Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Reciprocating Compressor
Reciprocating Compressor
5.1 Introduction
− A compressor is a power absorbing machine used to increase the pressure of fluid
(air, gas or vapour) above that at which it is available.
− “A machine which takes in air during suction stroke at low pressure and compresses
it to high pressure in a piston cylinder arrangement and then delivers it to some
storage vessel (receiver) is known as reciprocating air compressor”. The high
pressure air from the receiver may be supplied by a pipe line to wherever it is
required.
▪ In axial flow compressors the flow is axial and there is no centrifugal action. Dynamic
compressors are characterized by large volumetric capacity and relatively low
pressures.
(1) In mining
− In mines due to danger of explosion-fire, no electrical or fuel motors can be used and
the of the machinery such as air motors, drills, haulage, coal cutters, mine
locomotives are driven by compressed air.
− Air lift pumps to pump water are very common with mines. Leakage improves
ventilation.
(2) In I. C. Engines
− Compressed air is used for starting I.C engines, fuel injection in diesel engines,
supercharging scavenging purposes.
(3) In Automobiles
− ln automobile industry compressed, air is used for spray painting, servicing cars, car
lifts, filling air in tyres, pneumatic brakes, pneumatic steering in heavy vehicles.
(6) In workshops
− Compressed air is used to operate blast furnace, forged hammers, presses,
pneumatic riveting and cleaning purposes.
(11) Agriculture
− Compressed air is used in processing of food farm maintenance by spraying of
insecticides.
− The safety of compressed air as well as its versatility makes it a desirable form of
powder for many operations in ammunition deposits and self locating plants. Air
operated ammunition hoists are spark free and quick acting.
− The piston reciprocates in a cylinder and derives its motion through a connecting rod
and crank mounted in a crank case, the inlet and delivery valves are provided are
mostly of thin steel plates provided with light springs because of pressure difference
across them.
a) Forward Stroke (or Suction Stroke)
− As shown in Fig. 5.1 (a) the piston is moving down the cylinder and any residual
compressed air left in the cylinder after the previous compression will expand. The
pressure of this air will drop below the atmospheric pressure.
− The inlet valve will open due to difference of pressure and fresh air will enter into
the cylinder. Admission of air goes on until the piston reaches the end of the
downward stroke.
− During admission of air the delivery valve remains closed because the receiver
pressure on the outside of this valve is much higher than the suction pressure.
(a) (b)
Fig. 5.1 Single stage single acting reciprocating compressor
− Since both the inlet and delivery valves are closed, the pressure of air will rapidly rise
at the expense of its volume.
− Eventually a pressure will be reached which is slightly of the compressed air pressure
on the outside of the delivery valve and hence the delivery valve will open. The
compressed air is now delivered from the cylinder to the receiver until the piston
reaches the end of its upward stroke.
− At the end of compression stroke piston once again begin to move down the
cylinder, the delivery valve closes, the inlet valve eventually opens and the cycle is
repeated.
− “In double acting compressor the same action takes place on each side of the piston.
The delivery from the compressor is intermittent. To smooth out pulsation the
compressed air is stored in a receiver from where continuous flow of compressed air
can be supplied.”
− If the heat transfer during compression is controlled in such a way that temperature
during compression process remains constant. The process 1 -2' will be isothermal
represented by, PV = constant.
− “ln practice the compression process 1-2 is neither isentropic nor isothermal. It lies
between isentropic and isothermal processes and may be regarded as polytropic
process with equation PVn = constant.”
Fig. 5.2 P-V and T-S diagrams for a reciprocating air compressor neglecting clearance volume
2 2 − PV
PV
= ( PV
2 2 − PV1 1)+
1 1
n −1
1
= ( PV
2 2 − PV1 1 ) 1 +
n −1
n
= ( PV
2 2 − PV 1 1)
n −1
n PV
= PV1 1
2 2
− 1
n −1 PV
1 1
Now for polytropic process 1-2,
Department of Mechanical Engineering Page 5.7
5. Reciprocating Compressor Fluid Power Engineering
1 1 = PV
n n
PV 2 2
1/ n −1/ n
V P P
2 = 1 = 2
V1 P2 P1
V
Substituting the value of 2 in equation, we get
V1
n P P −1/ n
W= 1 1 2 − 1
2
PV
n −1 1 P1
P
n −1
P2 n
− 1 J/cycle
n
1 1
P1
W = PV (5.1)
n −1
n −1
P n
T2
Also, for polytropic process, 2 = 1 1 = mRT1 in above equation
and substitute PV
P1 T1
(5.1),
n T
W= mRT1 2 − 1
n −1 T1
n
W= mR (T2 − T1 ) J/cycle
n −1
Where ‘m’ is the mass of air inducted and delivered per cycle.
Work input per kg of air is,
n −1
RT1 − 1 J/kg
n P2 n
W= (5.2)
n −1 P1
CP
CV
W= m ( CP − CV )(T2 − T1 )
CP
−1
CV
W = mCP (T2 − T1 ) J/cycle (5.4)
− The work done on air is least when the compression is isothermal (n = 1) and
maximum when it is adiabatic (n = ϒ), because the isothermal compression curve has
least slope than an adiabatic compression.
− Work required for isothermal compression = area 4-1-2’-3-4
o Work required for adiabatic compression = area 4-1-2”-3-4
o Hence work saved if air is compressed isothermally = area 1-2”-2’-1.
− Thus least desirable form of compression in reciprocating compressor is isentropic
compression process.
Methods to Achieve Approximation of Isothermal Compression
− Isothermal compression is achieved by the following methods even running at higher
speed.
(1) Cold water spray (Injection):
− In this method, the increasing temperature of the air is reduced by spraying cold
water while air being compressed.
− Without the cold water spray the compression will be adiabatic 1-2”. With cold
water spray the compression curve 1-2 will be approximately of the form of PV1.2,
this bring the compression near the isothermal and saving in work shown by shaded
area. (Refer Fig. 5.4)
Fig. 5.5 P-V diagram of single stage reciprocating compressor considering clearance volume
Work Done Equation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering Page 5.11
5. Reciprocating Compressor Fluid Power Engineering
n −1
ma RT1 − 1
n
n P
W= 2
n −1 P1
n −1
n T P n
T2
W= ma RT1 2 − 1 but 2 =
n −1 T1 P1 T1
n
W= ma R T2 − T1 J/cycle
n −1
n
W= R T2 − T1 J/kg (5.7)
n −1
[Note FYI: This equation independent of clearance volume. Thus clearance volume does not
affect the theoretical work required to compress and deliver the air, this is because work
required to compress the mass air held in clearance space is returned when the same mass
of air expands during the expansion 3-4.]
V =
(VC + VS ) − V4
VS
VC V4
V = 1 + − (5.8)
VS VS
For polytropic expansion process 3-4 we can write,
3 3 = PV
n n
PV 4 4
1/ n
P
V4 = V3 3 But P4 = P1 and P3 = P2 and V3 = VC
P4
1/ n
P
V4 = VC 2
P1
Substitute the value of V4 in the above equation (5.8),
1/ n
V V P
V = 1 + C − C 2
VS VS P1
P 1/ n
V = 1 − C 2 − 1 (5.9)
P1
V P
Where C = clearance ratio = C and r = 2 = pressure ratio
VS P1
P1 Ta
1/ n
P2
V ( amb ) = 1 − C − 1 (5.11)
Pa T1 P1
Fig. 5.7 The effect on the volumetric efficiency of increasing the delivery pressure
▪ In the limit, if the compression ratio is increased from P1 to P2", the compression
Iine intersects the line of clearance volume at point 2" and the re-expansion-follows
the same path as compression, the effective swept volume is zero and there is no
delivery of air. The attempt made to deliver the air at a higher pressure of P2" would
result in compression and re-expansion of the same air again and again without any
delivery of high pressure air. Therefore, the maximum pressure ratio attainable with
a single stage compressor is limited by the clearance volume.
▪ An intercooler is used between two stages, so that the compressed air from the first
stage cools down before it enters second stage with low temperature. Air cooling
between stages provides the means of an appreciable reduction in the compressor
work and maintaining air temperature within safe operating limits. By cooling the air
between stages the compression is made to approach isothermal.
(5) Less Leakage: due to better lubrication and reduced pressure difference across the two
sides of the piston and valve, there is less leakage loss past the piston.
(6) Size of cylinders: Size and strength of cylinders can be adjusted to suit volume and
pressure of air.
(7) Lighter Cylinders-Lighter Construction: due to lower pressure range in low pressure
stages Iight6r cylinders are used where as in high pressure stages robust but less
voluminous are used. This makes the construction lighter.
(8) Disadvantages: a multistage compressor needs more than one cylinder, intercoolers with
water pipes and a continuous supply of water. The multistage unit becomes more
complicated and expansive in initial cost.
5.10 Work Done in Two Stage Reciprocating Air Compressor with Intercooler
Fig. 5.8 shows the schematic diagram of a two stage reciprocating compressor and P-V and
T-S diagrams of the compression cycle.
First Stage Compression (L.P Stage)
▪ In the two stage compressor with intercooler, the air is first drawn into the low
pressure (L.P) cylinder at point 1 with pressure P1, and volume V1. The air is
compressed polytropically to some intermediate pressure P2, as shown by process 1-
2'.
▪ The compressed air at pressure P2 and temperature T2 is then cooled at constant
pressure P2, by passing the air through intercooler. This is represented by a constant
pressure process 2’-2.
Second Stage Compression (H.P Stage)
▪ The air then enters the high pressure (H.P) cylinder, where it is further compressed
polytropically along 2 - 3. Pressure of air increases from P2 to P3, and finally
discharged to the receiver at pressure P3. Thus in each stage pressure of the air is
successively increased and the initial temperature is maintained at the end. During
the whole process the compression is approximated isothermal process.
Fig. 5.8 Schematic of two stage compressor with intercooler and P-V & T-S diagram
▪ If the compression had taken place in a single stage, the compression curve would
have followed the polytropic curve 1 - 3". The saving in work input by the use of
multi stage compression with intercooling is shown by shaded area 2 - 2' -3" -3 - 2.
Both the LP and H.P cylinders are mounted on the same crank shaft and are driven by an
electric motor or prime mover.
Assumptions:
1. The effect of clearance is neglected.
2. The index 'n' in the polytropic compression law PVn = C is same for each cylinder.
3. The intercooling in each stage is at constant pressure and there is no pressure drop
between two stages i.e. delivery pressure of one stage equals the suction pressure of
the next stage.
4. The mass of air handled by the L.P and H.P cylinders is the same.
5. Suction and delivery pressures remain constant during each stage.
Consider a two stage reciprocating air compressor with intercooler. Then,
Let P1 = pressure of air entering the L.P cylinder
V1 = volume of L.P cylinder = stroke volume of L.P cylinder
P2 = Pressure of air leaving the L.P cylinder or entering the H.P cylinder
V2 = Volume of the H.P cylinder = stroke volume of the H.P cylinder.
P3 = Pressure of air leaving the H.P cylinder
Total work done required per cycle in both the cylinders is,
1 1 = PV
Substituting PV 2 2 in above equation,
n −1 n −1
n P n P n
W= 1 1
PV 2
+ − 2
3
(5.13)
n −1 P1 P2
5.11 Condition for Minimum Work or Maximum Efficiency for a Two Stage
Reciprocating Compressor
The total work required per cycle by two stage reciprocating compressor with complete
Intercooling is given by,
n −1 n −1
+ − 2
n P n P n
W= 1 1
P1
2 3
PV
n −1 P4
n
Let, =y
n −1
P y P y
W = Constant 2 + 3 − 2
P1 P4
1
= Constant P2 y y + P3 y P2 − y − 2
P1
For minimum work,
dW yP y −1
= Constant 2 y − yP3 y P2 − y −1 − 0 = 0
dP2 P1
yP2 y −1 yP3 y
= y +1
P1 y P2
P2 y −1 P2 y +1 = P1 y P3 y
P2 2 y = ( P1 P3 )
y
P2 P3
P2 = PP
1 3 or = (5.14)
P1 P2
Above equation shows that for minimum work required, the intercooler pressure is
geometric mean of the initial and final pressures or pressure ratio in each stage is the same.
P P
Substitute the 2 for 3 in equation of work done,
P1 P2
Total minimum work required per cycle,
n −1 n −1
n P2 n
P2 n
W= 1 1
PV + − 2 (5.15)
n −1
1 P1
P
n −1
2n P2 n
W= 1 1
PV − 1
n −1
1
P
2 1
P P P P P P P P 2
Since 2 = 3 , then 2 = 2 3 = 3 , thus 2 = 3
P1 P2 P1 P1 P2 P1 P1 P1
1
P2 P3 2
Substitute the = in above equation of work done,
P1 P1
n −1
− 1
2n P 2n
Wmin = 1 1
P1
3
PV
n −1
For x number of stages, the pressure ratio is,
1 1
P2 P3 P4 Px Px +1 Px +1 x Final pressure No. of stages
= = = = = =
P1 P2 P3 Px −1 Px P1 Initial pressure
Minimum work for X number of stages with perfect intercooling at all stages is given by,
n −1
− 1
xn P xn
W= 1 1
x +1
P1
PV (5.16)
n −1
Where Px +1 = final delivery pressure and P1 = initial or suction pressure
The following conclusions are drawn for the minimum work required to compress and
deliver air in a multistage compressor:
(1) The air is cooled to the initial temperature after each stage of compression.
Department of Mechanical Engineering Page 5.21
5. Reciprocating Compressor Fluid Power Engineering
Fig. 5.11 P-V diagram for two stage compressor with clearance
Total work done required per cycle in both the cylinders is,
W = WLP + WHP
n −1
n −1
P2 (V5 − V8 ) − 1
n P n
n P n
W= P1 (V1 − V4 ) − 1 +
2 3
n −1 P1 n −1 P2
For perfect intercooling, T1 = T5 therefore, P1 (V1 − V4 ) = P2 (V5 − V8 )
n −1 n −1
P1 (V1 − V4 ) + − 2
n P n P n
W= 2 3
(5.17)
n −1 P1 P2
Irrespective of the temperature T2’ attained in the first stage, T2 is the temperature to which
the air at the intermediate pressure P2, can be cooled is fixed. Here T2 > T1 as shown in Fig.
5.12.
Work done required per cycle in the L.P cylinder,
n −1
− 1
n
n P
= 1 1
P1
2
WLP PV
n −1
P1 P2
W = AT1 P2 B P1− B − 1 + AT2 P3 B P2 − B − 1
For minimum work input,
dW
= 0 = AT1 BP2 B −1 − AT2 P3 B BP2 − B −1
dP2
AT1 BP2 B −1 AT2 BP3 B
=
P1B P2 B +1
T2 B B
P2 B −1 P2 B +1 = P1 P3
T1
T2
( P1P3 )
B
P2 2 B =
T1
1 n
T B
T n −1
P2 = 2
2
( P1 P3 ) = 2 ( P1 P3 )
T1 T1
1
n
n
2
T2 n −1
P2 P3 T2 n −1
P2 = PP
1 3 or = (5.18)
T1 P1 P1 T1
The minimum work required for a two stage compressor with incomplete intercooling is
obtained by substituting the value of P2 in equation of work done then,
n −1
n
2n
−
n T2 n −1 1 n
n 1
1
Wmin =
mRT1 P1 P3
−1 + mRT2 P3
n
− 1
n −1 1
T n − 1 n − 1 n −1
P1
n
2n
n T2
n −1
P1 P3
1
T
n −1
n −1
mR T1T2 − T2
n P3 2 n
n P3 2 n
= mR T1T2 − T1 +
n −1 P1 n −1 P1
n −1
mR 2 T1T2 − (T1 + T2 )
n P 2n
Wmin = 3
(5.19)
n −1 P1
Fig. 5.13 Two stage compressor with perfect intercooling pressure drop in the intercooler
For perfect intercooling P2'V2' = PV
1 1 and P2 = CP2
'
W = WLP + WHP
n −1
n −1
− 1
n P n
n P n
W= 1 1 −1 + ' '
P1 n − 1 2 2 P2
2 3
PV PV
n −1
n −1 n −1
n P n P n
W= 1 1 + − 2
P1
2 3
PV
n −1 2
CP
n n
Let, mR = A and = B and substitute in above equation, then
n −1 n −1
P A P B
W = A 2 + 3 − 2
P1 CP2
= A P1− B P2 B + P3 B C − B P2 − B − 2
For minimum work required,
dW
= 0 = A P1− B BP2 B −1 − P3 B C − B P2 − B −1
dP2
P2 B −1 P3 B P2 − B −1 P3 B
= = B B +1
P1B CB C P2
B
PP
P2 = 1 3
2B
C
PP
P2 2 = 1 3
C
P2 P P
= 3 = 3' (5.20)
P1 CP2 P2
If C = 1, the pressure ratio reduces to the same pressure ratio in both the stages. The work
done will be larger compared to the condition of zero pressure drop. Though work done in
each case will be equal, it will be larger than when there is no pressure drop. This is a
practical situation as some pressure drop will occur in flow through the heat exchanger.
▪ The wavy curves during suction and delivery strokes are due to valve flutter,
resulting in fluctuation in intake and delivery pressure. The H.P and L.P diagrams
overlap due to pressure drop in intercooler.
▪ The inertia and friction effects result in valve flutter increase the area of the diagram
slightly. The overall effect of this is to increase the total work of compression.
P
W= P1 V1 2 − 1
−1 P1
1.4−1
1.4
1.3 5 7
= 100 − 1
0.3 60 1
= 21.69 kW
Example 5.2 The diameter of reciprocating air compressor cylinder is 140 mm and stroke
length of the piston is 180 mm and the clearance volume is 77 cm3. The pressure and
temperature at the end of suction and at beginning of compression is 0.97 bar and 13°C. The
delivery pressure is constant at 4 bar. Taking the law of compression and expansion as PV 1.3
= constant. Calculate,
1. For what length of stroke air is delivered
2. The volume of air delivered per stroke in liters
3. The temperature of the compressed air
Solution:
P4 0.97
V1 − V4 = 2.847 10 −3 − 2.2897 10−4 = 2.618 10 −3 m3
(3) The temperature of the compressed air
n−1 0.3
P n
4 1.3
T2 = T1 2 = 286 = 396.6 K
P1 0.97
Example 5.3 In a two stage single acting reciprocating compressor, intake pressure and
temperature are 1 bar and 20°C respectively. Air is taken into the compressor at the rate of
6 m3/min and compressed to a final pressure of 9 bar. The law of compression in both the
cylinders is PV1.3 = C. If the intermediate pressure is ideal and intercooling is perfect and
the compressor runs at 600 rpm. Neglecting the clearance and determine,
(1) Intermediate pressure
(2) Volume of L.P. and H.P cylinder
(3) Power required to drive the compressor if mechanical efficiency is 80%.
(4) The rate of heat rejected in the intercooler
(5) Rise in temperature of cooling water if the mass flow rate of water through the
intercooler is 8 kg/min. Take Cpa = 1 kJ/kg k for air and Cpw = 4.2 kJ/kg k for
water.
Solution:
Data given: Find:
V1 = 6 m3 / min P2
P1 = 1 bar = 100 Kpa VLP ,VHP
T1 = 20 + 273 = 293 K B.P
P3 = 9 bar Q IC
N = 600 rpm dTw
Cpa = 1 kJ / kg K Cpw = 4.187 kJ / kg K
m = 0.8
mw = 8 kg / min
(1) For perfect intercooling, the intermediate pressure,
P2 = P1P3 = 1 9 = 3 bar
(2) Volume of L.P and H.P cylinder
Volume of L.P cylinder / cycle is,
V1 6
V LP = = = 0.01 m3 / cycle
N 600
For perfect intercooling,
P1 VLP = P2 VHP
P1 VLP 1 0.01
VHP = = = 0.0033m3 / cycle
P2 3
(3) For perfect intercooling work required to compressed air in two stage is,
n−1
P1 V1 − 1
2n P 2n
W= 3
n−1 P1
1.3−1
2 1.3 6 9 21.3
= 100 − 1
1.3 − 1
60 1
= 25 kW
Brake power required to drieve the compressor,
I.P 25
B.P = = = 31.25 kW
m 0.8
(4) The rate of heat rejected in the intercooler
Mass flow rate of air per minute,
P1 V1 100 6
m= = = 7.135 kg / min
RT1 0.287 293
Now, temperature of air entering the intercooler
n−1 1.3−1
P n 3 0.3
T2' = T1 2 = 293 = 377.55 K
P1 1
Heat rejected by the air in the intercooler,
mCpa ( T2' − T2 ) = mCpa ( T2' − T1 )
7.135 1 ( 377.55 − 293 ) = 603.26 kJ / min
(4) Rise in temperature of cooling water in intercooler
Heat gained by intercooler water = Heat lost by air = Heat rejected by the air
mw Cpw dTw = maCpa ( T2' − T1 )
4 4.2 dTw = 603.26
dTw = 17.954 0 C
Example 5.4 A single acting, two stage reciprocating air compressor has to deals with 3
m3/min of air under atmospheric conditions 1 bar, 25°C at 220 rpm and delivers it at 80 bar,
assuming perfect intercooling between stages. Find out,
(1) Minimum power to drive the compressor
(2) Diameter of L.P and H.P cylinder and common stroke length
(3) % saving in minimum power if compression is assumed as three stage
Take piston speed is 154 m/min, mechanical efficiency of compressor is 80%, volumetric
efficiency is 85% same for each stage, law of compression in both the cylinders is PV 1.3 = C.
Solution:
Data given: Find:
V1 − V4 = V a = 3 m3 / min B.Pmin
N = 220 rpm dLP ,dHP
Px +1 = 80 bar % saving in power
P1 = 1 bar
T1 = 250 C + 273 = 298 K
Vp = 2LN = 150 m / min
m = 0.8,n = 1.3
For two stage compression, with perfect intercooling the minimum I.P
n−1
P1 ( V1 − V4 ) − 1
2n P 2n
N
I.P = 3
n−1 P1 60
0.3
2 1.3 3 80 21.3 220
= 100 − 1
0.3 220 1 60
= 28.513 kw
I.P 28.513
B.P = = = 35.64 kW
m 0.8
154 154
Piston speed = 2LN = 154 L = = = 0.35 m
2N 2 220
Volumetric effciency of LP cylinder,
V1 − V4
vL = = 0.85
VSLP
V1 − V4 3 1
Swept volume of LP cylinder = VSLP = = = 0.016 m3 / stroke
0.85 220 0.85
But swept volume,
VSLP = dLP2 L = 0.016
4
dLP = 0.24 m
3 3
Actual volume of air inducted by L.P cylinder / cycle,V1 − V4 = m
220
For perfect intercooling,
P1 ( V1 − V4 ) P2 ( V5 − V8 )
= and since T5 = T1
T1 T5
P1 ( V1 − V4 ) 3 1
V5 − V8 = = 1 = 1.525 10 −3 m3
P2 220 8.94