Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cicarellimemory
Cicarellimemory
Encoding is not limited to turning sensory information into signals for the brain.
memory Encoding is accomplished differently in each of three different storage systems of mem-
an active system that receives ory. In one system, encoding may involve rehearsing information over and over to keep it
information from the senses, puts that
in memory, whereas in another system, encoding involves elaborating on the meaning of
information into a usable form, and
the information—but let’s elaborate on that later.
organizes it as it stores it away, and then
retrieves the information from storage. KEEPING IT IN: STORAGE The next step in memory is to hold on to the information for
some period of time in a process called storage. The period of time will actually be of
encoding
different lengths, depending on the system of memory being used. For example, in one
the set of mental operations that people
system of memory, people hold on to information just long enough to work with it, about
perform on sensory information to
20 seconds or so. In another system of memory, people hold on to information more or
convert that information into a form that
is usable in the brain’s storage systems.
less permanently.
GETTING IT OUT: RETRIEVAL The biggest problem many people have is retrieval, that
storage
is, getting the information they know they have out of storage. Have you ever handed in
holding on to information for some
an essay test and then remembered several other things you could have said? Retrieval
period of time.
problems are discussed thoroughly in a later section of this chapter.
retrieval
getting information that is in storage into
a form that can be used.
6.2 Models of Memory
6.2 Explain how the different models of memory work.
information-processing model
model of memory that assumes the
Exactly how does memory work? When the storage process occurs, where does
processing of information for memory that information go and why? Memory experts have proposed several different
storage is similar to the way a computer ways of looking at memory. The model that many researchers once felt was the most
processes memory in a series of three comprehensive* and has perhaps been the most influential over the last several decades
stages. is the information-processing model. This approach focuses on the way information
Information enters through the sensory system, briefly registering in sensory memory. Selective attention filters
the information into short-term memory, where it is held while attention (rehearsal) continues. If the information
receives enough rehearsal (maintenance or elaborative), it will enter and be stored in long-term memory.
ICONIC SENSORY MEMORY The example of seeing the possibly pantless person is an ex-
ample of how the visual sensory system works. The visual sensory system is often called
iconic memory, and it only lasts for a fraction of a second. Icon is the Greek word for
“image.” Iconic memory was studied in several classic experiments by George Sperling
(1960), as shown in the Classic Studies in Psychology feature.
0 .15 .3 .5 1.0
SBAX Low tone
Delay in signal (seconds)
Sample grid of letters for Sperling’s test of iconic memory. To determine if the entire grid
existed in iconic memory, Sperling sounded a tone associated with each row after the
grid’s presentation. Participants were able to recall the letters in the row for which they
heard the tone. The graph shows the decrease in the number of letters recalled as the
delay in presenting the tone increased.
Using this technique, Sperling found that participants could accurately report any of
the three rows. This meant that the entire grid was in iconic memory and available to the
participants. The capacity of iconic memory is everything that can be seen at one time.
Sperling also found that if he delayed the tone for a brief period of time, after about a
second, participants could no longer recall letters from the grid any better than they had
during the whole report procedure. The iconic information had completely faded out of
sensory memory in that brief time.
In real life, information that has just entered iconic memory will be pushed out
very quickly by new information, a process called masking (Cowan, 1988). Research
suggests that after only a quarter of a second, old information is replaced by new
information.
Moomsabuy/Shutterstock
Although it is rare, some people do have what is properly called eidetic imagery,
or the ability to access a visual sensory memory over a long period of time. Although the
popular term photographic memory is often used to describe this rare ability, some people
claiming to have photographic memory actually mean that they have an extremely good
memory. Having a very good memory and having eidetic imagery ability are two very
different things. People with eidetic imagery ability might be able to look quickly at a These sparklers appear to create trails of
light when, in fact, no light continues to exist
page in a book, then by focusing on a blank wall or piece of paper, “read” the words
after passing a given point along its path.
from the image that still lingers in their sensory memory. Although it might sound like a
The apparent trails of light are due to the
great ability to have while in college, it actually provides little advantage when taking brief persistence of light from each sparkler
tests, because it’s just like having an open-book test. If a student can’t understand what’s in sensory memory, a concept referred to as
written on the pages, having the book open is useless. It is unknown why some people visual persistence, or persistence of vision.
have this ability, but it is more common in children and tends to diminish by adolescence
or young adulthood (Haber, 1979; Leask et al., 1969; Stromeyer & Psotka, 1971).
Iconic memory actually serves a very important function in the visual system. Chapter
Three discussed the way the eyes make tiny little movements called microsaccades that
keep vision from adapting to a constant visual stimulus, so that what is stared at steadily
doesn’t slowly disappear. Iconic memory helps the visual system view surroundings as
continuous and stable in spite of these saccadic movements. It also allows enough time
for the brain stem to decide if the information is important enough to be brought into
consciousness—like the possibly pantless person.
ECHOIC SENSORY MEMORY Another type of sensory system is echoic memory, or the
brief memory of something a person has heard. A good example of echoic memory is
the “What?” phenomenon. You might be reading or concentrating on the television, and
your parent, roommate, or friend walks up and says something to you. You sit there
Anton Havelaar/123RF
for a second or two and then say “What? Oh—yes, I’m ready to eat now,” or whatever
comment is appropriate. You didn’t really process the statement from the other person
as he or she said it. You heard it, but your brain didn’t interpret it immediately. Instead, it
took several seconds for you to realize that (1) something was said, (2) it may have been
important, and (3) you’d better try to remember what it was. If you realize all this within
about 4 seconds (the duration of echoic memory), you will more than likely be able to Tuning a piano requires the use of echoic
“hear” an echo of the statement in your head, a kind of “instant replay.” sensory memory. What other occupations
might find a good echoic memory to be an
Echoic memory’s capacity is limited to what can be heard at any one moment and
asset?
is smaller than the capacity of iconic memory, although it lasts longer—about 2–4 seconds
(Schweickert, 1993).
Echoic memory is very useful when a person wants to have meaningful conversa-
tions with others. It allows the person to remember what someone said just long enough
eidetic imagery
to recognize the meaning of a phrase. As with iconic memory, it also allows people to
the ability to access a visual memory for
hold on to incoming auditory information long enough for the lower brain centers to
30 seconds or more.
determine whether processing by higher brain centers is needed. It is echoic memory
that allows a musician to tune a musical instrument, for example. The memory of the echoic memory
tuning fork’s tone lingers in echoic memory long enough for the person doing the tuning auditory sensory memory, lasting only
to match that tone on the instrument. 2–4 seconds.
tions going on in the background but you are still able to notice when some-
one says your name, you have experienced this effect. In this kind of a situ-
ation, the areas of the brain that are involved in selective attention had to be
working—even though you were not consciously aware of it. Then, when that
important bit of information (your name) “appeared,” those areas somehow
filtered the information into your conscious awareness—in spite of the fact
Each person at this gathering is involved in a that you were not paying conscious attention to the other background noise
conversation with others, with dozens of such (Hopfinger et al., 2000; Mesgarani & Chang, 2012; Stuss et al., 2002).
conversations going on at the same time all around. Yet
Dr. Anne M. Treisman (Treisman, 2006; Triesman & Gelade, 1980) pro-
if a person in another conversation says the name of one
of the people in the crowd, that person in the crowd will posed that selective attention operates in a two-stage filtering process: In the
be able to selectively attend to his or her name. This is first stage, incoming stimuli in sensory memory are filtered on the basis of
known as the “cocktail-party effect.” simple physical characteristics, similar to Broadbent’s original idea. Instead
of moving to STM or being lost, however, there is only a lessening (attenua-
tion) of the “signal strength” of unselected sensory stimuli in comparison to the selected
stimuli. In the second stage, only the stimuli that meet a certain threshold of importance
are processed. Since the attenuated stimuli are still present at this second stage, some-
thing as subjectively important as one’s own name may be able to be “plucked” out of
the attenuated incoming stimuli. Even when deeply asleep, when the selective attention
filter is not working at its peak level, it still functions: A sleeping mother will awake to her
infant’s cries while sleeping through louder, less important sounds such as a dog barking
(LaBerge, 1980).
What happens when information does pass through the selective attention filter
and into short-term memory? Short-term memory tends to be encoded primarily in
auditory (sound) form. That simply means that people tend to “talk” inside their own
heads. Although some images are certainly stored in STM in a kind of visual “sketch-
pad” (Baddeley, 1986), auditory storage accounts for much of short-term encoding. Even
short-term memory (STM)
a dancer planning out moves in her head will not only visualize the moves but also be
the memory system in which information very likely to verbally describe the moves in her head as she plans. An artist planning
is held for brief periods of time while
a painting certainly has visual information in STM but may also keep up an internal
being used.
dialogue that is primarily auditory. Research in which participants were asked to recall
selective attention numbers and letters showed that errors were nearly always made with numbers or letters
the ability to focus on only one stimulus that sounded like the target but not with those that looked like the target word or number
from among all sensory input. (Acheson et al., 2010; Conrad & Hull, 1964).
Memory 243
WORKING MEMORY Some memory theorists use the term working memory as another
way of referring to short-term memory—they see no difference between the two concepts.
Others feel that the two systems are quite different. In this discussion, we will use short-
term memory to refer to simple storage and working memory as relating to storage and
manipulation of information (Baddeley, 2012). Short-term memory has traditionally been
thought of as a thing or a place into which information is put. As mentioned earlier,
current memory researchers prefer to think of memory in terms of a more continuous
system, where information flows from one form of representation to another, rather than
a series of “boxes.” Working memory is therefore thought of as an active system that pro-
cesses the information present within short-term memory. Working memory is thought to
consist of three interrelated systems: a central executive (a kind of “CEO” or “Big Boss”)
that controls and coordinates the other two systems, the visuospatial “sketchpad” of sorts
that was mentioned earlier, and a kind of auditory action “recorder” or phonological loop
(Baddeley, 1986, 2012; Baddeley & Hitch, 1974; Baddeley & Larsen, 2007; Engle & Kane,
2004; Van der Stigchel & Hollingworth, 2018). The central executive acts as interpreter
for both the visual and auditory information, and the visual and auditory information
are themselves contained in short-term memory. For example, when a person is reading
a book, the sketchpad will contain images of the people and events of the particular pas-
sage being read, while the recorder “plays” the dialogue in the person’s head. The central
executive helps interpret the information from both systems and pulls it all together. In a
sense, then, short-term memory can be seen as being a part of the working memory sys-
tem (Acheson et al., 2010; Bayliss et al., 2005; Colom et al., 2006; Kail & Hall, 2001).
Another way to think about short-term memory is as a desk where you do your
work. You might pull some files out of storage (permanent memory), or someone might
hand you some files (sensory input). While the files are on your desk, you can see them,
read them, and work with them (working memory). The “files” are now conscious ma-
terial and will stay that way as long as they are on the desk. Less important files may get
“thrown out” (forgotten as you fail to pay attention to them), while more important files
might get stored away (permanent memory), where they are not conscious until they are
once again retrieved—brought out of the desk.
CAPACITY: THE MAGICAL NUMBER SEVEN, OR FIVE, OR FOUR George Miller (Miller, 1956)
wanted to know how much information humans can hold in short-term memory at any
one time (or how many “files” will fit on the “desk”). He reviewed several memory studies,
including some using a memory test called the digit-span test, in which a series of numbers
is read to participants in the study who are then asked to recall the numbers in order. Each
series gets longer and longer, until the participants cannot recall any of the numbers in order.
What you will discover is that most everyone you test will get past the first two
sequences of numbers, but some people will make errors on the six-digit span, about
half of the people you test will slip up on the seven-digit span, and very few will be
able to get past the nine-digit span without errors. This led Miller to conclude that the
capacity of STM is about seven items or pieces of information, plus or minus two items,
or from five to nine bits of information. Miller called this the magical number seven, plus
or minus two. Since Miller’s review of those early studies and subsequent conclusion
about the capacity of STM being about seven items, research methods have improved, as
has our knowledge and understanding of memory processes. Current research suggests
that working memory capacity can vary from person to person (Engle, 2018; Shipstead
et al., 2016). For example, younger adults can hold three to five items of information at
a time if a strategy of some type is not being used. When the information is in the form
of longer, similar-sounding, or unfamiliar words, however, that capacity reduces until it
is only about four items (Cowan, 2001; Cowan et al., 2005; Palva et al., 2010). There is a
way to “fool” STM into holding more information than is usual. (Think of it as “stacking” working memory
related files on the desk.) If the bits of information are combined into meaningful units, or an active system that processes the
chunks, more information can be held in STM. If someone were to recode a sequence of information in short-term memory.
244 Chapter 6
WHY DO YOU THINK THEY CALL IT “SHORT TERM”? How long is the “short” of short-term
memory? Research has shown that short-term memory lasts from about 12 to 30 seconds
without rehearsal (Atkinson & Shiffrin, 1968; J. Brown, 1958; Peterson & Peterson, 1959).
After that, the memory seems to rapidly “decay” or disappear. In fact, the findings of
one study with mice suggest that in order to form new memories, old memories must be
“erased” by the formation of newly formed neurons (Kitamura et al., 2009). The hippo-
campus only has so much storage room, and while many of the memories formed there
will be transferred to more permanent storage in other areas of the brain, some memories,
without rehearsal, will decay as new neurons (and newer memories) are added to the
already existing neural circuits.
Most people realize that saying something they want to remember over and over
again in their heads can help them remember it longer. We sometimes do this with
names we want to remember, or a phone number we want to remember long enough
to enter into our phone’s contacts. This is a process called maintenance rehearsal.
Oleksandr Hrytsiv/123RF
With maintenance rehearsal, a person is simply continuing to pay attention to the in-
formation to be held in memory, and since attention is how that information got into
STM in the first place, it works quite well (Atkinson & Shiffrin, 1968; Rundus, 1971).
With this type of rehearsal, information will stay in short-term memory until rehearsal
stops. When rehearsal stops, the memory rapidly decays and is forgotten. If anything
This restaurant server is taking the woman’s interferes with maintenance rehearsal, memories are also likely to be lost. For example,
order without writing it down. Which
if someone is trying to count items by reciting each number out loud while count-
memory system is she using? Do you think
that her capacity for items in this system may
ing, and someone else asks that person the time and interferes with the counting pro-
be greater than someone who does not try to cess, the person who is counting will probably forget what the last number was and
remember items like this often? have to start all over again. Short-term memory helps people keep track of things like
counting.
Interference in STM can also happen if the amount of information to be held in STM
exceeds its capacity. Information already in STM may be “pushed out” to make room for
newer information. This is why it might be possible to remember the first few names of
people you meet at a party, but as more names are added, they displace the older names.
A better way to remember a person’s name is to associate the name with something about
the person’s appearance, a process that may help move the name from STM into more
permanent storage. This more permanent storage is the process of long-term memory,
which is the topic of the next section.
Working memory is an important area of research and has implications for
understanding not only intelligence but also learning and attention disorders such as
attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, and various dementia-related memory prob-
lems (Alloway et al., 2009; Jafarpour et al., 2017; Kensinger et al., 2003; Martinussen et al.,
2005). Researchers have trained mice to improve their working memory and found that
maintenance rehearsal the mice become more intelligent with improved working memory (e.g., Light et al.,
practice of saying some information to 2010). Other researchers have found that working memory is helpful in solving mathe-
be remembered over and over in one’s matical problems but may actually hurt the ability to solve creative problems (Wiley &
head in order to maintain it in short-term Jarosz, 2012). Creative problem solving seems to benefit from a less focused approach
memory. than the focused attention taking place in working memory.
Memory 245
DURATION As for duration, the name long term says it all. There is a relatively permanent
iStock/Gettyimages
physical change in the brain itself when a memory is formed. That means that many of
the memories people have stored away for a long, long time—even since childhood—
may still be there. That does not mean that people can always retrieve those memories.
The memories may be available but not accessible, meaning that they are still there, but
These students are rehearsing for a concert.
for various reasons (discussed later under the topic of forgetting) people cannot “get to” They will use maintenance rehearsal
them. It’s like knowing that there is a certain item on the back of the top shelf of the (repeating the musical passages over
kitchen cabinet but having no ladder or step stool to reach it. The item is there (available), and over) until they can play their parts
but you can’t get to it (not accessible). perfectly. The movements of their hands
and fingers upon their instruments will be
“Long term” also does not mean that all memories are stored forever; our personal
stored in long-term memory. How is this
memories are too numerous to be permanently retained, for example. Nor do we store kind of long-term memory different from
every single thing that has ever happened to us. We only store long-lasting memories of something like the memorized lines of
events and concepts that are meaningful and important to us. one’s part in a play?
Information that is rehearsed long enough may actually find its way into long-term
memory. After all, it’s how most people learned their Social Security number and the
letters of the alphabet (although people cheated a little on the latter by putting the al-
phabet to music, which makes it easier to retrieve). Most people tend to learn poems and
the multiplication tables by maintenance rehearsal, otherwise known as rote learning.
Rote is like “rotating” the information in one’s head, saying it over and over again. But
maintenance rehearsal is not the most efficient way of putting information into long-term
storage, because to get the information back out, one has to remember it almost exactly as
it went in. Try this: What is the 15th letter of the alphabet? Did you have to recite or sing
through the alphabet song to get to that letter?
Although many long-term memories are encoded as images (think of the Mona
Lisa), sounds, smells, or tastes (Cowan, 1988), in general, LTM is encoded in meaningful
form, a kind of mental storehouse of the meanings of words, concepts, and all the events
that people want to keep in mind. Even the images, sounds, smells, and tastes involved
in these events have some sort of meaning attached to them that gives them enough im-
portance to be stored long term. If STM can be thought of as a working “surface” or desk,
then LTM can be thought of as a huge series of filing cabinets behind the desk, in which long-term memory (LTM)
files are stored in an organized fashion, according to meaning. Files have to be placed in the system of memory into which all the
the cabinets in a certain organized fashion to be useful—how could anyone ever remem- information is placed to be kept more or
ber any kind of information quickly if the files were not in some order? The best way to less permanently.
246 Chapter 6
2014). See the Applying Psychology to Everyday Life feature at the end of this chapter for
more on elaborative rehearsal.
Getty Images
of Lenny in the motion picture Memento as well as Dory from Finding Nemo and
Figure 6.3 Tower of Hanoi
Finding Dory.) One of the more famous anterograde amnesia patients, H.M., is dis-
cussed in detail later in this chapter.
Interactive
A B C
In one study of nondeclarative memory (Cohen et al., 1985), patients with this
disorder were taught how to solve a particular puzzle called the Tower of Hanoi
1
(see Figure 6.3). Although the patients were able to learn the sequence of moves nec- 2
essary to solve the puzzle, when brought back into the testing room at a later time, 3
they could not remember ever having seen the puzzle before—or, for that matter,
the examiner. Yet they were able to solve the puzzle even while claiming that they
The Tower of Hanoi is a puzzle that is solved in a
had never seen it before. Their nondeclarative memories for how to solve the puz-
series of steps by moving one disk at a time. The goal
zle were evidently formed and stored in a part of the brain separate from the part is to move all of the disks from peg A to peg C; the
controlling the memories they could no longer form. Even people with Alzheimer’s rules are that a larger disk cannot be moved on top of
disease, who also suffer from anterograde amnesia, do not forget how to walk, talk, a smaller one and a disk cannot be moved if there are
fasten clothing, or even tie shoes (although they do lose motor ability because the other disks on top of it. Amnesic patients were able to
brain eventually fails to send the proper signals). These are all implicit, nondeclara- learn the procedure for solving the puzzle but could
not remember that they knew how to solve it.
tive memories. In fact, it would be rare to find someone who has lost nondeclarative
memory. Literally, these are the kind of memories people “never forget.”
Nondeclarative memories are not easily retrieved into conscious awareness. Have
you ever tried to tell someone how to tie shoes without using your hands to show them?
The participants in the Tower of Hanoi study also provide a good example of implicit
memory, as they could solve the puzzle but had no conscious knowledge of how to do
so. Such knowledge is in people’s memories because they use this information, but they
are often not consciously aware of this knowledge (Roediger, 1990). A memory from
one’s early childhood of being frightened by a dog, for example, may not be a conscious
memory in later childhood but may still be the cause of that older child’s fear of dogs.
Conscious memories for events in childhood, on the other hand, are usually considered
to be a different kind of long-term memory called declarative memory.
DECLARATIVE (EXPLICIT) LTM Nondeclarative memory is about the things that people can
do, but declarative (explicit) memory is about all the things that people can know—the
facts and information that make up knowledge. People know things such as the names of
the planets in the solar system, that adding 2 and 2 makes 4, and that a noun is the name
of a person, place, or thing. These are general facts, but people also know about the things
that have happened to them personally. For example, I know what I ate for breakfast
this morning and what I saw on the way to work, but I don’t know what you had for
breakfast or what you might have seen. There are two types of declarative long-term
memories, semantic and episodic (Nyberg & Tulving, 1996).
One type of declarative memory is general knowledge that anyone has the ability
to know. Most of this information is what is learned in school or by reading. This kind declarative (explicit) memory
of LTM is called semantic memory. The word semantic refers to meaning, so this kind of
type of long-term memory containing
knowledge is the awareness of the meanings of words, concepts, and terms as well as information that is conscious and known.
names of objects, math skills, and so on. This is also the type of knowledge that is used on
game shows such as Jeopardy. Semantic memories, like nondeclarative memories, are rela- semantic memory
tively permanent. But it is possible to “lose the way” to this kind of memory, as discussed type of declarative memory containing
later in the section on forgetting. general knowledge, such as knowledge
The other kind of factual memory is the personal knowledge that each person has of language and information learned in
formal education.
of his or her daily life and personal history, a kind of autobiographical* memory (LePort
et al., 2012). Memories of what has happened to people each day, certain birthdays, anni- episodic memory
versaries that were particularly special, childhood events, and so on are called episodic type of declarative memory containing
memory, because they represent episodes from their lives. Unlike nondeclarative and se- personal information not readily avail-
mantic long-term memories, episodic memories tend to be updated and revised more or able to others, such as daily activities and
less constantly. You can probably remember what you had for breakfast today, but what events.
you had for breakfast 2 years ago on this date is most likely a mystery. Episodic memories
that are especially meaningful, such as the memory of the first day of school or your first
date, are more likely to be kept in LTM (although these memories may not be as exact as
people sometimes assume they are). The updating process is a kind of survival mechanism,
because although semantic and nondeclarative memories are useful and necessary on an
ongoing basis, no one really needs to remember every little detail of every day. As becomes
obvious later, the ability to forget some kinds of information is very necessary.
Some evidence suggests that women are a bit better at retrieving episodic
memories than are men, while there seems to be no similar gender difference for
semantic memories (Fuentes & Desrocher, 2013; Herlitz et al., 1997; Maitland et al.,
2004). Women tend to use more verbal descriptions than do men, and perhaps women
are using more verbal cues when encoding and retrieving episodic memories, creating
an advantage over men who may not be relying as much on verbal cues. As semantic
memories are verbal in their very nature, there would be no gender advantage in this
memory system—both men and women would be using verbal cues.
Episodic and semantic memories are explicit memories because they are eas-
ily made conscious and brought from long-term storage into short-term memory. The
knowledge of semantic memories such as word meanings, science concepts, and so on
can be brought out of the “filing cabinet” and placed on the “desk” where that knowl-
edge becomes explicit, or obvious. The same is often true of personal, episodic memories.
Long-term memory
Long-term memory can be divided into declarative memories, which are factual and typically conscious
(explicit) memories, and nondeclarative memories, which are skills, habits, and conditioned responses that are
typically unconscious (implicit). Declarative memories are further divided into episodic memories (personal
experiences) and semantic memories (general knowledge).
264 Chapter 6
Interactive
100
Immediate recall
Percentage remembered
80
60 20 minutes
1 hour
40 9 hours
20
0 2 4 6 8 10 15 20 25 31
Elapsed time (days)
Ebbinghaus found that his recall of words from his memorized word lists was greatest immediately after
learning the list but rapidly decreased within the first hour. After the first hour, forgetting leveled off.
encoding failure study a body of material all at once. For example, studying your psychology material
failure to process information into for 3 hours may make you feel that you’ve done some really hard work, and you have.
memory. Unfortunately, you won’t remember as much of what you studied as you would if you
had shorter study times of 30 minutes to an hour followed by short breaks (Cepeda et al.,
memory trace
2006; Dempster & Farris, 1990; Donovan & Radosevich, 1999; Simon & Bjork, 2001). See
physical change in the brain that occurs
Learning Objective PIA.5.
when a memory is formed.
decay
loss of memory due to the passage of
6.11 Reasons We Forget
time, during which the memory trace is 6.11 Identify some common reasons people forget things.
not used. There are several reasons people forget things. We’ll examine three theories here.
disuse ENCODING FAILURE One of the simplest is that some things never get encoded in the
another name for decay, assuming that first place. Your friend, for example, may have said something to you as he walked out
memories that are not used will eventu- the door, and you may have heard him, but if you weren’t paying attention to what he
ally decay and disappear. said, it would not get past sensory memory. This isn’t forgetting so much as it is en-
coding failure, the failure to process information into memory. Researchers (Nickerson
& Adams, 1979) developed a test of long-term memory using images of a common
Figure 6.8 Stop! object for many people, a penny. Look at Figure 6.8. Which view of a stop sign is the
correct one? People see stop signs nearly every day, but how many people actually
Interactive
look at them that closely so the information is encoded into long-term memory?
MEMORY TRACE DECAY THEORY One of the older theories of forgetting involves the
concept of a memory trace. A memory trace is some physical change in the brain,
perhaps in a neuron or in the activity between neurons, which occurs when a memory
is formed (Brown, 1958; Peterson & Peterson, 1959). Over time, if these traces are not
used, they may decay, fading into nothing. It would be similar to what happens when
a number of people walk across a particular patch of grass, causing a path to appear
in which the grass is trampled down and perhaps turning brown. But if people stop
using the path, the grass grows back and the path disappears.
Forgetting in sensory memory and short-term memory seems easy to explain
as decay: Information that is not brought to attention in sensory memory or contin-
Many people look at stop signs multiple times
a day. Which of these stop signs is closest to an
uously rehearsed in STM will fade away. But is decay a good explanation for for-
actual stop sign? The answer can be found on getting from long-term memory? When referring to LTM, decay theory is usually
the next page. called disuse, and the phrase “use it or lose it” takes on great meaning (Bjork &
Memory 265
Bjork, 1992). Although the fading of information from LTM through disuse sounds
logical, there are many times when people can recall memories they had assumed
Comstock/Stockbyte/Getty Images
were long forgotten. There must be other factors involved in the forgetting of long-
term memories.
INTERFERENCE THEORY A possible explanation of LTM forgetting is that although
most long-term memories may be stored more or less permanently in the brain, those
memories may not always be accessible to attempted retrieval because other information
interferes (Anderson & Neely, 1996). (And even memories that are accessible are subject
to constructive processing, which can lead to inaccurate recall.) An analogy might be
The fact that these women can remember
this: The can of paint that Phillip wants may very well be on some shelf in his storeroom, the events shown in the pictures in these
but there’s so much other junk in its way that he can’t see it and can’t get to it. In the case photo albums even after many years makes
of LTM, interference can come from two different “directions.” it unlikely that the memory trace decay the-
ory can explain all forgetting in long-term
PROACTIVE INTERFERENCE Have you needed to use your new password but had trouble
memory.
remembering it because you kept remembering bits of the old one? The reason you
experience difficulty is called proactive interference: the tendency for older or previously
learned material to interfere with the learning (and subsequent retrieval) of
new material. (See Figure 6.9.) Figure 6.9 Proactive and Retroactive
Another example of proactive interference often occurs when someone Interference
gets a new cell phone number. People in this situation often find themselves
remembering their old cell phone number or some of its digits instead of
Proactive Interference
the new cell phone number when they are trying to give the new number to
French, learned beforehand, interferes proactively
friends.
Study French Study Spanish Spanish Test
RETROACTIVE INTERFERENCE When newer information interferes with
the retrieval of older information, this is called retroactive interference.
(See Figure 6.9.) What happens if you find you need to remember that old
password, maybe to get into an older tablet or phone? You might have trouble Retroactive Interference
remembering the old one, retrieving bits of the newer password instead, Spanish, learned afterwards, interferes retroactively
because the newer information retroactively interferes with remembering the
old information. Study French Study Spanish French Test
How might interference work in each of the following cases?
1. Moving from the United States to England, where people drive on the
left instead of the right side of the road.
If a student were to study for a French exam and then a
2. Trying to use your old Amazon Fire TV® remote after having used your Spanish exam, interference could occur in two directions.
newer Roku® remote for a year. When taking the Spanish exam, the French information stud-
ied first may proactively interfere with the learning of the
3. Moving from one type of cell phone system to another, such as going
new Spanish information. But when taking the French exam,
from an iPhone® to an Android® system.
the more recently studied Spanish information may retroac-
The different ways that forgetting occurs are summarized in Table 6.1. tively interfere with the retrieval of the French information.
Decay or Disuse Information that is not accessed decays from the storage retroactive interference
system over time. memory problem that occurs when newer
Proactive Interference Older information already in memory interferes with the information prevents or interferes with
learning of newer information. the retrieval of older information.
Retroactive Interference Newer information interferes with the retrieval of older
information. The answer to Figure 6.8 is the middle right
image.
268 Chapter 6
It was only new declarative memory—both semantic and episodic—that was lost. H.M.,
who can now be revealed as Henry Gustav Molaison, died in December 2008 at the age
of 82. His experience and his brain continue to educate students and neuroscientists, as
he agreed many years ago that his brain would be donated for further scientific study
upon his death. To learn more about the H.M. postmortem project, go to https://www
.thebrainobservatory.org/project-hm
There is some evidence that memories of the same event may involve different
areas of the hippocampus (Collin et al., 2015). The different areas seem to correspond to
different degrees of memory detail for the event, such as remembering reading a specific
text message from your partner before going to class (a fine detail) or recalling going out
to eat after class (a broader event).
The posterior cingulate cortex also seems to be involved in the formation of long-
term memories. See Learning Objective 2.7. This is one of the areas of the brain that shows
damage in people with Alzheimer’s disease. It is involved in consolidation, as researchers
have found evidence that the posterior cingulate is not only activated when engaging in
active rehearsal to first remember specific information, but it is also active when retriev-
ing that memory (Bird et al., 2015). Furthermore, improved memory appears to be related
to how similar brain activity during retrieval is to the activity in this same area during
active rehearsal. It is possible that active rehearsal and activity in the posterior cingu-
late strengthens memory by helping link both episodic and semantic information (Binder
et al., 2009; Bird et al., 2015).
of the induced seizure seem to significantly ease the depression, the shock also seems to
Figure 6.10 Retrograde and
disrupt the memory consolidation process for memories formed prior to the treatment. Anterograde Amnesia
While some researchers in the past found that the memory loss can go back as far as three
years for certain kinds of information (Squire et al., 1975), later research suggests that the
Interactive
loss may not be a permanent one (Meeter et al., 2011; Ziegelmayer et al., 2017).
ANTEROGRADE AMNESIA Concussions can also cause a more temporary version of the
kind of amnesia experienced by H.M. This kind of amnesia is called anterograde amnesia,
or the loss of memories from the point of injury or illness forward (Squire & Slater, 1978).
People with this kind of amnesia, like H.M., have difficulty remembering anything new.
One of your authors knows a young man who was struck by lightning in the summer of
2018. He remembers walking behind his brother, pulling a cart they had their tools in.
His next memories start about two months later. He cannot remember the lightning strike
nor his time in the hospital or other experiences that occurred in the two months follow-
ing the strike. This is also the kind of amnesia most often seen in people with dementia,
a neurocognitive disorder, or decline in cognitive functioning, in which severe forgetfulness,
mental confusion, and mood swings are the primary symptoms. (Dementia patients also
may suffer from retrograde amnesia in addition to anterograde amnesia.) If retrograde
amnesia is like losing a document in the computer because of a power loss, anterograde
amnesia is like discovering that your hard drive has become defective—you can read data
that are already on the hard drive, but you can’t store any new information. As long as you
are looking at the data in your open computer window (i.e., attending to it), you can access (top) Sometimes a blow to the head, such as
it, but as soon as you close that window (stop thinking about it), the information is lost, might be sustained in an accident like this
one, can lead to the loss of memories from the
because it was never transferred to the hard drive (long-term memory). This makes for
time of the injury backwards—a loss of recent
some very repetitive conversations, such as being told the same story or being asked the
memory which may be only a few minutes to
same question numerous times in the space of a 20-minute conversation. See Figure 6.10 several hours or days, or in some cases, even
for a comparison of retrograde and anterograde amnesia. years of the past. This is called retrograde
amnesia, because “retro” means “relating to
ALZHEIMER’S DISEASE Nearly 5.7 million Americans have Alzheimer’s disease the recent past. (bottom) Anterograde amnesia
(Alzheimer’s Association, 2018). It is the most common type of dementia found in adults involves the loss of the ability to form new
and the elderly, accounting for nearly 60 to 80 percent of all cases of dementia. It is es- memories. Memories of the distant past may
timated that 1 out of 10 people over the age of 65 has Alzheimer’s disease. It has also still be intact, but newer memories such as the
name of the person you just met or whether
become the sixth-leading cause of death in the United States and the fifth-leading cause
you took your medication or not seem unable
of death in people 65 years and older, with only heart disease and cancer responsible for to “stick.” That’s why a person with this type
more deaths (Alzheimer’s Association, 2018; Antuono et al., 2001; National Center of amnesia (common in dementia) might not
for Health Statistics, 2015). remember a conversation that just took place
With Alzheimer’s disease, the primary memory problem, at least in the beginning, or a visit from the day before.
is anterograde amnesia. Memory loss may be rather mild at first but becomes more severe Sources: (top) Dmitry Kalinovsky/123RF; (bottom) highwaystarz/
Fotolia.
over time, causing the person to become more and more forgetful about everyday tasks.
Eventually more dangerous forgetting occurs, such as taking extra doses of medication or
leaving something cooking on the stove unattended. As Alzheimer’s disease progresses,
memories of the past seem to begin “erasing” as retrograde amnesia also takes hold. It is
a costly disease to care for, and caregivers often face severe emotional and financial bur-
dens in caring for a loved one who is slowly becoming a stranger.
What causes Alzheimer’s disease is not completely understood. While it is normal
for the brain to begin to form beta-amyloid protein deposits (plaques) and for strands
of the protein tau to become twisted (“tangles”), people who suffer from Alzheimer’s
disease are found to have far more of these physical signs of an aging brain (Chen et al.,
2012; Lim et al., 2012). One of the neurotransmitters involved in the formation of mem-
ories in the hippocampus is acetylcholine, and the neurons that produce this chemical
break down in the early stages of the disease (Martyn et al., 2012). While one early-onset
form of Alzheimer’s appears to be heavily genetically influenced and involves several
different genetic variations, this seems to be the case for fewer than 5 percent of the
total cases of the disease (Alzheimer’s Association, 2010, 2018; Bertram & Tanzi, 2005;
270 Chapter 6
Haass et al., 1995). The sad truth is that there is not one cause but many, and even those
who do NOT have Alzheimer’s disease are not safe from other forms of dementia, such
as dementia caused by strokes, dehydration, medications, and so on (Karantzoulis, &
Galvin, 2011).
Treatments can slow but not halt or reverse the course of the disease. Six drugs
are currently approved for treatment, but as yet only slow down the symptoms for an
average of 6 to 12 months. What is known is that the risk factors for Alzheimer’s (and
many other forms of dementia) are something that can be managed: high cholesterol,
high blood pressure, smoking, obesity, Type II diabetes, and lack of exercise all contribute
(Alzheimer’s Association, 2010; 2018; Baumgart et al., 2015). Keeping the brain mentally
active is also a way to help prolong good cognitive health. One study’s findings indicate
that continued everyday learning stimulates brain-derived neurotrophic factors (BDNF),
a key protein involved in the formation of memories (L. Y. Chen et al., 2010). A more re-
cent study suggests that a drug intended for use in treating diabetes, AC253, may be able
to restore memory to Alzheimer’s-affected brain cells (Kimura et al., 2012), while another
new drug, ORM-12741, also shows promise (Rinne et al., 2017; Rouru et al., 2013).
We also know that Alzheimer’s is not caused by eating food from aluminum pots
and pans, using the artificial sweetener aspartame, having silver dental fillings, or getting
a flu shot—all myths you may have seen on the Internet or social media. None of these
are true (Alz.org®: Alzheimer’s Association, 2018).
People with dementia or traumatic brain injuries may end up with both types of
amnesia. In a study of a recent case of anterograde amnesia, a musician suffering brain
damage from a bad case of encephalitis (brain inflammation) no longer remembers his
past life, friends, or relatives (retrograde amnesia) and can no longer learn new infor-
mation (anterograde amnesia). Yet he can still play his cello, can read music, and can not
only play pieces from before his brain injury but can also learn new pieces (Finke et al.,
2012). These are nondeclarative skills, and this type of memory is typically unaffected by
amnesia, suggesting that a different area of the brain is involved.
INFANTILE AMNESIA What is the earliest memory you have? Chances are you can-
not remember much that happened to you before age 3. When a person does claim
to “remember” some event from infancy, a little investigation usually reveals that the
“memory” is really based on what family members have told the person about that event
and is not a genuine memory at all. This type of “manufactured” memory often has the
quality of watching yourself in the memory as if it were a movie and you were an actor.
In a genuine memory, you would remember the event through your own eyes—as if you
were the camera.
Why can’t people remember events from the first 2 or 3 years of life? One explana-
tion of infantile amnesia involves the type of memory that exists in the first few years
of life, when a child is still considered an infant. Early memories tend to be implicit, and,
as stated earlier in this chapter, implicit memories are difficult to bring to consciousness.
Explicit memory, which is the more verbal and conscious form of memory, does not really
infantile amnesia
develop until after about age 2, when the hippocampus is more fully developed and lan-
the inability to retrieve memories from
guage skills blossom (Carver & Bauer, 2001).
much before age 3.
Katherine Nelson (1993) also gives credit to the social relationships that small chil-
autobiographical memory dren have with others. As children are able to talk about shared memories with adults,
the memory for events and facts related they begin to develop their autobiographical memory, or the memory for events and
to one’s personal life story. facts related to one’s personal life story.