Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bar Cap 3
Bar Cap 3
Hans F. Olsen, CFA - Head of Investment Strategy Americas +1 212 526-4695 hans.olsen@barclayswealth.com
12th August 2011 CONTENTS: Page 3: Equities Page 5: Fixed income Page 7: Currencies Page 10: Commodities
Cont. 1
Investors are grappling with two primary questions: will the US slip into another recession and will the Euro survive? While the risks have risen as economic activity has slowed, the fact remains that jobs are still being created, corporate profits remain robust and resilient, and the consumer is still spending. On survival of the Euro, there has been too much political and financial capital expended to let it die. Currency unification is an enormous and complicated enterprise. Decades in the planning, Euro zone leaders have shown one consistency: the willingness to do whatever it takes to support one another in the name of economic union. Undoubtedly, this will lead inexorably to further economic integration and the likely creation of a Euro zone Ministry of Financethe European counterpart to the US Treasury Department. Some have posited the notion that this will create the United States of Europethat is, if the German populace doesnt say, Genug!
Portfolio Implications
We have been preparing our portfolios over the last several months for this environment. Ahead of the market pull back this week, we raised cash by four percent adding to the existing over weight to cash created by our reduction in emerging market debt and corporate bonds at the end of June. As the market recedes, appealing opportunities emerge. Notably, dividend paying stocks become even more fetching by the day as yields rise. In an environment where investors are starving for income, dividend paying stocks offer the best of both worlds: generous income and an undated call option on future prosperity a compelling combination. In a testament to diversification, our macro managers who are long volatility are performing well posting positive returns.
A Different View
The rush to sovereign debt as a haven of safety is understandable. What is less apparent is how expensive this debt has become. Consider Figure 3. Figure 3 shows the price earnings ratio for the 10-year reference security for sovereign nations and compared the results to each countrys corresponding equity market. The results are noteworthy. The bull market in sovereign debt is at extremes. With a multiple of 46, the US government debt looks extremely overvalued compared to the equity market. Combine this with a negative real yield and the case for sovereign debt is thin. Indeed, at these levels, it is hard to make a case for Developed Market Bonds as the asset class is long risk and short much in the way of return.
3.5% 3.0%
60 50 40 30 20 9 35 24 1 2 1 4 1 2 1 0 1 0 41 45 38 32 20 8 9 1 0 20 9 1 2 1 2 1 2 39 39 48 46
2.5% 2.0%
1 0 0
1 .5% Jan-2008
Finland
Italy
Spain
US
EQUITIES
William Hobbs - Research, Economics & Strategy +44 (0)20 3555 8415 william.hobbs@barclayswealth.com
EQUITIES
OUR CONVICTIONS Markets to make progress in
2011
THIS WEEK
Markets pricing in double dip recession Earnings season continues to provide relief from mixed economic news Valuations imply a significant opportunity across developed markets
Opportunity knocks
Equity markets continued to oscillate wildly this week, though to little end effect. The S&P put us through 4 days of moves in excess of 4% and yet finished trade last night almost exactly where it began the week. On a very short term view, this looks to be a fair assessment of the week by the market. The news from Standard & Poors was not unexpected and seemed to do little to deter the feeding frenzy on US government bonds, while the FOMC statement similarly provided little we didnt already know about. Sentiment is still being dictated by fears of a US double dip recession and by fears the European sovereign debt crisis is creeping closer to the core of Europe. At times in the last two weeks, it has seemed the only anomaly in all the negative data and news flow has been the Q2 earnings season in the US. There are those who dismiss corporate earnings as a backwards looking indicator, which to some extent is fair. However, for those of the belief that US economic growth is already in negative territory, we would counter that the average peak in annualised trailing earnings has tended to come five months prior to the beginning of a recession (looking at S&P 500 earnings changes during post WWII recessions) and there are only two occasions that earnings were still rising, as they are now, when a recession actually began - the 1974 - 75 oil shock and the 1981 82 monetary policy induced recession. Figure 1: S&P Price to 12month forward earnings
(x) 24 22 20 1 8 1 6 1 4 1 2 1 0 8 Aug-01
Our colleagues at Barclays Capital suggest that Q3 earnings would have to miss bottom up consensus forecasts by some 14% for the year on year growth rate to actually fall. This would represent quite a one quarter turn around for a broadly unleveraged corporate sector, in seemingly robust health. We mentioned the ongoing Q2 earnings season in last weeks weekly, but one week on, the situation remains little different. Nearly 90% of the constituents of the S&P have already reported earnings and on average they have managed to beat consensus expectations by an average of 5.7%, registering some 23% earnings growth for the quarter. All of this is not to say that such a collapse in earnings is impossible, but on current evidence, it looks unlikely. As Hans Olsen noted in his piece on the front page, the market has already opted to more than factor in such an eventuality, providing what we see as an attractive opportunity. Yes data has been patchy, and in some cases, outright poor, however we do not think that it points to a double dip yet and still expect the US to manage economic growth in the second half. Stuttering - maybe, slow almost certainly, but growth all the same. If corporates manage to eke out similar levels of profit growth to those seen in the first half, amidst a weak economic backdrop, we would expect the developed equity markets to reward investors with significant gains from these levels. The S&P is trading on a paltry 11x forward earnings forecasts, some 29% below the 10 year average as shown by the chart below. Figure 2 Weekly market performance
YTD % return -25 -20 MSCI dev. mrkts S&P 500 DJ Eurostoxx 50 Nikkei 225 FTSE1 00 MSCI EM
-1 5
-1 0
-5
Aug-03
Aug-05
Aug-07
Aug-09
Aug-1 1
-1 0 Weekly
-8
-6
-4
-2
1 Avg 0yr
EQUITIES
EPS and PE ratios are based on IBES (Institutional Brokers Estimate System) consensus data.
Japan: neutral
We responded to the post-disaster sell-off by closing our underweight call. The yen may not rise far, and valuations have likely undershot. Long-term issues remain, but after the write-down, the chances of a cyclical rebound remain high.
UK: underweight
The FTSE should make progress in the second half of the year, but may be marginally held back by concerns surrounding the implementation of the austerity programme.
EM: Underweight
Emerging market valuations are up with events but we still like the long term outlook. Look to increase emerging market exposure via cheaper developed market stocks.
FIXED INCOME
Fadi Zaher, Fixed Income Strategy, +44 +44(0) 20 3134 8949 fadi.zaher@barclayswealth.com Amie Stow, Fixed Income Strategy, +44 (0) 20 3134 2692 amie.stow@barclayswealth.com
FIXED INCOME
OUR CONVICTIONS Rates to rise only slowly Cash provides portfolio
insurance
THIS WEEK
US treasuries have shrugged off the downgrade with risk aversion dominating flows The ECB has provided some respite to Italian and Spanish bonds Our fixed income portfolios have been rebalanced to reflect our TAA changes
gap until the EFSF is put in place. We believe that this is unlikely to be until mid-September at the earliest, as it still has to get approval from the various European parliaments. Until then, the ECB is unlikely to want to push yields much lower but will instead maintain them at a stable level ahead of both Spain and Italy coming back to the markets in September. Over the medium term, fiscal integration is needed in the euro area and we expect more discussions around this at the EU summits this year. Credit markets have also seen considerable volatility, with spreads across investment grade and high yield widening out. In Europe this has been most noticeable in financials. French banks have been the worst hit, with their CDS reaching new highs however, we believe that these solvency concerns are not justified given the strength of balance sheets and solid margins. Overall, on a valuation basis, this sector still looks compelling in our view.
total return (%) UK IL US IL US HY US IG Eur 1 0yr Eur 2yr UK 1 0yr UK 2yr US 1 0yr US 2yr -6.0% -4.0% -2.0% 0.0% 2.0% 4.0% 6.0% 8.0% 1 0.0% 1 2.0% 1week Yr to date
FIXED INCOME
EUR End 2011 (F) Current level End 2011 (F) Current level
Curve (Bps)
3m-10y 227 down 160 down 197 down
Inflation (%)
CPI 3.6 up 3.1 up 4.2 up
Curve
We expect a flattening bias overall, though long end has little room for yields to fall further after recent rally.
Inflation
In the UK we expect that inflation will peak in November before moderating to our long-term average throughout 2012.
Credit Spreads
We are sharply underweight investment grade credit. We are also underweight high yield: valuations look expensive and risk aversion may persist through the autumn.
Figure 4 Fixed Income Portfolio Tilts and Opportunities August 7th changes Cash: extended overweight reduces risk in the portfolio and leaves funds available for opportunities ahead Government bonds: cut to underweight look substantially overvalued and are trading at low yields but core government bond holdings do provide insurance headwinds out there Investment Grade credit: remain underweight valuations are expensive and event risks like M&A are increasing headwinds. High Yield & Emerging Market bonds: remain underweight market looks fully priced, and potentially vulnerable to macrodriven summer volatility. Concerns about GEM inflation leave that segment looking less attractive.
Source: Barclays Wealth Strategy
CURRENCIES
CURRENCIES
OUR CONVICTIONS The US dollar to stay soft The Swiss franc to weaken in
time
THIS WEEK Despite the US downgrade, the US dollar remained broadly supported However, the US growth outlooks, coupled with its fiscal position, will likely keep USD soft Speculation about the Swiss franc peg to the euro materially weighed on the franc
particularly rosy, we expect the currency to range trade against the euro and sterling in the near-term. The world of currencies is about relative value and neither sterling nor the euro are necessarily better alternatives to the US dollar (and vice versa) over the weeks ahead. The ongoing concerns about the viability of peripheral countries are likely to prevent the euro appreciating materially, while the clouded outlook for the UK economic recovery (as underscored by this weeks Inflation Report and the dovish tone of the subsequent press conference) does not make sterling a clear cut better choice. It took guts to trade the Swiss franc this week, with the currency volatility far exceeding other main crosses (Figure 2). With risk aversion dominating markets, the franc rose to near parity against the euro, prompting the Swiss National Bank to further step up its efforts to curb the currency appreciation. The SNB increased the Swiss Monetary Base by a further CHF 40bn and announced additional foreign exchange swap transactions. Although this stopped the franc appreciation, what sharply reversed the currency trend were remarks (and the subsequent speculation) of the SNB Deputy President Thomas Jordan that a franc peg to the euro cannot be ruled out. The currency depreciated against the euro by almost 10% (from its peak to trough) in three days. We remain cautious about near-term prospects for the franc, given the ongoing concerns about the global economic outlook and the sovereign debt situation in the euro area. However, we continue to judge that the currency has a lot of scope to weaken in the long term. The franc now appears extremely rich. Against the euro, the franc is overvalued by 42% and 29%, based on Purchasing Power Parity by OECD and our Fundamental Equilibrium Exchange Rate model respectively. Moreover, the currency strength is likely to spill into the domestic economy while Swiss corporates, such as Nestle, already see the franc strength materially eating into their sales growth. Figure 2 The Swiss francs volatility exceeded other main crosses
3 month Implied Option Volatility, EUR 24 Earthquake in Japan Recent market jitters
20
1 6
EUR/USD
CURRENCIES
Notes: 1We use Barclays Capital FX forecasts for the 3 month, 6 months and 12 months forecasts. The Forecast vs. Forward is the expected return on a cross-rate long position having accounted for the cost of carry. Confidence intervals determined using Barclays Wealth FX Scorecard, based on popular FX strategies: momentum, value and carry. See FX forecasting: Introducing confidence levels for details.
High confidence: FX indicators strongly supportive of the forecast; historic success rate around 60-85%. Medium confidence: FX indicators mildly supportive of the forecasts; historic success rate around 50-65%. Low confidence: FX indicators not supportive of the forecast; historic success rate around 30-50%.
CURRENCIES
SUMMARY OF VIEWS
G10 currencies
US dollar: Concerns about the US growth outlook, fiscal position, loose monetary policy and current account deficit are likely to continue to weigh on the USD over the quarters ahead. Euro: The euro is likely to remain supported by still favorable interest rate differentials as well as a lack of a credible alternative among the major currencies. However, concerns about the sovereign debt situation in the euro area are risks to the currency. Sterling: Although sterling remains inexpensive, it seems that a catalyst for the currency to appreciate is not in place yet. The feeble UK recovery remains a concern and despite the high levels of inflation, the MPC seems to be in no rush to start the tightening cycle. Japanese yen: We expect the yen to remain supported by the uncertainty about the US fiscal position and global growth prospects over the months ahead. However, loose monetary policy for an extended period is likely to weigh on the yen in the long term. Swiss franc: Currently overvalued, low interest rates for an extended period should likely cause the Swiss franc to weaken in time. Canadian dollar: CAD has benefited from elevated oil prices, but is expensive. It may stay supported against the US dollar due to USD weakness. Australian dollar: Although overvalued, the highest rates among G10 currencies may continue to support AUD. New Zealand dollar: The currency appears overvalued and provides scope for the NZD dollar to fall. Norwegian krone: Healthy economic recovery, interest rate hikes, firm oil prices and a relatively strong fiscal position should support NOK. Swedish krona: Robust economic growth, expected rate hikes and a likely rebound in global growth should cause SEK to appreciate.
2011 Q3 0-0.25 0.50 1.50 0-0.1 1.00 4.75 0-0.25 2.25 2.00
2011 Q4 0-0.25 0.50 1.75 0-0.1 1.25 4.75 0-0.25 2.50 2.25
Forecasts 2012 Q1 2012 Q2 0-0.25 0-0.25 0.50 0.75 2.00 2.25 0-0.1 0-0.1 1.75 2.25 5.00 5.25 0-0.25 0-0.25 2.50 2.75 2.50 2.75
The ECB was the first to hike among G4. We expect the BoE to stay on hold this year while the Fed is not likely to hike until mid-2013 Japans and Switzerlands interest rates are likely to be kept low for an extended period, weighing on the yen and the franc in time. The Australian dollar is the only G10 currencies which offer an attractive yield in money markets. We expect the Norwegian and Swedish central banks to continue in their tightening cycles.
Source: Barclays Wealth Economics and Barclays Capital
COMMODITIES
COMMODITIES
OUR CONVICTIONS Long-term oil and metal
fundamentals constructive
THIS WEEK Commodities show signs of stabilising this week but returns are likely to remain volatile When global growth picks up, attractive returns could be made in oil and industrial metals Upside risks for agricultural commodities have increased following cuts to harvest estimates
Despite our view that the global recovery will resume an upward trajectory in the second half of the year, near term investor sentiment will continue to dominate returns. However, when market volatility eventually normalises and global macro indicators start to show signs of further stabilisation, we could see particularly attractive returns within the energy and industrial metals sector with supply-demand fundamentals looking encouraging. Constrained supply-side prospects on the back of potential mine supply disruptions should tighten industrial metal markets, while oil demand growth (driven by EM demand) outpacing supply growth, alongside ongoing MENA tensions and eroding global spare capacity, should help to provide some upward momentum in oil prices in the medium and long-term.
Fear or fundamentals?
Much as with other perceived risk assets, escalating fears about global growth over the last two weeks resulted in a broad-based selloff in commodities. Oil and industrial metal prices dropped even agricultural commodities slipped, despite their supposed immunity to broader macroeconomic concerns. Although prices started to show signs of stabilising this week, with fears of a double-dip recession likely to continue dominating sentiment in the short term, it seems timely to ask whether we are nearing the end of the commodities super cycle? Probably not is the simple answer. Short-term investor sentiment will likely play a very important role in the day-to-day fluctuations in prices and this is likely to continue for some time. But given our expectations of a gradual global recovery, we expect this period of weakness in prices to be short-lived and expect fundamentals to reemerge as the primary driver of prices in the medium and long-term. One important reason why we think the super cycle is not over is because of the increasingly dominant role of emerging economies in commodity markets. The ongoing urbanisation in emerging markets, particularly in China, has meant strong growth in infrastructure and manufacturing, equating to robust demand for raw materials. We still believe that demand in emerging economies will be more than sufficient to offset declining demand from more mature service oriented economies. There are those who highlight that current consumption in developing markets for commodities leaves very little room for further upside. However, as Figure 1 illustrates, there is still a wide disparity between per capita consumption in the emerging world vs. their developed peers. Figure 1 Oil consumption and consumption per capita
mb/d 20 18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 United States China Japan India Russia Canada Consumption per capita (lhs) b/yr 30 25 20 15 10
5
-20%
2006-07 Wheat
2007-08
2008-09
2009-10 Est.
Soybeans
Corn
10
COMMODITIES
Level
316.2 463.5 213.0 565.9 174.8 366.4 74.1
w-o-w %
0.0 0.7 1.0 3.6 0.0 -5.2 -1.0
mtd %
-3.4 -2.7 -6.9 4.5 0.3 -10.6 -0.6
ytd %
-3.1 0.7 -9.3 22.9 -4.3 -9.8 -1.7
y-o-y %
19.0 27.6 -4.5 62.0 33.2 11.2 2.9
Commodities
Brent Crude oil ($/bbl) WTI Crude oil ($/bbl) Gold ($/oz)
Spot
107 86 1754
w-o-w %
-4.6 -1.3 4.5
mtd %
-9.2 -10.7 8.1
ytd %
15.0 -6.2 23.8
y-o-y %
37.6 10.1 46.4
Forecasts
Brent Crude oil ($/bbl) WTI Crude oil ($/bbl) Gold ($/oz)
Q311
110 99 1560
Q411
115 102 1580
2011
112 100 1509
2012
115 110 1550
Long term
135 137 850
Notes: We use Barclays Capital forecasts for all commodities. All forecasts are average quarterly and average annual forecasts.
Energy
Ongoing tensions in the MENA region alongside tightening fundamentals in the oil market should sustain oil prices at elevated levels, offsetting potential weakness in US natural gas prices due to oversupply. However, a slowdown in global growth may increase downside risks to oil prices in the short-term.
Precious metals
Investment demand remains the predominant driver of gold and silver prices and this is unlikely to change in the short and medium-term. When monetary policy tightening cycles in the developed world eventually kick into gear, appetite for safe-haven assets will likely diminish slowly, which should eventually cause prices to ease from current levels in the long-term.
Industrial metals
Global industrial production should continue to slowly recover as the economic recovery finds its feet. This is likely to support OECD and EM demand while tight supply conditions are likely to underpin industrial metal prices in the second half of the year. Tightening credit conditions in China remain a key risk to metals demand growth as a slowdown in Chinese demand could weigh on prices.
Agriculture
Adverse weather conditions, which hampered near-term supply in 2010, are likely to be a key issue in 2011. Inventories for some agricultural commodities are still at very low levels, while demand continues to remain robust. Figure 3 Contributions to DJ-UBS total return index
%m-o-m, nsa 1 2 1 0 8 6 4 2 0 -2 -4 -6 -8 -1 0 Jan-1 0 Energy May-1 0 Agricultural Sep-1 0 Livestock Jan-1 1 Ind metals May-1 1 Prec metals 0.2 0.0 -0.2 -0.4 -0.6 -0.8 -1 .0 -1 .2 1 2 30-Jun-1 1 3 29-Jul-1 1 4 04-Aug-1 1 5 6 1 -Aug-1 1 1
DJ-UBS CI
11