Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cene A U2 VS
Cene A U2 VS
Luxury superbrands
N = Narrator, Int = Interviewer, MWC = Man in a white cap, MBC = Man in a blue cap,
DT = Dana Thomas
N: Fashion superbrands. They have the power to drive us crazy with desire. They've
invaded our wardrobes and our minds, these are the huge global organisations that
touch all our lives, and which have turnover in the billions. So what is the secret of their
power? How can, for example, a belt made by Gucci seem so different to a belt made
by Louis Vuitton?
Int: And you've got a Gucci belt, is there any – I mean, would you wear a Gucci belt?
MBC: I don't know, it just doesn't – for me it just doesn't, it's not smooth. I think Louis
Int: Right.
MWC: Yeah, I agree. Gucci's a bit more tackier - that's my look, man - it's a bit more tacky. I
like that.
MBC: Yeah.
Int: Well this, this was about eight quid this one, it's great, it's still keeping my trousers up,
in't it?
N: Known as The Pyramid Model, this is how luxury brands keep us hooked. At the top of
the pyramid, you have limited edition products for the very, very wealthy. In the middle,
you have well-made products that you can buy in store. And at the bottom, you have
the high volume money spinners: perfume, wallets, belts, scarves, umbrellas, key
chains, things aimed at the masses. And that's how they manage to appeal to
Hollywood stars and royalty at the same time as selling to the rest of us.
DT: It's a delicate balance of selling masses to the masses whilst still remaining exclusive
Int: So the top of the pyramid is, is where you build the image, where you build the, the
kudos, and then the rest of the pyramid is where you exploit it and turn it into cash.
DT: Exactly.
N: And, of course, the trick is to keep everyone's eyes firmly fixed on the top of the
pyramid.
World view
Sop = Sophie, Ju = Jurgen, K = Keith, Lu = Luis, C = Clare, Say = Sayful, Imo = Imogen
Sop: I think luxury brands encourage people to work for what they would like to spend their
money on, I know that I have an expensive taste in some ways, so I would like to work
hard and be able to afford the thing that I would really like to buy.
Ju: I don't necessarily think luxury brands are either good or bad, I just think they're a
waste of money. I tend not to buy luxury brands myself unless it comes to things like
food because I think it's important to eat healthily. But other than that electronics, cars,
K: I don't really trust, ah, luxury brands and maybe I don't really trust brands in general,
ah, because I think that, um, where you're talking about big brands I think companies
have often spent so much on the marketing to get to that position where they've got a
big brand, that they haven't spent quite as much on the product itself and on the quality
of the product.
So I'm not really, ah, a believer in brands and, and the idea of buying brands myself, I
think there's a very good quote about, um – ah, that kind of thing, ah, by a singer, and
I'm trying to remember who, who said the best firms advertise the least, and I think
Lu: I think luxury brands are good in some ways and bad in others. Good in the sense that,
um, it's great to get – innovations – of one kind or another, it's good to get the
economy going and getting those who can afford it to spend money and to recycle in
the economy.
Bad in the sense that people who can't afford it aspire to have luxury branded goods,
which in effect, ah, makes them spend a lot of money on some things that they may
not need. So from that point of view it's not a very good thing.
C: I think luxury brands are a good thing, I think it's really nice sometimes to treat yourself
to something a little bit special, um, I don't think they're an essential thing, I think good
old value packs are – have their place, um, but it is nice to treat yourself now and then
to something luxurious.
I like luxury brands, I like to treat myself now and then. But I don't think that they're
necessarily any better than the good old value packs, um, I'd buy a little bit of both, so
my orange juice might be value, but then my bread might be luxury. So I try to mix it up
Say: I think it affects, um, society in such a way that people look at each other, ah, with envy
and jealousy, um, wishing that they had something that they can't afford. Um, my own
attitude would be that I – if I can afford it, if I like something then I'll buy it, um, but
Imo: Um, personally I'm not a huge – but I'm not really into luxury brands in a big way but I
have friends who are and they say that it's terribly important and, um, I had a friend the
other week who was, we were talking about what one looks for in a partner she said,
“Oh if they don't wear the right trainers, I'm simply not interested” - which was baffling
to me, but, she explained it that, you know, this was a symbol of being into the same