Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Suplements in Rehab 2
Suplements in Rehab 2
doi: 10.4085/1062-6050-550-19
Ó by the National Athletic Trainers’ Association, Inc Current Concepts
www.natajournals.org
Nutritional interventions are not commonly a standard of care immobilization, and maximize the chance of safe return to play.
in rehabilitation interventions. A nutritional approach has the These recommendations include identifying the individual’s
potential to be a low-cost, high-volume strategy that comple- caloric requirements to ensure that energy needs are being
ments the existing standard of care. In this commentary, our met. A higher protein intake, with special attention to evenly
aim is to provide an evidence-based, practical guide for distributed consumption throughout the day, will help to
athletes with injuries treated surgically or conservatively, along minimize loss of muscle and strength during immobilization.
with healing and rehabilitation considerations. Injuries are a Dietary-supplement strategies may be useful when navigating
normal and expected part of exercise participation. Regardless the challenges of appropriate caloric intake and timing and a
of severity, an injury typically results in the athlete’s short- or
reduced appetite. The rehabilitation process also requires a
long-term removal from participation. Nutritional interventions
strong nutritional plan to enhance recovery from injury. Athletic
may augment the recovery process and support optimal
trainers, physical therapists, and other health care profession-
healing; therefore, incorporating nutritional strategies is impor-
tant at each stage of the healing process. Preoperative als should provide basic nutritional recommendations during
nutrition and nutritional demands during rehabilitation are key rehabilitation, discuss the timing of meals with respect to
factors to consider. The physiological response to wounds, therapy, and refer the patient to a registered dietitian if
immobilization, and traumatic brain injuries may be improved warranted. Because nutrition plays an essential role in injury
by optimizing macronutrient composition, caloric consumption, recovery and rehabilitation, nutritional interventions should
and nutrient timing and using select dietary supplements. become a component of standard-of-care practice after injury.
Previous research supports practical nutrition recommenda- In this article, we address best practices for implementing
tions to reduce surgical complications, minimize deficits after nutritional strategies among patients with athletic injuries.
T
he economic burden of injury is high, with more initiate optimal healing; as a result, nutritional interventions
than $9 billion spent annually on injury and intended to control inflammation in this acute phase may be
rehabilitation in young adults (17–44 years).1 contraindicated for optimal healing.3 However, minimizing
Injuries are the leading contributor to medical costs in this prolonged or excessive inflammation by ingesting dietary
age group. Beyond monetary costs, athletic injuries also supplements may enhance healing and accelerate a safe
result in significant mental and physical burdens. Health- return to play. Patients with injuries that require immobi-
related rehabilitation interventions are most cost effective lization or surgery deserve special nutritional consider-
when practitioners adopt an interdisciplinary approach that ations due to the large physiological demand of wound
encompasses low-cost, high-volume services.2 Nutritional healing (Figure 1). Even athletes with more minor injuries,
interventions are not commonly used as standard of care in such as muscular strains, stress fractures, or ankle sprains,
rehabilitation interventions. However, numerous nutritional
warrant special nutritional attention. In a different category,
approaches are available as potential low-cost, high-volume
strategies to complement the existing standard of care, traumatic brain injuries (TBIs)—even mild cases—also
particularly for patients pursuing musculoskeletal rehabil- need nutritional attention. Nutritional recommendations for
itation. patients with TBI constitute a growing field, with new
Injuries are a normal and expected part of exercise research emerging rapidly. In this article, we will present an
participation. Regardless of severity, injuries typically evidence-based, practical guide for nutritional consider-
result in short- or long-term removal from participation. ations of injuries, including wound healing, immobilization,
The initial healing stage that occurs immediately after and TBI. Specifically, nutritional considerations for athletes
trauma involves an inflammatory response and may last with injuries treated surgically or conservatively who are in
from a few hours to several days, depending on the nature the preoperative, postoperative, or healing phase will be
of the injury.3,4 This inflammatory response is essential to addressed.
Figure 1. Physiological and metabolic demands after injury can be ASSESSING POSTOPERATIVE AND
addressed with key nutritional targets; elevated caloric demand,
increased protein, glucose regulation with complex carbohydrates,
REHABILITATIVE NUTRITIONAL NEEDS
and essential fatty acids should be considered. In addition, based Most often, an injury results in immobilization or disuse.
on the evidence, specific dietary supplements may mitigate the
negative effects of surgery and immobilization and support faster
Under these circumstances, muscle tissue can be lost after
healing. Abbreviation: HMB, b-hydroxy-b-methylbutyrate. as little as 36 hours of inactivity,18 with global gene
expression alterations after 48 hours and a significant loss
of muscle tissue within 5 days of inactivity.19 At a
PREOPERATIVE NUTRITIONAL CONSIDERATIONS fundamental level, the goal of rehabilitative nutrition is to
Once an injury is sustained, a cascade of inflammatory, provide enough calories and protein to aid in wound healing
immune, and metabolic responses is activated, resulting in a and prevent a loss of lean body mass (LBM). Other goals
hypermetabolic state. To support this hypermetabolic state include modulating inflammatory and immune responses,
and the injury-healing process, significant macro- and enhancing control of blood glucose levels, and providing
micronutrient support is required. The nutritional needs of a macro- and micronutrients to optimize the recovery and
patient before surgery are often omitted from standard healing process.3 During the rehabilitative phase, a stress
presurgical guidelines; preoperative attention to nutrition is response initiates an overall increase in energy demand.5
typically focused on recommendations to fast from food The resulting net catabolic response upregulates the use of
and fluid beginning at midnight of the day of the amino acids and proteins for healing and concomitantly
operation.5,6 This food and fluid fast ensures an empty decreases LBM. When caring for a patient who is
stomach at the time of anesthesia and minimizes the risk of recovering from injury, it is important to identify calorie
pulmonary aspiration.5 More recently, accumulating data needs, protein needs, and micronutrient requirements
have led to suggestions that less strict fasting routines can (Figure 3).
be adopted without placing patients at risk.6,7 Feeding
patients with a high-carbohydrate beverage immediately Calorie Needs
before surgery was safe, reduced catabolic surgical stress, Nutrition is an important aspect of general athlete health
and might have enhanced postoperative outcomes.6,8 Newer and performance. Knowledge of basic energy recommen-
guidelines9 advise that patients fast after a light meal 6 dations may provide additional information regarding an
hours before and from clear liquids 2 hours before surgery. athlete’s unique needs before and after injury.20,21 Whether
With these guidelines in mind, it may be possible to take an injury is treated surgically or conservatively, the
advantage of this preoperative time to maximize recovery patient’s basal metabolic rate (BMR) increases to match
potential. cellular turnover during recovery. To identify the individ-
Preoperative carbohydrates and insulin have been shown ual’s calorie needs, the BMR should be either measured via
to reduce insulin resistance, metabolic stress, and inflam- indirect calorimetry or estimated using predictive equations
mation and prevent hypoglycemia postsurgery.10 Preoper- that reflect the energy required to maintain homeostasis.22
ative glycemic control, particularly using carbohydrate Another estimate of BMR in young adults is 25 kcal/kg
feeding, improved surgical outcomes by reducing the ideal body weight.5 Metabolic rate should then include
catabolic cascade and insulin resistance that occurred with additional calories during the rehabilitative process as
surgical stress.11,12 Specifically, preoperative consumption estimated using a stress factor (Figure 4). This stress factor
of 100 g of glucose in an oral solution the night before can increase metabolic energy demands from about 20% for
surgery and 50 g 2 hours before surgery was effective in minor injuries and surgeries to 100% for more severe
reducing postoperative insulin resistance.13 Another study14 bodily insults such as burns.23,24 Although musculoskeletal
demonstrated that preoperative consumption of a 100-g injuries may not increase metabolic rates to the same extent
carbohydrate-containing drink the evening before the as more severe insults, any injury that activates the stress
surgery and 50 g 2 to 3 hours before surgery attenuated response may result in increased energy expenditure and
protein catabolism. Last, calorie demands from physical loss of muscle.3 In turn, a negative energy balance will
activity should be included (Equation 1). likely lead to greater losses in functional strength and
(1) Total Daily Energy Requirements ¼ BMR 3 Stress prolong the time to return to play, which can significantly
Factor 3 Activity Coefficient24 affect the athlete’s career. Although concerns about weight
Maintaining the caloric balance and meeting the and fat gain are warranted, the macronutrient composition
increased energy demands after an injury is critical. Due of the diet, in combination with caloric intake, can help to
to reduced physical activity after surgery (eg, anterior manage body-composition changes.25 In short, diets
cruciate ligament, rotator cuff, joint replacement, fracture) emphasizing fewer carbohydrates (ie, approximately 40%)
or an injury, the initial response of many individuals is to or a 2:1 carbohydrate:protein ratio (eg, 260 g carbs and 130
reduce caloric intake to avoid weight and fat gain. g protein), have been shown to promote positive changes in
However, a negative energy balance is likely to exacerbate body composition.26–28 By consuming a greater proportion-
the problem by slowing wound healing and increasing the al increase in protein, in combination with complex
carbohydrates, patients can minimize weight and fat gain
while still meeting the nutritional needs of recovery. An
example of caloric needs and macronutrients is depicted in
Figure 5. Of additional concern is alcohol, which should be
avoided. Alcohol ingestion impaired muscle protein
synthesis and wound healing by reducing the inflammatory
response to injury.29,30
Protein Needs
Demand for amino acids is also significantly elevated
after an injury. Amino acid uptake accelerates to support
wound healing, tissue rebuilding, and glycemic control.9,23
Without nutritional support, this hypermetabolic demand
for amino acids is met by the catabolism of skeletal
muscle.23 Depending on the severity of the injury, degree of
immobilization, and length of time between injury and
surgery, this could result in substantial loss of skeletal
muscle. Loss of LBM is an independent risk factor for
increased length of hospital stay, whereas malnutrition,
especially of protein, delayed wound healing and increased
Figure 3. Injury and surgery result in a significant stress risk of postsurgical infection.9,23 After a surgical procedure,
response, which highlights the potential for nutritional support.
The demand for glucose and amino acids increases, which initiates
the amino acid demand would be expected to rise even
a hormonal response resulting in a catabolic environment, leading more to support healing and repair of incisions, tissue
to large losses in lean body mass. Adapted from Demling.23 grafts, and other secondary trauma. Encouraging increases
Figure 5. Energy needs and quality of calories should be evaluated postsurgery and during recovery. A diet consisting of complex
carbohydrates, high-quality protein, and high-quality fats is advised. For example, create a plate with a 30-g serving of complete proteins
paired with a complex whole grain. Then add fresh fruits and vegetables in a variety of colors to help provide antioxidants to enhance
recovery, control inflammation, and provide important micronutrients. Abbreviations: ACL, anterior cruciate ligament; CHO,
carbohydrates; PRO, protein; RMR, resting metabolic rate.
upon approval, the appropriate logo may be placed on the size or strength.57 The immobilization was followed by a
label to demonstrate that the product passed inspection. 12-week rehabilitation program and a weekly reduced dose
of 15 g (weeks 1–3) and 5 g (weeks 4–10); when combined
Creatine Monohydrate with rehabilitation, CrM enhanced the recovery of muscle
mass, resulting in greater hypertrophy of all muscle fiber
Creatine is an organic compound that is synthesized in types than the PL.57 Although the exact mechanisms by
small amounts in the body from the amino acids arginine, which CrM may benefit the immobilized muscle have not
methionine, and glycine. Creatine can also be obtained been established, some evidence suggests it is the result of
exogenously from foods that are high in protein, such as an upregulation of myogenic transcription factors (myoge-
fish and beef.48 Approximately 95% of all creatine stores nin)57,58 and satellite cell activity.59,60 Additional data61
are in skeletal muscle; numerous researchers have shown indicated that CrM may serve as a potential strategy for
increased intramuscular creatine with supplementation.49 enhancing bone remodeling by stimulating cell growth,
Based on decades of work, creatine monohydrate (CrM) is differentiation, and mineralization, which would be bene-
one of the most effective ergogenic aids available for ficial for skeletal injuries.
improving intense exercise performance and enhancing Creatine monohydrate is the most commonly studied
LBM when combined with exercise.49 Additional benefits form of creatine and is arguably the most bioavailable and
of creatine included preventing traumatic brain injuries as effective.62 More importantly, no detrimental effects of
well as improving bone health and neuromuscular func- supplementation with CrM have been identified.51,62 To
tion.50–54 Furthermore, despite reports in the popular press date, the only reported side effect in some individuals was
casting doubt on the usefulness of the substance, CrM may minor weight gain, which subsided after 1 to 2 days of
act as an agent to improve or maintain hydration and supplementation. Thus, the potential benefits are likely to
thermoregulation, thereby preventing muscle cramps and be significant, with minimal to no risk. After immobiliza-
dehydration.55 When consumed during immobilization, tion and injury, a loading dose is recommended: 20-g (4 3 5
creatine had positive effects on muscle size and strength. g daily) loading dose for 5 days or a daily 5-g dose.63
Specifically, when compared with a placebo (PL), 20 g (4 3 This is followed by approximately 20 g per day in 4
5 g) per day of CrM consumed during 2 weeks of arm divided doses for 5 days and then 3 to 5 g per day thereafter
immobilization better maintained lean mass (CrM: þ0.9% to maintain elevated stores.
versus PL: 3.7%), strength (CrM: 4.1% versus PL:
21.5%), and endurance (CrM: 6.5% versus PL: 35%) in
Omega-3 (x-3) Fatty Acids
young healthy men.56 However, a similar supplement
strategy of 20 g CrM (4 3 5 g) versus PL during 2 weeks The potential benefits of the long-chain x-3 fatty acids
of leg immobilization had no effect in maintaining muscle eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid
duration and side effects of antibiotic therapy.86 The health the lack of direct data, the risk:benefit ratio of multivitamin
benefits of probiotics are strain specific and dose depen- use is low to moderate, with moderate benefit and few risks.
dent.87 The strands Lactobacillus acidophilus and Bifido-
bacterium longum have exhibited positive immune effects. TRAUMATIC BRAIN INJURY OR CONCUSSION
In addition, Bacillus coagulans improved protein absorp-
tion,88 which may be important for rehabilitation. The Traumatic brain injuries, including repetitive subcon-
recommended dose consumption of either strand is 1010 cussive injuries, cause a cascade of neurologic dysregula-
colony-forming units consumed in fermented foods such as tion.94 After a TBI, axonal damage, neuroinflammation, and
yogurt or as dietary supplements.89 Supplemental probiotics dysregulation of ions (Naþ, Kþ, Ca2þ) occur; the influx of
are likely to be more effective if stored in the refrigerator calcium (Ca2þ) leads to mitochondrial dysfunction and
and consumed daily on an empty stomach via high colony- oxidative stress that contribute to cellular damage.94
forming units containing at least the strains L. acidophilus Nutritional interventions have the potential to mitigate
and B. longum. symptoms of TBI; this area is ever expanding, with novel
treatments being reported frequently. Several groups95–97
Micronutrients determined that supplementation of x-3 fatty acids
decreased inflammation, cellular death, and damage to the
Vitamins and minerals are the most frequently consumed axons in rodent models. Although studies of x-3 fatty acid
dietary supplements. Unlike other supplements, vitamins supplementation after TBIs in humans are limited, the
and certain minerals are considered essential due to their recommended dose of 40 mg/kg/d (4 g for a 100-kg
roles in normal physiological function. Deficiencies in most individual) immediately after injury was effective in
micronutrients can be problematic and should be avoided, adults.94 In addition, curcumin at a dose of 100 mg/kg
especially during times of high stress. Due to the increased
containing 95% curcuminoids reduced neuronal apopto-
metabolic demands of recovery from injury and surgery,
sis,97 decreased oxidized proteins,98 and improved cogni-
increased emphasis on micronutrient intake may be
important. Specifically, vitamins A, C, and E have tion after concussive brain injuries.99 However, further
important roles in immunonutrition for injury recovery human research in healthy and clinical populations is
and wound healing.90–92 Vitamin A had positive effects on warranted.
wound healing even in a nondeficient state,91 whereas In addition to x-3s, CrM supplementation may improve
vitamin C supplementation was largely only beneficial in symptoms after a TBI. Brain creatine is reduced after a
patients with severe stress or injury.90 Vitamin E supple- TBI100; creatine supplementation may balance adenosine
mentation resulted in decreases in oxidative stress, thereby triphosphate stores and reduce the negative effects on
decreasing wound healing time.92 The major functions of energy status. In a recent review101 of healthy and clinical
these key vitamins and whole food sources are provided in populations, creatine supplementation of varying doses (4–
Figure 8. The Institute of Medicine Committee on Nutrient 20 g/d) enhanced brain creatine between 3% and 10%. A
Composition of Rations for Combat Operations recom- larger dose of 0.4 g/kg/d (32 g for an 80-kg person) for 6
mended that nutrients should be provided as whole foods months post-TBI improved cognitive function and de-
first, followed by fortified foods and a multivitamin dietary creased headaches, dizziness, and fatigue in children.102
supplement if an individual is having difficulty consuming Creatine monohydrate may improve symptoms of TBI by
the recommended daily amount of micronutrients via mitigating nerve damage, mitochondrial dysfunction,
whole-food sources.93 However, little information is oxidative stress, and inflammation101; however, further
available on the dose and frequency needed for these evaluation of these physiological mechanisms in humans is
supplements to be effective. Micronutrient intakes above essential to enable appropriate recommendations after
normal have not been shown to be more effective.3 Despite injury. Consumption of creatine monohydrate is low risk,
Address correspondence to Abbie E. Smith-Ryan, PhD, CSCS*D, Department of Exercise and Sport Science, University of North
Carolina at Chapel Hill, 209 Fetzer Hall, CB #8700, Chapel Hill, NC 27599-8700. Address e-mail to abbsmith@email.unc.edu.