Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Occupational Balance From A Clinical Perspective
Occupational Balance From A Clinical Perspective
Occupational Balance From A Clinical Perspective
To cite this article: Brightlin Nithis Dhas & Petra Wagman (2022) Occupational balance from
a clinical perspective, Scandinavian Journal of Occupational Therapy, 29:5, 373-379, DOI:
10.1080/11038128.2020.1865450
SHORT REPORT
CONTACT Brightlin Nithis Dhas brightlindhas@gmail.com Qatar Rehabilitation Institute, PO 3050, Occupational Therapy, Hamad Medical
Corporation, Doha, Qatar
ß 2020 Scandinavian Journal of Occupational Therapy Foundation
374 B. N. DHAS AND P. WAGMAN
theory practically useful, and begins by selecting a purpose-meaning are important occupational dimen-
theory to be used in practice and then using practice sions that shape OB. While exploring the meaning of
to further refine the theory [13]. In this article, this the term OB among Iranian OTs, Yazdani, Roberts,
strategy is used to advance discussions on the prac- Yazdani, and Rassafiani [16] found four themes:
tical applications of OB, by reviewing the current integrity in being, equilibrium in doing, contentedness
publications on OB (theory phase) followed by a in becoming, and harmony in belonging. Other quali-
description of two practice-based vignettes (practice tative studies exploring the perception of OB follow-
phase). The vignettes are used as a point of departure ing conditions that basically change people’s PDOs,
for reflections on the challenges with the current con- such as retirement or onset of a physical disability,
cepts of OB, when applied in practice. Thereafter, the found that people were able to restructure their PDOs
benefits of combining OB and external perceptions of to reconstruct positive OB [17–20], implying that OB
the patterns of daily occupation (PDO) is proposed as is a relative state.
a way forward in clinical settings. The method is also In addition to the use of time and individualistic
similar to the Type 1 scientific inquiry described by conceptualisation of OB, some authors found rele-
Mosey (1992), wherein theory and practice are used vance in the contribution of external social elements
back and forth, with an aim to develop a con- on the perceived state of one’s OB. Wagman and
cept [14]. Håkansson [21] highlighted the importance of consid-
ering the perspectives of both the individual and
those around him or her in terms of how one’s OB
Theory phase: literature review of
affects and is affected by others. Yazdani et al. [15]
occupational balance
stated that ‘the right occupational balance is not only
A literature search was conducted in CINAHL, about an individual’s own satisfaction but it must also
MEDLINE, and PsycINFO using the search term follow the principle of no harm to others’ [p.295].
‘occupational balance’, to review the current state of Yazdani et al. [16] suggested that a person’s occupa-
OB research, and is summarised below. This was lim- tions need to be in harmony with shared values of
ited to articles that contributed to the theoretical the family and the community in order to perceive
approach of OB. Articles that primarily aimed at find- OB. Clouston [22] maintained that general assump-
ing associations between OB and other factors, and tions of a neoliberal market culture that favours paid
those that used other terminologies to describe the work over other types of occupations, force individu-
balance of occupations in daily life were excluded. als to make occupational compromises that affect the
Meyer [2] was the first to recognise the need for perception of OB.
balance between work, play, rest, and sleep for healthy Among other factors, time and financial constraints
survival in his philosophy of occupation therapy in were found to prevent new OT students from achiev-
1921. Since then different conceptualizations of OB ing OB [23]. Backman [24] suggested that societal
have been proposed. Some authors [3,4], following expectations specific to life phases, and occupational
Meyer’s legacy, conceptualised OB as a state of bal- restraints and opportunities extended by the specific
ance that could be attained by spending a certain pro- environment influence OB in addition to the personal
portion of the time in different types of occupations factors. Moreover, reports of experiencing poor OB
reinforcing the time use perspective of OB. among carers of people with disability suggest that
Qualitative studies aimed at primarily describing external caring demands affect one’s OB [25–28].
OB, revealed the various occupational dimensions Anaby, Backman, and Jarus [29], suggested that occu-
that an individual needs to balance to perceive OB, pational balance and imbalance are rather two distinct
thereby supporting the individualistic perspective of dimensions that co-exist within an individual. Thus,
OB [5,15,16]. For example, from a qualitative study of they added another theoretical angle to OB; however,
10 subjects with rheumatoid arthritis, Stamm et al. [5] this perspective was not further discussed in
identified three dimensions in which an individual the literature.
needs to strike a balance: challenging versus relaxing Five review articles were found in the literature
occupations, occupations meaningful for oneself ver- that contributed to the definitions, theoretical con-
sus occupations meaningful to others, and occupa- structions, and knowledge gaps in OB [6,21,24,30,31].
tions intended to care for oneself versus occupations In terms of measurement, self-reporting has been the
intended to care for others. Yazdani et al. [15] identi- sole method of assessing OB in quantitative research,
fied that complexity, obligation-willingness, and and standardised questionnaires [32–34] have been
SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY 375
developed for this purpose. One known exception to of her family. On the advice of the OT, Naomi com-
the self-reporting method of assessing OB is the exter- pleted an occupational diary. Indeed, most of Naomi’s
nal assessment of the client’s OB by the OT, based on day was devoted to work, or education related occu-
PDOs derived from activity diaries [35]. pations. Naomi acknowledged that the constraints of
Temporal organisation of time, which can be a complex life situation with a lack of insight on the
objectively observed through time use patterns, is impact of her occupational patterns on her spouse
sometimes considered as an important aspect of OB has led to a false sense of good OB and neglect of val-
[36,37]. Essentially, patterns of daily occupations ued family occupations such as spending time with
(PDO) are seen as objective facets closely associated her daughter. She was willing to make some compro-
with OB resulting from the same occupational inter- mises to create an occupational pattern that is also
actions, and the importance of addressing both, OB harmonious with the entire family, and reduce the
and PDO simultaneously has been emphasised [6]. stress experienced by Peter.
In summary, OB is theorised to be a perceived
state that is individualistic, relative, and being affected Kumar and his family
by external social elements. OB is considered as a Kumar has schizophrenia. Although Kumar has
subjective construct with PDO as its objective coun- recovered from the acute stage of illness, he continues
terpart. Although it is acknowledged that external ele- to have negative symptoms. Kumar’s father runs a
ments contribute to the perceived state of OB and small shop and according to him, Kumar, being the
one’s state of OB could affect others, the appraisal of elder son in the family, is expected to take over the
OB and PDO contributing to the state of perceived business from him soon. However, Kumar does not
OB is primarily considered from the individual’s per- participate in the family business as he used to before
spective. There is a paucity in literature about the the illness; instead, he sleeps for most of the morning.
external appraisal of an individual’s OB and PDO. Kumar’s father has a pre-determined schedule for
Kumar based on his family norms, which include tak-
ing Kumar’s younger brother to school and buying
Practice phase: practice based vignettes
things for the shop in the morning, and spending
The current subjective and individualistic concept of time with him in the shop in the evening. In addition,
OB throws some challenges when applied in practice. he wants Kumar to maintain a good relationship with
These challenges are formulated in the form of fol- his regular customers. Kumar could not complete a
lowing vignettes. These vignettes were adapted from self-reported measure of OB due to his cognitive limi-
real-life examples faced by the first author while tations. He acknowledges that his daily occupational
working in a city from Southern India, and will be pattern lacks variety in occupations but at the same
considered as a point of departure for further reflec- time does not know how to create a better schedule
tions and suggestions. that promotes balance. However, he wants to fit in
with his community and be a good son to his father.
Naomi and Peter Hence, he would like to follow the expectations of his
Naomi and Peter are married and have a 3-year-old father and his family. For the time being, Kumar pre-
daughter. In addition to a full-time job, Naomi is ferred someone else to create a schedule that is also
pursuing her PhD through distance education. Peter in accordance to his family expectations, as this would
also has a full-time job and has his non-work time make him feel confident. As a long-term goal, he
filled with child-care occupations. He developed clin- would create his own schedule. Kumar’s father was
ical depression and was admitted to a hospital. happy as Kumar acknowledged the family expecta-
Among other issues, Peter’s discontentment with tions and felt that he should create a schedule for
Naomi’s daily occupational pattern was a major Kumar with the help of an expert. He was ready to
source of stress for Peter. For instance, Peter felt that assume partial responsibility for helping Kumar to
Naomi could spend more time on child-care occupa- maintain that schedule.
tions. The couple was referred to occupational ther- The vignettes were presented to contemplate on
apy services. During the initial visit, Naomi’s scored some fundamental questions related to the concept of
high on a self-reported OB question while Peter OB as follows. What if a client considers his OB to be
scored less. Peter felt that Naomi’s occupational life right, but his/her context disagrees? What if a client
was imbalanced. He was concerned that Naomi’s cur- cannot decide the right amount and variation of
rent schedule did not accommodate the expectations occupations to achieve OB? Who can decide the
376 B. N. DHAS AND P. WAGMAN
work–life Imbalance. Bri J Occup Ther. 2014;77(10): [36] Eklund M, Erlandsson LK, Leufstadius C. Time use
507–515. in relation to valued and satisfying occupations
[23] Wilson L, Wilcock A. Occupational balance: what among people with persistent mental illness: explor-
tips the scales for new students? Br J Occup Ther. ing occupational balance. J Occup Sci. 2010;17(4):
2005;68(7):319–323. 231–238.
[24] Backman CL. Occupational balance: exploring the [37] Eklund M, Leufstadius C, Bejerholm U. Time use
relationships among daily occupations and their among people with psychiatric disabilities:
influence on well-being. Can J Occup Ther. 2004; Implications for practice. Psychiatr Rehabil J. 2009;
71(4):202–209. 32(3):177–191.
[25] Nissmark S, F€ange AM. Occupational balance [38] Håkansson C, Morville A-L, Wagman P. 2017.
among family members of people in palliative care.
Aktivitetsbalance. [Occupational balance]. In Kaee
Scan J Occup Ther. 2018;27:1–7.
Kristenssen IH, Larsen Maersk J, Bach A-S, editors.
[26] Hodgetts S, Mcconnell D, Zwaigenbaum L, et al.
The impact of autism services on mothers. OTJR. Nordisk aktivitetsvidenskab [Nordic occupational
2013;34:81–92. science]. København [Copenhagen]: Munksgaard
[27] Ludwig FM, Hattjar B, Russell RL, et al. How care- Gyllendal A/S.
giving for grandchildren affects grandmothers’ [39] Wada M, Backman CL, Forwell SJ, et al. Balance in
meaningful occupations. J Occup Sci. 2007;14(1): everyday life: dual-income parents’ collective and
40–51. individual conceptions. J Occup Sci. 2014;21(3):
[28] Mcguire BK, Crowe TK, Law M, et al. Mothers of 259–276.
children with disabilities: occupational concerns and [40] Håkansson C, Milevi S, Eek F, et al. Occupational
solutions. OTJR. 2004;24(2):54–63. balance, work and life satisfaction in working cohab-
[29] Anaby DR, Backman CL, Jarus T. Measuring occu- iting parents in Sweden. Scand J Public Health.
pational balance: a theoretical exploration of two 2019;47(3):366–374.
approaches. Can J Occup Ther. 2010;77(5):280–288. [41] Watford P, Jewell V, Atler K. Increasing meaningful
[30] Wagman P, Håkansson C, Jonsson H. Occupational occupation for women who provide care for their
balance: a scoping review of current research and spouse: a pilot study. OTJR. 2019;39(4):213–221.
identified knowledge gaps. J Occup Sci. 2015;22(2): [42] Reilly M. A psychiatric occupational therapy pro-
160–169. gram as a teaching model. Am J Occup Ther. 1996;
[31] D€ur M, Unger J, Stoffer M, et al. Definitions of 20(2):61–67.
occupational balance and their coverage by instru- [43] Eriksson T, Karlstr€ om E, Jonsson H, et al. An
ments. Br J Occup Ther. 2015;78(1):4–15. exploratory study of the rehabilitation process of
[32] Håkansson C, Wagman P, Hagell P. Construct valid- people with stress-related disorders. Scan J Occup
ity of a revised version of the occupational balance Ther. 2010;17(1):29–39.
questionnaire. Scand J Occup Ther. 2020;27(6): [44] Eklund M, Tj€ ornstrand C. Associations between
441–449.
occupational and social interaction factors and well-
[33] Eklund M, Argentzell E. Perception of occupational
being among people with psychiatric disabilities liv-
balance by people with mental illness: a new meth-
odology. Scand J Occup Ther. 2016;23(4):304–213. ing in supported housing in Sweden. J Occup Sci.
[34] D€ur M, Steiner G, Fialka-Moser V, et al. 2020;27(1):54–68.
Development of a new occupational balance-ques- [45] Pemberton S, Cox D. Perspectives of time and occu-
tionnaire: incorporating the perspectives of patients pation: experiences of people with chronic fatigue
and healthy people in the design of a self-reported syndrome/myalgic encephalomyelitis. J Occup Sci.
occupational balance outcome instrument. Health 2014;21(4):488–503.
Qual Life Outcomes. 2014;12:45. [46] Kassberg A-C, Nyman A, Larsson Lund M.
[35] Bejerholm U. Occupational balance in people with Perceived occupational balance in people with
schizophrenia. Occup Ther Mental Health. 2010; stroke. Disabil. Rehabil. 2019. DOI:10.1080/
26(1):1–17. 09638288.2019.1632940.