Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Prurigo Simplex or Itchy Red Bumps
Prurigo Simplex or Itchy Red Bumps
REVIEW ARTICLE
Series
Joanna WALLENGREN
Department of Clinical Sciences Lund, Dermatology and Venereology, Lund University, Lund Sweden and Skåne University Hospital, Lund,
Sweden
T he term prurigo, originating from the Latin prurire condition that clinically resembles dermatitis herpetifor-
(to itch), is a condition of itching papules. Prurigo mis with histologic features similar to papular urticaria”.
was a common disease in the 19th and 20th centuries, and Another controversial issue is whether prurigo simplex
a great number of scientific descriptions, bearing names or “itchy red bump” disease is a clearly defined entity or
of leading dermatologists, were published. A detailed a variant of chronic prurigo. It has been suggested that
review of the literature in 1962, a “conceptual chaos” it is a transitional stage of prurigo that transforms from
according to its author, resulted in a rough classifica- an acute to a chronic form (7).
tion of prurigo variants into acute, subacute and chronic The objective of this study was to search the litera-
forms (1). ture for case reports and relevant theories, as well as
Acute prurigo (strophulus), common in regions of poor to analyse patients with presumed prurigo simplex at a
sanitary conditions, is associated with insect stings or university dermatology department to further delineate
infestations (1, 2). Chronic prurigo, on the other hand, is this condition and explore its relation to chronic prurigo.
triggered by endogenic factors causing itch (3). The main
criteria for chronic prurigo have recently been consented
METHODS
to the presence of chronic pruritus for ≥ 6 weeks, a history
or signs of repeated scratching and multiple localized Literature search
or generalized pruriginous skin lesions (3). Chronic A PubMed search was performed in January 2021 using the follow
prurigo may present as papules, nodules (flat/topped or ing search terms: “prurigo simplex”, “prurigo simplex subacute”,
This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC license. www.medicaljournals.se/acta doi: 10.2340/00015555-3912
Society for Publication of Acta Dermato-Venereologica Acta Derm Venereol 2021; 101: adv00539
2/7 J. Wallengren
“subacute prurigo”, “papular dermatitis in adults” and “itchy red Two other reports from Japan deal with 6 patients with
bump disease”. Publications on conditions of papular dermatoses “grouping prurigo” (14). The patients presented with
ActaDV
coined by Willan in 1798 and referred by Kocksard (4). dermatitis herpetiformis, pityriasis lichenoides et varioli
Most frequently, the skin lesions presented at doctors’ formis acuta or transient acantholytic dermatosis (11).
visits were papules with no vesicular element, but often Other conditions with excoriations to be differentiated
with excoriations, as in 26 patients reported by Ollech (9) from prurigo are neurotic excoriations, which display no
and 28 patients reported by Uehara & Ofuji (10). Multiple papules and acne excoriée, where comedones are present.
flesh-coloured to erythematous non-follicular papules Histopathology is diagnostic in such cases. Ollech et al.
with superimposed excoriations or lichenification were (9) presented a diagnostic algorithm for the evaluation
described in 12 patients (11). The pruritic papules were of chronic pruritic papular eruption.
mostly confined to the neck, behind the ears, trunk, ex- There are some reports of prurigo simplex associated
tremities or buttocks (9, 11). with bullous diseases: a case of “subacute prurigo-like
There are 2 reports on papular eruption on the trunk linear IgA disease” and 2 cases of bullous pemphigoid
and upper extremities in 7 black men and 20 Korean men mimicking prurigo simplex (17–19). In all cases, direct
(12, 13). The lesions were characterized by recurrent, immunofluorescence was positive. These entities belong
severely pruritic, non-follicular, monomorphic, ery to the spectrum of bullous diseases and not primarily
thematous urticarial papules. There was no evidence of to the prurigo group. Immunofluorescence assays in
insect stings, atopy or other pruritic erythematous papular patients affected by long-lasting pruriginous dermato-
dermatosis, and the authors considered the condition a ses are recommended to exclude autoimmune bullous
variant of prurigo (12, 13). dermatoses.
www.medicaljournals.se/acta
Prurigo simplex or “itchy red bump” disease 3/7
skin disease, or alternatively by positive prick-tests, the patients are not atopic by strict criteria, but that “the
has been described in several reports on prurigo simp- clinical and histological presentation bridges the descrip-
lex (11, 15, 20–22). The most commonly observed tion of prurigo simplex subacuta and papular variant of
internal disease was diabetes (7, 15, 22). Hypertension atopic dermatitis” (11).
and renal disease were also mentioned (15). Seikowski Although acute prurigo (strophulus) and prurigo simp-
& Frank (23) examined 70 diagnosed patients using lex share common morphology (the sero-papule) Kogoj
psychological tests. One-third of the patients reported emphasized 2 differences (1). The seropapule is the pri-
psychosomatic complaints, and one-third reported se- mary lesion in prurigo simplex, while it is preceded by
Acta Dermato-Venereologica
vere psychosocial risk factors, mostly in terms of critical a weal in strophulus (1). Secondly, prurigo simplex has
life events (23). a continuous course, while strophulus is recurrent (1).
Prurigo simplex and chronic prurigo are considered
separate entities, but some authors are of the opinion
Therapy that transitional stages between them are common (7).
As antihistamines and topical steroids are often insuf- The main argument for this hypothesis, according to
ficient, patients require systemic treatment, which often Greither, is that the conditions share the same aetiology,
starts with courses of systemic steroids (9, 12, 13). How including metabolic and endocrinological disorders, as
ever, the problem tends to recur as soon as the medication well as atopy (7).
is stopped (12). On the other hand, Pereira & Ständer (5) empha-
The second line of treatment seems to be phototherapy. size demarcation between prurigo simplex and chronic
A comparative study on courses of ultraviolet B (UVB) prurigo. The main argument for this statement is dif-
alone, ultraviolet A (UVA)/UVB and psoralen ultraviolet ferences in the aetiopathogenesis and morphology of
A (PUVA) showed that, although patients in all groups skin lesions (5). While papules and papulo-vesicles of
relapsed with time, the PUVA-treated patients had the prurigo simplex are primary skin lesions, the lesions
best response rate (24). PUVA and UVA1 were reported of chronic prurigo are secondary to scratching. This
as superior to UVB-narrow band in the management of theory is in accordance with that of Kocsard, who goes
prurigo simplex (25). Also, bath PUVA was reported to even further: “In prurigo simplex subacuta, the clinical
ActaDV
Number/Age,
ActaDV
years,
Sex Clinical Pathological-anatomical Course and clinical
Age of onset Co-morbidities presentation diagnosis/ DIF appearance over time Previous treatments Present treatment
1/53 years Heart disease, Few extremely itchy, Orthokeratosis and focal Persistent, 7 years Emollients, topical steroids, Since 3 years: emollients,
F depression, grouped 5-mm parakeratosis, moderate (19 visits) at centre. tacrolimus, antihistamines, antidepressants, anti
44 years psychosocial papules on the scalp, perivascular lymphocytic Excruciating itch which PUVA, naltrexone, histamines, and cyclo
stress. No skin nape and trunk. inflammation with just a few affects her daily life and antidepressants, sporine in initial dose
disease. eosinophils and a few mast- disturbs her sleep. nternal steroids, 3 mg, tapered down to
Stress cells. Negative DIF. methotrexate (15 mg/ 1.5 mg/kg.
week), dapsone, Well-controlled.
omalizumab.
2/51 years Severe Extremely itchy Hyperkeratosis, focal Persistent, 5 years UVB narrow-band, Since 1-year emollients
Acta Dermato-Venereologica
F psychosocial excoriated pinhead parakeratosis with traces (14 visits) at gabapentin, systemic and methotrexate in
43 years stress at work. papules on the of blood in epidermis, centre. A few 5-mm steroids. doses 20 mg/week for 3
Atopic eczema extremities. which is slightly acanthotic. excoriated papules or years, thereafter 15 mg/
and asthma in Subepidermal oedema hyperkeratotic papules week. Well-controlled.
childhood. Scalp with no split, perivascular on extremities at visits.
psoriasis. lymphocytic infiltrate
with moderate number
of eosinophils and slight
inflammation around sweat
glands and a single nerve.
Negative DIF.
3/78 years Heart disease Extremely itchy Slight acanthosis and Persistent, 3 years, Topical steroids, anti For 2 years metho
F and psychosocial red papules with ordinary subepidermal (14 visits) at centre. histamines, systemic trexate; initially 15 mg/
73 years stress. Previously exudation on her layer. Minimal lymphocytic Few excoriated 5-mm steroids, intralesional week and later 7.5 mg/
folliculitis of the trunk, arms and inflammation, no excoriated papules on steroids, UVB-NB and week for 1 year when it
scalp. legs. eosinophils or neutrophils. the arms and back. On PUVA. can be withdrawn. No
Negative DIF. the legs, up to 15-mm treatment for the last 6
macular lesions or months.
ulcerations. Initially,
itch is unbearable.
4/65 years Type I diabetes, Small excoriated Subepidermal split, minimal Persistent with Potassium permanganate Since 2 years metho
F high blood papular eruption on spongiosis, moderate occasional baths, emollients, topical trexate with dose of 17.5
61 years pressure, the arms, trunk and perivascular lymphocytic exacerbations. Three steroids, antihistamines, mg/week at maximum
hyperlipidaemia. ulcerations on lower inflammation with just a years (13 visits) at antibiotics, internal steroids due to elevated liver
Atopic eczema in legs. The itch few eosinophil granulocytes. centre. Frequently and intralesional steroids. enzymes. Itch is still
childhood. is severe. Negative DIF. 5-mm excoriated bothersome. Dupilumab
macules on elbows, is being considered, but
flanks, lower trunk, is postponed due to
buttocks and lower legs. COVID-19.
ActaDV
5/52 years None Very itchy, papules Epidermal hyperplasia, Persistent. Three years Tenutex (disulfiram- Since 2 years metho
M with blisters on feet mild focal spongiosis (11 visits) at centre. benzyl benzoate. Bioglan, trexate; initially 15 mg/
49 years and lower legs. and superficial and deep Excoriated, sometimes Malmö, Sweden), topical week, tapered over time
perivascular inflammatory vesicular 5-mm papules and internal steroids, to 7.5 mg/week.
infiltrate with lymphocytes, on trunk and arms, and antihistamines and a Well-controlled.
histiocytes and a few 5–10 mm excoriated course of UVB-NB.
eosinophils. lesions on the legs.
No DIF performed.
DIF: direct immuno-fluorescence: PUVA: psoralen plus ultraviolet A; UVB: ultraviolet B; UVB-NB; UVB narrow band.
www.medicaljournals.se/acta
Prurigo simplex or “itchy red bump” disease 5/7
ActaDV
Acta Dermato-Venereologica
disease may therefore be a preferred term (32). In the Fig. 2. Prurigo simplex. Erythematous papules and papulo-vesicles on
ICD nomenclature, it can be classified as “other prurigo,” the upper arm of case 5 before systemic treatment.
lymphocytic perivascular infiltrates, few eosinophils and the condition relapsed after the UV course was comple-
sometimes spongiosis. These findings are not precise, but ted (24–27). Only immunosuppressants could clear the
histology is helpful to exclude other pruritic diseases (9). symptoms. In this case series, relatively high doses of
In all the cases in the current study, dermatopathologists methotrexate were required, higher than those reported
considered eczema not likely. Our patients displayed by others (28).
this histopathological picture a long time after their first In the current study university setting, this entity con-
appearance, as the mean time for the first biopsy at the stituted approximately 10% of all prurigo cases with a
centre was 1.5 years after reported onset. Negative di- chronic course. A limitation is, however, that some cases
rect immunofluorescence, performed in all but 1 of the
patients excluded bullous diseases, such as dermatitis Table II. Proposal of major and minor diagnostic criteria for prurigo
herpetiformis or bullous pemphigoid. simplex
The most striking feature in this case series was that so Major criteria Sudden occurrence of pruritic papules or papulo-vesicles
(prurigo papules)
few tiny lesions could cause unbearable itch. All patients Papules occur first, not after scratching
reported a negative impact on their daily lives, while 3 pa- Skin biopsy reveals lymphocytic perivascular infiltrates, few
eosinophils and occasionally spongiosis
tients reported severe psychosocial stress for long periods. Skin lesions continue to occur for years
Based on the cases described in the literature and on Itch is very intense
the 5 patients in the present case series, some major and Minor criteria Papules do not transform to nodular prurigo lesions
Functional aspects (impaired daily life and sleep)
minor diagnostic criteria of prurigo simplex are drafted in Emotional aspects (feelings of anxiety, depression or
Morphology Papulo-vesicles, crusted papules and papules with erosion Papules, nodules, linear scratch lesions, lichenified plaques
Histopathology No or only slight acanthosis Focal hyperparakeratosis, acanthosis and papillomatosis
No collagen proliferation Increased collagen in the dermal papillae
Perivascular cell infiltrates with occasional eosinophils Mononuclear cell infiltrate in dermis
Immunohisto-chemistry Damaged epidermal nerve fibres in papules with erosion Reduction of epidermal nerve fibres in prurigo nodules
Subepidermal proliferation of nerve fibres in the healing phase Subepidermal proliferation of nerve fibres and nerve bundles in the
dermis
Course of disease Persistent, occasional exacerbations Persistent
Impact on daily quality of life High High
Comorbidities Psychosocial disorders, eczema, metabolic. endocrinological Eczema, metabolic, endocrinological and cardiovascular disorders,
and cardiovascular disorders psychosocial disorders
Acta Dermato-Venereologica
Topical therapy Emollients, potent corticosteroids, tacrolimus, capsaicin, Emollients, potent corticosteroids, tacrolimus, capsaicin, potassium
potassium permanganate baths permanganate baths
Systemic therapy Antihistamines UVB-NB, PUVA, systemic steroids, intralesional Antihistamines, UVB-NB, PUVA, systemic steroids, intralesional steroids,
steroids, antidepressants, gabapentin, methotrexate, antidepressants, gabapentin, methotrexate, ciclosporin, azathioprine,
ciclosporin, azathioprine dupilumab, nemolizumab
meeting diagnostic criteria for prurigo simplex might In conclusion, the literature review and case series
have been missed being registered as toxicoderma, drug suggest that the disorder presented here belongs to the
eruption or eczema instead. prurigo group of diseases. Based on the literature and on
In addition to differences in morphology and histo- this case series, diagnostic criteria for prurigo simplex
pathology, there are some similarities between prurigo and a comparison with chronic prurigo are suggested.
simplex and chronic prurigo (Table III). Notably, in Future investigations that test these hypotheses more
both disorders, immunohistochemistry shows dermal directly in patients from other centres or in a multicentre
proliferation of nerve fibres and damaged nerves in the study are warranted. A consensus on the definition and
epidermis (16, 33, 34). This pattern is also seen in other classification would greatly facilitate further research on
pruritic conditions, such as brachioradial pruritus (35). the pathogenesis and therapy of this burdensome disease.
Most importantly, the therapy used in chronic prurigo
also seems to be effective in prurigo simplex (Table SI1,
ActaDV
and Tables I and III). Here, lessons can be learned from ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
guidelines on chronic prurigo (36). The immunosuppres- A research grant from the Edvard Welander Foundation/Hudfon-
sive treatment has to go on for years in both conditions. den is gratefully acknowledged.
Consequently, it is important to switch therapy to medi-
cations with a good safety profile.
New drugs targeting specific receptors in the nervous REFERENCES
system and in the immune system have proved effective 1. Kogoj F. Urticaria, strophulus, prurigo, pruritus. In: Jadas-
sohn J, editor. Handbuch der Haut und Geschlechtskrank-
as antipruritic therapies (37). Dupilumab, a human mo- heiten: Ergänzungswerk vol II/1. Berlin: Springer Verlag,
noclonal antibody against interleukin IL-4Ra, common
Advances in dermatology and venereology
1962: p. 475–544.
to IL-4 and IL-13 receptors, has been reported to clear 2. Wallengren J. Prurigo: diagnosis and management. Am J Clin
Dermatol 2004; 5: 85–95.
symptoms in several case series of prurigo nodularis 3. Pereira MP, Steinke S, Zeidler C, Froner C, Riepe C, Augustin
(37–39). It could also be tried in prurigo simplex, as M, et al. European Academy of Dermatology and Venereology
increased expression of IL-4 and IL-31 was shown even European prurigo project: expert consensus on the definition,
classification and terminology of chronic prurigo. J Eur Acad
here (40). Dermatol Venereol 2018; 32: 1059–1065.
Nemolizumab, a humanized antihuman interleukin-31 4. Kocsard E. The problem of prurigo. Aust J Dermatol 1962;
receptor A monoclonal antibody, has proved promising 6: 156–166.
5. Pereira MP, Ständer S. How to define chronic prurigo? Exp
in a phase II randomized, placebo-controlled trial on
Dermatol 2019; 28: 1455–1460.
chronic prurigo (37, 41). 6. Ackerman AB. Superficial perivascular dermatitis. In: Histo-
Interestingly, a special feature of prurigo simplex is the logic diagnosis of inflammatory skin disease. Philadelphia:
presence of eosinophils. Theoretically, eosinophil activity Lea & Febiger, 1978; 18, p. 4.
7. Greither A. Pruritus und prurigo. Hautarzt 1980; 31:
could be reduced using monoclonal antibodies against 397–405.
IL-5 or Janus kinase (JAK2 inhibitor), which blocks 8. Pereira MP, Hoffmann V, Weisshaar E, Wallengren J, Halvor-
activation of IL-5 by intracellular mechanisms (42). sen JA, Garcovich S, et al. Chronic nodular prurigo: clinical
profile and burden. A European cross-sectional study. J Eur
Baricitinib (selective JAK1-and JAK2-inhibitor) could Acad Dermatol Venereol 2020; 34: 2373–2383
be tried here, as it was shown to significantly reduce 9. Ollech A, Hodak E, David M, Trattner A, Didkovsky E, pav-
pruritus in a phase II, double-blind, randomized trial on lovsky L. Idiopathic papular dermatitis in the spectrum of
chronic papular eruptions (subacuta prurigo): reappraisal
AD (37, 43). However, the effectiveness and safety of the and diagnostic algorithm. Dermatology 2019; 235: 205–212.
novel medications has to be confirmed in larger studies. 10. Uehara M, Ofuji S. Primary eruption of prurigo simplex suba-
www.medicaljournals.se/acta
Prurigo simplex or “itchy red bump” disease 7/7
cuta. Dermatologica 1976; 153: 49–56. treatment of papular dermatitis: a retrospective study. J
11. Sherertz EF, Jorizzo JL, White WL, Shar GG, Arrington J. Dermatolog Treat 2015; 26: 431–434.
ActaDV
Papular dermatitis in adults: subacute prurigo, American 29. Daudén E, García-Díez A. Severe resistant subacute prurigo
style? J Am Acad Dermatol 1991; 24: 697–702. successfully controlled by long-term cyclosporin. J Derma-
12. Rosen T, Algra RJ. Papular eruption in black men. Arch Der- tolog Treat 2003; 14: 48–50.
matol 1980; 116: 416–418. 30. Tokura Y, Yagi H, Hanaoka K, Ito T, Towyama K, Sachi Y, et
13. Chang SN, Kim SC, Chun YS, Kim KT, Ahn SK, Park WH. al. Subacute and chronic prurigo effectively treated with
Chronic pruritic papular dermatitis in adult men: a variant recombination interferon-gamma: implications for participa-
of prurigo. J Dermatol 1999; 26: 442–447. tion of Th2 cells in the pathogenesis of prurigo. Acta Derm
14. Sakurai Y, Matsui H, Izaki S, Kitamura K. Grouping prurigo: Venereol 1977; 77: 231–234.
report of cases. J Dermatol 2001; 28: 75–80. 31. Jorizzo JL, Gatti S, Smith EB. Prurigo: a clinical review. J Am
15. Gambichler T, Skrygan, A Werries A, Scola N, Stücker M, Acad Dermatol 1981; 4: 723–728.
Altmeyer P, Kreuter A. Immunophenotyping of inflammatory 32. James WD, Berger TG, Elston DM, Neuhaus IM. Andrews’
cells in subacute prurigo. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol diseases of the skin. Philadelphia: Elsevier, 2016: p 51.
Acta Dermato-Venereologica