Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Djabourov 2017
Djabourov 2017
Introduction
Gelatin and collagen gels are usually compared and often confounded by non-
specialists. This comparison is justified because originally gelatin and collagen
are the same macromolecule, the same protein. In this paper, we shall make a
systematic parallel between the two types of solutions and gels and analyze
three different aspects: the mechanisms of gelation, the structure of the
networks and the rheological properties of the gels. We examine two classes of
collagen solutions: Type I collagen from vertebrates and from cuticle of deep
sea worms. Particular emphasis is put on the sol-gel transition, with the help
of different experimental approaches, combining, for gelatin gels, rheology and
transport phenomena through the gel network. The process of gelation is
analyzed in the context of the modern theories of percolation. Finally, the
influence of mechanical actions on the kinetics of gelation is briefly evoked.
191
192 Collagen and gelatin gels Vol. 30, Nos. 3 & 4
extensively heated, or when the native tissues are subjected to chemical and
thermal treatments, the hydrogen and covalent bonds that stabilize the collagen
helices are broken and the molecules adopt a disordered conformation. This
material is gelatin and is soluble in water at 40-45° C.
Table 1
(260 atm) and high temperatures (350° C) near hydrothermal vents. The
cuticle collagen is a giant flexible molecule whose length reaches 2.4 )lm in the
so-called Pompeii worms (Gaill and Hunt, 1991) (see Fig. 2) and 1.5 )lm in
the so-called tube worms (Gaill et al., 1991). In the native state, these
molecules do not form striated fibrils. Microfibrils are arranged in a liquid
crystalline-like structure. The fibrils are organized in a plywood structure
exhibiting a long range orientational order (Gaill, 1990).
The thermal denaturation of collagen individual rods is around 37° C for
the Type I collagen and 40° C for cuticle collagen from annelid worms, due to
a higher content of hydroxyproline (170 residues per mil) (Gaill et al., 1991).
Gelatin solutions
Gelatin solutions can be prepared at variable pHs and ionic strengths. The
important requirements are for the temperature to be above 30° C and for the
pH to be different from the isoelectric point, in order to screen the
interactions between charged groups. This can be achieved by either
modifying the pH or by adding salts to the solution. Gelatin solutions have
been investigated by dynamic light scattering (Heming et al., 1991), static LS
and small angle neutron scattering (SANS) (Pezron et al., 1991) at 45° C. The
individual gelatin coils are semi-flexible coils or worm-like chains with a radius
of gyration of the order of 300 nm and a persistence length of the order of
2 nm. In semi-dilute solutions (c ;?: 1 %), the coils overlap and interpenetrate
each other. The characteristic structural length in solution is then the mesh-
Vol. 30, Nos. 3 & 4 Collagen and gelatin gels 195
size or the correlation length between different chains. The mesh size
decreases with greater concentration, varying between 7 to 3.5 nm when the
concentration increases from 1 to 5%, for instance. The scattering spectra of
a
A
-
E
c lag phase growth plateau
-
,..
o:t
C')
Q)
u
c
co
....
.0
oen
.0
«
o 30 60 time (min)
b
A (314 nm)
Reference
T=25 °C
1=0.23
1 _ _ " c=0.05
H=7.1
/' .......---'~--.,;...;;..;;...--I
/
/
0.5 /
/
/
/
b
o
o 30 60 time (min)
l'1g. 3. Kinetics of aggregation of Type I collagen molecules: 3a)
the increase of absorbance reveals the different stages of the
process. During the lag phase the primary aggregates are formed,
the growth step corresponds to the lateral association of the sub-
units and the plateau indicates the end of the process. 3b) The
effect of various parameters (pH, temperature, ionic strength and
concentration), on the kinetics of aggregation is shown.
196 Collagen and gelatin gels Vol. 30, Nos. 3 Be 4
gelatin solutions follow the scaling laws established for synthetic linear
polymers in solution in good solvents (De Gennes, 1985).
Gel Formation
Gelation of collagen or gelatin solutions is achieved by modifying the
thermodynamic conditions. Collagen gelation deals with the process of
aggregation and fibril formation in vitro, which is induced by changes of ionic
strength, pH and temperature. Numerous studies have been devoted to the
mechanisms of fibril formation, aimed at elucidating the process of
fibrillogenesis in the extracellular matrices, especially in its early stages.
Aggregation of collagen molecules in solution can be monitored by changes in
turbidity. Typical plots of the kinetics aggregation of Type I collagen are
shown (Herbage et al., 1990) in Figs. 3a and 3b. The increase in absorbance
(at A = 314 nm) proceeds in three distinct steps: a) a lag phase, during which
no modifications in absorbance can be detected and the primary aggregates,
dimers and trimers of collagen molecules, are nucleated;
b) microfibrillar aggregation starts with the lateral aggregation of sub-units;
c) finally, an equilibrium is reached that corresponds to a maximum plateau of
absorbance. Its amplitude is related to the size of the largest fibrils. The effect
of various parameters, such as pH, temperature, concentration, and ionic
strength on the kinetics of gelation, is schematically shown in Fig. 3b. The
enthalpy change accompanying the self-assembling process of collagen is
positive, ranging between 50 and 120 kcal/mole of collagen (Na et al., 1989)
when the gelation temperature is raised from 20 to 28° C. The enthalpy change
is driven by the breaking of hydrogen bonds within the shell of water molecules
surrounding the collagen rods. This process requires a net positive change in
entropy which accompanies the loss of order of the water molecules in the
shell. The same conditions are required for gelation of the cuticle collagen of
annelid worms, although no systematic investigation of these parameters has
been done so far.
Gelation of gelatin solutions results from a temperature variation, i.e.,
cooling solutions below 30° C, provided that they are concentrated enough to
be in the semi-dilute range. The basic mechanism of gelation is related to the
reverse coil-to-helix transition during which the helices that are created are
similar to the collagen triple-helix. The best method to monitor the coil-helix
transition in gelatin solutions is the measurements of the optical rotation which
can be directly converted into the helix amount of the gelatin strands, X, or the
fraction of residues in the left-handed conformation (Djabourov et al., 1988a).
Such measurements are shown in Figs. 4a and 4b. First, the increase of the
helix amount vs. time in a linear scale is plotted in Fig. 4a over periods of more
than 100 hours. Contrary to the collagen gelation, no lag phase is observed.
The temperature affects the kinetics in the opposite way: the lower the
temperature, the higher the rate of helix formation. In Fig. 4b, the kinetics are
plotted on a logarithmic time scale. One can see, then, that the helix amount
does not reach a constant value; thus, no equilibrium is reached. After a rapid
increase, the subsequent growth of the helices proceeds with a logarithmic time
dependence over periods of hundreds or thousands of hours! Thus, gelatin
gels are not in equilibrium.
As it appears in the temperature dependence of tl1e kinetics, the gelatin
gelation has an enthalpy change that is negative. The process of triple-helix
formation is analogous to a crystallization transition, with a nucleation step that
is favored when the transition takes place far below the equilibrium melting
temperature, in the so-called supercooled state for a pure liquid or a polymer
Vol. 30, Nos. 3 & 4 Collagen and gelatin gels 197
a
x
0.8
0.6 a
b
0.4
o ~ _____ __
~ ~ __ ___
~ ~~ __ ~ __ ~ __ ~ __ ~ ____ ~ __ ~~
o 20 40 60 80 100
tlme(hours)
b
,r-------~--------~--------~--------~------_.
x
.8
.6
.4
.2
1 10 10 2 10 3
tlme(hours)
Fig. 4. Kinetics of gelation of gelatin gels: 4a) The increase of the
optical rotation of the solutions can be related to the amount of
helices created, X. Time is given in a linear scale up to 120 hrs.
The different curves correspond to the following temperatures: a)
T = 10° C; b) T = 20° C; c) T = 26° C; d) T = 28° C. 4b) The
same data plotted vs. time in a logarithmic scale. The helix
amount increases slowly with time; no limit appears after 1000
hrs. The continuous and the dotted lines correspond to the
phenomenological analysis proposed by Djabourov et al. (1988a).
198 CoUagen and gelatin gels Vol. 30, Nos. 3 Be 4
Collagen Gels
Replicas of Type I collagen gels are shown in Fig. 5. The replicas were
obtained by a quick freezing, deep etching and rotary replication method
(Favard et al., 1989) and observed by TEM. The gel was formed in vitro from a
solution with 5 mg/ml concentration. Gelation was obtained by exposure'to
concentrated ammonia vapors (Bouligand et al., 1985). The micrograph
shows a network that contains two types of fibrils: the staggered arrangements
of collagen fibrils with a periodicity comparable to the stained micrographs
and with various diameters of the order of 50 to 500 nm. The fibrils are easily
recognized at the unscraped surface of the quickly frozen gels, as shown in Fig.
5a. These fibrils coexist with randomly oriented microfilaments which might
either be individual rods or aggregates of a small number of rods. An enlarged
detail from the network for the frozen sample, whose surface was scraped
before etching and shadowing, is shown in Fig. 5b.
A gel prepared from cuticle collagen of annelid worms is shown in Fig. 6.
The supramolecular structure has a more disordered aspect, with a mesh size
larger than in the previous example. Periodic arrangements and large
aggregates of collagen rods do not appear in this network.
Gelatin Gels
The gelatin gel network prepared by the same technique is shown in Fig. 7 for
a gel with a concentration of 2%. It is a fine and dense entangled network,
where the thin filaments are the triple-helices covered by the Pt-C coating.
Image analysis allows us to derive the total amount of triple-helices per unit
volume of the solution. The order of magnitude is 1500 Jlm/ Jlm 3 for a 2%
concentration. Besides the triple helical structure apparent on the
micrographs, it is known that a substantial fraction of the strands subsists in the
coil conformation (about 50%), but cannot be made visible on the
micrographs. because the thickness of the strands is below the resolution of the
TEM technique (about 1 nm).
Rheology of the Sol-Gel Transition
The sol-gel transition has been the subject of numerous studies during the last
decade that have been stimulated by modern ideas based on the analogy
between gelation and percolation, first proposed by P.-G. De Gennes and D.
Stauffer (see De Gennes, 1985, for instance). Interpretation of the gelation
processes of model systems (essentially covalent networks created through a
polymerization reaction) have been supported by theoretical studies and
accompanied by numerical simulations. Other experimental studies dealt with
Vol. 30, Nos. 3 & 4 Collagen and gelatin gels 199
a
random orientations. The dependence of the elastic modulus with the protein
concentration should then be investigated (Sinclair et aI., 1983). There is,
however, a serious limitation to the description appearing on the micrographs:
for the Type I collagen gel, the structure obviously contains both randomly
oriented rods and large fibrils. The modulus of such a binary network is more
complex to analyze. Gels of the cuticle collagen of annelid worms had a more
uniform distribution of fibrils, so an investigation of the concentration
dependence of their elastic moduli should be relevant to this type of
interpretation.
With the sol-gel transition of gelatin, besides rheology, another experiment can
be used to follow the kinetics precisely without disturbing the process. This is
DLS in solutions cont.aining latex spheres (of a diameter <I> = 100 nm) that act
as markers. The mean square displacement. of the latex spheres, <r2>, t.hrough
the solution at different moments in the course of gelation, was followed. This
is summarized in Fig. 9. As long as the solution is f1uid (sol state), the latex
spheres diffuse, undertaking brownian movements (the mean square
displacement increases linearly with the correlation time, 't), the long time
diffusion coefficients (slope of <r2> vs. 't, in the limit of large 't values) being
related to the macroscopic viscosity of the solution . As soon as a gel is formed,
with a network mesh size of the order of the diameter of the latex spheres, the
local diffusion coefficients (slope of <r2> vs. 't, in the limit of small 't) begin to
increase. This effect is due to an elastic coupling between the spheres and the
network. No diffusion at long distances is observed. The movements of the
particles are confined, as shown in Fig. 9, anc! the mean square displacements
202 Collagen and gelatin gels Vol. 30, Nos. 3 & 4
•o
o
C
• T=24°C
5 oT=25°C
o aT= 26°C
• T= 26'5°C
4 • T= 27°C
• T-27·5°C
o
• T. 280C
gel point
!a-:~
O'------~~~~~------~------~----~
X (0/0)
o 5 10 15 20
2,5
< r2> (10- 2 ~m2)
_e_ 6 min.
1,5 {
sol -0- 24 min.
I I I I I I t (IlS)
8000 10000 12000 14000 16000 18000
Fig. 9. Mean square displacement of latex spheres during gelatin
gel formation. The first two measurements are in the sol state,
when the spheres undertake a brownian motion, the last two
measurements are in the gel state when the particles are trapped.
Concentration 4.7%. Temperature of gelation T = 26° C.
50 l I
I viscosity (Pa s) I i
I
I I
I
I
I
I
a b(!
,
c I
I
J
I
!
i
,i I
i I
!
j I
,I
,I
i
I
I
I
I
I
/
I
/
I
,I
.'
~ /
O~---- __----~----~=--- ----~-
- ____ ----~----__----~----____----T-----~
Conclusion
This paper aims to clarify the differences between collagen and gelatin gels.
The modern ideas on gelation and percolation are used to describe the sol-gel
transition of gelatin solutions and many other complex systems. These theories
can predict the changes of the rheological properties of collagen solutions
under suitable conditions for gelation, in relation to their structure and
composition. More experimental work is expected in this area.
References
BOULIGAND, Y., DENEFLE, J. P., LECHAIRE, J. P., and MAILLARD,
M. (1985). Twisted architectures in cell free assembled collagen gels:
study of collagen substrates used for cultures. Biol. Cell 54, 143-162.
DE GENNES P. G. (1985). Scaling Concepts in Polymer Physics. 2d Ed.,
Cornell Univ. Press, Ithaca, New York, 324 pp.
DjABOUROV, M., LEBLOND, j., and PAPON, P. (1988a). Gelation
of aqueous gelatin solutions I: Structural investigation. J. Phys.
(France) 49,319-332.
DjABOUROV, M., LEBLOND, J., and PAPON, P. (1988b). Gelation
of aqueous gelatin solutions II: Rheology of the sol-gel transition. J.
Phys. (France) 49, 333-343.
DjABOUROV, M. (1991). Percolation and gelation of complex
systems. In: The Living Cell in Four Dirnensions. AlP Conf. Proc. 226,
Paillotin G. Ed., AlP, New York, pp. 488-507.
FAVARD, P., LECHAIRE, j. P., MAILLARD, M., FAVARD, N.,
DjABOUROV, M., and LEBLOND, J. (1989). A technique of
labelling the sample surface for quick-freeze, deep-etch rotary
replication electron microscopy: Application to the study of gelatin gel
structure. Biol. Cell 67, 201-207.
FORGACS, G., NEWMAN, S. A., OBUKHOV, S. P., BIRK, D. E.
(1991). Phase transi tion and morphogenesis in a model biological
system. Phys. Rev. Lett. 67, 2399-2402.
GAILL, F. (1990). Geometry of biological interfaces: The collagen
network. J. Phys. 23, 169-182.
GAILL, F. and HUNT, S. (1991). The biology of annelid worms from
high temperature hydrothermal vent regions. Rev. Aquat. Sci. 4, 107-
137.
GAILL, F., WIEDEMAN, A., MANN, K., KHUN, K., TIMPL, R., and
ENGEL, j. (1991). Characterization of two forms of collagen from
worms collected at deep sea level. J. Mol. Biol. 221, 209-223.
HERBAGE, D., WILLEMS, R., HERBAGE, B., and PAjEAN, C.
(1990). Etude des interactions entre collagenes et differents
phlebotoniques. Phlebologie 43,743-752.
HERNING, T., DjABOUROV, M., LEBLOND, J., and TAKERKART,
G. (1991). Conformation of gelatin chains in aqueous solutions II: A
quasi-elastic light scattering study. Polyrn. 32, 3211-3217.
NA, G. C. (1989). Monomer and oligomer of Type I collagen:
Molecular properties and fibril assembly. Biochern. 28,7161-7167.
Vol. 30, Nos. 3 &: 4 Collagen and gelatin gels 205
This paper was delivered at the 8th Congress of Biorheology, Yokohama, 1992, at the
Symposium on the Rheology of Biopolymer GeL5.