Francisco Pascasio Moreno

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 4

Monteregio Moreno

OTHER SOURCES
MORENO, FRANCISCO PASCASIO
Cignoli, Roberto. “La obra matemática de António Monteiro.” (b. Buenos Aires, Argentina, 31 May 1852; d. Buenos
In II Encontro Luso-Brasileiro de Historia da Matemática, Aires, 22 November 1919), anthropology, geology, paleon-
edited by Sergio Nobre. São Paulo, Brazil, 1997. A clear
tology, geography.
account of Monteiro’s mathematical work.
Moreno, who can be considered one of the first
Gomes, Alfredo Pereira. “O regreso de António Monteiro a
anthropologists of Argentina, worked intensively to col-
Portugal de 1977 a 1979.” Portugaliae Mathematica 39
(1985): 33–41. Special issue in honor of António Monteiro.
lect materials in that country and to make them known
through preservation in local museums. Moreno spent
Luís Gomes, Ruy and Luis Neves Real. “António Aniceto
several years in Europe, where he was inspired by major
Monteiro e o C.E.M. do Porto (1941/1944).” Portugaliae
Mathematica 39 (1985): 9–14. Special issue in honor of
natural history museums to promote the building of a
António Monteiro. national establishment of that kind in Argentina. At the
start of the twentieth century he was appointed by the
Monteiro, Luiz. “Profesor Dr. António A. R. Monteiro y su
actividad en la Universidad Nacional del Sur.” In II Encontro
Argentine government to act as an expert (perito) in the
Luso-Brasileiro de Historia da Matemática, edited by Sergio border conflict between Argentina and Chile. His late
Nobre. São Paulo, Brazil, 1997. years were devoted to politics, public education, and the
development of scientific and natural resource policies.
Nachbin, Leopoldo. “The Influence of António A. Ribeiro
Monteiro in the Development of Mathematics in Brazil.”
Portugaliae Mathematica 39 (1985): 15–17. Special issue in Social Context. Francisco P. Moreno was born in Buenos
honor of António Monteiro. Aires, where he attended primary school. His English-
Ortiz, Eduardo L. “Professor Antonio Monteiro and Creole family—the Moreno Thwaites—were active in
Contemporary Mathematics in Argentina.” Portugaliae Buenos Aires commercial, financial, and insurance circles,
Mathematica 39 (1985): 19–32. Special issue in honor of as well as local politics. His father, Francisco Moreno
António Monteiro. (1819–1888), was one of the founding members of the
———. “Transferencias de Matemática Pura y Física Teórica de influential Club del Progreso, secretary of the Buenos
Portugal a Argentina en 1943–58: Beck, Monteiro y Ruy Aires Commerce Stock Market, director of the Buenos
Gomes.” In Um dia com o Centro de Estudos Matemáticos do Aires Province Bank, member of the Argentine parliament
Porto, edited by Maria do Céu Silva, et al. Porto, Portugal: (1854), and a member of the board of Argentine railroads.
Centro de Matemática da Universidade do Porto, 2001. Francisco Pascasio and his brother did not attend univer-
———. “António A. Monteiro and the Practice of sity; rather they worked in the family’s insurance compa-
Mathematics.” In The Practice of Mathematics in Portugal, nies. The family also possessed sheep ranches in Buenos
edited by Luís Saraiva and Henrique Leitão. Coimbra, Aires, where the Moreno sons started their first natural
Portugal: Por ordem da Universidade, 2004. Monteiro’s ideas history and archaeology collections, later stored in their
on mathematics research and education. private residence. Francisco Pascasio pursued this activity
Ribeiro, Hugo. “Actuação de António Aniceto Monteiro em in his adult years. Moreno’s scientific self-education relied
Lisboa entre 1939 e 1942.” Portugaliae Mathematica 39 on handbooks for amateur scientific travelers, such as
(1985): 5–7. Special issue in honor of António Monteiro. David Kaltbrunner’s Manuel du Voyageur published in
Silva da Silva, Circe Mary. “António Aniceto Ribeiro Zürich in 1879. Thanks to his family connections—
(1907–1980) no Brasil.” In II Encontro Luso-Brasileiro de especially the friendship of his father with the minister of
Historia da Matemática, edited by Sergio Nobre. São Paulo, government of the Province of Buenos Aires—he became
Brazil, 1997. part of Argentine learned societies and political networks,
Sousa Amaral, Elza Maria Alves de. “António A. R. Monteiro— where he negotiated state support for his scientific endeav-
Um matemático Portugués no Brasil.” In II Encontro Luso- ors (Quesada, 1924–1925). He received an honorary doc-
Brasileiro de Historia da Matemática, edited by Sergio Nobre. torate from the University of Córdoba in 1877 and the
São Paulo, Brazil: 1997. Royal Geographical Society Founder’s Medal in 1907 for
extensive explorations in the Patagonian Andes.
Eduardo L. Ortiz
Anthropological Collections. The interest of young
Moreno in amassing collections of natural history and
archaeology drew the attention of prominent members of
MONTEREGIO, Buenos Aires political and intellectual circles. Becoming a
member of the Sociedad Científica Argentina (Argen-
JOANNES DE tinean Scientific Society), established in 1872, he acted as
SEE Regiomontanus, Johannes. director of the society’s museum (1875). Moreno was an

180 N E W D I C T I O N A RY O F S C I E N T I F I C B I O G R A P H Y
Moreno Moreno

extensive traveler: subsidized by his father and Sociedad time, were perceived to be in the process of “extinction.”
Científica, in the years 1873–1877 he explored the valleys In the late 1870s and the 1880s several campaigns against
of Patagonia and the Argentinian Northwest, where he native peoples from Patagonia and Chaco were carried out
continued to collect natural history and archaeological as governmental or private initiatives to erase “savagery”
objects, recording the natural resources of the regions. He from lands to be included in the market economy. Either
pioneered in Argentina the use of both anthropometric to preserve information about “vanishing races” or to
instruments created by French anthropologists and Paul record the changes experienced by native peoples in the
Broca’s instructions for the collection of calibrated anthro- process of becoming “civilized,” expeditions were dis-
pometric data. patched to the localities where that process was taking
In 1877 he presented his collections to the Province place. As a result, the Museo de La Plata repositories con-
of Buenos Aires for the purpose of establishing an archae- tinue to represent, in the early twenty-first century, one of
ological and anthropological museum and to be the sources for researching the preindustrial period of
appointed as its perpetual director. The museum was native peoples inhabiting present-day Argentina and the
inaugurated in August 1878. In the years that followed, Southern Cone (Sheets-Pyenson, 1988; Lopes and Pod-
Moreno’s rhetoric, little by little, became plagued by argu- gorny, 2000). This position was not always assured:
ments that tied science to fatherland, and exploration administrators of the budget of the Province of Buenos
traveling to the country’s rights over Patagonian territo- Aires were not always sympathetic to Moreno’s require-
ries. In 1879 he was appointed by the national govern- ments, and he had to redefine the mission of the Museo
ment to lead the Southern Territories’ Exploring de La Plata several times in order to justify its continuing
Commission, sent to the rivers Negro and Deseado, in the existence.
Patagonian plateau. Instead, he left the expedition to
explore the Patagonian Andes, where he was taken pris- Geological and Geographical Expeditions. During his
oner by the Manzaneros’ chief Shaihueque. expeditions of the late 1870s in the Southern Andes,
The national government considered Moreno a Moreno explored Lake Nahuel Huapí and Río Santa
deserter of a public mission. For that reason the minister Cruz. In doing so he named several lakes, such as the Lake
of government suggested he leave Argentina to acquire San Martín.
real scientific education at the École d’Anthropologie in A concern with the question of the distribution and
Paris, in order to become a professional scientist and to origin of mammals as posed by Florentino Ameghino
skip the dangers of enthusiasm and self education, ele- (1854?–1911) in the late 1880s had been responsible for
ments that Moreno celebrated as the core of his scientific shifting the interest of the museum’s expeditions toward
endeavors. In Paris he acted as an Argentine correspon- Patagonia vertebrate paleontology. Naturalist travelers
dent in the frame of the extensive international network were dispatched to Chubut, Santa Cruz, Tierra del Fuego,
articulated by Broca’s successor Paul Topinard for com- and Isla de los Estados to collect fossil mammalians, rep-
pleting the collection of skeletons and crania of the École tiles, and birds. These collections represent an outstanding
d’Anthropologie. In the late 1870s he contributed in pro- contribution to the knowledge of a previously unknown
viding evidence to the idea sustained in Paris that in the fossil fauna. Museo de La Plata employees also surveyed
Americas, as in Europe, the native race was characterized different regions of the country and published geologic
by dolichocephalism, the brachycephalic race having profiles of the Argentine Andes. The research expeditions
arrived lately from the West. also revealed a great number of lower forms of vertebrates,
including numerous marsupialia, some of which—accord-
La Plata Museum. Returning to Argentina in 1881, ing to Moreno—were closely related to the mammals of
Moreno lobbied for the formation of a monumental the Pleistocene fauna of Australia.
national museum in Buenos Aires, which by different cir- When Moreno was appointed in 1896 as geographi-
cumstances was established as a provincial institution in cal perito (expert) in the border conflict with Chile, fol-
the city of La Plata, a short distance from Buenos Aires. lowing the policy settled in the Treaty of 1881, he
The Museo de La Plata, Argentina, established in 1884, explored the Andean regions with a team of geologists.
was the first in South America to have a building espe- Maps, photographs, plans, and geologic profiles comple-
cially designed for the requirement of a museum. Devoted mented a complete geographical and physiographic
to the study of “American man” and evolution in South description of Patagonia that resulted from the expedition
America, the museum envisioned a continental scope; to under Moreno’s leadership. One of Moreno’s most impor-
achieve its goals Moreno employed different strategies to tant accomplishments was the observation of the fact that
collect objects that encompassed geology, zoology, paleon- in the Patagonian Cordillera the interocean divortium
tology, botanic, archaeology, and societies that, at the aquarum in many places does not overlap with the

N E W D I C T I O N A RY O F S C I E N T I F I C B I O G R A P H Y 181
Moreno Moreno

highest peaks of the Andes. Moreno also recognized two travels continues to be very popular even in the early
glacial events in Patagonia (Camacho, 2000). During twenty-first century. Instead of a reliable source for the
those years, he also propagated the idea of the ancient historian of science they constitute a corpus that still
connection between the new uplifted lands of the south- requires further study to enable a full understanding of the
ern part of the American continent and the other lands of history of ideology in Argentina.
the Southern Hemisphere—Africa and Australia (Cama-
cho, 2000; Moreno, 1899). In 1899 Moreno proposed in BIBLIOGRAPHY
London that experienced geologists from the Royal Geo-
WORKS BY MORENO
graphical Society, the Royal Society, and the British
Museum, with other scientific institutions, should carry “Cementerios y paraderos prehistóricos de la Patagonia.” Anales
científicos argentinos 1 (1874): 2–13.
out the systematic examination of the Argentine country
in order to investigate south American fossiliferous strata “Sur des restes d’industrie humaine préhistorique dans la
République Argentine.” Compte-rendu du Congrès
(Moreno, 1899).
international d’anthropologie et d’archéologie préhistoriques.
Stockholm: Norstedt & Söner, 1876.
Scientific and Educational Policies. In 1906 Moreno El estudio del hombre Sud-Americano. Buenos Aires: La Nación,
resigned the directorship of the Museo de La Plata. He 1878.
was elected national deputy for 1910–1913. In this capac- Viaje a la Patagonia Austral, 1876–1877. Buenos Aires: La
ity he proposed several projects, such as the construction Nación, 1879.
of railroads in Patagonia (1910); the acquisition of “Voyages en Patagonie.” Bulletin de la Société de Géographie de
Ameghino’s collections and library for the national l’Est 2 (1880): 534–571.
museum (1911); the creation of a national scientific serv- “Antropología y arqueología. Importancia del estudio de estas
ice (for topographic, hydrographical, geologic, and bio- ciencias en la República Argentina.” Anales de la Sociedad
logical surveys, 1912); and the establishment of national Científica Argentina 12 (1881): 160–173, 193–207.
parks (1912) (Ludueña, 1995). Moreno cooperated in the “Patagonia. Resto de un antiguo continente hoy sumergido.
organization of the Congreso Científico Internacional Contribuciones al estudio de las colecciones del Museo
Americano (Buenos Aires, 1910). He acted as vice presi- Antropológico y Arqueológico de Buenos Aires. Conferencia
dent of National Council for Education, devoting much del 15 de Julio de 1882.” Anales de la Sociedad Científica
work to the protection of working-class children, and to Argentina 14 (1882): 97–137.
the dismantling of the National Museum of Pedagogy, “El Museo de La Plata, rápida ojeada sobre su fundación y
which was led by socialist teachers. Moreno was also active desarrollo.” Revista del Museo de La Plata 1 (1890): 1–30.
in the introduction to Argentina of the Boy Scouts move- Esploración arqueológica de la Provincia de Catamarca: Primeros
datos sobre su importancia y resultados. La Plata, Argentina:
ment in 1911. Most of Moreno’s articles were published
Tall. del Museo, 1891.
in the Revista and Anales of the Museo de La Plata, publi-
“Notas sobre algunas especies de un género aberrante de los
cations he established in 1890.
Dasypoda (Eoceno de la Patagonia) conservadas en el Museo
de La Plata.” Revista del Museo de La Plata 2 (1891): 57–63.
Public Dimension of Moreno. Moreno died in Buenos With Alcide Mercerat. “Catálogo de los Pájaros Fósiles de la
Aires in November 1919, in a country divided by the so- República Argentina conservados en el. Museo de La Plata.”
called social issue (cuestión social ) that generated the most Anales del Museo de La Plata 1 (1891): 7–71.
diverse reactions among the Argentine upper class, such as “Reconocimiento de la región andina de la República Argentina.
the creation in January 1919 of Liga Patriótica, a perma- Apuntes preliminares sobre una excursión a los territorios del
nent citywide militia that upheld “fatherland and order.” Neuquén, Río Negro, Chubut y Santa Cruz hecha por las
Moreno’s funeral was a public event attended by the pres- secciones Topográfica y geológica bajo a dirección de F. P.
ident of the Liga Patriótica, who turned Moreno into a Moreno, director del Museo.” Revista del Museo de La Plata 8
hero of the Argentine Right movements. (1898): 99–372.
“Note on the Discovery of Miolania and of Glossotherium
This adoption of Moreno by the Argentine Right was
(Neomylodon) in Patagonia.” Nature 1556, no. 60 (1899):
fulfilled in the 1930s and 1940s. Since then, Moreno has 395–398.
been presented to the public as the sentry of Patagonia.
In this frame, those elements that during Moreno’s life OTHER SOURCES
were criticized by his contemporaries—enthusiasm, self- Bertomeu, Carlos A. El perito Moreno, centinela de la Patagonia:
education, and amateurism—became the key elements for Estudio biográfico. Buenos Aires: El Ateneo, 1949.
Moreno’s future biographers, such as Aquiles Ygobone Camacho, Horacio. “Francisco P. Moreno y su contribución al
(1953) and Carlos A. Bertomeu (1949). This kind of conocimiento geológico de la Patagonia.” Saber y Tiempo 9
biography that emphasized the patriotic value of Moreno’s (2000): 5–32.

182 N E W D I C T I O N A RY O F S C I E N T I F I C B I O G R A P H Y
Morgan Morgan

“Embodied Institutions. La Plata Museum as Francisco P. in genetics, but also the study of heredity as a logical and
Moreno’s Autobiography.” 34th Cimuset Conference in consistent part of a more complex Morgan excited about
Brazil, Río de Janeiro, 2006. Río de Janeiro: Mast, 2007. natural history and organisms generally. Allen introduced
Hosne, Roberto. Francisco Moreno: Una herencia patagónica Morgan’s most important students, but the emphasis
desperdiciada. Buenos Aires: Emecé, 2005. remained on Morgan and his ideas and methods. The
Lopes, Maria Margaret, and Irina Podgorny. “The Shaping of picture was consistent with that presented in formal obit-
Latin American Museums of Natural History.” Osiris 15
uaries and earlier biographical sketches, though Allen was
(2000): 108–118. An accessible overview of the history of the
Museo de La Plata.
much more aware of the larger context in which Morgan
worked than most previous authors.
Ludueña, Felipe. Labor parlamentaria del Perito Doctor Francisco
P. Moreno. Buenos Aires: Secretaría Parlamentaria. 1995. In his much longer biography of Morgan published
Luna, Félix. Francisco P. Moreno. Buenos Aires: Planeta, 2001. two years later, Allen developed this picture further and
Moreno, Eduardo V. Reminiscencias de Francisco P. Moreno. added some additional themes that he pursued in other
Versión propia. 2nd ed. Buenos Aires: Editorial Universitaria work in more detail. Chapter 3 of Thomas Hunt Morgan:
de Buenos Aires, 1979. The Man and His Science (1978) laid out the idea of a
———. Perito Moreno’s Travel Journal: A Personal Reminiscence. “revolt from morphology” that had formed a foundation
Buenos Aires: El Elefante Blanco, 2002. for his textbook, Life Science in the Twentieth Century.
Moreno Terrero de Benites, Adela. Recuerdos de mi abuelo Thus, Morgan became the exemplar for a broad interpre-
Francisco Pascasio Moreno: “El perito Moreno.” Buenos Aires: tation of trends in the history of biology.
s.n., Tall. Gráf. La Tradición, 1988.
Podgorny, Irina. “Bones and Devices in the Constitution of Work at Bryn Mawr. Importantly, the years that Allen
Paleontology in Argentina at the End of the Nineteenth characterized in terms of the “revolt” and that he tied to
Century.” Science in Context 18, no. 2 (2005): 249–283. The Morgan’s endorsement of the experimental embryological
most accessible discussion in English.
program of “Entwicklungsmechanik” were also the years
———. “La derrota del genio. Cráneos y cerebros en la filogenia
that Morgan was on the faculty at Bryn Mawr College.
argentina.” Saber y Tiempo 5, no. 20 (2006): 63–106.
Allen acknowledged the significance of this appointment
Quesada, Ernesto. “Doctor Francisco P. Moreno: 1852–1919.
at a leading women’s college in a couple of pages, but later
Fundador y primer director del Museo: Homenaje a su
memoria en representación del Instituto Histórico y scholarship by Margaret Rossiter and Helen Lefkowitz
Geográfico del Brasil.” Revista del Museo de La Plata 28 Horowitz has carried exploration of the role of women in
(1924–1925): 9–16. The most reliable biographical note on science, and the role of Bryn Mawr and Martha Carey
F. P. Moreno. Thomas in particular, much further.
Sheets-Pyenson, Susan. Cathedrals of Science: The Development of The fact that Morgan and fellow leading biologists
Colonial Natural History Museums during the Late Nineteenth Edmund Beecher Wilson and Jacques Loeb each began his
Century. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press, 1988. A career at Bryn Mawr in the last two decades of the nine-
good overview for the general reader.
teenth century deserves more attention. Despite the lim-
Ygobone, Aquiles. Francisco P. Moreno. Arquetipo de argentinidad.
ited archival materials in the scientists’ collections
Contribución al estudio e investigación histórica, geográfica,
económica y social del País. Buenos Aires: Orientación
concerning this early period, there may well be instructive
Cultural, 1953. materials available at Bryn Mawr or in collections of out-
standing students there. Researchers have little under-
standing of what Morgan, Wilson, and Loeb gained from
Irina Podgorny Bryn Mawr, though it is clear that Morgan gained a wife.
Lilian Vaughan Sampson Morgan became Morgan’s collab-
orator on many projects, and a researcher in her own right.
It is known what scholarly work Morgan carried out
MORGAN, THOMAS HUNT (b. Lexing- at Bryn Mawr, but there is little about his teaching or
ton, Kentucky, 25 September 1866; d. Pasadena, Califor- interactions with students in his lab. One can hope for
nia, 4 December 1945), embryology, genetics. For the future insight along these lines to illuminate the way sci-
original article on Morgan see DSB, vol. 9. ence was carried out in that time and place and to learn
The original DSB article presented Thomas Hunt more about what the growing study of women in science
Morgan as a specialist in embryology and genetics. Gar- reveals about scientific careers more generally. Because the
land E. Allen painted Morgan as a man “known to his building of a collaborative team became a central feature
friends, colleagues, and students as a man of quick mind, of Morgan’s research approach, and because Morgan did
incisive judgment, and sparkling humor” (p. 515). The work with such outstanding young women as Nettie
reader sees a Morgan who won a Nobel Prize for his work Maria Stevens during his Bryn Mawr days, one can only

N E W D I C T I O N A RY O F S C I E N T I F I C B I O G R A P H Y 183

You might also like