Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 18

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/352890910

Morphotectonic evolution of the Quaternary landforms in the Yangui River basin


in the Indo-Myanmar Range

Article  in  Journal of Asian Earth Sciences · June 2021


DOI: 10.1016/j.jseaes.2021.104877

CITATIONS READS

6 187

7 authors, including:

Khayingshing Luirei Kapesa Lokho


Wadia Institute of Himalayan Geology Wadia Institute of Himalayan Geology
47 PUBLICATIONS   573 CITATIONS    22 PUBLICATIONS   194 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Girish Ch. Kothyari


University of Petroleum & Energy Studies
147 PUBLICATIONS   1,622 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

This article is from sub-Himalaya while the other one is from Lesser Himalaya View project

Geological Evolution of Kachchh Rift Basin: Western India View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Girish Ch. Kothyari on 31 July 2021.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


-RXUQDO RI $VLDQ (DUWK 6FLHQFHV   

"  
  
   %
 &


E   )
 + %
 
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jseaes


   
      
  




     


 

      
      !

 "# 


 
 $ %# $  &
'

 (  

 
    


          

 
      

        !   "


)  *  "  +  ( , - ) / % *  ) " *

 # $ *   


    


    



      
   
  
  

 

      01 
   



 #

  -


     
  23456      

 7$       
  
  
. 

   

      
   8

 
   7  # *   7
%

  
*
 $
      
 # * 7
       9  
(         # *   
   
   7
 
   
    

     6 # )   ::5;
  $  
 
 (+%< $

 
  
=   
  
   # +      

 
     
 (+%<# 
    
    ((+%%<  


    9  
 >  $   +(+%<% $
      (<%+  


 #        
 

   
 

 $   
  
  
# "
  
 
       
    



>
              # *   ?     (<%<
  
   9 
 


  $
  $ $
  

  
   
=
   "  ,  0",1# 
      
 
 



 #

 
  *
 

         
   

 # %

  
 
 

 > 

  7
 
 

       


  
 

  
  

 
 0)  :@DB> .  :@@3>
 
  
 
    $   $ 
  
 

   %

 :@@3> .

  E  :@@41#
        
  0  * (% 
    
 .   
  
  $

  .
 :@@5> -
 :@6:1# !
   
 
 
          01  

 
=
        
 ?  $
   
    / 
  0
   $ :@D4>




   
     8  
  )   # :@@B> /     
 3BBC> %  3BBC1>

  0%$   A   :@@B :@@;> %         

 0(  :@D5> F  
  # 3BB;> %    # 3BBB> %
   # 3BBC1# , 
    :@D5> /? :@@:1# ! 
  
 
 
 
        

   
    
     
  
  

  
 

 $

7     
 0%  :@@6> (  3BB:>     !  3B:C> <    #
     0) :@6B> -
:@64> & 
   3B:; # *   
 $    


"$
' :@@:>     .
 :@@5> ! 
   /
 3BBD1# 
 
  
   
 
  

 " 
 #
%&  $
G 

H

# 0# 

1 


G H

# 0!# "# 
1#

IJJ
#J:B#:B:5J?#?#3B3:#:B;6DD

 3D - 3B3B> 


  D  3B3:> ) 3D E  3B3:
$YDLODEOH RQOLQH  -XQH 
‹  3XEOLVKHG E\ (OVHYLHU /WG
'(
  '
-RXUQDO RI $VLDQ (DUWK 6FLHQFHV   


  
 

 0)
   # 3B::>      # 3B:@> 
  :@6:1# *  
        


   # 3B3B1#  8 

 ´     &
    /
 0  :6D5>
(
 
       
  
 +   :@C3> / $
  :@55> (  :@D5> )   
$


   ! 
 %    
 !% 0:@661>    # :@65> %
 3BB5>     # 3B:@1 0,
# C1# * 

0:@@D1> !% 03B::1   %
   %
 03BBD1# !.% 
 
  8      
# 
    $ 
      !  03B:C1    "  
  
    
 

  


,  0",1   
       
  
 ='
 
 ='
 =' 

 

 :5 J  8 

   # )
     # 0/ $
  :@55> F
   # :@651# %

 
     
   $
      03BB51   %
    03BB61   
$  

 $
 
    
 

      
  8   
    8 
  

     ", 0   # 3B::>     !  ( 
  
  +  . '
  0)

   # 3B:@1#
3B:C> <    # 3B:;1# 
    


 ´       

(
 


  
   
        + /  *  
 * 0F


   
  
    
 $   
     # :@651# * 


 ´     $ +  
 8 0,
# :1# A 
      . 
   K "   
  
  
  

   
       
 K . 
    A  
        
# 
   
 
  7

 
  0!% :@66> !% 3B::1#   
 
    


   8
  

 
 
  F     
    7
    

   
$   
        

 
 # *     
   
 
     0F
   # :@6@> %
   # 3B:31# * &
 
C3#4 ± :#:               0   # !
    
 =        

:@@D> !% 3B::1# &
    
 
   %
   $
 

 
   
    9 
   
  %
 03BB51 
     
   # *   
  +   K " # * K &
  ,

F 
    
      
       
   K +   0    # 3BB;>    
  
  
 
            3BB6>     # 3B3B1# * 

 
   



 $   
 .    / 
  0%
     $
  &
    /
# *     /
!
%
 3BBD1# *  

 


  %

    $ 
 
 -
   K +   
 
  
 
   3456    

      D65      
   
     $
   
  
0,
# :   31# *
 

 $   * 
 $     0    # 3B:D>     # 3B:61# * ?  

  #        $   + /  , 
*    
  

   
 
 

 0$ , 1  *   ,     * ,  0( 


     
      
 9  
 3BB:> %
 3BB5> )    # 3B3B1# * *   ,  

      
  0,
# 31# -
  
    
 $   0%
 3BB51# * *

  0-%1        
  
 ,    

 $  
     

  
        
 
# 0%
 3BB51# *         ,    
* ,         *   ,   . 
 
  K    0%
 3BB51# -  $

     ",
$

 $     , 
  0 
  # 3B:C1#
*  
       

   ) 

A
    0 , :@D4>     *
 :@D4>  
*
   # :@651 0,
# :   C1# * 
  
 $

     
  
   

    
 .  * 
    

  
   


  / 
       0(  :@6B>  
 

  % .5%%  ")*-%)*:   ! 

   &+ $
  A
  >       $ 8# 0,

       

 9    
 
  $ 
  
 
 #1


'(
  '
-RXUQDO RI $VLDQ (DUWK 6FLHQFHV   

   01 &+ $


 
    01 &
     # þ

   
 
  -%  #

+# * 

  $ ? 
 
   .    03B:C1  
    
  
   

   
   
 #    
  $ $  
0χ1# *
  



'
  

 # * 
  
       
 9 
  

 $
  

  
  

 
  0
   # :@@4> "   
 $
 
  
   


 0E
  # 3B3:>
  3BB:> A    # 3BB41 
   
    
  # 3B3B> 
   # 3B3B1# * χ   
  

$     


  
 

   
    
  
 
   8
9
       


    

   
 


 
=


  0
# &


         

   # 3BBB> .     3B:C1# * χ   

   
 
     :I4BBBB              
   
 
  
'  

3 
  
  
    

9       
 
     
 
  χ
   
   # %     
 0   # 3BBB>    .  3B:C> .    
      
 
    
 
 3B:C1# "
0χ1      

 /
$   ' 
 &+
 
      

      
)*)/ $# ) 
   
 $ 9  
 
 

  # $   # *
  $  7$    
   7$ 

 # * 
 χ 
  

    
 
  
# )
   
 J   $       9  
  
 
  

 
  $  
  3=  J # *  9    J 

  $  


 $  
  
  
 # %     $
 
  $

 
   .

  $ 
 
 9  
# ) 
       03B:C1# %  
 
 
'

 
  
     $ 
  
 +&)% )!(+   
    
       0  
)!% $# )   ::5;
  $ 
  .  3B:C1# )  

 
    
 
    
 
 0,
# ;1#    
   9  
 
 0<
    # :@@@>
 
    

 
 


 

 =  A
  # 3BB51# *  
 $
 
  



9 

   



  
   
           0
   <
  3B:3> ( 
    
  
# )  $ =   # 3B:D1# %     
 
9  

   J

 
  $

     
  
    0!
   # 3B:@1    8  $

 
     0A$    :@6C> A$ :@@6>       
  
 
 
  ,
’
%    &

 :@@6> <
    *  :@@@>  3B:;> 
 $ 0:@D;1# *  
8 0 1  
 $
 
   
  <
  3B:3> A   # 3B:;> E
  # 3B3:> 
   #     
 
   $
 
 

    
3B3B1#  

  
 9     $
       0    # 3B:41# *      8 

  
     $


    

     

      
 

     


 
 
 
   
 
  0.     3B:C> 
  # 3B3B1# *  
0L$
  # 3BB4> <   # 3BB5> <
    # 3BB61# 
9    
   $    
    


'(
  '
-RXUQDO RI $VLDQ (DUWK 6FLHQFHV   

   01 *
   (+ 
 0(  :@D5>    # 3B::1# 01# ! 
   
 0%
 3BB5> (
?   # 3B:31# (*( 
*> ","  , > *,* , > ,   , > *,*   , I K,K  , > .,. 
, > +/,0,1+ / 
,  0$ , 1> 

> KK  > %%

>  # %      8#

0<   # 3BB51# %   -% 


 $         
 

# *      <
  03BBB1 $  $

*J-%  <A! & # * =
    0&1   $ *
  
         ((+%%< (+%<J
   
 



 0B#6 1   -%  & ’ +(+<%< <(<+%+   (<%+ 

 >   
  
)   $# ,      

    
      B–C4◦ J:6B–3:4◦  C5–@B◦ J3:5–3DB◦  @:–:3B◦ J3D:–CBB◦

 
   

 
  $     :3:–:6B◦ JCB:–C4@◦ 
  0,
# ;1# &   +< 

M,# *  
  

*  :# 
   ((+%%< 
  
     
B–C4◦ J:6B–3:4◦ 0,
# ;1# A 365
  
 3;#5N  
 $

     $ $
  
    
. 
 K        *   0,
# C   ;1# *


'(
  '
-RXUQDO RI $VLDQ (DUWK 6FLHQFHV   

   01 
      # 01   
   
   
 $

   
 
 B–C4◦ J:6B–3:4◦  C5–@B◦ J
3:5–3DB◦  @:–:3B◦ J3D:–CBB◦   :3:–:6B◦ JCB:–C4@◦ #

 
' -
  %
  
  0-%1   7
 
     # +     
 0M,1       
  
=
    0&1    
 #
 (# %).+ (-# & 01 K 01 * 01 .
  0N1 +=
   & 0&1 &  0!J 1 ) 0 1

&CCD3 /3 :#4 :#@4 3#5@ B#64 3#43 ± B#;;@ :#5: ± B#B6 :#5 ± B#C
&CCD; "%C : :#36 4#B@ B#64 :#@6 ± B#@@ :#5C ± B#B6 :#3 ± B#5
&CCD4 -%; :#4 :#4D 5#3C :#:; :D#3: ± 4#:; 3#B; ± B#B3 6#; ± 3#4

    (+%<J+(+<%< <(<+%+   (<%+    +(+<%<# &8 



  
     
  
C5–@B◦ J3:5–3DB◦  @:–:3B◦ J3D:–CBB◦   :3:–:6B◦ JCB:–C5B◦   
   
# *
 

  
    


 # *    
 # ,  C5–@B◦ J3:5–3DB◦        (+%<
    


  5;:
  
 44N    $  # ,   
 $  "    /
0(  3BB:1# * (+
@:–:3B◦ J3D:–CBB◦   :3:–:6B◦ JCB:–C5B◦ 
 
     %<   (<%+
   
  8 

  

    $ :64   43 $

 :4#@N   ;#4N     

 

   0 

 
1 
  

  
 # *    $  $
 
     

  
    $
  
 
   <
8   # 0:@DC1   %    %
 0:@D51#  
 
   7
 
 
  
)
 
   
   
     $      0,
# 41# *     
      
    :    
  :D#6 0,
# ;1# *    
   8     "    /
  7
 
     
        $
    ((+%%<7$
 "
$

   (+%< 


              
 
 # * 0,
# 4
 1# %   
   
  
 
 
     K   $ $
   
     
 
 
      
  > 
     
 
   # 
       9
   
 $

  6#5 = # * 
      
  (%   ((+
7     $    #
%%<     
   . 
 K        *
  # ) 44N  
        (+%<J


'(
  '
-RXUQDO RI $VLDQ (DUWK 6FLHQFHV   

   "
 (+%<   (<%+
 

   ?

  # &7
   "
$

   (+%<
  0+  
 1#

 

    0,
# 41#   
    ((+%%< $


    
  
       8       

& 8  

   
     

     # *
   
  9  
$            

                $
  
   #

 


 # ) 


    @;◦ :6′ C4#DB′′ + *    
   
 +(+<%<   
  
  34◦ B3′ :@#DC′′ (  
 
     
    9     # * 
  
   
 (<%+

 


    0,
# 51# *  
    $

   
       9  
   
      > 
 $

    #   $   ((+%%<  

   
  $
    9   
  0,
# 5–1# &7
     (<%+  

 # &
    

 9      
             
      7 
 0,
# 5
1# <


     9  


 #
$
  
    

    
   #
*
 

 

  
'  
   !  "     # #
 
  
#  
    
 

 


 
  
  # *  
   * 7
          

 
 
    
 $
 $  $      ((+%%<J(%     
 # * 


 ?       
# *
   
     

 
  '    

          
  
  $    0,
# 31# *        
9 
   $  


# * 
    
  
   
 


 
    

    

 
 7
           # *    
 
  
 7
 #     7

     ;      
  
    
  7
    $   
      # )       * ,         # *        
 
%      
   

 0,
# D1# / %

  %  0    1    *  
  
$ 
   * 
      '   /
  %  # , $   %    
  

     

    $
  &
     7    
   # <     
  

   
  # &
     
         
      

     


      $     $ 
   +< 
   $# A        
     :;66


 $   
#   ?

 $       $
  $   :     7   
    
 @;◦ B;′ :;#C′′   @;◦ ;:′ ;:#B;′′ +   
  

      $      0*:   *31 
34◦ B@′ C5#5D′′   34◦ 44′ :4#@D′′ (  
 
       # *3 
  :;D:   
    $
 *:
 $


'(
  '
-RXUQDO RI $VLDQ (DUWK 6FLHQFHV   

  ! 01 * 


    
    

  

       * , # 01 
      


 # 01 (%  
      +<  
 

 

  #    $ 
 
  9  
#

    :;5:        


 
    

     @3B    @35    @;;     @DB   
 #
   
  
 > 
 
  $# )    ) 
          # * 
  *;

                *3   # ) %

 
  > *C
    $
     
 8
            $
    =
 0,
# :B1# *   *3   *:  $
    # 
      0,
# 61# * 
       *3
 8     $    
 $
    
    
# *;
     
   
 
7
 
 0,
# :B1# , $  *3

  
  :;B6    *C  :C@C    *3  :C@B     *:     
 7
 
   :3  
    &
 
:C66   # ) %  0    1          0,
# :B 1# *  *: *3 *C   *;      @BC 
   *:  ::6B    *3  ::66     *C  ::@;     @:B    @:C     @3:   
 # ) %   
0,
# 61# *   
 
  ::DD   # *:
          *: *3 *C   *;  $       
 
 7
 
   $
    
   
    6D4    66B    666     @CB    
  0,
# :B
   &
  ! 0,
# 61# *  

  
 1# 
   

 
         $



    +<   B#4  $  
 
 7
 # -%   $     *:    
  
    $# )       *3   0&CCD31   
  *  0&CCD;1    

$ 
# )      

  
     0&CCD41# )       $       
7  $
  *
 
# A      $
   
  
> 
   
     
 
 
$
             *:  :B54    *3  
# *  
  
 
  6 # ,  

:BD:     *C  :B6D   # *   
    
 $   $          $ 
 $
 *3   *:  $    0,
# @  1# )   # *  
       *:   :#3
 
     *C# E 
  7  $
   
  :#5  
  0*  :1#

      *
 

 
 $

   
 $     
 7$  # , $ 
 * $ #
 
          $    0,
# @1#
*    *;   *C  
      
*  
 
 $ 
  
   
7
  
  
 # *  


 8
   $
           
 
 0,
# @1# ) *3 7
   

 
   
   = 

       0    .
 :@@51#
  

 
# *:
   
  $   7 , 
9 


   $
 
   
 
  $   

'
   # )    
 
  *:   
8
 
 "
    7 $
 
  
  *3     $9
 = # * 
       
     
 9     

   &
        
     
 7  #

        0,
# @1# *    
 
  
     9  
   # *  *: *3 *C   *; 


'(
  '
-RXUQDO RI $VLDQ (DUWK 6FLHQFHV   

  $ 01 *  


    
       
0%
   %
 3BBD1# 01 %  

  
  8     


  %      * ,  ' # 01 "
  

   ))′
,
# 5 ,*,  # 0   1 %  

    /

  
    ,  ' # 01 A
   &
   
    ,  ' # 01 %  

  
     
  
,  ' #

)'*'    ?  # *     θ  $ :B   C4B
0,
# ::1 $     
  θ?  
 
%       

 /
$   '  
 
     
 $ 4   3BBB 0,
# :B1# *
 

'   0  1   ?   0 1# * θ = B#;4 

9  
 
 
   $
     
$     
     θ? = B#DD   
 
 $  
# *
       
  θ    
θ
  
    
  
'  > θ?
   

 # * 
 
 
'  


'(
  '
-RXUQDO RI $VLDQ (DUWK 6FLHQFHV   

  % 0 1 F     %



    % # 0 1 ,
   $
 
          % #

?           


     $
 
  $

 
   .   

  9  0,
# :31# * 

 
$   
    03B:C1# * χ   $   9 J 
  
  B#;C 
 θ   θ?      

 /

  B#DB# *  
 J 
  B#5; $    

 
     
     
 # 
0,
# :;1# * χ      

  
 

 



 $  8
 0'   
1    
 0'  

 1

  

 9  0,
# :;1# % 

  
)'+' ,  
 9 

   
 
  
   
=


> 
 

    
    
#
&$  
       
 $     
K     

       $ =



  9     

  
 

 0,
# :C 1#  

0    .  3B:C> <
   # 3B:;> %$   

 
 9      
 
 
  
%  3B:D> ,   <
  3B:6> %    %$ 

     $
   
      9 
3B:@1# " 
χ    

     
=



0!
   # 3B:@> .     3B:C1# A$   

$ 
 
     
   $


      $    8    
     
 0    .  3B:C1# *

 
# (
 
 $
 
9
  


       9 
 $


  

 /
 $
  $

    
$   


 χ     
    
      $ 
0,
# :C 1# -  46
 
 34    
 $
 

   χ   0,
# :;1# &
 

   
((+%%< 
 $         


   χ   8
   
  

0,
# 5 D :C1# *
 

 
9    



 0   .  3B:C1 $     $  
9   
9 
  –     
     
   8
   
    
 
# *
 0,
# :31 $  
     $   $

9     

  
 

 $ 
  

 

   
  $
 
      
       $  ? # *  

 $ 

 
     
 9  0,
# :C1#
   9   $ :3BB    
  $
   :3BB   9 

  8 
 $ :3BB   3:BB  $
   χ  
)'-' ".χ / 0,
# :;1# * χ            B  :;BB 
$
     
   $

  # A$  
"
0χ1      

 /
$   ' 
 &+    8 '  χ    3BBB  4BBB  0,
# :;1# *
   

)*)/ $# ) 
   
 $ 9  
 
  7$ 9 
            (+%<
 
   
   7$ 

 # * 
 χ   

   $  
          

 J   $       9  
   J #   
 
 
 $    #
*  9    J 

  $  
  


'(
  '
-RXUQDO RI $VLDQ (DUWK 6FLHQFHV   

  & 0 1 F          * # 0 1 ,


   $
 
             * *:  
 
  
# 01 ,
   $
          *  # 01 *:
   > 7
 
     

  
   &
   #

)'0'    ! 1 #  !   .2 / $


  

 65 
         
# F      B#B45  D#34; $
     :#BD:
F  7    
 

 8  F = 3F$JO0+  − 0*  31# * 9 
  

 ?   %  $
+1 + 0+ − +1P $ F$ –   7 $
 +    + –    F      B#BD5  D#34;# &$   
  
 7$

   

   + –   7 
 0/   ,      
     $ :B   
   
:@DD>     .
 :@@51# $  

         '>    F  
 B#;D;#   
 
  :4




 $ 
  

    $
 $      
  $ >    $ B#B45

# * F    

   $           3#;44 $
     B#;35# *  
   
 ;4        :B4 # ) 
    B#C4  
  $      
 # A 5D   
  $
$  $ $  
   
 >   :35    >     B#:;5  D#::B $
     :#B4C#

  $ # )   
    :  $ 
 /$ 
   %    
 7$       

     

  


# -  :35   
     $
 F   $ B#:65   C#5CB   

   
  F   
  ;B   
 
    :#CB@# , %        $
 

     
          
  
=  
      #  
 
   5 
 


'(
  '
-RXUQDO RI $VLDQ (DUWK 6FLHQFHV   

  ( 0 1 F $


      
   %  # 01 *:   
 %     

     3    


  7
 
 # 01 ,
   $
 
          
 # 01 ,
   $
 
 7
 



  *3  
 # 01 ,          %  #

$    $  


 7    # * ",   $ $
 !.%  $ 7
   
 

  F  
 
   $
    
  

  
      
        
      
C#D5:# 
   0 3BB6>     !  3B:C> <    # 3B:;1#
*      01
       $  
% ' 
    =   
    
 .     /

  0!    # 3B:C> 
   # 3B:@1#   

*    
               
 
 
 0%    # 3B:5>


 $   
 .    / 
  0%
 
   # 3B:@1
     
 0! 
3BB51# * 
 
   "  ,     # 3B:C1 0,
# :41# *    2(%  
  

 
  
 $  0 3BB6> %
   %
 /    $

    A
  , 
3BBD>     !  3B:C> <    # 3B:;1 $   * 0A,*1
 2+<  
 A
 
   23BB 

 ",
  
      $
   
 

     # 
     
 

8 

  # 
         

 

  =  0%    # 3B:5> 



'(
  '
-RXUQDO RI $VLDQ (DUWK 6FLHQFHV   

   . 
$   
8   01 
'  
 θ = B#;4   01 ?  
 θ = B#DD# 01 "
0χ1   
      
 
 J = B#5;#

0,
# D1# %
   %
 03BBD1    



  $ 
   

       
8

  
  * , 
    ",

$#  
    * , 
 
   

  
0,
# D1# *
 

  



     

   

F
     
  
# *


      
'  
   
 8
    
 8        *
,  0,
# 5   D1 $
         

# *  

   3C 
     5 

$
 $
    8
 
  (+%<# ) 
    

        8
    # *    

  $
  
  $ '  0,
# 5–1# )
  9       
 
 
 
 

   
 

 
  
>    
           
   ?
  = B#;4   
   
     
  # %  
 ? B#DD>         
     $
   
 
    

   7  $
 

 
# 
  
   # , 
 

    
(%  
        
 $    
  # 3B:@1# * ",
     
  



 #  
# 
           


*  ", 
     

 
 
 ?  
    
    
   
   8 

     

 #  
    
  0,
# 3   C1 $ 
)  
   
     7
   
 *           
 #  
 
  
         
  0,
# ;1  


 
'     
 #


     ", 0<    # 3B:;> 

  # 3B:61# *   *        '   /
    
  "  /
0"/1 
    


   

  
 0,
# D   1 $
  &
     
 
2(%  
 %

 ,  0%,1 $
    

   0
       

 0,
# D1#
  # 3B:@1# (  03BB:1  

  
   
  
*  /

       
  
   ", (  
      8
   
   * ,  0,
# D1# 
   8 

 
 
      $
     
 
   &
      
 $   0%
   




 # ) 44N  
        (+
%
 3BBD1 0,
# D1# *

 $   
 .    %<J+(+<%< 0C5–@B◦ J3:5–3DB◦ 1# *
  
 
=   ((+
/ 
       
 
    %%< 
  
# * (<%+  

   
 ;#4N
 
 
  $

     0"   # :@D@1# $

  # * ?  
      
* 
     
 
   
   $  
 # * 
     ((+%%<

  


     
     0A   $

  
      ?  
 
 
  :@D:> <   % :@@;1# %
   %
 03BBD1 

  
    #  
   

    
   &
,               $ ,   
  

 8
 
>   
      
 ((+%%<# -  
   
  
      ((+%%<
 
   
    F     
  

       9 

 # * 


'(
  '
-RXUQDO RI $VLDQ (DUWK 6FLHQFHV   

   01  

 
 9    
   

   
   # *           9     

 
# 01  

 
 9   
   
    

 
# * 
  
 
      =# 01 . 

$  "
0χ1    J B#5; $ 
  
 
    $
 9  
 # 0,

       

 9   

    $ 
  
 
 #1

      8


    
  
   

     # -  
   
  
 

$ 
   +(+<%<    +< 


    
      
 ((+%%<# * 

  # * (<%+ 

      
    
  
 
 $
  +(+<%<   ((+%%<
 

 # -  
  
  
 
   
   
   
  
 # * ((+%%<
      9 
      

 # *
 $  $  +(+<%<     $   
(<%+   # %

   
    
  
 

 $
  $ 


  
 
  

 
   
 
  0(  3BB:1# *  

  
 0,
# C1 $  ((+%%< 
 ? 

             
 +(+%<% +<
  <(<+%+#
% ?   
     
  


   
  
     # *  


7$       * ,       * # *
*
 
  
    
     

  # %


   "
9    

   
    
  
  $   %
   %
 03BB51 $ 
   
#   
     
        
   
 # * 

   


 
=   
  
    
 $ #
 
% 7$
     

 
      
)   F        %   $   % 
     

  #
  > 
 

       
 $
  

#   $ ,  '    $    7$  
% ( +  + + F$ F
   

   "
$

 $    # A
: :;C4#: :434#C :3@B#D 46#; B#CC@  

      
  
  >  8

3 :C4D#D33 :C5D#445 ::D4#:5D :;:#::: :#BD5   
 8   (+%< 

 # *
C :C;6#@CC :C6C#:CC ::3:#; D3#; B#;35
; ::64#B; ::6:#@3 @5C#D5 3;C#465 :#CC5

   
 +(+%<%   (<%+ 8 8
   
4 :B4;#6 :B46#3 6D6 4C B#5:5 > 
   
 # %   7
  


'(
  '
-RXUQDO RI $VLDQ (DUWK 6FLHQFHV   

   
  


    /  
$
    0 $  
 1# 
  ? 
 
 # /  $   !.% 

   !    #
03B:C1
 
   # 

 
   =  %"+A/
   :@B4  3B:D# 


)!% :B#B  % 
 *
  &


+  
  0%*&+1  
$
)   "%4 
$# 0,

   
    

 9  
 
    $

  
 
 #1


'(
  '
-RXUQDO RI $VLDQ (DUWK 6FLHQFHV   

   


      

   L    
 

9     

  
  
 
       
   # %     
  

 
   χ  
# *    χ  


 
          $ # * F 
       

      
   

  
         
    9  $
  
 
 
# *   χ  
 

    
  
 $
     
          



    
=


   

$  # * $ F     $   

    $
        
  
  ?     # K  %       ((+%%< 

  
 

   #
 


    # *    



'    
    
   0%
   )*    #
    
%
 3BB51# *
       
    

(+%<   $

     
   >   8
 +     , " 
'
  <

 

 
'        
   
# * 7
 &   
 %

  
$   

# +# -,
                " 
'
  <

 

  &   
 %

 
$
      
       
 
$   

 ,
 


 #   - , ,
 
    
  

   (  # &  8 



 #    ) + , " 
'
  <

 


 

   7
     
9>  $  
 &   
 %

  
$   

# *  * , &

  
 

  #     
  
   
 %$   ,   
# . / *.,
 7
   
 
           &   
 %$   ,   
# ' 0"  

# -%  
   
 
       6  1-, ,
 


 #
$
   
 :#5 # 
        $
  
    ?

   7
   
  $
  
  ?      
 

# K

 '
   )#  
A
         
   
  
 $

    
    
  

 # * 
  *         $ 
 9  

 
   A
   
      
      
     
 
       
7 
  8
  $  # .   
    
   $ 

 #
 
 $ 
       
 
  $ # *  

 7$ $ $

 
  2
-.

=   ((+%%< 
   # * 
 

$

  
/

 46   $
 34  
 $
  *  0# # ## # #   ##1     &

(+%< 

  $
   

   $   # <
  
  A
  !  &   

 
* 
  
 
     7$   

   


  
 

     9 $  
  

     (+%< 

 #    
  $ # * <
  
  

   
 


    
    
 ((+%%<
 

 <A!JBB@:# <    $    
    

    
     # * χ        $    
$ $

   =

 

  
 

 $  
  

    # , $     . 
L$  
 
$  8
 0'   
1    
 0'   
 1

 
    


#
 

 9 # % 

     9 

 
 
 
  
    

  =


    * 

    
    
# *  


     9   $    
  :3BB      8 ) %##  &## :@65# . 
  
 # !   (  
-

# ! # % #  
 # ::@ D4–D@#
9    :3BB # *  8    9 
   (+
) %##  ## %  %# :@@B# *
  

    ( A

%< 

   # *  
         )      
#  I ( # ! %##   &# 0+#1
   
 
 
 $    # *    %   *
I *  
 % # (# ) %
#  
 0+  
 B#;4        −B#DD   χ    B#5;    
.  # %
#1 @@ :6D–:@@#
) E# :@6B# )
 

   K
 % 
 
 I !
  

 /

      
 
 
=


# 
 
 # ! # 6 ;;3–;;5# 
I:B#::CBJBB@:D5:C0:@6B16<;;3I
>3#B#>3#
& )
   )  ,# :@DB# , 
   
 
 $  
  
   



 
 
 
# )# E# %
# 356 3;C–35C# IJJ
#J:B#3;D4J
?#356#C#3;C#
*  $

   $    
   )
 # 

 # / 
 %#%# *  !#*# 
 !#"# 3B::# !


   
     
   ,  /     
  '

   
    


   (   (+  
# L

 Q ! 
 44 3;D–354#

    ?

 # *  
     )

  E#"# ) )# /$
 %# "   !##    *## 
 %#   #

 
9    
     

  %? 
 &#  *# * (# L  # L # 3B:@# *
   

 
  
# *

 
 
  
 
    $ 
  / 
   $ 
  


  
# *
 C6 :D:6–:D;:# IJJ
#J:B#:B3@J3B:6*"BB4B;@#
$       
# A       )  #*# - #L# <
 ##  !#,# *  %#*# (
  <# 3B3B# )


=   
      # *
      
   "    , /
I  
  . 
 

    

          

   . , # E# )
 + %
# IJJ
#J:B#:B:5J?#
?8#3B3B#:BBBCD#

  
#  
    
 

  
  /  !#  
 "# 3BBC# *
   $ 
  %  
  
  
 
 $   # * 
  0   1I


    
 
 
=    

  
     
 9  
      -
 # E# )
 + %
# 3: ::C@–::4D# IJJ
#J:B#:B:5J:C5D
@:3B0B31BB:6C@#
 
 
 

>  

 



/? "# :@@:# * 

    
— 
 '  




      
# * 


 9     8    / 
  # * 
 :@: 3:C–333# IJJ
 $ 
 # *  $        
#J:B#:B:5JBB;B:@4:0@:1@BB4D#
 

  # 
       

 /  <#/ ,  #&# :@DD# *
        
!    "

#  I &
 &#-# 0+#1 ! 

 
 
  
 


 # *   7     .
 +
 )  !  %
 %K( /
  (
 

 /

 .     ,  /    -

 % K%) # ::4–:C6#


'(
  '
-RXUQDO RI $VLDQ (DUWK 6FLHQFHV   

/ $
  #-# :@55# -  !     /  # E# ! # %#   #  # 3BB6# ,
 0*    
  1
)# :C :CD–:@;#   +   ))  /
   
# "# %
# @; 5;D–543#
" #&#&# %  E# 3BB:# .
I   
 
     '
   # %
  !#  #"# 3B:D# )      
  


  

   # "# !
# 3D .   
    ( A
  /  ' # A
# ! # C6 0:1
43D–4C;# IJJ
#J:B#:B:5JBB@6CBB;0BB1BB:;5:# 65–@B#
" E##  &#!# $  #)# +  ,#E# 
 #<# A  # 
    # %
 /#.# <
 # +'  -#"# 3B:6#      
  ,

# :@D@#*
   )  %   /#  I <
 E#   # 0  +   -
 1  ( A
  /   0/1I
&
   .#<# 0+#1 ! 
   !
  

   " 
  . 
   

9 # E# )
 + %
# :53 :C–3;#

 )
 )

 . # ! 
 # 3@ :6@–:@6#   # %
 /#.# / 
 )# 3B:@# )  
 
$  + 
   
& 
 /# "$
' E# :@@:# .

   
 
  
      /   0/1 (+  
     $ A
 I
 
 I )

      
   L
 /
#  
     

 # E# .  # %#  
 5; 0:1 C@–;6#
* 
 :@; 3CD–35C# IJJ
#J:B#:B:5JBB;B:@4:0@:1@B35C#   # )

  E#"# <
 #  
 &# L # ? &#%#(# 3B3B# + 
+   .# :@C3# +8          $
  *
 
 

   ( A
  
      01I 

 

)# * # 
# ! # #  #  # 3D :56–3;6#     
  
 # E# )
 + %
# :@: :B;34@#
,
 E#E# :@D;# % 
     
   
   
# <    # 

 # 
 E#(# *  !#*# 3B:@# (
 


 
 # :B @5@–@DC#  % /       &

 (  I +
  
, )# <
  # 3B:6# "

   *   &

 &
 &

 
 # E# )
 + %
# :DB :C6–:4;#
%

 ;@C :B3–::D# 
I :B#C:33CJ#
J 3@# 

 #   # 
 !# 3B:6# (
 

     " 
!  F##   /# 
 %#%# "
 E#  )# %
 #&#  , 
      
  
I   
  
*
$
 #.# " ## %  %## )
 )#  .# /   )# 
   # )
 E# !
# :: 04:D1 :–:5#
(
 # 3B:C# )

    
  / $ $   ,## :6D5# -   9    ( A
 
   
  
%  )# !  ;: 3C4–3C6# IJJ
#J:B#::CBJCCDD:#:# %
 

 )# # ! # % #  
 :3 031 355–C5C#
!
  /#  %## "  ,#E# .
 &# A #&# 3B:@# )  
 
  # 
 +#-# ,  # A E# / ? .# A
 +## 3B:@# )

   
  8
   = 
9
 
 
  "      
/%  .       ($ " 
 !.%

   9 # + %# & # D 3::–3CB# IJJ
#J:B#4:@;JD ($ # E# !# #I %
 + :3; C:44–C:D:# IJJ
#J:B#:B3@J
3::3B:@# 3B:6?B:5;6B#
! 
  !# /
 .# 3BBD# 
    
      9 I    %##   # / E#.# F  .#!# A
 (# "
  # 3B:4#
  
  A ’ %     
         
 0 %
 


  :B /
 
     .
 
&% 1# + %# .#   C3 5;@–5D:# IJJ
#J:B#:BB3J  
  I )       
  
 
# +
#:;:C# .   %
# # ;34 :4;–:5D# IJJ
#J:B#:B:5J?# #3B:4#B4#B4B#
!% :@66# !
   +  
   F    
       

  E#&# %

 E#.## :@@3# !
J*
 "   %
 

 "  ) 
# .   ,# %# :@6465 35# &
   - I *    %  
 
# E# ! # :BB
!% 3B::# !    
   
 
' (     *
# 434–4;;# IJJ
#J:B#:B65J53@5B5#
! # %#  
 
# . # CB 0F1 :B; # 
  )#  $ <#%# :@D4# )   +  
   / -   
A  E# !

 (## E   E#.##  /#.# 3B:;# 
 
7   %
 " 
# ! # %# )# / # 65 CB4–C:4# IJJ
#J:B#::CBJ

 
   
  


   
 9    
  $
 BB:5D5B50:@D4165<CB4I>3#B#>3#


   /
   # A$

# E# !# # + %# ::@ 051 


 ) )$   
" ! *    E
 ! 3B3B#  


:;:6–:;;B# !
 )   

 )
 &

 ,   
 
A   <#/# :@D:# *
  

" 
 %
' # ! # # :B6 "   ( A
 # !
 4; 0;1 4;C–453#
3D–;3# 
  )#A#!# :@6:# . '
    


  %+ )
 
A
 # + '  # <
  #M# L
  +# %  E#   )# ,
9  ## A
    *
# E# ! # %# :C6 :B@–:33# IJJ
#J:B#::;;J
3BB5# )
9 
   $        # ?#:C6#3#B:B@#
E# !# # + %# ::: ,B;BB;# IJJ
#J:B#:B3@J3BB5?BBB;5:# 
 E#(# 

 #    # 
 !#"# *  !#*# 3B3B# 
A$ )#&# :@@6#   9          I  
    

       &
   . 


$
  $
  
    
   #  I *
 #   (    
# ! # E# 44 ;4D–;D5#
<  +#+# 0+#1 
    I , 
 
   I )#   .# *
 .# :@D4# " '
 
  )
I     
 
!# K
 !#   :BD 3@D–C:@# 

 # %
  :6@ ;:@–;35# IJJ
#J:B#::35J
 #:6@#;3B:#;:@#
A$ )#&#  !# :@6C# "   
  # ! # %# )# / # @; 051  )#%# <
  )#!# 3BBB# 
  
  =' 
 
 
DC@–D43# IJJ
#J:B#::CBJBB:5D5B50:@6C1@;3#B#"->3# 
 
=  
  # 
# # C3 4D–DC#
A  ## /   -# % ,#&# 3BB4# 
  8
     
 (  &## :@D5# * )  8
   A
 )   
 I 
# . # 3;#

  )(&%)* +*   )%*+
# " I %


 ! # % #  # 3 C5C–C5D#
   F
 #  % # +
 # 
# !% ) # ! # F 4@6C# (  &## :@6B# *
 .
(+  
#  # E# + %
# D 0:1 :BC–:BD#
IJJ
#J:B#:::DJ:3#53D5@@# (  &## 3BB:# ! 
  (  
   )?

 
 # )/" . 
E
 ( 
" ! .  " " 3B3:# &
  
    
       
 # 3B@#
 
 
  
  ($ A
 A
   
# # (  )#/# /   /# /  &#<# 3B:D# ) 
 '   

 # 4D44D5 CD–4B# IJJ
#J:B#:B:5J?#=
#3B3B#B4#B3;#  
 0L.
 1    '  
   I "

   

 #
 %## . %#  !# :@@D#   
 
   ! 
 E# !# # + % :33 :3C5–:35:# IJJ
#J:B#:BB3J
/   ?


  
       . 
 A   3B:DE,BB;34B#
 # . 
 ;5 0:–31 :@5–3:B# (
? .# & "# !
 %# ,
  )#%# %  &# 3B:3# -

 
  +#)# .
 (# :@@5# )
 *
I =  
    #  

'
   9    
 -

 " 8
  
. 
 A  K %  
 (E  CC6#   
 '  (  
# E# )
 + %
# 4B :36–:;B# IJJ

 +# <
  #M# 3B:3# +8
  
 


   # 
#J:B#:B:5J?#?#3B:3#B:#BB;#
E# %# ! # ;; 4;–D4# IJJ
#J:B#:B:5J?#?#3B:3#BD#BB@# -
 "#&# :@6:# *
    #       # C3;#

 # (  %# -
 # :@@4# 
    
  

 
  -
 %# :@64#     
 
   $ 
 
   # ! # %#
%  *
 ) 
 0%*)1# "# !
# 3: :B@:–::B;# IJJ
#J )# / # @5 4B;–4:4# IJJ
#J:B#::CBJBB:5D5B50:@641@5<4B;I
:B#:B:5JBB@6CBB;0@41BBB;3D# >3#B#>3#
 )# 3BB6#  B   
  
   # % 
 %
  .  %# :@@3# )
   
 
     
 


    
 
 $   A
    % $ * # E# ! # %# :;@ :BC:–:B;;# IJJ
#J:B#::;;J
)
 # 4:–5B# ?#:;@#5#:BC:#

" ! 
 % / *    .  " " E
  3B3B# +
   .  E#*#   # 3B:C# )
    
 9    
#

 

    !
  
 A
 "   A
  + %# .   C6 051 4DB–4D5#
 
# ! # E# IJJ
#J:B#:BB3J?#CD@:# .

 &#)# E   !#&# :@@4# &

     .
 .
 
 )# % ? # %
 # &   *# 3B::# )
 &
       


$ .
 # ! # %# )# / # :BD 6@4–@33#
"   ,  0",1
  /  I  



  
 "# 
 *#   ,# 3B:C# "
   +
J%  
=
+
 #  # E# !
# B3 4@D–5B@# IJJ
#J:B#;3C5J
?#3B::#3;B53#      +*
  7$   
 
  /# E# )

  /# !  F## 3B:C# *
   
  
  8
  + %
# D5 :64–:@;#

/  
   +  
# "# %
# :B; @3B–@CC#   # "   # <
  # 3BBB# +  
  
   
 9   
 &# 3B:;# *  $ 



  I 
      #


 I   
  
    
  
 9      
 

+ %# .#   C@ 0:1 C6–5:#   


 # + * # )# !# K
 6: 0, 
 % #
 , .# :@D4# A
 
  I   $    
  # )# E# ) *53,B@1 6: :–3#
%
# 3D4 :–;;#   # .  E#*# 3B:C# % 
     $ =
   

 
  # F   # ? &#%#(# 3BB;# K


   
    
  
  

 9 # E# !# #+ %# ::6 031


I 
    
 
        
 ;@D–4:6#
 
   
 K &
   (   + A
   
 %  %#.# :@@6# %

  / 
 I 
 

R !#



 
 8 
 #  # E# .# ! # :C D@–@5# # # 34 C:6@–C:@3# IJJ
#J:B#:B3@J@6 B3345#


'(
  '
-RXUQDO RI $VLDQ (DUWK 6FLHQFHV   

%  %#.# 3BBC# -


= .  "  
  / 0 1 %  #%#    &## )  %#A# % # ,  # !  E# A
 +##
%
 
 # . ) # !# :5B :5::–:54B# IJJ
#J:B#:BBDJ A$ # 3B:5#     
 
  
 
  
BBB3;BBC3CD6B#   /  # (# !
# @ 5:4–5:6# IJJ
#J:B#:BC6J
%  &# %$  <# 3B:@#  
9
   
  
 


3D5B#


   
  # + % & 
 &

 I  
$ 0 %  )#!# %
 ## :@D5# *
 * 
   / "  


 3B:@4:1 OIJJ
#J:B#4:@;J3B:@4:P# &

% )  ,  L  %  * "

# )).! / # 5B
%  # <
  # /9  /# "  # 3BB;# !
  
  0:31#
 
 8
      $
  
 
    *
 .# . ' !# )
? # :@65#-  
   

 $
.
 "
# ! # %# )# / # ::5 6@4–@B@# IJJ
#J:B#::CBJ  
   )
#  I # .# "$ )# "# 
 0+#1 "

 
 @::4–:4D#
34C5;#:# ! # %# %# . #   #
%$  <# %  &# 3B:D# /

 9 I  
     F
  #*# %  # / %# :@65# / 
 "  
  

 
 = 
 
 
=# + %# & # 4 63:–6C@# !  
 9 
   ( 
 

  # # !% ::; 0F1
IJJ
#J:B#4:@;J463:3B:D# D–:;#
%
 .#!# ! E## L' "# /? *# 3BBC# ,     
 
F
  #*# E
 )# ! %# ! #.# %  # :@6@# 
 -

#
% %
I  
    
   =  

#  !  
 
     #  I ! (#"# 0+#1 . '

!  34B 3BC–335# -

   
# %  .  .  # :@D–3:3#
%
 )## %
 (## &
 #&# %
 ##/# 3B:3# !
  
 
 F #   # :@D5# *
 

9       

9

   
 -


 " 8    -
  
 

  
# * 
 C; ::D–:CC# IJJ
#J
/  (+  
# E# ! # %#  
 6B 3C:–3;B# IJJ
#J:B#:BBDJ:34@; :B#:B:5JBB;B:@4:0D51@B:6BC#
B:3B:CC@# <  # %
 # *  %#*# 
 ## 
 *# 3B:;# )
 
   = 
%  #%# &

 <#+# :@@6# 
  

 9    


  I  
     
 # E# !# #I %
 + ::@ CD5D–C633#
% $   
7   
     I *
 #   <  +#+# IJJ
#J:B#:BB3J3B:C?B:BD53#
0+#1 
    I , 
 
   # )# !# K
 <
  #M# *  !#+# :@@@# & 
   $ 



  I
!#   :BD # 3CD–35B# 

   


   
      
 
%  (#.# <
  #M# *  !#+# 
 &#E# 3BBB#         # E# !# # – %
 + :B; :D55:–:D5D;# IJJ
#

 
I &

   
    
   9 
  
 J:B#:B3@J:@@@E/@BB:3B#

  ? 
 
   "

# ! # %# )# / # ::3 :34B–:35C# <
  #M# 
 +# /  %#A# :@@@# !


  


IJJ
#J:B#::CBJBB:5D5B503BBB1::3<:34BI >3#B#>3#


 
# ( ;B: C@–;C#
%
 # 3BB5#  
   
 
    
  



   <
  )#"# )  # "$
 .#)# *  !#+#  !# 3BB6# &

 
      # A
# ! # 3D :::–:33#    
      
 
  
  
   9 #
%
 #   # "# 3BB6# ! 
   
 
  
I !  :BB 4B5–435# IJJ
#J:B#:B:5J?##3BB6#B:#B:6#


    
      #  I % 
 %
  <
8 #+# A
 *#.# %  &## :@DC# /
 $  
# )).! / # 4D
    
 
 $   A
    % D;–@5#
)
 # 3C–C4# <  (#A# % "# :@@;# " 
  

 
#  I A   .##
%
 # %
 #.# 3BB5# )  
  
   
  


  0+#1 " 
  &
 # .  -8 # 34:–35C#
  
       #  I % 
 .#%# 0+#1 A
  <
 %#&#  %#<# .  E#*# !  # "  "## 3B:;# & 

0! 
 )1 ; 36:CB3# 
'
  
 /
 :3;6D54–:3;6D54 %
  C;C# IJJ
#J
%
 # %
 ##A# 3BBD# *  
  


= 
 
I :B#::35J
 #:3;6D54#
    8 #  I % 
 .#%# 0+#1 A
  0! 
 )1 4 < "#<# <
  #M# A #F# 3BB5# (
   "  ( 
3DC3@D# A
 I " 
  
 
 ;B)JC@)     
%$ #%# A   .## :@@B# <
   R +
 :C 345–35C#  
# *
 34 *";B::# IJJ
#J:B#:B3@J3BB4*"BB:@C4#
%$ #%# A   .## :@@;# (
#  I A   .## 0+#1 " 
  L$
 /#E# .''
 ,#E# +    +#/# 3BB4# "


7   9 
&
 # .  -8 # CDB–;B@#  
   



 # E# !# #+ %# ::B ,C# IJJ
#J
:B#:B3@J3BB;?BBB:C6#



View publication stats

You might also like