Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chanakya-Sun Tzu Comparative Analysis
Chanakya-Sun Tzu Comparative Analysis
85
2
85
Ref : Mehta, Thakkar. Kautilya and Arthashastra. New Delhi: S. Chand & Company Ltd, 1980
Hakims’
Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
7
Literary Works 85
Hakims’
Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
8
Idea of the State 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
9
Idea of the State 85
• Intellectual strength
• Material strength
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
10
Take on Diplomacy 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
11
Thoughts on Economy 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
12
Notions of Leadership 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
13
Notions of Leadership 85
• Lust
• Anger
• Greed
• Excessive Pride
• Arrogance
• Over Joy
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
14
Ideas on Warfare 85
• Instigation of treachery
• Clandestine Ops
• Assassination of Leadership
Ref : Khokhar, Ayaz. “Indian foreign policy in light of Kautilya’s Arthashastra.” Daily Times, 17 April 2019
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
15
Ideas on Warfare 85
• Open War
• Concealed War
For a weak King using subversion
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
16
Ideas on Warfare 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
17
Ideas on Warfare 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
18
Ideas on Warfare 85
Force of Counsel
Power of Treasury
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
19
Validity in Contemporary World 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
20
Validity in Contemporary World 85
• Literary Work
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
21
Validity in Contemporary World 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
22
Validity in Contemporary World 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
23
Validity in Contemporary World 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
24
Validity in Contemporary World 85
• Non-Military Coercion
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
25
Validity in Contemporary World 85
• Regime Change
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
26
Validity in Contemporary World 85
• Regional Relationships
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
27
Critique 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
28
Critique 85
His ideology has given birth to racial supremacy, caste and religious
freedom suppression and misinterpreted expansionist’s ideas of Akhand
Bharat
Safe to assume that for Chanakya, morality and statecraft have no inter-
relation
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
29
Critique 85
For the naïve souls, Chanakya is a soulless materialist who uses anything
to his advantage to achieve his ends, while those who can see tomorrow
witness an enlightened pragmatist who recognizes that one must
sometimes engage in distasteful acts in order to achieve noble ends.
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
30
85
SUN TZU
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
31
Biography 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
32
Biography 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
33
Historical Environment 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
34
Historical Environment 85
• Translated in 29 languages
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
36
Ideas and Strategies 85
Importance to State
“War is of vital importance to the state. It is a matter of
life and death, a road either to survival or to ruin. Hence it is
mandatory that it be thoroughly studied”
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
37
Ideas and Strategies 85
Ref : Tzu, Sun. The Art of War (Translated in English by Lin Wusun). Beijing: Foreign Languages Press, 1999.
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
39
Ideas and Strategies 85
Heaven Signifies effects of day and night and heat and cold
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
40
Ideas and Strategies 85
Waging War
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
41
Stages of Evolution of State 85
Attack by Stratagem
Momentum / Power
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
43
Ideas and Strategies 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
44
Ideas and Strategies 85
Maneuvering
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
45
Ideas and Strategies 85
• Limitations
• Movement
• Stationing
• Deployment
• Tactical maneuvering
Ref : Tzu, Sun. The Art of War (Translated in English by Lin Wusun). Beijing: Foreign Languages Press, 1999.
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
46
Ideas and Strategies 85
Ref : Tzu, Sun. The Art of War (Translated in English by Lin Wusun). Beijing: Foreign Languages Press, 1999.
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
47
Ideas and Strategies 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
48
Ideas and Strategies 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
49
Ideas and Strategies 85
• Desperate/
Commander deadly/
must fatal
take region:
measuresFight to avoid
suited annihilation
to these varieties
Ref : Tzu, Sun. The Art of War (Translated in English by Lin Wusun). Beijing: Foreign Languages Press, 1999.
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
50
Ideas and Strategies 85
• Know the enemy and know yourself, in 100 battles, you will
never be in peril
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
51
Emphasis on Leadership 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
53
Impact on Conduct of War 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
54
Impact on Conduct of War 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
55
Impact on Conduct of War 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
56
Impact on Conduct of War 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
57
Impact on Conduct of War 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
58
Validity of Ideas in Modern Times 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
59
Validity of Ideas in Modern Times 85
• Information dominance
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
60
Validity of Ideas in Modern Times 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
61
Validity of Ideas in Modern Times 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
62
Validity of Ideas in Modern Times 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
63
Critiques 85
The text itself is very basic compared to its contemporaries and doesn’t
actually cover the proper way to build, maintain and secure lines of
communication and logistics: the true nuts-and-bolts of warfare
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
64
Critiques 85
Some of the lessons even promote methods which are consider a crime as
per International Humanitarian law, such as pillaging or plundering enemy’s
countryside for supplies and substituting own flags for those of enemy
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
65
85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
66
Themes for Assessing Similarities
85
• Anatomy of Power
• Role of deception
• Importance of intelligence
• Other similarities
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
67
Anatomy of Power 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
68
• Counsel
• Military might
• Economic factors
• Motivation
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
69
• Conciliation
• Sowing dissension
• Occult means
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
70
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
71
• Knowledge
• Military might
• Economy
• Chi (spirit)
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
72
Planning and Preparedness 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
73
Role of Deception 85
• Chanakya
Avoid direct military as
- Art of deception engagements when
part of covert and possible
psychological in
warfare
favour of other means of weakening the adversary
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
74
Conditions for Military Engagement 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
75
Management of External Relations 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
76
Importance of Intelligence 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
77
Other Similarities 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
79
Differences Between Sun Tzu and Chanakya 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
80
Differences Between Sun Tzu and Chanakya 85
Hakims’
Hakims Chanakya Sun Tzu Conclusion
Comparison
81
Conclusion 85
• Both Sun Tzu and Chanakya systematically explored the taxonomy of strategy,
the mechanics of wars and the architecture of peace
• Both strategists were able to utilise lessons from the past to evolve new
fundamentals of war and peace
• Sun Tzu was a general in the Army while Chanakya learned about war through
constant observation and analysis
• The wisdom of these two strategists on how to approach war and peace and
issues of intelligence and foreign policy are still relevant today
85
Thank You
83
Bibliography 85
Georges M. Halpern, Yves P. Huin. "Dr. Georges." The Arthashastra of Chanakya. 2018. https://drgeorges.net/wp-
content/uploads/4-GMH-Arthashastra-nm.pdf (accessed October 02, 2022).
Thiran, Roshan. Chinese Military Strategist Sun Tzu Reveals Secrets To Success. February 02, 2018.
https://leaderonomics.com/leadership/sun-tzu-secrets-success (accessed October 02, 2022).
https://www.worldhistory.org/Kautilya/
https://scroll.in/article/858304/in-the-21st-century-what-do-we-want-more-the-artha-of-chanakya-or-the-dharma-of-
ram-rajya
https://www.thequint.com/voices/opinion/chanakya-niti-amit-shah-sharad-pawar-indian-democracy-maharashtra-
election-drama#read-more
https://chanakyaforum.com/chanakya-latent-influence-on-indian-strategic-thoughts/#_ftn1
84
Bibliography 85
Bhattacharya, inaki. "Chanakya: An Empiricist as a Philosopher." Strategic Analysis Vol-5 (2014): 738-740.
McNeilly, Mark. Sun Tzu and the Art of Modern Warfare. New York: Oxford University Press, 2015.
R.P. Kangle, Shan ul Haq Haqqi. Translation of "The Kautiliya Arthashastra". Karachi: M Ismail Zabeeh, 1991.
Tzu, Sun. The Art of War (Tanslated in English by Lin Wusun). Beijing: Foreign Languages Press, 1999.
Usha Mehta, Usha Thakkar. Kautilya and Arthashastra. New Delhi: S. Chand & Company Ltd, 1980
85
Bibliography 85
https://qz.com/india/1772614/top-indian-politicians-are-being-called-chanakya-but-who-was-he/
Ingals, Daniel H. "The Cāṇakya Collections and Nārāyaṇa's Hitopadeśa." Journal of the American Oriental Society
Vol-86, no. 1 (1966): 1-19.
Khokhar, Ayaz. "Indian foreign policy in light of Kautilya’s Arthashastra." Daily Times, April 17, 2019.
Siddiqui, Wg Cdr Munawar Alam. Chanakya, The Indian Mechiavelli. " AWC Journal 1992
86
Bibliography 85
87
Bibliography 85
88
Bibliography 85