Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Insights Weekly
Insights Weekly
Insights Weekly
• The key stress points in Asia around much The key stress points in Asia around much higher oil
higher oil prices will be India and Indonesia, as prices will be India and Indonesia, as it already has been
it has been the case this year already. the case this year. But inflation will become a problem
everywhere, either in actual manifestation as the higher
• Beyond India and Indonesia, sharply higher oil
import cost is passed through to the consumer
prices will pose macro challenges across the
(Philippines) or suppressed through fiscal subsidies
board. Inflation will become a problem
everywhere, either in actual manifestation as (China). While fuel is excluded from core inflation
the higher import cost is passed through to calculations, we have seen a strong pattern in the past
the consumer (Philippines) or suppressed (both in developed and emerging economies) that if high
through fiscal subsidies (China). headline inflation persists for a couple of quarters, it
tends to pull up core inflation as well. Monetary
• Malaysia will be one unambiguous winner in
authorities will have to be cognizant of this eventuality.
the bullish commodity price environment.
Taimur Baig
• If high fuel prices persist, inflation will spill
over from headline to core, forcing many
central banks in Asia to follow the Fed in 2019.
2019 2019
Baseline $100 oil Baseline $100 oil
Growth (real GDP, % YoY) 6.2 6.1 Growth (real GDP, % YoY) 2.9 2.7
Inflation (average, % YoY) 2.2 2.4 Inflation (average, % YoY) 2.5 2.7
Fiscal balance (% of GDP) -4.0 -4.2 Fiscal balance (% of GDP) 1.7 1.7
Current account (% of GDP) -1.0 -2.0 Current account (% of GDP) 3.0 2.7
Policy rate (eop, %) 4.35 4.35 Exchange rate (eop, per USD) 7.81 7.83
Exchange rate (eop, per USD) 6.75 7.00
Surging oil prices has negligible impact on the services-
Domestic fuel prices are heavily regulated by the Chinese based Hong Kong economy because oil accounts for 1.7%
authorities. The following chart shows the divergent of total imports. Potential repercussions on the current
trend of PPI and CPI despite surging Brent prices, as account is mild. The risk of cost-push inflation is also
producers are not allowed to pass cost increments onto low. In fact, motor fuel, liquefied petroleum gas and
consumers easily. other fuel only account for 0.77% of the whole consumer
price basket.
Upstream industries will be hit much harder than the Source: CEIC, DBS
consumers. Should oil prices hit $100 at some point, the
state will have to vent the upward pressure somehow Samuel Tse
onto the consumer. Yet, the magnitude is likely to be very Chris Leung
mild. Policymakers will unlikely withstand rising cost-
push inflation on the back of weakening domestic
demand and a worsening trade war with the US.
Page 2
Weekly 5 October 2018
India Indonesia
2019* 2019
Baseline $100 oil Baseline $100 oil
Growth (real GDP, % YoY) 7.8 7.4 Growth (real GDP, % YoY) 5.2 4.9
Inflation (average, % YoY) 5.0 5.4 Inflation (average, % YoY) 4.0 4.3
Fiscal balance (% of GDP) -3.2 -3.5 Fiscal balance (% of GDP) -1.9 -2.4
Current account (% of GDP) -3.1 -3.6 Current account (% of GDP) -2.6 -3.1
Policy rate (eop, %) 7.50 8.50 Policy rate (eop, %) 6.50 7.00
Exchange rate (eop, per USD) 75.0 83.0 Exchange rate (eop, per USD) 15250 16500
*Year ending March 2020
High oil prices are a key Achilles heel for the Indian Currently, Indonesia’s domestic inflation has been
economy, complicating the inflation, current account, protected from increasing oil prices due to the implicit
fiscal balance and currency outlook. This vulnerability below-the-line subsidy. However, if oil prices reach $100
stems from India’s rising reliance on imported crude, to in 2019, the government will finally adjust domestic fuel
meet 83% of its domestic oil demand (vs 78% in past prices, at least partially. A full-fledged adjustment of
three years), amplified by a weakening exchange rate. domestic oil prices will boost inflation by 1ppt, yet we
think that the increase will be implemented gradually
The outlook for external balances, particularly the after the election. We pencil in an additional 0.3ppt to
current account, is negative. With every USD1pb move in our headline inflation baseline, reaching average inflation
the Brent prices adding ~USD2bn to India’s oil imports of 4.3%. The higher inflation will erode consumption that
bill, high oil prices risk widening the net oil deficit as well barely reached 5% in the last year.
as the current account gap. We estimate that a 10% rise
in crude prices, widens the current account deficit (CAD) In addition to the inflation impact, oil trade deficit will
by 0.4-0.5% of GDP. Factoring in the tail risks on oil, the continue to widen. We estimate that the impact will be
CAD could widen past 3.5% of GDP next year. Higher close to 0.5% of GDP, resulting in a CAD number that
foreign capital will be required to finance this gap, as the exceeds the comfortable level of 3% especially given the
balance of payments risks falling deeper into red. tightening outlook on the financial side. Widening trade
deficit that could also induce more outflows can pressure
For CPI inflation, the direct impact of higher crude prices Rupiah closer to 16.500/USD. We believe that Bank
might be modest given the configuration of the price Indonesia will raise policy rate several times to be ahead
basket, but despite this a 10% rise in global crude prices of the curve, facing more pressure to Rupiah due to the
stands to potentially lift headline CPI inflation by 20-30 widening CAD and inflation that is close to BI’s upper limit
ppt, assuming a complete pass-through. The impact will of 4.5% in our scenario.
be higher if we include the second-order pass-through of
high transport costs feeding into manufacturing/ food On another account, the impact on fiscal balance is a net
costs. On the fiscal end, the government has prudently positive – 0.5% of GDP – as the impact of additional non-
held back from either reinstating subsidies or cut taxes to tax revenues is bigger than possible increase of diesel
lower record high domestic fuel prices. Approaching subsidy. A $1/bbl increase in oil prices is associated with
elections and relative inelasticity of domestic energy increase in government revenues by IDR3tn. As the 2019
demand, however, suggests the fiscal and external budget assumption of oil prices is $70, the additional
balances will continue to be tested. non-tax revenues will be around IDR90tn. The impact of
price increase is bigger for diesel compare to gasoline, as
Radhika Rao diesel price will feed into logistics costs. We assume
another adjustment of IDR1,500 to diesel subsidy like this
year. All in, under this scenario, GDP growth will slip
below 5%.
Masyita Crystallin
Page 3
Weekly 5 October 2018
Malaysia Philippines
2019 2019
Baseline $100 oil Baseline $100 oil
Growth (real GDP, % YoY) 4.5 4.9 Growth (real GDP, % YoY) 6.7 6.0
Inflation (average, % YoY) 2.5 3.1 Inflation (average, % YoY) 5.5 5.9
Fiscal balance (% of GDP) -3.0 -2.8 Fiscal balance (% of GDP) -3.0 -3.2
Current account (% of GDP) 3.5 5.1 Current account (% of GDP) -1.4 -3.0
Policy rate (eop, %) 3.25 3.50 Policy rate (eop, %) 5.50 6.00
Exchange rate (eop, per USD) 4.16 4.18 Exchange rate (eop, per USD) 56.5 60.0
Higher oil prices are in general positive for Malaysia given Oil price scenario of $100 can boost inflation by 0.4ppt,
that it is a net oil exporter. Net oil exports (excluding LNG) reaching a number of 5.9%, above the BSP’s upper limit.
registered MYR8.7bn (0.6% of nominal GDP) in 2017. Inflation has been high in recent years due to higher
Higher oil prices should reasonably bring about higher commodity prices – way exceeding the BSP upper limit of
production output from the mining industry and 4%. Oil imports account for more than 10% of total
contribute directly to overall GDP growth. imports, hence have a big impact on trade. This year
alone (until July), there was an additional USD14bn of
We expect better outcome from the external balance as imports which were mostly due to oil price increases.
well. When oil last rose above USD100/bbl in 2010/11, Current account deficit is likely to reach 3% - already
Malaysia’s current account to GDP ratio registered about considering the weaker remittances which was the case
11%, albeit the upside could be limited by in recent years.
correspondingly higher imports on refined petroleum
products. Moreover, the removal of the fuel subsidy in Given that the Philippines economy is currently
Dec14 also means that high oil prices will be positive for overheating, BSP will likely raise rate further by at least
the fiscal balance. Petroleum related tax revenue another 75bps to contain inflation in our baseline
accounts for about 9% of overall tax revenue. This will scenario. If oil goes to $100, there could be another 5-bps
help narrow the fiscal gap arising from GST removal. upside to the policy cycle. Widening trade deficit and
possibly weaker consumption due to lower purchasing
But as fuel subsidy has been removed, the inflationary power, will adversely impact growth. Under this
impact of high oil prices will be more direct. A 10% rise in scenario, GDP growth in 2019 will only reach 6%
oil prices is expected to lift inflation by 0.2ppt. We expect compared to 6.7% in our baseline.
Bank Negara to adopt a slightly tighter monetary policy
stance to anchor inflation expectation. Expect another Masyita Crystallin
25bps hikes in the OPR to 3.50% by end 2019 when
inflation rise above 3%.
Irvin Seah
Page 4
Weekly 5 October 2018
2019 2019
Baseline $100 oil Baseline $100 oil
Growth (real GDP, % YoY) 2.7 2.6 Growth (real GDP, % YoY) 2.9 2.2
Inflation (average, % YoY) 1.8 2.7 Inflation (average, % YoY) 1.8 2.7
Fiscal balance (% of GDP) 1.0 -0.1 Fiscal balance (% of GDP) 0.5 0.4
Current account (% of GDP) 19.0 17.0 Current account (% of GDP) 5.0 4.0
Exchange rate (eop, per USD) 1.38 1.40 Policy rate (eop, %) 2.00 2.00
Exchange rate (eop, per USD) 1160 1190
Although Singapore is a net oil importer, with a deficit of
SGD9.7bn (2.1% of nominal GDP), its oil and gas sector Higher oil prices will boost inflation, erode real incomes
(accounting for 5-6% of GDP), together with other and cut GDP growth for South Korea. The impact will be
supporting services, are expected to benefit from the significant and immediate, given the country’s heavy
higher oil price. Though oil imports may affect the reliance on energy imports and adoption of a floating fuel
external balance, Singapore has one of the highest pricing mechanism. We estimate that a 10% rise in crude
current account position in the region (+18.8% of GDP) oil prices (in KRW terms) will boost headline CPI by 0.3%.
and the impact will also be offset by increase in refined Inflation would easily exceed the Bank of Korea’s 2%
petroleum exports. target next year, should oil prices rise to USD100/bbl.
Impact on the economy will be mostly felt in terms of A surge in oil prices will likely strengthen the case of BOK
inflation. Every 10% increase in oil prices will likely add rate hikes. Following an explicit inflation targeting
about 0.3ppt to the headline CPI inflation. And there is framework, the BOK raised the benchmark rate by 25bps
marginal upside risk considering the upward adjustments and 75bps respectively during the oil price rally in 2008
made in utility tariffs in recent years. However, with a and 2011. Nonetheless, policy response would be more
record budget surplus of SGD9.6bn in FY17, the prudent this time. The output gap, domestic demand and
government is in a strong fiscal position to introduce labour market conditions are relatively weak during the
offset measures to curb against the price impact on current cycle, which should help to contain the second-
consumer spending via a small deficit. round inflation effect of oil price increase.
From monetary policy perspective, the MAS will likely The stress on external balance will be manageable. The
continue to maintain an exchange rate policy stance of a current account is expected to decline by USD7.2bn on
gradual appreciation of SGD NEER to mitigate against the the annual basis (0.4% of GDP), for every USD10/bbl rise
inflation risk. This should likely help to keep the SGD in crude oil prices. A swing into deficit is very unlikely
resilient against the USD. even if oil prices shoot up to USD100/bbl. A small decline
in current account surplus, coupled with a rise in portfolio
Irvin Seah investment outflows (due to deterioration in growth-
inflation dynamics), would mean moderate deprecation
pressure on the KRW.
Ma Tieying
Page 5
Weekly 5 October 2018
Taiwan Thailand
2019 2019
Baseline $100 oil Baseline $100 oil
Growth (real GDP, % YoY) 2.2 1.7 Growth (real GDP, % YoY) 4.0 3.8
Inflation (average, % YoY) 1.0 1.6 Inflation (average, % YoY) 1.5 1.8
Fiscal balance (% of GDP) -0.3 -0.5 Fiscal balance (% of GDP) -2.8 -3.2
Current account (% of GDP) 13.4 12.2 Current account (% of GDP) 9.0 8.0
Policy rate (eop, %) 1.50 1.375 Policy rate (eop, %) 2.00 2.50
Exchange rate (eop, per USD) 33.2 35.0
Fuel prices are floating in Taiwan, despite the partial
subsidies provided by the state-owned Chinese The Thai economy is dependent on the global crude
Petroleum Corporation (CPC). The CPC adjusts domestic supply, with its own domestic crude production
retail fuel prices by 80% of the changes in wholesale sufficient to only meet about a quarter of its total
prices, which are calculated based on the weighted demand. The net oil deficit has narrowed in the past
average of Brent and Dubai oil prices (in TWD terms). three years as global prices fell, but the current account
Normally, a 10% rise in global oil prices will push up math is unlikely to turn dire as the economy continues to
Taiwan’s CPI inflation by 0.2ppt. Thanks to a high enjoy strong trade surpluses (~10% of GDP), led by higher
comparison base, we estimate that inflation will rise but non-oil export shipments and tourism receipts.
remain below the 2% mark in 2019 under the scenario
Rising oil prices has prompted the government to
of oil price spike to USD100/bbl.
partially reinstate the diesel subsidy scheme this year,
tapping the support of its national oil fund. This has
A surge in oil prices will also depress Taiwan’s GDP
happened in the past (2008, 2011 etc.) to alleviate the
growth. The business sector will face a profit squeeze due
impact of a surge in prices on consumers and
to higher upstream costs. The household sector could
manufacturers. Under the present arrangement, retail
withstand higher inflation in the near term thanks to the
diesel prices will be subsidised to keep prices below
pickup in wage growth this year (about 2.5% YoY). But the
THB30/litre, as the oil fund set aside THB6bn for this
support from the labour market would start to fade if
measure. This arrangement is likely to remain in place
corporate profits were to remain weak for several
until late 2018, if crude prices (Dubai crude is used as the
quarters. We reckon that GDP growth may fall below 2%
official benchmark) hold below USD85/bbl. Official
in 2019 if oil prices stay at USD100/bbl.
remarks, however, suggested that if the tail risk of oil
prices surging towards USD100/bbl materialises the
Taiwan’s central bank (CBC) will face a dilemma on
government might allow a bigger pass-through into retail
monetary policy. The CBC raised rates by 25bps during
prices, in light of rising burden on the oil fund as well and
the global oil price rally in both 2008 and 2011. Back then,
as fiscal balances. Rationalisation of these subsidies will
GDP growth was running above potential and the output
be negative for inflation and growth prospects.
gap was positive. During the domestic fuel price hike in
2012, the CBC refrained from monetary tightening as
The Thai baht’s outperformance this year has been
higher inflation (together with weaker global demand)
laudable, but we don’t see it bucking global USD trends
triggered a significant growth slowdown. We think the
into 2019. Given the lingering risk from China-US trade
CBC is more likely to follow the 2012 path and opt for a
wars and the Fed Funds Rate, in addition to a surge in oi
neutral policy this time.
prices, that continues to rise above the BOT policy rate,
the baht is likely join rest of the region in ending the year
weaker. Rising inflationary risks might also prompt
Ma Tieying
measured rate hikes by the Thai central bank next year.
Radhika Rao
Page 6
Weekly 5 October 2018
Strategy
With oil prices pushing higher, the impact on USD rates The negative correlation between yields and oil prices in
has to be considered. We look briefly at two periods (1Y 2007/2008 is largely due to the Fed cutting rates even as
ending mid-2008 where oil prices pushed sharply higher oil prices were climbing relentlessly. This lead to
and the past 5 years) to see how rates and oil interact. downward pressure on yields across all tenors, more than
The intuition is that higher oil prices should translate into offsetting the rise in inflation expectations caused by high
elevated inflation expectations, thereby pushing US oil prices. In the coming quarters, it makes more sense for
yields up. However, the reality is not quite so simple. us to assume that the US economy continues to hold up
Correlation does not imply causation and there are many well and that the Fed will deliver on rate hikes as
other factors to consider even as we try to isolate the forecasted. At the very least, even if there is no
impact of oil on rates. It is true that the WTI’s correlation passthrough from short-term USD rates to longer-term
with inflation expectation (5Y breakeven) is high (0.6 for ones, the level of the UST curve should not be heading
one-year ending mid-2008, 0.9 since 2014). However, lower. Therefore, we should be reasonably confident that
the correlation between 10Y US yields and WTI did not higher oil prices should translate into higher inflation
hold as well. To be sure, this figure is positive in recent expectations and higher UST yields. Taking a correlation
years. However, the period in 2007/08 saw 10Y yields of 0.6, a 33% jump in WTI price to USD100/bbl could
fall even as oil prices push to a record USD145/bbl in push inflation expectations (5Y breakeven) and 10Y
mid-2008. yields up by approximately 30bps.
Eugene Leow
Page 7
Weekly 5 October 2018
The market cap composition of Asia suggests that about Macro headwinds will affect Indonesia, Philippines and
14% of the region’s market cap is exposed to the energy India the most. While market exposure is part of the
and materials sector which should benefit from rising oil analysis, the macro headwinds of rising current account
prices. Cyclical sectors make up 39% of the total market deficit (rising import bills) and high inflation as a result of
cap which means they are likely to be negatively affected higher oil price will likely pressure markets on a broad
by rising oil prices. For industrial cyclical sectors, the macro basis, leading to weakened currencies, risk
sensitivity on earnings is related to higher input costs and aversion and fund outflows. This is especially applicable
material costs, thereby affecting margins, while top-line for Indonesia, Philippines and India.
revenue growth for consumer cyclical sectors could be
impacted by squeeze in purchasing power. Interest-rate- Oil & gas-related stocks are prime beneficiaries, airlines
sensitive sectors account for 30% of market cap. are losers. E&P (exploration and production) players
which have greater sensitivity to oil prices remain the
The likely threat of central banks having to raise rates due preferred proxies to ride the upward trend of oil prices.
to inflationary pressure should raise concerns on the In our earnings models, we have assumed Brent oil to
financial sector. That said, the balance of both positive average US$70-75/bbl in 2018 and US$75-80/bbl in 2019.
and negative exposure should mean Asia countries will Our forecast earnings will have to be raised if high oil
likely suffer from higher oil prices when looking at sector prices are sustained above US$85/bbl. We estimate that
exposure by market cap. Among Asia countries. Thailand every US$1/bbl increase in crude oil price could lift
has the highest exposure benefiting from higher oil earnings by about 2-3% for some of the companies in our
prices, while Singapore, Philippines, Hong Kong and coverage. Sustained high oil prices will also lead to capex
China have the lowest exposure. expansion in 2019 and beyond, and filter through the
value chain. The spotlight shall then turn to Oilfield
Market weights by economic-sensitive sectors Service Providers.
Interest rates Global price The sharp increase in oil price is negative for airlines, as
sensitive Cyclicals Defensive sensitive jet fuel costs account for 25-45% of operating costs (more
Singapore 47% 32% 18% 3% so for low cost carriers), though the impact on individual
Malaysia 32% 15% 40% 13% airlines would depend on how well and far they have
Indonesia 35% 14% 38% 14% hedged. Yield-to-fare pass on typically requires time lag.
Thailand 23% 26% 19% 32% Meanwhile, the Chinese carriers do not hedge any of
Philippines 34% 29% 32% 5% their fuel requirements, but they do have significant
Hong Kong 35% 34% 24% 7% pricing power on their domestic routes to offset some of
China 39% 51% 3% 7% the higher fuel costs.
Korea 12% 59% 15% 13%
Taiwan 18% 53% 12% 18%
India 25% 27% 23% 25%
Asia exJ 30% 39% 20% 14% Joanne Goh
Source: Thomson Reuters, DBS
Page 8
Weekly 5 October 2018
Page 9
Weekly 5 October 2018
Key Forecasts
Page 10
Weekly 5 October 2018
Group Research
Economics & Strategy
Sources: Data for all charts and tables are from CEIC, Bloomberg and DBS Group Research (forecasts and transformations).
Disclaimer:
The information herein is published by DBS Bank Ltd (the “Company”). It is based on information obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but the Company
does not make any representation or warranty, express or implied, as to its accuracy, completeness, timeliness or correctness for any particular purpose. Opinions
expressed are subject to change without notice. Any recommendation contained herein does not have regard to the specific investment objectives, financial situation
& the particular needs of any specific addressee. The information herein is published for the information of addressees only & is not to be taken in substitution for
the exercise of judgement by addressees, who should obtain separate legal or financial advice. The Company, or any of its related companies or any individuals
connected with the group accepts no liability for any direct, special, indirect, consequential, incidental damages or any other loss or damages of any kind arising from
any use of the information herein (including any error, omission or misstatement herein, negligent or otherwise) or further c ommunication thereof, even if the
Company or any other person has been advised of the possibility thereof. The information herein is not to be construed as an offer or a solicitation of an offer to buy
or sell any securities, futures, options or other financial instruments or to provide any investment advice or services. The Company & its associates, their directors,
officers and/or employees may have positions or other interests in, & may effect transactions in securities mentioned herein & may also perform or seek to perform
broking, investment banking & other banking or financial services for these companies. The information herein is not intended for distribution to, or use by, any
person or entity in any jurisdiction or country where such distribution or use would be contrary to law or regulation. Sources for all charts & tables are CEIC &
Bloomberg unless otherwise specified. DBS Bank Ltd., 12 Marina Blvd, Marina Bay Financial Center Tower 3, Singapore 018982. Tel: 65-6878-8888. Company
Registration No. 196800306E.
Page 11