Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 23

TOPIC 1 (Week 1) (activities to know if there is a need for

transportation improvement: able to conduct a


survey for the specified study area, data of the
Transportation Engineering study area and its surrounding such as the travel
survey, to review relative studies that are relevant
- A sub-discipline of civil engineering useful for the study)
which deals with the application of
technology and scientific principles to Problem definition- describe the problem in terms
the (functional areas of transportation of the objectives to be accomplished by the
engineering) planning, functional design, project and to translate those objectives into
operation and management of facilities criteria that can be quantified (establish criteria to
for any mode of transportation (land, measure the effectivity of the proposed
water, air). alternatives/proposal)
- Not an independent discipline but an
Search for solutions- idea generating phase
interdependent one.
- considering variety of ideas, designs,
locations, and system configurations that
Transportation Planning might provide solutions to the problem
- Includes conducting preliminary
- Process of evaluating the current feasibility studies, some data gathering,
transportation system field testing, and cost estimating
- Deals with the relationship of land use to
travel patterns and demands Analysis of performances- to estimate
- Provide a prediction of usage demand in performance if proposed alternatives under
future travel and to ensure all the present and future conditions
necessary facilities and services cater to
- Estimation of investment cost and annual
that demand
cost of the project, the travel demand, and
Why is Planning important? the environmental effects.

- Planning is the vital face of a project Evaluation of alternatives- determine how well
- Identify multiple options for alternatives achieve the objects of the project as
transportation (system or network defined by the criteria
applied, modes of transportation,
- perform data produced in the analysis
structural aspects and elements, etc.)
phase are used to compute the benefits
- Outlying problems to a transportation
and costs that will result if the project is
system
selected
- Formulate solutions to those identified
problems Choice of projects- project selection is made
- Recall purpose of construction design considering the factors involved
- Organize existing transportation system
Specification and construction- detailed design
and structural design
phase in which each of the components of the
facility is specified
Basic Elements of Transportation Planning
Situation definition - involves activities required
to understand situation that gave rise to the
perceived need for transportation improvement

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering
Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3
CE431 – Transportation Engineering
Composition of Transportation System
Transport System
Core components:
- Modes- conveyance used for mobility of
passenger and freight
-mobile elements of
transportation;
-land (road, railway), air
(scheduled and chartered flights), water
transportation (ferry and cruise ships)
- Infrastructures- physical support of
transportation modes, such as routes and Demand – A derived function for the mobility of
terminal. the people, freight, and information for a variety
-Fixed elements of transportation of socioeconomic activities.
including superstructures
*Transportation is a derived demand*
- Networks – system linked location
(nodes)
-Functional and spatial
organization of transportation
-ex: terminals
- Flows- movement of people, freight and
information over their network
-has origins, intermediary
locations and destinations

Transport Geography
- is a sub discipline of geography,
concerned about the mobility of people, Direct Derived Demand – a movement that will
freight, and information and its spatial fulfill a socioeconomic activity
organization considering attributes and
Ex: Transportation
constraints related to the origin,
destination, extent, nature, and purpose Indirect Derived Demand – a movement that will
of movements fuel other movements to fulfill their activities
- based on the premise that transportation
is a system supporting complex Ex: A truck that carries the extracted fuel to a
relationship articulated by three central gasoline station.
concepts Nodes – where movements are originating,
-Transportation nodes ending, and transiting (intermediacy), entry or
-Transportation networks exit points in a transport system. They vary
-Transportation demand according to geographical scale being considered
ranging from local nodes (local air and sea ports)
to global nodes (international air and sea ports).

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering
Networks – composed of a set of linkages
expressing the connectivity between places and
the capacity to handle passenger or cargo
volumes.

Location (nodes – demand) – nodes where


demand is expressed as an origin, destination, or
point of transit. The level of spatial accumulation
of socioeconomic activities (production and
consumption) jointly defines demand and where
this demand is taking place.
Flows (networks – nodes) – the amount of traffic
over a network, which is composed of nodes and
linkages. This is jointly a function demand and
the capacity of the linkages to support them.
Infrastructures (demand – networks) – the
conveyances such as roads and terminals
expressing the physical reality of a network and
are designed to handle demand with specific
volume and frequency characteristics. Facilities
enabling access to a network are jointly
characterized by their centrality and the linkages
that radiate from them.

*The transportation system would need to cater


the movement of the passengers, freight, and
information*

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering
Topic 2 (Week 2)
State of the Public Transport System in the How was public transportation planned before?
Philippines

• No government-led planning of the road transit


Atty. Martin B. Delgra III network
-Chairman, Land Transportation Franchising • Mostly operator-initiated routes
Regulatory Board
• Franchises issued based on Route Measured
Capacity (RMC)
THE PHILIPPINE PUBLIC TRANSPORT • Route-based only, not network-based
SYSTEM
• Doesn't consider road capacity constraint

Our public transport system is deemed unsafe,


Outcome:
unhealthy, unreliable, and uncomfortable.
•Widespread competition among various
transport modes, overlapping routes
PUBS and PUJS: Serve 67% of demand but uses
•No hierarchy of modes
28% of road space (JICA, 2014)
•Low-capacity vehicles in high-demand areas,
leading to reduced road capacity
• PUJS dominate road-based public transport:
•Prevalence of Low/Oversupply of public
o 180,000 PUJs nationwide. 90% are 15 years old transport
and above (LTFRB)
o 17% ambient air pollution in Metro Manila and
Current System
upto 80% in other cities due to PUJS*
On-street competition
。 PUJ passengers 10 times more likely to get
into accidents than private car riders* •Accidents
•Chaos in the streets
Effects: •Traffic violations
Php 2.4 Billion in economic losses due to traffic
congestion (JICA, 2014)
RESULTS:
Car = Filipino Dream (Ambisyon Natin 2040)
•Low-income Exhausted drivers
• DISTRESS and DISCOMFORT when
commuting •Prone to accidents
•Prone to more bad behavior

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering
Main Objectives of the PUV Modernization A transformational large-scale initiative and the
Program largest non infra flagship project of President
Rodrigo Duterte
•Modernize the current PUV fleet
•Reform and consolidate the industry
It envisions a restructured, modern, well-
•Move towards low emission PUVS
managed, and environmentally sustainable
•Route rationalization boosted by Technology transport sector where drivers and operators have
stable, sufficient, and dignified livelihoods while
•Improve welfare of commuters and encourage commuters get to their destinations quickly,
modal shift safely, and comfortably.
•Improve standards of living of drivers, operators,
and their families

2015 - First country to formally regulate


Transport Network Corporation (TNC) using
Transport Network Vehicle Service (e.g. Grab,
Uber)
“It is not goodbye Uber and Grab. It is goodbye
illegal Uber and Grab.”

ROAD-BASED PUBLIC TRANSPORT


REFORM PROGRAM PUV
MODERNIZATION

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering
sufficient due to the lack of sustainable financing.
Improving transport infrastructure is critical for
strengthening the investment climate and
Philippines: Transport Sector Assessment, enhancing economic growth. The Philippines has
Strategy, and Road Map seen modest improvement in the quality of its
transport services, but a large part of the road
network remains in poor condition and
Sector Assessment: Context and Strategic Issues intermodal integration is generally weak. Poor
sector governance also impedes efficient
operation of the sector.
A. Introduction

3 Roads. As of 2011, the country's road system


comprised about 215,000 km. of which about
1. This assessment, strategy, and road map (ASR)
15% were classified as national roads, thereby
documents the current assessment by the Asian
falling under the jurisdiction of the Department of
Development Bank (ADB) of the transport sector
Public Works and Highways (DPWH). The
in the Philippines in relation to the government's
remaining 85% of the network is defined as local
strategic plans to strengthen policies, institutions,
roads and falls under the jurisdiction of a variety
and investments in the sector. The ASR
of local government units: As of November
highlights sector performance, priority
2011,79% of national roads and only 18% of local
development constraints, government plans and
roads were paved with either asphalt or concrete.
strategy, past ADB support and experience, other
The percentage of national roads that are paved
development partners' support, and ADB's
has risen only slowly from 71% in 2001 and
strategy for support. The ASR is linked to, and
remains well below the government's original
informs, ADB's country partnership strategy for
target of 95% by 2010
the Philippines. Both the ASR and the " country
partnership strategy for the Philippines target the
period through 2016.
4. Of the 31,400 km of national roads in the
system, only about 45% (14,200 km) were
assessed as being in good or fair condition in
B. The Philippine Transport System
November 2011. This figure is lower than the
percentages in 1982 (about 52%) and 2001 (about
47%). For local roads, the 2009 figure was much
2 Transport is a key sector in the Philippine lower, at about 20% (about 35,300 km of 176,300
economy, linking population and economic km). Annual investment in the road system has
centers across the islands. The transport system of remained at about 0.6% of gross domestic
the Philippines consists of road, water, air, and product (GDP), which is much lower than the
rail transport. Water transport plays an important comparable figure for most other countries in
role due to the archipelagic nature of the country, Southeast Asia. As a result, efforts to upgrade or
but road transport is by far the dominant subsector expand the network have been limited.
accounting for 98% of passenger traffic and 58%
of cargo traffic. While the transport infrastructure
has been developed and spread across the country
5. The extent of the road network in the
(about 215,000 kilometers [km] of roads, 1,300
Philippines, when measured in terms of road km
public and private ports, and 215 public and
per square km, road km per capita, and road km
private airports), the level of service has not been
per dollar of GDP per capita, is comparable with

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering
or better than many neighboring developing $1.9 billion, equivalent to 2.8% of the country's
member countries. However, when the quality of GDP. According to the Department of Health, in
the road system is considered-both in terms of the 2008 road accidents became the fourth leading
percentage of paved roads and the percentage of cause of death in the Philippines.
roads in good or fair condition-the Philippines
lags well behind nearly all of its regional
neighbors and competitors. 8. The government has developed a network of
tolled expressways in central Luzon to address
transport constraints on economic development
The major cause of the overall low quality of the by (1) linking the major economic and transport
road network is poor and inadequate centers in Metro Manila and adjacent provinces,
maintenance. This is the result of (i) insufficient from Tarlac in the north to Batangas in the south;
financial resources being made available for and (ii) facilitating multimodal transport. The
maintenance, and (ii) inadequate institutional expressway network, developed through public-
capacity of agencies responsible for road private partnerships (PPPs) and with bilateral
maintenance. The high prevalence of overloading development assistance, links industrial parks
of trucks also contributes to the low quality of the and special economic zones, the ports at Subic
network. Axle-load surveys conducted by the and Batangas, and Diosdado Macapagal
DPWH in 2005 showed that 11% -12% of all International Airport in Pampanga. While the
trucks were overloaded. Lax enforcement of axle- development of this network has reduced travel
load regulations compounds this problem. In times significantly, additional efforts to increase
addition to the low quality of the road network, port capacity and improve management are
the poor state of repair of much of the vehicle necessary to realize fully the benefits of an
fleet and inadequate enforcement of traffic integrated multimodal transport system.
regulations are also major contributors to the
unsatisfactory status of road transport in the
Philippines. 9 Water transport. Interisland water transport is a
very important subsector of the national:
transport system. There are about 1.300 ports, of
7. The poor quality of the road network is a which about 1000 are government owned and the
contributing factor to the rising number of road rest are privately owned and manages Of the
accidents. There were 14,794 recorded road government owned ports, about 140 fall under the
accidents in 2008, a 28% increase from 2007. jurisdiction of the Philippine Ports Authority
Deaths from road accidents in the first half of (PPA) and the Cebu Ports Authority, the
2009 reached 624, which was 9% more than in remainder are the responsibility of other
the equivalent period in 2008. These figures may government agencies or local government units
underestimate the severity of the road accident International cargo and container traffic has
problem, because in counting road accident grown steadily in recent years, supported by
deaths the Philippines uses a definition of death significant investments in the port of Batangas by
as occurring within 24 hours of a road accident, the PPA and in the port of Subic by the Subic Bay
whereas the internationally accepted definition is Metropolitan Authority Despite growth in both
death occurring within 30 days of an accident. In the economy and the population, passenger traffic
addition, it is estimated that only about 10% of on domestic interisland shipping services fell by
road accidents are officially reported, although about 13 between 2003 and 2008. Freight traffic
these are likely to include many of the most on interisland shipping services has not grown in
serious accidents. In 2005, the national cost of line with the economy and now stands at about
road accidents in the Philippines was estimated at the same volume as in the mid 1990s.

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering
served by different shipping operators. This
program has not only linked the country's major
10.Interisland shipping continues to suffer from a
island groups of Luzon, Visayas, and Mindanao,
poor reputation for safety, with an average of 160
but it has also had positive effects on the
maritime accidents annually. The causes of
economies of the smaller islands along the major
maritime accidents include human error; natural
routes. The ro-ro policy has had a major positive
causes, such as typhoons, bad weather, and rough
impact, derived from the significant reduction in
seas; lack of vessel traffic management; lack of
transport costs. The principal sources of savings
navigational aids; and poor ship maintenance.
have been the elimination of cargo handling
Natural causes were the main causes of maritime
charges and wharfage fees. As a result of the
accidents, comprising 36% of the total incidents
opening of the nautical highways, (i) goods are
recorded. Accidents caused by human error were
being shipped more efficiently, (ii) transport costs
also a major contributor, comprising 24% of all
have been reduced, (iii) new interisland and
recorded accidents. To address this deficiency,
regional links are being created, (iv) regional
the Maritime Industry Authority is embarking on
markets have expanded. (v) tourism has
a number of safety programs during 2012-2013,
benefited. (vi) local area development is being
including (1) a vessel retirement and replacement
accelerated, (vii) logistics practices are changing,
program; (ii) nationwide mobile registration,
and (viii) the domestic shipping industry is
licensing, and franchising of motor bancas
restructuring and becoming more competitive.
(wooden double outriggers); (iii) nationwide
The growth of ro-ro services may have
revalidation of ships' documentation; (iv) pilot
contributed to the decline in both freight and
implementation of an audit-based ship inspection
passenger traffic on conventional interisland
system; (v) enhancement of competence of
shipping services. It is estimated that the use of
technical personnel; (vi) implementation of the
ro-ro offers a saving of about 12 hours in travel
categorization of navigational areas; (vii) a
time between Mindanao and Luzon, and a
review of safety policies; and (viii) nationwide
reduction of about 30% in the cost of freight
revalidation of crew documents.
transport and 40% in the cost of passenger
transport.

11. In recent years, there has been significant


development of roll-on roll-off (ro-ro) ferry
12. Port facilities to accommodate ro-ro vessels
services, which are aimed at providing an
have been built or rehabilitated under the
alternative to traditional long-distance interisland
program, with 42 ro-ro vessels operating on
shipping services. The ro-ro system allows
routes between these ports. However, these 42
vehicles to drive onto and off ro-ro ferries without
vessels are run by some 25 shipping operators,
loading or offloading of cargo. Because this
which may suggest that the structure of the ro-ro
eliminates cargo-handling labor and equipment,
subsector is fragmented. While ro-ro facilities are
and reduces the amount of time cargo is required
already in place in some ports, prioritization of
to be in port, reductions in sea transport costs can
the development, construction, and rehabilitation
be considerable. In 2003, the Government of the
of ro-ro ports is hampered by the need for massive
Philippines issued a policy to promote ro-ro. This
capital outlays Therefore, the PPA is working to
was manifested in the opening of the
facilitate private sector participation in the
government's Strong Republic Nautical Highway
provision of passenger terminal buildings and ro-
Program. The Strong Republic Nautical Highway
ro terminal services so that these needs can be met
is composed of three major trunk lines: the
without creating an excessive burden on
western, eastern, and central nautical highways.
government resources. The PPA is fast-tracking
These three major lines consist of 12 main routes
the finalization of policies that allow private

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering
sector participation in the provision of these and have led to substantial increases in travel
buildings and services. through these airports.

13 Air transport. There are 215 airports in the 15. Urban transport. The Philippines is
Philippines, of which $4 are government-owned experiencing rapid urbanization, and by 2030,
and controlled and the rest are privately owned about 77% of the population will live in urban
and operated. Of the government-controlled areas. There are 120 cities in the country,
airports, 10 are designated as international including 16 in Metro Manila, which is the only
airports, 15 are Principal Class airports, 19 are metropolitan area in the Philippines. Other major
Principal Class 2 airports, and 40 are community urban agglomerations exist, including in Davao,
airports. The busiest airport in the Philippines is Cebu, and Iloilo, but they lack formal
Ninoy Aquino International Airport (NAIA) in metropolitan organizations. Transport systems in
Manila, which handled 435,486 aircraft these cities are almost entirely road based, with
movements and an estimated 29.6 million the exception of Metro Manila. Transport
passengers in 2011. Mactan International Airport services consist mainly of jeepneys (public utility
in Cebu is the second-busiest airport in the vehicles), taxis, tricycles, and pedicabs that are
country with 82,554 aircraft movements and 6.3 privately owned and operated In 2010, taxis
million passengers in 2011. Domestic passenger comprised 667,424 (35%) of the 1.9 million
traffic at NAIA has been growing at almost 10% vehicles in Metro Manila, and half of the 6.6
per annum since 2000. The growth of domestic million vehicles in the country were motorcycles.
freight traffic has been much less at about 2.4% Motorcycle users are vulnerable to road crashes
per annum. Given the growth of both and contribute significantly to traffic congestion.
international and domestic air traffic through
NAIA in recent years, serious capacity
constraints are likely to emerge before long To 16. In Metro Manila, the urban transport
address this, the government has plans to further infrastructure consists of a network of roads and
develop Diosdado Macapagal International railways. A functional classification system of
Airport, formerly Clark International Airport, as roads has been established with the arterial roads
an alternative international gateway serving forming a radial circumferential pattern of 10
central Luzon. These plans will need to be closely radial roads and 5 circumferential roads. Two
coordinated with those for the development of circumferential roads are incomplete and a sixth
NAIA, and they will need to include is in the planning stage. While some of the
consideration of appropriate land transport principal road corridors in Metro Manila have
connections between Diosdado Macapagal high capacities, traffic volumes are also
International Airport and Metro Manila. extremely high. As a result, the movement of
people, goods, and services is becoming
increasingly difficult. Although restrictions on
14. The government has intensified efforts under vehicle are in place, their effectiveness is
way since 1992 to liberalize air transport. In decreasing as rates of motorization increase,
particular, it has been promoting the development consequently, congestion in Metro Manila is
of secondary international gateways through increasing rapidly and is estimated to cause
negotiating bilateral "pocket open skies" economic losses equivalent to about 4.6% of
agreements pertaining to secondary airports in the GDP. While congestion in urban areas outside of
Philippines. These agreements now cover all Metro Manila is less severe, increasing urban
secondary international gateways in the country usage populations combined with higher rates of

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering
motorization suggest that traffic congestion in MRTC to the LRTA. A further LRT line has been
those urban areas will worsen in the near future. approved for development and others are under
consideration for development through PPP.

17. As in other urban areas, road-based public


transport in Metro Manila is provided entirely by 19. A limited number of heavy rail commuter
the private sector. There are an estimated 433 bus services are operated by the Philippine National
companies operating 805 routes. The majority of Railways (PNR), serving areas to the south of
bus companies own more than 10 units, with only Metro Manila. The PNR carried 9.1 million
7 bus companies owning 100 units or more. passengers in 2010 and 15.4 million in 2011. The
Jeepneys serve 785 routes in Metro Manila, with increase in ridership is attributed to the
many jeepney operators owning only one unit. In completion of the rehabilitation of the Caloocan
addition to jeepneys, air-conditioned Asian utility to Alabang section of the commuter line and the
vehicles provide express services in several areas introduction of new rolling stock, both financed
of Metro Manila, together with taxis and by bilateral development assistance.
localized modes of transport such as tricycles and
pedicabs. Tricycles and pedicabs are restricted to
serving local areas and provide a feed service to 20 Other than these commuter services and some
the larger-scale public transport services. other services linking towns in the Bicol region,
the heavy rail lines in the Philippines have been
essentially nonoperational for several years. The
18. Railways. The railway system consists of Southern Line linking Manila to the Bicol region
light rail transit (LRT) lines in Metro Manila and has not operated since it sustained typhoon
heavy rail lines in Luzon. The three LRT lines damage in 2006, although the line has now been
commenced operations in 1984, 1999, and 2003. restored and trial services have been operated
Two lines are owned and operated by a between Naga City and Metro Manila. Before its
government-owned corporation, the Light Rail closure in 2006, passenger traffic on this line had
Transit Authority (LRTA), while the third was been declining steadily and freight traffic was
financed and constructed by a private negligible. The Northern Line has been
corporation, the Metro Rapid Transit Corporation nonoperational for more than 25 years, although
(MRTC), and is operated by the government there are plans to reopen it under the Northrail
under a build-lease-transfer agreement. The lines Project.
operated by the LRTA carry about 579,000
passengers each day, while the MRTC line carries
more than 400,000 passengers daily. Fare C. Sector Performance, Problems, and
structures are distance based, and fare levels are Opportunities
low relative to comparable systems elsewhere in
the region. One reason that fares can be set at
these low levels is that the debt of the 21 Key sector challenges. The Philippines'
government-owned and controlled corporations archipelagic setting and the increasing
is serviced by annual allocations in the urbanization of its population make accessibility
government budget, which has the effect of between, and mobility within, the islands the
subsidizing the operations of the light rail primary goals of the transport system. Efficient
systems. Overall load factors on the LRT lines transport is critical for strengthening the country's
exceed 60% and overcrowding is common at investment climate and enhancing economic
peak periods. The government is reported to be growth. The islands need to be linked by a
considering transferring the operations of the

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering
seamless transport network to enable the cost- and institutional capacity, (iv) lack of quality
efficient movement of goods and services within urban transport systems, and (v) limited private
the country and to facilitate inclusive economic investment in transport infrastructure. While poor
growth. The same principle applies to enhancing connectivity arising from deficiencies in water
economic growth in the subregion in which the and air transport systems has historically
Philippines is located-archipelagic Southeast constrained transport and economic development
Asia Stimulating broad-based economic growth, in the Philippines, substantial progress is now
reducing poverty, and improving the welfare of being made in these areas through market
people inhabiting the subregion's numerous liberalization, development of the Strong
remote islands is a major challenge, the solution Republic Nautical Highways Program, and the
to which starts with improved connectivity. The establishment of open skies agreements for the
Philippines nautical highways model, which is development of secondary airports. Improving
working toward establishing seamless connec sustainable financing, supporting infrastructure
connectivity from north to south across seas and development and maintenance activities,
islands, is seen as having great potential for the contributing to governance reforms (such as
subregion. Linking islands comprising the procurement, financial management, and quality
subregion's constituent countries in such a control), and supporting private sector
network would stimulate international trade participation remain the keys to strengthening the
between neighboring islands, promote economic transport sector. A problem tree for the Philippine
activity, and reduce transaction costs transport sector is in the Appendix.
significantly (footnote 3). In addition to linking
the islands, the levels of service of urban transport
systems on the more populous islands need to be 24. Road network quality. Although roads are
addressed immediately to improve productivity used to transport the majority of passengers and
and meet the demands of an increasingly freight in the Philippines, much of the network is
urbanized economy. of poor quality. This results in high transport
costs for road users. An assessment by Bantay
Lansangan (Road Watch), a road stakeholder
22 One indicator of the extent of the challenges partnership, showed that in 2007, the average
facing the transport sector is the country's ranking road user cost was P21.17 per vehicle-km-41%
in the World Economic Forum's Global more than the estimated P15.17 per vehicle-km
Competitiveness Report 2012-2013. The cost of operating in optimum conditions. In part,
Philippines was ranked 87th of the 144 countries the poor quality of the national road network can
surveyed for quality of roads, 94th for railroads, be attributed to the fiscal constraints faced by the
112th for airports, and 120th for port Philippines in recent years, which resulted in a
infrastructure. Poor performance in the transport shortage of funding for the transport sector.
sector has reinforced the perception that the However, the share of public expenditures on
Philippines is not a good investment location due transport infrastructure allocated to maintenance
to the loss of economic opportunities, increased declined between 2000 and 2006, when only
pollution, and decreased productivity caused by 19.9% of total public expenditure on transport
poor transport infrastructure. went to operation and maintenance.

23. The main challenges faced by the transport 25 The availability of resources for road
sector, many of which are interrelated, include (1) maintenance received a significant boost in 2001
the poor quality of the road network, (ii) poor with the introduction of a motor vehicle user's
intermodal integration, weak sector governance charge to raise additional, earmarked resources

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering
for road maintenance, safety, and vehicle technical resources available to the DPWH, but it
pollution control. While annual funding for road also distorts the planning and budgeting process
maintenance from the Special Road Support for the overall road network. 28. Intermodal
Fund, into which the revenues of the user's charge integration. While roads, ports, and airports have
were paid, rose rapidly following the introduction been developed throughout the
of the scheme, the general appropriations for road
maintenance from the government budget fell by
an almost equal amount, so there was little overall Philippines and many journeys require the use of
increase in the funding available for maintenance. more than one mode of transport, coordination
This situation is being addressed and general among the agencies responsible for transport
appropriations for road maintenance have been infrastructure is generally very limited. In
increasing since 2007, when they were addition, coordination between the transport
reintroduced. However, there is still a funding sector agencies and the agencies responsible for
gap for road maintenance, and continuing capital economic development is poor. As a result,
expenditure on the road system means that the planning for the development of infrastructure for
demands for maintenance expenditures are individual transport modes is not linked with
increasing all the time. planning for other transport modes or potential
growth sectors such as manufacturing,
agriculture, and tourism. This lack of intermodal
26. In addition to financial constraints, weak planning has often resulted in inadequate
sector governance and limited implementation consideration being given to the optimum
capacity are also significant factors that solution to meet specific transport needs. For
contribute to the poor quality of the road system. example, funds used to invest in new ports and
Although the DPWH received a substantial airports to address perceived transport limitations
increase in its budget in 2007, it only managed to might have been used more efficiently to improve
disburse 66% of available funds. In addition, road connectivity to existing ports, ro-ro
expenditures have not necessarily been well facilities, or airports. The lack of intermodal
prioritized. For example, although the Special planning, and consequent lack of intermodal
Road Support Fund has collected about P56,5 integration, in part reflects the weak institutional
billion from motor vehicle user's charges since capacity for planning in sector agencies.
2001, only 38% of these funds have been spent on
prioritized projects, while 25%-30% of annual
routine maintenance expenditure has been spent 29. Governance and institutional capacity. The
on roadside cleaning and beautification projects capacity of transport agencies to undertake
designed mainly to generate employment rather procurement, financial management, internal
than to maintain or improve the quality of the audit, and quality control continues to be weak.
national road network As mentioned in para. 26, in 2007, the DPWH-
one of the main agencies active in the transport
sector only y managed to disburse 66% of its
27. The maintenance of local roads has suffered available budget, despite extensive demands on
because of the generally inadequate financial and that budget in terms of fproposed capital and
technical capacities of most local government recurrent expenditures. This was due to
units. One result is that many roads that have deficiencies in financial management and
primarily local functions have been converted, procurement procedures. A survey of more than
through legislation, to national roads to tap the 2,800 DPWH projects in 2006 showed that 353
DPWH maintenance budget. This not only (12.5%) had major defects. While steps have been
increases the pressure on the financial and taken to improve project supervision, the overall

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering
quality of projects is still poor. In addition, as
reported by Bantay Lansangan, a road
places added burdens on the agencies responsible
stakeholder partnership, there is a common
for the additional infrastructure. The distortion of
perception that procurement procedures in the
the functional classification system for roads,
DPWH suffer from a lack of transparency and
through the redesignation of local roads as
widespread corruption.
national roads to enable the DPWH to take over
responsibility for maintenance, is largely a
consequence of this
30. Technical capacity in planning, intermodal
integration, project appraisal, and monitoring is
also insufficient in sector agencies. Although the
32 While the Philippines has a wide range of
DPWH is now developing information
generally well-developed regulations governing
technology enabled planning and programming
the transport sector, implementation of these
systems with the support of ADB and the World
regulations is often weak, which significantly
Bank, it has not yet been able to take full
limits the intended positive impact of these
advantage of them. The technical and financial
regulations on performance. Within the port,
capacity of the local government units
aviation, and rail subsectors, the PPA, the PNR,
responsible for the development and management
the Civil Aviation Authority, and the LRTA have
of the local road network and other components
responsibility both for operations and regulation.
of the country's transport infrastructure is
Given that in the port and aviation subsectors
generally regarded as inadequate.
there are publicly owned operators that are in
competition with private sector ones, there is
significant potential for conflicts of interest
31. As mentioned in para. 28, coordination
within the sector agencies and discrimination
between the transport agencies and with the
against private sector operations. Although
agencies responsible for economic sectors is
proposals have been made for institutional
generally lacking. In addition, the links between
reforms in these subsectors to separate the
plans prepared by the DPWH and the Department
regulatory powers of the agencies from their
of Transportation and Communications and
operational responsibilities, no progress has been
regional development plans are also generally
made.
weak. This lack of planning and implementation
capacity in the main sector agencies and the local
government units can be compounded by the
33. Urban transport. Throughout the Philippines,
effects of local political pressures that lead to the
urban public transport is dominated by road based
inclusion in national or local transport plans of
modes such as jeepneys, Asian utility vehicles,
projects whose contribution to the country's
taxis, tricycles, and pedicabs, some of which
overall transport or economic development
provide door-to-door service. Many urban road
strategy may not have been validated. Political
networks are inadequate and poorly maintained.
pressures of this type lead to the identification of
Urban transport planning and traffic management
investment projects becoming politicized and
are insufficient and ineffective, and traffic control
nontransparent, undermine the integrity of the
devices, such as traffic signs, signals, and road
design, procurement, and implementation
markings, often do not conform to official
processes. In addition, while funding for the
standards or meet needs. Buses form a major
capital investment in such projects may come
element of the urban transport system in Metro
from discretionary sources within the national
Manila but not in other urban centers, while LRT
budget, funding for subsequent operation and
is confined to Metro Manila and is heavily
maintenance is generally not forthcoming. This

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering
subsidized. Franchising procedures for road- private sector involvement was instrumental in
based urban transport are often ineffective and bringing about the necessary changes in policy to
enforcement of regulations is lax. All of these support the development of the ro-ro system
factors contribute to increasing levels of traffic through the Strong Republic Nautical Highway
congestion in urban areas, particularly around Program and the establishment of open skies
transit terminals and public markets. This in turn agreements for the development of secondary
results in longer travel times, loss of economic airports into international gateways.
opportunities and productivity, and increasing air
pollution which has become a serious problem in
many large urban areas. 36 While private sector investment in transport
infrastructure has been significant, only a few of
the transport projects were developed using an
34. With rapid urbanization expected to continue open, competitive bidding process aimed at
in the Philippines, urban transport infrastructure securing funding for the projects within a clearly
will be put under increasing pressure, thereby prioritized transport investment program. Most
posing a major risk of further deterioration in the successful projects have been the result of
mobility of urban populations. The planning and unsolicited proposals from potential investors to
development of new public transport terminals form PPPs with government corporations
that integrate different modes of public transport mandated to develop and operate transport
would help to mitigate many of the problems infrastructure. In part, this reflects the lack of
currently associated with urban transport, thereby capacity within sector agencies for project
reducing the costs of urban mobility and planning and preparation. However, it also
improving the economic productivity and reflects a lack of clear principles and rules for the
competitiveness of urban areas. development of such partnerships. One
consequence of this reliance on unsolicited
proposals is that project proposals may not be
35. Private sector provision of infrastructure. properly assessed by the public sector parties
While the provision of transport services, receiving the proposal, and this in turn may result
particularly in the road and aviation subsectors, is in suboptimal allocation of project risks being
dominated by the private sector; the role of the accepted by the government side of the
private sector in providing transport partnership. An extreme example of this is the
infrastructure has been inconsistent. A build- Metro Rail Transit Project (LRT 3), for which the
operate-transfer law has been in place in the government appears to be responsible for
Philippines since 1990. During 1998-2007, virtually all of the demand, commercial.
private sector investment in transport performance, and financial risks, in addition to
infrastructure was equivalent to about 1.9% of the political and regulatory risk.
GDP-higher than the level of public sector
investment in transport in that period (1.6% of
GDP). However, in recent years private sector II. Sector Strategy
investment in transport infrastructure has been
declining both in terms of monetary value and as
a percentage of GDP. Private sector investments A. Government Sector Strategy and Plan
have been primarily for projects in the port and
road subsectors, although investments have also
been made in rail and aviation. The private sector 37. The primary objective of the Philippine
has become increasingly important in promoting Development Plan 2011-2016 (PDP) is the
transport sector policy reforms; for example,

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering
pursuit of inclusive economic growth, which is the procedures and processes for project approval
defined as "sustained growth that creates jobs, and implementation.
draws the majority into the economic and social
mainstream, and continuously reduces mass
poverty." The PDP recognizes that inadequate 40. To foster transparency and accountability,
infrastructure and the resulting poor logistics stakeholder participation will be encouraged in
network are critical constraints to investment and governance, monitoring, and provision of
growth. It also recognizes that this inadequacy in feedback on infrastructure development. In
both the quantity and quality of infrastructure is relation to dimate change adaptation and
the result of the low level of public and private mitigation of natural disasters, the PDP calls for
sector investment which is inadequate for the these issues to be institutionalized in
requirements of an expanding economy and a infrastructure development through their
growing population. In addition, inequitable incorporation in plans and designs. With respect
access to basic infrastructure services has acted as to providing productive employment
an obstacle to poverty reduction and inclusive opportunities to facilitate inclusive growth, the
growth by limiting the opportunities for PDP calls for the adoption of labor-intensive
economic and social advancement of approaches where they are most appropriate. The
marginalized groups throughout the country. PDP envisions that achieving these objectives
will result in a safe, secure, efficient, viable,
competitive, dependable, integrated,
38. The PDP sets five objectives for infrastructure environmentally sustainable and people-oriented
development, including the transport sector: (1) Philippine transportation system. To achieve this,
optimize resources and investments, (ii) attract the PDP sets out a strategy containing the
investments to infrastructure, (iii) foster following four elements:
transparency and accountability in infrastructure
development, (iv) adapt to climate change and
mitigate the impacts. of natural disasters, and (v) 41. Develop an integrated and coordinated
provide productive employment opportunities. transport network. The first element of the
government's strategy for developing the
transport sector is to pursue the development of
39 an integrated and coordinated transport network.
The starting point will be the adoption of a
comprehensive long-term national transport plan
To optimize resources and investments, the PDP (NTP) to guide the restructuring of the national
calls for improved project planning and transport system. By clearly laying out the
development, and implementation and government's policies in relation to all aspects of
synchronization of planning and budgeting. It sector development, the plan would reduce
also recognizes the need for the coordination and uncertainty about government decisions and lend
integration of infrastructure initiatives at all predictability and consistency, thereby enhancing
levels of government. accountability. The NTP will encourage the
implementation of PPP projects by establishing
To attract investments in infrastructure, the PDP clear policies on risk allocation and clarifying the
calls for an improved institutional and regulatory roles of the private sector and government
environment for the infrastructure sector, agencies in the operation and management of
including the separation of the operational and transport infrastructure. Likewise, it will address
regulatory functions of sector agencies, and for the relative roles of national and local
the encouragement of PPPs through improving government entities i the development and

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering
management of transport infrastructure. Linkages
between the planning and budgeting processes
46. While ADB has been engaged in regular
will be strengthened through the NTP to ensure
policy dialogue with the government on the
that resources are allocated most effectively
development of the transport sector, direct
within the transport sector.
operational activities in the sector were limited
for several years preceding 2008. The country
assistance program evaluation (CAPE) for the
42 Rationalize the functions of transport
Philippines, prepared in 2008 and covering the
agencies. The second element of the strategy is
period 2003-2007, identified only two loan
the rationalization of the overlapping and
projects that were under implementation during
conflicting functions of transport and other
that period: the Sixth Road Project and the Third
concerned agencies. In particular, the functions of
Airports Development Project." In addition,
the organizations responsible for ports and rail
nonsovereign support was given for a PPP to
and air transport will be restructured and their
develop the North Luzon Expressway.
current regulatory responsibilities will be
transferred to a separate, independent regulator.
47.
43. Ensure transport safety and security. The third
element of the strategy is to improve compliance
The implementation of the Sixth Road Project
with safety and security standards, and to
was adversely affected by quality-at-entry issues
strengthen their implementation and enforcement
associated with the lack of a clear land acquisition
for each mode of transport in line with
and resettlement policy and problems relating to
international best practice. 44 Promote the
subproject selection. Nevertheless, 80% of the
development of impoverished and conflict-
project objectives were achieved and the project
affected areas. The final element of the strategy
was rated successful."
relates to the need to improve transport networks
in underdeveloped regions and areas affected by
conflict. The aim is to open up these areas to
greater economic opportunities and bring their 48. Implementation of the Third Airports
populations into the mainstream of economic Development Project was terminated in 2005 and
development, thereby enhancing their prospects the balance of the loan was cancelled. The
for inclusive economic growth. termination was the result of the very poor
implementation performance resulting from the
slow progress of land acquisition and
resettlement, severe delays in the recruitment of
45. In addition to the PDP, the government
consultants, and significant issues relating to the
established the National Environmentally
procurement of civil works and equipment. None
Sustainable Transport Strategy in 2011 through
of the originally planned outputs was achieved
Presidential Administrative Order No. 254, with
and the project was rated unsuccessful."
the Department of Transportation and
Communications and the Department of
Environment and Natural Resources responsible
for implementation. 49. Overall, the CAPE rated ADB's assistance to
the transport sector relevant, because support was
consistent with government and ADB strategies
for developing provincial and regional transport
B. ADB Sector Support and Experience
infrastructure; but in terms of its achievements

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering
the CAPE rated ADB's assistance to the transport
sector partly successful.

30 The approval in 2008 of technical assistance


for the preparation of the Road Sector
Improvement Project" marked the start of ADB's
operational reengagement in the transport sector
in the Philippines. Since reengaging, ADB has
coordinated closely with development partners in
order to address effectively current and emerging
road subsector issues through lending and
technical assistance. The technical assistance 52. In addition to supporting investment projects,
project for Strengthening Transparency and the development partners have extended
Accountability in the Road Subsector," approved assistance to a range of programs almed at
in December 2009, is addressing key issues in addressing key issues in the road subsector and
subsector governance: mitigation of procurement developing the capacity of the DPWH and
risks, strengthening internal accountability subsector institutions. The World Bank has
mechanisms, and strengthening external focused its activities on addressing the issues of
accountability mechanisms. It complements insufficient financing for road maintenance, weak
assistance provided by other development institutional capacity of road subsector
partners and forms part of the multidonor effort institutions, and low productivity in road
to improve the capacity of key sector institutions. administration. ICA has also provided significant
The Road Improvement and Institutional assistance to address the weak institutional
Development Project is providing further support capacity of road subsector institutions and the low
for this coordinated multidonor effort and for productivity in road administration. In addition,
improvements in the national road network. JICA has provided assistance to address the low
(para. 56) level of private sector participation in the road
subsector. AusAID has focused its activities on
the issue of weak governance in the road
C. Other Development Partners' Support subsector, as well as supporting improvements to
the organizational effectiveness of the DPWH. A
summary of assistance is in Table 2.
51. ADB's major development partners in the
transport sector are the Australian Agency for
International Development (AusAID), the
Department for International Development of the
United Kingdom, the Japan International
Cooperation Agency (JICA), the Millennium
Challenge Corporation, and the World Bank.
Before its 2008 merger with JICA, the Japan
Bank for International Cooperation provided a
substantial amount of support for the transport
sector. The activities of these development
partners since 2004 have been focused primarily
on the road subsector (Table 1).

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering
enhancement of transport efficiency; (ii)
development of urban transport; and (iii)
sustainability of the transport system in terms of
the physical sustainability of assets, the social
sustainability of operations in relation to safety
and security, and its environmental sustainability.
As such, ADB's strategy for the Philippine
transport sector is fully consistent with ADB's
Sustainable Transport Initiative, which supports
the development of transport systems tare
economically, socially, and environmentally
sustainable."

55. To address the three core issues, the strategy


supports four key areas of intervention: (1)
improvement of national highways, (ii)
development of urban transport, (iii)
strengthening of sector governance, and (iv)
facilitation of private sector infrastructure
development and regional operations. The
strategic linkages underpinning these four areas
of support are shown in figure. The Transport
Sector Road Map and Results Framework is in
Table 3.

D. ADB's Sector Strategy 56. Improvement of national highways. ADB is


undertaking a major initiative to help the
government address core issues facing the
53. ADB's partnership with the Philippines is national road network through the Road
based on the intersection of PDP priorities with Improvement and Institutional Development
ADB's Strategy 2020." A principal objective of Project, approved in December 2011. The project
ADB support for the Philippines is to help in the is supporting investments to improve the quality
achievement of high, inclusive, and sustainable and sustainability of the national road network,
growth. Support for infrastructure development, and it will also support improvements in sector
including transport, forms a core part of ADB's governance and strengthening of institutional
operational strategy for the country. capacity at the DPWH.

54. ADB's strategy in the t transport t sector 57 The investment component of the project is
grows out of this overall strategy to support supporting periodic maintenance of about 340 km
inclusive, environmentally sustainable growth of nine national roads located in three areas: the
and the government's priority investment west coast of Luzon, the Visayas, and Mindanao.
program." The strategy aims to address three core This maintenance will directly support improved
issues within the transport sector: (1) efficiency of vehicle movements over the roads in
question by reducing transport costs and travel

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering
times. It will also enhance the physical development and quality assurance system. This
sustainability of the assets. Improved road will improve project quality by enhancing the
conditions should also lead to a reduction in road DPWH's capacity for materials testing and
accidents, thereby contributing to enhanced assuring the quality of civil works. It will also
social sustainability, while more efficient vehicle support the development of a sustainable research
operations over these roads should lead to a program to investigate the factors affecting
reduction in fuel usage and hence lower carbon durability.
and other emissions. During implementation of
this periodic road maintenance, the project will
support improved transport sector governance 60. The institutional development component is
through implementation of a comprehensive also assisting in improving the social and
governance risk mitigation plan focusing on (0) environmental sustainability of the national road
elimination of opportunities for corruption, (ii) network. It is supporting the improvement of road
improved public expenditure and financial safety through the enhancement of traffic
management, and (iii) enhancement of accident recording and analysis, and the
procurement procedures. implementation of a road safety audit system to

58. The institutional development component of


the project is consistent with, and builds on, the
ongoing efforts by the government and
development partners to improve the capacity of
the DPWH and the efficiency and sustainability
of the road system. Under this component,
support is being given to the DPWH for
institutional and capacity development in six
areas that are critical for improving the quality
and sustainability of the road network.

59. The institutional development component is


supporting the improvement of the physical
sustainability of the national road network
ensure that engineering designs for existing and
through the institutionalization of a road
new national roads Increasingly incorporate road
maintenance and management system designed to
safety features. The component is also helping to
enhance the DPWH's capacity to plan and
strengthen the DPWH's capacity to undertake
implement maintenance of roads under its
environmental and social assessments of projects
jurisdiction. It is also supporting improvements in
and mainstream gender issues in project
the quality of the road network through the
development. The DPWH's capacity for
development and installation of a project
environmental management of projects and
management information system that will
management of infrastructure rights-of-way is
strengthen the DPWH's project management
also being improved.
capabilities by improving its capacity to track the
progress of projects, including procurement,
construction, handover, and evaluation. A third
element of the institutional development 61. The final area in which the project's
component is support for an infrastructure institutional development component is

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering
supporting the development of capacity in the 64 Strengthening of sector governance. ADB is
DPWH is by improving human resource already supporting increased transparency and
management through the development of a accountability for road subsector budgets and
comprehensive human resource development investments through an ongoing technical
plan and strengthening of the DPWH's assistance operation (footnote 15). The project is
organizational culture. playing a key role in mitigating corruption risks
for planned road subsector activities, and
strengthening governance and capacity to achieve
62. The project is the first in a planned series of improved transparency and accountability. The
projects through which ADB will work with the investment component of the Road Improvement
DPWH to address core issues facing the road and Institutional Development Project (footnote
subsector. Project preparatory technical 16) is supporting the implementation of the
assistance projects for the second and third road outputs of this technical assistance through their
improvement and institutional development application to procurement for and management
projects are planned for approval in 2013 and of the project within the DPWH.
2014, and the loans are planned for approval in
the subsequent years. These projects will finance
the improvement of additional sections of the 65. Facilitation of private sector and regional
national road network and continued operations. ADB's private sector operations will
strengthening of the DPWH's institutional also be responsive to the government's transport
capacity. sector priorities. Private sector operations will
support private sector projects for (i)
construction, expansion or modernization, and
63 Development of urban transport. ADB has operation of toll roads; (ii) construction and
already undertaken pre-feasibility analysis for a operation of mass transit systems such as light
project to improve public transport services in and/or metro rail systems, bus rapid transit
Davao City Building on this, policy and advisory systems, and nautical highway systems; (iii)
technical assistance is proposed to support modernization or expansion of transport fleets or
modernization of the city's public transport rolling stock; and (iv) construction, expansion or
system. Following this, project preparatory modernization, and operation of ports and
technical assistance is proposed to prepare and
conduct the necessary. due diligence for a Davao
sustainable urban transport project. The project is
expected to comprise investment in the
construction of a bus rapid transit system, as well
as in capacity development for sustainable
management of traffic in Davao City, If
successful, this project could generate useful
lessons that could be replicated in other cities
throughout the country. In addition, ADB's
program for the Philippines includes the proposed
Market Transformation through Introduction of
Energy Efficient Electric Tricycles Project being
prepared by ADR's Southeast Asia Energy
Division.

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering
airports. Support for private sector operations will
also come, indirectly, through the improvements
in sector governance and the strengthening of
institutional capacity, which should result in
improvements in the investment climate.

66. ADB will support regional integration


through possible support for improvement of
ports. particularly those handling ro-ro ferry
operations, and roads providing access to ports of
regional significance.

III. Transport Sector Road Map and Results


Framework

Philippines: Transport Sector Assessment,


Strategy, and Road Map

The Asian Development Bank (ADB) is


preparing sector assessments, strategies, and road
maps (ASRS) to help align future ADB support
with the needs and strategies of developing
member countries and other development
partners. ASRS are working documents that help
inform the development of country partnership
strategies. This transport sector ASR highlights
development issues, needs, and strategic
assistance priorities of the Government of the
Philippines and ADB, with a focus on roads and
intermodal integration, governance and
institutional capacity, urban transport, and private
sector provision of infrastructure. It highlights
sector performance, priority development

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering
constraints, the government's strategy and plans,
other development partner support, lessons
learned from past ADB support, and possible
future ADB assistance including knowledge
support and investments. The report serves as a
basis for further dialogue on how ADB and the
government can work together to tackle the
challenges of managing transport sector
development in the Philippines in the coming
years.

About the Asian Development Bank

ADB's vision is an Asia and Pacific region free of


poverty. Its mission is to help its developing
member countries reduce poverty and improve
the quality of life of their people. Despite the
region's many successes, it remains home to two-
thirds of the world's poor: 1.7 billion people who
live on less than $2 a day, with 828 million
struggling on less than $1.25 a day. ADB is
committed to reducing poverty through inclusive
economic growth, environmentally sustainable
growth, and regional integration.

Based in Manila, ADB is owned by 67 members,


including 48 from the region. Its main
instruments for helping its developing member
countries are policy dialogue, loans, equity
investments, guarantees, grants, and technical
assistance.

YOUTUBE VID:
Update on the State of Transportation System in
the Philippines:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iLVtoO3iO
Lw

Compiled by: Kyara Angelie Tago, BSCE-3


CE431 – Transportation Engineering

You might also like