Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Letitia Landon and Romantic Hellenism
Letitia Landon and Romantic Hellenism
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms
The University of Chicago Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend
access to The Wordsworth Circle
Noah Comet
University of California, Los Angeles
"Wordsworth is a poet that even Plato might have admitted lenism was hesitant and introspective, uneasy with th
into his republic. He is the most passionless of writers. Like Greece it promoted. In an exemplary poem, "The
the noblest creations of Grecian sculpture, the divinity is lian Fountain," she at first invokes the topoi of Roma
shown by divine repose" (Landon, Letters, 145). lenism, and then dismisses them as disingenuous, ou
themes. She manipulates Hellenist themes in order to dis
In this excerpt from a letter, Letitia Landon compli- turb the narrative from which she derived them, and in
ments Wordsworth by rephrasing his own concept of poetry Thessalian Fountain" she takes issue with the sexual p
as "emotion recollected in tranquility." Although the senti- of neoclassicism in particular. Challenging Hellen
ment is familiar, she places Wordsworth in an unconven- masculine movement, unsympathetic to women, t
tional context, the discourse of Romantic Hellenism, along demonstrates how women writers could engage with an
with Plato and the Apollo Belvedere. An ambitious footnote dermine it as an authoritative frame of reference, and
to the quotation might name some of the preeminent Ger- thetic response to history,
man Hellenists of the eighteenth century. For instance, "di
vine repose" echoes Johann Winckelmann's observations on Landon's critique of Hellenism from a femini
the sedate emotionality of Grecian art,1 while merging of spective extended the contemporary cultural revi
statuary with philosophy and poetry recalls A.W. Schlegel's glish Romantic Hellenism was a "primitivist ficti
lectures on Greek drama and sculpture. These authors make disregarded the "authentic native classical history" of
strange companions for Wordsworth, who seldom expressed Britain (Gaull 16; 17). The circulation of Hellenist them
an interest in Greek subject-matter or aesthetics. For the crit- any number of aesthetic genres (architecture, cookery
ical discussion of Romantic Hellenism, the quote reveals furnishings, etc) signaled not the invasion of a ver
more about Landon than Wordsworth. Greek culture, but rather the evasion of a British imperial
tory—a history written by the Roman conquerors, not the na
Like Mary Robinson, Landon cultivated a lyrical per- tive Britons. If Romande artists groaned under
sona on the model of Sappho, through which she fed the hegemonic weight of the Greek legacy, still, this w
public's appetite for tragic femininity. Like Lucy Aikin, she imposed burden, one of their own invention, and one
developed a keen understanding of ancient history, espe- freed them from a confrontation with the remn
cially the social history of women. And like Felicia Hemans, darker classical past that was literally at their feet (Ga
her contemporary, she distrusted the martial values pro- The result was a Hellenism with little historical or textua
moted in the Greek and Roman classics that she read in sis, creatively and materially dependent on the forc
translation. These similarities notwithstanding, Landon's dernity its proponents claimed to circumvent. "
Hellenism differed from that of Robinson, Aikin, and He- Thessalian Fountain" participates in a stigmatizing
mans, in its variety and reflexivity. Her collected works in- nism: in a candid but subversive expression of its trop
clude more than thirty poems involving ancient Greek don reproaches the idea of ancient Greece as nothin
mythology, literature, or history. These poems cover a range than modern intellectual property,
of topics and attitudes, from the anxieties of motherhood
during the Persian War ("Eucles Announcing the Victory at Landon included "The Thessalian Fountain" in
Marathon"), to a rallying cry for modern Greek liberation cal Sketches, a collection of poems depicting scen
("Greek Song"). Throughout this diverse collection, most of Greek and Roman myth and history. The collection wa
which appeared under the signature "L.E.L." in the 1830s, a part of her 1835 volume, The Vow of the Peacock, a ret
Landon maintained an interest in both the Hellenist aes- poetry after a spell of novel-writing. Though not a
thetic, and the work of cultural memory it entailed. Her Hel- cial success by her own standards, the volume won f
76
77
Landon casts the idea of Greece in a feminine role, a But these days
fountain preserved by a jealous obsession with chastity. Al- Of visible poetry have long been past!—
though her nymph's snowy-white skin invokes the marble No fear that the young hunter may profane
sculptures of Winckelmann's ekphrastic essays, her fountain The haunt of some immortal; but there still—
is a mirror, a setting for self-reflection, not ekphrasis. Lan- For the heart clings to old idolatry,
don describes a tentative scene, liable to vanish when the ob- If not with true belief, with tenderness,—
server moves because she recognizes the relevance of the Lingers a spirit in the woods and flowers
observer: the Hellenist idea of Greece is ephemeral and too Which ha[s] a Grecian memory,—-some tale
rarefied to withstand objective scrutiny. By implication, all Of olden love or grief linked with their bloom,
ekphrasis is reflective, a form of displaced introspection. Seem[s] beautiful beyond all other ones.
Landon anticipates Walter Pater's assertion in The Renaissance The marble pillars are laid in the dust,
(1873), that the first step toward seeing "the object as in itself The golden shrine and its perfume are gone;
it really is," is to establish "what effect [. . .] it really produces But there are natural temples still for those
on me" (xix-xx). By challenging an uncritical impulse to re- Eternal though dethroned Deities,
cycle Romantic notions of classical Greek beauty, she calls at- Where from green altars flowers send up their incense:
tention to the precariousness of such notions: an observer This fount is one of them. . . (24-39)
who stands in the space endorsed by the ideologues of En
glish Hellenism will see the pale nymph in the mirror. But Long after the age of Greece, the flourishing age of Greece
move just a little, and the reflection changes. worship has passed away. Landon's young hunter, fearing to
"profane / The haunt of some immortal," recalls the young
While she looks skeptically at Romantic Hellenism, Keats, prefacing his Endymion with some trepidation, lest he
Landon nevertheless deems the idea of Greece a necessary belatedly dull the brightness of Greece. Landon, on the
fiction—a "supreme fiction."3 Hellenism was a foundational other hand, acquiesces in the remoteness of the past. For
myth upon which English culture had come to depend, an her, Greece exists in the post mortem realm of memory, and
avoidance of less desirable histories, and a Zeitgeist that com- despite new attempts at ancient storytelling, it defies resur
pelled aesthetic revaluations and ideological and physical rection: "The marble pillars are laid in the dust, / The
warfare in the name of restoring cultural integrity to modern golden shrine and its perfume are gone."
Greece. However, when Landon composed the poem in
1835, these wars were over. The exigencies of Philhellenism For Landon, the monumentality of Greece has decom
had subsided in 1832, when Greece officially declared sover- posed. Its symbols dissolve with time, remaining only as col
eignty at a convention in London, a city now swept up in do- lective memory, mapped onto a realm more organic than
mestic reform. Writers and artists continued to shape and be statuesque, "a spirit in the woods and flowers / Which ha[s] a
shaped by the idea of Greece throughout the nineteenth cen- Grecian memory." Again, Landon invites a distinction be
tury, well after the arrival in England of F.A. Wolf s "Homeric tween the substantive (the Greek) and the adjectival (the
Question," but by the 1840s, English Hellenist discourse took "Grecian"). She naturalizes the thematics of Hellenism, re
a critical turn as it absorbed a new wave of continental schol- placing its marble ruins with "natural temples": "The golden
arship (Turner 6). For Landon and her contemporaries, the shrine and its perfume are gone," but the Grecian memory
sting of Byron's death in the cause of Greek liberation was fills the void with "green altars." She de-Hellenizes Helle
gone, and much of the novelty of Hellenism had worn off. nism, insisting that it has less to do with Greece than with
greenness, a Wordsworthian impulse to disperse subjectivity
With the dissolution of the ideals that had underwrit- into nature. The poem contains unmistakable echoes of
ten Hellenist excess, all that could remain of Greece was an Wordsworth's "Nutting," especially his hazel trees that rise
archaeological and textual history unequal to the posturings "Tall and erect," protecting a "virgin scene" (19-21), and the
of a Hellenism it had never really inspired. The artifacts of belated and displaced sense of guilt that he too called "a
Greece were no match for the "artifice of Hellenism" (Gaull, spirit in the woods" (56). Like Wordsworth, Landon projects
78
poet of the 1830s, one with a vexed relationship to Romantic presented at NASSR 2005 in Montreal and will appear in an
poetics.5 But the pale nymph, and the gendered configura extended study of nineteenth-century English Hellenism, dealing
tion of a fountain surrounded by paternalistic trees, also with gender, and the aesthetics of condescension.
point to her dissatisfaction with Romantic Hellenism as a
shortsighted, masculine neoclassicism whose patrons femi H follow Landon in using the term "grecian" rather than the
nized and eroticized the idea of Greece. From her reading more substantive "Greek" because Winckelmann primarily examined
of Greek and Roman translations, Landon was aware of wo Roman copies of Greek statues, rather than originals.
men's status in the ancient world, commenting on the matter
in an essay on Sir Walter Scott, "there is none of this high 2Landon borrowed from Spenser: lines 73-86 of the Prothala
toned imagination in the classic fictions; women were then mion present a scene of two Thessalian "Nymphes" with "snowie Fore
79
Wordsworth had been planning a visit to Ireland ever Descending, first I met that honoured Bard;
since his first meeting with the Irish Astronomer Royal, Wil- And gazing scarcely satisfied at length
liam Rowan Hamilton, in September, 1827. Introduced by A reverential longing; nor till night
Caesar Otway, author of Sketches in Ireland, whose book Had wrapped up long, and morning brought her star,
Wordsworth received that same year (Shaver 191), they were Ceased I to listen, or to pour my soul
on an excursion to Helvellyn, and, according to Hamilton, Forth in enthusiast talk, by the blandest mood
reluctant to part: "[Wordsworth] walked back with our party Of him encouraged. (46-7)
as far as their lodge; and then. . . I offered to walk back with
him, while my party proceeded to the hotel. This offer he Wordsworth described Hamilton as "a young man
accepted, and our conversation had become so interesting extraordinary genius" (Letters 5.120), and in a conver
that when we arrived at his house, a distance of about a mile, with Aubrey De Vere in 1831, as "singularly like Coler
he proposed to walk back with me on my way to Ambleside, a (41). Through letters, through Hamilton's visits to the
proposal which you may be sure that I did not reject; so far District and London, their friendship and intellec
from it, that when he came to turn once more towards his change lasted until Wordsworth's death, and extended to
home, I also turned once more along with him. It was very entire family; Hamilton was also friends with Edwa
late when I reached the hotel after all this walking" (Graves, linan, Dora's husband, and became godfather to
1.264). Afterwards, Wordsworth described himself as "over worth's grandson,
stimulated" (5.120) by the conversauon, while Hamilton
wrote "Recollections of Wordsworth": In late August, 1829, two years after their first meeting,
Wordsworth began his first and only visit to Ireland. With a
. . . that earliest evening, when, from top, friend, John Marshall, he sailed from Holyhead to Dublin
Mist-clad, of old Helvellyn, image-fraught, Bay, then to the Dunsink Observatory in Castleknock, south
80