Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Alarm Management in Process Plants
Alarm Management in Process Plants
1.0 IMPORTANCE OF ALARM SYSTEM presented at a rate that the operator can deal
Alarm systems are increasingly important in with, be easy to understand.
the safe management of plant and machinery.
Alarm systems forms an essential part of the 2.0 ALARM GROUPING
operator interface which provides vital support Alarm grouping is one of the important theo-
to the operator by warning them of situation ries in the plant alarm management system
that need their attention. Alarm systems thus where the alarms configured are to be
have an important role in preventing, control- grouped into different categories. All alarms
ling and mitigating the effects of abnormal sit- which are configured in the system should be
uations. The effects can be very serious if specified with a group name. The alarm
these alarm systems does not work well. grouping activity later supports alarm rational-
Alarm systems are a very important way of ization activity as well significantly for analy-
automatically monitoring the plant condition sis.
and attracting the attention of the process
plant operator to significant changes that re- 2.1 GENERAL GUIDELINES
quire assessment or action. They help the op- Instrument tags related to process which
erator to maintain the plant within a safe oper- are configured with alarms are to be pro-
ating envelope. A good alarm system helps vided with the group name with respect to
the operator to correct potentially dangerous the respective defined process areas.
situations before the Emergency Shutdown These alarms are commonly called as
(ESD) system is forced to intervene. This im- “PROCESS ALARM”.
proves plant availability, helps to recognize Safety systems related alarms shall be
and act to avoid hazardous situations, helps to provided with the group name of
identify deviations from desired operating con- “SAFETY”.
ditions that could lead to financial loss and Equipment start/stop related alarms shall
helps to understand complex process condi- be provided with a group name of
tions. Alarms should be an important diagnos- “EQUIPMENT”.
tic tool and are one of several sources that an Shut down valves, Blow down valves and
operator uses during an upset. Alarms are sig- Control valves related alarms shall be
nals which are annunciated to the operator, provided with a group name of “VALVES”.
typically by an audible sound, some form of DCS or PLC system related and Commu-
visual indication, usually flashing, and by the nications related alarms shall be provided
presentation of a message or some other with group name of “SYSTEM”.
identifier. An alarm will indicate a problem re- Electrical switch gear related alarms shall
quiring operator attention, and is generally ini- be provided with group name of
tiated by a process measurement passing a “ELECTRICAL”.
defined alarm setting as it approaches an un-
desirable or potentially unsafe value. Alarm 3.0 ALARM PRIORITY
Management helps to identify process prob- Alarm priority is used to aid the operator de-
lems like valves / equipment & instruments termining the order in which to respond to
malfunction and controller tuning problems, alarms. Effective prioritization typically results
reduces unplanned down time of plant, reduc- in higher priorities chosen less frequently
es production losses, prevents incidents, im- than lower priorities. Most of the alarms
proved productivity – both equipment’s and should be assigned to the lowest alarm priori-
personnel’s. Alarm systems should be de- ty (least important) and the fewest to the
signed to meet user needs and operate within highest alarm priority (most important) with
the operator's capabilities. This means that the the consistent transition between the two.
information alarm systems present should be The resulting priorities should have alignment
relevant to the operator’s role at the time, indi- with the consequence and allowable re-
cate clearly what response is required, be sponse time such that the lowest priority
72
alarms have the least severe consequence which are having direct relation to the to-
and longest allowable response time and the tal plant trip or respective valve closure /
highest priority alarms have the most severe open status which gives very less re-
consequence (Example: Fire and Gas system sponse time for operator to take action
alarms) and the shortest allowable response can be considered for “CRITICAL”.
time. Instrument tags which are configured with
alarms which performs remote operation
3.1 GENERAL GUIDELINES i.e. operation performed by operator to be
All alarms configured in the system will be pri- considered for “LOW” class.
oritized based on the class names. Characteristically all bad PV (Process
Value) alarm shall be configured with low
Facility shall generally use four classes for priority except for the points/tags with high
process related alarms and one class for priority alarm where bad PV shall also be
system related alarms. assigned high priority.
Alarms which are grouped under SYSTEM As per HAZOP study report, Alarms listed
should be classified as “SYSTEM”. as safeguards measures or recommenda-
Other alarms which are grouped under tion shall be assigned with priority as de-
different names as per the alarm groups fined by the severity consequence matrix.
guidelines as specified above are to be
classified as “CRITICAL”, “HIGH”, 4.0 REFERENCES
“MEDIUM” and “LOW”. ANSI/ISA-18.2.2016 Management of Alarm
Priority distribution of the process related Systems for the process industries
alarms class shall be: CRITICAL: 5%,
HIGH: 15%, MEDIUM: 30% and LOW: EEMUA PUBLICATIOn No.191 Edition 2
50%. (Determination of priority percentage Alarm Systems A Guide to Design, Manage-
is a case dependent activity with respect to ment and Procurement
the respective process industry/plant. Gen-
eral percentage which works and practical- ABOUT THE AUTHOR
ly possible to implement were suggested
here).
Alarms which are critical to process safety
of the protection of human life or personnel
safety protection by default are to be con-
sidered for “CRITICAL” priority class.
Alarms for commercial loss or product
quality shall be considered for “CRITICAL” Praveen Nagenderan C is a Chemical Engi-
priority class. neer with experience in the field of Oil & Gas
Instrument tags which are configured with production & processing facilities and Refin-
alarms having direct relation to the total ery process units. Professional experience
plant trip or a section trip shall be consid- covers in Production operations, Facility sur-
ered for “CRITICAL” priority class. veillance, Technical safety, Technical Ser-
Instrument tags which are configured with vices - Process, and Projects. Praveen has
alarms which affects the section of the worked with major Oil & Gas companies in
plant but provides relative response time India namely Nayara Energy formerly known
to the operator or which doesn’t trigger as Essar Oil Limited and Cairn Oil & Gas.
total plant shut down immediately shall be
considered for “HIGH” priority class.
Equipment stop related alarms shall be
considered for “HIGH” class based on the
criticality of the equipment with respect to
the process conditions whereas equipment
start related alarms shall be considered for
“LOW” class based on the criticality of the
equipment with respect to the process
conditions.
Alarm priority class for Shutdown valves or
solenoid valve status alarms to be decided
based on the criticality of the process con-
ditions. Shutdown vales or solenoid valve
status feedback CLOSE/OPEN alarms
31
REFERENCES
ANSI/ISA 18.2 Management of alarm systems
for the process industries
AUTHOR
applicable for the only process-related alarm Chattering Alarms (Daily Analysis)
and its defined classes. Other categories are
Details of System alarms (Daily Analysis)
excluded from the analysis.
7.) Number of Alarm occurrences for a partic- Alarms setpoint changes
ular group of systems: Alarm group changes
Each alarm configured in the system is to be Alarms priority changes
provided with a group name. The number of
alarm occurrences for a particular group of Details of Alarm rationalization taken up
systems to be identified from the daily list of Review meetings outcome
annunciated alarm lists.
Progress against the resolution of an iden-
8.) Number of Chattering and Fleeting Alarms: tified nuisance alarm list
Chattering alarm repeatedly transitions be- Action plans to improve performance com-
tween the active state and the not active state pared to KPIs and progress of those
in a short period. Fleeting alarms are similar plans
short-duration alarms that do not immediately
repeat. In both cases, the transition is not due AUTHOR
to the result of operator action. A chattering
alarm can generate hundreds or thousands of
records in a few hours. This results in a signif-
icant distraction for the operators. Chattering
alarms are often high in the listing of the most
frequent alarms. Target performance ac-
ceptance criteria are there is a no-term ac- Praveen Nagenderan C is a Chemical Engi-
ceptable quantity of chattering or fleeting neer with experience in the field of Oil & Gas
alarms. production & processing facilities and Refinery
process units. Professional experience covers
PERFORMANCE REPORT
Production operations, Facility surveillance,
Generation of performance reports provides Technical safety, Technical Services - Pro-
an accurate picture of the alarm system per- cess, and Projects. Praveen has worked with
formance. The facility shall generate alarm major Oil & Gas companies in India namely
system performance report monthly apart Nayara Energy formerly known as Essar Oil
from the bi-weekly review meetings on the Limited and Cairn Oil & Gas.
alarm system. Monthly alarm system perfor-
mance report to be generated by System/
Instrument Engineer.
An alarm system performance report
should include the below-mentioned items:
Alarm rates (Daily analysis)
Peak Alarm Rate (Daily analysis)
Percentage of time when the alarm sys-
tem is in flood condition (Daily analysis)
Frequently occurring alarms (Daily Analy-
sis)
Annunciated Alarm priority distribution
percentage (Daily Analysis)
Alarms Suppressed by the operator (Daily
Analysis)
List of shelved alarms with duration (Daily
Analysis)
List of out-of-service alarms with duration
(Daily Analysis)
Stale Alarms (Daily Analysis)
41
Engineer. AUTHOR
Any alarm to be removed from the system
shall go through the rationalization pro-
cess, and rationale for removal to be men-
tioned in the request form by the Produc-
tion operations team for removal from the
system by System/Instrument Engineer.
System/Instrument Engineer to update
Praveen Nagenderan C is a Chemical Engi-
master alarm database summary list upon
neer with experience in the field of Oil & Gas
any inclusion or modification, including new
production & processing facilities and Refin-
alarm point addition in the system or re-
ery process units. Professional experience
moval from the system or any setpoint
covers Production operations, Facility surveil-
changes.
lance, Technical safety, Technical Services -
Process, and Projects. Praveen has worked
TRAINING CONTENT
with major Oil & Gas companies in India,
Training shall be conducted for all direct and
namely Nayara Energy, formerly known as
indirect user department personnel to familiar-
Essar Oil Limited and Cairn Oil & Gas.
ize the facilities alarm system functions and
management. Every person working in the di-
rect and indirect user departments shall under-
go training every year. Training content is as
mentioned below:
Familiarization of Alarm management phi-
losophy
Alarm Rationalization
Alarm Master Database document
Details about Key Performance Indicators
of Alarm system
Alarm system performance monitoring
methods and reporting
Change process for Alarm set point
Use, designation, and distinction of Alarm
Priority
Change process and request process for
addition/removal of alarm or changes in
alarm attributes
Features of the control system’s alarm
presentation, annunciation, and manage-
ment
Permissible and Non-permissible changes
to the alarm system by operations person-
nel’s
Usage of Advanced Alarm handling strate-
gies
Procedures regarding handling and report-
ing of nuisance alarms
Methods for silencing and acknowledging
an alarm
Usage of alarm HMI features
Methods for alarm shelving and suppres-
sion
Methods for removing alarm from service
REFERENCES
ANSI/ISA-18.2.2016 Management of Alarm
Systems for the process industries
EEMUA PUBLICATIOn No.191 Edition 2
Alarm Systems A Guide to Design, Man-
agement and Procurement