Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Systematization of Common Cracking Patterns in Buildings
Systematization of Common Cracking Patterns in Buildings
Case studies
Extended Abstract
May 2015
Abstract
The cracking phenomenon has been, over the years, one of the most common pathologies in buildings, concerning not only
the external façades but also the interior elements. This phenomenon occurs due to imperfect design or execution, or simply
due to accidental actions over which it’s almost impossible to predict their consequences.
This work intends to study the most common cracking patterns in buildings, through an inspection that will be conducted over
6 case studies. The analysis of these cases intends to give a practical application to what was referred in the literature review,
regarding cracking characteristics, cracking patterns and diagnosis of the main causes.
To conduct the inspection, it’s developed a methodology focused on the cracking phenomenon, which includes the elaboration
of an inspection sheet to gather data concerning the building and its pathologies.
The data analysis will allow to create a cracking patterns catalogue that intends to represent the patterns observed and its
main characteristics.
Keywords: Cracking patterns; Façades; Inspection; Diagnosis
individually. Cracks appear when stress is bigger than the – shear force (kN); A – area (m2)
1
The relative displacement of parallel sections causes 2.4. Causes and cracking patterns
strain that can be extension or distortion according to the According to (CEB, 1992), the occurrence of cracking can
axis in which the displacement occurs. In case of uniform be related with two different periods on the life of the
axial strain, stress can be calculated with the Equation 3: structure – before and after concrete hardening. Listed
𝜎 = 𝐸𝜀 Equation 3 below are the main causes associated with each of these
Where: periods.
𝜎 – normal stress (kPa); E – modulus of elasticity (MPa); 𝜀 – strain (m/m) Before concrete hardening:
- Plastic cracks: Plastic shrinkage in concrete (i); Plastic
The volume range of the materials is the result of its free settlement of concrete (ii).
expansion or shrinkage. In case this range is restricted, - Cracks that occur due to displacements during
there will appear stress on the material. In the special case construction: Incorrect reinforcement setting (iii);
of temperature difference, this stress can be obtain using Premature removal of formwork (iv).
the Equation 4: After concrete hardening:
𝜎 = 𝐸 𝛼𝑡 ∆𝑇 Equation 4
- Physical cracks: Concrete shrinkage (v); Plaster
Where:
shrinkage (vi).
𝜎 – normal stress (kPa); E – modulus of elasticity (MPa); 𝛼𝑡 – coefficient
- Structural cracks: Creep of concrete (vii); Differential
of linear thermal extension (m/m ºC); ∆𝑇 – temperature difference (ºC)
settlements (viii); Accidental overload (ix); Excessive
2.3.1. According to its width compressive loads on masonry walls (xi); Seismic action
(GASPAR, et al., 2006) considers 5 levels: - Hygrothermal cracks: Thermal actions (xiii); Fire action
- Level 0 (<0,1 mm): Hair strand; (xiv); Freeze thaw (xv); Moisture-induced size changes
- Level 2 (0,25-1 mm): Visible; - Chemical cracks: Reinforcement corrosion (xvii); Alkali
- Level 3 (1-2 mm): Well defined; silica reaction (xviii); Salt crystallization (xix).
2.3.2. According to its evolution 3.1 are listed the most common cracking patterns related
According to (LAPA, 2008) and (SILVA, 1998), cracks can to the causes referred.
two types of cracks it’s their movement, i.e., in case there’s 3.1. Applied methodology
no movement or this can be considered negligible, then The applied methodology on the case studies inspection
of cracks can suffer aggravation of its causes over time or ii. Data organization
just suffer from cyclical or random variations (LUCAS, a. General analysis of cracking
2
Table 3.1 – Cracking patterns, elements affected and possible
causes
3
allowing to determinate the most probable cause to each Case study B – Neighbourhood with 11 building blocks,
type of crack. each one with 4 floors and no basements. The buildings
have a reinforced concrete structure with fungiform slabs.
3.2. Suggested inspection sheet The foundation consists in shallow foundation connected
Inspection sheets used in this work intend to fully by beams.
characterize the inspected buildings, analysing each
Case study C – 14 buildings, with residential floors on the
façade separately. In case of interior cracking, inspection
top floors and shops on the ground floor, making a total of
sheets are filled for each interior room observed.
276 flats and 6612 m2 of commercial area. Each building
In each façade is characterized the widest or biggest crack
has 8 floors on the west façade and 11 floors on the east
of each type.
façade. It also has an underground park made for 170
The organization of the inspection sheets is the following:
vehicles. The buildings have a reinforced concrete
building ID; used instruments and available documents;
structure.
main characterization of the façades; cracking
characterization.
Case study D – Rehabilitated high school, consisting on
the erection of three new buildings. Two of these buildings
3.3. Characterization of the case studies
are an extension of existing ones – the main and gym
Table 3.2 shows the total number of buildings, façades
buildings.
and interior rooms visited on each case study, as well as
the number of inspection sheets filled on each of them. Case study E – Historical convent from the XVII century,
Table 3.2 – Total of building, façades and interior rooms on located on Bairro Alto. It was rehabilitated, being now used
each case study as a complex of luxury apartments. The convent has a
Number of exterior Number of interior stone masonry and wood structure. It has 4 floors and no
façades rooms
basements.
CS NB
Observed IS Observed IS
Case study F – Hotel next to Avenida da Liberdade, with
A 9 9 4 0 0
3 floors and 4 basements. The main façade was kept from
B 12 14 3 0 0
the original building and the rest of the hotel was built
C 2 0 0 14 6
posteriorly. This façade is made of stone, and the rest of
D 4 11 6 0 0
the building has a reinforced concrete structure.
E 1 2 4 0 0
4
Figure 4.1 – Diagonal (a) and map (b) cracking Figure 4.3 – Vertical (a) and diagonal (b) cracking
5
Figure 4.5 – Horizontal (a) and vertical (b) cracking
windows or other openings (both with 14%). Figure 4.9 – Correlation between cracking pattern and possible
causes
6
Analysing Figure 4.9, we can see that causes like
excessive deformation of the support elements, moisture-
induced size changes and differential settlements are
related with the most part of the cracking patterns, i.e.,
these causes can lead to different cracking patterns. The
other causes are related with fewer cracking patterns, as
it happens with plaster shrinkage that only lead to mapped
cracks.
MP – “fissuras mapeadas” (mapped cracks); JA – “fissuras junto a
janelas/aberturas” (cracks next to windows); TM – “fissuras na transição de
materiais” (cracks on the interface between different materials); HE – “fissuras
horizontais em esquinas” (horizontal cracks on corners); DG – “fissuras diagonais”
(diagonal cracks); HZ – “fissuras horizontais” (horizontal cracks); VT – “fissuras
verticais” (vertical cracks); VC – “fissuras horizontais em varandas/consolas”
(cracks on balconies or cantilevered elements)
small to moderate widths. Cracks with big or very big horizontais em esquinas” (horizontal cracks on corners); DG – “fissuras diagonais”
(diagonal cracks); HZ – “fissuras horizontais” (horizontal cracks); VT – “fissuras
widths are only a small percentage of the cracks observed. verticais” (vertical cracks); VC – “fissuras horizontais em varandas/consolas”
However, these widths are observed on every type of (cracks on balconies or cantilevered elements)
crack, with the exception of mapped and horizontal cracks Figure 4.12 – Correlation between cracking pattern and other
7
possible to determinate the main causes of the observed Table 4.1 – Cracking patterns catalogue – Exterior walls (cont.)
cracks, as well as an indicate of characteristics that can be
description
Expected
elements
Cracking
Possible
expected for each cracking pattern.
Affected
Element
causes
width
Table 4.1 – Cracking patterns catalogue – Exterior walls Horizontal cracks
on balconies,
AO Large (1-2
formed MW, C
DM mm)
description
perpendicularly to
Expected
elements
Cracking
Possible
Affected
Element
causes
width
the façade.
Balconies
Diagonal cracks
with similar
spacing between
Irregular mesh Small (0,1-0,25 AO Large (1-2
PS them, next to the MW, C
covering most mm) to DM mm)
TA C upper part of a
part of the medium (0,25- cantilevered
MC
façade. 1 mm) element.
Horizontal and
different materials
continuous DS Variable MW, C Linear cracks
Interface between
cracks. along the
DM
Vertical cracks interface between Small (0,1-0,25
TA SE/MW
Walls
C
between the MC mm)
masonry wall and
the concrete
structure.
5.Conclusions
Platbands
ground.
Diagonal cracks
forming a 45 diversified base to study cracking patterns, as well as the
degree angle,
with similar DS Variable
SE, elements affected and the main causes that originates
MW, C
spacing between
them, next to the
them.
ground. It was applied a methodology that allowed a full
Horizontal cracks
with similar Small (0,1-0,25 characterization of the buildings and their pathologies.
spacing between mm) to
DM MW, C
them, on the medium (0,25- This methodology consisted on the creation of an
Corners
corner of 1 mm)
buildings. inspection sheet that intends to be quick and easy to fill
Vertical cracks
with variable and that provides all the information needed to diagnose
DS Variable MW, C
width formed
from corners.
the pathologies observed.
8
Table 4.2 – Cracking patterns catalogue – Interior walls - the most common cracks were the vertical ones, with
24% of the totality of cracks observed. This type of cracks
description
Expected
elements
Cracking
Possible
were observed on walls, corners and ornamental
Affected
Element
causes
width
elements, as stonework;
- the part of the building that was most affected by cracking
Diagonal cracks
Small (0,1-0,25
forming a 45 ED C were the walls, where 34% of the cracks appeared;
mm)
degree angle.
Walls
Vertical cracks
Medium (0,25- - the most recent buildings, with year of construction after
along the full ED MW, C
1 mm)
height of the wall. 2010, showed the lower area’s percentage of the façade
affected by cracking, never exceeding 50% of the area;
other openings
Windows or
Cracks formed
from the corners
ED
Medium (0,25-
MW, C - the main causes of cracking were structural, namely,
of windows or 1 mm)
other openings. differential settlements and differential movements of the
structure. These two kinds of movements led to cracks
Vertical cracks
next to corners
ED
Medium (0,25-
MW, C with different orientations, widths and patterns, showing,
and along the full 1 mm)
height of the wall. once again, the difficulty behind searching for a cause-
Corners
Diagonal cracks
that cross two effect relationship;
Medium (0,25-
adjacent masonry ED MW, C
1 mm) - the most affected elements were the coating and the
walls, along the
masonry joints.
masonry walls, consisting in 49% and 26% of the affected
different materials
Interface between
mm)
elements
9
LUCAS, J. A. Carvalho. 1987. Revestimentos para
paramentos interiores de alvenaria de blocos de betão
celular autoclavado - VOL. II: Betão celular autoclavado -
Fissuração de paredes de alvenaria em geral; Fissuração
de paredes de alvenaria de betão celular autoclavado no
nosso País. Relatório 109/87-NCCt : LNEC, Lisboa, 1987.
PAIVA, J., AGUIAR, J. and PINHO, A. 2006. Guia
Técnico de Reabilitação Habitacional. s.l. : LNEC, Lisboa,
2006.
SILVA, José António Raimundo Mendes. 1998.
Fissuração das alvenarias - Estudo do comportamento
das alvenarias sob acções térmicas. Dissertação de
Doutoramento em Engenharia CIvi, especialidade de
Construções : Coimbra, 1998.
VEIGA, R. 1998. Comportamento de argamassas de
revestimento de paredes. Contribuição para o estudo da
sua resistência à fendilhação. Teses e Programas de
Investigação : LNEC, Lisboa, 1998.
10
11