Andersson 2000 EJAP

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 7

Eur J Appl Physiol (2000) 83: 566±572 Ó Springer-Verlag 2000

ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Johan Andersson á Erika Schagatay


Anna GisleÂn á Boris Holm

Cardiovascular responses to cold-water immersions of the forearm


and face, and their relationship to apnoea

Accepted: 18 July 2000

Abstract Apnoea as well as cold stimulation of the face


or the extremities elicits marked cardiovascular re¯exes
Introduction
in humans. The purpose of this study was to investigate
Apnoea or cold stimulation of either the face or the
whether forearm immersion in cold water has any e€ect
extremities elicits marked cardiovascular re¯exes in hu-
on the cardiovascular responses to face immersion and
mans. Stimulation of both the sympathetic and para-
apnoea. We recorded cardiovascular responses to cold-
sympathetic nervous systems are involved in evoking
water immersions of the forearm and face in 19 (part I)
these re¯exes. The human diving response is initiated by
and 23 subjects (part II). The experimental protocol was
apnoea and is augmented by immersion of the face in
divided in two parts, each part containing four tests: I1,
cold water (Gooden 1994). It is characterised by a
forearm immersion during eupnoea; I2, face immersion
reduction in heart rate, which is caused by an increased
during eupnoea; I3, forearm and face immersion during
parasympathetic activity via the vagus nerve that
eupnoea; I4, face immersion during apnoea; II1, apnoea
inhibits the cardiac pacemaker, and an alpha-adrenergic
without immersion; II2, forearm immersion during
sympathetic vasoconstriction in selective vascular beds
apnoea; II3, face immersion during apnoea; and II4,
(Heistad et al. 1968; Frey et al. 1980a; Gooden 1994).
forearm and face immersion during apnoea. The water
The reduction in cardiac output is not balanced to the
temperature was 9±11 °C. Cold-water immersion of
vasoconstriction and, as a consequence, blood pressure
either the forearm or face was enough to elicit the most
is increased. The diving response is augmented by
pronounced thermoregulatory vasoconstriction during
stimulation of cold-receptors in the upper facial region,
both eupnoea and apnoea. During eupnoea, heart rate
which is innervated by the ophthalmic branch of the
responses to forearm immersion (3% increase) and face
trigeminal nerve (Schuitema and Holm 1988).
immersion (9% decrease) were additive during concur-
Cold stimulation of the extremities during eupnoea
rent stimulation (3% decrease). During apnoea, the
(the cold pressure test) elicits an inhibition of the para-
heart rate responses were not a€ected by the forearm
sympathetic activity and increases the beta-adrenergic
immersion. The oxygen-conserving diving response
sympathetic activity to the heart, resulting in a tachy-
seems to dominate over thermoregulatory responses in
cardia. At the same time, an alpha-adrenergic sympa-
the threat of asphyxia. During breathing, however, the
thetic vasoconstriction is induced (Frey et al. 1980a, b;
diving response serves no purpose and does not set
Allen et al. 1992). These two responses cause an increase
thermoregulatory adjustments aside.
in blood pressure. As the immersion continues, stimu-
lation of the arterial baroreceptors returns the heart rate
Key words Diving response á Bradycardia á
towards the pre-immersion rate, often within the 1st min
Tachycardia á Arterial blood pressure á Cold stimulation
(i.e. the beta-adrenergic sympathetic activity is reduced
while the alpha-adrenergic sympathetic activity contin-
J. Andersson (&) á E. Schagatay á B. Holm ues to result in vasoconstriction and increased blood
Department of Animal Physiology, pressure; Frey et al. 1980a, b).
Lund University, Helgonav. 3B, According to previous studies, chilling of the forearm
22362 Lund, Sweden
e-mail: johan.andersson@zoofys.lu.se and the face has opposite e€ects on heart rate. The
Tel.: +46-46-2229349; Fax: +46-46-2224539 purpose of the study presented here was to investigate
A. GisleÂn
whether forearm immersion in cold water has any e€ect
Department of Zoology, Lund University, on the cardiovascular responses to face immersion and
Lund, Sweden apnoea (the diving response). This was done by
567

recording the cardiovascular responses to cold-water test did not include forearm immersion, the subject was instructed
immersion of the forearm and face during eupnoea and to lay his/her arm on the table. During forearm immersion tests,
the right forearm and hand were immersed. If the test did not
apnoea. include face immersion, the subject was instructed to hold his/her
face just over the water. During face immersions, the entire face
including the forehead and chin were immersed. This assured an
Methods identical position during all the tests. The subject was instructed to
breathe normally throughout the experiment and to make a deep,
but not maximal inspiration when initiating apnoea. In all of the
Subjects eupnoea tests the subject started breathing through a snorkel at
least 2 min before the beginning of the test. The individual respi-
A group of 34 healthy subjects, 23 men and 11 women, ranging in ratory frequency and tidal volume during the control period before
age from 19 to 30 years (mean 23.4 years) participated in this the immersions were continued during immersions as judged by
study. All subjects were non-smokers but two were taking snu€. observations of the breathing movements on the analogue recorder.
Their physical exercise averaged 3.3 h/week, with a range from 0 to The recording of all parameters was commenced 2 min prior to
9.5 h/week. each test. The pillow was removed 15 s prior to the tests. At this
point, the subject was instructed to put his/her right arm in position
beside the trough. A countdown was given during the last 10 s.
Measurements During apnoea tests, the initiations of apnoea and immersion were
simultaneous. Immersions without apnoea lasted for 60 s, while
An electrocardiogram was checked for anomalies prior to testing apnoeas were performed to individual maximal duration [mean
(Cardisuny 501, lead 2, Fukuda ME Kogoyo, Tokyo, Japan). The (SD) for all apnoeas: 108 (49) s]. After the immersion/apnoea was
subject's vital capacity was measured (Spirolite 201, Vise Medical, terminated, the recording continued for a further 2 min. The pause
Chiba, Japan), ®rst in the standing position and thereafter with the between each test comprised 10 min of prone rest.
subject lying prone on a bed with the equipment attached. Heart
rate and arterial blood pressure were recorded continuously in all
subjects on the left middle ®nger by a photoplethysmometer Data analysis
(Finapres 2300, Ohmeda, Madison, Wisc., USA). Skin capillary
blood ¯ow in the left thumb was recorded continuously in 22 of the The control values for heart rate, skin blood ¯ow, and mean
subjects with a laser Doppler ¯owmeter (Advanced Laser Flow- arterial pressure were calculated as time averages from the period
meter 21, Advance, Tokyo, Japan). The left hand was positioned at 90±30 s before each test. The time averages of these parameters
the same level relative to the heart throughout the experiment were also calculated during the period 30±45 s into each test. The
(cf Schagatay and Andersson 1998). Heart rate, blood pressure, relative changes were calculated between the time averages from the
and skin blood ¯ow values were stored continuously in a computer. period 30±45 s into the tests and the corresponding control values.
Breathing movements were recorded by a pneumatic chest bellows, We chose the period 30±45 s into the tests for comparative analysis
which was connected to an ampli®er and an analogue recorder. because other studies indicate that the heart rate e€ect of forearm
immersion in cold water is of a short duration (Frey et al. 1980a,
b), and because it takes approximately 30 s for the human diving
Experimental procedures
response to develop completely (Jung and Stolle 1981; Andersson
and Schagatay 1998b; Schagatay et al. 1999). Thus, the chosen
All experiments were conducted in conformity with the principles
period was considered as the optimum for investigating the inter-
of the Declaration of Helsinki and were approved by the Research
action between the responses to forearm and face immersion and
Ethics Committee of the Faculty of Medicine, Lund University.
their relationship to apnoea. For statistical evaluations within the
The experimental protocol was divided into two parts, each part
two parts of the study, a paired t test with Bonferroni correction for
containing four tests as follows. For part I:
multiple comparisons was used. For comparisons between the two
1. Eupnoea with forearm immersion. apnoeas with face immersions, an unpaired t test was used. The
2. Eupnoea with face immersion. level of statistical signi®cance was set at P < 0.05.
3. Eupnoea with forearm and face immersion.
4. Apnoea with face immersion.
And for part II: Results
1. Apnoea without immersion.
2. Apnoea with forearm immersion. Development of cardiovascular responses
3. Apnoea with face immersion.
4. Apnoea with forearm and face immersion.
Part I
Nineteen subjects performed part I [mean (SD) age 23 (3) years,
height 1.77 (0.1) m, body mass 70 (12) kg, vital capacity 5.3 (1.0) l], During the forearm immersion, the heart rate increased
and 23 subjects performed part II [mean (SD) age 24 (2) years,
height 1.79 (0.1) m, body mass 72 (10) kg, vital capacity 5.2 (1.0) l]. slightly, but towards the end of the 60-s immersion the
Eight subjects participated in both parts of the study. The forearm heart rate had returned to the control level (Fig. 1).
and face were immersed in water at 9±11 °C. Room temperature was The skin capillary blood ¯ow was reduced throughout
22±26 °C. The order in which the tests were conducted was rando- the entire forearm immersion. The mean arterial pressure
mised for each subject, and for the eight subjects that participated in
both parts, part I and part II were performed on separate days. increased during the forearm immersion. During the face
The subjects were familiarised with the equipment and thor- immersion while breathing through a snorkel, a similar
oughly informed about the experimental procedures, after which an pattern of cardiovascular responses could be observed,
informed consent form was signed. The subject assumed a prone except for the heart rate response. After an initial
position on a mattress with the head resting on a removable pillow
above the face-immersion trough. The subject's arms were resting tachycardic response, a heart rate reduction well below
on each side of the face-immersion trough. To the right of the bed, the control level developed. During the concurrent face
the forearm immersion trough was situated on a small table. If the and forearm immersion, the skin blood ¯ow and blood
568

pressure followed the same pattern as during forearm or tions observed during the apnoeas without face immer-
face immersion, while the heart rate response was of an sions were not as marked as those observed during the
intermediate magnitude compared to during forearm or apnoeas with face immersions. The skin capillary blood
face immersion. After an initial tachycardic response, ¯ow was reduced during all of the apnoeas. During the
apnoea with face immersion induced a de®nite heart rate apnoea without immersion, the ®nal level of skin blood
reduction. The skin blood ¯ow during apnoea with face ¯ow adjustment was higher than in the other tests. After
immersion followed the same pattern as during the other initial reductions during the ®rst 20 s, the mean arterial
tests, while the increase in blood pressure was more pressure increased throughout the apnoeic episodes.
marked during the apnoea than in any other test in part I. Again, the responses during apnoeas without face im-
mersions were not as marked as in the other two tests.

Part II
Anticipatory responses
During all of the apnoeas, a heart rate reduction followed
an initial tachycardic response that started even before For both heart rate and skin blood ¯ow, anticipatory
the beginning of apnoea (Fig. 2). The heart rate reduc- responses beginning about 30 s prior to apnoeas or

Fig. 1 Mean heart rate, skin capillary blood ¯ow, and mean arterial Fig. 2 Mean heart rate, skin capillary blood ¯ow, and mean arterial
pressure before, during, and after tests I1±I4: I1 eupnoea with forearm pressure before, during, and after tests II1±II4: II1 apnoea without
immersion; I2 eupnoea with face immersion; I3 eupnoea with face and immersion; II2 apnoea with forearm immersion; II3 apnoea with face
forearm immersion; I4 apnoea with face immersion. Heart rate and immersion; II4 apnoea with forearm and face immersion. Heart rate
arterial pressure: n ˆ 19; Skin blood ¯ow: n ˆ 14. Downward-pointing and arterial pressure: n ˆ 23; Skin blood ¯ow: n ˆ 16. Downward-
arrows indicate the start of the tests, and upward-pointing arrows pointing arrows indicate start of the tests, and upward-pointing arrows
indicate the end of the tests. The break in the line of test I4 indicates indicate the end of tests. The break in the lines indicates that the
that the apnoea was of a longer duration than 60 s apnoeas were of longer duration than 60 s
569

immersions could be observed. We performed additional forearm immersion. Within part II, the apnoeas without
experiments on six subjects to elucidate the e€ects of face immersions resulted in less pronounced heart rate
``dummy immersions'' on the anticipatory responses. reductions when compared to the apnoeas with face
With the same experimental set-up, after an identical immersions (P < 0.001). However, heart rate responses
countdown, subjects had the forearm lowered (by the during the apnoea in air and the apnoea with forearm
experimenter) into a trough with or without cold water. immersion did not di€er. Neither did the responses
Subjects were unaware of the presence or absence of the during the apnoea with face immersion and the apnoea
water until the forearm was lowered into the trough, as with face and forearm immersion di€er.
con®rmed by post-test interviews. Results similar to
those observed in the main experiment were observed
during the ``true immersion'' (Fig. 3). The heart rate Skin blood ¯ow
increased slightly, by 1%, compared to the control level
during immersions, and the skin blood ¯ow was reduced The relative changes in skin capillary blood ¯ow did not
by 54%. During the ``dummy immersion'', the cardio- di€er among tests I1±4 (Fig. 4). However, the skin blood
vascular parameters followed a di€erent pattern (Fig. 3). ¯ow reduction during the apnoea in air was less
The heart rate decreased by 4% and the skin blood ¯ow pronounced than the reductions during the apnoea with
increased by 15%. forearm immersion and apnoea with face and forearm
immersion (P < 0.05).

Comparisons between cardiovascular responses


to immersion and apnoea

There were no di€erences in the cardiovascular


responses to apnoea with face immersion between parts I
and II.

Heart rate

The relative changes in heart rate from the control levels


during the period 30±45 s into the tests were compared
(Fig. 4). Within part I, the apnoea with face immersion
resulted in a heart rate response that di€ered from all the
other tests (P < 0.01). The forearm immersion and the
face immersion resulted in di€erent responses
(P < 0.01). The responses in these two tests did not
di€er from the response during concurrent face and

Fig. 3 Mean skin capillary blood ¯ow before, during, and after the Fig. 4 Percentage changes in heart rate [n ˆ 19 (part I) or n ˆ 23
forearm was lowered into a trough with (true immersion, solid line) or (part II)], skin capillary blood ¯ow [n ˆ 14 (part I) or n ˆ 16 (part II)],
without cold water (dummy immersion, dashed line). Values are means and mean arterial pressure [n ˆ 19 (part I) or 23 (part II)] from the
from six subjects. Downward-pointing arrows indicate start of the control period for tests I1±I4 and II1±II4 (see Figs. 1, 2). Data are
immersions, and upward-pointing arrows indicate the end of immer- presented as the means (SEM). *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01,
sions. ***P < 0.001
570

Mean arterial pressure by the lack of di€erences in skin capillary blood ¯ow
among the tests of part I in this study (Figs. 1, 4).
The mean arterial pressure increased more (P < 0.01) The heart rate reduction and selective vasoconstric-
during the apnoea than in any other test within part I tion elicited by apnoea without immersion were aug-
(Fig. 4). During the apnoea with face and forearm im- mented by immersion of the face in cold water, as
mersion, the mean arterial pressure increased more than reported previously (Kawakami et al. 1967; Hurwitz and
in the apnoeas without face immersions (P < 0.05). Furedy 1986; Marsh et al. 1995; Andersson and Sch-
agatay 1998a). However, forearm immersion did not
a€ect the cardiovascular responses during apnoea as it
Discussion did during eupnoea (i.e. the human diving response was
una€ected by cold stimulation of the forearm during the
Earlier studies have shown that the cardiovascular apnoeas). When comparing the response to apnoea with
responses to cold stimulation of the extremities can be that obtained during the apnoea with forearm immer-
additive to the responses from other cardiovascular sion, we found no di€erence in heart rate or blood
challenges (e.g. changes in central blood volume and pressure responses. Neither were any di€erences found
isometric exercise; Ebert et al. 1982; Peikert and Smo- when the responses during the apnoea with face
lander 1991). There has been, to our knowledge, no immersion and the apnoea with face and forearm
other study investigating whether cold stimulation of the immersion were compared. Therefore, we conclude that
extremities a€ects the cardiovascular responses to forearm immersion has no e€ect on the development of
apnoea, the human diving response. Our results indicate the general diving response when immersed simulta-
that during eupnoea, the heart rate response to simul- neously as apnoea begins.
taneous cold stimulation of the forearm and face is an The reduction in skin capillary blood ¯ow during
additive response to the two stimuli, while the skin apnoea was augmented by cold-water immersion. In
blood ¯ow and arterial pressure responses are not fur- fact, all immersions resulted in similar skin capillary
ther augmented by the combined stimulation. During blood ¯ow levels, during both eupnoea and apnoea.
apnoea the pattern changed. Instead of an additive re- Cold stimulation is the most e€ective stimulus causing
sponse, a complete development of the human diving re¯ex vasoconstriction in the skin (Heistad and Abboud
response occured (i.e. cold stimulation of the forearm 1974). Thus, our results indicate that cold stimulation,
does not attenuate the heart rate reduction, nor does it regardless of the site of stimulation, elicits a vasocon-
augment the skin blood ¯ow or blood pressure re- striction in skin vessels that can not be further aug-
sponse). mented by simultaneous cold stimulation of another
Cold stimulation of the extremities elicits ther- part of the body surface.
moregulatory re¯exes that result in a reduction in heat The mean arterial blood pressure was more elevated
loss to the environment. One of the most prominent during the apnoeas than during the immersions with
responses is a reduction in peripheral blood ¯ow. As the eupnoea. It has been shown that the cardiac output is
result of a general sympathetic activation, the heart rate reduced during breath holding (Ferrigno et al. 1986).
and heart contractility is increased (Frey et al. 1980a). The increased blood pressure thus implies that the total
The vasoconstriction and increased cardiac output leads peripheral resistance has increased more than the
to an increase in the arterial blood pressure. This pattern cardiac output decreased. Thermal stimuli primarily
of cardiovascular re¯exes could be observed in the a€ect skin blood ¯ow (Heistad and Abboud 1974).
results of this study. Immersion of the face in cold water Apnoea also a€ects blood ¯ow in other vascular beds
elicited a di€erent cardiovascular response. Stimulation (e.g. muscle blood ¯ow; Zbrozyna and Westwood
of the facial cold receptors resulted in a heart rate 1992). The ®ndings of higher arterial pressures during
reduction and a reduced peripheral blood ¯ow. These the apnoeas compared to the eupnoeic immersions
autonomic re¯exes are brought about by vagal chrono- could thus be due to a vasoconstriction in vessels not
tropic e€ects on the heart and alpha-adrenergic sympa- a€ected by thermal stimuli. At the onset of apnoea,
thetic out¯ow to resistance vessels (Finley et al. 1979; there was a transient reduction in blood pressure. This
Frey et al. 1980a; Fagius and Sundlof 1986). Since the is caused by the elevated intrathoracic pressure that
reduced cardiac output in this situation was not follows holding the breath with a large lung volume,
balanced to the increased total peripheral resistance, the initially impeding the venous return and consequently
arterial blood pressure was elevated. When the two reducing stroke volume and cardiac output (LineÂr 1994;
stimuli (forearm and face immersion) were combined, an Andersson and Schagatay 1998b).
additive response pattern was observed regarding the There were anticipatory responses during the count-
heart rate. The heart rate during concurrent forearm and down before the tests, but true physiological responses
face immersion was at an intermediate level compared to developed during the immersions and apnoeas. Antici-
during the forearm or face immersion. However, the patory responses were also clearly visible before the
vasoconstriction obtained during either the forearm or ``dummy immersion'', in particular as transient reduc-
face immersion was not further augmented by cold tions in skin blood ¯ow after the instructions ``60 s left''
stimulation of both areas simultaneously, as indicated and ``30 s left'' (Fig. 3). However, when the subjects
571

besides the reduction in skin blood ¯ow, which would


further increase the total peripheral resistance.
The main conclusions from this study are that during
eupnoea, heart rate responses from forearm and face
immersions are additive, while the heart rate responses
to apnoea are not attenuated by the forearm immersion.
The fact that the oxygen-conserving diving response has
priority over thermoregulatory responses in the threat of
asphyxia appears to be a functional property. During
breathing, however, the diving response serves no pur-
pose, since oxygen delivery is undisturbed and ther-
moregulatory adjustments will be more appropriate
during cold stimulation.

Acknowledgements This study was supported by grants from the


Hierta-Retzius' Foundation for Scienti®c Research, the Royal
Physiographic Society, and the Swedish National Centre for Re-
search in Sports. All experiments comply with the current laws of
Sweden.

References
Allen MT, Shelley KS, Boquet AJ Jr (1992) A comparison of
cardiovascular and autonomic adjustments to three types of
cold stimulation tasks. Int J Psychophysiol 13: 59±69
Andersson J, Schagatay E (1998a) Arterial oxygen desaturation
during apnea in humans. Undersea Hyperb Med 25: 21±25
Fig. 5 Schematic model for the integration of the cardiovascular Andersson J, Schagatay E (1998b) E€ects of lung volume and in-
re¯exes evoked by the three stimuli (cold stimulation of the forearm, voluntary breathing movements on the human diving response.
cold stimulation of the face, and apnoea). (i Inhibition, + increase, Eur J Appl Physiol 77: 19±24
) decrease) Ebert TJ, Stowe DF, Barney JA, Kalb¯eisch JH, Smith JJ (1982)
Summated circulatory responses of thermal and barore¯exes in
humans. J Appl Physiol 52: 184±189
were surprised by the absence of water, the cardiovas- Fagius J, Sundlof G (1986) The diving response in man: e€ects on
cular parameters promptly returned to the pre-count- sympathetic activity in muscle and skin nerve fascicles. J Physiol
down level. In particular, the skin blood ¯ow, which also (Lond) 377: 429±443
showed the most marked anticipatory responses, in- Ferrigno M, Hickey DD, LineÂr MH, Lundgren CEG (1986)
Cardiac performance in humans during breath holding. J Appl
creased almost instantaneously towards the control level Physiol 60: 1871±1877
during the dummy immersion. Finley JP, Bonet JF, Waxman MB (1979) Autonomic pathways
Based on the results from this and previous studies, a responsible for bradycardia on facial immersion. J Appl Physiol
schematic model for the integration of the cardiovascular 47: 1218±1222
Frey MA, Selm EA, Walther JW Jr (1980a) Re¯ex cardiovascular
re¯exes elicited by the three stimuli (cold stimulation of responses to cold exposure of the face or foot. Jpn Heart J 21:
the forearm, cold stimulation of the face, and apnoea) is 665±679
suggested (Fig. 5). During eupnoea the heart rate reduc- Frey MA, Siervogel RM, Selm EA, Kezdi P (1980b) Cardiovas-
tion derived from chilling of the face is attenuated if the cular response to cooling of limbs determined by noninvasive
methods. Eur J Appl Physiol 44: 67±75
forearm is chilled simultaneously. Thus, the increased Gooden BA (1994) Mechanism of the human diving response.
chronotropic sympathetic stimulation evoked by arm Integr Physiol Behav Sci 29: 6±16
immersion counteracts the chronotropic parasympathetic Heistad DD, Abboud FM (1974) Factors that in¯uence blood ¯ow
activity induced by facial chilling. The peripheral blood in skeletal muscle and skin. Anesthesiology 41: 139±156
¯ow reduction is not further augmented by cold stimula- Heistad DD, Abboud FM, Eckstein JW (1968) Vasoconstrictor
response to simulated diving in man. J Appl Physiol 25:
tion of yet another skin area (i.e. the maximal reduction in 542±549
skin capillary blood ¯ow during immersion in cold water Hurwitz BE, Furedy JJ (1986) The human dive re¯ex: an experi-
is obtained by either immersion of the face or forearm mental, topographical and physiological analysis. Physiol
separately). During apnoea, on the contrary, the forearm Behav 36: 287±294
Jung K, Stolle W (1981) Behaviour of heart rate and incidence of
immersion has no e€ect on the heart rate response. Thus, a arrhythmia in swimming and diving. Biotelem Patient Monit 8:
heart rate reduction was induced by an increased para- 228±239
sympathetic activity, whereas the sympathetic stimulation Kawakami Y, Natelson BH, DuBois AR (1967) Cardiovascular
evoked by forearm immersion was not expressed. The e€ects of face immersion and factors a€ecting diving re¯ex in
man. J Appl Physiol 23: 964±970
augmented increase in blood pressure during apnoea LineÂr MH (1994) Cardiovascular and pulmonary responses to
compared to that during eupnoeic immersions might be breath-hold diving in humans. Acta Physiol Scand Suppl 620:
explained by a vasoconstriction in speci®c vascular beds, 1±32
572

Marsh N, Askew D, Beer K, Gerke M, Muller D, Reichman C Schagatay E, van Kampen M, Andersson J (1999) E€ects of re-
(1995) Relative contributions of voluntary apnoea, exposure to peated apneas on apneic time and diving response in non-
cold and face immersion in water to diving bradycardia in hu- divers. Undersea Hyperb Med 26: 143±149
mans. Clin Exp Pharmacol Physiol 22: 886±887 Schuitema K, Holm B (1988) The role of di€erent facial areas in
Peikert D, Smolander J (1991) The combined e€ect of the cold eliciting human diving bradycardia. Acta Physiol Scand 132:
pressor test and isometric exercise on heart rate and blood 119±120
pressure. Eur J Appl Physiol 62: 445±449 Zbrozyna AW, Westwood DM (1992) Cardiovascular responses
Schagatay E, Andersson J (1998) Diving response and apneic time elicited by simulated diving and their habituation in man. Clin
in humans. Undersea Hyperb Med 25: 13±19 Auton Res 2: 225±233

You might also like