Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Analytic Synthesis of Hysteresis Motor
Analytic Synthesis of Hysteresis Motor
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: http://www.researchgate.net/publication/245160157
READS
283
3 AUTHORS:
SEE PROFILE
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: This paper presents the unique synthesis of a motor with a hysteresis torque–speed characteristic. The
Received 20 November 2009 machine is synthesized from a conventional polyphase squirrel cage induction motor (SCIM) with a high
Accepted 8 July 2010 rotor resistance to leakage reactance r2/x2 ratio, which is mechanically coupled to a polyphase transfer
Available online 2 August 2010
field (TF) machine but with an inversion of the usual torque–speed characteristic of the latter about
the speed axis and both machines are connected in parallel to the supply. It is shown that the resultant
Keywords: torque of the combined machines is constant, from standstill to full speed x0, typical of that of a hyster-
High rotor resistance to leakage reactance
esis motor. Unlike the conventional hysteresis motor, the output torque of the synthesized version can be
r2/x2 ratio
Inverted torque–speed characteristics
made large.
Mechanically coupled machines Ó 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Transfer field (TF) machine
1. Introduction no slip rings, no brushes and no dc field winding, low cost and
practically maintenance free operation.
The induction motor is the most common of all ac motors and The hysteresis motor, like the reluctance motor does not have a
has been variously described as the ‘‘work-horse” of industry. In dc excitation and rotor windings. Unlike the reluctance motor,
its normal working range, the speed of the induction motor re- however, the hysteresis motor does not have a salient rotor. The
mains reasonably constant, varying only slightly with load. For this rotor of a hysteresis motor has a ring of special magnetic material,
reason, it is regarded for all intents and purposes as a constant such as chrome hard steel or cobalt, mounted on a cylinder of alu-
speed motor. The major shortcoming of the induction motor is minum or some other non-magnetic material having high retentiv-
the relative low power factor which is always lagging. ity, so that the hysteresis loss is high. The rotor of the ideal
Synchronous machines on the other hand are constant speed machine is assumed to have zero conductivity and so no torque
machines with controllable power factor, which can be made lead- is produced as a result of induced currents in the rotor circuit.
ing. However, they are more expensive to produce due to slip rings The motor torque therefore would be entirely due to hysteresis
and brushes compared to squirrel cage induction motors. The ma- effects.
jor demerit of synchronous machines is the problem of synchroni- The stator field and the induced rotor field are present at all
zation. The polyphase reluctance motor on the other hand operates speeds from zero up to synchronous speed where the rotor is no
at a fixed speed, synchronous speed of the rotating magnetic field. longer subject to alternating magnetization. The torque is constant
The major differences between the reluctance and synchronous throughout and the motor is therefore self-starting. The hysteresis
machines are the absence of rotating windings and dc excitation motor is the smoothest and the quietest running ac machine be-
in the rotors of reluctance machines. The major disadvantage of cause of the smooth rotor periphery and freedom from mechanical
the reluctance machine apart from the relatively low power factor and magnetic vibrations. These characteristics have endeared it to
due to excessive reactive magnetizing current is the synchronizing such applications as in quality sound reproduction equipment, re-
problems. The pull-in torque is generally less than half of the pull- cord player motors, electric clocks and other timing devices. In
out torque. A reluctance motor is therefore several times larger contrast with a reluctance motor, which must ‘‘snap” its load into
than a synchronous motor with dc excitation having the same synchronism from an induction motor torque–speed characteristic,
horse power and speed ratings. However, in some applications a hysteresis motor can synchronize any load which it can acceler-
these disadvantages may be off set by its simplicity of construction, ate, no matter how great the inertia and no other electrical ma-
chine possesses this unique feature. The major limitation of the
hysteresis motor is its specific low output power which has nar-
rowed its applications to low power devices. The output power is
* Corresponding author. Tel.: +234 803 053 7642.
E-mail addresses: luanih@yahoo.com (L.U. Anih), obeunn@yahoo.com (E.S. Obe), about one-quarter of an induction motor of the same dimensions.
okennagbachi@yahoo.com (E.O. Agbachi). Hysteresis motors are generally available as fractional horse power
0196-8904/$ - see front matter Ó 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.enconman.2010.07.014
Author's personal copy
392 L.U. Anih et al. / Energy Conversion and Management 52 (2011) 391–396
motors and most of the studies on the machine were skewed to- thus prevented from interfering with the supply [7]. Furthermore,
wards production of the machine by exploiting hysteresis loss there is a complete electrical separation of the winding carrying
phenomena of magnetic materials [1–3]. In this paper, an entirely the mains supply current of x0 frequency from that which carries
different approach is adopted towards producing a hysteresis mo- the low frequency current of (x0 2x). However, the two wind-
tor with good output power by synthesis from ac machines with ings are magnetically coupled. Additionally, the auxiliary winding
well known output power characteristics. Agu [4] has suggested terminals are accessible for control purposes. An alternative con-
that the synthesis of a hysteresis motor from two induction motors figuration of the TF machine can be obtained by holding one-half
could be possible if one of the motors could be made to operate of the machine stator and rotor while the other half stator and ro-
with inverted torque–speed characteristics. This paper is an exten- tor is rotated until the pole-axis of the two halves are in alignment;
sion of the work done in Ref. [4] and presents a simple method of and the axes of the main windings are out of phase by 90° electrical
deriving negative torque in the low-speed region 0 6 x < x0/2 and degrees and the alignment of the axes of the auxiliary windings in
positive torque in the high speed region x0/2 < x 6 x0 from a reduced from 180° to 90° electrical degrees [10].
transfer field (TF) machine so that the combination of its torque–
speed characteristic with that of a squirrel cage induction motor 2.1. Principle of operation of the TF machine
(SCIM) with high rotor resistance to leakage reactance ratio will re-
sult in a hysteresis motor torque–speed characteristic. The main winding is connected to the source and draws a cur-
rent I0 at frequency x0 which produces an mmf whose distribution
is expressed as
2. Transfer field (TF) machine
m0 ¼ M 0 cosðh x0 tÞ ð1Þ
The stable operation of a polyphase induction motor at one-half The air–gap permeance distribution in the two halves of the
normal speed by means of unbalanced impedance in the rotor cir- machine may be expressed respectively as
cuit is well known as Gorges phenomenon [5]. The half-speed
operation did not receive industrial acceptance because of the PA ¼ P0 þ PV cos 2ðh xtÞ ð2Þ
associated vibration and noise due to injection of low frequency
and
current of (x0 2x) into the supply system. Broadway and Tan
[6] improved the industrial acceptance by mechanically coupling p
PB ¼ P0 þ PV cos 2 h xt ¼ P 0 PV cos 2ðh xtÞ ð3Þ
two identical machine elements together and connecting their 2
windings in parallel to the supply and thus creating a local loop be- where x is the rotor speed.
tween the machine windings for the circulation of the low fre- The corresponding flux distribution in the air–gap of the respec-
quency currents of (x0 2x) and thus diverted from the supply. tive halves of the TF machine due to the mmf m0 is obtained from
Agu [7] evolved a configuration of a composite two-element reluc- the product of Eq. (1) and Eq. (2) or Eq. (3). If space harmonics are
tance effect machine known as the transfer field (TF) machine. Un- neglected, the flux distribution are given by
like [6], there are no windings in the rotor, including damper
M0 PV
windings. Instead, there are two windings on each unit stator com- BA ¼ M 0 P0 cosðh x0 tÞ þ cosðh þ ðx0 2xÞtÞ
prising the TF machine, known as the main and auxiliary windings. 2
The main windings are connected in series while the auxiliary ¼ B01 cosðh x0 tÞ þ B02 cosðh þ ðx0 2xÞtÞ ð4Þ
windings are transposed (anti-series) in passing from one unit ma-
and
chine to the other. Like [6], the rotors of the two machine elements
are salient in configuration and in space quadrature as shown in M0 PV
BB ¼ M 0 P0 cosðh x0 tÞ cosðh þ ðx0 2xÞtÞ
Fig. 1. Cathey and Nasar [8] studied the steady-state equivalent cir- 2
cuit of the TF machine for asynchronous operation while Anih and ¼ B01 cosðh x0 tÞ B02 cosðh þ ðx0 2xÞtÞ ð5Þ
Obe [9] studied the dynamic performance of the TF machine.
In the TF machine arrangement, the low frequency current of From Eqs. (4) and (5) above, the average net flux linking the
(x0 2x) is confined to circulate in the auxiliary windings and main windings is obtained by their summation and is given by
Bm ¼ B01 cosðh x0 tÞ ð6Þ
L.U. Anih et al. / Energy Conversion and Management 52 (2011) 391–396 393
The circulation of current in the auxiliary winding will cause the 3. Review of current loci of asynchronous motors
main winding to draw an additional current I1 from the source
which will balance the auxiliary winding current reflected in the The rotor circuit voltage equation of an induction motor in pha-
main winding, in a manner similar to what is obtained in a trans- sor form can be written from its equivalent circuit of Fig. 3 as:
former and induction motors. An equilibrium condition is attained r
2
when the emf induced in the auxiliary winding by the flux due to I1 E2 ¼ I2 þ jx2 ð10Þ
s
balances the self-induced emf due to I2 in the auxiliary windings.
The torque of the machine is due to the interaction between the From (10), the per-phase rotor current at any slip s is given by:
main and auxiliary winding mmfs in the respective halves of the E2
machine. If the auxiliary winding mmf supports the main winding I2 ¼ qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
r 2 ð11Þ
2
mmf in one-half of the TF machine say, it will oppose it in the other 2
s
þ x2 \arctanðu2 Þ
half due to the transposition of the auxiliary winding. When the
torque is maximum in one-half, it is zero in the other half and where
the load torque swings cyclically from one machine half to the sx2
other while the net torque remains constant. The roles of the main
u2 ¼ ð12Þ
r2
and auxiliary windings can be interchanged and will produce the
same result. and the rotor current lags the rotor voltage E2 by u2
The power input to the rotor is given by:
jx2
I2
E2 r2/s
Fig. 2. The torque–speed characteristics of the TF machine showing the effect of the
leading pf and high (r2/x2) ratio. Fig. 3. Rotor equivalent circuit of an induction motor.
Author's personal copy
394 L.U. Anih et al. / Energy Conversion and Management 52 (2011) 391–396
E2 E2
I2 I2
jI 2 r 2
r -
ϕ2 E - jI 2 2
j 2- sx 2
ϕ2 E
(2s - 1)x 2
j 2-
x2 A x2 A
0 0
r
jI 2 2 jI 2 r2
sx 2 (2s - 1)x 2
I2 I2
Fig. 4. Current locus for inductive rotor circuit of induction machine. Fig. 7. Current locus of inductive auxiliary winding of a TF machine.
r
Suppose capacitance is injected into the rotor circuit through 2
E2 ¼ I2 þ jx2 ð17aÞ
the slip rings and of magnitude twice that of the leakage reactance 2s 1
x2 say, the overall reactance of the rotor circuit becomes jx2 even
or
though s is positive. Eq. (16a) will now be modified to:
E2 I2 r 2
j ¼ I2 j ð17bÞ
x2 ð2s 1Þx2
jE2 r2
¼ I2 þ jI2 ð16cÞ r2
x2 sx2 From the preceding discussion, the locus of I2 as ð2s1Þx 2
varies
from 0 to 1, that is, as s varies from 0 to 1/2 is a semi-circle above
From Eq. (16c), the locus of I2 as s varies from 0 to 1 is as shown r2
OA co-ordinate as shown in Fig. 7. If ð2s1Þx takes negative values,
in Fig. 5. 2
supersynchronous speed of the rotor (x > 1/2x0), that is s < 1/2,
It can be seen from Fig. 5 that the rotor current I2 leads the ap-
the phasor I2 will trace out a semi-circle below the OA co-ordinate
plied voltage E2 by u2 > 90°. Consequently, the leading power fac-
and lags the applied voltage E2 by an angle greater than 90°. The
tor cos u2 is negative, which means that power flows out of the
power factor will become negative and there will be a reversal of
machine from the rotor to the stator resulting in generating oper-
r0 power flow from the auxiliary winding to the main winding, gen-
ation Pg ¼ I22 sx22 . In summary, the generating operation can be
erating operation.
obtained at rotor speeds below synchronous (x < x0) by capacitive r2
Alternatively, ð2s1Þx can be made negative by capacitive injec-
injection into the rotor circuit, such that the overall reactance of 2
tion into the auxiliary winding while s is within the range of motor
the rotor circuit becomes capacitive (i.e. injected capacitive reac-
operation. Suppose a capacitance is injected into the auxiliary
tance xc is greater than the leakage reactance x2).
winding which is twice that of the leakage reactance in magnitude,
Similarly, consider the auxiliary winding circuit of a transfer
the overall reactance of the auxiliary winding will become capaci-
field (TF) machine operating in the asynchronous mode as shown
tive (x2). Eq. (17b) will then be modified to:
in Fig. 6.
The auxiliary winding voltage equation in phasor form can be E2 I2 r 2
written directly from its equivalent circuit of Fig. 6 as: j ¼ I2 þ j ð17cÞ
x2 ð2s 1Þx2
r2
The locus of I2 as ð2s1Þx 2
varies from 0 to 1 will be as shown in
E2 Fig. 8.
E2 The phasor I2 now leads the applied voltage E2 by an angle > 90°
j
x2 ϕ2 0 and consequently, the power factor is negative and therefore there
X will be a reversal of power flow from the auxiliary winding back to
r2 the main winding. Like an induction machine, however, the main
jI 2 I2
sx 2 winding will still be connected to the supply for the purpose of
deriving the magnetizing current.
From the discussions thus far, it follows that generating opera-
tion can be obtained from an induction machine and a TF machine
Fig. 5. Current locus for the capacitive rotor circuit of induction machine. without the rotor necessarily operating above the synchronous
E2
E
j 2
x2
ϕ2 0
X
jI2 r 2 I2
(2s - 1)x 2
Fig. 6. Equivalent circuit of an auxiliary winding of a TF machine. Fig. 8. Current locus of capacitive auxiliary winding of a TF machine.
Author's personal copy
L.U. Anih et al. / Energy Conversion and Management 52 (2011) 391–396 395
Lm2 Lm1
L2 L1 I2
Fig. 9. Per-phase coupled coil representation of the TF machine with injected Fig. 11. The idealized torque–speed characteristics of a hysteresis motor and
capacitance in the auxiliary winding. component torques.
Author's personal copy
396 L.U. Anih et al. / Energy Conversion and Management 52 (2011) 391–396
7. Conclusion