Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Re-Processed Spice Mix Formulation and Changes It 1
Re-Processed Spice Mix Formulation and Changes It 1
Abstract
Wet and dry spice and condiments of optimized quantities were pre-processed and mixed to prepare a spice mix formulation. The
formulation was unit packed in 100 g quantities in glass bottles and held separately at 2772 or 3772 1C for 6 months. Freshly
prepared spice mix contained (g/100 g) 6.8 moisture, 21.4 fat, 5.1 protein, 7.2 ash and 14.2 NaCl. Gradual decrease in pH from 4.0 to
3.7 and 4.0 to 3.6, increase in aw from 0.52 to 0.54 and 0.52 to 0.57, increase in free fatty acid (FFA) values (as % oleic acid) from
0.14 to 0.56 and 0.14 to 0.58 and increase in thiobarbituric acid (TBA) values (mg malonaldehyde/kg sample) from 2.5 to 2.9 and 2.5
to 2.9 were noticed during storage at 2772 or 3772 1C respectively. Similarly decrease in Hunter L (lightness), a (redness) and
b (yellowness) values were noted during the same period. Standard plate count (SPC), spore counts and staphylococci counts
(log cfu/g) were low, 4.0–4.7, 1.2–2.0 and 1.4–2.0, respectively, and yeast and moulds and coliforms could not be detected in all the
samples throughout the storage period of 6 months. Two ready-to-serve products, viz., dhal fry and chicken fry prepared by using
spice-mix stored for up to 6 months were judged acceptable as indicated by sensory quality scores of 6.8–7.9 (on a 9-point hedonic
scale). The spice mix formulation prepared is useful in the preparation of varieties of vegetarian and non-vegetarian ready-to-serve
products such as aloo mattar, gobi masala, mattar mushroom, kheema mattar, Mutton chilly fry, etc.
Keywords: Spice mix; pH; aw; Colour; Rancidity; Microbial quality; Sensory quality
1. Introduction such as the skill and style of the chef. The ‘recipe’
product in a commercial sense, should possess certain
Indian cuisines are a vast array of spicy delicacies. attributes such as a well-defined product profile, a
Every food product acquires its final profile principally scheduled manufacturing procedure, uniform quality
from two components, namely, ingredients and proces- and specified shelf-life, all of which are essential for
sing methods. Traditional Indian delicacies require organized trade. Thus, there is a need for a pre-
processing of varieties of spices including one or more processed ready-to-use and shelf-stable spice mix
of unit operations such as roasting, frying, powdering, formulation for the preparation of varieties of
etc. in order to obtain an appropriate flavour profile plant-based and muscle-based food products in order
from spices. These flavour profiles are caused by thermal to minimize the drudgeries of processing in kitchen
effects and interactive effects due to processing of spices. and food preparation time to cater to the needs of
A kitchen preparation is prone to variations due to increasing population of working couples, single persons
regional and ethnic practices and to subjective factors living, etc.
Several authors have studied the role of a number of
Corresponding author. Tel: +91 821 2514 840; spices in food products with respect to their anti-oxidant
fax: +91 821 516308. effects (Martinez-Tome et al., 2001; Pszczola, 2001;
E-mail address: nsmahendra@yahoo.com (N.S. Mahendrakar). Leal, Braga, Sato, Carvalho, Marques, & Meireles,
ARTICLE IN PRESS
2. Materials and methods Add (i) Cumin seeds, heat for 20 s till seeds
crack partially and become brown
(ii) Sliced green chillies, chopped garlic and
Several trial and error formulations of spice mix were chopped ginger and fry for 7 min till Vegetable oil (Sun
brownness, Add in hot oil (110 ˚C) flower oil),
attempted using different spice ingredients and time–- (iii) Citric acid, turmeric powder, coriander
Fried onion slices powder, red chilli powder, garam masala and
temperature schedules of processing in order to obtain a common salt Heat to 100 ˚ C
mix, which was acceptable to taste panelists. The
appropriate ingredients composition of spice mix is
given in Table 1 and processing conditions for the Dry fresh onion Mix well Hot oil
rings, at 70 – 80 ˚C
preparation of spice mix are provided in the flow chart for 2 h in Cross
(Fig. 1). Flow Air Dryer
Cool to 27± 2 ˚C
in a pan, heated to 120 1C, clean onion slices were Use for the preparation of vegetarian or non-
vegetarian food products
transferred in to the hot oil and fried for 20 min and
fried onions were taken out from the oil (Step 1). To the Fig. 1. Preparation of spice mix.
remaining hot oil were added cumin seeds, fried for 15 s
till partial cracking of seeds occurs and turns brown,
followed by addition of sliced green chillies, peeled and temperature for 2 h, packed in glass bottles of 100 g
chopped garlic, peeled and chopped ginger, and fried till capacity each and stored at ambient temperature of
brownness. To this mix was added citric acid, turmeric 2772 or 3772 1C.
powder, coriander powder, red chilli powder, garam
masala (commercially available) and common salt in 2.2. Quality evaluation
that order while continuously mixing (Step 2). Along
side, refined sunflower oil (remaining quantity) was Moisture, fat, protein, ash and salt content of freshly
heated to 100 1C, and fresh onion rings were dried in a prepared spice mix formulation were determined by
cross flow air drier at 75 1C for 2 h to obtain dried onion following AOAC (1999) procedures. The spice mix
rings. The hot oil, dried onion rings and fried onion formulation packed in glass bottles and stored at
slices (Step 1) were then added to spice mix of Step 2 and 2772 1C and/or at 3772 1C was sampled at 0 (freshly
mixed thoroughly. The final spice mix formulation was prepared), 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6 months and analysed for
removed from flame and allowed to cool at ambient different quality parameters. The pH of spice mix
ARTICLE IN PRESS
formulation was measured using a pH meter by products by the department of Sensory Science of the
inserting the combined glass–calomel electrode directly. institute. Only those members who are found suitable
The spice mix formulation was filled in the cup of for sensory studies were employed in this investigation.
Pawkit water activity meter and aw measured directly.
Similarly, the spice mix formulation was filled in a cup
2.4. Statistical analysis
of Hunter colour measuring system and L (lightness),
a (redness) and b (yellowness) values were recorded.
The experiment had a completely randomized design
For determination of free fatty acids (FFA), sample
with two storage temperatures (2772 or 3772 1C) in six
(10 g) was mixed with anhydrous Na2SO4 (100 g) and
replicates. Spice mix product prepared six times on
fat was extracted in CHCl3 (100 ml) and filtered in
different days represented the replicates. The spice mix
order to remove non-fatty acids, which may have come
prepared on different days were stored and sampled at 0,
from formulation ingredients, an aliquot of CHCl3
1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6-month intervals. The mean values for
extract washed three times with 4–5 volumes of distilled
all parameters were examined for significance by
water in a separatory funnel. Non-fatty acids
analysis of variance and when significant difference
partitioned in aqueous layer and fatty acid in CHCl3
ðPo0:05Þ was observed, mean separation was accom-
layer (Mahendrakar, Rathina Raj, Khabade, Dani, &
plished by Duncan’s multiple range test using STATIS-
Ramesh, 1995). The FFAs as % oleic acid were
TICA software (Statsoft. Inc., 1999).
estimated in washed CHCl3 extract as per AOAC
(1999) procedure. Thiobarbituric acid (TBA) values
were measured by the distillation procedure of Tarlad-
gis, Walts, Younathan, and Durgan (1960). 3. Results and discussion
Microbiological quality of spice mix formulation was
assessed by enumerating standard plate counts, spore 3.1. Physical and chemical quality characteristics
counts, staphylococcus, coliforms and yeasts and
moulds using standard procedures of APHA (2001). Spice mix freshly prepared by using appropriate
ingredient quantities (Table 1) and processing condi-
2.3. Preparation and evaluation of sensory quality of dhal tions (Fig. 1) contained (g/100 g) 6.8 moisture, 21.4 fat
fry and chicken fry (ether extract), 5.1 protein, 7.2 ash and 14.2 common
salt (Table 2).
Spice mix formulation packed in glass bottles and Wide variation in chemical composition of two well-
held at 2772 1C and/or 3772 1C was drawn at monthly known spice mixes, viz., Channa masala and Meat
intervals and used for the preparation of a vegetarian masala, available in India has been reported by Kalra
product, viz., dhal fry and a non-vegetarian product, et al. (1998). Channa masala (30 samples) and Meat
viz., chicken fry, as follows: masala (35 samples) contained (g/100 g) 4.0–12.0 and
Dhal fry: Red gram dhal (Cajanus cajan) (100 g) was 5.1–9.2 moisture, 5.3–16.3 and 5.4–18.8 fat (ether
taken in a stainless-steel vessel to which water (400 g) extract), 1.0–2.4 and 6.2–9.8 ash and 3.8–27.8 and 0
was added and subjected to cooking under a steam common salt, respectively, (Kalra et al., 1998).
pressure of 1 kg/cm2 for 5 min, and allowed to attain The pH of freshly prepared spice mix was 4.070.11
normal pressure. The cooked dhal was mixed with 30 g which decreased gradually ðPp0:05Þ to 3.770.05 and to
spice mix formulation and the mixture was heated on a 3.670.04 when stored for 6 months at 2772 and at 37
low flame for 1–2 min. The dhal fry prepared is a ready- 72 1C, respectively (Fig. 2). The gradual decrease in pH
to-serve product. could be due to chemical changes and not due to
Chicken fry: Dressed broiler chickens obtained from microbiological activity as explained later. The pH value
market were deskinned. The meat with bone was cut of spice mix were marginally ðPX0:05Þ lower through-
into 3–4 cm size chunks. Meat chunks (500 g) in a out the storage period at higher temperature (3772 1C)
stainless-steel vessel was mixed with spice mix formula- compared to those at 2772 1C. Water activity (aw), on
tion (60 g), sunflower oil (25 g) and water (100 g). The
mixture was subjected to cooking at 90–95 1C for
12–15 min. The product is ready-to-serve. Table 2
Chemical composition (g/100 g) of spice mix formulation
Dhal fry and chicken fry products, soon after
preparation, were subjected to evaluation of sensory Moisture 6.871.9
quality attributes, viz., colour, flavour, taste and overall Fat 21.471.1
quality by 10 in-house trained panelists using 9-point Protein 5.170.5
hedonic scale (Modi, Mahendrakar, Narasimha Rao, & Ash 7.270.2
NaCl 14.270.6
Sachindra, 2003). Many scientific staff members of the
institute are trained for sensory evaluation of food Values are mean7SD (n ¼ 6).
ARTICLE IN PRESS
oxidation and production of volatile metabolites in the subsequent storage up to 6 months. Hunter a (redness)
presence of oxygen during aerobic packaging and values fluctuated in the narrow range of 9.6–10.3 during
storage. The increase in TBA values in food products storage for 6 months at 2772 1C whereas they gradually
during storage is well documented (Chiang, Norton, & ðPp0:05Þ decreased from 9.670.10 to 6.070.60 during
Anderson, 1981; Reddy, Setty, & Dora, 1992; Lai, Gray, the same period when held at higher temperature of
Booren, Crackel, & Gill, 1995; Martin, Timan, Patron, 3772 1C (Fig. 4). On the other hand, b (yellowness)
Ventanas, & Antequena, 2000; Modi et al., 2003, 2004a). values increased gradually from 7.870.19 (0 month) to
Although many spices are reported to have anti-oxidant 11.270.27 (6 months) when stored at 2772 1C whereas
effect (Pszczola, 2001; Leal et al., 2003), Srinivasan, these values increased gradually ðPp0:05Þ up to 3
Sammbaiah, and Chandrasekhara (1992) observed loss months which then remained almost constant there after
of active principles in turmeric, chillies, etc. during up to 6 months (Fig. 4). Higher temperature of storage
domestic cooking, i.e. boiling of spice mixes with food resulted into marginally ðPX0:05Þ lower L values and
ingredients. significantly ðPp0:05Þ lower a and b values compared
Colour reflectance values measured on Hunter Colour to those held at 27721C (Fig. 4). Changes in visual
Difference Meter revealed that the L (lightness) values colour (reflectance) of spices are reported to be
decreased drastically ðPp0:05Þ in the first 2 and 3 dependent on method of processing (Pesek & Wilson,
months when held at 2772 and 3772 1C (Fig. 4). The 1986), packaging conditions (Alvarez & Binder, 1984),
values then decreased marginally ðPX0:05Þ during degree of exposure to light (Kim, Park, & Hwang, 2002)
and interaction of ingredients (Osuna-Garcia, Wall, &
Waddell, 1997). In the present investigation, visual
colour appearance of the spice mix product was quite
acceptable even after 6 months storage at 2772 or
3772 1C despite changes in instrumental chromatic
attributes (L, a and b values).
Table 3
Changes in sensory quality of dhal fry prepared by using spice mix stored for 6 months at 2772 or 3772 1C
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
Colour
2772 8.670.2ax 8.470.2abx 8.270.3bcx 8.170.2bcdx 7.970.2bcdx 7.870.3dx 7.570.3ex
3772 8.670.2ax 7.970.2by 7.870.3bcy 7.670.2cy 7.270.3dy 6.970.2dey 6.870.3ey
Flavour
2772 8.670.2ax 8.270.3bx 8.170.2bcx 7.870.3cx 7.870.3cx 7.470.4dx 7.270.3dx
3772 8.670.2ax 8.270.2bx 7.870.4bcx 7.770.3cx 7.670.2cx 7.270.3dx 7.170.2dx
Taste
2772 8.370.3ax 8.270.3abx 8.170.2abx 7.970.2bcx 7.670.4cdx 7.570.3dx 7.270.3dx
3772 8.370.3ax 8.170.2ax 7.570.3by 7.470.4by 7.370.3bx 6.970.4cy 6.870.4cy
Overall quality
2772 8.670.2ax 8.370.3abx 8.270.3bcx 7.970.2cdx 7.870.3dx 7.770.3dex 7.370.3ex
3772 8.670.2ax 8.370.3ax 7.870.3by 7.670.2bcx 7.670.2bcx 7.370.4cy 6.970.4dy
Values are mean 7 SD (n ¼ 6). Values with different superscripts in rows (a,b,c,d,e,f) and in columns (x,y) for each parameter differ significantly
(Pp0.05).
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Table 4
Changes in sensory quality of chicken fry prepared by using spice mix stored for 6 months at 2772 or 3772 1C
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
Colour
2772 8.870.3ax 8.870.3ax 8.470.4abx 8.270.3bcx 8.070.3bcx 7.970.4cx 7.970.4cx
3772 8.870.3ax 8.170.2by 7.970.4bcy 7.670.2cdy 7.270.3dey 7.070.4ey 6.870.6ey
Flavour
2772 8.670.2ax 8.470.2ax 8.370.3abx 8.070.3bcx 7.970.4cdx 7.870.3cdx 7.670.5dx
3772 8.670.2ax 8.370.3abx 8.070.4bcx 7.870.3cdx 7.470.2dey 7.170.4efy 6.970.4fy
Taste
2772 8.470.2ax 8.170.4abx 8.070.3abx 7.870.3bcx 7.770.3bcx 7.470.4cx 7.370.5cx
3772 8.470.2ax 8.070.3abx 7.770.4bcx 7.570.6bcx 7.270.4cdx 7.270.5cdx 6.970.6dx
Overall quality
2772 8.670.2ax 8.370.3abx 8.370.3abx 8.170.2bx 7.870.3cx 7.670.2cx 7.470.2cx
3772 8.670.2ax 8.270.3abx 8.070.3bx 7.670.2cy 7.670.2cx 7.370.4cx 7.070.4dy
Values are mean7SD (n ¼ 6). Values with different superscripts in rows (a, b, c, d, e, f) and in columns (x, y) for each parameter differ significantly
(Pp0.05).
Martinez-Tome, M., Jimenez, A. M., Ruggieri, S., Frega, N., Pszczola, D. E. (2001). Antioxidants: from preserving food quality to
Srabbioli, R., & Murcia, M. A. (2001). Antioxidant properties of quality of life. Food Technology, 55(6), 51, 52, 54, 56–57.
Mediterranian spices compared with common food additives. Reddy, L., Setty, T. M. R., & Dora, K. C. (1992). Studies on storage
Journal of Food Protection, 64(9), 1419–1419. behavior of frozen fish fingers from croacker and perched. Fishery
Modi, V. K., Mahendrakar, N. S., Narasimha Rao, D., & Sachindra, Technology, 29(1), 35–39.
N. M. (2003). Quality of buffalo meat burger containing legume Sen, A. R., & Karim, S. A. (2003). Storage stability of rabbit pickle at
flours as binders. Meat Science, 66, 143–149. room temperature. Journal of Food Science and Technology, 40(2),
Modi, V. K., Mahendrakar, N. S., Sachindra, N. M., & Narasimha 197–200.
Rao, D. (2004a). Quality of nuggets prepared from fresh and Srinivasan, K., Sammbaiah, K., & Chandrasekhara, N. (1992). Loss of
smoked spent layer chicken meat. Journal of Muscle Foods, 15, active principles of common spices during domestic cooking. Food
195–204. Chemistry, 43, 271–274.
Modi, V. K., Sakhare, P. Z., Mahendrakar, N. S., Subramani., & Statsoft Inc. (1999). STATISTICA for windows. 2300, East 14th Street,
Narasimha Rao, D. (2004b). A process for preparation of pre-mix Tulsa, OK: Statsoft Inc.
formulation for Indian cuisines. Indian patent filed in March 2004. Tarladgis, B. G., Walts, B. M., Younathan, M. T., & Durgan Jr. L.,
Osuna-Garcia, J. A., Wall, M. M., & Waddell, C. A. (1997). Natural (1960). A distillation method for quantitative determination of
antioxidants for preventing colour loss in stored paprika. Journal malonaldehyde in foods. Journal of American Oil Chemists Society,
of Food Science, 62(5), 1017–1021. 37, 44–48.
Park, S. H., & Lim, H. S. (2003). Effects of red pepper, salt fermented Yashoda, K. P., Jagannatha Rao, R., Mahendrakar, N. S., &
anchory extracts and salt concentration on the tastes of Kimchi. Narasimha Rao, D. (2004). Egg loaf and changes in its quality
Journal of Korean Society of Food Science and Nutrition, 32(3), during storage. Food Control, 15(7), 523–526.
346–349. Zalacain, I., Zapelena, M. J., Astiasaran, I., & Ballo, J. (1995). Dry
Pesek, C. A., & Wilson, S. A. (1986). Spice quality: effect of cryogenic fermented sausages elaborated with lipase from Candida cylindacea
and ambient grinding on colour. Journal of Food Science, 51(5), Comparison with traditional formulations. Meat Science, 40(1),
1386–1388. 55–61.