Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 363

APPENDIX E

Republic of the Philippines


Palompon Institute of Technology
Palompon, Leyte 6538

MODULE
SCIENCE, TECHNOLOGY AND SOCIETY (STS)
GENERAL EDUCATION CURRICULUM 8 (GEC 8)
Course

Prepared by:
Ma. Lourdes B. Paloma
TABLE OF CONTENTS

Pages

Letter of Introduction

…………………………………………… i

Directions for Using the Module

…………………………………………… ii
Module Content

…………………………………………… ii

STS Module General Objectives

…………………………………………… iii

Course Syllabus: Course Overview and STS Course Outcomes

………. iv

Learning Plan

…………………………………………… vii

Chapter I – General Concepts and STS Historical Developments

……. 1

I. Module 1 – Topic: Historical Antecedents in which Social

Considerations

Change the Course of Science and Technology and

Intellectual
Revolutions that Defined society.

………………………… 4

I. Module 2 – Topic: Science and Technology in Philippine

Nation Building 22

Chapter II – STS and Human Condition

…………………………………... 42

II. Module 1 – Topic: The Human Person Flourishing in

terms of

Science and Technology and The Good Life

………. 45

Chapter III – Specific Issues in STS (Highlight of STS course )

………. 59

III. Module 1 – Topic: When Technology and Humanity Cross

…….. 62
III. Module 2 – Topic: The Information Age

…………………………… 77

III. Module 3 – Topic: Biodiversity and the Healthy

Society…………. 90

III. Module 4 – Topic: Genetically Modified Organisms

(GMO): Science, Health and Politics

……………………………………… 103

III. Module 5 – Topic: Gene Therapy ( Stem Cells)

…………………… 121

III. Module 6 – Topic: The Nano

World…………………………………. 138

Note: Midterm coverage - Chapter I and II modules, Chapter III.

Modules 1 and 2

or called packet 1: prelim coverage – Chapter I and II

modules
packet 2: midterm coverage – Chapter III.

Modules 1 and 2

Final coverage – Chapter III modules 3, 4, 5, 6

or called packet 3: semi-final coverage – Chapter III

modules 3, 4 and 5

packet 4: final coverage– Chapter III modules

6
Appendix Letter: Letter of Introduction

Science, Technology and Society (STS), is one of the

essential course in the General Education of tertiary education.

The course aims to develop appreciation and critical

understanding of the role of science and technology for the

development of people and the society. The module is constructed

specifically for an STS course to guide undergraduate students to

develop critical thinking as they use science in understanding

human conditions, social issues, science role in nation building,

scientific theories and ideas, innovations and research which is

brought by science to develop technologically.

The STS modules focus on the important topics which

relates to science, technology and society as a whole. It is


designed to get connected across different fields of knowledge

and to widen students view in global issues and concern. This

module is challenging and interesting. It is contained, vital and

the learning experiences in these modules would certainly

encourage students’ capability for lifelong learning, so that they

can face the challenges of the future with easiness and self-belief.

Ma.
Lourdes B. Paloma
Researcher

DIRECTIONS FOR USING THE


i MODULE
1. Every topic in the modules is very important, intensive

reading is needed as you go through these modules. Read the

objectives carefully for your own guidance.

2. Answer honestly the entry-test given in each topic. This is

done to give you an idea of your progress after taking the

entry-test in each lesson. Avoid guessing of answer.

3. After answering the entry-test, proceed to the lesson proper

of the module. You will find varied activities to do after

every part of the lesson. Make sure you work on them before

going to the next part. This will help you check your

understanding of the concepts being discussed. Once you are

through with the lesson, take the exit-test, checked your

answer against the correct answer in the answer key at the

last page. Place your score on the blank space provided.

Compare your scores. Is there an improvement from that of

your entry-test?
4. After completing the modules in each term period, submit it

on or before the set deadline and at the end of the semester

take the retention test provided by the teacher. If you find the

lessons or the activities difficult to understand, your teacher

is willing to help you, feel free to discuss this to your

teacher.

Module Content

The subject matter of the modules was divided into three

major chapters. The first chapter: General Concepts and STS

Historical Developments, second chapter: STS and Human

Condition while the third chapter: Specific Issues in STS.

Generally, the modules discuss the relationships between


ii

scientific and technological innovations and society, the

directions and risks of science and technology, the impact of

information and communication technologies, the study of how


social, political, and cultural values affect scientific research and

technological innovation and how science and technology affect

society politics and culture. It includes the introduction to the

history of Science and technology, its development and progress

and discusses the problems, doubts, issues in Science and

Technology.

The modules include varied activities, contains important

information, activities, and guide questions that will help students

in learning STS. Several new research and development in

science and technology since the last decades of the 20th century

is also included in the modules. Science, Technology, and Society

draws on popular issues in everyday life to elaborate the social

implications of science and technology.

STS Module General Objectives:


The STS Modules is design for individual and small group

learning and it requires individualize instructions, individual

guidance, personal reflection and individual efforts of the

learners. Students perform the role of a resourceful learner and

become independent thinkers. The following objectives are set to

help the students attain the basic concept of the course using this

modular approach in teaching STS.

At the end of each lesson in the modules the students will be able

to:

1. Understand the relationship between science, technology

and society.

2. Generate a better contribution to increase human

understanding of the world as an integrated whole.

3. Learn to make good use of modern technology, use it wisely

to improve the quality of life, but not to abuse or over-

relying on it or to the extent of destroying the environment.


4. Develop the capacity to construct knowledge through

enquiring contemporary issues which affect the world


iii
around us.

5. Identify the values underlying different views and

judgments, and apply critical thinking skills, creativity and

different perspectives in making judgments on issues and

problems.

Course Syllabus:

Course Overview

STS is an essential course in the General Education curriculum

for tertiary education. The course deals with interactions


ii

between science and technology and social, cultural, political, and

economic contexts. It is an interdisciplinary course hereby

engaged students to confront the realities of various scientific

issues and technological developments. Such realities pervade the


personal, the public, and the global aspects of our living and are

integral to human development. Scientific knowledge and

technological development happen in the context of society with

all its socio-political, cultural, economic, and philosophical

underpinnings at play. This course is design to develop deep

appreciation and critical understanding of the role of science and

technology in the society and will absorb reflective knowledge in

the students that they are able to live the good life and display

ethical decision making in the face of scientific and technological

advancement. This course includes mandatory topics on climate

change and environmental awareness. (CMO No. 20, series of

2013)
Course Units: 3 hours every week
iv for 18 weeks or 54 hours in

a semester

STS Course Outcomes

At the end of the course, students should be able to:

1. Broaden their theoretical and practical understanding of

STS as a course and as a field of study which leads the

students to be articulate about the impacts of science and

technology on society, specifically Philippine society.

2. Analyze the concepts, theories, principles, historical

events in science and its development in various

civilizations and the role of science in nation building

with emphasis on government programs and projects for

the advancement of science and technological capabilities

of the country.
3. Explain how science and technology affect society and the

environment, the impact of social media on the students’

life and Philippine society in general and analyze the

human condition in order to deeply reflect and express

philosophical ramifications that are meaningful to the

student as a part of society.

4. Develop scientific ideas, draws inspiration from the

physical and natural world and that society is always a

recipient of the positive benefits of science and

technology which will enhance their capabilities for self

employment or become a well competent skilled

professional in their field of specialization. (CMO No. 20,

series of 2013)
Knowledge v

1. Articulate the impacts of science and technology on society,

specifically Philippine society

2. Explain how science and technology affect society and the

environment and its role in nation-building

3. Analyze the human condition in order to deeply reflect and

express philosophical ramifications that are meaningful to the

student as a part of society

4. Define and demonstrate the impact of social media on the

students’ life and Philippine society in general.

Values
1. Imbibe the importance of science and technology in the

preservation of the environment and the development of the

Filipino nation

2. Critique human flourishing vis-à-vis the progress of science

and technology such that the student may be able to define for

himself/herself the meaning of the good life

3. Foster the value of a healthy lifestyle toward the holistic and

sustainable development of society and the environment.

Skills

1. Creatively present the importance and contributions of science

and technology to society.

2. Examine shared concerns that make up the good life in order

to come up with innovative and creative solutions to

contemporary issues guided by ethical standards


3. Illustrate how the social media and information age impact

their lives and their understanding of climate change. (CMO


vi
No. 20, series of 2013)

LEARNING PLAN

STS Intended Learning Outcomes

(based from CMO No. 20, series of 2013)

Chapter I: GENERAL CONCEPTS AND STS

HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENTS

I. Module 1– Topic: Historical Antecedents in which Social

Considerations

Change the Course of Science and

Technology

Objectives:

1. Discuss the interactions between S&T and society

throughout history
1.1Discuss how scientific and technological developments

affect society and the environment

1.2 Identify the paradigm shifts in history

2. Articulate ways by which society is transformed by

science and technology.

I. Module 2 – Topic: Science and Technology in

Philippine Nation Building

Objectives:

1. Discuss the role of Science and Technology in Philippine

nation

building

1.1 Evaluate government policies pertaining to science

and
technology in terms of their contribution to nation

building.

1.2 Identify actual science and technology policies

of the government and appraise their impact on the


vii
development of the Filipino nation

Chapter II: STS AND HUMAN CONDITION

II. Module 1 – Topic: The Human Person Flourishing and

the Good Life in

Terms of Science and Technology

Objectives:

1. Analyze the human condition in order to deeply reflect

and express philosophical ramifications that are

meaningful to the student as a part of society


2. Critique human flourishing vis-àvis the progress of

science and technology so


iv that the student can define for

himself/herself the meaning of the good life.

3. Examine shared concerns that make up the good life in

order to come up with innovative, creative solutions to

contemporary issues guided by ethical standards.

4. Examine human rights in order to uphold such rights in

technological ethical dilemmas

5. Evaluate contemporary human experience in order to

strengthen and enlighten the human person functioning in

society

Chapter III: SPECIFIC ISSUES IN STS (Highlight of the

STS Course)

III. Module 1 – Topic: When Technology and Humanity

Cross
Objectives:

1. Determine the different technological advancements in

the society

2. Discuss the effects of the interplay between technology

and humanity through the dilemma(s) they face.

III. Module 2 – Topic: The


viii Information Age (Gutenberg

to Social Media)

Objective:

1. Link learned concepts to the development of the

information age and its impact on Society.

1.1 Illustrate how the social media and the information

age have impacted our lives.

III. Module 3 – Topic: Biodiversity and the Healthy

Society
Objective:

1. Determine the interrelatedness of society,

environment, and health

III. Module 4 – Topic: Genetically Modified Organisms:

Science,

Health and Politics

Objective:

1. Discuss the ethics and implications of GMOs and

potential future impacts

III. Module 5 – Topic: Gene Therapy (Stem Cells)

Objective:

1. Describe gene therapy and its various forms.

1.1Assess the issue’s potential benefits and

detriments to
global health

III. Module 6 – Topic: The


ix Nano World

Objective:

1. Discuss the major impacts (both potential and

realized} of nanotechnology on society

1.1Analyze the issue through the concept of STS,

benefits to

society and critique the issue on its costs.


Chapter
x I

GENERAL CONCEPTS AND STS HISTORICAL

DEVELOPMENTS
Introduction:

This chapter aims to motivate the interest of the students to

study science and technology and how it affects the society. It

illustrates the great influence of science and technology in our

lives. Included in this chapter are the presentations of the

different contributions of some famous intellectuals, Filipino and

foreign scientist, inventors, psychologist and their revolutionary

ideas, scientific revolutions will be discussed to trace the history

of science, the influence of science and technology in Philippine

nation-building, government policies pertaining to science and

technology, concept of science education in the Philippines and


the concept of indigenous science and its contribution in the

development of science and technology in the Philippines.

Entry-Test (I. Module 1)

Score_______

To determine if you have the knowledge needed to enter

the module and check whether you have learned the lessons to

be taught.

Multiple Choice - Directions: Answer the following questions

based from your existing knowledge and write your best

answer in the blank before each number.

_____1. Which of the following is an example of science that is

both a body of knowledge and

process?
I. doing research III. believing in old

practices and tradition.

II. presenting a research IV. looking for a good

treatment for COVID 19

A.I, and II only B. I, II and III C. I, II, III and IV

D. IV only

_____2. Science give rise to the production of more fuel-efficient


2
Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments

vehicles. Does this benefits the

society?

A.Yes, fuels are needed in transportation.

B.No, fuels is not a part of the basic needs.

C.No, there is scarcity of fuels around the world.

D.Yes, majority of vehicles cannot function without fuels.


_____3. Which statement best describes technology?

A.Any physical object or device that changes society for

the better.

B.Using personal experience to complete a task or solve

a problem.

C.The completion of tasks or solving of problems using

indigenous method.

D.The application of scientific knowledge to create a

device that helps complete a task or solve a problem.


Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments I. MODULE 1 3

Topic: Historical Antecedents in which Social Considerations

Changed

the Course of Science and Technology

Overview:

Since the beginning of time, science and technology has

existed. Science and technology are interrelated. It affects

people’s lives and provides great influence in the society,

especially in ways of thinking and doing things. The contributions

of scientists and other intellectuals who provided revolutionary

ideas and dominant theories, the discoveries, inventions,


evidences and truths of their time were very useful in our world

today. Scientists are ordinary people doing extraordinary things,

some were sentenced to death, others were condemned by the

Church, some were never appreciated during their times but

despite of all predicaments and challenges they experienced they

never stopped experimenting, discovering new ideas and

knowledge, they are driven by their deep passion to know and to

discover. Scientific attitudes possess by the scientist makes

individual in the society develop interest in Science and

Technology, they become scientifically and technologically

literate, cope with the demands of this world shaped by science

and technology.

Keyterms:

Science, Technology, Society and Scientific

Revolution
Objectives:
Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 4

1. Discuss the interactions between S&T and society

throughout history

1.1Discuss how scientific and technological developments

affect society and the environment

1.2 Identify the paradigm shifts in history

2. Articulate ways by which society is transformed by

science and technology.

Read

How do we define science, technology and society?

The word "science", creates imaginary pictures like white

lab coats and microscopes, a textbook, a naturalist in the tropical


rainforest, Albert Einstein's equations scrawled on a chalkboard,

an astronomer look closely through a telescope, the launch of the

space shuttle, the bubbling beakers …. All these pictures reflect

some aspect of science, but science always interlinks with

technology and society. Science has a broad definition.

Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 5


Science is both a body of knowledge and a process. In school,

science may sometimes seem like a collection of isolated and

static facts listed in a textbook, but that's only a small part of the

story. Just as importantly, science is also a process of discovery

that allows us to link isolated facts into coherent and

comprehensive understandings of the natural world. Scientists

are motivated by the thrill of seeing or figuring out something

that no one has before.


Science is useful. The knowledge generated by science is

powerful and reliable. It can be used to develop new technologies,

treat diseases, and deal with many other sorts of problems.

Science is ongoing. Science is continually refining and

expanding our knowledge of the universe, and as it does, it leads

to new questions for future investigation. Science will never be

"finished."

Science is a global human endeavor. People all over the world

participate in the process of science. And you can too!

Technology is the human attempt to change the world by6 creating


Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments

products that can help people. It involves tools, techniques and

procedures putting the findings of science to something useful.


Example of technology are the following: cellphone, electric fan,

car, airplane, washing machine etc.

Society is a human interaction that includes on how to figure

things out and to make things. It is a group of individuals

involved in persistent social interaction, or a large social group

sharing the same geographical or social territory, typically subject

to the same political authority and dominant cultural expectations

Review Questions:

So what is the relationship between science and

technology?

Here is an example of interrelationship between

science and technology:

 Science is knowledge while technology is the

application of knowledge.
 Science explores for the purpose of knowing while

technology explores for the purpose of making

something useful from that knowledge.

 Engineers focus on using science to develop

products.

Activity:

 Based from the given example, create or describe your

own interrelationship between science and technology,

using at least two specific examples. Write your

answer in complete sentences. (minimum of three(3)

sentences only).

7
Read:Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments

Scientific Revolution
Scientific revolution refers to the rebirth (renaissance) or

new beginning of modern-day science, which encouraged

curiosity, investigation, discovery, modern day knowledge and

caused people to question old beliefs. During the era of Scientific

Revolution, people began using experiments and mathematics to

understand mysteries. New discoveries was made, some old

beliefs began to be proven wrong. It should not be seen as a

revolution in science but a revolution in thought and practice that

brought about modern science. It happened when developments

in various branches of studies, especially in biology, chemistry,

physics, math, astrophysics, completely transformed the way of

living.

Scientific Revolution took place during the 16th and 17th

centuries. It started in Europe. It is a new view of physical world,

nature emerged during the Scientific Revolution and

transformation of concepts, methods, and institutional approaches


to the natural world happened that are recognizable in modern

science.
What is an example of a scientific revolution?

Thomas Kuhn is an American physicist and philosopher who

presented his concept of a paradigm shift in his influential book

The Structure of Scientific Revolutions (1962), according to

Kuhn (1962), scientific revolution is a paradigm change also

called a paradigm shift, is a fundamental change in the basic

concepts and experimental practices of a scientific discipline.

Some Intellectuals and their Revolutionary Ideas


The following contributions of some intellectuals will give

us more ideas, knowledge, provide examples and explanations

about scientific revolution, the paradigm shift of science and

technology.

Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 9

Nicolaus Copernicus
One of the best examples of a paradigm shift in science is

the Copernican Revolution (1543). Copernicus is a renaissance

mathematician and astronomer (1473-1543), who formulated a

heliocentric model of the universe which placed the sun, rather

than the earth, at the center of the universe. He was the first who

suggested that the Earth was not stationary in the center of the

universe but was revolving around the Sun, not considered as the

first modern astronomer but as the last of the great medieval

astronomers. This caused the paradigm shift of how the earth and
Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 10

sun were placed in the heavens/universe. It is the idea that

rejected Ptolemaic model (earth is the center of the solar system)

and proved the heliocentric model (Sun is the center of the solar

system having the earth revolving around it.) The Copernican

Revolution, or the paradigm shift from the Ptolemaic model of

the heavens to the heliocentric model with the sun at the center of

the solar system, began with the publication of Copernicus’s De


revolutionibus orbium coelestium, and ended with Newton’s work

over a century later. Being in a risky and unsafe theory in the

past, but still this theory was adapted in the modern science and

exploration was done. The theory the Sun-centered planetary

system called the Copernican heliocentrism, the name given to

the astronomical model developed by Nicolaus Copernicus and

published in 1543. It positioned the sun near the center of the

universe, motionless, with Earth and the other planets rotating

around it in circular paths, modified by epicycles and at uniform

speeds.

Copernicus is a brave man, even though the Copernican

model still a theory accepted today, during those times in the 16 th

century, it was judged to be heretic and therefore it was an

unacceptable idea to be taught to Catholics and banned the

Copernican model and was ignored by Rome.


Thomas Kuhn's book the Structure of Scientific Revolutions

(1962), inspired chiefly by the Copernican revolution (which he

made the subject of an earlier book) Kuhn developed a theory

about the nature of scientific progress based upon radical

innovations that mark a revolutionary disruption from earlier

thinking. Kuhn's influence has been greatest among philosophers

and sociologists of science concerned with understanding the

nature of scientific innovation and advance, but his ideas were

directly inspired by and modeled upon the historiography of the

scientific revolution.

Charles Darwin and Sigmund Freud revolutionary ideas

Charles Darwin

 Darwin is a geologist and naturalist from the 19th century.

Darwin published his book “The Origin of Species” in 1589.

Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 11


His theory of the origin of species consisted of two main

points; 1) diverse groups of animals evolve from one or a

few common ancestors; 2) the mechanism by which this

evolution takes place is natural selection. This book was

banned because it completely contravened the Christian

religion of the time, and was thought as blasphemy.

 Charles Darwin is famous for his theory of evolution, “The

Natural Selection”. He joined a five-year voyage through the

HMS Beagle on the Islands of Galapagos to study nature.

Natural selection is the process through which populations of

living organisms adapt and change. Individuals in a

population are naturally variable, meaning that they are all

different in some ways, this variation means that some

individuals have traits better suited to the environment than

others. It is the differential survival and reproduction of

individuals due to differences in phenotype (the physical and


psychological characteristics of an organism from both

genetics and environment, or a group of organisms having

like traits.). Natural Selection is the key mechanism of

evolution.

 Darwin introduced the book, “The Descent of Man” which

create or start the idea of all organic life, including human

beings, under the realm of evolutionary thinking. This book

is one of the most important works in scientific literature.

Sigmund Freud

 Freud is a famous figure in the field of psychology. He

developed an important method to gather reliable data to

study human’s inner life. This method is popularly known as

the method of Psychoanalysis. His method was remarkable-

focusing on human sexuality and the evil nature of man. It is

defined as a set of psychological theories and therapeutic


12
Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments
techniques that have their origin in the work and theories of

Sigmund Freud. The core idea at the center of

psychoanalysis is the belief that all people possess

unconscious thoughts, feelings, desires, and memories.

Sigmund Freud's psychoanalytic theory of personality argues

that human behavior is the result of the interactions among

three component parts of the mind: the id, ego, and

superego.

Darwin, Darwinism, and Psychoanalysis

Cengage Updated July 20, 2020

In 1859, when Charles Darwin published The Origin of

Species, Sigmund Freud was three years old. As a young student

and later, during his early years as a dedicated scientific

researcher, Freud greatly admired Darwin, who had gained

considerable popularity throughout Europe. In his


Autobiographical Study, Freud would recall that "Darwin's

doctrine, then in trend, was a powerful attraction, since it

promised to provide an extraordinary thrust to understanding the

universe". Freud cites Darwin at least twenty times in his

published writings.

The first Darwin is the Darwin of The Expression of the

Emotions in Man and Animals (1872), referred to by Freud in the

Studies on Hysteria (1895d), one of the principles laid claim to

by Darwin to explain the expression of the emotions—the

principle of the overflow of excitation as Darwin has taught."

Consisting "originally of acts that are well-motivated and

appropriate," This sort of reference occurs several times,

especially in Inhibitions, Symptoms, and Anxiety (1926d), where


Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 13
the affects are "reproductions of earlier events is important, a

preindividual." Adaptation is involved since "anxiety must fulfill


the biologically essential function of reacting to a state of danger.

Therefore, the theory of Freud about anxiety presented in this

work is considered to be of Darwinian origin. Emotion (anxiety)

is adaptive in two ways, for it prepares the animal for danger not

just by mobilizing energy but also by aiding adjustment based on

the nature of the threat (signal anxiety).

The second Darwin is the Darwin of The Origin of Species

(1859). This is the influence that is most often noted. It is used to

support Freud's views when he postulates a correspondence

between phylogenesis (humanity's evolution since its origins) and

ontogenesis (the individual development of the child of today).

Freud writes, "Important biological analogies have enabled us to

acknowledge that individual psychic evolution repeats, the

evolution of humanity". Freud writes, "The phylogenetic schemas

that the child possesses at birth . . . are the precipitates of the


history of human civilization . . . this instinctive heritage would

constitute the core of the unconscious."

The third and final Darwin is, the Darwin of The Descent of

Man (1871), a work that postulated a process of continuous

evolution from animal to man and distinguished stages within

human evolution, that is, a temporal sequence that was also a

form of progress, a hierarchy ranging from the most primitive

forms to the most noble: lower animals, higher animals, the

"savage," civilized man. Darwin distinguished between "inferior"

human races and "superior" races, even superior nations (such as

Great Britain). Like many others at the time, Freud accepted these

ideas and used them to support his views on the progress of

civilization. This notion of the evolution of civilizations remains a

source of continued interest until now.

Scientific Revolution in Various Parts of the World


Development of Science in Mesoamerica

1. Maya Civilization- Maya civilization lasted for

approximately 2000 years, these people are known for their

works in:

a) They are the first people to produce rubber products.

b) Astronomy: Mayan incorporated their advanced


Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 14
understanding of astronomy into their temples and other

religious structures. Example: The “El Castillo pyramid at

Chichen Itza” is situated at the location of the sun during the

spring and fall equinoxes. Mayan knowledge and

understanding about celestial bodies was advanced for their

times. In predicting eclipse they use astrological cycles in

planting and harvesting.

c) The Mayan Calendar System: Mayan is known for

measuring time using two complicated calendar systems. It


is useful for their life especially in planning activities and

observing religious rituals and cultural celebration.

d) Mayan Heiroglyphics – writing system of Mayan. Mayan are

considered one of most scientifically advanced societies in

mesoamerica.

e) They are skilled in mathematics. Created number system

based on the numeral 20. Developed the concept of zero and

positional value.

f) They built hydraulics system with sophisticated waterways.

g) Mayan built looms for weaving cloth.

h) They devised rainbow of glittery paints made from mineral

called Mica.

See video in the link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?

v=qhWItvjk9Yg

2. Inca civilization: These people are famous for their works in:
a) Road paved with stones e. First suspension

bridge

b) Stone buildings f. Inca textiles

c) Irrigation System g. Quipu, knotted

ropes to keep records

d) 12 months calendar

3. Aztec civilization: These people were also known for15their


Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments

works in:

a. Mandatory education e. Chinampa- agricultural

farming

b. Chocolates which land is divided

into

c. Antispasmodic medication rectangular areas and

canals

d. Aztec calendar f. Invention of the canoe


Development of Science in Asia

Asia is the the biggest continent in the world. It is considered

as the home of ancient civilization. The host of many scientific,

cultural, economic and political activities of all ages.

India

a) India was known for manufacturing iron and in

metallurgical works. Their iron steel is considered to be the

best and held with high regard in the whole of Roman

Empire.

b) Ayurveda, a system of traditional medicine is still practiced

as a form of alternative medicine. Susruta Samhita,

describes different surgical and other medical procedures.

c) Standardized the measurement of length to a high degree of

accuracy and designed a ruler, the Mohenjodaro ruler.


d) Aryabhatiya, introduced a number of trigonometric

functions, tables, and techniques as well as algorithms of

algebra. Explained the use of zero as both a placeholder and

a decimal digit, along with the Hindu-Arabic numeral

system.

China

a) China discovered various medical properties and uses of

different plants and animals to cure human illness. An


Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 16
example is the practice of acupuncture.

b) Other Discoveries and inventions of China: compass,

papermaking, gunpowder and printing tools, iron plough,

wheelbarrow, propeller, design a of different models of

bridges, invented the first seismological detector, developed

a dry dock facility.


c) In Astronomy China made significant records on

supernovas, lunar and solar eclipses and comets and uses

lunar calendars.

Middle East Countries

a) Ibn al-Haytham is also regarded as the Father of Optics,

especially for his empirical proof of the intromission Theory

of Light.

b) Muhammad ibn Musa al-Khwarizmi gave his name to the

concept of the algorithm while the term algebra is derived

from al-jabr, the beginning of the title of one of his

publications.

c) Jabir ibn Hayyan is the Father of Chemistry.

d) Ibn Sina pioneered the science of experimental medicine and

was the first physician to conduct clinical trials. His two most
notable works in medicine, the Book of Healing and The

Canon of Medicine were used as standard medicinal texts.

Africa

a) Egypt was known to be the center of alchemy, which is known

as the medieval forerunner of chemistry.

b) Egypt tried to study human anatomy and pharmacology and

applied important components such as examination, diagnosis,

treatment and prognosis for the treatment of diseases.

c) In Astronomy, Egypt developed the three types of calendars:

lunar, solar, and stellar.


Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 17
d) They invented metal tools used in their homes, in agriculture

and in building their magnificent architectures.

e) Lebombo Bone-a tool for multiplication, division, and simple

mathematical calculation or a six month lunar calendar, is

considered to be the oldest known mathematical artifacts.


Review Questions:

1. What were the contributions of Copernicus, Darwin and

Freud to modern science?

2. During the Scientific Revolution, how did scientists and

the people around the world approach problems during

this time and what were their contributions to scientific

thinking and knowledge?

3. Now in modern time or what we call in modern

science? Do you think the church should intervene in

scientific activities?

Related Articles/ Video clips/STS Website/Film Clips:

 Balakrishnan, Janaki and BV Sreekantan (2014). eds. Nature’s

Longest Threads: New Frontiers in the Mathematics and

Physics of Information in Biology, World Scientific.

 Dayrit, Fabian (2011). “Sustainable Development: An

Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 18


Evolving Paradigm for the 21stCentury,” in Stellar Origins,

Human Ways: Readings in Science, Technology, and Society,

ed. Ma. Assunta Cuyegkeng, Quezon City: Ateneo de Manila

University Press,

 Video: Stephen Colbert’s interview with Neil Tyson,

https://www.youtube.com/watch

 Youtube: World’s Greatest Inventions/Philippine Great

Inventions

 http://www.history.com/topics/enlightenment/videos/

mankind-the-story-of-all-of-us-scientific-revolution

 https://www.youtube.com/watch, Flow of History - How to

Play - YouTube

Activity:

Directions: Answer the following questions briefly in a

paragraph form.
f)

g)

1. Discuss how modern life is made possible by the Scientific

Revolution.

2. If Copernicus, Darwin and Freud were still alive, what do

you think are the major changes (paradigm shift) they would

make to their theories?

3. At present time, do you think thought experiment is still

useful?

4. Scientific Revolution was a threat to religious authorities in

16th century? Imagine that you are Copernicus or Darwin or

Freud. Would you deny what you believed to be true?

Assessment/Evaluation:
Exit-Test (I. Module 1)

Score_______

Multiple Choice - Directions: Choose the best answer and

write your answer in the blank before each number.

___ 1. Science give rise to the production of more fuel-efficient

vehicles. Does this benefits the

society?

A.Yes, fuels are needed in transportation.

B.No, fuels is not a part of the basic needs.

C.No, there is scarcity of fuels around the world.

D.Yes, majority of vehicles cannot function without fuels.

Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 19


_____2. Which of the following is an example of science that is

both a body of knowledge and


process?

III. doing research III. believing in old

practices and tradition.

IV. presenting a research IV. looking for a good

treatment for COVID 19

B.I, II, IV B. I and II only C. III and IV only

D. I, II, III, IV

_____3. Which statement best define technology?

A.Any physical object or device that changes society

for the better.

B.Using personal experience to complete a task or

solve a problem.

C.The completion of tasks or solving of problems

using indigenous method.


D. The application of scientific knowledge to create a

device that helps complete a task or solve a

problem.

References:

Bisht, R. (1982). “Excavations at Banawali: 1974-77.” In Possehl,

Gregory L. (Ed). Harappan Civilization: A contemporary

Perspective. New Delhi: Oxford and IBH Publishing Co.

Bose, M. (1998). Late Classical India. A. Mukherjee & Co.

Craig, B. & Walter, D. (2000). “Clinical Pharmacology in the

Middle Ages: Principles that Presage the 21 st century.”

Clinical Paharmacology & Therapeutics. 67 (5): 447-450

Gribbin, J. (2003). Science: A history. London, UK: Penguin

Books.
Jacquart, D. (2008). “Islamic Pharmacology in the Middle Ages:

Theories and Substances. “European Review. Cambridge:

Cambridge University Press. 16:219-27.

Joseph, G. (1991). The Crest of the Peacock. London: Penguin

Kuhn, Thomas S.; Hacking, Ian (2012). The Structure


20 of
Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments

Scientific Revolutions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

p. iv. ISBN 978-0-226-45812-0.

Kuhn, Thomas S. (1962). “The Structure of Scientific.

Revolutions”. Second Edition, Enlarged. VOLUMES I AND

II • FOUNDATIONS OF THE UNITY OF SCIENCE. 1962.

https://www.lri.fr/~mbl/Stanford/CS477/papers/Kuhn-SSR-

2ndEd.pdf

Needham, J. (1986). “Science and Civilization in China.” In

mathematics and the Sciences of the Heavens and the Earth.

3.208.
Needham, J., Wang, L. & Lu, G. (1971). “Science and

Civilization in China.” Cambridge, UK: Cambridge

University Press.

Philosophy of Science (Encyclopedia)Scientific Progress,

Scientific Revolutions

Ritvo, Lucile B. (1990). Darwin's influence on Freud: a tale of

two sciences. New Haven: Yale University Press.

Sarma, K. (2008). “Astronomy in India. “Encyclopaedia of the

History of Science, Technology and Medicine in Non-Western

Cultures” (2nd Ed.) Berlin: Springer Science & Business

Media.

Warren, J. (2005). “War and the Cultural Heritage of Iraq: A

sadly Mismanaged Affair. “Third World Quarterly. 26 (4-5):

815-830

Weiner, E. (2016). The Geography of Genius: Lessons from the

World’s Most Creative Places. New York: Simon & Schuster.


Lecture and. Discussion. •

http://www.flowofhistory.com.readings. • Flowcharts/revival-

west/the-age- enlightenment. • http://hti.osu.ed/scientific

revolution/lesson

The Copernican

Revolutionhttps://courses.lumenlearning.com/boundless-

worldhistory/chapter/the-scientific-revolution

Darwin, Darwinism, and Psychoanalysis | Encyclopedia.com

https://www.encyclopedia.com/psychology/dictionaries-
21
Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments

thesauruses-pictures-and-press-releases/darwin-darwinism-

and-psychoanalysis

Natural Selection | National Geographic Society

https://www.nationalgeographic.org › encyclopedia › natural-

s Oct 24, 2019

The Origin of Species, Charles Darwin - BANNED BOOKS

wcbannedbooks.weebly.com › the-origin-of-species-charl
How Psychoanalysis Influenced the Field of Psychology

www.verywellmind.com ›
22
Entry-Test (I. Module 2)
Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments

Score_______

To determine if you have the knowledge needed to enter the

module and check whether you have learned the lessons to be

taught.

Multiple Choice - Directions: Answer the following questions

based from your existing knowledge and write your best

answer in the blank before each number.

______1. Which of the following statement describe development

of a country?

I. The acceleration of economic growth

II. Reduction of inequality

III. Eradication of absolute poverty

IV. Degradation of environment


A.I and II only B. II and IV only C. I, II, III

D. IV only

______2. The following statement are the description of a nation

building. Which of the choices

is best suited to the term nation building?

A. A masonry construction C. Infrastructures

B. Peoples development D. Countries new

buildings

I. MODULE 2
Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 23
Topic: Science and Technology in Philippine Nation

Building

Overview:

Science and technology had a major influence on society.

Science influences society through its knowledge. Scientific

knowledge used by scientists influence the way individuals in

society think about themselves, others, and the environment. The

effect of science on society is neither entirely beneficial nor

detrimental. Science and Technology is coupled with modernity

and it is an important tool for rapid development. Modernization

in every aspect of life is the greatest example of the

implementation of science and technology in every nation. At

present, some countries are classified as developed and

developing countries. The major classification is based on


economy and the application of science and technology.

Countries which have a strong base in science and technology are

the ones that developed faster. Science and technology has made

life a lot easier and also a lot better with the advancement of

medicines, development in education, communication,

agriculture, industry etc.

In spite of the advancements in almost all sectors, the world

is not free from disease, hunger, pollution, poverty and illiteracy.

The gap between the rich and the poor has widened. The right

applications of research, development, and implications of

science and technology can create difference in the society. As

citizens of the nation, each one has an equal responsibility24 for the
Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments

growth. The youth with all possible facilities for their research,

needs support from the government and motivation, the future of

the nation lies in their hands and they are the hope of every nation
to be more advance and professionally equipped with the

knowledge of science and technology.

In the Philippines, Science and Technology had experienced

periods of rapid growth as well as long dormant periods. Social

influences has a big impact on the direction and emphasis of

scientific and technological development, through groups

pressure on specific issues and commonly accepted social views,

priorities and values.

Keyterms: Nation building, Indigenous knowledge Systems,

Indigenous science, Non-Indigenous science.

Objectives:

1.Discuss the role of Science and Technology in

Philippine nation

Building
1.1 Evaluate government policies pertaining to science

and

technology in terms of their contribution to nation

building.

1.2 Identify actual science and technology policies of

the

government and appraise their impact on the

development of the Filipino nation.

Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 25


Read:

What is nation building?

Nation is a country with group of people living in

certain territory under one government while the term

building is not the masonry construction but development.

Nation building is country's development or the

development of a nation, especially one that has recently

become independent. Science and Technology influence

the development of the Philippines as a nation. The


growth of science and its development in the Philippines

were based from the ideas of indigenous people and

foreign countries.

Brief History of Science and Technology in the Philippines

Precolonial Times:

During the precolonial times, Filipinos were already

engaging in activities and practices related to science

forming primitive or first wave technology. The early

inhabitants of the archipelago had their own culture and


26
traditions. They have their own belief system and indigenous
Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments

knowledge which keeps them organized and sustained their

lives and communities for many years.

Stone age - Philippines history of science and technology

can be traced as early as the Stone age. During 3,000 B.C.

they were producing adzes ornaments of seashells and


pottery. Asian mainland modern man first came over land on

across rigid channels to live in Batangas and Palawan about

48,000 B.C. They formed settlement in Sulu, Davao,

Zamboanga, Samar, Negros, Batangas, Laguna, Rizal,

Bulacan and Cagayan. They made simple tools and weapons

of stone flakes and later developed method of sawing and

polishing stones.

Metal Age - Third century B.C. to 11th century A.D. -

Filipinos were engaged in extraction, smelting and refining

of iron from ores, then cast the iron. The metals were used as

tools, weapons, for agriculture and domestication purposes.

They made Gold and Silver jewelry. They learned to

cultivate lowland rice and dike fields of terraced fields

utilizing spring water in mountain regions, they plant crops

that provide them food and learned the medicinal uses of

some plants, they take care of animals for food production,


learned to weave cotton, make glass ornaments and also

learned to build boats called Caracoa for trading purposes.

Caracoa is a refined plank built warships suits for inter

island trade raids. They have also interpreted the movements

of heavenly bodies to predict seasons and climates. They

learned how to trade with other countries.

Colonial Times: The Spanish period

Galleon Trade (1565 to 1815) – The galleon trade influence

the changes of culture, language and environment for both

Filipinos and Spaniards. Before the Spaniards came to the

Philippines, Filipinos were already trading with Japan,

China, India, Cambodia, Moluccas, Siam and Borneo. In


Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 27

1789, Manila was opened to Asian shipping, inaugurating an

era of increase in export of rice, hemp, tobacco, sugar,

indigo, and they also import manufacturing goods. Manila

became the center of commerce in the East. The country


became one of the centers of global trade in SEA. The

society promoted cultivation of indigo, cotton, cinnamon,

and silk industry.

18th Century – The Spaniards set up schools and initiate the

concepts of subjects and disciplines. The Spaniards

established colleges and universities in the Philippines. They

introduced the formal education and founded scientific

institution. Medicine and advanced science were introduced

in formal colleges and universities. In 1871 the school of

medicine and pharmacy were opened to UST, after 15 years

it had granted the degree of Licenciado en Medicina to 62

graduates. Science learning focuses on the different concepts

of the human body, animals and plants while technology

focuses on developing house tools. The Filipinos learned to

replicate technology using indigenous materials. Catholic

schools were established, teaching religion, reading, writing,


music and arithmetic. More advanced methods of agriculture

and sanitation were also taught. Catholic doctrines, practices

and superstitious beliefs stop the progress of science in the

Philippines.

American Period

19th Century – The Americans reorganized science learning.

In basic education, science focuses on sanitation and nature

studies until this became a subject formally known as

“Science”. Science teaching in higher education greatly

improved. Aside from science concepts they also introduced

the English language. The used of English language

Instruction and American history, lead to the formation of


Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 28
Filipino nationalism and national identity. Public education

system, improved engineering works and health of the

people. The country had a difficult time to rebuild itself due

to the damages and destruction caused by World War II.


Filipinos struggles to survive and rebuild the country but the

capacity of the country to recover what was destroyed was

limited and weak.

The New Republic

Using the limited resources in improving S&T (Science and

Technology) capability. The Use of ODA or Overseas

Development Allocation to improve scientific productivity

and technological capability and human resource

development focusing on producing more scientists,

enginneers technology experts, doctors and other

professionals were needed in the country. The development

of S&T is shaped by several factors and influences. The

Internal Influences such as survival, culture, economic

activities while External Influences are the Foreign

Colonizers, Traders with Foreign Countries, International

Economic demands.
Government Policies on Science and Technology in Philippine

Nation Building

The government of the Philippines introduced and

implemented programs, projects and policies to boost science and

technology. The goal is to prepare the whole country and its

people to meet the demands of a technologically driven world and

indulge the people to live in a world driven by science. In

response of the ASEAN 2015 Agenda, the NRCP remains

committed as an advisory council to the Philippine national

government for basic sciences. The NRCP recommends policies

and programs that will help to improve and prepare the

Philippines in meeting the ASEAN 2015 Goals. The Council

focuses on basic research as the foundation of scientific

development and to recognize Philippines as truly competitive


Southeast Asian region where everyone work together under one

vision, one community and one ASEAN identity.

The four NRCP clusters gave policy recommendations that

should form part of the overall ASEAN 2015 agenda.

Cluster I (Social Sciences, Humanities, Education, International


Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 29

Policies, and Governance) recommended

(1) integrating ASEAN awareness in basic education without

adding to curriculum,

(2) emphasizing teaching in the mother tongue,

(3) developing school infrastructure and providing for ICT

broadband,

(4) local food security, (

5) harnessing indigenous knowledge systems and practices;

Cluster II (Physics, Engineering and Industrial Research, Earth

and Space Sciences, and Mathematical Sciences) recommended


(1) emphasizing degrees, licenses, and employment opportunities,

(2) outright grants for peer monitoring,

(3) review of RA 9184, and

(4) harnessing science and technology as independent mover of

development;

Cluster III (Medical, Chemical, and Pharmaceutical Sciences)

recommended

(1) ensuring compliance of drug manufacturing firms with

ASEAN harmonized standards by full implementation of the

Food and Drugs Administration,

(2) creating an educational council dedicated to standardization of

pharmaceutical services and cares.

(3) empowering food and drugs agencies to conduct evidence

based research as pool of information,

(4) allocating two percent of GDP to research, and

Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 30


(5) legislating a law supporting human genome project; and

Cluster IV (Biological Sciences, Agriculture and Forestry, and

Veterinary Medicine) recommended

(1) protecting and conserving biodiversity by full implementation

of existing laws,

(2) use of biosafety and standard model by all ASEAN countries,

(3) promoting indigenous knowledge systems and indigenous

people’s conservation, and

(4) formulation of common food safety standard.       

Other Fields of Science and Technology that Contribute to

Philippine Identity and Nation Building

 Department of Science and Technology (DOST)


 Philippine Atmospheric, Geophysical and Astronomical

Services Administration (PAGASA)

 Philippine Institute of Volcanology and Seismology

(PHIVOLCS)

 Philippine council for Agriculture, Aquatic, and Natural

Resources Research Development (PCAARRD)

 The National Engineering Center (NEC) was first

established on January 29, 1978 as the research arm of the

University of the Philippines College of Engineering.

 The Food and Nutrition Research Institute (FNRI) was

established as the principal research arm of the Philippine

government.

 National Integrated Research Program on Medicinal Plants

(NIRPROMP) - Mandated to distribute inexpensive


Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 31

medicine to the poor, propagate the use of herbal


preparations with proven medicinal efficacy and identify

scientifically validated medicine to improve the

pharmaceutical industry. On 1995, NIRPROMP isolated

vitex negundo (commonly known as lagundi), as a natural

source for developing an effective herbal medicine.

 The Philippine-American Academy of Science and

Engineering (PAASE)

 Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics

(STEM). The current K to 12 education program, one of the

major tracks in the senior high school program to encourage

more students to enrol in science-related fields.

 The Philippine-California Advanced Research Institutes

(PICARI), the newly launched project of the Commission on

Higher Education to allow institutions in the Philippines and

some US-based laboratories, research institutes and

universities to work on research and projects related to


science, agriculture, engineering, health and technology. The

project is hoped to strengthen the STEM competitiveness of

the country.

Various laws related to science and technology was

created by the Philippine Congress. These laws will serve as

a legal framework and varies according to different themes

such as: health-related, conservation, supporting basic

research and technology-building among others. Some laws

are in line with international treaties such as United Nations

Educational Scientific and Cultural Organization

(UNESCO), United Nations (UN) and Association of

Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) and other international

agencies. Science and technology policies, programs and

projects need to be aligned to national goals, international


treaty, legal frameworks and respond to various needs, issues

and problems.

The Department of Science and Technology (DOST) is


Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 32
the agency that manage and responsible for science and

technology. Numerous national scientists have contributed in

different fields of science. The Filipino scientists are:

 Fe del Mundo - in the field of Pediatrics

 Eduardo Quisumbing - in the field of Plant taxonomy

 Gavino Trono - in the field of tropical marine

Phycology

 Maria Orosa - in the field of Food technology and many

more

Lee-Chua (2000) identified ten (10) outstanding Filipino

scientists who are recognized and made significant


contributions here and abroad. They have made outstanding

contributions in different science disciplines: biology,

agriculture, chemistry, marine science, medicine,

mathematics, engineering and physics.

The Filipino Scientist are:

i. Ramon Cabanos Barba –research on tissue

culture of Philippine mangoes

ii. Josefino Casas Comiso – observed the

characteristics of Antarctica by using

satellite images

iii. Jose Bejar Cruz Jr. – officer of the famous

Institutes of Electrical and Electronic

Engineering

iv. Lourdes Jansuy Cruz – notable research on

sea snail venom


v. Fabian Milar Dayrit – research on herbal

medicine

vi. Rafael Dineros Guerrero – research on

tilapia culture

vii. Enrique Mapua Ostrea Jr. – invented the

meconium drugs testing

viii. Lilian Formalejo Patena – research on plant

biotechnology
Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 33

ix. Mari-Jo Panganiban Ruiz - educator and

graph theorist

x. Gregory Ligot Tangonan – research on

communication technology

Other outstanding Filipino scientist here and

abroad are:

 Edgardo Gomez and Angel Alcala – famous

scientist in marine science


 Caesar A. Saloma – an internationally

renowned physicist

 William Padolina – Chemistry related

research and president of National Academy

of Science and Technology (NAST)-

Philippines

Many Filipino scientist were inspired by noble and

great teachers, they were able to establish themselves as

scientists and as science educators in different fields of

science. Innovations and inventions were done by these

scientists. The global demands and ASEAN economic

agenda prompted the Philippines to invest in science and

technology programs.

The Role of Science and Technology in the Society


1. Change and modify the way people live with

profound effects on economic development.

2. It is a solution to the problem that leads to

development through scientific revolutions that

support economic advances, education,

improvements in health systems, communication

and infrastructure. The technological revolutions

of the 21st century are rising, based 34on bio-


Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments

technology, gene therapy, genetic engineering,

telecommunications, micro-processors and nano-

technology etc. Products are transforming business

practices across the economy.

Review Questions:

1. What are the important contributions of Spaniards and


Americans to science and technology in the

Philippines?

2. What can you say about the implementation of science

and

technology policies in the country?

3. What are the significant contributions of the Filipino

scientist to

the development of science and technology in the

country?

Read:

Science Education in the Philippines

Science Education links to technology and industry, which is

a national perspective, are areas of high priority for development.

Science education deals with the teaching and learning to develop

science literacy. It develops students’ scientific inquiry skills,


values and attitudes, such as objectivity, curiosity, honesty and

critical thinking. All these are useful to the students for his

personal development, future career, and life in general. The

learning of science is also important for the nation’s cultural

development and preservation of its cultural identity. Science is

very useful to a nation when it is utilized to solve its own

problems and challenges.

Science Schools in the Philippines

The Manila Science High School (MaSci) was established in

1963. It was the first science high school in the country. It was

patterned after the Bronx Science High School of New York.

1963 was when the first batch that entered the pilot science
35 high
Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments

school graduated. It started in 1959 with 36 students.

In 1964, the Philippine Science High School System

(PSHSS) was established. It was under the Department of Science

and Technology (DOST). The premier science high school in the


country, it is considered among the top science high schools in

ASEAN. Aside from its main campus in Diliman, Quezon City, it

has 12 other regional campuses in the Philippines.

Special Science Elementary Schools(SSES) Project- is in

pursuance to DepEd Order No. 73 s. 2008 and DepEd Order No.

51 s. 2010. This project started in June 2007 with 57 identified

elementary schools that participated or were identified as science

elementary schools in the country.

Manila Science High School – is the first science high

school in the Phil. The Manila Science High School Admission

Test (MSAT)

Central Visayan Institute Foundation - is the home and

pioneer of the prominent school-based innovation known as the

Dynamic Learning Program (DLP). The school takes pride in its

Research Center for Theoritical Physics (RCTP).


Review Question:

How does science school form science and

technology in

the Philippines?

Read:

Indigenous Science and Technology in the Philippines

Indigenous Knowledge Systems

Indigenous knowledge Systems is also referred to as “local”

or traditional knowledge. It was the knowledge that communities

have developed themselves for centuries and allowed them to live

in their environment for often long periods of time. Indigenous


36
Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments

knowledge is a set of perceptions, information and behaviors that

guide local community members in terms of how to best use their

natural resources. The local knowledge or traditional wisdom that

is unique to a culture or society, which is passed from generation

to generation, usually by word of mouth and cultural rituals. This


is large body of knowledge and skills developed outside formal

education, the knowledge that a local community accumulates

over generations of living in a particular environment which

includes technologies, know-how, skills, practices and beliefs that

enable a community to achieve a stable and sustainable

livelihood. Such body of knowledge and skills is unique to a

particular people. It shaped decision making in all domains of life

including food preservation, folk astronomy, in health like using

herbal medicine, education, child rearing, natural resource

management, and in agriculture such as classifying the different

types of soil for planting, producing wine and juices from fruits,

keeping the custom of growing plants and among others.

Many different terms are used to refer to this indigenous

knowledge (IK). It is commonly known as Traditional Ecological

Knowledge (TEK), other terms are local knowledge, rural

peoples’/farmers’ knowledge, ethnobiology, ethnobotany,


ethnozoology, ethnoscience, folk science and indigenous science.

UNESCO says that these many terms coexist because the wide

range of social, political and scientific contexts have made it all

but impossible to for a single term to be suitable in all

circumstances. UNESCO has recognized the importance of

Indigenous Knowledge Systems, that it launched the Local

Indigenous Knowledge Systems (LINKS) Project in 2002. The

LINKS Project focuses on this interface between local &

indigenous knowledge and the Millennium Development Goals of

poverty eradication and environmental sustainability.

Indigenous Knowledge Systems Quote

“To the early Native people, education was a part of

everyday life. Their books were the rocks, the rivers and

lakes, the trees and roots, the sun, the moon and the stars. It
Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 37

was from these elements that they fashioned their material

culture. Creative life was in everything. One loved nature


and nature loved in return. The people believed in only one

Supreme Being, The Creator, whose mighty power governs

and directs the beginning and end of all things.” (Harold

Flett)

Indigenous science incorporates traditional knowledge and

Indigenous perspectives, is essentially the cumulative body of

knowledge associated with ecological relationships, which is

handed down through generations by Indigenous people. It is the

knowledge system that embraces community knowledge, skills,

attitudes and technologies with a particular community. The

source of knowledge is often derived from culture and history.

Such knowledge reflects information and behaviors originate

from local knowledge and wisdom.

Throughout history, Indigenous people also called local or

original people who have been responsible for the development of

many technologies like the tools and built structures, herbal


medicine and observed heavenly bodies etc. have substantially

contributed to science. These are examples of indigenous science,

which is the foundations of modern science. Non-Indigenous

scientific or the modern science approaches are commonly

recognized as Western science. The Philippine Constitution, in

recognition of this diversity and under the framework of national

unity and development, mandates state recognition, protection,

promotion, and fulfillment of the rights of Indigenous

Peoples(IPs). Further, Republic Act 8371, also known as the

“Indigenous Peoples Rights Act” (1997, IPRA), recognized the

right of IPs to manage their ancestral domains; it has become the

cornerstone of current national policy on IPs.

Review Question:

What are examples of indigenous science

practices?
Related Articles/ Video clips/STS Website/Film Clips:38
Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments

Philippine Great Inventions, https://www.youtube.com/watch

Filipino Great Men and Women, https://www.youtube.com/watch

“Philippines Then and Now”, https://www.youtube.com/watch

Indigenous Knowledge, Ecology, and Evolutionary Biology by

Raymond Pierotti. Routledge, 2011.

“What tradition teaches: Indigenous knowledge complements

western wildlife science” by Paige M. Schmidt and Heather K.

Stricker. USDA National Wildlife Research Center – Staff

Publications, 2010.

Activities:

Answer the following questions briefly.

1. Review the history of science in the

Philippines and make a timeline highlighting


the major discoveries and development in

science. Starting from pre-colonial time to

new republic period.

2. Discuss major science-related issues and

problems in the country this year 2020 and

identify science and technology policies that

could be adapted or implemented that will

help in solving the issues and problem.

3. Identify Filipino indigenous knowledge

(share at least one).

Assesment/Evaluation
Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 39
Exit-Test (I. Module 2)

Score_______

Multiple Choice - Directions: Choose the best answer and

write your answer in the blank before each number.

______1. The following statement are the description of a nation

building. Which of the choices

is more suited to the term nation building?

A. A masonry construction C. Infrastructures

B. Peoples development D. Countries new

buildings

______2. Which of the following statement describe development

of a country?

I. Reduction of inequality

II. Degradation of environment

III. Eradication of absolute poverty


IV. The acceleration of economic growth

A.I and II only B. II and III only C. I, III and IV

D. IV only

References:

Amboloto, D. J. (n.d.). Major contributions of science and

technology to Philippine nation-building? Retrieved February

27, 2019.

Caoli, O. (1986). “A History of Science and Technology of the

Philippines,” in Analysis of Conditions for National Scientific

and Technological Self-Reliance: The Philippine Situation,


Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 40

Quezon City: University of the Philippines.

Estrado, A. (2018). Science and Technology and Nation Building.

Retrieved on February 27, 2019.

Despi, L. (2014, March 26). Brief history of science, and

technology. Retrieved on February 27, 2019.


Devaney, E. (2018, April 25). List of Tools & Weapons From

Stone, Retrieved on February 27, 2019.

https://doi.org/10.1080/07341512.2015.1126022

Flett, H. (2008). "Customs and Beliefs."

http://www.nald.ca/CLR/chikiken/titleiii.htm>.

Hickel, J.“Forget ‘developing’ poorcountries, it’s time to ‘de-

develop’ rich countries,”The Guardian, Online:

http://www.theguardian.com/global-development-

professionals-network/2015/sep/23/developing-poor-

countries-de-develop-rich-countries-sdgs

Trademarks, Utility Models (2013, September 20). National

Integrated Research Program on Medicinal Plants. Retrieved

on February 27, 2019.

Galleon Trade: Philippine History

www.philippine-history.org/galleon-trade.htm
https://www.ibmastery.com/blog/indigenous-knowledge-systems-

notes-theory-of-knowledge

Chapter II
Chapter 1: General Concepts and Sts Historical Developments 41

Science, Technology and Society and the Human Condition


Introduction:

This chapter focused on human flourishing, human condition

and how to live a good life. Science has given man the chance to

pursue societal concerns such as ethics, education, justice and to

create cultures. Every nation requires development of each

individual living in the society. Humans are the most intelligent

among all living things, awareness of the environment is

necessary for them to live, such as the passage of time, can

remember the past and imagine the future, and are aware of their

own life. Only human beings are known to ask themselves

questions relating to the purpose of life, the nature of their

existence? like Why I am here? Why I was born? etc., their

struggle to find answer to these questions is the way to improve

the human condition. Humans need socialization to interact with


the people in the society and this is one of the most important

aspects of life. So, social life in a particular community is

necessary for a man to flourish as a human being, this enables

science and technology to develop and flourish making one’s own

country to prosper.

Entry-Test

Score_______

To determine if you have the knowledge needed to enter

the module and check whether you have learned the lessons to

be taught.

Multiple Choice - Directions: Answer the following questions

based from your existing knowledge and write your best

answer in the blank before each number.


_____1. Which of the following activities is most likely to

promote students' understanding of

the concept of cause and effect in science?

A.using leaves and a taxonomic key to identify the types

of trees present near the school


Chapter II: Science, Technology and Society and the Human Condition 43

B.recording the time it takes for bean seeds to germinate

when given different amounts of water

C.creating cross-sectional models of the Earth with clay to

illustrate the thicknesses of different layers

D.tracking the daily high and low temperatures of two

nearby cities during a three month period

_____2. Some societies have different views on the use of

technology. Which technological concern would most likely

be the most important for the people living in this planet

Earth?

a. Looking for ways to obtain fresh water from the Earth.


b. Looking for ways to minimize earthquake occurrence.

c. Looking for ways to prevent the occurrence of typhoon.

d. Looking for ways to prevent tsunami.

_____3. According to Aristotle, “Eudaimonia” is usually

translated as happiness, but a better

translation is _____.

a. Pleasure b. Morality c. Truth d.

Fulfillment

Chapter II: Science, Technology and Society and the Human Condition 44
II. Module 1

Topic: The Human Person Flourishing and the Good Life in

Terms of

Science and Technology

Overview:

Eudaimonism (or Eudaemonism or Eudaimonia) is a

moral philosophy that defines right action which leads to the

"well-being" of the individual and having essential value. Greek

philosopher, were practicing virtues over their lifetime and

exercised practical wisdom to resolve dilemmas or conflicts.

Aristotle, is a renowned Greek philosopher, who invented logic,

defended reason, focused on reality, and stress the importance of

life on earth. The concept of Eudaimonia were based from

Aristotle's "Nicomachean Ethics", which dates from the 4th


Century B.C., described "eudaimonia" a classical Greek word,

generally translated as "happiness", but perhaps better described

as "well-being (morality)" or "human flourishing" or "good life".

According to Aristotle, a rational and productive self-actualization

which should manifest honesty, pride, friendliness, wittiness,

rationality in judgment and scientific knowledge makes each

individual in the society to flourish and attain good life.

Keyterms:

Human flourishing, Eudaimonia, Human condition and

Good life

Objectives:
1. Analyze the human condition in order to deeply reflect

and express philosophical ramifications that are

meaningful to the student as a part of society.

2. Critique human flourishing vis-àvis the progress of

science and technology so that the student can define for

himself/herself the meaning of the good life.

3. Examine shared concerns that make up the good life in

order to come up with innovative, creative solutions to

contemporary issues guided by ethical standards.

4. Examine human rights in order to uphold such rights in

technological ethical dilemmas.

5. Evaluate contemporary human experience in order to

strengthen and enlighten the human person functioning in

the society.

Read:
Human Flourishing

Human flourishing also called personal flourishing is the

normal use of one's potential, including abilities, talents, values

and virtues in search of his freely and rationally chosen goals.

Human flourishing is a moral accomplishment and a fulfillment

of human capacities. An action is considered to be proper if it

leads to the flourishing of the person performing the action. Self-

actualization is a moral growth which enables man to achieve. To


Chapter II: Science, Technology and Society and the Human Condition 46

live morally one must have virtues and values. The important

virtues of man such as integrity, independence, rationality,

justice, honesty, courage, productiveness, pride and

trustworthiness must be applied, although each person varies in

attaining self-actualization. Human flourishing is the reward of

the virtues, values and happiness done by individual in the

society.
Self-direction is the use of one's reason, freedom in decision

making, sense of worth and happiness. Respect for individual

freedom is important to human flourishing. This leads to the

personal direction of one's life, including the use of his talent,

capacities, and energies which are necessary for the possible

attainment of human flourishing. Self-realization of a man is not

the same as the other. In terms of actual achievement such as

choice of career, education, friends, home, and others, varies from

person to person. Human flourishing becomes real when one uses

his practical reason to consider his situation, his unique needs,

competence and so on.

Human knowledge contributed much to science and

technology. How man uncovered the secrets of the universe,

answers all the questions of his existence and leads man to its

future direction were all science knowledge. Man’s role as


caretaker of the mother earth uses his self worth and importance

as part of the universe. Man’s flourish, through hardwork with the

application of values and virtues, makes man to be creative,

skilled and resourceful. So, man was able to developed

technology. Through technology which is a human activity, it

makes man excel in science and are the evidences of science

achievements. Human flourishing goal is relevant to science and

technology. The goals of both science and technology and human

flourishing are related, that goodness leads to reality, truth,

achievement and development of science and technology. 

     

Scientific Procedures, Techniques and Criterion in Science

Scientific Methods and Results

Scientific method is a step by step process on how to gain

and apply science knowledge. In school the scientific method is

Chapter II: Science, Technology and Society and the Human Condition 47
introduced in the earlier part of the discussion for

experimentation and research. Science will search for the truth

with enough facts and evidences. Scientists applied the steps of

scientific method and possess scientific attitudes in finding the

truth, in their inventions and discoveries. This was done to

preserve science reputation, science claim for objectivity and

systematic methodology.

OBSERVATION - using the five senses, unexplained

occurrences can be determined.

IDENTIFY THE PROBLEM – Identify the problem of the

study and the factors involved.

FORMULATE A HYPOTHESIS – Make a guess answer to

the problem based from experiences. Explain the said

phenomenon. The goal is to reject the null hypothesis and

accept the alternative hypothesis for the study “to count


significant”, “to generate prediction or to infer from past

experiments”.

EXPERIMENTATION – by setting the control and

experimental set-up, the dependent and independent

variables and trying to see how independent ones affect

dependent ones.

GATHER AND ANALYZE DATA –will analyze the study

if the data gathered are significant enough to conclude

results.

FORMULATE CONCLUSION AND PROVIDE

RECOMMENDATION – make a generalization of the final

result and make suggestions for further or to broaden the

study.

Throughout history, there is a heavy objection of

scientific procedures which separate science and the so

called pseudoscience. Pseudoscience includes beliefs,


theories, or practices that have been or are considered

scientific, but have no basis in scientific fact. This could

mean they were disproved scientifically, can't be tested

scientifically, or lack evidence to support them.

Verification Theory

The earliest criterion that distinguishes philosophy

and science is verification theory. The idea proposes that a

discipline is science if it can be confirmed or interpreted in

the event of an alternative hypothesis being accepted. It

only takes into account those results which are measurable

and experiments which are repeatable. This is promoted by

the movement in the early twentieth century called the

Vienna Circle, a group of scholars who believed that only

those which can be observed should be regarded as


meaningful and reject those which cannot be directly

accessed as meaningless.

Falsification Theory

Falsification theory asserts that as long as an

ideology (beliefs or philosophy) is not proven to be false

and can be best explain a phenomenon over alternative

theories, we should accept the said ideology. Karl Popper is

known proponent of this view, he state that the theories of

the time, such as Sigmund Freud’s Psychoanalysis, are not

testable and thus not falsifiable and questioning the theories

status as scientific. There is no assurance that observable

event or evidences are indeed manifestations of a certain

concept or “theories”. Falsification method is prone to the

same generalizations committed by the verification method.

There is no known rule as to the number of instance that a

theory is rejected or falsified in order for it to be set aside.


Similarly there is no assurance that observable events or

evidences are indeed manifestations of certain concept or

theories, even though theoretically, falsification method is

more accepted, scientists are still not convinced that it

should be regarded as what makes a discipline in science.

A new school of thought on the differentiation of science


Chapter II: Science, Technology and Society and the Human Condition 49
criterion emerged. Since, the methodologies previously

cited were questionable.

1. Science as a Social Endeavor= Several philosophers such

as Imre Lakatos, Paul Thagard, Helen Longino, David

Bloor and Richard Rorty among others presented the new

view which science and technology generally benefits

society.

2. Science and Results= Science is able to produce results,

its not entirely foolproof, such that it is correct 100% of


the time but religion, luck and human randomness are

some of its contemporaries in the field. It can be then

concluded that science does not take over the claim for

exact results.

3. Science as Education=government must provide holistic

education by assuring that other non-science courses are

covered, proficiency in science and mathematics are the

primary condition to be admitted.

Review Questions:

1. Is our appreciation of science justified?

2. Do we consider technology as human flourishing?

Read:

Human Condition Before Common Era

The human condition includes the totality of 50


human
Chapter II: Science, Technology and Society and the Human Condition
experience and the way of living. The ongoing way in

which humans react to or cope with these life events is the

human condition. The term is also used to describe the joy,

fear and other feelings or emotions associated as human

being and his existence.

People’s lifestyle in the past and those who are living in

the present all have different views what it means to

flourish, primarily due to the kind of environment people

live in that particular period. Ancient people were contented

with their relationship with nature, they rely on the

environment. Assessment of the environment is needed to

know if possible human flourishing happened in the past.

Since, there are major changes in peoples way of life and

awareness of the environment, it can be inferred that there

are also major changes in people’s actual human condition.

These changes were due to some factors but basically it was


brought about by science and technology.

The scientific revolution was carried out by intellectual

who wants to gain more knowledge in experimentation. The

experimental ideal of thinking was recognized, the ideal

thinking that represents what we call now “modern

science.” Aristotle’s views of science aimed at truth and

assurance while modern science aims at the most reasonable

explanations of experimental data. Currently, for example,

we have theories or laws about gravitation and evolution

that are widely accepted as true.

Technology relies on science but the changes in

technology, from indigenous science to modern science, the

revolutionary development of science and technology came

about by connecting practical know-how and technique to

newly emerging scientific theories. Procedures and

technique evolved into three interrelated disciplines, the


scientific research, applied science, and technology as we

know today. Technology produced a lot of inventions used

by the society. The discoveries in science and inventions in

technology, imply others to think that history itself might be

progressive. That is, wars and disease may be the only

temporary hindrance in the continuous progress in the

human condition.

The Human Condition In the Common Era

Human existence includes several events that


51 are
Chapter II: Science, Technology and Society and the Human Condition

considered basic to normal human beings, like events in

life, from infancy to adulthood, education, profession,

special celebrations, health condition, death and so on. One

of the saddest events in life is health condition which leads

to death. In most developed countries, improvements in

medicine, which increases life expectancy, in education,

literacy rate increase and public health have brought about


remarkable changes in the human condition. Humans of

today are much better compared to humans in the past. With

the introduction of modern gadgets in every walk of life,

life has become more comfortable and this is possible only

because of implementing science and technology together.

Without having modern equipment’s in all sectors, in

medicines, infrastructure, electricity, information

technology or any other field, the advancement and benefits

that we face today would not have been possible without

science and technology. Human condition greatly improved

in terms of using technology which makes the way of living

easier.

Modern humans nowadays relied on technology. They

find ways from nature to ultilize and achieve growth for

betterment. In terms of growth humans view the world as a

field of resources but there is danger by too much reliance


52
Chapter II: Science, Technology and Society and the Human Condition
on technology. Humans lose track of things that matter.

Today we are much more doubtful about what science and

technology can do for human condition. People must live

with biological weapons, deadly invasive species like

viruses and nuclear bombing, which is becoming available

to more nations throughout the world and we have yet to

solve the technological problem of de-radiating the waste

from nuclear power plants. People are bombarded with

economic pressures to buy whatever technology has

produced—despite higher risks to our health and to the

environment. Humans valuation to life is one sided, geared

towards technology for more consumption which is believe

would lead to good life but people are trying to make sense

of their existence in the world but technology does little to

aid them in their pursuit of life’s meaning on how to live

with true happiness, a good life.


Review Questions:

Can you live without technology?

Read:

Happiness as the Goal of a Good Life

The ancient Greek philosophers were pretty much

obsessed with the idea of a good life. Their whole way of

life was organized around ideas about what makes human

life “good” or “noble” or “worthwhile.” According to

Aristotle, human beings have a natural desire and capacity

to know and understand the truth, to pursue moral

excellence, and to initiate their ideals in the world through

action.  For Aristotle, the individual human action of using

wealth is what constitutes the economic dimension. The

purpose of economic action is to use things that are

necessary for life (i.e., survival) and for the Good Life (i.e.,
flourishing). The Good Life is the moral life of virtue

through which human beings attain happiness.

John Stuart Mill – declared the Greatest Happiness

Principle by saying that an action is right as far as it

maximizes the attainment of happiness for the greatest

number of people.

Materialism – the first materialists were the atomists in

Ancient Greece. Democritus and Leucippus led a school

whose primary belief is that the world is made up of and is

controlled by the tiny indivisible units in the world 53called


Chapter II: Science, Technology and Society and the Human Condition

atomos or seeds. In terms of human flourishing, matter is

what makes us attain happiness.

Hedonism – the hedonists, see the end goal of life in

acquiring pleasure. Pleasure has always been the priority of

hedonists. For them, Life is about obtaining and indulging

in pleasure because life is limited. The mantra of this school


of thought is the famous, “Eat, drink and be merry for

tomorrow we die.”

Stoicism – Another school of thought led by Epicurus, the

stoics espoused the idea that to generate happiness, one

must learn to distance oneself and be apathetic. The original

term, apatheia, precisely means to be indifferent. For stoics,

happiness can only be attained by careful practice of apathy.

In this worldview, adopt the fact that some things are not

within our control. The sooner we realize this, the happier

we can become.

Theism – The ultimate basis of happiness for theists is the

communion with God. The Philippines as a predominantly

Catholic country, is witness to how people base their life

goals on beliefs that hinged on some form of supernatural

reality called heaven.

Humanism – The humanism is another school of thought


espouses the freedom of man to carve his own destiny and

to legislate his own laws, free from the shackles of God that

monitors and controls. For humanist man is literally the

captain of his own ship, humanist see themselves not

merely as stewards of the creation but as individuals who

are in control of themselves and the world outside them.

This is the spirit of most scientists who thought that the

world is a place and space for freely seeking for ways on

how to improve the lives of its inhabitants.

MAN OF THE WORLD – Modern Man

The human actions are voluntary and intentional, it

follows that action requires the prior internal mental acts of

deliberation and choice. Human beings seek to fulfill


54
their
Chapter II: Science, Technology and Society and the Human Condition

perfection via action. Observing that human nature has

capacities pertaining to its dual material and spiritual

character. The highest or most general good to which all


individuals should aim is to live most fully a life that is

proper to man. The proper function of every person is to

live happily, successfully, and well. This is done through

the active exercise of a man's distinctive capacity,

rationality, as he engages in activities to the degree

appropriate to the person in the context of his own

particular identity as a human being.

Review Questions:

1. What is the best way for a person to attain happiness?

Related Articles/ Video clips/STS Website/Film Clips:

 Macat Thinking News. (2016). Aristotle’s Secret to

Happiness: What Will Make Us Happy

Now? Accessed February 3, 2017.


https://wwwmacat.com/blog/aristotles-secret-

Happiness/.

 Heidegger, Martin. (1982). The Question Concerning

Technology and Other Essays, Harper & Row

 Thagard, P. (1978). “Why Astrology is a Pseudoscience.”

PSA: Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the

Philosophy of Science Association 1978: 223-234

 Film: Akiro Kurosawa’s Dreams “Village of the

Watermills”

Activity:
Chapter II: Science, Technology and Society and the Human Condition 55

Answer the following questions briefly in

paragraph form.

1. What is the most important goal every person should


have to flourish? Do we consider technology as part of

human flourishing?

2. In modern science, what is the role of technology in

human condition?

3. What does it mean to live a good life?

4. What is the relationship between science and technology

to good life?

Assesment/Evaluation:

Exit-test: (II. Module 1)

Score_________

Multiple Choice -Directions: Choose the best answer and

write your answer in the blank before each number.


_____1. According to Aristotle, “Eudaimonia” is usually translated

as happiness, but a better

translation is _____.

A.Pleasure B. Morality C. Truth D.

Fulfillment

_____2. Which of the following activities is most likely to

promote students' understanding of

the concept of cause and effect in science?

A.using leaves and a taxonomic key to identify the

types of trees present near the school


Chapter II: Science, Technology and Society and the Human Condition 56
B.recording the time it takes for bean seeds to germinate

when given different amounts of water

C.creating cross-sectional models of the Earth with clay

to illustrate the thicknesses of different layers.


D.tracking the daily high and low temperatures of two

nearby cities during a three month period.

_____3. Some societies have different views on the use of

technology. Which technological concern would most

likely be the most important for the people living in this

planet Earth?

A.Looking for ways to prevent tsunami.

B.Looking for ways to obtain fresh water from

the Earth.

C.Looking for ways to minimize earthquake

occurrence.

D.Looking for ways to prevent the occurrence of

typhoon.
References:

Feynman, Richard. (1999). “The Pleasure of Finding Things Out:

What Is and What should be the role of scientific culture in

modern society” inThe Best Short Works of Richard Feynman, pp.

97–115, Perseus Books.

Floridi, Luciano. (2014). The FourthRevolution: How the

Infosphereis Reshaping Human Reality,Oxford University

Press.

Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy. (n.d.). John Stuart Mill.

Accessed February 3, 2017.http://www.iep.utm.edu/mill-eth.


Chapter II: Science, Technology and Society and the Human Condition 57
Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy. (n.d.). Renaissance Humanism.

Accessed February 2, 2017. http://www.iep.utm.edu/humanism?

Gripaldo, Rolando. (2009). “The Concepts of the Public Good: A

View from the Filipino Philosopher” in The Making of a Filipino

Philosopher and Other Essays, pp. 82-100, National Bookstore.

Hickel, Jason. (2015). “Forget ‘developing’ poorcountries, it’s time to


‘de-develop’ rich countries,”The Guardian, Online:

http://www.theguardian.com/global-development-professionals-

network/2015/sep/23/developing-poor-countries-de-develop-rich-

countries-sdgs.

Lehrer, Jonah. (2010). How We Decide, Mariner Books,

Maboloc, Christopher Ryan. (2010). “Eudaimonia and Human

Flourishing”in Ethics and Human Dignity, 15-23, Rex Bookstore.

McNamara, Daniel J. (2011). “A Return to the Beginning,” in Stellar

Origins, Human Ways: Readings in Science, Technology, and

Society, ed. Ma. Assunta Cuyegkeng, Quezon City: Ateneo de

Manila University Press.

Rodriguez, Socorro M. (1996). “Philippine Science and Technology:

Economic, Political and Social EventsShaping Their

Development.”

Thomson, J.A. (2003). The Nicomachean Ethics. London: Penguin

Von Baeyer, Hans Christian, Information: The New Language of


Science, Harvard University Press, 2005.

58
Chapter III
Chapter II: Science, Technology and Society and the Human Condition

Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society


Introduction:
This chapter focused on specific issues that greatly affect

human beings. Each person in the society is directly or indirectly

affected by technology whether he likes it or not. Most people

survived in their everyday lives with great reliance to the different

technological advancements already available to the masses.

Technology is already an inevitable part of the society.

Entry-Test (III. Module 1)

Score_______

To determine if you have the knowledge needed to enter

the module and check whether you have learned the lessons to

be taught.

Multiple Choice - Directions: Answer the following questions

based from your existing knowledge and write your best answer

in the blank before each number.


____ 1. Robotic technologies is needed in our society for a

variety of reasons. Which of the following statement express the

importance of Robotic technologies?

I. Develop machines just for display

II.Develop machines that can substitute for humans.

III. Develop machines that can replicate human actions.

IV. Develop machines with computer system as their

control.

A.I and II only B. II and III only C. II, III and IV

D. IV only

____ 2. The following are the “prime directives” that Robocop

has been programmed to obey without questions, which

apply the three laws of Asimov. Which of these is not

included?
A. Serve the public trust C. Protect the

Innocent
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 60

B. Uphold the law D. Kill the

murderer

____ 3. Robots can be used in many situations and for lots of

purposes, but TODAY the robots are placed in a risky type

of environment to do an important task and mission. Which

is not considered a risky type of environment for the robot?

A. Home as small toys for kids.

B. Factories for manufacturing processes.

C. Outer space, or where humans cannot survive (e.g. in

space).

D. Dangerous environments (including bomb detection

and deactivation)
____ 4. Which of the following statement is NOT considered as

ethical dilemmas faced by technological advancements such

as cellphones, computer, laptops and television?

A. Gadgets or digital addiction and alienation.

B. The devise are primarily used for communication.

C. The devise can make the person lazy and unhealthy

D. Moral dilemmas, freely exposed to information

which is not suited for young age.

____ 5. Scientists creates robot to perform an essential task.

Which of the following statement

best describes the use of robotics?

A.Robotics requires you to read.

B.Robots are design for movies.

C. Robotics is about innovating healthy

foods.
D. Robotics produces robots and machines

to make one’s work easier.


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 61

III. Module 1

Topic: When Technology and Humanity Cross

Overview:

The word “technology” came from the Greek words techne

and logos which mean art and word, combining the two words

together, technology means a discourse on arts (Buchanan, 2010).

It first appeared in the seventeenth century where the concept was

used to talk about applied arts. As technology developed,

additional meaning was used where art is no longer the topic but

concepts like machines and tools were also involved to the word

“technology”. People nowadays relie on technology, the different

technological advancements already available in the society. It


would not be possible to exist if it were not from the brilliant

mind of the scientists. Can we say that technology is a necessity

or want? Is it for convenience, pleasure, happiness or

communication? Anything too much is bad. Different ethical

dilemmas related to the use of technological devices, misuse or

overuse create different problem, some inventions produce bad

results. This topic will discuss about the importance of

technology, the ethical view, how the technological devices must

be properly initiated and its effects to the lives of people.

Keyterms: Technology, Technological advancements, Ethical

dilemmas and Robotics

Objectives:

1. Know the different technological advancements in the

society;
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 62
2. Discuss the effects of the interplay between technology and

humanity through the dilemma(s) they face.

Read:

Television Sets, Mobile Phones, Computers and Humanity

One of the most commonly used appliances is Television.

According to Kantar Media, in 92 percent of urban homes and 70

percent of rural homes own at least one television set. Households

with television set reached 15.135M (Noda, 2012). Television

plays a great role in the lives of the people. Paul Gottlieb Nipkow

in the late 1800s, was very successful in his attempt to send

images through wires with the aid of a rotating metal disk

(Nipkow disk) “electric telescope” – 18 lines of resolution. Alan

Archibald Campbell-Swinton and Boris Rosing developed a new

system of television by using the cathode ray tube in addition to

the mechanical scanner sytem.


How about Mobile Phones, Filipinos love to use their mobile

phones anywhere, anytime. More than half of the Filipino

population own at least one mobile phone regardless (ABS-CBN

News, 2010 of type. Mobile phones are considered a must-have

among young Filipinos) 1 out of 3 Filipinos cannot live without a

mobile phone. Computers and Laptops on the other hand, are not

possible for all Filipino families to own at least one computer or

laptop. Most profits gained by computer and laptop


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 63
manufacturers come from offices, businesses, or schools.

Growing number of Internet users in the Philippines, has

problems regarding the Internet providers. Facts about Filipinos

and their use of gadgets and the Internet: Mobile phone

subscription is at 119M, 3.2 hours on mobile and 5.2 hours on

desktop daily, Philippines has one of the highest digital

populations in the world 47M active FB accounts, Fastest-

growing application in the market. There are ethical dilemmas


experienced and observed by people while using these device or

gadget which has a negative impact to society.

Some Ethical Dilemmas by these Technological Advancements

a. Most parents would argue that these devices make

their children lazy and it’s unhealthy.

b. People are freely exposed to different things on

televisions, mobile phones, laptops or computers.

Review Questions:

1. Should there be a limit to technological

advancements despite the ethical dilemma we are

facing?

Read:

Robotics and Humanity


Robotics deals with the design, construction, operation, and

use of robots, as well as computer systems for their control,

sensory feedback, and information processing. These

technologies are used to develop machines that can substitute for

humans and replicate human actions. A robot, is an actuated

mechanism programmable in two or more axis with a degree of

autonomy, moving within its environment, to perform intended

tasks. Autonomy is the ability to perform intended tasks based on

current state and sensing without human intervention.

Roles played by Robotics: Ease the workload of mankind,

make life more efficient and less stressful, perform complicated

activities, pleasure, entertainment in parks or exhibits, child-


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 64

friendly toys and used in movies.

Some Ethical Dilemma/s faced by Robotics

1. Safety - Who should be held accountable if someone’s safety

is compromised by a robot? Who should be blamed, the


robot, the agent using the robot, or the maker/inventor of the

robot?

2. Emotional component - It is not completely impossible for

robots to develop emotions. What if robots become

sentiment? Should they be granted robot rights?

History of Robotics

Who is the father of robotics? Engelberger is widely known

as the father of the modern robotics industry Engelberger worked

closely with inventor George Devol, licensing patents and

developed the first industrial robot in the United States under the

brand name “Unimate.”

The Word “Robot” Originated in a Czech Play in 1921:

Discover Karel Čapek’s Sci-Fi Play R.U.R. (a.k.a. Rossum’s

Universal Robots). The word robot conjures all of these


associations in science fiction: from Blade Runner’s replicants to

Star Trek’s Data. We might refer to these particular examples as

androids rather than robots. Our language has forgotten that

robots started in sci-fi as more human than human, before they

became Asimov-like machines. Like the sci-fi writer’s

pronunciation of robot, “ro-butt”, the word originated in Eastern

Europe in 1921, the year after Asimov’s birth, in a play by Czech

intellectual Karel Čapek called R.U.R., or “Rossum’s Universal

Robots.” The title refers to the creations of Mr. Rossum, a

Frankenstein-like inventor. Čapek told the London Saturday

Review after the play premiered that Rossum was a “typical

representative of the scientific materialism of the last [nineteenth]

century,” with a “desire to create an artificial man—in the

chemical and biological, not mechanical sense.” As technology

analyst and Penn State professor John M. Jordan writes at the

MIT Press Reader, Čapek’s robots were not appliances or


sentient, nor trusty, super powered sidekicks. They were, in fact,

invented to be slaves. The robot… was a critique of

mechanization and the ways it can dehumanize people. The word

itself derives from the Czech word “robota,” or forced labor, as

done by serfs. Its Slavic linguistic root, “rab,” means “slave.”

The original word for robots more accurately defines androids,

then, in that they were neither metallic nor mechanical.

What are the principles of robotics? One is that robots are

computerized. But the household robot in the Jetson’s as well as

the robot toys of the 1960’s were basically pre-computer. So

while there are some general characteristics that describe a robot

and principles of robotics that are used to teach how to make

robots. Below were some of the principles of Robotics:

 Mechanical device

 Mobile

 Performs at least one function (or task)


 Has human or animal characteristics

 Has a sensor to detect environmental conditions

 Computerized with a CPU or microprocessor

Take note that there are exceptions that you might add on the

principles of robotics that is missing. But the majority of

robots built today will have all or most of these 6 principles

mentioned.

Roboethics: The Human Ethics Applied to Robots

By Susan Fourtané

September 22, 2019

Who or what is going to be held responsible when or if an

autonomous system malfunctions or harms humans? 


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 66
In the 1940s, American writer Isaac Asimov developed the Three

Laws of Robotics arguing that intelligent robots should be

programmed in a way that when facing conflict they should remit

and obey the following three laws: 


 A robot may not injure a human being, or, through inaction,

allow a human being to come to harm 

 A robot must obey the orders given it by human beings

except where such orders would conflict with the First Law

 A robot must protect its own existence as long as such

protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law

Isaac Asimov’s Laws of Robotics were first introduced in the

short science fiction story Runaround, (PDF) published in the

March, 1942 issue of Astounding Science Fiction. 

The Three Laws in film

 Robby the Robot in Forbidden Planet (1956) has a

hierarchical command structure which keeps him from

harming humans, even when ordered to do so, as such orders

cause a conflict and lock-up very much in the manner of

Asimov's robots. Robby is one of the first cinematic


depictions of a robot with internal safeguards put in place in

this fashion.

 The film Bicentennial Man (1999) features Robin Williams

as the Three Laws robot NDR-114 (the serial number is

partially a reference to Stanley Kubrick's signature numeral).

Williams recites the Three Laws to his employers, the

Martin family, aided by a holographic projection.

 Harlan Ellison's proposed screenplay for I, Robot began by

introducing the Three Laws, and issues growing from the

Three Laws form a large part of the screenplay's


67
plot
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society

development. This is only natural since Ellison's screenplay

is one inspired by Citizen Kane: a frame story surrounding

four of Asimov's short-story plots and three taken from the

book I, Robot itself.

 In the 1986 movie Aliens, in a scene after the android Bishop

accidentally cuts himself during the knife game, he attempts


to reassure Ripley by stating that: "It is impossible for me to

harm or by omission of action, allow to be harmed, a human

being".

 In the 1987 film RoboCop and its sequels, the partially

human main character has been programmed with three

"prime directives" that he must obey without question. Even

if different in letter and spirit they have some similarities

with Asimov's Three Laws. They are: Serve the Public Trust,

Protect the Innocent, Uphold the Law and Classified These

particular laws allow Robocop to harm a human being in

order to protect another human, fulfilling his role as would a

human law enforcement officer. The classified fourth

directive keeps him from arresting any senior OCP officer,

effectively putting OCP management above the law.

Today, Asimov's Three Laws of Robotics represent

more problems and conflict to roboticists than they solve.


Roboticists, philosophers, and engineers are seeing an

ongoing debate on machine ethics. Machine ethics, or

roboethics, is a practical proposal on how to simultaneously

engineer and provide ethical sanctions for robots. Who or

what is going to be held responsible when or if an

autonomous system malfunctions or harms

humans? Currently, researchers are following a trend that

aims at promoting the design and implementation of

artificial systems with embedded morally acceptable

behavior.

On ethics and roboethics

Ethics is the branch of philosophy which studies human

conduct, moral assessments, the concepts of good and evil, right

and wrong, justice and injustice. The concept of roboethics brings


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 68

up a fundamental ethical reflection that is related to particular


issues and moral dilemmas generated by the development of

robotic applications. 

Roboethics - also called machine ethics-- deals with the code

of conduct that robotic designer engineers must implement in the

Artificial Intelligence of a robot. Through this kind of artificial

ethics, roboticists must guarantee that autonomous systems are

going to be able to exhibit ethically acceptable behavior in

situations where robots or any other autonomous systems such as

autonomous vehicles interact with humans.

Ethical issues are going to continue to be on the rise as long

as more advanced robotics come into the picture. In The Ethical

Landscape of Robotics by Pawel Lichocki et.al.,(n.d.) published

by IEEE Robotics and Automation Magazine, the researchers list

various ethical issues emerging in two sets of robotic

applications: Service robots and lethal robots. Service robots are

created to peacefully live and interact with humans, whereas


lethal robots are created to be sent to fight in the battlefield as

military robots. 

According to The Ethical Landscape of Robotics, Noel

Shanky argues that "the cognitive capabilities of robots do not

match that of humans, and thus, lethal robots are unethical as they

may make mistakes more easily than humans." And Ronald Arkin

believes that "although an unmanned system will not be able to

perfectly behave in battlefield, it can perform more ethically that

human beings." In part, the question about the morality of using

robots in the battlefield involves commitments on the capability

and type of Artificial Intelligence in question. 

Robots in the military: Designed to kill and moral accountability 

Military robots are certainly not just a thing of the present.

They date back to World War II and the Cold War. The German

Goliath tracked mines and the Soviet teletanks. Military robots


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 69

can be used to fire a gun, disarm bombs, carry wounded soldiers,


detect mines, fire missiles, fly, and so on. Today, many other uses

for military robots are being developed applying other

technologies to robotics. The U.S. military is going to count with

a fifth of its combat units fully automated by 2020. What kind of

roboethics are going to be embedded to military robots and who

is going to decide upon them? Asimov's laws cannot be applied to

robots that are designed to kill humans. Also in 2020, the U.S.

army is going to live test armored robotic vehicles. A

demonstration was held in May in Texas.  

Will robots become moral agents in the future?

Roboethics will become increasingly important as we enter

an era where more advanced and sophisticated robots as well as

Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) are going to become an

integral part of our daily life. Therefore, the debate in ethical and

social issues in advanced robotics must become increasingly

important. The current growth of robotics and the rapid


developments in Artificial Intelligence require roboticists and

humans in general to be prepared sooner rather than later. As the

discussion in roboethics advances, some argue that robots will

contribute to building a better world. Some others argue that

robots are incapable of being moral agents and should not be

designed with embedded moral-decision making

capabilities. Finally, perhaps not yet but in the future robots could

become moral agents with attributed moral responsibility. Until

then, engineers and designers of robots must assume

responsibility regarding the ethical consequences of their

creations. In other words, engineers and designers of robots must

be morally accountable for what they design and bring out into

the world. 

Review Questions:
What are other ethical dilemmas played by using the

technological advancements in science like robotics?


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 70
Related Articles/ Video clips/STS Website/Film Clips:

 The Real Robotics Revolution Arrives as a Service

 Robots Will Now Be Built by Robots in World's Most

Advanced Robotics Factory  

 Artificial Intelligence and the Fear of the Unknown

 The Three Types of Artificial Intelligence: Understanding

AI

 Video clips, The ethical dilemmas of robotics, “ Sophia”

and Hanson Robotics' Little Sophia Teaches STEM,

Robotics, AI to Children

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/6432307,stm.

 Watch this movie at home, Robocop, the 1960's episode of

the Jetson Family or as an alternative, look for pictures of


toy robots from the 1960s - perhaps Rock em Sock em

Robots.

 http://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/information-

anxiety.html

 History, Literature, Science, Technology .February 4th, 2020

http://www.openculture.com/2020/02/the-word-robot-

originated-in-a-czech-play-in-1921.html)

Activities:

Activity 1: Principles and Ethics of Robotics

Describe the principles and ethics of robotics and write your

answer in the activity box below.

1. What are other principles of Robotics not mention above,

give at least 2 robotic principles.

2. State at least 3 ethical delimmas of robotics based from

the article above.


Activity 2: Draw a Fictional Robot
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 71

Name at least 2 robots (real and fictitious) you could think of.

Create/develop your own robot - fictitiously of course. (2 pts each

question, total score is 10)

 What is it’s name? What animal or human characteristics

will it have?

 What functions can it perform? How will it move?

 Will it obey the three laws of robotics (Asimov’s Law)?

Activity 3: Answer the following questions briefly.

1. Is it ethical to have robotic soldiers? Explain your answer.

2. What is the implication of the third law?


3. Can you cite at least one ethical dilemma in technological

advancement like television sets, mobile phones, computers

and laptops.

4. Should there be more budget for technological researches

despite the dilemmas they are currently facing.

5. Do technological devices bring more good than bad to

people?

Assessment/Evalution:

Exit-test: (III. Module 1)

Score_________

Multiple Choice -Directions: Choose the best answer and write

your answer in the

blank before each number.


____ 1. Robotic technologies is needed in our society for a

variety of reasons. Which of the following statement express the

importance of Robotic technologies?

V.Develop machines just for display

VI. Develop machines that can substitute for humans.


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 72

VII. Develop machines that can replicate human

actions.

VIII. Develop machines with computer system as their

control.

A.I and II only B. II and III only C. II, III and IV

D. IV only

____ 2. The following are the “prime directives” that Robocop

has been programmed to obey without questions which

apply the three laws of Asimov. Which of these is NOT

included?
A. Serve the public trust C. Protect the

Innocent

B. Uphold the law D. Kill the

murderer

____ 3. Robots can be used in many situations and for lots of

purposes, but TODAY the robots are placed in a risky type

of environment to do an important task and mission. Which

is not considered a risky type of environment for the robot?

A. Home as small toys for kids.

B. Factories for manufacturing processes.

C. Outer space, or where humans cannot survive (e.g. in

space).

D. Dangerous environments (including bomb detection and

deactivation)
____ 4. Which of the following statement is NOT considered as

ethical dilemmas faced by technological advancements such

as cellphones, computer, laptops and television?

A. Gadgets or digital addiction and alienation.

B. The devise are primarily used for communication.

C. The devise can make the person lazy and unhealthy

D. Moral dilemmas, freely exposed to information

which is not suited for young age.


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 73

____ 5. Scientists creates robot to perform an essential task.

Which of the following statement

best describes the use of robotics?

A.Robotics requires you to read.

B.Robots are design for movies.

C. Robotics is about innovating healthy foods.

D. Robotics produces robots and machines to make

one’s work easier.


References:

Calo, Ryan. “Robots in American Law. (2016). ” The Strauss

Center, University of Texas School of Law, 22 Mar. 2016,

www.strausscenter.org/strauss-events/robots-in-american-

law.html.

Estardo, A. (2018) “WHEN TECHNOLOGY AND HUMANITY

CROSS” Published in: Education, Sep 5, 2018 - bsp-stspt6,

https://www.slideshare.net/annaestardo/bspsts-pt6)

Evans, D. (2007). “The Ethical Dilemmmas of Robotics,”

Accessed Feb 6, 2017.

http://newsbbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/6432307

Goodwin, R. (2016). “The History of Mobile Phones from 1973-

2008: The Handsets that Made it ALL Happen.” Accessed

February 3, 2017 from


http://www.knowyourmobile.com/nokia/nokia-3310/19848/hi

story-mobile-phones-1973-2008-handsets-made-it-all-happen.

Gunkel, David J. (2017). Machine Question – Critical

Perspectives on Ai, Robots, and Ethics. Mit Press Ltd, 2017

History, Literature, Science, Technology. February 4, 2020.

http://www.openculture.com/2020/02/the-word-robot-

originated-in-a-czech-play-in-1921.html)
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 74
Jesek, G. (n.d.). “The history of Television” Accessed February 3,

2017.

http://www.the historyoftelevision.com/

Knight, Will. (n.d.) “There’s a Big Problem with AI: Even Its

Creators Can’t Explain How It Works.” MIT Technology

Review, MIT Technology Review, 12 May 2017,

www.technologyreview.com/s/604087/the-dark-secret-at-the-

heart-of-ai/.
Lietzen, Iina.(2017). “Robots and Artificial Intelligence: MEPs

Call for EU-Wide Liability Rules .” Robots and Artificial

Intelligence: MEPs Call for EU-Wide Liability Rules | News |

European Parliament, European Parliament Press, 16 Feb.

2017,

www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/press-room/20170210IPR6

1808/robots-and-artificial-intelligence-meps-call-for-eu-wide-

liability-rules.

Pitti, Alexandre. (2018). “Ideas from Developmental Robotics

and Embodied AI on the Questions of Ethics in Robots”.

Cornell University Library.


75
Entry-Test (III. Module 2)
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society

Score_______

To determine if you have the knowledge needed to enter

the module and check whether you have learned the lessons to

be taught.

Multiple Choice - Directions: Answer the following questions

based from your existing knowledge and write your best answer

in the blank before each number.


1. Due to COVID 19 pandemic, students need social media to

support their studies. Which of the following is the negative

side of social media which affect students studies?

A. Social media helps the students in research study.

B. Social media provides knowledge about important

information.

C. Social networking has increased the rate and quality of

collaboration for students.

D. The more time students spend on social sites, the less

time they spend socializing in

person.

2. Today we are facing ethical dilemmas with social media.

Which of the following statement is considered one of the

ethical dilemmas of social media?

A. Blind in falls or fake news.


B. Increases technology awareness.

C. Increases socializing via internet connections

D. Increases connections in the real world.

Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society III. Module 276

Topic: The Information Age (Gutenberg to Social Media)

Overview:

Information evolution leads to the information age, each era

from the Stone Age up to the present has led to the world with

relevant information. Through human evolution, dissemination of

information has also evolved in many ways. Without the

information, knowledge and discoveries of those from the past,


will not be shared and passed on from one generation to the next.

The past has shaped our present and will continue to shape our

future. Information was shared and managed in different ways

and means. It started to grow rapidly where people are

unprepared on how to manage a lot of information, what we call

information overload. Technological changes of information

brought remarkable new options, new forms of entertainment, in

commerce, research, education, work and communication in the

society. Hence, information is one of the important tools for

survival.

Keyterms: Information Age, Gutenberg Era, Post – Gutenberg

Era, Social Media,

Social Network, Information Anxiety

Objectives:
1. Link learned concepts to the development of the

information age and its impact on society.

2. Illustrate how the social media and the information age

have impacted our

lives.
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 77
Read:

The History of Information Age

First Era - The first era was the oral tradition. People used

the sound and light, or simple symbols and graphics to convey

information. It was the growing state of the word. It was an era

where dissemination of information only served the purpose to

survive. The information content was small and scattered, and the

structure of the expression was unordered. The oral

communication phase lasted tens of thousands to one hundred

thousands of years.
Second Era - The second era is the age of literacy. This

period can be further divided into three parts which consist of

pictograms (written symbols), phonetic alphabet, and typography,

which the last one is the printing press (McLuhan, 1962). It

includes the period from the invention of writing to the discovery

of electricity and its usage in the form of the telegraph. The

application of the text was significant to the development of

dissemination of the information because, with text, information

could be recorded. As a result, information could spread without

the constraints of physical space and time. Information

transmission could last longer and reach farther. This was when

newspaper started to emerge. Handwritten communication played

an important role in ancient society. At that time, the forms of

news distribution were broadly divided into two categories: the

official communiqué for the dissemination of political and


military information, and the newsletters mostly for personal

information dissemination in aristocratic society.

Gutenberg Era - The Gutenberg era means the distribution of

information which lasted for 500 years, this was first established

by Johannes Gutenberg. His invention of the printing press, made

the widespread distribution of information. The distribution


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 78
became the dominant partner of information because it is costly,

needs more money to distribute the material. This relationship

between information and distribution – which is termed the

Gutenberg principle – meant that the flow of information within

our society became institutionalised to generate the revenues

necessary to pay for the high costs involved in printing presses,

TV and radio networks etc. Almost every institution present in

today’s society fundamentally owes its existence and structure to

the basic rules about information distribution established by


Gutenberg. A bank, for example, is simply a mediator of

information about people who have money.

The characteristic, which could be called the Gutenberg

principle, is the fact that the mass distribution of information

became possible, but was expensive and therefore

institutionalised. Gutenberg combined the technology of

manufacturing of paper, development of ink, and woodblock

printing. The mechanical movable type printing technology along

with other printing technology quickly spread through Europe. It

had led to a huge increase in printing activities. People

reproduced and spread information widely and rapidly.

Typographical text production had finally led to the first printing

press. The modern journalism was born in Europe under the

background of The Age of Discovery. By the time of the

Industrial Revolution, due to the rapid economic growth and

population density, the need of information that focused on


different categories had led to the emergence of commercial

newspapers (mercantile sheets) after the political newspapers,

which also included Penny Press and quality newspapers. The

newspaper was one of the oldest tools for communication. It was

revolutionary since it was one of the two communication tools

(the other one is postal communication) that exist from the BC

era (59BC) and still exist now. (Encyclopædia Britannica, 2017).

Post-Gutenberg Era - also called the social media –

Broadband internet access and the tools of what is being called

social media mean that it now costs nothing to distribute

information to a mass audience. Information has been separated


79
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society

from its means of distribution and it is now free. Information can

now flow everywhere in the world, without any form of

institutionalised intervention, except the provision of a freely

available technological infrastructure.


Information Age - The Information Age is also called the

New Media Age or Digital Age because it was related with the

development of computers. The information Age started in the

last quarter of the 20th century when information is open through

publications and through the management of information in

computers and computer networks” (vocabulary.com, n.d.).

According to Webster’s Encyclopedic Unabridged Dictionary,

information is “knowledge communicated or obtained concerning

a specific fact or cirscumstance”.

The Information Age brought about many new inventions

and innovations. Many communication services like texting,

email, and social media developed and the world has not been the

same since. People learn new languages easier and many books

have been translated into different languages, so people around

the world can become more educated. However, the Information

Age is not, “all good”. There are people in the world who believe
they can live their entire life through the Internet. Also, huge

criminal organizations rely on hacking into government systems

and obtaining confidential information to continue their way of

life.  Jobs have also became easier, and some jobs can even be

done from the comfort of your own home. The Information Age

is also known as the Age of Entrepreneurship. Now

entrepreneurs can start and run a company easier than

ever before. It also brings great impacts to work ethics by

distracting us and causing us to lose interest in the task we are

doing. This time period has also created a shortage of jobs and

making many jobs obsolete because machines are now being used

to do the work humans once did. Radio and television had

changed people’s use of idle time, while the Internet is more

subversive to change the entire media ecology. Internet had

achieved the integrations of a variety of media.


Social Network - Ahlqvist (2008), defined that Social-

network is the means of interactions among people in which they

create, share, exchange and comment contents among themselves

in virtual communities and networks. The cost of online

communication is almost free. Everyone with a computer that can

link to the internet is an information distributor and can provide

information. The user of social media platform changes

themselves from a news receiver to a news contributor. The

reader has more choice on what to read, and they are all free.

Hence, social networks had enabled the true “freedom of speech”.

The online social mobile communication is not just a

communication tool, but it is the accelerator and amplifier that

enable the social movement to turn bigger. It gives people hopes

of success by empowering people with the ideas to get their

words out. The internet allows people to connect and to

communicate equally. It eliminates physical, economic, social,


educational gaps between people. Internet passes the power

originally held by a large corporation (media, government,

businesses, etc.). The online power is changing from

institutionalised channels (think newspapers and ads) into

processes of information facilitation (think Google) and forms of

community (think social networks).

Review Questions:

3. Who are the contributors of the technological advances of the

Information Age?

Read:

Information Anxiety - Human cost of information overload

is what we call Information Anxiety. In the words of Richard

Saul Wurman (author of the book 'Information Anxiety'), it is

"produced by the ever-widening gap between what we understand


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 81
and what we think we should understand”. It is the black hole
between data and knowledge, and what happens when

information doesn't tell us what we want or need to know."

“Truths of the Information Age” (n.d.), article of Robert Harris

detailed some facts on the

Informaton Age.

1. Information must compete. There is a need for information to

stand out and be recognized.

2. Newer is equated with truer. We forgot the truth that any fact

or value can endure.

3. Selection is a viewpoint. Choose multiple sources of

information to have more balanced view of reality.

4. The media sells what the culture buys. Infromation is driven by

cultural priorities.

5. The early word gets the perm. The first media channel to

expose an issue often defines the context, terms and attitudes

surrounding it.
6. You are what you eat and so is your brain. Do not draw

conclusions unless all ideas and information are presented to

you.

7. Anything in great demand will be counterfeited. The demand

for incredible knowledge, scandals and secrets is ever-present:

hence, many events are fabricated by tabloids, publicists, or

other agents of information fraud.

8. Ideas are seen as controversial. It is almost certainly

impossible to make any assertion that will not find some

supporters and some detractors

9. Undead information walks ever on. Rumors, lies,

disinformation and gossips never truly die down. They persist

and continue to circulate.

10. Media presence creates the story. People behave much

differently from the way they would if being filmed when the

media are present, especially film news or television media.


11. The medium selects the message. Television is mainly

pictorial, partially aural and slightly textual, so visual stories are

emphasized: fires, chases and disasters.


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 82

12. The whole truth is a pursuit. The information that reaches us

is usually selected, verbally charged, filtered, slanted and

sometimes fabricated. What is neglected is often even more

important than what is included.

Computer is an electronic device that stores and processes data

(information). It runs on a program that contains the exact, step-

by-step directions to solve a problem. (UShistory.org, 2017).

Types of Computer

1. Personal Computer (PC) is a single-user instrument, first

known as microcomputers since they were a complete computer

but built on a smaller scale.


2. Desktop Computer PC is not designed for portability. The

workstation is a desktop computer that has a more powerful

processor, additional memory, and enhanced capabilities for

performing special groups of tasks such as 3D graphics or game

development. Most desktops offer more storage, power and

versality than their portable versions. (UShistory.org, 2017).

3. Laptops are portable computers that integrate the essentials of a

desktop computer in a battery- operated package, they are

commonly called notebooks.

4. Personal Digital Assistants (PDAs) these are tightly integrated

computers that usually have no keyboards but rely on a touch

screen for user input. PDAs are typically smaller than a

paperback, lightweight, and battery-powered. (UShistory.org,

2017).

5. Server is a computer that has been improved to provide

network services to other computers. Servers usually boast


powerful processors, tons of memory, and large hard drives.

(UShistory.org, 2017).

6. Mainframes are huge computer systems that can fill an entire

room. It is used by large firms that process millions of


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 83
transactions every day. The term “mainframe” has been

replaced by enterprise server. Although some supercomputers

are single computer systems, most comprise multiple, high

performance, parallel computers working as a system.

(UShistory.org, 2017).

7. Wearable computers involve materials that are usually

integrated into cell phones, watches, and other small objects or

places. They perform common computer applications such as

databases, emails, multimedia, and schedules. (UShistory.org,

2017).

The World Wide Web (Internet)


Claude E. Shannon an American mathematician is the “Father of

Information Theory”. He published a paper proposing that

information can be quantitatively encoded as a sequence of

ones and zeroes. The Internet – worldwide system of

interconnected networks that facilitate data transmission among

innumerable computers. Companies like Intel developed faster

microprocessors so personal computers could process the

incoming signals at a more rapid rate. (UShistory.org, 2017).

Applications of Computer in Science and Research

Bioinformatics application of information technology which

functions is to store, organize, and analyze vast amount of

biological data which is available in the form of sequences and

structures of proteins. A consolidated formal database known as

SWISS-PROT protein sequence database was initiated in 1986.

Plant biotechnology is a bioinformatics found to be useful in


the areas of identifying diseases resistance genes and designing

plants with high nutrition value. (Madan, n.d.)

How to check the Reliability of Web Sources (Lee College

Library, n.d.)

1. Who is the author of the article/site?

2. Who published the site?

3. What is the main purpose of the site? Why did the author write

it and why did the publisher post it?


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 84
4. Who is the intended audience?

5. What is the quality of information provided on the website?

Review Question:

What other technological advancements can possibly be

developed in the future?

Related Articles/ Video clips/STS Website/Film Clips:


Video Clips – TEDTalk: Julian Assange on “Why the World

Needs

Wikileaks”

https://richardstacy.wordpress.com/2009/10/30/what-is-the-

social-media-revolution

http://richardstacy.com/2008/11/20/gutenberg-and-the-social-

media-revolution-an-investigation-of-the-world-where-it-costs-

nothing-to-distribute-information

Activity:

Activity 1: (Optional/not applicable due to Covid 19 pandemic)

Video Presentation: Create a group consisting of three to

five members each and prepare a video presentation that focuses

on the evolution of transmission of information in various time

periods and areas of the world. The members may act in the video

presentation and they can use props or materials to improve


presentation. Limit the video presentation in three to five minutes

and the venue of your video should be inside the school campus,

in the student center area. Send your video presentation to the

class group chat. Please submit your video on time.

(Note: refer your score to the STS Rubric criteria for video

presentation, perfect score is 20)

Activity 2: Answer the following questions briefly.


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 85

1. What is information age?

2. Aside from communication, what other aspects of

society is/are influenced in the Information Age.

3. Name at least five (5) useful and reliable web sources.

4. What is the impact of information age and social media

in our lives? Do people really need information

technology? Is it really a necessity? Can you live

without Information technology?


Assessment/Evaluation:

Exit-test: (III. Module 2)

Score_________

Multiple Choice -Directions: Choose the best answer and write

your answer in the

blank before each number.

1. Today we are facing ethical dilemmas with the use of

social media. Which of the following

statement is considered one of the ethical dilemmas of

social media?

A. Blind in falls or fake news.

B. Increases technology awareness.

C. Increases socializing via internet connections


D. Increases connections in the real world.

____2.Due to COVID 19 pandemic, students need social media to


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 86
support their studies. Which of the following is the negative side

of social media which affect students studies?

A. Social media helps the students in research study.

B. Social media provides knowledge about important

information.

C. Social networking has increased the rate and quality of

collaboration for students.

D. The more time students spend on social sites, the less

time they spend socializing in

person.

References:
Harris, R. (n.d.). “Truths of the Information Age.” Accessed

February 26, 2017. http://www:virtuasalt.com/infotrue.htm).

Lee College Library.(n.d.). How Can I tell if a Website is

Reliable? Accessed August 2, 2017.

Madan, M. (n.d.). “Bioinformatics-an aid for biological research.”

Accessed August 2, 2017.

http://www.mrc-lmb.cam.ac.uk/genomes

madanm/articles/bioinfo.htm.

Matthew J. Belvedere, (2016) New York Times subscription

growth soars tenfold, adding 132,000, after Trump’s win,

CNBC News

Selin Ece Güner, St.(2016) The impact of social media on

political change: Gezi protests in Turkey. Edwards University

Domestic Policy, Political Analysi


Silverman, Craig and Jeremy Singer-Vine. (2016). “Most

Americans Who See Fake News Believe It, New Survey

Says.” BuzzFeed News

USHistory.org. (n.d.). “Living in the Information Age.” Accessed

February 26, 2017. http://www.ushistory.org/us/60.asp.

Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 87

Entry-Test (III. Module 3)

Score_______

To determine if you have the knowledge needed to enter

the module and check whether you have learned the lessons to

be taught.
Multiple Choice - Direction: Answer the following questions

based from your existing knowledge and write your best answer

in the blank before each number.

_1. Biodiversity creates the _______ of ecosystems and the

_________ of populations.

A. sustainability and stability C. stability and

sustainability

B. life and existence D. existence and life

_2. Biodiversity provides enough benefits to humans and other

organisms. Which aspects will affect

biodiversity?

 A. agriculture  B. tree planting C. ecotourism

D. deforestation 
_3. Most Invasive species undergo mutation and most of them

become wild in a certain habitat.

Why are invasive species a threat to biodiversity?

I. they can outcompete native organisms for their

resources 

II. they can cause harm to the environment

III.they can be harmful to humans 

IV.they can live harmoniously with other organisms

A. I and II only B. II and III only C. I, II and III

D. III and IV only


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 88
_4. What particular term fits this definition, the disappearance of

a particular population from a given area, but not the entire

species globally.

a. Extinction b. Extrapolation c. Extirpation

d. Excavation
_5. Some human activities creates harm and bring damage to

biodiversity. Which of the following is considered a human

threats to biodiversity?

I. Pollution II. Reforestation III. Population growth

IV. Habitat destruction

A.I and II only B. I and III only C. I, II, and III

D. I, III and IV

_6. Biodiversity is important to all organisms. Which of the

following statement is the most

effective means of conserving biodiversity?

A.Habitats preservation

B.Elimination of predators

C.Vaccination of some species

D.Monitor species during breeding season


_7. Which of the following statement best describe biodiversity?

A. Habitat destruction

B. Less species on Earth

C. A variety of species on Earth

D. The extinction of some animals and plants

_8. In a more diverse ecosystem we can say that organisms_____.


89
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society

A. species are less

B. can easily survive

C. resources are scarce

D. survival is very different

_9. In times of pandemic, which of the following factors is


necessary for a healthy person?
I. Vaccination III. Balanced diet
II. Enjoy life IV. Personal hygiene
A.I and II only B. I and III only C. I, III and IV
D. II, III and IV

_10. Global warming is one of the problem which affects

biodiversity. Which of these activities

can control Global warming?

A.Reducing solid waste

B.Limit wastage of water

C.Reducing consumption of fossil fuels

D.Protection of animals and plants

Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 90


III. Module 3

Topic: Biodiversity and the Healthy Society

Overview:

Biodiversity is the source of the vital goods and ecological

services that constitute the source of life for all and it has direct

consumptive value in food, agriculture, medicine, and in industry

(Villaggio Globale, 2009). Understanding biodiversity within the

concept of ecosystem needs thorough study on the relationship of

the biotic, the living organisms and the abiotic, the nonliving

organisms. Biodiversity plays a major role in this natural dynamic

environment (Tagacay, 2019). Humans are the inhabitants of the

ecosystem, they must preserve and conserve the biodiversity of

all creatures. In simple terms, it is true that people will always

depend on biodiversity on the wholeness of our being and in our


everyday lives. Somehow, there are ways and processes in the

ecosystem that are not apparent nor appreciated by us, human

beings. Think about the need to drink clean and fresh water, the

need to eat healthy vegetables and food, or the need of man to

transport which makes him rely on fuel. All of these are human

needs that are answered and provided by our ecosystem. Thus, if

we fail to keep the process of taking care of the ecosystem, it is us

who are actually putting our lives at risk. Significant decline in

biodiversity has direct human impact when ecosystem in its

insufficiency can no longer provide the physical as well as social

need of human beings. Indirectly, changes in the ecosystem affect

livelihood, income, and on occasion, may even cause political

conflict (WHO, n.d.,).

Keyterms: Biodiversity, Ecosystem, Environment, Health

Objective:
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 91
1. Determine the interrelatedness of society, environment, and

health.

Read:

BIODIVERSITY

Biodiversity is the sum of all the different species of

animals, plants, fungi and microbial organisms living on Earth

and the variety of habitats in which they live. Biodiversity

underlies everything from food production to medical research.

Many people around the world still depend on wild species for

some or all of their food, shelter and clothing. All our

domesticated plants and animals came from wildliving ancestral

species. Much of Earth’s great biodiversity rapidly is

disappearing, even before we know what is missing. Species of

plants, animals, fungi and microscopic organisms such as bacteria

are being lost at alarming rates. Because of this, scientists around


the world are focusing their research on cataloging and studying

global biodiversity in an effort to better understand it and slow

the rate of loss. As a result, the majority of current biodiversity

research concentrates on preserving biodiversity and assessing

environmental quality and change. (Rensik & Porter, 2017)

Services or Benefits of Biodiversity

Biodiversity plays an important role in the way ecosystems

function and in the services they provide. The following is a list

of some of the benefits, or services of biodiversity: Provisioning

services such as food, provide nutritious food, clean water,

timber, fiber and genetic resources, regulating services such as


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 92

climate, floods, disease, water quality and pollination, cultural

services such as recreational, aesthetic and spiritual benefits,

supporting services such as soil formation and nutrient cycling.

(Rensik & Porter, 2017)


Types of Biodiversity

Biodiversity includes three main types: diversity within species

(genetic diversity), between species (species diversity) and

between ecosystems (ecosystem diversity).

Genetic Diversity means each species on Earth is related to

every other species through genetic connections. The more

closely related any two species are, the more genetic information

they will share, and the more similar they will appear. An

organism’s closest relatives are members of its own species, or

organisms with which it has the potential to mate and produce

offspring. Members of a species share genes, the bits of

biochemical information that determine, in part, how the animals

look, behave and live. One eastern gray squirrel, for example,

shares the vast majority of its genes with other eastern gray

squirrels, whether they live in the same area or are separated by

thousands of miles. Members of a species also share complex


mating behaviors that enable them to recognize each other as

potential mates. Mammals have hair, raise their young on milk

and have three bones in the middle ear. All mammals, in turn, are

more distantly related to other animals with backbones, or

vertebrates. All these organisms are animals but share a common

cell structure with plants, fungi and some microbes. Finally, all

living organisms share a common molecule, ribonucleic acid

(RNA), and most also have deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA). While

all species have descended from a single, common ancestor,

species diverge and develop their own peculiar attributes with

time, thus making their own contribution to biodiversity.

Species Diversity is the variety of species within a habitat or

a region. Species are the basic units of biological classification

and thus the normal measure of biological diversity. Species

richness is the term that describes the number of different species

in a given area. The world total is estimated at five to 1093 million


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society

Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 59


species, though only 1.75 million have been named scientifically

so far. Some habitats, such as rainforests and coral reefs, have

many species. For example, tropical North and South America

has about 85,000 flowering plant species, tropical and subtropical

Asia has more than 50,000 and tropical and subtropical Africa has

about 35,000. By contrast, all of Europe has 11,300 vascular

plants. Yet other areas, such as salt flats or a polluted stream,

have fewer species. Species are grouped together into families

according to shared characteristics.


Ecological Diversity is the intricate network of different

species present in local ecosystems and the dynamic interplay

between them. An ecosystem consists of organisms from many

different species living together in a region and their connections

through the flow of energy, nutrients and matter. Those

connections occur as the organisms of different species interact

with one another. The ultimate source of energy in almost every

ecosystem is the sun. The sun’s radiant energy is converted to

chemical energy by plants. That energy flows through the systems

when animals eat the plants and then are eaten, in turn, by other

animals. Fungi derive energy by decomposing organisms, which

releases nutrients back into the soil. Thus, an ecosystem is a

collection of living components (microbes, plants, animals and

fungi) and nonliving components (climate and chemicals) that are

connected by energy flow. Measuring ecological diversity is


difficult because each of Earth’s ecosystems merges into the

ecosystems around it.

Threats to Biodiversity

Major threats identified by United Nations’ Environment

Programme (WHO, n.d.) are the following: Habitat loss and

destruction, alteration in ecosystem composition, over-

exploitation, pollution and contamination and Global climate

change.

Biodiversity and Environmental Health Hazards

Advances in agriculture, sanitation, water treatment, and

hygiene have had a far greater impact on human health.


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 94
Organisms depend on their environments for energy and materials

needed to sustain life: clean air, potable water, nutritious food,

and safe places to live. For most of human history, increases in


longevity were due to improved access to these necessities.

(WHO, n.d.)

Biodiversity Loss Consequences

What are the consequences of biodiversity loss. The basic

concept about biodiversity loss was from Charles Darwin and

Alfred Russel Wallace. The particular species making up an

ecosystem determine its productivity, affect nutrient cycles and

soil contents, and influence environmental conditions such as

water, cycles, weather patterns, climate and other non-biotic

aspects. The loss of biodiversity has many consequences. As

stated by Tilman, “The Earth will retain its most striking feature,

its biodiversity, only if humans have the prescience to do so. This

will occur, it seems, only if we realize the extent to which we use

biodiversity (Rainforest Conservation Fund, 2017)” Lack of basic

necessities is a significant cause of human mortality. The

environment sustains human life, it can also cause diseases.


Environmental hazards increase the risk of cancer, heart disease,

asthma, and many other illnesses. These hazards can be physical,

such as pollution, toxic chemicals, and food contaminants, or they

can be social, such as dangerous work, poor housing conditions,

urban sprawl, and poverty. (Rainforest Conservation Fund, 2017)

Environment-related human illnesses include: Heart disease,

Asthma, Cancer, Diabetes, Chronic obstructive pulmonary

disease, Obesity, Occupational injuries, Arthritis, Parkinson’s

disease, Malaria, Dysentery and Depression. Some human

activities that promote health and extend human life can have

adverse environmental effects. For example, food production


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 95
causes environmental damage from pesticides and fertilizers, soil

salinization, waste produced by livestock, carbon emissions from

food manufacturing and transportation, deforestation, and over-

fishing. Health care facilities also have adverse environmental

impacts. Hospitals use large quantities of electricity and fossil


fuels and produce medical wastes. To prevent some diseases, it

may be necessary to damage the environment. (Rensik & Porter,

2017).

Unsafe drinking water and poor sanitation and hygiene are

responsible for a variety of infectious diseases, such as

schistosomiasis, diarrhea, cholera, meningitis, and gastritis.  In

2015, approximately 350,000 children under age 5 (mostly in the

developing world) died from diarrheal diseases related to unsafe

drinking water, and approximately 1.8 billion people used

drinking water contaminated with feces.  More than 2 billion

people lacked access to basic sanitation. (WHO, 2007)

Review Question:

1. Since humans are the caretaker of our mother Earth. Do

you think that Earth can exist without human beings? Or

biodiversity also needs human beings for it to be in a continous

growing process.
Read

COVID-19 and its link with Biodiversity, Illegal Wildlife

Trafficking and Bioculturality

Article: On line, Open UNESCO, May 22, 2020, Mexico City

[Distrito Federal], Mexico

This year the motto of the International Day for Biological

Diversity is "Our solutions are in nature" to emphasize hope,

solidarity and the importance of working together at all levels to

build a future of life in harmony with nature. The current trend of

the COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted the extreme importance

of combating the loss of biodiversity. Within this framework, the

UNESCO and UNEP Offices in Mexico will organize the Virtual

Dialogue "COVID-19 and its link with biodiversity, illegal

wildlife trafficking and bioculturality".


The Convention on Biological Diversity is the international

instrument for "the conservation of biological diversity, the


96
sustainable use of its components and the fair and equitable
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society

participation in the benefits derived from the use of genetic

resources", which has been ratified by 196 countries.Given the

importance of public education and awareness for the application

of the Convention at all levels, the General Assembly proclaimed

May 22, the date of approval of the text, International Day for

Biological Diversity in 2000.

The appearance of COVID-19 has shown that when we

destroy biodiversity we destroy the system that supports human

life. The more biodiverse an ecosystem is, the more difficult it is

for a pathogen to spread rapidly or dominate. Loss of biodiversity

provides an opportunity for pathogens to pass between animals

and people.
We must learn and adapt faster than ever, and the COVID 19

virus has lessons that apply to global crises of biodiversity loss.

For this reason, our best vaccine for the future is to protect nature

and biodiversity. It is no longer just a matter of ecology but of

being aware that if we want to reduce the occurrence of

pandemics we must have a healthy nature. Loss of biodiversity

also means that we are losing, before discovery, many of nature's

chemicals and genes, of the kind that have already provided

humanity with tremendous health benefits. Traditional medicine

continues to play an essential role in health care, especially in

primary health care.

Bioethical, Social, and Legal Considerations

Relationships between human health and the environment

raise many ethical, social, and legal dilemmas by forcing people

to choose among competing values. These considerations can be

grouped into the following categories.


Managing benefits and risks

Many of the issues at the intersection of health and the

environment have to do with managing benefits and risks. For

example, pesticides play an important role in increasing crop


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 97

yields, but they can also pose hazards to human health and the

environment. Alternatives to pesticide use create trade-offs in

health. The extreme action of stopping all pesticide uses could

significantly reduce agricultural productivity, leading to food

shortages and increased food prices, which would, in turn,

increase starvation in some parts of the world. Public health

authorities have opted to regulate the use of pesticides to enhance

food production while minimizing damage to the environment

and human health. Energy production and use helps sustain

human life, but it can also pose hazards to human health and the

environment, such as air and water pollution, oil spills, and

destruction of habitats. Environmental Risk Factors for Disease


include: Pollution, Microbes in air, water, or soil, contaminants in

food, weather conditions (e.g. droughts, heat waves), natural

disasters (e.g. hurricanes, earthquakes, floods), pesticides and

other chemicals, pests and parasites, radiation, poverty and lack

of access to health care. For many years some politicians and

scholars argued that we should wait for more evidence of global

warming before taking action, since the steps needed to prevent

or minimize it could have disastrous economic consequences.

Others have argued that society cannot afford to wait for

complete evidence because the consequences of global climate

change could be catastrophic and irreversible. This difference of

opinion raises fundamental questions about the ethics of risk

management: what is the role of scientific evidence in decision-

making? Should we use risk/benefit or precautionary decision-

making to develop environmental health policies? (Rensik &

Porter, 2017)
Social justice:

Managing benefits and risks raises social justice concerns.

In general, people with lower socioeconomic status have greater

exposure to certain detrimental environmental conditions in their

homes or at work, such as lead, mercury, pesticides, toxic


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 98
chemicals, or air and water pollution. Communities and nations

should minimize such injustices when making decisions such as

choosing a site for a factory, a power plant, or waste dump, or

regulating safety in the workplace. The decision-making process

should be fair, open, and democratic, so that people who will be

affected by environmental risks have a voice in these

deliberations and can make their concerns known. Social justice

must be a factor in allocating resources for health care.

Governments spend billions of dollars trying to improve the

health of citizens and prevent diseases. These funds go to

biomedical research, overseeing the safety of foods and drugs,


enforcing environmental or occupational health regulations, and

running programs for disaster preparedness, public health, health

education, sanitation, water treatment, and so on. In the U.S., the

share of health resources goes to providing medical diagnosis and

treatment, but one might argue that it would be wiser to shift

some resources to disease prevention programs, such as

environmental protection, public health, and health education,

since prevention is generally more cost-effective than

treatment.  (Rensik & Porter, 2017)

Human rights:

Human rights is the right of an individual against the good

of society, such as mandatory treatment, vaccination, or

diagnostic testing, isolation and quarantine, and disease

surveillance. The main argument for these public health strategies

is that individual human rights may have to be limited to prevent


the transmission of infectious diseases, such as COVID-19,

SARS, tuberculosis, HIV/AIDS, and pneumonia. But restrictions

on rights should be well thought-out and safeguards put in place

to prevent public health authorities from overstepping their

bounds. Protecting the public’s health should not come at the

expense of human rights. Some health and environmental

protections also limit property rights. The owner of a coal-

burning power plant must deal with many laws concerning the

operation of the plant, workplace safety, and carbon emissions. A

developer who plans to build 150 new homes with land he has

purchased may also have to deal with laws concerning storm

drainage, water and sewage lines, gas lines, sidewalks, and so on.

Restrictions on property rights are justified to protect human

health and the environment. But opponents of these restrictions

argue that they are often excessive or not adequately supported by

scientific evidence.
Human rights issues also come up in research on

environmental health that involves human subjects. For such

research to be ethical, human subjects must give consent, and

great care must be taken to ensure that they understand that they

can opt out of the research project. Since the late 1990s, some

pesticide companies have tested pesticides on human subjects to

gather data to submit to the government for regulatory purposes.

Some commentators charge that these experiments are unethical

because they place people at unacceptably high risk without a

clear benefit to society. Others have argued that the experiments,

if properly designed and implemented, could produce important

benefits to society by providing useful knowledge about the

effects of pesticides, which could lead to stronger regulations.

(Rensik & Porter, 2017)


Emerging Issues

There are many new developments in science, technology

and industry that are bound to pose benefits and risks to the

environment and human health. These include nanotechnology,

genetic modification of plants and animals, antibiotic resistance,

threats to food safety, the growing market for biofuels and

invasive species can be plants, animals, and other organisms (e.g.,

microbes), which are non-native (or alien) species that have been

introduced by human intervention (involvement) such as COVID-


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 100
19, human actions are the primary means of invasive species

introductions. Invasive species can lead to the extinction of native

plants and animals. Extinction is the disappearance of particular

animal or plant species, the species has died out. This is a natural

part of evolution. But sometimes extinctions happen at a much

faster rate than usual, Invasive species destroy biodiversity, and

permanently alter habitats, it has the ability to threaten our native


wildlife, cause damage to our environment, economy or human

health. Invasive species can be introduced to an area by ship

ballast water, accidental release, and by people.

Longstanding challenges persist, including the preservation

of ecosystems, the endangered species and questions about

animal, viruses, bacteria experimentation (such as the Covid 19).

Many more developments will emerge. To deal with them in a

responsible way, we must continue to research the relationship

between human health and the environment and must be fair in

democratic public deliberations, such as community forums,

academic conferences, and legislative debates, involving

participants with diverse cultural, socioeconomic, philosophic,

and scientific perspectives.

Review Questions:

1. In small ways, what do you think would promote protection

and preservation of our biodiversity?


Related Articles/Video Clips/STS Website/Film Clips:

 Why is biodiversity so important? - Kim Preshoff –

YouTube

www.youtube.com › watch › GK_vRtHJZu4

 View full lesson: http://ed.ted.com/lessons/why-is-

biodiversity-so- ... Click here to visit our frequently asked

questions about HTML5 video.

 Ideas about Biodiversity - TED Talks www.ted.com › topics

› biodiversity

 Biodiversity. A collection of TED Talks (and more) on the

topic of Biodiversity. Video playlists about Biodiversity ...

 ESS Topic 3.1: Introduction to Biodiversity - AMAZING


WORLD ...
www.mrgscience.com › ess-topic-31-introduction-to-bi...
Follow this link to see population pyramids for nearly every

country on Earth - US ... Click here to visit our frequently


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 101

asked questions about HTML5 video.

Exit-Test (III. Module 3)

Score_______

Multiple Choice - Direction: Answer the following questions and

write your best answer in the blank before each number.

_1. Biodiversity creates the _______ of ecosystems and the

_________ of populations.

A. sustainability and stability C. stability and

sustainability

B. life and existence D. existence and life

_2. Biodiversity provides enough benefits to humans and other

organisms. Which aspects will affect


biodiversity?

 A. agriculture  B. tree planting C. ecotourism

D. deforestation 

_3. Most Invasive species undergo mutation and most of them

become wild in a certain habitat.

Why are invasive species a threat to biodiversity?

I. they can outcompete native organisms for their

resources 

II. they can cause harm to the environment

III.they can be harmful to humans 

IV.they can live harmoniously with other organisms

A. I and II only B. II and III only C. I, II and III

D. III and IV only


_4. What particular term fits this definition, the disappearance of

a particular population from a given area, but not the entire

species globally.

A. Extinction B. Extrapolation C. Extirpation

D. Excavation
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 102

_5. Some human activities creates harm and bring damage to

biodiversity. Which of the following is

considered a human threats to biodiversity?

I. Pollution II. Reforestation III. Population growth

IV. Habitat destruction

A.I and II only B. I and III only C. I, II, and III

D. I, III and IV

_6. Biodiversity is important to all organisms. Which of the

following statement is the most

effective means of conserving biodiversity?


A.Habitats preservation

B.Elimination of predators

C.Vaccination of some species

D.Monitor species during breeding season

_7. Which of the following statement best describe biodiversity?

A. Habitat destruction

B. Less species on Earth

C. A variety of species on Earth

D. The extinction of some animals and plants

_8. In a more diverse ecosystem we can say that organisms_____.

A. species are less

B. can easily survive

C. resources are scarce

D. survival is very different

Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 103


_9. In times of pandemic, which of the following factors is
necessary for a healthy person?
I. Vaccination III. Balanced diet
II. Enjoy life IV. Personal hygiene

A.I and II only B. I and III only C. I, III and IV


D. II, III and IV

_10. Global warming is one of the problem which affects

biodiversity. Which of these activities

can control Global warming?

A.Reducing solid waste

B.Limit wastage of water

C.Reducing consumption of fossil fuels

D.Protection of animals and plants


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 104

Entry-Test (III. Module 4)

Score_______

To determine if you have the knowledge needed to enter the

module and check whether you have learned the lessons to be

taught.
Multiple Choice - Direction: Answer the following questions

based from your knowledge and write your best

answer in the blank before each number.

_1. Scientists know that some methods used to increase the food

supply are dangerous to humans. Which method is known to be

harmful to human health?

A. GMO

B. Rice terraces technique

C. The use of organic fertilizers

D. Produce conventional fruits and vegetable.

_2. How long does it take to develop a new genetically modified

crop?

A. One year B. Five years C. Twelve years

D. Twenty years
_3. As the human population grows, the effect of changes made

by the people in the ecosystem surrounding them has been

to______.

A. simplify the ecosystem

B. increase the number of species

C. leave the ecosystem undisturbed

D. make the ecosystem more disturbed

_4. Bt corn is one of the most common GMO product.105


Does Bt
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society

corn or Bt cotton only kill specific pests that damage the crop?

A. The Bt toxin kills all insects.

B. The Bt toxin kills European corn borer and other flying

insects.

C. The Bt toxin kills the European corn borer and its close

relatives.
D. The Bt toxin only kills the insects for which it is targeted.

_5. Can scientists predict with certainty where an inserted gene

will go on a plant chromosome?

A. With modern genetic techniques, scientists can insert

genes precisely.

B. Genes are inserted on the proper chromosome, but there

is no control on where it

goes on the chromosome.

C.Scientists have a general idea of where the gene will go

and what it will do to the

plant.

D.For scientists it is called a shot in the dark which

means using air guns that shoot the

genetic material into the cells but scientists have no

control over where the genes might


go in the plant cells.

_6. Some of the processed food in the groceries are GMO made
product. Which breakfast food is likely to include GMO
ingredients because it is often made with soy and corn
products?
A. Cereal B. Eggs C. Orange juice
D. Biscuits

_7. Crops are often genetically engineered to improved traits.


Such crops and organisms are
called______.
A. Clones B. Transformed C. Changed D.
Genetically modified organisms
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 106

_8. Which of the following statement is a medical application of


genetic engineering?
A. Genes modification to achieve desirable traits
B. Crops is engineered for greater nutritional content
C. Manipulation of DNA to produce glowing monkeys
D. Inserting human DNA into Bacterial DNA for insulin

production
_9. Genetically modified crops are pesticide resistance. Which of

the following practices is

then unnecessary or not useful?

I. Crops irrigation III. Spraying of

pesticides

II. Stem cutting IV. Alteration or

change of genes

A.I and II only B. II and III only C. I, II and III

D. IV only

_10. Which of the following means of genetic engineering would

have the greatest impact on

world hunger?

I.Gene Modification of crops for greater nutritional

content
II. Manipulating DNA in trees for less requirement of

water

III.Modifying genes to achieve a desirable traits in

organisms

IV.Insertion of human DNA to bacterial DNA for

insulin production

A.I and II only B. II and III only C. I and IV

only D. I, II and III

Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 107


III. Module 4

Topic: Genetically Modified Organisms (GMO): Science,

Health and Politics


Overview:

The world’s population is increasing. Food production from

natural resources could not supply human needs. So researchers

find means to produce more food using molecular-level

techniques. The product or the result of this molecular-level

techniques is called Genetically modified organisms (GMOs).

GMO’s are living organisms whose genetic material has been

artificially manipulated in a laboratory through genetic

engineering. This creates combinations of plant, animal, bacteria,

and virus genes that do not occur in nature or through traditional

crossbreeding methods. A wide variety of organisms have been

genetically modified (GM), from animals to plants and

microorganisms.

The word GM food is used for such crops which are formed

by genetic engineering. Such plants have been altered in the


laboratory to improving many interesting characteristics such as,

disease resistance or to improve nutritional value. Genetic

engineering helps to produce such plant with exact desire trait

rapidly. (Verma, 2011) Example of this technique, an extracted

gene which contains drought tolerance trait and inserts that gene

into the different plants. The new plant will be genetically

modified drought tolerance. So with the help of GM food, we can

increase the quantity of food by using small portion of land but

high productivity is cultivated.

Through continous searching for development. Genetic

engineering no longer stayed in science fiction novel. It became a

reality in science laboratories. The general process of genetic


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 108

engineering is the deliberate manipulation of the organism’s gene.

Currently there are ongoing researches on GMOs such as using

genetically modified male mosquitoes as pest control over female

mosquitoe carriers of Zica virus.


This lesson presents the reality of GMO, despite creating

solutions for problems, genetic engineering faces much

opposition. How GMOs affects life, the impact to human health

and the ethical, social and environmental issues and the

controversies of genetic engineering.

Keyterms: Genetically Modified Organisms (GMO), Genetic

Engineering, Health,

Ethics and Politics

Objective:

1. Discuss the ethics and implications of GMOs and potential

future impacts.

Read:

Genetically Modified Organism (GMO)


World Health Organization

Genetically modified organisms (GMOs) can be defined as

organisms in which the genetic material (DNA) has been altered

in a way that does not occur naturally. The technology is often

called "modern biotechnology" or "gene technology", sometimes

also "recombinant DNA technology" or "genetic engineering". It

allows selected individual genes to be transferred from one


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 109

organism into another, also between non-related species. Such

methods are used to create GM plants -- which are then used to

grow GM food crops. Genes have been transferred within the

same species, across species (creating transgenic organisms) and

even across kingdoms. Organisms that have been genetically

modified include micro-organisms such as bacteria and yeast,

insects, plants, fish, and mammals. Some GM animals are the

Sheeps, Goats, Mice, Cow and Fish. 

Benefits of GM foods
GM foods are developed -- and marketed -- because there is

some perceived advantage either to the producer or consumer of

these foods. This is meant to translate into a product with a lower

price, greater benefit (in terms of durability or nutritional value)

or both. Initially GM seed developers wanted their products to be

accepted by producers so have concentrated on innovations that

farmers (and the food industry more generally) would appreciate.

The initial objective for developing plants based on GM

organisms was to improve crop protection. The GM crops

currently on the market are mainly aimed at an increased level of

crop protection through the introduction of resistance against

plant diseases caused by insects or viruses or through increased

tolerance towards herbicides.

Insect resistance is achieved by incorporating into the food plant

the gene for toxin production from the bacterium Bacillus

thuringiensis, (Bt) such as Bt Corn. This toxin is currently used


as a conventional insecticide in agriculture and is safe for human

consumption. GM crops that permanently produce this toxin have

been shown to require lower quantities of insecticides in specific

situations, e.g. where pest pressure is high.

Virus resistance is achieved through the introduction of a gene

from certain viruses which cause disease in plants. Virus

resistance makes plants less susceptible to diseases caused by

such viruses, resulting in higher crop yields. Example is GM

papaya or rainbow papaya. The papaya ringspot virus (PRSV)


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 110

is known to be detrimental to papaya plants. The effect was like

the vaccines humans have against measles or influenza virus.

Herbicide tolerance is achieved through the introduction of a gene

from a bacterium conveying resistance to some herbicides. In

situations where weed pressure is high, the use of such crops has

resulted in a reduction in the quantity of the herbicides used.

Example is Roundup Ready soybean. Glyphosate an herbicide


for weeds, was introduced to soybeans making it tolerant to the

herbicide itself. Farmers then can spray the herbicide killing the

weeds but not the soybeans.

Fortification a GM plants fortified with certain chemicals such as

Golden Rice, with Beta-carotene, a precursor of Vit. A, was

introduced through biosynthesis genes to the rice, making the rice

grains fortified with vitamin A.

Increase growth rate - AquaAdvantage salmon, a gene from an

ocean pout, an eel-like fish was introduced to Pacific Chinook

salmon, making the salmon grow faster than its normal rate

which has a higher yield in growth than normal species.

Cosmetic preservation a GM plants such as Arctic Apple which

resist natural discoloration, the apple variety genetically modified

to suppress the browning of apple due to superficial damage.

Non-Food Crops GMOs and Microorganisms


Pharmaceutical productions – a bacterial genes were added to the

periwinkle plant to enhance the production of vinblastine, an

alkaloid usually added to drugs for cancer treatments like

Hodgkin’s lymphoma (Runguphan, 2010).

Paper production – Lignin is a complex polymer in trees that is

removed from wood to make paper through kraft process, by

inserting genes that code for ferulic acid in young poplar trees,

the lignin structure is modified, making lignin easier to

breakdown. (Veniza, 2014)

Bioremediation – Some bacteria can produce biodegradable

plastics, and the transfer of that ability to microbes that can be

easily grown in the laboratory may enable the wide-scale


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 111

“greening” of the plastics industry. In the early 1990s, Zeneca, a

British company, developed a microbially produced

biodegradable plastic called Biopol (polyhydroxyalkanoate, or

PHA). The plastic was made with the use of a GM bacterium,


Ralstonia eutropha, to convert glucose and a variety of organic

acids into a flexible polymer. GMOs endowed with the bacterially

encoded ability to metabolize oil and heavy metals may provide

efficient bioremediation strategies. Another example is the GM

plant that can help in the bioremediation of polluted sites, such as

shrub tobacco, (Nicotiana glauca), genetically modified with

phytochelatin TaPCSI1, is used for bioremediation. It shows high

level accumulation of zinc, lead, cadmium, nickel and boron and

produces high biomass.

Flower production – the so-called “blue” roses, which has a

natural color of lilac and purple contained large amounts of

flavonols, the introduction of flavonoid 31, 51-hydroxylase gene

into pelargonidin- or cyaniding-producing rose cultivars diverts

the anthocyanin biosynthetic pathway toward the production of

delphinidin glucosides and change the flower color to blue which


are seen in modified colors and extended the vase life of flowers.

(Elomaa & Holton, 1994).

GMOs in the medical field – one example is Humulin, a

genetically engineered insulin used by type 1 diabetes patients

who are insulin dependent.

Enzyme and drug production – a microorganism, bacterium

Bacillus which was genetically modified with the gene of a

thermophilic anaerobe, Thermoanaerobacter carrying

Cyclomaltodextrin glycosyltransferase (CGTase), an enzyme

used for food flavor enhancer (Pedersen & Jorgensen, 1995).

Another is example artemesin. Artemesinic acid is a compound

used for anti-malarial drug extracted from sweet wordwood plant

and through genetic engineering it can be synthetically produced

by yeast and bacteria with sweet wordwood plant gene. (Zimmer,

2006)

GMO’s potential risks and issues to human health


The safety assessment of GM foods generally investigates:

(a) direct health effects (toxicity), (b) tendencies to provoke

allergic reaction (allergenicity); (c) specific components112thought


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society

to have nutritional or toxic properties; (d) the stability of the

inserted gene; (e) nutritional effects associated with genetic

modification; and (f) any unintended effects which could result

from the gene insertion.

While theoretical discussions have covered a broad range of

aspects, the three main issues debated are tendencies to provoke

allergic reaction (allergenicity), gene transfer and outcrossing.

Allergenicity. As a matter of principle, the transfer of genes from

commonly allergenic foods is discouraged unless it can be

demonstrated that the protein product of the transferred gene is

not allergenic. While traditionally developed foods are not

generally tested for allergenicity, protocols for tests for GM foods

have been evaluated by the Food and Agriculture Organization of


the United Nations (FAO) and WHO. No allergic effects have

been found relative to GM foods currently on the market.

Gene transfer. Gene transfer from GM foods to cells of the body

or to bacteria in the gastrointestinal tract would cause concern if

the transferred genetic material adversely affects human health.

This would be particularly relevant if antibiotic resistance genes,

used in creating GMOs, were to be transferred. Although the

probability of transfer is low, the use of technology without

antibiotic resistance genes has been encouraged by a recent

FAO/WHO expert panel.

Outcrossing. The movement of genes from GM plants into

conventional crops or related species in the wild (referred to as

"outcrossing"), as well as the mixing of crops derived from

conventional seeds with those grown using GM crops, may have

an indirect effect on food safety and food security. This risk is

real, as was shown when traces of a maize type which was only
approved for feed use appeared in maize products for human

consumption in the United States of America. Several countries

have adopted strategies to reduce mixing, including a clear

separation of the fields within which GM crops and conventional

crops are grown.

GMOs issues of concern for the environment


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 113

Environmental risk assessments cover both the GMO

concerned and the potential receiving environment. The

assessment process includes evaluation of the characteristics of

the GMO and its effect and stability in the environment,

combined with ecological characteristics of the environment in

which the introduction will take place. The assessment also

includes unintended effects which could result from the insertion

of the new gene.


Issues of concern include: the capability of the GMO to

escape and potentially introduce the engineered genes into wild

populations; the persistence of the gene after the GMO has been

harvested; the susceptibility of non-target organisms (e.g. insects

which are not pests) to the gene product; the stability of the gene;

the reduction in the spectrum of other plants including loss of

biodiversity; and increased use of chemicals in agriculture. The

environmental safety aspects of GM crops vary considerably

according to local conditions. Current investigations focus on: the

potentially detrimental effect on beneficial insects or a faster

induction of resistant insects; the potential generation of new

plant pathogens; the potential detrimental consequences for plant

biodiversity and wildlife, and a decreased use of the important

practice of crop rotation in certain local situations; and the

movement of herbicide resistance genes to other plants.


Review Question

Is genetic engineering a pure scientific process or it is indeed

an act of humans playing like God?

Read Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 114

GMOs Biosafety, Ethics and Implication

The way governments have regulated GM foods varies. In

some countries GM foods are not yet regulated. Countries which

have legislation in place focus primarily on assessment of risks

for consumer health. Countries which have provisions for GM

foods usually also regulate GMOs in general, taking into account

health and environmental risks, as well as control- and trade-

related issues (such as potential testing and labelling regimes). In

view of the dynamics of the debate on GM foods, legislation is


likely to continue to evolve. Different GM organisms include

different genes inserted in different ways. This means that

individual GM foods and their safety should be assessed on a

case-by-case basis and that it is not possible to make general

statements on the safety of all GM foods. Several international

organizations are involved in developing protocols for GMOs for

protection and safety of human population regarding issues and

concerns of GMOs.

 The Codex Alimentarius Commission (Codex) is the joint

FAO/WHO body responsible for compiling the standards,

codes of practice, guidelines and recommendations that

constitute the Codex Alimentarius: the international food

code. Codex is developing principles for the human health

risk analysis of GM foods. The premise of these principles

dictates a premarket assessment, performed on a case-by-

case basis and including an evaluation of both direct effects


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 115
(from the inserted gene) and unintended effects (that may

arise as a consequence of insertion of the new gene). The

principles are at an advanced stage of development and are

expected to be adopted in July 2003. Codex principles do not

have a binding effect on national legislation, but are referred

to specifically in the Sanitary and Phytosanitary Agreement

of the World Trade Organization (SPS Agreement), and can

be used as a reference in case of trade disputes. (WHO,

2014)

 The Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety (CPB), an

environmental treaty legally binding for its Parties, regulates

transboundary movements of living modified organisms

(LMOs). GM foods are within the scope of the Protocol only

if they contain LMOs that are capable of transferring or

replicating genetic material. The cornerstone of the CPB is a

requirement that exporters seek consent from importers


before the first shipment of LMOs intended for release into

the environment. The Protocol will enter into force 90 days

after the 50th country has ratified it, which may be in early

2003 in view of the accelerated depositions registered since

June 2002. (WHO, 2014)

What are people’s reactions and raised questions related to the

different attitudes towards consumption GM food in various

regions of the world? What is the state of public debate on GM

foods in other regions of the world?

The release of GMOs into the environment and the

marketing of GM foods have resulted in a public debate in many

parts of the world. This debate is likely to continue, probably in

the broader context of other uses of biotechnology (e.g. in human

medicine) and their consequences for human societies. Even

though the issues under debate are usually very similar (costs and

benefits, safety issues), the outcome of the debate differs from


country to country. On issues such as labelling and traceability of

GM foods as a way to address consumer concerns. Depending on

the region of the world, people often have different views and

attitudes to food consumption. In addition to nutritional value,

food often has societal and historical connotations, and in some

instances may have religious importance. Technological

modification of food and food production can evoke a negative

response among consumers, especially in the absence of good

communication on risk assessment efforts and cost/benefit

evaluations. Nearly half of American farms grow genetically

modified crops such as Bt corn or glyphosate-resistant (Roundup-

ready) soybeans. Peter Goldsbrough, a plant scientist and expert

in genetically modified crops at Purdue University, has developed

questions to test your knowledge of genetically modified foods

and agricultural biotechnology:


Understanding GMO crops

Is there a decrease of chemical use in farms because of

genetically modified crops?

In some cases the use of genetically modified crops may

reduce the use of pesticides, but people are still going to use

herbicides to control weeds," Goldsbrough says. "But it can

reduce the use of some pesticides that are more likely to damage

the environment, and that is progress." (Goldsbrough, P. (n.d.)

Will insects develop resistance to the toxins produced in Bt corn?

It is almost certain that insects will develop resistance to Bt

corn. Insect resistance to Bt toxin has already been demonstrated

in the laboratory and observed in the field, according to

Goldsbrough. "Insects will eventually develop resistance to the Bt

toxin," he says. "Farmers are required to plant refuges of

conventional crops and take other measures to slow down the

development of resistance in insects, but it will eventually


happen. Nobody knows when that will happen – this is a big

ecological experiment that's going on." (Goldsbrough, P. (n.d.)

Does Bt corn or Bt cotton only kill specific pests that damage the

crop?

The Bt toxin kills the European corn borer and its close

relatives. Scientists were not surprised to learn last summer that

monarch butterflies would die if forced to eat the Bt toxin. The

European corn borer is the larva of a moth, and the Bt toxin will

kill only moth or butterfly larvae that eat it. However, monarch

butterflies typically don't eat the corn plant. "The Bt


117 toxins
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society

produced by Bt corn aren't species specific," Goldsbrough says.

The idea that this will killing all insects such as the monarch

butterfly. Genetically modified crops offer a number of

advantages compared to spraying insecticides." (Goldsbrough, P.

(n.d.)

When did crops become resistant to herbicides?


Crops have always been resistant to some herbicides. "If

they weren't, then farmers couldn't use herbicides such as atrazine

on corn or some of the common herbicides on soybeans,"

Goldsbrough says. "While there is something novel about the

herbicide-resistant crops produced through biotechnology, there

is also something that is very much the same as before. This is

more of an evolution than a revolution." (Goldsbrough, P. (n.d.)

Can genes escape from genetically modified crops and jump to

other plants?

Yes, and often do. If crops are able to breed with wild

relatives, the new genes will be spread to those wild plants. For

example, sorghum can breed with the common weeds johnson

grass and shattercane, and canola can breed with wild mustard

plants. "So if you made Roundup-ready sorghum you'd quickly

end up with Roundup-ready shattercane," Goldsbrough says.

Scientists safeguard against this by not releasing genetically


modified crops in areas where wild relatives are present. "There

are no relatives of maize [corn] and soybeans in the United States

where the crops are planted," Goldsbrough explains.

(Goldsbrough, P. (n.d.)

If we make plants that survive in regions where they normally

wouldn't survive, such as very cold regions, could this cause

unexpected ecological changes?

It is possible that a crop might invade the surrounding

ecosystem. "I don't think that's likely be the scenario, but it could

happen," Goldsbrough says. "For example, if you make

strawberries that can resist frosts, you may have made the plant

more competitive under certain conditions, and it is possible that

it could become an exotic weed like wild mustard. That's

something that's difficult to predict." (Goldsbrough, P. (n.d.)

Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 118


How long does it take to develop a new genetically modified

crop?

Ten years. "At the moment it takes approximately 10 years

to develop a new genetically modified crop," Goldsbrough says.

"It takes several years to test these genes to see how they work.

Then the crops are evaluated under different environments over

several years, just as other crops are evaluated before they're

released to the growers. It's a long, careful process. That doesn't

mean it's foolproof, but it's a deliberate process." Goldsbrough

says new advances in technology, such as genomics, may speed

the process of discovering desirable genes, but bringing new

genetically modified crops to market will still take several years.

(Goldsbrough, P.(n.d.)

Can scientists predict with certainty where an inserted gene will

go on a plant chromosome?
It's a shot in the dark. In some cases, a literal shot. For the

most part, genes are moved into plants in one of two ways: using

bacteria as carriers, or using air guns that shoot the genetic

material into the cells. Just a few years ago scientists used .22

caliber blank cartridges to shoot the genes into the cells, giving

the technique the label "gene gun." Once the genetic material is in

the cells, the plants incorporate the DNA into their own

chromosomes. But because scientists have no control over where

the genes might go in the plant cells, they must germinate, grow

and test hundreds or thousands of plants to find the ones where

the introduced genes work properly and produce the desired traits.

"The current state-of-the-art technology is unpredictable. Where

the genes end up is a random process and can have unanticipated

effects," Goldsbrough says. "But the plants that don't have the

appropriate characteristics are discarded." (Goldsbrough, P. (n.d.)


Can agricultural biotechnology reduce our dependence on

petroleum?

Some of it. "Plants harvest the energy in sunlight, the

ultimate renewable resource, and plants are being developed that

will produce plastics, fuels and other high value products. This
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 119

has the potential to reduce our consumption of petroleum-based

products. Biotechnology may allow us to reduce our reliance on

fossil-based fuels," Goldsbrough says. (Goldsbrough, P. (n.d.)

WHO’s responsibility to improve the evaluation of GM foods?

WHO will take an active role in relation to GM foods,

primarily for two reasons: (1) on the grounds that public health

could benefit enormously from the potential of biotechnology, for

example, from an increase in the nutrient content of foods,

decreased allergenicity and more efficient food production; and

(2) based on the need to examine the potential negative effects on

human health of the consumption of food produced through


genetic modification, also at the global level. It is clear that

modern technologies must be thoroughly evaluated if they are to

constitute a true improvement in the way food is produced. Such

evaluations must be holistic and all-inclusive, and cannot stop at

the previously separated, non-coherent systems of evaluation

focusing solely on human health or environmental effects in

isolation. Work is therefore under way in WHO to present a

broader view of the evaluation of GM foods in order to enable the

consideration of other important factors. This more holistic

evaluation of GM organisms and GM products will consider not

only safety but also food security, social and ethical aspects,

access and capacity building

Biosafety of GMOs in the Philippines

In 2006, the Philippines became part of the Cartagena

Protocol on Biosafety. In the same year, Executive Order No. 514

was issued to address the biosafety requirements of the Cartagena


Protocol and the establishment of the National Biosafety

Framework (NBF)

In 2012, Representative Teddy Casino, together with other

congressman, filed a bill pushing for the mandatory labelling of

GM food and food products. To date, there is no Philippine

Biosafety Law, only biosafety regulations formed under 120


NBF. A
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society

study on the biosafety regulations of the Philippines concluded

that the existing regulation is weak, which can be fixed through

legislation such as a republic act (Richmond, 2006).

In December 2015, the Supreme Court ordered to put and

end to the field testing of GMO Bt eggplant and declared

Administrative Order No. 8, series of 2002 of the Department of

Agriculture as null and void. This means that any actions or

procedures related to GMO importations and propagation is

temporarily put to stop until a new administrative order is issued

in accordance with the law.


In March 7, 2016, five government agencies namely, the

Department of Science and Technology, Department of

Agriculture, Department of Environment and Natural Resources,

Department of Health and Department of the Interior and , Local

Government passed a Joint Department Circular No. 1, series of

2016 on rules and regulations for the research and development,

handling and use, transboundary movement, release in the

environment and management of the genetically modified plant

and plant products derived from the use of modern biotechnology.

This joint department circular paves way to issuance of new

permits for planting and importing GM crops in the Philippines.

Review Question:

1. How would you resolve the advantages and disadvantages

that GMOs bring to humans?


Related Articles/Video Clips/STS Website/Film Clips

 Are GMOs good or bad? | TED-Ed

ed.ted.com › best_of_web

 Apr 19, 2018 - Click here to visit our frequently asked


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 121
questions about HTML5 video. ... Watch these

recommended TED-Ed Lessons ... FAQs on genetically

modified

 What is genetic modification? - YouTube

www.youtube.com › watch

Activities

Activity 1: (Optional/not applicable due to Covid 19 pandemic).

Do not answer this activity

Video Presentation - Create a group consisting of three to five

members each and through video presentation, choose one topic

below and discuss based from your opinions. Each member may
discuss their opinions in the video presentation. Limit the video

presentation to 10 minutes and the venue of your video should be

inside the school campus, in the student center area. Send your

video presentation to the class group chat. This video will be

presented also in the classroom. Please submit your video on

time.

Topics:

a. The advantages and disadvantages in using genetic

engineering in both fields of medicine and food, and

agriculture.

b. Moral issues, controversies of GMO that are still

debatable up to the present.

c. Major concerns of the opponents like the long term effect

of GMO’s to humans and how about the proponent’s

success stories of the GMO recipients.


Activity 2: Individual written report – Choose one topic below

and discuss the ethics, implications and impacts of GMOs:122


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society

Topics:

a. Issues on Philippine Biosafety policies

b. Effects of GMO’s to life and the impact to human health

c. Social, environmental issues and the controversies of

genetic engineering

Assessment/Evaluation

Exit-Test (III. Module 4)

Score_______

Multiple Choice -Directions: Choose the best answer and write

your answer in the


blank before each number.

_1. Scientists know that some methods used to increase the food

supply are dangerous to humans. Which method is known to be

harmful to human health?

A. GMO

B. Rice terraces technique

C. The use of organic fertilizers

D. Produce conventional fruits and vegetable.

_2. How long does it take to develop a new genetically modified

crop?

A. One year B. Five years C. Twelve years

D. Twenty years
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 123
_3. As the human population grows, the effect of changes made

by the people in the ecosystem surrounding them has been


to______.

A. simplify the ecosystem

B. increase the number of species

C. leave the ecosystem undisturbed

D. make the ecosystem more disturbed

_4. Bt corn is one of the most common GMO product. Does Bt

corn or Bt cotton only kill specific pests that damage the crop?

A. The Bt toxin kills all insects.

B. The Bt toxin kills European corn borer and other flying

insects.

C. The Bt toxin kills the European corn borer and its close

relatives.

D. The Bt toxin only kills the insects for which it is targeted.


_5. Can scientists predict with certainty where an inserted gene

will go on a plant chromosome?

A. With modern genetic techniques, scientists can insert

genes precisely.

B. Genes are inserted on the proper chromosome, but there

is no control on where it

goes on the chromosome.

C.Scientists have a general idea of where the gene will go

and what it will do to the

plant.

D.For scientists it is called a shot in the dark which

means using air guns that shoot the

genetic material into the cells but scientists have no

control over where the genes might

go in the plant cells.

Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 125


_6. Some of the processed food in the groceries are GMO made
product. Which breakfast food is likely to include GMO
ingredients because it is often made with soy and corn
products?
A. Cereal B. Eggs C. Orange juice
D. Biscuits

_7. Crops are often genetically engineered to improved traits.


Such crops and organisms are
called______.
A. Clones B. Transformed C. Changed D.
Genetically modified organisms

_8. Which of the following statement is a medical application of


genetic engineering?
A. Genes modification to achieve desirable traits
B. Crops is engineered for greater nutritional content
C. Manipulation of DNA to produce glowing monkeys
D. Inserting human DNA into Bacterial DNA for insulin

production
_9. Genetically modified crops are pesticide resistance. Which of

the following practices is

then unnecessary or not useful?

I. Crops irrigation III. Spraying of

pesticides

II. Stem cutting IV. Alteration or

change of genes

A.I and II only B. II and III only C. I, II and III

D. IV only

_10. Which of the following means of genetic engineering would

have the greatest impact on world

hunger?

I.Gene Modification of crops for greater nutritional

content
II. Manipulating DNA in trees for less requirement of
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 126
water

III.Modifying genes to achieve a desirable traits in

organisms

IV.Insertion of human DNA to bacterial DNA for

insulin production

A.I and II only B. II and III only C. I and IV

only D. I, II and III

References:

Elomaa, P. & Holton, T. (1994). Modification of Flower Colour

using genetic Engineering, Biotechnology and Genetic

Engineering Reviews. 12:1, 63-88, doi:

10.1080/02648725.1194.10647909.https://www.researchgate.

net/profile/Paula_Elomaa/publication/

284702780_Modification_of_Flower_Colour_using_Genetic_
Engineering/links/56b213dd08ae5ec4ed4b22a8/

Modification_of_Flower_Colour_using_Genetic_Engineering

Goldsbrough, P. (n.d.) Understand GMO crops? Test yourself

with this quiz. WEST LAFAYETTE, Ind. (765) 494-1334;

goldsbrough@hort.purdue.edu.

Pedersen, S., Jensen, B.F,. & Jorgensen, S.T. (1995). “Genetically

Modified Foods.” In American Chemical Society Symposium

Series. Vol. 605.doi 10.1021/bk-1995-0605.ch017 Accessed

August 1, 2017. http://pubsacs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/bk-1995-

0605.ch017.

Richmond, C. (2006). “Genetically Modified Crops In The

Phillipines: Can Existing Biosafety Regulations Adequately

Protect The Environment?” In Pacific Rim Law & Policy

Journal Association. Vol. 15. No. 2. Accessed August 1,

2017.
https://digital.lib.washington.edu/dspacelaw/bitstream/handle/

1773.1/631/15PacRimLpolyJ569.pdf?sequence=1).

Rungupan, W., Qu, X., & O’Connor, S. (2010). “Integrating

Carbon Halogen Bond Formation into Medicinal Plan

Metabolism”. In nature.doi: 10.1038/nature09524.


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 127

https;//www.sciencedaily.com/release/2010/11/101103141533

.htm.

Tally, Steve. (n.d.) tally@aes.purdue.edu. Purdue News Service:

(765) 494-2096; Biotechnology time line,International Food

Information Council Foundation survey on consumer views

on biotechnology.purduenews@purdue.edu

Veniza, K. (2014). Greener paper through genetically engineered

trees.

https;//geneticliteracyproject.org/2014/04/09/greener-paper-

through-genetically-engineered-trees/.
World Health Organization. (2014). “Frequently Asked Questions

on Genetically Modified Foods.” Accessed October 25, 2017.

http://www.who.int/foodssafety/areas_work/food-

technology/faq-genetically-modified-food-food/en.

Zimmer, Carl. (n.d.). “Scientist of the Year: Jay Keasling.”

Discoverer Magazine December 2006 Issue. Accessed

August 1, 2017. http://discovermagazine.com/2006/dec/cover.


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 128
Entry-Test (III. Module 4)

To determine if you have the knowledge needed to enter the

module and check whether you have learned the lessons to be

taught.

Multiple Choice - Direction: Answer the following questions

based from your existing knowledge and write your

best answer in the blank before each number.

_1.Successful gene therapy systems that are available and very

useful today are the viral vectors.


Which of the following viruses are viral vectors?

I. Pox virus II. Herpes virus III. Adenovirus

IV. Ebola virus

A. I and II only B. II and III only C. II and IV only

D. I, II, and III

_2. Germ-line gene therapy refers to the germ cells or called sex

cells, or simply called the sperm or egg cell, in this process

genes are altered by the introduction or insertion of suitable

normal genes and eradicate abnormal genes. Can we say that

germ-line therapy is heritable or non heritable?

A. Germ-line therapy is heritable C. Sometimes

germ-line therapy is heritable

B. Germ-line therapy is not heritable D. Germ-line is

not related to heredity


__3. In gene therapy the healthy gene inserted into a target cell.

In what way gene therapy became

successful in the process?

A. The healthy gene take over and kill the defective gene

B. The healthy gene is attached to the cell's mRNA

molecules

C. The healthy gene is inserted manually into the cell's

mitochondria

D. The healthy gene be able to make the correct amount of


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 129
the protein needed

__4. To carry a healthy gene in the process of gene therapy.

Which vehicles/vectors are often

used?
A. Bacteria B. Plastic capsules C. Powder

balls D. Viruses

__5. What was the purpose of the Human Genome Project?

A. To create new antibiotics C. To develop first

human clones

B. To improve stem cell research D. To map the entire

human genome

__6. Virus need a certain habitat for their reproduction and to

keep them alive. What do virus

need to reproduce?

A.They need a parasite C. They need a host

cell
B. They need a bacteria D. They need

genetic material

__7. What process of gene therapy is used to treat Cystic

Fibrosis?

A. By inducing a mutation

B. Removing a portion of the abnormal gene

C. Replacing the abnormal gene with a copy of the normal

gene

D. By adding a nitrogen base to the beginning of the DNA

sequence

__8. A child is born with a faulty gene that causes a serious

disease. Which process can solve

this problem?
A. Gene Therapy C. RNA

duplication

B. DNA fingerprinting D. Genome

sequencing/splicing
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 130

__9. When a virus invades a living cell, what material will take

over the cell’s functions?

A. Mitochondria B. Cytoplasm C. plasma

membrane D. Genetic material

__10. Which of the following cells can lived longer and may last

a lifetime to an individual

which provides a major benefit to gene therapy?

I. Muscle cells II. Stem cells III. Neuron cells

IV. Sperm cell


A. I and II only B. I, II and III C. II, III and IV

D. III and IV
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 131
III. MODULE 5

Topic: Gene Therapy (Stem Cells)

Overview:

Gene therapy is a cure or treatment that involves insertion or

introducing a normal copy of a gene into a patient, to repair or

restore a defective genes responsible for the patient’s disease.

When a gene is damaged, the blueprint for the construction of the

protein it codes is imperfect which makes the resulting protein to

be abnormal. The goal of gene therapy is to cure a genetic disease

or disorders by repairing the damaged gene responsible for the

disease. Like for example, a disease that is caused by a


"variation" or "mutation“ of a gene. Genetic disorders can be

passed on to family members who inherit the genetic abnormality.

A small number of rare disorders are caused by a mistake in a

single gene. Most disorders involving genetic factors, such as

heart disease and most cancers, arise from an interplay of

multiple genetic changes and environmental factors.

Keyterms: Gene, Gene therapy, Stem cells, Genetic disorders

Objectives:

1. Describe gene therapy and its various forms.

2. Assess the the gene therapy’s issues, potential benefits and

detriments to global

health.
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 132
Read:

What is a gene?

The gene theory was proposed by T. M Morgan which states

that “Chromosomes are bearers of hereditary units and each

chromosome carries hundreds or thousands of genes”. The genes

are arranged on the chromosomes in the linear order and on the

special regions or locus which are the fractions or part of DNA

molecule which is regarded as the genetic material. Gene was

coined by W Johansen in 1909. The gene is the unit of genetic

information that controls a specific aspect of the phenotype genes.

Genes can be transmitted from parent to offsprings. “The gene is

to genetics while the atom is to chemistry”. The Human Genome

Project (HGP) was the international, collaborative research

program whose goal was the complete mapping and

understanding of all the genes of human beings. All our genes


together are known as our "genome." Based from HGP, humans

have between 20,000- 25,000 genes.

Gene Therapy

Gene therapy is defined as a set of techniques that modify

the expression of an individual’s or correct abnormal genes, this

is the introduction of genes into existing cells to prevent or cure a

wide range of diseases. This process will correct defective genes

responsible for disease development. Gene therapy is a novel

treatment method which utilizes gene as therapeutic molecules

instead of conventional drug. The disease is treated with minimal

toxicity by the expression of the inserted DNA by the cell

machinery.

History of Gene Therapy


1972 -The concepts of Gene Therapy were introduced by

Friedman and Roblin authored a paper in Science titled "Gene


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 133
therapy for human genetic disease”.

1984 - A retrovirus vector system was designed that could

efficiently insert foreign genes into mammalian chromosomes.

1990 - The first approved gene therapy in the US took place

on September 14, 1990, at the National Institutes of Health

(NIH) under the direction of William French Anderson. The first

patient to receive gene therapy for SCID (severe combined

immunodeficiency) was a 4 year old girl named Ashanti DeSilva.

1992 - Doctor Claudio Bordignon performed the first

procedure of gene therapy using hematopoietic stem cells as

vectors to deliver genes intended to correct hereditary diseases.

1999 - Jesse Gelsinger death due to gene-therapy experiment.


2003 - a research team inserted genes into the brain for the

first time. They used liposomes which, unlike viral vectors, are

small enough to cross the blood–brain barrier.

2006 - gene therapy was successfully used to treat two adult

patients for X-linked chronic granulomatous disease.

2007 - first gene therapy trial for inherited retinal disease.

2008 - Gero Hutter a man with HIV has cured using gene

therapy.

2010 - gene therapy successfully treated an 18 year old male

patient in France with major beta- thalassemia.

2011 – gene therapy was accepted by Medical community to

cure HIV.

Recent Advancement in Gene therapy

2011 - A gene therapy called NLX-P101 dramatically reduces

movement impairment in Parkinson's patients, according to

Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 134


results of a Phase 2 study published on March, 2011 in the

journal Lancet Neurology

2014 – August of 2014 the FDA approved a drug Kymriah,

first gene therapy available for treatment of children with a form

of acute lymphoblastic leukemia. The marketing authorization of

Glybera and Strimvelis by the European Medicines Agency

(EMA) marked the end of the long and often troubled road of

gene therapy from biological concept to medical practice.

Glybera is a recombinant adeno- associated virus (AAV) vector

designed for gene therapy of lipoprotein lipase deficiency, while

Strimvelis is a genetically modified hematopoietic stem cell

preparation for the treatment of severe combined

immunodeficiency (SCID)

2011-2015 – this year mark an ongoing research of gene

therapy and there is an increases of the number of diseases that

has been treated successfully.


2017 – 16th of October the Food and Drug Administration

approved a promising new treatment, made by Gilead Sciences,

Called CAR-T. Gilead’s treatment, to be sold as Yescarta, is the

second CAR-T to win FDA approval

2018 - 20th of March 2018, a 13-year-old boy from New

Jersey became the first person in the US to receive an FDA-

approved gene therapy for an inherited disease. The therapy,

Luxturna, from Spark Therepeutics, was approved by the FDA in

December to treat a rare, inherited form of blindness.

2019 - Epigenetic therapy refer to strategies that aimed at

altering the expression of genes implicated in transformation. One

of the major targets of this strategy is histones, around which

DNA is wrapped to form nucleosomes. An epigenome consists of

a record of the chemical changes to the DNA and histone proteins

of an organism; these changes can be passed down


135 to an
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society

organism's offspring. Changes to the epigenome can result in


changes to the structure of chromatin and changes to the function

of the genome. The epigenome is a multitude of chemical

compounds that can tell the genome what to do. DNA holds the

instructions for building the proteins that carry out a variety of

functions in a cell. They can attach to DNA and direct such

actions as turning genes on or off, controlling the production of

proteins in particular cells. (Bennett, 2019)

The idea of epigenetic therapy is to stay away from killing

the cell. Rather, what we are trying to do is diplomacy, to change

the instructions of the cancer cells. You see, cancer cells start out

as normal cells. They have the set of instructions that is present in

every one of our cells.

(www.pbs.org › wgbh › nova › article › epigenetic-therapy)

Gene Marking is the attachment of Epigenomic compounds to

DNA, “Unchanged DNA sequence” but “Changed DNA

instructions”, The marks are sometimes passed on from cell to


cell as cells divide. They can “switch ON or OFF the genes”

followed by uncontrolled growth of cells. (www.pbs.org › wgbh ›

nova › article › epigenetic-therapy)

Types of Gene Therapy

Stem Cell Gene Therapy

Why are stem cells so important in gene and cell therapy?

The goal of gene and cell therapy is to develop a treatment

that lasts the lifetime of the patient. Most cells of the body turn

over in days, weeks, or months. Changing the protein expression

of a cell that lives only a few days, weeks, or months means that

the therapy would require multiple administrations. A few cells,

such as muscle cells, stem cells, neurons, and memory cells of the

immune system, are long lived and may last the lifetime of the

individual.  Stem cells provide two major benefits for gene


136 and
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society

cell therapy. First, they provide a cell type that can self-renew and

may survive the lifetime of the patient. Second, stem cells are
mother cells that have the potential to become any type of cell in

the body, they provide daughter cells that mature into the

specialized cells of each tissue. These differentiated daughter

cells can replace the diseased cells of the afflicted tissue(s).

Therefore, gene and cell therapy that uses stem cells theoretically

improves the disease condition for as long as those modified stem

cells live, potentially the lifetime of the patient.

(https://www.asgct.org/education/more-resources/gene-and-cell-

therapy-faqs)

Germ line gene therapy refers to the germ cells or called sex

cells, or simply called the sperm or egg cell, are altered by the

introduction of suitable genes, normal version of gene is inserted

into germ cells, those germ cells will divide normal versions of

the gene, any zygote produced as a result of this germ cell will

have a correct version of the defective gene and will continue

passing it on to their offspring. The change due to germ line


therapy would be heritable and would be passed on to later

generations. This approach, theoretically, should be highly

effective in counteracting genetic disorders. However, this option

is prohibited for application in human beings for a variety of

technical and ethical reasons.

Somatic cell gene therapy refers to a single defective cell

taken out of an individual’s body, then the functional version of

gene introduced into cell in a laboratory, cells reproduce, each

copies of cells with a corrected version of the gene is injected

back into the patient and the good gene treat the patient. Somatic

cell gene therapy is not inherited by the offspring.

Review Questions:

1.What are the risk and challenges of gene therapy and stem cell

research?
Read:

Approaches to Gene Therapy

Approaches to gene therapy are being tested, which includes the

following (Fliesler, 2017):

-Replacing a mutated gene that causes disease with a healthy

copy of the gene. _Inactivating, or “knocking out,” a mutated

gene that is functioning improperly.

-Introducing a new gene into the body to help fight a disease.


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 137
VECTOR SYSTEM FOR GENE THERAPY

A gene cannot be directly inserted into a person’s cell. It must be

delivered to the cell using a carrier, or vector. Vectors are carrier

molecules which are employed to enhance gene transfer

efficiency in gene therapy. In optimizing a particular vector, one

must consider the host immune responses ( Science Daily 2017):

– Must target specific tissues for long term gene expression.

– Regulation or maintenance of the gene after insertion.


Viral vectors system

One of the successful gene therapy systems available today

are viral vectors, such as retrovirus, adenovirus (types 2 and 5),

adeno-associated virus, herpes virus, pox virus, human foamy

virus (HFV), and lentivirus. All viral vector genomes have been

modified by deleting some areas of their genomes so that their

replication becomes deranged and it makes them more safe, but

the system has some problems, such as their marked

immunogenicity that causes induction of inflammatory system

leading to degeneration of transducted tissue; and toxin

production, including mortality, the insertional mutagenesis; and

their limitation in transgenic capacity size. Other types of viruses

are under investigation to date and recently, many more different

virus vector systems are being developed. These are derived from

vaccinia virus, human cytomegalovirus, EBV, but as mentioned

earlier, problems, such as their mutagen and carcinogen


properties and long-term maintenance, are major limitations in

utilizing the viral vectors in gene therapy. (Nayerossadat, 2012)

Retroviral vectors - Retroviral vectors are one of the most

frequently employed forms of gene delivery in somatic and

germline gene therapies. Retroviruses in contrast to adenoviral


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 138

and lentiviral vectors, can transfect dividing cells because they

can pass through the nuclear pores of mitotic cells; this character

of retroviruses make them proper candidates for in situ treatment.

(Nayerossadat, 2012)

Adenoviral vectors - Adenoviral vectors have been isolated from

a large number of different species, and more than 100 different

serotypes have been reported. Most adults have been exposed to

the adenovirus serotypes most commonly used in gene therapy

(types 2 and 5). Adenoviruses type 2 and 5 can be utilized for

transferring both dividing and nondividing cells and have low

host specificity so can be used for gene delivery into large range
of tissues. They would not integrate into the host genome, their

gene expression is too short term. Natural and acute immunologic

responses against adenoviruses have made their clinical

application limited to a few tissues, such as liver, lung (especially

for CF (Cystic Fibrosis) treatment), or localized cancer gene

therapy. Gene therapy by adenoviral vectors has caused serious

bad side effects and even death of some patients. (Nayerossadat,

2012)

Adeno-associated vectors - Adeno-associated vectors (AAV) are

like adenoviral vectors in their features but because of having

some deficiency in their replication and pathogenicity, are safer

than adenoviral vectors. In human, AAVs are not associated with

any disease. Another special character of AAV is their ability to

integrate into a specific site on chromosome 19 with no

noticeable effects cause long-term expression in vivo. The major

disadvantages of these vectors are complicated process of vector


production and the limited transgene capacity of the particles.

AAVs have been used in the treatment of some diseases, such as

CF, hemophilia B, Leber congenital amaurosis. (Nayerossadat,

2012)

Herpes simplex virus - Herpes simplex virus (HSV) is one of the

recent virus candidate in gene delivery. HSV systems include the

development of the so-called disabled infectious single copy


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 139

(DISC) viruses, which comprise a glycoprotein H defective

mutant HSV genome. Herpes vectors has the greatest potential for

gene delivery to nervous system, tumors, and cancer cells.

(Nayerossadat, 2012)

Lentiviruses - Lentiviruses are a subclass of retroviruses. They

have recently been used as gene delivery vectors due to their

ability to naturally integrate with nondividing cells, which is the

unique feature of lentiviruses as compared with other

retroviruses, which can infect only the dividing cells. Lentiviral


vectors extensively used for ex vivo gene transfer in central

nervous system with no significant immune responses and no

unwanted side effects. Lentiviral vectors have the advantages of

high-efficiency infection of dividing and nondividing cells, long-

term stable expression of a transgene, low immunogenicity, and

the ability to accommodate larger transgenes. There are numerous

examples of effective long-term treatment of animal models of

neurologic disorders, such as motor neuron diseases, Parkinson,

Alzheimer, Huntington's disease, lysosomal storage diseases, and

spinal injury. (Nayerossadat, 2012)

Poxvirus vectors - Poxvirus vectors are members of the

Poxviridae family that are widely used for high-level

cytoplasmatic expression of transgenes. Poxviruses have been

used for cancer therapy in various studies, such as prostate

cancer, colorectal cancer, breast cancer, and lung cancer. There

are some problems in utilizing poxviruses for gene delivery


because of their complex structure and biology, so further studies

are required to improve their safety and to reduce the risk of

cytopathic effects. (Nayerossadat, 2012)

Epstein–Barr virus - Epstein–Barr virus as a herpes virus can be

used for the expression of large DNA fragments in target cells.

Because Epstein–Barr virus (EBV) establishes itself in the host

nucleus in a latent state as extrachromosomal circular plasmid,


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 140
this virus is suitable for long-term retention in the target cell.

Because of the natural B-cell tropism of the virus, EBV-derived

vectors, such as B-cell lymphoma, have been tested for immune

therapy of cancer. (Nayerossadat, 2012)

NONVIRAL DELIVERY SYSTEMS

Nonviral systems comprise all the physical and chemical

systems except viral systems. Efficiency of this system is less

than viral systems in gene, but their cost-effectiveness,

availability, and more importantly less induction of immune


system and no limitation in size of transgenic DNA compared

with viral system. The viral system is more effective for gene

delivery than nonviral delivery systems to date. (Nayerossadat,

2012)

Physical methods of nonviral gene delivery - Physical methods

applied for gene delivery are based on making transient

penetration in cell membrane by mechanical, electrical,

ultrasonic, hydrodynamic, or laser-based energy so that DNA

entrance into the targeted cells is facilitated. (Nayerossadat, 2012)

Naked DNA - Naked DNA alone is able to transfer a gene into

skin, thymus, cardiac muscle, and especially skeletal muscle and

liver cells when directly injected, also it has been applied directly.

Long-term expression has been observed in skeletal muscle

following injection for more than 19 months. Although naked

DNA injection is a safe and simple method, its efficiency for gene
delivery is low so it is only proper for some applications, such as

DNA vaccination. (Nayerossadat, 2012)

DNA particle bombardant by gene gun - DNA particle

bombardant by gene gun is an ideal alternative technique to

injection of naked DNA. Gold or tungsten spherical particles (1–3

μm diameter) are coated with plasmid DNA and then accelerated

to high speed by pressurized gas to penetrate into target tissue

cells. Actually it is a modification of a technique called


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 141
“biolistic,” originally developed for plant transgenesis, but now

used for in vitro and in vivo gene delivery into mammalian cells

too, such as skin, mucosa, or surgically exposed tissue and

especially for DNA-based immunization or vaccination.

(Nayerossadat, 2012)

Electroporation - Electroporation is temporary destabilization of

the cell membrane targeted tissue by insertion of a pair of

electrodes into it so that DNA molecules in the surrounding


media of the destabilized membrane would be able to penetrate

into cytoplasm and nucleoplasm of the cell, but unfortunately the

trangene can integrate only to 0.01% of the treated cells.

Electroporation has been used in vivo for many types of tissues,

such as skin, muscle, lung, and tumor treatment. There are some

problems in this method too that the more important are the

difficulty in surgical procedure in the placement of electrodes into

the internal tissues and that the high voltage applied to tissue

might damage the organ and affect genomic DNA stability.

(Nayerossadat, 2012)

Hydrodynamic - Hydrodynamic is a simple and highly efficient

method for direct intracellular delivery of any water-soluble

compounds and particles into internal organs. The efficiency of

this simple method in vivo is higher than any other nonviral

system. This method has been successful for gene delivery into

rodent liver and expression of hemophilia factors, hepatic growth


factors, in mouse and rat but it has been successful only in small

animals and not in human. (Nayerossadat, 2012)

Ultrasound - Ultrasound can make some nanomeric pores in

membrane to facilitate intracellular delivery of DNA particles

into cells of internal organs or tumors, so the size and

concentration of plasmid DNA have great role in efficiency of the

system. (Nayerossadat, 2012)

ADVANTAGES OF GENE THERAPY

Gene therapy has the potential to eliminate and prevent hereditary

diseases such as cystic fibrosis, ADA- SCID etc. It is a possible

cure for heart disease, AIDS and cancer. It gives someone born

with a genetic disease a chance to live. It can be used to eradicate

diseases from the future generations.

DISADVANTAGES OF GENE THERAPY


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 142
Long lasting therapy is not achieved by gene therapy due to rapid

dividing of cells, benefits of gene therapy is short lived. Immune

response to the transferred gene stimulates a potential risk to gene

therapy. Viruses used as vectors for gene transfer may cause

toxicity, immune responses, and inflammatory reactions in the

host. Disorders caused by defects in multiple genes cannot be

treated effectively using gene therapy.

ETHICAL ISSUES

What are the ethical issues surrounding gene therapy?

Gene therapy involves making changes to the body’s set of basic

instructions, it raises many unique ethical concerns. The ethical

questions surrounding gene therapy include ( Genetics Home

Reference, 2017):

 Can we use the gene therapy in the prenatal stage of

development in babies?
 Who are responsible or decides which traits are normal and

which constitute a disability or disorder?

 The high costs of gene therapy make it available only to the

wealthy, how about less previlege?

 How can we identify the good and bad uses of gene therapy?

 Could the widespread use of gene therapy make society less

accepting of people who are different?

 Should people be allowed to use gene therapy to enhance

basic human traits such as, intelligence, height, musically

inclined or athletic ability?

 Is gene therapy interfering with God’s plan? Who will have

authorization to gene therapy?

GENE THERAPY AND REGULATORY AFFAIRS


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 143

Regulatory and ethical issues of gene transfer are usually a

secondary preoccupation of researchers. Conducting gene therapy


clinical trials with genetically modified organisms as the vectors

presents unique safety and infection control issues. The area is

governed by a range of legislation and guidelines:

-Recombinant DNA Advisory Committee (RDAC)

-Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research (FDA - CBER)

-European Union - Biotechnology (EU)

-The European Medicines Agency (EMA)

- Gene Therapy Discussion Group of The International

Conference on Harmonization(ICH)

Review Question: How reliable is gene therapy?

Related Articles/Video Clips/STS Website/Film Clips

 Gene Therapy Basics – YouTube

www.youtube.com › watch
 Jan 17, 2019 — Gene therapy has been studied for more than

40 years and can help stop ... Your browser does not

currently recognize any of the video formats ...

 Gene Therapy, a new tool to cure human diseases –


YouTube

www.youtube.com › watch

 Dec 19, 2012 — Video created by UAB's Centre for Animal

Biotechnology and Gene Therapy (CBATEG) on gene

therapy and the advances already achieved in ...

 The Word on the Street: Cell and Gene Therapy – YouTube

www.youtube.com › watch
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 144

 Sep 24, 2019 — Enjoy the videos and music you love,

upload original content, and share it all with friends, ... A

gene therapy platform for treating diseases.

 Gene Therapy Explained – YouTube

www.youtube.com › watch
 Nov 28, 2016 — In gene therapy, a functional copy of the

gene is delivered into a ... This video explains how gene

therapy, delivered by AAV vectors, works.

Activities: ( Note: Do not answer activity 1 & 2 )

Activity 1: Compare the two types of gene therapy using a Venn

Diagram.

Activity 2: Have a debate on the bioethical issue on gene therapy.

Activity 3: Reflection Paper – answer the following questions

briefly in paragraph form.

Without its 100% assurance of effectiveness would you

allow yourself for gene therapy, What gene therapy can do and

cannot do today?

Assessment/Evaluation:
Exit-Test (III. Module 4)

Score______

Multiple Choice -Directions: Choose the best answer and write

your answer in the

blank before each number.

__1. Successful gene therapy systems that are available and very

useful today are the viral vectors.

Which of the following viruses are viral vectors?


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 145

I. Pox virus II. Herpes virus III. Adenovirus

IV. Ebola virus

A. I and II only B. II and III only C. II and IV only

D. I, II, and III


__2. Germ-line gene therapy refers to the germ cells or called sex

cells, or simply called the sperm or egg cell, in this process genes

are altered by the introduction or insertion of suitable normal

genes and eradicate abnormal genes. Can we say that germ-line

therapy is heritable or non heritable?

A. Germ-line therapy is heritable C. Sometimes

germ-line therapy is heritable

B. Germ-line therapy is not heritable D. Germ-line is

not related to heredity

__3. In gene therapy the healthy gene inserted into a target cell.

In what way gene therapy became

successful in the process?

A. The healthy gene take over and kill the defective gene

B. The healthy gene is attached to the cell's mRNA

molecules
C. The healthy gene is inserted manually into the cell's

mitochondria

D. The healthy gene be able to make the correct amount of

the protein needed

__4. To carry a healthy gene in the process of gene therapy.

Which vehicles/vectors are often

used?

A. Bacteria B. Plastic capsules C. Powder balls

D. Viruses

__5. What was the purpose of the Human Genome Project?

A. To create new antibiotics C. To develop first

human clones
B. To improve stem cell research D. To map the entire

human genome

6. Virus need a certain habitat for their reproduction and to keep


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 146

them alive. What do virus need

to reproduce?

A.They need a parasite C. They need a host

cell

B. They need a bacteria D. They need

genetic material

__7. What process of gene therapy is used to treat Cystic

Fibrosis?

A. By inducing a mutation

B. Removing a portion of the abnormal gene


C. Replacing the abnormal gene with a copy of the normal

gene

D. By adding a nitrogen base to the beginning of the DNA

sequence

__8. A child is born with a faulty gene that causes a serious

disease. Which process can solve

this problem?

A. Gene Therapy C. RNA

duplication

B. DNA fingerprinting D. Genome

sequencing/splicing

__9. When a virus invades a living cell, what material will take

over the cell’s functions?


A. Mitochondria B. Cytoplasm C. plasma

membrane D. Genetic material

__10. Which of the following cells can lived longer and may last

a lifetime to an individual

which provides a major benefit to gene therapy?

I. Muscle cells II. Stem cells III. Neuron cells

IV. Sperm cell

A. I and II only B. I, II and III C. II, III and IV

D. III and IV
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 146

References:

Dwivedi, Anupam (2019). Basics of Gene Therapy and its

Regulatory Aspects

Published on Aug 29, 2019.

www.slideshare.net/ssshammi1234/gene-therapy-by-anupam-
dwivedi-ms?qid=e107065e-cd5e-44ca-8a9d-

1e619c3c93f4&v=&b=&from_search=6

Epigenetic Therapy - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics

www.sciencedirect.com › topics › epigenetic-therapy

Epigenetic Therapy | NOVA | PBS Oct 15, 2007

www.pbs.org › wgbh › nova › article › epigenetic-therapy

Fliesler, N. (2017). “Now Hear This.” Accessed August 1, 2017.

https://hms.harvard.edu/news/now-hear

Genetics Home Reference. (2017). “What are the ethical Issues

surrounding gene therapy?” Accessed August 1, 2017.

https://ghr.nlm.nih.gov/primer/therapy/ethics.

Nouri Nayerossadat,1,2 Talebi Maedeh,1 and Palizban Abas Ali3

(2012) Viral and nonviral delivery systems for gene delivery -

NCBIwww.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov › pmc › articles › PMC3507026

Jump to Article information — Adv Biomed Res. 2012; 1: 27.

Published online 2012 Jul 6. doi: 10.4103/2277-9175.98152


Katare DP, Aeri V. Progress in gene therapy: A review. I.J.T.P.R.

2010;1:33. [Google Scholar]

Katare DP, Aeri V. Progress in gene therapy: A review. I.J.T.P.R.

2010;1:33. [Google Scholar]

Novel, Stone (2010) viral vector systems for gene therapy.

Viruses. 2010;2:1002–7. [PMC free article] [PubMed]

[Google Scholar]

Rosenberg SA, Aebersold P, Cornetta K, Kasid A, Morgan RA,

Moen R, et al. Gene transfer into humans immunotherapy of

patients with advanced melanoma, using tumor- infiltrating


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 147

lymphocytes modified by retroviral gene transduction. N Engl

J Med. 1990;323:570–8. [PubMed] [Google Scholar]

Science Daily. (n.d.) “Gene Therapy” Accessed August 1, 2017.

https://www.sciencedaily.com/terms/gene_therapy.htm.

Talebi Maedeh, and Palizban Abas Ali (2012). “Viral and

nonviral delivery systems for gene delivery”. Adv Biomed


Res. 2012; 1: 27. Published online 2012 Jul 6.

doi: 10.4103/2277-9175.98152PMCID: PMC3507026 PMID:

23210086

What is the Human Genome Project?

www.genome.gov › human-genome-project ›

Bennett, Richard L. ... Jonathan D. Licht, in Encyclopedia of

Cancer (Third Edition), 201

Entry-Test (III. Module 6)

Score_______

To determine if you have the knowledge needed to enter the

module and check whether you have learned the lessons to be

taught.

Multiple Choice - Direction: Answer the following questions

based from your existing knowledge and write your

best answer in the blank before each number.


___1. Nanotechnology creates a problem to our environment.

Which of the following is NOT an

environmental concern in using Nanotechnology?

A. No nano-specific Environmental Protection Agency

(EPA) regulation.

B. High reactivity and toxicity.

C. Rapid and uncontrolled distribution in the

environment.

D. Improved detection and removal of contaminants.

Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 148

___2. Which of the following is an issue and concern of

Nanotechnology?

A. Nanotechnology seeks to develop new materials with

specific properties.
B. Nanomanufacturing leads to the development new

products and improved

materials.

C. Nanotechnology may introduce new efficiencies and

paradigms which may make some practices

uncompetitive or obsolete. 

D. It may be complicated to detect its presence unless

one has the specialize tools of

Nanotechnology.

____3. Professor Norio Taniguchi coined the term

nanotechnology. The prefix nano comes


from the_______meaning________.

A. french word meaning billion. C. greek

word meaning dwarf.

B. spanish word meaning particle D. latin

word meaning invisible

____4. Richard Feynman is often credited with predicting the


potential of nanotechnology.

What was the title of his famous speech given on


December 29, 1959?

A. The bottom is dotted.

B. There is a tiny room at the bottom

C. Things get microscopic at the bottom


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 149

D. There is a plenty of room at the bottom


___5. Grey goo can solve some environmental problems but
create a devastating effect to nature.

Which of the following statement describes grey


goo?

A.Toxic byproduct resulting from synthesis of carbon


nanotubes

B. The feeder material used to grow grey nanoparticles


in the laboratory

C. A hypothetical substance composed of out-of-control


self-replicating
Nanobots that consumes all living matter on Earth

D. Waste product from the production of nanoglue made


from the
Membranes on the feet of the Madagascan Grey
Gecko
III. Module 6
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 150

Topic: The Nanoworld


Overview:

Nanoscience and nanotechnology involve the ability to see

and control individual atoms and molecules. Everything on Earth

is made up of atoms, the food we eat, the clothes we wear, the

buildings and houses we live in, and our own bodies. But

something as small as an atom is impossible to see with the naked

eye. In fact, it’s impossible to see atoms using the microscopes

typically used in high school science classes. In recent decades

the development of microscopes capable of displaying particles as

small as atoms has allowed scientists to see what they are

working with. Scientists have been studying and working with

nanoparticles for centuries, but the effectiveness of their work has

been hampered by their inability to see the structure of

nanoparticles. Medieval stained glass windows are an example of


how nanotechnology was used in the pre-modern era. (Courtesy:

NanoBioNet)

Keyterms: Nanotechnology, nanomaterials, nanoparticles

Objective:

1. Discuss the major impacts of nanotechnology on

society.

1.1Analyze the issue of nanotechnology through

the concept of STS,

benefits to society and critique the issue on

its costs.
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 151

Read:

NANOWORLD – NANOTECHNOLOGY
The term "Nanos" comes from the Greek and means dwarf.

"Nano" is the term used for the billionth part of a metre (= 1

nanometre). Nanotechnology is science, engineering, and

technology conducted at the nanoscale, which is about 1 to 100

nanometers. It is the generic term for a wide range of

technologies used in the research, development, processing and

production of structures and materials measured within the

nanometre scale.

Facts:

• When two carbon atoms join together to make a molecule the

distance between them

is in the range of 0.12-0.15 nm.

• DNA double helix is about 2 nm from one side to the other. It

develops into a new field

of DNA nanotechnology. In future DNA can be manipulated

that can lead to new


revolution. Human genome can be manipulated according to

requirements.

• A nanometer and a meter can be understood as the same size-

difference as between

golf ball and the Earth.

• One nanometer is about one twenty-five-thousandth the

diameter of a human hair.

Fingernails grow one nanometer per second.

• There are 25,400,000 nanometers in an inch

• A sheet of newspaper is about 100,000 nanometers thick

Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 152


How nanotechnology started

The ideas and concepts behind nanoscience and

nanotechnology started with a talk entitled “There’s Plenty of

Room at the Bottom” by physicist Richard Feynman at an

American Physical Society meeting at the California Institute of

Technology (CalTech) on December 29, 1959, long before the

term nanotechnology was used. In his talk, Feynman described a

process in which scientists would be able to manipulate and


control individual atoms and molecules. Over a decade later, in

his explorations of ultraprecision machining, Professor Norio

Taniguchi coined the term nanotechnology. It wasn't until 1981,

with the development of the scanning tunneling microscope that

could "see" individual atoms, that modern nanotechnology began.

Nanomaterials

Nanotechnology has nanomaterials which can be classified

into one, two and three dimensions nanoparticles. This

classification is based upon different properties it holds153such as


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society

scattering of light, absorbing x rays, transport electric current or

heat. Nanotechnology has multidisciplinary character affecting

multiple traditional technologies and different scientific

disciplines. New materials which can be scaled even at atomic

size can be manufactured. You might be wearing nanotechnology

pants (that's "trousers" to you in UK), walking on a

nanotechnology rug, sleeping on nanotechnology sheets, or


hauling nanotechnology luggage to the airport. All these products

are made from fabrics coated with "nanowhiskers." These tiny

surface fibers are so small that dirt cannot penetrate into them,

which means the deeper layers of material stay clean. Some

brands of sunscreens use nanotechnology in a similar way: they

coat your skin with a layer of nanoscopic titanium dioxide or zinc

oxide that blocks out the Sun's harmful ultraviolet rays. Nano-

coatings are also appearing on scratch-resistant car bumpers, anti-

slip steps on vans and buses, corrosion resistant paints, and

wound dressings.

Carbon nanotubes are among the most exciting of

nanomaterials. These rod-shaped carbon molecules are roughly

one nanometer across. Although they're hollow, their densely

packed structure makes them incredibly strong and they can be

grown into fibers of virtually any length. NASA scientists have

recently proposed carbon nanotubes could be used to make a


gigantic elevator stretching all the way from Earth into space.

Equipment and people could be shuttled slowly up and down this

"carbon ladder to the stars," saving the need for expensive rocket

flights.

How to view minute nanoparticles?

Nanoscientists use high-powered microscopes that use

unique methods to allow them to see the surface features on the

atomic scale, effectively opening the door to modern

nanotechnology. In 1930s, scientists were able to see at the

nanoscale using instruments such as the scanning electron


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 154

microscope, the transmission electron microscope, and the field

ion microscope. The most recent and notable developments in

microscopy are the scanning tunneling microscope and the atomic

force microscope.

The electron microscope, first developed by German

engineers Ernst Ruska and Max Knoll in the 1930s, uses a


particle beam of electrons to illuminate a specimen and create a

highly magnified image. Electron microscopes yield much greater

resolution than the older light microscopes; they can obtain

magnifications of up to 1 million times, while the best light

microscopes can magnify an image only about 1,500 times.

The scanning tunneling microscope (STM) is among a

number of instruments that allows scientists to view and

manipulate nanoscale particles, atoms, and small molecules. Its

development earned its inventors, Gerd Binig and Heinrich

Rohrer, the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1986. Atomic force

microscopes (AFMs) gather information by "feeling" the surface

with a mechanical probe. Gerd Binig, along with Calvin Quate

and Christoph Gerber, developed the first AFM in 1986. These

microscopes make use of tiny but exact movements to

enable precise mechanical scanning.


Nanotechnology Applications in:
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 155

Medicine

Researchers are developing customized nanoparticles the

size of molecules that can deliver drugs directly to diseased cells


in your body.  When it's perfected, this method should greatly

reduce the damage treatment such as chemotherapy does to a

patient's healthy cells.

Electronics

Nanotechnology holds some answers for how we might

increase the capabilities of electronics devices while we reduce

their weight and power consumption.

Food

Nanotechnology is having an impact on several aspects of

food science, from how food is grown to how it is packaged.

Companies are developing nanomaterials that will make a

difference not only in the taste of food, but also in food safety,

and the health benefits that food delivers.


Fuel Cells

Nanotechnology is being used to reduce the cost of catalysts

used in fuel cells to produce hydrogen ions from fuel such as

methanol and to improve the efficiency of membranes used in

fuel cells to separate hydrogen ions from other gases such as

oxygen.

Solar Cells

Companies have developed nanotech solar cells that can be

manufactured at significantly lower cost than conventional


156
solar
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society

cells.

Batteries

Companies are currently developing batteries using

nanomaterials. One such battery will be a good as new after

sitting on the shelf for decades. Another battery can be recharged

significantly faster than conventional batteries. 


Space

Nanotechnology may hold the key to making space-flight

more practical. Advancements in nanomaterials make lightweight

spacecraft and a cable for the space elevator possible. By

significantly reducing the amount of rocket fuel required, these

advances could lower the cost of reaching orbit and traveling in

space.

Fuels

Nanotechnology can address the shortage of fossil fuels such

as diesel and gasoline by making the production of fuels from low

grade raw materials economical, increasing the mileage of

engines, and making the production of fuels from normal raw

materials more efficient.


Better Air Quality

Nanotechnology can improve the performance of catalysts

used to transform vapors escaping from cars or industrial plants

into harmless gasses. That's because catalysts made from

nanoparticles have a greater surface area to interact with the

reacting chemicals than catalysts made from larger particles. The

larger surface area allows more chemicals to interact with the

catalyst simultaneously, which makes the catalyst more effective.

Cleaner Water
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 157

Nanotechnology is being used to develop solutions to three

very different problems in water quality. One challenge is the

removal of industrial wastes, such as a cleaning solvent called

TCE, from groundwater. Nanoparticles can be used to convert the

contaminating chemical through a chemical reaction to make it

harmless. Studies have shown that this method can be used


successfully to reach contaminates dispersed in underground

ponds and at much lower cost than methods which require

pumping the water out of the ground for treatment.

Chemical Sensors

Nanotechnology can enable sensors to detect very small

amounts of chemical vapors. Various types of detecting elements,

such as carbon nanotubes, zinc oxide nanowires or palladium

nanoparticles can be used in nanotechnology-based sensors.

Because of the small size of nanotubes, nanowires, or

nanoparticles, a few gas molecules are sufficient to change the

electrical properties of the sensing elements. This allows the

detection of a very low concentration of chemical vapors.

Sporting Goods
If you're a tennis or golf fan, you'll be glad to hear that even

sporting goods has wandered into the nano realm. Current

nanotechnology applications in the sports arena include

increasing the strength of tennis racquets, filling any

imperfections in club shaft materials and reducing the rate at

which air leaks from tennis balls.

158
FabricChapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society

Making composite fabric with nano-sized particles or fibers

allows improvement of fabric properties without a significant

increase in weight, thickness, or stiffness as might have been the

case with previously-used  techniques.

National Nanotechnology Initiative (NNI)


The vision of the National Nanotechnology Initiative (NNI) is

a future in which the ability to understand and control matter at

the nanoscale leads to a revolution in technology and industry that

benefits society. The NNI expedites the discovery, development,

and deployment of nanoscale science, engineering, and

technology to serve the public good through a program of

coordinated research and development aligned with the missions

of the participating agencies. In order to realize the NNI vision,

the NNI agencies are working collectively toward four primary

goals; please note that each of the following goals is linked to a

page detailing each goal's objectives:

1. Advance a world-class nanotechnology research and

development program;

2. Foster the transfer of new technologies into products for

commercial and public benefit;


3. Develop and sustain educational resources, a skilled

workforce, and a dynamic infrastructure and toolset to

advance nanotechnology; and

4. Support responsible development of nanotechnology.

Program Component Areas (PCAs), which provide an

organizational framework for categorizing the NNI's activities,

are major subject areas under which related projects and activities

are grouped. Progress in these areas is critical to achieving


159 the
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society

NNI's goals and to realizing its vision. The investment for each

PCA is reported in the annual NNI supplement to the President’s

Budget.

The PCAs are:

1.     Nanotechnology Signature Initiatives and Grand Challenges

  1a. Sustainable Nanomanufacturing: Creating the Industries

of the Future

  1b. Nanoelectronics for 2020 and Beyond


  1c. Nanotechnology Knowledge Infrastructure (NKI):

Enabling National Leadership in

Sustainable Design

  1d. Nanotechnology for Sensors and Sensors for

Nanotechnology: Improving and

Protecting Health, Safety, and the Environment

  1e. Water Sustainability through Nanotechnology: Nanoscale

Solutions for a Global-

Scale Challenge

  1f. Nanotechnology-Inspired Grand Challenge for Future

Computing

2.     Foundational Research

3.     Nanotechnology-Enabled Applications, Devices, and

Systems

4.     Research Infrastructure and Instrumentation

5.     Environment, Health, and Safety


Advantages of Nanotechnology

High complexity, fast construction, medical uses ➔

rearrangement of single molecules instead of cells, environmental

uses ➔ zero pollution ➔ rebuilding of the ozone layer, fast

computers, inexpensive access to space, space elevator, new

weapons

Disadvantages of Nanotechnology

Grey goo, a nightmarish scenario of nanotechnology in which

out-of-control self-replicating nanobots destroy the biosphere by


Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 160

endlessly producing replicas of themselves and feeding on

materials necessary for life. The term was coined by American

engineer Eric Drexler in his book Engines of Creation (1986)➔

unstoppable replication destroying everything around (Sabil

Francis, 2010)
Disastrous accidents, abuse, new weapons, nanobots taking over

the world

Ethical, Legal, and Societal Issues

Accountable development of nanotechnology is one of the

four goals of the NNI and is essential to advancing the other three

(specifically, continuing a world-class R&D program; fostering

the transfer of new nanotechnologies into products for

commercial and public benefit; and educating the workforce,

engaging the public, and sustaining an effective nanotechnology

R&D infrastructure).  

An important component of responsible development is the

consideration of the ethical, legal, and societal implications of

nanotechnology. How nanotechnology research and applications

are introduced into society; how transparent decisions are; how

sensitive and responsive policies are to the needs and perceptions

of the full range of stakeholders; and how ethical, legal, and


social issues are addressed will determine public trust and the

future of innovation driven by nanotechnology. (

https://www.nano.gov/you/ethical-legal-issues)

The NNI is committed to fostering the development of a

community of experts on ethical, legal, and societal issues (ELSI)

related to nanotechnology and to building collaborations among

ELSI communities, such as consumers, engineers, ethicists,

manufacturers, nongovernmental organizations, regulators, and

scientists. These stakeholder groups will consider 161


potential
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society

benefits and risks of research breakthroughs and provide their

perspectives on new research directions. With its industry

stakeholders, the NNI will also develop information resources for

ethical and legal issues related to intellectual property and ethical

implications of nanotechnology-based patents and trade secrets.  (

https://www.nano.gov/you/ethical-legal-issues)
Review Questions:

What are the factors that need to be considered before

manufacturing materials

through nanotechnology?

Related Articles/Video Clips/STS Website/Film Clips:

 Article: “Nanoethics: The ethical and Social Implications of

Nanotechnology” (Patrick Lin and Fritz Allhoff, Hoboken,

New Jersey: John Wiley and Sons, Inc. 2007

 Dayrit, Fabian M. Ppt: Can we build a culture of science

through

nanotechnology?(2013)

 Article: “Environmental Impacts of Nanotechnology and Its

Products” (Zhang et. Al

Proceedings of the 2011 Midwest Section Conference of the

American Societyfor
Engineering Education, 2011)

 Article: “Nanoethics: The ethical and Social Implications of

Nanotechnology” (Patrick

Lin and Fritz Allhoff, Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley

and Sons, Inc. 2007

 How the optical microscope became a nanoscope, The Nobel

Prize in Chemistry 2014, The Royal Swedish Academy of

Sciences

 Molecular Expressions—Science, Optics and You, Florida

State University

 Nanoworld Center for Microscopy and Microanalysis,

University of Queensland,

Australia

162
Activities: (Note: Do not answer activity 1)
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society
Activity 1: Group discussion. Form groups made up of four

to eight members and

discuss the impact of nanotechnology in

various aspects

(environment, in economy, health, ethics, etc.)

of the society. Share

your own ideas and principles in relation to the

topic.

Activity 2: What are the contributions of nanotechnology

for the improvement and

sustainability of our environment and

society as a whole? Discuss

one ethical issue of nanotechnology.

Assessment/Evaluation:
Exit-Test (III. Module 6)

Score:_________

Multiple Choice - Direction: Choose the best answer in the blank

before each number.

___1. Nanotechnology creates a problem to our environment.

Which of the following is NOT an

environmental concern in using Nanotechnology?

A. No nano-specific Environmental Protection Agency

(EPA) regulation.

B. High reactivity and toxicity.

C. Rapid and uncontrolled distribution in the

environment.

D. Improved detection and removal of contaminants.


___2. Which of the following is an issue and concern of

Nanotechnology?

A. Nanotechnology seeks to develop new materials with

specific properties.
Chapter III: Specific Issues in Science, Technology and Society 163

B. Nanomanufacturing leads to the development new

products and improved

materials.

C. Nanotechnology may introduce new efficiencies and

paradigms which may make some practices

uncompetitive or obsolete. 

D. It may be complicated to detect its presence unless

one has the specialize tools of

Nanotechnology.

___3. Professor Norio Taniguchi coined the term

nanotechnology. The prefix nano comes


from the_______meaning________.

A. french word meaning billion. C. greek

word meaning dwarf.

B. spanish word meaning particle D. latin

word meaning invisible

___4. Richard Feynman is often credited with predicting the


potential of nanotechnology. What was the title of his
famous speech given on December 29, 1959?

A. The bottom is dotted.

B. There is a tiny room at the bottom

C. Things get microscopic at the bottom

D. There is a plenty of room at the bottom

___5. Grey goo can solve some environmental problems but


create a devastating effect to nature.
Which of the following statement describes grey
goo?
A.Toxic byproduct resulting from synthesis of carbon
nanotubes

B. The feeder material used to grow grey nanoparticles


in the laboratory

C. A hypothetical substance composed of out-of-


control self-replicating
Nanobots that consumes all living matter on
Earth

D. Waste product from the production of nanoglue made


from the
Membranes on the feet of the Madagascan Grey
Gecko

References:

National Nanotechnology Initiative. (2017). “Manufacturing at

the Nanoscale.” Accessed February 25, 2017.

https://www.nano.gov/nanotech-101/what/manufacturing

National Nanotechnology Initiative. (2017). “Nanotechnology

101” Accessed February 25, 2017.


https://www.nano.gov/nanotech-101/.

National Nanotechnology Initiative. (2017). “What is

Nanotechnology.” Accessed February 25, 2017.

https://www.nano.gov/nanotech-101/what/definition

University of Washington. “Societal and Ethical Implications of

Nanotechnology.” Accessed February 25, 2017.

http://depts.washington.edu/ntethics

https://www.nano.gov/nanotech-101/what/seeing-nano

Seeing at the Nanoscale | nano.gov www.nano.gov › nanotech-

101 › what › seeing-nano

https://www.britannica.com/technology/grey-goo

https://www.encyclopedia.com/science/encyclopedias-almanacs-

transcripts-and-maps/nanoethics

You might also like