Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 51

JMJ MARIST BROTHERS

NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY


INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

THE LIFE OF MOBILE LEGENDS GAMERS

A Qualitative Research Paper

Presented to the Faculty of Senior High School Department

Notre Dame of Marbel University

Koronadal City, South Cotabato

In Partial Fulfilment of the Requirements

In Practical Research I

Pinky Jocelle Caluya

Francis James Sunga

Honey Barcenilla

Arissa Jean Enriquez

Grade 11-STEM St. Gabriel

March 2020
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

ABSTRACT

Mobile legends is created by China developer Moonton Technology Co.ltd

and Shanghai Mulong Network and Technology Co.ltd. This game is trendy

because of its reputation and its ongoing popularity In online games especially

the mobile legend the player can interact with the other player to communicate or

to give ideas. They can also invite others they want to play with or if they want to

bond together with their group of friends. As we observe in our modern

generation, some people today are more inclined to depend their own

entertainment to video games and sitting and staring in front of a screen for

extended periods of time. This study shows how this game affects Senior High

School Students of Notre Dame of Marbel University- IBED. Firstly, the physical

and psychological effects both positive and negative. Second, the personal

reasons of playing it, and lastly, the effects to their love ones. There was a total

of 10 (ten) participants in the study and thematic analysis was used in the

analysis of the data gathered afterwards. This research is significant to students,

teachers, parents and future researchers. It would enlighten them how Mobile

Legends affects a person’s life and answers some questions in their mind

regarding on this topic.

i
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

First and foremost, praises and thanks to the God, the Almighty, for all the

blessings he had bestowed upon us. We thank Him for being with us throughout

this research. He knows how tired and grateful we are that we had finished this

study successfully. We are honored to have this opportunity to create a research

paper with this specific topic.

This work would not have been possible without the support and teachings

from our research teacher, Ms. Juliet Arellano, the one guided us to create our

research papers properly and accurately throughout the entire semester. We are

grateful to all of those with whom we had the pleasure to participate during this

practical research, our participants who whole heartedly contributed in our

research. It is because of them why we had completed this study with insightful

ideas and information that would help our society.

ii
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page No.

Abstract i

Acknowledgment ii

Table of Contents iii

List of figures v

INTRODUCTION

BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY 1

- Conceptual Framework 3

REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE 4-7

- Physical Health Issues 4

- Problems to Personal Relationships 5

- Relieving Stress 6

- Psychological Effects and Problems 7

RESEARCH QUESTIONS 8

SIGNIFICANCE OF THE STUDY 9

DEFENITION OF TERMS 10

METHODOLOGY

Locale of the Study 12

Participants of the Study 13

Sampling Design 13

iii
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

Research Instrument 13

Data Collection Procedure 14

Data Analysis 14

Ethical Consideration 14

FINDINGS & DISCUSSIONS

Themes 15

Problems encountered 16

Scope and Limitation 17

Conclusion 17

Recommendation 18

REFERENCES 19-20

APPENDICES

LIST OF APPENDICES

Appendix A Summary of Data Analysis Scheme 21

Appendix B Transcription of Data 22-29

Appendix C Data Set Analysis 30-39

Appendix E Letter of Request to Conduct Research 40

Appendix F Letter of Consent 41

Appendix H Curriculum Vitae 42-45

iv
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

LIST OF FIGURES

Figure 1. Conceptual Framework (Literature Map) 3

Figure 2 Research Design Paradigm 11

Figure 3 Map of the Locale 12

v
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

INTRODUCTION

Background of the study

There are a lot of ways to get ourselves entertained. We can be immersed

through music, sports or in any other way. Nowadays, technology really brought

humanity where it is right now by its upgrades, new innovations and how it

contributes to our environment. One of its inventions was the mobile games. A

mobile game has been a hit since 1994 where a game called Tetris has been

known and played by many. After that game, another has been launched

successfully by Nokia and a line of mobile games follows to that.

Though a mobile game has been stereotyped to be irrelevant and a waste

of time, believe it or not, it also has its perks in building up strategically skills and

analytical thinking of a gamer. Moreover, one aspect of many multiplayer games

is team work where the player has to work together with their team. In our

generation, the game that has been a trend since 2016 and until now was

Moontoon’s Mobile Legends: Bang Bang and became the first-choice gamers to

play.

1
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

Mobile legends is created by China developer Moonton Technology Co.ltd

and Shanghai Mulong Network and Technology Co.ltd. The Mobile Legends:

Bang Bang is a game designed only for phone.

In online games especially the mobile legend the player can interact with

the other player to communicate or to give ideas. They can also invite others they

want to play with or if they want to bond together with their group of friends.

Mobile legends is a popular 5v5 Multiplayer Online Battle Arena (MOBA)

that was originally designed for mobile phones. It’s reminiscent of games like

DOTA but in a mobile format and it is why it’s a hit for gamers. As we observe in

our modern generation, some people today are more inclined to depend their

own entertainment to video games. As time passes by, the longer the game

exists, the more players are becoming interested on the game. It is also

becoming a trend because of its reputation and its ongoing popularity to the point

that they included it in an international event like the Southeast Asian Games,

including the amount of promotion the game gets.

The reason why we decided to undertake this specific topic is because the

game Mobile legends is a very popular and in demand game from teenagers to

adults since the year 2016. Its popularity sky rocketed when it was included in an

international game. We wanted to know why they decided to play this game more

than the other games that are also popular. We wanted to dig deeper the surface

2
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

of their intentions of playing this game and how it affected them while playing it

and lastly, how it affected their personal relationships.

Conceptual Framework

The life of a Mobile Legends gamer

Psychological and physical health effects Positive and negative

Coping with stress and problems

Personal relationships of students

Figure 1. Conceptual Framework

The conceptual framework illustrates the study of the researchers entitled

“The Life of Mobile Legends Gamers” and that it affects the Grade 11 STEM

students of NDMU-IBED. Firstly, the physical and psychological health effects to

gamers and that includes its positive and negative effects. Secondly, it illustrates

that playing Mobile Legends is also a way to cope with stress and problems.

Lastly, this shows that gaming affects a gamer’s personal relationship like family,

friends, etc.

3
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

Review of Related Literature

Physical Health Issues

Gaming has effects to health, especially when a gamer is doing it in a long

period of time. According to Juventus Vox (2018), their study shows that there

are positive and negative effects in playing mobile games like playing mobile

legends to the behavior and health of students. Its positive effects includes

improving brain functions and educating gamers while it still has its cons and that

is the distraction while performing another important activity, affecting social

interaction, sleep problems and loss of productivity. In addition, this worldwide

game is arguably one of the most popular mobile games currently being played.

MOBA has positive effects to a person. However, using too much of this

can cause a lot of problems to a person’s health who chose to play than to

prioritize his health. In terms of health, According to Jannell Obrero (2019) Lots

of individuals, particularly in Southeast Asia, got addicted to this online game

easily and some also spends not just their time but also their money to buy

“diamonds” for a hero’s skin and lucky spins. Kids or even oldies above know

how to play this game.

A game like Mobile Legends has its dangers when playing overboard as

the game became really addictive to some. According to Tiffany Reyes (2019)

gamers skips their meals in order to plat the game. There are also risks for

4
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

childhood obesity, as well as headaches, backaches, eye-strain, and many other

conditions brought by sitting in front of a computer or over a mobile phone for

extended periods of time. Moreover, the gamer’s attention is always on their

games, they may cease to be present for their families and friends and given by

that fact, it also affects personal relationships. They may not hold conversations

with them, or may entirely skip events altogether just to play with their games.

Not only that, those who are addicted to video games may fail to perform well.

Problems to Personal Relationships

Gaming does bring problems to personal relationships. According to Kate

Borbon (2019), their research was to find married couples think about what

issues they think that they would need to be addressed early on in a marriage,

before they become bigger problems. Many responded by citing communication,

finances, inequity in the distribution of housework, and even too much playing

of Mobile Legends. There are issues at hand that married couples are facing,

such as miscommunication, not having enough time household management and

more.

In other else’s perspective, video games can harm relationships beyond

what we see as it is. According to Julia Austin (2018) video games have a very

peculiar nature as they can let a gamer escape from reality far more than most

other activities that are available at the touch of a button. Julia Austin noticed

5
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

how gamers join online forums and communities, having live conversations

through their headsets with other gamers.

In addition, as gamers communicate to other gamers, they often forget about

their partner who led to lack of communication and time for each other.

Relieving Stress

The game Mobile legends is also considered as a stress reliever.

Regarding of the gained attention of the game from people, According to Honey

Orio- Escullar (2019), an actress, Nadine Lustre was also into playing mobile

legends. She was the newest ambassador of Montoon’s Mobile Legends: Bang

Bang (MLBB) LIGA2 Kontrabida. It is a street battle event that brings non-

professional players and avid fans of the game together to compete for amazing

prizes and the opportunity to be recognized as the best non-pro team in the

country. The first Liga was held last 2018 with hundreds of squads signing up to

battle each other. Furthermore, she likes how the mobile game really relieved her

stress but she had to stop because it’s getting really addictive and it is also her

way to escape reality.

Moontoon’s Mobile Legendes: Bang Bang was being played due to

entertainment. Not only that, According to Iowa State University (2018), some

play the game for entertainment or for the competition, while others play as a

way to cope with stress or anxiety. Based on their study, an English professor

6
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

who gamed to cope with work-related stress, relationship issues and day-to-day

setbacks. The researchers write that the gamer’s experience illustrates video

game addiction is more than prolonged play. Moreover, the researchers found

that it is a type of coping strategy for anxiety and stress relief.

Based from the article of Human Factors and Ergonomics Society (2017)

those who took a silent rest break reported that they felt less engaged with work

and experienced worry as a result, whereas those who participated in the guided

relaxation activity saw reductions in negative affect and distress. Only the video

game players reported that they felt better after taking the break.

Psychological Effects and Problems

The risk of cell phone addiction is a social and psychological problem

which has been proposed by psychologists, psychiatrists, and educational

supervisors. Kerman University of Medical Sciences (2014) based on their

research through the student in a university in Iran, many mobile phone addicts

are people with low self-esteem and poor social relationships; thus, they think

they should be in constant contact with others. Mobile phone silence can lead to

anxiety, irritability, sleep disturbances, shaking, insomnia, and digestive

problems. From the perspective of Thomee et al. problematic and overuse of

mobile phones is associated with anxiety, insomnia, depression, psychological

distress, and unhealthy lifestyle. The emotional attachment to mobile phones for

7
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

their users is in a way that makes them believe they cannot live without a cell

phone. Researches have presented the negative impact of excessive use of

mobile phones on physical and mental health of students.

A blogger also shared his thoughts about mobile gaming. Jawara Makalah

(2018) stated that a game is actually an application made with the aim to reduce

the level of stress or anxiety level due to activities or daily activities that are done

by humankind though Jawara also that that it was the opposite since that based

from his observations, the game even add to the problem at the end of its

influence. So it can be said that the game is not reducing the burden of the

human mind but added to the problem for humans themselves

Research Questions

This study aims to know how playing Mobile Legends affect Senior High

School Students of Notre Dame of Marbel University- IBED. Specifically, it

answered the following:

1. What are the physical and psychological effects of playing Mobile Legends

to students?

2. What is their main purpose of playing Mobile Legends?

3. What are the effects of playing Mobile Legends to personal relationships?

(i.e. Family, friends and etc.)

8
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

Significance of the Study

The Significance of the study provides the benefits and the beneficiaries of

the study to any aspect of the society and how it can make advantage of the

research.

STUDENTS. The results of the study will help the students to be aware of

its positive and negative effects on their psychological and physical health and to

control themselves to play to be able to manage their time wisely.

PARENTS. This study is to confirm and clarify the parents about the

effects of gaming and how it affected their children. It will also help them gain

knowledge about the advantages and disadvantages of playing mobile games.

TEACHERS. The research can help teachers to deeper understand how

playing mobile games are being used to cope with stress and problems and not

to be used as a way to procrastinate only. It also helps them to consider and

manage students who have gaming addiction problem.

FUTURE RESEARCHERS. This study can provide other perspectives and

thoughts relating on the topic. This can also help the future researchers figure out

components and different contents that they will soon put on their paper.

9
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

Definition of terms

The definition of terms provides other terminologies of the study to be

clearly defined.

Anxiety- It's a feeling of fear or apprehension about what's to come.

Escapism- the avoidance of reality by absorption of the mind in entertainment or

in an imaginative situation

Overboard- to do something too much

Personal relationship- refer to close connections between people, formed by

emotional bonds and interactions.

Psychological- related to the mental and emotional state of a person.

Risk- a situation involving exposure to danger.

Stereotype- over-generalized belief about a particular matter.

10
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

METHODOLOGY

Research design

This study has a qualitative research design wherein a data gathering tool

was used to gather data from the participants, and the result will be analyzed. An

interview schedule were used a set of structured questions that have been

prepared, to serve as a guide for the researcher’s interview for data gathering.

The Problem Data Sources Data Collection Data Analysis

The Life of NDMU-IBED Interview Data


Mobile Legends SHS STEM (Audio- Recorded) Transcription
Gamers STUDENTs

Data
Translation

Thematic
Analysis

Drawn Theme

Figure 2. Research Design

Locale of the study

11
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

The study was conducted in the a private University located in Brgy. Sto. Niño,

City of Koronadal, South Cotabato, the Notre Dame of Marbel University –

Integrated Basic Education, Senior High school building.

It is the first high school opened in South Cotabato and it is also a Green

University that aims to be claimed and healthy environment and it has a total of

maximum of 1800 Senior High School students in South Cotabato.

Figure 3. Locale of the Study

Participants of the study

12
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

The researchers will have selected participants for the study from the

Grade 11 STEM students. The required participants of this study should be a

student from Notre Dame of Marbel University- IBED. They were chosen based

on an inclusion criteria, such as : 1) Gamers of the game “Mobile Legends”, 2)

Their grade level which is grade 11 Senior High school students of Notre Dame

of Marbel University, 3) the strand of the participant is STEM and lastly if the

participants are 4) Willing to be interviewed.

Sampling design

The study used a sampling technique were selected students will become

the respondents of the interview with the researchers.

Research instrument

The research instrument that was used in this study was the interview

schedule that was constructed by the researchers. The questions will be based

on the topic on how playing Mobile Legends affects their personal relationships,

psychological and physical health and how it helps the participants cope with

their stress and problems. A recorder was being used during the interview as a

documentation of the study.

Data collection
13
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

The researchers made a consent letter or form for the participants and requested

approval through a formal letter to the person authority. The researchers will ask

permission to the participant with the letter consent for the in-depth interview and

asked permission to used voice recorder and we conducted a face-to-face

interview with the participants at a time and the researchers will to present the

purpose of the study and asked questions that was prepared.

Data analysis

The researchers will analyze the gathered data and follow all the data

collecting procedures. The data collected will be checked if the questions and

answers are related to the topic. All responses from the voice recorder that was

used in the interview will be transcribed to clarify the responses of the

participants.

Ethical consideration

We followed an interview protocol before conducting the interviews.

Hence, an informed consent was sought from each participant of the study with a

letter containing the rights of the participants to accept or refuse to be

interviewed. It also expressed that their identity will be kept in private and all

responses that will be used for academic purpose only shall be treated with

utmost confidentiality.

FINDINGS AND DISCUSSIONS


14
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

Themes

THE THOUGHTS OF GRADE 11 STEM STUDENTS TOWARDS PLAYING

MOBILE LEGENDS

The results indicate that playing Mobile Legends to relieve stress and to

cope with it. According to Iowa State University (2018), a student playing video

games is a way to cope with stress or anxiety. Playing Mobile Legends also

became escapism to problems and reality. Based on the study of Orio- Escullar

(2019), gamers play Mobile Legends to escape reality like the actress, Nadine

Lustre and like her, respondents also has the same experience.

The data contributes a clearer understanding of the effects on social

interactions and to personal relationships when gaming. Julia Austin (2018)

stated that video games have a very peculiar nature as they can let a gamer

escape from reality far more than most other activities that are available at the

touch of a button and stated that having live conversations through their

headsets, gamers communicate to other gamers, they often forget about their

partner who led to lack of communication and time for each other. Based on the

answers of our respondents, though it helped improve their socializing skills with

others, it also causes the lack of communication between the gamers and their

15
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

personal relationships. In addition, a respondent also mentioned that Mobile

Legends is an addictive game.

The respondents also shared their insights about how it’s fun and

entertaining playing Mobile Legends and how it kills time when they have their

vacant time. Regardless of how Mobile Legends have helped them

psychologically, it also has its negative effects. The respondents’ stated that

gaming doesn’t affect them that much psychologically though physically, some

respondents don’t have the time to be physically fit and to have enough amount

of sleep. According to Juventus Vox (2018), gaming affects social interaction,

sleep problems, and loss of productivity.

Problems encountered

Research, by its nature, is really a challenging task that requires depth

knowledge of the topic or the subject matter that has been chosen, planning, and

hard work in creating this research into completion. The researchers had difficulty

in finding specialized and related references for the topic that was chosen to

study. It requires time and critical thinking to decide whether the articles that we

have found will support our study.

16
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

Scope and limitation of the study

The study will be conducted at one of the schools in the city of Koronadal,

namely, Notre Dame of Marbel University-IBED. This study focuses on the

effects of playing Mobile Legends to students, specifically the psychological and

physical effects, and benefits to student gamers and also how it affects their

personal relationships. In finding participants,


16 the researchers have a criterion for

looking a participant to provide more information about his or her thoughts about

the study. The researchers only used an audio- recorder and the questions from

the interview schedule that was validated through a permission letter. This study

is limited to the participants of the study excluding the other groups and people.

Conclusions

Based from the findings of the study the following conclusions were done:

1. Due to gaming, it can also be addictive and results not just positive, but

also negative effects to a person.

2. it does cause sleep problems, it causes the body to become fatter and

unhealthy due to staying up all night and doesn’t have the time to be

physically fit.

3. Gaming can reduce and relieve stress and can make a person in a calm

state.

4. It can be escapism to problems and reality for people

17
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

5. Playing Mobile Legends affects social interaction by communicating

through the game but its con is the time it can consume that also causes

lack of time for their love ones.

Recommendations

Comprehensive findings the researchers would like to recommend are the

following:

1. Playing Mobile Legends must be played must be limitedly and in an

appropriate event or schedule.

2. Planning for screen time actually helps. It is when or when a person

should play and gaming must be done moderately, especially when it

comes to addictive game like Mobile Legends.

3. Know their priorities to avoid problems.

4. Be knowledgeable about the effects of gaming especially when it is played

for extended period of time.

18
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

References

Vox, J. (2018). Is Mobile Legends good? Retrieved January 09, 2020 from

https://www.sunstar.com.ph/article/1803509

Orio- Escular, H. (2019). How Nadine copes with stress. Retrieved January 09,

2020 from

https://www.google.com.ph/amp/s/www.philstar.com/entertainment/2019/

10/07/1957879/how-nadine-copes-stress/amp

Iowa State University (2018). Playing video games to cope with anxiety may

increase the risk for addiction. Retrieved January 09, 2020 from

https://www.google.com.ph/amp/s/medicalxpress.com/news/2018-10-

video-games-cope-anxiety-addiction.amp

Borbon, K. (2019). Quality time vs. Mobile Legends: 7 issues married couples

need to work on now/ Retrieved January 09, 2020 from

https://www.smartparenting.com.ph/life/love-relationships/married-couple-

issues-address-early-a00286-20190525-lfrm

Obrero, J. (2019). The effects of Mobile Legends. Retrieved January 09, 2020

from https://sagisag.com/article/413/Entertainment/The-Effects-of-Mobile-

Legends-

19
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

Babadi, A, et al. (2014). The relationship between mental health and addiction to

mobile phones among university students of Sharhkekord, Iran. Retrieved

January 09, 2020 from https://europepmc.org/article/PMC/4354213

Human Factors and Ergonomics Society (2017). Feeling stressed during

Monday? Playing video games may help. Retrieved January 09, 2020

from https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2017/07/170725100704.htm

Markalah, J. (2018). The influence of game Mobile Legends addiction to

children’s psychology and mental. Retrieved January 09, 2020 from

https://steemit.com/writing/@fajarharapan/the-influence-of-game-mobile-

legends-addiction-to-childrens-psychology-and-mental-3d665ea2ca443

Austin, J. (2018). How video games harm relationships more than you think.

Retrieved January 09, 2020 from https://madamenoire.com/1014333/how-

video-games-harm-relationships-more-than-you-think/

Reyes, T, (2019). Mobile Legend addiction: how excessive gaming damages

you. Retrieved January 09, 2020 from

http://bridgesofhope.com.ph/index.php/mobile-legends-addiction-

excessive-gaming-damages/

20
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

APPENDICES

Apendix A

Summary of Data Analysis Scheme

Statement of the
Data Sets Sources of Method of Data
Problem (Research Data Collection Data analysis
technique
Objectives)
1.What are the Participant’s - 10 senior high In depth Constant
physical and experiences in school Honor interview Comparison
psychological effects playing Mobile students of Thematic
of playing Mobile Legends NDMU-IBED
Legends to students?

2.What is their main Participant’s - 10 senior high In depth Constant


purpose of playing personal school Honor interview Comparison
Mobile Legends? reasons of students of Thematic
playing Mobile NDMU-IBED
Legends
3. What are the Participant’s - 10 senior high In depth Constant
effects of playing experiences school Honor interview Comparison
Mobile Legends to with personal students of Thematic
personal relationships NDMU-IBED
relationships?
(i.e. Family, friends
and etc.)

21
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

Appendix B

Transcription of Data

Participant 1

I: How does the game Mobile Legends affect you psychologically and physically?

P1: For me, Mobile Legends affect me psychologically, uhm… okay it’s for fun

and at the same time it entertains me. Uhm… physically, yun lang yung ano kasi

medyo parati ka ng nag pupuyat at tsaka hindi maganda sa katawan.

I: Why do you play Mobile Legends?

P1: I play Mobile Legends because since I was a kid, mahilig na talaga ako sa

games.

I: How does Mobile Legends affect your personal relationships? (i.e. family and

friends)

P1: For family, I think di parin sila pabor na mahilig ako mag Mobile Legends and

sa friends, it’s okay because kasi nakakasabay naman sila dahil naglalaro din

sila.

Participant 2

I: How does the game Mobile Legends affect you psychologically and

physically?

P2: it does affect me psychologically by being mean to others and it affects me

physically by not exercising

22
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

I: Why do you play mobile legends?

P2: To have fun and to communicate with others.

I: How does Mobile Legends affect your personal relationships? (i.e. family and

friends)

P2: It affects my personal relationships with my friends in a good way because

we can play with each other and have fun but in my family its…aaahhh… it does

affect my family bad way because I don’t have lot of time to spend in, basta sa

kanila.

Participant 3

I: How does the game Mobile Legends affect you psychologically and physically?

P3: For me, I think that this game uhm… actually helps me uhm… heal uhm… it

often distracts me from my real life problems and uhm… physically I think that

uhm… I think it has uhm… a big uhm… what do you call this uhm… effect on me

because usually when I play Mobile Legends I stay up late and it causes me to

change my uhm… body clock so I don’t usually get much sleep.

I: Why do you play Mobile Legends?

P3: Uhm… I play Mobile Legends because at that time uhm… it was very famous

and I want to be in trend so I tried playing it and I played it a lot of times because

it’s very amusing and yeah like what I said it distracts me from my real life

problems.

I: How does Mobile Legends affect your personal relationships? (i.e. family and

friends)

23
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

P3: Uhm… I think uhm… it doesn’t really have uhm… an effect because I only

play on my free times when there, I have no company around and uhm… when

I’m alone.

I: okay, thank you

Participant 4

I: How does the game Mobile Legends affect you psychologically and physically?

P4: Uhm… ano maka adik gid siya kay parang stress reliever mo na siya amuna

ang mga tawag sina amuna ang way mo nalang para pang kwan mo sang stress.

I: Why do you play Mobile Legends?

P4: To ano ng... kung lalo na pag stress ko gahampang gid ko para madula

bisan gamay lang.

I: How does Mobile Legends affect your personal relationships? (i.e. family and

friends)

P4: Uhm ano ng hindi gid ko maistorbo pag ako ang gahampang lalo na pag may

mga ano kami hagadon ko sang family ko nga mag amuni pero ng daw hindi gid

abi ko maistorbo amuto ng hindi gid ko maka socialize sa iban nga tao dahil lang

sa game nga ni.

Participant 5

I: Okay, for the first question. How does mobile legend affect you psychologically

and physically?

P5: Di ko maintindihan

I: Okay lang kahit ano. Tagalog, ilonggo ,ilokano…

24
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

P5: Tagalogin mo yung question

I: Okay, paano nakaka affect yung paglalaro ng Mobile Legends sayo

psychologically at physically?

P5: Okay so pag naglalaro ako ng mobile legend daw sa kada free time ko

parang yun nalang yung naging stress reliever ko para makalimutan ko yung

mga studies and everything na stress sa school, diba?

I: Sa physically? Paano siya nakaka affect?

P5: Physically? daw wala man siya kay more on mentally lang gid

I: Next question. Why do you play mobile legends?

P5: Yun nga nag lalaro ako ng ml para lingaw lingaw lang ng kapag free time

pang patay oras lang

I: Okay.last question. How does Mobile Legends affect your personal relationship

for example to you friends and family?

P5: Amm… minsan kapag naglalaro ako ng Mobile Legends di na ako maka

sabay sa kanila minsan... makalimutan ko sila na andyan tapos parati pa akong

naiiwan kasi nauuna na sila kunyari pag naglalakad kami yun di ko na sila

namamalayan na wala na pala sila kung saan-saan na ako focus parin sa ml

ganun daw nakakalimutan ko na sila, minsan di na ako makaka-communicate sa

kanila.

I: Thank you for your truthful answer.

25
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

Participant 6

I: First I have a question. So...How does the game Mobile Legends affect you

psychologically and physically?

P6: Nang...pwede tagalog? Nang kwan abi mapadula siya sang stress tapos kay

mapadula siya sang stress tapos kay kung wala ka may mahimo amo lang ng

imo nga tawag sina thing nga mga fulfill sang imo happiness.

I: How about in physical?

P6: Physically? Daw wala man.

I: Okay po. For our sencond question. Why do you play mobile legend?

P6: Hmmmmm.. well stress reliever.

I: Amm...okay. How does mobile Legend affect your personal relationship

towards your family, friend and etc.?

P6: Maka affect siya sa kwan sa communication kay while ga hampang kami

may ara abi na siya tawag sinang daw mic. Basta amo sina open mic kag dali

lang kamo ka communicate.

I: Okay thank you po.

Participant 7

I: So first question, how does the game Mobile Legends affect you

psychologically and physically?

P7: It can affects me non.

I: Second question, why do you play Mobile Legends?

26
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

P7: For uhmm… when I get bored I play Mobile Legends for just let the time

passed.

I: Last question, how does Mobile Legends affect your personal relationships?

P7: It can affects my relationship because even you are uhh… your time mostly

goes on your family but your time mostly consumed in Mobile Legends when you

play it.

I: Thank you.

Participant 8

I: For our first question, how does the game Mobile Legends affect you

psychologically and physically?

P8: Personally, Mobile Legends has helped me relieved my stress. However,

sometimes it also affects me psychologically and physically because some uses

tricks that will get into your nerves and it will cause even more stress instead of

relieving the stress you have.

I: For the second question, why do you play Mobile Legends?

P8: It is actually for leisure or to kill some time especially when you’re alone and

bored.

I: For the last question, how does Mobile Legends affect your personal

relationships like family and friends?

P8: Mobile Legends is an addictive game, I will not deny that and I think it will

affect your personal relationships with family and friends because it will consume

27
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

most of your time, sometimes when you’re at home and your parents will tell you

to do something, you will have to balance your time with them and your game.

I: Thank you.

Participant 9

I: How does the game Mobile Legends affect you psychologically and physically?

P9: pwede tagalog?

I: yes

P9: Umm… ilonggo?

I: ikaw bahala.

P9: gahatag siya saakon sang ano sang joy tapos nang ginapalimot niya sakon

kis.a sa mga problema.

I: For our second question, why do you play Mobile Legends?

P9: Para iwas stress tapos pampalipas oras, lingaw-lingaw lang.

I: For the last question, how does Mobile Legends affect your personal

relationships like family and friends?

P9: sa mapansin ko magamay nalang akon time para sa akon family kis.a kay

mas gafocus ko sa ml kesa magbonding sa ila.

I: Thank you for answering.

Participant 10

I: how does the game Mobile Legends affect you psychologically and physically?

28
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

P10: Sa physically… ano nang ga tinamad ka tapos ga tinambok syempre

nalingaw ka hampang. Sa psychological, nang dasig ka ma badtrip kay syempre

daw gina isip mo nga daw tuod ang hampang basta amo na

I: Why do you play Mobile Legends?

P10: Wala, pang palipas oras lang.

I: How does Mobile Legends affect your personal relationships? (i.e. family and

friends)

P10: Sa family syempre halimbawa akig ka sa hampang syempre ma dala sa

friends mo and family.

29
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

Apendix C

Data Set Analysis

Table 1: Effects of playing Mobile Legends to students psychologically and


physically
Participant’s answer Meaning Theme

P1: “It’s for fun and at P1 said that it’s fun and Entertaining and a
the same time it entertaining and it causes reason to stay late at
entertains me. Physically, to stay late at night which night.
yun lang yung ano kasi is not good for the body.
medyo parati ka ng nag
pupuyat at tsaka hindi
maganda sa katawan.”
It’s for fun and at the
same time it entertains
me. Physically, it’s that, it
when you’re staying late
at night and it’s not good
for the body.

P2: “It does affect me P2 said that the effects of Being mean to others
psychologically by being gaming is being mean to and not exercising.
mean to others and it others and not exercising.
affects me physically by
not exercising.”

P3: “It often distracts me P3 mentioned that it’s a Distraction from real life
from my real life distraction from real life problems and not getting

30
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

problems and physically I problems and physically it enough sleep.


think that it has a big… causes P3 to stay late up
what do you call this? night and can’t have
effect on me because enough sleep which also
usually when I play causes the body clock
Mobile Legends I stay up changing.
late and it causes me to
change my body clock so
I don’t usually get much
sleep.”

P4: “Maka adik gid siya P4 said that the game is Addictive and a stress
kay parang stress addictive and it became reliever.
reliever mo na siya the only way to relieve
amuna ang mga tawag stress.
sina amuna ang way mo
nalang para pang kwan
mo sang stress.”
It’s addictive and it’s like
becoming your stress
reliever and it became
your only way to relieve
stress.

P5: “Daw sa kada free P5 said that it’s a stress Stress reliever and forget
time ko parang yun reliever and a way to everything that’s
nalang yung naging forget about studies and stressful.
stress reliever ko para everything in school
makalimutan ko yung that’s stressful.
31
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

mga studies and


everything na stress sa
school”

Whenever it’s my free


time, it’s like my only
stress reliever and for me
to forget about my
studies and everything in
school that’s stressful

P6: “mapadula siya sang P6 said that it’s a way to Stress reliever and to
stress tapos kay kung relieve stress and a way achieve happiness.
wala ka may mahimo to achieve P6’s
amo lang ng imo nga happiness.
tawag sina thing nga mga
fullfill sang imo
happiness.”
It relieves stress and like
it’s the only thing you
could do to fulfill your
happiness.

P7: “It can affects me P7 said that it doesn’t Doesn’t have an effect
non.” have an effect both both psychological and
psychological and physical.
physical.

P8: “Mobile Legends has P8 said that it gaming Stress reliever and also a

32
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

helped me relieved my help is relieving stress stressor.


stress. However, but sometimes it is the
sometimes it also affects reason that’s making P8
me psychologically and stressed.
physically because some
uses tricks will get into
your nerves and it will
cause even more stress
instead of relieving the
stress you have.”

P9: “Gahatag siya P9 said that it provides Provides joy and to


saakon sang ano sang joy and causes to forget forget problems.
joy tapos nang problems.
ginapalimot niya sakon
kis.a sa mga problema.”
It provides be joy and it
makes forget about my
problems sometimes.

P10: “Physically ano P10 said that it causes to Become lazy, fat, and
nang ga tinamad ka become lazy and fatter. being truly immersed in
tapos ga tinambok Psychologically, it gets the game.
syempre nalingaw ka into your nerves since
hampang. Sa that the game is
psychological, nang becoming like a real
dasig ka ma badtrip kay game.
syempre daw gina isip
mo nga daw tuod ang 33
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

hampang basta amo na.”

Physically it’s making you


lazy and making you
fatter since you’re so
entertained in
Physically it’s making you
lazy and making you
fatter since you’re
gaming. In psychological,
it gets into your nerves
since that the game is
becoming like a real
game.

Table 2: Reasons for playing Mobile Legends.


Participant’s Answer Meaning Theme

P1: “Since I was a kid, P1 really likes games Fond of playing games.
mahilig na talaga ako sa ever since he was a kid.
games.”
Since I was a kid, I am
really fond of playing
games.

P2: “To have fun and to P2 plays to have fun and For fun and to socialize.
communicate with communicate with others.
others.”

34
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

P3: “It was very famous P3 said that he was into Its trending and a
and I want to be in trend trend like ML and it is a distraction from
so I tried playing it and I distraction from real life problems.
played it a lot of times problems.
because it’s very
amusing and yeah like
what I said it distracts me
from my real life
problems.”

P4: “Pag stress ko P4 plays to lessen stress Gaming to lessen stress.


gahampang gid ko para even just a little.
madula bisan gamay
lang.”
Whenever I’m stressed, I
play for it to lessen even
just a little.

P5: “Lalaro ako ng ml P5 plays for Entertainment and to kill


para lingaw lingaw lang entertainment and to kill time.
ng kapag free time pang time when there vacant
patay oras lang.” time.

I play ml to for
entertainment and to kill
time when It’s free time. 35
P6: “Well, stress P6 plays for relieving To relieve stress.
reliever.” stress.
P7: “When I get bored I P7 play ML to let the time Making the time pass
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

play Mobile Legends for pass when feeling bored. when feeling bored.
just let the time passed.”

P8: “For leisure or to kill P8 said to kill some time For relaxation and to
some time especially and for relaxation when make the pass.
when you’re alone and P8’s alone and bored.
bored.”

P9: “Para iwas stress P9 plays to avoid stress For relaxation and to
tapos pampalipas oras, and for entertainment. make the pass.
lingaw-lingaw lang.”

P10: “Palipas oras lang.” P10 plays to let time Let time pass.
pass.
To let the time pass.

Table 3: Effects to personal relationships (i.e. family,friends, etc).


Participant’s answer Meaning Theme

P1: “For family, I think di P1’s family doesn’t like Family is not is favor with
parin sila pabor na P1 playing Mobile gaming.
mahilig ako mag Mobile Legends
Legends”

For family, I think they


are still not in favour of
mne playing Mobile
Legends. 36
P2: “It affects my P2 said that it affects in a Affects in a good and bad
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

personal relationships good way with friends way.


with my friends in a good because they can play
way because we can play and have fun while it
with each other and have affects in a bad way with
fun but in my family its family due to lack of time
does affect my family bad
way because I don’t have
lot of time to spend in”

P3: “It doesn’t really P3 plays only when Doesn’t affect personal
have an effect because I there’s no company relationships.
only play on my free around which doesn’t
times when there, I have affect any P3’s personal
no company around and relationships.
when I’m alone.”

P4: “Hindi gid ko maka P4 can’t socialize with Can’t socialize with
socialize sa iban nga tao anyone because of anyone.
dahil lang sa game nga gaming.
ni.”

I can’t socialize with


anyone because of this
game

P5: “Daw nakakalimutan P5 tends to forget family Tends to forget family


ko na sila, minsan di na when gaming and when gaming.
ako makaka- sometimes cannot
communicate sa kanila.” communicate
37 with them
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

I forgot about them and


sometimes I couldn’t
communicate with them

P6: “Maka affect siya sa P6 said that it is easier to Easier to communicate


kwan sa communication communicate with others with others.
kay while ga hampang because the game has
kami may ara abi na siya an open microphone.
tawag sinang daw mic.
Basta amo sina open mic
kag dali lang kamo ka
communicate.”

It can affect
communication because
when you are gaming,
there is this mic. It’s just
like when we play with
open mic and it’s easier
to communicate.

P7: “Your time mostly P7’s time is mostly Time consumed by


goes on your family but consumed by playing gaming.
your time mostly that’s how it affects P7’s
consumed in Mobile family.
Legends when you play
it.
38
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

P8: “It will consume most P8 is distracted with Doing both gaming and
of your time, sometimes doing tasks for parents doing tasks.
when you’re at home and when gaming and have
your parents will tell you to balance P8’s time with
to do something, you will family and the game.
have to balance your
time with them and your
game.”

P9: “Mas gafocus ko sa P9 focuses more in Focuses more on gaming


ml kesa magbonding sa gaming than bonding with than family.
ila.” family.

I focus much more on


playing ML than to bond
with them

P10: "Akig ka sa P10’s anger when Anger in gaming affects


hampang syempre ma gaming affects P10’s personal relationships.
dala sa friends mo and family and friends.
family.”
Since that you’ve been
“badtrip” by the game, it
will affect my family and
friends

Appendix E

39
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

Letter of Request to Conduct Research

07 January 2020
Mrs. Leann Jester D. Rosali, MSC
SHS Principal, NDMU-iIBED

Mrs. Rosali:
Greetings of Peace!

We, the researchers of St Gabriel STEM 11 Senior High School students are
currently conducting a qualitative study entitled “Life of Mobile Legends Gamers”.

We are humbly asking for your permission to allow us to interview STEM 11


students who are interested to participate in our research.

Your approval to conduct this study will be greatly appreciated. We hope that
youll grant our request. Thank you!

Respectfully,

JAY PEDRAJAS PINKY JOCELLE CALUYA

FRANCIS JAMES SUNGA ARRISA JEAN ENRIQUEZ

HONEY BARCENILLA

Noted: Approved:
JULIET C. ARELLANO MRS. LEANNE JESTER D. ROSALI
Practical Research 1 Teacher SHS Principal
Appendix F

40
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

Copy of the letter of consent

Interview Schedule

Directions: this is an interview schedule to be used during one-to-one interview.


An interviewer will state the following questions that are prepared beforehand.
The questions may be rephrased or reconstructed if needed according for its
reference of the study.

Reminders:
1. A phone will be used for the recording in the entire interview.
2. The confidentiality of the interview is given high regard.
3. The identity of the participants will be confidential.

Questions:
1. How does the game “Mobile Legends” affect you psychologically and
physically?

2. Why do you play Mobile Legends?

3. How does Mobile Legends affect your personal relationships (i.e. family,
friends, etc.)?

41
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

Appendix H
Curriculum Vitae

Name: Pinky Jocelle M. Caluya

Address: Fernandez 1st blk. Barangay Poblacion,

Tacurong City, Sultan Kudarat 9800

Contact Number: 09309642246

Email: caluyapinkyjocelle@gmail.com

Personal Information

Sex: Female

Birthdate: November 12, 2002

Place of Birth: Tacurong City, Sultan Kudarat

Civil Status: Single

Religion: Roman Catholic

Citizenship: Filipino

Educational Background

Senior High School: Notre Dame of Marbel University- IBED

Junior High School: Notre Dame of Tacurong College

Elementary: Montessori Learning Center, Tacurong City

42
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

Name: Arrisa Jean M. Enriquez

Address: Prk. Pag-asa, Brgy. Lemsnolon, Tboli,

South Cotabato

Contact Number: 09067485299

Email: arrisajean@gmail.com

Personal Information

Sex: Female

Birthdate: July 11, 2002

Place of Birth: General Santos City

Civil Status: Single

Religion: Alliance

Citizenship: Filipino

Educational Background

Senior High School: Notre Dame of Marbel University- IBED

Junior High School: Edwards National High Shool

Elementary: Lemsnolon Elementary School

43
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

Name: Francis James N. Sunga

Address: Prk. Paraiso, Brgy. Esperanza,

Koronadal City, South Cotabato

Contact Number: 09774194586

Email:fjamesunga@gmail.com

Personal Information

Sex: Male

Birthdate: May 31, 2002

Place of Birth: Koronadal City

Civil Status: Single

Religion: Roman Catholic

Citizenship: Filipino

Educational Background

Senior High School: Notre Dame of Marbel University- IBED

Junior High School: Notre Dame-Siena School of Marbel

Elementary: Notre Dame-Siena School of Marbel

44
JMJ MARIST BROTHERS
NOTRE DAME OF MARBEL UNIVERSITY
INTEGRATED BASIC EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
Senior High School

Name: Honey O. Barcenilla

Address: Prk. Matinatapon, Brgy. San Jose,

Koronadal City, South Cotabato

Contact Number: 09120141053

Email: hbarcenilla777@gmail.com

Personal info

Sex: Female

Birthdate: January 16, 2003

Place of Birth: Koronadal City, South Cotabato

Civil Status: Single

Religion: Iglisia Filipina Independiente

Citizenship: Filipino

Educational Background

SHS: NDMU-IBED

JHS: Notre Dame of San Jose

Elementary: Marbel 5 Central Elementary School

45

You might also like