!<B8?C8I M< @CB<C GI@D8KC8I YQ<EJ@Q:< ;8MI8E8E :8ECb 9@I
P8I8KbB 1< PYBJ<BC<I< WbBD8B @JK<P<E XCDYf 9@I KYI ,8KC8P

8:bC8IC8 ;FCL B@IC@ 9@I f@D;@ *XKIFE 9FD98I;bD8Eb )YK?@f <JI8ICb


9@I><WD@f
I8C8IbE;8?@W9@I@C@fB@FC8D8Q $@W9@I@C@fB@
d--%$dS( %-%-)%

#<D@ XE:< D8;<E;<E P8GbCDbf 9@I @JB<C<K >@9@P;@ .FEI8


YQ<I@ 8cbI 8cbI G8IC8B 9@I ;<I@PC< B8GC8E;b dW@E< >8I@G 9@W@D;< FI

>8EC8IP<IC<fK@I@C;@
#<D@E@E ><C@fD<J@PC< @C>@C<E<E 9YKYE @EJ8EC8IbE @W@E;< =@Q@B@
FC8I8B <E 8Q /?FIEKFE $8DD<I W8CbfKb @I@ ;bfbE;8  <CB@ ;<
9L PYQ;<E <E =8QC8 J8P>b >XI<E ;< P@E< $8DD<I;b '8cbKC8I8
W@Q@C<E GC8EC8IbE K<D<CC<I@E@ FCLfKLI8E D8K<D8K@B J<D9FCC<IC< F @C

>@C<E;@ L GC8EC8I ;8 ><D@P@ FCLfKLI8E W<f@KC@ B@KC< M< ;<c@f@B


KYI;<<E<IA@C<I@EK<D<CC<I@>XI<M@E@P8GKbC8I
$8DD<I f@D;@ PYQYE< @P@:< FKLI8E >XQCYcYEYE 8IB8JbE;8E
W8CbfD8C8Ib :@;;@ :@;;@ J<PI<;@PFI;L #XQCYcYE :8DC8Ib
K8M8E;8B@ =CFI<J8E KYGC<I@E@E bfbcbEb P8B8CbPFI M< JFEI8 FEC8Ib
GbIbCKbC8I ?8C@E;< P8EJbKbPFI;L ,IFA< @W@E G8I8Pb M<I<E f@IB<K@E
G<IJFE<C 9XCYDYEY K<DJ@C <;<E /?<F;FI< (<E>P<C $8DD<Ib
P8EbE;8;LILPFI;L
@I;<E9@I< G8ID8cbPC8 J<IK 9@I @f8I<K P8G8I8B [dfK< F \ ;@P<
?FDLI;8E;b [eL8;8D \
$8DD<I98BKb ['8E<@D@B8JK<;@PFIJLE\
[eLP<f@CKLCLDCL8;8D !C@E;<9@IdE>@C@Q8E8?K8IbM8I \
['8E<F ,<B@ FELEC8E<8CbGM<I<D<P<:<c@EM8I\
[+ 8;8DbE E< @f P8GKbcbEb TcI<ED<B @JK@PFILD #<I@
Q<BVCbEbE K<B@ F \ (<E>P<C@E PYQY PLM8IC8B M< KFD9LC;L 48E8B

C8IbPJ8?8=@=W<K@KI@PFI;Lf@D;@
$8DD<I ;XEYG FE8 98BKb dE:< MY:L;LELE ?<I J8EK@D@
?FfELKJLQCLcLEL 8WbBCbPFI;L J8EB@ [4FBJ8 FEL I8?8KJbQ Db
<KK@E\
D &-&87G= <KD<B D@ +ELEC8 BFELfKLD <E@D >XI<M@D
@ @
fW C<IC< BFELfD8B FEC8IbE >XIYfC<I@E@ 8EC8D8B 9@C>@ KFGC8D8B
<E 9YKYE 9LEC8I;8E P8I8IC8E8I8B DFI8C@ ;YQ<CKD<B @W@E B8D

G8EP8C8I;YQ<EC@PFILD \
 

['8E<`@E9YKYE9LEC8I8E<Q8I8IbFCLPFI\
['YJK8? 9@I@ +E8 P`8 <I@f<:<B FC8E 9@I ><D@E@E YQ<I@E;<
W8CbfD8EbE E8JbC 9@I f<P FC;LcLEL JFI;LD #<D@E@E PbC;bQC8I8
LQ8E8E 9@I PFC FC;LcLE;8E JXQ <KK@D <CB@ BFELPL 9@I8Q ><E@f

C<KK@D /8D F JbI8;8 '8E< WFB B898 9@I K8MbIC8 ;XEYG >@KK@ +EL
><I@ W8cbI;bD M< _*<I<P< >@;@PFIJLE` ;<;@D 8E8 _<E 9L KYI
BFELfD8C8I;8E JbBbCbPFILD ` ;@P< :<M8G M<I;@ _#@;@G PbC;bQC8I8
98B8:8cbD `\
$8DD<I 98fbEb J8CC8;b [/8D8D '8E< PbC;bQC8I8 98BD8B

K8E?FfC8EbPFI \
[L FC8P >YE;YQ FC;L ;8D ><I@ Q<B8Cb + 8E;8E 9<I@;@I
'8E<@>XQ?8GJ@E<8C;bD EC8;bDB@ ?@WW8CbfDbPFI \
[LEL9@C@PFILD \
[+?8C;<FELE<;<E?VCV9LI8;8KLKLPFIJLE\
$8DD<I 8E@ 9@I f@;;<KC< [SYEBY FELE 9LI8;8 FCD8JbEb
@JK@PFILD \;<;@ [SYEBY98E87f8EJ><K@I@PFI \
(<E>P<C f8f8C8;b [e8EJ Db ><K@I@PFI '8?I<KJ@E L ;8 E<
;<D<BFCLPFI\
[eL ;<D<B FCLPFI F P8BbEbD;8PB<E B8=8D ;8?8 @P@ W8CbfbP

FI !C@E;< F B8?IFC8Jb:8 CE>@C@Q 8E8?K8IbPC8 P8EbD;8E ><W<IB<E


8BCbD8 G8IC8B =@B@IC<I ><C@PFI UJK<C@B YW B<Q ><IW<BC<f<E 9L FC8Pb
9@I KYICY 8WbBC8P8DbPFILD 58K<E F B8;8I ;8 XE<DC@ ;<c@C D8
'8E<9LI8;8B8C8:8B \
[e8B8<;@PFIJLE \
[$8PbI <KD@PFILD IKbB9<E@P8CEbQ9bI8B\

'8E< P<f@C KLCLDLPC8 FI8;8 ;LILPFI;L dE>@C@Q 8E8?K8Ib ;8


<C@E;<P;@
<C@IJ@Q:< ><D@E@E ?<D<E ?<D<E ?8QbI FC;LcLEL 8ECbP

FI;L I8W 9@I @EJ8Eb K8fbD8B @W@E P8GbCD8DbfKb D8 P@E< ;<
9@I B@f@ @W@E P<I M8I;b LEL ;@c<I f<PC<I@ E8JbC 8ECbPFIJ8 XPC<
8ECbPFI;L
TIE<c@E WFcL Q8D8E @EJ8EC8IbE P8EbE8 P8BC8fD8D8Jb
 

><I<BK@c@E@E =8IBbE;8P;b dEJ8EC8I FEL <C@E;< dE>@C@Q 8E8?K8IbPC8


>XID<P< 8CbfbE:8P8 B8;8I ?<I Q8D8E FELEC8 ;FC8fD8JbEbE f8IK
FC;LcLELE ;8 JCbE;8 B8DL=C8A WFB BYWYB f<PC<I;<E FCLfLP

FI;L eLdE>@C@Q8E8?K8IbEbK8fbD8B>@9@
'8E< K8D 8EC8DbPC8 B8MI8P8D8;bcb 9@IK8BbD >Y;YC<I@E
<KB@J@E;<P;@ TIE<c@E PbC;bQC8I8 98BD8B >@9@ 8fC8E>bWK8 PbCC8I
PbCC8I XE:< PbC;bQC8I8 8WbBC8E8D8Q 9@I 8:bPC8 98BDbfKb .FEI8
P8M8f P8M8f @C>@J@E@ >XBPYQYEYE 9<C@IC@ 9@I 9XCYDY W<BD<P<
98fC8;b IB8JbE;8E;8B<J@E9@IEFBK8
+EFBK8;8PbC;bQC8IPFBKL #XIYC<:<B?@W9@If<PPFBKLFI8;8
+ EFBK8 @CB98?8IbE JFEC8IbE;8 P< P8Q 8PC8IbE;8 ><:<C<I@
>XBPYQYEYE WFB PLB8IbC8IbE;8 FCLI;L '8E< 98Q8E 9YKYE ><:< F
EFBK8Pb >YE<P98Kb L=BLE8 ;FcIL @E@E:<P< B8;8I J<PI<;<I PbCbE
;@c<IQ8D8EC8IbE;8;8>YE;YQM8BK@FEFBK8P8>XQC<I@E@;@B<I;@
+ EFBK8PC8 @C>@C@ 9@I ;YfYE:< M8I;b 8D8 '8E< 9LELE 9<II8B

C8fD8JbEb 9@I KYICY J8cC8P8DbPFI;L 4bCC8I ><W<IB<E 9L ;YfYE:<


>YWC<ED@f M< PYQ<P< ;8?8 P8BC8fDbfKb *<I<;<PJ< FIK8P8 WbB8

:8BKb D8P@E<;<9<C@I>@E;<c@C;@
'8E< ?LQLIJLQ:8 BbDbC;8P8I8B ><D@P< P8BC8fKb L ?<D<E
?<D<E K8D8DC8EDbfKb IKbB 9@I 9YKYE J8PbC89@C@I;@ $<I f<P LP

>LE9@W@D;<P<IC<fK@I@CD@fK@ $<D<E?<D<E
#<D@E@E @W@E;< @P@:< 9LILE8 ;FcIL 9@I @EJ8E;8E 9@I8Q 9YPYB
9@I P<I M8I;b @I @EJ8E;8E ;8?8 ><E@fW< 9@I G8J8A FE8 ;FcIL LQ

8EbPFI;L !IK<J@ >YE 9L G8J8A8 ><I<BC@ f<PC<I@E JFELE:LC8Ib P<I

C<fK@I@C<:<BK@ /89@@ 9L P8GbCD8;8E XE:< F 9FfCLcLE ;FC;LILC

D8Jb><I<B@PFI;L D8 431&6G3 GC8EC8;bBC8Ib9@W@D;<;<c@C


'8E< ><D@P< ;8?8 ;8 P8BC8fKb 8D8 FELEC8 @C>@C<E<E FCD8;b
$<IB<J8CbfDbfKb'8E<<
.FE 8WbB P<I< <I@fD<B @W@E D<I;@M<E< KbID8ED8B M< @JB<C<P@
@C<I@P< ;FcIL @KD<B ><I<B@PFI;L '8E< F 8WbBCbcbE E<I<;<
FC;LcLEL ><D@P@ B<E;@ <CC<I@PC< P8GDbfW8JbE8 9@C@PFI;L )<I;@

M<E;<EWbB8I8B@JB<C<;<@C<IC<;@ +JbI8;8FI8;8?@WB@D
$8PbI P8EbCbPFI;L +I8;89@I@M8I;b
 

+8;8DJ<IKJ<IK [LI8;8E<@f@EM8I\;<;@
'8E< ;@BC<fK@ M< ;8C>bE 98BbfCb >XQC<I@E@ FE8 ;@BK@ dE>@C@Q
8E8?K8IbEb B8C;bI8I8B @fW@E@E 98fbE8 ?8=@=W< @E;@I;@ dfW@ ;8I9<;<E
BLIKLCD8P8W8CbfD8;bM<P<I<PbcbC;b
'8E< 8;8Db FI8;8 XPC<:< 9bI8BKb '8PbKJbQ:8 dfW@ LQLE JYI<
98P>bE B8CD8P8:8BKb D8 8I8;8E ><W<E JYI<;< '8E< @W<I@;<B@
F P<I< JYQYC<9@C<:<B 8;8D B<E;@E< ><C;@c@ Q8D8E '8E<@ ;<
98PbC;bcbEb ;8 ?8KbIC8D8P8:8BKb 48f8DbEbE 9<f ;8B@B8Jb B8P

9FCDLf FC8:8BKb 9XPC<:< D8 F 9L 9<f ;8B@B8Pb E< 9LC89@C<:<B


E<;<8I8P8:8BKb
+ ?Y:I< >@9@ P<I B8I8ECbBKb M< K89@@ FI8;8 ?8M8C8E;bID8 ;8
PFBKL D8 '8E< 9LE8 8C;bID8;b dW>Y;YC<I@E@E E<;<E FC;LcL
9@I >YM<EC< ?Y:I<P< ;FcIL KbID8E;b .FEI8 JFCLB JFCLc8 FI8;8
XPC<P8KKb $Y:I<FE8@P@:<LPLPFI;L .8EB@9@II8?@DD@f>@9@
dB@ J88K JFEI8 ?8P8K@ 8I8W M< ><I<WC<I@E JFELE:LC8IbEb ;8
DFEK< <;<:<B M< G8J8Ab B8G8P8:8BC8I;b "8IBbE8 M8ID8;8E
'8E<@ ;< FI8;8 9bI8B8:8BC8I;b /89@@ 9L D<K8C J<I8D@B M<
P8BbKK8E P8I8KbC8E ><D@E@E @W@E;<B@ K<B <K M< B8E;8E FCLf8E f<P
'8E<FC8:8BKb
'8E< B<E;@J@E@ Q8D8EbE;8E XE:< FI8;8 9LCLM<ID<C<I@E;<E
BFIBDLPFI;L ,IFA< YQ<I@E;< W8Cbf8EC8I;8E ?@W9@I@E@E 9L ?Y:I<

;<E ?89<I@ PFBKL TIE<c@E $8DD<I ;<E@C<E 8;8D ,IFA< YQ<I

@E;< W8Cbf8EC8IbE C@;<I@P;@ F 1< <E =8QC8 <KB@C<E<E@ '8E<@E


<KI8=bE;8B@ J@C@B >XC><C<I< 9<EQ<P<E @EJ8EC8IbE 8I8JbE;8 F 9@I8Q
9<C@I>@E:<P;@ '8E< 98Q8E W8CbfD8 8C8EbE;8 8cbI 8cbI J8EB@
<KI8=bEb J@JC<I J8IDbf >@9@ ;FC8fbIB<E $8DD<I@E P8BbEbE;8E
><W@PFI M< F Q8D8E 8;8Db =8IB<;@PFI;L #<I<B<E J8;<:<
9LP;L $8DD<I@EP8BbEbE;8E><WD<B
'8E< ;8?8 XE:< ;< ;LILDLE 9XPC< FC;LcLEL 8EbDJbPFI;L
TQ<CC@BC< BLI8D:bC8I BFELJLE;8 (@J< )<@KE<I EXKIFE 9FD98I;b

D8EbE8 KLKLC8E LI8EPLD;8E YI<K@C<E D8;;<C<I 8I8JbE;8 98IPLD


8I8D8P8 B8I8I M<I;@c@ Q8D8E '8E< ;< B@DJ<E@E ;@BB8K@E@
W<BD<;<E P8BbE;8B@ BFI@;FI;8 8cbI 8cbI PYIYPFI;L  ;<
 

><EW !@EJK<@E ;YfYE:<C@ ;YfYE:<C@ 9@I G8IBK8E ><W<IB<E '8E<


;< FI8;8 BLILDLf P8GI8B M< WXGC<I@ KFGCLPFI;L .FEI8 !@EJK<@E
8BCbE8 9@I;<E9@I< 9@I =@B@I ><C;@c@ @W@E 8;bDC8IbEb JbBC8fKbIDbfKb
'8E<9LEL9@I<C<BKI@BfFBL>@9@?@JJ<KD@fK@
D8 F 9YKYE 9LEC8IbE E8JbC FC;LcLEL 9@CD@PFI;L @I XIYD

:<c@E @CB 8cbEb XID<P< 98fC8;bcb Q8D8E D@D8I@ K<FI@P@ 9@C;@c@


;YfYEYC<9@C@ID@
$<I f<P WFB ;8?8 ><I@C<I< LQ8EbPFI;L #<EW *<NKFELE B8

=8JbE;8 P<E@ 9@I ;YfYE:< 9<C@ID<P< 98fC8IB<E P8 98BKbcb >YE


'8E<;<FI8;8P;b 1<;8?8;8XE:<J@M8I;b9LELE

*<N )<O@:F;8B@ ><E<CC@BC< 9Ff FC8E 9L WXC;< f@D;@ @EJ8EC8I


B8IbE:8C8I >@9@ >XBPYQYE< ;FcIL LQ8E8E M< D8;<E;<E ;<M 9@I
BLIfLE8 9<EQ<P<E 9@I f<P@E <KI8=bE8 YfYfDYfC<I;@ L ><D@
;8?8XE:<P8GbC8EC8I;8EWFB=8IBCbP;b
L ><D@ ;YEP8EbE <KB@J@E;<E ;@c<IC<I@E;<E ;8?8=8QC8 BLIKL

C8:8BKb /<BI8I P<IPYQYE< ;FcIL ;YfD<P< 98fC8D8;8E XE:<


LQ8BC8f8:8B M< PbE <KI8=bE;8 ;FC8f8:8BKb dW@E< ;FC;LILCDLf
FC8E 8C<KC<I PbE =FKFcI8=C8IbEb W<B<:<B P8PbEC8E8E bJbPb XCW<

:<B I8;PF8BK@M@K< 8I8P8:8B M< D@BIF


;8C>8PC8 B@DP8J8C P8GbC8Ib
9LCD8P8 W8Cbf8:8BKb dEJ8EC8IbE 9LCLE;LcL 9@I LQ8P ><D@J@E@E
P8G89@C<:<c@ ?<I f<P@ D8B@E<C<I 98f8I8:8BKb +E;8E JFEI8
@W@E;< 8JKIFEFKC8I 9LCLE8E 9@I ><D@E@E >XE;<I@C<9@CD<J@ @W@E P<

K<I@B8;8I9@C>@KFGC8P8:8BKb
D88JCbE;89L@W@E;<@EJ8E9LCLE8E9@I><D@J8PbC89@C@I;@
S<f@KC@ ?YBYD<KC<I@E <E;YJKI@C<I@E KFGCLDJ8C M< <BFEFD@B
>ILGC8IbE K<DJ@C:@C<I@ M8I;b 9LI8;8 /<C<M@QPFE B8D<I8C8Ib M<
>8Q<K<:@C<I;<
+I8P8 >@;<D<P<EC<I LQ8P ><D@J@E@E ?8I<B<K@E@ <MC<I@E;<E
J<PI<KK@C<I M< ><I@ J8Pbfb ;@EC<;@C<I @I LQD8E 9L @f@ ;@BB8KC< M<
K<B;YQ< 9@I J<JC< P8GKb +KLQ PbC >@9@ BbJ8 9@I JYI<;< 9@I ><C<E<B
?8C@E@8CDbfKb9L
.b=bI\;8 I<8BJ@PFE DFKFIC8Ib W8CbfD8P8 98fC8;b M< ><D@
 

8cbI8cbI?8M8C8E;b

'8E<?bQC8LW8E>8QC8IbE>YIYCKYJYEY;LPLPFI;L .8EB@
LQ8BC8I;8E ><C@PFI;L 9L J<JC<I '8E< ><D@ ?bQC8EbIB<E J8EB@ 9@I
>Y:YEB<E;@J@E@@KK@c@E@?@JJ<KK@
'8=8JbEb 98cbDJbQC8fKbI;b F Q8D8E +EL PLB8IbP8 @C<I@P<
;FcIL @KK@ 8E8:bJb ;LPD8D8B M< I8?8KJbQ FCD8D8B @W@E B8

=8JbEbEMY:L;LPC8;FcIL;8E;FcILP8FC8E98cC8IbEbWXQ;Y
.<IJ<D J<IJ<D F LQLE PFC:LCLcLE JFE8 <ID<B YQ<I<
FC;LcLEL B8MIbPFI;L IKbB @EJ8EC8IbE XCYDJYQ FC;LcLEL 8E

C8D8D8C8Ib @W@E ;@BB8KC@ ;8MI8ED8B QFILE;8 B8CD8P8:8BKb


@BB8K@ W<BD<D<B @W@E 8IB8 GC8E;8 B8CD8P8 W8CbfD8P8:8BKb @I
P<I;<E 9@I P<I< >@;<I<B 8;bEb M< B@f@C@c@E@ JbB JbB ;<c@fK@ID<P<

:<B B8=8C8IbPXEC<E;@ID<P<:<BK@
/89@@ K8D 8EC8DbPC8 @P@:< J8BC8E8D8DbfKb + <JB@ 0W8E $FC

C8E;8Cb M< .<IJ<I@ 48?L;@ <=J8E<C<I@ ;FcDLfKL D8 P@E< ;<


;YEP8;8P8f8DbfM<FELI8?8KJbQ<;<EFCD8DbfKb
'8E< >XBPYQYE;<B@ F EFBK8Pb >XI<9@C@PFI;L '8Kb 9@I :@J@D
FC8E ><D@E@E @W@E;<E ?<D ;< <CB@ ;< 9LEL 8JCbE;8 >XID<B ;@

P< K8EbDC8D8B P8ECbfKb '8E< 9L ;LILDL 8WbBC8P8:8B LP>LE


JXQ:YcYPJ<9@CD<D<BK<P;@
D8 LP>LE 9@I B<C@D< FC;LcLEL 9@C@PFI;L '8E< 9@C;@c@
f<PC<I@E 8Q 9@I BbJDbEb 9@C< E8JbC XcI<E;@c@E@ 8EC8P8DbPFI;L .8

;<:< PYQPbCC8I ><W<IB<E ?<I f<P@ D8EKbBC8 8WbBC8D8Pb ><I<B

K@ID<P<E9@I>YM<EC<9@C;@c@E@8EC8DbfKb
+ P8f8D8 9@I PLDLIK8 FC8I8B 98fC8DbfKb  8?8 ;FcILJL
9@C;@c@ <E P8BbE B<C@D< 9L PLDLIK8 JXQ:YcYP;Y  4LDLIK8Pb
JFEI8;8E @EJ8E ;@P< K8EbDC8E8E <KI8=K8 ;FC8f8E M< 8MC8E8E
P8I8KbBC8I @CB B<EKC<I@E@ BLID8;8E WFB XE:< ;YEP8P8 9bI8B

DbfC8I;b K8Jb P<IPYQYEY ;@BB8KC< J<WD@fK@ $<I ;YEP8 LP>LE


;<c@C;@
$8E>@ ;YEP8 LP>LE;L TCWY E<P;@ '8E< 9L JFILC8IbE
:<M8GC8IbEb?VCV9@CD@PFI;L
 

/bIKbI <f<B8IbJb PLDLIK8C8IbEbE @W@E;< 9<JC<E<9@C<:<c@ XIYD

:<c@ J<W@G FEL XCD<P<:<c@ 9@I 9@W@D;< JFBD8;8E XE:< 8EJ@BCF

G<;@E@E9X:<BC<I9XCYDYEY@E:<C<ID@P;@
.FELE;8 PLDLIK8 P8IbCDbf M< ;bf8Ib WbB8E '8E< ;< @EJ8E
9@W@D@E@ 8CDbfKb dEJ8EC8IbE 8I8JbE8 B8IbfDbf 8D8 B<E;@E@ FEC8I8
B8Ifb BFILDLfKL 1< 9@I K<B 8D8:b M8I;b dEJ8ECbcbE 9@I LQ8P
><D@J@PC< JFELWC8E8:8B 9@I PFC;8E @C<IC<D<J@E@ J8cC8D8B +
><D@E@E@W@E;<9@I?Y:I<FC8:8BKb $Y:I<E@E@W@E;<;<B<E;@J@
#<D@ 8KDFJ=<I;<E WbB8IB<E >XBPYQYE;<B@ F EFBK8;8 9<C@I

>@EC<fK@ '8E<@E B8=8JbEbE B@C@;@E@ 8W8E 8E8?K8I ;8 9L FC;L @C

D<:<E@EK8D8DC8ED8JbEbJ8cC8P8EJFEG8IW8
+ EFBK8;8 @EJ8EC8IbE WbGC8B >XQC< >XI<D<P<:<BC<I@
PbC;bQC8I bfbC;bPFIC8I;b dWC<I@E;<E XQ<CC@BC< 9@I K8E<J@ bfbC bfbC;b
1< '8E< FE8 B8Ifb DYK?@f 9@I XQC<D ;LPLPFI;L dW@E;< LQLE
9@IJYI<;<E9<I@>YWC<E<EJXQ9@I;<E9@I<8cQbE;8E=bfBbI;b
'8E< [4LI;LD \;@P<=bJbC;8;b
@C@PFI DLP;L @I JFD 98Cbcb PbCC8I XE:< PLDLIK8;8E WbBKbcb
FK8KCbJLB8PE8cbEb9LCD8B@W@E?8I@K8C8IbDb@E:<C<I
.FE 8;bD J<B@Q 9@E PbC JYI<E F 8cbI FC>LEC8fD8 JbI8JbE;8
8KbCDbfKb '8E<8IKbB9@IC8IM8;<c@C <I>@E9@I:8ECbP;b
!I>@E '8E< C8IM8Pb BFILP8E @EJ8E <K@E;<E FCLfDLf MY:L

;LE @W@E;<E B8WKb 0Q8P ><D@J@E;<E ;< /<C8fC8 @E8EbCD8P8

:8B 9@I ?bQC8 B<E;@ ;YEP8JbE8 ;FcIL >@KK@ <CB@ @C<I@;< 9@I >YE
FI8;8E PFC8 WbB8I8B LQ8P;8 ;FC8f8:8B M< B<E;@ PLDLIK8JbPC8
;XCC<P<:<c@9@I><Q<><E8I8P8:8BKb
48I8KbB LQ8P;8 ?bQC8 @C<IC<;@ Ff BI@Q8C@J@ K8fbP8E ><D@P@
;YfYE;YcY 9@C< PFBKL .bI= '8E< ;<E@C<E P8I8KbcbE FC>LEC8fbG
8D8:bE8 <I@fD<J@ @W@E 9YKYE 9@I ;YEP8Pb K<BEFCFA@ M< LQ8P PFC

:LCLcLE8;FcILJYIYBC<;@c@E@;<;YfYEDYPFI;L
@I 8Ib 98CXQYEY <D;@BK<E JFEI8 LQ8BC8fbIB<E ><I@;< B8C8E
W@W<c<E<FC;LcLEL?@W;YfYEYIDY



$!-d-d d-'ed"
$<ID8E ?FLEJ XEJ<Q@C<I@E< @E8E8E 9@I 8;8D;b .8Q8E
?8BCb WbB8I 98Q8E ;8 P8EbCbI;b +I8E <CC@ <CC@P;@ !? ;FcIL :<M

89b @?K@D8CC<I;<E FCLf8E BFJBF:8D8E 9@I <MI<E;<E J<W@G 8CD8B


QFILE;8FC;LcLDLQ8>XI<<CC@<CC@;<?@W=<E8J8PbCD8Q;b
?FLEJ 9L ;LILD;8E ?<I Q8D8E D<DELECLB ;LPD8Q;b L
@f J@E@IC<I@E@ ><I@PFI;L FELE dEJ8EC8I KFGC8fbG 9@I JFILEL
;YfYEYPFI @f@E @W@E;<E WbB8D8PbE:8 ;8 FE8 ;XEYPFIC8I;b [.<E
E<;@PFIJLE ?FLEJeLXEJ<Q@E@W8CbfKbI98B8CbD \
48ECbf K8?D@E;< 9LCLELIJ8 JFILDCLCLB ?<D<E FE8
PYBC<E@PFI;L
)<JC<c@ ;< ;LILDL ;8?8 BXKYC<fK@I@PFI;L ?FLEJ 9@I
8I8fKbID8:b
BVf@=K@
+E8 [L ><Q<><E< P8BbE;8E 98BD8P8 ;<c<I D@\ ;@P<
JFILPFIC8I;b [*<;<IJ@E ?FLEJ\
;8D 9L PYQ;<E@B@ B@f@C@B 9@I K@D< J<W@C@E:< WFB I8?8KC8;b
L XE<DC@ FCD8P8E 9@I P<I< PFCC8E8:8cb M< 98JBbC8I;8E ;8 BLI

KLC8:8cb 8EC8DbE8 ><C@PFI;L  +E8 @C<E .D@K?C< 9@IC@BK<


W8Cbf8:8cbEbJXPC<;@BC<I@Q8D8E?FLEJ;8?8;8J<M@E;@
.D@K? =8QC8 ?<P<:8EC8ED8P8E JFcLBB8ECb 9@I K@GK@ 4FC8 @CB
WbBKbBC8Ib >YE ?FLEJ8 [.<E@E fL P<K<E<B \ ;<;@ [<PE@E;<B@
8Eb ;FJP8C8Ib ?<IB<J@EB@E;<E ;8?8 ?8QbI;8 9<BC@PFI @I JFILEC8
B8IfbC8fKbcbE Q8D8E 9@Q@D 9<CB@ ;< ?8KbIC8P8D8;bcbDbQ 98Qb L=8B
K<=<B f<PC<I@ 8EbDJbPFI M< B8I8I M<I@PFIJLE LE;8E XEJ<Q@ ;@P<
JXQ <KD<B 9L P<K<E<c@E< <JI8ICb 9@I ?8M8 M<I@PFI D8 8JCbE;8
?@W;<XPC<;<c@C \LJXQC<I@JXPC<IB<EJ8WC8IbEb8IB8P8;FcIL
@KK@ .8WC8IbJ8IbP;bM<98fbE8 9@IK8BB<>@9@@P@:<;<P8GbfbPFI;L
?FLEJLE J8WC8Ib @J< 9@W@D< >@ID@PFI;L LIEL BYWYB M<
B8CBbB 9@I8Q ;8 <cI@P;@ ;8D ?<I Q8D8EB@ >@9@ PLDLf8B 9@I
 

J<JC< \<CB@;<9LK<C<G8K@PC<@C>@C@ \;@P<:<M8GM<I;@


[*<\
\@IKYIK<C<G8K@8D8WFB?8=@=@ \
.D@K? ;< ?<I Q8D8EB@ >@9@ >YIYCKYCY 9@I B8?B8?8 8K8I8B 8C8P
<KK@ [$8P;@ FI8;8E @C@D 8;8DC8Ib 9@E PbC;8E 9<I@ GJ@FE@B
=<EFD<EC<I@ @QC@PFI 8D8 P@E< ;< ?@W9@I P<I< M8I8DbPFIC8I TPC<
f<PC<I PFB ;FJKLD XE:<;<E 9@CD< K<C<B@E<Q >8@GK<E ?89<I
M<ID<M<K<C<G8K@\
[LEL B89LC <;@PFILD D8 9@I ;< fLEL ;YfYE @P<C@D B@
9@I >ILGK8B@ @EJ8EC8IbE E<C<I ;YfYE;YcYEY 8ECbPFILD $8KK8 E<C

<I FC;LcLEL 9@CD<J<D 9@C< L ;YfYE:<C<I@ 9@IC<fK@I<I<B 9@I


:<M8G FCLfKLI8D8Q DbPbD #ILGK8B@ 9@I K<B B@f@;<E ;8?8 =8QC8
9@C>@D FC8:8cb @W@E ;@c<IC<I@E;<E ;8?8 @P@ B8I8I M<I<9@C@I@D ;<c@C
D@48E@ 98Q8E \
[LELB8EbKC8P89@C@ID@J@E\
?FLEJ LPJ8C 98BbfCb >XQC<I@E@ .D@K?< ;@BK@ [<E@DB@ J8

;<:<9@IXEJ<Q@ \
dB@ LQD8E @P@ ><W@E@PFIC8I;b ?FLEJ .D@K?@E @EJ8Eb :8E

C8E;bI8E F GI8K@BC@c@E;<E ?FfC8EbPFI;L .D@K? @J< FELE


;YfYE:<C<I@E@ <C<fK@I@PFI;L .bB JbB K8IKbfbPFIC8I 8D8 ?@W B8M>8
<KD@PFIC8I;b
$<;<=C<I@E< <I@fK@BC<I@E;< 8IK8E ><I@C@D ;LILDL
BXKYC<fK@ID<;@ $<;<=C<I@ F Q8D8E8 B8;8I @EJ8E <C@E;<E WbBDbf
8KFD I<8BKXIYEYE <E<IA@ ;8C>8C8IbEb ?@W ?@JJ<KD<D@f FC8E 9@I
BYI<C<IBYD<J@P;@
.D@K? [ YEP8;8B@C<I@E 9L 9@C>@C<I@ E< P8GKbBC8IbEb D<I8B
<;@PFILD \ ;<;@ [8Q8E 98E8 9YKYE 9LEC8I 9FfLE8 Q8?D<KD@f
>@9@><C@PFI \
?FLEJ [ YEP8;8B@ @EJ8EC8I P8M8f P8M8f <KI8=8 P8PbCD8P8
98fCbPFIC8I \ ;@P< :<M8G M<I;@ [@I D@CPFE PbC JFEI8 @EJ8EC8IbE
>8C8BJ@;< E<I<C<I< <I@f<:<BC<I@E@ B@DJ< 9@C<D<Q /FGC8;bcbDbQ
><Q<><EC<IC<@C>@C@?<I9@C>@@C<I@;<9@I>YE@f<P8I8P8:8B \
[I8fKbID8 K@DC<I@E< >XEYCCY 9LCD8B @W@E ?8QbIC8E8E
 

<CB@K89bE;8E =8IBbE PFB .<E:< FELE @C>@EW 9@I P8Eb M8I Db\
.D@K? M@Q@
C<M?8Pb @f8I<K <KK@ LE;8 P8BbEC8fD8P8 98fC8P8E
BYD<P<I<;XBYCDYfK8CBGL;I8JbE89<EQ@PFI;L
[<CB@ TEJ<Q@C<I@D 98E8 \ ?FLEJ ;LI8BC8;b PLKBLE;L
#XQC<I@E@9@I@B@;<=8BbIGKb .FEI8;8LJLC:8>YCYDJ<;@
.D@K? 9LILE BbMbI;b [!E P8BbE;8B@ PbC;bQ >IL9LE8 ;FcIL
;XE<C@D 1< ><Q<><EC<I@E <E JbB FC;LcL P<I;<E ><W<C@D +
E@E 8CKbE;8 9@I ):'FD@E FI8Eb 9LC8:8cbDbQ;8E <D@E@D @I< FE
98?J<>@I<I@D \
?FLEJ [1< 98?J@ B8P9<;<IJ@E \ ;@P< DbIbC;8E;b @I;<E

9@I< ?<P<:8EC8EDbfKb 4<E@ ;YEP8C8I 8P8BC8IbEbE 8CKC8IbE8 J<I@C<

:<c@ Q8D8E ?<G 9XPC< FCLI;L L WFB ;8 _9LC8fb:b 9@I ;LP>LP;L


$<I PbC PYQC<I:< ><E:@ <KB@C<I;@ ?FLEJ ;8 9@I Q8D8EC8I XPC< 9@I
><EWK@ L ;<C@B8ECbC8I K@DC<I< B8KbCbI @C<I@;< 9@I >YE KFILELE

C8IbEbE J8?@G FC8:8cb ;YEP8C8Ib >XID<B @W@E J89bIJbQC8EbIC8I;b


$<I9@I@;<9@I<IBVf@=K@J8EB@
.D@K?C< ?FLEJ ?8QbICbBC8Ib K8D8DC8;bC8I M< BYD<E@E @W@E<
;FcIL @CB ?@G<I
LQ8PJ8C JbWI8D8Pb P8GKbC8I .FEI8 ><Q<><E J@J

K<DC<I@E@ 9LC89@CD<B @W@E PbC;bQC8Ib @E:<C<D<P< 98fC8;bC8I +E

C8IbE @f@E@ 9@C>@J8P8IC8I P8GbPFI 8PIbEKb ;FCL ;FJP8C8IbE J8PbJb >@K

>@;< 8IKbPFI;L $<I f<P GIF>I8D8 >XI< D<DELECLB M<I<:<B 9@I


9@W@D;< @C<IC@PFI;L .FEI8  ELD8I8Cb J@JK<D;< ;LILD ;<c@fK@
.bWI8D8Pb K8D8DC8;bBK8E 9@I8Q JFEI8 ><D@E@E ?@G<I
8KFD@B DF

KFIC8Ib;LI;L
?FLEJ [/L?8= \ ;@P< DbIbC;8E;b [E8C@Q:@C<I E<P@E
9FQLBFC;LcLEL8WbBC8DbPFIC8I \
$8BCbP;b d9I<C<I ;YQ<EJ@Q:< K@KI@PFI M< 9@I EFBK8;8 BbJ8 9@I
JYI< @W@E 9@C< ;LIDLPFIC8I;b +ELE @W@E JFILEL 8WbBC8D8C8Ib
FC8E8BJbQ;b LELE JFEL:L FC8I8B @B@ 8IB8;8fbE K8D@I P8G

D8C8Ib;8DYDBYEFCD8P8:8BKb
.D@K? ?FDLI;8E;b [e@D;@P< B8;8I 9XPC< 9@I f<P ?@W
>XID< ;@D $<I f<P@ B8G8KD8DbQ M< 8C<KC<I@ <CC< W8CbfKbI8I8B
;LILDLXcI<ED<D@Q><I<B<:<B \


?FLEJ K<C<JBFGLE 98fbE8 ><WD@fK@ 9@C< [$@W FCD8QJ8


9LEL I8?8KW8 P8G8CbD *FID8C >YWK< 9@I 9FQLBCLB PFB L J@J

K<D;<LP>LE@B@><Q<><EM8I \
D$& *<B8;8ILP>LE1<?8E>@C<I@\
[eL ;XIKCY;<E 9@I@E:@ M< dB@E:@J@ dB@J@ ;< JL
FBJ@A<E
>IL9LE;8E @I@E:@J@ ;YEP8;8E 9@I8Q ;8?8 Jb:8B M< 9YPYB
dB@E:@J@@J<9@I8Q;8?8JFcLBM<BYWYB /8D8DDb\
[8ECbC8I\
[dB@KYI;< $@WFCD8QJ89@KB@XIKYJYM8I \
.D@K? @EJ8Eb f8fbIKD8P8:8B 9@I f<PC<I DbIbC;8E;b .L
FB

J@A<E ;YEP8C8IbE;8 ><E<CC@BC< 9@KB@ FCLPFI;L M< 9@KB@C<I


?8PM8EC8IbE K<IJ@E< K<C<JBFGC8 >XIYC<9@C@PFIC8I;b 48 ;8 ;8?8
;FcILJL JG<BKIFJBFGC8 $<I KYI 9@KB@;< J8;<:< =FKF
B@DP8J8C
;XIK 9FP8 D8;;<J@ M8I;b LEC8I P8EJbKKbBC8Ib bfbBC8I8 >XI<
J<W@C<9@C@PFIC8I;b
?FLEJ [dB@ ><Q<><E;< ;< 9@KB@C<I BCFIF=@CC@ \ ;<;@ [dB@J@
;< YEP8P8 9<EQ@PFIC8I J8EbIbD '<E;@D@Q@ <M@D@Q< ;XEDYf
>@9@?@JJ<;<:<c@Q \
.D@K? [$8E>@J@;8?8P8BbE\;@P<JFI;L
[dB@E:@ $<D<E PFC8 ;<M8D <;@PFILQ 8E8 @E<:<c@D@Q
><Q<><EWFB?Ff9@IP<ID@f>@9@><C@PFI \
.D@K? [.<E:< 9@I J8BbE:8Jb PFBJ8 9LE8 8C<KC<I< 98B8I8B
B8I8IM<I<:<c@D \;<;@
D8 ?FLEJLE XEJ<Q@C<I@ >8C@98 9L J<=<I FEL P8EbCK

D8D8C8I;b #<Q<><E M8?f@ 9@I P<I ;<c@C;@ +BP8ELJC8I;8E


FCLf8E B8ID8fbB 9@I f<9<B< bJbJb =8QC8 ;<c@fD<P<E 9@I @BC@D
J8cCbPFI;L .bI8;8cC8I 8CW8B K<G<C<I@ ;< PLM8IC8BKb @KB@C<I@E
P8PbCbfbE;8EKFGI8cbEM<I@DC@FC;LcL8EC8fbCbPFI;L
#<D@><Q<><E<@E<IB<E?FLEJBFEKIFCC8IbE98fbE;8P;b
.D@K? [*<;<E 9L B8;8I K@K@QC@B <;@PFIJLE\ ;@P< J89bI

JbQC8E;b [$<IP<I9@I9@I@E<9<EQ@PFI \
?FLEJ [WbGC8B 9@I P<I 8IbPFILD \ ;@P< 8WbBC8;b [@I
;XEYDCYBP<I;<B@9@KB@C<I@P8BD8P8?@W><I<BPFB \


[48B8IJ8EE<FCLI\
?FLEJ [48 P8BD8QJ8D E< FCLI\ ;@P< B8IfbCbB M<I@IB<E
8I8;bcb>@9@9@IP<I9LCDLfKL
dB@ LQD8E 8E:8B ><D@ ><Q<><E< @E;@BK<E JFEI8 E8JbC 9@I
f<PC<B8IfbB8IfbP8FC;LBC8IbEb9@I8QB8MI8;bC8I
.D@K? [0Q8P8;bE8\;@P<98cbI;b
?FLEJ J<IJ<DC<D@fK@ 0Q8P;8 ?8PM8EC8I 9@KB@C<I;<E ;8?8
<E;<I 9LCLELPFI;L BbCCb :8ECbC8IC8 B8IfbC8fD8B @J< ;8?8 ;8 <E

;<I >XIYC<E 9@I f<P;@ D8 9LI8;8 @E;@BC<I@ EFBK8;8E 8E:8B 8CKb
P<;@ PYQ D<KI< XK<;< 8CW8B J8Q ;8DCb BLCY9<C<I M8I;b +EC8IbE
@CB<C9@IQ<BVEbEYIYEYFC;LBC8Ib;8WFB9<CC@P;@
.D@K?f8fBbEf8fBbE [ @BB8KC@FC \;<;@
?FLEJ [LI8EbE Q8I8ICb FC;LcLEL J8EDbPFILD \ ;@P<
DbIbC;8E8I8B ><Q<><E@E PYQ<P@E< B<J@E M< >YM<EC@ 9@I K8MbIC8
8P8B98JKb .D@K?FEL@QC<;@
?FLEJ ?<P<:8EbE8 QFICLBC8 ?8B@D FC89@C@PFI;L [)YK?@f
e@D;@P< B8;8I J8;<:< D8c8I8C8I P8 ;8 XIYCDYf 8c8W ;8C

C8IbE;8E;8?8YJKYE9@If<P9@C;@I@CD<;@ \
[+EC8IbEQ8I8IJbQFC;LBC8IbEbLD8IbD \
[8BJ8E8 9LI8Jb ?LQLI ;FCL 58I8ICb P8I8KbBC8I FC8D8QC8I eL
?8M8Pb9@IBFBC8 \
0=LBK8B@ 8CW8B K<G<C<I ;bfbE;8 ?<I K8I8= K8KCb 9@I G<D9< I<E><
9YIYEDYfKY dEJ8E8 ?LQLI M<I@PFI;L L G<D9<C@BC<I@E 8I8JbE;8
BCFIF=@CC@ P<f@C C<B<C<I >XIYCYPFI;L 48BbE;8E 98BKbBC8Ib Q8D8E 9L
G<D9<C@c@E E<;<E@E@E BYWYB W@W<BC<I FC;LcLEL 8EC8;bC8I SFB
Q8I@= M< >YQ<C BFBLCLP;LC8I 9LEC8I .8;<:< BLCY9<C<I@E <KI8=b
B<?I@98II<E>@P;@ +I8;8K8?bC89<EQ<P<E9@If<PC<IM8I;b
'LCY9<;<E P8I8KbBC8I WbBbPFI M< B8I8IJbQ:8 ><D@P< P8BC8fbP

FIC8I;b XIK 98:8BC8Ib M8I;b )<P@CC@ MY:LKC8IbEbE PYBJ<BC@c@ FDLQ


?@Q8JbE;8 ;FBJ8E J8EK@D B8;8I;b 8fC8Ib FDLQC8IbEbE 8I8JbE8
P8GbfKbIbCDbf >@9@P;@ #XQC<I@ G8KC8BKb ?FLEJ 8CKb >XQ J8P;b  @I
;8@I< YQ<I@E;<B@ 9L >XQC<I @EJ8Eb f8fbIK8:8B 9@W@D;< K<B
98fC8IbE8 ?8I<B<K <;<9@C@PFIC8I;b ?FLEJ B8=8C8IbEb


W<M@I<D<;@BC<I@@W@E>XQC<I@E@FPE8KbPFIC8I ;@P<;YfYE;Y
$<I ?8PM8EbE L:L W8K8CCb 9@I BLPILcL M8I;b L J8cC8D W8K8Cb
?<GJ@ ;< ?8M8;8 ;@D;@B KLKLPFIC8I;b L 8PIbEKbC8I ;LID8;8E
K@KI<fK@BC<I@@W@E@EJ8EFEC8Ib@P@:<J<W<D@PFI;L
?FLEJ [$8P;@ \ ;<;@ [@Q< Q8I8I M<ID<P<:<BC<I LE;8E
<D@E@D \
$8PM8EC8I BLfBL M< ;@BB8KC< 9@I8Q LQ8BK8 ;LI8I8B @B@ @EJ8EbE
<KI8=bE;8 9@I ;8@I< FCLfKLI;LC8I 'LPILBC8IbE;8E DbIbCKbP8 9<EQ<P

<E?8=@=9@IJ<JPYBJ<C@PFI;L
?FLEJ [<CB@ FEC8I 9XPC< BFELfLPFIC8I \ ;<;@ [1< 9<E:<
9@KB@;<E 98fB8 9@I f<P P<D<;@BC<I@ B<J@E \ 'LCY9<C<I;<E 9@I@E@
@f8I<K <KK@ +I8;8 8PEb :@EJ;<E ;8?8 BYWYB 9@I ?8PM8E B898
<KC<I@E@E YQ<I@E< FKLIDLf B<?I@98I I<E>@ K8?bCC8Ib BLPILcLPC8 BF

G8IbPFI M< 98f8BC8Ib 8cQbE8 8KbPFI;L $8I<B<K@ 9@I BYI;8E8 K8BbCb


C@BXICY9@IM@fE<P@P@P<E9@I@EJ8EbEB@E<9<EQ@PFI;L
.D@K? [dEJ8EC8I ;8 D8ILC P@PFIC8I \ ;@P< ?8KbIC8KKb [L ?@W9@I
f<P@B8EbKC8D8Q \
+ BLPILBCL P8I8KbBC8I;8E 98fB8 ><C<EC<I FC;L +EC8I @EJ8E

C8IbE 9@I8Q LQ8cbE;8 ;LI;LC8I .FEI8 ;8 G<D9<C<I M< P<f@CC<I@E


8I8JbE8;8C;bC8I
?FLEJ B<J@E 9@I K8MbIC8 [.8;<:< 9@KB@C<IC< 9<JC<E@PFIC8I \
;<;@ [E8YIYEYE8JbCP<K@fK@I;@BC<I@E<9@I98BJ8E8 \
?FLEJLE ;<P@D@PC< 8E8 YIYE P<I< P8BbE PLDLf8B P<f@C 9@I
98f8BK8E FCLfLPFI;L 48P>bE FC8E M< ;8?8 WFB 9@I K8:8 9<EQ<P

<E 9L 98f8cbE FIK8JbE;8E KYPCY 9@I J8G WbBbPFI;L LELE YQ<I

@E;< 9<f J8EK@D 8I8PC8 ;8D8ICb <KC@ KFDLI:LBC8I M8IVb +EC8I


XPC< ?8P8K ;FCLP;LC8I B@ E<I<;<PJ< 9@I B8CG >@9@ 8KD8P8 98fC8P

8:8BC8I;b .8GbE L:LE;8E F G<D9< W@W<BC<I PYBJ<C@PFI;L


@KB@E@E ;YEP8;8B@ KYIC<I< <E 9<EQ<P<E K8I8=b ;8 9L W@W<BC<I@P;@
D8I<EB;bfbE;8
@KB@C<I WFB ;YQ>YE JbI8C8I ?8C@E;< ;@B@CD@fC<I;@ !KI8

=C8IbE;8B@ KFGI8BC8I B8QbCDbf M< 9LE8 P898E:b 9@I KFQ


B8IbfKbIbCDbfKb E:8B >Y9I< FC89@C@I;@ 9LEC8I /8IC8Pb ?8PM8EC8IbE


><W<9@C<:<BC<I@ ;8I PFCC8I 9@I9@IC<I@PC< B<J@f@PFIC8I;b $<I G8K@B

8EbE P8EbE;8E 9@I J8M8B P8K8cb LQ8EbPFI;L LELE JL @W@E


P8GbC;bcbB<J@E;@
$8PM8EC8I 8IKbB K8IC8P8 ;8cbCDbfC8I 98fC8IbEb <cD@f ;@BB8KC<
W8CbfbPFIC8I;b dB@ 8;8DbE P8BbEbE;8 J8;<:< 9@IB8W P8I8KbB
B8CDbfKb
?FLEJ98fbEbJ8CC8;b [dP@9@I<IW@=KW@FEC8I \
.D@K? ;< [!M<K =<E8 ;<c@CC<I \ ;@P< :<M8G M<I;@ !E
P8BbE;8B@ LWLB I<EBC@ G<D9< W@W<c< ;FcIL >@;<I<B <C@E@ LQ8KKb
D8 JFEI8 W@W<c< FE 9<f J8EK@D B8C8 ;LI8BC8;b $8PM8EC8IbE
BLPILB K@KI<f@DC<I@E@E E<;<E FC;LcL J<J @P@:< K@QC<fD@fK@ 48I8KbB

C8I;8E 9@I@ ;< BLPILcLEL FELE BFCLE8 ;FBLE;LIDLfKL L ;FB

LELf ?8=@= 8D8 B<J@E;@ $8PM8E BLPILcLEL 9@KB@PC< .D@K?@E


8I8JbE8LQ8KKb
;8D><I@C<;@ [0Q8P8;bE8 \.@C8?bE8LQ8E8:8BFC;L
?FLEJ ?<D<E [$<P<:8EC8E8:8B 9@I f<P PFB \ ;<;@
[#<Mf<9@I8Q \
CKb P8I8KbB @B@ 8;8DbE <KI8=bE;8 KFGC8EbPFI FEC8I8 8CW8B
>XEYCCYCYBC< M< LJLC:8 K8?bC 98f8BC8IbEb LQ8KbPFIC8I;b 8QbC8Ib
BLPILBC8IbEb BLCC8EbPFI 98QbC8Ib @J< 98f8BC8Ib 9LILEC8IbPC8
@K@PFIC8I;b
?FLEJ [ FJK >XIYEYPFIC8I \ ;<;@ [<CB@ ;< W@W<B BFG8I

D8B FEC8IbE KXI<C<I@E< 8PBbIb $<I?8C;< 9@KB@C<I< B8Kb BLI8CC8I8


>XI< ;8MI8EbCbPFI /8IbDb 9@C<E ?<I KFGCLD;8 9<I<B<K KXI<EC<I@
P8GbC89@C@I L KXI<EC<I@E E8JbC f<PC<I FC;LBC8IbEb ;8 /8EIb 9@C@I
@KB@C<I@E P<K@fK@I@CD<J@PC< @C>@C@ BLI8CC8I JbBb FCD8Cb 4FBJ8 9XPC<
JFE ;<I<:< ;YQ>YE 9@I 9@W@D;< <B@CD<QC<I;@ ? 0Q8P 8;bE8
YEP8;8B@C<I 9YKYE 9LEC8Ib ;LP;LBC8Ib Q8D8E WFB
f8fbI8:8BC8I\
'LPILBC8I;8E PYBJ<C<E DbIbCKbC8I P@E< K@QC<f@IB<E @B@ 8;8DbE
P8BbEbE;8B@ P8I8KbBC8I ><I@C<;@C<I PEb :@EJK<E 9@I ?8PM8E FI

K8;8B@;8?89YPYB9@IBLCY9<;<EWbBbPFI;L
?FLEJDbIbC;8E;b [$<I?8C;<I<@JF \


48I8KbB 8cbI 8cbI P8BC8fKb 'LPILcLEL ?8M8;8 KLKLPFI;L


LELE @B@ LQ8EKbJbEb BYWYB J@P8? 9@I<I :@JD< J8IDbfKb $8PM8E
@EJ8EC8IC8 8I8JbE;8 9@I 9LWLB D<KI< B8C;bcb Q8D8E BLPILcLEL
XE<;FcIL0Q8KKb
.D@K? f8fbIDbfKb [+EC8Ib 9@Q< M<I@PFI ?FLEJ /8EIbD
FE8 ).00&81* 98B\
?FLEJ 9LEL P8GbPFI;L Q8K<E $<D ;< ?<P<:8EC8 .FEI8
9FcLCLI:8JbE8 [#8DFN G@I<
LQ8P ;YI9YEY FEC8I \ ;<;@ [+E
9@I;FC8ICbB9@If<P9L \

.D@K? 9@I J88K ><D@;< B8C;bBK8E JFEI8 ;bf8Ib WbBKb -8DG8;8


;LI8I8B DYK?@f 9@I ?<P<:8EC8 [S8CbfbPFIC8I\ ;@P< 98cbI;b
['LJLIJLQ 5<E>@E@Q\
?FLEJ ;8 8IB8;8fbE8 J<JC<E;@ ['LCY9<C<I@E@ 8I8;bD
8fB8;YI9YE9LC8D8;bD \
[@B@ ;YI9YEY BYWYDJ<D< /8EIbD +EC8I 9@I 8MLW G8I8;8E
=8IBJbQ \
D8?FLEJ<CC<I@E@9<C@E<;8P8Dbf<KI8=bE898BbEbPFI;L
T=B<C@P;@ + BLPILBCL P8I8KbBC8I;8E YWY BLCY9<;<E BLCY9<P<
>@;<IB<E G<f@E;<E 8PIbCD8DbfC8I;b .89bIC8 ;8MI8EDbf
?FLEJLE @f@E< ;< B8IbfD8DbfC8I;b D8 ?<I Q8D8E ;YQ>YE:<
P<K@fK@I@CD@f FC8E F G<D9< W@W<BC<IC< 8;8DbE 8I8JbE8 >@ID<P@ LE

LKD8DbfC8I;b e@D;@;<;LIDLf?FLEJ898BbPFIC8I;b
.D@K? <BC<;@ [UJK<C@B <E JFE DF;<C eLI8P8 98B \ C<K@E
YQ<I@E;<B@ P8QbP8 @f8I<K <KK@ [)F;<C 3
 #8DFN UIYEC<I@
18IfFM8 MILG8.<BKXIY \
?FLEJ P8QbP8 98BKb M< J89bIJbQ:8 [e@D;@ 9<E@ F ;YI9YEC<I

;<E 9@IB8W K8E< ;8?8 9LCD8B @C>@C<E;@I@PFI \ ;<;@ [LI8;8 9@I


P<I;< JYIYPC< #8DFN ;YI9YEY FC;LcLEL '.1.<4692 M< FEC8Ib
@JK@PFILD \48E8BC8IbBbQ8IDbfKb B<J@BB<J@BJFCLPFI;L

#YE<f 98K8IB<E ?8M8 JFcLD8P8 98fC8DbfKb .D@K? @B@ ;<=8




8BJbI;b .FEI8;8?FLEJ
.D@K?9LIELELW<BK@ [58KYII<<FC8:8cbQ \
?FLEJLE @E8;b KLKDLfKL [+EC8IbE ;LILDL 8EC8D8C8IbEb
J8cC8D8CbPbD \ /<C8fC8 9@I BLKL ;FDLQ JL:LcL P<D@f YQ<I@E<
P@E<9@IK<E<B<Jb:8BB8?M<@WD@fK@ /<BI8I;<E<D<P<?8QbI;b
YI9YEY B8C;bI8I8B BFCC8IbPC8 ?8M8;8 ;8@I<C<I W@Q;@ [ 8?8
=8QC8 8?8 =8QC8 \ TE:< 9@I ;YI9YEY JFEI8 ;8 ;@c<I@E@ @f8I<K
<KK@ .8EB@ XEYE< WFB J8Pb;8 F 8C<KK<E ;@Q@CD@f >@9@ ;8MI8EbP

FI;L [ 8?8WFB \
.FEI8 >YE<f L=LBK8 B8P9FCLIB<E K8IK8EbE ?<I K8I8=bE;8 F
DbIbCKbC8I P8EBbC8E;b YKYE ?8PM8EC8I 98fC8IbEb <c<I<B BLPILB

C8IbEb B8C;bI;bC8I C8:8B8I8ECbBK8 BLPILBC8IbEbE @B@ L:LEL ?bQC8


>XQC< >XIYC<D<P<:<B B8;8I K@KI<K<I<B WbcCbBC8I8 9<EQ<P<E J<JC<I
WbB8I;bC8I
.D@K? <E;@f<PC< [0Q8P 8;bE8 \ ;@P< =bJbC;8;b [$<P fL
W@W<BC<I<98B\/<BI8I8BJbI;b
0WLB G<D9< W@W<BC<I >XQC< >XIYC<:<B 9@I 9@W@D;<
JFCLPFIC8I;b
?FLEJ F >YIYCKY;< J<J@E@ ;LPLI89@CD<B @W@E 98cbID8P8
98fC8;b [<CB@ W@W<BC<I >YE<f@E 98KbfbE8 9XPC< 9@I I<8BJ@PFE
>XJK<I@PFIC8I @C@IJ@E 98Qb W@W<BC<I ><:<C<I@ B8G8EbI <CB@ 9L
>YIYCKY><I

W<c@;@EC<@C>@C@9@I9@W@D;<8WbBCbPFI \
@C<c@E<?8=@=W<9@IBLPILB?FLEJ`LE;@BB8K@E@
?<D<E W<BK@ !E P8BbE;8B@ P8I8KbcbE BLPILcLP;L 9L $8PM8E
f@D;@ FEL B8C;bIDbf 98Kb L=BLE8 P8BbE G8IC8B 9@I EFBK8Pb @f8I<K
<;@PFI;L .FEI8 BLPILcLPC8 ;YI9YEY >XJK<I;@ IB8JbE;8E P@E<
PbC;bQ8@f8I<K<KK@
?FLEJ ?<P<:8EC8 [/89@@ P8 \ ;<;@ [dW ><Q<><E
48f8D8P8 LP>LE ;@c<I ;YEP8 \ .FEI8 9@I ><IW<c@ ?8KbIC8P8I8B
J8EB@ fFB ><W@I;@ [$<P .D@K? ?@G<I
8KFD@B DFKFIC8I ?VCV
W8CbfDbPFI \
.D@K? ;< J8EB@ 9LEL LELKDLf >@9@ J8IJbC;b .FEI8 [LEL
 

J8E8JXPC<P<:<BK@D \;@P<DbIbC;8E;b [S8CbfbPFI \\


[)FKFIC8IbK8D@ID@<KK@E\
[ FBLED8;bD 9@C< D8 ;YI9YEC<I@ ;<E<IB<E ?@G<I
8KFD@B

C<I@ BLCC8E;bD M< FEC8I ;8 W8CbfKb + JbI8;8 9L ;LILDC8 @C>@C<E

D<;@D +EC8IbE 9FQLCDLf FC;LBC8IbEb LELKLD $<I E<PJ< IKbB


W8CbfbPFIC8I \
?FLEJ ?<D<E 8KbC;b [+ ?8C;< >@;<C@D \\ 0PLD8B 8BCbE8
9@C<><CD<;@

dB@ 8;8D 8CKb J88KC@B PFC:LCLB JbI8JbE;8 ?@W LPLD8;bC8I


YPYB 9@I ?bIJC8 BFEKIFCC8IbE 98fbE;8 FKLI;LC8I .8EB@ 9L
@JK<BC<I@E@ 9@IK8BbD @C8WC8I 9<JC@PFI;L dB@ 8IB8;8f P@E< @ED<B @W@E
WbGC8B9@IP<IJ<WK@C<I
$8M8 Jb:8BKb .8EB@ 8JKIFG@B8C 9@I 9XC><;< XcC<;<E JFEI8JbP

;b 48EC8IbE;8E ><E@f W8DLICL 9@I E<?@I 8cbI 8cbI 8BbPFI;L .LP

LE F K8I8=K8B@ BbPbJb J<IK W8DLI;8E;b M< YQ<I@E;< G<B WFB WLBLI


M8I;b 'YWYB9@I<ID8c8I8Pb8E;bI8:8BB8;8I9YPYBKYC<I
dB@ BVf@= ><Q<><E@E PYQ<P@E< @E;@C<I .FEI8 .D@K? 9FcLB
9FcLB 98cbI;b [?FLEJ fLI8P8 98B\ ;8Db BFCLE;8E
P8B8C8;b
?FLEJ J@CB@E<I<B FELE <C@E;<E BLIKLC;L [PEb 9@KB@C<I
/8EIbD\
+ LWLB G<D9< W@W<BC<I@ ;8D8ICb KFDLI:LBC8Ib FC8E J8GC8Ib
M< 8CKK8B@ K8W 9@W@D@ 98f8BWbBC8Ib K8EbD8D8B @DBVEJbQ;b L
9@KB@C<I ;< P@E< WFB ;YQ>YE 8I8CbBC8IC8 ;@B@CD@fC<I;@ !KI8=C8Ib W8G

8C8EDbfM<>Y9I<M<I@CD@fK@ .LB8E8CC8Ib9LI8;8;8M8I;b
.D@K? [@I ?8K8 P8GDbf FC89@C@I D@P@Q\ ;@P< JFI;L [48E@
;FC8fKbBM< a\
[fL >YE<f< 98BJ8E8 S8Gb ;@c<I@E@E @B@ B8Kb eLI8P8 ;8 9@I
>XQ8K \
*<?I@E BbPbJbE;8B@ WLBLIC8I;8E PbC8EC8I >@9@ BFCJLQ 98:8BJbQ
;YQ>YE >XM;<C@ 9<A I<E>@ P8I8KbBC8I BbMIbC8 9YBYC< WbBbPFIC8I;b
FPC8Ib YW D<KI< W8GC8Ib FKLQ J8EK@D;@ dB@ LWC8Ib ;8 8PEb



;<I<:<;< BYKKY 1< ?@W9@I 8PIbEKb ;8 PFBKL 9L LWC8I;8 +IK8


9XCYDC<I@E;< YJKK< f@fC@BC<I M8I;b YKYE 9L f@fC@BC<I J8EB@ 9@I
@f8I<K M<I@CD@f >@9@ @B@ 8;8DbE >XQC<I@E@E XEYE;< B898I8I8B f@f

D8E FM8C 9@W@D< >@I;@C<I dB@P< 8PIbC8I8B ;L;8BJbQ 8cbQC8I8


;XEYfKYC<I $8PM8EC8I 8cbQC8IbEb 8WbG B8G8IB<E 9@I9@I@E< MLILC8E
BLILJFG8C8IbEf8BbIKbJbEb8E;bI8E9@IJ<JWbBKb
.FEI8 ;bf ><Q<><E;< FC;LcL >@9@ D<I8BC8IbEb >@;<I;@BC<I@ M<
BFIBLC8Ib;8><WK@c@@W@E;@BB8KC<<B@CD@fK8IC8P8;FcIL>@KK@C<I
.D@K? 8BJbI;b .FCLcLEL ?bQC8 M<I@IB<E :<B<K@E@E BFCLE;8E
KFQC8I PYBJ<C@M<I;@ ;8D FEC8I8 ?8PI<KC< 98BKb .FEI8 YQ<I@E<
MLID8P8 98fC8;b ['8?I<KJ@E /FQ @W@E;< B8CDbfbD \ /FQC8I LWLB
G<D9< 9@I J@J >@9@ ;8C>8C8E;bC8I ;8D [.<E ;< 8PEb ?8C;<J@E \
;@P<<BC<P<I<B?FLEJLEYQ<I@E@JYGYI;Y
dB@LQD8E8IKbB;LID8;8E8BJbIbPFIC8I;b
?FLEJ [L KFQC8I YQ<I@D@Q< X9YI ><Q<><E;< 9LC8fKb
J8EbIbD \;<;@
[C<IA@FC89@C@I@Q \
[dDBVEJbQ \ ?FLEJ ;YI9YEC<I;<E 9@I@E@ ?8M8P8 B8C;bI8I8B
F PbC8E8 9<EQ<P<E P8I8KbBC8IbE 8IB8JbE;8E J<JC<E;@ [.@Q;<
9LE;8EM8IDb\
@I JYI< 9@I :<M8G 8C8D8;b e@D;@ J8;<:< JLPLE f8GbIKbJb
;LPLCLPFI;L 8Qb PbC8E P8I8KbBC8I B8P8I8B E<?I< ;8CbPFI M<
>YDYf< 9<EQ<P<E JL ?8PM8EC8IbEb P8B8CbPFIC8I;b +EC8I >XM;<C

<I@E@E8CKbE;8B@LQ8BK8E>XQYBD<P<E8cbQC8IbE88KbPFIC8I;b
.FEI8 ;@c<IC<I@E;<E ;8?8 LQLE FC8E 9@I PbC8E
P8I8KbB P<I;<
JYIYE<I<B @C<IC<;@ 'YK LWC8IbE;8E 9@I@E@ 9@I f<P@ 8I8fKbIbPFIDLf
>@9@ 9<f J8EK@D B8;8I PLB8Ib B8C;bI;b L L:L BXI:<J@E< @B@ P8E8
J8CC8D8P8 98fC8;b #XM;<J@E@E FIK8JbE;8B@ B898IbB XE:< ?8=@=
?8=@= f@fK@ .FEI8 BFIBLKL:L 9@I ?bQC8 1< PLDIL BFC8PCbBC8 ;LPL

C8E M< 9@I G8KC8D8Pb 8E;bI8E 9@I J<JC< P8IbC;b e@D;@ 9L 8cbQ >@9@
WLBLI;8 @B@ ;YI9YE ;8?8 M8I;b 'Vf@=C<I< ;8?8 XE:< M<I@C<EC<I@E
<f@P;@C<I9LEC8I
?FLEJ ?<P<:8EC8 [? /8EIbD\ ;<;@ [*< ?8I@B8 ;<c@C
 

D@\ /<C8fC8 XE< 8KbC8I8B ;YI9UEC<I@ 8CD8B @W@E >@KK@ +EC8Ib KLK8E
PLDIL P8JJbC8fbG LQ8;b *<I<;<PJ< ;FBLE8WC8I8 ;XEYfKY M<
;YEP8CbP8;FcILLQ8E;b
?FLEJ >YCYG ;LILPFI;L +EC8I ><IW<BK<E #8DFN ;YI9YE

C<I@P;@ dCB @B@J@E@E <f@P;@C<I /8D K8DbE8 <f@ ?FLEJ ;YI9YEC<I@


FBf8;b
.D@K? ?8PBbIbPFI;L [<E@ ;LPDLPFI DLJLE '8?I<KJ@E
?FLEJ9<E@;@EC< \
;8D [*<\ ;<;@ .D@K?@E 9@I @B@ ;8B@B8;bI B<E;

@J@E< 98cbI;bcbEbE?8P8CD<P8C=8IBbE;8P;b
[S@W<BC<I<98B ?FLEJ \
+EC8I ;8 ;@c<I ><Q<><E;<B@ W@W<BC<I >@9@ B8G8EbPFIC8I;b
4bC8E
P8I8KbBC8I JbI8C8IbE 8I8JbE;8 9@I LWC8IbEbE YQ<I@E;! B8CBbP

FI M< >8I@G ;YQ<EJ@Q 9@I K<DGFPC8 ;8C>8C8EbPFIC8I;b 0WLB


G<D9<W@W<BC<I@EYQ<I@E;<EJ8;<:<FBYKLWC8Ib>XQYBYPFI;L
.D@K? [+EC8IbE B8I8ECbB 98JKbI;bcb @W@E B8G8E;bBCI8bbEb JXP

C<P<D<QJ@E \;<;@ [ 8?8FIK8CbB>YECYB>YE<fC@B \


?FLEJ FDQLEL J@CBK@ [8fB8 ><Q<><E 98fB8 9@KB@ $8P;@
><C !C@D@Q<;8?8@B@;YI9YE><WK@ 8fB8C8Ib;8FCD8Cb \
[?FLEJ ><C 8IKbB >@;<C@D \ .D@K? 98:8BC8IbEb 8W8I8B @E8KC8
;LI;L ?FLEJLP8B8JbE;8EJbBb:8P8B8C8;b
4YQY BbQ8ID8P8 98fC8P8E 8IB8;8fb FE8 X=B<PC< 98BKb [*<
P8GbPFIJLEJ<E\
[<E@DC< ?<D<E ><D@P< ;XED<QJ<E J<E@ 98PbCK8:8cbD dfK<
f@D;@9LELP8GD8P8?8QbIC8EbPFILD \
?FLEJ 9@I 8E B8I8IJbQ:8 ;LI;L .FEI8 F WbC>bE K8MbIC8Ib B8P

9FC;L 1Y:L;L><Mf<;@M<[,<BVCV \;<;@

4bC;bQ BYD<J@E;<E P8Ib WbBDbf ;LILD;8C8I;b .D@K?


[*8JbCJbE\;@P<JFI;L
?FLEJ I8EQ8JbE;8 ;FcILC8I8B J8WC8IbEb B8IbfKbI;b ]*FID8C

C<fK@DJ8EbIbD BCbD98fbD8><C;@ *<B8;8ILPL;LD\


]+E@B@J88K \
 

]48J<E\
[I8;8 JbI8;8 9@I8Q B<JK@I;@D \ .D@K? D8?JLJ BFEKIFCC8I8
;FcIL ;XE<I<B 98J@K 9@I 8P8IC8D8 P8GKb .FEI8 ;8 LK8E8 JbBbC8
JFI;L [#<I@;< F><Q<><EC<I;<E<C<IFC;LcLEL9@C@PFIDLJLE\
?FLEJ ].<E9@C@PFIDLJLE\;<;@
]TPC<J8EbPFILD \
[48LEL98E8;88WbBC8IDbJbE\\
.D@K? [dB@ ><Q<><E;<B@ 9@KB@C<I ;< 9@I9@I@E@E <f@P;@ \ ;<;@
]LELB89LC<;@PFIDLJLE\
[/89@@<;@PFILD \
]@KB@C<I E8JbC FC;LPJ8 9@I ><Q<><E;<E ;@c<I@E<
>XKYIYCDYfC<I;@ e@D;@ 9@KB@C<I F @B@ ;YEP8;8 ;8 >8P<K >YQ<C 9@I
9@W@D;< P<K@f@PFIC8I D8 8I8;8 JbI8;8 W8GI8Q ;XCC<ED<
><I<B@PFI dB@ :@EJ@E B8IbfD8Jb $<I?8C;< 9L 9@KB@E@E >YWCY FC

D8Jb@W@Ef8IK XPC<9@If<P;YEP8DbQ;8;8JbBJbBFCLPFI \
[@KB@C<I@E >YWC<E;@I@CD<C<I@ @W@E W8GI8Q ;XCC<ED< J8cC8E

D8Jb!M<K \
[D8 @@B@ :@EJ@E B8IbfD8JbEb '.= J8cC8;bB @I ><Q<><E< @E

;@B M< YJKYDYQ 98fbDbQ W@W<B KFQLPC8 B8GC8E;b S@W<BC<I@E


B8G8ED8C8IbEb ?8KbICbMFI DLJLE $<I?8C;< 9L FEC8IbE KFQC8IbEb
J8CbM<ID<C<I@E;<E JFEI8 FC;L @Q ;< F PYQ;<E 8BJbI;bB Q8K<E
.FEI8 ;@c<I ><Q<><E< @E;@B 1< W@W<B KFQC8IbEb YQ<I@D@Q;<E
JYGYI;YB IKbB P<E@ 9@I D<C<Q KYI P<K@f<:<B @Q @B@ 98:8BCb 9@I<I
8IbP;bB ?FLEJ S@W<BC<IC< @C>@C@ FC8I8B >XI<M@D@Q@ P<I@E<
><K@I@PFI;LB \
?FLEJ LJLC:8 >YCYDJ<;@ [JCbE;8 9L ?@W ;< ?Ff 9@I IFC
;<c@C \
['8?I<KJ@E .FILE F ;<c@C .<E K<?C@B<E@E =8IBbE;8 ;<c@C D@J

@E *<;<E B<E;@ ;YEP8DbQ8 ?<D<E ;XED<D@Q ><I<BK@c@E@ 8E

C8DbPFIDLJLE\
[*<;<E\
]SYEBY FI>8E@QD8C8I 9@I ?@W< LPD8P8 W8CbfD8QC8I + 9@KB@C<I
><Q<><EC<I8I8Jb ;XCC<ED<P< LPDLf >@9@P;@C<I $8KK8 Y:I<K@D@Q


;< X;<E;@ IbC8IbE Y:I<KC<I@ X;<E;@c@ >@9@ @Q< 98CXQY ;<c@C


#8DFN;YI9YEC<I@M<I@C;@ \

!\
[#<Q<><EC<I8I8Jb ;XCC<ED< @W@E 9@I@E@E P8 ;8 9@I f<P@E 9L @f@
P8GD8Jb ><I<B@I L >XI<M@ 9L J<=<I '.= P8GKbB D8 F PbC;bQ
BYD<J@E< >@I<E @CB @EJ8EC8I 9@Q;@B + ?8C;< 9L @f@ 9@Q;<E XE:<
@EJ8E FCD8P8E P8I8KbBC8I P8GbPFIC8I;b <CB@ ;< 9@KB@P@ 9@I ><Q<

><E;<E ;@c<I@E< ;< P@E< F @EJ8E FCD8P8E P8I8KbBC8I >XKYI;Y L


;8 fL 8EC8D8 ><C@PFI 9L PbC;bQ BYD<J@E;< 8BbCCb :8ECbC8I P8fbPFI
+EC8I LQ8P;8 PFC:LCLB P8G8:8B B8;8I Q<B@C<I 1< ;YEP8 9L ;LI

LDLXcI<ED<C@ \
?FLEJ98fbEb [$8PbI \;<I>@9@8cbI8cbIJ8CC8;b
.D@K?@EB8fC8IbW8KbCDbfKb [LD8EKbB;@Q@J@E;<9@I?8K8Db
M8I\
?FLEJ 98fbEb 8MLWC8IbEbE 8I8JbE8 8C;b 4YQYE;< YQ>YE 9@I
@=8;< M8I;b [.<E@E ?<D<E ?<I f<P@ >XQ;<E B8WbI;bcbEb
JXPC<P<9@C@I@Q \
.D@K?X=B<PC< [*<C<I@>XQ;<EB8WbI;bD\;@P<JFI;L
[.<E@E W8GI8Q ;XCC<D< M8IJ8PbDbE =<E8 J8PbCD8Q 8JCbE;8
8D8 9@IB8W EFBK8Pb ?<J898 B8KD8;bE + PbC;bQ J@JK<D@E< P8B

C8fKbcbDbQ Q8D8E ?@G<I


8KFD@B DFKFIC8IbDbQ 9FQLC;L $<D ;<
FKFD8K@B BFEKIFCC8IbE 8EC8P8D8;bcb M< FE8I8D8;bcb 9@I 9@W@D;<
#<Q<><E< @E;@BK<E JFEI8 DFKFIC8Ib K8D@I <KD<P@ ;YfYED<;@B
$8KK8 FEC8Ib LELKKLB + DFKFIC8Ib ;8?8 JFEI8 W8CbfKbI;bcbE Q8D8E
@B@J@E;< ;< ?@W9@I 8IbQ8 FCD8;bcbEb >XI;YE LEL ?@W
XE<DJ<D<;@c@E @W@E 98E8 9L ;LILD;8E 8E:8B 9@IB8W J88K
JFEI8JXQ<KK@E
[8fB8 9@I f<P@ 8C8CbD @Q ><Q<><E< @ED<B @W@E E< B8;8I ;8
bCbP>LE P<IC<I J<WK@B dB@ ><Q<><E;< ;< ?<IE<E ?8PM8EC8IbE
P8EbE8 @E;@B .8;<:< 9@I I8JC8EKb DbP;b 9L 1< F P8I8KbBC8IbE WFB
@P@ E@P<KC@ FC;LBC8IbE8 @E8E;bB L 8BCbE 8C8:8cb 9@I f<P D@P;@
#<D@;<E WbBD8;8E XE:< ?8M8;8 Q<?@I FCLG FCD8;bcbEb 9@C< BFE

KIFC<KD<;@B


[PIb:8 9<E@ <E WFB <E;@f<C<E;@I<E ;< F #8DFN ;YI9YEC<I@


PYQYE;<E @P@:< WbC;bID8D *<;<E !M<K FEC8I ;<c<IC@ D8 ;<

C@P< ;XE<:<B 0&)&6 ;8 ;<c@C UJK<C@B 9<E ><E<CC@BC< W89L:8B 9@I


@B@G8G<CB8Q8E8:8cbD;@P<8BCbDbB8WbID8D \
.D@K? 9L BFELfD8Pb <E;@f<C@ 9@I J<JJ@QC@B @W@E;< ;@EC<D@fK@
.FEI8 [YKYE9LEC8IXE<DC@;<c@CB@ \;<;@
[$8P;@ .D@K? 48GD8 :8EbD dB@D@Q@E B8=8JbEbE ;8
;bf8Ib;8EBFEKIFC8CKbE88CbE;bcb9<CC@;<c@CD@\
.D@K?@E 8cQb W8IGbCDbfKb C8P Db <;<:<BK@ PFBJ8 BLfBLC8E

D8Jb Db ><I<B@PFI;L 9LEL 9@C<D@PFI;L [4@E< F GJ@FE@B @CC<K@E D@


KLKKL
[!M<K #<IW<B ><IW<BK@I .8E8 XEJ<Q@C<I@D@E 9@I KYI @CB<C K<C<

G8K@FC89@C<:<c@E@JXPC<D@fK@D \
[L ;8 Db 9@I ><IW<B @IB8W >YE XE:< ?@W ;< 9XPC<
;YfYEDYPFI;LE \
[D8 f@D;@ 9XPC< ;YfYEYPFILD @EC< <E J<E;<E ;8?8 @P@
9@I _8Cb:bPbD + PYQ;<E ;8?8 @P@ 8ECbPFILD 8?8 =8QC8 <KB@
8C;bcbD@W@E ECbPFIDLJLE\
.D@K?J<IKW< [$8PbI \;<;@
[+ ?8C;< 9<E@ 9@I8Q ;8?8 ;@EC< .<E #8DFN WCYI9YEC<I@E@E
;XCC<ED<P< P8I;bD <KD<D@Q@ J8cC8P8E 98CXQY FC;LcLEL JXPC<;

@E LELJ<EB<E;@EJXPC<;@E \
[,<B8C8
[TPC<PJ< E<I<;<E ><C;@ FEC8I + ;YI9YEC<I ;YEP8DbQ;8
YI<K@CD@f f<PC<I;@ $8KK8 ;YI9YEC<I@E YQ<I@E;<B@ YI<K@:@E@E 8;bEb
M< D<;<C@E KYIYEY FBL;LB $8I= ?8I= D8 9L PbC;bQ BYD<J@E<
;8?8 XE:< ?@W9@I @EJ8E LcI8D8Dbf + ?8C;< F ;YI9YEC<I E<I<

;<E ><C;@ dB@D@Q ;< F JbI8;8 9L EFBK8Pb ;YfYEYG <E;@f<C<E

D<;@B9@C< .<E@Ef@D;@;<<E;@f<C<E;@c@EPFB \
[e<P \
[#<D@P< 9@E;@BK<E JFEI8 F ;YI9YEC<I@ E< P8GKbE .D@K? +E

C8Ib9<E;<E8C;bE LB8;8IbEb?8KbICbPFILD \
.D@K? B<E;@J@E@ J8MLED8B @JK<I:<J@E< [+EC8Ib B8J8P8


BFP;LD \;@P<:<M8GM<I;@
[+E;8EJFEI8;YI9YEC<I<?@W;FBLE;LEDL\
[$8PbI \
[489<E<E;FBLE;LDDL\
[@C;@c@DB8;8IbPC8;FBLED8;bE \
e<I<=@D YQ<I@E< P<D@E <;@PFILD FEC8I8 9<E ;< ?@W ;FBLE

D8;bD *<;<Ef@D;@B8J8Pb8WDbPFIJLE\
.D@K? 8cbI 8cbI B8J8P8 >@KK@ L 8;8DbE G8ID8B @QC<I@E<
>XI< 8P8IC8EDbfKb '8G8B ?<D<E 8WbC;b .D@K? B8J8EbE @W@E<
98BD8;8E LQ8E;b M< JFEI8 PYQYE;<B@ @=8;< ;<c@f@M<I;@ /@Q 9@I
J<JC< 98cbI8I8B B8J8;8B@ f<PC<I< 98BKb I;bE;8E FEC8Ib <C@E<
8C;b
e@D;@ <C@E;< ;<c@f@B I<EBC<I;< ;XIK K8f G8IW8Jb M8I;b LEC8I
B898:8;@B;XIK><E9@W@D@P;@C<I
?FLEJ LJLC:8 [@Q@ JYIYBC<D<B @W@E ;LP>LC8IbDbQb BLC

C8E;bC8I \ ;@P< 8WbBC8;b .8EB@ 9L B<C@D<C<I@ K<B<I K<B<I


8IB8;8fbEbE @E8KWb B8=8JbE8 JFBD8P8 W8CbfbPFI;L [#<Q<><EC<I

;<E 9@I@E< @ED<D@Q @W@E ?@G<I


8KFD@B DFKFIC8IbE 9FQLC;LBC8IbEb
J8ED8DbQb J8cC8;bC8I $8E>@ ><Q<><E< @E<:<c@D@Q XE<DC@
;<c@C;@ J8EbIbD @I@E< @E;@c@D@Q Q8D8E ;8B@B ;YI9YEC<I 9LC

;LcLDLQL J8ED8DbQ8 E<;<E FC;LC8I $<D<E ;@c<I ><Q<><E<


BFfD8DbQ@W@E \
.D@K? @EC<;@ ['@D 431&6 'LPILBC8I Db PFBJ8 PbC8EC8I Db
4FBJ8?<I@B@J@;<D@\
?FLEJ [dB@J@;<;<c@C \;<;@ [@KB@C<I \
[@KB@C<ID@ >.A*01*6 D@P8E@\
[/89@@ dB@ ;<c@f@B KYI ?8PM8EbE 8PEb :@EJ W@W<BC<I< 98BKbB

C8IbEb >XI;YB @Q ;< 9@I<I ?8PM8E FC;LcLDLQ @W@E <=<E;@C<I@E ;<
FEC8I FC;LBC8IbEb J8E;bB D8 9XPC< ;YfYED<D@Q @W@E 9@I E<;<E
M8IDbP;bTQ<E>XJK<I@C<E:8ECbC8I9@KB@C<I;@8JCbE;8 \
[@Q;YEP8;8;89@KB@P<K@fK@I@PFILQ ?FLEJ \
;8D [D89@QF9@KB@C<I@P@PFILQ \;<;@
[<CB@FP8I8KbBC8I;8G<D9<9@KB@C<I@P@PFIC8I \


?FLEJ [ @P<C@D B@ FEC8Ib P<D<;@BC<I@E@ 9@C@PFILD \ ;@P<


98fbEb J8CC8;b [@Q@ @P@ PXE<KK@C<I #<D@P@ @E;@ID<B @W@E WbGC8B 9@I
P<I9LCD8P8E<9YPYB9@IK@K@QC@BC<W8CbfKbcbDb?8KbICbPFIDLJLE\
D*3 XPC<9@I@JK<B;LPD8;bD \\
[.<E BFEKIFCC8IbE 98fbE;8 ;<c@C;@E +ELE @W@E J<E@ ;YfYEYG
<E;@f<C<ED@PFIC8I;b .FEI8 fLEL ;8 LELKD8 9@Q F W@W<B
KFQC8IbEb ?@W =8IB<KD<;@B +PJ8 YJKYDYQ 98fbDbQ GFCC<EC< B8

GC8EDbfKb LILDL 8E:8B @B@E:@ ><Q<><E< @E;@BK<E JFEI8


>XI;YB \
[+C8D8Q $@W 9L B8;8I D8EKbBJbQ:8 9@I f<P ;LPD8;bD
dDBVEJbQ9L \\
[*<;<E @DBVEJbQ @Q Q<BVPC8 9@KB@C<I 8I8JbE;8 ?@W9@I Q8

D8E 9@I 98cC8EKb BLID8PbQ SYEBY 9@KB@C<I@E J@E@I J@JK<DC<I@


PFBKLI
D8 9L 9@KB@C<I;< FC89@C@I .8GC8IbE YJKYE;<B@ F <KC@ KFDLI:LBC8Ib
?8KbICbPFI DLJLE PIb:8 9@KB@C<I I8?8KW8 <KI8=K8 ;FC8f8D8QC8I
D8 GJ@FE@B >YWC<I@E@ ><C@fK@I;@BC<I@ M< I8?8KW8 ;FC8f8E ?8PM8E

C8Ib BLCC8E;bBC8Ib K8B;@I;< 9LE8 ><I<B B8CD8Q +EC8I8 98BbCbI


>Y9I< M< JL M<I@C@I XCC<ED<C<I@ J8cC8EbI M9 $8PM8EC8I F
9@KB@C<I< WFB 98cCbP;bC8I +EC8I8 J<M>@PC< 98BbPFI M< 9L PYQ;<E
DLKCLCLB ;LPLPFIC8I;b SYEBY 9@KB@C<I FEC8IbE B<E;@C<I@E@ DLKCL
?@JJ<KD<C<I@E@J8cCbPFIC8I;b \
.D@K? K<B;YQ< 9@I J<JC< [.8E8 8:bPFILD \ ;<;@ [$<C< 9L
?@BVP<P@ ;YEP8;8 8EC8KD8P8 B8CB8IJ8E J8E8 ;8?8 ;8 WFB
8:bP8:8cbD \
?FLEJ [<E@D 8IKbB ?@W9@I ?8P8C@D PFB \ ;@P< DbIbC;8E;b
[D8 ;YEP8DbQb LP8ID8BK8E 98fB8 E< P8G89@C@I@D + 9@KB@C<I

@E?8PM8EC8I8E<C<IP8GKbBC8IbEb>XI;YE \
[.8E8>XI<FEC8IbB<E;@C<I@E<<J@I<;@PFIC8I \
[ 8?8 ;8 BXKYJY 48 BLPILBCL P8I8KbBC8I P8 PbC8E E<JE<C<I
M<P8 @B@J@ 9@I;<E M8BK@PC< LQ8P PFC:LCLcL P8G89@C<:<B B8;8I LP

>8IDbfC8I 4FBJ8 @B@ ><Q<><E;< ;< 8PEb 9@KB@;<E FC8D8Q;b D8


9@KB@C<I GJ@FE@B >YWC<I@E@ ><C@fK@I@I ><C@fK@ID<Q 9L LP>8ICbB JFE8


<ID@f <CB@ D<C<Q 9@I KYI 9LEL 98f8I;b  KFD W8cbE8 <I@f<E
?8PM8EC8I K<?C@B<C@ P8I8KbBC8I;bI + PYQ;<E F P8I8KbBC8IbE 9YKYE
9LEC8Ib LELKD8C8Ib J8cC8EDbf 1< JFELE;8 >XI;YcYE F ;LILD8
;YfDYfC<I '8?I<KJ@E .D@K? F 9@KB@C<I <MI<E@E <E K<?C@B<C@ :8E

CbC8Ib YEP8P8 FEC8Ib ?89<I M<ID<D@Q ><I<B@PFI SYEBY 98fB8


;YEP8CbC8I;8FBYD<P<>@I@PFIFC89@C@IC<I \
.D@K? [@C@PFI DLJLE\ ;@P< >YC;Y [SFB P8EbCbPFIJLE +
9@KB@C<I 9@Q@ ><IW<BK<E BFEKIFCC8Ib 8CKbE8 8CDbf FCJ8C8I;b ><Q<

><E;<EB8WbG98fB8C8IbEbLP8ID8DbQ8@Q@EM<I@IC<ID@P;@\
?FLEJ;LI8BC8;b [@CD@PFILD \
.D@K?@E B<P=@ P<I@E< ><C;@ [@I 8E 9<E@ 98P8cb BFIBLKKLE
LEL@K@I8=<KD<C@P@D \
?FLEJ 98fbEb @P@:< FM8C8;b #@KD<D@Q< E<;<E @Q@E M<I;@C<I
;@P< ;YfYEYPFI;L 58K<E E<;<E ;YEP8Pb LP8ID8B @W@E 9L B8;8I
K<C8fC8EbPFILD <CB@ ;< 9@Q@DB@C<I F ><Q<><EC<I< 8E:8B 9@E PbC
JFEI8>@;<:<BC<I
;8D W8I<J@Q:< ;YfYE;Y M< JFELE;8 B8=8JbE;8 9@I =@B@I 9<

C@I@I >@9@ FC;L ?FLEJ FEL P8B8C8D8P8 W8CbfKb 8D8 ;YfYE:< B8P

9FCLG >@KK@ ;8D8 9@I 8E J8EB@ 9@I >YW 9L =@BI@ 9@I P8E8 .8
.:*62.K >@9@><C;@ D8?FLEJJFEI89LEL;8LELKKL
e@D;@ J8;<:< ><D@E@E JFE JYI8K >@KD<J@ ><I<BK@c@E@ 9@C@PFI;L
:<C<<KD<C@P;@C<I

XPC<:< J8PbJbQ PbCC8I JFEI8 P@E< LP>LE f8IKC8I FCLfDLfKL


E8 9@KB@E@E @B@ ><Q<><E;< P<K@f<E :@EJC<I@E@E GIFKF
JGFIC8Ib
B8IfbC8fbG 9@I9@IC<I@E< B8IbfDbf M< P<E@ ><C<E ?8PM8EC8IbE <C9@J<C

<I@E< J8WC8IbE8 M< ><D@C<I@E< P8PbCDbfC8I;b 1< ?<D<E ?<D<E


8PEb 8E;8 D<C<Q JGFIC8I FCLfDLfKL .8;<:< 9L D<C<Q JGFIC8IbE
P<E@9@I;YEP8P88Cbf8:8B>YWM<P<K<E<BC<I@M8I;b
.GFIC8I f@D;@ ><D@;< J<JJ@Q:< 9<BC@PFIC8I;b E8 9@KB@ ><D

@;<B@ P8I8KbBC8IbE B8=8C8IbE8 JFE 9@I >Y;Y P<IC<fK@ID@fK@ +


PYQ;<E DYK?@f 9@I ?bQC8 P<E@ M< FC>LE 9@I ;YEP8P8 ;FcIL >@;@PFI

C8I;b + ><Q<><E;< XQ>YI:< ;FC8f8E P8I8KbBC8I 9@KB@C<I@E




@?K@P8WC8IbEbB8IfbC8P8:8BC8I;b
.GFIC8I 9@KB@C<I< XQ>Y F J89bIC8 9<BC<;@C<I $@W9@I ?8PM8EbE
9@C<D<P<:<c@ ?<I f<P@ 8CK <;<E 9@I J89bI;b 9L 1< JGFIC8IbE ?<I
9@I@;<BYWY:YB9@I<IBVf@=J8PbC89@C@I;@
$)'(-
*8IFE LQLE XDYICY FC8E -@><C bIBbE;8E;b M< 8@C<J@E@E >8C8BJ@
B8PbKC8IbEbKLK8E;XI;YE:YYP<J@P;@
*8IFELE 9YPYB 9@I ;<=K<I@ M8I;b LE8 >8C8BJ@C<I;<B@ B8=8C8Ib
><C@f<E WFB J8Pb;8B@ bIBC8I B8P;<;@C@PFI;L 8?8 BYWYB 9@I
;<=K<I< @J< FC>LEC8f8I8B #8C8BJ@ "<;<I8JPFELE8 >@ID<P< ?8B
B8Q8E8E bIBC8I P8QbCbPFI;L @I@E:@ ;<=K<I;< 98Qb @J@DC<I W@Q@CD@fK@
SYEBY FEC8I fL P8 ;8 9L E<;<EC< 98f8IbJbQ FCDLfC8I;b
e8EJJbQCbB 9@PF=@Q@B P8 ;8 9@PFB@DP8J8C BLJLIC8I KFGCLD8 8P8B
LP;LI8D8D8 E<;<E FCLPFI;L 9LE8 D8 BYWYB ;<=K<I< 8;C8Ib
><W@I@C<E?@W9@IYP<FQ8D8E8B8;8IJ@C@ED<D@fK@
@I ?89<I:@ P8BC8fbIB<E @I@P8Ib M< JFE ;<I<:<;< P8fCb 9@I @E

J8EFC8E*8IFE;898fbEbB8C;bI;b
$89<I:@ [*8I8E \;<;@ [0CL@EJ8E \
[! E<M8IeLD<I8J@D@9@IK8I8=89bI8B \
[@I>ILGFI>8E@QD8;8?8FC>LECLc8<I@fK@ \
[$8I@B8 $8I@B8 IKbB ;8?8 W89LB FC>LEC8fbPFIC8I @I PbC
><WD@PFIB@ P<E@9@IYP<D@QFCD8JbE ,<B@B@D9L>ILG\
$89<I:@ >8C8BJ@E@E B<; ELD8I8JbEb M< FELE @W@E;<B@
;YEP8EbEBFFI;@E8KC8IbEbM<I;@
*8IFE [? \ ;<;@ [+ ;YEP8Pb 9@C@PFILD \ 1< JYJCY 9@I
P8QbPC8 8;b @CB ;<=K<I< P8Q;b .FEI8 @B@E:@J@E< ;< B8P;<KK@ ;<K
FC;LcL @W@E F ;YEP8P8 <E B8C898CbB KFGCLDLE M<I;@c@ 8;b BLC

C8EbPFI;L *8IFE [IQ \;@P<P8Q;b


[L P<E@ P8I8KbBC8I 9@I I<BFI BbI;bC8I \ ;<;@ [8fB8 ?@W9@I
>ILG 8BbC;8E FC>LECLc8 9L B8;8I W89LB ><WD<;@ @I ?8K8 FC

D8;bcbEbLD8IbD\
$89<I:@ [$8K8PFB <=<E;@D \;@P<:<M8GM<I;@
[/<IDF
EYBC<<I<E<IA@P@XcI<E;@C<I;<c@CD@\
[!M<K <=<E;@D \
[!? XCWYDYQ ;< 9L \ *8IFE >YC;Y [1< P8BbE;8 LQ8P



><D@C<I@PC<><C<:<BM<=<;<I8JPFEC898cC8EKbBLI8:8BC8I \\
$89<I:@ @JK<D<P< @JK<D<P< [0CL <=<E;@D \ ;@P< DbIbC;8E;b
[#XQC<D:@C<I@D@Q FEC8IbE ?<EYQ LQ8P8 8WbCD8;bBC8IbEb
9@C;@I;@C<I \\
*8IFE f8fbI;b [$@W D@ 8WbCD8DbfC8I @I LQ8P @JK8JPFEC8Ib
;8PFBDL\\
[$<EYQPFB <=<E;@D \\
[D8 D8;<D K<IDF
EYBC<<I >YWC<I@ M8I <E<PC<I M< G8K

C8KD8C8IE<I<;<P8GbCbPFI\
['<E;@><Q<><EC<I@E;< <=<E;@D \\
CKb D<KI< 9FPLE;8 FC8E *8IFE 8P8c8 B8CB8I8B ['<E;@
><Q<><EC<I@E;<D@\;@P<>YIC<;@
[!M<K <=<E;@D \\
*8IFE 8cbI 8cbI B8C<D@E@ WbB8I8I8B BYWYB ;<=K<I< JFE P8Q;bcb
8;b W@Q;@ + Q8D8E8 B8;8I >XIYCDYf 9@I f<P ;<c@C;@ 9L D8
*8IFE WFB 8BbCCb 9@I @EJ8E;b M< >8C8BJ@;<B@ ?<IB<J >@9@ F
B8WbEbC8D8P8:8BJFEL:L>XI<9@C@I;@
;8D [?D8BC8I \\;@P<?FDLI;8E;b

.+*
%# &#"!( &$#'!

You might also like