Professional Documents
Culture Documents
5 TinanoffandPalmerJPHD2000
5 TinanoffandPalmerJPHD2000
Send correspondence to Dr. Tinanoff, Department of Pediatric Dentistry, 666 West Baltimore Sheet, Room 3 E 10, Dental School, University of
Maryland, Baltimore, MD 21201. E-mail:nlinanoff@dental.umaryIand.edu. Ms. Palmer is with the Department of General Dentistry, Tufts
University School of Dental Medicine. Manuscript received: 3/1/00; accepted for publication:4/3/00.
198 Journal of Public Health Dentistry
snalacia (vitaminD deficiency) (45). oral cleaning and toothbrushing tech- Systemic fluoride supplements for
Evidence from underdeveloped niques (54). In addition to lack of thosechildrenolder thanage 6 months
countries with poor nutrition shows knowledgeof dental care for their chil- who reside in communities known to
that developmental defects (enamel dren, the eating habits and cravings of be nonfluoridated may be recom-
h,ypoplasia) of the primary teeth are pregnant women may lead to frequent mended (Table 3). Prescribingfluoride
common (46,47).A comprehensivere- snackingon candy or other decay-pro- supplements for infantsyounger than
view found a strong assoCiation be- moting foods,thereby increasing their 6 months of age, or supplementing a
tween enamel hypoplasia and dental risk of caries (55). child without first determining the
caries in developing countries. For in- Pregnant women therefore should fluoridecontent of the drinkingwater,
stance in Map&, an isolated atoll in be instructed on the importance, for is not recommended because of the
the Pacific, developmental defects of them and for their unborn children,of risk of fluorosis. Fluorosis of the teeth
the primary teeth are reported to be a healthy diet during pregnancy. Em- is gmerally not hanxfui,but can pro-
between 51-86 percent, with 5&61 phasis on the Food Guide Pyramid, duce a viswi problem (whitetines) on
percent of these teeth developing den- obtaining the majority of calories from the front teeth. Currently, it isbelieved
tal caries (48). Surprisingly, a high nutrient-rich foods, and consuming that the major c a w s of excessivefluo-
prevalence (14 percent) of enamel hy- suffiaent calaum are essential.Sweets ride intake and subsequent fluorosis
poplasia alsohas been found in inner- and other calorie-dense, low-nutrient are inappropriate use of fluoridated
aty US populations Pouglass J, per- foods should be minimized. supplements and/or unsupervised
sonal communication, 1999). Besides Birth to 1 Year of Age. Nutritional consumption of toothpastes by the
the high prevalence of enamel hy- s the first year of infancy are
~ e e d in child. Parents need to make sure that
poplasia possibly due to poor prenatal met primarily by breast milk and/or onIy a peasized or smaller amount of
nutrition, frequent enamel hypoplas- infant formula, followedby sequential fluoridated toothpaste is used to brush
tic areas and subsequent dental caries introduction of baby foods starting a child's teeth (60). In general, systemic
in primary teeth also are found in chiI- with fortified cereak at approximately fluoride supplementation should not
&en who are born prematurely (49). 6 months of age. Adequatenutrition is be the cornerstone of a caries preven-
children with enamel hypoplasia re- vitally important during thisperiod of tion program because the greatest
portedIy have a 2.5 times greater risk signhcant tooth development. Even benefit of fluoride is considered to be
of developing dental caries than chil- brief occunrencesof malnutrition dur- due to its topical effect, compliance
dren who do not have such defects ing the first year of life may result in with correct dosages of fluorideis low,
(28). enamel hypoplasia and consequently and a prescription is needed to obtain
In addition to the possible effect of increased risk of caries (56). Breast the supplement, p i n g a barrier to
poor prenatal nutrition on increased feeding should be encouraged be- their use.
enamel defects in their offspring, cause of its general health benefits and Children make the transition from
mothers with active caries are more the little likelihood that this means of the exdusive milk diet of infancy to a
likely to transmit cariogenicbacteria to nutrition fosters caries. Evidence atso variety of foocfs inthe first year, so this
thek offspring (50).Conversely, re- suggests supplementinginfants' diets is an important time to exert positive
ducing mutans streptococci in moth- with vitamins because they can reduce influence on eating habits. At around
ers by means of antimicrobial agents the prevalence of enamel hypoplasia the age of 6 months, when infantsstart
(e.g., dtlorhexidine) has been shown (57). the transition from bottle to cup, it is
to reduce both the m a t e d transfer of Breast milk is relatively low influo- important that they not be allowed to
these bacteria and dental caries in the ride (58);however, infantswho receive use a sippy cup for long periods of
offspring(5132). all or some of their feedings from dry time because this behavior will pro-
Fluoride is an important nutrient powder or concentratedinfant formu- mote caries.
that increases the resistance of teeth. las may receive enough fluoride if the Children can be introduced to su-
However, fluoride supplementation local water supply is fluoridated (59). crose-containing food and drinks at
for pregnant women is not recom- around the time of the eruption of the
mended because there is little evi- fxst tooth. while childrenare indined
dence that systemic fluoride (e.g., oral TABLE 3 to like sweet and salty foodsand avoid
fluoridesupplements)provided to the Systemic FIuoride Recommendations sour or bitter foods, repeated experi-
mother during pregnancy reduces car- Based on Fluoride Content of Water ence and parental influence shape
ies prevalencein their offspring (53). and Child's Age their preferences for the majority of
Pregnancy, thus, is a critical time to ~- foods.The predispositions that shape
focus on preventive oral care a p Fluoride Content of food acceptance patterns also include
proaches. However, a survey of expec- Water (ngF) the fear of new foods, and the ten-
tant parents demonstrated that they dency to learn to prefer and accept
were generally uninformed about <0.3 0.3-0.6 >0.6 new foods when they are offered re-
dental practices, despite their high
ievel of concern about the dental
Age PPm --PPm Ppm peatedly. Thus, the caretaker's feeding
practices play a fundamental role in
6mos- 0.25 0 0
health of their offspring. Parents be- the development of the child's choice
lieved oral hygiene practices should 3 F of food types. Infants given sugars
start "early," but they were unsure at Wyrs 0.50 0.25 0 early in life favor products with higher
what age they shodd begin. Further, 6-16yrs 1.00 0.50 0 sugar levels when they are todders
they were not familiar with proper (61,62). In addition, dental caries in
Voi. 60,So. 3, Summer 2000 203
k o m the bottle, mealtimes by reducing between-meal ence for high-calorie foods were fatter
0 discourage a child from carrying snacking. and had higher fat diets than their
and continuously drinking from a bot- 2-5 Years of Age. At these ages, peers (68).
tle or sippy cup, caregivers and health care workers As children approach the 4A-year
limit juice or sugar-containing need to ensure that good dietary hab- age range, they generally have fewer
drink intake to 4 oz per day and only its, including regular meal patterns, feeding and nutritional problems.
in a cup, are instilled in the child. Repeated However, because they are more inde-
restrict cariogenicfoods to meal- positive experiences associated with pendent, food intake between meals
times, high-sucrose or high-calorie foods tends to increase. Sound eating prac-
establish routine meals with tend to increasechildren’s preferences tices learned earlier should help with
family members eating together, and for them. In a study of 3-5-year-olds, appropriate snack choices. Noncario-
stimulate a child’s appetite at children with a conditioned prefer- genic snacks should be provided at
home and in lunch boxes (Table 4).
Sugar-containingsnacks that are eaten
slowly (e.g., candy, cough drops, IOU-
TABLE 4 pops, suckers) should be discouraged
Cariogenic Potential of Children’s Foods and Snacks strongly.
Noncariogenic Low Cariogenic Highly Cariogenic Additional guidelines for pre-
schoolers include the following:
Cheeses Fruits (except dried) Candy+ promote nutritious, noncario-
KUtS* Chocolate milk COOkieS genic foods for meals, as well as for
Dried meat sticks While grain products Cake sllacks;
Plain milk Sweetened beverages strongly discourage the con-
sumption of sfowly eaten, sugar-con-
Vegetables (includingfruit juices) taining foods; and
Popcorn” Fruit roll-ups, dried fruit encourage that the majority of
Flavored club soda Breakfast bars food consumption be at regular me&
Diet sodas times.
Children with Special Health Care
*Not appropriatefor infants and toddlers due to potential choking problems. Needs. Children with special needs
Sticky and/or slowly eaten candy is extremely cariogenic. may have greatly increased caries risk
TABLE 5
Oral Health Dietary Guidelines for Expectant Mothers and Preschool Children
Dental Period Fluoride Nutrition
Pregnant women Fluoride supplementationnot indicated FolIow the Food Cuide Pyramid, taking into
account increased needs for pregnancy
Use of fluoridated toothpaste Take prenatal vitamin/mineral supplement as
prescribed
Limit intake of cariogenic foods, especially as
between-meal snacks
Birth to 1 year 0 Oral supplementation recommended after Avoid allowing the infant to sleep or nap with
6 months, if appropriate bottle
0 Use of fluoridated water if available Avoid excessive consumption of juice
0 With eruption of teeth, start tooth cleaning Eliminate dipping pacifiers in sweetened foods
1-2 years 0 Oral supplementation recommended, if Avoid frequent consumption of juice or other
appropriate sugar-containingdrinks in bottle or sippy cup
0 Use of fluoridated water if available Encourage weaning
Toothbrushing with fluoride-containing Continue avoidance of the bottle to bed
toothpaste. Promote noncariogenicfoods for snacks
Foster routine eating pattern and Food Guide
Pyramid
2-5 years Oral supplementation recommended, if 0 Discourage slowly eaten sugar-containingfoods
appropriate 0 Promote noncariogenicfoods for snacks
Use fluoridated water if avaiIable Encourage eating at meals and Food Guide
0 Toothbrushingwith fluoridecontaining tooth- Pyramid
paste
Voi. 60, No.3, Summer 2000 205
due to feeding: difficulties, frequent Biol1975;20171-4. 24. Gardner DE, Norwood JR,Eisenson JE.
snacking on sweets, poor oral dear- 6. I(am T, CYSufli~anDA, TLnanoffh'.MU- At-& breast feeding and dental caries:
tans strcptococd levels in S-15-month- four case reports. J Dent Child 1977;44:
ance of foods, xerostoznia, or chronic old children. J W l i c Health Dent 1999; 186.91.
use of sugar-based medications. For 5S:24S-9. 25. Kotlow LA.Breast feeding: a c a w of
example, children with Down syn- 7. Berkowitz RJ, Turner J, GreenP. Primary dentid caries in children. J Dent Child
drome, cerebral palsy, and muscuIar oral infection of infants with Streptococ- 1977,251924.
CUS mutans. Arch Oral Biol1980;25':221-4. 26. Johnsen X. Charaaeristics and back-
dystrophy may have decreased rnus- 8. KoNer 8, Andreen I, Jonsson B. The ear- grounds of children with "nursing car-
d e tone, often producing difficulties lier the colonization by mutans strepto- ies." Pediatr k t 19S2&218-24.
with sucking and/or swallowing. coca, the higher the caries prevalence at 27. Tinanoff N, O'SUUivan DM.?&ly chiid-
Such problem may prolong feeding 4 yean of age. Oral Wmbiol Immunol hood caries overview and recent find-
time and food clearance, exposing the 19SS3:14-17. %.Pcdiatr Dent 1987;19:12-16.
9. Edwardsson S. M i a o o r p i s m s assoEi- 28. Davies Gh'. Early c h i l d h d caries-a
teeth to cariogenicfoodsfor longer pe- ated with dental caries. In: Thyktrup A, synopsis. Community Dent Oral Epide-
riods (69). Any one of these factors Fejerskw 0.Textbook of cariology. Co- mi01 199S;26(Supp11):106-16.
may greatly increase dental caries in- penhagen: Munksgaard, 1966:107-14. 29. Dougiass Jh4, Wei Y, Zhang BX, Tinanoff
adence in children who also present 10. Tamer JM. Microbiology of dentalcaries, K. Caries prevalence and pattern in 3- to
In:Slots J, Taubman MA. Contemporary 6-year-old Beijing children. Community
challenges in performing preventive oral microbiology and immunology. St. Dent Oral Epidemiol1995;23W3.
and restorative dental care. Therefore, b u k , MO: Mosby Year Book, 1992:377- 30. schachetele CF. Dental caries: preven-
exceptionalmeasures must be taken to 424. tion and control. L.i: S W RE, ed. A
prevent caries and other oral health 11. RuggGunnAJ.Dietanddentalcaries.tn: textbook of preventive dentistry.2nd ed.
problems in children with special MurrayJJ.keventionof oral disease. Ox- Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders, 1982241-
ford:Oxford University Press, 19963-31. 53.
needs. Preventivenutritionalcounsel- 12. Marthaier 'I'M. Epidemiological and 31. DennisonBA. Fruitjuice consumption by
ing that can reduce the development clinical dental findings in relation to in- infants and childrm a review. 1Am Coll
of oral disease in these children is es- take of carbohydrates. Caries Rcs 1967; nut^ 1996;15:4SllS.
sential (70). 1:222-3s. 32. Reynolds EC, Riley PF, Storey E. Phos-
13. Gustafsson BE, Quensel CE, Swenander- phoprotein inhibitionof hydroxyapatite
W e L, et af. The Vipehoh dental car- dissolution. Calcif Tiss Int 1982;34:5%2-6.
Conclusions ies study. The effect of different levels of 33. Weiss ME, Bibby BG.Effects of milk on
Children, especially those living in carbohydrateintake on caries activity in enamel solubility. Arch Oral Biol 1966;
low socioeconomicsituations, are sus- 436 individuals observed for five years. 1k49-57.
Acta Odont Sand 1956;l k232-6. 34. Kosikowski F. Cheese and fermented
ceptible to dental caries perhaps due 14.Burt BA, Wund SA, Morgan KJ, et al. milk food. Ann Arbor, ?vlI: Edwards
to poorer nutrition, less emphasis on The effects of sugar intake and frequency Brother, 1970330.
following health behaviors, and insuf- of ingestion of dental caries increment in 35. Reynolds EC, Johnson M. Effect of milk
Baent access to dental care (Figure 4). a bee-year longitudinal study J Dent on caries incidence and bacterial compo-
Appropriatenutrition early in life rep- 1988;671422-9. sition of dental plaque in the rat Arch
13.Bowen wki, Amsbough SM,Monell-Tor- Ord Bio11981;26:445-51.
resents a major determinant of the rnS, Brunelle J, Kurmizlk-JonesH, Cole 36.BowenWH, PeammSK.Effett of milkon
child's dental, as well as general MR. A method to assess cariogenic pc- cariogenesis. Caries Res 1993;U:461-6.
health. Caregivers need information kential of foods. J Am Dent Assoc 1960; 37. Erickson PR, Mathnri E. Investigation of
and guidance to help foster positive 100:677-81. the role of human breast milk in caries
16. United States Department of Agricul- development Pediatr Dent 1999;21:S6-
dietary and dental health behaviors ture, Center for Suhition, Policy and 90.
that enable an early start in preventing Promotion, 1999. http/ /:www.usda. 35.McDougaU WA. Effect of milk on enamel
dental caries in their children.Strate- gov/ cnpp/. demineralization and reminerahtion
gies should begin with the mother be- 17. Kaste LV,Gift HC. Inappropriate infant in vitro. CariesRes 1977;11:166-72
fore birth and continue through in- bottle feeding. Status of the Healthy Peo- 39. Mohan A, Morse D, O'Sulli~a~~ DM, Ti-
ple 2000 Objectives. Arch Pediatr 1995; nanoff N. The relationshipbetween bot-
fancy and childhood (Table 5). These 149:786-91. tle usage/content, age, and number of
nutrition and oral care guidelines 18.Powell D. Mill< ... is it related to rampant teeth with salivary mutans streptococci
should have a meaningful impact on caries of the eaxy primary dentition? J levels in 6- to 2 4 m n t h old children.
the child's caries experience. Calif Dent Assoc 1976$:5&63. Community Dent oral Epidemiol1998;
19. OSullivan DM, T i o f f N. Social and 2612-20.
biological factors contributing tocariesof 40.Scheinin A, Makinen KK, Ylitalo K.
References the ntaxillanr anterior teeth.Pediatr Dent Turku sugar studies V. Final report on
1. Larsen MJ, Bmun C. Enamel/saliva-in- 1993;1541-4: the effect of sucrose, fructose, and xylitol
organic chemical reaction. Ln: Thybtrup 20. Swerint JR,Mungo R, Negrete VF, Dug- diets on the caries incidence in man. A&
A, Fejerskov 0.Textbook of cariology. gan AK, Korsch B M ChiId-rearing prac- Odontol Scand 1976;34:179-216.
Copenhageh. M W p r d , 19s6:181-9S. tices and nursing caries. Pediatr 1993; 41. Holst K,KohIer L. Preventingdental car-
2. Fitzgerald RJ, Keyes PH.Demonstration 92233-7. ies in children: report of a Swedish pro-
of the etiologic role of streptococci in ex- 21. Reisine S, DouglassJM.Psychosocial and gram DeveI Med Child New: 1975;17
perimental caries in the hamster. J Am behavioral issues in early childhood car- 602-4.
Dent Assoc 1960;61:2323. ies. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 42. Holm AK, Blomquist HK, Grossner GG,
3. Thibodeau EA, OSullivan DM. Salivary 1998;26(Supplt)32-44. Grainen H, Samuelson G. A compara-
mutans streptococci and dental caries 22. Cumon MEJ, Dnrmmond BK. Case re- tive study of oral health as related to
patterns in preschool children.Commu- port-rampant cariesin an infantrelated general health, food habits, and sodo-
nity Dent Oral Epidemiol1966;243164-8. to prolonged ondemand breast feeding economic condition of 4-year-old Swed-
4. Loexhe WJ. Role of StTep:ococncs mutans and a lacto-vegetarian diet. J Pediatr ish children. Community Dent Oral
in human dentaI decay. Maobiol Rev Dent 19S7;3:25-2& Epidemiol1975;3:34-9.
198s;50:353-80. 23. Dilley GJ, Dilley DH, Machen JB. Pro- 43. Becks H. Rampant dental caries: preven-
5. Berkowitz RJ, Jordan HV,White G. The longed nusinghabit: a profifeof patients tion and prognosis. A five-year dinical
early establishment of Strqtcux~usmu- and their families. 1Lknt Child 3980;47: study. J Am Dent ASOC 1944;31:1189-
tans in the mouths of infants. Arch Oral 102-8. 200.
206 Journal of Public Health Dentistry
44.Krasse B. Approaches to prevention- h tive measures in mothm influence the Dent J 1997&7213-17.
Stiles HM, Locsche WJ, O'Brein TC, eds. establishment of the bacterium Sfrepfe 62.Rossow I, Kjaernes U, Hokt D. Patterns
koceedings of "microbial aspects of den- coccus mutans in their infants. Arch Oral ofsugareonsumptioninearlychildhood.
tal caries" [Abstract]. Microbiol 1976; Biol1983,2&225-31. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol1990;
%SpecS~ppl):s67-76. 55. Leverett DH, Adait SM, Vaughan BW, 18:12-16.
45. RPaolS DP,Faine MB, Palmer CA. Nu- Proskin HM, Moss ME. Randomized 63.Ismail AI. The role of early dietary habits
trition in relation to dental medicine. In: dinical trialof the effect of prenatal fluo- in dental caries development Spec Care
shils ME$ Ofson JA, Shike M, Ross AC, ride supplements in preventing dental Dent 1998;13:40-5.
eds. M&em nutrition in health and dis- caries.Canes Res 1997;31:1749. 64.Tang J, Altman RS,Robertson D, O'Sul-
m.9& ed. Baltimore, MD: Williams 54. Tsamtsouris A, Stack A, Padamesee M. livan DM,'DouglassJM,Tinanoff N. Den-
and Wiikins, 1m1099-124. Dental education of expeaant parents. J tal cariesprevalence and treatment levels
46.Davies GN. A comparative epidemi- Pedodont 1986;1@309-21. in A&OM preschool children Public
ological study of the diet and dental car- 55. Chiodo BT,Rosenstein DL.Dental treat- Health Rep 1997;112319-29.
ies in three isolated communities. A a ment d u r i n g p r e p n q a preventiveap- 65.Munoz KA, Krebs-Smith SM' Ballard-
Dent RW 195&4:19-28. proach. J Am Dent Assoc 1985;11@309- Barbash R, et aL Food intakes of US chil-
47. Sweeny EA, GuzmanM. Oral conditions 21. drenand adolescentscompared with rec-
in children from t h e e highland villages 56. Alvarez JO. Nutrition, tooth develop ommendations. Pediatrics 1998;101952-
in Guatemala. Arch oral Biol 1956;11: ment, and dental caries. Am 3 Uin Xutr 3.
687-9s. 1995%1:410S16S. 66. Sullivan SA, Birch LL Infant dietary ex-
a.&ow WK. Biological mechanisms of 57. May RL, Goodman AH, Meindl RS. Re- perience and acceptance of solid foods.
early childhood caries. Community Dent sponse of bone and e n a d formation to Pediatrics 199453271-7.
oralEpidemioi 1998;26(SuppI1):8-27. nutritional Supplementation and mor- 67. Kashket S, plMs J, Van Noute J. Accu-
49. JohnsenD, Kreja C, Hack M,Fanaroff A. bidity among malnourished Guatemalan mulation of fermentable sugars and me-
Distribution of enamel defects and the children. Am J Phys Anthropo11993,92 tabolic acids in food particies that be-
assodation with respiratory distress in 37-51. come entrapped on the dentitiom J Dent
very low birth weight infanis. J Dent Res 58. Burt BA. Ihe changing pattems of sys- Res 19965'51885-91.
1984;63:39-64. temic fluoride intake. J Dent Res 1992; 68. Fisher JO, Birch LL. Fat preferences and
50. KoNerB,BratthallD. Intra-familiallevels 721226-37. fat consumption of 3- to Ej-year-old chil-
of Stwptococcusmu- and some aspects 59. Levy SM,Kiritsy MC, Warren JJ. Sources dren are related to parental adiposity. J
of the bacterial transmission. stand J of fluoride intake in children. J Public Am Diet Assoc 199595:75964.
Dent Res 1978W354-2. Health Dent 1995;55:39-52. 69. McKinney LS, Palmer CA, Dwyer JT,
51. KohlerB,AndreenI, JanssonB.Theeffect 60.Croll TP, Tinanoff N.The dentifrice de- Garciii R Common dentally related nu-
of caries-preventive measures in mothers ception revisited. Quintessence Int 1992; trition concerns of chilbenwith special
on dental caries and the oral presence of 23:77-8. needs. Part 1.Topics ClinNutr 19916:M
the bacteria S.bv$ococnrs mutars and lac- 61.Jamel HA, Sheikam A, Watt RG, Cowell 5.
tobadlli in their children Arch Oral Bid CR. Sweet preferences, consumption of 70. Tesini DA, Fenton SJ.Oral health needs
1984;29:S79-83. sweet tea and dental caries: studies in of persons with physical or mental dis-
52.Kohler B, BrattMI D, fiasse B. Preven- urban and rural kaqi popuhtions. Int abilities. Dent QinN Am 19949:4&3-9&.