Reply Reference: RMC- STH -SAL- ESR -75 REV01-22 Reply Date: 19- Dec -2022

ENGINEER’S SUBMITTAL REPLY FORM

Project Title: Royal Medical center
Submittal Title: Fire rated and non-fire rated door
Submittal Ref. : P120/SEC/SD/ARCH/0008-REV01
Document Ref. :
Received Date: 12/12/2022
Replied Date: 19/12/2022
Approval Status
A B C D E
Approved Approved As Noted Revise and Resubmit Rejected For Information

Comments and Recommendations

- Contractor replay to commnet 02 in ESR75 is not accepted because:

.1 During ADCD inspection , inspector will request equipment list which include fire rated doors and its approval certificate
number and approved fire rated door installer license , beside physical Barcode installed on fire rated doors ,

.2 Acoustical properties are included in project specs , removing this properties requires formal approval from client

.3 Warranty duration is subjected to client approval

.4 Consider lead lining in D05 –D06 –D16

.5 Missing door in block B (double 180 FD1 ) – check comments on drawings

.6 Contractor must comply with door dimensions (exa… D1 shutter width- clear access is 90cm / not structural opening )

.7 As per sample at site sample. finish is not veneer ( its HPL) .

Providing vision panels to all doors may affect the room privacy , or be commented by DOH , the decision is subjected
.8 to client judgment and approval .
.9 Check last 3 drawings and provide proper labeling

.10 Main contractor must integrate the drawings with approved ironmongery & hardware and update door schedules

.11 The above comment shall be closed / addressed prior to start any fabrication on site.

Reviewed by: Eng. Ehab Merhej Designation: Sr. Resident Engineer

Signature: Date: 19- Dec -2022

STH consultant Page 1 of 1

PROJECT TITLE: ROYAL MEDICAL CENTER
SUBMITTAL TITLE: FIRE RATED AND NON FIRE RATED DOORS COMMENTS RESPONSE.
SUBMITTAL REF: P120/SEC/SD/ARCH/0008
NO CONSULTANT COMENTS RESPONSE BY SUBCONTRACTOR REMARKS
The proposed manufacturer is not listed vendor as per the project approved LOM.
1 However, the proposed manufacturer is technically accepted subject to client final subcontractor is approved by the client. comply
approval and the comments indicated here under.

Fire rated door manfacturer is just supplying the door shutter with veneer and without
Contractor is eligble only for non fire rated door. Approved supplier / installer for fire
any paint finish. Al khayam carpentery will manfucture and install all the frames and
2 rated doors must stamp the drawings ( fire rated door drawings must be coming form
architrave and other decorative designs on the shutter. Hence the shopdrawing and other
approved supplier) ( refer to drawing A509)
material submittal can be submitted only from al khayam carpentery.
N/A
The submitted door outfit design is subjected to client approval ( Fire rated doors must All the fire rated doors are with fire rated vision panel as per ADCD regulation with rubber
3
contain fire rated glass panel) seal comply
Contractor must consider access control lproperties for designated doors ( provide in
4 we will corrdinate with the main contractor for the access control proporty doors.
door description in schedule) comply
5 Contractor must attached door shedule ( similar to the following) Attached comply
metal skirting and kick plate will be reflected in door hardware schedual. With kick plate
6 metal skirting / kick plate is required
specification and location. comply
Contractor is not complying with required quality materials. (check comments on
7 Rectified the comments on the shop drawing.
drawings) comply

All the material is subject to decorative design of the door. Because we cannot achive the
8 architrave must be beech wood ( not veneer)
approved color from beech wood. So it has to be veneered MR MDF
comply
9 Follow same lebaling as tender. (D01 - D02)… rectified the comments on the shop drawing. comply
Acoustic propertied fill is not in our scope because there will be a variation for acustic
10 fill materials must have acoustical properties (confirm)
properties door. comply
Supplier proposed his own fixation method for frame / architrave (approval will be
11 subjected to site mock up) and (life time) warranty certificate for doors function provided life time warranty is not applicable. Maximum we can provide you 5 years warranty.
in the material submittal N/A

we cannot treat wood with any chemical because it will exceed the VOC limit. Normally
12 Door must be anti - fungal / anti bacterial treated - certificate is required
we can propose anti fungle paint properties and anti bacterial paint.
comply
Main contractor must integrate the drawings with approved ironmongery & hardware
13 Comply
and update door schedules comply

14 The above comment shall be closed / addressed proor to start any fabrication on site.