Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 5

[Downloaded free from http://www.ym-kdham.in on Friday, February 10, 2023, IP: 1.38.99.

17]

Review Article

Yoga and attention: A systematic review


Kanchan Yadav, Arti Yadav, Sandeep Singh

Department of Yoga Science, University of Patanjali, Haridwar, Uttarakhand, India

Abstract In modern times, people are suffering from numerous types of difficulties. Stress and mental problems have become
part of one’s life. Excessive use of mobile phones, other electronic devices, and drug intake has caused many
cognitive and mental problems. Attention, memory, and cognitive functions are affected by electronic and digital
devices. Previous studies have shown that yoga can reduce stress and anxiety and improve cognitive functions
such as attention and memory. The patient, intervention, comparison, and outcome search strategy was used to
identify the keywords. Using the key words “yoga and attention,” 285 studies were identified from three databases
(PubMed, Cochrane Library, and Science Direct) and a search engine (Google Scholar). For discussion, 18 studies
were included in the review. There was a wide range of age groups where the effectiveness of yoga on attention
had been researched. This systematic review also revealed that attention in children also depends on memory
development and anxiety. The particular study on the systematic reviews showed the high effectiveness of yoga,
yogic exercises, mindfulness, and other yogic techniques on the level of attention among children. The study also
revealed the coexistence of attention with memory development.

Key Words: Attention, children, memory, yoga

Address for correspondence:


Dr. Sandeep Singh, Department of Yoga Science, University of Patanjali, Haridwar ‑ 249 405, Uttarakhand, India.
E‑mail: drsandeepksingh@gmail.com
Submitted: 02‑Jun‑2022 Revised: 01‑Sep‑2022 Accepted: 14‑Sep‑2022 Published: 15-Dec-2022

INTRODUCTION mechanical understanding of attention. Working memory, top–


down sensitivity control, competitive selection, and automatic
The practice of yoga has been regarded as a spiritual discipline bottom‑up filtering for salient stimuli are the four processes that
since ancient times. Modern scientific researchers have shown makeup attention. Each process contributes to attention in a vital
its efficacy for the benefit of humankind at a different level and essential way.[5] Attention is a required element of cognition
of persona, mainly attention. Modern cognitive psychologists and has been characterized in two ways, namely, (i) either as a
believe that attention is the constant process of filtering out capacity or (ii) as a skill of resource implementation. Attention
information from one’s perceived surroundings and focusing is the ability to attend to a task for the needed time.[6] Some other
on specific elements. [1,2] In a study, meditation practice is causes affecting attention are found to be drug abuse. Attention is
associated with changes in the physical structure of the brain negatively affected using marijuana and positively affected using
and positively impacts attention in an individual. Compared to nicotine.[7,8] The substantial use of alcohol affects the cognition
controls, meditation participants had thicker brain areas involved and attention of college students.[7] A study has shown that
with attention and sensory processing than matched controls.[3] 20%–30% of the diagnosed population suffered primarily from
Another study discovered that regular meditation practice is linked attention deficit.[9] Several studies investigated the effects of yoga
to a significant increase in attention ability.[4] The elucidation on cognitive functions and found that it had effects on attention.
of the neurological basis of conscious experience requires a Meditation has shown a positive impact on attention.[10] A study

Access this article online This is an open access journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution‑NonCommercial‑ShareAlike 4.0 License, which
Quick Response Code: allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non‑commercially, as long as
Website:
appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.
www.ym‑kdham.in

For reprints contact: WKHLRPMedknow_reprints@wolterskluwer.com


DOI:
10.4103/ym.ym_66_22 How to cite this article: Yadav K, Yadav A, Singh S. Yoga and attention:
A systematic review. Yoga Mimamsa 2022;54:128-32.

128 © 2022 Yoga Mīmāṃsā | Published by Wolters Kluwer - Medknow


[Downloaded free from http://www.ym-kdham.in on Friday, February 10, 2023, IP: 1.38.99.17]

Yadav, et al.: Yoga and attention: A systematic review

found that yoga practice had improved attention and memory Exclusion criteria
in children.[11] Another study found that the practice of yoga Conference abstracts, books, review articles, theses, and
and meditation improves cognitive skills, sustained and divided dissertations were not included in the present systematic review.
attention, concentration, short‑term memory, visual information Articles other than English language articles were excluded from
processing, working memory, complex cognitive speed, and the study.
flexibility of students.[12] To our knowledge, there is no systematic
review assessing the effects of yoga on attention. Hence, this Data extraction
systematic review aimed to assess the effects of yoga on attention. The studies that fulfilled the inclusion and exclusion criteria were
assessed in detail. Information that was extracted from the records
MATERIALS AND METHODS included the author, year of the study, sample size, study design,
and age group of samples. Clarifications and doubts, if any, were
sorted out by brainstorming and mutual discussion.
Search strategies
The present review used electronic database searches with
PubMed, Cochrane Library, and Science Direct, supplemented
RESULTS
with Google Scholar search. From January 2015 to December
A total of 18 studies were included in the review  [Figure  1].
2020, published scientific studies  (randomized control trial,
After searching databases, 285 articles were identified (Cochrane
case studies, and pilot studies) in English were reviewed. The
Library = 83, PubMed = 69, Science Direct = 87, and Google
search expression used for the search strategy was “yoga” and
Scholar = 46). Two hundred and sixty‑seven studies were excluded
“Attention.” The present study primarily relied on electronic from the study. Two hundred and thirty‑four studies were excluded
searches (online databases) as a part of this review. because they did not have “yoga” or “Attention” in their titles.
Twelve studies were excluded due to duplication. Nine studies
Screening and selection were excluded because they were not in the English language. Six
Article selection was determined through successive screening of studies were excluded because they were theses, dissertations, or
the study design, titles, abstracts, and full‑text articles based on books. Three studies were excluded because they were reviews.
the level of assessment required to ascertain eligibility. Three studies were not relevant to the objective of the study.
The most common instrument used was the Trail Making Test ,
Inclusion criteria followed by other rating scales including the Letter Cancellation
The current systematic review includes studies published in Task, Six‑Letter Cancellation Test, Visual Attention Test, Attention
English under the titles “yoga” and “Attention” with full‑text deficit hyperactivity disorder  (ADHD) Rating Scale‑IV, d2‑R,
articles, with participants of all ages and suffering from any strengths and weaknesses of ADHD symptoms and normal
disease. behavior  (symptoms and normal‑behavior), Digit Cancellation
Identification

Record Identified through Cochrane Additional record identified through


Library, Pub Med and Science Direct other sources (Google Scholar)
(n = 83 + 69+87 = 239) (n = 46)
Screening

Record Screened Record Excluded on titles


(n = 285) (n = 234)

Full-text articles excluded on abstract


selection (n = 33)
Full-text articles 1. Duplication = 12
assessed for eligibility 2. Non-English Article = 9
Eligibility

(n = 51) 3. Thesis/ Dissertation/Book = 6


4. Review paper = 3
5. Not relevant on subject = 3

Full text selection Study Excluded


(n = 18) (n = 0)
Inclusion

Study Included for analysis


(n = 18)

Figure 1: Identification and Inclusion of the study

Yoga Mīmāṃsā | Volume 54 | Issue 2 | July-December 2022 129


[Downloaded free from http://www.ym-kdham.in on Friday, February 10, 2023, IP: 1.38.99.17]

Yadav, et al.: Yoga and attention: A systematic review

Test, Attention Control Scale, Test/Digit Span Test and Stroop raj yoga, and mind–body training, which are also known as
Color Test, Mindful Attention Awareness Scale, Response super brain yoga.[13,14] According to a study, high‑frequency
Inhibition Task, Number–Letter Task, Attention Network Task, yoga breathing and yoga‑based breath awareness combined
Continuous Performance Test, Conners’ Continuous Performance with quiet sitting can significantly improve attention and reduce
Test  (CCPT), Second Edition CCPT, ADHD RS‑IV Preschool anxiety.[15] A pretest–posttest study on 91 sample sizes with an
Version, Visual Pursuit Test, and Determination Test. The sample age group of 10–12 years showed that super brain yoga improves
size of the studies varied from 20 to 802, from the age group of short‑term memory and selective attention of the students.[16] In
3 to 35+ years. a cross‑sectional, single‑center study with 40 sample sizes, that
30  min of yoga package, which included chanting, postures,
DISCUSSION breathing exercises, and relaxation for 12  months, improved
memory, reduced anxiety, increased self‑confidence, and changed
The systematic literature reviews using the patient, intervention, students’ perceptions.[17]
comparison, and outcome strategy show that yogic practices
and allied interventional approaches significantly affect the The randomized control trial with a sample size of 113 with an
cognitive functions, particularly attention and anxiety, in samples age group of 7–14 years has justified that yoga practices such as
of different age groups. The reviews had a wide range of studies Hatha Yoga, deep breathing, stretching, meditation, relaxation,
with different age groups [Table 1]. All the studies included in breath awareness, body awareness, and rhythmic movements
systematic reviews have been classified into five different age for 40–45 min for 8 weeks can significantly improve attention,
groups. memory, performance on task and lower impulsivity in children
with cerebral palsy and reduce attention problems and inhibition
Out of 285 papers screened, 18 research papers included for the problems in children suffering with ADHD.[18‑20] In a study with
discussion [Table 2] shows a significant impact on attention. The a sample size of 60, a group of yogic physical activities such as
research articles also reveal some additional information and Surya Namaskar, asanas, pranayama, and DRTs can significantly
its effects. Primary school children and adults having attention improve attention, concentration, and cardiovascular endurance
problems with the age groups between 7 and 14  years and 17 after weeks of practice.[21] A study showed that 6–8 weeks of yoga
and 35 years simultaneously discussed. The six studies between practice such as traditional ashtanga vinyasa yoga, ujjayi, and raja
the age group 7 and 14 years included showed high significance yoga meditation significantly improved perceived stress, salivary
in improvements in memory and performance of the samples. cortisol, and improved perception and attention in the age group
The studies included suggest an improvement in attention for of 18–35 years.[22] A research on 100 samples showed that yoga
the 17–35 year age group with yoga as an independent variable. for 12 weeks regularly for 30 min, 5 days a week significantly
The five studies in the age groups 0–7 and 14–17 also show a improved attention, concentration, and memory in healthy
significant effect on attention and concentration among children. medical students.[23] In other research, 180 university students
participated in a study where they were randomly assigned to
The high school children’s age group between 14 and 17 years mindfulness training (experimental groups), awareness exercises
was discussed secondarily, with three studies out of 18 studies (active control group), or no training (passive control group). Two
included for systematic reviews. Concludes that most of the studies mindfulness‑based interventions, one of which included yoga and
are done on primary school children and adults between the ages the other of which did not, were used to teach mindfulness. In
of 17 and 35 years. regards to the aspect of attention regulation, the study found that
seven biweekly mindfulness training sessions did not reveal any
The group of researchers researched that yoga practices such different advantages from mindfulness training with or without
as postures  (asanas), breathing techniques  (Pranayamas), and yoga.[24] Through a research intervention, where 20 participants
yogic games for 6–12 weeks improve attention among 3–5 years were given elective yoga lectures and philosophical instructions
of children. They also proved that indices such as visual motor for 6 weeks, it was suggested that after the yoga course, depression,
precision, the parent’s rating scale of attention, decreased anxiety, stress, and other mental health problems were reduced
omission errors on some attention tasks and the behavior of with improved attention control.[25,26] An experimental control
inattention, and hyperactivity at the age of 3–5  years can also study with a sample size of 60, it was revealed that an hour of raj
be affected substantially. The results showed that practices vary yoga practice for 8 weeks can significantly improve the perception
from Hatha Yoga, mindfulness training, and yogic practices and attention of individuals aged 21–23 years.[27] The pre‑ and
such as Surya Namaskar, deep relaxation techniques  (DRTs), postexperimental control study showed that 25‑min sessions
of Hatha Yoga and meditation for 12  weeks can considerably
Table 1: Number of literature reviews article with improve attention and hyperactivity in high school students.[28] A
the sample’s age group randomized controlled trial on 802 samples showed that 1 h of
Age groups 0-7 7-14 14-17 17-35 Above 35 yoga training or physical exercises for 2 months daily can improve
(years) executive functions, attention, and working memory in adolescent
Number of studies 2 6 3 6 1 school children.[29] A research reported that asanas such as warrior
included in the study pose, easy lotus pose, sun salutation, deep breathing exercises,

130 Yoga Mīmāṃsā | Volume 54 | Issue 2 | July-December 2022


[Downloaded free from http://www.ym-kdham.in on Friday, February 10, 2023, IP: 1.38.99.17]

Yadav, et al.: Yoga and attention: A systematic review

Table 2: The systematic review table for the included studies


Author Study design Age groups Results
(years) (sample size)
Cohen Mixed‑methods 3-5  (23) Yoga has no significant improvement on attention, hyperactivity and
et al., 2018[13] randomized impulsivity in preschool‑age children with ADHD symptoms
waitlist‑controlled trial
Jarraya RCT 5.2±0.4 (45) Yoga group has shown significant positive effect on the development of
et al., 2019[14] visual attention A in comparison to the control group. Yoga has shown
significant positive effect on the development of visual attention B in
comparison to physical education
Rezaei Three‑way parallel group 7-11 (21) Yoga and neurofeedback have significant improvements in sustained
et al., 2018[18] RCT attention and memory compared to the control group in children with
attention deficit hyperactivity disorder
Nilsoge Cross‑sectional 8-14 (40) The practice of yoga significantly improves memory and self‑confidence;
et al., 2016[17] single‑center study reduced anxiety shows positive changes in the perception of students
Mak Waitlist RCT 9.1 (42) Mi Yoga has enhanced sustained attention and consistency of
et al., 2018[19] performance on tasks while lowering impulsivity in children with
cerebral palsy
Chou and Pre‑  and postexperimental 10.50 (50) Study shows that yoga exercise can be implemented as an alternative
Huang, 2017[20] controlled study therapy for children with ADHD to reduce attention problems and
inhibition problems
Jois Pre‑  and posttest design 10-12 (91) Yoga has shown significant improvement in selective attention and
et al., 2017[16] short‑term memory of students
Telles Self as a control study 11-12 (61) HFYB has a significant increase in attention and significant decrease in
et al., 2019[15] the anxiety of preteen children
Nagaraj Pre‑  and postexperimental 14-16 (60) Yoga has significantly improved attention, concentration, and
et al., 2019[21] controlled study cardiovascular endurance in volleyball players
Joice Pre‑  and postexperimental 17-23 (100) Yoga has shown statistically significant improvement in attention,
et al., 2018[23] controlled study concentration, and memory of medical students
Schmalzl RCT 18-35 (65) The study shows that yoga breathing practice can lead to measurable
et al., 2018[22] changes in sustained attention, perceived stress, and salivary cortisol in
novice practitioners
Jesintha, Experimental‑control 21-23 (60) Raja yoga meditation has a significant improvement on cognitive
2020[27] study abilities; perception, and attention among school girls
Ravikumar[25] Pre‑  and postexperimental 21-25 (100) Yoga has significantly improved attention, concentration, and memory
controlled study of B.Ed. students
Wimmer Nonrandomized pre‑  and 24.92 (180) Mindfulness training has no significant difference found with or without
et al., 2020[24] postdesign yoga, regarding the aspects of attention regulation
Amemiya et al., Pre‑  and postexperimental 25.65 (20) Yoga significantly reduces depression, anxiety, stress and mental health
2020[26] study problems and improves attention control
Saxena Pre‑  and postexperimental 174 Study shows that Hatha Yoga can improve attention and hyperactivity in
et al., 2020[28] controlled study high school students
Vhavle RCT 802 Yoga has significantly improved executive function, attention and
et al., 2019[29] working memory as effectively as physical exercise intervention in
adolescent school children
Gothe RCT 62.0±5.59 Yoga practice leads to improve attention and information processing
et al., 2017[30] (118) abilities in older adults
HFYB, High‑frequency yoga breathing; ADHD, Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder; RCT, Randomized control trial

meditative exercises, and mantra repetition can significantly and depressive behavior in a targeted population. This systematic
improve the attention and information processing abilities in review advocates the need for yoga intervention in school settings
older adults.[30] by assessing its efficacy in the management of psychological
disorders in the targeted population. Hence, yoga and other
CONCLUSION techniques are indeed effective in increasing people’s attention
levels. Therefore, it needs to be the primary intervention strategy
The review suggests that yoga, yogic exercises, mindfulness, and for future studies.
other yogic techniques had significant improvements in attention
among children. The study also revealed the coexistence of Financial support and sponsorship
attention with memory development. The review also suggests Nil.
that yoga can have a substantial effect on memory development
and attention in all age groups. A  few studies included in this Conflicts of interest
review have also revealed that yoga helps in reducing anxiety There are no conflicts of interest.

Yoga Mīmāṃsā | Volume 54 | Issue 2 | July-December 2022 131


[Downloaded free from http://www.ym-kdham.in on Friday, February 10, 2023, IP: 1.38.99.17]

Yadav, et al.: Yoga and attention: A systematic review

REFERENCES et al. Evaluation of attention and verbal memory in yoga practicing


pre‑adolescents: A cross‑sectional study. J Restor Med 2016;5:3‑13.
1. Ashcraft M. Cognition. 4th ed. New York: Prentice Hall; 2005. 18. Rezaei  M, Salarpor Kamarzard  T, Najafian Razavi  M. The effects of
2. Goldstein E. Sensation and perception. 7th ed. United States: Wadsworth. neuro feedback, yoga interventions on memory and cognitive activity
2007. in children with attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder: A randomized
controlled trial. Ann Appl Sports Sci 2018;6:17‑27.
3. Lazar SW, Kerr CE, Wasserman RH, Gray JR, Greve DN, Treadway MT,
et al. Meditation experience is associated with increased cortical thickness. 19. Mak C, Whittingham K, Cunnington R, Boyd RN. Effect of mindfulness
Neuroreport 2005;16:1893. yoga programme Mi yoga on attention, behaviour, and physical outcomes
in cerebral palsy: A randomized controlled trial. Dev Med Child Neurol
4. Linden W. Practicing of meditation by school children and their levels of
2018;60:922‑32.
field dependence‑independence, test anxiety, and reading achievement.
J Consult Clin Psychol 1973;41:139‑43. 20. Chou CC, Huang CJ. Effects of an 8‑week yoga program on sustained
attention and discrimination function in children with attention deficit
5. Knudsen EI. Fundamental components of attention. Annu Rev Neurosci
hyperactivity disorder. PeerJ 2017;5:e2883.
2007;30:57‑78.
6. Sethi  JK, Nagendra  HR, Sham Ganpat  T. Yoga improves attention 21. Nagaraj GP, Manjunatha SK, Eshwara KA. Effect of yoga on attention
and self‑esteem in underprivileged girl student. J Educ Health Promot concentration and cardio‑vascular endurance of secondary school
2013;2:55. volleyball players. Int J Physiol Nutr Phys Educ 2019;4:96‑7.
7. Pope HG Jr., Yurgelun‑Todd D. The residual cognitive effects of heavy 22. Schmalzl L, Powers C, Zanesco AP, Yetz N, Groessl EJ, Saron CD. The
marijuana use in college students. JAMA 1996;275:521‑7. effect of movement‑focused and breath‑focused yoga practice on stress
parameters and sustained attention: A randomized controlled pilot study.
8. Levin ED, Conners CK, Silva D, Hinton SC, Meck WH, March J, et al.
Conscious Cogn 2018;65:109‑25.
Transdermal nicotine effects on attention. Psychopharmacology (Berl)
1998;140:135‑41. 23. Joice PP, Manik KA, Sudhir PK. Role of yoga in attention, concentration,
and memory of medical students. Natl J Physiol Pharm pharmacol
9. Spencer TJ, Biederman J, Mick E. Attention‑deficit/hyperactivity disorder:
Diagnosis, lifespan, comorbidities, and neurobiology. J Pediatr Psychol 2018;8:1526‑8.
2007;32:631‑42. 24. Wimmer L, Bellingrath S, von Stockhausen L. Mindfulness training for
10. Valentine ER, Sweet PL. Meditation and attention: A comparison of the improving attention regulation in university students: Is it effective? And
effects of concentrative and mindfulness meditation on sustained attention. do yoga and homework matter? Front Psychol 2020;11:719.
Ment Health Relig Cult 1999;2:59‑70. 25. Ravikumar NG. Role of yoga in Concentration, Attention, and Memory
11. Sahasi G. A replicated study on the effects of yoga on cognitive functions. of B. Ed Student Teachers. Indian Yoga 2019;8:6.
Indian Psychol Rev 1984;27:33‑5. 26. Amemiya R, Takahashi G, Rakwal R, Kahata M, Isono K, Sakairi Y.
12. Uthaman  S, Uthaman  S. Impact of Yoga and meditation on cognitive Effects of yoga in a physical education course on attention control and
functions of students. J Soc Work Educ Pract 2017;2:53‑7. mental health among graduate students with high sensory processing
sensitivity. Cogent Psychology 2020;7:1.
13. Cohen SC, Harvey DJ, Shields RH, Shields GS, Rashedi RN, Tancredi DJ,
et al. The effects of yoga on attention, impulsivity and hyperactivity in 27. Jesintha AR. An impact of raja yoga meditation on perception and attention
pre‑school age children with ADHD symptoms. J  Dev Behav Pediatr among school girls. Journal of Information and Computational Science
JDBP 2018;39:200. 2020;10:3.
14. Jarraya S, Wagner M, Jarraya M, Engel FA. 12 weeks of kindergarten‑based 28. Saxena K, Verrico CD, Saxena J, Kurian S, Alexander S, Kahlon RS,
yoga practice increases visual attention, visual‑motor precision and et al. An evaluation of yoga and meditation to improve attention,
decreases behavior of inattention and hyperactivity in 5‑year‑old children. hyperactivity, and stress in high‑school students. J Altern Complement
Front Psychol 2019;10:796. Med 2020;26:701‑7.
15. Telles S, Gupta RK, Gandharva K, Vishwakarma B, Kala N, Balkrishna A. 29. Vhavle  SP, Rao  RM, Manjunath  NK. Comparison of yoga versus
Immediate effect of a yoga breathing practice on attention and anxiety in physical exercise on executive function, attention, and working memory
pre‑teen children. Children (Basel) 2019;6:84. in adolescent schoolchildren: A randomized controlled trial. Int J Yoga
16. Jois SN, D’Souza L, Moulya R. Beneficial effects of superbrain yoga on 2019;12:172‑3.
short‑term memory and selective attention of students. Indian J Tradit 30. Gothe NP, Kramer AF, McAuley E. Hatha yoga practice improves attention
Knowl 2017;16:0972‑5938. and processing speed in older adults: Results from an 8‑week randomized
17. Nilsoge D, Bagade A, Tumbigeremutt V, Kulkarni P, Rao SB, Arpitha M, control trial. J Altern Complement Med 2017;23:35‑40.

132 Yoga Mīmāṃsā | Volume 54 | Issue 2 | July-December 2022

You might also like